Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Varn Vlog

Varn Vlog artwork

Leninism in the Age of Populism: Anti-Economism, Strategy & The Left with PK Gandakin

Oct 12, 20262 hr 16 minAudio

In this episode of VarnVlog, C. Derick Varn sits down with PK Gandakin, editor-in-chief of Geese Magazine and communist organizer, to discuss the state of the American left, the limits of modern economism, and the strategic relevance of Lenin today. Together, they unpack: The Mission of Geese Magazine: Why a non-sectarian, strategy-focused communist press is essential in today's political terrain. Rethinking Lenin & Gramsci: Moving beyond ultra-left dogmas to embrace dialectical flexibility, mass politics, and organic centralism. Electoral Strategy & The DSA: Navigating the rise of figures like AOC and Zoran Mamdani, the limits of "clean/dirty break" debates, and building a genuine left pole. Lessons from BLM & Mass Movements: Why past spontaneous struggles failed to build lasting cadres - and how communists can engage with mass agitation effectively. Links: https://www.geesemag.com/articles/the-critique-of-economism-in-marxs-critique-of-hegels-philosophy-of-right https://www.geesemag.com/articles/leninism-in-the-age-of-populism https://www.geesemag.com/articles/reading-gramsci-on-economism-political-method-and-urbanism Send us Fan Mail Musis by Bitterlake, Used with Permission, all rights to Bitterlake Support the show Crew: Host: C. Derick Varn Intro and Outro Music by Bitter Lake. Intro Video Design: Jason Myles Art Design: Corn and C. Derick Varn Links and Social Media: twitter: @varnvlog blue sky: @varnvlog.bsky.social You can find the additional streams on Youtube Current Patreon at the Sponsor Tier: Jordan Sheldon, Mark J. Matthews, Lindsay Kimbrough, RedWolf, DRV, Kenneth McKee, JY Chan, Matthew Monahan, Parzival, Adriel Mixon, Buddy Roark, Daniel Petrovic,Julian, Drea, Free Beer, SNT-BRCH, Joshua Parsons

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

C. Derick VarnHello, I am here with PK Gadonkin, who is a communist writer and an organizer out there in the belly of the beast, good old DC. And he is a writer for geese. Are you also an editor for geese? I can't I cannot remember.

SPEAKER_01Yes, I'm the editor-in-chief currently.

C. Derick VarnOh, well, then that makes it a lot easier to say you're an editor for geese. Um, and you are interested in Marx and Lenin. You were involved with the CPUSA and now with the DSA just to a large degree. And lots of us who follow communist media felt like geese kind of came out of nowhere around the election of Zaram Mamdani. Your magazine is not an org of caucus or sect.

C. Derick VarnI want to be so that's also interesting. So while I think a lot of you are associated with groundwork caucus, it is not a groundwork organ. And so that allows you guys a certain amount of independence. And I've been following you for a little bit, actually. I was expecting us way back in the day, well back in the day, being like six months ago, to have hostile interactions because I am loosely associated with factions in the DSA that are nominally hostile to groundwork and a few other groups.

C. Derick VarnBut not, I mean, in reality, what I find very interesting is I'm actually on caucus myself in the DSA. And also I work a lot in person actually with groundwork and reform and revolution, more than I even do the people that I am associated with online. And the the the reason I'm associated with Marxist Unity Group actually is almost historical. It's like I knew Donald Parkinson back back when he was starting to found that thing.

C. Derick VarnI don't think he's even in mug anymore, interestingly enough. And was involved with the Marxist Center and the Red Party 10 years ago before that collapsed. And so people have assumed somewhat correctly, actually, that I am more or less aligned with mug. But again, I'm on caucus. I bring all this up as kind of context for this conversation because I I surprisingly find that I enjoy reading Geese Magazine and I've enjoyed interacting with most of you because you have you behaved yourself like principal con uh principal comrades and not and also are not interested in causing unnecessary sectarian splits.

C. Derick VarnAnd I wanted to start that off in the conversation then, because I was gonna ask you with that attitude, which I think is a good one, it's a healthy one. What do you see geese doing? What is this intervention right now? And why did you see the project as necessary?

SPEAKER_01So, in some ways, there's like an interesting answer here, and like a theoretical answer. In some ways, there's like maybe a less interesting personal answer, right? And maybe I'll start with a personal answer, which is that a lot of us coming out of the CPSA, and I think you'll find this interesting too, is that in terms of the editorial board, we aren't even all DSA members, right? And I personally have really only gravitated more towards DSA since Noran's election, right? So I would consider, you know, I've been a paper member for a very long time of DSA, you know, while I was also organizing at CPSA.

SPEAKER_01But I I say that just to really emphasize that our goals, as you say, are really sectarian, right? And our sort of feeling after our experiences organizing in the left for a while, was that we felt that a lot of what Lenin was saying, a lot of what historical communists have been saying about, you know, political discussion, politics in command, you know, the importance of the socialist press or the newspaper, that they it it may not be everything, but it's certainly something.

SPEAKER_01And it's something that's really lacking today. And we felt that if we truly are communists, right? And I think that this is something that like, you know, was partially like an emotional thing to grapple with, our relation to the movement and what we want to do, that our job is to, you know, put forward our views, right? We just, you know, we disdain to conceal our views. Our job is to have these discussions. And I think a lot of people, as you're saying, feel like we came out of the came came up suddenly. I think it's very true, but I don't think it has anything to do with us, right?

SPEAKER_01The way I like to and materialism in general is it's much more a matter of like almost like evolutionary niches, right? Where there's a need in the environment and there's no animal or organism that can fulfill that need, you know, one will rise to take its place. And it feels like to me that there's been a need for some kind of like very political strategy focused, non-sectarian, and you know, explicitly opinionated without being like dogmatic, as you're saying, attached to an organization or a caucus or a formal line that's willing to get it wrong and to get it wrong publicly, to disagree publicly, to put forward specific claims publicly, was like an evolutionary niche that was not getting filled and one that we happen to fill, I think, at this moment in time.

SPEAKER_01So for us, in like a more specific sense, you know, it's just whatever we say, whatever we believe is on the paper, right? We have no, there's no like secret aim, I guess, behind it. What we say is true is like I do think that like AOC 28 is like a historic opportunity for communists. I do think that we need to be less economistic. I do think that the pot the relationship between something like populism and Marxism is more complex than we've been sort of so far assessing it as. And there's nothing more to it, right? And my goal, my hope in like, you know, what is the best case scenario with geese? And this is something we've said since we formerly started a couple of years ago, but you know, really have only started properly publishing last year around Mamdani's election.

SPEAKER_01But our goal is like, like, you know, hopefully someone eliminates us, right? Hopefully someone negates us. But we can't reach a situation where we're negated by going backwards, right? We have to somewhat negate economism, we have to somewhat negate this culture of activism and political silence and you know form this sort of like nationally oriented, politically oriented political communism, right? And you know, I I'm almost certain we're going to get it wrong because how would we get it right, right? You know, just from a historical perspective perspective, we're just a couple, a few people, right, in a very long history.

SPEAKER_01But we need to exist to be negated. And I think that that's something that I felt that a lot of other communists who often I think are you know much smarter than we are, much have much more insight than we do, are not offering, right? They're not building out this kind of press. They're not actively, you know, trying to talk to people and get theirs their their articles read by people, right? Right about interesting things, rights about stuff that people care about and stuff that's going on, like Momdani.

C. Derick VarnYeah, I um you know, interestingly enough, I have been kind of the opposite of you is I was not a member at all until Zoran Momdani. And I came in to the DSA to try to intervene. Not against Zoran, actually. Uh that was a misunderstanding of why I entered. It was to see and help people pull apart what they were doing and trying to look at the context in specific areas.

C. Derick VarnSo, like, you know, one of my big arguments was we do need to put forth candidates here, but in Utah that needs to be locally because there's no infrastructure at the at the state level the way there is in New York. And that was gonna require a slightly different approach. And locally, uh I I did not participate a lot in our one state candidate election here. Taylor Patton is a person that I know actually pretty well.

C. Derick VarnNot when I wouldn't say we're like close friends, but like I've followed him for a while. And he didn't do so well in this election, but they I think they learned a lot from it. The I I find it interesting though, the moving beyond economism, because one of the the groups that you guys are like often have debates with are the people around both Lightnir, that's mug, and then Cosmonaut.

C. Derick VarnAnd nominally, they have the same concerns. They also hate economism, they also uh are are trying to get Marxism out of the whole thin veil of interest thing, and they're very they're very politics first. In fact, some of our my debates with that group or those two groups now have been about um maybe overcorrecting uh against economic limitations. But geese does feel very different, and I wanted to ask you, maybe why do you think it feels different than some of the other Linen inflected groupings and and magazines that exist right now?

SPEAKER_01I think the sort of self-evident answer is that compared to a lot of current Leninist formations, we have the appearance of being a lot more rightist, right? Um we're much more open to elections, for example. We're much more energetic about electoral participation and the importance of the democratic struggle more generally. And, you know, if I had to be polemic, I would say, polemical, I'd say that the reason is because sort of not after Lenin won and after he died, he's been sort of turned into like a generic ultra-leftist in many ways, the sort of pseudo-anarchist.

SPEAKER_01And I do think that we have a quote unquote more authentic Lenin on our side. But I do think what you're identifying is a very interesting historical sort of trend, right? And the joke I sometimes make is with regards to the Communist Party. And obviously, I do believe we're more left, and I do believe we're more left than the most existing Leninist caucuses. But the joke I like to make is that we're the only Leninist like communists who left and broke right, right? In many ways, we sort of inverted a lot of the common pattern of the way that those things usually go.

SPEAKER_01And I think that's very like, I don't want to say intentional, but it is like essential in a sense where it feels like, and maybe this is where our anti-economism differs from their economism. And I have a great essay you may enjoy on this called Good for the Gander, uh, where I talked about these different types of economism where you know their economism doesn't feel 100%. It feels like it goes halfway and a halfway anti-economism to me. You know, it's going to be both bad economism and it's going to be bad anti-economism. So our thinking, and I think this is also probably why we've made such a splash, is that we almost we don't want to be on the left or right of the existing terrain, but we want to understand why the terrain is the way it is today and see what we could do to shift that terrain to a more productive one, right?

SPEAKER_01Because I think that especially within the DSA, the left has almost like sequestered itself by its approach to politics, where it's very uh negative, it's very reactive. That's the word, very reactive to the right. It's very much like the DSA right is doing all these things, and how are we going to do X, Y, and Z in relation to those things? How are we going to discipline elected? How are we going to make sure that New York City DSA doesn't host fundraisers for certain candidates, right? And I think that's not a good posture to be in. And I think that's a it's a structurally oppositional posture to be in.

SPEAKER_01And it worries me because to me, the end sort of like, you know, historically, what is the end result of those kinds of tendencies, right? It ends up being marginalization at best or being forced to leave, right, and start your own organization at worst. And where I guess the question has gone a little bit away from me. But, you know, in the sort of Leninist sense, I want to, I do, I do think that the left and ourselves should, you know, take the positive elements of the moment, right? Try to understand where things are developing and how we can intervene positively. And I think that's where we differ a lot from the modern prop of Leninists who I think treat Lenin more as a negationist in the other sense, right?

SPEAKER_01Or he wants to, you know, he's he's the radical of who's controlling things rather than the constructor or the builder. And just an example, I think I think it's very funny. I was reading your review or your response to our review of your book, which I enjoyed a lot. It was a very good response. But what one thing I thought was very interesting too was like what there's a discussion of Lenin in the youth response, and it discusses how he always maintains like a class analysis. And I believe I maintain a class analysis, but what I want to point out briefly that I think is often left out here, is that he has been completely like decomplexified.

SPEAKER_01Like the Mensheviks accuse Lenin of being a populist. The Mensheviks accused him of being a class collaborationist. And I think that it's true that we should you know maintain a principled Marxist line, but it also has to be a living one and one that sort of engages with and you know maybe moves beyond maybe critiques and so on existing terms, but it's still you know part of that existing critical wave.

C. Derick VarnYeah. So one of the funny things that I actually found about this is when when I was reading you guys' work, and you know, I know that some of you read my book, I'm pretty sure you even have, but let's just say my books. Mine and Daniel Tut's book. And uh, I don't want to negate Daniel's contributions actually there, at least in some ways, even more significant than mine theoretically. But I was thinking about like who I included in left populism, and I was going back and forth to Daniel.

C. Derick VarnI was like, I don't even know that I would include everything that geese includes are geese in my definition yet, because I realized that one of the things that actually came up in that debate is like was our definition of populism. And I'm like, I think we have a fundamentally different definition, and it would apply to certain things and not others, and we apply it. I'm actually surprised that when we applied it to more ultra-centered groups like the communization movement, that we haven't got more pushback from communizers on that.

C. Derick VarnBut I want to turn into this a little bit because one thing I actually fundamentally do agree with you is Lenin is all over the place, and that is not me saying that he is being inconsistent, that that is me saying that Lenin's analysis for what they what they needed to be done was guided by basically responding to an ever-shifting political terrain. And when you saw the debates in the 1920s in the common turn, like between Trotsky and Stalin and Bukharin and Azenebev and Kemenev, and all that, I was like, well, all of them are citing Lenin, and frankly, they're all citing Lenin correctly, like depending on the time period you're looking at Lenin at.

C. Derick VarnAnd it it kind of got me thinking about the problem that Lenin presents for a lot of us, because we do try to turn him into a very coherent set of like doctrines that we can add on to more fully flood out the political side of Marxism, because Marx and Engels' politics are like us trying to figure out things from actions they took in the first international letters that they sent as foreign representatives of the SP Day, and their own internal letters.

C. Derick VarnAnd it does feel like I'm doing lipstick traces a lot of the time. Like, like we know that Marx and Engels wrote about the party, but actually very little. It's very, it's very, I'm frankly underdeveloped, but but also they're dealing in a very early period of the of the movement. So it feels a little weird for me to be like, oh, well, you didn't know all the party problems in 1865, when there are no parties of the type you're describing anywhere on the planet that we know about.

C. Derick VarnSo that does seem to be an issue. I I also go ahead, respond.

SPEAKER_01Oh sorry, I was gonna say one thing I think is kind of funny is that despite like the attention we've been getting, no one seems to have really picked up on our philosophy quite yet, even though we talk about it a lot. I think that what you're hitting on is really like the crux of like where I do think that, and I think this is related to where we feel like maybe similar anti-economist orientations do fall into economism, is that there's also a certain appropriate mental model. And the sort of model, mental model dominant in today's Marxist discourse is of like the rational individual subject, or like, you know, in the formal sense, the academic.

SPEAKER_01So for this, you know, rational subject, your your thoughts, your principles, your tactics have to be non-contradictory, right? But in the real world, right, in real Marxism, we see exactly what you're saying, where Lenin is saying that capitalism can only be overthrown with a violent revolution one year, and the next year he's saying that we must do a peaceful revolution in Russia. And then the year after that, he's saying the peaceful revolution is no longer possible. We must do a violent revolution. And I think we can point to this and say he's being inconsistent or he's changing his mind. But at a certain point, we have to ask how much this is part of his method, right?

SPEAKER_01How much this is part of the dialectical method. And I think that this also retroactively, like it applies to Marx as well. And one thinker who you may know that we we we like a lot of this, Bertel Ullman, and he talks about this a lot. And for him, he says that Marx does contradict himself. Marx is very ambiguous, right? Labor and capital are both dichotomies, but labor is also variable capital. Capital is also dead labor. These things are both one thing and another. And Ullman tells us to look at this as part of Marx's method. And I think that's what we're trying to do, too.

SPEAKER_01You know, we can't if if if your model of Lenin doesn't account for his defense of legal Marxism or his defense of peaceful revolution, then clearly you don't have a correct model of Lenin, right? Because you would fight Lenin if you're in issues or if you're in that situation. And, you know, vice versa, of course, it applies to the reformists as well, but you know, they don't claim Lenin.

C. Derick VarnOne thing that leads me to about, you know, I've surprised many of the quote DSA right by occasionally siding with them, which they're often like, what Varn agrees with us on something. And it it's not often, but it does happen. And one of the reasons why I think that comes up is that you know, I'm not gonna lie, I kind of have an ultra-left background. I I have moved towards the center of the communist world. And my deep background's actually right-wing, like far back.

C. Derick VarnAnd I have been concerned by a couple of things in the development of being involved with communism in some way for 20 years at this point. One is that ultra-leftist positions often hollow out into right-wing positions over time. And and I I don't want to say it's unique to them.

C. Derick VarnIn fact, in fact, I've said to people, look, you know, this idea that any one doctrine that you're gonna see in socialism is going to just genealogically make you pivot right is bullshit. Like it's not true for Trotskyism, it's not true for Maoism, it's not true for traditional Marxist-Leninism, it's not true for the ultra-left either. But you can kind of see tendencies where there are specific outs in certain ways of thinking. And one of the things that I have noticed over time that got me really thinking about you know, moving away from some of the ultra positions is that one the invariant program.

C. Derick VarnI mean, one of the things that I was laughing at when you were talking about this, but I'm gonna mention the invariant program for a second, Bordeaux's become kind of revived in the last two decades. I mean, like, you know, when I was studying Marxism of my own and the aughts, like almost nobody knew who the hell he was unless you were really deep into the subforms at Libcom or something. And today it comes up a lot. But one of the things I've pointed out is even that a lot of people hate him, a lot of like former Marxist Leninists are uh you know, or even Hojist and people like that.

C. Derick VarnI was like, funnily enough, with the exception of the explicit faction ban, you guys actually agree with Bortiga on like 80% of everything.

SPEAKER_01Um well, it's the same thing with Lennon. You know, people have turned Bortiga into generic ultra too. You know, it's like he was to the left of Lenin for sure, but he was still in the common turn, right?

C. Derick VarnYou still have until 27. Right. Yeah, but that's actually important because I've actually pointed this out when everyone's like, oh, and I'm like, look, yeah, he's mostly on the right, right? Well, and also the people get got targeted in and left-wing communism and infantile disorder. The council communists left on their own, they weren't kicked out. And Bortegas stayed in, in fact, stayed in so much that like he actually became a key figure in the foundation of the first the first non clandestine edition of the Italian Communist Party.

C. Derick VarnAnd so, you know, yeah, he's written out when the party's re founded. It in 45, between 40 and 45, it's hard to know when you're dealing with the clandestine reformation. But and yeah, there's you know people involved even as early as 36. But one of the things that I've looked at and all that is like there was a myth from both sides, like painting like Vortiga as the anti-Gramshi that you saw from Vortigas and from like post-Gramshians, right?

C. Derick VarnPost-Gramshians, other Italian communists like Lacerdo, etc. etc. etc. When you actually dig into the history and like look at what was going on in like the 30s, like Gramsci and Bortiga still had a relationship on a prison island, and they were not hostile to each other. And I've always like taken that to be okay, something's gone wrong if we don't understand that.

SPEAKER_01And more than that, Gramsci was Bortiga's disciple in many ways. Really, like he grew up under him. I I used to have kind of an anti-Bordiga streak that really studying Gramsci made me realize was foolish completely because Gramsci does not exist without Bortiga. You know, there's no Gramsci without Bortiga, and there's no Italian Communist Party in general without Bortiga. I think like in this quest again for like the sort of internally consistent rational individual standpoint, we want to say Gramsci was right and Bordiga was wrong, or Bordeaux is right and Gramsci was wrong.

SPEAKER_01But there, you know, it's again in the sort of dialectical sense, right? There's no, there is no Gramsci without Bortiga. Bortiga is historically necessary for the Communist Party for a phase, even in the sense of like the invariant program or so on. And you see very interestingly that Gramsci, who I would say is a very committed anti-economist, defends economism throughout a lot of the prison notebooks. And to really understand economism, you have to be able to defend it. Because as you know, Gramsci says, economism is historically necessary for a certain phase of the development of the party.

SPEAKER_01And I think that sort of the, as you're saying, the sort of twin tendencies to separate Portiga and Gramsci are exactly with the you know practical result, maybe if not the intent, of making both of them much more mechanical, much less effective revolutionary thinkers.

C. Derick VarnThat's actually a very good point. I mean, same thing with Tagliati, who I used to I used to paint as a villain. I used to be like bad, everything bad. And now I'm sort of like, no, actually, he was important.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. Um sometimes you might find this funny. Sometimes in the internal conception, maybe this is giving away too much of the game. As in our minds, sometimes we like to think of ourselves our closest historical and analogs, or maybe like Bordiga before the comment turn in Plekunov, and we're just waiting for Graham cheese and Lenins to come along and get rid of us. But but that phase needs to be fulfilled, right? And to me, it seems like a lot of the current Leninist, the current communist left is much more interested in you know developing theories of the world, which is fair, and you know, doing various organizing work, which is also fair, but there's an entire gap here, right?

SPEAKER_01And fortunately, the gap is the political gap, right? It's the gap where millions of people are paying attention to right now, where unfortunately, of course, they are compromised, but elections are figuring as a place where millions of people are re-rethinking their relationship to socialism in American society. And it's just deeply worrying to me that the communists are not who historically are the ones on the left who you know understand the importance of these kinds of moments and these kinds of massive strategies, are the ones docking from it, right?

SPEAKER_01And of um hiding almost, it feels like, and being like, no, we don't want to do that. That's not that's not this, that's not that. And these sort of like forecasts of like the DSA will take power and they'll betray us, right? AOC will take power and betray us. I that all, I think, let's say, like, I think that all is very possibly true. But the question is, you know, what's our relative position and what do we do about it? And the current approach to me doesn't seem to be saying, like, you know, we know they're going to do X, Y, Z. Let's not do anything about it, right? Let's not, let's not get involved.

SPEAKER_01Let's not try to, you know, win our own contingency or contingent. Let's not try to, you know, make our mark, leave our quote unquote imprint on the democratic revolution, as Stunman might say. And I think that's really where I find that we differ ultimately in our Leninism and we differ ultimately in our anti-economism. So I don't think I don't think a formal anti-economism, where we we do economism, but we also do with a you know a better flyer than the people around us is a real economist, is a real anti-economism. I think it's just another form. And I think that I go as far as to say that like, you know, geese is economist, right?

SPEAKER_01If we understand it as like a historical tendency, as a historical era. And I think maybe that's really what what where we break from a lot of these other formations so that we're, you know, it's almost like we're ready to eat the sins, so to speak, right? We'll do electoralism, we'll we'll we'll do, you know, we'll we'll we'll push communism in these spaces. And if that makes us like, you know, like unprincipled, then so be it, right? Someone has to do it so that we can get move forward. And if if they're not going to do it, you know, these random people are stuck doing it, i.e.

SPEAKER_01us.

C. Derick VarnBut this actually gives brings me to a couple a couple of interesting things that maybe I think confuse people about, you know, like mine and Daniel's position. One of the things we were talking about with with populism, it's actually funny because in the book we say it was dying, and I actually, in a footnote, in the drafting of the book, and I was like, I'm not so sure this will ever completely go away, guys. Like, I actually said that. I was just like, I'm like, because in some ways I would admit to being a retroactively economistic thinker, meaning that when I go to look about why things happen, I look at larger economic scales, but I do not use them to predict the future, and that confuses people.

C. Derick VarnI mean, one thing I would say is like like I think, like, for example, Cordelia and I went with uh who you know about four years ago, I had a long conversation about this, where I talked about my relationship with the Marxist humanist organization initiative, not organization, there's so many damn post-trotsky orgs, and I was initially a kind of climaite, although not completely. There's elements of Climanite that I always rejected. But my worries about like, for example, value form theory and value theory, which were this big debates in the the late aughts, early aught teens, and the Marxist left.

C. Derick VarnI think partly because there was nothing else for us to do really before Occupy happened. We're just sort of like, well, people care about Marxism again, but like we don't have orgs in like 80% of the country, so I guess we can do theoretical debates. That'd that you know, we were honestly, I think a lot of us thought we were biting our time. And anyway, the point was like there were these thinkers, you know, around the the TSSI and like the chafferinism and you know uh the the issue around the transformation problem.

C. Derick VarnAnd I remember talking to Kidilia about this and going, you know, well, even when I was involved in that, it always struck me like why do we care not about getting the theoretical right once we're in charge, right? But it seems like we are so concerned about being being perfectly correct theoretically, about something that I cannot even tell if it has political implications that we will probably start siding with the status quo.

C. Derick VarnAnd you know, in my experience, that is what the Marxist Humanist Initiative really did. They were they ended up being so afraid of Trumpism and so afraid of uh bad economics coming out of Bernie Sanders that they supported uh the center of the Democratic Party actively.

SPEAKER_02Right.

C. Derick VarnAnd I'll be honestly, if you know the the history of the of the CPUSA and the and the 90s and all, I was not in it, so I can't speak and from it from an internal experience, but there is a similar trend. I mean, I remember reading an article by the by one of CPUSA leader uh in like 2015 that said Bernie Sanders was an ultra-leftist and like laughing.

SPEAKER_01But maybe this is go ahead. No, I just can agree. I think that uh actually I'll start here. I think it's funny that you say that you think populism is is nearing its close, is how I put it. Because I do agree. Recently, I don't think you've read I published uh the series towards active revolution uh this week that I think you'd enjoy a lot. But I I I agree that the era of populism, quote unquote, is kind of ending. And even here we could sort of use a Marxist method and say, why is it ending?

SPEAKER_01You see that really it's ending because it was started by a faction, right? Primarily the MAGA Republicans, and now it's being universalized, right? And one thing I really try to emphasize is that populism can only be a certain period, it goes it must end at some point because it's a specific reaction to another period, to neoliberalism slash technocracy and the sort of various affects of that era. And I think when you look at it that way, what you're saying to me seemed very true. And something I'd agree with 100%, because a lot of these current Marxist forces are almost like legal Marxism, you know, in the Leninist sense, where they sort of become a sub-branch of liberalism and a sub-branch of technocracy.

SPEAKER_01So, like as a sub-branch of technocracy, you're right, you have a very definite philosophical standpoint. And that's like what we like to call the position of contemplation, right? And that position is what is correct? You know, what is the intern, again, what's the internally self-consistent theory, right? What is value in the proper sense? And that those are the same questions that the Democratic Party is asking. What is the correct policy? What is the correct way to understand the economy, right? But we know that, right, as Marx has said, it's a critique of political economy, which is something the value form people like to say too.

SPEAKER_01It's not political economy. It's something that goes beyond the scope of political economy. And what populism is to me, is this sort of like return of the political. It's the disruption of this technocratic, policy-oriented like objectivism, and this return to the understanding that politics is a necessary political, that there are sides, that there are arguments, and that that there's no such thing as the objective, correct economic understanding. There's the understanding that has the majority or whatever politically relevant or salient category on its side, right? And that that may sound opportunistic, but one thing we also like to emphasize is what something Lenin calls stick bending, right?

SPEAKER_01Which is that unfortunately we're not smart enough to have the full answer. So we can only make the best relative answer. And I think in this case, you know, this is what it is, is that there is a return of the political and we're we're stuck in the technocratic uh standpoint. And it sort of applies also like party debate, right? One thing, I don't know if you read Leninism in the age of populism, but this is kind of a similar theme where it's like are so many of us are theorizing like what's the most efficient party form or what's the most correct party form, right? What's the party form where all the people can most effectively uh exist and structure and build together?

SPEAKER_01And that obviously has utility, but it only has utility if we understand that that party will never exist, right? That that perfect organization will never exist. And that sort of these technocratic solutions are only like pointers, maybe like directions. They're tools for political actors to use.

C. Derick VarnYeah, this is actually interesting because this gets into like something that I do here. Like I will go through forms of uh organization on my solo shows and pointing out like where they succeed, where they fail. And people will take this as me endorsing or not endorsing a formal organization, like tenant unions, because I'll be like, they have tenant unions have really low bar entry, and that's actually good. And you can get into social reproduction issues, and that's good, but it's totally dependent on the law and pretending that it's not as delusional, and like the landlord can still valorize the value of the property in ways that a producer can't, and people will take that as me saying that, like, oh, you don't need to do tenions union.

C. Derick VarnI'm like, no, no, no, no, no. Like, that's not what I'm saying. I am saying you need to just account for what we know the structural limits are, right? Because none of us right now know, particularly in America, in the United States, how exactly to build a socialist party that doesn't just become another fucking sect, right? Because, and I say that because, and you know, I I I would sometimes push back on my friend Donald Tuckinson about this because he talked about what Lenin tells us and we can do this.

C. Derick VarnAnd I'm like, but Donald, the entire United Front and Popular Front strategies are based off of a parliamentary system that we don't have, right? And so I know you you know their answer is we need to overthrow the constitution, and my answer is how the fuck are you going to do that?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, putting the cart before the horse, right? You know, the constitution is the terrain, it's not it's not something that we have to get rid of to get to the true terrain of struggle, is where I would agree with you there. You know, I think like the American political system has a lot of remarkable qualities that are actually very much very useful for us, right? Like the sort of non-parliamentary system means that elections are very high moments of politicization. They almost become existential, right? And that's led, for example, with Bernie in 2016. That quality of American elections has led people like him to make much more of a dent in creating socialists and creating activists because politics are treated existentially here in a way that, you know, of course, to a more limited extent they are, but to extent I don't think they are in parliamentary systems.

SPEAKER_01And I think Lenin would say that's great. Like we should analyze what the system here is, right? And what the terrain here is and operate on that terrain instead of you know operating on the assumption that we can create the terrain we want and then do the struggle on that terrain. Right.

C. Derick VarnWell, it's not it's not even just groups like Mug that do this. Like I I remember, you know, the big thing out of Jacobin for years was like we need to abolish the Senate. And I was like, well, how are you gonna do that without first taking the Senate? Like that requires a constitutional amendment that's massive, and you would have to take over 40 states to have done that. So if that's your limit to power, like we're gonna lose.

SPEAKER_01Right, you're conceptualizing it wrong, exactly.

C. Derick VarnRight. Well, and it also seems like when you do that, what you're actually saying is you're making a preemptive excuse for not doing anything. Yeah, I agree. Uh and that's the one thing that has got me. Like when we talked about you mentioned the DSA left, like, oh, we need to discipline electeds, and I was like, you know what, sure, we do. But also, I want to put, I want to, I actually on a show did this whole thing that I haven't actually seen a lot of people who who like listen to me really pick up.

C. Derick VarnBut I was like, the the other thing you have to deal with though is like the way you guys talk about this, the electeds are just you know something that you have to hold to a line. We don't a the DSA does not have a very strong program, so you need that. And I I get the the I get the point of that. You guys talk about it being a non-ideological program, in which case I agree with you, but then like the way you kind of also insist on things, it seems like ideological lines.

C. Derick VarnBut also, I mean, my point was it's like you also can't protect elected. So if all you're going to do is punish them and never protect them, if you just think about this in a simple game theoretical way, like there should be a tit for tat relation, right? Like with it with an individual and getting your stuff done. And if your I idea is like, oh, we can punish you for not doing what we want, but I'm like, but can you protect them? Right. And the answer is no, right?

C. Derick VarnThen A, you can't punish them anyway, but B, why what's the incentive for them to play the game with you if you're not also trying to protect them?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, and frankly, I think this is a great example of like this sort of like very negative mental model that the DSA left has, where it's like, I don't even want to be asking the question of how do I control X or Y elected, right? Because we know for structural reasons that the average elected is going to be to the right of the average DSA member, to the left of the average American, right? And that they're going to, you know, this is this is because they represent a large amount of Americans who are not DSA members. So my question in this kind of scenario is not, and I and it kind of boggles me too many, and maybe maybe maybe it's because we're a little we we have to have a longer experience in this act.

SPEAKER_01But the question to me is like, what do we do to take advantage of this, right? It's like, what is what does AOC or any elected do for us, right? Where if we posture ourselves correctly, if we employ the correct tactics, communism can gain some sort of advancement, right? And it feels like it's in lieu of that question, we're asking how do we make these electeds better? And I think that's a very, I guess, fair question, but it's not it's not my focus, I guess. My focus is not on how to improve the electeds we have. A lot a lot of whom I think are, as you're saying, exist in a game theoretical sense, right?

SPEAKER_01They're not really good or bad. They're just sort of you know parts of the structure and much more, much more concerned about what happens in 10 years. Like where's the left? Where is the communists? Where is our relative influence over the movement? Where is our relative do we have any even anyone in Congress that can genuinely represent our views? And to me, to see something like AOC or this larger socialist movement and not see that as an opportunity to ask these questions and instead use that as an opportunity to say that no, this is wrong, right? It just seems to be like not having your eye on the ball, I guess, in some way.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, I want to get to No, not really.

C. Derick VarnI mean, it is and it isn't. I mean, one of the things that I've actually said a lot is like, even if you're an electoralist, which I am, some degree you have to stand a little bit at a remove of uh of the elections and stuff that you are participating in. Because both legally and structurally, there is no way in the United States at current to hard maintain a ballot line because of state primary laws, because of the kinds of recall laws that exist, because no matter who you are, even if you were a more standard Democrat or Republican, no caucus really has the ability to completely even all they can really do is deny you appointments to committees.

C. Derick VarnAnd I have been thinking about this, you know, in a in a parallel way, actually. And it's I think it's it's interesting. You know, one of the things I first said about geese is like, well, of all the people I've ever heard promote a popular front, you guys are the only people I know who are completely honest about how like that actually necessitates eventual internal inviting. And that made me like, well, at least they're being honest about it because it's true, right?

SPEAKER_01Well, what I was gonna say about the Labor Party. If he says stay until it's impossible to stay any longer, and you know, that's what I said too. I said this to DRG recently, too. It's like, uh forget the dirty break, clean break. I want them to kick me out of the Democrat Party, you know, kicking and screaming where I get everyone can see me. I think that's the best outcome. What's a calling everything that happens? Sorry, keep going.

C. Derick VarnNo, no, but this is actually good because I have actually people have been surprised that I am that I was like, I am a long clean breakist, and people are like, What that just and I'm like, you don't have the infrastructure right now. But in some ways, I have also been like the dirty break has always struck me as one of the dumbest ideas, and the reason why isn't because the break is the problem, it's because you're announcing to the world that you're gonna betray the people you're currently in alliance with years and years and years and years before you have the capacity to do that betrayal, and then act surprised when they treat you as a hostile faction.

C. Derick VarnOne of the things that I've also appreciated about geese, and I I I I I don't say this to blow smoke up your ass because I don't really care about that, but like I love it when people blow smoke up nose, kink is that I have found what you guys do to be a little bit more honest than what we see out of like Jacobin or uh bread and roses, where like there is some there is a way in which support starts to be equated with we need to make excuses for, and I actually don't see you guys doing that.

C. Derick VarnAnd one of the things, you know, I and I have some, you know, I have some critiques of like uh of some things about Mamdani, I've had critiques about the way the DSA has handled certain things. I'm I'm not I don't want to remove that, right? But the the key point for me is uh how do we start. Thinking about pushing for these policies and whatnot while admitting that we even when it comes to policies, let's be quite frank, we don't actually know all that we need to do.

C. Derick VarnYou know, I I believe in socialized medicine just like the next one, but I also know in the United States it actually is a different project than in countries that did it 60 years ago, because there were you aren't you aren't having to deal with the cost of taking down prior infrastructure, which we will have to do, and then dealing with the employment implications of that, which means that trying to fully and that is not a reason not to do it. I want to be very clear, but it means it means that when we talk about this stuff, we have to maintain that we're not gonna know exactly what we need to do as a policy.

C. Derick VarnAnd I've also pointed out liberals, conservatives, even fascists, don't have this problem. They know that they don't know all that. They're given to you, right?

unknownYeah.

SPEAKER_01Well, well, I think what you said is very interesting about Jacobin and B and R because I think this actually does get us something important, which is that I don't think that we're honest and they're dishonest. And I don't I don't think that Jacobin is a dishonest version and we're an honest version, but I think we do it actually at fundamentally different theories of change, right? Like I think that they there's this attitude that we can form the political party and we can form, for example, the policy understanding that we need to form like on our own somehow, right?

SPEAKER_01But I I I have this feeling that I I don't think that's the path. I think that we have to be a very public and we have to be a very real political pole in American society. And the moment that there's like a million Americans or whatever who are socialists, who are communists, right? I I just have much more faith in one million people, some you know, some subset of those people being the intelligentsia, some subset of that being the staff of the party, so on and so forth. I have a feeling that they're going to be able to figure out a lot more about American capitalism and the tactics of socialism than any sort of like small group of a hundred or one thousand or ten thousand people who, you know, is a very, I think a very optimistic uh portrayal of communism in the United States, like serious communism versus just people who call themselves that.

SPEAKER_01So to me, these these formations aren't fighting for that, right? They're not fighting for a communist poll. So I just don't see I obviously there's overlap, and there's tactical overlap, and there's maybe in some cases ideological overlap, but there's no strategic overlap, in my view. Like they they to me, AOC 28 is an opportunity for us to become a real pole in American society, independent from the sort of like inevitable social democratizing that AOC will do. And because necessarily inevitable, right?

SPEAKER_01But also not just being once again thrown into the complete margins of society while the liberals and republicans hash it out with each other, this time with maybe a more social democratic flair. Like we need to have our own faction, we need to have our own poll. And to me, that's everything, right? And I I don't know if it feels like many of these formations you're talking about are fighting for that.

C. Derick VarnYeah, well, uh, I I was thinking about this in terms of you know your article on reading Grab Shannon on Economism, political method, and urban urbanism. And I'm gonna link all the articles we mentioned today uh in the show notes. But uh when you think about like the Jacobin concerns, it does tend to be a thin doctrine of interest, it tends to hyperfocus on either immediate workplace demands or immediate policy demands, and and it's not that these aren't vital, but it can lead to like fundamental mistakes.

C. Derick VarnI was thinking about this debate, debate, and that's in quotation marks, between Brianna Joy Gray and Dan DeVere, Dan DeVere. And so bad faith in the dig. And uh unfortunately, I actually you're gonna be surprised. I read left-wing period articles, I actually kind of avoid left-wing podcasts and media, even though I show on them all the time, and people are often surprised by that. But I'm like, well, so much of this ends up being personality-driven, like gook and like grievance mongering and this, that, and the other, which can get a lot of views, but it I think it's like deleterious to having a clear line if you get too involved in it.

C. Derick VarnBut I did think I did find it interesting watching Brianna Doragray and Dan and Dan DeVere argue because Brianna Doragre was treating a tactic, the force to vote, as a principle. And Dan DeVere was treating a strategy as a principle. And I was very I was very much like, okay, so from my perspective, these are both errors.

C. Derick VarnOne of them is a bigger error than the other, actually, but but they are both errors. Because the the base building stuff that like De Vere wants to do is is pretty sound. The what what Brianna Droid Gray wants to do has a very media focused view of politics. That if you just pulled the right, frankly, political stunt, consciousness would would then swoop out of that stunt upon upon the the rest of the of the the population, and it would be clear that the you know the center democratic party are hacks.

C. Derick VarnAnd and what I find funny is I'm like, Gray, if you actually look at like fundraising, statistics, whatever, that happened anyway. Most people do feel. I mean, like most most, not just most communist, like go on and listen to the average progressive on TikTok or Instagram. They also think that the Democratic Party is a bunch of centrists. Yeah, every Democrat thinks this.

SPEAKER_01That's why they call it in political science, they call it negative partisanship. Everyone today, you know, almost everyone today votes because they hate the other party more than they hate their own party, not because they actually like their own party.

C. Derick VarnRight. And and I'm just like, you know, negative partisanship, the anti-political moment, and I'm like, well, that that is something that you can use. The the issue is how do you build a positive politics out of that? And it and the other thing is like it's already happening, it doesn't lead to what you think. So how do you build how do you build those cadres? And I I do like I did I do like that about what geese is doing, because when you you guys talk about AOC, you're not talking about AOC as as going to be the person who single-handedly delivers a socialism, which which I find maddening when it happens.

SPEAKER_01I remember I think you'll find this interesting. Like, what is the sort of you know, I think that what's very likely to happen if we have a sort of let's say things go the way they quote unquote should, where AOC wins, we have a sort of tame DSA slash like uh left progressive electoral wing and Congress, right? Is that the Democrat Party will social democratize. I'm sure we'll get a lot of good reforms, but we're not going to do socialism. And probably, you know, a lot of the critics, right, the ultraless, will say who say this will result in demobilization, right?

SPEAKER_01This will result in a new consensus, which a lot of them aren't even saying, but which they should be saying. And uh it's true. I think it's very true. I think what frustrates me is that like if we know this is true, what are we doing about it? Right. And I think that's that's kind of the equal where I feel like I break with the Brianna Joy Grey types, right? Is that we have to see what's happening. And exactly as you're saying, the phenomenon you're describing of this sort of loss of faith in the Democratic Party has happened. And it's largely happened through the methods of the DSA, if not exclusively by the DSA, that is, by radicals running in democratic primaries and very publicly and directly contesting democratic establishment leaders.

SPEAKER_01But we also know historically that the end result of this process is usually co-option and a shift in the politics of the Democratic Party slash the nation, writ large in a more social democratic direction, right? Before the cycle continues in 20 years. So what are we doing? What are we doing about it? What we seem to be doing is just like maybe, maybe we'll do what we did in every previous historical cycle, which is that the the radicals will split, right? We'll we'll do our own activism, we'll complain that the rightists are not revolutionary enough, and then in 20 years again, uh we'll come back to, you know, restart at the same cycle.

SPEAKER_01Or we take advantage of the moment and disrupt it in some sort of fashion, right? I think that what frustrates me about the left is that like we don't have an optimistic vision of how an AOC presidency or how even this sort of electoral wave will go, but we do have to have a serious vision. We do have to understand that things do happen and we have to react to them, right? We can understand that AOC will not save socialism, but it feels like people stop the analysis there, right? They say AOC will not do this, or she's a rightist, and they're correct, and then they stop talking, right? But the question is that she is a rightist, she is not going to bring us socialism, and what are the tactics appropriate to this moment to ensure that we have the largest possible influence over society, so on and so forth, right?

SPEAKER_01And I think that's the that that that's the frustration here. And I think it's very Leninist, right? Is that always Lenin's sort of like constant methodology, right? He never he never passes historical judgment on anything. He even defends legal Marxism, right? But he defends it on what basis? He doesn't defend it because it's good, and he doesn't criticize it because it's bad. He just he says this is what happened, this is what changed the proletariat, and now this is the opportunities and tactics open to us, right? And AOC running in 28 slash this general DSA electoral success over the last, let's say, 10 years since Bernie Sanders, including the left progressives.

SPEAKER_01This is a historical event, right? This is a change in the structure of American politics, right? It's not socialism, it's not communism, of course it isn't, right? But but these are real historical changes. If AOC runs and wins in 28, that'll be the first time in American history that the United States will have an ideologically socialist president. Does that mean that we will have socialism? Of course not. But that I think very obviously changes the terrain that we're operating on, changes our relation to our tactics, right? And changes our relationship to the working class. And to me, again, these are the questions we should be asking.

C. Derick VarnYeah, and now this is interesting because this is not necessarily an area where you and I disagree, but it is actually something that I want to pull out because I always talk about people will go and they'll talk about how you know postmodernism, whatever the fuck that is. I mean, but by that they usually mean French post-structuralism, destroyed the left, blah blah blah blah blah. And I always point out that, like, well, what to me seems to have happened, honestly, is the French Communist Party could not handle the Sino-Soviet split.

C. Derick VarnIt also didn't know how to position itself to Mitterrand, it got into a sunk cost uh relationship with Mitterrand, and and to me that's the problem more than the initial support of Mitterrand.

SPEAKER_01Like I agree. Uh it became part of the bourgeois ideology, so to speak, of the time.

C. Derick VarnRight. Yeah. Right. And then but then you go, okay, well, they never should have should have, you know, sided with Mitterrand. And then I'm like, well, but what else were they to do? You know, what we saw with people uh with like people like Baudrillard, if you go back and read The Divine Left or or any of it, I actually find it really fascinating to read when he's his where he's honest about like why he left the French Communist Party and what he was frustrated. I'm like, he wanted some big violent rupture that frankly they would lose, right at a pretty high cost of potentially even the life of cadres.

C. Derick VarnIt's like, why would you do that?

SPEAKER_01And even more important than that, like even if it could succeed, why didn't it happen? Right? It didn't happen.

C. Derick VarnSo ergo, you know, we can't act on the basis of things that we wish would have happened, but right, and and then he goes in a completely different theoretical position that goes, you know, from hyper-Marxist to completely anti-Marxist almost. Yeah, you know, and yeah, people will go back and say, Well, he was never a good Marxist, his theory was all over the place, and I'm like, okay, yeah, that's fair enough. But also, as I've told people many times, if you expect us all to have like if my politics involves everyone having varn analysis across the planet, that's never gonna happen.

C. Derick VarnNo, it's terrible.

SPEAKER_01Like, well, and that's how a lot of sex operate, honestly, because it's just like it's like if only people would realize we were correct, you know, if only people would just listen to us, and it's like, yes, that's like if if only people listened to anyone, then we would have perfect harmony, you know, we would have perfect society. Unfortunately, the exact opposite is true, and that's precisely why we have a need for a party, right? That's precisely why we need partisan communists, because if we didn't, you know, if we those things didn't exist, we wouldn't need to do politics at all. We could just proceed to communism happily and merrily.

C. Derick VarnRight. I mean, I I uh I'm actually doing some some lectures for the channel on Plato right now, and I was like, that's literally the answer going all the way back to Plato. If we could just get people to do what we wanted them to do ideologically, we'd have a a just society that we know can't. I mean, Plato even says in the Republic it can't exist, but but we don't need it to exist in the in the world perfectly, we need it to exist in our hearts. And like, funnily enough, I was like, part of that is insane, but part of that's actually somewhat fair.

C. Derick VarnLike the the the part of it is insane, is like we're just gonna convince everyone to do everything, even if we have to like lie and make all kinds of weird, like almost impossible structures, and and what you know, if you've read the Republic, you know what I'm talking about, but like the part about knowing that the maximalist program is not implementable tomorrow is important, and to me, that's always been what separates us from anarchists, at least certain kinds of anarchists and certain kinds of left communists is like you know, I remember arguing with a left communist who really believes that like you don't need any transition, you know, you just need to abolish property tomorrow, and I'm like, okay, a I don't know how you do that, but B, like that's not how anything has worked historically ever.

C. Derick VarnLike, like, to be quite frank, bourgeois politics developed incrementally over 300 to 400 years out of antique ideas and was implemented imperfectly, is still implemented imperfectly. I mean, if like we've talked about, I tell people to go read Arnold Mar and you know, in his work on the ancient the Anshan regime, and be like, we didn't get rid of most of the Anshan regime and most of Europe until like World War II, and in Britain, you still haven't done it.

C. Derick VarnThat's the birthplace of capitalism, and in some ways, the Anshan's regimes have been totally tamed by the by the social realities. Matt McNair makes this argument, and I think that's fair, but they weren't just gotten rid of, right? And also, no one sat down and thought out every element of every part of bourgeois politics ahead of time that just did not happen. And I know that you know, if you go back to Marx, Marx argues that we're kind of the first people that could do that, but even he says we can't like we you can't build the blueprints for the future now, history as you please, right?

C. Derick VarnRight, yeah. And so that got me thinking a lot about this. I want to go back for a second, though. I we've been talking a little bit and get into some actual stuff from the articles, you know. In your uh your piece on Gramsci on the reading Gramsci, you specifically talk about the thin doctrine of interest, you know, forms of Marxism, which I kind of think Jacobin is sometimes guilty of. And in modern organizing, we see a hyper focus on immediate material workplace demands, and we also see, I would say we see a manichan, and this is actually interesting because people think I just think this is true about populists.

C. Derick VarnBut think we have like a manichan view of key figures. One of the one of the issues where you and I were actually on the same side against both elements of the DSA right and the DSA left was the defense of Prince Small of Chris Smalls. Where I was like, you know what? Yeah, Chris Smalls actually probably isn't the greatest leader of a union, but he was a stellar organizer to build it. And while, yes, he has been involved in the trappings of fame, he has used it for something.

C. Derick VarnIs he arrogant? Quite possibly. I don't know him, I have no idea. But but it isn't an all or nothing situation, and his and people were surprised to see you guys defend Smalls while also you know being on the AOC 2028 train. And what I recognized is like this is not about a perfectly consistent politics for you. This is about trying to understand who was good at what and what was actually emerging in the comp in the conflicts and contradictions of the situation.

C. Derick VarnYou know, Smalls is a contradictory character. I think we can say that sincerely and honestly, and still be like, you don't need to throw him under the bus because he's not perfect, and because maybe as a as the leader of a union that it that exists, his his duties are different than as someone building FA union. In fact, I don't know why you would expect that that the same person would actually be good at both. But you know, it's not to say he's necessarily terrible at the job either.

C. Derick VarnI just wanted to like get people to not have this like simple all or nothing view of this figure.

SPEAKER_01And that was a very sorry, go ahead.

C. Derick VarnGo ahead. No, I wanted to get you thought.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, I just want to say that was very it's such an interesting thing too, because it's like, you know, within the rationalist model, the question is posed of why are we fixating on this person at all? Like, what is there to need to take someone who isn't an elected official and out of the United States or the DSA and you know, drag him right a lot, drag him a lot. And and it's you know, it's because obviously this isn't rational. These things are stand-ins for different political tendencies. And I think there's like a sort of mutual DSA left, DSA right, or slash left, slash right, where you know it's sort of mutually necessary that they have this Munichianism because you know they need AOC to be purely bad so that she can be on the other side, or they need Chris Malls to be purely bad so he can be on the other side.

SPEAKER_01When it's simply, you know, from a historical perspective, I think clearly not the case. Right. Like, like one thing I think about is like with with with the Bolsheviks, half the people then were polemicizing it against were other Bolsheviks, right? Bogdanov was another Bolshevik. These these are patterns of thinking and problems that are primarily within our own political understanding that need to be confronted and engaged in. And in this case, you know, there's a common unity. It's almost sometimes I recently said this was somewhat controversial, and it's better.

SPEAKER_01I said like it's almost like derived from cancel culture rather than Marxism per se. And I'm not like a huge like cancel culture is this guy. I just mean like the the the structures of it are very similar, right? Where the the these people who there's no need to create these labels and permanently box them into one or the other instead of understanding them as a historical phenomenon. But it's done because it's part of the culture, it's part of this activist culture, it's part of this sort of team sports, almost Hogwarts Housey kind of approach to politics, where politics is my side, my team, and that's it, right?

SPEAKER_01It's not this larger scientific comprehensive understanding of politics. And Chris Smalls in particular, like he it's very clear to me at least that he was a symbol, right? Much more than it was actually about him as a person. And the reason we defended him is because he was a symbol to us and a symbol to a lot of people we know. And we were involved in various ways in the ALU campaign uh years ago, uh, when we were part of the CPSA, is that he was a symbol for like, you know, a genuine militant black labor organizer, right?

SPEAKER_01Which was something that has not existed for a very long time on the left. Um which something that, you know, like he did something that people said was impossible, that people said was something that literally could not be done. And I think that we should appreciate what he stood for and the ways that he advanced our movement, right? Instead of, I don't know, like it's like it's just like I don't, I don't, we don't litigate each other's arrogance, right? I don't I don't when I go to a local DSA chapter meeting, I'm not going to each person and finding out how arrogant they are or what mean things they've said, and then you know, writing articles about it. We understand that we're comrades, right?

SPEAKER_01And that we're sort of in this fight struggle. And I just think criticism should be political, you know, it shouldn't be the style of criticism that was being livid against us balls.

C. Derick VarnYeah, that was uh it was interesting. I mean, particularly when they got into his aesthetics, and I was like, who the fuck cares? Like Like, I'm a potato man with long hair. I don't necessarily think that has much to do with anything either. But I do think it's interesting, like, to think about this in terms of getting beyond, you know, like why yes, it is important to get a contract, right? But as as I I I I have told people ironically about this economism, is it's actually very bad at getting what it wants, partly because it is very short-termist, but also there I think there's other contradictions there that we can maybe parse out.

C. Derick VarnBut for example, like there was a lot of stuff. I remember I don't know you guys who's positioned this, but Eric Blanc doing a lot of the defenses of the of the Biden NCL NCLB and you know support of Biden in that way. And I was like, I was also very interested in like, well, can we can we talk about not that this exists? I'm not denying that that the NCLB was better under Biden than even under Obama, definitely under Trump.

C. Derick VarnThat's that's that's like very clear. And I also was like, the reason for that actually is generational, it's structural, it's it's Biden's actually more of a Mondale Democrat, but that's something we that we're barely familiar with now because it wasn't the dominant mode of politics for most of our lives, and they've always been about giving do you know giving to both sides of the coalition. That's what the Mondale Democrats kind of do. And instead of defending or condemning Biden about this, are you know why aren't we talking about how we play that in a little bit more honest way?

C. Derick VarnBecause this is a situation where, like, we know he's also gonna give to our enemies. I don't need to defend him to understand his policies, but I also don't need to can to condemn him on those issues either. Like, there are plenty of issues to condemn Biden on, but not like not actually that one. And I I just was I was very frustrated. I mean, I remember Bashkar Sankara going, uh, you know, Biden's the most progressive president since since FDR.

C. Derick VarnAnd I was like, whether it's true or not, I don't think we should be declaring that at the beginning of a of a presidential campaign. I agree.

SPEAKER_01And really, I think this is where like we clash in terms of our political strategy from what we might call broadly DSA right, is where it's like at the time I was very young when the Biden presidency first began, relatively young. So, you know, and and one thing we get a lot with geese is that it's like, who are these guys? They shouldn't talk publicly, you know, they should stop posting, you know, so on and so forth. And it's like, you know, for a very long time that is what we did, you know, we didn't really feel like our views, and I think this is how maybe 95% of people who are currently organizing feel.

SPEAKER_01Like we didn't feel like our views were substantive or meaningful enough to state or argue for. And one of these at the time was like, I felt wanted to push the Communist Party hard and to, you know, criticize and fight it from the left. Like one thing I remember in particular, and maybe, you know, obviously it can be concretized more, and maybe in a different way or a better way, but uh it needed to happen, which is like we push maybe he has to use executive orders to sort of defend trans rights at the time was this particular moment. And the point I want to make is that something like Biden being in power is an opportunity for us to criticize the president of the United States to build our left flank.

SPEAKER_01And something that I think a lot of leftists don't seem to understand is that, like, especially in American culture, like criticism is very normal. Like throughout Biden's presidency, liberals were criticizing him the entire time, Republicans are criticizing him the entire time, right? Both left Democrats and right Democrats were criticizing Biden. But for some reason, there are people who think that we shouldn't be doing that, right? And that's just bizarre to me, is that like we sort of live in a culture where that's that's acceptable and we should take advantage of that. And our failure to build an independent poll from Biden and to make it clearly like to clearly differentiate ourselves from him, I think was a massive, massive, massive reason that the, you know, we as a movement like purely in terms of the status shrank, right?

SPEAKER_01We became less dramatically powerful. Yeah. We became a lot less powerful. And a lot of our you know, even our representatives like AOC, for example, like tarred their reputations by taking this line, by taking this uncritical line. Like to this day, people still like are not willing to forgive AOC for her comments. And while from like a tactical reason, I disagree with that approach, from a tactical approach, AOC also was wrong, right? And obviously, morally she was wrong, so on and so forth. But even leaving aside the moral elements of this orientation, it's just an ineffectual orientation, it's impractical.

SPEAKER_01It just means that you disappear for four years, right? And you get lumped in with the failures of the existing administration. And so to sort of loop back, I guess, maybe to AOC is like the same thing I feel like will happen with AOC. Maybe, maybe AOC will be like uh national zona, and she'll win the hearts and minds of America, and in that case, we'll be in a very good situation, probably. But I think it's much more likely that she doesn't, right? And that there's a lot of opposition to her administration because everyone has opposition to the current administration.

SPEAKER_01And where's that discontent being funneled? The far right has been extremely effective at funneling discontent into its own enemies. And we've been not nearly as effective, despite the fact that we've had a lot of, I think, objective things on our side. And one of the big reasons is because we've sort of taken this, I think, half-in, half-out approach, where we're either the most militant enemies of the state and the Democrats when we're not doing politics, and then when we're in politics, we're the most silent defenders, right?

SPEAKER_01And this sort of like dialectical relationship is mutually necessary again. Activism is something we like to say, is like ultralight activism is dependent on the sort of right reformism and vice versa. They sort of mutually justify each other's failures by pointing at the other one and being like, that one's wrong, ergo, what we're doing is right. But it's clear that like both are dead ends, right? That this whole sort of process is a dead end. And if we don't do something different from 28 on, then we're going to be in, in my opinion, you know, a bad situation.

SPEAKER_01We're going to lose a lot that we could gain and we're going to be punished for for what should be our victory, right? Because this sort of like opening of a left flank would be a sort of historic moment. It would be a place where finally, you know, we can channel discontent not towards the existing sort of liberalism and democratic, uh sorry, conservative structures, not towards like MAGA or Charlie Kirk, but like with our own network, right? With our own sort of ability to cohere to subject. And I'm I feel like I've drifted from the question again, but you know, like no, no, no.

SPEAKER_01Biden should be destructive. Like we failed during the Biden administration. So how did we fail? You know, we can at one level it was a moral failure, but we also have to understand the tactical elements. And this was the tactical element, is that we didn't clearly differentiate ourselves, we didn't form an opposition in within. And I think that was a very bad situation for us.

C. Derick VarnIt's interesting to hear that we actually completely agree about this because that was also like, you know, at the time, you know, and I am I'm realizing way older than you, but um uh because we're like, I was young then, I'm like, I was 40. But anyway, yeah, so it's funny.

SPEAKER_02Yeah.

C. Derick VarnI just had this horrifying realization that when I started podcasting, you were probably like, well, anyway. Um, but that's my personal anxiety, don't worry about it.

SPEAKER_01The well, but I mean, I know, I I kind of talked to this about BRG too a little bit, but you know, one thing is that you guys kind of produced us, you know, it's like unfortunately, uh we're we're we're the product of the last 20 years, whether we like it or not. You know, we have all your flaws in many ways, you know, it's almost not even in the sense of like me, we as in geese, but also you yourself in many ways, the current leftism as it exists in the environment, is like it's historical. I think a lot of people forget that, you know, it's it it really does exist in history. And one reason we forget that is because in the 90s we lost that history, you know, we it was a massive devastation, like the the sort of line of tradition was cut, you know, and and we're rebuilding that and you know, we're part of it.

SPEAKER_01So it's like that's how I think this appeared G2 is like like one of the reasons why I'm so insistent on this idea of public communism, right? Is because when I was growing up, there were very few people who were public communists, right? Who are openly like, I'm a communist, this is what I believe, and I'm gonna talk about it with other people, right? I'm not just going to post the masculine running theory, I'm going to like represent it publicly. And you know, without that, does it geese exist? I don't know, probably not.

C. Derick VarnWhich is actually really important because for during the uh during the the unfortunate period of the first Obama administration, there's a lot of us who were, you know, I was very careful to call myself a Marxian, not even a Marxist, much less a communist. And that was partly out of cowardice, but it's partly because it was not a viable position to actually expound, unless you were in a sect. If you said you were a Marxist, people go, Well, you're not in a Marxist organization.

C. Derick VarnI'm like, Well, there's only like six of them, and and they're not even in my state at the time. Um, they're not very good, and they they yeah, and also they kind of suck. Like, like my options were the CPUSA back when they were basically when everyone made fun of them of just being the radical wing of the Democratic Party, they wasn't even that radical. The DSA before even Bosh Garsankara was involved, so it was 5,000 people mostly who were fans of either Cornell Russ or Barbara Ehrenreich, or Michael Harrington, but even I don't even think Harrington was a big figure by the time that we're talking about.

C. Derick VarnOr it was the ISO, I would have been great to join, or it was the RCP Avakian, uh, and also really only in Chicago and and and the Bay Area, and then I don't know. I mean, the the WWP and the PSL kind of existed, but they were coming into the latter, it was coming into their own at the time, and my experience with them was you know kind of mid, so it was just it was pretty alienating.

C. Derick VarnAnd I agree with you, like I I have actually said as a person who came up in the 90s, like we lost our history, there was a generational gap, because a lot of people think then you left was mostly uh baby boomers. It actually wasn't, it was mostly silent and gin. I used to go to these meetings in the mid-ought, and there would be like five 18-year-olds, and then like five people in their fucking 70s.

SPEAKER_01No, I'd like to have to tell the story of my first CPSA meeting uh before I uh so I was part of the like the re-establishing of ICL and so on. Uh, but in New York, which is like you know, one of the biggest chapters, and apparently at least when I first joined and went to my first club meeting, it was me and four guys who I love all above retirement age, right? And then just me like in my first year of college as an 18 or 19 year old, and me like, you know, what's up?

SPEAKER_01And it it it's it's something we talked about a lot is that like missing generation, you know, or missing generations, I guess, right? This this missing cohort.

C. Derick VarnYep. I mean for example, for the example, in my chapter, I was actually, I can make it like explicitly, that my chapter of the DSA only came into being um in 2017. However, there was a DSA two people here going all the way back to 82, maybe 83, I mean, like since the organization was formed. And today, I still talk this guy, he's still in the DSA, but there's like this one 80-year-old dude with the memory of the organization.

C. Derick VarnThen me in my 40s, who even though I haven't been a member for the past 10 years, has interacted and worked with them for 10 years, and then unfortunately, there's not a lot of institutional memory going back before 2022, and this current there's like maybe four or five people. So often I go in, even though I've only been a member for six months, and like this is what you guys were doing in 2019. Like, you don't know it because we've lost all of our institutional memory multiple times, yeah. But that that big gap from like the late 80s, the end of the new communist movement, until like 2008 is huge.

C. Derick VarnAnd like the number of organizations, I was actually telling someone about this. Uh, when I was becoming a Marxist, what I was actually seeing were organizations that had existed to the some of them almost all the way back to the 19th century, like the the Daniel de Leon party, for example, or some of these Trotsky's parties that you went back to the 50s and 40s, they were dying in front of my eyes. Like, literally, I mean, when I say they were dying, I don't just mean that they were like like slowly becoming less.

C. Derick VarnI mean, literally their membership was so old that they were dying, and nothing nobody was replacing them. Like, so yeah, there was a huge drop of institutional memory. But the other thing I would say is even us, we couldn't get out of the fact that we were the children of the new left, whether we liked it or not. Like, yeah, we were reacting against them, like almost anxiety of influence-wise, like you know, the and you still hear it amongst older millennial left where you'd be like, Oh, the new left fucked everything up if we'd have just like if we'd just like stayed like the CPUSA in I don't know, 1927 or something, we'd have been fine.

C. Derick VarnAnd I'm like, guys, okay, but let's be let's be serious for a minute, right? The new left actually existed for a reason, it wasn't just an ideological deviation. So if you want to not do that, you can't just complain about the ideological deviation. You have to look at why that was a seemingly rational decision to make in from 1955 to 19, I don't know, 72 or whatever, and then try to deal with that.

C. Derick VarnAnd you know, I d I do think that can end up being economistic in analysis, but like you, I I'm not saying that's our destiny, like in fact, I I I was gonna write a book, a different book, about the history of the left in America from like the fall of Henry Wallace to the rebirth of the DSA in 2014, 2015. And I decided not to do it. And the reason why I decided not to do it is when I was writing, it it started to feel like I was accidentally making an argument for an eternal return of just the same things happening over and over again because it does feel that way, right?

C. Derick VarnAnd I was like, Well, this is wrong though. Stuff is changing, yeah, and we have to figure out how it's changing, even if it rhymes, even if even if we're failing, we are gonna fail. Like we fail at most things. Like, uh, and by the way, they're like, Oh, that's the left. Have you ever been on the right? Have you ever like listened to what they say? They fail more than they don't too, as do liberals. That's that's politics. It's life, yeah.

SPEAKER_01I've really enjoyed my recent essay towards active revolution. It has like a sort of extreme, very short and schematic history from about like early nine, like maybe 1922, 24, with the entire premise of being like, and I was thinking there's that great classic quote that Gramscians love from The Leopard, which is like the more things change, the more things stay the same. And I was thinking of you know having it framed out. But it's very true is that exactly what you're saying is that like, of course, everything is the same. Of course we still live under capitalism, of course we live under imperialism, of course we failed.

SPEAKER_01But the only interesting question for someone, you know, for the revolutionary is what things have changed, right? And and again, I think this has been a theme in this whole conversation, is that I think this is a question that is essential to the Marxist method, and one that a lot of Marxists don't want to ask, you know.

C. Derick VarnHmm. So I want to talk about Lenin as an age of populism because I did read it for this. And there's an interesting contradiction here that I find very fascinating to kind of pull out. Uh, there's two. And one is that you know, as you state, and I kind of agree, populism often appears highly spontaneous, it it is very image-driven, and today we might say media-driven.

C. Derick VarnIt's weird to talk about media-driven when you're talking about 19th-century populist, but whatever. And it does have a tendency to focus on charismatic, charismatic individuals and cultural phenomenon rather than durable institutions. But you also point out that like cadre building is was able to utilize this really well. I mean, like, like the the the funny thing is like going back and reading the Misheviks call Lenin a populist, and then hear the way we talk about Leninism today as if it was like the most disciplined super cadre organization, and they were just like shoot and completely.

C. Derick VarnI've actually pointed this out that this is wrong, but like there's like shooting everyone who disagreed with them, and like hyper, and I'm like, I'm not saying they didn't engage in political violence, but it's actually a lot rarer than you think. And and they were managed, they managed to do cadre. In fact, they managed to be in some ways the most successful cadre builders in this situation, right? Compared to the to either faction of the of the SRs or to the Mensheviks, and even a lot of Lenin's enemies, like Martov, respected him and he respected them back.

C. Derick VarnSo, how do you like talk to people about the seeming contradiction of like we're operating in a the end of a populist period? Maybe there's another one emerging. We'll see. Like I said, I kind of think there might be another one emerging, but uh Daniel and I were back and forth on it because I'm like, no, I just think we're I think actually the populism of the uh of the future is just not the populism we're seeing right now.

SPEAKER_01I agree. Take some elements of today's populism, but just like populism today takes elements of past historical formations, but it will be something new.

C. Derick VarnLike what as I said in the response to uh the your your author's review, I was like, well, even we recognize that like populism in the 19th century had a completely different class base than like left populism in Europe did uh you know 10 years ago. So so uh how do you see today being able to like bridge that kind of you know uh and I think this is super important. I I want to like I'll give an example, then I'll turn it back to you.

C. Derick VarnI feel like we failed to bridge the spontaneity of BLM into something more tangible, and because we failed to do that, you got you had the double move of like liberal institutionalists seizing the moment with like D DI initiatives and whatever. I'm not saying those are good or bad, they just were what they were, right? And then when those DI initiatives failed, they were also those same people who set them up, also was able to use them as a scapegoat.

C. Derick VarnAnd I was like, if we had been able to deal with the spontaneous moment and emerge out of it and build cod rates out of it, which you know, in some degree the DSA had actually done in 2014 and 2015. I mean, arguably, the DSA doing that from and the in the three years between occupying the beginning of the burning campaign is the only reason the DSA is the organization we're in today, like because if it hadn't done that, we would have been like, who wants to hang out with like Cornell West fans?

C. Derick VarnI can just go to an NPR meeting and do that. Um, and uh so so how do you see us doing that today? Because one of the things I do like about a lot of you and Geese is you have done organizing, and I know organizing can be a word that we can we do, we like mystify, like like you know, but how do we start to look at that knowing, and I'm gonna also caveat this, that there's no way you or I can have a perfect answer right now. Right, right.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, I mean, I think in a sense, to sort of answer answer the question in your posing of the question when you you you point out correctly that the cadre building projects of the Bolsheviks were much more successful than decomparable factions. I think this really is the ultimate thesis of Lenin's in the age populism and a sort of back and forth I had with many other people in the CPSA back in the day, which is you know, how do you form cadre? Right. And it's very rationalist, it's very commonsensical to say, oh, you build cadre by building cadre. But I just don't think that's true. You know, you build cadre by engaging in political struggle.

SPEAKER_01And in the process, Of political struggle, cadres emerged. They learn concretely, sort of as Lenin puts it, right? They learn from every single unit of oppression, every single individual conflict during demise in the party form the importance of socialism and the ways we actually practice socialism. So I think we reach a situation where cadre, I just don't know what cadre means anymore. Like, does cadre mean like someone who is an organizational intern for one of the existing sects? You know, because that's what it seems to mean. Or is this someone who actually is, you know, leading some struggle, some section of struggle, right?

SPEAKER_01Is this someone who is in their workplace, let's say, for example, and people look at them as a labor leader? I think that's someone who's an example of a literal cadre, of quote-unquote vanguard, as the forefront of the masses, not as the ideologues of the party, right? This is that that type of vanguard. Is someone who, and BLM, I think is a great example because that's something that I think caused us to really, really dig our fields in and try to understand what we were doing a lot better. And one thing that I think has to be really, really emphasized is that we failed to, you know, build the BLM movement into something more sustainable.

SPEAKER_01But that doesn't mean we didn't try. There were a lot of people who tried and who are, you know, attempting to employ the same methods they did then now, right? And who, because of those methods, you know, of course it was co-opted. Of course, the enemy opposes us. But we still, when we identify our errors, can only identify it in our own tactics because our tactics are a response to these objective conditions, right? And during that moment, it wasn't just that we didn't do it, it's that we attempted to, and our strategy was a failure, right? We it didn't result in in this sort of like effective critical growth.

SPEAKER_01And I think it's exactly because of this model of the cadre, right? Is that one example back then I remember a lot of clashing with um not just CPSA people, but a lot of people on the left, period, in DSA and outside of DSA was, for example, the Instagram infographic uh contingent, which I don't know if you've heard of, which is just a very popular thing where it's like, look at all these people, they just want to share Instagram infographics uh on their story and not do anything else. And it's like, this is the exact opposite attitude a political organization has to a very large segment of the population organically producing progressive agitation and propaganda, organically organizing each other and raising each other's consciousness and attempting to advance that.

SPEAKER_01Of course, imperfectly, because again, if it was the correct quote unquote way, then there would be no need for the party and I wouldn't be a Leninist. But that is still what is happening. And the almost universal attitude was dismissive, right? So, so why are why were we not the ones who were producing that propaganda? Just to keep this example going. Why were we not the ones who were making these infographics and being identified as the people who were leading these kinds of things, right? It's because we didn't want to lead it, you know, in some sort of like metapsychological sense. You know, we hadn't we had we had an aversion to it in the sex.

SPEAKER_01At least had sort of fun, like when I was in the sex. We we didn't want to do that because that was quote unquote like there was some element of mass work or mainstreamness or compromise that we identified. And I think one thing that a lot of people miss about us is that we kind of come from the same cloth, you know, like the same Leninism, the same like ultraism. Like I was against elections for a very long time, like even any participation in them um when I was much younger. But we have to face facts, right? The BLM we failed. And we failed in ways that are not necessarily necessary, right?

SPEAKER_01And I think one thing you said earlier, too, about like, for example, the Senate is that people use it as an excuse. I I feel like the same thing holds for a lot of Marxist analysis today. There are a lot of explanations for why we failed, but there are not really any solutions, I guess, if that makes sense. You know, it's like again to use BLM as an example, and our many arguments with people about this movement, you know, we always hear it was co-opted, right? It was the the liberals took it over, you know, so on and so forth.

SPEAKER_01These are all explanations, you know. But but if we're historical actors, you know, we can't stop at explanations. And I think that that that like what have we learned from BLM? I don't know. To me, it feels like we haven't really properly learned the lessons as communists, you know, which is of this sort of mass democratic struggle.

C. Derick VarnBut yeah. Well, this is something I've thought a lot about in regards to the election line issues. So one of the things right now is within the Democratic Party itself, similar to the Republican Party after George W. Bush, actually, there is a throw the bastards out mentality. That can't and the DSA has been, despite its setbacks during the Biden administration, still the most organized faction in most of a American society, even against other progressive things like these super PACs and stuff like the R Revolution or the various agencies.

C. Derick VarnWe we've even been more organized than them in some ways. And and and and as some recent events that I'm not going to go particularly into has illustrated, we've also handled it a little better. But the thing I was thinking about here when it comes to cadres, because there's all this discussion about cadres in the DSA and cadre candidates, and I was literally like, you know, I tend to support member candidates and I tend to be skeptical, I tend to also think but that we should be careful, and maybe more than you guys, but that we should be careful on endorsing.

C. Derick VarnBut that does not mean we oppose these people either. Like, you know, like if there's some you know, milk toast ass progressive in where I'm at in Salt Lake, I'm still gonna be like, I'm not gonna get in his way because unless he's doing something that's actively against my interest. Absolutely not, but I'm in a I'm in a situation where like you see foreclosing of democracy everywhere here because the the the GOP realizes even in deep, deep, deep, deep, deep red Utah, their internal divisions are making them democratically unviable.

C. Derick VarnAnd so, you know, I might, you know, I'm not going out here to endorse just to mention the candidates, Bim Mac Adams or Nay Blue and or any of those guys, uh, and Bit Mac Adams won. But I'm also not here to be like, oh, it's just another progressive all the time, because I'm also looking around and going, I need a state of play to be different. In the in the late aughts, we had an imperfect progressive mayor who actually did a whole lot. And and when we when we came back, he ran again and lost in 2024.

C. Derick VarnAnd I had actually, you know, I got hit up because they're like, oh, he's a white dude. And I'm like, okay, so who cares though? Like, like, is he a white dude who is substantively going to help people of color here in in our town or not? And I am like, are you endorsing him? Like, I'm not endorsing anybody in this election. I'm just asking you, like, is your reason sound? Are you just responding to your last hurt? My other response, I was sitting through a meeting of the DSA.

C. Derick VarnI'm not gonna go into it because I don't betray my comrades, but I will say this a lot of people who were talking took an anti-not an anti-electoral position, but an anti-democratic party position, which in my core, in my heart, I am sympathetic to. Like few people hate the Democrats in the same way I do. However, I was listening to them and thinking, you're responding to betrayals you feel by democratic centrist betrayals, and I'm gonna put that in in in quotation marks, as an activist, and a lot of it during BLM.

C. Derick VarnAnd I I was going, they're acting the way that you should expect them to act, not because it's not even because they're cynical, actually. You're not their only constituency, yeah. No, and I'm just like, I'm like, I'm like, you should treat all these people almost as forces of nature who who you you know you don't you don't expect the rain not to rain.

C. Derick VarnIt can be helpful or hurtful depending on how you you know use uh irrigation, but you bring an umbrella, right? And then whether you breathe the umbrella and you you put the sandbags out, but you know what the rain is probably going to do because of patterns and structures in history. That doesn't mean that there isn't, I'm not so hard of a determinist that I think everything is gonna, you know, is set in stone. I'm just saying that like you should not treat these people, and I've told people about Mam Dani, like like I don't treat Mam Dani as our savior or our enemy at all.

C. Derick VarnHe the it there's a set of incentives, like when people were getting mad when he was doing certain things in New York City, and I was like and in like and I'm like, look, guys, I just like yes, I do think there are some major errors mostly around Tish and a few other things, or like when I was pointing out a lot of Mamdani victories are actually expansions of Bill de Blasio policies, but don't think that's bad. Like, like, like that's not the problem. The problem is like, to me, not so much Mamdani, but the institution around him of people like I will name names, or like Davis Sorota and people like that, who this is an inter-elite fight within the Democratic Party, yeah, and they need to make it seem like there's more of a distinction than there actually is.

C. Derick VarnI'm not even saying we should blame Davis Sorota for that. That like actually makes sense as an inter elite fight in the Democratic Party. That's what you would do. The the issue is we should be smarter than that, and we should know that, and we should be able to adjust and to be somewhat cynical around how we handle not just you know, you know, Bernie Sanders or whatever, our AOC or Mandani, or even things like you know, God forbid Glam Platiner.

C. Derick VarnI'm not, you know, and you you and I it was maybe it was one of the geese people, I think it was you. We were talking about this afterwards with the gloating about Platiner and his downfall from people, and I was like, look, look, there are a thousand red flags with Platner, but there's also reasons why those red flags to a certain point would even have been political benefits. My worry about Platiner was always not even what people think it was, like, oh, he's a secret Nazi. And I was like, I one, I don't believe it, two, I don't care.

C. Derick VarnI mean, I do care if he was an actual secret Nazi, but like the the tattoo bothered me for a different reason than it bothered a lot of other people, and that was because I was like, Can't do we understand that this person has interpersonal discipline because we are turning him into an avatar symbol of you know the blue-collar working class in some ways, even though he's not that right, and can we deal with that appropriately? And do we have a good understanding that isn't totally moralistic about why he would or would not have been popular, despite what seems to be like clearly devastating moral flaws?

C. Derick VarnAnd so I was thinking about that and thinking about like I think the issue is people get so involved in democracy as identification with figures and not democracy as a these are people on a chessboard, they have their own agendas, whatever they are. We can't control those agendas. Like, I don't I don't like even the Bolsheviks could not control every agenda in the Bolshevik Party.

C. Derick VarnAnd in fact, if we're honest, it's probably why the use trying to do that is probably why the use of China was as bloody as it was. So, like I think it's a great example.

SPEAKER_01I just sort of briefly interject, like everything you're saying is like perfect to me. You know, like I 10,000% agree. And with the Bolsheviks too, for forget they didn't try not they didn't try not only do they not try to control anything or whatever, but they didn't try, right? They didn't want to do that. They their entire political strategy was premised on the exact opposite. And there's like a there's like a section in LWC, which I think would be a little funny to do as a comparison, where he talks about Malinovsky, the USSR, oh sorry, the spy in the RSDLP, right?

SPEAKER_01The czaristate spy who came in and was like feeding information and rose to the central committee, the Bolshevik Party. And Lenin is like, everyone is saying, see, the Bolsheviks had these problems because you guys let Malinovsky into the central committee. And I say, What's wrong with that? You know, to get into the central committee, he had to do all this organizing for us, he had to do all this political agitation for us, right? He had to use his connections and actually achieve things for us, and that that's why he was from the central committee. So it actually ended up working out for us in the end. And it's just that kind of similar mindset we have to have, which is exactly what you're saying, which is these are forces of nature.

SPEAKER_01You know, in an ideal world, everyone does what we want them to do. In a non-ideal world, which we are in, we have to act in a way where no matter what the opposition does, we gain some benefit from it, right? Right.

C. Derick VarnYeah, that's actually such a great point because I've also people be like, Oh, the the the Western powers like destroyed the Soviet Union and like there were spies everywhere. And I was like, I my response has been, I mean, this has been true for 20 years for me. Yeah, of course there were fucking spies everywhere. What is wrong with you? Like, like, you have to operate knowing that and knowing that, like, probably probably right now. Like, I have no idea if there are feds in the DSA, but I suspect there probably is. You know what I'm not gonna go do?

C. Derick VarnStart a Fed jacketing campaign, yeah. But because you know what that's gonna go do, we're gonna get a lot of innocent people uh tied up in this when a misredo people are.

SPEAKER_01We just have to know, we won't even end up achieving what we want, yeah, right.

C. Derick VarnRight. So you just kind of have to know that that's gonna happen. Yeah, I wanted to talk a little bit about your article, Communism and Immediate Race, and then we'll start tap wrapping this up.

SPEAKER_02But sounds good.

C. Derick VarnYou mentioned both the utopian and the objectivist readings of kill of killing the real movement, you know. In your view, what does a healthy and active engagement with the idea of the media race nature of our current of the movement towards communism? I'm not gonna say communism because I don't exist yet. Uh and what does that look like for us today? I mean, like, why do you think so many people get hung up? Like, for example, I mean, one of the biggest things is like we're trying to police people's views on geopolitics, like, how do you feel about China or not?

C. Derick VarnAnd in this, that, and the other. And I've always been like, is it totally relevant in all cases? Like, there are times when yes, you don't want like someone who has an anti-Chinese bias on like international communications board. Yes, that matters, but do we have to have a perfect line? Do we even know? I mean, do we even think the Chinese Politburo knows exactly where where where China is developing historically?

C. Derick VarnAnd and the to me, the answer is like no, and also me, I've I've told people before that like I critique China all the time, but I also leave it alone a lot of stuff because it's not relevant to me.

SPEAKER_01And uh I'm not gonna I don't even know what's going on over here, you know.

C. Derick VarnYeah, right, right, exactly. And it's just like it's like why do we have to have this vision of a state as being purely good or purely for communism or purely not? That seems to me to be childish. Yeah. So how do we how do we build up a real movement without you know having organizers really put their pet their pet, frankly, political and emotional hang-ups first?

C. Derick VarnLike, how do you encourage people knowing that they're gonna do that? No, we have to accept that we know that people in some way are going to do that, right? Like that that's uh that that's unavoidable. Like, I'm not asking us to have this perfect cadre where no one like has weird hangups and that but how do we and we have weird hang-ups too? Yeah, no, I definitely do. Um so like you know, even talking about myself, I mean, there are there are times where like we if you talk about the Obama administration more than the Biden administration actually for me, because I was initially an Obama supporter and felt betrayed betrayed um instantly by his his his reliance on Clinton era officials, right?

C. Derick VarnBut then I had then I had to stop and think about it. And this is not a defense of Obama, I think Obama is a thoroughly mediocre president, but I had to stop and think about what would I expect him to do? Like, really, what would I have expected him to do given that he had not had time nor inclination to build up a counter network himself? And let's just be frank here. There's always going to be pressures on a minority political leader to be more conservative than otherwise.

C. Derick VarnIt's not always true. You can look at like Sean Baum in Mexico, it doesn't always go that way, but that is statistically the most likely way it's going to go. So why am I so hurt? I mean, I've still hurt about it, I'm still mad, like deeply, but you know, and it's been like 20 almost and in two years, it's been 20 years, like, like, and and yet, like, I have to, I have to like like part of my self-discipline is not letting that drive the entirety of my politics, and and that's hard for people to do.

C. Derick VarnSo, how would you suggest, you know, as an organizer, as a person writing this theoretically, we start encouraging people to admit they have these kind of hangouts, but then not let them be the thing that defines everything they do. Another example is I've gotten into arguments about with Eric with with Eric Blanc that have been somewhat heated. I have to, but he's still a comrade. At the end of the day, you know, I might want him to be politically defeated in the DSA, but I don't actually, it is it is totally counterproductive to the movement.

SPEAKER_01If I was like, I want Eric Blonc destroyed in every like because you know that's how contingent this stuff is, you know, it's like expulsion is not like it's not like you remove someone from the movement, it's it's a specific relation to a particular org. And ultimately, like in the broad strokes, like what for 1917 to happen, you don't just need Lenin, but you also ultimately do need the Mensheviks, you also do need the SRs, and you also probably need Kerensky, you know, to get to that situation. You you also need to have the lines and the separations, but you know, we're also not going to ever be in a situation where, and this has never has never happened historically, where the Bolsheviks are in charge and making the decisions, and this is how we get revolution.

SPEAKER_01But like to what you're saying, it's it's a great question, and it's hard to answer, really, is what I it's what I feel about it, is because you know, I don't want to give a psychologistical answer necessarily. I don't want to give like a like a sort of finger-wagging answer to where it's like, you know, get you guys have to get over it, you know. And but I don't know, it's a good question.

C. Derick VarnSometimes maybe you do have to get over it though.

SPEAKER_01No, that's true. Go ahead. But one thing like, you know, and one reason why we did, as you mentioned earlier, it seems like we came out of nowhere, is kind of because we did come out of nowhere. We just sort of started writing and then blew up, right? And partly what the lesson to me in this has been is that you know, somewhat this behavior needs to be modeled and actually practiced, right, to some degree for other people to recognize it as something that they want to do too. And it's not really something that we've done a very good job of publicly modeling, you know.

SPEAKER_01So one thing, you know, we try to emphasize is that we love responses and discussion. And, you know, we have our opinions, but we don't believe that our opinions aren't like get in or get out, right? We try to syndicate responses to um our articles and stuff like that, even you know, oppositional ones.

C. Derick VarnAnd the reason we syndicated mine, which was pretty oppositional, actually.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah, yeah. Although it's not up yet. So don't give us credit for it yet. But uh that yeah, that's a good example. It's like I want my reader, quote unquote, whatever that you know means. I don't want him to read my stuff and be like, okay, now I figured out the truth, you know. I want him to read my stuff and be like, okay, this is interesting. This makes me think about things differently, and then you know, read your response and then be like, okay, this is interesting. Now I need to reach a position where I can square both of the analysis, right? Into sort of one larger whole. Again, not in this rationalist model where one theory is correct and the other theory is wrong, but like, and this is very ulmanite, right?

SPEAKER_01It's like, what are the what what what perspective does this article or this sort of approach to populism offer me? Right? What what what potential insight am I able to glean from this theorization versus you know the opposite theorization, right? And I think you know what what should be clear is that in real revolutionary practice, you're going to learn a lot from a lot of places, right? You're going to learn from the Nerodniks, you're going to learn from Cherneshevsky, you're going to learn from Platinov, you're going to learn from the German social democrats, and you're going to come up at the end with your own, you know, your own thing at the end.

SPEAKER_01And some people will be like, that's its own whole new theory. It's called Leninism. But but it's just a historic, it's a of all history, right? A law of all theory is that ultimately we're going to have to be, we're going to all the all the little tendencies that are fighting right now are going to be subled, right? No, none of us are going to win over the other tendency and finally like conquer the truth or something like that. We're all fighting and we're generating problems and generating different understandings for a situation. And just like how that's how science operates too, right? At a certain point there'll be a paradigm shift, right? And then, you know, what do you know?

SPEAKER_01There'll be new factions, they'll be arguing about new things. Just like right now today, we we're closing the end of arguing about clean break, dirty break stuff. Whereas 10 years ago, that was just starting to be a conversation and we were mostly arguing about stuff like value form theory. Right. But these conversations are are are not just, I think we we we we we have this very advanced historical materialist theory, but we don't apply it to ourselves, right? It's like these conversations are structural, right? So it's not just that we are going to want to stop talking about value form theory or something like that in 20 years, but we just won't be able to talk about it anymore.

SPEAKER_01Like structurally our mouths will not be able to do that or whatever that means, right? Maybe we can use the words, but it'll be its own conversation. And how to do that, I'm not sure how to do that, how to how to make people understand that except for saying it over and over and over again. But um one thing I think that we we kind of failed at is is you know saying it over and over again is not is ultimately not like the final solution to convincing people or building the party. But it's it's a pretty important part and it's something that it feels like we've kind of left by the wayside a little bit.

SPEAKER_01Yeah.

C. Derick VarnYeah I I I think this is this is I always tell people when dealing with movements treat even your your internal enemies with a lot of respect unless unless there is a there's an unless here you interpersonally see them acting in complete bat faith.

SPEAKER_02Right.

C. Derick VarnAnd then and then even then that should be about your morality not about the morality of the group and and that is that's hard to ask for people because it is like there is a way in which people tend to identify themselves with the group and like yeah one thing I have said that one of the advantages of being middle age is like I just don't do that at this point but I would have totally and I think it is natural to want to do that when you're like coming up in politics and actually it takes a whole lot of failure um and and wrong judgment and you know going into groups and being like oh wow this is not what I thought it was to be to know like at a certain point you're like well this is what we're dealt with this actually has the leverage this is going to be the way we intervene here and you know on one hand I can get it where like one of the interesting things about both populism and and the and the DSA and I don't I don't actually equate the two despite people accusing me of doing so which I find weird because I'm like if I thought they were the same why would I be in the DSA?

C. Derick VarnI don't know anyway but they both like the DSA in some way is a real material movement that has real material structures. They are highly imperfect for reasons that have to do with charter and laws and all kinds and it's history and all kinds of things but it's the best we got as I as people will will sometimes say when I like critique the DSA for remaining in GO I'm like but it's also remarkably honest as one like it doesn't have to be and my point about that is also like with populism I in my response to you guys I actually made uh I want I wanted to make a crucial concession that like both in the case of the Bolsheviks and in the case of the SPA and the Debsian Socialist Party they are not possible without the victories and failures of populists before them just like when I've always said Marxists are not liberals we we aren't like I I tend to you know get a little bristly at my friend Matt Matt Manus when he talks about liberal socialism.

C. Derick VarnHowever we are dependent on liberalism existing and pushing things out for our ideas to even be thinkable. It you know whether or not you think the values of liberalism are saving or not we come into existence out of the contradictions of those values and out of the historical failures are are you know necessary structural impediments of those values being actually implemented by bourgeois society and its resultant capitalist mode of production.

C. Derick VarnAnd and so we are dependent on that right so I like the like one of the things I remember back in it was more common you know 10 years ago was like we needed to get rid of every trace of liberalism in our thinking and I would be like well then we're just gonna be reactionaries because like they already do that.

SPEAKER_01And also it's impossible you live in a liberal world you live in a yeah with as the meme goes you live in a society um uh I also think this is a great great point that I think we try to emphasize a lot too or I try to emphasize and like I think I partially explained like people will often feel like our positions can be a little bizarre like left and right for example with the Christmas thing. But to me they're perfectly you know consistent and comprehensible from a dialectical perspective.

SPEAKER_01And like what you're saying is like it's like the is like the truth of it. It's like Marxism like we have to apply the theory consistently we know for example that ideologies are formed on the basis of contingent social formations. You know Marxism was produced as one of those ideologies. Under communism we won't have Marxism anymore because Marxism is a revolutionary theory under capitalism. But we also know that any sort of revolutionary or any ideology period developed under capitalism is structurally bourgeoislash capitalist ideology, right?

SPEAKER_01There's no way to really understand Marxism without understanding that Marxism is in some sense like a product of bourgeois society. And the same thing with socialism itself right that's why socialism is an intermediate stage. It's a transitional stage. But to say it's a transitional stage, you have to ask what is it transitioning from right? And whatever is one thing is transitioning from one thing to another thing, it retains qualities and is in reaction to the first thing, right? And there seems to be this sort of like and I do think it's fundamentally anarchistic like in terms of like the historical struggle Marxist struggle against I think this type of attitude which wants to say that like history is actually like a series of of sin almost right that needs to be rejected out of hand and that we we we represent something totally new versus and I think Ramshew puts it out puts it very well that like ultimately the Communist Party's revolution the proletarian revolution will be part of the history of the country right be a part of the history of the people and it will be like internal to the narrative of the history of the people like when we do socialism they're not going to be like there was all this bourgeois society and then finally they got shit together right they're going to say wow you know like there's the civil rights struggles there was the various economic struggles and we kept fighting and we kept fighting and in that ultimately led to socialist revolution in the same way that today we look at like 1776 or reconstruction or you know even the New Deal right and then after those people they'll look back and say wow the socialists didn't go far enough you know the socialist state didn't go far enough and that's fine right this is just how history works.

SPEAKER_01People have to grow up you know it's generational as we were saying earlier. Like um Kierkegaard has this great line where he says every generation has to learn about the world like for the first time on its own right and it's very true. It's like I think this kind of gives us this illusion of not being in history of being able to purely objectively react to history without being part of it. But it's a very dangerous and very incorrect illusion.

C. Derick VarnYeah that's a great place to to start wrapping up I wanted to ask you a little bit as my final question and I think it was ironic actually because I was thinking about this because Daniel and I dedicated our book in some ways to a Sod hater who is someone who I critiqued a lot when he was alive but was an immense immense fan of in a lot of ways I mean you know I'm not an off to sarian so whenever you get on off to Sarian stuff my eyes would kind of glaze over but I did find it interesting and just to to to to talk about this for a second Gramsci for me at coming up in the 1990s you know who used Gramsci right wingers yeah right wingers not even liberals people like oh liberals are cooperating I'm like no the no no no yeah you watch the Heritage Foundation and like Pat Buchanan read Gramsci and like salivate um it's weird and it wasn't just it it wasn't just one faction of the right it was like Heritage Foundation it was also like Paul Godfrey and what was going to become the alt-right it was like it was like across the board and so I was like okay Gramsci is obviously fucked up and then I read the work of Assad hater and viewpoint magazine I was like okay okay I misunderstood Gramsci because the historical moment I came up in and the way he was being used in that historical moment and that there is no way and I'm not you know I'm not saying this as a defense of myself either but you know there was no way at first to approach him without that baggage same with Christopher Lash who I've you know who I've both critiqued but also done stuff with because the way that Lash was used after his death was largely by right wingers he never considered himself a right winger and I wanted to like dig into why that dichotomy was there.

C. Derick VarnDo you see what you guys are doing as related to what viewpoint and Assad hater were doing Gramsci I mean if you don't if you don't know about them that's also perfectly acceptable as an answer but I suspect you do and you know you were taken in a different direction there are some ways in which viewpoint was both hyper leninous and also a little bit you know ultra lefty at the same time but do you see yourselves as like trying to revive Gramsci again or kind of extend this out in any way like like why is he such a key figure to your movement?

C. Derick VarnAnd and I always find it interesting with Hayter because Hayder was an Altissarian who loved Gramsci and if anyone knows anything about what Altisaire was actually concerned about the humanism that Altisaire was attacking was largely justified I'm not saying it was actually what Gramsci believed and Gramsci being used by the by the French Communist Party in the 50s and early 60s. So I wanted to ask you about that if you know what what is driving your use of Gramsci and how do you see him is useful for you guys?

SPEAKER_01Yeah so I think it's kind of maybe this will be independently interesting too so we definitely have people like on the team who read Viewpoint and hater but I I unfortunately didn't didn't really know much. I I heard his name in passing but I unfortunately didn't know much about it until after he passed away and that's when I started reading really digging into him and he really is you know quite an insightful mind and like in particular what struck me as one of my favorites and just kind of a stereotypical answer maybe but you know socialists think is just an incredible piece um or workers think.

SPEAKER_01And to me I think that's a lot of like where we it captured a lot of what we were thinking about like where we our our our sort of break from American you know dogmatic Marxism was that like our feeling that like it very much creates people like they don't think like people you just have to like in maybe the narrow economic interest or Jacob Jacobin sense it's like you know just wave the policy in front of them and they'll turn into ideologues right or in this sort of activist sense as the universe you know you you you create material gains in their personal life whether in the workplace or in through like mutual aid and then they also become ideologues.

SPEAKER_01And I simply don't think that's true. I think you know people think. And if you want someone to another thinking individual worker to believe what you're saying, you have to convince them of it. You can't buy them off. And I think that's something a very important insight where I think a lot of people you know naturally come to Gramsci because of that because Gramsci is trying to say okay you know like let's do politics. Let's not we're not just going to you know follow this model of the rational individual where it's like they can be incentivized by pluses and are disincentivized by minuses. You know we're talking to real living breathing people.

SPEAKER_01And so it's no surprise to me that Gramsci has been sort of like a recurring almost specter in Marxism right is because he's and I think this is somewhat taken in the essay too that you brought up earlier about Gramsci is that like he's almost like the you know being forced into position he was forced to which is writing in prison without access to Marxist text in many cases, without being able to make a direct political intervention. He almost becomes like like I'm having difficulty finding the right word but it's almost like purely methodological right it's almost Marxism in itself.

SPEAKER_01And I think that's very very very fascinating. And I think it shows that there's a lot more depth and complexity to Marxist theory as espoused by Marx and Lenin than as often assumed but to I guess focus on the questions like for Gramsci there was never any sort of even like political polarization moment towards Gramsci. What happened the real origin of geese funnily enough is in the CPO say in the YCL we had a Gramsci reading group and we read it and we were like holy fucking shit what are we doing?

SPEAKER_01Like this is all like we all have our own little famous section some people like the Italian and this was the International Publishers prison notebooks which also has an incredibly um thorough and valuable introduction which is one of the key moments that made me change my opinion on on Bordiga right and understand him as someone that was historically necessary rather than you know before I was just very dismissive because it goes through the history of Gramsci and the PCI early PCI in the 19th 20th century early 20th century. But you know it's like that that's all it was and it was just like when it comes to Gramsci when it comes to laclau move for example it often feels and when it comes to left populism it often feels like we're we're just picking up labels as we go you know we're picking up individuals as we go with LaCloud MOOC like I love unpopular reason.

SPEAKER_01I think a lot of the other stuff is good. Hegeman socialist is very smart even though I disagree with a lot of it but they were never even particularly central to our sort of approach until you know sort of other people begin being like these are the move guys right these are the left populist guys I never I never you know I've never called myself a left populist and I've told people this I like I don't consider myself a left populist I consider myself like maybe like politically a communist without adjectives maybe in tradition slash thinking I'm a Leninist because that's how I grew up so to speak in the movement.

SPEAKER_01But you know I'm not a left populist in the sense of self-describedly but I think partly one thing is just we've been kind of okay with it. You know it's just like who who cares if all these you know people are associated with us if that's what makes people read them that makes people get more interested and invested in them as like real critical thinkers you know so I guess that's maybe a little bit boring answer.

C. Derick VarnBut no as I I'm actually refreshed as an honest answer because you know a lot of us are driven by by reading groups and and fat like I've I've talked to people you know like yeah a lot of my writing deals with you know high theory communization not because like it was super you know I was able to apply it or are or prove that it failed it was because this is what we were reading in 2012 and we tried to apply it both theoretically and not and you know in actual things and in Occupy etc and then you know I I did the way a lot of people naturally move I responded negatively to that then responded I was responding also to being in an organization that I don't like talking about anymore.

C. Derick VarnAnd you know communization was way out of that for me but then I you know I went and like really sat with it really set with Bortega and came to a lot of similar conclusions. People came from the a completely opposite direction and I find that like fascinating because you know I I like I critiqued Bordaga for like being both brilliant I actually will say he's still one of the most weirdly brilliant communists that ever existed even though I think the invariant program's a little bit insane.

C. Derick VarnAnd ultimately organic centralism either looks like technocracy or I don't even know and I don't think anyone else does either like those that go ahead. DSA is actually existing organic central purely voluntary if you if you're with the program you can join us knock it out all up to you no punitive but sorry yeah but that that is the other thing about people miss about organic centralism is like basically Border's arguing we need we need the centralism that Lenin says but we should not do it punitively it's just about agitating for the invariant line until everyone comes to the right conclusion.

SPEAKER_01Whoever's on that on that wave will be part of the organic centralism who's not part of that wave is and that's also the thing is that like it's one thing I really hope to accomplish more than anything else is that we just have a more much more interesting and creative reading of historical marks of them is because organic centralism is like intentionally a very weird concept in this way that we're talking about like this is not an accident we're not subverting Bordiga. It's just that today people want to treat it as something much more simple and much more straightforward and much more definitionally closed than it really is. But no it's fucking weird you know in many cases geese can also be somewhat understood as organic centralist right because we're incredibly open and people getting involved and submitting and so on and so forth.

SPEAKER_01But yeah sorry go on. Yeah no it makes a lot of sense I mean yeah especially if we treat them not as tactics but like historical formations right it's like you can't choose to do democratic centralism because we don't have a party that has an administrative basis you know homogene section of the working class.

C. Derick VarnRight physically impossible to do democratic centralism yeah I actually remember talking but back when there was still the democratic centralist abandoned the DSA left over from the Cold War basically and I was like why does this matter one way or the other we can't do it we can't impose it either like like there's no way to impose it in this organization and also you know that was my way of you know I would agree that people say it was a relic of the Cold War and then I was also like but it doesn't like no one's doing democratic socialism outside of a caucus in this fucking organization.

C. Derick VarnThere's no way but anyway thank you so much for your time people thank you know where they can find your work I'm gonna link the articles we explicitly discussed today in the show notes. I I will want to say I have been fascinated by the responses to the Project 2029 piece out on talking about that. Yeah well maybe maybe I'll have you and somebody else who actually wrote it come back on because one of the things I was thinking about it was everyone just glommed on to your you know the assumption of a coup and I am like look I'm just gonna say like right now I have no idea if a coup is gonna happen pro or con you know in 2028.

C. Derick VarnThe the question that you I think we do have to sincerely consider though is like what are our strategies if it does and not not that it will but if it does because it's not a non-zero chance I mean like there is a non-zero chance of it at this point I I've said this about the other day like people will hear me talking about when people were talking about the civil war in the beginning of the Biden administration I mocked them and then I mentioned it in 2024 I was like I still feel the same way about those predictions that were made however it is not non-zero now I can even tell you the the events that could happen that could lead to it pretty easily yeah even though I'll also tell you it's not likely it's just I could see the possibility now it is not it is not it is not unheard of and so the response to that was like wild to me because everyone's just like well they're assuming there's going to be a coup and I'm like well I don't know that they're assuming that I just think they're like what do we do if there is and they're like well the you know the the armed forces will immediately rebel and I'm like well they'll do that probably no matter what we do so it's also it's also ridiculous because it's like what are we doing here?

SPEAKER_01It's like to me I I was very frustrated by the response and I think it's fine it was fine I think we sort of took the attitude of letting it be what it is because people will digest in their own. But you know you're going to sit here and say abolish the Senate but when AOC is in the presidency and not abolishing the Senate what what are you going to say? You have to have a concrete thing, you know, a concrete point of agitation. Maybe you could point at the specific acts or actions she can take to do those things that you claim that you want to do. And a lot of us felt very much like a lot of people who want to do a lot of very radical things suddenly being very offended at the idea that like there might be a concrete situation where we wouldn't actually be able to pressure or create you know sort of those demands or use them agitationally.

SPEAKER_01And that was very frustrating. You know it's like okay we can abolish the presidency we can abolish the Supreme Court but only if you put it in the program as a vague abstract future thing to do. Don't you dare ever think about actually doing it. And then it was just you know I think it goes back to this whole idea of like what is the left versus the right and just sort of bizarrely like in this document is this document right wing because it sort of focuses on AOC or is the left wing because it demarcates a very clearly like radical and transformational approach to governance that you know demarcates us from the social democrats and demarcates us from the reformists.

SPEAKER_01And you know that I don't think me I don't think I just think ultimately that question doesn't really have an answer. You know there's that great infamous quote right where it's like what's worse left opportunity you know left opportunism or sorry right opportunism or left deviationism and the answer is both are worse. And really it's just because it's true is the question is like some of these are like categories that we're using to construct political disagreements and sometimes I think we mistake them for the thing itself.

C. Derick VarnYeah that's fair enough that's actually a good point. I was just I was just fascinated by the responses because I was like when I shared it I'm like all I said was this is something we should seriously consider and the pushbacks were like bizarre as if I was saying like there will be a coup and then we will counter coup and then we will I'm like whoa whoa whoa okay well there's a lot of people I think who are like a little ideologically committed in certain ways to react in certain ways to certain things I guess to be very diplomatic about it.

C. Derick VarnYeah fair enough well thank you for your time I'll put the links in the articles and I'll be reaching out to you guys soon I you know I I one of the things I also believe is like getting various left factions to talk to each other even if by proxy through things like this because I'm like we have this media universe and we could do it for stupid shit like driven debates or we could actually like have dialogues and figure out where these things where there are agreements and differences that matter are where they don't matter and and uh one is not going to make you as rich as the other but one is more politically important in my mind.

C. Derick VarnSo there we go. So I'll be reaching out to you guys thank you so much.

SPEAKER_02Thank you bye bye

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. The Yellow Vests & The Battle for Democracy with Ida Susser

    Nov 19, 20261 hr 42 minAudio

    In this episode of VarnVlog, C. Derick Varn sits down with Dr. Ida Susser (Distinguished Professor of Anthropology at Hunter College and the CUNY Graduate Center) to explore her open-access book, The Yellow Vests and...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. How History Gets Hijacked By Christian Nationalist Myths with Warren Throckmorton

    Nov 16, 20261 hr 14 minAudio

    In this episode of VarnVlog, C. Derick Varn is joined by author, public researcher, and retired professor of psychology Dr. Warren Throckmorton to discuss his book, The Christian Past That Wasn’t: Debunking the...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Peronism Explained with Brandon Lightly

    Nov 12, 20261 hr 52 minAudio

    In this installment of the National Fronts series on VarnVlog, C. Derick Varn is joined by writing partner Brandon Lightly to deliver a comprehensive historical and materialist deconstruction of Peronism (Justicialism)...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Wired For Authoritarianism with Charles Derber

    Nov 9, 20261 hr 43 minAudio

    In this episode of VarnVlog, C. Derick Varn is joined by veteran sociologist, author, and activist Dr. Charles Derber (Boston College) to discuss his book Wired for Authoritarianism: American Oligarchies and How to...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Anti-Politics Still Explains Politics with Tad Tietze

    Nov 5, 20261 hr 34 minAudio

    In this episode of VarnVlog, C. Derick Varn is joined by psychiatrist, writer, and political commentator Dr. Tad Tietze (co-author of Left Flank) to unpack the evolving dynamics of anti-politics and hyperpolitics across...

    Credit the people on this episode