Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Varn Vlog

Varn Vlog artwork

An Inconvenient Woman and the Reactionary South with Keri Leight Merritt

Oct 22, 20261 hr 24 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

In this episode of VarnVlog, host C. Derick Varn sits down with historian, writer, and independent scholar Dr. Keri Leigh Merritt (author of Masterless Men: Poor Whites and Slavery in the Antebellum South) to discuss her new book, "An Inconvenient Woman: The Extraordinary Life of Lillian Smith, The Southerner Who Defied Jim Crow America" (St. Martin's Press). Together, they explore the life and legacy of Lillian Smith - a radical Southern white woman, educator, and writer who publicly called for complete integration long before it was widely accepted. From running the avant-garde Laurel Falls Camp in Appalachia alongside her lifelong partner Paula Snelling, to publishing Black writers in South Today, and writing the explosive, best-selling novel Strange Fruit and the psychological critique Killers of the Dream, Merritt and Varn unpack the rich, often erased history of Southern anti-racism, class solidarity, and radical dissent. Featured Topics & Takeaways: Rediscovering Lillian Smith: Why one of the earliest white Southern voices for integration was marginalized and erased from mainstream history. Laurel Falls Camp: How Smith and Paula Snelling turned a girls' summer camp into a progressive space for free speech, critical inquiry, and racial tolerance. The Intersections of Class & Race: Smith's groundbreaking analysis in essays like "Two Men and a Bargain" on how wealthy elites used racial division to stifle labor solidarity. Censorship & Strange Fruit: The national backlash, banning, and massive success of Smith's 1944 novel addressing interracial love and lynching. Psychology of White Supremacy: Smith’s use of trauma psychology and Freudian theory in Killers of the Dream to explain the psychological toll of racism on white Southerners. Links & Support Patreon: Support VarnVlog on Patreon to access exclusive classes, reading lists, and behind-the-scenes content: https://www.patreon.com/varnvlog Order: Order my new mini-book with Daniel Tutt, "The People Are Not One," available now via Revol Press: https://www.revolpress.com/people-not-one Guest Links: Check out Dr. Keri Leigh Merritt’s books and work at https://kerileighmerritt.com/ Send us Fan Mail Musis by Bitterlake, Used with Permission, all rights to Bitterlake Support the show Crew: Host: C. Derick Varn Intro and Outro Music by Bitter Lake. Intro Video Design: Jason Myles Art Design: Corn and C. Derick Varn Links and Social Media: twitter: @varnvlog blue sky: @varnvlog.bsky.social You can find the additional streams on Youtube Current Patreon at the Sponsor Tier: Jordan Sheldon, Mark J. Matthews, Lindsay Kimbrough, RedWolf, DRV, Kenneth McKee, JY Chan, Matthew Monahan, Parzival, Adriel Mixon, Buddy Roark, Daniel Petrovic,Julian, Drea, Free Beer, SNT-BRCH, Joshua Parsons

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

C. Derick VarnHello, and welcome to Borblog. And today I'm with Dr. Carrie Lee Merritt, who is a historian, writer, and independent scholar based out of the Southeast, specifically my old stomping ground. And if people know me, they'll know where that is. Her academic work focuses on the intersection between race, class, labor, and economic inequality in the American South. She has her proper credentials with a BA from Ivory, an MA PhD from the University of Georgia. Her first book is Masterless Men, Poor Whites in Slavery in the Annabellum South.

C. Derick VarnBut we are specifically talking today about an inconvenient woman, the extraordinary life of Laryland Smith, the Southerner who defied Jim Crow America, which came out from St. Martin's Press this year. I said came out. I'm actually not sure if it has come out or is coming out. So we can clarify that.

SPEAKER_01It'll be September 29th.

C. Derick VarnAll right. So this actually will come, this will be released right before it comes out. So perfect timing. So I have been interested in your work for a little while because I'm very interested in the antebellum South and also the Jim Crow South. Obviously, I grew up my first 20-something years of my life was primarily in Georgia, Central Georgia in specific. So this has a lot of weight on me. And I find that the South is misunderstood by both progressives and Marxists a lot of the time.

C. Derick VarnPrimarily because the question of labor is often not dealt with directly and it's mystified. But also the the entire history of southern anti-racism has been systemically kind of not erased, but let's say muddled.

SPEAKER_01Absolutely.

C. Derick VarnAnd this brings me to Lillian Smith, who is a person I actually hadn't heard of, which was deeply embarrassing for me, being that I'm from the Southeast. So what interested you in Lillian Smith and why did you think it was time to write about her?

SPEAKER_01Well, thank you so much, first of all, for having me on. And that's a great question. And actually, do not feel embarrassed because that's exactly why I wanted to write about her, is because I, you know, I grew up in the South as well, spent most of my life here. And I thought I knew every Southern writer, especially the women writers. And yet I was in graduate school at the University of Georgia and came across her name in a history book, actually, and realized I had never read any of her work and really didn't know much about her at all. And so that's what kind of led me down learning about her and really like what a radical figure she was in the 1930s and 40s, especially.

SPEAKER_01She she claims to be the first white southerner to call for integration, to publicly call for integration. And from what I can tell as a historian, that's that's actually a true claim. And not only was she pushing for integration, she was living integration up in Clayton, Georgia, you know, right up in the northeast corner of the state and Appalachia, the Blue Ridge Mountains.

C. Derick VarnYeah, um, that actually brings uh something very interesting to mind about one of the histories of anti-racism is a lot of times it's weirdly regional in ways that are obscured by modern southern divisions. And like if you think of the Northeast Corridor of Appalachia today, that's just tick off of Marjorie Taylor Green Country, but it really is very interesting in the Civil War, the role that that the Appalachia played for resistance to the planter class.

C. Derick VarnSo go ahead.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, the area that she lives in, it's crazy because that area would have been very heavily unionist and also mainly anti-Confederate. You know, most of the people that I write about masterless men, the poor whites and and people that didn't own land and didn't own enslaved people, were mostly anti-Confederates in the deep south. They just they didn't want to fight for anybody, they didn't really even understand what was going on on a big political level. You know, they're just happy to live their own lives, keep to themselves. And so I always say it's really interesting today with the lost cause narrative and all of that.

SPEAKER_01Like you'll see the Confederate, the few remaining Confederate stores and Confederate flags flying, especially in these areas where unionism and anti-Confederate sentiment was actually the highest during the Civil War. There's almost like an inverse correlation there. And I mean, I think class and labor does have a lot to do with that.

C. Derick VarnYeah, um when I think about Lillian Smith in particular, it it is interesting because it reminds me of West Virginia, which you know I've gone up and down the East Coast many times, and I'm always shocked that like West Virginia, the place that all the that literally succeeded from Virginia so it didn't have to fight in the Civil War is the place where I see the most Confederate flags when I'm going through the the Southeast. And so that irony is deep, but it very much seems to be not so much a legacy of the Civil War, but a legacy of actually a time period of your book about Lillian Smith, because that seems to be where the shift really happens, where this connection to a hostility from the southern working classes to the planned class somehow gets erased.

C. Derick VarnWhat role do you think? Like, what was Lillian Smith responding to, and what how did that get erased?

SPEAKER_01It's a really, really good question. So we have to remember she was actually born in 1897, and her parents were born in uh in Georgia and North Carolina. Her father was from North Carolina during the Civil War, actually, born during the Civil War, and her mother came from you know very wealthy family. They had many enslaved people, and so she was her mother was you know nursed and probably wet nursed by an enslaved woman. And Lillian herself was also raised by a black nurse, which we can get into later, becomes a big part of her kind of psychological assessment of Southerners.

SPEAKER_01But, you know, I think that had a heavy mark on how she understood not only the Civil War, but especially the period of Reconstruction, because she would hear her parents literally talk about living through it. But I think more important in her life, in terms of how her outlook on racial or other kind of more progressive issues was her father's deep Christianity. And he was a Methodist, very, very extremely religious, pious person, but he really did kind of live out the ideal of, you know, do unto others as you want to be done unto you, like the golden rule.

SPEAKER_01And so this was best seen in her sixth book. She's she published seven altogether, but her sixth book was about one Christmas when she was a teenager, and her father literally invited the entire chain gang who was who were working in the local area near Clayton, Georgia, invited the entire chain gang to Christmas. And so the Smith children had to work for days and days cooking this big Christmas dinner. And I mean, these were these were hard-ended criminals, they were rapists, murderers, and you know, he gave them all a lesson in you know not judging people that we all make mistakes, that you just have to be good and positive and love everyone.

C. Derick VarnSo uh Lily Smith's background is kind of interesting. You discussed it a lot in her in your first chapter. And and I was wondering like, how did this interesting intersection of generational wealth, which was derived from a slave holding family and rice plantations in specific, which was while not as brutal as like the sugar plantations, were still pretty damn awful, even for plantation life. And Calvin Smith's roofless entrepreneurial rise in the timber industry, like set up what she would see.

C. Derick VarnSo there the like what how did her class background affect her in the seemingly contradictory ways?

SPEAKER_01That's a also a fantastic question because her life gets upended in World War I, even though she comes from a lot of wealth. Again, her mother was born into wealth and so had a lot of family inheritance. Her father was scrappy, you know, and and worked his way up. He was he was middle class, but really worked his way up, married well, and then opened a bunch of businesses in Jasper, Florida, Northern Florida. Most of them were were related to lumber and and turpentine. But then when World War I broke out and all the you know shipping vagarities and different, what's the word I'm looking for?

SPEAKER_01The closed borders, like he couldn't ship any of his lumber. And so he basically went out of business in South Georgia. Well, Calvin Smith was always an investor and before this point had bought land up in Clayton outside of Clayton, Georgia, for a place for them to go during the really, really hot summers, humid summers, get away from the heat and the mosquitoes and go, you know, spend the summer in the mountains. And when the lumber business, you know, he had to sell everything and and pack up, they went up to Clayton, and that's where they started making a life there.

SPEAKER_01That's where she ended up going to college at Piedmont University in North Georgia and spent her first years really learning how to be a teacher. She wanted to be a pianist. She was always very, very into art and and music, and originally wanted to be a musician, but she just felt that she wasn't talented enough to go into that. And so she kind of became a teacher out of default.

C. Derick VarnYeah, it it that fascinates me. The the the kind of like the fact that she only really had the option to be a teacher given her situation, and that that seems to have expanded some insights that she had had uh from her background. I want to go, you know, you mentioned the her theory of the mother wound, but I find this fascinating because even as late as the 1980s, I I'm I'm I'm older than I look, but I was raised in central Georgia in the 1980s, and I come from a very blue-collar working-class background.

C. Derick VarnAnd I say that, however, because this relationship on like old elderly black women often doing child care for working parents was still a thing as late as the 1980s, and so I found myself like weirdly resonating with this, even though it's like almost it's weird because people don't talk about it anymore. But you know, I was my my um babysitter as a child was was a woman born before uh World War II, a black woman who didn't have a social security card because they didn't give them to them, um, and and stuff like that.

C. Derick VarnAnd so we had a very real connection to the Jim Crow South that was that was in most people's homes, and it's reflected in our accent too, like the weird mixture of like West Midlands and Scotch-Irish, and then like African dialectical patterns that you hear in southern English. I remember in the 90s the whole Ebonics now we call African-American vernacular English problem, and they'd be like, 'Oh, white people can't understand this.' And I was like, 'Well, I can.

SPEAKER_01Absolutely. If you're from the deep south, you can understand it, right?

C. Derick VarnRight.' If you're of a certain class, yeah, right. Just sounds like Southern English to me. I also didn't understand why watermelon and fried chicken was racist for a long time because, like, we just eat that, like everybody eats, right?

SPEAKER_01No, absolutely. That was a point I always made was where I first learned about class was going uh and visiting where my parents grew up in Easley, South Carolina, which is an old mill village, cotton mill village. And my father was middle class, and actually he was like people don't get it, like you know, it wasn't just an upper class thing by the time of the 1940s, 50s, and starting into the 60s. Like, if you're even middle class, you usually had a black woman at home watching your children. If you're out working, you know, and you've got black women at home watching your children, acting as a maid, a nanny, a cook.

SPEAKER_01And so my father had that in his house. My mom was really poor. And so they lived in the mill village, but the mill village, even back then, even in the 50s and 60s, was integrated, right? I mean, it might have been sides of the street, but you all live together. And so there was such a if you go over to my father's side of the town across the railroad tracks, everything's segregated, but you go to the mill village and everything is totally integrated. And that doesn't mean that those white people were, you know, racially egalitarian by any means, but there was a very different kind of intimacy going on in those areas.

C. Derick VarnYeah. And I mean, I think I mean that's still true in southern cities today. Like if you're in Macon or Atlanta, you can be in these very seemingly segregated upper middle class and upper class neighborhoods, and then just turn a corner and you're like in a middle class black neighborhood or even something else. So it's I think that's I think a lot of people's images for that are actually northern cities where the communities are a lot more separated and a lot in clearer demarcated parts of the city.

C. Derick VarnAnd that's just not the case for most southern cities.

SPEAKER_01Right, there's no planning down here, so yeah, yeah, for sure.

C. Derick VarnBut you know how do you think Lillian Smith was able to integrate this experience of white children having polarizing, I think, response to being waived by black domestic labor, effectively. I mean, it it it even does like like you can do linguistic studies, as I mentioned, and like trace out the effect on southern planter English and it changing with the influences of wet West African speech patterns and and whatnot, creating kind of the early 20th century southern dialect.

SPEAKER_01Right.

C. Derick VarnIt go ahead.

SPEAKER_01I mean it permeates everything. And so her second book, Killers of the Dream, which she published in 1949, really was about racism and white supremacy. And this is where she really gets into this issue about black nurses raising white children. And she honestly did not have a great relationship with her own mother, and like I said, was raised primarily by a black nurse who she considered, you know, her mother figure. And she always felt very emotionally distant from her mother, and that her mother was very cold and reserved, you know, as opposed to her father who was very warm and loving.

SPEAKER_01And she really did, she started reading a lot of Freud, and really, I mean, she could have done a PhD in psychology from how into the research she got. She read all of Freud's students, she knew tons about this. This is when she was running the camp, Laurel Falls camp. And so she was really reading it about child psychology to begin with, but then started integrating it with what was going on in Jim Crow, America. And really what she was talking about is what we call attachment issues today, attachment disorders. And so if you're not raised by your biological mom, you know, and then biological parents, and we see this in adopted kids all the time, you know, even if you're adopted at birth, there's something biological if you're not with your biological mother that happens and causes these attachment disorders.

SPEAKER_01And these disorders are often characterized by an inability to control emotion and inability to control anger, especially. And so, I mean, it it really from a neurobiology perspective answers a lot of the big questions about like why are all of these, you know, supposedly you know well-off white men and white white people, but white men particularly, so angry and so overcome, you know, with with this kind of violent emotion.

C. Derick VarnYeah, it it is fascinating. I I was thinking about that and then pairing that with southern honor culture, and it seems like a perfect, like like a perfect brewing point for like the most toxic masculinity you've ever seen in your life.

SPEAKER_01And she even takes it a step further, of course, like with all the Freudianism, and some, you know, some people think she's crossing a line here, but I think there there is some merit to it, is when you then take it and look at you know, what does it do sexually as well, you know, the the kind of sexual repression and sexual frustrations when when you're brought up by a black woman and you know and love this black woman and like love her as your own mother, and then you're told how wrong that love is and how you know how disgusting that love is, and and kind of what that does, especially to men, to white men, and and and and their own sexual repression, which then she argued added to to their rage uh issues.

C. Derick VarnYeah, another thing that comes up in that first chapter that I was actually surprised by because I did not know this was common in this time period, is when Linlian's first teaching, she ends up in in China in the warlord era era, which you know, right before the revolution, well, one of the revolutions. Um what what kind of insights specifically do you think this gave her?

C. Derick VarnAnd like maybe as a bridge to class issues, to imperialism, like what all did she see and how did she incorporate it?

SPEAKER_01Her three years in China, it was right after she finished college and and taught for a year or two, uh served as a principal in this tiny little one-room schoolhouse in Appalachia through because she was Methodist, of course, there are all sorts of programs in China, and her sister was married to, I think, the the head of the one of the heads of the W, the YMCA. And so they were moving people to China all the time to evangelize and and you know convert people.

SPEAKER_01And so she got a job teaching in a Methodist girls' school, teaching music. She's the music director there for three years, and like you said, 1921 through, or sorry, 20, yeah, 21 through 23, 24. And so she was right there as everything was falling to communism. She got to see she saw violence with her own eyes, even in the kind of rural area she was in. And it made her really be anti-communist, even though she was accused of being a communist and you know, had an FBI file on her 134 pages long, and was followed and accused by you know Hoover and everyone else of communism, even though she absolutely was anti-communist.

SPEAKER_01But it also really shaped her ideas about imperialism and connected her ideas on colonialism and imperialism to the type of racism that was going on in the US. And it you know, that comes out in a lot of her later, like kind of Cold War era books, where she's constantly comparing the situation that's going on in China and India to the racial kind of caste system in America.

C. Derick VarnSo moving on a little forward in the book, we get to her relationship with Paula Snelling and and the establishment of Laurel Falls. In what ways did the class background of the wealthy and conservative families who sent their daughters to Laurel Falls create a create a paradox for Lillian who who had already embraced deliberate efforts to teach racial tolerance and human equality and start looking at labor issues?

SPEAKER_01So when Lillian takes over Camp Laurel Falls, that's in 1925, and they they run it for 20 years. She and uh Paula was actually already working there, and and once she and Paula meet again when she returns from China and they literally basically become an item the minute they meet each other again and are inseparable for the rest of their lives after that. Paula's the assistant director, and they just transform the camp. They get rid of all the patriotic things. There's no pledge of allegiance, there's no flags, they get rid of all of the competitive activities and sports where there are winners and losers, and instead transform it into an extremely, extremely creative space where the girls, and the girls range from like seven to seventeen and they go all summer, so they're for two months, and they come from all over the South, like the most prominent families in the South.

SPEAKER_01And they are engaged in all sorts of arts, uh, writing, you know, literature, poetry, creating plays, putting on plays, fine arts, and then outdoor activities. But the one of the most important things was that Lillian wanted to foster just an area of free speech for these girls to exist in. And so on Sunday mornings, instead of going to church or having some kind of religious service, they would all just sit together outside in nature and discuss literally everything from racism and white supremacy to by the time World War II is going on, you know, Nazism and even what Americans were doing to the Japanese.

SPEAKER_01And, you know, everything from lynchings that happened 40 miles down the road to bodies and sexuality and sex, like really taboo topics that you would never hear spoken about in the 1930s or 40s. Or 20s, you know, in the South, especially. But Lillian was doing this. And the campers' families knew about it. Even these father figures knew about it. And she always contended that they knew, but they still chose to send their daughters there year after year after year because they knew that they were so psychologically stunted because of what white supremacy and the mindset of white supremacy did to them, that they needed somebody else to teach their children not to be like they are, essentially.

SPEAKER_01I mean, it's a really kind of messed up situation, but it's also, it's like, wow, you really think of these hardened races, some of them, you know, prominent politicians, sending their daughters to this school, you know, and ostensibly like people kind of knew there there are you know quite a few lesbians and you know, kind of non-binary women running uh running the place, and and yet still chose to send their daughters there year after year.

C. Derick VarnYeah, this this chapter also kind of got me to a paradox of of Southern life. On one hand, if you know the history of Savannah and Macon, you know that it's been a thriving queer scene for since they've been cities, basically. Right. On the other hand, talking about that before, I don't know, maybe the 1970s was nearly impossible. So, so how did Paula and Lillian make this work? And and you know, it seems like it was kind of an open secret emboston marriage kind of thing, but but what was the response in the community like?

SPEAKER_01Well, so I think being in that rural area was the key to everything because it really is like you know, that people in that area were just they live and let live, like do what you want to do. We're not gonna get into your business unless you're you know in infringing on our rights. And so there is a lot of when you have a big old piece of land, you have a lot of room for secrecy and living how you want to. But that I do argue it wasn't a secret. It was, it was really, you know, pretty open that if you look in any of their correspondence, people, although they're not referring to Paula as Lillian's wife, they're inquiring about her as they would a spouse, always talking about the two of them together.

SPEAKER_01They hosted parties and events together. Lillian inscribed and dedicated strange fruit to Paula. I mean, it was it was people, her, her family, the the other Smith siblings, when Lillian was traveling to India to research a book, they literally raised the money so that Paula could accompany her. They knew, even if they didn't want to fully admit the sexual relationship that the women had, they knew that they were together and in every other sense of the word. And what's really interesting is on the little mountain where Laurel Falls is, it's called Old Screamer Mountain, beautiful, just bucolic, beautiful place.

SPEAKER_01There were several other gay couples there and lesbian couples there, and they all they honestly had like a kind of a little community. And when Lillian got extremely sick with breast cancer and was traveling up and back to New York City to get treatment at what becomes Memorial Sloan Kettering, she's bankrupting herself getting these treatments. And it's actually a a lesbian that lives right down the street from them, named Ulmer, where she goes by her last name, and she's actually from down middle Georgia, big slaveholding family. And her dad had gotten rich on shipping iced melons up to New York, I believe.

SPEAKER_01That was the source of wealth. But she ended up loaning Lillian, you know, I think probably like a thousand dollars at the time to help her and Paula really keep the land on Old Streamer and survive through those medical bills.

C. Derick VarnIt's interesting. There's a lot of that in the in the Lower Appalachians in the uh in the early 20th century, and that a lot of that has been kind of erased, even though you can see it in you know the Firefox Collective and well the Black Mountain School in the Carolinas. So it's it's it's there, but it is amazing how even like in American countercultural history it's not really spoken about.

C. Derick VarnWhat do you think that is?

SPEAKER_01I honestly think it goes against our narrative of what we want to think about the South in a lot of ways, right? Of being this backwards, like non-progressive place. And and it really does kind of shatter that. But I also think people just don't know about it, that there was there is a culture of silence. That it's like, you know, my my good friend Karen Cox, who who is a scholar of the queer south, you know, she's like, you just use euphem euphemisms, and you know, that's your your strange uncle or your you know, whatever. You use the euphemisms and get on and just don't think about it too much.

SPEAKER_01And so it's like we know they're there, we know we we we fully realize like what these people are doing, but just because we don't name it, it doesn't necessarily get it written about.

C. Derick VarnYeah, I mean that's even true. I think about making because I literally went at one point lived in uh little Richards community, which is unfortunately at least in the aughts, was a very rundown part of town. But like how much queer life was there, and just you would never know. Like, you know, it was just kind of a race. And I run I found that ironic, particularly at the time, because it was the time of like midnight in the garden of good and evil, and people realizing this about Sunday Anna, and I was like, that's everywhere here, right?

SPEAKER_01Right, it's kind of like the weird south, right? I mean, you just kind of accept the weirdness that's especially in these rural areas, yeah.

C. Derick VarnSo yeah, it one of the things about Laurel Falls, it does also seem to enable Lillian and Paula to get a lot of support. One of the biggest ones seems to be the Julius uh Rosenwald fellowship. How did that affect them to be able to do more research?

SPEAKER_01Right. Well, I mean, it was just it was a cash influx, and so you know, they were running the camp during the summers, but otherwise, basically Paula was having to go back down to Macon and teach. She worked as a teacher. She she Paula has a or had a master's degree from Columbia University. Paula, in her own right, was brilliant, could have been an amazing writer had she really stuck with it. And I do argue that you know she was a key to all of Lillian's success and fame, and was, you know, much more than just a kind of editor and and secretary, but probably really a co-writer, at least a co-thinker on most of the big ideas that that Lillian had.

SPEAKER_01But I mean, the the community there like fully supported them. They really the the one thing I point out that other books haven't really made a lot about is that Lillian's older brother, Frank Adam Smith, was actually basically the CEO, was basically the CEO of Raven County up in that area. And so while he was in government, he really did keep the two women safe. He was he was essentially like the main, the head judge, everyone in the county knew him, law enforcement was at his behest.

SPEAKER_01So he was able to keep them safe. But as soon as he is out of office, you see all of these, you know, three different arsons are started at her house. The threats get worse. And so, so really he is able to kind of keep a hold on things until about the mid-50s. And that's when 1955 is when the first major arson happened that took out you know almost all of her works in progress, and so much of her correspondence and notes for for works that she was planning to write.

C. Derick VarnYeah. So yeah, you you had the arsons, and then also it seems like you had the the onset of World War II, which uh despite the fact that the Popular Front seemed to make that a war that a lot of progressives and stuff were okay with. How did it shift the political consciousness of the campers? And what kind of pushback did Lillian and Paula get to their explicitly anti-war and explicitly unpatriotic or at least apatriotic curriculum?

SPEAKER_01So Lillian was used to getting pushback and she would always be, you know, trying to push the envelope on things from the very earliest days of the camp. She actually tried to have black campers there, and the parents, of course, would not have that. And I think she realized legally she couldn't do that. But so instead, what she would do is she would bring local black children to the camp during the day. You know, they couldn't stay there at night, but they'd come in and have lunch and do activities with the girls so that the girls would actually spend time and get to know black children in a way that they wouldn't outside of that kind of situation.

SPEAKER_01But, you know, when she, especially when she started, they started the writing for the magazine and started becoming more and more outspoken about white supremacy and combating any kind of inequality. She thought that there would be a lot more girls, you know, whose parents pulled them out of the camp. And that simply just didn't happen. I think after she published Strange Fruit, which like should have made half of them go running, I think she had like two or three drop out. And but there were, you know, dozens waiting to take their places.

SPEAKER_01So it was never an issue about having enough campers or whether she was too radical. And she openly compared white supremacy and racism in America to Nazism, and would frankly ask little girls, like, you know, are you are you comfortable with being holding the same views as a Nazi? And it seemed to be very effective. Like the campers, that's something that they talked about later in life, was were those kind of comparisons that kind of really knocked them out of their sense of entitlement and privilege and got them to realize kind of the errors of what they had been taught and the the community that they had grown up in.

C. Derick VarnIt's quite interesting. I was thinking about like how much more censorious the southeast and or I live in Utah now, which Utah does a lot of the same thing. Like you couldn't get away even today, actually, with some of things they were doing in the 30s and 40s. And I was like, I was kind of amazed by that. I was I was surprised. I was just like, this is interesting because later on they are much better at censoring this kind of thing with children. Um but that does bring me to South Today, which which you mentioned, the magazine.

C. Derick VarnAnd I I was interested, I did not know about this magazine, and I find it interesting because even though I was in a nominally anti-racist school in an anti-racist English department, blah blah blah, that you exist in the southeast, uh, I wasn't taught about it. And I wasn't taught that there was actually pushback to the Southern agrarians out of Nashville uh at all. And how did the magazine really push back on the Southern Agrarian narrative and on the other like social economic trends out of sociologists at Chapahill and whatnot?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, it was it was so they this they started the thinking about the magazine 1935. Paula had had a really bad horseback riding accident and where she almost died. And so she was like laid up for months and months and months recovering. And Lillian was caretaking for her mother as well. Her mother was basically in the final stages of dementia where she was, you know, really probably physically and mentally abusive, like very hard to take care of. But Lillian was doing the work, and they were both both women were just totally depressed and you know didn't have anything to kind of live for at some points.

SPEAKER_01And so they Paula had this idea let's start a magazine. And Lillian went for it. They they started as co-editors and ran it for 10 years from 1936 to 1945, had a couple of name changes, but it had started out as really like literary criticism and talking about literary traditions in the South. And you know, in that kind of era is when the Nashville agrarians had were were big. They were being read, of course, in the the late 30s.

SPEAKER_01And so Lillian and Paula had gotten to know all of the sociologists at UNC Chapel Hill, and really a lot of their ideas really melded with what the women believed as well. They were, of course, way more racially egalitarian and were trying to figure out very real ways to modernize and industrialize the South so that you know living would be life would be better for for the poorest Southerners, essentially. And so they, you know, they were ahead of the curve in publishing really progressive academics as well as black writers as well.

SPEAKER_01They were the only white publication in the South at the time publishing black writers. They were the first people to publish black writers in the South. So, you know, again, another pretty revolutionary thing that they did, it became more and more kind of socially activist as time went on. And it became really widely read, not only throughout the South, but throughout America. Like some of the articles that Lillian would write that were combating racism, combating segregation, telling white people how to act, like literally telling white people what to do to combat segregation, those would sell hundreds of thousands of copies throughout the US and be sent all over the world, even.

C. Derick VarnYeah, and that's that's important because we have to remind ourselves that magazine networks in this time period are regional. They're not even really national, much less international, with rare exception. So yeah, I I was really struck by by one essay you mentioned in the the the piece, which is two men in a bargain, which really goes into the way racial animus is used to prevent class and labor solidarity.

C. Derick VarnAnd I mean, we see this line. I remember when you started seeing this in other parts of the country like Wisconsin, when they started pushing back on public bargaining, and I was like, Well, I'm from Georgia, and that's been illegal here literally since there's been unions, uh like there is no public sector unions here of any of any importance, you have associations, but they can't collectively bargain anywhere. And those laws are still in the books, but it really showed up.

C. Derick VarnI remember learning, I must have been about 10 years ago, that as bad as it was even for for black labor in the northeast, that black labor in the northeast still actually did better than white labor in the south. And we're not talking about black labor, which was basically completely suppressed. You know, how what kind of effect do you think this essay had at the time and and and why is it kind of forgotten since it gets to something a little bit obvious?

SPEAKER_01Well, I mean, I think that's probably why it's forgetting forgotten, right? Is that that there's a reason that that the people who are choosing what you learn and what you read don't want you to read this essay, because it does so perfectly lay out the the role that that class plays in in maintaining white supremacy and even classism itself. And and because the South, and especially the deep South, where you have almost half the population black and half the population white throughout most of its history, you always have strikebreakers, you always have a segment of strikebreakers, and and you don't ever end up with any kind of real labor solidarity when there's racism.

SPEAKER_01And so she just takes you step through step. It's really she writes it as a conversation between Mr. Rich White and Mr. Poor White, and it really is brilliant how simply she does it. And you know, it's just Mr. Rich White is is telling the poor white, well, you can be racist and you can lord over all these black men and black women as long as you do what we tell you to do, essentially, and toe toe the status quo line in regards to race and class. And anytime the Mr. Poor White tries to step out of place and do something or or or make friends with the black man or do anything to improve his lot, you know, Mr.

SPEAKER_01Rich White always has something to stamp out that you know, any kind of chance he has to get himself out of that situation because he holds so much power and holds, you know, all the key to all the jobs in the area, the key to all the wealth. And so, I mean, she really did understand the organization of the South in a way that few other people who were writing, and especially you know, the people that are writing who came from the upper classes really were able to understand how how much racism was dependent on classism.

C. Derick VarnYeah. Yeah, it really hit me because I'm like, well, this feels like it should have been obvious, and yet it really wasn't, and sometimes it kind of still isn't. Like when you try to explain, I I remember having some arguments with some well-meaning Northeastern socialists and progressives, like, oh, we weren't hard enough on the South. And I was like, Well, you were plenty hard on the economic realities of the South. Like, the South was basically used as a textile mill. And if you know anything about like capitalism where the textile mills is usually where the worst shit happens today, that's Bangladesh.

C. Derick VarnBut you are right that, like, for some reason the southern planter class escaped okay, and it was almost like northern industrial capital figured out that they could use the southern planter class to administer the entire thing.

SPEAKER_01Well, that's it, yeah, that's exactly what happens, right? I mean, you don't you there if there's no penalties after the civil war, and the main leaders are never actually held accountable in any kind of way, wealth never changes hands because even though the primary form of wealth was enslaved people, that's gone. You still own all the land, and so if you own all the land in an agricultural society, you you've got a monopsony.

C. Derick VarnYeah, and I mean it it and it's interesting because it was in the North's interest too, in that like it forced a lot of poor whites into the military, which you know from World War IV becomes like a major part of the southern economy, maybe like almost straight out of the way the British treated the Scottish and the Irish, even. And and yet you're absolutely right, the leadership was not punished at all. And in fact, arguably it's still kind of in power, but but today, I I mean I find it frustrating when I talk to people there like, oh, the South won.

C. Derick VarnAnd I'm like, Well, no, you guys just re-empowered the planter class, and these are their children, but like most southern people weren't actually all that sympathetic to that, at least before the 1950s.

SPEAKER_01Right, right. The South at large did not win because most people are living below the poverty level. Most people are at living in the kind of you know, developing nation conditions throughout most of the deep south in reality. And and so, yes, it's it was a reinforcement of the planter class elites who you're completely right. Like you look at who still owns the majority of wealth, particularly in rural areas in the south today, that you can trace their descendants, their lines back exactly to who owned the most enslaved people, you know, 150, 200 years ago.

SPEAKER_01Yep.

C. Derick VarnThis kind of brings me to the the poster censorship of South today, though, which was seemed to be a coalition between the Klan. I believe it was the second clan. I'm always getting making sure I got my clan numbers right because they are different. And uh Southern State Astartes, which they really seemed to be able to do in late 1942. How were they able to do that? Like what were what was the Klan and these these politicians able to do to get the federal post office to to to censor this magazine?

SPEAKER_01I don't, you know, that's a I don't know exactly how those back channels worked, except for that most of the upper class elites who are running these counties, you know, were involved in in if not the Klan, then white citizens' councils and things like that, kind of the and so yeah, so South today is like they had they farmed it out to be printed one time, and it got into the hands of somebody who gave it to the Klan.

SPEAKER_01And they had the Klan after them on one hand, and literally like the GBI and the postmistress of Raven County going after them on the other hand. So like fighting, you know, government and vigilante forces at the same time to try to get their little magazine out to people, you know, mainly mainly white housewives throughout the region. And so it's just it's it's kind of like a lesson in an absurdity, but that's how I mean that's how threatening the message was, right? Is that you've got you've got at the clan, and that's probably where a lot of her threats are coming from when they come from within the region, are these organized groups of white supremacists.

C. Derick VarnWell, I mean, I can understand why why the right supremacists were so up and armed, in so much that like not only was she publishing black writers, but let's talk about the specific black writers she was publishing, because we're talking about communist period, WEW Boys, we're talking about Holly Murray. It was like it wasn't just it wasn't just that they were publishing black writers, which is uh in and of itself at the time was huge, but like they published the most radical ones you could find in the South, period. Right. Like, how did this help these black writers?

C. Derick VarnWas it able to spread their you know are some of these people more names? Like, is you know, do we know more about WBG Boys because of this? Or are You know.

SPEAKER_01Well, so Du Bois was already like totally established, not him, but Polly Murray for sure. She got her first paycheck through writing for South Today and really credited the women with a lot of her success. And she ends up getting a Rosenwald fellowship as well. While she's at Howard University Law, uh Law School, getting her law degree, she was gonna have to drop out altogether until Paula and Lillian wrote her a letter of recommendation to get one of these fellowships.

SPEAKER_01And that's literally what kept her in law school. And they served as kind of like mother figures in a way of introducing Pauly to people and getting her writing out there. And it wasn't just her, it was all throughout their lives until Lillian died in 1966. Of course, she was those last few years, especially, she was so sick with breast cancer and on all sorts of experimental drugs that really messed with her head. But she always, she and Paula always would have activists, young activists up to old Screamer Mountain, where they would just like mother them, feed them well, have them rest, take care of them, and really liked to help care for others in those kind of ways.

C. Derick VarnWell, this gets us up to about the time of Strange Fruit, which is a novel that I thought I like. So this came out in 1944, right? And it was it was best selling to you. This is the other thing that makes its erasure kind of weird. So you want to talk about the a little just a little bit about the plot of the novel and its initial response?

SPEAKER_01Sure. And so yeah, I I had never read Strange Fruit growing up. I never even heard the title of it again until graduate school, but released on Leap Day of 1944, completely, completely like you know, blew people's minds because of the radical nature of it. It describes basically an interracial love affair between a soldier coming back from World War I, and he he's in love with this young college-educated, Spelman-educated black woman. And they, of course, can't ever have you know live out their romance.

SPEAKER_01And she the woman gets pregnant and it becomes this big plot line, and the novel actually ends up with a lynching of a black man. And so just just a very you know racially explosive book in so many different ways. It's immediately banned in Boston for lewdness, banned in Detroit. It's shadow banned basically throughout the South, but it still sells three million copies, it's translated into dozens of languages, it makes an international star out of Lillian, and she becomes basically accepted into New York high society.

SPEAKER_01She's going to like salons at Dorothy Norman's house and you know, basically rubbing elbows with the intelligentsia and really feeling like she's finally made it as a writer. And it even leads her into she's invited to make a Broadway play out of it, which she does, unfortunately. In that Broadway play, she was basically kind of strong alarm by the other director into making it very focused on the lynching in the book. When she didn't want it to be focused on the lynching, she wanted to be focused on kind of white people's brokenness and psychological issues resulting from white supremacy.

SPEAKER_01But because it ended up focusing on the lynching, and because it had like just this huge cat cast and it was super expensive, you know, it closed after 10 months and was kind of panned by the press. And she always saw this Broadway play as like bringing down even, you know, the good parts and the the good reception of the novel itself.

C. Derick VarnYeah, what one thing your book also made interesting to me about this novel. I mean, one is the Comstock Dack was even used to censor it under FDR, and it took Eleanor Roosevelt intervening for it to be able to be shipped through the mail again. But also the difference between the formal and informal ways of censorship between the South and the North, because the the formal bannings were actually mostly in the Northeast. Even as early as the 40s, Southerners had already realized that it was easier to informally do everything, so you couldn't challenge it, than it was to do formally do everything.

C. Derick VarnAnd and you know, I was thinking about this in regards to the way the South worked even when I was a kid, because there were areas in the 80s and 90s and even aughts that like had totally private prompts, and you're like, why are there only private prompts? And you go back and look at oh, so they could stay racially segregated way later than you would have expected, because it was informal and unofficial. Um so why do you think like what do you think kept the the book in circulation despite these vans?

C. Derick VarnAnd you know, how much did informal censorship in the south curtail the novel? It doesn't seem like a lot.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, it doesn't seem like a lot because I think this is something that especially southerners who were well read always had dealt with, right? This censorship has always been a huge issue in the South, from the time of enslaved being unable to read to not educating poor whites so that they couldn't read either, to censoring things like Hint Helper's book in the 1850s. They they never wanted this kind of knowledge about class or racism to reach the populace of the South. And so, you know, she Lillian herself described it as, yeah, it was probably effective in some ways of keeping it out of the hands of people.

SPEAKER_01But, you know, the the flip side of book bands is it makes people want what they can't have, right? It makes people more intrigued by what is that book saying that I can't read. And so it literally like they stick the book in brown paper bags and pass it around like it was, you know, illegal drugs or something. And you know, even the UGA library got copies of it. And so, like, you know, if you even had a few librarians, you know, every few counties getting a copy of it, it would be checked out for you know years at a time.

SPEAKER_01And so it it was, I think it was really a lot more well read than the actual number of copies showed.

C. Derick VarnBut this does start, as you already mentioned in uh in a response to an earlier question, but this does start the FBI really looking into uh Lilian Smith and trying to tie her to communism a lot. Um to some degree, it's uh even though she was a starch uh an anti-communist, she did move around radical black circles, which at the time did almost necessarily, given who was supporting the black arts in the 40s and 50s, put you near communist.

C. Derick VarnHow did this affect her? And did it have any effect? Because it does also seem like in this time period under Hoover, they were basically accusing everybody of being communist.

SPEAKER_01So I don't know that it really affected her because she didn't seem to know about it until much later. I think she kind of realized that she was being watched, I believe, in the early 50s, if I remember correctly. One of her agents told her that she was on a list, but that she, you know, Ralph McGill wasn't, she thought it would have to do with the being a Rosenwald recipient, but then she was questioning and it was like Ralph McGill wasn't being watched, and you know, Paula wasn't being watched. But so I don't think it really affected her, but she, I mean, 134 pages is a big file back then, and they watched her literally from 1943 when they right before they knew Strange Fruit was about to come out, and they had already, I think, been monitoring some of the articles she was writing for South Today, and then her relationship with Mary McLeod Bethune and also the the first lady Eleanor Roosevelt, they were monitoring all of that stuff, and and then once she becomes friends with the Kings in the 1960s, that oh, they're all over that, especially any of her involvement with Coretta Scott King.

SPEAKER_01But I think at the time it's not even a question of like really it was she a communist, they're just using the word communist as anybody who's sympathizing with andor working towards you know civil rights in any kind of way.

C. Derick VarnWhich I guess also brings me to the nonfiction book, which I also didn't know and felt really dumb for not knowing about. Um, which is I didn't either Killers of the Dream. I was surprised that someone like spelled this out in 1949, like because you know, people spell this out now. I mean, like, you know, I remember post 80s scholarships talking about the same thing, but this is basically 30, 40 years before that, right?

SPEAKER_01Um and it and it's it's kind of shadow banned too, so it doesn't sell anywhere near you know what Strange Fruit does, it's not anywhere, even though it's probably associated with her most these days. Uh strange fruit was far more red uh at the time and even now.

C. Derick VarnSo it it it talks about the planners, you know, doing the poll text things, doing the primaries, doing demagogue, but also how it crushes and also co-opts the populist movement. So you would go to her argument there because I actually really uh wrote a book recently that was a critique of American left populism, but I was also like confounded, and I have been historically confounded by why William Jennings Bryant decides to liquidate into the into the Democratic Party of the Confederacy, not of FDR.

C. Derick VarnAnd that needs to be like very that needs to be clear when we talk about that, because it's like it's easy to retroactively make it seem like that makes sense because of the FD because of FDR, but that that's not when Bryan did it. So, and this is a big part of her book is her talking about the the the making irrelevance of the populace. So, what's what's her argument and does it historically hold up in your opinion?

SPEAKER_01I think it mostly holds up. Yeah, she, I mean, it's it's the same argument that most historians would make today is that you know you have all of these kind of unpunished, unreconstructed planters and sons of planters that maintain power within the south. And you know, the it's gave and rights, the economists gave and rights argument that these these labor lords they they become landlords, right? Their wealth just shifts forms. And since they own all the land, they still control everything in a place.

SPEAKER_01And and so if you control all the resources, you basically have a monopsony and and you can control labor by choosing what what to pay them. And then, like I said, you know, if you have problems from any of your labors, you can switch to all black laborers or all white laborers and use them as strikebreakers and use them, you know, in gender racism and try to keep them apart and and hating each other. And it's there's always some form of cheap and and usually cheap and unfree labor to use in the South that is always gonna unundercut you know any kind of free labor and any kind of earning a living wage.

C. Derick VarnYeah, I I remember realizing how much prison labor from press gangs to even stuff today like prison manufacturing and semi-privatized prisons, really played a role in wage suppression in the southeast forever, like since since there's been a southeast of the United States. And what I but what I also found interesting about the book is that she does, unlike a lot of other activists who are interested in the sociology of it at the time period, well, even now, she does come up with a psychological theory to pair with the sociology that we've already kind of talked about a little bit about the mother room, but how much did the three ghost relationship theory like affect this book?

C. Derick VarnAnd and you know, why isn't that argument picked up more today?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, I I mean I think it would definitely be uh still controversial today and probably generate a lot of interest, but yeah, the these this these three ghost relationships make up the the basis of Killers of the Dream, and and really she uses them to explain the psychology behind hatred, the psychology behind how to maintain white supremacy even when it doesn't benefit you know, even certain white people. And if whether by looking at the that kind of mother wound, not having your mother raise you, and then having attachment issues, or then you know what it does to sexuality and sexual repression between the races, and and then kind of just what what does all of this racism and hatred?

SPEAKER_01We know what it does to black people and the people that are being hated, but what does it do to white people? What does it do to the psyches and psychology of white people? What does being in a state of hatred, you know, not even physically, but just mentally, do to you? And I again with the with kind of all the research and and the the like the emphasis in the last few years on the mind-body connection and like how you can make yourself sick with different, you know, different psychological states. I mean, I I think this is more relevant than ever in terms of you know when you're just manifesting all of this hatred all of the time, you know, how does it come out in your actions?

SPEAKER_01How does it come out in your everyday behaviors?

C. Derick VarnYeah, I actually went and looked up this book uh from reading yours and then was was like, I feel like this would get a lot more play now than it even would, not even when it was written, but even like 20, 30 years ago, because it does seem so far ahead of like trying to bridge political economy, sociology, and trauma psychology together for all sides.

SPEAKER_01Right, and even spirituality, she's she's throwing that back in too. Right.

C. Derick VarnI I also wanted to know, I was surprised at how much pushback this got, not just from you know who you expect it to get, of course, you know, Dixiecrats are gonna hate it, but also it got a lot of pushback from moderate anti-segregationists like uh Ralph McGill and Holding Carter II. Why is that? What was motivating this pushback from what would otherwise have been seemingly like liberal allies to this person, you know, to Lillian?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, so Lillian made it kind of her personal mission to really go after these white men, and most of them were you know in in publishing or in writing or academia somehow, who were native-born Southerners who who said that they spoke for the South, would claim to speak for the South, who she felt did not go far enough in promoting racial equality or civil rights or integration. And I mean, it's true, Ralph McGill never said a thing about integration until integration had already happened.

SPEAKER_01And yet, you know, whenever we see even lists today about who were some of the great, you know, white Southerners to fight for civil rights, like Ralph McGill is usually number one on the list. And he really was pretty moderate, even though she kept trying to push him to be more progressive and push him publicly. Like she excoriated him in the media, and he her too. He he panned her books publicly, he went after her personally because she she was pushing to make those kind of big changes, you know, in the 30s and 40s, even way before the South was even having those conversations.

C. Derick VarnAnother thing that I I I kind of noticed about uh her in this time period, so this is you know, I guess we're talking about 49 to 5152, is that she does take an like an active role in the liberal wing of the anti-communist movement, particularly for Americans for uh for democratic action, confusingly the ADA, because you know, we don't need enough overlapping letters. But I found that interesting when you paired this with her defense of Paul Robeson and a lot of like acting like black active communists that she knew were communists.

C. Derick VarnHow did she square that? And what you know, like like why was that so important to her that she not be part of the people, you know, demon demonizing or suppressing these communists, even when she opposed them ideologically so thoroughly?

SPEAKER_01That's a fantastic question. I I honestly think it's because she was such an empathetic person, like she really was an empath, and she could, in a way that very few white people probably have tried to do, but even can do, was able to put herself in the shoes of how black Americans felt. And it probably was because of all the personal relationships, very close relationships she had with black Americans at the time, that she did understand how they felt. She did understand the way that they thought, and that the way that they thought was different than the way that she thought, because they're coming from completely different places, different backgrounds, different histories.

SPEAKER_01And she, I mean, if nothing else, damn, she was a researcher. She was gonna go read, you know, 50, 100 books on a subject and learn everything she could, and was always more than willing to read books, you know, by black authors, by whether when she was doing India and China research, by you know, those authors and and willing to see things from different perspectives.

C. Derick VarnSo just you know, we are approaching sadly the end, you know, the wrapping down of her life. She's uh we're in the by the early 50s unbeknownst to her, so at least she's only got about 19 years left. But I I was kind of taken by the fact that we can really see her internationalism in a way that you don't expect from from like a woman from the deep south at the time, as almost at bookends of her life, because you have this trip to China in her 20s, and then and then towards the end of her life, you have her travel to India, you know, for the fam uh for the famine commission.

C. Derick VarnHow did that affect her views of Jim Crow and and did it expand her views about colonialism in any way? She was already pretty radicalized on this on this subject, but it seems to you know have been a big deal towards the end of her career.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, it absolutely shaped a lot of her beliefs, not only Chinese philosophy when she was in China, but then she spent time six months in India in 1946, and then again in 1954. And both times Lil, sorry, Paula accompanied her. And these were long trips where she really toured the country. This the second one, by that time, she was already friends with some really high-up officials in the UN who were Indian, who then introduced her to like the Gandhis and all sorts of prominent officials.

SPEAKER_01But she also really became a pro a proponent, strong proponent, lawful, lifelong proponent of nonviolence because of her connection to India. And so it was even following Gandhi, you know, before she met Martin Luther King and held on to that kind of, you know, that that philosophy of nonviolence, even when the civil rights movement, you know, by the mid and late 60s had made a turn away from nonviolence. She she held steadfast to those kind of beliefs.

C. Derick VarnYeah, I was gonna ask about that because it does seem like you know the the civil rights movement gets more and more radicalized by the mid-60s for for a good reason, because not a lot of people often link it to like, oh, it's a change of campus culture at the time. But I was like, Yeah, but a lot of them were killed just flat up. Like uh both white and black, they're just gone. You know, my parents were from this time period, and they would tell me stories about about you know the news about those people just be oh, a group of SNCC activists went into Alabama and then they weren't there anymore.

C. Derick VarnLike there wasn't even that much of an investigation of what happened. So how how did she maintain that, you know, in that time period? I mean, it it's it's interesting that she did when when things were and did she get a lot of pushback from others in the movement for maintaining that that way.

SPEAKER_01So by the time this was happening, she again she was so sick with cancer. She she had originally been diagnosed with cancer in 1953 and she dies in 66. So she had a 13-year, and and she shouldn't have been probably alive longer than the first five years, but it was only because she was going up to New York and getting all these experimental treatments that it really prolonged her life. But but you know, the flip side is she's on all of these experimental treatments that really messed with her head in terms of her thinking.

SPEAKER_01She got really paranoid on some of the drugs. But she was she was kind of out of her head by those last few years. So I don't want to take like, you know, everything that she did or said in those years as what she would have done had she been really well in herself and been possibly able to evolve in in a real way. But she definitely just kind of stuck with what she knew and and actually ended up getting some real pushback from especially black activists during that time period.

SPEAKER_01She she gets into like some Vietnam War controversy as well, but you know, it's it's just you you see like this struggling. Old woman who's dying, and it's like, how you take anything she's really saying, yeah, at face value when she's on all sorts of crazy drugs and prednisone and steroids that really affect your thinking. But yeah, she she she could not evolve with the movement those last few years.

C. Derick VarnYeah. Did the hounding of her for being a communist, which is deeply ironic given her roles we've already talked about as an avid at the communist, did that affect her during this period of of her health? Because you know, she's still she's still being targeted during the Red Scare, and that's when she starts getting sick.

SPEAKER_01So yeah, it's messed up. I'm I really do think, you know, again, if we if we want to go down this road of like the body keeps the score kind of thing, you see her starting to get really, really sick from overwork and overexertion right after strange fruit. And she that's kind of why they end up closing the camp because she can't do both things. She can't continue being a writer and run the camp. It's just too much. And I think she goes for like a year where she where she does almost nothing, is just on like a bunch of antibiotics.

SPEAKER_01And I'm wondering if that's like kind of when it really starts brewing in her body, and then she's she's keeps getting sick, keeps getting sick and until they finally find find the tumor. But yeah, she she had a pretty good attitude about it. And she and Paula actually ended up doing a whole bunch of research on disability because she started having all these surgery and this radical mastectomy, and they removed a bunch of her muscles in her right arm. So even her ability to work and write was affected. And that's what made her the most depressed was like she couldn't work as much as she wanted to.

SPEAKER_01And she would literally be getting up out of the hospital bed and going and writing uh, you know, for an hour and then returning back to her hospital bed. And but I mean it didn't stop the racist because she was literally at at Emory getting a treatment when they started one of the arsons in 1958.

C. Derick VarnSo I one of the things that that you bring out a lot is this kind of somewhat conventional the division of labor and the root and the relationship between Paula and Lillian. They were also non-monogamous to some degree. And how does that affect them throughout their lives? Like, how does this, you know, how does this relationship enable Lillian to do her work?

C. Derick VarnEnable, you know, how does Paula feel about the activism? Because she's clearly Lillian's equal. So how does that all go?

SPEAKER_01I I mean, I love Paula Snelling. She is one of the most fascinating characters I've ever come across. And like, you know, when I think about turning this into a film treatment or something at some point, I'm always like, oh, if you could do it through like the love story of her and Paula, because it's just such a beautiful story. And it really, I mean, Lillian, you if you read enough of Lillian, there are times you do not like her and you see kind of like the narcissist in her coming out a little bit. But Paula is just this lovely, lovely human being who is kind of a giver and she takes care of Lillian.

SPEAKER_01Like I said, everything from coming up with ideas, coming up with book projects, doing the research, doing the field work, editing, helping her write, all of it. She does all of the professional stuff, but she's also her caretaker, her nurse. And like essentially, like she is the traditional wife role in the relationship, nurturing and propping up, you know, somebody who is, you know, the producer and who becomes kind of the big star. And that's the role she always wanted, though. It wasn't anything like put upon her. Paula will literally say over and over again in their correspondence, like, all I want to do is support you.

SPEAKER_01I want to support you so you can be the writer. You know, she was just a teacher, she was a she was a caretaker, and and she genuinely loved, loved, loved Lily and seemed to do anything she could to make her life easier.

C. Derick VarnYeah, um the ability of those two to stay together was actually really impressive considering everything else that was going on.

SPEAKER_01Right, right.

C. Derick VarnSo I guess I have some big theme questions to kind of round us off throughout the book and as early as her like late teens and twenties, Lillian Sm insists that racism is not merely a moral setting or part of southern culture, you know. Uh, it might be those things too, but it's it's it's not the the essential element. She sees it as an economic tool utilized by elite planters and industries and and northern industrialists to fracture the working class and and destroy solidarity within the working class.

C. Derick VarnHow does Smith's analysis align with WED Du Bois's concept of the psychological wages of whiteness? Are some of these early middle theories about the way white supremacy actually worked, and and how might it differ from our understanding in 2025, 2026?

SPEAKER_01So I think she definitely was reading Du Bois, she definitely understood the psychological wages of whiteness and believed that you know that that was a big part of keeping white supremacy going. But then I think she takes things a step further in terms of looking at you know even at like a deeper psychological level. Like, not what does it do like when you're thinking I'm better off than him, but like when you're really sitting with yourself and really like doing, you know, kind of a deep dive into your own psyche, what does it, what has that done to the white worker, you know, who has given up his own and his own family's well-being, just what, so he can be racist?

SPEAKER_01You know, what has it gotten him? And and how does that kind of kill your soul? You know, the the whole the whole idea of killers of the dream is is resonant in that analysis of class, I think. And today, I mean, obviously, I believe that it it certainly resonates. And you know, there were definitely in the last few years, there've been a whole lot of books about like, you know, what should white people not do, how to not be racist, and and certainly we needed those things at that time and place.

SPEAKER_01But now I think it's uh it's much more important to have kind of good role models, have you know, kind of a map of what you can do, what you can do to make changes. And you know, everybody needs heroes, everybody needs heroes, every group of people needs heroes and heroines. And I think you know, if you look, nobody's perfect, but if you look at her life overall and the kinds of things she stood for, the kinds of things she she fought for, the way she took her privilege so seriously and used it to help other people, you know, she Lillian Smith is a heroine we should be looking up to.

C. Derick VarnYeah, yeah, it is interesting. I guess just kind of brings me to the next question I got from the from from the overall book is like I said, not only are you and I fairly educated people, we're fairly educated people from the deep south, and yet we didn't know about this. I mean, you learned it in grad school. I heard about it from you basically, and it really got me thinking about the deep isolation of pre-civil rights anti-racist in in the southeast, and even now, and for reasons that are understandable, because you know you don't want another white savory narrative or whatever.

C. Derick VarnI mean, I I get that, but in a strange way, that's actually played into the erasure of these figures and what they believed. What can we learn from Lillian Smith about the erasure of these kind of radicals in the in the late 19th and early 20th century? And how can we make them you know more known and more relevant again so that it doesn't seem like everything began and also maybe got stalled in the 1960s and 70s?

SPEAKER_01That's that's a fantastic question that I wish I had better answers to. I think it's you know, just slowly uh telling their stories again and really bringing to light the fact that, yeah, overwhelmingly civil rights has had to be incumbent upon the people who are oppressed. But that's it, they've never been the oppressed have never been fighting alone, never at any point in our history, you know, and no matter what a lot of the popular histories would say, there have always been biracial, multiracial movements. There have always been allies alongside, you know, fighting for civil rights.

SPEAKER_01And the whole reason that this narrative is gone is because this kind of you know multiracial coming together, especially among poor people, working class people, is exactly what people in power still fear today, particularly in a country where there's complete elite capture of government at every level. And so this these are the stories they don't want told, you know, is it told. It's one thing to say, okay, yeah, these these black radicals are fighting for one for civil rights. But when you start saying, oh, these white people are working with them and working, you know, and even taking orders from them within the movement, and you know, things like that, that that complicates a narrative and and gives it so much nuance and that it makes it dangerous to the to the powers that at B, I think.

C. Derick VarnRight. I mean, you know, I think about this like with like the the kind of reckoning we've had with John Brown, but it seems like everyone's like, okay, we've had the reckoning with John Brown, I want to talk about anybody else. Yeah.

SPEAKER_01Well, there's a lot of them. There's a lot of them. So we start bringing them out and and get get their names known again.

C. Derick VarnYeah, I think the other flip side of that is what we have let represent white anti-racism is like the most milked toast elements of it. It's the Ralph McGills, it's you know, God bless them, the more modern ends of the Quakers. Yeah, that sort of thing. And even the radical Republican tradition in the north is relatively not understood or contextualized today, like the you know, the coalition of uh uh people in the Republican Party that were so radical that like you had the the first international writing them letters and you know they were doing German language stuff with communists at the time.

C. Derick VarnI mean, like that stuff has been mostly erased, even from the people who do tell a history of white allies. It's always like the really safe, you know, to kill a mockingbird, like allies that they put up.

SPEAKER_01They love a moderate, yeah.

C. Derick VarnI mean, it's actually why as bad as that the book was, it was a sequel to it. I was actually glad they published it because I was like, it makes some realistic points about who some of these moderates were, but anyway. So I think my last question is one of the things I I keep noticing when you're looking at Lillian Smith's Rice beyond the context of the South, is the national context of wars, World War I, World War II, and the and the cold war really do affect all this.

C. Derick VarnAnd we've talked a little bit about World War II, and you brought up World War I, but how much did the did the geopolitical pressures of the Cold War constrain or dilute radical economic critiques within and about the early civil rights movement? And also in what ways does that lead to the suppression of these pre-civil rights figures like Lillian Smith?

SPEAKER_01I I think it actually does. I think that the fact that she knows what she's talking about in regards to a lot of Asian diplomacy and you know, China-India relations and and communism itself. And she actually writes about a lot of this in her post 49, post-Killers of the Dream books, including in uh in long form pieces as well. And she's always connecting American racism, American imperialism to what's going on in these Asian countries.

SPEAKER_01And I think that actually is a reason that she's probably her later works are not as well read, mostly because most Americans don't really understand fully what's going on and and don't you know know how to kind of compare these situations. But then also I think it probably historically kind of relegated her as well. And you know, it's not like you can show this kind of clear-cut essay to to your class on civil rights when it's really going into all of these like international questions and and and you know, taking all of these different sets of of history and literature and politics and combining them together.

C. Derick VarnYeah, I was imagining teaching any middle or late Lillian Smith essay to a bunch of high schools. I'm a high school teacher as my day job. And I was like, there's no way I'd get away with that in Georgia or in Utah. Like there's absolutely no way it would it would be, you know. And so I find that kind of interesting, uh, just in this, like, why we don't know about these people in the same way that we do know about other people a little later. You know, it makes it harder to suppress people like Angela Davis when they live in a period of mass media because you have to also go and erase all the media references to them, right?

C. Derick VarnU yeah, I guess that that that wraps us uh that wraps us up on the book. I wanted to ask you like, do you have any current research stuff you're looking at? I know you're gonna be promoting this book for a little while, but what else are you working on in the future?

SPEAKER_01So I I definitely want to get back to writing a I've been researching this on and off for the last few years, but maybe like a newer Marxist history of reconstruction. There were several good ones in the late 60s, early 70s, and you know, they haven't kind of been picked back up. And I actually got I have a dear friend who just took over as the main editor for Freedman's Southern Society Papers and found a treasure trove of documents about, you know, kind of what's going on between poor whites and blacks right after the Civil War.

SPEAKER_01And it's just some amazing, amazing stuff that I'm still kind of sorting through. So definitely that a book on Reconstruction. And honestly, I'm I might try my hand at fiction at some point soon as well.

C. Derick VarnYeah, I would love a book on Reconstruction because I feel like I'm always like, okay, we have Eric Foner and we have the WD boys in the classics from the periods we got some good liberal and Marxists from the six from the 40s to the 60s, and that's it. Right. That's all I got. And it is important. I mean, like, I was taught the bad, dumb, you know, reconstruction failed because of carpet baggers and their black allies in school in the 1990s, like like explicitly, it wasn't even a little bit hidden.

C. Derick VarnAnd I feel like today the way we handle that is they don't teach that anymore, they just don't teach it at all. Like it's like reconstruction is like a you talk about it for a day and then you move on and you don't really go into it that much anymore.

SPEAKER_01So, right, because so few people really understand it, it's such a complicated and complex period. So a lot of great stuff.

C. Derick VarnYeah, it is always funny when I'm like trying to explain the to kids, like, yeah, there's this one black senator from Georgia in 1870, and there hasn't been another one until like 1985. Like, um, and there's like, wait, what how'd you get the first one? And I'm like, Well, that's that's a complicated question, kiddo.

SPEAKER_01Um well, thank you for teaching. I mean, it's so so important, especially right now. And keep fighting the good fight.

C. Derick VarnYeah, and you try to teach literature more than history, but yeah, it's I I'm trying, it's hard. Well, thank you for writing this book. Where can people find your work if they're interested?

SPEAKER_01I'm on some social media, not as as often as I used to be, but definitely check out my website, Carrie Lee Merritt.com. It's got all my books, got some some merch going on with some southern women writers there for sure, and some stuff about Lillian.

C. Derick VarnAll right. Thank you. I'll put that link in the bio. And I'm very glad you're doing this work because I as a as a as a as a far leftist who's also from the deep south, I'm also like, man, I wish you guys got our history right. Like, like it's way more interesting than you think it is.

SPEAKER_01Exactly, exactly. We'll we'll work together to change that.

C. Derick VarnYeah, thank you so much. Have a great rest of your day.

SPEAKER_01You too. Thanks, Derek.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. The Yellow Vests & The Battle for Democracy with Ida Susser

    Nov 19, 20261 hr 42 minAudio

    In this episode of VarnVlog, C. Derick Varn sits down with Dr. Ida Susser (Distinguished Professor of Anthropology at Hunter College and the CUNY Graduate Center) to explore her open-access book, The Yellow Vests and...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. How History Gets Hijacked By Christian Nationalist Myths with Warren Throckmorton

    Nov 16, 20261 hr 14 minAudio

    In this episode of VarnVlog, C. Derick Varn is joined by author, public researcher, and retired professor of psychology Dr. Warren Throckmorton to discuss his book, The Christian Past That Wasn’t: Debunking the...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Peronism Explained with Brandon Lightly

    Nov 12, 20261 hr 52 minAudio

    In this installment of the National Fronts series on VarnVlog, C. Derick Varn is joined by writing partner Brandon Lightly to deliver a comprehensive historical and materialist deconstruction of Peronism (Justicialism)...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Wired For Authoritarianism with Charles Derber

    Nov 9, 20261 hr 43 minAudio

    In this episode of VarnVlog, C. Derick Varn is joined by veteran sociologist, author, and activist Dr. Charles Derber (Boston College) to discuss his book Wired for Authoritarianism: American Oligarchies and How to...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Anti-Politics Still Explains Politics with Tad Tietze

    Nov 5, 20261 hr 34 minAudio

    In this episode of VarnVlog, C. Derick Varn is joined by psychiatrist, writer, and political commentator Dr. Tad Tietze (co-author of Left Flank) to unpack the evolving dynamics of anti-politics and hyperpolitics across...

    Credit the people on this episode