In today’s episode of Truth Wanted, Objectively Dan and Deconstruction Deacon wrestle with the concept of free will before uncovering their own limitations of free will when it comes to deciding what species to consume over another. Salvatore in LA calls to continue a conversation had with the co-host, and defines free will as the ability for a moral agent to choose. What are your thoughts around the ability not to choose? The caller explains that free will is a mechanism used to explain the problem of evil. Deacon uses his Street Epistemology skills to ask the caller a series of thought provoking questions. What does the process of choice look like in the brain? What factors in life make a person more likely to choose one option over another? In what sense is "will" free? Our choices can’t be truly free if we don’t understand all the conscious and unconscious processes. How is it free will when we are coerced? Chase, calling from the USA, wants to talk about speciesism, discrimination against other beings for not being human. If this is a form of harm reduction, what happens when one species is starving and another is abundantly available for food? If this is maximizing well being, how does this play out when one species consumes another due to dietary and nutritional needs? What happens when it is in the best interest of a spider to continue to live in a house that is occupied by someone who is terrified by spiders? Why do we put some animals in the food category such as pigs, and not other animals like dogs? Thank you for joining us this week! Our back up host, Scott Dickie joins us to close out the show and remind us of the question of the week: What is the worst example of god’s unconditional love? Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/truth-wanted--3195473/support.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Speaker 1Hey, folks, welcome to Truth Wanted, the show where beliefs are examined, assumptions aren't challenged, and claims aren't put to the test. I'm your host, objectively Dan, and get ready to talk to some callers because the show is starting right now, Objectively danagain. Hello everybody, welcome back to another episode of Truth Wanted Again. I am your host, Objectively Dan. This is the live calling show that happens every single week Fridays at seven pm Central Time, when we talk to people about what they believe and why, and if
Speaker 1you'd like to call us to do that very thing, you can do that right now. The number is five to one two two, or you can call it your computer at time dot cc slash call t W And as always, Truth Wanted is a product of the Atheist Community of Austin, a five oh one c three nonprofit organization dedicated to the promotion of atheism, critical thinking, secular humanism, and the separation of religion and government. And every single week, folks always try to have a special guest. This week is no different. I have the Deconstruction Deacon joining me
Speaker 1today aka Adam Adam. Welcome to Truth Wanted.
Speaker 2I am so excited to be here. Thanks for having.
Speaker 1Me, Thanks for coming on to the show, Adam. Adam, you have a very interesting story, and I really just want to just dive right into it. Adam, if you could summarize you know what you're doing on the internet in one sentence, what would it.
Speaker 2Be I like to do street epistemology. I used to be a preacher. I was a professional evangelist for eleven years, a pastor for seven years, and a Bible professor for three years. I spent a lot of time telling people what they should believe, and that didn't really work out for me in the long run. I ended up asking myself more questions about why I believe what I believe, and I found that it is much a much better
Speaker 2use of my time to ask questions about other people's beliefs then tell them what they should believe.
Speaker 3Yeah.
Speaker 1So, you know, if I were to take your resume right there, and I just knew all those facts about you, I would say you were probably somebody that is pretty deep in the paint. In other words, I'd be very surprised that a deconstruction such as yourself, such as your story, you know, wouldn't happened because I think, and this isn't anybody's fault, right, but you know, people get invested into who they are and their identities, and when you're in a role of leadership and in a role of teaching as well and public presenting, I imagine that must have
Speaker 1been really hard to sort of separate all of that and figure out what's going on here. So how does that happen?
Speaker 2Tell me about that, Well, it happens over a long period, Like there's no specific moment I can point to where I go, Oh, there's my deconstruction. But I think it was the earliest steps of it. I'd like to start the timer around seven years before I deconverted, and that is when I was studying Biblical Greek coin a Greek and I ended up studying it, I ended up teaching it at the college. And what this allowed me to do was to separate what the Bible actually said from what I was being told it said, or what I
Speaker 2was even saying it said. So because I could go to the original language, because I could get into the tense voice, mood, all of that, I could be very specific with interpretation. But this also brought me face to face with context. This brought me face to face with history. You know, what did the word sarks? What did the word flesh mean to the people who read this the first time? Where is that idea coming from? How did this develop? And that journey brought me to a greater understanding of how the Bible came together, and it looked
Speaker 2very different than what I had been taught. But to answer your question, it was extremely difficult. You know, if you deconstruct, even if you're not a leader, even if you're not a teacher, if you deconstruct from a religious context, you lose community, You lose at times emotional coping mechanisms, and all sorts of things. So, yeah, it was it was certainly no walk in the park. But thanks to some time and therapy, I was able to get through it and some good supportive friends as well.
Speaker 1Yeah, and you know you laugh at that therapy line, but I'm so glad you point that out because I think that's so important. You know, I say this all the time, but these beliefs that we hold, you can't just wish a genia to take them away from you, right like, you know, they're going to be ingrained into you on levels that you may not even fully realize until you really look at it. I mean, that's what that deconstruction process is about, right for those who don't know when we use that term, because it is kind of a newer term. I've seen it more used in the last ten years than anytime before that. But it's
Speaker 1this idea that you have these beliefs and they're constructed over time, most of it sort of constructed for you, sort of somebody given it to you, and you're sort of breaking that apart and bringing it down. And I know that there are some Christians that call themselves deconstructed Christians, and probably I have more in common with them than I do with other kinds of people. And then there's folks like yourself who kind of say, yeah, I can't even have this whole foundation of Christianity anymore. It's not even viable to stand on, and so you know, you kind of don't have that identity and working on that
Speaker 1is very tough work. So good for you for doing that, because it's it's very very hard.
Speaker 2Thank you. And I think, by the way, no matter who you are, how mentally healthy you are, I think everyone should do therapy.
Speaker 1Absolutely.
Speaker 2The therapist you click with When I was the guy who was like the professor, the Greek language guy, the Bible history guy, I became one of the answer guys, right, like the people that you come to with your obscure Bible questions, and I would work with you to figure it out. But then you know, discovering that you have made so many assumptions, not just because wanted to or anything, but as you mentioned, the way you're raised, the circumstances
Speaker 2you're born in, the people in your life, the leaders that you come across. And when I left, I continued that same sort of preaching mechanism, but I was doing it for atheism, and I was trying to go around deconstructing like I was trying to justify my disbelief, and I found that ultimately to be completely pointless as people would just get upset, people wouldn't listen, they would feel defensive, and then it was just a fight. So being introduced
Speaker 2to Street Epistemology by Anthony, who I learned after Jimmy Junior talking to me, helped set up this show. So that's really cool. I'll just say I really appreciate what this show and others are doing where we encourage these respectful dialogues where we just ask questions where we get to the bottom of these things, because those are the things that are actually going to break people out of these ideas that have not been critically examined before being say,
Speaker 2used to make decisions for other people.
Speaker 1Yeah, I like that you're talking about, you know, this idea that, Yeah, you tried this sort of preaching atheism thing and you realize it's it's a pretty frustrating process and it absolutely is going to be if you choose it, because you know, like you said, these kinds of journeys that people have with their beliefs, they just usually don't change within a day. I mean, I'm not saying it never happens. I'm saying it's pretty freaking rare. It's way more common to have journey such as yourself where it just kind of takes time to break all that down. And obviously I'm a fan of s freet epistemology and
Speaker 1talking people through those beliefs and the methods where street epistemology is great at is examining how those beliefs measure up to reality. Another problem is people in general just don't have a great common language to talk about these beliefs out getting very defensive like you're talking about right. My goal is never to piss people off when I talk about it, and I know yours probably isn't either, right. It's to genuinely help people examine this stuff, and of course not just with Christianity.
Speaker 4Right.
Speaker 1But that's you know, part of the deal there. But going back to your story, because your story is really crazy to me, just because you were not only involved in leadership, you also had that academic background and I'm always fascinated by that because to me, knowing more about the Bible was pretty instrumental in my own deconstruction. Learning how this document was put together was all stuff that I had to learn from academic sources or secondary sources to academic sources. It was very rarely, if ever, the church. Right.
Speaker 1So you sound like that there was that disconnect there for you as well. You talk about you being the Bible guy, Like if you had to guess what was the biggest factors in your own journey, what was like sort of the stuff that came to the tipping point for you?
Speaker 2For me, it was it was a number of things. Like I said, that first distinction between what studying the Bible would inform me of and what say someone behind the pulpit would inform me of. That first distinction allowed me to sort of separate myself from the tradition. Now in the church that I worked for, this was this was a good thing because it's a very very kind of rogue, you know, screw the establishment kind of church. And so that worked. That worked well for a while,
Speaker 2but then I started noticing, Hey, these textbooks that we're giving our students, like this textbook here is saying this, and I don't agree with that because of this, this, this, and I'll give you this evidence. So now what do we do with this? And I had I butted heads at times with the staff when choosing reading materials for my students because I had to be very careful with my job. If I gave them something that wasn't traditional, it would be it would be a big problem. But the biggest factors that separation that I just described, evolution
Speaker 2like natural selection was was a big one because that when I did my MA and everything and I learned about primary sources and proper research methodology, I started going to the scientists and reading them directly. And then I discovered. Hey, these apologists. What they say evolutionists believe, what they say atheists believe isn't actually what they do. And now I've got this dishonesty kind of kicking around, like, hey, what are we doing here?
Speaker 3Yeah?
Speaker 1Because, and not to interrupty, but that's an interesting part of your story that I think we should mention because you were part of the Pentecostal community, which by and large is fairly conservative, right, particularly on things like Young Earth creationism and things like that. Were you a Young Earth creationist as well?
Speaker 2Well? We had. We were gap theorists, so we believed in an old Earth and old universe, but we believed that humanity itself was only six thousand years old, that there was some preademic race, some judgment of Satan, and that led to this chaotic state which then got built up from Of course, the Jewish scholars will tell us stop doing that, but we didn't read them, so no problem.
Speaker 1Awesome. I love that because like in any other context, and this isn't bilil your your upbringing, by the way, but I am just saying that in any other context, that sounds like a conspiracy theory, you know what I mean. That's some shit you would find on four Chan. But you know, like, yeah, that's like that was your church position, which is just you know, it's just what it is. It's interesting.
Speaker 2I had closed door meetings with some of my colleagues and like, hey, let me show you this book by John H. Walton, who is an Old Testament scholar, specifically ancient Near East scholar, and how he presents this scheme in Genesis and shows evidence offical language and stuff like that, what if just hear me out, what if God did evolution? I never made very much headway with them, but these were the things I was wrestling with personally. I was like, Okay,
Speaker 2either my understanding of the Bible is wrong, or my understanding of the science is wrong, or the Bible itself is wrong, or the science you know, or the science itself is wrong. So I had to work through all these issues.
Speaker 1Yeah, and now on the other side of this, what's the label you feel most comfortable calling yourself now or do you have a label for that?
Speaker 2Well, it depends on the context. Really, Like if you give me a conception of God, that is the biblical literalist God, right, the God of the evangelicals, the omni God, I'm an active disbeliever. I will make the positive claim that that God doesn't exist. That's just that's my position. But if you present to me some other concept of God that I haven't weighed, I'm agnostic in terms of like personal practices. There are different definitions for religious, but I don't like saying I'm religious because of the supernatural
Speaker 2connotations that go on there. I do identify as an athiopagan Druid. I have no supernatural beliefs, but I do have a passion for nature, for studying just the way things are, my upbringing probably being the cause of that. But so I'm of the position that if we want to understand how to make things better, then we need to be systems thinkers, and if we want to study
Speaker 2complex systems, the best source for that knowledge is nature. So that is what I spend my time thinking about and pondering on. When I'm not doing stordistemology.
Speaker 1I will mention the Druidic element of your belief there, the contemplation of the systemic parts of nature.
Speaker 2Yes, yeah, that's where the druidry comes in there, And there are simple and meanings and things that I attached to that at various places. I will mention that the last thing, the thing that kind of where I had to declare myself a non believer, where I began to disbelieve actively, was was the Resurrection, because when I was hanging on for dear life to my faith with everything else, I'm like, if the Resurrection is true, I can still work with all this. But if it's not true, or
Speaker 2if I can't be sure it's true, then what's the point, you know? So it was my study into what evidence we did have for the resurrection, which was in my view, scant, and so that was sort of the final straw.
Speaker 1Man. I want to talk man. I was about to go to a question of the week, but I want to talk to you about that actually real quick while we bring that up, because I've been thinking about this very specifically, because you're not the first person to talk about this idea amongst Christians, this idea that it's all about the resurrection, and that's like kind of the most important part of Christianity, and I wonder how true that really is. And I want you to tell me what will you think about this, because you know, I think that's a framing that's often used by apologists like William Lane Craig talks about this idea. A whole bunch of
Speaker 1other people talk about this idea, and I'm wondering if that's just like almost a marketing thing, because I feel like there's so many other claims that also have to be true in order for Christianity to even realistically make sense or have any coherence, right, And my evidence of this is maybe, like, you know, everything that Jesus talks about is almost always in reference to the Old Testament or at least alludes to it in some way, whether it's directly quoting it or doing his own spin on it. And it kind of makes me think, aren't there parts of the Old Testament that have to be true or
Speaker 1at least have to have some sort of legitimacy in order for Christianity to also be true. It's kind of like saying, well, Mormonism can't be true if Christianity isn't true, right, like, because Mormon doesn't kind of relies on Christianity being true. So don't parts of Judaism also have to feature? I don't know, I'm just spitballing here, but are you picking up when I'm putting it down?
Speaker 2I am well. I mean I see this all the time, asking interviewing people's beliefs, where it's like, okay, do you want to examine your denominational beliefs or do you want to examine your God beliefs? And I would prefer to do God because that's foundational, because if we address that, then then that will that will either preserve or collapse the stuff that's built on top of that. And with a New Testament, the way that it interprets the Old Testament, the way that it interprets the Tonock, the innovations it
Speaker 2makes in that process put it in that sort of position where now they have to defend these readings of the to Knock in order for the New Testament to survive. And that's something that apologists have a lot of trouble with. To answer your question before that about like how true is it really that our faith stands d fallows on the resurrection, And I would appeal at the time to First Corinthians fifteen seventeen, wh says, if Christ is not raised, then your faith is futile, it's pointless. We are of
Speaker 2all men most miserable if this isn't true. And so I internalized that of course, because for most of my life I believe that the Bible was the inspired, in errant word of God.
Speaker 1Sure, yeah, okay, yeah, that's fair.
Speaker 2Culture is it? Actually? There are Christians that have more symbolic understandings or more cultural understanding. So I wouldn't make a hard rule that says, if you don't believe in the resurrection, you can't call it yourself a Christian.
Speaker 1Yeah, that's fair because, like you know, I think about, like, oh, what about the genealogy of Jesus, But then I hear people say, like, oh, but that genealogy is also a metaphor, which I don't know how genealogy can be a metaphor exactly, but go off, king, you know, if that's your thing. I don't know.
Speaker 2It gets from the serpent in the garden is not a metaphor?
Speaker 1Yeah, that's like okay? What about like sin?
Speaker 3Right?
Speaker 1What about this idea of original sin? Is that is that real? Is it trans for? I don't know, it's it's very it gets it gets really complicated. I really want to keep this conversation going. I have to interrupt. We got to do our question of the week real quick, and folks just remind you we do have some open lines right now, so please call in, come talk to us, Come talk to deconstruction Deacon. If you're a Christian, maybe you want to challenge his ideas. Or a pagan or a druid and you want to challenge his ideas. I love to see that conversation, honestly, but we want to
Speaker 1talk to you. Doesn't have to be about Christian stuff, of course, but that's kind of what we're talking about today. I want to get Scott on real quick to help us talk about question of the week, because that's what we uhould do with our backup hosts. Maybe if Scott can can join us here in just a saying thing crew, I don't know, maybe not. Maybe they're not right.
Speaker 5There is, hey, Scott, there is no they were.
Speaker 6I think they were just fascinated by Adam's story, just like I am.
Speaker 5It's just like I think we got a show to do here.
Speaker 1Yeah, absolutely, Scott. What was our question last week?
Speaker 6Our question last week was what's the worst lie you were caught in?
Speaker 1Yeah? Okay, and can you tell us our answers?
Speaker 5Absolutely? Absolutely so.
Speaker 6Coming in at number three, frequent contributor Chuck Gatos was The biggest lie I was caught in was saying I do at my wedding. I forgot most of those vows when a cute bridesmaid walked by a dangerous, dangerous thing to admit there, Yeah, what the hell?
Speaker 1Okay, all right, all right, that game. That's that's something.
Speaker 6Okay, if that was a lie, that would be a pretty bad lie, I think.
Speaker 1Yeah, I'd say so, Chuck, you know what, that's fair. He did answer the prompt.
Speaker 5Okay, yeah, all right.
Speaker 6So coming in at number two is our own ironclad alibi. When I was in college, I signed up for several record clubs using fake names to get the free records. I got caught and had to pay off the subscriptions. They will always catch you. They will always catch you, dude.
Speaker 1Scams like pre internet scams, also are just awesome because you could just go to another state or whatever and like nobody, like it just doesn't matter. You can just do anything that's good. That's like like in the wild West when you can move, when you're the new guy in town, it's like everybody's looking at you because you could you could just be a grifter from the next town, right, you know.
Speaker 6Right, And they don't even know that you're willing money from, you know, down Alamo or wherever he was.
Speaker 1Yeh yeah, talking about now it's great anyway. What's our number one?
Speaker 5Our number one?
Speaker 6Our number one answer or response was from Bagel Bites. It was I have been caught in eight inches.
Speaker 1Oh Jesus, Okay, well.
Speaker 5Yeah, that's where we're going, that's where that's where we're taking this.
Speaker 2I get it. I get it.
Speaker 1Guys, Thanks so much for your answers this week. Those are very funny and I really liked all of them. Scott, what is our prompt this week going to be?
Speaker 6So the question for this week and I give it some good thought here is what's the worst example of God's unconditional love? What's the worst example of God's unconditional love?
Speaker 1What's your answer on that? Scott?
Speaker 6You know, I thought really hard about it. I don't I can't find it. Isn't that like the main thing?
Speaker 5Isn't like that? The theme of the whole thing? Right, thou shalt do this or else?
Speaker 2This?
Speaker 6I don't know, but if I had to pick one, I think it would be I think it was from Revelation, the the Goats and the Sheep you know where they had the chasm and the goats are on one side and the sheep are on the other side. That is literally like you're past the point of no return at that point.
Speaker 2Yeah.
Speaker 6So I think that is definitely the worst example of God's unconditional love there.
Speaker 1Yeah, I that's that's a very good one. Adam, what is your answer to this question?
Speaker 2Well, I would say putting a condition and unloving condition on salvation.
Speaker 6Yeah, that goes like straight to the heart with that one.
Speaker 5That was like right in there.
Speaker 1Yeah, that was that was academic for sure. He was like, I did the research on this. This is actually number one here and here's my sources.
Speaker 4Yeah.
Speaker 1I agree, that's that's pretty bad. I was thinking about Abraham and Isaac because it's like, wow, God, God, should you how awesome and faithful? He was going to be, Oh, not you, Isaac. We're talking about Abraham. Okay, you you were you know, you were a byproduct. Anything gonna happen to you, and it doesn't really matter. This story is about Abraham, not you, Okay. So you know that's that's what I always think of that story.
Speaker 5Co star he gets a co star, Yeah, he gets.
Speaker 1A co star role. And you know, anything could happen there. But folks, uh, I want to hear your answers. To leave your best comment below what's the worst example of God's unconditional love? And we will read those answers next week. For now, Scott, thanks so much for for doing the questions.
Speaker 5My pleasure, My pleasure anytime.
Speaker 1Alrighty, and now we're back to the show here, folks, once again, we have open lines. We want to talk to you and have you call us, come talk to us about uh, you know, the stuff we usually talk about on Truth Wanted. Here we were joking. We were joking about whether or not we should talk about Scott Adams. If anybody has a calling about Scott Adams, I will talk about Scott Adams. I don't think I can talk about Scott Adams like unprompted because that's just uncouth. But if somebody else brings it up, you know, I hate that just throwing out ideas. I'm just saying it just hintent,
Speaker 1just intent, you know. I just started out there.
Speaker 2And to anyone who like is thinking of calling like I have made some pretty strong statements about my beliefs and where I come from, but like you call in and want to share your beliefs with us, Like I'm not gonna be laughing at you and don't gonna be making fun of you or anything like that, like I, well, my face might do a thing sometimes.
Speaker 7Yeah, or the ghost of Scott Adams, I guess, but yes, no, I co sign on that we're not here to make fun of people.
Speaker 1Find out, absolutely, find out for sure. I want to go back to you, though, Adam, because you are in your community and from what you describe it, you're going at it pretty hard. You're doing all these things. You're having disagreements with people because you have done your homework and other people have it, and you're making your case. Every time I've heard this story happen, it tends to not go well for the person who's, you know, doing what you're doing. So what happens because there is no
Speaker 1way that you say, hey guys, I'm not a Christian anymore and everything's just fine and dandy, right, liked was their arguments? Was there kicking out of the church. What's your story there?
Speaker 2So it's multifaceted. I will say that like when I arrived at the church, I was sort of like the poster child for their brand of the message of the Cross, because like I grew up poor and traumatized and all that stuff, and when in twenty ten, I was suffering from a lot of depression and no good stuff, and when my beliefs came back into my life a pretty serious way where I considered that my beliefs saved my life.
Speaker 2And I would tell people, if I can't make this work this time, that's it for me. Like if this redemption plan where I just trust in His sacrifice for my life, if I can't hang on to that, then I've got nothing else. So when you say I was going hard, like this was life or death for me, now glad now that I'm out of it, I've re examined my beliefs about non belief and it's a lot better on this side. But so I go from that
Speaker 2and sort of that position of trust, moving up very quickly into the different TV programs and the college and all that. And then I start having some disagreements about things that brought up evolution and the main one, the main one I argued with them on was how they handled mental illness. In the Pentecostal context, emotions are the spirit and so any emotional problems are in the domain of spiritual help, and they were very much opposed to therapy, very much opposed to psychology, very much posed to anything
Speaker 2that works. And so another there's an example of where I throw a jab in guys like yeah there is.
Speaker 1Yeah, well you have a belief, and you have a right to that belief, you know, just like anybody else that's calling in. So yeah, you know, I say, go for it.
Speaker 2Yeah, I appreciate that. So so when I would kind of push back on these ideas, I wrote not it wasn't even a homework assignment or anything. I wrote an eleven page introduction in an academic way, but kind of brought it down from the from the Ivory Tower a little bit and handed it to the head pastor's family, colleagues and all these just like and the title of it was a call for dialogue, which is like, let's get together and talk about this. We can do it
Speaker 2closed doors. We don't have to freak out the people with the hues, we can just we can just talk about this. And their response was to have this conversation on live TV next the head pastor and kind of and it wasn't like a fair conversation style, like I would try to bring something up, but like within about a month of this, some people were swearing mad and like the donations are dropping off, and it was like get this guy out of here sort of.
Speaker 1So let's back up a minute. How is this church on TV? What's this TV element that you're talking about? Here are you on like public access or what are we doing with that?
Speaker 2They have their own dedicated twenty four to seven channel on DirecTV and two thirds of the globe.
Speaker 1And that's that's a channel. And you talked about this before the show with Jimmy Swagger.
Speaker 2Yes, yeah, okay, so this was Jimmy Swagger's network, so he had an extensive global reach in the eighties. In the late eighties, there was a scandal. In the early nineties another one, and that TV audience really dropped off and they were struggling. They sold off all the properties, buildings and stuff like that, and they maintained a core. I say struggling. There are different levels of struggling, yeah, yeah, but there were.
Speaker 1Struggling where it's used to be Yeah, for sure, Yeah, absolutely.
Speaker 2And it was sort of like a comeback story where Jimmy Swaggert and Professor Lauren Larson. Lauren was very close to me where they were talking together and sort of steering. There was some steering of conversation happening. I'm not going to go into too much detail, but they come to this place where it's like, it's all about the cross, and the reason that Jimmy was saying, he was like, the reason that I wasn't able to behave the reason why I wanted to serve God but couldn't kept failing
Speaker 2in the flesh is because my faith wasn't anchored in the correct object, this this sacrifice. So they kind of took this academic step in preaching, like it's all about this, all about this, and then in the process of doing that, there was a rise in popularity of the evangelical movement right around this time, in the late two thousands, and they rose in this popularity. They got on direct TV. I was there in the radio station when we reached our first million dollars to get on the satellite network.
Speaker 2It was just you know, mod pod donations, but it built up over time and I think right now it cost something like five million dollars a month to keep their airtime. And then so it was this big comeback story. Look what the Holy Spirit has done to Jimmy Swagger. This message, this, this success is the seal of approval of the Holy Spirit. And so we're doing the right thing. And it was very exciting.
Speaker 1This is a twenty four hour, twenty four to seven church network that is making at minimum, well around or perhaps we're estimating five million just to keep the lights on every single month. They're getting that from donations directly to the network.
Speaker 2Yes, wow, they get donations to the network. And then he also has his own record label, so he sells music and records music, and his musicians record music as well. His musicians are fantastic.
Speaker 8Wow.
Speaker 1Yeah, I'm sure they've diversified their investment portfolio. I'm sure they have multiple streams of revenue coming in.
Speaker 2We got other other ones as well, but yeah, so yeah, so they had this success. It was very exciting to me because I'm doing this like life or death thing and then I'm sort of riding up with this this comeback story of Jimmy Swagger. So just like emotional highs all the time, it was, you know, fantastic. And then but just in the process of studying, that's when we get into like having these questions and stuff like that. So I was on I was on the morning program called Message of the Cross with Jimmy Swaggerant for about a month or so, just weekly, and it was it was kind of frustrating because when I wasn't on TV
Speaker 2with them, when they had the morning program where I wasn't scheduled to be on it, I would listen on the radio and they would just be like tearing my points apart, but like not in a fair way, and I would just be like yelling at the radio, like what you do it?
Speaker 1They talked about your points when you weren't even there to defend yourself.
Speaker 2Yeah. Yeah, that didn't feel very good. But I was still just like I saw it as I'm not here for you. I'm not here for the church. If God has taught me this thing about treating mental illness with integrity and intelligence and respect, then that's what I'm here for. It was sort of like my mission into like let's deal with this because this is kind of what I have in life. And then they just they were done talking about it. There was no more conversation we had. And then I was like, Okay, God, you know, like
Speaker 2what now sort of thing. But I was already getting pretty deep in my deconstruction at this point as well. I ended up texting Jimmy's grandson Gabriel. Still like them very much. I texted him them like, hey, man, can I come to your office talk to you? He said yeah, and I was like, hey, I'm you know how a couple months ago I said I'm struggling to believe some things like evolution and like all that. He said yeah. I said, well, now I'm struggling to believe any of it at all, and I don't know what to do about it.
Speaker 3Wow.
Speaker 2And he said, well, let me make some calls and we'll see what we can do. Maybe you can finish the semester out, teach it by the book, and give God a chance to restore your faith sort of thing. Twenty minutes later, I got a call in my office and they're like, your classes are canceled. I was like, I'm going to draft my letter of resignation. Thank you.
Speaker 1Wow. Wow, man, that is awful. So they didn't even let you finish teaching now, they didn't even give you a checks for that.
Speaker 2They just kind of let you danger danger. We have a believer in our midst right right.
Speaker 1Yeah, that's I man. I relate to that feeling so much. It's like as soon as you start asking too many questions, Uh oh, get this guy out of here right, like he's not one of us. Wow, that must have been a very complicated time for you. How are you feeling when that happened?
Speaker 2It took me months to feel okay, Like cause when I tell you, not just a life or death, but like I watched Jimmy on t since I was four years old. I had his music's music on and I would just like cry in front of the TV. So like, this was my entire life coming back to this. And I talked about that difficulty I was having in twenty ten, and I interpreted it as the reason I'm struggling with all this depression and stuff is because I'm running from that call, so I better go do that call sort
Speaker 2of thing. So when this ended, I was already having trouble believing the resurrection because the evidence that I thought was there wasn't there. So I was already like, I don't think I believe it. That's why I had the conversation. And then when all this fell apart, it was like all those things I thought God was telling me about this ministry, about my place in it, and all that that was me just trying to cope and survive, you know. So yeah, it took a little while to work through all that.
Speaker 1Yeah, I can imagine that can take a minute to work through all that. And you also mentioned that you know your wife before the show you mentioned also you had a similar sort of deconstruction journey. Of course, I don't want you to speak for her, so I imagined, you know that probably had an element with your family and everything. So yeah, I can I can only imagine what that must be to go through someone who is so deep in the paint. Right, you knew Jimmy Swagger on a first name basis. That is incredible, And then
Speaker 1you walked away from that. But you did it because you couldn't sincerely believe, right? Is that the biggest reason.
Speaker 2Like towards the end of it, where I was still preaching, like I preached a sermon in the main Sanctuary Global TV, and the last sermon I preached, I was already pretty much not believing anything, And that was sort of just like my last effort to sort of channel the Holy Ghost, you know, And teach something, and I had people coming up to me after Jimmy himself, He's like, now we need more preaching like that, Bud. But I was like a little do you know, I'm really struggling here. So I will mention that my wife stopped attending the services
Speaker 2before before most of this happened, with like the months of being on his show for that topic and all that, So she's a lot smarter than I am.
Speaker 1Folks, I know you have we have some callers who are waiting in the queue. I'm asking crew to fix something real quick, and we're gonna get to you in a second, I promise. Okay, we're just trying to fix some stuff on the back here. But I'll be honest, I don't mind waiting making you guys wait, because I'm really enjoying Adam's story here and you know, this conversation, because gosh that I thought I had a hard boy man. I did not have my paycheck on the line when it came to you know, uh, leaving the faith and also just your friends and your community. I mean, gosh,
Speaker 1do you still keep up with a lot of the folks from that time or is it just kind of oh yeah, we used to know this guy. Kind of a situation.
Speaker 2Yeah, it's there are from those days in terms of regular contact. Two really and so like everybody was hands off and like to be fair when I first left, and I was I was sort of like blackmailed to out myself on social media as an atheist. And so I spent all that time like with all those like followers and stuff, demanding answers of like why why are you turning your back on God? Don't you know a fool has said? And you know that sort of stuff.
Speaker 2So I spend a lot of my time kind of just lashing out. And you know, in the personal life, you have all those emotions going and that that came into my conversations. And this is this is where I get into how much I value street of pistemology. But yeah, and therapy.
Speaker 1And therapy, Yeah sometime three pismology can be therapeutic too. You know, I'll say that it has therapeutic benefits. I don't know if I can can I say that medically, Like, I don't know if that's a protected term. It's helpful, it makes you feel better sometimes, I think I'll say that I'll stick with that. I don't know. Good therapy good, Yeah, therap be good. I co sign on that that's great. Gosh yeah and wow, and now you're spending your I'm talking to other people about this, you know, this whole crazy belief thing is obviously like why not, right? I
Speaker 1think we're probably in the same mind here where Even though Christianity isn't part of my life anymore, I still find it quite fascinating and I do enjoy hearing other people talk about their beliefs and why they believe. But what's the motivation for you? Why do you do strid pistemology?
Speaker 2Because the people that are in my life are just as deep in the sauce as I was, and they're not there if I try to approach it with like a debate, like if I try to do a reductio with them or anything like that, Like the second that they feel like they have to defend their beliefs, the psychological ability to consider them and to challenge them, God, it disappears so streetentopology. Pistemology has actually allowed me to resume having conversations with parents, loved ones, and that in
Speaker 2itself has kind of done some relations ship repair. So it's more than just Oh I like productive conversations. That's productive conversations with people I care about. It's opened that door.
Speaker 1Yeah absolutely, I man, so so interesting your story, Adam. I hopefully we can talk about it even more. But what this is a call in show, right, so I should probably talk to some callers now. I think I think we should switch gears and maybe do that. What do you think I think that'd be a good idea. Okay, all right, I think so too. Let's go ahead and get started with that. Before we do, folks, you know, I always have to thank the patron of the week every single week. We're always giving a shout out to the folks who donate through the patreon. Thank you to
Speaker 1everybody that donates to that. But this week's patron of the week is going to be drum roll, please, crew can get that name on the screen. It is Paul Schneider who is the patron of the week this week. Thank you so much, Paul Schneider, and thank you to everybody that donates on the Truth Wanted Patreon. You guys rock. And we are going to get into some calls now. We'll start with somebody who says they're a buddy of yours actually that wants to call in, so we'll get to how about the buddy treatment. Let's do that today.
Speaker 9Huh.
Speaker 1We have Salvator calling in from Louisiana and they should be in here. There we go, Salvator, you are now live on Truth wanted. What's going on? Hello, Salvator, can you hear us? Okay, We're gonna put you back in the screening room again. Like I said, folks having a little bit of technical difficulties. I actually think let's make fun of let's try I wonder if the issue I'm we're having is because of this. I'm going to try
Speaker 1this here, Salvator. Can you hear us? Now?
Speaker 3I can hear y'all.
Speaker 9Can you hear me?
Speaker 1We can hear it? There you go. Okay, Yep, we had some, like I said, some back end issues going on today, but we're on track. Salvator, thanks for calling the show.
Speaker 3Oh, y'all are welcome.
Speaker 9How and yes, I I am a friend of the co host and he I've listened to him to do his treat epistemology, and I've done it with him or been the subject of and he does an amazing job.
Speaker 1Yeah, I believe it. I believe it. So you're a subject. So does that mean are you a Christian? And you've had conversations with him about that?
Speaker 9No, we've had discussions about free will actually, okay?
Speaker 3And does free will exist?
Speaker 1Okay? And that's what you want to talk about today.
Speaker 9Yes, we had a conversation that we did not weren't weren't able to finish on one of his TikTok lives, and I wanted to see if you wanted to, uh to finish that conversation or bring you into it.
Speaker 1Yeah, okay, Well yeah, well let's start with you, salvator. What's your position on free will?
Speaker 3So?
Speaker 9Near first off, I think it needs to be narrowly defined, right, free will? So when I think about free will, I think of a moral action or more I'm sorry, I'm sorry, not an action. It is the ability of a moral agent to choose.
Speaker 1Okay, Yeah, that works it for me. You know, like there's probably more narrow definitions than that, there's less error definitions. Obviously, I work with what I got here, so yeah, I'm okay with that.
Speaker 9And okay, and sometimes the reason why I try to narrow that definition is because this just at base value, free will doesn't really make sense. I mean, you like, you can't freely choose to make a triangle or circle? Right, That one of the classic one of that classic statement. So free will is just is automatically not free and just by the experience of life. And that's kind of where I think that word breaks down in the argument.
Speaker 1Okay, so so free will? Are you a believer then? Yes? Or no?
Speaker 3I'm sorry? Yes, I am? Okay, the narrow comspines is that definition? Yes, sir?
Speaker 1Gotcha? Okay, No, no, nothing I apologize for. Yeah, I just I just want to know. Yeah, okay, so you're a free will defender. How do you feel about the subject atam?
Speaker 2Well, I would I would ask if we kind of took that word free off, because if I heard you correctly, you said your definition of free will is the ability for a moral agent to choose? Correct. Yes, okay, Now, if we took just the word free off and said will, what is what distinction? What difference does that word free make? Like if I say an agent, a moral agent has will, and if I were to define that as the agent has the ability to choose, therefore has a will, what
Speaker 2does the word free do or is there something about will that's that's in itself not free.
Speaker 9Well, I'm not sure that we've so kind of the point I would like to. So it's these choices are always constrained, right, constrained by a bunch off just by the fact of life. Like I am constrained because I am geographically in Baton Rouge, and you know I'm not in New York City. So and from what I've seen, like a lot of this discussion turns on complete freedom, which I don't think is reasonable.
Speaker 1Yeah, here's I'll chime in on this, because here's where I see this discussion usually goes. I'm more interested in this idea of Okay, well, we seem to exist in a material reality, and we seem to be able to explain a lot of the phenomenon that happens in the world through a material lens. I don't think when I look at the Aurora borealis that there's a magic spell being cast, right. I think that there's some sort of phenomenon within nature that through what we call natural laws, which are just descriptions of natural processes, right, that are
Speaker 1happening to produce the Aurora borealis. And so I think when it comes to free will, there is this idea that, well, our free will is actually also just a product of natural forces. And if it's a product of natural forces, how what does control? What does identity? What does choice actually mean? When we're just talking about a natural phenomenon? And that's what perplexes me. I don't have a great answer to that. I don't know, but it does make me question whether free will is a real thing. What
Speaker 1do you think about that?
Speaker 3Give me a second. I'm digesting that.
Speaker 9Absolutely and I so this is why when when I'm in street epistemology terms, I'm eighty percent confident because you're exactly right, like all of our emotions, all of our you know, the things that make me react or make me decide, are these these chemicals in these neurological firings, right.
Speaker 3So all the like exactly as you said.
Speaker 9And this, I think was where Adam and I had part of a discussion. Was so part of you know, uh, part of the discussion of for real, like you said, is like every decision, so you come to decision, you come to a decision point is that truly free as are constrained by all these other factors? And please correct me if I'm wrong, because I'm not quite sure if I remember how I said it. And do you remember this part of that discussion? You you make all these little decisions in it along the way, and those shape
Speaker 9this next decision. So the idea is that this is why you're especially your moral decisions and things that impact the world, like you do the little decisions over time so that the harder decisions become easier.
Speaker 3And that's one.
Speaker 9Way we shape our shape, our decision making process and free will.
Speaker 3Oh and that's right.
Speaker 9The other part of it is a shout out for therapy. You know, as we as our brains fire and our chemicals dump, it gets filtered through the lens of I guess you want to say, will or gets filtered through the lens of our experiences, and therapy is what helps reshape those lens that lens so that when we do come to you know, a really hot button point, you know we all have something or this decision point, it helps us reshape all of those that dopamine or I'm sorry,
Speaker 9help us reshape all those chemicals.
Speaker 3Sorry, guys, I'm a little nervous.
Speaker 9And that is what I think importance of the idea of free will, I'll go there.
Speaker 2I think it might be helpful to to kind of hone in on what we mean by like choose, yeah, because like when when I hear will, right, I think, like I want to do something. Do you believe in free won't like the ability to choose not to choose, the freedom to not choose?
Speaker 1I should say yeah.
Speaker 9I mean I would think that even a non choice is a choice, and it depends on the action. So you know, I guess I would need to give me a real word example, real world example.
Speaker 2Okay, So like let's talk. Let's let's bring this down to the level of like the brand or making a choice. So I am feeling peckish and I want to choose between Burger King and McDonald's. What does it mean for me to make a choice here? How does that process occur? What does that look like? Can you kind of break down maybe what's happening in the brain or what factors might influence which decision I make.
Speaker 9Sorry, I'm pondering for a second, guys, take your time. So I think this is where Sorry, guys, I'm pondering.
Speaker 1That's okay, I'll talk for a second while you're thinking. If you don't mind because I want.
Speaker 3To professional talkers talk for a second.
Speaker 1That's absolutely So you brought up an interesting point which has me feeling I was thinking about this recently, so I'm glad you brought it up. I have a very conflicting idea about free will because for a while, and I still think I am this way, I am a person that I don't think free will in most conventional senses of the word actually exists. But at the same time, because you brought up human psychology and therapy, I actually think it's healthier to think that people do have an ultimate sense of free will and choice. I think there's
Speaker 1evidence that shows that people who feel like they have more choice in their life are happier and are healthier and and you know, live better lives than people who feel like nothing is in their control. Now that now saying what's in your control and what's outside of your control, that's a bit different from free will, right, And I understand there's a conflation there, But there's there's there's like you said, there's ramifications. If we think that there's no free will, there's legal ramifications. What does it mean to punish somebody if if if we truly believe that they don't have a choice, right, So, so lots of implications there,
Speaker 1go ahead, Salvator.
Speaker 3Oh yeah, I got really excited there.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 9So, I think I think even more fascinating than this free will exist or not, because.
Speaker 3I agree with what you said.
Speaker 9It helps if people and and uh have you know, believe if we have that ability right soon. But free will, I think is a basically it's a theological construct or.
Speaker 3I think it's started as that.
Speaker 9To where uh in a way to explain the problem of evil and give God the out, and that concept we smuggled into our legal system, our whole society. Effect capitalism is kind of based on that and this whole idea of the American dreams that you know, if we just make the right choices right, then I don't know why you're at where you're at, you know, And that is really a much more important discussion, I think.
Speaker 1Perhaps so perhaps so. I have a lot more thoughts on this, but I want to bring it back to you, Adam, what are you thinking?
Speaker 2Uh, well, I've got my thoughts on it as well. But I'm trying to dig dig through Salas here because I've heard like there's a conception of free will that I kind of go okay, And it's like the availability of options in that for what you want to do. There's people that like, want to do a certain thing, but due to certain circumstances, restrictions, coercions, they're unable to do what they want to do. So there are f to do something that they don't want to do, and in that sense, their will is not free. So I go, okay.
Speaker 2So I do understand what you're saying there when you say, like, we have more options and so there's more free But when I try to drill down to the level of the brain, I'm interested in, like what a choice looks like, Like if I put you in fMRI machine and tell you to make a choice or present you with options, I want to see what your brain is doing. And then I want to take that pattern of activity and I want to trace it backwards the state, the brain state, the geometrical, synaptic, and gram whatever that is in that moment,
Speaker 2What were the priors that fed that moment, that caused that moment, and then go back and back. I think Robert Sapolski uses the example of like is it turtles all the way down or is there some turtle floating somewhere? And when I'm asking these questions, I'm trying to figure out where people put the turtle. And so you know, when I ask you if I present you with an option McDonald's or Burger King, and I kind of want to get your thoughts sell on, like what the influences, what the factors would be in driving you to one decision versus the other.
Speaker 9Speaking for myself or speaking generally, I mean, it's your choice, personal preference. It could be you know, choices could range from a man one time I got, or you know, the the list of priorities in the decision making tree? Am I answering you correctly? Are you looking for? Like what the physical processes are?
Speaker 2Not so much. I'm not expecting you to break down the neuroscience or anything, but I'm just wondering if you could identify factors in your own life or generally where you be, like that would make you more likely to choose one over the other.
Speaker 9Oh, I mean each situation would have a different set of priorities.
Speaker 3How hungry am I? Which really says the shortest.
Speaker 9Line, which is the easiest to turn into I really want.
Speaker 3To eat some chicken nugats, or I don't want to get a whopper.
Speaker 9That's if that sounds a little flippant, I apologize, No, not.
Speaker 2Flipping at all.
Speaker 1Right, Yeah, you sort of. You have a set of priorities and you and the hierarchy of said priorities. Change is based on circumstances. Yeah, yes, yeah, sure.
Speaker 2And okay, so and then these circumstances, like, let's drill it down on one, like, wait time, what are some factors that would make weight time more important to you that day versus say two days from now.
Speaker 3If I'm on a way to a meeting.
Speaker 2Okay, So if you're on your way to a meeting, you're gonna be like, hey, I don't have time to get in that line. I'm gonna I'm gonna kind of suck it up and get a whopper. Yeah, okay, and then that meeting, and just to kind of communicate to you where I'm getting out by drilling down these factors, we could do this for a long time. The idea is, I don't think we're ever going to get to a turtle that isn't buried in a singularity somewhere, So then that's where I go to the question like and and Dan brought it up a minute ago, where we kind of conflate this like factors we have control over versus
Speaker 2factors we don't have control over that being like where where the free and free will lives? And what I'm trying to get is where where does free live? For you? What does free do to will? And like what does free mean? In what sense? Is will free?
Speaker 3Wondering?
Speaker 1Pondering?
Speaker 2We like pondering around here.
Speaker 1Yeah, we're pondering today. This is a pondering show. You know, I'm not used to that. I'm not usually comfortable with that amount of dead air, but you know, what's work. We're letting it happen today.
Speaker 2You know, it's a pregnant pause a.
Speaker 9Little bit, and I know y'all got to fill fill time, right, that's why people listen. Where does can you restate the question?
Speaker 3Adam?
Speaker 2Yeah? In what sense is will free? What is the word what is the word free doing there?
Speaker 9For you?
Speaker 4So?
Speaker 9Yeah, so even all right, maybe the class the example of you know somebody is, uh, you got to somebody holding a gun to your head and says you must do X. Right, there's in that situation, in that sort of situation you know, there are there are a lot of constraints on your actions because of the consequences, but there's still an ability to make a choice.
Speaker 2Okay, So, if I'm hearing you correctly, you're saying that, oh, I'm sorry, were you no?
Speaker 3Go ahead?
Speaker 2Go ahead, I've got to get better at not stepping on those pauses. Uh. But okay, so you're you're saying, though, then that what what free means there is free means you're not being coerced, You're not being forced to do something that's contrary to what you want to do.
Speaker 9No, like if if your life is being threatened unless you do something that is definitely coercion and and and there's definitely constraints on your actions. But I still think that you can. A person has the ability to make a decision. And that's why I when I kind of think about free will, and the way I think about free will is it's never free. It's it's constrained, and it's not necessarily about action, but about the decision even though you can't act.
Speaker 2Okay, so you're saying that it does, it does. Well, Okay, well let's check. Let's check make sure I'm hearing your correctly.
Speaker 9Yeah, check it out.
Speaker 2Yeah, so you're saying that, like, if you have this this threat of coercion, it's not free you know because it because because you're being coerced, And so are you saying that than any sort of Well, and you also said there's always coercion, but you do believe in free will, so is free will not like an honor off. There's always constrains. Oh okay, so you're making a distinction between coercion and constraints.
Speaker 9And yeah, absolutely no cohercion. Coercion is seed to me. It seems like it is an outside force, like someone exerting their will upon and trying to shape your will. But constraints are just the very fact of being a live toinite person in this world.
Speaker 2Okay, circus, Well that's yeah.
Speaker 1I have thought about that, but I don't know because I don't what do we really have control over. I'll give you an example of this. I'm going to be hungry in the next six hours and that's going to affect my mood. That's going to affect my physiology, right, and I have to I plagate that because I'm alive and I have a biological drive to do that. That's that I didn't choose to have that biological drive, but it's going to affect me either way, and I'm not being coerced. But I also can't do anything about it
Speaker 1either as long as I'm alive, right, unless I got some sort of big continuous tube and me and and and that's just one small example. But the truth is we will probably never know the totality of the human mind and the total total of human existence as long as we live. So how can we say our choices are informed or truly free if we truly don't understand all of the processes, both conscious and unconscious that kind of go on here. I think that's that's one of my biggest problems with free will. And and uh, you
Speaker 1know Adam has been alluding to this, I think, is what where's the free part? Where does that come in? Because it seems like everything that leads up to my decisions all have priors to them, all of them being material.
Speaker 3Okay, I have hold on for a second.
Speaker 9So your example of being hungry, I mean that is the can there's some I'm saying that is that is a constraint right that you have to eat? Now you can shoot you can still choose to not eat, and people have make some choice.
Speaker 1So, but it's coercive too, isn't it. I Mean, it's kind of coercive in nature. It may not be coming from an external agent, but it's still it's still you know it in a way, it's kind of like putting a gun to my head. If I don't eat for three days, right, my body's probably it feels like guns to my head, right, saying hey, you should eat.
Speaker 4I think we do.
Speaker 9I think there's some nuance there to explore, Like, okay, because because in the sense that I'm using the word coercion, I'm thinking of like a let's say, an outside agent like the gangster, right, he's the outside agent trying to coerse my will. And then so that's an outside force. Constraint is you know, again, just the condition of being a finite being in this universe.
Speaker 3So now maybe maybe ooh ooh, maybe maybe there's some maybe there's some common ground that you.
Speaker 9Know, maybe we can consider h oh oh, Hold up, y'all, we consider the physical process is a constraint of free will, and that would kind of fit in with my thinking.
Speaker 1Yeah, yeah, my thinking on this, and I'll bring back to Adam, because I'm not doing straight to pistemology right now. I'm kind of giving my opinions, but it's more just like you know, I don't I don't know if I view those ideas of constraint and coercion is separate. I kind of think every constraint is kind of coercive in a way. I think we're just so used to that as people. We don't fully realize that. But if it's outside of my control and it's coercive, because it's it's gonna make me do things that in other states of mind I may not always do. If I'm on drugs, if I'm on LSD, you know, I may not be
Speaker 1introverting reality the same way as I would if I'm sober, that's going to be coercive to my mental well being. Or if I was just born just a little bit differently, maybe my brain doesn't work the same way as other people. That's just, you know, going to be a difference that I have. But anyway, I'm talking too much, Adam, I'm bringing it back to you.
Speaker 2I love it. I love what you're sharing. This is super fascinating conversation with me. I'm a Sipolski fan, So I love talking about this stuff. So you seem to make this distinction between internal and external. You said, if it's an internal factor, that's a constraint. If it's an external factor, that's coercion. What is it? Where is that boundary between inside and outside? Is like the skin a special boundary or is there some other internal external difference?
Speaker 1And I want to try to wrap this up in the next couple of minutes, just so we can get our other callers a chance to talk as well. Thanks Salvador.
Speaker 3Well yeah, well look, let me let me wrap up with this.
Speaker 9And because Adam, I'm I know that's going to lead down to a rabbit hole. I think though, I think I can find common ground in considering that the physical processes that we talked about, you know, the neurons firing and all that is part of the constraints that I see around that that make the concept of.
Speaker 3Free will work for me. So that's that is something I will ponder on. Yeah, all right.
Speaker 1Cool, there you go. I'm happy with that, Salvad, or anything else you want to leave us with before we let you go today. Thanks so much for Colin.
Speaker 9Yeah, the therapy is cool, y'all definitely.
Speaker 3Worth it, right.
Speaker 1I hope you call in again, and not just you know, for for Adam here, But yeah, I've enjoyed talking with you today. Thanks so much for calling the show, and I hope you have a great rest of your weekend, folks. That was Salvador from Louisiana, conversation about free will. What'd you think of that, Adam?
Speaker 2I enjoyed that very much like I said, the topic for you. I personally I am a disbeliever in free will.
Speaker 1Yeah, and so, but.
Speaker 2I'm always curious to hear other people's ideas. Like I don't remember who it was that made the statement of like if you're not free to do what you want because you're being coerced, then you know than than your your will is not free, and otherwise it is. But then we get into like do I have control over what I want? Can I can I will what I want?
Speaker 1Yeah? That's another one change to yeah, the metaparts of like want what I don't even control the wants. So if I can't control the wants, why did it even matter what I want? Right? That seems to be a whole other problem. So yeah, I'm with you, I'm a skeptic, but I'm still one of those guys that still acts and chooses and thinks that I have a choice every day, and I just think that that's a healthier way to live life. I don't know, and maybe that's a bias, right, but yeah.
Speaker 2I think a sense of a sense of lack of control. It never feels good. Somehow, ironically, I gain a greater sense of agency by not believing in free will, because by understanding the automatic processes, I can sort of apply that wisdom and position myself in such a way to get the outcome that I want, So that comes with agency. I should also mention that neuroscience was sort of a part of my deconstruction that I glossed over, But we'll talk about that after we're we've got some dead air to deal with.
Speaker 1But yeah, okay, well you know, before well, we're not going to get to data. We're going to talk to some more people. But before we get to our next ers just want to remind folks that a great way to support the show is also by sending those super chants. If you do send it in super chants today, we will read them on the show. I also want to give a shout out to our atheistic community dot org. Principle call in flyers. If you want to get people to call into the show in your community and you have permission to do so, you can print out these flyers and help out the show. If you do, send us a picture on social media and we would love
Speaker 1to see that happen. One other thing as well, if you want to email the show, we have an email for that truth at Atheist Typecommunity dot org and TV at Atheist Hypeingcommunity dot org for the greater Atheist Community of Austin network. And of course you can go to our website at you guessed it, Atheist Hyphencommunity dot org. Last monoalagues. Before we move on, I have to also thank the wonderful, amazing, stupendous crew. Then he'll make this show happen every single week. And they're here in the background here, Hello, there they are now they're in the foreground. Hello, crew,
Speaker 1thanks so much for doing what you do. Really appreciate it. And let's go ahead and dive back in to our next caller. We have someone who hasn't called into the show for a while, but I recognize the name because the topic is something that he would want to talk about. It's Chase calling in from the United States. Chase, welcome back to truth wanted yo.
Speaker 4Yo yo. What's happening my friends?
Speaker 1How we doing doing good? Chase? I can't remember the last time you've called. It's been a long time, but I'm glad you're calling in today. And of course you're talking about issues related to animal rights, which I think is on brand for your Chase. I love that. What do you want to talk to us about today specifically?
Speaker 4Well, to be clear, I do care about humans also, but yeah, I talk about the animals quite a bit. Huh Okay, So I was hoping that we I think it might be fun if we did some street epistemology on me about a claim I have that people should deconstruct species.
Speaker 1Is absolutely I want to see Adam talk to you about this. If Adam is up for it. Adam, you want to talk to Chase about specism?
Speaker 2Oh? I am down to cloud all right?
Speaker 3Right?
Speaker 2Yeah, So can you give, like, maybe just like a two or three sentence summary of specism and what that means to you?
Speaker 3Yeah?
Speaker 4So speciesism is like discrimination against other beings just because they're not human, all.
Speaker 2Right, so discrimination again other beings because they're not human. What are some examples of this discrimination? Can you list off a couple.
Speaker 4Sure, if we were to, you know, kick a dog and say, oh, well, it don't matter, it's.
Speaker 10Just a dog, well, that would be speciesism.
Speaker 4The dogs don't want to be kicked anymore than you and me. If we were to say it's okay to slaughter a cow or a pig or a chicken just because we enjoy their flesh taste or it's convenient for us, you know, that would be speciesism because we surely wouldn't do that to an innocent human or you know. So, usually it applies to animals, but it could also apply to a species of aliens. For example, if we were to find aliens that exist on another planet, or if they were to come here or something, and we were to discriminate against those beings just because they're not human,
Speaker 4that would also be a form of speciesism.
Speaker 2Okay, so you're saying, like performing an act of violence on a member of another species just because they're a member of another species or despite you know, our cravings or whatever, that this is This is a form of specism. This is discrimination. Am I tracking you so far.
Speaker 4Yes, And to be clear, it would also be speciesism if another form of aliens were to discriminate against humans just because the humans were not born aliens.
Speaker 2Right, or So specism can cross all kinds of species boundaries. It's not just humans and others, but it's non human species and non human species.
Speaker 1Right. Yeah, I saw that movie. It's called District nine. Okay, so yeah.
Speaker 2Yeah, okay. So what I want to drill down to then is is this is this a general principle for all species or are there aspects? Let me ask it this way, because when you say doing something to another a member of another species, just because they're a member of another species, I want to give a scenario to you. If you are starving somewhere out in the woods, outstarving, you're going to perish, and you've got tasty looking squirrel
Speaker 2all over there. Would it be an example of specism to eat that squirrel to survive?
Speaker 4I think so. But it might be understandable that you had to do it. Your survival was at stake, you know. And I might do the same to a human if I had to in order to survive.
Speaker 2That's an interesting point. That's an interesting point. So it's like specism becomes somewhat justified in certain situations of duress, Right I wouldn't.
Speaker 4I'm not sure if i'd say justified, but understandable. You know, I would still consider it immoral to kill the squirrel to stay alive, But it would also be a moral for me to let myself die, you know, because like I'm an activist for human rights and animal rights and the environment, so I do a lot of good with my life, so let myself perish would be you know, immoral to myself.
Speaker 2Okay, all right, so yeah, there's.
Speaker 4I would I would tell you I would value my own life and the good that I could do more so than I would value the life world.
Speaker 2Okay, So your your moral position on this comes down to sort of like would you say, like max more harm reduction.
Speaker 4Well, it's a few things. It's about maximizing well being and the preservation of life and minimizing needless suffering and death and rights violations and exploitation, you know, trying to get rid of that as much can in this world. But we can't be perfect, all right.
Speaker 2I guess this is where I would ask you about like convenience, because like we talked about the extreme situation where we're starting in the middle of the woods. What about like convenience where said certain food staples aren't available or they would be available if we did some work on it. But it's just a lot easier to do this. Is this just sort of like a greater form or a less understandable form of specism, like you.
Speaker 4Said, yeah, like if you can go vegan, you should go vegan because the animals don't deserve this needless violence, and so like it's just that case of like I understand that it's a little bit harder.
Speaker 10To be vegan in this non vegan world that we live in, but you know, it's not that hard. We can do it, you know, like most of us, at least in most parts of the world. You know, certainly in the US, most of us, unless you're like homeless or something like that. That on Pop viewers and was serving in a vegan but that was in California where it was significantly easier and stuff like that. You know, everybody has the car when they're living on the streets.
Speaker 4So I just think that because it's harder for some people who want to go vegan, but they can't go vegan because they don't have access or they don't have enough money or whatever, even though a vegan diet is usually cheaper, you know, like we got those of us who can go vegan should go vegan because then it makes it easier for other people to have access to those foods because it affects the supply and demand chain, puts more vegan products on the shelves, makes them more accessible.
Speaker 2Okay, So the phrase you used earlier, you said, like like maximizing wellness, right, is that is that correct?
Speaker 4Maximizing well being?
Speaker 2Maximizing well being? Okay, So if we're if we're maximizing well being, our there dietary requirements for some species that where if they stopped being, if they stopped performing these acts of specism species speciesism, that they would become less well say whether it's protein intake or iron deficiency or anything like that, would would it would there be an increase in wellness with specism cause an increase in wellness.
Speaker 4Well, So take a lion for example, a lion, Like usually I don't think a non moral agent can be a species because they can't understand concepts of morality and rationality to the degree that we can you know, like the mind of a lion is similar to the mind of a child. You know, they just don't know any better. And a lion is in a is a carnivore and they're in a survival situation where they have to eat animals.
Speaker 3In order to survive.
Speaker 4But we, on the other hand, are civilized humans who can make compassionate choice at the grocery store, and so we're held to higher moral standard I think.
Speaker 2Okay, And so yeah, it seems it seems like it keeps coming down to sort of like that that maximal wellness. So it sounds to me like your position is sort of like an ought claim that if it would increase your well being, you should or you ought to not engage in specism if doing such would increase your well being. But if your well being would be served by performing acts of specism, that's understandable pretty much.
Speaker 4Yeah, Like we I think, I just look at it like a trait equalized human. You know, a human who has the same intelligence level and lifespan of a dog or a pig. You know, we still give them respect, and we don't, you know, treat them with the violence if we don't have to, because they value their existence, they value their lives and.
Speaker 3How they're treated.
Speaker 4And I see no difference between these animals and a human who is of the same intelligence level.
Speaker 3I'm not sure if that answers your question.
Speaker 2It does? It does? I would also I want to see how far you take this. But like using using an example, so, do you live with anyone? Yeah, do you live with a female?
Speaker 4I live with my parents right now. Yeah, I'm taking care of my parents and they're taking care of me.
Speaker 2Is in that male's ents? Okay? It would have been better for me to just ask, is anyone you live with afraid of spiders?
Speaker 4My mom's probably afraid of spiders a little bit.
Speaker 2So in this scenario, in this hypothetical, you are in a room with your mother, she spots a spider terrifies her. What do you do?
Speaker 3Well?
Speaker 4One option is to just you know, catch and release the spider outside, you know, But then I also have concerns like, that's what's best interest of the spider, you know, That's what would be the nice thing to do for the spider. But a spider is also a predator, and they're going to go outside and kill a bunch of other animals. So so maybe the best thing to do is just kill the spider so that less harm is done.
Speaker 2Interesting, what if the best interest of this spider is to continue to live in your house.
Speaker 4If I'm dealing with an infestation or something, I you know, like like oftentimes I try to catch and release that the bugs. But like I had to kill a bunch of bed bugs as they were crawling on me and eating me alive while I was sleeping, And that's not cool. I got to get my rest, you know, So God, do what you gotta do. But I would do the same thing if a human came into my house in the middle of the night and crawling on me while I was trying to sleep, you know, to them, no ability to reason with them, you know, I'd resort to violence.
Speaker 2Okay. And then so you you used infestation as an example, It's like, okay, wow, there's going to be some harm done to my family here if I let this infestation continue. Is that what you were saying in my correct.
Speaker 3Yeah pretty much.
Speaker 4But like you know, cows and pigs and chickens are not infesting our homes. They're non violent beings that are just minding their own business. So I think we put down the knife.
Speaker 2Okay, And here I'm really just trying to test the boundaries and limits of like your your devotion to this art claim. Right, So if we don't go all the way to infestation, let's just say it's just one wee little spider. He's up in the corner and you're not hurting anybody. He's freaking out your mom. Do you let him stay there? Do you relocate him to another area in your house?
Speaker 3Do you?
Speaker 4I mean, like, typically I catch and release, but I'm like really concerned about the victims of the spider also because there's going to be multiple victims. Again, I'm like, I am more concerned about the cows and the pigs of chickens that aren't hurting us as opposed to like bugs that are crawling on us inside our house or even just up in the corner at our house, especially predatory animals that will harm other beats. So, like I value a deer more than a lion, for example.
Speaker 2Interesting evaluate a deer more than a lion. And you said, because of like a li a lion can do more damage to more things than a deer, right, Yeah, same.
Speaker 4Reason that I value an innocent child more than I value a school shooter.
Speaker 2Fair. Okay, So when you make a distinction between say, bugs and I'm going to say harmless bugs, and when I say harmless, I mean harmless to humans or let's say maybe a leaf eating bug. And this might be where we kind of try to find another distinction. Do you consider plants in this species specism view?
Speaker 4No, because they're not Plants are not sentient, they're not conscious. They don't have a brain or central nervous system capable of giving them a subjective experience.
Speaker 2Subjective experience is the distinction for you. Okay, so you would not consider, say me knocking down a tree to be an example of specism, even though that tree is a different species than I am.
Speaker 1Correct.
Speaker 2Okay, so it's the central nervous system. Interesting, Yeah, because.
Speaker 4As I said at the onset, it's about other beings. How we treat other beings that I don't think a treat as another being. The sentience, it's a living organism.
Speaker 2Okay, now now I have to ask you about sentience. Now, now we've entered into a whole other area of this, Dan, you have any thoughts, Yeah, for sure.
Speaker 1I mean, you know, Chase, you called into the show before suit. You know my thoughts on this. We're we're in agreeance about a lot of things, Chase. You know, and I have to thank callers like yourself for challenging me about my own principles about this, because I wouldn't be a vegan today if it wasn't for people challenging me on some of these principles. This idea of specism is, you know, it's it's utilized in vegan communities, and I think there's there's merits to this idea, and I mostly agree with the concept. I think I'm talking about some
Speaker 1of these challenges that I think would trouble people. The plant thing comes up a lot, right, and I'm with you, Chase, because it's like, well, we don't have evidence that a plant has any kind of sentience or mechanism for sentience. They don't have the same systems like nervous systems or systems of no sucception right, systems of where they can feel pain because there's no central thing going on. It seems to be an organism that that exists without consciousness. So it's it's kind of like like you would treat an embryo. It's you know, most of us on the
Speaker 1left are okay with abortions in that same sense, And and that gets arguably as you know, you know, it gets some of the territory there. But yeah, you know, sentientism kind of overrides. And I think is a better idea for me to talk about than specism. And and and we're kind of hitting on that because like sentienism, I think people can get more on board with. Even though the idea of sentience is a controversial idea, it makes more sense and I think it is more intuitive to people than specism because to me, specism, I think while it does make sense, you get into these things
Speaker 1of like, well what about the bugs? Right? What about what about the spiders in your house? And stuff?
Speaker 3Right?
Speaker 1And and those are you know, valid points because if you're truly against specism, then and you're actually going to you know, hold all life at equal value. And I don't think vegans do that. I think we still do have these hierarchies. They may be diminished hierarchies compared to the average person that eats meat, but I think those hierarchies still exist and I think it's fair to acknowledge them anyway. That's my opinions there Chase, what do you think, Well.
Speaker 4I mean, like, you know, a puppy. Okay, so let's talk about a burning building and we only have time to save one individual that's in the building. It's either a puppy or Hitler. I must save the puppy over Hitler, right, because it doesn't matter what species they are. Well, you know Damage and the puppies.
Speaker 1Now, you know, Jase, if I saw Hitler in a burning building, I'd be having a lot of questions. But yeah, I guess I probably do the same thing. I think most people when they use that analogy, they usually use like an infant, right, like a human infant. What do you think about that scenario where it's like a puppy versus a human infant.
Speaker 4Yeah, that's tricky because the human infant is innocent, and we'll have a longer lifespan than the puppy and more qualitative experience, you know, with more sentience level, I think, and the baby might grow up to be a good human that helps.
Speaker 10The world in a lot of ways.
Speaker 4That the puppy couldn't because the puppy's not as smart. However, this baby might grow up to be your next serial killer or child abuser or whatever. So you know, we don't really know, but whereas we know more with the puppy, what the puppy's gonna do, so you know. But also you know, like a lot like the child could grow up to be a meat eater but then become a vegan later, you know, and like stand up for animal rights and human rights and do all this stuff, and we don't know, you know, like I used to be a non vegan. I used to make fun of vegan
Speaker 4and now look at me, right, So people to change, right, But sure, it's a tough call. I probably I'd probably go with the baby.
Speaker 1Yeah, And I would too, and I think every vegan that I know would because on some level we still have an affinity towards others humans and so we still have and we recognize that value. And I don't think that's a bad thing. But you know, I'm with you, though, Chase, because it's like we're the specism is trying to address this problem that we have where we treat other animal species differently. We kind of put some animals in like a food category that for the most part is kind of arbitrary and in fact does differ culturally around the world,
Speaker 1what some consider food and what some consider sacred. Hinduism is a great example of that.
Speaker 3Right.
Speaker 1Cows are not to be messed with there, and we eat them every day in the United States. Dogs Southeast Asian Southeast Asian nations don't have as much of a problem with that, and they will raise them for food. And that's something that discussed a lot of Americans. But if you truly don't have a care for animals, then why would you care? Right, So it's something to explore.
Speaker 8What are you going to say, Chase, Well, there are a lot of Asian activists, you know, for animal rights who are living in Asia that are of course since the dog and cat meat trade and rescuing those animals from slaughterhouses.
Speaker 4And I think most of the population there does not.
Speaker 3Eat dogs and cats.
Speaker 4But like, we might as well be eating dogs and cats if we're going to eat other animals, because there's no legitimate different between a dog and a pig. You know, they both value their lives and they feel pain and pleasure. They have friends and families that they care about, and they don't want to die. So like there there is no burning building right now, That's the thing. Like actually we're forcing animals into a burning building, the slaughter house, you know, poking and prodding them into there, and they don't want to go there. You know, it's not fair.
Speaker 1I'm with you on that. Let's stick with the let's as we're wrapping this up, let's stick to this idea that you brought to the table, though, which is this idea of specism. Are you still confident that this idea of specism holds water or do you think Adam's questions maybe it shifted how you think about it a little bit.
Speaker 4No, I'm still like I would have started and ended at a ninety nine percent confidence level that speciesism, that people should deconstruct speciesism because nobody gets to control how they're born, and there's nothing wrong with being different. And so if we're against racism and sexism, we should also be against speciesism and ableism and everything else attached to it.
Speaker 1All right, all right, Chase, thanks thanks so much for answering. Man. I will let you go today, but I hope you have a great weekend, and I hope I get to hear from you a different time. Man, have a good one, And there you go. That was Chase, What did you think of that, Adam, that was fun.
Speaker 2I found it interesting that, like we explored the boundaries of the specism itself, it seemed to me like the aught itself rested more on the sentience aspect than the species aspect. But his initial claim saying people should deconstruct specism, that deconstruction of specism led us to the to the sentience question. Yeah, and any anytime the question is and I'm going to take off my street epistmology hat of course, like anytime the question is should we deconstruct these thoughts,
Speaker 2I'm going to just say yes, no matter what the thoughts are, because you know, truth is going to withstand scrutiny.
Speaker 1Yeah, or so we hope you know.
Speaker 8So.
Speaker 2Yeah, that's my optimism kicking in.
Speaker 1I guess absolutely, and I have that optimism as well, even though I may not have a choice, a free choice and optimism it's still there when it.
Speaker 2Comes to like the burning building thing too. I like as a philosophical thought experiment, it's fun and we can sit there and go, you know, the puppy is less likely to commit a genocide, so it's true.
Speaker 1We can introduce what if that buffy grows up to be Hitler's dog though, you know, and so then was a good boy. Yeah.
Speaker 2Yeah, well, and then so I just think, if I'm actually in front of a burning building and I'm actually faced with this choice, my mammalian brain is going to kick in, and whatever my brain identifies with the most value at that time is gonna it's just going to kick in. I'm not even going to figure out. Yeah, and it's probably going to be the baby, because I'm a mammal and that's how we work.
Speaker 1Yeah, I'm with you on that, And that's why it's really hard to have some of these conversations to take you know, animal rights seriously in that aspect, because people will choose other humans and I'm going to agree with them. I think that's the right thing to do. But yeah, at some point.
Speaker 2The conversation of sentience and what is required for that and the functions that it performs, and compare that to some things that trees do, it becomes an interesting conversation.
Speaker 1Yeah, And why do you say that?
Speaker 2Because the trees exchange information with other species, they have immune responses. They don't have the nervous system in the sensor like neurons like we have. But there are logical gits that respond to the environment to make internal changes. There are memories, there's color perception in some cases, and so when we start talking about these things, it's tempting sometimes to think, Okay, well, maybe sentience isn't this thing
Speaker 2that you either have it or you don't. Maybe there are degrees and kinds of sentience, And sometimes I feel like trees deserve some consideration for, and not just treats, but plant life in general. What is sentient, what isn't? To what extent what kind? It becomes a very interesting conversation.
Speaker 1You're definitely right, and I wish we had more time to talk about that. However, we are at the tail end of tonight's show. I want to thank you Adam aka Deconstruction Deacon for being on with me today. It was awesome having you on. Would love to get to talk to you and sometime if people want to find you, where should they go.
Speaker 2Well, I can be found on TikTok Deconstruction Deacon. I have a link stack that you can check out as well for other socials, but I am mostly active on TikTok and that is where I will be found most often. I do live street epistemology videos and sometimes we just hang out nice.
Speaker 1Yeah. I love that. So you should go check out Deconstruction Deacon stuff if you'll want to see more of his things. And I want to bring Scott on if he's still with us here there, man, go with you, go with you quick with that. You see how fast they were with that? Holy shit, I didn't know they I think.
Speaker 6They were recovering from the tongue lashing you gave them last time when I didn't count.
Speaker 1That's right, that's right. Yeah, I know, I know, I'm so mean like that, but bro, they were ready. Okay, Scott, Wow, you're here. Scott. Thanks so much for being back up posts today. I really appreciate that. Can you remind us what the question of the week was this week?
Speaker 6The question of the week is what's the worst example of God's unconditional of all?
Speaker 3Right?
Speaker 1Thank you so much for that, and leave a comment below, not in the live chat, but a comment folks down below, and we will read our top three answers next week. Before we go, I like to ask our guests about words of wisdom. You have any words of wisdom for us? Before we wrap things up, Deconstruction Deacon I'm going to.
Speaker 2Just apply what I have applied to my own life. In some things, you're smarter than you think, but in most things you're dumber than you think.
Speaker 1All right, And that's our word of words of wisdom tonight, folks, I'm objectively Dan. Remember to always keep one the truth, and we'll see you next time.
Speaker 2Watch Talk Ethan Live Sundays at one pm Central.
Speaker 5Visit tiny dot c c slash y t t H and call into the show at five one two nine nine one nine two four two, or connect to the show online at tiny dot c c slash call th H
In today's episode of Truth Wanted, ObjectivelyDan welcomes guest Out Of Body Atheist, with The Beard of Empathy on backup, to dig into Reiki, New Age spirituality, homeopathy, and the long road from woo to skepticism!...
In today's episode of Truth Wanted, Jon the Skeptick, Volcy, and Sofia Spina explain why no one can talk to the dead, from Haitian Vodou and grief dreams to Jon's past as a spiritualist! Bob jumps from objective...
In today's episode of Truth Wanted, ObjectivelyDan and Nintendrew, later joined by The Beard of Empathy, tackle a world run on Jesus, the magic of manifesting, and a prayer that actually got answered! Bob in NY, a...
In today's episode of Truth Wanted, ObjectivelyDan, Kelley Laughlin, and The Beard of Empathy tackle standards of evidence, miracle claims, and the false binaries of moral philosophy! Dean in VA questions why skeptics...
In today's episode of Truth Wanted, ObjectivelyDan and Chad Harris tackle Christian nationalism, police brutality, and the uncomfortable truths about racism and immigration. Big E in TN survived police brutality and...