In today's episode of Truth Wanted, Kelley Laughlin and Ms. Non Sequitur tackle moral accountability, inherited sin, and whether Christianity's forgiveness model makes sinning too easy! GreatBaisk on TikTok plays devil's advocate, arguing Christians don't actually want to sin. The hosts counter that Christianity builds forgiveness directly into the religion, creating a cosmic reset button that makes sin acceptable. If you can always be forgiven, what stops you from doing whatever you want? The discussion turns to inherited sin and Ezekiel 18:30. Does Christianity's guilt-and-forgiveness cycle actually encourage the behavior it claims to condemn? Alex in VA presents a neo-Quinian meta-ontology argument for God's existence. The hosts challenge the complexity of his model and ask what empirical proof distinguishes it from pure speculation. Alex identifies as a deist believing in an immaterial, non-interacting God. If your God doesn't interact with reality, how is that different from a God that doesn't exist? What does your philosophical framework predict that we can test? Thank you for joining us this week! We'll see you next time! Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/truth-wanted--3195473/support.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Speaker 1Christianity offers unlimited forgiveness on the band. Sin, repeat, rinse, repeat. No consequences. If anything, atheists have more reason to behave since there's no cosmic reset button for us. We want to know what's actually keeping you from sinning freely. It's just one prayer away. Call in and make the case that forgiveness is in a loophole because the show is starting right now. Hello, and welcome to another episode of
Speaker 1Truth Wanted. This is a live call-in show we do every Sunday at 2.45 Central, where we want to know what you believe and why you believe it. My name is Kelly Laughlin. I'll be your host today. And as always, we have a very special guest. And my guest today is the wonderful, the lovely Ms. Nan Sekweter. Hi, how are you?
Speaker 2Hi, thanks so much for having me. I'm so excited about this topic when I first heard it. I was just, this is going to be so good. This is going to be so freaking good. So I'm excited about today.
Speaker 1I am excited, too, and I'm hoping everybody out there is excited. And if you want, you can call us at 1-512-991-9242 or use your computer at aca.show slash call. Truth Wanted is a product of the atheist community of Austin, a 501c3 nonprofit organization dedicated to the promotion of atheism, critical thinking, secular humanism, and the separation of religion and government.
Speaker 1I juggled there because you'd think I would have that totally memorized by now. I've said it a million times and I still don't. We are tri-steaming today, though. So I want to give a big shout out to all of our viewers on TikTok and on YouTube mobile. And if you are watching us on TikTok today and you want to talk to us, then request to join. We'll bring you on up. But please make sure you are 18 before doing so. And with that, I think I got all the stuff out of the way and I can come back to you, Mr. Nonsequitur. Hey, how are you?
Speaker 2I'm great.
Speaker 1First off, before we do anything else, tell everybody where they can find you and what you do.
Speaker 2Well, I'm just kind of starting out on TikTok. I've been doing lives for a few months, so that's the first and best place to find me. I take these conversations. Sorry, panelists. And we have really pleasant, usually pleasant conversations about things like belief and the evil god monster and things like that. Just really nice conversations.
Speaker 1Yeah, I think you do something on Wednesdays too, do you not?
Speaker 2Oh, yes. On the Discord, I do Damn Random Chat and Chill. It is on the Daily Atheist Media Network Discord. And I occasionally co-host on the Daily Atheist Morning Show, which is every morning at 9.
Speaker 1Cool, cool, cool. I know I was just hanging out with you the last Wednesday. I used to hang out with you a lot, but we switched something that I do on weekday nights, but I'm back to having my Wednesdays open again. So I hope to show up.
Speaker 2I love having you there. It's so much fun.
Speaker 1Wow, thanks. I don't hear that very often. So I really thought we had a great topic today, and it was something I was thinking about a couple of weeks ago, that we as atheists really do have to not— well, first off, sin is a religious concept, so it's hard for an atheist to sin because— It is an affront against the God.
Speaker 1And since we don't have a God, it's hard to affront one, right? But that aside, there are more things that are morally bad that I think most theists would consider to be sin. And we don't have a way to be absolved from that or to get forgiveness for that. So I think we have to walk a little bit more carefully than, say, most Christians. What do you think of that concept?
Speaker 2Well, I certainly think that... we i'm sorry i'm echoing now oh sorry i forgot to mute myself on.
Speaker 3This i apologize all right i certainly think that we care more about the effects of our actions because we don't feel like we can just be absolved at a moment's whim the moment.
Speaker 2We say i'm sorry daddy i was bad mm-hmm.
Speaker 1Now, I've talked to a lot of Christians about this concept, and all of them always tell me that it's not allowed to sin and then be absolved and just go out and sin and be absolved again. You can't do that. But that doesn't seem like what's done in practice, does it? I mean, to me, from my point of view and from my experience, it seems like that is the way it's used.
Speaker 2Right. I heard a lot about how it's not if you don't truly intend to stop sinning, it's not real repentance. And so it doesn't count. But I think you can truly intend to stop sinning. And then once you've repented and you feel absolved, well, then that intention changes, doesn't it?
Speaker 1Sure, sure, sure. And to like Mike, like I could be repentant of this particular sin.
Speaker 4Right.
Speaker 1And still go out and do another sin and be repented for that one, too. Oh, yeah. So that one wouldn't count as a second strike with the first one.
Speaker 5Right.
Speaker 1Because they were two different sins. I don't know.
Speaker 2Imagine.
Speaker 1I mean, I don't know how that works. I don't have a I used to hit when I was a Christian. I had a pocket sin calculator, but I threw it out when I deconverted.
Speaker 2So, yeah, my pocket sin calculator is is called Sheila. It's the anxiety that lives in the back of my head.
Speaker 1Yeah. So I would love to talk to some Christians about this and see what they think. Absolutely. I know that I've had a lot of conversations about this with Christians. So, you know, give us a call. Let us know what you think. And, you know, if you're an atheist and you want to talk about it too, we'd be happy to talk to you. Well, we are willing, but we'd be happy to as well. So, yeah. Now, how long
Speaker 1have you you said you just started doing your podcast? How long? A few months now. Is that correct?
Speaker 2Yeah, I think it's been two ish that I've been going live before that for I'd say since the beginning of the year, I would frequently join other lives. And that's how I built up enough of a following. to, to go live myself. You don't need a whole lot to do it. And since I I've had enough, I've been, um, going live myself and I've been having a really good time. I'm lucky enough to have some brilliant friends, including the beard of empathy. Who's our backup post tonight who come
Speaker 2on with me regularly and, um, make me look good. So, uh, I, I have a really good time with it. And, um, Yeah, smart friends help answer questions that I don't know the answers to.
Speaker 1That's why I had you on today was to look good. So there you go. I totally understand that concept. What is your favorite topic to talk about on your TikTok channel?
Speaker 2Without a doubt, I love the is belief a choice question. That is my bread and butter. I always have it up. My prompts often change around a bit, but is belief a choice is always there. And it definitely is the one that gets the most responses, too. That is always the one that people most want to talk to when they come in.
Speaker 6Interesting.
Speaker 2And, of course, my position is that belief is not a choice, and therefore it is a horrible, horrible thing to send somebody to an eternity of torment for something that they cannot help. And I have a good time talking about that.
Speaker 1I kind of disagree with you on that, believe it or not. And I know it's a really unpopular opinion. And I do believe that a lot of times you don't choose your belief. I do believe that. But I also think it's possible for you to choose a belief as well, that you can convince yourself of something that you want to believe. I really believe. I think that. And I think that because I feel like I did that to myself once already.
Speaker 2Yeah.
Speaker 1I convinced myself that newage ideology was true.
Speaker 4Newage.
Speaker 2I love how you say it like that.
Speaker 1I say it so it rhymes with sewage. But I really wanted it to be true. I wanted to be one with the universe. I wanted magic to be real. I really, really wanted it. So I started doing. I was counting all the hits and not seeing the misses, right? And that was one of the ways I was convincing myself that this stuff was true. So I think it's possible to make yourself choose to believe something if you really want to.
Speaker 2Well, I guess one of the reasons why I disagree is because I failed so spectacularly at convincing myself of something I really... wanted to believe. So I'll admit there may be some bias there, which is one of the reasons why I like to talk so much about it. Because if somebody convinces me, see, but there you go, you've got to be convinced. Maybe I'll change my belief about it.
Speaker 1I think most people don't choose most of their beliefs. I really think that is true, that probably 98% of the people do not choose 98% of their beliefs. But I think it is possible if you need to do it. So I don't know. What does the chat think? I see a bunch of people talking in chat. What do you guys think?
Speaker 2I'm looking at chat here, too, and.
Speaker 1Hypatia said she chose to be the enemy of monotheists, which I thought was great.
Speaker 2Hypatia is really funny. She's always in the chat in the mornings with us, and she's hilarious. I enjoy her a lot. I see a lot of people that I see elsewhere. Hi, guys.
Speaker 1I was trying to get everybody that you know on here today to support you, so I kept back everybody in the morning. I appreciate that.
Speaker 2Yeah, that makes me less nervous to have friends in the chat.
Speaker 1Yeah, that's what I figured. So let's say you could have any phone call right now to talk about anything. Is that what you'd want to talk about? Can you choose your belief or is there some other topic you'd really like to talk about?
Speaker 2Well, actually, I mean, I'm really excited about today's topic. Because I really think, you know, when you talk about things like, like, the serial killers who just repent at the end of their life and they're going, theoretically, they're going to heaven. And we who are fundamentally decent people, at least, I mean, I can speak for myself. I don't know about Kelly too, but a little shady over there. But, you know, are fundamentally good people and we will be
Speaker 2in torment forever because we don't believe and therefore can't repent. because you can't repent if you don't have a relationship with God and you can't have a relationship with God if you don't believe.
Speaker 1Right, right, right.
Speaker 2So in the end, I, I do, I do notice that a lot of my, uh, conversations end up in that direction eventually, which is one of the reasons why I enjoy that topic so much.
Speaker 1If, uh, You know, sin is such a weird concept to me, and it's one of the things that I argue with theists a lot, because they're always saying that we are the ones that want to sin. We don't have a get-out-of-sin-free card. So it seems like, and it's something that they actually built into their religion. I mean, to me, it seems like they're the ones that want to do all the sinning. It's just more and more projection, right?
Speaker 2They built the whole framework that this person did it so they could just say sorry and oof, no more sin. I mean, they're the ones that designed it that way. I don't see how it's not clear that they at least accept that they're going to sin and they're kind of okay with it because they don't actually feel like they have to pay for it at all.
Speaker 1Right, right. Don't even admit it. We're all sinners. We can't be, you know, we can't, we basically, we can't help but be sinners. Well, geez, you know what? I'm going to do my best to try to be morally good. You know, I might not be a sinner, but I'm definitely going to do my best to be morally good. And when I hear somebody say that they can't help themselves, I just hope that they don't move next door to me. You know, that's, that's what I get out of those conversations. Boy, you know, stay away from me and out of my neighborhood.
Speaker 2One of, one of the prompts I I'll, I'll do sometimes on Tik TOK is if you need the threat of heaven, the threat of, well, to me, it's kind of the threat of heaven. Everything I've heard of the Christian heaven sounds awful, but that's a different story. Uh, the threat of hell or the promise of heaven to be a good person. You're just a bad one on a leash. Um, and, uh, That that is, you know, that is, I think, fundamental to their religion that they just they don't actually have to pay for anything. Somebody
Speaker 2else did that for them and they somehow deserve it just by, I don't know, loving this guy, you know, I guess.
Speaker 1Do you think you can sin in heaven?
Speaker 2I that is a question. That is another one of the prompts. Is there sin in heaven? I have a guest.
Speaker 1Oh, that cat just stole the show.
Speaker 2That is another one of my prompts. And most people tend to tell me, I don't know, because I don't know what heaven's like, but most people tend to tell me that there is no sin in heaven, which I think is really interesting because the other prompt is, is there free will in heaven? And most people tell me, yes, of course there is. So clearly God can create a place where there's no sin and there is free will.
Speaker 1But what if my will is the sin?
Speaker 2Well, that is the question, isn't it?
Speaker 1Then there isn't free will, right? And if there isn't free will in heaven, how did the angels rebel? I have questions, man. I stay up late at night thinking about this shit. Christians call and tell me, explain this stuff to me.
Speaker 2It is puzzling. You know, in the religion I grew up in, I grew up LDS and for certain sins, there is a bit of a repentance process. I don't know if that is true for, for more mainstream Christians, but for bad sins and you know, there's no real strict line. You kind of get to decide what, which is the bad sins, but some, you know, are bad sins. Um, you have to go to the Bishop and you have
Speaker 2to go through this whole process of repentance of praying and, uh, abstaining from taking the sacraments and things, um, for a certain amount of time and until you're worthy again to actually get, uh, forgiven for this grievous sin, which is, you know, probably like masturbation or something. Um, And so that I, I gotta say, I kind of get that a little bit better. It's at least a process. You gotta have to, you gotta at least do something to
Speaker 2kind of earn it. And I almost understand that more than just, sorry, daddy. I was bad. Forgive me, please.
Speaker 4Yeah. Yeah.
Speaker 1Yeah. I, uh, I had something in my mind while you were talking, and it totally sped up. I'm going to admit something right now. I've been having a hard time memorizing things over the last couple of weeks. I've been feeling a lot better this week. I'm so glad to hear it. I forgot my ex-wife's name for like three days. I mean, somebody I was with for 12 years, and I couldn't remember her first name. And you want to hear something really sad? Her first name is Kelli.
Speaker 1So I was having a little bit of aphasia this week. It was a little rough. Or not this week, last week.
Speaker 2That's funny, but distressing as well. I'm glad you're feeling better.
Speaker 1I am too. I really am too. So that's why I forgot what I was going to say. It's actually kind of good that something like that happens. I had a little brain. My brain attacked me, everybody, if you don't know. But it's kind of good to have something like that happen to you every once in a while because you can use it as an excuse. Right?
Speaker 2I just use the ADHD as an excuse mostly. No, I try not to. I try not to. But it hits hard sometimes. It hits real hard sometimes.
Speaker 1Oh, I did get a checked out chemical squirrel. I got good medical help. So I'm just recovering now. Thank you. I appreciate the concern, though.
Speaker 2That's so funny.
Speaker 1That's so funny you should say that, Hypatia, because when I did remember her name, I was talking to a friend of mine and I said, actually, I kind of wished I hadn't. Right along the same vein.
Speaker 2Yeah, I was kind of like thinking, oh, how do I do that?
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 2There are a few exes names I wouldn't mind forgetting.
Speaker 1There's a few just exes I wouldn't mind forgetting at all completely.
Speaker 6There you go.
Speaker 2Yeah.
Speaker 1So, so, so, so, um, I would, I think a lot of, a lot of Christians equate sin with things that are morally bad and they don't realize. I mean, like I talked to a lot of, I'm trying to stay on topic as much as I can.
Speaker 4Yeah.
Speaker 1And they don't and they don't equate sin specifically with God. And that's the way I see it. I mean, that's I mean, even if you look up the definition, it's tied to a religious sin. to religion so when uh it when i say atheists can't sin i i mean that we can't like affront a god that we believe in but christians will say we're still sinning because we're still affronting their god do you agree with that Well.
Speaker 2I think if their God exists, sure. I think I would have to agree with that because, um, their God, uh, is, is real, gets real shirty about, about things like that. He, he just, he's a sensitive guy, sensitive, real sensitive. Um, he, he, uh, doesn't like it when, when people don't remember his in, in general, um, And so he gets real mad when we don't think to repent because we don't believe in him.
Speaker 2I guess. I mean, if he's real, like I said.
Speaker 1You know, earlier... you mentioned that we had beard behind the scenes here and, and beards like a brain guy. He talks about, you know, he knows people's brains and I was wondering if maybe we could bring him up so we can maybe talk some brain stuff with, I.
Speaker 2Would love that. I always love, I always love listening to brain, to beard.
Speaker 1To brain stuff. And I was, I thought maybe we could specifically like, uh, talk about brains and, uh, sins at the, you know, together, like how sinning of would affect, uh, Like, hi there, beard. How are you? Hi, I'm doing all right.
Speaker 4Cool.
Speaker 1So I know. The brain guy.
Speaker 4Yeah, Mr.
Speaker 1Brain Guy. Never been called that before. Does sinning have a, can sinning have a negative or positive effect on somebody's mental health?
Speaker 7I guess it depends on what you would call sin. But I think it more would be more negative in general because it's a self-judgment on activities and moralized actions. judgment on those things. Sometimes we should be feeling bad about certain things, right? And you steal something, guilt is an appropriate response. But some of the things usually, you're not feeling that guilt there, Kelly. We need to talk about some stuff after the show. But in general, some
Speaker 7of the things that are found in the Bible, just it's ridiculous that they're even considered sins. Because there are things that we can't control, can't do anything about. Isn't it Jesus who says that if you look upon a woman with lust in your heart, you've committed the sin of adultery?
Speaker 1One of the big ones.
Speaker 7Except that you can't not. You don't get to control over lust thoughts because it's part of what's called the limbic system, which is automatic responses. We see something, brain reacts, then we get the thought. But we can't stop the thought. Because we have the reaction in the lower brain. So it's going to come. It's going to hit us.
Speaker 1And then we're going to be judged as bad for that automatic reaction. Well, you are. I'm not. We're going to hold you to it to a higher standard.
Speaker 2Well, I mean.
Speaker 1As long as you hold God to a lower standard. Right.
Speaker 2Exactly.
Speaker 1You hold me to a higher standard, but hold God to a lower one.
Speaker 2Because, of course, sin doesn't count if God told you to do it. And nothing is sin if God says it's okay.
Speaker 1I found it interesting that you called it a self-judgment. Most self-judgment. I mean, yeah, I just thought that was really interesting because, I mean, let's face it, when people say, oh, I sinned, they are self-judging. If there's no God there to judge them, let's face it, they're self-judging. And I thought that was great that you put it that way. I never thought about it that way, so it just kind of hit me.
Speaker 7The way I think of all morals, I think all morals are the rules we set for ourselves. It's how I live and whether I can live with what I've done and how I'm going to feel about it. And I can only live my life based on my morals and my code. I can't live based on somebody else's because it's not mine.
Speaker 2I grew up being told that guilt and shame were gifts of the Holy Ghost to tell us when we had done something wrong. And to tell us, okay, time to repent. You've done something wrong. And I think that that ties into that. Shame and guilt are things you do to yourself. So I agree with that completely.
Speaker 7Shame I usually see is the only emotion I would call useless. Because shame is kind of this idea that you're unlovable. And that's just not true for anyone. Everyone is lovable. Somebody is going to love you no matter what. Even people in prison for being serial killers, you mentioned earlier, they have people writing in and loving them all the time. There are serial killers who have gotten married while in prison after having killed horrible people. They can find love.
Speaker 7Somebody is going to love them. So it's just everyone has some lovability. So nobody is unlovable. So shame is useless. It tells us a false message. Guilt can be useful because guilt can let us know, hey, I violated my own sense of morals or I hurt somebody else and I want to make good on that. That's guilt. Guilt can be a good thing.
Speaker 1Shame? Not really. But that's what the religion wants you to do. Shame everything.
Speaker 6Yeah.
Speaker 2Shame is a big tool because if you feel guilty, Shame is uncomfortable. And if you feel shame when you do things the church doesn't want you to do, then you will avoid doing them. And so that's useful to them.
Speaker 7It looks like you guys have some calls in the queue.
Speaker 1Yeah, it looks like we have somebody from TikTok that wants to come up. So I was going to say, go ahead and bring them up. I'll just crawl back into my cage. We have somebody. Well, thank you for keeping the cage warm for me.
Speaker 7Well, it's a pretty nice cage at this point. You've got it decked out pretty well.
Speaker 1Yeah, yeah. There's a blanket. There's a pillow. I make them change the paper every other day now, too, so that's not so bad.
Speaker 2Every other day they spoil you.
Speaker 1And I used to have a plastic food dish, and they brought in the ceramic one last month, so that's pretty classy. Sorry, I broke that one.
Speaker 7You're going to have to get the plastic one.
Speaker 1All right. Well, we'll put you back in the cage, and we'll bring up, it looks like, Infamous Wizard. Is that happening? I'm not sure what's going on. Oh, they dropped, unfortunately. Oh, they dropped. Okay. Sorry. Okay. Well, I guess that blows that for us. But we do have a couple of people who have called in. I think Alex is now ready to come up on line. So let's bring him up.
Speaker 1Alex in Virginia. It says the existence of God and wants to talk about the existence of God and whether God is good. Hi, Alex. How are you? How are you doing? Alex, you there? Hello. Well, that's two calls we've had a problem with. I'm going to pop Alex back into the queue. And it looks like he dropped, actually. And he's calling back. Oh, good. Yeah, he dropped and
Speaker 1he's calling back.
Speaker 4Cool.
Speaker 6Wow.
Speaker 1But we do have another third caller that's being screened right now. So we got two people dropped. I guess, you know what? I think they saw you were here, Ms. Sunsuck, with her and thought, geez, I can't go up against her. She's going to just wipe my butt with my butt. They're intimidated.
Speaker 2No, they were like, oh, no, I don't want.
Speaker 1To talk to that girl. Totally intimidated. So now the third person has dropped out, too, as well. But Alex is still being screened. on his callback. So, uh, we'll still, uh, keep, be patient and keep waiting. Um, so I, I could see where very negative self judgments would be a problem with mental health. I mean, isn't that, that's probably a source of a lot of mental health problems.
Speaker 6Yeah.
Speaker 7So, so the self-directed thoughts and negative thoughts are very, very damaging.
Speaker 6What do you know?
Speaker 1Go ahead. Go ahead.
Speaker 2That's baked right into religion, especially Christianity, when you're actually born with the sin already in you. You know, you're born to burn. You have to fix yourself in order to be worthy to live with this supposedly loving God. It's really strange.
Speaker 1But it's easy to do. All you got to do is ask for forgiveness and And then you're okay. You just wipe that.
Speaker 2Well, that part might be easy. But the believing in him part, that's not so easy. Okay.
Speaker 1We got another TikTok person who is requesting to come. GreatBasek. I'm thinking is how it's pronounced. GreatBasek. So if you want to bring GreatBasek up, we'd love to have them on and talk to them.
Speaker 6Hello.
Speaker 1Hello. How are you doing? Did I get your name right? Great Basque?
Speaker 6It's Biasque.
Speaker 1Biasque. Okay. And are you at least 18 years old?
Speaker 5Yes.
Speaker 1All right. Cool. Thank you. So what would you like to share with us today?
Speaker 5I just wanted to So I was on the call, like maybe like three minutes ago, the guy, and he told me to come request up.
Speaker 1Okay.
Speaker 5Because I had a disagreement with the prompt. So it's going to sound weird, but I am playing devil's advocate right now.
Speaker 1Okay. What do you think is wrong with the prompt?
Speaker 6I don't think, I do not think Christians want you to sin.
Speaker 1I didn't say they wanted me to sin. I think they themselves want to sin. That's why they have a built-in process to be forgiven from it.
Speaker 5So when you say sin, when you say Christians want to sin, you're saying that they want to sin and they want to be forgiven for it?
Speaker 1I'm saying that they have a system that they built into the religion so that they can sin.
Speaker 5And then because they sin, they can just be forgiven. So they do want to sin.
Speaker 1Christians always say, you know, Christians always say to me that they're sinful, that they can't avoid being sinful. So I don't like I can avoid being doing bad things. I don't find it hard at all to avoid doing bad things.
Speaker 4Right.
Speaker 1But Christians are always saying that we're all sinners. I don't I don't believe I'm a sinner because I don't believe in God. And to me, sin is a front against the God. So if I don't have a God belief, then I really can't sin. I can do things that are morally wrong, but I choose not to do those things that it's not hard. So I don't understand why Christians think everybody is sinful and they're willing to commit sin. And why?
Speaker 4And it's.
Speaker 1Because they believe they're sinful, and why they built something into their religion to forgive sins that they're not supposed to do to begin with. Does that make any sense?
Speaker 5That makes sense, and I do have a disagreement with what you are saying. So the theological viewpoint of Christianity is not that they want to sin and that they just created this system because sin and because they wanted to be forgiven for it and they are sinful and they can't avoid sin i if i am correct biblically we we are sinners because we.
Speaker 1Know speak for you speak for yourself you are a sinner i'm not speak for yourself.
Speaker 6I never said i was a sinner because i.
Speaker 1Know you said you said we are sinners and i'm just saying speak for yourself don't call me i'm saying from the.
Speaker 6Theological viewpoint.
Speaker 5So I'm just saying, because in the theological viewpoint, we are inherited sin.
Speaker 1No, from my theological viewpoint, I am not. That's what I'm saying. Please do not accuse me of something I'm not. That's all I'm asking.
Speaker 6What is your definition of sin?
Speaker 1An affront against God.
Speaker 6And so you haven't committed sin?
Speaker 1No, because I don't have a God. I can't affront a God that I don't believe in. If I don't think God exists, I can't affront it. You understand that, right?
Speaker 6I do understand that.
Speaker 1And so on my theological view, sin doesn't exist.
Speaker 5Yeah, but I'm saying from somebody who is in a theological viewpoint of a Christian, and they're saying, well.
Speaker 1Yes, I realize that. And I'm saying that that's the way you are, but that's not me. So you can't say we. You can't include me in your we is all I'm saying.
Speaker 5Okay, so I guess we've kind of, I think we have kind of drifted away from the topic because it's saying Christians just want to sin.
Speaker 6And I'm pretty sure they don't want to sin. They're literally trying to avoid it, but they cannot.
Speaker 1Well, why can't they?
Speaker 5Because you inherit the sin, because they inherit the sin.
Speaker 2Why did God decide to make the rest of us inherit the first two people's sin, if, you know, that would make things much more difficult for all of us for something we didn't do.
Speaker 1Doesn't the Bible also say you can't hold the son responsible for the sins of the father?
Speaker 5Well, to be honest, I think I have read only the maybe half of the New Testament, a little bit of the Old Testament.
Speaker 1Oh, it does say that. It does say that you can't hold the son responsible for the sins of the father.
Speaker 6Which verse is that?
Speaker 1I'll look it up for you right now.
Speaker 7What's interesting is sin comes from a Greek archery term. It just means to fall short. So I think what Kelly kind of was pointing out was that you can only sin if you're aiming at that target. Your arrow is not going to fall short of the target if you're not aiming at that target. If I'm just shooting my arrow straight up in the air and it comes down, it hasn't fallen short of anywhere because I wasn't aiming at anything. So if we're not following that religion, we're not aiming at that God, we're never going to fall short.
Speaker 1So we don't sin. It's Ezekiel 1830. The son shall not suffer for the iniquity of the father, nor the father suffer for the iniquity of the son.
Speaker 2Oh, we know that's a contradiction since, you know.
Speaker 1The righteousness of the righteous shall be upon himself and the wickedness of the wicked shall be upon himself. So we're not, I mean, it's saying right, God's saying right there, he's not holding us responsible for the sins of somebody that came before us.
Speaker 5Well, I am pretty sure that the, yeah, that is the only, sorry. The only, the historical, like historically Christianity, I'm pretty sure they teach these two things, which is that we inherit a broken human nature and that the very same principle of representation is how Christianity solves the problem because just as we fell with Adam, Christians believe that we can be redeemed with Christ.
Speaker 1Okay, well, this is the problem and this is what I've been saying, right? That right there, I just showed you right there in Ezekiel that God is not holding you responsible for the original sin, right? Right. And yet Christianity is telling you that you are a sinner because of this original sin that God said you're not responsible for.
Speaker 4Right.
Speaker 1So now you've already got into the mindset of sinning. So it's OK to be a sinner.
Speaker 4Right.
Speaker 1Because we're all sinners. So it's OK. But but it's fine because we have an out for you. So no matter what sin you do, we have an out. So you're trained to be sinners.
Speaker 2What I wonder is if Adam and Eve were not born or made rather with this sinful nature, how did they sin in the first place then? And, you know, because they clearly did or that's the story, right? So how does that work? Why were we then cursed with this broken, I mean. How did they break something that was perfect if God
Speaker 2made them perfect?
Speaker 6I'm sorry.
Speaker 5Do you want me to respond to what you're saying or what Kelly is saying?
Speaker 1You can respond to Ms. Nonsequitur.
Speaker 2Okay.
Speaker 6Well, I'm sorry. I was too focused on responding to Kelly.
Speaker 2That's okay. Go ahead and respond to Kelly. I'll put a pin in it.
Speaker 6I apologize. Don't worry. I'll definitely respond to it. But I think you are right, Kelly. So Ezekiel.
Speaker 5Does tell us that God does not hold the children guilty for the parents and for their individual sin. But I think Christianity can separate the personal guilt from our inherited condition because we aren't sinners because God set a trap. We are sinners because humanity broke the source at the beginning and we inherit that broken system.
Speaker 1God's saying after that happened. that you're not responsible for. Christianity is literally going against the word of God in Ezekiel. I mean, I don't know what else to say to you. You know, you're saying, well, God, well, Christians added, yeah, you added this sin thing that you're not responsible for. And it makes me wonder why. Why did you add something to make everybody feel so guilty? right, that they have to come running to something else to absolve them
Speaker 1of a guilt that God already says they're absolved from. That's the part that I don't get, and that's the part why I say Christians just want to sin. They have literally built sinning into their religion.
Speaker 5I don't think Christianity doesn't view moral guilt as like the something meant to beat you down. It's just like an alarm system that just tells you.
Speaker 1I don't know where that came from because I never made that claim.
Speaker 6I'm pretty... You did say.
Speaker 1I'm just saying that you built sinning into your religion. You have built a way that you can sin, that it's okay for you to sin. Now that... that wasn't in the original religion that wasn't in judaism they don't have that that's all and i'm trying to and i'm what i'm wondering is why would christians build it build that sin thing into their religion to make everybody feel guilty to begin with And then anything you could possibly
Speaker 1do after that can also be forgiven as well. So it doesn't matter what you do. You could be forgiven. You can sin. It's okay. We can forgive you. And what really is bad about that is people who are forgiven by Jesus are also forgiven by Jesus's followers. And some of those people shouldn't be forgiven. Some of those people do bad things to children and they shouldn't be forgiven. Some of those people do horrible things to other people and they shouldn't be forgiven. And yet we built a
Speaker 1thing into Christianity to be able to forgive those people and have followers of Jesus forgive those people for doing these horrible things that they should never be forgiven for.
Speaker 6So I'm going to want you to define all loving.
Speaker 2Why?
Speaker 1What does all loving have to do with this?
Speaker 6Just define it.
Speaker 1I don't know what it is. I don't believe it exists. So I don't know what the definition of it would be because I don't think it exists.
Speaker 6I guess from a classical.
Speaker 5Theistic viewpoint that yeah, you wouldn't know what all loving is because I don't think we can if God does exist, we can assign God attributes. We can't assign them attributes besides the ones that we can obviously deduct.
Speaker 6Like if You're on mute.
Speaker 1You're muted.
Speaker 2Oops, sorry. You assign God attributes all the time. You've done it constantly in this very discussion.
Speaker 5Oh, yeah, because this is a Christian. I just told you I was playing devil's advocate. So, of course, I'm going to assign God a attribute because I'm playing from a Christian viewpoint.
Speaker 1So when you say God is forgiving, he's not forgiving?
Speaker 6From a Christian viewpoint, God is forgiving.
Speaker 1But I thought like you giving an attribute to it would be wrong.
Speaker 6Yeah, that's from my viewpoint.
Speaker 1Oh, okay. So it's okay for you to do it, but not others.
Speaker 5I don't think you understand what I mean when I'm saying I'm playing devil's advocate.
Speaker 6I'm not playing for my own. personal viewpoint. I am playing from a Christian.
Speaker 1Wait a minute, though. You just said before you were talking from a Christian viewpoint, and now you're saying you're talking from... I don't understand. It seems like... They're switching viewpoints that you're talking about. And if you're not doing that, it's really confusing because it seems like it because you're saying that from different points. Am I mistaken here, Ms. Nonsequitur? Were you getting the same idea? No, because he was.
Speaker 2Saying you can't assign attributes to God. And when I said, but you're doing that, he said, well, Christians do it. But didn't you also say that Christians say you can't assign attributes to God?
Speaker 5That is a complete shraman of what I'm trying to say. And honestly, it's okay. But the reason I said we can't assign attributes to God, because I was agreeing from my view, I was just like, yeah, I think we can. We can't assign attributes like all loving to God. But from a Christian viewpoint, this then so.
Speaker 6If you know what I mean.
Speaker 1No, I don't. I'm trying to I'm trying to understand it, but I'm not. I'm not getting it.
Speaker 6Oh, wow. Yeah, maybe. Maybe I should, should I just stop playing devil's advocate?
Speaker 1Yes, please. Just start, you know, just start playing your advocate. That would be best probably.
Speaker 6I'm definitely not doing it well.
Speaker 5So I think that me personally, we can't assign attributes to God because, but we can deduct attributes.
Speaker 6Like if God created the universe, it sounds pretty powerful.
Speaker 1That's a big if there, that word if was carrying a lot of weight.
Speaker 6Yeah, because it's just like an if, then this. So like an if this did happen, then this. We can deduct.
Speaker 5Same way we can be like, well, if we think theistic evolution, think.
Speaker 6About how complex we are and how complex the universe is.
Speaker 1You have to prove the if is correct. You can go on. All the rest of the stuff is just conjecture if you can't prove the if first.
Speaker 6I think I'm going to have to. Oh, okay.
Speaker 5Yeah.
Speaker 6I think I'm going to have, then I'd have to pull a whole nother argument.
Speaker 1That's just like, you're, you're like saying all these things that come along after the fact that you, you know, that you have, that you haven't proven anything that you've said connects to anything that's actually real. That's my point. And that, that's, I think what we're stuck at.
Speaker 6I agree with you.
Speaker 1Like, I don't, like, I don't think sin is real, right?
Speaker 6But a Christian would.
Speaker 1But I'm not getting their viewpoint. I know, because Christians have invented sin into their religion. They put it in there. But they've also said it's okay to sin because there's a way out of it.
Speaker 7And we'll all forgive you. They made some of the more fun things sins. Things you can't help doing. Things that are just really fun. Things that people want to do. They made them all sins because that's how the religion controls people.
Speaker 6Well, now I'm going to argue from a Muslim viewpoint. Okay, so....
Speaker 1Why don't you just do it from your viewpoint? Yeah, why don't you do it from your viewpoint?
Speaker 5Well, yeah, because my viewpoint is probably not much different from yours. But, like, I would take a classical theistic viewpoint, if you know what I mean.
Speaker 2I find it very difficult to discuss things with people when they're trying to use other viewpoints than their own. And I know it's an exercise that a lot of people do, but it's not one I enjoy participating in personally. I don't know about Kelly. I'd rather just hear about
Speaker 2what you think about it. Um, then what other, what you think other people think about it.
Speaker 5Well, the reason why I am playing devil's advocate, because I think personally for me, it is definitely a good practice because if you're going to argue against something like a good way of practicing debate is having to argue for it and also being able to argue against it.
Speaker 6I feel like that's just a smart way of debating. It's something I learned in logic's class.
Speaker 1Um, It's like steel manning the other viewpoint.
Speaker 6Yeah, like, yeah, yeah, yeah.
Speaker 5But from my viewpoint, I think that, like I said, I don't disagree with you guys on a lot of things. I disagree that the possibility of God not exist or that there's full evidence to show that God does not exist at all. Maybe I just straw manned your guys' whole viewpoint, but.
Speaker 6I don't know.
Speaker 1Yeah, I don't think any of us are claiming that.
Speaker 4No.
Speaker 5Yeah, so, yeah, I definitely just straw manned your viewpoint.
Speaker 1Well, honestly— I'm an ichthyist. I don't know if you know what an ichthyist is.
Speaker 5I'm not a— I think IG— is it like IG and an ichthyist?
Speaker 1IG theist.
Speaker 6I just learned about— I literally just learned about that. That's crazy. Yeah. I just learned about that.
Speaker 1So, I mean, a lot of people think that atheism is just a subset of atheism, but, I mean, you could believe in a personal God, so it could be a form of theism as well. But I just think that any conversation about the existence of God is moot because no two people can actually agree 100% on what God is. And if we can't do that, then how can we tell if God is real or not, if we don't even know what God is?
Speaker 6Yeah, that is.
Speaker 5I might be atheist because that is probably the viewpoint I would take. I don't think that philosophical arguments isn't going to convince somebody.
Speaker 6Nobody would change.
Speaker 5Not that I have seen somebody would change their viewpoint because of a philosophical argument.
Speaker 6And because everything can be argued.
Speaker 5Like you can argue anything, like especially arguing for these arguments for God, like Somebody could argue against it. It goes back and forth, and I feel like it can go back and forth forever. It will never come down to this conclusion.
Speaker 2I think philosophical arguments can be convincing.
Speaker 6Which ones would you say are convincing? Or maybe....
Speaker 2Well, I certainly haven't heard any that are convincing for God, but I have been convinced by philosophical arguments of other things in my life. For instance, there was a time... when I was pro-life, for instance, when I was quite young. And um, I got convinced by philosophical arguments that, um, that was not the best viewpoint. Um, so, you know, uh,
Speaker 2I think that philosophical arguments can be convincing of some things. Like I said, I certainly haven't been convinced of the, of any for God yet, but.
Speaker 6Have any of you guys ever heard of the Bayesian fine tuning?
Speaker 1Bayesian fine tuning, yes.
Speaker 6Yeah, I think I.
Speaker 5Just did not pronounce it correctly, but whatever the name is. I thought it was convincing for a while, and it almost made me become a theist. Then I actually started looking into videos, and I was like, yet again, you can never come to the conclusion with these arguments forgotten.
Speaker 6Well, I don't think.
Speaker 2That you necessarily need to have hard proof to be convinced of something. I think most people are often convinced of things without actual proof, just sufficient evidence.
Speaker 5Yeah, I'm not like an empiricist, so I don't take empirical evidence and be like, this is the only way to prove things. Because obviously I think we know that things can be proven without empirical evidence.
Speaker 6Math and stuff, whatever. But that's a whole different topic.
Speaker 5Actually, I do want to ask you guys a question because I wanted to ask an atheist this question.
Speaker 6Ms.
Speaker 5Non-Secretory, I might have asked you this question. If you do remember, I am ToughBoyCash.
Speaker 2Oh, very nice to see you again. I think both me and Beard talked to you on the TikTok.
Speaker 6Yeah, I know. Yes, I do remember I remember you guys.
Speaker 2Hey, well, good to hear from you again.
Speaker 6Yeah, thank you.
Speaker 5So I wanted to talk about Islam, actually. Do you think that Islam is more plausible than Christianity?
Speaker 1Nope.
Speaker 4No.
Speaker 6So I debated a Muslim yesterday. And here, I'm going to pull up the verse.
Speaker 5So they claim that there was a lot of scientifically accurate Quran verses there.
Speaker 1Yeah, they do all the time. Almost none of them. Not almost none of them, but none of them are. They're kind of.
Speaker 2Like how Jesus fulfilled prophecies. It's kind of like retroactively, oh, this totally means this other thing that's actually scientific, really fancy scientific stuff that we didn't know before now.
Speaker 7All sorts of pretzels they have to go into in order to try and make it work as scientific.
Speaker 1And the ones that are scientifically accurate, like I'm thinking of one about fetuses, is something that anybody, I mean, they were freaking herdsmen. Of course they knew what a freaking fetus was.
Speaker 6Oh, the embryology?
Speaker 1Yeah, that's just such a bullshit one to bring up. I brought up that.
Speaker 6I brought up that viewpoint on embryology. He was like, oh yeah, this viewpoint, he found this out. I was like, no.
Speaker 5There was tons of people before that had already made that sort of.
Speaker 1You think that they never slaughtered a goat that was pregnant? I mean, seriously.
Speaker 6And then they brought.
Speaker 5I just told them that all these scientifically accurate verses, this shit was known before Islam. Ancient hieroglyphics show that people already knew this. like the whole separating the earth from the heavens. I was like, the earth was formed billions of years after the Big Bang, so it's not even accurate.
Speaker 6And there was the bee one. I actually, I didn't know what to say on this.
Speaker 5I kind of conceded it, but I was like, okay, I'm just going to concede this point because I don't care if he got the feminine bee workers correct. It's not convincing at all. It was Surah 1668. So they use the correct feminine form for the bees actions saying that the bees, the worker bees were female and nobody else knew that.
Speaker 7I think biologically speaking depends on what the definition of female is. There's some indication that the drones are not technically female because they can't reproduce at all. You have to be a queen to reproduce. So the, the, the pronoun use for bees is just our choice.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 5I think I did say something similar to that. It was that like Arabic, there was an Arabic, uh, grammatic forms for bees and that there was just a, that even before that verse, they use female pronouns to describe mountains and They describe a lot of things with people.
Speaker 2Exactly.
Speaker 1They use female pronouns to describe boats, too.
Speaker 2And they had a 50-50 chance of getting it right, too. Exactly.
Speaker 5Even if I take that he got it correct, it's not convincing. I'm not going to convert to Islam because he got this one.
Speaker 6Prophet correct.
Speaker 1I would hope not anyway, right? Absolutely not.
Speaker 5And there's so many other problems with Islam. that I don't think it can be convincing. And the only reason it's convincing is because people just want to do bad shit.
Speaker 6Because we already know Islam. No more than Christianity.
Speaker 1Not every Islam is going to do bad things.
Speaker 5Not every Islam is going to do bad things, but I think we know some of the.
Speaker 2Like not every Christian.
Speaker 1Yeah, not every Christian is going to do bad things either, right?
Speaker 6Yeah.
Speaker 1Some are actually going to try not to do things that are morally wrong. So I do agree.
Speaker 5Yeah, I have Christian friends who are pretty good people. And then I have Muslim friends. They're also good people. And do you guys agree with the whole like you should try to get them out of their religion or their faith?
Speaker 1No, I don't. I don't think we should. I don't think it's our job to. I would like it if everybody does, but it's not my job to do it. Yeah.
Speaker 2And I think there are some people. My my mom. is my favorite person in the world. And she is a devout Christian. She's 80 years old. And right now what she's living for is the idea that she's going to see my dad again in, you know, a handful of years. And I can't see myself ever trying to take that away from her, frankly.
Speaker 6Yeah, I do agree.
Speaker 5I think that, you know, for some people, like religion, their faith is a good coping mechanism for them. You know, people are going to use their religion for bad things. We know religion is a tool. Religion has historically been used as a tool. The Spaniards, their colonization, even Hitler, he literally used Christianity as his tool. So we know religion is a major tool, but I still think that people can have faith and still be a good person
Speaker 5because their faith is what they think is correct.
Speaker 6It helps them cope. It brings them peace. And if it brings them peace, then I don't think there's a problem with it. If it starts to.
Speaker 5Become a problem, then I think that they need to separate themselves from it because when things become problems, that's when you have to separate yourself from it. Unless there is some type of greater good out of it, but I don't see any greater good out of colonization or.
Speaker 6Stuff like that.
Speaker 1I agree.
Speaker 6That's just my viewpoint.
Speaker 1Yeah, that's a good viewpoint. We do have other callers that spend a lot of time on this one. So I did enjoy the conversation. I'm sure everybody else did. It was great talking to you again. Yeah, yeah. Apparently, I didn't know who you are. I'd love to talk to you some more. So hopefully, you'll give us a call back in the future. But I am going to move on to one of our other callers, if you don't mind.
Speaker 6Yeah, have a good day, and tell them I apologize for taking up so much time.
Speaker 1Oh, no, you don't have to apologize. I could have cut you off 15 minutes ago if I had wanted to, so it's all on me, okay? Keep asking questions. Yeah, keep asking questions. All right, you know what? Real quick, Alex, give me a second. We'll bring you up here, but real quick, I want to do a couple of real quick announcements. You can become a channel member by clicking the Join button below the video, and you'll get custom chat emotes. You'll get, like, Dan's face you can put up there. It's cool, and you can get... John the Skeptic.
Speaker 1You can put his face up there. You get early access to clips and shorts that we post. And you will help perpetuate the mission of Truth Wanted and the atheist community of Austin. So we'd love to have you do that. You can get Truth Wanted merchandise. Some of it's really cool. T-shirts, sweatshirts, hoodies, hats, all kinds of stuff. Pipe glasses, mugs at aca.slashmerch. And yeah, it's good stuff. Good stuff. I just saw somebody wearing a Truth Wanted shirt the other day. It was awesome. Another way to
Speaker 1support us is by sending us Super Chats. You can send them in and we will read them, as many of them as we can, assuming that they are YouTube appropriate. People used to do tongue twisters for me all the time. I don't know why they stopped doing that, but that was kind of fun.
Speaker 2Send me tongue twisters i'm really good.
Speaker 1At them i nailed every one of them actually and uh but another thing you do is just please like the video if you don't like it click the don't like it button twice Subscribe to the channel, enable notifications, comment on things below. I always read the comments, so sometimes I'll even talk back to you in the comments. Do that. Please leave a comment. I'm a little bit out of it today. I'm sorry. Last but not least, we want to thank a big, a big, huge thank
Speaker 1you to the crew. They're the ones who are putting up with me here today and making me look good. So let's get the crew cam up and see everybody. All these wonderful, beautiful, look at all those amazing people there.
Speaker 4Awesome.
Speaker 1What great facial hair on everybody. Yeah. We got a crew of facial hair.
Speaker 2It's making me feel, you know. I don't want to see everybody has good facial hair except me.
Speaker 1I don't want to see you with the beard.
Speaker 2Oh, I would look great. I mean, I've seen myself with the beard of empathy.
Speaker 1I was about to say, I was just about to say I have actually seen you with the beard.
Speaker 6Amazing.
Speaker 2It's beautiful.
Speaker 1I do want to bring up our next caller, though, Alex. Alex is from Virginia, and he says he wants to talk about the existence of God and whether God is good. So hi, Alex. How are you?
Speaker 2Hello.
Speaker 4Good.
Speaker 1How are you? So what do you want to talk about? What do you got for us?
Speaker 4Yeah. Yeah, I believe in a specific conceptual model of God that embeds like neo-Quinean meta-ontology.
Speaker 1I don't have any idea what that means, so you're going to have to explain that.
Speaker 4Yeah, so neo-Quinean meta-ontology is just a version of saying that there is a best way of deciding what exists using like explanatory power or simplicity or unification. and thereby, by embedding this given conceptual model, we could see that God's existence would be deflationary or central, and then there would be, like, large convergence towards that model, which would be, like, evidence that the model is true. I.
Speaker 1Yeah, do you want to simplify that and give us the model that's true, the true model?
Speaker 4Yeah, what exactly is, like.
Speaker 1I want you to explain it to us and our viewers as if we were all five years old.
Speaker 4Yeah, so if a model that makes God's existence the simplest and most unifying explanation that would gain large agreement among people, then that model would be successful and true.
Speaker 1Why? Why? Yeah, if we can't prove it's true, why would it gain white acceptance?
Speaker 2Oh, yeah.
Speaker 4Specifically because non-activity, meaning that being, wouldn't be like an activity or process that things undergo or perform. Rather that when we do embed like neo-Kinney and meta-ontology, we're looking at the.
Speaker 1You got to stop. Dude, dude, dude, dude. A five-year-old would not understand that last sentence.
Speaker 4Okay. So are you asking how we embed this into a system or what makes it true?
Speaker 1I'm asking what makes it true that people would believe in it without any proof.
Speaker 4Yeah, it's trivial given the... It's just analytically true given how the model works. Meaning that Existence would simply only work within the modifier given that there's univocity, that there's being would be identical.
Speaker 1What is univocity?
Speaker 2A five-year-old would not understand univocity, my friend.
Speaker 4Yeah, univocity means that you have only one possible meaning or interpretation.
Speaker 1Okay, why didn't you just say that instead? Why didn't you just say that instead? Why don't you, again, please talk as if nobody understands words that have more than eight letters, okay?
Speaker 4Okay.
Speaker 1Because a lot of the people who are watching don't.
Speaker 5Okay.
Speaker 1You're speaking to an audience, not to yourself.
Speaker 4Okay. I guess, do you want me to give a formal argument that's way more simpler?
Speaker 1Yes.
Speaker 4Yes.
Speaker 1Yes, that's what we've been asking for. Like I said, you've got to give something that just a normal person would understand. You're a normal, everyday guy on the street, and the words you're using and the concepts you're using, the way you're explaining them, the normal guy on the street ain't going to understand.
Speaker 7So arguments and discussions like this are only fruitful if everyone can understand what's going on. And your argument can only be accepted or really considered by your interlocutor if they understand what it is you're talking about. And that's incumbent on you as the one sending the message to make it as simple as you possibly can for the other person to understand it. Because you're not a mind reader and you don't know what it is that we
Speaker 7know and what we don't know. So please simplify your argument as much as possible.
Speaker 4I'm ready to give the argument.
Speaker 1Okay. Yeah.
Speaker 4So the conditional would just be like, if a model would treat God as the simplest, ultimate explanation that gains large agreement, then that model is true. There is such a model that.
Speaker 1So wait, wait, wait. So are you saying that just because a lot of people believe it, that makes it true?
Speaker 6Yeah.
Speaker 1I'm pretty sure there's a fallacy about that. Yeah, that's called— yeah, that's a fallacy.
Speaker 3Populism.
Speaker 4Argument by populism. Yeah. convergence is usually a marker that when a way of understanding the world would be of like univocity, the term that I invoked before, which just means.
Speaker 1That you're not talking to a five-year-old anymore.
Speaker 4When we understand the world simpler, there would be that we explain more things with fewer assumptions and solve problems better than more careful thinkers that gradually move toward it. Meaning these good explanations would tend to win over time.
Speaker 1Wouldn't that be with something that we can actually experience and experiment with? You keep suggesting that this concept is the simplest concept, and yet you can't seem to.
Speaker 2Relate this concept using words that we can understand. So how, I mean, if it's so simple, make it simple.
Speaker 4Yeah, what I mean by God there is just the simplest ultimate explanation that is attracting large and growing agreement. So that's what the term God means. And that agreement would itself count as evidence that the model is succeeding. So I'm just defining God in a deflationary sense.
Speaker 1So you're just saying God is just a belief that people have.
Speaker 4Correct.
Speaker 7And it's true if more people believe it. But the problem is.
Speaker 4Go ahead.
Speaker 7Your problem is that you're violating Occam's razor immediately. You're adding entities into every discussion. The God entity, which has no evidence behind it, is adding an entity to any other description or explanations. Your simplest explanation is already not simplest when you add God into it.
Speaker 4Yeah, well, firstly, Occam's Razor does not say always choose a theory with fewest entities. It says do not multiply entities beyond necessity.
Speaker 7Yeah, beyond necessity, which means by adding God in, you're doing that unnecessarily with most every other explanation.
Speaker 1Why?
Speaker 6Okay.
Speaker 4Again, if I treat, like, for instance, the theistic model that I'm using is just treating God as a single, necessary, unlimited mind that can make things expected rather than surprising, and that fundamental reality would explain existence, order, intelligibility. Would you say that that's obviously unexplainable as opposed to, like, nationalism, for instance?
Speaker 7I would reject your presupposition that God isn't necessary for anything.
Speaker 4No, that's just what I mean when I invoke the term God. So again, I'm just referencing a given concept.
Speaker 7When you invoke the term God, you're invoking a presupposition that it's necessary.
Speaker 1You just said it.
Speaker 4Are you saying that I'm presupposing its existence?
Speaker 2You're presupposing its necessity. You're presupposing that God is a necessary being.
Speaker 4Do you think it's metaphysically impossible for a necessary being to exist?
Speaker 1Is it possible? No.
Speaker 2I said that.
Speaker 4Okay, so if there's a... given conception of a necessary being, I don't see how that would be a presupposition, given that we converge on that idea.
Speaker 2No, the possibility of something doesn't mean you can presuppose that it is.
Speaker 4We're not referencing probabilities. We're referencing possible world semantics.
Speaker 2You asked us if God was possible.
Speaker 4Yeah, metaphysically possible. You already agreed to that, that God is metaphysically possible, meaning that there's a given conception of a necessary being that could exist.
Speaker 2That doesn't mean it does exist.
Speaker 1Right. It's possible. I would say it's possible, but implausible.
Speaker 4Okay, yeah. What I'm simply saying by God is this given conceptual model that utilizes God as a necessary and limited mind, that conception of God would just be what I mean by God.
Speaker 1A conception.
Speaker 4Yeah, that conception. So if... My first original premise was that if a model that treats the simplest ultimate explanation, if this model would gain large agreement, which we do see in the status quo, then that model would be true.
Speaker 1Go ahead. I was just going to say, can you take that premise and smash it down to one small sentence? Because that was a really hard premise to follow when you think about it. You just put four sentences for your first premise.
Speaker 2Uh, yeah.
Speaker 4Um, I mean, I can give you the reasoning behind the first premise.
Speaker 1I mean, I don't want the reasoning. I want you to just explain it easily in one sentence.
Speaker 4I mean, my conditional is kind of like, um, okay, sure. Okay.
Speaker 1So, so the premise has conditions.
Speaker 4Okay. So if a model treats God as a, as a simple explanation and this gets agreement, then the model is true.
Speaker 5Why?
Speaker 4The model does treat God as the simplest ultimate explanation. Therefore, the model is true.
Speaker 5Why?
Speaker 2That's the presupposition.
Speaker 1Yeah, that's, yeah, you're presupposing.
Speaker 4You want me to justify premise two?
Speaker 1I want you to justify the first and the second one. Because I don't see a justification for either.
Speaker 4The only way I could justify a conditional is by justifying the second premise.
Speaker 1So you don't think that's such a model? So your first premise isn't true. Unless your second premise is true.
Speaker 4Yes, that's how a conditional works. That's how a modus ponens works.
Speaker 2Okay, then I guess prove your second premise.
Speaker 4Yeah, so you would agree that in the status quo there exists, there could exist like a model which we could see like through Abrahamic religions, we could see through like polytheistic religions that we treat, that they treat God as the simplest ultimate explanation.
Speaker 1No, I don't agree with that at all. I think they treat God as a very complicated explanation.
Speaker 2And they have to constantly put more complications into God to make it make sense.
Speaker 1Yep, yep.
Speaker 4Okay, well, firstly, I'm not saying that, like, there could exist, like, well, by ultimate there, what do you think I mean? Like, do you think I mean that, like, it's, like, simply unexplainable?
Speaker 1You know what? Here's the thing. You tell us what you mean.
Speaker 4Yeah. By simplest ultimate explanation, I just mean, like, by, okay, so an ultimate explanation would just be, like, the deep root cause or fundamental reason for why it exists. But that would be different from like a proximate explanation. So what I mean by an ultimate explanation is just a non-proximate explanation. But a proximate explanation is just something that tells you.
Speaker 1Instead of giving us an explanation of why something could exist, why don't you give us proof that it does exist? Yeah.
Speaker 4What I'm trying to prove is that the model that treats God as the simplest act.
Speaker 1In the model I'm just interested in God himself right and I don't give a shit about a model I'm talking about let's let's look at the reality and not a model and by God you mean what well I don't know you're the one that's claiming there's a God not me.
Speaker 4Yeah I already told you what I mean by.
Speaker 1God okay and I don't and I don't see any and you have said nothing at all to prove that your concept of God actually exists yeah.
Speaker 4Okay, do you want me to repeat what I mean by God?
Speaker 1No, we already heard it. I'm just telling you that it doesn't make any sense. It didn't make any sense to me, at least. I don't know if it made any sense to anybody else on the panel, but it made absolutely no sense to me.
Speaker 4Okay, I'll say it in simpler terms. When I say that God exists, I mean that he exists deflationary so he's just presented as.
Speaker 1So so if i let all the air out he somebody let all the air out of him come on man i mean let's start using words that are freaking usable but you know seriously and don't use that.
Speaker 4Means it just means that Major concepts like truth do not have deep, hidden metaphysical nature or some sort of substantive property to be discovered.
Speaker 1And how does that prove a God?
Speaker 4Well, firstly, the argument that I gave you prior was supposed to be the evidentiary deductive argument for God.
Speaker 1I don't want an evidentiary argument. I want proof. Evidence is thrown out of court.
Speaker 4What's your standard of proof?
Speaker 1Something that's actually real and prove that I did something that is unambiguous, right? Yeah, I mean, that's like what.
Speaker 4I'm arguing for. That's like the entirety of my argument.
Speaker 1You didn't even let me finish. You didn't even let me finish. You cut me off before I was even done with my definition. So it's not what you were arguing for because you don't even know what I was saying.
Speaker 2Okay. Right?
Speaker 4Right.
Speaker 1It would have to be completely unambiguous. There could be no other explanation for it. And it would have to be something that we could prove empirically, something that everybody could test and see and would work the same for everyone.
Speaker 4Okay, well, I mean, if you rely on empirics for standard of evidence, then obviously we can't really utilize that because God is immaterial.
Speaker 6What we.
Speaker 1Does God interact with the world?
Speaker 4I mean, it depends on how you.
Speaker 1Does God interact with the world? Yes or no?
Speaker 4Under my interpretation, no. I don't think he interacts.
Speaker 1Okay. Because most people who believe in a God think he does interact with the world. And I was going to say we could then measure that interaction.
Speaker 2So are you like a deist?
Speaker 4Yeah.
Speaker 1Are you a deist?
Speaker 4Yeah. I believe in deism, yeah.
Speaker 7Okay, so what's the point in believing in God?
Speaker 1Yeah, what's the point?
Speaker 7If the God is immaterial and doesn't interact in any way with the world, why believe in him? Why assign him as an explanation for anything?
Speaker 2Your world is exactly the same with or without God.
Speaker 1Which gives you a more complicated explanation.
Speaker 4If you're saying that the only conception of God needs to be a God that fulfills you, then that would just be completely ignorant and completely.
Speaker 1Like, I don't think that's what he's saying. What I think he's saying is that why believe in a God that does nothing? I think that's the point. If God does nothing, who cares? Who cares about that God?
Speaker 4We don't know. Theists don't say that God does nothing.
Speaker 7You just said that God does not interact with the world.
Speaker 5Yeah.
Speaker 1And he's immaterial. You just said that.
Speaker 4I think that we can conceive of something outside of our universe that could act. Yeah, probably the immaterial world.
Speaker 7Do you have evidence of that?
Speaker 1Yeah, what is that? What is the immaterial world?
Speaker 4Yeah, like math.
Speaker 1We have math. We have math in this world. I don't know where you think that exists.
Speaker 4You think math exists in the universe?
Speaker 1Yeah, it's a language. It's a language that we invented.
Speaker 4Wait, does language exist materially?
Speaker 1When you write it down on a piece of paper, yes.
Speaker 4Okay, so... Okay, so obviously I think you're confusing what the mechanisms of language are. Like, for instance, writing on paper was what.
Speaker 1I was an English major, man. I actually have a degree in language.
Speaker 4Yeah, I think you're confusing what you mean there by language. You don't mean like writing on a paper is language. Yeah, it is.
Speaker 5Yeah, it is.
Speaker 1It totally is. Language, writing on a paper is totally language. Math is a language as well.
Speaker 4Yeah, but when we refer to language, we're not referring to the paper in itself, the pen on the paper itself. We're referring to.
Speaker 1Okay, when I'm speaking to you right now, right now, see, I'm speaking to you right now, and I'm creating sound waves that are physical. And yes, language and speech is a physical thing that exists within this world. That's it. I mean, I don't know how else to explain it to you, but yes, speech is a physical thing that exists within the physical world.
Speaker 4Yeah, again, specifically, the act of making sounds with your voice is physical, but language is not the same thing as speech. Like, for instance, language is just a physical... system. Truth, reference, concepts, they're not identical to brain states. They're not identical to vibrations in the air. Like you can have a physical voice without language.
Speaker 1Yeah, it's just like talking on the phone, right? It's just like you take your voice and you turn it into vibrations and those vibrations are the physical part of your language that are going through the wire and coming like an old landline or going through the air and coming out the phone on the other side, right? That was a physical thing. That language was a physical thing. And whether you think that that is just sound without language... Wait, wait, you're not... I didn't never cut you off. So whether
Speaker 1or not you think that that language is just sound and not communicating anything, that's irrelevant, right? But the sound that is communicating things are a physical part of the physical world. That communication is physical.
Speaker 4I agree, but.
Speaker 1Okay, then. So why are you saying it's not part of the universe? Meaning is not.
Speaker 4Located in time. Meaning is atemporal and meaning is aspatial. Meaning that it doesn't exist within space-time. Meaning it's immaterial.
Speaker 1And I'm saying it's not. And I just told you why it's not.
Speaker 4You think propositions are located somewhere?
Speaker 1I don't even know what the hell you mean by that. What I'm saying is that when people communicate, when they use language to communicate, it creates a physical existence in this world. That's what I'm saying. You cannot agree with that, but it is true. That communication has a physical existence in the physical world.
Speaker 4Okay, let's say I say 2 plus 2 equals 4 out loud. I write it on paper. I think it. I sign it with my hands. I coded it on a computer. All of these are different physical events. You would agree they carry the same meaning. But if the meaning were just a physical thing... changing the physical form should change the meaning. But obviously it doesn't.
Speaker 1Why? Why would it change it? And go ahead, Beard, explain why it does. Yes, it does. If you're talking about amounts.
Speaker 4You're the one saying that it's physical, which invokes that it's in time. Because anything that exists in space-time is physical.
Speaker 1Yeah. If we're talking about amounts of things.
Speaker 2And.
Speaker 4You're saying that obviously... These things that when you say two plus two equals four hours.
Speaker 7Listen, if we're talking about amounts of things and we have two apples and two oranges and we say we have four fruits and I make a physical change by adding an apple to the apple side, I've just changed two plus two to two plus three. I've made a change, a physical change. And if we write down the note, if we write down the numerals for two plus two equals four, and then we make a change to one of those symbols, it changes the meaning. So it gets
Speaker 7all in the physical and the interpretation we have happens in your brain. It's a physical reaction. It's your brain interprets the information in a physical fashion.
Speaker 2Okay.
Speaker 4So are you saying like, if we add an apple to something that will change the truth of two plus two equals four?
Speaker 1I would change it from two plus two to something else.
Speaker 5Yeah.
Speaker 4So let's say I start with two apples.
Speaker 2I have one more.
Speaker 1I have to jump in real quick. I have to jump in and stop this real quick because we're running out of time. We only got a few minutes left and we need to wrap the show up. Alex, I'm sorry. If you want, you can call back next week or if you want to stay on the line, you can talk to him at AXP, I guess, or call back either way. And talk to him on the next show. But I have to wrap this one up. Sorry.
Speaker 6Okay.
Speaker 1Okay. And so thanks for calling. I appreciate it. And, again, like I said, please call back if you'd like to next week.
Speaker 4Okay.
Speaker 1And that will be about it for us this week. I want to remind everybody that we are always looking for volunteers here at the ACA, and it is really a fun, wonderful place to work at and to volunteer your time at. If it wasn't, I wouldn't have been doing it for the last six years. And I want to remind everybody about Ms. Nonsequitur, how awesome she is, and have her tell us again where we can find you.
Speaker 2I do lives on TikTok frequently. And I also sometimes host on the Daily Atheist Morning Show. And I am on Discord. I do a Wednesday chat and chill with some friends on the Daily Atheist Media Network Discord server. So it's fun.
Speaker 1And cool. And everybody, go check her out. She's awesome. We got a little bit of her here. I wish we could have had more time. So you got more of her because she's incredible. Beard, thank you so much for coming up when we needed you. That was awesome.
Speaker 2Oh, one last thing. I almost forgot. I am going to be on Misinterpretations this week as well.
Speaker 4Oh, cool.
Speaker 2Cool.
Speaker 1There you go. And now one thing that we always do to put our guests on the spot, we never tell them about it. Can you give us some words of wisdom to leave behind?
Speaker 2Words of wisdom. Let's see. I would say that if you are going to put your face in your cat's belly, be prepared to have your hair messed up.
Speaker 1Okay.
Speaker 2Sorry, it's the best I can do.
Speaker 1No, that's fine. That's fine. It works. It totally works. And I just want to implore everybody to support your local artists and musicians. And always, always just keep wanting the truth.
Speaker 2Oh, I was so nervous. I was so quiet the whole time. I'm sorry.
Speaker 4That's okay.
Speaker 2It'll be funny.
Speaker 6Okay.
Speaker 1Watch Talk Heathen Live Sundays at 1 p.m.
Speaker 2Central and call into the show at 512-991-9242 or connect to the show online at aca.show slash call.
In today's episode of Truth Wanted, ObjectivelyDan welcomes guest Out Of Body Atheist, with The Beard of Empathy on backup, to dig into Reiki, New Age spirituality, homeopathy, and the long road from woo to skepticism!...
In today's episode of Truth Wanted, Jon the Skeptick, Volcy, and Sofia Spina explain why no one can talk to the dead, from Haitian Vodou and grief dreams to Jon's past as a spiritualist! Bob jumps from objective...
In today's episode of Truth Wanted, ObjectivelyDan and Nintendrew, later joined by The Beard of Empathy, tackle a world run on Jesus, the magic of manifesting, and a prayer that actually got answered! Bob in NY, a...
In today's episode of Truth Wanted, ObjectivelyDan, Kelley Laughlin, and The Beard of Empathy tackle standards of evidence, miracle claims, and the false binaries of moral philosophy! Dean in VA questions why skeptics...
In today's episode of Truth Wanted, ObjectivelyDan and Chad Harris tackle Christian nationalism, police brutality, and the uncomfortable truths about racism and immigration. Big E in TN survived police brutality and...