In today's episode of Truth Wanted, ObjectivelyDan, Kelley Laughlin, and The Beard of Empathy tackle standards of evidence, miracle claims, and the false binaries of moral philosophy! Dean in VA questions why skeptics can't specify what would convince them of supernatural claims. What counts as good evidence for a miracle versus a historical event? The hosts explore the difference between empirical and testimonial evidence. When someone claims a miracle, why should we accept testimony over repeatable observation? If a claim can't be tested or falsified, what makes it worth believing? The conversation reveals how shifting standards and unfalsifiable claims make productive dialogue nearly impossible. Gohan in TX insists morality is either utilitarian or absolute, arguing atheists can only have goal-oriented ethics. Why present this as a binary when multiple moral frameworks exist? The hosts clarify distinctions between utilitarianism, consequentialism, deontology, and virtue ethics. Can you hold moral principles without believing in absolute divine commands? What happens when you confuse philosophical terms and collapse nuanced positions into false dichotomies? This call exposes how misunderstanding moral philosophy leads to strawman arguments about atheist ethics. Thank you for tuning in this week! We'll see you next time! Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/truth-wanted--3195473/support.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Speaker 1Hi, folks. Dan here.
Speaker 2And I'm here to tell you that it is my opinion the anti-vax movement does not actually run on data. Instead, I think it just runs on retracted studies, celebrity testimonials, and a deep distrust of institutions that get mistaken for doing your own research, right? Meanwhile, actual research that's conducted across millions of people over decades is is pretty much about as settled as science gets. And I think choosing
Speaker 2fear over evidence doesn't actually make you a critical thinker. I think it makes you a vector for the next pandemic. So I want to see what the research you think overturns a century of immunology is really doing for you. So call in and show us your sources because the show is starting right now. Welcome back, everybody. Hello, hello, and welcome to another episode of Truth Wanted. I am
Speaker 2your host, Objectively Dan, and I want to welcome you to Truth Wanted, the live call-in show that happens every single week, Sundays at 2.45 p.m., where we talk to people about what they believe and why they believe it. And if you'd like to call us, you can do that at 512-991-9242, or you can call through your Now, Truth Wanted is a production of the Atheist Community of Austin, a 501c3 nonprofit organization that's dedicated to the promotion of atheism, critical thinking, secular humanism, and the separation of religion and government.
Speaker 2And folks, we are tri-streaming today, so a big shout out to our viewers on TikTok and YouTube mobile. If you are watching us on TikTok tonight and you'd like to talk to us, then please send a request to join us. And we'll bring you up on stage. Please make sure that you are over the age of 18 before doing so. And folks, every single week, I always have a guest with me. This week, it is fellow host of the show, Callie Laughlin. Callie, welcome to your own show.
Speaker 3Well, thanks, Dan.
Speaker 1You help produce at this point.
Speaker 4I was just sitting here, you know, you're going through the whole intro thing, and I was thinking, wow, it's really weird for me to sit here and not be saying all of that stuff myself.
Speaker 2Yeah, we have been getting a good little rotation going on, which has been pretty good. Folks, I need to start today with an apology, okay? Because this time of year is a very special time for Truth Wanted. It's that Halloween time. It's the spooky season. And we take Spook Season very seriously at Truthwanted. We started in October. Virtually every year, we've done something special for Halloween. And we are not doing a particularly special broadcast this year. There's
Speaker 2a couple reasons for that. One, it's kind of weird because now we're doing stuff on the Sunday. And this year, Sunday, we're six days away from Halloween, which is the farthest you can get. The next Sunday is going to be November 1st. So already the vibes are off. But there's another reason as well. There was a lot of work that was put into doing a special show this year. The scope of this project that we had intended had changed at various points. So We tried to get some stuff done last week. Long story short, we couldn't get
Speaker 2something to you in time for today. However, that does not mean that we're not going to do anything special later.
Speaker 1We've already put a lot of work in. into this. It's a very ambitious thing.
Speaker 2We've never done anything like this for Truth Wanted, and we don't want that to go to waste. So I would ask that you please give us some time and maybe, maybe you'll see, I don't know, a spooky Thanksgiving.
Speaker 1Special this year.
Speaker 2I want to try to at least, I want to see that we get this done before the end of the year, because we really do like to honor this time of year. It's always great for Truth Wanted. But as of today, We are just doing a regular live show. We're not doing anything specifically Halloween focused. But I'd ask that you give us some patience while we figure some stuff out behind the scenes. And Kelly can tell you what's great about this is that I am deliberately being
Speaker 2kept out on the loop. as the part of it, and Kelly is too. This is a work between me, Kelly, and Greg, and Greg has parts that even we don't know. It's hard to explain, but it's part of the ambitious nature of this project. So that's a little teaser for you as to what to expect. Like I said, we're doing something... totally different but it's not quite ready yet so let us cook okay let us cook and we'll get back to you on that anything you want to
Speaker 2add to that kelly i was just.
Speaker 4Gonna say we didn't like you said we're letting it cook we didn't take it off the stove it's just on the back burner right now and it yeah it'll it'll come to fruition and i think everybody is gonna love the idea i mean i loved it.
Speaker 2I, yeah, it's going to be, it's going to be, it's going to be one of those ones. It's going to be one of those ones for sure. I think, um, people will, uh, people will like people will like, but, um, yeah, let us cook on that and we'll get back to you on it when we're ready. But for now, you know, like I said, this is going to be a regular live call-in show, um, which is not typical for us for Halloween usually, or sometimes we do it, but usually we have some pre-recorded stuff or some other stuff going.
Speaker 1But no, we're here.
Speaker 2We're talking to you and we're ready to take some calls right now. We have open lines on our phone line and also on TikTok. So if you want to connect with us, come do that. And we will do that. I will, you know, we talked about the anti-vax movement. We don't talk about it super often. And here's why in the past, YouTube has been not very nice. about us talking about it. I think because of stuff that happened with COVID, they became a lot more restrictive about some of the information on there.
Speaker 1And even though.
Speaker 2We've pushed back historically on anti-vax narratives because people talk about anti-vax stuff on the show, like some of the flagging kind of picks up on that. And it, even though we're pushing back, it still has trouble with it. So we're trying it again today to see if it's going to kick us off or what we're going to, what's going to happen.
Speaker 1I don't know. Um, but you know, I, I, Kelly, you have the same take.
Speaker 2I do. Um, anti-vax, um, ideology is, um, not only bad, it is actively harmful.
Speaker 3Um, Yeah.
Speaker 2Yeah.
Speaker 4I also have the idea, the ideology that we should push the limits to and see how far.
Speaker 1We can go. Yeah, because I think it's worth talking about.
Speaker 3Yeah, exactly. Exactly.
Speaker 2I don't I don't want to be restricted by YouTube's or TikTok's policies on this stuff, but also like that's where we put content out. So like it's it's a catch 22. So we're trying out. We're going to see if we're going to see what happens next.
Speaker 1You know, like we do.
Speaker 2But here's one reason why it hits really hard for me. I have parents who work in healthcare. They don't normally work hospital, but like, you know, they do clinical work. And when COVID hit, my parents had to work They took on shifts at the local hospitals. This was before vaccines were out. This was when COVID was at its peak and they needed people.
Speaker 1And it was an.
Speaker 2Extremely scary time. And, you know, I worried for them. They were literally putting their lives on. This was when we weren't we didn't even know for sure what COVID was doing to people and stuff. And, you know, thankfully, of course, you know, they got to get the vaccine a bit earlier than other people because they worked in health care and they're on the front lines for that.
Speaker 1And the fact that people push back on.
Speaker 2That, the fact that people made their lives objectively harder and other people write that were working in that field harder because they They have a higher risk of exposure, right, by not getting it.
Speaker 1I think it's a bit unforgivable in my eyes. I really do. I think grown-ass adults should know better.
Speaker 2I understand that there's mistrust because there were scientific methodologies that were a bit new for some people to understand. And I'm not going to pretend like I completely understand that. How the development of vaccines work. I'll tell you, I wouldn't be getting paid what I do now. I'd be I'd be doing something else. But like, I do have trust in these institutions. And I think that trust is still a valuable and healthy thing. I don't think we
Speaker 2should always trust our government institutions on every single little thing.
Speaker 1God, no.
Speaker 2I'll give you plenty of examples of why you can't and shouldn't. But when it comes to this stuff, the people who knew what they were talking about and had the degrees to back it up and who had the more experience and who are more qualified and whose opinions mattered more than mine, more than Kelly's, more than anybody else at the ACA, they spoke out about it. And I chose to listen because I think it was– the right thing to do. Anyway, that's a strong way to start this, but this is a strong topic for me. I have very strong feelings about it. So there you go, Kelly.
Speaker 2That's my thoughts.
Speaker 1What do you think?
Speaker 3Yeah, I agree with you.
Speaker 4I had actually some very strong feelings too while it was all going on. I was misdiagnosed with blastomycosis. It's a fungal lung disease. And I had been on an antifungal medication for like six months. I didn't get any better because I didn't have blastomycosis. I just had a simple lung infection. Eventually, I was able to see an infectious doctor, an infectious disease specialist. And he figured it out, put me on a regular antibiotic, and I was fine. But because my lungs have been so messed up, I
Speaker 4had pneumonia five times in one year.
Speaker 5And I.
Speaker 3Had my last bout of.
Speaker 4Pneumonia in November, and then COVID got really bad that January, so it started in December. So I was really, really fearful of my own life at that point, because I was literally the population of people that was at risk, right? So yeah, I mean, it was really personal to me, too. I totally get it.
Speaker 3And the degree of.
Speaker 4Mistrust in experts really surprised me from a group of people that normally trust.
Speaker 3Experts, just not scientists.
Speaker 4If any of those people had a car broken down, they would have trusted a mechanic. So I don't understand why all of a sudden an expert in one field you can trust, but not in another field.
Speaker 3That was really confusing to me.
Speaker 2Yeah, it's– to me, when I think about COVID, when I think about the pandemic and the reactions people have, I think of selfishness, honestly. I'm thinking about, like, the guys that were banging on the doors of Chili's, like, demanding them to be open so they could get their jalapeno poppers just like it was any other weekend.
Speaker 1You know, it's just like– I mean– You know, if.
Speaker 2We genuinely just followed the procedures like every other damn country trying to do, we wouldn't have had to have the lockdowns for as long as we did. We wouldn't have had to had the effects that we had, but we didn't get our shit together. And, um, there are some people that speculated maybe it would take a pandemic like that for people to get their shit together on like global issues like climate change and stuff. And we didn't get our shit together. And it makes me wonder about what happens the next time. What if we get
Speaker 2something that's COVID, but worse, how is America going to respond? And I think people are, are, are, are going to be really shitty, you know?
Speaker 1Um, and I don't know what to do about that.
Speaker 2Yeah.
Speaker 3I'm afraid we're going to respond the same way.
Speaker 5I'm afraid of that.
Speaker 4There was, there was a big mass controversy in 1919 during the Spanish flu.
Speaker 6Right.
Speaker 2Right.
Speaker 4So, I mean, there was, it's something that Americans just don't like to listen. Humans don't like to listen. I don't think it's, it's unique to Americans. It's humans just don't like to be told what to do.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 2I just, again, there's socioeconomic factors at play that I think, um, have explainability, but I also wonder, you can't help but wonder the cultural things with that. I mean, as Americans, we're taught this exceptionalism. We're taught that you have this freedom. You can do whatever the frick you want.
Speaker 1And it doesn't matter.
Speaker 2And people should, churches should be able to do what they want. Businesses should be able to do what they want. You know, forget all these lockdowns and these rules and these things. This is, you know, we have a right to do these things. And it's not about, it was never about infringing on people's rights. It was always about trying to do what's best for everybody. And everybody suffered as a consequence. The businesses suffered, the churches suffered, people suffered. And and and we we suffered more than we had to. You know, I'm not I'm not happy about the fact
Speaker 2that small businesses and people, you know, like lost their livelihoods and things like that. You know, like I don't want that to be the case. I don't want people to have to have to go through that. But at the same time. What was the alternative? You just kind of open it and then everybody gets sick and we never close down anything like we the closing stuff down helped slow that shit down.
Speaker 1And there's just no way around that for me. So I don't know.
Speaker 2Now we're kind of talking about lockdown stuff more than anti-vax, I guess. But like the anti-vax stuff plays into a part of that because that fueled a lot of that.
Speaker 3It was definitely part of the big scope of things.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 4And we had I don't know how much you know about what was going on in Michigan at the time of all that. But we actually had the dress rehearsal for January 6th here at our Capitol.
Speaker 3Only they brought guns here and here in Michigan.
Speaker 1Yeah, of course.
Speaker 4And yeah, I mean, if you look, if you just Google takeover of Michigan Capitol, you can see. And that was over that was over the lockdowns in the vet and people thinking that they had to go get vaccinated. They were being forced to get vaccinations. my store was closed down for nearly three months by law. So it did, it hurt a lot of us. I mean, it put us in the debt for, it took us a long time to recover from that, honestly.
Speaker 6So, yeah.
Speaker 1And you know what, like America, guess what?
Speaker 2We had PPE loans and people abused the shit out of that too.
Speaker 1So that's like a whole other thing.
Speaker 2Like, it's not like small businesses weren't, weren't going to have options to recover. The problem is what was, what options was my grandma going to have to recover from You know, well, I mean, she passed away at that time, but the point is like, well, people's grandmas.
Speaker 7You know what I mean?
Speaker 2Like they don't get to get a business loan to get their shit back.
Speaker 1They get sick and they could die.
Speaker 2Like that's the reparations are not the same.
Speaker 1I don't know.
Speaker 2Yeah. I, I, you know, Texas obviously was, was, you know, in Austin, it was kind of different from the rest of the state. Of course, I think they were better about the lockdown stuff, but like, you know, you saw news all the time.
Speaker 1People be like, yeah, we're still operating like whatever. We don't really care. Blah, blah, blah. It's yeah. Just the front.
Speaker 4Yeah.
Speaker 2And churches all over the place just didn't care.
Speaker 5Yeah.
Speaker 1None of the churches up here.
Speaker 4None of the churches up here.
Speaker 2But yeah, I get like I'm not going to be the guy to be like, oh, yeah, I know. I know the ins and outs of this vaccine. I can tell you everything about why it works and why it doesn't. I'm not I'm not trained. I'm not qualified. Um, I can tell you some basics that I know, but like, honestly, it's not my bag there. And there's people that are in our community that could tell you better than I could. But, but, but, but the, what I base my argument on as to why this is a moral good and why you should do it is because like at the end of the day, We all have faith in institutions for a lot of
Speaker 2our takes and our opinions, because if you're saying, oh, yeah, my thing is backed up by evidence. I didn't make I didn't do those studies, man. I didn't I didn't come up with that stuff. I'm I'm reading stuff and I'm evaluating methodology. But at the end of the day, I am going to hope that somebody is right about that. And that's something that we all have to kind of embrace if we're honest with ourselves. And this was one of those cases. Um, cause we can't be experts on everything, you know? Uh, right.
Speaker 8Right.
Speaker 1So, um, it is what it is.
Speaker 2That's my, that's my, my big take, but it's not a hot take for you, Kelly, because you, you, you know, you think the same way I do. I thought these things broadly speaking, right. We still have somebody who is screening in our call room right now, so we'll get to that. We have a super chat from– I can't read that. What is that, Jay Wissick? Thank you so much for that. They gave $ 9. 99, and they said, Jesus failed to stop me from sending this to you.
Speaker 1That's terrible. Thank you so much, Jay Wissick, for the $ 9.
Speaker 599.
Speaker 1And, yeah, I agree with that.
Speaker 2He did not intercept that communication. Maybe that's the free will thing.
Speaker 1I don't know.
Speaker 6That's awesome.
Speaker 2Yeah.
Speaker 1Any thoughts, Kelly, before we move on?
Speaker 4You know, you were talking about, you know, doing research. And I saw in the intro and I kind of laughed at that. And I was thinking, but Dan, a bunch of these people who are anti-vaxxed, They did search and research their feelings.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 3And their feelings told them it was just bad. So to them, they did research.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 2It's always just like, oh, yeah, there's the one there's the one doctor from Abilene that's that's thanks. Abilene, Texas, I think the vaccines are. are bad or something like, yeah, that's a guy's opinion, but the consensus was not that. So like, that's, that's why we rely on consensus from things you're, you're going to see there's rarely a hundred percent consensus on a lot of things in science. And so I don't know why that in particular is any more special, um, in that regard, but. You know, um,
Speaker 2it is what it is. Anyway, we have some callers that, that want to talk to us. So I think we can, we can switch it up. You ready to talk to some people?
Speaker 3I'm always ready to talk to people. You know me.
Speaker 1All right. We'll do that then.
Speaker 2So before we do that, I need to give a shout out to the folks on the Patreon. Every single week, you guys are getting a shout out. One person from the list gets a shout out anyway. Anybody that donates through ACA.show slash patron TW is eligible for a shout out.
Speaker 1And this week's patron of the week is.
Speaker 2is uh my wife lauren z thank you so much lauren and thank you to everybody um but she's on the list so she qualifies okay this isn't nepotism that that that's just what happens so thank you thank you uh thank you honey for donating appreciate it um and thank you to everybody who donates um you guys are awesome um so with that out of the way let's go ahead and get to our next call this is We're asking for trouble today, Callie I already can feel it I feel it in my bones We're asking for trouble today But we're doing it anyway Let's dive right
Speaker 2in Man, I think Let's talk to Dean We got Dean who's calling in from Virginia Dean wants to talk to us about Standards of evidence for belief And non-belief Dean, you're live on Truth Wanted, what's up? Hear your voice again, Dan Hi, Dean. Nice to hear from you, too. Thanks for calling. Appreciate it.
Speaker 5Yeah. So here's a pattern that I see in talking to skeptics, nonbelievers. And I think it's okay to ask for a.
Speaker 1pretty high.
Speaker 5Standard to believe in something like a resurrection or a miracle or for the existence.
Speaker 1Of god um.
Speaker 5But the pattern that i see is often it goes something like this okay well you know This particular argument and the evidence to support.
Speaker 7This argument is not convincing.
Speaker 5And then the question ultimately gets to, okay, well.
Speaker 7What would convince you?
Speaker 6And then the.
Speaker 5Response is typically something like, well, I don't know what would convince me. And then the question, this is kind of my question, like, why. How could you say that you don't know what... I guess that's my question. Why is that kind of a typical pattern that can take place within the skeptical community of, well, that's not... That doesn't meet a standard of evidence that
Speaker 5would convince me. And then when asked, hey, what would convince you? A answer is often, well, I don't know.
Speaker 8I think.
Speaker 4I think that's because nobody knows the particular thing, right? But I have standards of what type of evidence would convince me. even though I couldn't tell you what particular thing was needed to convince me. Sorry, Dan, I didn't mean to cut you off.
Speaker 1No, well, I just want to comment.
Speaker 2I think Dean is right that this is a very, this is a common response to say, like, I'm not sure what the standards are. You know, it's important that, obviously, skepticism and atheism is not a monolith, right? There's people that have, like, you obviously, Kelly, you have your particular standards. But I've definitely, I've had co-hosts who have said, yeah, I'm not sure. So that's definitely come up for sure. I think this comes up because it's like Kelly said, it's, it's, it's kind of in the particulars. It's the reason why, like, you know, in, in, in like, when we have like
Speaker 2case law, and I use this as an example, like, you know, everybody has a right to shoot a trial if they really want you. So most of the time you don't, you don't get there because you kind of establish precedent and you kind of figure out the, what, what, what goes before anyway. But if there's things that are particular to a case that may need to be judged upon and people can't figure it out, that's why we have that system and rule of law to be able to, to determine that. And like, when it comes to claims about science or the world, um, we do a similar kind of thing. We rely on principles to predict general behavior.
Speaker 2Laws of physics, for example, are a great way of how we predict and understand the general days today. If there's something that appears to violate that, that may require higher scrutiny, and that may require looking at evidence or materials or methodologies that we haven't considered before. This happens all the time in math, for example. A lot of solutions or ways that people find proofs in math often come in unexpected ways, ways that they have to apply math in ways that they may not anticipate, but still follow a set pattern of rules of behavior, right? So
Speaker 2when it comes to miracles, it kind of does depend, but at minimum in this day and age, if you're flying i want to see if you're walking on water i want to see a video you know like there's got to be some basics i would say um but yeah it's hard to evaluate claims in particular about miracles that are talking about events that occurred 2 000 years ago because all we have are at best at best written testimony and even then the testimony that we have Often isn't actually Direct eyewitness testimony It's people Anonymous writings
Speaker 2or it's other kinds of things It depends on which Scripture you're talking about But hopefully that is a satisfactory answer there Dean.
Speaker 5So I see what you're saying Dan my question would be Because you made the example of If you're walking on water I think you're walking on water or you're flying I want to see a video.
Speaker 1Yeah I would wouldn't you.
Speaker 5I mean, no, but I feel like I feel like with that particular video of somebody walking on water be enough for you to believe that that's actually.
Speaker 1What I know.
Speaker 8Yeah.
Speaker 1And that's what I'm saying. Like, that's the minimum.
Speaker 2That's the minimum, you know, like it's got to be more than that, obviously, for sure.
Speaker 5And I understand what you're saying About something that took place 2,000 years ago I get that But even for today Let's not talk about 2,000 years ago Even today If there were Let's say there were I don't know A hundred Peer-reviewed Articles That talked about This particular event that took place And they came to the conclusion that the The best explanation for this was something non-natural.
Speaker 1That'd be incredible.
Speaker 5That's my question. How many people would it take testimonial evidence for you?
Speaker 8Only one.
Speaker 3Only one.
Speaker 4But the proof would have to be unambiguous and it would have to be empirically proven.
Speaker 3And that's it.
Speaker 4And almost everything that people believe exists past those two tests. Almost everything that everybody believes in can be proven to be unambiguous.
Speaker 3It's really there or it isn't. And I can sense it in some way.
Speaker 4And hardly anybody believes in anything that isn't like that except for religion and supernatural stuff. All the stuff that nobody can prove exists.
Speaker 3But they'll accept.
Speaker 4But they need that same evidence, but they use the same evidence for everything else they believe in. And for some reason, people who are religious and believe in ghosts, they don't think about that.
Speaker 3They just let that evidence slide away.
Speaker 2If you were describing a new disease that came out of Africa, for example, the topic of diseases, I imagine you have people that are exhibiting symptoms.
Speaker 1Maybe you have a sample disease.
Speaker 2Of what maybe if it's from a if its origins are bacterial in nature you have a sample of that and you know not all diseases come from the same place right but you have these things that come from it whereas if we're talking about like a demon possession right what do we have usually other than like a story or maybe we have somebody acting weird on a video but it's just it's just not enough for a for a material science perspective to really analyze and gain you information from right or understand so.
Speaker 5I'm with you about somebody claiming a demon position like I I'm skeptical of those as well okay I'm with you there Kelly you said it had to be what was it unambiguous and what was the second.
Speaker 3Piece and unambiguous and empirical and what.
Speaker 5Do you mean for me what do you mean by empirical.
Speaker 4Does that you have to be able to sense it to be repeatable No, you have to be able to sense it.
Speaker 2And I think, well, just to clarify, you don't mean just human senses, but also through like reliable technology that can sense things, right? Like that make observations in the world.
Speaker 4Well, even if a machine's making the observation, we can observe the machine making that observation, right?
Speaker 1Yeah, right.
Speaker 2Because I'm saying like with particle physics and stuff, they're not like looking at the atoms.
Speaker 1They're like, oh, man, that's crazy. How would the machines do that?
Speaker 3But they are looking at the traces of the atoms, right?
Speaker 2Yeah, yeah, yeah, for sure. Using technology to explain that.
Speaker 1So they're still.
Speaker 3Able to see it in an empirical sense.
Speaker 2Yeah, I'm just trying to help you man your point.
Speaker 3Gotcha.
Speaker 2Gotcha.
Speaker 3Okay. It's cool.
Speaker 1So there you go, Dean.
Speaker 5So, yeah, no, I, I got you. So, um, I, sorry, I'm trying to navigate what Kelly said there. So by sense sensible, you just don't mean, like you said, you don't mean human senses. You mean something that can. Yeah.
Speaker 4I mean, if humans have to be able to be able to sense it in some way or another. Like in the example that Dan gave, there's enough data from the machine that we can use that, right? We can sense that data. But what is it? Let's say for a ghost, right? What can I empirically do with a ghost that's unambiguous as well?
Speaker 5Yeah, I think I see your point there as far as being able to detect or sense a ghost. I guess the question would be, in a hypothetical sense, if someone said, if there's a peer-reviewed article that said, hey, you know, this person was missing an index finger and they prayed over that person in the name of Jesus and their index finger grew back, would the peer-reviewed journal article,
Speaker 5if that was attested to.
Speaker 3Sure, if it was repeatable.
Speaker 1Well, I don't even know.
Speaker 2I mean, the repeatable, I don't know, Kelly. I don't think it has to be repeatable in that sense.
Speaker 3When was the last time somebody grew a digit?
Speaker 5No, no, I'm just saying hypothetically. I'm just trying to.
Speaker 4I understand you're saying hypothetically. I'm just saying that that's something that is unbelievable in any way, shape, or form, right?
Speaker 3So you're going to need... That's a.
Speaker 4Very extraordinary thing to have happen. So you're going to have to come up with, and I'm going to say it, extraordinary evidence, right? So like one peer reviewed thing that you're going to hand me, I don't know who it was that peer reviewed it. There's more to it than just saying I have a peer reviewed thing. And I'm a scientist. I've actually had things peer reviewed.
Speaker 5Right.
Speaker 3So I understand the process.
Speaker 4So it's just just because it's peer reviewed, believe me, doesn't mean that it's true because there's all kinds of there's all kinds of publications that have a an agenda.
Speaker 3To put across.
Speaker 4And the people who are peer reviewing for that publication are not peer reviewing it the way that maybe the consensus would see it.
Speaker 2Yeah.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 5Sure, and you can dispute, and you can also write a counter to that peer-reviewed article to dispute the findings. And I don't mean to say that you don't understand what peer review is.
Speaker 1Don't hear me say that.
Speaker 3All right. No, that's cool. That's what I'm just saying. I've been through the process.
Speaker 6That's all.
Speaker 3And like I said, if.
Speaker 1Someone's in a hospital, sorry to cut you off, Kelly.
Speaker 2Just like if somebody's in a hospital and a doctor is there and they see a finger grow and they're like, yeah, I saw a finger grow. That would be that would be crazy. That would be you don't need a peer review, I'd say, for that. I mean, like that's that's that's something to consider. Especially if you're like, yeah, everybody in my life said I didn't have this finger before. And then I was here and then it prayed and then it growed like that. That's a kind of testimony that would be very powerful only if only for the fact that's literally never happened.
Speaker 1Right.
Speaker 4Unless you're just trying to sell some chemical that would make your fingers grow back.
Speaker 1I guess, but that would have a serial explanation, though.
Speaker 3Then I would totally doubt it.
Speaker 2Yeah, but that's different from attesting to the origins or at least attesting to the fact that somebody prayed and there appeared to be a causal relationship there between the finger growing, right?
Speaker 1That would be a phenomenal thing.
Speaker 5And I guess here's my follow-up for you, Kelly, is if that only happened once and it wasn't.
Speaker 7Repeatable, would you dismiss it?
Speaker 1Probably. That's a good question.
Speaker 6Probably.
Speaker 3You would? Yeah, I probably would.
Speaker 2So you think it would be like maybe somebody playing a trick?
Speaker 3Yeah, yeah. I mean, because because to me, it's not unambiguous. Right.
Speaker 4I mean, if somebody was able to keep doing it all the time and we and we could watch him doing it all and we can take the ambiguity out of it. But somebody doing it one time, there's too many other factors involved.
Speaker 8Right.
Speaker 1That's a good point.
Speaker 2If only for the fact that like. Well, you know, I see what Kelly's point is, because like if if if. You could pray and something happened and that doesn't necessarily mean that's the causal relationship.
Speaker 5Right.
Speaker 1It doesn't. It's not completely unambiguous. I think you're right.
Speaker 2I think that's why Kelly's adding this idea of repeatability being necessary, because it could be that some other unrelated God just happened to take pity. Right.
Speaker 1And did this.
Speaker 2It may not have been the Christian God, for example, or maybe an alien zap array through space. And it happened to land on a finger that one time.
Speaker 1Right.
Speaker 2But if somebody is continually praying and it happens, you know, that brings a higher regard for it. So I see the merit to that. But ultimately, we're talking about something that seems to have never occurred and probably will never occur.
Speaker 1Right. So I don't know.
Speaker 5No, I was just saying, we're playing the hypothetical game.
Speaker 1I'm just trying to.
Speaker 5Understand, maybe not along the lines of not just the methodology, but the, I guess the, what's the word I'm looking for? Epistemology of accepting or not accepting a miracle came from the skeptic point of view.
Speaker 2Yeah.
Speaker 7That's all I'm... after.
Speaker 5So, I mean, I don't really have anything else other than that. I don't know why Dan was just like, man, we're.
Speaker 1In trouble today.
Speaker 2Well, I said that not because of this call, but more just the anti-vax thing.
Speaker 3The anti-vax thing.
Speaker 1That was what I'm more worried about. But, yeah, it wasn't in relation.
Speaker 5To– I didn't know if there was a causal relationship between you saying that and me being in the queue.
Speaker 6No, no.
Speaker 1That's right.
Speaker 2So you see, this is where repeatability is necessary, right? Anyway, but let me ask you this, Dean. What does a miracle have to be for you in order to believe it?
Speaker 1Do you believe in miracles?
Speaker 5So I do believe in miracles. Can I say that I've ever seen one or experienced one?
Speaker 4No.
Speaker 5I don't believe that I have, but I am very skeptical, and I'm going to get in trouble with some of my Pentecostal friends for this one, but I'm very skeptical of the charismatic movement in American Christianity.
Speaker 7Just because of things that.
Speaker 5Kelly, you may remember this guy. I remember Peter Popoff.
Speaker 3Oh yeah, I know who Peter was. James Randi?
Speaker 5I'm very skeptical of those things. Even in my own friend group of Christian ministers and friends, when someone says, I think I had a dream and it was from God, I'm very like, I.
Speaker 1Don't know about that.
Speaker 5So I don't necessarily know that I do lean more along the line, you know, closer to see it to believe it, right? I think Kelly is right. I think it has to be unambiguous. I don't know that I'm at the spot of it has to be repeatable over and over and over again because I think that's what
Speaker 5makes a miracle a miracle to a certain degree.
Speaker 2I don't know, Jesus multiplied some stuff a couple times, you know?
Speaker 1Sure, sure. If you believe the narrative, he did it more than once.
Speaker 5Yeah, but he also only did stuff once as well, like... That's also some miracles that he did that he only did once.
Speaker 1Yeah, which I think is odd.
Speaker 2But let me ask you this, because like you're saying on the one hand, you're skeptical of the Pentecostal miracles. And I have to agree. You should be skeptical with that. But on the other hand, you say you don't necessarily you lean more on the side of seeing to believe, but you still have some miracles that you believe in that you haven't seen. So what what's the distinction for these other kinds of miracles?
Speaker 5The ones that I have not seen?
Speaker 2Yeah, like you say that you believe in miracles, or at least there are some miracles. So why do you have more credibility towards those miracles?
Speaker 5So I believe– well, part of the reason why I believe that miracles are possible is because I have a God belief, right? So I think necessarily if you believe in Christianity, if you're a Christian, I think that you– by definition as a Christian and the worldview of Christianity believe that miracles are at least possible even if they're
Speaker 5not current day or even if in your life they're not necessarily plausible via your experience.
Speaker 2Yeah, I would agree with you. To be consistent and to be Christian, I think that makes sense.
Speaker 1Yeah, I agree.
Speaker 5Yeah.
Speaker 2But does that mean– so like the miracles in the Bible, like those are good, but every miracle claim after that is suspect?
Speaker 1Like what is that– what does that look like?
Speaker 5I wouldn't say that every miracle claim after that is necessarily suspect. I would say once again– and this is where you and I, Dan, are going to disagree is– You say that these particular writers are not eyewitnesses and that they are anonymous. I think just because a particular document in ancient history is anonymous doesn't mean that there
Speaker 5can't be.
Speaker 7An establishment of authorship.
Speaker 5I mean... That kind of seems to be the vibe of ancient.
Speaker 3Isn't that what anonymous means?
Speaker 5Greco-Roman biography, right? So, like, Plutarch writes, you know, his, what is it, 12 lives, and he doesn't put his name on any one of them. But, you know, the consensus of, you know, the Greco-Roman audience during his, you know, during his time and even after his time is like, Plutarch.
Speaker 7Wrote those, and it's not really disputed.
Speaker 5So I don't know why, if the Gospels are Greco-Roman.
Speaker 7Biographies, even though they're anonymous, you can't establish authorship.
Speaker 4Because with Plutarch, we have writings of Plutarch to compare them to. We don't have any writings from Mark to compare the Gospel to.
Speaker 8Right.
Speaker 2And you've got to understand, there's not just a Gospel of Mark, Matthew, Luke, and John. There's also a Gospel of Thomas. There's a Gospel of. There's a gospel of Judas. There's a gospel of Mary. There's a gospel of Philip. There's a gospel of all kinds.
Speaker 3There's a child gospel.
Speaker 2But, you know, the church has largely sort of abandoned these as sources of truth. But the thing is, there were all kinds of other sources of truth in early Christianity.
Speaker 1That's what makes it so suspect.
Speaker 2Why does a true event have so many interpretations of its reality of what happened? I think it's because early church, early Christian people who had no testimony personally to the events, maybe were using this as to push their own theological ideas interpretations of and use their own traditions of stories that they heard. And I think the Gospels that did make it into the Bible also have evidence of this. The evidence of this is that they have narrative events
Speaker 2that seem to contradict each other quite directly, most particularly in the resurrection accounts. I think that's where you find the most differences. But I mean, this goes into a whole other discussion. The fact is, we don't have a consensus as to the current attributions that we have to the Gospels of Mark, Matthew, Luke, and John in biblical scholarship that they were written by those people. If anything, we have evidence to the contrary. They were in Koine Greek, right? And these were Aramaic-speaking people. These were fishermen that didn't
Speaker 2have literacy, likely. At best, they used somebody else to write down their words, but we don't have direct evidence of that either.
Speaker 1That's also just speculation.
Speaker 5Which one of these things do you want me to talk about first?
Speaker 2I mean, whatever you feel called to, Dean, I know that's a lot of info, but if we're going to the route of.
Speaker 1I want to keep it high level, at least on the miracles.
Speaker 2If your miracle belief is based on these testimonies being reliable, I would question that.
Speaker 1I'd question that.
Speaker 5I think I would disagree with you, Dan, in that just because there are different interpretations of a particular event that automatically means that that event did not happen, right?
Speaker 1I don't think it's automatic, but I think it should be suspect.
Speaker 6Yeah, I do.
Speaker 5Well, that happens, you know, even today that takes place, right?
Speaker 7Yeah.
Speaker 5I mean, even today, like I passed, on the road, I passed an eight-car pileup And you're going to ask the witnesses of that eight-car pileup, what happened? And they're going to give you a different interpretation of those particular events. Now, I understand that these documents are written, you know, after the events.
Speaker 7And they're written, you.
Speaker 5Know, during a significant time after those events.
Speaker 7I would grant you that.
Speaker 5But I would say that just because there are different interpretations doesn't mean that that particular event or the.
Speaker 7Events that they're describing.
Speaker 5didn't happen i think the other piece that i would say.
Speaker 2The problem is they're describing different events entirely like entirely right like the number of like who who witnessed jesus when they be first resurrected was it did he just visit the boys or was it some women that came to him first right did he did he witness to a group of 500 like paul says Or was it something else? I mean, there's these different ideas that don't seem to line up. But besides all this, Dean, right, I could grant you that the Gospels are written by
Speaker 2the people that have their names on the cover, right? Does that give more credence to the miracle claims just because we know who wrote those accounts?
Speaker 1I'm not sure that that does.
Speaker 5Yeah. I don't know that it's an automatic one-to-one.
Speaker 7I would agree with you there.
Speaker 5I don't know that it's an automatic one-to-one just because those particular.
Speaker 1Names are on there.
Speaker 5It automatically means.
Speaker 7That those things took place.
Speaker 1Yeah, I would grant you that.
Speaker 5But in the inverse of what you said earlier, I.
Speaker 7Do think that.
Speaker 5If you have those particular names and those are actually the people that wrote it, you get closer to, instead of anonymous, maybe even secondhand testimony, you get closer to original eyewitness testimony. Would you agree with that? If those are actually the people that did write it?
Speaker 2I think there were 12 witnesses to, I think there are, well, 11 special witnesses plus Joseph Smith to the golden.
Speaker 1Tablets, right?
Speaker 2And I don't think those are real either. And that's even more modern in history, you know? Like, I don't know if that gives more emphasis or more truth to these things being real.
Speaker 5Well, I think there's also the question of Were there people, and I'm no Mormon scholar by.
Speaker 7Any stretch of the imagination.
Speaker 5I'm an entry-level Mormon expert at best, which is why I don't go to Utah, right?
Speaker 1Fair enough. Although you should go to Utah because it's beautiful.
Speaker 3Yeah, Utah is beautiful.
Speaker 1It's amazing.
Speaker 5I've been to Utah once.
Speaker 7I've been to Utah once.
Speaker 5Way back when. So my point would be, and once again, this is for anybody who is a Mormon scholar, who isn't a Mormon scholar. I just don't know. So I'm asking this question strictly because of my ignorance. Are there instances of people who were close to Joseph Smith who later. You know, recanted that particular belief about.
Speaker 1Yes.
Speaker 2I mean, no, there, there are people that, well, so they, they didn't recant their testimony that that's what Mormons will tell you, which is true, but they did leave the church. But here's another thing, Dean. We don't know what happened to the 12 disciples. The most we know about is Peter, right? And then from there on, it kind of gets more ambiguous. We have church traditions about what happens, but largely the other disciples of Jesus are absent in the literature. We
Speaker 2have no idea really concretely what happens.
Speaker 1With these other folks.
Speaker 2It could very well be that these other folks recanted and left. I mean, there's a lot of mysteries to early Christianity that we simply don't have the answers to.
Speaker 5Now, here's where I might get in trouble with you. I would reference you to Sean McDowell's book, The Fate of the Apostles, the updated edition. Now, Sean, I think of all of the Christian apologists that are out there, gives the fairest assessment possible. Of what happens Because he mentions things like you said Like when we talk about What happened to Thomas.
Speaker 7There are these Thomistic Christians.
Speaker 5In India But you know hey Here's the fair evidence for Is that the case Or is that plausibly not the case So I would say I would reference you there to To him if you want The fair Probably one of the fairest treatments that could be given by a Christian within the Christian worldview.
Speaker 7Of those guys.
Speaker 5But I also think that you're right. I think, you know, it's clear with regards to the New Testament, there's this narrative that takes place within the Gospels. You get to Acts, you know, the last time that we see the 11 plus Matthias, that'd be 12. The last time we see them really together is in the early part of Acts. And then really after Acts chapter 10, we really don't even hear much from Peter again until I think it's
Speaker 5like Acts 15 of the Jerusalem Council. So I grant you that there's not a lot known about what takes place.
Speaker 1After that.
Speaker 5But I don't think, and you tell me this, like, do you think that it's an argument from silence to say, Based upon the historical evidence that we do have, it's more probable than not that the earliest disciples of Jesus didn't recant their faith.
Speaker 1I can't evaluate that.
Speaker 4No idea.
Speaker 3There's no way to tell.
Speaker 2It's interesting that we have the writings that we do of Christianity for sure, right? I mean, we can't expect to have surviving accounts of everybody that came at that time because, first of all, like I already mentioned, at least half, if not more, of those disciples could not read or write, right? They just didn't have the education to do that. So it's just, it's, it would be, uh, it would be weird if we had testimony from all of them, but we don't, we don't have it. And so I, it's not something I can evaluate, but I, I,
Speaker 2I'm not erring on the side of, um, oh, therefore they all recanted or therefore they're all the same. I'm just saying, I don't know. I, I, I don't know what, I don't know what evidence Sean McDowell managed to rake up that, that, that other.
Speaker 1People haven't been able to figure out, but yeah.
Speaker 5That's unfair to Sean to say that.
Speaker 7He raked it up.
Speaker 1Why? Well, Sean McDowell is not a historian. He's an apologist. So I don't know what historical methodology is. he used.
Speaker 2As far as I'm aware, he doesn't have a training in the discipline, and it's not his specialty.
Speaker 3I don't understand why that verb is negative. Am I missing something?
Speaker 5Well, I would just say, have you read the book?
Speaker 1No, I haven't read the book.
Speaker 3Seriously, why is that a negative verb?
Speaker 1I'm not disparaging him. I'm just saying he is not.
Speaker 2If I hear a novel theory of disease from somebody that's not a doctor, how much credence am I going to put into that? Now I'm going to have a novel historical interpretation of several figures from history from somebody that's not a historian.
Speaker 1Is it wise of me to take that person's opinion? Based on a book. I mean, maybe he's got good research.
Speaker 5I don't know.
Speaker 1I'd have to look at it. But on the face of it, I should be suspect.
Speaker 2Yeah.
Speaker 8Okay.
Speaker 5I would just say look at it and see what you think is raked up and what isn't.
Speaker 2But what am I going to get from that, Dean? Let's say you move me on the needle and I say, okay, the other disciples didn't recant.
Speaker 1So what?
Speaker 2Yeah. Yeah.
Speaker 5So the issue there would be it would not be a fair comparison to compare the earliest disciples who didn't recant their faith.
Speaker 2No, the Mormons– I already expressed that the Mormons, the 11 witnesses, did not recant their testimony either.
Speaker 1Mormons are very particular about this point.
Speaker 5But they did– But what you said is that they did leave.
Speaker 2Some of them did leave the church, yes, but they did not recant their testimony. Now, I would be of the same mind as you. Listen, let me finish. I would be of the same mind of you to say, yeah, that should point to something.
Speaker 5Right?
Speaker 1If you're leaving the church, that should point to something. I agree. I agree.
Speaker 2I don't know the ins and outs of what the disciples did and who left and who didn't.
Speaker 1I know at least one of.
Speaker 2Them betrayed Jesus. He wasn't a big fan. So that I have at least have one of them, but I don't know what happened with the others. I'd have to look at Sean McDowell stuff. The point is people are still mistaken, man. You know who else had a bunch of people and like, like people were following Jim Jones to the very end. People were following, um, you know, um, all kinds of folks to the very end. And I, I don't know if that necessarily points to some, somebody being more, more credible in that instance.
Speaker 1You know, um, all we can.
Speaker 2Say is, yeah, there's some people that really believed in Jesus and maybe that can give me pause, but that still doesn't give me any basis for miracles for today.
Speaker 1I'll tell you that.
Speaker 5Um, I see. I, I just will, uh, respectfully disagree in the sense that, in this particular.
Speaker 7Sense, I do think that.
Speaker 2It is, it.
Speaker 5Would be telling if you did have these disciples and they were, you know, first-person witnesses to what they.
Speaker 3Believe they saw.
Speaker 2Dean, there are people who went on the Long Island Medium that say that, oh, wow, she really did talk to my dead grandma. Am I supposed to believe them too? This is just people's testimony. I don't know if that.
Speaker 4there were people there were people that there were people that witnessed when they dug up the card of giant too.
Speaker 2Yeah there's people that went to see david blaine this year i'm assuming he's still doing magic and like that guy like did some magic he did you know like and they're and they can be fully convinced of that i don't know if that means he really did it though right sure i.
Speaker 5Agree with you about david blaine so here's my question and instead of me going down the the long rabbit trail.
Speaker 2Okay. And then please let, and just, we've been on for 30 minutes now and.
Speaker 1I have other folks that want to talk.
Speaker 2So let's let, let's wrap it up with this question and then, and then move on from there if that's okay.
Speaker 8Sure.
Speaker 5Is there, is there any amount of historical testimony that would convince you that any miracle is true?
Speaker 3No, because that's not unambiguous and empirical.
Speaker 2Yeah.
Speaker 3I mean, like, Simply put.
Speaker 2You know, like you could point to like the Fatima stuff. I mean, people are like, wow, there's a bunch of people that kind of stuff. But we don't even know how many people saw that. The number changes every time people talk about it. I mean, if we're talking about a witness to a historical event that is natural and means my my my need for believability is less. than something that has literally never occurred in history, right? If it's something that has literally never occurred in history, I'm going to need more than just eyewitness testimony to that
Speaker 2because that's just, I think, the reasonable position to have. Otherwise, anytime that anybody's made an eyewitness to something like a David Blaine shit is going to be like, oh, wow, 500 people saw David Blaine last night and they swear he moved a tiger through that woman. And that must mean that that was real. Like that's that's just not enough.
Speaker 5Right.
Speaker 2That's just not a reasonable enough thing to conclude. I know it's a bit different because. there's a strict performance there. But people are charlatans in history, right? People come up with claims and people deceive others. And that's something that we have to keep in mind with this.
Speaker 4That's why I mentioned the Cardiff Giant, because we all know that was a huge hoax, right? And they left it half buried so that witnesses could say that they unburied.
Speaker 3It, that it was found that way, right?
Speaker 4And it was a huge hoax, but there were witnesses to it being unburied. So, I mean, just because you have some witnesses there at the time doesn't mean that they were not fooled, that they weren't conned, right?
Speaker 3That's one of the things.
Speaker 4And before we do take off, Dean, there was an English mathematician, John Littlewood. I mention him all the time. He came up with Littlewood's law. We don't need to go into detail, but it's pretty cool. It's a pretty good mathematical law. Look it up when you got a chance, and I think that explains a large portion of miracles.
Speaker 5Okay. Gotcha. Real quick before we go, is there any way off air, Kelly, I need to get your information. I'd like to do a public discussion with you and a public discussion if Dan's interested at some point with some college students.
Speaker 1You can email the show tv at atheist-community.org.
Speaker 2It's also in the description for any kinds of stuff like that.
Speaker 1Cool.
Speaker 5Thank you, guys.
Speaker 1Appreciate it. Thanks, Dean. You have a great.
Speaker 5One.
Speaker 1Long conversation with Dean. Dean's called in before. He is great. He called in.
Speaker 2Dean was one of the first.
Speaker 1Dean's watched the show since year one.
Speaker 8Right.
Speaker 2I've talked to Dean for a while. So I'll let him talk for a bit longer than some other people. I usually don't go on for that long. What's interesting with Dean is I just think that we always like, you know, talk about like Sean McDowell and these other things. I just there's more credence given to these Christian writers now. I see then, then, then I give, and I haven't read Sean McDowell's book. Maybe he's got some points that I need to consider, you know, uh, I'll, I'll, I'll grant that. I haven't read it, but I do know that even if we had all 12 that were like,
Speaker 2oh yeah, he was the real deal. I don't know if that moves the needle enough for me, man, because like anything, there's so much more to it. There's so much more to it than just a guy did some miracles once. They also said you could do miracles again. They said it several times in the gospels. Like, yeah, you pray and stuff happens. Like there's, there's all kinds of, the book of X is all about miracles, right? Of what the early Christian church was doing. And suddenly in the world of recording stuff, We can't show anything. We
Speaker 2have an entire 2000 year history of Christians saying that they perform miracles on other people, demon possessions happening, right? All kinds of stuff. And we don't have anything good for that.
Speaker 4No, no, there's no, no unambiguous empirical evidence for a single one of those things happening.
Speaker 2Yeah, so it's like, I don't care how cool the 12 guys were. I don't care how rock stars they were and how they believed till the end. A lot of people believed till the end at the Waco siege, too. It didn't say anything about the truth of the statements.
Speaker 1It's just, you know, a lot of people believed.
Speaker 2That's not enough. But anyway, I think Dean's a nice guy. He's the first Christian that ever donated to Truth Wanted, as far as I know.
Speaker 7Really?
Speaker 2Yes.
Speaker 3I've always liked Dean. He's always. He's fun to have a conversation with.
Speaker 8Yes.
Speaker 2So anyway, I appreciate you guys. I know it's a longer conversation than I usually grant. I gave Dean some leeway there, even though obviously we disagree. But before we move on to our next call, let me just give a quick shout out to some things here. First of all, if you were in the Austin area, you should follow us on Meetup. Keep up with the community events. You can see what's going on at ACA.show.com. meet up for a philosophy of the stars and game night and all kinds of stuff. And also we want to hear from you. We want to know what you liked, what you thought
Speaker 2was effective and more broadly, what you thought we could do better. You can email us at TV at atheist hyphen community.org and let us know. Another way to support us is by sending super chats. If we get more super chats, we will read them in assuming they of course are appropriate and Um, and, um, last but not least, um, you know, well, actually I should also say.
Speaker 1You know, like, and subscribe, enable notifications, all that good stuff. You know, that's a given.
Speaker 2I hope you're doing that to all the content careers you like, but last but not least, I need to send a big thank you out to the crew who put this show together every single week.
Speaker 1Maybe we can see that crew cam real quick. Thanks, crew. That's what's happening. That's what's up. Look at that. Awesome folks who are doing great stuff. Appreciate you all.
Speaker 2Um before we move on kelly was there anything else you want to add am i done ranting about.
Speaker 4No that was good i didn't have something that i forgot but it was okay i really did i had i was like you know i'm going to add something to the end of it oh i remember when you were talking about you know getting a hold of us and letting us know about the show right definitely let definitely write in and tell the crew and dan what a great job they're doing because people always write in and tell them how bad they are And they never get any good mail either.
Speaker 3So send Dan and the crew a.
Speaker 2Yeah, you know, Kelly gets about 100 bad messages a day. We don't tell him about it. We put it– we hide that. We delete it before it gets to his inbox. You know, send some stuff to Kelly too. He really needs this. I'm fucking around. I don't think I've ever seen anything negative come in for Kelly. Um, but, um, no, seriously, media opportunities are always available for, I did an interview for a podcast this week for somebody TV at atheist, have a beauty.org.
Speaker 1If, if, if you want to talk to a host for any of your media opportunities, um, let's go ahead and move on.
Speaker 2Um, dude, we got, man, I want to, Ann's been waiting for a while, but we also have somebody in the queue named Gohan.
Speaker 1And I kind of want to talk to Gohan. Um, I haven't talked. I've talked. I'm pretty sure I've talked to Ann before. I wonder, what do you think, Kelly? Should we talk to Ann? Because Ann's been waiting.
Speaker 3It's up to you.
Speaker 4I mean, I believe I've talked to both of them before.
Speaker 1I don't know that I've talked to Gohan. Ann, I'm sorry. I know you've been waiting a while. I'm going to wait.
Speaker 2I think you're a real one, and you're going to be able to wait for just a little bit longer. I want to talk to Gohan real quick. That's me being selfish.
Speaker 1I'm sorry.
Speaker 2But Gohan is calling to me. Beard's shaking his head. Listen, you don't know, okay? You might do the same thing if you're in my position.
Speaker 1Don't judge. I see you, all right?
Speaker 6Anyway, no, he wouldn't.
Speaker 5I want to say sorry to Anne.
Speaker 2You know, Gohan, we're talking about, apparently you want to talk to us about utilitarian and absolute morals.
Speaker 1Did I make the utilitarian choice in talking to you? I don't know. Anne's still in the queue. We're going to get to Anne.
Speaker 2We're going to get to Anne, but let's talk to you first, Gohan.
Speaker 1What's up?
Speaker 8Yeah, so I talked to you a couple weeks, I think it was about three weeks ago, about this topic. I was trying to see if we could continue our conversation.
Speaker 1Okay.
Speaker 8It was about there being two main, and you corrected me when I said this, I said the only two are utilitarian or absolute, and you said there are others, and that's true.
Speaker 3Yes.
Speaker 8I think the two main outlooks on morality are either utilitarian morality or absolute morality.
Speaker 1Where did you get this idea from?
Speaker 5Um.
Speaker 8I guess thinking about it myself, I don't know.
Speaker 1Well, did you know that they actually do surveys?
Speaker 2They do surveys on philosophy departments and philosophy researchers, and they actually have a consensus on the percentages of what people's morality looks like.
Speaker 1Did you know that, or what their views are?
Speaker 8I can believe it. No, I didn't know that, but yeah, it makes sense that they would be doing that.
Speaker 2Dude, the PhilPapers survey is a polling project that actually analyzes and collects philosophical views from professional philosophers. So I'm doing this to say that your question, this assumption that this is where people lie, is actually an empirical one. You can actually measure that. You can actually see how people line up on this spectrum. And there is data to show. And I think you might be surprised. It might be more diverse still. then you might give it
Speaker 2credit for.
Speaker 8Well, I think regardless of what that data says, it wouldn't be able to answer the question of if morality is absolute or if it's utilitarian.
Speaker 1You're absolutely right.
Speaker 8Regardless of what the majority of people say, that doesn't actually answer the question.
Speaker 1You're definitely right about that.
Speaker 2It is surveyological— I don't know if that's the right word— in nature, right? It's just, it's just catching the field, but you know, in just talking about, well, is it either this or this, right? There's still a binary there that may be a kind of a false binary, right?
Speaker 1There may be other ways.
Speaker 8Right.
Speaker 5Exactly.
Speaker 1Well, I was right. I was cooking last time. I still think I'm right.
Speaker 5For the sake of a call, I would like.
Speaker 8To pretend, even though I understand that's not the case, but I would like to pretend the two options are either utilitarian or absolute morality.
Speaker 1Why? Why? Why should I pretend that if that's not the case?
Speaker 8Because I think the other options are like no like amoral systems or systems I already reject anyways. So, I mean, like I believe there is a such thing as morality and I see it as either being goal oriented or not.
Speaker 5Okay.
Speaker 2So we have to reject everything else, every other conclusion that every other person has made because you personally reject it?
Speaker 1I'm confused. I don't know if I like this hypothetical that I have to follow.
Speaker 5You guys don't have to do anything. You guys don't have to do anything. I have to. So I have.
Speaker 8To, since I do accept that morality exists, I have to figure out Is it something that I just feel or is it an absolute truth? Is it just my subjective feelings based on like utilitarian views? Like I don't want bad things to happen, therefore bad things are evil? Or is it things are evil regardless.
Speaker 5If they have a bad outcome?
Speaker 8They're just evil just because they are evil.
Speaker 2You could, or what if morality exists, but we don't really know how to, what if it's unknowable? That's a conversation we had on Talk Heathen like an hour ago with somebody, right? What if morality is objective, but it's beyond human comprehensibility?
Speaker 1There's an idea.
Speaker 2I mean, like I said, it's just, what's the, what's the point of putting things in a false binary?
Speaker 1I just, I don't get it, man. I don't get it. Why, why, why limit yourself?
Speaker 5Because I, let me just say, last time.
Speaker 8You asked me a pretty decent question, it was something like, I don't remember the exact scenario, but you gave me a scenario and you asked me, is it absolutely like, is it good or bad? Is this the morally right choice? And I said, I don't know what the right answer is, but as long as there is a right answer, then that means I believe there's absolute morality. If I don't believe there's a right answer, then I'm a utilitarian. If I do believe there's a right answer, then I believe
Speaker 8in absolute morality.
Speaker 4Do you mean like an objective morality, something that's like the same for everybody when you say absolute?
Speaker 8No, because objective morality can still be utilitarian. utilitarian is tied to a goal.
Speaker 5But like if the goal is uh betterment of.
Speaker 8Uh humanity the flourishing of humanity that didn't really okay can you ask it again.
Speaker 4Yeah when you say absolute right what do you mean by basically i'm asking what you mean by absolute do you mean objective like free of any other mind that it's the same for everybody.
Speaker 8I would say objective is not a strong enough word to describe absolute, because absolute objective could still describe utilitarian.
Speaker 3So can objective.
Speaker 1Sorry?
Speaker 3So can objective. That's why I'm a little confused.
Speaker 8Yes, objective can describe utilitarian, which is why.
Speaker 1No, no, but Kelly, he's saying that's why he's saying absolute.
Speaker 4Yeah, but I'm trying to understand what exactly he means by absolute. Like, who decides what the absolute is?
Speaker 5Nobody decides.
Speaker 7It's recognized.
Speaker 8Like, the laws of math are absolute regardless of the outcome. They aren't decided upon. They're recognized.
Speaker 1Same with the.
Speaker 8Laws of morality.
Speaker 3I don't think morality works like math.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 2So that would be an example of a universe. I think that's the distinction. We kind of talked about this last time, right? The distinction between objective and universal morality, right? So a universalist position would be that something is true or observable regardless of time or place, right? Which is different from something being objective, right? which is something that's mind independent. Okay, so they're kind of similar, but they're actually kind of different. But from what I'm hearing, it sounds like you're describing a universalist morality. In other words,
Speaker 2morality is not just a right or wrong thing. It's also a fact of the universe that can be discovered.
Speaker 8Yeah, I'm fine with using that term.
Speaker 6Sure.
Speaker 1Okay.
Speaker 8And it's not, my big point is it's not anything that's tied.
Speaker 1To a goal.
Speaker 5I think the only way for.
Speaker 8An atheist to have some form of morality would be a utilitarian view, which is tied to a goal, which makes me reject all forms of atheistic morality. It leads me only to atheistic morality, which would.
Speaker 5Be a form of morality.
Speaker 2That's what's crazy is that I'm an atheist and I don't, I just don't think that way. I actually, I think my morality, my morality aligns more with a negative consequentialist view, right?
Speaker 1So not even utilitarian.
Speaker 8That is a utilitarian.
Speaker 5It's like the goal.
Speaker 1No, it's not. Utilitarian means that it's duty bound, right?
Speaker 3Utilitarian means you choose the least bad outcome.
Speaker 2That's not the same thing as consequentialism though, because, a utilitarian, for example, would say lying is bad under any circumstances, whereas a consequentialist would say it depends on what happens if you lie. If you're lying to save the Jewish girl for being picked up from the Germans, that's OK. A utilitarian would say, no, you're you're doing a bad thing for lying.
Speaker 1You shouldn't lie.
Speaker 8Right.
Speaker 1That's that's the distinction. I agree. They are not the same thing.
Speaker 8Sorry, I disagree really quick. A utilitarian 100% can say lying is good as long as it helps to achieve the goal.
Speaker 2Emmanuel Kant would disagree with you, I think. So would David Hume. I don't think that's true. Tell me why.
Speaker 8They would disagree with me other than that.
Speaker 2They've literally talked about this. I didn't make up that argument about the lying stuff. Like Immanuel Kant has talked about the duty-bound ideas of lying, right? In order to be a true utilitarian, you have to have these concepts in place and follow them to their logical conclusions. So they are absent of the consequences. That's why they are different moral philosophies. They're not the same.
Speaker 8No, utilitarianism is dependent on the consequences. It's not absolute consequences.
Speaker 2No, it's not dependent on the consequences. I'm sorry, this is not what the literature suggests. I highly recommend starting with the Wikipedia article on utilitarianism and then looking at consequentialism and seeing that they are different things.
Speaker 8Okay, so maybe let me just say, maybe I have my terms 100% incorrect. Let me just say this. Instead of using terms that are out of my field, I reject all forms of morality that are dependent upon consequences. I accept all forms of morality that just are, irregardless of consequences.
Speaker 1You might be described as a utilitarian.
Speaker 8Sure.
Speaker 1Which is different from consequentialist.
Speaker 8Right. OK, then if I have my terms 100 percent mixed up, then I will start to describe myself as utilitarian with somebody who does not base morality upon its consequences.
Speaker 1Yeah, I mean, that's fine.
Speaker 2I would say look into what utilitarianism is before you decide this for yourself. Get familiar with the terms before you make declarations because you might find that you need to update yourself and change, and that's fine.
Speaker 1That's the human experience.
Speaker 2I don't use the same words to describe my morality that I did five years ago.
Speaker 5Right.
Speaker 2But, you know, it's important that we keep these terms distinct and defined for a reason.
Speaker 8Right.
Speaker 2Otherwise, we're already disagreeing on on on our meanings here. And and to make broad statements about what an atheist can or can't be when we can't even have a clarity on what these terms are.
Speaker 1That leaves that leaves me.
Speaker 2Lacking for for an explanation on on why I should trust your conclusion.
Speaker 5Yeah, I think that's fair. If I'm wrong, I'm still not 100% sold.
Speaker 8I still think utilitarianism is built upon goals.
Speaker 5But let's just say I'm 100% wrong on that.
Speaker 8Then let me stop using that term and just say goal-oriented morality is a morality I reject. I think all atheistic views on morality are built off of goal-oriented morality.
Speaker 1I mean, I, I don't, that's just not true. I don't know. There's not, not everyone's utilitarian.
Speaker 8Can you describe to me a, uh, goal oriented morality that, uh, or can you describe to me an atheistic morality that's not built off of goals?
Speaker 3I don't know of any morality. It's not based off of goals. I, I, that's no.
Speaker 1There's morality is not based on goals. I don't, I don't know.
Speaker 3Where have we ever had that?
Speaker 2No, Kelly, I'm telling you, no, there are, there are moralities that aren't focused on goals and virtue, virtue ethics, virtue ethics is not, it's not a consequentialist. It's not, it does not rely on, on, on that sort of thing. Virtue ethics can, can, can, can be argued as, as one example of that, right? This idea that a pursuit of, of, of things because they are virtuous for the sake of it. Right. I guess you could say that that's a goal, but it's, it's, it's a bit more distinct.
Speaker 8I guess.
Speaker 3To me, you just described the goal of virtuism. Can any atheist do that, though?
Speaker 1Can any atheist do that? Be a virtue ethicist? I mean, sure.
Speaker 3Yeah.
Speaker 1Why not?
Speaker 5How?
Speaker 8You have to ask where do those morals come from? How is it absolutely wrong?
Speaker 1Because.
Speaker 2Okay, so deontology, right, is... is is is being described for your duties you have you can have duties towards something right whereas a virtue ethicist can can have um uh can can pursue virtues for the sake of virtues themselves it doesn't it the the ontology of those virtues do not have to be objective right or universal in order to be worth pursuing for some people can you
Speaker 2explain that part again They do not have to be objective or universal to be worth pursuing, right? You could run a cat shelter because you love cats and you think cats are great, right? You don't have to be like, oh, my goal is to save all the cats in the city. You could just have a cat shelter because you like helping cats, right? There's no consequentialist end goal there. There's no larger, broader reasoning other than that.
Speaker 8That is a consequentialist end goal. The end goal is your happiness improves with helping cats.
Speaker 2It could, but that may not be the reason why I go volunteer at a cat shelter.
Speaker 1It could be just because I like seeing the cats.
Speaker 5It's not because you love cats.
Speaker 8You just do it because you think it's correct, not because you love cats.
Speaker 1No, it doesn't have to be correct. It could just be because I like cats. This is my point. It doesn't have to be.
Speaker 8Yeah, but that's goal-oriented. That's to make you happy. If you don't love cats or if you're not doing it because you love cats, then it's not goal-oriented. But if you're doing it because you love cats, that's goal-oriented.
Speaker 5If I'm doing something because of X, X is a goal.
Speaker 2But I'm not saying... But where's the goal in saying I like cats?
Speaker 5Your own happiness. Improving your own happiness.
Speaker 1But what.
Speaker 5I....
Speaker 2Improving my own happiness is sort of i think outside of the statement i like cats if i'm doing something because i like cats i mean i guess i guess you could argue there's an implication there that it's to improve my own happiness but what if i like cats because uh i just think they're neat i don't know is that is that is that going to improve my happiness to volunteer at the shelter I mean, I don't know.
Speaker 8If it was a true virtue, you might do it regardless if you like cats or not.
Speaker 5Does that make sense?
Speaker 1I mean, yeah, I guess I see where you're going with this.
Speaker 2I just think it's a bit reductionist to just say all atheists have to view things this way in order for them to be consistent. I just don't think all moral systems are consistent either. I think that's, you know, that's part of it. I think you're saying in order for them to be consistent, they have to be goal oriented.
Speaker 1And maybe, maybe that's true.
Speaker 2But that doesn't mean that's what all atheists are doing.
Speaker 8I don't know. Sorry, let me back up. It's not all atheists, but the vast majority of atheists that I have spoken to, which is not raw data, it's just empirical data for myself. From what I've understood is you guys have tried to get your morality, which is.
Speaker 5Sometimes better than even my morality, but you try.
Speaker 8To get your morality from goal orientation, which is the betterment of humanity. And I'm going to say I think that's a terrible foundation for morality, even if it is, even if you are more moral than I am, which a lot of you guys are, but your foundation is not good. The betterment of humanity can never be a good.
Speaker 3Foundation for morality. That's not what I base my morality on, but that's cool. Actually, I know very few.
Speaker 4When I talk to atheists a lot, that's not something that most of them tell me that they base their morality on. It's based on whether they're doing harm to another person or not.
Speaker 1Okay. Yeah, that's true.
Speaker 8Maybe I was talking more about secular humanists, but let me say that.
Speaker 4I think that what I just said holds true for most secular humanists I know as well.
Speaker 5I thought secular humanists had.
Speaker 8A part of their rules is that to be a secular humanist, you have to want what's better for humanity. You have to want the increased flourishing or the well-being of humanity.
Speaker 4That doesn't mean you have to base all of your morality on that. You can still base your morality on whether or not you're hurting the person standing next to you or not.
Speaker 1Right, which is a consequentialist, a negative consequentialist view.
Speaker 4In the end, if you're not hurting that person, you are bettering all of humanity, right?
Speaker 8Yeah.
Speaker 2So sometimes goals can be aligned, but not every atheist is a secular humanist. Some of them are Satanists. Some of them say we should do it because our will wants it.
Speaker 1And that's it.
Speaker 5That's fair.
Speaker 3Yeah, that's fair.
Speaker 5So I'm going to not say every. I'm going to say most. And if you're including, I equivocate.
Speaker 3I wouldn't even say most.
Speaker 2Again, the most thing, like this isn't a empirical thing. You can figure that, like this is something you can survey. This is why I brought this up earlier where it's like you can actually, you can figure out what how people think about this you don't have to guess.
Speaker 8Well kelly for your uh view of morality to do the least harm to humanity that is also a um morality that a basis for morality that.
Speaker 3I reject That's cool.
Speaker 4I mean, if you don't think hurting people next year is a bad form of morality, do me a favor and don't move next door to me.
Speaker 2Yeah, this is what I find interesting, Gohan, is that you say that you think that there are atheists that are even more moral than you, but at the same time, we have an absolute foundation that isn't somehow workable to reality that's bad. And I find that very strange. I don't know how those two things can be true, but maybe.
Speaker 1You can enlighten me.
Speaker 8Yeah, if I could give an example.
Speaker 2Very briefly, because I do want to get to Anne as well. We're getting close to the end of the show. I would love it if we could try to wrap things up.
Speaker 1Yeah, that's fine.
Speaker 8You could argue that the Thanos snap was done to prevent more harm to humanity. Yes.
Speaker 1Well, in a very fucked up way. That was one way, yeah.
Speaker 3You could also argue that it totally harmed humanity.
Speaker 1Yeah, you could also argue it harmed people.
Speaker 5I mean, I don't know.
Speaker 3Totally bad example, man. Totally bad example.
Speaker 5Let's say Thanos was.
Speaker 8Right, and he weighed the harm of humanity after the Thanos snap, and that was actually less than if he never did a Thanos snap. So that would mean in your view of morality, Thanos was right and he.
Speaker 5Should have snapped his fingers.
Speaker 6No, it's not.
Speaker 3No, it's not at all. I don't know how you drew that conclusion.
Speaker 4Yeah, I have no idea how you drew that conclusion.
Speaker 3Because it reduced.
Speaker 5Because it reduced the harm of humanity the most.
Speaker 4I just told you that's not what I made my morality on.
Speaker 1I don't think people agree with that.
Speaker 8Yeah, to reduce the harm of humanity.
Speaker 3No, that's not what I just told you.
Speaker 4I didn't make my morality on that, though.
Speaker 8Well, I thought you said it was to reduce harm.
Speaker 5What was it? Maybe I misheard.
Speaker 4What's not going to harm the person standing next to me. I do not want to hurt people. And it has nothing to do with humanity. I just don't want to hurt people.
Speaker 6Period.
Speaker 2Yeah, if I snap Kelly away from existence, that's going to hurt his family, his friends, other people that like Kelly and want him to be on Earth. So I don't know how you justify that and say, wow, this is great, actually.
Speaker 8People are humanity. I mean, those two words are interchangeable.
Speaker 4A person is not humanity. I'm sorry, but that is not interchangeable. That is not. And if you think that's interchangeable, you need to find a dictionary and look up both definitions.
Speaker 1Gohan, I got to let you go because we're running out of time.
Speaker 5No, thank you.
Speaker 1I appreciate it. Go look into Immanuel Kant, okay? Go look into Immanuel Kant. See what he was about. And then let's discuss next time, all right?
Speaker 2And let's figure out the difference between utilitarian... in deontology and consequentialism and all this fun stuff.
Speaker 1Sound good?
Speaker 5All right.
Speaker 8Yep.
Speaker 1Talk to you again. All right. Thanks, Gohan.
Speaker 2Okay, I'm moving very quickly because I promised Anne we would talk to her.
Speaker 1Anne has been waiting for over an hour.
Speaker 2And I talked to Gohan first, and I feel bad about it. Anne, you're live on Truth Wanted. We only have a few minutes. I really appreciate you waiting.
Speaker 1I'm sorry.
Speaker 2I was too tempted by the name Gohan, and that was a moral failing on my part. Whether I caused harm to my fellow human, I'm not sure. Maybe I caused harm to you. In that sense, I'm sorry.
Speaker 1Anne, what's up? What's happening? Anne, are you there?
Speaker 5Oh, no. Oh, no.
Speaker 1Oh, the call dropped.
Speaker 8Oh, no.
Speaker 1It was terminated. No, we didn't even get to talk to Anne. We didn't. I failed. Who Thanos snapped Anne?
Speaker 2Was this you, Kelly?
Speaker 3No, it wasn't me.
Speaker 1We just talked about this. We said it was bad. Was it Gohan? I'm watching you go on.
Speaker 3Is he the one Thanos snapping in?
Speaker 1I don't know. I don't know.
Speaker 2Well, we got like a couple minutes here, but we need to start wrapping things up. Um, I want to thank, uh, go on. It was good talking to you, but we need to get our terms straight.
Speaker 1Okay.
Speaker 2Let's get our terms straight. Let's figure it out. Cause you're, you're obviously a smart guy. I think you can figure I like we've, we've worked.
Speaker 1You've, you've jet.
Speaker 2You, you, you told me that, um, I gave you questions. I gave you pause and that that's always a nice thing to hear. That's a great way to butter me up. So thanks for telling me that we'll talk some more next time we call it for now. I need to give a thanks to everybody that helped make the show today. Thank you to everybody that donated. Thank you to everybody watching. You guys are awesome. I want to give a special thanks to our backup host beard of empathy. Who's been watching through his sick, sick colored microphone. That is very mesmerizing to look at.
Speaker 5I'm not going to lie.
Speaker 2I think it distracted once or twice looking at those are sweet, sweet RGBs beard.
Speaker 1What's up, man. How'd you feel about today's show?
Speaker 6Oh, it was a good show. I enjoyed some of the conversations. I think that the whole idea of what evidence is convincing to us, it's really hard because we don't get to pick that. It's based on what our priors are, the things we already know. Any new information we get is compared to all that. And it's not just one piece of prior information. It's everything surrounding that particular topic.
Speaker 1Right.
Speaker 6I can't tell you what would bypass or overpower all of the evidence surrounding that, any concept. So I don't know. I can't tell you that for sure.
Speaker 4And I think our bias is taped at evidence, too. When we were having that conversation, I was thinking, if you already believe in ancient astronauts... chariots of the gods is a really convincing book.
Speaker 2Right yeah yep i yeah and this is again don't want a shadow box okay i but like it is this is the thing i have with dean in particular when i talk with him and some other folks in the christian community who do tend to have this um i don't know there is like a reference for these early christian writings and it's like oh we really should take credence in this.
Speaker 1I don't know, man.
Speaker 2I don't take any credence from the January 6th people that were there when they say, yeah, it was actually Antifa that was there in the crowd.
Speaker 1I don't know.
Speaker 2That's a firsthand account that I just don't think is there. I think that's a motivated idea. And I think that the early Christians also had a lot of motivated ideas. That's why there are so many freaking gospels that didn't make it to the Bible. They all kind of had different ideas and And that's something to think about. And we shouldn't dismiss them just because the church doesn't think that they're real. But anyway, yeah, this was a great show. I had a lot of fun. Again, thanks to everybody for watching. I always try to leave our words of
Speaker 2wisdom for our guests but you know it's kelly that's here so i don't know what beard i want to give it to you let's give it there you go what's good what's your words of wisdom before.
Speaker 6We go oh i don't know i'll i'll give you the ones that kelly once gave to me and that's always ask the question that's simple as that.
Speaker 1Always ask the question.
Speaker 2Okay all right i like that i'm trying to think of something funny like a funny question to ask but i can't really think of uh one in this.
Speaker 6Only stupid question is the one you don't ask.
Speaker 1Ooh, only stupid questions are the ones you don't ask. Okay.
Speaker 5All right.
Speaker 2Again, trying to think of something funny. I'm not that clever, I guess. It's not coming to me. The audience members can leave a better comment. On that note, thanks everybody for... That's a good idea. Have all the audience members leave your words of wisdom. Leave your words of wisdom today. Also, I'm kind of realizing at the end of the show, I'm.
Speaker 1Dumb here because.
Speaker 2Kant is not a utilitarian He's a deontologist And I was kind of realizing that halfway as I was talking I was like wait that's not right But anyway I was right that Gohan's wrong about Kant But I'm not.
Speaker 1Anyway You can't be serious. I know.
Speaker 2This is why you don't trust podcast hosts to make good statements about what philosophy is because I don't know fuck from hell, from shit.
Speaker 1And you know what? It's showing.
Speaker 2But right now, I have to end the show. That's what I do know. So thank you, Callie. Thank you, Beard, for joining us.
Speaker 1I'll ask questions.
Speaker 2Or regret it that's that's the take i got um tune in next time until next time remember to always keep wanting the truth we'll see you then.
Speaker 4Don't forget to support your local artist and.
Speaker 2Musician yeah do that too i guess.
Speaker 7Unless they suck and.
Speaker 5I won't say who.
Speaker 3Yeah, you got to support him to get better.
Speaker 5Yeah, I don't think he's going to get better.
Speaker 1No, I don't think so either. Watch Talk Heathen Live Sundays at 1 p.m.
Speaker 6Central and call into the show at 512-991-9242.
Speaker 1Or connect to the show online at aca.show slash call.
In today's episode of Truth Wanted, ObjectivelyDan welcomes guest Out Of Body Atheist, with The Beard of Empathy on backup, to dig into Reiki, New Age spirituality, homeopathy, and the long road from woo to skepticism!...
In today's episode of Truth Wanted, Jon the Skeptick, Volcy, and Sofia Spina explain why no one can talk to the dead, from Haitian Vodou and grief dreams to Jon's past as a spiritualist! Bob jumps from objective...
In today's episode of Truth Wanted, ObjectivelyDan and Nintendrew, later joined by The Beard of Empathy, tackle a world run on Jesus, the magic of manifesting, and a prayer that actually got answered! Bob in NY, a...
In today's episode of Truth Wanted, ObjectivelyDan and Chad Harris tackle Christian nationalism, police brutality, and the uncomfortable truths about racism and immigration. Big E in TN survived police brutality and...
In today's episode of Truth Wanted, Kelley Laughlin and Ms. Non Sequitur tackle moral accountability, inherited sin, and whether Christianity's forgiveness model makes sinning too easy! GreatBaisk on TikTok plays...