In this episode of VarnVlog, host C. Derick Varn is joined by Scott Parkin (organizing director at Rainforest Action Network and co-host of the Green & Red Podcast) and Dr. Thomas Zeitzoff (professor at American University's School of Public Affairs and author of No Option But Sabotage). Together, they explore the history of the radical environmental and animal liberation movements from the 1980s through today. They unpack the evolution from Earth First! to the Earth Liberation Front (ELF) and Animal Liberation Front (ALF), discussing the deep subcultural roots in punk rock and zine culture, the philosophical splits over deep ecology versus social ecology, the impact of the 1999 Seattle WTO protests, and the post-9/11 "Green Scare" state repression. Finally, they examine how state repression tactics continue to evolve today amidst anti-data center resistance and contemporary climate activism. Featured Topics & Takeaways: Defining Radical Environmentalism: Why radicalism is defined by a systemic critique and strategy - not just tactics. The Evolution of Eco-Radicalism: Tracing the shift from 1980s Earth First! wilderness defense to 1990s ELF/ALF direct action and sabotage. Subculture & Politics: The vital role of the 1980s/90s hardcore punk scene, zines, and DIY culture in socializing young activists prior to the internet era. State Repression & The Green Scare: How post-9/11 terrorism frameworks and corporate lobbying (such as the Animal Enterprise Terrorism Act) were used to target eco-activists. The Modern Landscape: Where the climate justice movement stands today, the rise of anti-data center resistance, and changing thresholds for state prosecution. Guest Links: Check out Scott Parkin's work at the Green & Red Podcast (https://greenandredpodcast.org) and Rainforest Action Network (https://ran.org). Find Dr. Thomas Zeitzoff's book No Option But Sabotage and updates at https://zeitzoff.com. Send us Fan Mail Musis by Bitterlake, Used with Permission, all rights to Bitterlake Support the show Crew: Host: C. Derick Varn Intro and Outro Music by Bitter Lake. Intro Video Design: Jason Myles Art Design: Corn and C. Derick Varn Links and Social Media: twitter: @varnvlog blue sky: @varnvlog.bsky.social You can find the additional streams on Youtube Current Patreon at the Sponsor Tier: Jordan Sheldon, Mark J. Matthews, Lindsay Kimbrough, RedWolf, DRV, Kenneth McKee, JY Chan, Matthew Monahan, Parzival, Adriel Mixon, Buddy Roark, Daniel Petrovic,Julian, Drea, Free Beer, SNT-BRCH, Joshua Parsons
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
C. Derick VarnHello, welcome to Varmblog. And I am talking to two guests today because of an overlapping topic. We are talking about the history of the radical environmental movement from the 1990s to now. We will focus a little bit on the ELF and maybe lesser degrees on the ALF and other things that developed since then. And so I have with me today Thomas Zeitzov and Scott Parkin of the Red, the the Green and Red.
C. Derick VarnGreen and red. Get my colors. And I was like, is it red or black? Green and black? Red, black. Okay, anyway.
SPEAKER_00Time actually.
C. Derick VarnGreen and red podcast. And Thomas is the author of Nasty Politics and No Option but Sabotage. And we'll be talking a lot of the material we're covering today is in this book, which Thomas was nice enough to send me and I have mostly read. So we're going to talk today about the environmental movement where it's at where it's at today and how it's gotten there since the 1990s. But I'm going to let you both kind of introduce yourself and your interests slash investment in these topics.
C. Derick VarnSo we'll start with Scott and move the Thomas.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. Hey everybody. My name is Scott Parkin. Like Derek said, I'm the co-host of the Green and Red podcast. I'm also a longtime environmental and climate justice organizer, law direct action organizing. And then I'm also currently the organizing director at Rainforest Action Network.
unknownYeah.
SPEAKER_01All right. My name is Thomas Seitzoff. I'm a professor in the School of Public Affairs here in Washington, D.C. I should preface this. I'm a scholar, not an activist. I have activist friends. So for whoever's listening, etc. No, but uh I got interested in this because I'm kind of an outsider to this. I study political violence mostly outside the US. And I got interested in the topic of environmental activism and in particular the repression. Basically teaching classes and doing some reading and finding out that the number one domestic terror threat after 9-11 was radical animal and eco-activists.
SPEAKER_01And I thought that was pretty wild and wanted to know more.
C. Derick VarnYeah. I kind of came into my own during the time period where that was being demonized. So I am a child of the Carter administration. But my adulthood really ran straight up into the Bush administration. And I very much remember during my anti-war period going out and defending environmental activists. And at the time, I'll be honest, I was not particularly sympathetic then the way I am now.
C. Derick VarnBut I thought that they were being unfairly persecuted, but uh, you know, unclearly bullshit lines like you're gonna go after them like harder than you go after white nationalists or are Islamist, and yet their body counts like one one thousandth of anything like that, and mostly themselves, unfortunately. So I wanted to talk to you guys about the history and how that happened and what it was like being active, particularly for Scott, what it was like being active during that time period, because I believe you were.
C. Derick VarnSo, you know, I'm gonna start off with the question that that Thomas, your book starts off with, and I'm gonna get both your answers. What makes a radical environmental movement radical and different from other forms of the environmental movement that had existed prior to the 1990s? We'll start with Scott.
SPEAKER_00Oh, start with me. I mean, you know, this is actually an ongoing discussion I have with many people, including Tom. And so, you know, when I think about like a radical environmental movement, often what scholars or media or even some activists go to is what makes you radical, or your tactics, right? You do a sit-in at a corporate office, or maybe you break a window, or maybe you engage in some act of sabotage or even arson.
SPEAKER_00But to me, what makes a radical environmentalist radical is actually having a critique of the system and actually a strategy in order to try and change that system is like we're basically looking at, you know, an economic system which is just devouring the planet, right? It's cutting down forests, it's extracting oil and coal and whatever else out of the ground, uranium, all that sort of stuff. And then it's also displacing people or it's having people live on the edge of some of these like terrible extractive projects or refining projects or mining projects or what have you.
SPEAKER_00And so the sort of like having a sort of philosophy, a radical philosophy around how to change that and challenge the system and overturn the system is actually what I think makes one a radical environmentalist, not so much the tactics.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Yeah, I would I would echo most of what Scott says and just say, my, I mean, the way that I sort of think about like that is there's like the out of like a core is this idea that like environmental, you know, destruction or harm is like a moral, it's not just like uh, oh, this is a policy problem you have to fix, but it's a moral thing that demands a solution. And also that mainstream groups, like there's a relational aspect to it, like mainstream groups like the Sierra Club or you know, World Wildlife Fund, or you know, other sorts of groups that are trying to work within the system are failing.
SPEAKER_01And then I think there is like a little bit of like a subculture part of it that we can definitely talk about, but it's this sort of commitment like you're not there's not like some hierarchical, like, hey, please sign up and you get a membership badge in our radical group, and here's your leader, here's your manager, etc. Right? It's a lot of this is you know anti-hierarchical, leaderless sort of organizing. And then I do think the tactics, you know, kind of help define that, but it's sort of in this sort of like subculture that I think you know, Scott can talk about, I can talk about that I think is super interesting, that kind of sprang up in the Pacific Northwest in the 90s.
C. Derick VarnI think it's interesting, you know, when we talk about this in the 90s, I'm focusing on the 90s, although in your book you kind of see a tale of the rebirth of ecological radicalism in the in the 80s with Earth First. And you break it down into three into three periods, basically the the Earth First era, the Earth Liberation Front era, which goes into about you know Barack Obama and then the climate justice era.
C. Derick VarnDo we do we want to look at like where the milieus around Earth first came from? Like what what nexus of groupings cause it to be so persuasive in the 80s, and how is it different from both say conventional environmentalism, but also maybe uh less ecological but quote unquote radical leftism of uh of the 60s and 70s. So neither one of you can start off there.
SPEAKER_01I mean, I'll jump in and just say, like, yeah, I mean, those are like rough groupings, but in my head. But I I think you know, there's a bunch to sort of jump on to. But I I I think the first part is Earth First was different than you know, it's even Earth First itself, like the founders, right? There are different wings within it, right? Like, I mean, Dave Foreman is, you know, a Republican, a Goldwater Republican.
SPEAKER_00And like was, was, was, was, whatever.
SPEAKER_01Redneck for wilderness, right? That whole sort of thing, and you know, kind of this, you know, backwoods, like, you know, pull them up from their boots, like whatever you want to sort of call, like sort of hearkening to that sort of, you know, the people who followed him, like, those were conservationists, right? Mike Rosell like came from like leftist civil rights movements, and like he had issues with leftists, but he also had issues with Dave. And he's like kind of represents a sort of different thing. So even from like the beginning, there was the like divisions, but I I do think like Earth First itself was like conservationist, preserved wilderness, and then later you get folks coming in with this critique about you know these earth first sort of politics.
SPEAKER_01I would say the other thing, too, that I think is important, and I always surprised me a bit is if you talk to people who you know were around Earth First or even like in the you know radical environmental movement, and even came in later, and even the people from the ELF era, I do think like one thing that is a through line is this deep belief that like nature is sacred and that like almost like a green religion.
SPEAKER_00The the other thing I agree with all that. One the one one thing I would add is that a lot of the original founders of Earth First actually came out of these more liberal reformist environmental groups that were like largely based in DC, largely worked in DC, groups like the Sierra Club, the Wilderness Society, Friends of the Earth, Friends of the Earth. Well, Friends of the Earth, I think, is a little different. But but but what I would what I would say is like one of the one of Earth First sort of battle cries or taglines is like no compromise in defense of Mother Earth. And that's because they were actually tired of doing all this work.
SPEAKER_00I mean, they all worked in places like you know, in the in the interior west, places like Utah and Wyoming, and they actually just saw these environmental groups just continue to compromise away, you know, the wilderness they were trying to protect to industry vis-a-vis the political system. And so they started Earth First as also like a direct action response to uh to like these more liberal reformist groups. And so I think that's actually a really important piece of earth first. I, you know, and those those those philosophical views, you know, precede Earth First and like a number of issues, but it's still it's still an important piece of the sort of like the sort of core element of who Earth First is.
SPEAKER_00Yep.
C. Derick VarnThat I find that very interesting in that Earth First seems to be both more practical, but somewhat related to what I grew up calling deep ecology. How affected was it by deep ecology and the deep green movement in the 70s? Was it a response to that? Because that was in my understanding, that was the prior imminent critique of standard environmentalism was the deep ecology movement.
SPEAKER_01But you guys are specialists and maybe can clarify that for me. I mean, I think of like the schisms with like I talk about in my book a little bit, but I I still think, right, is the schisms in the book are like there's a philosophical kind of schism between deep ecology, basically, like you know, all living things have equal value. And like I think the deeper subtext of this is all we care about is wilderness and protecting wilderness.
SPEAKER_01Like that's like you know, deep ecology kind of, you know, there's much we can go much deeper into like what people thought about it, but that's what it is at its core, versus the social ecology critique, which is like that's an incomplete kind of politics. Then this is Murray Bookchin and the Institute for Social Economicology basically say, you know, come at from a left-wing critique that like wilderness is a crappy concept, and if you only focus on wilderness and protecting it, you're missing the causes, you know, is that human, you know, suffering is related to animal suffering, which is related to you know, environmental suffering.
SPEAKER_01And so I also though think that the schisms, again, are not just like philosophical, but again, it's this subculture. Like, are you a conservationist? Do you like is that how you see things through the world, or are you a broader left-wing activist where environment is kind of one of that? And that's I think like a sort of bigger part of that story.
SPEAKER_00The the the one part of the story which I I feel like is like not really discussed within the history of Earth first, but I think it is important within the the history of like an of environmental action, let's call it, is that there's there's there's also an element with like the people who live on the front lines of where this environmental destruction is happening. Yeah. And so even way before Earth First came around, we had anti-strip mining movement in Appalachia in the 1960s, for example. And I think the group was called the Save the Land and People.
SPEAKER_00And it was like Appalachians who organized, you know, they were also coal miners, but they they organized against the coal industry who were like just like evicting them from their homes and you know, strip mining it. And, you know, they did everything from like burning bulldozers to chaining themselves to things to like letter writing campaigns and all of that. That's where we actually what I talked about before, where the DC reform groups really kind of start screwing over people on the environment, save the people, the save the land and people were one of the groups who were early, early uh victims of the environmental nonprofit complex, as I call them.
SPEAKER_00And I and I think that's an important third piece there that comes out less in the sort of conversation around deep ecology and biocentrism, but it's important and it precedes Earth First. Yeah.
C. Derick VarnI mean, one of the things I think is that is interesting from this book is a lot of these movements are associated with the Pacific Northwest. Uh, I remember in the 90s as a teenager, I was involved in the zine community, and I actually would get these debates between like Sarzon and Book Chen and Bob Black and Book Chen, and Bob Black and everybody.
SPEAKER_00Be careful with moving those zines around, man.
C. Derick VarnYeah, oh yeah, yeah, particularly now. Um I have a bunch of reasons I should probably be careful. Nonetheless, I I was I I was reading all these debates, and this seemed to be very specific northwest centered debate structure. But from reading the history, I've learned a lot more about the place of the southern and western states, particularly Appalachia and and the mountain west, and where I live out in Utah, where this is a big live issue, and the hostility between like the Sierra Club and pretty much everybody is palpable out here.
C. Derick VarnI mean, up to and including the fact that like the Sierra Club here has had private prison owners sit on their board and and stuff like that. So why do you think the perception that this was mostly a Pacific Northwest phenomenon really caught wave? It seems to me that it caught wave even before the ELF, that it really happens at the end of this Earth first period. Because, you know, like Green Anarchy magazine, for example, like predates ELF a little bit.
C. Derick VarnAnd I wanted to get your your take on why that perception may have become popular and what is missed from that view that this is mostly a Pacific Northwest phenomenon.
SPEAKER_01I mean, I I I don't think it's like I think yeah, it's true, it's not mostly a Pacific Northwest phenomenon. But I think if you say when the movement was kind of most salient in the public conscience, like, and right, getting the most attention from law enforcement and also carrying out a lot of kind of the pace of most intense actions, the Pacific Northwest and Eugene in particular was the epicenter. And like why that's the case, I mean, I think it's pro you know, this is one part of like the broader anti-globalization movement.
SPEAKER_01Like, I think you can't tell the story of the ELF and other things, the fact that it's all being cross-fertilized, right? And Eugene, like the ELF was like one symptom of this sort of broader, like, you know, as I interviewed people involved in law enforcement who like, we had a riot like every weekend, and people hated the police, and this was all part of these, you know, anti-fascist, you know, anti-globalization folks. So I think that's part of it. I think it's also just, you know, Eugene, it's it's an interesting place, like politically.
SPEAKER_01Like, I think it's super, you know, I was just out there, and I think it still has this weird thing where it's like a very, you know, quote unquote radical college town with a lot of lefty politics, and then you step foot outside of Eugene, and it is with a country, it's like a almost like a bimodal politics, right? Like there's no left, and it's like there's no like, oh, I'm a centrist Eugene, right? I mean, it does exist, but I think it has that. And I think the fact that you can go, they could go do actions. There was the Warner Creek blockade that was you know instrumental and kind of forming the backbone of a lot of the ELF.
SPEAKER_01And you know, the fact that logging was still a big thing in the Pacific Northwest, and it's a place-based campaign, and you still had some people who were like, you know, John Zerzan himself, right, is somebody who kind of you know has this lineage from the 60s, 70s sort of radicals and brings that in there and sort of meets with this kind of eco critique. And yeah, I mean, you get it why place matters, I think, Eugene, for sure. Like it's it's it's important geographically and culturally. I don't know. I mean, Scott, what do you think?
SPEAKER_00I mean, I I I I I agree with that. I I think there's I think there's some like sort of greater cultural stuff going on too. I mean, it's like it's it's a big base of the of like the punk scene up and down the up and down the west coast, particularly in the northwest. That was like highly influential. Also, those organized well, those radical animal rights and radical environmental activists use the punk scene to organize, recruit, do outreach. So I I think that's a and Tom can tell you more of the bands that were involved in that than I can, but you know, I think that there's I think I think that cultural piece is pretty important.
SPEAKER_00I also have a view where these these areas where we have the you know, maybe in mainstream media they would call deep blue. I actually feel like we see a much more we see bigger radical bubbles emerge in those sort of deep blue places. And so it's it's it's a place that's really friendly to people having different ideas and which can lead into you know all kinds of stuff around politics and environmental politics. Yep.
unknownYeah.
SPEAKER_00I mean, the the other radical episode, one of the other radical epic centers is where I live, which is the Bay Area, right?
C. Derick VarnSo right. I actually I was I was gonna think I was actually thinking about the Bay Area as a contrast where you have just as much radicalism, however, the the fever pitch of the street battles is not as obvious because there is you know, in the Bay Area, you're surrounded by like Aurora and Modesto Valley and and like these things that are actively like physical community buffers where there's a bunch of purplish people between you and Greater Idaho, for lack of a better term.
C. Derick VarnAnd I I have experienced this in Oregon in particular, particularly around both Eugene and Portland, where you just go from like the the most aggressive rural areas you've ever seen in your life, as far as conservatives, where like the area nation is deliberately setting itself up to hang out, like in in Idaho, straight into the bluest area you've ever been in your life outside of the Bay Area and or New York. And I do think that is like combustible.
C. Derick VarnIt also seems like that's where I mean, a lot of the weirder figures in this movement, some of which are not in your book, Thomas, because they're more problematic, like like Troy Southgate, the guy who comes over from Britain and like tries to infiltrate the the great anarchist scene and like use it for basically what could be called quasi-eco-fascism. That that happens there too, partly I think because of this geographic particularity. Because you know, we we have similar radicals here in Salt Lake, but we don't get like we're so removed, even you know, from what people don't understand about Utah.
C. Derick VarnUtah is even the conservative areas of Utah are highly urbanized because you can't really live in most of the state. Um it's not really hospitable for life. Although there's a lot of very important stuff you want to keep alive in the area, microbiotic soils. I mean, obviously, the Great Salt Lake, very very important for for irrigate, but not just irrigation, but also pollination and migratory birds. You know, so this is a live area for that, but we don't have the same kind of flash-ups that you see in the Pacific Northwest.
C. Derick VarnI was gonna I I think tying it to the altar and anti-globalization movement is super crucial. My only ever encounter with with Alpher Elf in person in my life was in '98 and the battle for Seattle when I was like 18 years old. It's the first time I met any of those people. I didn't meet any of the people that you guys mentioned specifically, but I ran across them. And as a at the time, a nascent like person battling out the a conservatism that's brought up for being from the central Georgia.
C. Derick VarnI was both sympathetic and terrified by elf. Like by Elf or ELF or both. By both, actually. Alf seemed ALF seemed I sympathize with ALF less actually than I did ELF. For those of you who don't know our actions, Alf is Animal Liberation Front, ELF is Earth Liberation Front. But those were the groups that I encountered, and I really only encountered them, I think, because I was mostly based in the South for the first part of my life.
C. Derick VarnIn my one trip, the Pacific Northwest. How big of a role does ninety eight play in like further radicalizing what's going to become the Earth Liberation Front and all that? 99. 99, 99. So yeah, yeah. So I'm doing math bad in my head.
SPEAKER_03Okay.
SPEAKER_01I mean, do you yeah, I I mean, so one thing I want to jump on, like for your point though, too, and I'm curious if Scott, what Scott thinks too, is like I found that like the animal liberation front, like one, I think it's some, you know, there's like a big question as to like how much there definitely was like some like overlap. People come I found people coming into the movement and whether that like that was kind of like this uncomfortable politics, uh, for a while, you know, people like they were joking as like you know, people eating burgers after you know at Earth First gatherings, and there's like that whole personal politics of veganism.
SPEAKER_01But I did find that like the Animal Liberation Front folks had like a harder edge in like generally, like, you know, if you believe that, you know, every slaughterhouse, you know, is like a torture, you know, every fact farm is a torture slaughterhouse, etc., there's a certain kind of immediacy to their kinds of politics. And I did find like, I don't know, I found that those folks were, you know, pardon the pun, but more hardcore, right? And they did come from the hardcore punk scene too. I don't know. What do you Scott? What do you well?
SPEAKER_00One thing I'll say is that the ELF and the ALF actually predate the the battle in Seattle. Yeah, yes, yeah. Like the ELF was doing the Earth Liberation Front was doing its actions.
SPEAKER_01Probably in the mid-90s? 95, 94, depending.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. They had started they there's a new book out by a a journalist named Matthew, a journalist and academic named Matthew Wool called Fires and the Night, um, which actually goes into a pretty detailed history of the Earth Liberation Front and also with the what they call the Eugene Cell, which is the sort of main ELF group that everybody talks about. Um it's a very good book. It's very but uh and also interviewed on Green and Red Podcast, if you ever want to check him out there. But uh so you know the ELF and the ALF sort of predate the battle in Seattle first, and then second, both are imports from the U from the UK, right?
SPEAKER_00Both are like both both the I think we have a debate debate.
SPEAKER_01No, they are they oh sorry, go ahead. I I want to because I want to ask out on this, yeah.
SPEAKER_00But the the ELF is definitely an import from the UK.
SPEAKER_01I think, yeah, cool.
SPEAKER_00I mean, that's what that's what Matt's that's what Matt's book says. Anyway, yeah. So so I think I think that that's sort of important to note. I think I think what the battle in Seattle is, is a confluence of a whole lot of movements and everything from like indigenous solidarity in the global south to you know anti-corporate, anti-capitalist stuff to earth first, earth first in the earth first was pretty big in the northwest through all of its campaigns in the 80s and 90s, cove mallard, Warner Creek, many other places. And so there's like a big gathering of Earth First there in all its different forms at the at the Battle of Seattle too.
SPEAKER_00Labor is super involved, and so you know, it it's it's a pretty important moment, it's a watershed moment, I would actually say, at most in modern movements. So just to put that out there, yeah.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, no, I I I think it like it is, and it's not right, like the import thing. Because I I mean, like the British like eco thing. I mean, there were people who I interviewed who definitely had gone to like the UK and saw it, but also said it was different, and there was like some back and forth, and like the ALF, I think was clearly like it was founded in the UK, and it was also like you know, it was intimately tied into the punk scene there. I do think like exactly what Scott said is like 99 was like the watermark, not just for like you know, the ELF, but also this broader alternate globalization, you know, anti-globalization movement, and then like 9-11 and it's you know, and it's gone.
SPEAKER_01And the you know, Warren Rock, and that's you know, that's all she wrote. And I think there is like an interesting, like counterfactual history is like, does it die anyways? Or you know, and I don't know, and that's something that you know uh is interesting to explore. Is like what happens if 9-11 doesn't happen with that movement.
C. Derick VarnWell, the I wanted to talk a little bit about that because I do like my own experience of of this time period is 9-11 is a radicalizing event for me, but not on the environmental front, but on the geopolitical front. And it doesn't manifest itself actually, even initially as leftism. For me, it manifested in this weird Pat Buchanan shit, which I grew out of very quickly, but um Wow Jerich, it's all coming out.
SPEAKER_01Well, yeah, yeah, no, it's it's paleoconservative. I knew it, I knew it.
C. Derick VarnWell, yeah, the funny thing is, yes, I was a paleoconservative in in the early aughts, and started thinking about capitalism and the environment simultaneously because of the oil shocks we were getting at the time. And I went back and read all those zines I've been exposed to in the late 90s, where uh so I went back and read all the book chin, like Zairs and debates and all that, actually in my early 20s as like part of my way out of this paleoconservative period.
C. Derick VarnBut it also seems to me that 90 99 does seem to be where this spills out from where like Elf and Alp are actually very like you need to be in the punk scene, you need to be in the zines, you need to be in the environmental movement to know that much about them. I did not hear that much about them after encountering them uh in '99 until a year later. And then after 9-11, we see we see them being crushed by the state.
C. Derick VarnAnd so my initial interest in them and the aughts is around them being suppressed and me going like I mean my I would tell you what I thought in my early 20s. Like, why are we like, why are we going after these hippies like with more than and I know this is a completely unfair characterization, but this is what I thought from Georgia. Um, why are we going after these hippies with more force than seems to be needed for this situation? Like, yes, they broke the law, you know, you hit them when savandalism charges, you hit them with property damage charges and call it a day.
C. Derick VarnWhy the hell are you going after them as terrorists when they've like killed nobody? And that's how I became really aware of them and became more and more sympathetic, particularly to Elf, as we moved on. But I wanted to ask a little bit about the punk scene element of it because that that does seem something very removed from now. Like politics traveling through music scenes was something that I also remember experiencing as a kid, but I don't see in the world that much anymore. Like music seems to seem pretty apolitical these days.
C. Derick VarnSo, can we talk about the relationship between the punk scene and the environmental movement, particularly in Pacific Northwest?
SPEAKER_01Can I can I just say one thing too? Like, you're talking about these 90s markers. I gotta say, right, 95 12 monkeys comes out, 99 fight club, right? Like, so it's not like the there was like this worry that these like masked, you know, I don't know, like non-hierarchical, leaderless, like leftist, amorphous groups were like a threat out there. And you know, and and that I think is is super interesting. The punk scene, I think, is you know, I grew up in Austin, Texas, and I had friends in the punk scene, and I was not like I would say I was not like one of the kids who had like all the scenes, but I had friends who had it.
SPEAKER_01And I think it's I mean, I do think there is something to be said for like that. Was like one of the things that surprised me doing this, you know, writing this book was that the pathway into activism and these subcultures that sort of nurture activists are super important because it kind of figures out like, you know, people are figuring out their politics or looking for a team, and so a lot of times they people find like a subculture or a group they like identify with and then they get their politics later. Like there's some really good, interesting books on like the anti-abortion movement.
SPEAKER_01And one of the things that's kind of wild is that people who got into the anti-abortion movement, yes, they have like you know pro what they would call pro-life leanings, right? But their politics becomes solidified after like these relationships are already formed. It was mostly personal relationships, and I think there's like a similar thing that the punk scene attracted a bunch of you know angry, disaffected kids. It was super vibrant. I mean, and it had, as you said, it had zines, it had an ethos. If you were pissed off at the world and angry, here's like a whole sort of you know book that you can give people.
SPEAKER_01And I do think like something, you know, this is my own pet theory, and I'm curious what Scott, you and Derek think about it. But like I think, you know, it is interesting that like the angry white dudes like got, you know, not all of them, but a lot of them got like inculcated with kind of lefty politics, and now the version of that is like gaming, like MMA, and which is like it's totally right-coded, and I think that is interesting.
SPEAKER_00The the one thing I would say about one thing I want to comment on the on the punk scene in the 80s and 90s, or I see the nice shirt, I love it. Yeah, where we're seeing where we're seeing a lot of this like inculcation is I I would actually say this is pre-internet, right? And so, like, you know, these kids hear about music, music show, they go, and then there's the band is maybe singing about left-wing politics or talking about left-wing politics. There's also like a lot of tables where you can get these zines and things like that.
SPEAKER_00And so I think I think the sort of that was a little bit how people were able to plug into like a political scene, whereas now they're doing it on gaming platforms or they're doing it on social media platforms or something like that. It's just one thing I'm gonna add there. Yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_01I mean, and it's also right. I mean, this is like the tail end too of grunge, but it's like, you know, in the in in the Pacific Northwest, but it there's just I don't know. I I think it's as you said, there's like an openness, like the fact that the internet, like people are not as like skeptical, maybe open to like looking for like new things, and not everything was available. So there is this like kind of, oh, there's this secret hidden, you know, place out there. Like I talk about there's a guy, Robert, in my book, who like he like saw like a sticker in like you know, he was in the Pacific Northwest in a big city, and he saw like a sticker, like stop eating meat.
SPEAKER_01He was like, Wait, what is that? Like, and like it kind of, you know, it wasn't everything, it wasn't like everything he had to go to a meeting. He had to like figure out, oh, like there's a bunch of other kids who also think like this, maybe not a bunch, but there's like a small little group of us, and oh wow, like it's actually also harder for the cops to figure out who we are because there aren't security cameras everywhere, and so we can get away with stuff.
SPEAKER_00Was it was yeah. So I mean, I grew up in Dallas, Texas in the 80s, and I grew up in a very conservative suburb of Dallas. And you know if you went to downtown Dallas, it was like a huge there was a there's an area where all the band where all the bars and music venues are, and there was a huge punk scene there, and it was very much it was very political, it was very anti-Ragan, it was very anti-nuclear proliferation, and very anti-authoritarian. And so I I I do think that those that was uh that was a place where a lot of those politics were disseminated by like the younger people who would you know plug into that, those who weren't part of like you know, future farmers of America or whatever.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. Which was a big thing in my high school too.
SPEAKER_01So but I but I think like at a deeper level, I do think there is something like about this kind of like I think there's a a view that oh, like people like the environment and then they get socialized, and then they like discover more and more radical politics, and that's kind of their pathway. When like I think what usually like in political science and like kind of what we found is that no, is that people have like a pro you know a predisposition or a view that something is wrong, like with society or the world, and then like they seek out and partially from friends, but also from other sources like what's a persuasive narrative that like explains why things are bad, and that's why you have people who are like Bernie Trump supporters, right?
SPEAKER_01That's you know, that there is this broader sort of like anti-establishment, and and I think that's like part of the interesting thing here is that sort of punk socialized a bunch of anti-establishment, anti-authoritarian kids in a certain direction.
C. Derick VarnI I would agree with that. I mean, one other thing I would say that I find interesting is like I punk was radicalizing, but not in in multiple directions, like you mentioned. I remember the Deaf to the World movement, which was this weird punk ultra-orthodox Christian movement in the late 90s, it was all around Father Sarah from Rose. Um, and there was also you know, I mean, you know, but my exposure to to elf was also my first exposure to Pat Buchanan, believe it or not, because I knew it was also so conservative as I knew it, Derek.
C. Derick VarnIt was coming, but he was also at the Battle for Seattle and I saw him speak there, it's weird. And you know, as an 18-year-old in '99, that was all brand new to me, particularly given that I was from central Georgia. And it only gotten involved through actually the punk scene and the zines attached to it. That's how we knew about all this stuff. We didn't like the internet existed, but barely, like, yeah. So we would hear about this stuff on on in zines and then on like you know, reading calls in the fact sheet five and on like weird email group listings, like Yahoo! groups for for punks.
C. Derick VarnThat's where I discovered a lot of this stuff. Um and to to emphasize that that that whole weird radical nature of the punk movement, that's also where I was exposed to like Ruby Ridge conspiracies and and stuff like that. They were both being moved somewhat seamlessly in this milieu in the late 1990s, and to very young people. I mean, like, you know, I was when I started reading about this stuff, I must have been like 16 or 17, uh, no, no older than that.
C. Derick VarnSo I guess so I I want to talk about the the philosophical distinctions a little bit. You you mentioned two of the philosophical beliefs that come up a lot in the Earth First movement, which is ecocentrism and then monkey wrenching. And then the other thing that you mentioned, however, that is a dividing line within that movement is responses to Paul Ehrlich's population bomb book, which is you know still a dividing line in a lot of movements, actually, to this day.
C. Derick VarnUh, I I wanted to, you know, ask you both about what did those philosophical divisions, how did they play into what was going on in that call from the UK for Alf and Elf to start to form? Like, is there a relationship between the two? Is it just incidental? You know, what you know, because it does seem like those are coming to a head at the same time that this other like precursor event really happens. I know we're jumping back in time a little bit, but let's travel back to 1995 or so.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I mean, I I I I I would say that some of that ELF call who the ELLF ELF was in the UK. Definitely the let's you called it monkey wrenching and call it direct action, it's sabotage, but you know, and then they take it up a notch and take it to arson. I mean, I think that's definitely an element of it. If you look at like what some of the folks from the Eugene cells said, is that they had actually been part of they had been at Warner Creek. They had, you know, they were all in and they stayed for like a year and you know, were eventually like violently extracted from like these more nonviolent direct action tactics, like chaining themselves to things and things like that.
SPEAKER_00And they actually felt like it was really ineffective. And so I think the call, I think that the that the call from the ELF is to like take it up a notch. And so I think they were responding to that. I'm less familiar with the politics around biocentrism with the with the ELF in the UK, but I would I would expect that it would, you know, they would have a similar philosophical outlook on it as some of the Earthfirsters and the ELFers did. I mean, most of all almost I think all of the ELFers came out of Earth First at some level, um in the in North America.
SPEAKER_00And then what was the third one? Paul Ehrlich, you were wanted to. Oh, yeah, the the population problem. That I I I'm less clear on. I I mean it's a that's a big divider in in Earth First in the the US, though. I can tell you that. I'm less clear on it what what where they were at with it in the UK.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I'm less I I I can't comment as much on the UK, but I I can tell you like the population question, like, and again, I think this is also something that to me is really wild, is that you know, our view of modern-day environmentalism is like again, I think very skewed by sort of recency bias about it being sort of like lefty activists and you know, folks with you know Prius and you know, asking, you know, climate justice activists, but there's like a really nasty kind of misanthropic streak like that runs through and you know, Paul like passed away recently, like that there is nothing left-wing inherently about environmentalism, and you know, you can go back and you can read like the blood and soil Nazi ecology, you can read the work by Peter Stadenmeier on this, and and so I think this kind of like overpopulation or concern about population, it's the third rail within the environmental movement because there's a the science behind it is not like is not great, but also it's been used like for cover, like going back to Madison Grant in the you know early 20th century, but even like in the 60s and 70s, and you know, Dave Foreman in the 80s, like this was like a really harsh kind of divide.
SPEAKER_01And I think I think that this is something that you know I've talked about with Scott and you know, Derek, you're probably you know, where to is I think the this is a latent issue. Like we're talking about like we had a crazy heat wave on the East Coast, it's like roasted. I mean, last week was awful, it was like over 100 degrees, and I think the only thing there is like the the Trump MAGA wing, like calling you know global warming a globalist hoax, like people see that as in perpetuity. And I think latent in the wings is a right wing kind of climate nationalism that somebody is like waiting to sort of call on, like as soon as the fossil fuel sort of you know, wing of the party, right?
SPEAKER_01It becomes kind of less advantageous. And that is there for people to to grab onto. And you know, I wouldn't be surprised if we see that. And that and again, right, that's that's you know, it's a little outside your question, but I I think it's it's related to this fact because there are these, you know, the movement of like the population question is this question that sort of divides like people who have these sort of maybe xenophobic anti-immigrant sympathies within the movement, right? Like Dave Foreman famously and and other folks, and the more sort of lefty socially social ecology critiques.
SPEAKER_00Well, the one the one the one figure I I would throw into that who I actually think plays into this is the person who was the sort of like intellectual godfather of the early earth first, which is Ed Abbey, who's the author of the Monkey Wrench Gang. You know, he's he's he's on record saying a lot of anti-population stuff, anti-immigrant stuff. And so I think I think it's uh I if if you read and if you read some of those books, I mean I actually feel like some of those guys come up, some of those could actually potentially come across as right wing with what they do and say.
C. Derick VarnSo yeah, uh being in Utah today and having spent a lot of time in Moab, he's like a saint there. Oh yeah. But so you just go into like the Moab bookstore and there's like a whole Ed Abbey section. But having read a lot of that, I I was also struck by like, whoa, like he's got some population ideas that he might not admit them as implying white nationalism, but it is not very hard to turn it that way at all.
C. Derick VarnYeah, I also think of like Robert Sale was another figure who's who was more out of the uh explicitly out of the punk scene, but like flirted with ethno-regional separatism, and that started tying into this, like the Greater Cascadia movement. Uh and so there's a lot of these figures that I I mean I remember encountering as like in the 90s is almost like Saints of the Movement that when you go back and look at now, you're just like, well, this is a mixed bag, clearly.
C. Derick VarnAnd so, you know, I I was thinking about that a lot today, and I was also thinking about the extension of that, which is Ted Kacinski. I mean, Kacinski is a figure, it comes up in your book, Thomas, but like he looms large in all these discussions, and he looms large into discussions left, right, and post-left, and in a way that I remember taking a somewhat nasty turn in the late aughts. I don't know if you guys know anything about the importation of a Mexican group, Atasha, which was I actually knew some people who were tied to bringing translating and bringing their stuff into the States.
C. Derick VarnYeah. And, you know, they would say stuff like the fascists were wrong because they didn't kill enough people. Like, and and stuff like that. And I also thought around you know the general consolation of Derek Jensen and the deep group resistance movement. I mean, this is all this is all in the aughts, and particularly the late aughts and early aught teens, but it does seem like part of the problem that that this has to people who are on the on the far left, but not in the environmental circles, is you're you get associated with some of these more problematic figures, and a lot of the less problematic figures are are you know under or have been arrested, are you know on court silences or whatever and thus don't speak out much to change the perception, at least at the time.
C. Derick VarnSo I I wanted to like, you know, how much is this period in the in the mid-90s leading up to stuff that's used against the this movement in the mid-aughts, not from the government, but from other like factors within the left are in and general culture?
SPEAKER_01I mean, so the I'll just I'll take the Kaczynski piece because I do think that is like I mean, that's something like that. I remember when I did like, I mean, Scott was there when I had my like book conference, and like some people were like, you know, you shouldn't call it Kaczynski an environmentalist. Like, and which was like it was like a there was like a fair portion of that critique where it's like, you know, don't like he's not you know, he's not you know sitting, you know, he's not writing like in the earth first magazine, but he was corresponding with them, right?
SPEAKER_01Like, and he was definitely, you know, seen, you know, as kind of a a you know positive role model within that Eugene scene. Like, I mean, that's like you know, definitely clear. And you know, I think there were people within ELF who will say, you know, that there were talks about like escalating this as like the next step was not just property destruction, but was actually targeting people, and then like those talks fell apart, but you know, there was definitely some inspiration from Kaczynski.
SPEAKER_01And I got interested in this partially because you know, I have my students read about Kaczy, and one of my students was like, Professor, you know, given what's going on with climate, why don't we see this anymore? And it was a good question. And I think that like Kaczynski, you know, if you go back, like I I encourage like folks who are listening to this or you guys go back and watch like the night, like the ABC News when they announced like the capture of Kaczynski, right? It's pretty wild, right? Because he has seen like you know, this rambling terrorist, you know, he's a math genius, the youngest, like you know, assistant professor in UC Berkeley history.
SPEAKER_01He looks crazy, right? Coming out of there. And that's how he was treated in the media. But there's like a weird thing is like, you know, I have my students read his manifesto, and like people nod along at the beginning. Like, they're like, ah, you know, he can write a lead, you know, about you know, industrial society's been a disaster, yada, yada, yada. But it's gone on some very weird journeys. And I think, you know, Kaczynski, you know, I'm surprised every year more of my students like know. I like when I started teaching in 2014, 2015, like, you know, probably like 30% of my students immediately know who Ted Kaczynski.
SPEAKER_01Now it's like 80%. And it's because he's become a meme. He's like, you know, people say, I'm turning off my phone, so I'm gonna pull a Kaczynski this weekend. He's been adapted by far right folks, right, who like his stuff. And I think it also goes to like the interesting place where the environment, you know, environmental movement is now, and I think something that like I'm happy to talk about as well as some of the anti-data center movements, which is like definitely something that has these sort of weird bedfellows about it. And I think there's you know, within Kaczynski, there's like a trenchant critique of like some of the sort of industrial society, et cetera stuff.
SPEAKER_01And then there's like the misanthropic side, and so there's kind of a choose your own adventure to him. But like I think environmentalists now, especially like on the left, want to be like, we have nothing to do with this guy, he's different. And like if you actually look at it, he was more embedded and he was like reading and like there's deep ecology like throughout the manifesto.
C. Derick VarnWell, Scott.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I mean, I'm I'm less studied on Kaczynski. I'm I mostly get my deeper stuff from reading Tom's book and talking to Tom about him. I I I'll say on the on your your question before though, around, you know, there's where this, you know, the mid-aughts, the state is is targeting the ELF. And and I will say that within the environmental movement, or more actually more the environmental nonprofit industrial complex, the the sort of organized institutions and reform liberal reformist kind of groups, is that they're like they're very much like outspoken and denounce, you know, what what the environment what the ELF does.
SPEAKER_00And you know, they they even when when they start when they do the sort of first data rest of the ELF folks, they're even like either quiet or trying to change the subject. I think I think that's an important thing to note. The other thing I'll say around the the state coming after the ELF, which is like not talked about enough, is that like that was a result of a lot of laws like the Animal Enterprise Terror Act being put into place. And those those were a result of corporate lobbying groups like who work for you know animal agriculture sector or big pharma, or I think the more reason there's there's there's been a whole new wave of those laws the last like nine or ten years.
SPEAKER_00That's actually becoming more for the fossil fuel sector because the climate movement got so strange. Infrastructure, infrastructure, critical energy, critical energy infrastructure. Yeah. And so like I I think it's I think we should never leave out industry in sort of creating this this scaffolding for state repression on people who are political dissidents. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01No, I guess go ahead. No, other than what I was gonna say is that I think like that's like the perfect point is like, you know, there are like there's the obvious sort of like, you know, CSI kind of law and order that like there are a bunch of like actions that are happening, and you know, I think for ELF activists, they were not stupid, right? In terms generally speaking, in terms of they like didn't talk about stuff, they you know knew how to gener, you know, as Jake Ferguson though that later proved to not be the case, they got the informant that was kind of used against them, but for the most part, right, they didn't leave a lot of evidence.
SPEAKER_01So there were these string of arsons that were happening, and there's that part that makes this like a target for investigation. But I think it's exactly what Scott said is it's the people in the groups that they're targeting. You're talking about the Vale Ski Lodge logging, timber, and then like the, especially with the animal liberation front and Shaq, you know, stop hunting to animal cruelty, who are targeting like hunting and life science as a major sort of group that does animal testing, right? These like have, you know, it's again, it's not like you're not targeting like a, you know, even like a like a political like like group.
SPEAKER_01It's you're targeting like industry and you know, enterprises that have, you know, especially in the Pacific Northwest, logging is a big interest, right? And so you're attacking organized interests, so it's not surprising that they're going to mobilize it in a in a big way.
C. Derick VarnUh can we talk about the the beginning of the post-9-11 repressions of these groups, particularly the Earth Liberation Front and the Animal Liberation Front, and how that kind of set the stage for later engagements with these groups? Because to me, that's like what that is what starts making me sympathetic, is just watching the state crush these people from like you're you know, you're throwing life sentences. I mean, a lot of these did not end up being life sentences, but they were originally charged with like life sentences for relatively minor things, like we see today with the with you know the prairie fire situation.
C. Derick VarnI mean, we're seeing this happen again.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah. Well, they actually got the sentences, it wasn't just like the cops throwing the charges at them, yeah.
C. Derick VarnYeah. So let's talk like how does the terror framework get used here and how how deep is the effect on the on this movement?
SPEAKER_01I mean, I I'll just say like though there's like a cartoon that like I still can't get over. I think it was in like this, I think it was in the Seattle Post Intelligence or the Seattle Times that like is a picture, like it's like a cartoon, and it's like bin Laden like fist bumping somebody from ELF saying, you know, right on, brother. And like like so the the framing of like, I mean, I I don't again, like, I think that the terrorism label definitely has an effect. I don't want to say like, but it was terrorism label plus like being targeted by a joint terrorism task force, plus the threats of sentences, right, that are coming.
SPEAKER_01And as you said, right, like people had serious jail time, right? Like you're talking about, you know, between like up to like 20 years in prison for Marius, right? But like that was after many of them like pleaded or like kind of popped the the what they were facing was you know huge. And I think you know, it's not just the prison sentences, it's the subpoenas, it's all these other things that come into place, you know, that Scott can talk even more about is right, there's this long tale, like, and it's something that I was really surprised by is I'm like, man, I've interviewed people in a lot of different like violent contexts, like why are environmental activists like some of the most cagey people like I've chatted with.
SPEAKER_00I I mean put post I post 9-11 and then post the the sort of first the the the big arrests of the green scare era, I think had this chilling effect, as it's called. And you see, I I I noticed like a a lot less of the sort of ELF tactics, right? I don't see arson, I don't see property destruction in a sort of organized way. And the ELF was very good at what they did. Their the FBI called their said their trade craft was some of the best they'd ever seen.
SPEAKER_00And they just got lucky in flipping Jake Ferguson, catching Jake Ferguson and flipping him and hold and leveraging his kit against him, which is like an important was an important piece there.
SPEAKER_01And he had an addiction issue.
SPEAKER_00So like yeah, there's that too.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_00But uh, but like lost my train of thought. I think I think we also like in this period, what we start seeing in the mid to late aughts is we start seeing the rise of a different environmental movement, which is the climate movement. And that is very much rooted in a lot of like mainstream groups, are really sort of like doing organizing on campus around that, organizing around communities. It's like really embracing a lot of like what we call frontline communities, those historically marginalized folks who live next to refineries or coal mines or what have you.
SPEAKER_00And there's when you're in those spaces, even if it's not one that's like officially sanctioned by some big green group, there's still very much like rules around no property destruction, right? And we're definitely not going to do what the ELF did. And I even saw that in like in the Northwest. And so I think I think that is like an important piece is that they is that the climate movement actually shifts away from that at at the time, anyway. And we and you know, that leads up some of the biggest moments in that is that we see the climate movement take on the Keystone XL pipeline.
SPEAKER_00And that's all still done very much within the parameters of acceptable activism. But they, you know, those folks all still, people who organized on Keystone still got like FBI visits. We see the People's Climate March in 2014, which was like huge, probably the biggest climate march we've definitely seen in the North America, if not the world. And then there's also Dakota Access Pipeline. And once when the Dakota Access Pipeline happens, is where we start seeing things kind of go back into we kind of where that we see a lot more state repression. You know, they're pretty scared about Obama vetoing the Dakota Access Pipeline, like the permit with the Army Corps of Engineers, and then it's also like a lot of non-white people who are out doing the protesting, and it's also in a very conservative part of the country, too.
SPEAKER_00And so, whereas I also feel like 9-11 has like faded a bit after that as well. I think it's is part of it. For some reason, the 9-11 stuff is coming back up, but I think Trump's just trying to take advantage of it. And we could talk about that kind of prairie land and things going on right now later if we want to too.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I was gonna say just in the Obama piece, right? Is like we're like, oh, you know, here's somebody who's lefty hope and change. Like he'll he'll make good policy, and I think that was the hope, right?
SPEAKER_00The the organizers of the Keystone XL pipeline fight definitely saw it as a campaign of persuasion against Obama. It's like we're gonna just persuade him to reject this pipeline, which he actually did, right? Trump later approved it. But it's like it's it's important though that was a campaign of, and and that was from a lot of like more what I would call like liberal friendly sort of people. And you know, I'm friends with him, but like Bill McKibben was like a leader in that campaign, and it was very much one of persuasion. There was some activity that happens with Keystone after we get into it, where people are doing like blockades and tree sits in East Texas fighting part of part of the Keystone pipeline, where that also gets into like people are getting like crazy charges, people are getting police being violent against them, and then they those folks affiliated with that were also getting like targeted by both the company and law enforcement, federal, state, and local.
SPEAKER_01But and can I like just to add, like, I think the the Keystone I call it I call it Green Scare Light, by the way, is that what I call that period. But like what Scott, I mean, and Scott will speak to this probably even more than I can is I mean, but there's a tail also to Dakota Access pipeline, right? And this is where Greenpeace gets hit with this suit for actions that they weren't directly involved in but may have sponsored, and they get held liable, right? In a court, and there's that it was just finalized in February.
SPEAKER_01It was a$345 million verdict, basically designed to, you know, bankrupt Greenpeace America and serve as a warning to any group that sponsors this. You will be prosecuted and bankrupt, you know. And I think so. I think that's you know, again, this the there's these tales that happen from these incidents of repression.
C. Derick VarnI I think that's actually really interesting because what I have noticed from the aughts to now is also what Scott is implying is that we're seeing a lot of these frameworks being resurrected in the shadow of 9-11, but without 9-11 being invoked at all. Like it's not like this Patriot Act terrorism stuff isn't isn't being tied to 9-11 in any.
SPEAKER_00They actually tried to make Charlie Kirk's assassination their their in my opinion.
C. Derick VarnBut yeah, that does seem to be the thing, although even they can't seem to care about that for long enough for it to stick. But as a person who literally lives a half an hour up the street from where that happened and has been in the exact spot where Charlie Kirk was shot, it's weird for me. I'm not gonna lie. I know people have been targeted too because they also tried to go after every single leftist group here, from the DSA to armqueers to uh to the Sierra Club to the ACLU, they all got tarred with we were really somehow secretly behind Charlie Kirk getting killed, that you know, and then they moved they give that up for Mossad apparently, but whatever.
C. Derick VarnBut I have found it that I I do see this being invoked quite a bit, and one thing I think people should take notice of, and it hasn't been invoked strongly yet outside of Prairie Land, but just being anti-data center or anti-fascist, and even you know, even normal liberals now are all potentially labeled as potential terrorists. Uh I do want to point out to some consternation, though, that this was already being expanded under Biden, that some of these left-wing groups were also listed as potential ish issues for investigation under the Biden administration, but Trump has clearly recognized this.
SPEAKER_00It feels like a much larger gamut of the same thing we saw in the aughts, but I'll let Scott and I mean I would I would actually say we could trace it back at least as far back as like the Oklahoma City bombing in the mid-90s. Some of the some of the architecture was for the Art Patriot Act and for some of these more repressive things going on. And then there's a long history of state repression of activist groups and left groups going back for forever. Contel pro, the red snag against the wobblers.
C. Derick VarnYeah, but it was yeah, but the 85 weird scares or whatever. Like but go ahead.
SPEAKER_01But I was gonna say, I mean, I I do think what is true though is, and I I think there is like a difference, like so like the national security presidential memorandum dash seven, right? Like countering domestic terrorism and organized violence, right? This is like this sort of blueprint is that there is a vast left-wing conspiracy that connects like mainstream liberal groups, like the Open Society Foundation, Sierra Club, right, to Antifa, like, and they're all like terrorists in in this sense. And I think you know, that's worth sort of pointing out that this is sort of the view.
SPEAKER_01But I think the other thing too is we're talking about the architecture, but like you talked about like the prairie land sentences and what ICE activ anti-ICE activists have been hit with, right? The the threshold, I mean, I'm in I'm outside of DC, the reflecting pool, the canoe guy, right, who's the former Olympian who's being charged under this, right? The threshold for charges and is even lower than it was in the early 2000s, right? As like what's being target charged as terrorism, and then like the sentences in the Prairie Land cases, right?
SPEAKER_01You're talking about people, not even like Benjamin Song, who was the one who actually fired a weapon, but people who were there, like facing 30, 50, 70, 80, like the sentences are are wild, right? And you know, who knows what will happen if those stand out. But that's I think something that's different is like the threshold for what constitute terrorism, right, has been lowered dramatically. And that's also why you've seen said that the administration has lost some cases because they're still not like the courts are not completely captured. But I also think that's definitely something, and Scott, correct me if I'm wrong, this is definitely something that activists have noticed.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, definitely. I mean, it's I I would say that the with the Prairie Land Census, I I've noted a lot of people who are very, very concerned. I mean, and and you know, they're they're they're they're prosecuting a variety of fronts with this stuff. Like the the 15 people, the mini up the Minneapolis 15, people who basically just organized like patrols and and protests and some direct action against what ICE did in Minneapolis in January and February.
SPEAKER_00Some cop city activists recently got indicted by the feds for something that happened in 2022. And then there's the Broadview Six who were also organizing these demonstrations, including a congressional candidate, you know, who were organizing demonstrations at the the Broadview ICE facility in in Chicago. That that got tossed out. Turns out the prosecutors, you know, there was prosecutor prosecutoral misconduct going on. So we'll see what happens. But you know, prairie land, fifth circuit, North Texas, it's very scary.
C. Derick VarnYep. It does seem the architecture is that's being built is so incredibly broad it can apply to almost anybody, and the only thing that's really keeping it from being applied to everyone is like technically the first amendment still kind of exists, but even then, if you can connect anything to uh as a material charge beyond the speech act, you get them on that. I mean, I think we're gonna also see Rico charges being ramped up. We started seeing this being threatened against unions too.
C. Derick VarnSo I wanted to ask you though, do you like this had a chilling effect in the aughts? I wonder if it will have the opposite effect now, because if it's so expansive that people are gonna start being like, well, there's no way to play within the rules anyway. You know, like if they're going after people for Z, then why should we play? Like, why should it matter anymore? Like the historically, that has been a logic that comes up. These things are first chilling, and then the repression gets too intense, and then they actually have a the repression has the opposite effect of chilling, it actually starts spreading back out and re-radicalizing.
C. Derick VarnBut I I you know we're very early in this cycle again. What are you guys' take on as we look on climate justice profoundly changing? Like I haven't seen a whole lot from Extinction Rebellion lately, for example, but it it does seem like things are getting serious enough that we might see at least a return to early 18 levels of activism. I mean, what do you guys think on that?
SPEAKER_00I mean, I I I you know there were very well organized community mobilizations intervening against ice in Los Angeles, Chicago, Charlotte, Minneapolis, Minneapolis being a sort of like peak moment for that. That I would actually say one, you know, that led to Operation Metro Surge ending and ICE pulling back significantly in Minneapolis. Led to Christy Gnome losing her her office. But you know, it was at a cost. It was like Renee Good and Alex Pretty were murdered.
SPEAKER_00By the state. But I mean, I think there's a win there. I think that's actually partially why the Trump administration is like really trying to sort of double down with these like sort of post-action legal use legal these legal tactics. I I feel like wherever, you know, we're seeing it at Delaney Hall in New Jersey right now as well, right? Or I think that's I think it's kind of slowed down a little bit. But like we're seeing a lot of people show up and push back. And so I don't know if Prairie Land's going to have a chill-in effect or not. It might have a, you know, key thing about Prairie Land is that Texas is an open carry state.
SPEAKER_00And particularly in North Texas, you go to a lot of demos, there'll be a lot of right-wing counter-protesters there carrying weapons. You'll also see a lot of left-wing protesters there carrying weapons. I I see, I mean, I'm from, I'm from, I grew up in Dallas. I lived in Houston for a long time. You see that actually less in Houston, and you see it some in Austin, but like in North Texas is actually a pretty normal thing. It could have a chilling effect on that around activists open carrying at protests. But you know, also Alex Predy was open carrying as well. And you know, that hasn't didn't stop anything in Minneapolis.
SPEAKER_00They still had general strikes, they had, you know, mass actions, they still did mass disruption of ice operations. So there's that. I mean, it's it's but it's it's a very scary time. And you know, we've actually done a couple of shows on Prairie Land on Green and Red. We actually just did one last week. And so I I I do I do want to say that the important thing is that it wasn't a conspiracy, it was maybe a little bit of could have been a better organized protest, obviously. But like people just need to like organize their protests, even if it's like a legal hold your sign sidewalk thing, it's like really just kind of have your um shit together.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. I mean, so I I like and I would I think what's interesting too is if you talk to anybody who's in like left-wing NGO spaces, whether it be in the climate space or even like voting or other things, right? The one thing that has happened is like money and donors are scared. That's like very clear, like happening right now. I think the big, you know, this is all ramping up to the midterms, right? And so I think like when you have people who are lefties who are from the opposition party, I think watch for targeting of those folks.
SPEAKER_01Like, I mean, they've talked about you know arresting different political figures and other things. So I think that's I mean, that's a as a scholar of democracy. I mean, I've done work in Ukraine and Turkey, like I've seen that that that play before. And I think like the big question, right, is and this is like the million-dollar question people who study like contentious politics, is when does repression you know mobilize people and when does it like lead movements to like die? And there's not like an easy answer for that. I will say the other thing too, right, is the big like if you know I'm not I don't like making predictions because you can always be proven wrong and you can be right, but like still be wrong.
SPEAKER_01But I still think like ahead of the 2028, that's where I think that's the the where you're gonna see a lot of sort of repression being like buckled down. I mean, we've already seen two. I think what is interesting, and I I was chatting with reporters earlier today was about like the sort of red baiting or like labeling of like communists that's sort of now becoming a through line. And you know, I think that's one I think I don't think that will stick, but again, I I think there is this architecture that they have through the National Security Presidential Memorandum 7.
SPEAKER_01And like even when those cases lose or other things, I mean it's miserable for the people who have to go through this and it raises the costs. And like I think your question about like, you know, does it mobilize or like demobilize people? I don't know, right? I think it's I think we're still waiting to see what happens. I do think like what is again interesting that's happening in these spaces are the some of the anti-data center stuff that is like also something that like I don't think either party really wants to talk about because it's very uncomfortable for them.
SPEAKER_01But it's definitely something that's you know been grassroots, it's place-based, and it's like there are both left-wing and right-wing folks who are opposed to it. And that I think is also like the big, you know, if you were to say like there's like the Trump sort of you know phenomenon, but then there's also the deeper sort of political economy of you know what is AI and tech and the tech oligarchs sort of mean for you know politics and contentious politics. And that's maybe like that's the next five to ten years, and that's like kind of the story, I think.
C. Derick VarnYeah, I I mean I I see I I weirdly a whole lot of stuff that you guys have mentioned has actually been right around where I live.
SPEAKER_01Um right, Mr. Wonderful is trying to build that massive data center, yeah.
C. Derick VarnYeah, the the the data center double the size of Manhattan in a dry but greenish valley in in Box Elder County near Brigham City, which would finish it would kill our alfalfa cropping entirely. It would finish draining the Salt Lake, it would probably raise temperatures in the mountains up to 25 degrees at ground level. But every every person in that county who voted for that is gone in the last election, every single one, and that's not by liberals, yeah.
C. Derick VarnLike, you know, Box Elder County is the the Mormonist of Mormon land you can probably go to. And we've seen Davis County, which is one of the most conservative counties in the country. So you know, it's up there with North Texas, Scott, actually start to turn purple over this, which is wild. That is that is like nobody has seen that on the horizon. Now, I'm not, you know, as a person who doesn't trust Democrats, I'm not I don't so much care that Democrats are are are winning.
C. Derick VarnWhat I care about is that there's such a pronounced change happening so fast here over environmental issues, but it's not clean because while you can get everyone to agree on the data centers, what we should do with the land after that, that's a completely different.
SPEAKER_00I I mean I don't know how much we want to get into this. I mean, I think well, a couple my thoughts on the data center thing is one, it's not just like Republicans who want AI data centers. Abigail Spamberger came out today and said there should be no regulation on that AI data centers.
SPEAKER_01But what what just happened too in the last day is the the gateway data center was canceled, the biggest proposed one in Prince William County, which is sorry, go ahead.
SPEAKER_00Uh and then and then two is that like I I think there's an environmental element to it, like around issues around water and noise and air pollution. But the the other the other thing, because you know, there's lots of AI diastrounds being fought in Texas, local control and lots of republic local rural Republicans are against them. And part of it has actually turned out to be a fight about local control of things as well. They don't want the stick, the state, the state of Texas or whatever other state out there coming and telling them what to do, which is something they didn't do when the state came in and imposed, you know, you know, stopped ordinances against fracking that were happening in Texas, like in the last 10 years.
C. Derick VarnWell, this would be my last question because we kind of skipped this, unfortunately, because we got to this, but you guys talk about the climate justice movement. Both of you have noted that it kind of came after the the suppression of the earth front style activist. Where do we feel like the climate change movement is now? Because it seems so dire, and we we we are beginning to have.
C. Derick VarnI mean, cognitive dissonance is a special thing, and there's gonna be people who deny this until like literally the earth is on fucking fire and there's no water left. But you the it does seem like there's a lot more people seeing the environmental uh repercussions even before you talk about the data centers. Like here in Salt Lake, we haven't had a cold winter in the valley in five years. Like we've had a couple of okay snow years, but in the valley, which used to get two or three feet of snow on average a year, we've had no snow.
C. Derick VarnIt's been rain, but it snows in the mountains, and that saves our snowpack, and it's been rain down here. But in the last two years, we're not even getting the snowpack anymore, and summers are getting wild now. Some of that's super El Nino, but like I've you know, I've experienced weeks now where the climate will be 50 one day and 107 the next, and I'm not exaggerating. That is historically not the case for this valley. We're not given towards randomly changing microclimates like this.
C. Derick VarnDo we feel like you know the concern is being felt more? I mean, particularly now that like you know, a lot of American energy infrastructure has been hurt by its own contradictory policies. Like, what are we seeing here? I mean, you guys are on the on this pulse more than me. I I feel like climate activists here seem both more concerned, but also they're scared in ways they weren't like even, you know, they they even started getting scared around 2022, even before Trump came back, because of people finally getting charged for stuff that happened during BLM and and and stuff around that.
C. Derick VarnSo I I want to get your take about how you guys feel like the the climate justice movement is and maybe how it's gone the last three or four years.
SPEAKER_00You were I mean, I think it's pretty quiet right now. Some of it is because of stuff we've already talked about. I think I think that the Trump administration, there's been a lot of grumbling from the Trump administration that they're gonna go after the foundations and the kind of bigger green groups, even those liberal reformist groups, which I've like kind of bragged on through this, is like those they're in there in the crosshairs. So there's that. I think funders are pretty scared to give the things that might get the eye of Sauron or the eye of Trump on them is part of it.
SPEAKER_00And then also we're you know, we've seen a lot of we've seen a lot of we haven't seen it, we haven't seen a federal law, but like lots of states have anti-protest, anti-energy infrastructure legislation that have been passed. You know, the Trump administration with MPSM7, you know, that's definitely would put like climate activists in the crosshairs. And then part of it is there's just like a lot of other stuff going on.
SPEAKER_00And so like lots of climate activists I know, like they go and they're working on ICE campaigns in their community, or they, you know, have been working on stuff around Gaza. Or what I am seeing now is I'm seeing a lot more climate groups and climate activists get interested in the in the data anti-data center movement, which I think is an interesting sort of segue there. But there's there's there's a lot of interesting things going on. The climate movement is definitely not where it was 10 years ago, where I actually felt like it was a force and it actually built some power.
SPEAKER_00But that that's all fleeting. The last one of the one of the last big hurrahs I can think of was in 2021 around the line three pipeline um up in northern Minnesota, where you see a lot of climate activists go there to be disruptive on the construction of the pipeline. And so for what it's worth, there's a new pipeline fight brewing in Michigan right now called line five. We'll see if anything happens with that. Doesn't seem like it is right now, though.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Yeah, I mean, I think like everything Scott said, and he has his finger on like kind of the pulse of activists even more than I do. I do think like what's interesting from like a political standpoint, if you look at the polling, is Americans are more concerned about like even with all the sort of, you know, especially on the the right, like the sort of it's a globalist hoax, etc., like being even sort of more doubled down on in like kind of the war on climate science. I mean, you could argue like anti-immigrant attitudes, corruption, and then like anti-climate science.
SPEAKER_01Those are like the three pot tripods of the Trump administration. And yet people are still like extremely worried, but I think there's there's been like a bunch of articles that have come out, and it's like clear that these are like leaked from like democratic strategists who are basically like climate is an elite issue, like we need to like back away. Let's like talk about affordability and other stuff. And I think I one, I think from like just a straight like you know, policy standpoint, it that's a disaster. It's two, it's also like people are scared, and there are things that like can work, it's just it's it's hard.
SPEAKER_01And I think that you know, the other so I think like the ability to sort of like push like policy one is there's no levers of power at the national level that Debs control, but even at the state level, right? We've seen like Hokel and Newsom like are like kind of like walking back on like a bunch of climate stuff because they see it as secondary to affordability concerns. And I think that one that's a false sort of framing. But I also think I also think that the the deeper question, and this is like you know, what Scott like hinted at, is that a lot of activists are involved in a lot of different campaigns, and that's part of like climate justice and climate activists and like this kind of intersectional bent to activism, which is like a good thing, right?
SPEAKER_01In general, like from a normative standpoint, but like from getting people committed to a cause, I think it goes back to what we're talking about, is like it's weird is the environment. Like, how many people like say, like, I don't like the environment? Like, it's it's something that has like a very high approval rating. Like most people, you say, I like nature, I like the environment. And yet I do think there is in left-wing spaces this critique. If you are like basically say, I'm really in it for the environment, that's really what I am, is that you have some kind of like like kind of undeveloped politics, right? And I think that means that people like when there are issues like Gaza or ICE or you know, any other sorts of issues, right?
SPEAKER_01It's the climate will always be second fiddle. And that's something that you know, activists, you know, and other folks from you know past eras bemoan. And some of it is like sour grapes, but I think there's some truth to it too.
C. Derick VarnI've been I've been noticing a lot of that. Like, I mean, just the obvious figure is Greta Thunberg has moved from climate change to Gaza just as a culture. Yeah, and and like all these things are things that I I care about personally. I mean, like I get it. Yeah, the I I have been sort of agasped at the utter not just of centrist, we often like pick on centrist democrats, but even of left in quotation marks, like progressive liberal democrats, their unwillingness to tie affordability in with climate change because if you can't grow food, food's expensive.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I mean, like, yeah, um, you know, people stink, like like tell anybody, like being in like 104 degrees is miserable, right? Like, that's not like something where you're just like, oh, you really gotta frame this one for people.
SPEAKER_00My my my question, my question for y'all is, and maybe I'm just like not looking at the right places, like with all these like left insurgents that are winning these democratic primaries in New York and Colorado and places like that, how much are they talking about climate? How much are they talking about fossil fuels? I saw Malou Kiro's kind of calling out the grit on it around taking money from the fossil fuel sector once, but yeah, it's it's not it's not a top issue for in these camp in these elections.
SPEAKER_01No, it's absolutely not. Can I also say, like, as a political scientist, I think there's also like a big this idea that like, well, you know, we should do we should meet people where they are, and like, you know, it's not the top issue, and therefore, like, you know, we should just kind of let it be. And I think one, it's a complete misreading of like what we know from like political science is that hey, by the way, politicians have the ability to shape issues. Like, I I mean, birthright citizenship people like 10 years ago, like would say nothing on that, right?
SPEAKER_01So, like, I think you know, if anything, politics of the last like you know, 12 years has taught us is that like politicians can, you know, who are smart and good at their job or like clever, like can figure out ways to make topics salient.
C. Derick VarnIt does bring me to that old image from the 90s about progressives versus conservatives, that the the progressives are the party of no ideas and the conservatives are a party of batshit insane ones. And in lieu of of ideas, the batshit insane ones usually win. And I I do sort of think that way. I mean, I uh you know, I I literally just wrote a book against left populism, so of course I'm like down on that. But I mean, as much as I think affordability is super important, and it absolutely is, I but I I think we can walk and through bubblegum at the same time, and yet it does seem like that's very hard for people to do.
C. Derick VarnUm, and I guess maybe I can have you two back uh together our separately to talk about this. Could you know, because my question is is this something about the cultures around activist groups that we saw develop that lead to, I mean, you guys kind of hinted at it in the 90s. For reasons that you talk about in your book, and we haven't talked about so much in in the interview, Thomas, you know, with the with the fall of the Soviet Union and like the temporary, you know, as someone who grew up in in the 90s and went to college in the early aughts, Marxism was nowhere to be found except in literary groups, and even then it was only Frederick Jameson, like and Altusaire, like no one actually talked about Marx back at the time.
C. Derick VarnAnd then post-2008, all that stuff is kind of back on the table for good and ill, I think, mostly good, but every now and then it's so dumb that I feel like maybe it would have been better. But but you know, I try not to be nihilist about it. I I how how do you think the culture of activism, and this is the last, this is the absolute last question, and maybe we can pick this up at another time too, because it's a big question. How do you think the culture of activism plays into these cycles? Because you guys talked about intersectionality being important, and that that also implied that in the 90s a lot of activists were single-issue activists, and that's just not true anymore.
C. Derick VarnBut what about the culture of activists makes sustained attention like this so hard? And we let's answer it quickly, and then maybe we can even come back and riff on this at another on another episode at another time.
SPEAKER_00It's an interesting question. I mean, I I uh I I definitely think part of it is that there's as a person who is versed and immersed in activist cultures and subcultures and and whatever else, I mean, there's there's definitely like a lot of different stuff going on, right? And so the all the stuff I named, Gaza, Ice, all of that sort of stuff, now and then a lot of fear around state repression.
SPEAKER_00So I mean, I think I think that's part of it. I think part of it is just like the sort of I I also don't think people within activist circles are necessarily the the deep thinkers that they think they are, or maybe or other people think they are, because I think they're also very susceptible to like what's in the news cycle or what's in the culture. And I think some of it's a response to that as well. And part of it is just like some of the technology, too, is that like they're they're on the 24-second news cycle, just like everybody else.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Yeah, I mean, I think it's I mean, this is like a super like deep question. I do think, like, great, at least in contentious politics, right? We know there are like waves of kind of organizing, like that came like in you, like think of like the waves of like just political violence in the US, right? That people talk about, right? Is you know, from the left you had like the early 20th century anarchists, and then you had kind of you know, Ku Klux Klan anti, you know, integration, and you had like the contentious civil rights movement, and then you had the emergence of like the new left, and then you had this long period of kind of right wing sort of violence, and like there's a big debate as to whether or not like, and I I can't, you know, you can't tell me after a year of data that we're on the like the verge of like left-wing radicalism and action, right?
SPEAKER_01But like there is something about like these things come in waves, and there are repression and resurgence, etc. And you know, I I think a lot of this, you know, what's happening right now is there's you know, on the left, there's I think one is I think people are saying, oh, there's this resurgence, you know, DSA and this huge left-wing progressive movement. And there is some truth to that. I also think it's that like even people in the middle really hate the Democratic Party for a lot of reasons. And so I think like some people will misread this as like a big shift of voters to the left.
SPEAKER_01I don't know if that's necessarily the case.
C. Derick VarnI feel like it's a throw the bastards out moment, what it feels like to me.
SPEAKER_01And the DSA there, yeah. Yeah, that's exactly. And they they're holding well organized. Yeah, right. They're like holding the door open, right? So like I think a lot of that is that, and so I think a lot of what we will see emerge is like going to be like as annoying as it is, but it's gonna be the product of yes, there's gonna be mass mobilizations and like pressure, but there's also going to be like, you know, political elites, even like from like activists, but also like within left-wing politics who are trying to figure out like what is our response to the moment, and they're gonna tell themselves stories and coordinate around that.
SPEAKER_01And it's not clear like that there is a strategy as to what is the coordination around the threat that Trump and MAGA pose yet. I think it's like win the midterms and punt, right? And so I think whatever happens after the midterms, that's when we're gonna have an idea. And that's like a very unsatisfying thing, but I think that's really what's happening because if you were to say, tell me who is the leader of the left in the US, there's none, right? Like, I mean, even like there isn't a person, and that's you know, both you know, a product of the moment, but also because it's not clear, anyways.
SPEAKER_01I rambled, but this was this was a lot of fun, Derek. This was yeah, yeah.
C. Derick VarnAll right, yeah. Well, I know you have to go, so I'm gonna ask you to plug where people can find your work, and I'm gonna remind everyone about Thomas's book, no option but sabotage. I don't think I've actually said the name. Yes, I did. I said it in the beginning. No option but sabotage. I enjoyed uh the first six chapters. I should finish chapter seven today. And Scott, how about your work and then anything else you'd like to plug, Thomas?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, you can just you can find my most public work at greenandredpodcast.org. I also work at Reinforce Action Network, which is ran.org. And you can also just watch for whatever activity we're working on.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, sweet. Encourage you guys to check out green and red. Uh zeitsoft.com is my website. Uh this book. I'm also one of the psych hosts on blue sky. So there we go. Um and thank you again for having us. This is awesome.
C. Derick VarnThank you guys for coming on. Have a great rest of your day.
In this episode of VarnVlog, C. Derick Varn sits down with Dr. Ida Susser (Distinguished Professor of Anthropology at Hunter College and the CUNY Graduate Center) to explore her open-access book, The Yellow Vests and...
In this episode of VarnVlog, C. Derick Varn is joined by author, public researcher, and retired professor of psychology Dr. Warren Throckmorton to discuss his book, The Christian Past That Wasn’t: Debunking the...
In this installment of the National Fronts series on VarnVlog, C. Derick Varn is joined by writing partner Brandon Lightly to deliver a comprehensive historical and materialist deconstruction of Peronism (Justicialism)...
In this episode of VarnVlog, C. Derick Varn is joined by veteran sociologist, author, and activist Dr. Charles Derber (Boston College) to discuss his book Wired for Authoritarianism: American Oligarchies and How to...
In this episode of VarnVlog, C. Derick Varn is joined by psychiatrist, writer, and political commentator Dr. Tad Tietze (co-author of Left Flank) to unpack the evolving dynamics of anti-politics and hyperpolitics across...