In today's episode of Truth Wanted, ObjectivelyDan and Nintendrew, later joined by The Beard of Empathy, tackle a world run on Jesus, the magic of manifesting, and a prayer that actually got answered! Bob in NY, a Catholic, argues the world would be better if everyone followed Jesus. Would turning the other cheek really fix things? The hosts weigh Jesus' flaws, Pascal's wager, and faith versus evidence. Is belief a reliable path to truth? Seconds after the hosts pray for a caller, Patrick from Earth, a self-declared ultimate Gnostic atheist, insists atheists waste time debating Christianity, citing Nietzsche, Bob Marley and G.I. Joe. Is knowing really half the battle? Thank you for tuning in this week! We will see you next time! Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/truth-wanted--3195473/support.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Speaker 1Hey folks, it's Objectively Dan here, and I want to talk to you about manifesting, okay? Manifesting is when the universe sort of rearranges itself based on your thoughts and intentions, which is a really nice idea if you don't think about it at all, right? Because what it's actually doing is basically taking credit for your coincidences and also for your hard work, right? And it's a subtle way to blame people for their own suffering and when the universe fails to deliver as well. So, I mean, setting goals
Speaker 1and working towards them is totally real, right? But I'm just saying that anything else beyond that is really just wishful thinking. But hey, I want to know how you can tell the difference between manifesting something and just wanting it just.
Speaker 2Like really badly, right?
Speaker 1So call it and give us your best examples that can't be explained any other way because the show is starting right now. Hello, hello, everybody, and welcome back to another episode of Truth Wanted. I am, again, your host, Objectively Dan, and I want to welcome you to the live call-in show that happens every single week, Sundays at 2.45 p.m.
Speaker 2We talk to people about what they believe and why they believe it.
Speaker 1So if you'd like to call us. You can do that, and you should do that right now at 512-991-9242 or through your computer at ACA.show slash call. Truth Wanted is a product of the Atheist Community of Austin, a 501c3 nonprofit organization dedicated to the promotion of atheism, critical thinking, secular humanism, and the separation of religion and government. And folks, we are tri-streaming today, so big shout out to our viewers on TikTok and YouTube mobile. If you are watching us on TikTok tonight and you'd like to talk to us, then request to join and we'll bring you up on stage.
Speaker 1But please make sure you are over the age of 18 before doing so. And folks, every single week on this show, we always have a special guest. This week is no different. I have Nintendrew joining me today again. Welcome back to the show, Nintendrew.
Speaker 3Thank you so much. Glad to be here. Marcy's glad that you're here.
Speaker 2You're rocking.
Speaker 1Oh, who's this?
Speaker 2Wait, who's this?
Speaker 3This is Marcy.
Speaker 1What munchie marcy marcy shout out to marcy all right we love that we love that we love our cats already intruding that's great also you're rocking the the nintendo shirt oh yeah smash bros it's it's it's uh november 1st today drew what did you do for halloween yesterday.
Speaker 4Oh i went to uh raka's house party in austin and just had a nice time so yeah i i dressed up as a vaguely daft punk inspired uh disco robot vampire.
Speaker 1So okay okay shout out to the vaguely daft punk inspired disco robot vampire that sounds sick as hell i wish i knew that before i would have asked you to get pictures.
Speaker 3So we could oh yeah yeah well yeah i'll send you some.
Speaker 1Okay put in the chat maybe we can get crude yeah those pictures that'd be sick um i stayed at home and let me tell you drew the halloween metagame has changed okay here's what i mean by this I saw the costumes yesterday. I saw from the local neighborhood kids. Crazy good. Also, the parents are in on it. Okay. I saw my favorite one was these two parents that dressed up as like NASCAR engineers and their kid was dressed up like Lightning McQueen.
Speaker 2It was awesome.
Speaker 1I saw a lot of anime. They're doing the anime stuff. I saw a girl as Kiki from Kiki's Delivery Service.
Speaker 5I saw.
Speaker 1some more video game characters and stuff. I'm like, man, they've upped the game. It's really, really cool. I'll tell you one thing I saw, though, Drew, and this is the craziest thing, is I saw a kid, I swear to you this is real, in his Halloween bag, he had a Pokemon card in there. I said, is that a Pokemon card? He said, yeah, I got that from the house. down the street and i was like what the heck man that's an investment these things you can't what are you doing you might as well be getting out bitcoin right like what's up with that.
Speaker 4Yeah no they they like pokemon every year makes those uh trick-or-treat or uh i think they're like trick-or-treat bags of like little like mini packs of pokemon cards.
Speaker 3Yeah really this is like thing yeah yeah.
Speaker 4They specifically like make sets that they sell to people to have in bowls to give out at Halloween?
Speaker 2No way.
Speaker 1Wait, so has that been scalped as well? Like, I'm just wondering how you get that nowadays.
Speaker 2Of course, right?
Speaker 3Of course it does.
Speaker 2That's crazy. First of all, that's sick as hell.
Speaker 1If I was a child in the early aughts and I got a Pokemon card in my Halloween bag, that'd be the sickest thing ever. I'd want to go back to that house every year. So it's like, now it's like, I'm an adult now. So it's like, I have to be that kid person right like i just didn't even know that was an option i didn't even know like the game has changed okay so it has yeah i gotta look into that for next year um but anyway yeah shout outs to the house down the street i guess for giving away pokemon cards that's pretty cool um
Speaker 1yeah besides that i watched the back rooms movie okay that was pretty good actually i enjoyed that quite a bit have you seen that.
Speaker 5I have not.
Speaker 3No, the most recent film I saw was the Nathan Fielder.
Speaker 5Yes.
Speaker 2Oh my goodness.
Speaker 1Have we, I don't know if I've talked about it yet because, oh yeah, the, we, we had problems with the show.
Speaker 5Okay.
Speaker 2I promise we'll get to the caller in just a second.
Speaker 1But listen, if you have not seen this Nathan Fielder, documentary about Elizabeth Holmes, you need to see this movie. This is a 10 out of 10 movie for me, right?
Speaker 5I agree.
Speaker 110 out of 10, you do?
Speaker 3Yeah, I've never seen a documentary quite like that.
Speaker 4Especially just like, it's artistically just unlike anything I've seen in that space.
Speaker 3It's filmed as if it's.
Speaker 4Like a thriller or horror film but it is people's real lives and like yeah the most intimate view of like a truly unwell person that i think i've seen i.
Speaker 1Agree and i and there's multiple people who are unwell in this movie but like um first of all if you're a nathan fielder head it's a must okay but even if you've never seen nathan fielder stuff and you don't know anything about him it's still worth watching i made i told my parents you have to go see this movie and i think they watched it and liked it it's the best movie i think i've seen in the last like five years it's incredible i loved it um if you're a truth wanted guy and you like knowing about fraudsters and scammers and um people in that
Speaker 1space it's it's definitely a movie you got to see but it's also one It's one of those ones where I literally can't tell you anything about it because you have to, you have to experience it for yourself.
Speaker 2Um, but yeah, that movie is awesome. Um, I, uh, I'm glad you saw it too. Cause it's really good.
Speaker 3Yeah, now we got to gossip about it.
Speaker 1Yeah, no, I mean, it's going to be a movie that they put into film textbooks, like starting in college next year, right? There's no way. I just think it has to be. But anyway, on that note, because I can't talk about it. It's too good to spoil. I just want to get to our first caller. I think we got a Bob from New York who wants to talk to us. Drew, you ready to talk to some people?
Speaker 3Sounds great.
Speaker 2Okay, let's do it. We got Bob talking to us from New York.
Speaker 1Bob says that the world could be a better place if everyone followed Jesus, which is interesting.
Speaker 2Bob, why do you think that? You're live on the air.
Speaker 6All right.
Speaker 5Well, thanks for inviting me. No, I appreciate it. By all means, I appreciate it. No, my point is we got a lot of problems in the world. We got wars.
Speaker 2Just one second, Bob.
Speaker 1Our folks on our side, they're going to up your audio, but if you could just talk as clearly as you can.
Speaker 2I'm not sure if you're on speaker.
Speaker 5If you are, you should definitely try not to speak. Okay, I turned the speaker off.
Speaker 2Yes, yes, that's better. Thank you so much.
Speaker 1Appreciate it.
Speaker 5Okay, but no, as I was saying, is that any better?
Speaker 1Yes, I can understand you now. I couldn't before, but I got you now.
Speaker 2Thank you.
Speaker 5I apologize for that. No, okay. Anyway, no, we got wars. We got rumors of wars. We got famine. We got disease. We got this, that, and the other. And if everybody... Uh-oh. What would Jesus do?
Speaker 1Oh, there he is.
Speaker 2Sorry, Bob, you cut out there for a second again, but just keep going. I hear you. So I get you. We got wars, rumors of wars, all kinds of stuff.
Speaker 1But if everybody was a follower of Jesus, you think the world, we're just going to be smiling, everything's going to be rainbows, we're all going to be holding hands and kumbaya?
Speaker 5Absolutely.
Speaker 7Okay.
Speaker 5Okay.
Speaker 1Did not expect you to say yes to that. I thought there'd be qualifiers, but no, you agree with that. Um, I'm going to say that's not the case. I'm going to say that's not the case, and here's why. We have entire countries that have predominantly been Christian for a long time, and they still get into wars with each other. France and England, pretty much believers of Jesus for the most part, for most of its history. France, maybe not as much now. Italy, everybody else, all these places, lots
Speaker 1of world powers that predominantly think that the Abrahamic sort of faith tradition is the way to go, at the very least, and are still getting in trouble with each other. So, like, I think that already kind of He debunks this idea that if everybody was Christian, we'd all get along, right?
Speaker 2Maybe you disagree.
Speaker 5I'm not talking about governments. I'm talking about people like neighbors. You're talking about the 1%.
Speaker 1Your claim was people would not get into wars with each other.
Speaker 2I mean, you said that.
Speaker 5No, no. If the 99% of people stood up and said, you know what? I'm going to live by the golden rule. I'm going to feed the hungry. I'm going to help the sick. If somebody asked me for my shirt, I'm going to give them my jacket too. If somebody asked me to walk a mile, I'm going to go two miles. If everybody did that and we started doing that today, if we said, you know, like the Good Samaritan, for example, if we saw somebody that we considered an outsider in need of help and we went over to them and
Speaker 5we gave them food, clothes, and shelter, everybody would be better off. That's my point.
Speaker 1I mean, I think the golden rule is different from following Jesus because you start off by saying following Jesus.
Speaker 5Right.
Speaker 1So just that's a different kind of thing. But like, I mean, I know actually I've been talking a lot here.
Speaker 2Drew, what's your take on this?
Speaker 3No, I feel similarly. I feel like that's an oversimplification.
Speaker 4Of, of the proposition, but yeah, I mean, I don't necessarily have an issue with saying that the world, like I could envision the world being a better place if most people aligned with the golden rule.
Speaker 3Like, I don't think that's, that's not a very controversial thing.
Speaker 4Like it's, I don't, I don't think that, that you'll find, um, opposition to the idea that there are, um, you know, uh, things that could, that there are, I guess you could, you could, um, There are good messages in the Bible, sure.
Speaker 3There are also heinous messages in the Bible.
Speaker 4And I think it boils down to an oversimplification.
Speaker 2What were you.
Speaker 5Going to say, Bob? Okay, now what I'm going to say is this. All right, now we as humans, we are given... Okay, now let me answer the question with a question. Do you believe in the concept of moral objectivity? It's wrong to steal, it's wrong to lie, and it's good to feed the hungry, and it's good to tell the truth. Do you believe in that?
Speaker 1I don't know if I believe in moral objectivity, but if we're just talking about is it good to tell the truth, is it good to feed the hungry? I mean, that was general principle I'll agree with you on, yeah.
Speaker 8Right, no, but why?
Speaker 5Why is it good?
Speaker 2Well, I'm interested in human well-being and human flourishing.
Speaker 9Why?
Speaker 1Because I'm a human being, and I think if other people did the same thing, the world would be a better place, for sure.
Speaker 5Well, so what? No, no, no, I know. But, like, if the sun is going to expand, and according to theoretical physicists or whatever, the sun is going to expand and it's going to consume the Earth completely. in a matter of years. So why even bother with trying to be, that's not going.
Speaker 1To, that's not going to happen while I'm alive, dude, but that's going to happen while we're all gone.
Speaker 2Okay.
Speaker 1Like that's where in the future, maybe they're going to be watching this on some cool hit future.
Speaker 5Yeah.
Speaker 4Yeah.
Speaker 1Go for it.
Speaker 4There's a, there's a, Bob, there's a quote from one of my favorite films. It's a Boots Riley film called sorry to bother you. It's about a guy who goes through a shady call center.
Speaker 5Unrelated.
Speaker 4But there's a quote early on where the main character, he is having kind of an existential crisis about the world and thinking that nothing that he's doing matters. Because the sun's going to expand and the universe is going to implode or whatever. It's all going to be for nothing. And his girlfriend is lying beside him in the bed and she says something to the effect of, When I kiss you, it's not for posterity. It's because this matters in this moment. We're experiencing something now. And I think
Speaker 4that that's maybe a place to start with that kind of reasoning.
Speaker 5Absolutely. No, absolutely. No, I mean, every moment matters. You know, every day you take it one day at a time. You don't take tomorrow for granted. But anyway, no, my point is why we even, you know, like... Why is there, like, I mean, what do you expect to happen after you die?
Speaker 1This is veering off-topic from the original premise of this call, which is that if everybody followed Jesus, we'd be holding hands and singing Kumbaya. I mean, I'm willing to entertain that for you, Bob, but, like, you know, the truth is I don't think anything's going to happen to me after I die. I'm not sure how that relates to the original premise, though.
Speaker 4It's preventable.
Speaker 5It ties into it. No, no, it ties into it because this is the thing. If everybody did what Jesus did, you know, everybody would be, you know, in a better place. And what I just asked you was what you think would happen after you die. And I guess I can rephrase that into what would you hope would happen after you die?
Speaker 1It doesn't really matter what I hope to happen.
Speaker 2What matters is what happens, right?
Speaker 5Right. Right.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 2What happens to me after I die?
Speaker 1I mean, if you're saying, if there's a moral calculus, right, if there's some sort of calculus you're deriving where, hmm, if I get to go to heaven because I'm doing some good things in life, I would understand why that's relevant, right?
Speaker 2But I don't believe that's going to happen to me. I think I'm going to be buried in the ground and the worms are going to eat me, and then.
Speaker 1I'm going to be forgotten after maybe 10 years, 20 years max, you know?
Speaker 2Maybe I'll have some.
Speaker 1Grandkids that will think about me.
Speaker 3Don't be so hard on yourself.
Speaker 8Yeah.
Speaker 2You know, beyond that, it's not going to be very long.
Speaker 7Right.
Speaker 2So like, I don't know.
Speaker 1You know, that doesn't actually matter for me to be good to other people, though.
Speaker 2That's what's kind of interesting.
Speaker 1I think Christians emphasize that because you do get you do get something after you die.
Speaker 5Right.
Speaker 2There is sort of a reward structure.
Speaker 7Right.
Speaker 1But like, I don't have that reward structure and I can still treat other people pretty good. And I think that can cause some cognitive dissonance. Within certain Christians, right? Because you don't really understand that without having that incentive.
Speaker 5Sure. No, no. Do you believe in objective morality? Yes or no?
Speaker 1Again, I already answered this. I'm not sure that I do. You know, I think it's a complicated question. But why does that have to do with the claim that everybody believing in Jesus is going to make the world better?
Speaker 5Because I believe he's the truth. Do you believe in the concept of the truth?
Speaker 1I believe I have a show called Truth Wanted, and I believe in that concept.
Speaker 2I don't know what it means to say Jesus is the truth or whatever.
Speaker 3You know?
Speaker 5Oh, no. I'm saying, like, how is it? Let me rephrase it. No, I'm not the most articulate person in the world.
Speaker 1That's okay.
Speaker 5But anyway, no, anyway, but I want you to give me one criticism of Jesus Christ.
Speaker 2One criticism? Just one? I mean, he's a megalomaniac, for sure.
Speaker 1Household he made people like leave uproot their lives he told somebody hey don't bury your father after he died right you need to spend your life following me up until the end of um you know his life um i think all that's a thing that cult leaders say right um hey you need to give up everything and follow me because i'm the way the truth in the life i'm literally the son of god right if you heard somebody down the street saying that you'd say no that's crazy don't follow that but for some reason because it's jesus we give him a pass i guess because
Speaker 1people think he's the real deal but i don't think he is sure okay now.
Speaker 5I'm gonna answer each one of those points anyway he said um let the dead bury their dead uh anyway no so what do you mean by that was saying like um Don't look back. Don't look behind. Look forward. Because in the future, the data is going to be resurrected and given.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 2And he was wrong. It didn't happen.
Speaker 5Right.
Speaker 1Like I think I mean, we're getting into theological territory here. I think like if you look at the claims of Jesus and what he was talking about, he was talking about an apocalypse that was happening like. relatively soon within the lifetimes of the followers of the text, because otherwise it doesn't make sense for people 2,000 years in the future to be reading it. But just to keep everybody on point and accountable for each other, I really want to stay true to the original thing that you called about, which is, would everybody following Jesus make everybody hold hands
Speaker 1and sing Kumbaya? I still think that that's not true. And I'm wondering why you disagree with that.
Speaker 5Because, okay, because this is what he said. He said, he said, blessed are the poor for they shall, you know, inherit the earth. No, blessed are the meek. Anyway, no, he said, no, he fed the hungry. Okay. He walked on water. So, I mean, I'm sure if everybody knows, and that's a, we can look at that both literally and, you know, metaphysically. Everybody goes through problems and we got wars and rumors of wars and we got all kinds
Speaker 5of problems. If everybody could perform their own miracle for good, for a good purpose, if everybody could just perform one miracle for a good purpose, then the world would be a better place.
Speaker 1If everyone could perform one miracle for a good purpose?
Speaker 5Yeah.
Speaker 2What does that mean?
Speaker 4It sounds like you're saying if everyone had superpowers for a day and used them for good, then.
Speaker 1The world would be better. Yeah, what do we mean by good miracle?
Speaker 5Well, no, that's pretty much what I mean. But no, what I mean is this. Okay, say, okay, for me, for example, if I have a sick family member and I got homeless people on the street, I could say, If I could do one miracle, I'd say, you know, God help those in need and then they'd be helped. Everybody in the world, because that's what Jesus did. He helped those in need.
Speaker 8For example.
Speaker 5There was a, in the Bible, I know you don't believe it, but whatever. He will take it with a grain of salt. But anyway, he said there was a guy with a fucking blindness and, sorry for my language, anyway, he spit in the mud and he rubbed the mud in his.
Speaker 1Eyes and the guy could see it Yes.
Speaker 5No, so he walked around. He went from community to community.
Speaker 2And how many, Bob, how many Christians do you know that have done that today?
Speaker 5No, I'm saying if.
Speaker 1Right, but it doesn't happen because Christians can't perform miracles, right?
Speaker 2Do you agree with that?
Speaker 5No, I don't necessarily believe that.
Speaker 1Really? How many miracles have you heard from your Christians in your community just recently?
Speaker 5No, but there's miracles. What about the miracle of Lanciano? No, no, no.
Speaker 1Listen, we can talk about some statue cried some weird substance or whatever. I understand these exist, but you put forward a very good miracle, right? You're like, hey, this guy's blindness got healed because he put some spit on, he put some mud in there.
Speaker 2Why don't we hear about that today? Where is that happening?
Speaker 1How come Christians aren't able to perform that kind of stuff at their local hospitals?
Speaker 5Sure.
Speaker 2I mean, there's lots of Christians in the world today, right?
Speaker 5Right, no, we live in a divided world. We live in a world where we have a conflict of interest.
Speaker 2You don't think Jesus lived in a divided time?
Speaker 5No, he definitely did.
Speaker 2So why can't we do it anymore?
Speaker 5We can. I'm saying we're in a better place if we fucking– I'm sorry. I keep saying that anyway.
Speaker 1You can keep– you can say whatever words you want. I'm not going to censor you for that. So don't worry about that.
Speaker 2But like what are you saying?
Speaker 1What do you mean when you say like if everybody could do it? I just want one person to do it.
Speaker 3I think to the extent of what– I think to the extent that what Bob is saying is true, it's not really useful or relevant. Like it's– I don't know.
Speaker 4Because it's not like even if like if you're saying, yeah, let's let's take like all the good things that Jesus said.
Speaker 3And if everybody followed all the good things, then the world would be better. Sure.
Speaker 4But like, does that get us anywhere closer to whether or not the facts of. the events as stated in the Bible are correct or an accurate account of history. This doesn't, like you can point to lessons in Marvel comics or to, you know, whatever you want to and say that this is good, but it doesn't really help us move conversation forward.
Speaker 5No, no, no, whatever.
Speaker 1Okay.
Speaker 5No, I personally believe that Jesus was a real person. I personally believe in every word of the Bible. Anyway, no, as a hypothetical situation, as a scenario, okay? And we have this guy, he's equally man, he's equally God. And he goes around, you know, speaking the truth and healing the sick and feeding the hungry and clothing the naked and this, that, and the other. So I'm just asking you to poke a hole, one hole and then the concept. Tell me why it's a bad, no, tell me why
Speaker 5it's not worthy of belief. Tell me why, no, I'm saying, no, that ties back in there.
Speaker 1This is like me saying, You need to understand, Bob, this is like me saying, no, no, I need you to believe everything Jim Jones said about himself, or I need you to believe everything David Koresh said about himself, and I need you to poke a hole in that. Well, if I start with the premise that everything that they're saying is true, well, then, yeah, that's going to be hard to argue with, right? Because Koresh thought he was the son of God, too. But, like, you know, that's the problem. I don't believe in the things that he said. And one– Bob, let me finish and I'll let you talk. One reason why I think it's not true is because
Speaker 1the Bible says in several parts, particularly in passages at the end of Mark, for example, and in the book of Acts when these things happen, that Christians can do miracles and can do stuff in performance of God, right? You brought this up. You said miracles– Could be could be done. Everybody could be doing stuff. And we're not even seeing that today.
Speaker 2Right.
Speaker 1Jesus said that, you know, that we wouldn't have to know death and that we could, you know, there be a coming world where the you know, the meek inherit the earth, all this kinds of stuff. And that hasn't happened for 2000 years. It hasn't happened. Right. So I just don't think that these stories are true.
Speaker 2In that sense. And that's part of the reason why I don't.
Speaker 5Why? Okay, no, okay, no, that makes, okay, well, no, I mean, I have my own personal doubts about the matter too. I'm not, I'm not going to say, I'm like, anyway, why do you think people are still talking about Jesus Christ if he was a nobody? Okay, no.
Speaker 1Why do you think people are still talking about the prophet Muhammad if he didn't do the miracles that he claimed he could do?
Speaker 5I don't want to get into it.
Speaker 2No, no, no, no, Bob.
Speaker 1You don't get to say, I don't get to get into this religion that also another billion people believe in.
Speaker 2What are you saying?
Speaker 5Okay, well, let me say this. Okay, no, because they're a little more protective of their ideology. And if I say something the wrong way, I might.
Speaker 1Bob, nobody is going to go after anonymous caller Bob from New York for talking shit about the prophet or not.
Speaker 2Okay, so don't worry about that.
Speaker 1But let's say, okay, you have issues with speaking out about the prophet. Peace be upon him. Okay, that's fine. You can talk about, like, other religions. Let's talk about Joseph Smith. There's millions of people that believe in Joseph Smith was the real deal.
Speaker 5Okay.
Speaker 1Why does that exist? If we know that Joseph Smith, let's break this down. If we know that Joseph Smith wasn't the real deal, why do millions of people believe it?
Speaker 2What would you say to that?
Speaker 5Okay, no, what I would say to that, and this is going to get me into some hot water, which I'm already in, but anyway, I would say it's the devil and demons trying to tempt people.
Speaker 2That wasn't the answer I was hoping you'd say, Bob.
Speaker 1What I was hoping you would say was, well, people can believe things that aren't true.
Speaker 7Right.
Speaker 2People can.
Speaker 1That's just the thing. People can believe things that aren't true. And people pass on those beliefs to their children and their children's children. And it just goes from there. So that's kind of my answer to your question is, why do people believe in Jesus? Right. It's because people can believe in things that aren't true.
Speaker 5No, I believe it's the Holy Spirit is why people believe in why we know. OK, let me put this way. Let me let me phrase it this way. And I want to hear what you have to say. Anyway, why would 2 billion people in 2026 worship a homeless lunatic, so to speak, in your view? Why would somebody worship a Middle Eastern homeless crazy guy? uh, megalomaniac, as you said,
Speaker 5to I in 2026, why would 2 billion people worship him? Uh, 2000 years later, if there was no matter to the message.
Speaker 2Drew, what would you say to that?
Speaker 3Uh, I mean, my first thought.
Speaker 4Would be like, why was the majority opinion that the, uh, that the sun revolved around the earth? Like, you know, uh, a few centuries back, you know, like there's the number of people who believe something, does not tell us anything about the veracity of it.
Speaker 5No, I'm asking why would they, do you think we're in a mass psychosis? Do you think we're just delusional or do you think we're just wishful?
Speaker 4No, I think that people get an, uh, an incredible amount of, of community and a sense of belonging and a sense of purpose from, from folklore and traditions and things that they, they passed down for generations. There's, I mean, we've been recently talking about how, like just being able, like we're, this is a production of, um, the atheist community of Austin and in, in, in Austin, we have a lot of in-person like community events at the Freethought library. And that's a, it's, it's been a really important kind of third space. And I'm glad that we have this language for this, this, the idea of a third space being something similar to a church, but not revolving around
Speaker 4dogma and around this, this kind of like tradition for tradition's sake. But I do think that there are, I mean, yeah, there's demonstrably a lot of sense of purpose, belonging, and community that people get from these faith traditions. And I think it's important to be able to have conversations about alternative sources for those kinds of.
Speaker 3Senses of purpose and belonging.
Speaker 5Okay, back to the original question. I'm sorry, but do you, or yes or no, do you think the world would be a better place If everybody tried to act like Jesus.
Speaker 3If everybody tried to act like Jesus. I don't know. I feel like we'd have to.
Speaker 1Jesus did not want people to act like Jesus. Let's be clear about that. Jesus wanted people to worship him. Right. So if we all act like Jesus, we want everybody to worship each other. That that wouldn't work out.
Speaker 5Right.
Speaker 1This is going back to my megalomania comments about Jesus. He was not he did not think you were you and I were equal. He thought he was the son of God. So there are some there is a difference there.
Speaker 5Right.
Speaker 2But, you know, besides that, like.
Speaker 1People have traditions and beliefs and you don't have to necessarily be delusional in thinking that these things are real or not real, right? Like people can just live their lives and these traditions can inform them on what to do and what not to do. And I also think people overemphasize the point of religion in their lives too. I think sometimes people bring it up When they feel pressured to. But if you ask them what they did on a day to day, they probably aren't following the Christians of sorry, the teachings of Christianity as much as you might think as well.
Speaker 5Right.
Speaker 1So there's kind of a balance in talking about these things. But I mean, to answer the question you just asked, definitely not. No, I mean, people would be um, claiming that they're the son of God and that nobody else is, and they'd be flipping over tables in front of, you know, uh, temples and stuff.
Speaker 2It'd be a bad time. I don't think it'd be good.
Speaker 5You got the wrong idea. Now, what I was talking about is, excuse me, you know, if everybody, uh, tried to, uh, You know, live, you know, and it says in the Bible, God did not, he said he equated, equality with God as robbery. In other words, he was humble. He was meek. He was mild. If everybody was humble, meek, and mild, if they went out of their way to help a
Speaker 5stranger in need, if they went out of their way to feed somebody who needed food, if they went and visited somebody lonely or in need of company, Anyway, no, it's basically the golden rule. Jesus was the living version of the golden rule. I'm saying he was the one who came up with it. No, by the way, I'm sure other people said similar things, but he was the one who it's attributed to. Anyway, it says, do unto
Speaker 5others that what you would do unto yourself. So, no, I'm saying, you know, how would the world improve?
Speaker 1I don't know that that's true. Bob, let me give you an example of why this might not be the case.
Speaker 2Are you married, Bob? Can I ask that? Do you have a spouse or a partner?
Speaker 5No, I have not been blessed in that department.
Speaker 2I got you.
Speaker 1Do you have family that you care about? Do you have a mom or a dad or a brother or sister?
Speaker 5I have parents and a brother, yeah. Okay.
Speaker 2So I'm going to use a very gruesome example. So bear with me, OK?
Speaker 1I'm going to say that somebody murders your family, right? God forbid that never happens. But let's say that does happen and somebody kills your family in cold blood and we take it to the court and the judge says, you know what? I was going to put this person in prison for life. And, you know, we were interested in maybe giving restitution for the family. But, you know, Jesus said to turn the other cheek. So I think we're just going to let this person go. We're going to forgive them for that. I mean, do you think that's just?
Speaker 5No, no.
Speaker 1No, you don't.
Speaker 2Why not? Why not? Why not turn the other cheek?
Speaker 5That's a golden rule.
Speaker 2No, the golden is the golden.
Speaker 8Really?
Speaker 2Do unto others as you would have them do unto you.
Speaker 1Right.
Speaker 5Oh yeah. No, no, I would not have somebody, you know, turn a blind eye to my own demise. What I would do is, and I would do the same thing to another person, is to stand up for them, stick up for them, testify for them, and the other. And no, so no, doing that would be a disgrace.
Speaker 2Well, Jesus says to forgive other people, right?
Speaker 1No, they'd be forgiven. He says, Father, forgive their transgressions as we forgive those who transgress against us.
Speaker 5Absolutely.
Speaker 4Right?
Speaker 5No, sure enough. Absolutely. No, no, they'd be, no. I mean, by God's grace, they'd be forgiven. But no, okay, let's talk about, let's use an example. No, no, no.
Speaker 1I would like to stick with this example, please. Let's finish this thought experiment out. You're okay.
Speaker 2What are you saying? You're saying this criminal should not face penalties?
Speaker 5No, no, I'm not saying that.
Speaker 2No, no, I'm saying.
Speaker 5With the person, okay. everybody should emulate Jesus in a way that is merciful. Look what happened when they accused the woman of adultery. They were ready to throw stones at her. And Jesus came in there and said, you know, right.
Speaker 1He said, he said, uh, he who has cast the first sin, don't throw the stone.
Speaker 5Right.
Speaker 1So in this scenario, we're saying Jesus is the judge and, and we're talking about the murderer and Jesus is saying, Hey, don't put this guy in jail. He who has not cast a stone.
Speaker 5Right.
Speaker 2I mean, like, like he would say, forgive him. Let's not do anything.
Speaker 5Sure. No, sure enough. No. Okay. Sure enough. No. Basically. No. I mean, No, basically, this is how it goes. Okay, no. They'd be forgiven on my behalf. I mean, as hard as it would be to forgive somebody that massacred my family or whatever. Okay. No, but they'd be forgiven.
Speaker 2But wait a minute. But the state should forgive him as well, right?
Speaker 1Because under your view, if everybody acted like Jesus, right, they'd have to forgive him, right?
Speaker 5Right. Not necessarily, no.
Speaker 1Oh, so there's some exceptions to this rule then.
Speaker 5No, no, no, no, no, no, no, no. By no means, because Jesus himself, he kind of got mad at one. You were talking about flipping the tables.
Speaker 1Right, because he's a megalomaniac, but that's my claim. Yeah.
Speaker 5He got mad because it was a temple and they were turning it into a flea market.
Speaker 1I understand, but I don't go to other people's spaces and flip tables that aren't my spaces. I feel like that's a little entitled to do that.
Speaker 5That was his place.
Speaker 2He was God. See, that's what I'm saying.
Speaker 1He thinks he owns everything.
Speaker 2He doesn't own that temple. He's just a guy.
Speaker 1But listen, man, my point with this, Bob, is I think I'm giving examples of if people actually did the thing that Jesus did in every situation and It may not actually lead to a just society, right?
Speaker 2It may actually give us different kinds of problems.
Speaker 1It may solve some things, but I don't know if the golden rule is applicable in every situation.
Speaker 5Oh, it is. That's why you know. Okay. I want you to give me one, one, just name one bad trait about Jesus.
Speaker 2I already did that. I feel like I already did that. I already told you he's a megalomaniac. He, he, he has an ego problem.
Speaker 1No, he's, He flipped people's tables over temples he didn't own and said it was his house or his father's house is what he said.
Speaker 2That's not a good trait. I'm not inviting that guy to my parties, Bob.
Speaker 1I don't want anybody that's flipping over tables, you know? Here's another one. He cursed the fig tree, you know, because he didn't give him fruit. I don't even know if it was his fig tree. I think it was just some random fig tree. He didn't owe him anything, you know?
Speaker 3No, I know.
Speaker 1You want me to keep going?
Speaker 5Yeah.
Speaker 1I can keep going. I can do this all day. I don't think Jesus is the guy you think he is, you know? I think you think he'd be kind of a jerk. Anyway, Bob, we should probably start wrapping up this call. We've been talking for like almost 30 minutes now. So I need to wrap things up. Is there anything else you wanted to say before we kind of wrap this up today?
Speaker 5Well, I mean, hang on. No, I appreciate you taking my call, by the way.
Speaker 2Of course.
Speaker 5Yeah, no, by all means. Well, no, I mean, basically, I mean, can I ask you one last question?
Speaker 1Anything, Bob, anything.
Speaker 5All right, no, okay. It's kind of grim. Okay, so how does an atheist make peace with the concept of losing their own life and seeing the loss of the life of their family. Like, how do we make peace with the idea of death? Because I don't know about you. I mean, I like being alive. You know, I like breathing the air. I like seeing the sunshine. I like hearing the birds chirping. I like, you know, just that
Speaker 5and the other. And it hurts me to think that, you know, someday everything is going to come to an end. blackness or like, you know, basically like before you were born. I heard Mark Twain say, I think it was Mark Twain. He's like, I've been dead for billions and billions of years before I was born and never caused me one bit of inconvenience. But, you know, once you're granted life, you know, you kind of seek it. And I'm wondering why some people don't seek eternal life. And let me
Speaker 5rephrase the question.
Speaker 1Yeah, you don't have to rephrase it. I think I get it, right? How do you deal with that? Because we don't have an out for life, right?
Speaker 5What do you have to lose if you believe in Jesus Christ, if you're just going to go into it?
Speaker 1Oh, well, that's a bit of a different question. That's a bit of a different question. Because, well, this is Pascal's wager, right? And the truth is, well, one, Christianity is not the only belief system that exists in the world. So there's going to be consequences for not believing in other religions as well, right? So it's not just a, well, you have nothing to lose. You do have something to lose. There is a tradeoff. Another thing that you can lose, though, is your sense of integrity, right? And your sense of what's really right and wrong and your sense of self,
Speaker 1because if you're following the Christian way of doing things, I actually don't think the Christian way of doing things is always the best way to do things.
Speaker 5Right.
Speaker 1I think you deny a bit of yourself. Bob, let me finish, please. And I'll answer your question so I can answer your question.
Speaker 5Right.
Speaker 1When I'm following Christians teachings on things, that's going to cause me into trouble with my friends. For example, if I tell them, hey, you can't love the person that you love in your life because you're a man and that person's also a man. I think that's wrong. I think you should be able to love whoever you want. But there's a lot of Christians that don't feel that way.
Speaker 5Right.
Speaker 1Hey, I actually think the earth is older than six thousand years old. Maybe you're not that kind of Christian, but there's a lot of Christians that say, hey, you have to understand a biblical worldview of history and creation in order to be a real christian and i think that's wrong so it's a denial of science there's all kinds of there's all kinds of bad consequences if you choose to believe that christianity is true and i want to take it drew do you have any other thoughts on that because i i think that there's um there's a lot of reasons why um you don't want to be that way.
Speaker 5No because no I'm a Catholic, okay, and there's a difference between Catholics and Protestants and Methodists and Baptists.
Speaker 2I know. I'm aware.
Speaker 1That's part of the problem.
Speaker 5Well, no, I believe no, and I don't mean to be egotistical, but I believe the Catholic Church is the one.
Speaker 2You don't say.
Speaker 5I mean, the Catholic Church is the only embodiment of the.
Speaker 4Revelations Okay, but how do we, this would lead to, in my mind, the outsider test for faith. How would we be able to discern between, because we've heard this a lot, right? Like, I grew up in a group that claimed to have the one true interpretation of God's word, right? And I know many others who grew up in mutually exclusive belief systems. So, yeah, the question becomes, how do we determine which one, if any, is correct? And when
Speaker 4you have so many mutually exclusive belief systems that, that each, uh, yeah, that, that, that cannot, that are not, uh, compatible with each other, then really what it comes back to the, I guess the old adage was that like, you know, you believe, or you, you disbelieve in, you know, uh, 999 different gods. And I just disbelieve one more than you do or whatever the, I'm butchering the phrase, but I think you probably know what I'm talking about, Dan.
Speaker 10Yeah.
Speaker 5Yeah. Well, no, I mean, it comes down to a matter of faith. I mean, I was going to say, you can't look and you can't use them. You can't build a big enough, excuse me, I got to cut my throat. You can't build a big enough telescope to see into heaven. Okay. You can't, you can't look at me eyes. Okay. And you can't. Okay.
Speaker 3So if that's the case, no, hold on, Bob. No, that's, that's very important.
Speaker 4If you're saying that the foundation for your belief system is faith, And if faith is incompatible with objective science, or not objective, but like scientific inquiry, or we'll say, you know, if it cannot be tested in the lab, right? You're saying that a cornerstone of your worldview is based on something that cannot be verified, that it is not testable, verifiable, falsifiable.
Speaker 4I am not content with that in my existence. I cannot find myself to be compelled by something that is not.
Speaker 3Verifiable, not testable, not falsifiable.
Speaker 4We can come up with any number of unfalsifiable explanations for the universe or for anything.
Speaker 3The strength of your.
Speaker 4Of your argument or your claim lands on the independent evidence that you can provide.
Speaker 3And right now I'm lacking.
Speaker 5Okay. Okay. I don't know. Before I get into the evidence, I want to talk about the contingency argument.
Speaker 2Well, hold on. So there is evidence for your belief.
Speaker 1Right.
Speaker 2So it's not by faith then.
Speaker 5Well, no, there's evidence, but there's not proof. So you've got to believe it, even when you can't see it. It's like when the wind blows, you can say, okay, it's blowing from the east to the west, even though you can't see the wind. You can't prove it.
Speaker 2You can measure the wind, though.
Speaker 1Right.
Speaker 5OK, OK. That was a bad example.
Speaker 1But anyway, well, I know I think it's important because one, that's not literally the first. I've heard that example several times.
Speaker 7Right.
Speaker 1But like we do have we can demonstrate that the wind exists as much as we can. Any other natural force exists.
Speaker 2In the universe, right?
Speaker 1So I think this is curious that you have this distinction or dichotomy between what counts as something that is by faith and what counts as something that you, quote, have proof for. Because if you have evidence for something, right, maybe your difference is, well, the evidence isn't conclusive. Okay, sure.
Speaker 2But if you have something that supports your idea of being more true than it's not true, that's different from believing in something where you have no capacity to determine What's real or not real, right?
Speaker 5No, no. This ties into it. No, this is what I would say to that. Okay. Now, why would the same... Okay, so the Roman Empire is under Pontius Pilate. Well, under whatever, but Pontius Pilate was a part of the Roman Empire. Anyway, he was the one who was responsible for crucifying Jesus. Okay, now explain to me why the Roman Empire, the same government that Murder Jesus Christ would convert into the Holy
Speaker 5Roman Empire, become a Catholic.
Speaker 2That was 300 years into the future.
Speaker 3No, but why?
Speaker 1Because it was 300 years apart. What are you talking about? First of all, Pontius Pilate didn't become a Christian.
Speaker 2You know that, right?
Speaker 5No, no, that's not what I said. What I said was, excuse me the roman government uh was the one.
Speaker 1Um yeah under constantine 300 years later why though why why because people believe people change religions what do you want me to say i mean he says it's because he had a he had a vision you know so that's that's going to be his reason.
Speaker 2Sorry say again what was that Well, no, I'm just.
Speaker 5Saying, like, and you discredit his experience? For what reason? Maybe he did have a vision.
Speaker 1Do you know, I mean, other world leaders have also had visions for other religious beliefs as well. Do you know how many people in the Arabic peninsula got converted to Islam?
Speaker 5Right?
Speaker 1I mean, like, all kinds of things happen, and people change religions, and that's just how the world works. I'm not sure why one person in one point in time changing their religious belief makes it more believable.
Speaker 3Well, I'm trying to figure out what the implication is.
Speaker 4Is it that this is a miraculous or divine intervention here that it happened?
Speaker 1Do you think that because one Roman guy executed somebody 300 years in the past that the entire civilization of Roman people can't become Christians? Do you think that the Roman people are just one single brain and they share– it's like pluribus?
Speaker 1I think we're hitting, I think we're hitting points that you can't really disagree with or give us good reasons for.
Speaker 2And that's why we're changing the.
Speaker 1Subject yet again, because we've done this like, like five times now in this conversation, Bob, and it's getting a little frustrating.
Speaker 5It's not, no, it's not because I want to go for it.
Speaker 3Yeah.
Speaker 1Okay.
Speaker 5Hmm. No, I suppose.
Speaker 8Okay.
Speaker 2Oh, yeah, Bob.
Speaker 1Okay. I'm going to let this go because we've been talking to you for over 30 minutes now. And now we're at 40 minutes. And I said that we were going to end this 10 minutes ago. Okay. So I am going to let you go now because I can't. This is too long. But you can call back. And if you have better things you want to talk about. Right. Or, or, or, or more evidence or more ideas you want to discuss with us or more questions.
Speaker 2That's fine. But we got to let you go for now. Okay.
Speaker 5Okay. No, but by all means, no, I mean, this is an ongoing thought process of mine. And the reason why I called in is because I like to, you know, I like to, you know, you know, check myself and, uh, stuff like that. But anyway, no, um, yeah.
Speaker 2I love that. And thank you.
Speaker 1Thank you for, for, for, for having that opportunity and for checking yourself with us.
Speaker 3Yeah. Keep thinking and keep working on those, those ideas.
Speaker 2I'll happily talk to you again. Yeah, for sure. Um, but, uh, we'll let you go for now, Bob.
Speaker 1Thanks.
Speaker 2Thanks so much for calling in.
Speaker 1Um, damn. Well, uh, Drew, what'd you think?
Speaker 3Yeah, it definitely was a meandering for sure.
Speaker 1Meandering is an understatement, I think. And this happens a lot on this show.
Speaker 2This happens a lot. This happens on AXP, on Talk Heathen. Why does this happen?
Speaker 1I think this happens because people have ideas in their head that they think maybe are good.
Speaker 2And they bring up those ideas. These ideas get countered.
Speaker 1And then they immediately want to pivot to something else that they think maybe is better. And then we counter that and we do this loop over and over and over and over again.
Speaker 2Right?
Speaker 3I thought it was odd just the way it started.
Speaker 4It seemed like he was coming from an angle that like, oh, if I could just get these guys to agree that that Jesus did nothing wrong and is a great role model, then it, then that means that the Bible is true. And I heard like that, that's kind of like, it felt like.
Speaker 3The angle he was taking, but yeah.
Speaker 1Yeah. Um, I mean, I think like, well, there's also this, um, capitulation between, uh, doing what Jesus wants and the golden rule. I actually don't think Jesus is very consistent in his application of, of that rule. He definitely treats other people differently depending on the narrative, for sure. I mean, that's a whole thing to get into. But at the end of the day, your idea of Jesus is going to be a culturally constructed one. The truth is, we all
Speaker 1know only so much about the guy. We have texts that are written from him that are not contemporary to his life, allegedly written by people who knew him. That's contested in many regards. And like a million forgeries. That's not even including the stuff that's not in the Bible. Like half the letters of Paul by modern Christians scholarship has basically been shown to be probably not written by him.
Speaker 5Right.
Speaker 1So it's like there's only so much we can know about Jesus, the character. And even then, I don't think he's the best role model. So what are they going to do with that? You know? Yeah.
Speaker 4I was thinking about I mean, you didn't bring this up specifically, but I was you'd brought up the the idea of what.
Speaker 3Was it was something that.
Speaker 4I guess just the golden rule isn't always applicable, but I was thinking of turning to the Ten Commandments and honor your mother and father. That's one that I can think of that is probably incorrect in a lot of scenarios when one's mother or father is wicked or doing something.
Speaker 2Yeah, what if your dad was Jeffrey Dahmer? Do you need to honor him? I don't know. Probably not, right?
Speaker 3I don't think so.
Speaker 2Maybe not.
Speaker 1Anyway, we still have open lines, folks, so I want to talk to you if you want to call in. And again, also, TikTok folks, get in here. Originally, our premise was about manifesting things. That was what we talked about. Bob called in before we announced the topic. But real quickly, before we keep moving on, I just want to give a shout-out to our Patreon. Please consider donating on their Patreon. If you like the content we produce, go to ac.show.com. patreon.tv for that and also hey go to our watch parties um we have watch parties here in austin um live
Speaker 1on sundays so you can watch talk heath and truth wanted an atheist experience and doors are open like literally right now they open at noon every sunday um so check that out if you want to uh do something in the area i'd way to support us is by sending us super chats.
Speaker 2I'm not sure that we have any in the moment.
Speaker 1Um, crew will let me know if that's not true, but, uh, we will read those out loud. If you send them in again, another way to send us, um, uh, and stuff, stuff to support us. Um, it please of course, like, and subscribe, enable those notifications and comment. On what your favorite part of the video is. If you want to help us with engagement. And last but not least. I need to give a special shout out to. The wonderful amazing fantastic crew. That help make this show happen. Every single week. Let's go to that crew cam. Real quickly. There's our crew. Lots of folks who help out. So
Speaker 1thank you all for that. And who all wear great t-shirts by the way.
Speaker 2Good stuff.
Speaker 1We also have Beard on deck. Shout out to Beard. Let's get Beard on screen real quick. Because Beard.
Speaker 3Yeah, you got to say this constantly.
Speaker 2First of all, hello, big boss. I didn't realize you were, you know, on the show with us.
Speaker 1That's great. How is, you know, how's Metal Gear doing? How are you, man?
Speaker 2It's going good?
Speaker 3Oh, he's muted.
Speaker 2You're muted right now, my friend. Got to get that sorted.
Speaker 8I went to the Kelly Laughlin School of Audio Tech.
Speaker 2Yeah, that's good.
Speaker 1That's good.
Speaker 6For some reason, everybody's been telling me today, yesterday was Halloween.
Speaker 8I don't know why.
Speaker 2This is just your daily fit. Yeah, I don't know why people are saying that, you know?
Speaker 8I don't get it.
Speaker 2It's true. It's true. You 3D printed that eye patch, right?
Speaker 8I did.
Speaker 3I did.
Speaker 2That's awesome.
Speaker 1That's so cool.
Speaker 8Nice design on there.
Speaker 2It is really good.
Speaker 1That is really good. Mainly, I just wanted you on screen to show off your sick eye patch.
Speaker 2So thank you. Thank you for doing that. What did you think of that last call, Beardball? We got you here.
Speaker 8Bob was all over the place.
Speaker 2Yeah, yeah.
Speaker 6He didn't know where he wanted to settle on any argument. He just, so many things he was just trying to do. The whole basic premise, like, wouldn't it be great if everybody believed in Jesus?
Speaker 2Yeah.
Speaker 8Okay, sure.
Speaker 6It'd be great if everybody believed the same thing. But that's a very small step away from everybody should be made to believe the same thing.
Speaker 1True.
Speaker 8That's a problem.
Speaker 5Yeah.
Speaker 10Yeah.
Speaker 2I agree with that. I agree with that.
Speaker 1There is this idea where, of course, I want everybody to think the same way I do because I think I'm right about things, right? But I also, there's a lot of things I don't know. And there's a lot of things that I probably think I'm right on. but it probably isn't right or true, right? And so maybe it isn't a good idea for everybody to think the way that I am. And as much as I want to just shake somebody's shoulders and be like, stop believing in this bullshit, right?
Speaker 2Like that's just not how people work. And maybe that's a good thing.
Speaker 1Um because i want to have my independence as much as i can and i think that same right should extend to other people including independence of thought right so you know something to something to think about there um well we still have open lines so um while we're waiting on that folks let's talk about our topic today which is manifesting uh reality i think by the way we talk about manifesting as this sort of new age concept,
Speaker 1which it is, but I think Christians actually manifest stuff all the time.
Speaker 7Right.
Speaker 1And what I mean by that is when you pray and you're like, I want this person to be better. I want to, you know, make sure I'm doing good on this test. I want to have this person be in my life or whatever romantically or something.
Speaker 5Right.
Speaker 1That's not too different from asking the universe for these things, in my opinion.
Speaker 5Right.
Speaker 2Is this a hot take? Do you agree with this?
Speaker 8I think it's pretty much the same.
Speaker 5Yeah.
Speaker 8Very similar.
Speaker 5Yeah.
Speaker 2Drew, same thing.
Speaker 3It, it feels, I mean, it's, it's an extension of positive thinking for sure.
Speaker 1Right.
Speaker 4Like where it's like, um, but a belief in positive thinking that it can, um, that it, that it's being received, right. Or that it's going to be acted upon in some way. So I think like, yeah, I, I, it certainly, um, when I was in that, uh, that world, I remember, you know, imagining or, or, or, you know, like taking a mental moment to, to, to send off a, a little, you know, micro prayer, you know, little things that you would want.
Speaker 5Right.
Speaker 3So, um, yeah, yeah. I definitely think it's in the same way.
Speaker 2You pray for things you hope for, right? Like you don't pray for things that you don't hope for.
Speaker 1Like, Oh man, God, I really hope I don't pass this test tomorrow or whatever.
Speaker 5Right.
Speaker 1Like, please make sure I don't, that doesn't happen. You pray for things that you want to happen.
Speaker 7Right.
Speaker 1Um, right yeah to me that's kind of the same thing as manifesting i think manifesting is just kind of a secular way to do it maybe you're not super comfortable with christianity or you don't know much about it but you still want things to happen for you.
Speaker 4Um well and it feels like i think it's it's rewarding in some way to the brain to feel like you are able to take some level of control so if you think that your, if it's, it's a nice thought to imagine that your mental state has an actual impact on the outcomes that you're going to experience.
Speaker 3So I think in.
Speaker 4That way, it's, it's kind of a, and also it's, it's one of those, like you count the hits, ignore the misses where like when it, when something pans out, you're like, Hey, I'll manifest next time.
Speaker 5Right.
Speaker 3But if it does, right. Not thinking about it.
Speaker 2So that's true. That's true.
Speaker 1I said, let me ask beard this cause beard as a therapist, um, I imagine you encounter folks that have this kind of mentality about things. And is your advice to people, you tell them to lean into that or do you just kind of.
Speaker 6No, I think we've got to we've got to change what it is manifesting. Manifesting often is just like I have this idea of what I want and I'm just going to send out positive vibes into the universe and then it'll come to me. But the reality is like we can send out all those positive thoughts all we want. If we start taking actions towards achieving that goal, then we're going to get it. But if we don't, we're never going to get it. So I just kind of pivot to the like, let's get you, let's walk the steps, like keep putting it out there. But let's also add
Speaker 6in doing things differently. Instead of just manifesting.
Speaker 4It's interesting that you put it that way because that makes me think about like the, I guess the morality or criminality of thought then in that sense, I feel like it's kind of like, a related concept in as much as like a lot of folks, a lot of Christians will, will think that they've like done something wrong by having a perverted thought or a thought that an ungodly thought, right. You know, something that, that they'll self-flagellate for. And I wonder if there's kind of similar lanes of reasoning.
Speaker 6Because Jesus tells them that's the thing, the case, right. You know, he, he who looks upon a woman with lust in his heart has committed the sin of adultery.
Speaker 5Right.
Speaker 8Like he tells them straight up, you have these thoughts, you're going to hell.
Speaker 4Yeah, so in a way I feel like both concepts are reinforcing the idea that thoughts are.
Speaker 3Actions in a sense.
Speaker 2Yeah, true, true, true.
Speaker 1Man, I'm like, if you're a person who gets value in it and it works for you, the positive thinking stuff and all that stuff, I guess I don't really care. uh but there are people who are just straight up like no there's actually strict rules to this thing like they're like you have to have like a vision board right you got to be like doing certain exercises and stuff and and that's going to work for you there's a guy i used to follow maybe you guys know about this i'm a fan of anthony fantano who's this guy that does music reviews on youtube he did this
Speaker 1review of this guy called uncle adams and he was this he was this I'm talking the dorkiest white Canadian rapper guy you can imagine in your head.
Speaker 2He had this mission called At Least a Million.
Speaker 1And his goal was to get to a million dollars through doing his rap stuff.
Speaker 2And he, he like took out loans. He made music videos. He did the whole thing did not work out for him.
Speaker 1I think he just like quit rapping a few years ago and is now just like working a regular job or whatever, but I got to respect it. One that he tried it, but two is just like, he genuinely really thought that if he just put enough effort into this thing and thought positively about it, that it would happen.
Speaker 2And that is like, One might call it delusion. One might call it delusion.
Speaker 3Yeah, that could be dangerous.
Speaker 2Especially when money gets involved.
Speaker 1Obviously, that's kind of an extreme example, but I think people do kind of smaller versions of that on the daily, right?
Speaker 2Yeah.
Speaker 8We were just.
Speaker 1Talking about Elizabeth Holmes at the beginning. She's someone, I think, that definitely thought she could manifest things into reality.
Speaker 3Yeah, they kind of fake it until you make it.
Speaker 2Exactly.
Speaker 5Yeah.
Speaker 4So.
Speaker 3I don't know. Yeah, I think there's there.
Speaker 4There is it's difficult because there's this kind of making me think of like the I guess the complications of the the the field of orthopedic or chiropractic.
Speaker 3Sorry, chiropractic.
Speaker 2OK, yeah.
Speaker 3That we're like. There's kind of– because there is something to be said about positive thinking.
Speaker 2I like orthopedic practices.
Speaker 1We don't– caring for children isn't real. That shit's fake.
Speaker 4Well, the reason I thought about it is because like– I mean there are legitimate– my understanding is that there are forms of legitimate chiropractic medicine that are dealing specifically with spinal alignment and like dealing with issues of the.
Speaker 3Back, whereas there are– a.
Speaker 4Different portion of, and maybe I'm, I mean, I don't know much about it, but like my understanding is that there's a split between like folks that actually went to medical school and then folks that are like doing this whole, like claiming that you can treat things that are not related to the spine or back.
Speaker 1Yeah. To be clear, you do not have to go to medical school to be a chiropractic. There is not a requirement. So that, that would, I would, I would say there are some that, um, are more into Western medicine than others.
Speaker 2So you can grade on a scale, right?
Speaker 1But I would say the foundations of chiropractic medicine practice is not based on i in my opinion is not based on anything real it's based on people that would be like ghosts in your blood oh gosh it's kind of wild um.
Speaker 4But well maybe that's a bad example the reason i was thinking of it is because basically what i was trying to say or insinuate was that like i i think there there are positive things to be said about positive thinking and positive reinforcement like like that that to the extent that you don't like plan or, or prepare that that's going to be the, I guess things are going to work out exactly as you hope, but that you, I guess, uh, there's a phrase, um, like act like you've been there before.
Speaker 5Right.
Speaker 3Like, like that you're like, like, um, don't, don't, um, I don't know. I think there's something to.
Speaker 4Be said about preparing for success and also being prepared for failure.
Speaker 5Right.
Speaker 4And whenever you're, in a situation with uncertainty, like when you, when the outcome is not clear, I think it's good to, um, to be prepared for the, the, the spectrum of possibilities. I.
Speaker 3I, so yeah.
Speaker 5Yeah.
Speaker 2Okay. Here's my hot take on this.
Speaker 1You tell me if you agree, both of you, I genuinely believe that people who think positively on average, I think we are more.
Speaker 2Successful than people who don't. That's my hot take. Do you agree with this?
Speaker 1Because I think that there's some evidence to suggest that that is the case. I think people who practice mindfulness and who practice that kind of thinking are generally able to survive and work through harder situations than people who don't practice that. I'm not saying there's a difference in socioeconomic standing.
Speaker 2I don't know if there is.
Speaker 1Maybe that's true. But I think people whose outcomes of life in terms of their personal life satisfaction are going to reflect differently from people who practice and employ these kinds of measures than people who don't. And maybe that explains a lot about me because I'm not very good about that kind of thing, right? But like, I don't know, that is my hot take. I want to know if you guys agree with that.
Speaker 8I think it's likely.
Speaker 6I don't think I've looked at any research and I'm sure that there absolutely is research on that topic It probably would bear out that particular thing. Mood and outlook definitely play a role in motivation, in our ability to do things and focus through tasks. And if we go into a task thinking, I can't do this, we're not going to try as hard as if we go into it thinking, I'm absolutely going to do this.
Speaker 5Yeah.
Speaker 6So, yeah, there's some positive thinking can impact our performance on tasks.
Speaker 3Okay.
Speaker 2Okay. Drew, what do you think?
Speaker 3Yeah, I'm pretty much in alignment with that.
Speaker 4I think, um, I, again, I, yeah, I haven't, um, seen the like hard evidence that, that like as a trend that that's the case, but I wouldn't be surprised at all if that were like, I mean, I think about like, you know, When you're throwing a baseball, you kind of want to look at where you're aiming, right? Or you're riding a bike. You don't want to veer off to look at a ditch, right? So you want to aim for success whenever you're trying to do something.
Speaker 1Okay, damn. I was hoping for some more adversity and thought. Now I need the most cynical motherfucker in the world to call into this show and be like, fuck you.
Speaker 5Well, okay.
Speaker 4So if I wasn't a devil's advocate, I mean, when you first proposed it, I was thinking like I could envision– that there are people in this world that are very cynical or very, um, maybe not cynical, but like, uh, pessimistic or anxious and that, that could be successful in, in that, uh, pessimism or anxiety. And as much as that, they are like hyper-focused on the worst case scenario and avoiding it. Um, you know, kind of like, uh, The idea of flying being like throwing yourself at the ground and missing. But I don't know that that's common or
Speaker 4that that would be a trend. So you were saying more that it's like.
Speaker 2Well, yeah, I like my theory on this.
Speaker 1And again, this is based on no expertise in any particular field whatsoever. But I think that like this is based on anecdote. I it seems that people who practice being positive or have a let's call it a predilection towards positive thinking. I think I just genuinely think they can handle situations better and manage situations better through hard stuff. And I, and when I look back at my own life and, and my own personal struggles with things, I
Speaker 1genuinely think I would not have struggled with certain things if I had a different like mindset about it. And I, and that's also like, I'm not sure if I can, if that's something, Oh, if I just practice positive thinking that that will necessarily change, it may just be like a predisposition. I don't know, but like, I just think that, you know, people have happier outcomes. I, you know?
Speaker 7Yeah.
Speaker 3No, I wouldn't be surprised.
Speaker 4I think it's important to make a distinction between being positive and being avoidant.
Speaker 2Okay.
Speaker 5Okay.
Speaker 1Yeah, that's fair.
Speaker 4If you have a situation where there's like, you know, like. For instance, the big one I would think would be climate change. There's a lot of folks on the religious right that are like, well, even if it's real, God's handling it. Humans certainly couldn't be... Piddly little humans couldn't affect this on a global scale. It's wishful thinking. I think that's the thing is that positivity could could there's a venn diagram between positivity and wishful thinking.
Speaker 11And i think right there's that toxic positivity people talk about right i think that's a great point drew because i worry about climate change and i think people who don't worry about climate change are probably happier than me well right i don't.
Speaker 2Know I don't know.
Speaker 1I wish somebody would call in and tell us about their manifestation stories. Or, hey, if you want to talk about Christianity or... bigfoot or aliens or whatever i'm happy to talk to you about it right now i'm just chilling aliens tell us about how you positively manifested bigfoot um a bigfoot sighting in your life and i'll give you 100 bucks right now that'd be awesome you can do that um don't quote me on that i probably but um but if you think positively enough about it maybe i will.
Speaker 4And I wish manifesting would work. Then we could manifest our way around the climate crisis.
Speaker 1Yeah. I want to manifest.
Speaker 2Some colors right now. Maybe we can do that together. Can we do that?
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 2Have you guys read The Secret? I haven't actually read it. I don't know how to do it.
Speaker 6Supposedly, if you get three Christians together, they can move mountains with faith as a mustard seed.
Speaker 2Yeah, that's true. What do you get with three atheists, though? How do we do that? Full house?
Speaker 1Wait, who's Danny Tanner in this situation? That's a whole other thing. I'm going to be Joey.
Speaker 2No, I did it. I said it first. Listen, Drew, you can be both Olsen twins.
Speaker 5Sick.
Speaker 1Can we pretend to be Christians for like a minute and then pray? Does that work?
Speaker 3Does that work? I don't think so.
Speaker 1I mean, we can.
Speaker 8Prayer doesn't do anything.
Speaker 1So you don't think if we prayed for callers.
Speaker 2We might get one. What if we did?
Speaker 3I didn't say that. I didn't.
Speaker 8We might.
Speaker 3But I would not draw a causation link there.
Speaker 1Listen, if I lead us in a prayer, would you guys be comfortable with that? Would you guys be okay with that?
Speaker 3I would be honored, Dan.
Speaker 8Sure, go ahead.
Speaker 5Okay, all right.
Speaker 1Let's try this.
Speaker 3I just want to say it's funny.
Speaker 2Heavenly Father. We come to you.
Speaker 1This is the first time we've ever prayed on Truth in One, I think. Can we come to you today? Please grant us a call. And that would be cool.
Speaker 2Amen.
Speaker 5I don't know.
Speaker 1I'm not going to make any promises, right? Because I want to say, oh, I've become more of a believer. Yeah, wait, we actually do. Wait, they're in the queue, though.
Speaker 2They're in the queue, though. They're not here yet. They're not here yet. Maybe, okay.
Speaker 3Bring them on.
Speaker 1They can pass screening. That's how we got to know. We have to let our call screener talk to them first to see if they're not just responding to the bit. But that'd be awesome if we could make that happen. Okay, they are talking to somebody. We'll put a pause on that.
Speaker 3You forgot to pray for an argument that will convince us of God's existence.
Speaker 5Oh, okay.
Speaker 2We can do it.
Speaker 1Well, we could.
Speaker 5Okay. P.S.
Speaker 1P.S. If you can give us an argument that could convince us, that'd be pretty sick too. Amen.
Speaker 2That's it, right?
Speaker 8Question it. The question is, which one of us has the faith the size of the mustard seed?
Speaker 2How big is a mustard seed?
Speaker 1It's really small. It's not the smallest seed. They're the smallest seed, right? I know that they're small seeds, and that's the point of the metaphor. But I don't know if I've ever actually seen one. I'm going to Google image this. How big is a mustard seed? How big is a mustard seed? Pretty small.
Speaker 5Wow. Okay.
Speaker 1That's pretty small. First one I see here is smaller than a penny. Well, I guess I would expect that.
Speaker 3Much, much smaller. Yeah, a penny is a pretty big seed.
Speaker 2I guess, yeah, a penny would be a big seed. So that's not a great point. Okay, it's really.
Speaker 1Smaller than a plum pit. I don't know how much better to say it in audio form.
Speaker 2It's very small.
Speaker 8Yes, it is smaller than a bread box.
Speaker 1Smaller than a bread box, that's true.
Speaker 8Much smaller than that.
Speaker 5Okay.
Speaker 1All right. They are in, they are in the screening room right now. I think, um, does that mean we occur? Are we good to talk to them? I think we can.
Speaker 4Um, yeah.
Speaker 5Right.
Speaker 2They look good.
Speaker 5Beer.
Speaker 2Am I crazy? Are they good? I think so.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 2No, they're not.
Speaker 3Okay.
Speaker 2No, no, they still need to be in the queue.
Speaker 1All right.
Speaker 3Nevermind.
Speaker 2We're almost there though. It was, it was answered like right.
Speaker 1Like Siri, the notification came up on our side like the minute I said not in the minute the second I.
Speaker 7Said that's almost supernatural that was pretty crazy that is the closest to a miracle we have gotten on this show in the entire time I have been hosting it I would.
Speaker 3Propose that someone might have been listening to the broadcast.
Speaker 2Now, hold on now, Drew.
Speaker 1This isn't realistic. We manifested that shit together.
Speaker 5Okay?
Speaker 8It took all three of us.
Speaker 2You've got to believe. You've got to think positively, dude.
Speaker 1Okay.
Speaker 2All right?
Speaker 1Because if you don't, then we're going to lose this call right now. We're not going to finish it.
Speaker 2Okay? So, you know?
Speaker 8If you collapse the waveform and the caller goes away.
Speaker 2Keep believing. I mean, I, so now this is what we have to figure out.
Speaker 1Was it because we called upon the universe or called upon God?
Speaker 2So you did say, I did say heavenly father.
Speaker 3It's always this, I don't know. It's a, it's a nebulous, like just MacGuffin.
Speaker 4Cause like, it's just, I was just thinking it's the same like pattern as Christmas stories, right? About like, you just got to believe in Santa or else they won't, um, right. Or like you get paid Peter Pan or you, you won't be able to, that one's also flying.
Speaker 5Yeah.
Speaker 3Like it's, it's, I, that's one thing that I.
Speaker 4Really, that is frustrating to me that in the, the broader cultural zeitgeist that at least in the period of time that I grew up in, that it was like, it was made to be virtuous. This, this idea of being, um, gullible almost, or just being, being, um, willing to suspend disbelief, like being, being willing to shut down critical thought.
Speaker 3Was made to be a virtue.
Speaker 4And in a lot of common.
Speaker 1Stories and things, that's frustrating to me. A caller is ready to talk to us. Guys, I think they're a legit call. I think they're not even, I'm not even sure if they respond to the bit. I don't want to see that.
Speaker 2Hold on. Let's get talking to Patrick. You better get this atheism.
Speaker 9I got another atheist here.
Speaker 5Uh-oh.
Speaker 2Okay. We just muted him. It sounds like a troll. That doesn't sound real. I think that's a troll.
Speaker 5Hang on.
Speaker 1I'm going to unmute it again.
Speaker 2Patrick, are you there? Nietzsche.
Speaker 10Nietzsche.
Speaker 9I'm serious. That's my man.
Speaker 10Look, Twilight of the Idols, the Antichrist, Christianity. Why are we even entertaining this? Nietzsche busted Christianity years ago.
Speaker 9Why are we still as atheists.
Speaker 10Talking about the Bible, wasting our time? You got atheist biblical scholars. What in the fuck?
Speaker 2Oh, Patrick, you're an atheist. You're an atheist calling in.
Speaker 10I'm mad about these other atheists focusing on Christianity. Now, we ain't made out of goddamn ribs, or we ain't made out of clay, Adam.
Speaker 2Now, come on.
Speaker 10Why are we wasting our time with this shit?
Speaker 2Wait, hold on.
Speaker 1Well, we talk about it because we're under threat of Christian theocracy, right?
Speaker 2Like, I agree with you.
Speaker 1If Christianity was like, had the same popular.
Speaker 10That's one single God guess.
Speaker 1So what? Patrick, I don't know how serious you are right now, but to answer your question, if Christianity had the same population as Zoroastrians right now, then yeah, I wouldn't be talking about Christianity. But the fact is Christianity is the world's largest religion, period. So like they have a certain influence over the world, which threatens us.
Speaker 9It's really popular too.
Speaker 5Yeah.
Speaker 2Okay, Patrick.
Speaker 1I'm not saying I'm talking about it because I think it's real, right? Obviously, if you're an atheist, you also don't believe it's real.
Speaker 10You think you're going to convince a Christian that Jesus and the Trinity and.
Speaker 2All– what? Yeah, I mean it's happened before.
Speaker 1There's people that have called in and said, hey, thanks for– thanks to your show. Like I don't believe in this stuff anymore.
Speaker 2Come on now.
Speaker 10Any number of God versions, and that's one of the worst ideas.
Speaker 9All right, let's refute pantheism. That's a little more difficult.
Speaker 10That's an observable God, has all the evidence.
Speaker 12Literally under the cosmological constant of Roger Penrose and Einstein, the universe is literally without beginning or end.
Speaker 9It sounds familiar.
Speaker 2Patrick, what?
Speaker 1You had a fun time on Halloween. I don't know what kind of energy you're bringing to this call right now, but it's a little wild.
Speaker 2I'm really serious about this.
Speaker 10I know you think I'm totally trolling the show and all this, but I'm really converting to atheism today.
Speaker 9I'm tired of it.
Speaker 3You're converting to atheism. What does that mean?
Speaker 9Goddamn clay shit.
Speaker 10Now, if it sounds like a children's story, it is, motherfuckers.
Speaker 2Well, okay. I don't know, Patrick. What do you want from us?
Speaker 10Let's get beyond this Christianity fantasy novel and.
Speaker 9Just might as well read J.R.R.
Speaker 5Tolkien.
Speaker 10Let's go back to The Hobbit and discuss that, motherfucker.
Speaker 1Patrick, we're not Christians.
Speaker 2You know that, right?
Speaker 10Yeah, but you're going to talk about it probably the rest of the show. We're talking about it too much now. I'm tired of this Jesus motherfucker.
Speaker 5Okay.
Speaker 1I'm tired of him too, but like, I think for different reasons than you.
Speaker 8I've been tired of you for 2000 years.
Speaker 1So, so atheists should just shut up about Christianity and we shouldn't talk about it?
Speaker 10Hell, you could learn that from Bob Marley or goddamn, who was that dude off the Beatles? John Lennon. They had the same kind of existential love. You didn't need Jesus. Just listen to Bob Marley, motherfuckers.
Speaker 1Did, Did Crew set us up with a prank? What is happening, dude?
Speaker 2What is going on?
Speaker 10I'm making a hardcore conversion. I'm going to just straight.
Speaker 2Conversion from what? What were you before?
Speaker 10I'm straight going nihilistic atheist.
Speaker 2Okay. Were you not an atheist before?
Speaker 10I'm confused.
Speaker 9Y'all aren't on my level. I'm a gnostic atheist. Y'all are probably agnostic.
Speaker 10You don't have the level of commitment I do.
Speaker 2Does it matter? Why does that matter?
Speaker 12I'm 100% sure There ain't no guy gonna pop out Behind a fucking cloud.
Speaker 1I don't know what to tell you. I mean, I don't think God's going to pop up behind a cloud either.
Speaker 3I'm happy for you and your Gnosticism. That sounds great.
Speaker 5I know.
Speaker 9And knowing is half the battle, like G.I. Joe said.
Speaker 5G.I.
Speaker 7Joe.
Speaker 1Yes.
Speaker 2More power to you, Pat.
Speaker 8Real American heroes.
Speaker 9That's all you need. You don't need God. You need G.I. Joe, bitch.
Speaker 2Listen.
Speaker 9Listen.
Speaker 2Patrick, I don't know if you realize this.
Speaker 1We literally prayed to God together on the show right now, and you showed up.
Speaker 2And I thought... I mean, did you hear us when we were praying?
Speaker 9You best not pray to some fake ass God on my.
Speaker 5No, no.
Speaker 2Wait, you know, Patrick, you don't understand.
Speaker 1We literally prayed on the show together and you, your call came in.
Speaker 2Like the second we were done, a beard called it out. He said, we just got a call and you came in.
Speaker 9I am the hammer of the atheist. Welcome back. I put the fires with a hammer.
Speaker 1I mean, I'm just saying we have some evidence now. We have to consider that, right, Pat?
Speaker 9What evidence?
Speaker 2Well, we prayed and you showed up.
Speaker 9Well, then I speak for the atheists.
Speaker 2Okay.
Speaker 1You're like the Lorax?
Speaker 2You speak for the trees? You speak for the atheists?
Speaker 10You thought Frederick Nietzsche was badass?
Speaker 9I'll bust on that sucker. I'm about to write some real shit. You wanted to see.
Speaker 3The Uber monk?
Speaker 5I am it.
Speaker 10I am the over man. I have come and we're going to bust this Christianity right out the frame.
Speaker 1I'm not mentally prepared for this conversation anymore, guys.
Speaker 2I don't know what to do with this anymore.
Speaker 3Yeah, it sounds... Look, Nick T4.
Speaker 10Told me come and now I have come.
Speaker 9Are you ready to hear the message?
Speaker 1What's the message? I'm still confused what the message is, to be honest with you. Is it that we shouldn't talk about Christianity anymore?
Speaker 10I'm debating all this and live your life as an atheist.
Speaker 9All right.
Speaker 10You're wasting your time out here debating Christians. This is a waste of our goddamn fucking time.
Speaker 1I think– I disagree on that one. Let's talk about that. That's an interesting idea. So are we wasting our time talking to people?
Speaker 5No.
Speaker 1I sometimes it does feel like I'm wasting my time, but whenever I've, let me hold on.
Speaker 2I'm a feature of you, Patrick, because.
Speaker 1Your, your, your energy is too crazy right now. I, I, I, sometimes I do these shows and I think, wow, I don't know if anything moved the needle at all.
Speaker 5Right.
Speaker 1But then I'll get calls from people or get emails from people or the comments from people that say, wow, this show is great. It put me through a hard time or man, I used to think a different way. And then the show taught me otherwise.
Speaker 2Um, So I have to.
Speaker 1Take that into account and think maybe I am doing something. And it's a small scale. Don't get me wrong.
Speaker 2We're not freaking, you know, Fox News or something.
Speaker 5Right.
Speaker 1We're not reaching all of America. But it's like I'd like to think I'm making a difference in some small way.
Speaker 2I mean, would you guys agree with that?
Speaker 3Yeah, absolutely.
Speaker 5Yeah.
Speaker 4No, I mean, I I have a history with ACA content because I was exposed.
Speaker 3To the atheist experience. Excuse me.
Speaker 10Yeah.
Speaker 3About I guess it would be.
Speaker 4Like 18 years ago now at this point when I was first seeing some, some ACA content and it was really impactful and important for me to be able to see, um, adults, um, asking the same kind of questions and talking about the, the same sort of issues that I was raising, uh, when I was having problems with my own, uh, church group.
Speaker 2So yeah.
Speaker 7Yeah.
Speaker 1In the inbox for AXP, especially like at its peak, every week, every week there's people coming in and saying, wow, this changed me, right? So, like, I think having conversations with people is good, actually. I think people do change their minds about things. There's a lot of people.
Speaker 4Who just haven't, like, thought about something from a particular angle. Like, I remember thinking for a long time that Pascal's Wager was a very compelling argument to me until.
Speaker 3I realized the obvious issues with it. And, like, I think there's, I don't know, a lot of people, I've heard that kind of.
Speaker 5Story a lot.
Speaker 2Yeah, I agree.
Speaker 1Okay, Patrick, I'm going to put you on mute now. So let's see what you got to say about this, okay? So what do you think after what we just said?
Speaker 9You're very tolerant of me. I appreciate you, fellas.
Speaker 2Listen, no problem, man. No problem. You can fight entertaining.
Speaker 1We're glad you called in.
Speaker 9I am the ultimate atheist.
Speaker 1I'm 100% with this.
Speaker 3Ultra instinct atheist?
Speaker 1Listen, we are not doubting your atheist credentials at this point. So don't get it twisted.
Speaker 9I just joined up.
Speaker 10Y'all should be happy. I was the ultimate agnostic. I was leaning towards pantheism. Now today, I was like, yeah, I was like, yeah, fuck this shit.
Speaker 1They talk about.
Speaker 4Well, what was the straw that broke the camel's back?
Speaker 9How you gonna not eat an apple? You put that apple out there.
Speaker 10I'm gonna go beyond George Carlin with.
Speaker 9My stand-up routine. You about to see and know me.
Speaker 2George Carlin's dead. Okay.
Speaker 9Call in as.
Speaker 10The Tallahassee Squirrel to 99 Rock. Look that up in the Emerald Coast on the iHeartRadio app. You'll hear the Tallahassee squirrel. You might know that motherfucker. And I'm going to go, George Carlin wasn't on my level.
Speaker 5Okay. All right.
Speaker 2I feel like you're not answering the question that we asked at all.
Speaker 9Well, I'm sorry about this.
Speaker 5I'm high. That's okay.
Speaker 1We had a conversation about whether talking to people actually makes a difference. You seem to say, no, we should all shut up and move on. And we were saying, actually, we think that.
Speaker 9Plato, Descartes, Einstein.
Speaker 1Yeah, I know, but I can't make anybody read anything, right, Patrick?
Speaker 5You don't need to have idiots talking to idiots.
Speaker 9Ain't nobody going to learn nothing.
Speaker 1I don't think that's true, though, Patrick. I think people have watched shows like ours, and I think they have watched some.
Speaker 5It is true.
Speaker 9It's coming down on society.
Speaker 10Do you know I was in the park today? This is how ignorant people have gotten. They've got it counterclockwise. They're saying walk clockwise. People don't even know how a clock or a watch works. All the signs are counterclockwise.
Speaker 1I get it.
Speaker 2Patrick, we're out of time.
Speaker 3We've got to move on.
Speaker 9I'm sorry.
Speaker 2We're at the end of the show here.
Speaker 9This motherfucking sign said walk clockwise.
Speaker 10I turned around and started walking clockwise.
Speaker 2I can't deal with this anymore.
Speaker 1I'm muting this call.
Speaker 2I'm ending this call.
Speaker 1I'm sorry, Patrick. We gotta let you go. This is too much. What the fuck did we just pray into existence? Because I think.
Speaker 3I don't know.
Speaker 8I think it was the prayer. It was the prayer. It was definitely the prayer.
Speaker 3It was an unholy prayer.
Speaker 2Guys, we did not pray to God.
Speaker 1I think we might have prayed to the devil or something. Because something happened there.
Speaker 3We summoned the ultra-instinct atheists.
Speaker 5I think.
Speaker 1Yeah, I think the ultra instinct atheist on from the old gods or something, because that was not whatever that was.
Speaker 2It was not holy. I'll tell you that much.
Speaker 8Note to self, do not pray to atheismo again.
Speaker 5All right.
Speaker 1Well, that was an experience. I want to thank both of you gentlemen for joining me today on this episode of Truth Wanted. Coming up next is the atheist experience. So if you're live, stick around for that. I want to give a special thank you to Beard for being our backup host and for joining us in the last 30 minutes here. Thanks so much, Beard, for hanging out. It was quite an experience with you. Um, and of course, thank you to, uh, Mike today, Drew Nintendrew shout outs. Um, go follow his stuff. If you want to check out
Speaker 1more from him. Um, Drew, we always like to, you know, end this show with some words of wisdom. Um, if you can make sense of whatever the fuck we just did for the last hour and a half and come up with words of wisdom, I would love to hear what that was.
Speaker 4Yeah, I think we had some valuable discussions on positive thinking. And I don't think we've shifted on our positions on manifesting, but I do think that there's value in hoping for things that are positive. And I hope for positive things for both of you and all of you out there listening and everyone on the crew and everyone.
Speaker 3Yeah they are after it's posted.
Speaker 1I think I agree with everything except you said you didn't change your position on manifesting I know I my position has changed I'm not scared.
Speaker 2Uh, I've now shared of what we.
Speaker 1Are capable of. Um, so I'm not sure if I'm ever going to do that ever again. But, um, other than that, yeah, I agree. Uh, great show. Thanks everybody for the calls. Thanks for everybody for hanging out with us. Um, tune in next week for some more truth, want goodness. And for now, uh, remember to always keep on the truth. We'll see you next time.
Speaker 2Bye-bye everybody.
Speaker 5Thank you.
Speaker 2Watch Talk Heathen Live Sundays at 1 p.m.
Speaker 1Central and call into the show at 512-991-9242 or connect to the show.
In today's episode of Truth Wanted, ObjectivelyDan welcomes guest Out Of Body Atheist, with The Beard of Empathy on backup, to dig into Reiki, New Age spirituality, homeopathy, and the long road from woo to skepticism!...
In today's episode of Truth Wanted, Jon the Skeptick, Volcy, and Sofia Spina explain why no one can talk to the dead, from Haitian Vodou and grief dreams to Jon's past as a spiritualist! Bob jumps from objective...
In today's episode of Truth Wanted, ObjectivelyDan, Kelley Laughlin, and The Beard of Empathy tackle standards of evidence, miracle claims, and the false binaries of moral philosophy! Dean in VA questions why skeptics...
In today's episode of Truth Wanted, ObjectivelyDan and Chad Harris tackle Christian nationalism, police brutality, and the uncomfortable truths about racism and immigration. Big E in TN survived police brutality and...
In today's episode of Truth Wanted, Kelley Laughlin and Ms. Non Sequitur tackle moral accountability, inherited sin, and whether Christianity's forgiveness model makes sinning too easy! GreatBaisk on TikTok plays...