Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Truth Wanted

Truth Wanted artwork

Truth Wanted 08.37 09-12-2025 with Kelley Laughlin and The Cross Examiner

Sep 13, 20251 hr 25 minAudio
  • Apple Podcasts
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

In today’s episode of Truth Wanted, Kelley Laughlin and The Cross Examiner unravel some helpful points about a recent event before taking a caller who was not wearing his big boy pants. Jon in Canada, says that now is not the time to talk about the political stance of Charlie Kirk, people should not be saying he deserved to be shot, and we should be mourning him. As good humans, we can all condemn what happened, however, not everyone needs to grieve about it. One can care about the action and the outcome of the action, and at the same time be apathetic about the individual. If this is not the time to discuss the political stance of Charlie Kirk, when would be a better time to reflect on this? Is it cool to talk about his politics for people who agree with him, or does this rule only apply to those who oppose his views? What is the proposed solution for controversial figures being targets? How do we talk about politics without living in fear? Even when someone advocates for violence, nobody deserves what happened to Charlie Kirk. If you are a horrible person who is considering political violence, don’t do it because you will be creating a martyr. Catholic Traditionalist in Paris asks the hosts to define god, tries to shift the burden of proof with a bit of snark, and states that if the hosts answer his questions, it will prove god exists. To make sure that we don’t make false conclusions, we don’t start with an assumption and work backwards. Instead of complaining and claiming repression, why don’t you provide refutable proof that god exists? When you don’t call to have a conversation, and prefer to whine and complain instead, you are wasting time and you get dropped. Sorry we are not on your script, man. Thank you for hanging out with us tonight! Godless Engineer, our back up host closes out the show with us and shares the question of the week: What is a job you can get in heaven? Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/truth-wanted--3195473/support.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Speaker 1Throughout history, every religion has had items that they deemed to be holy relics, whether they were possessions of or actual body parts of the gods, saints, or prophets of that religion. It's claimed that they have had magical powers, things from healing all the way to ensuring pregnancies. Do you know about any holy relics? Do you believe they hold magical or holy powers? Is so we want to talk to you, So give us a call because the show is starting right now. Hello, and welcome to another

Speaker 1episode of Truth Wanted. I am your host, Kelly Laughlin, and how if you're not sick of seeing me? But this is a live call in show that happens every single week on Fridays at seven pm Central Time, where we talk about what you believe and why you believe it, And if you'd like, you can call us right now at one five, one two nine you four two, or you can call us through your computer at tiny dot cc slash called tw truth one. It is a product

Speaker 1of the Atheist Community of Austin, a five oh one c three nonprofit organization dedicated to the promotion of atheism, critical thinking, secular humanism, and the separation of government and religion. And every week we have a special, super special guest, and this week is no different. And my guest this week is the amazing Cross Examiner. How you doing, How you doing?

Speaker 2Hello?

Speaker 3Yeah, it's great to be here. I'm not sure amazing, but amazingly pleased to be on the show with you. For sure. I got to meet you when we met up at the back cruise. That was the first time we met in person. It was a real thrill for me. So thank you so much for having me on your show.

Speaker 1I hope this doesn't embarrass you, but I'll be honest with you. I can still see your face, your look of amazement when all those bats came flying out.

Speaker 3That was all I gotta say. Man, it was really cool. There's very, you know, very few times in your life where you see something like that for the first time, and you know, you just got to revel in it because that was just stunning.

Speaker 1So I was watching you look in amazement and I was like, that had to be what I looked like, so.

Speaker 3Very true. I was just worried. I just wanted, didn't want because it's like one point to one point four million bats live under that one bridge, and I'm like, that's a lot of poop. I don't they don't poop on us.

Speaker 1Keep your drink covered when you're flying. So yeah, I really, I really was thrilled to meet you in real life. I was really glad you were there.

Speaker 3Thanks, thanks so much. It was it was it was much better than I thought it would be. I mean, I thought it'd be great, but meeting every person that was with the ACA, and then meeting people who were just viewers who wanted to come along and hang out and be able to sit down and have a drink with them and chat, it was really a highlight. I'm really glad I went, and I look forward next year.

Speaker 1Yeah, I'm looking forward again to next year as well. So I really really am. So a lot of people know you. I guess from our flag Well, I don't want to see our flagship show because the Flagship Show is the nonprofit that's right. But let's say from the signature show, the atheist experience. So how long have you been on that on that.

Speaker 3That's a great question. I'd say coming on two years, maybe it's a while ago. I decided to start a podcast. It was basically the January sixth situation that really I had been pondering what to do as an attorney, and my chief concern is the rise of Christian national and the nationalism that we've seen since pre Bush, and that got heightened with Tea Party and then Trump and all of that stuff. And Jan six really got me off my butt and decided to start, you know, at least

Speaker 3trying to do a podcast. And then I heard that the ACA was looking for some people to help out, and I volunteered and started out on UH Nonprofits and other shows, and eventually had the opportunity to start appearing occasionally on The Atheist Experience. And I've enjoyed that too, but I love all the shows. If I could appear more, I would so let the producers know. I like coming on and just chatting with people.

Speaker 1I've really been looking forward tonight. Actually we have actually worked together before on AHP, and so I was really looking forward to it again. I actually have a relic left over from that episode, the My Mango on The's Right Mango episode.

Speaker 3Oh my gosh, that guy. Oh that episode was frustrating and hilarious at the same time. The guy just would not get past that. We were fixated on the mango metaphor.

Speaker 1Yeah, it was really fine. And and then when we use the mango metaphor back to him, it just went right over his head. It was amazing. It was amazing. Folks.

Speaker 3That's a lesson to you. If you're gonna bring a metaphor, you gotta know all the ins and outs and the ways that we're going to sort of playfully go along with it.

Speaker 1Well, you know what, before we get too far into this, every week we do a question of the week and we always have our backup post come up and do it, and we have. I couldn't believe we had the backup post today, but here they are. It's godless engineer John Gleeson.

Speaker 3Hi, Jay, John, what's up? He?

Speaker 4Then's how y'all doing? Hey?

Speaker 1Hey, what's up? Buddy? Just heaving it out?

Speaker 4Yeah, yeah, all right, yeah, So first time in the in the backup slot really, so, you know, it's it's a little weird for me. But before we get started today, we did want to give everybody the results of last week's We Want Truth or w w TT segments. And last week we asked people here on Truth Wanted name of time, believers don't mind playing god and here are our favorite answers. First up, number three, We've got no

Speaker 4no what says believers don't mind playing God when they water their plan m that's.

Speaker 1You know, that's really funny. Could my stepdad or not my stepdad? My real dad when he was alive, lived in Portland, Oregon, and when he was watering his flowers, his neighbor would always come out and yell at him and say, ah, you're doing God's work. Don't be doing her I supposed to water your flowers. When I saw that, that reminded me of my dad. So thanks, no what. I appreciate that. That was a good one. Uh.

Speaker 4Second up is Chuck Gaetos or Gaetos saying believers don't mind playing God when their daughter's first date picks her up on his motorcycle.

Speaker 3Is it playing God or screaming Jesus Christ?

Speaker 4They could work both ways on And the number one from last week is know what again saying believers don't mind playing God when they take y agra.

Speaker 2Wow?

Speaker 1Yeah, yeah, I disagree with that.

Speaker 3Any medical miracle quite frank? I mean, who says that the Jehovah's witnesses don't have it right and you shouldn't be taking blood transusions. Yeah, yeah, yeah, excellent, know what?

Speaker 4Yeah? And so this week's prompt is what is a job you could get in heaven? And so I'm really curious as to what you guys have for that you want to go?

Speaker 1You want to go first?

Speaker 3I have a slightly more serious answer. Do you want the serious answer or your silly answer? I don't know. I have a serious answer. Go ahead, psychoanalyst. And here's why many people have made this observation. It's really stuck with me. If you have a relative who's religious. Let's say your mom and you die an unbeliever, and under her belief system, you're going to Hell and she goes to heaven. Either she's going to know you're in hell and be horribly upset for eternity, which in which case not heaven, or she's not going to know you're in

Speaker 3hell and not remember you. Therefore she can be eternally happy and she's going to need therapy trying to remember you. Either way, there's a problem here with this whole heaven and hell and who you loved and all of that sort of stuff. So maybe a psychoanalyst to help with the misery, or a psychoanalyst to help you recover lost memories. I don't know, but that's my serious answer. I think that's a real job that would be needed in Heaven.

Speaker 1I was thinking I might be able, I might be able to get a job as a halo polisher. I was thinking that if I if I went to Heaven, I don't think they're going to give me a very good job. That's all.

Speaker 3Is that halo polisher coming from rock polishing?

Speaker 1Is that where you got that? I just figured I'm going to be on the bottom wrong if I make it up there.

Speaker 3So I think helo polishing is really important. You got to be ready for all of those, you know, Renaissance portraits that they're going to paint you. So about you, John?

Speaker 1Yeah? What about you? John?

Speaker 4You know, to be quite honest, I feel like I would have to go with something starkly different than whatever I'm doing now. So like, yeah, you know, probably what's that what's that job where funk shue. I'll be a fun guy. I'll just be able and I'll be a total hic about it too, right, because I'll just be able that Yeah, why don't you just put that count right over there? It really works with the flow of the energies. You know, I don't worry, I could see energies.

Speaker 1That's what happened.

Speaker 4Uh, you know they got me here.

Speaker 3Oh it's great. I thought you were going to go a different direction to say, I'm gonna have to do something totally opposite that when I do you now, which is I guess I'll be wrong in heaven because I'm always right now.

Speaker 4I mean, that's what I essentially said.

Speaker 1I mean, thanks a lot, John, I really appreciate you coming up and do this. I'm gonna have you come back at the end of the show. We'll check in with you again. So thanks a lot, appreciate it. Alrighty, that was awesome.

Speaker 3John is just an awesome guy.

Speaker 1Yeah. I was about to say that was like the best backup post I ever had.

Speaker 4That.

Speaker 1I was not expecting that.

Speaker 3Hey, I've been your backup.

Speaker 1You know, have you been my I backups?

Speaker 3So I don't know, I.

Speaker 1Don't think so. Just I know I usually have a really really really awesome backup post. That's Eli Slack. I really appreciate it.

Speaker 3Yeah, yeah, yeah, good.

Speaker 1Eli's freaking awesome. So where were we we were talking about your are you starting out on the show, and then and then you mentioned your own podcast. Tell us a little bit about that.

Speaker 3Well, it's the Cross Examiner podcast. I've been on a hiatus for a while now because it takes a surprising amount of energy to produce a regular podcast of any sort of quality. It seems that the Ai Sludge and the TikTok generation are not interested in the type of stuff that I want to do very often. I have a lot of followers, and I'm going to produce more content this season, but it's been slow to get motivated, quite frankly, because I prefer to do deep dive sort

Speaker 3of If you imagine the introductions that Rachel Maddow would do on her episodes, whill she'd be like in nineteen twenty eight, a person invented the the little rubber thing that you put on the end of your toothbrush, and then somehow she connects that through a series of interesting facts five minutes later to whatever happened in the news today, and she educates you, entertains you. I kind of like doing those deep dives where I sort of teach about things. But what I've learned recently is I need to get back to why I started this which was January sixth, and I think it's because I'm passionate about educating people

Speaker 3about what things are and how their government works, how law works, and what civics are. I think we're missing basic civics education, and that's how we get election denial. And we have basic science education that's missing, and that's how we get vaccine denial and all the things that you see on Truth Wanted, where you get conspiracy theories and arguments from ignorance and things, those sorts of things. So this season, I think I'm going to be focusing more on let's talk about what is the Constitution? What does it say? In fact, I have this idea of

Speaker 3creating a high school level ethics course that says, let's look at all the major clauses of the Constitution and what can we derive from them from an ethics perspective, like ethics through the filter of the Constitution. So I might be doing some of that on the air as well as well well as some deep dive like hey, did you know why the Supreme Court can be the final word on things? And why it's a problem with any given president says they're going to ignore it here's the whole history of that and why it's important. So that's what I like focusing on. So that's my podcast,

Speaker 3and when I come here, I really really enjoy hanging out with people like you guys and our audience and seeking people who have inter things, interesting things to tell us while being open to being questioned because we're all, you know, should be a little skeptical of crazy claims. So having those discussions is a lot of fun for me.

Speaker 1Yeah, I'll agree to that. I have those discussions myself. I find it very entertaining and informative too, because I always end up learning something right.

Speaker 3Absolutely, absolutely, just prepping for this show on the topics you said you were interested in, I've learned a whole bunch of things today, so I really appreciate that, you know.

Speaker 1And I was going to mention that you mentioned doing a deep dive on something, and we have been doing deep dives now. We're starting one regularly every week. We call him the truth Bombs. It was Dan's idea originally, and you wanted to bring it back, so we're doing it every week. And I wanted to bring this week's truth bomb to us to everybody, So if you'll bear with me for a minute or two. Absolutely, I want to talk tonight about the Holy prep whos Now. I started out the show talking about holy relics, and there are many, many holy relics that are associated with Jesus' existence.

Speaker 1There's pieces of the cross, there's the nails, the shroud of turin, all kinds of things. However, unlike a lot of the saints that came after him, we don't have any actual pieces of Jesus's body. This is, of course, because he's supposedly ascended into heaven and apparently nobody thought to keep any of his fingernail clipping or all the trimmings from his hair and beard. I guess nobody thought he was going to be famous in the future or anything, so they didn't think of saving that. But and maybe

Speaker 1Jesus actually didn't need to do any of that grooming. Maybe he just woke up looking heavenly every morning. I don't know. But there was one thing that was supposedly cut off from his body that does seem to have survived, and that's the Holy prepouse, or it's more commonly known as the Holy foreskin. Now, there is an account in one of the Infancy Gospels, which would probably be a good idea for a deep dive in the future. But it's about the circumcision of Jesus. And this gospel was

Speaker 1pretty popular amongst the populace. That's why it was popular until it was ruled non canonical at the Council of Nicea and it was completely tossed out by the church. So popular was it, in fact, that there was a holy feast egg or the foreskin, that was on January we first, Yes, we used to start every year off with the Feast of the Circumcision of Our Lord. That was its actual official name. And every town that had

Speaker 1a holy foreskin would bring it out, showed around to all the townsfolk put it away back in the church. And yes, I did say every town that had one, because there were a lot of them. There were even possibly hundreds of these things. And you gotta wonder, how does a story like this even start. And it, of course it starts with the Holy Roman Emperor, right why not? And it's not just any old Holy Roman Empire, but

Speaker 1emperor but Charlotte made himself, and good old Charlie supposedly gifted it to Leo the third, the pope when the Pope crowned him emperor, and it's claimed that Charlie got it from one of two sources. He either was presented by an angel when he was praying, or he received it as a wedding gift from Princess Irene of Byzantium, which probably has to make it the weirdest wedding gift of all time. But that story is a lot more

Speaker 1plausible than the first one, So I would believe that over the angel story. This foreskin was supposedly apparently placed inside of a golden cross shaped relquarry. I always have a hard time saying relacquerry. And it was. It was actually included in an inventory of holy relics that was made in nineteen oh five, so the cross was still there in the Vatican. However, it was stolen in nineteen forty five, so it's gone that Holy prep Bous is

Speaker 1no longer around. Now there's another story of another Holy prep boost that was supposedly in the Vatican, and it was it was supposedly brought there by Saint Brigida, and that will was supposedly stolen in the Sack of Rome in fifteen twenty seven by of all people, the Holy Roman Empire, and it was stolen, completely stolen, along with a lot of other relics. There is a legend that a German soldier was captured with it about fifty miles

Speaker 1away in the Italian village of Calcatta. It was placed in the church there. It was officially was like the foreskin, the real Holy foreskin. It was brought out every year and shown to everybody up until nineteen eighty three, when it too was stolen. You've got to wonder who's out there stealing foreskins right now. Of the hundreds of foreskins that possibly existed in meanievul times, not a single example

Speaker 1still exists, not a single one. As I mentioned, the two most famous claimants to the title being the one true foreskin, were both stolen in the last one hundred and twenty five years, which has led some people to believe that the Catholic Church was behind the thefts, and behind the disappearance of all the foreskins for that matter, in order to squash the veneration of what they deemed, more in modern times to be an embarrassing relic of the Church. Now. I don't know if that would happen personally,

Speaker 1I'm not sure the Church would do anything in secret. How about you? How about you cross exam you think the church would do anything secret.

Speaker 3I could do a whole season on that.

Speaker 1Yes, absolutely, I thought that was a pretty good topic for a book stunning.

Speaker 3So, like my first question is, and this is the stuff I learned you stuff you don't know about. I mean, first, I have this image of the Catholic Church, like making it rain four skins on John j anyway, first, because every town has one, So first 't that. But then the more the deeper question I had was if you study the history of Jesus and what people wrote about him, and when we see a pattern of all we see that the early writings of Jesus of when he was born and what happened when he was a kid, that all came down much later, and they get a lot

Speaker 3of stuff wrong, just playing out wrong. The dates are all wrong. The whole story about a census and having returned to your city, that's all bs we know that didn't happen. So it's all obviously stuff that was written after the fact to give a backstory to this Jesus character. And then there's this gap of nothing and then as an adult. We follow up with Jesus and he's oh, now he's here, and he's performing miracles and tough. Jesus is, you know, making whips and chasing money changers out of the temple and being a cool dude, and you know,

Speaker 3healing people and doing a lot of nice things. But I've always wondered, like if the stories were made up. So obviously nobody was writing anything real at the time that Jesus was born. Nobody's sitting there going, WHOA, this kid's gonna be somebody someday. We better follow this guy quick grab his foreskin. Like so, if that didn't happen, if they're not writing about it, there was no like like, oh my god, this star came over and all these wise men came along and like like it beig came news and that this kid is going places. Then how

Speaker 3the hell do people think that the foreskin was retained? Was it a Jewish tradition to keep the foreskin of your kid for thirty years? No, it was what happened there, do you know.

Speaker 1Yeah, Supposedly the mother of the man who performed the circumcision had a vision that this kid was going to be somebody famous. In the future, and she preserved it in a bottle of oil. I can't remember what kind of oil it was. It was one that I had never heard of before. It was a weird one. But yeah, it was supposedly preserved in this bottle of oil and then apparently passed through the centuries until it got the Princess Irene of Byzantium. That's how one of the legends goes. I'm not sure how Saint Bridgeta got her foreskin, so

Speaker 1I don't even know if she was out there looking for forth with you out there actually hunting forest and hunters.

Speaker 3I tell you, we need a new Indiana Jones movie.

Speaker 1I tell you I was wondering. You know, you gotta wonder if there's hundreds of them. You know, they can't all be real, right, but maybe they could. Maybe like every time he cut it off, he just healed it.

Speaker 3I mean, we have this whole concept that all things are possible in prayer, and people have claimed that they've seen amputees grow their toes back, among other things. Recently, go to show me Thetoes dot com, by the way, and that's not my site. It's just the whole story about a church you gotta see it. So yeah, absolutely, he could have sort of lizard DNA powers where he regrows his foreskin as a little side hustle, just keep cutting it off selling the relic. Although I learned researching

Speaker 3for this show, First of all, I learned most Christians don't venerate relics the way that Catholics do. I kind of knew that intuitively, but I went and looked it up, and sure enough, not only do Catholics venerate relics, they have a classification system. There are three classes is class one, Class two, and class three relics. Class one is the body of a saint or of Jesus or something like that, so the foreskin would be a we're talking about a class one relic here. Class two is the possessions of such a person, so the clothing. And I don't know,

Speaker 3does the foreskin become a possession after it's cut off. Is it demoted to a class two relic because I.

Speaker 1Was once supposedly the older woman kept it, so it wouldn't be right.

Speaker 3Yeah, I don't know. And there is anything that has touched a class one or two relic becomes a class three relics, So there's a whole business into touching things with relics, So this would be a class one or class two relic. I assume class one. But it is apparently a sin, like a very big sin, to sell a relic, And that led me to ask the question, well if it so, if it's a sin to sell a relic, is it a sin to buy one? Isn't like both sides of the tracks action to blame, But no, no, no. Conveniently,

Speaker 3the Catholic Church says, no, no, no, it's not it's not a sin to buy them, and then they proceeded to go around to buy a bunch of relics, so that's kind of convenient as well. So, yes, it's a sin to sell relics, and it's a sin to keep them for yourself if you are not a true believer and you're not going to share them with others who venerate. But it is not a sin to buy them.

Speaker 1It can't be, because then the church would be sitting exactly. That just seems like to me, so exactly. Drew Harrison said something really funny in the chat Indiana Jones and the Holy prep Us of Doom. Yeah I know, Eli said that for the record, the crew came up with the Indiana Jones reboat reboot. First. I'm sorry I didn't see it, but man, that was pretty funny. I got to say the Holy prep rouse of Doom, so I had.

Speaker 3That's going to be the I'm going to make a I'm really into board games and now I'm in my mind's spending on a on a on a board game for you know, be a kid like an old nineteen a seventies nineteen eighties Hasbroro Monopoly, like you know, mouse Trap game something like that where it's like, you know, a spinoff on Saturday Night Live of Who's going to get the Prepousive Doom? And Well, and there's like this little plastic foreskin that you're chasing around the board. I think that would be great. It's holy, it's a relic.

Speaker 3How dare you say that it's not appropriate.

Speaker 1I'm not going to say it. We should probably get to a call though, when you.

Speaker 3Think sure, absolutely.

Speaker 1We have one of my favorite callers, John from Canada. He him John and he says, Charlie Kurrk does not the zero of all the bad press he's getting. So, Hi, John, how you doing?

Speaker 2Kelly? How are you?

Speaker 3Man?

Speaker 1Good. How are you man, I'm doing alright.

Speaker 2That's happy to hear that. Man. How are you across, examiner, I'm doing well, John.

Speaker 3How are you doing?

Speaker 2I'm doing well. Okay, let's get to it. As you know, two days ago, sort of comment dere Tellier kir was tragically viciously gunned down as a tragedy. In my heart goes out to his wife, his children, it was a cut barum.

Speaker 1But to any victim of gun violence in their families, my heart goes on too.

Speaker 2Yeah, good, excellent. But it's really sicking in me that you have people who are out there who are saying that he deserved it. Instead instead of saying like, is it traggy, they were talking about his politics without the place in this scenario.

Speaker 3That's it, because I'll ask two questions of you. I just want to clarify because you said two things there. One, you said there are people out there saying he deserves it, and that's a separate statement from there are people talking about his political stances. So I want to clarify what you're objecting to to be clear. As far as I know, I personally, everybody i've spoke to it, the ACA and the acas. You know, certainly their stances. There is no place for violence in the world, much less in political discourse. You know, political change through violence is imhorrant and uh

Speaker 3and horrific. So I don't know anybody in my personal set of friends who are saying he deserves it.

Speaker 1Now.

Speaker 3I'm sure the Internet being the Internet, there are people saying that, but I would immediately block those people on my social media platforms and I would ignore them as unserious people. So can we can we agree that nobody on this call, and I assume Kelly would agree, nobody here is saying that Charlie Kirk deserved to be shot? Can we all agree on that with that? Okay? So is your objection simply that now is not the time to talk about his political stance? Okay, why do you

Speaker 3think that's.

Speaker 2The case, Well, he just said it. There's no room for violent and political course or in the world. We all have to unite here because it's tinoa anyone.

Speaker 3Who whoa, whoa, wha, wha, wha, whoa whoa. You made a big jump right there. So I asked you why now is not the time to talk about his political stances without getting into politics on the show, we're talking in the abstract here, and you said, because now is not the time, you sort of repeat it, and then you said we have to unite. I'm going to object to that, first by definitionally I don't know what you mean. And second, I don't think anybody has to unite over anything. But what do you mean you have to we have to unite?

Speaker 2I met as a specie, we're all one people, Okay.

Speaker 1Time should we? I don't know that we should all be grieving, John, but I think we I think as humans, as a good human being, we can all condemn what happened, But I don't think that everybody needs to be grieving. It's like if if if I don't care for a person for whatever reason, that I don't care for that person, and that person does have bad luck, something bad happens to them in this case of death, it doesn't mean that I even though I can condemn the violence, I can say that person doesn't deserve to have that happen

Speaker 1to them, it still doesn't I can be apathetic about how I feel about them having to suffer from this. Do you understand what I'm saying. It's like if I don't know Charlie Kirk. I don't agree with Charlie Kirk. I actually have very opposite opinions of some of the things that Charlie Kirk says. So when Charlie Kirk gets hurt, I can condemn the fact that he was hurt, but I don't really care that he got hurt. Do you know what I mean? I care about how he was hurt,

Speaker 1but not that he was hurt. Yeah.

Speaker 3To clarify, this is sort of like the question of guilty, not guilty, innocent? Right, I don't have to I don't have to actively mourn somebody that I do disagree with, but that doesn't mean that I actively wanted them to die. I can be indifferent. My heart goes out to his family, my heart goes out to his loved ones, my heart goes out to the world in this country that we are in this state. But it doesn't mean that I can't be apathetic about the individual right, Like millions of

Speaker 3ten thousand kids starve to death every single day on this planet, I am more upset about that than I am about one politician in the United States being killed. From a just individual case perspective, does that make sense?

Speaker 2I'm not asking you to put their lives on hold for him. But the least the people should say this is a tragedy.

Speaker 3We said that, yeah, it is that we must unite and that we should mourn him. And that's I think where we're disagreeing.

Speaker 1You're right, I like, as cross examiner said, the fact that all these children are dying actually has a way bigger impact on me than Charlie Kirk does.

Speaker 2But he was a human being. It should be the same.

Speaker 5Yeah.

Speaker 1No, well not necessarily. I mean, you know, like, like, do you care about some guy who lives in Saskatchewan that you never met before when he died? No, you don't. I mean you're.

Speaker 3Apathetic evially at least you know, you're.

Speaker 1Apathetic toward that. And I just had that same feeling towards towards Charlie. I just, you know, I condemn what happened to him. I don't think he deserved what happened to him. But Charlie Kirk himself, I don't really care about. I really don't care about him. I care about the action. I care about the outcome of the action. I condemn both those things. I don't think they should happen to anyone anyone, but I don't really care specifically for one

Speaker 1particular person.

Speaker 3Let me ask you this, John, when is the appropriate time to reflect upon Charlie Kirk's political stance?

Speaker 2Okay, we shall give it a year?

Speaker 1WHOA, Wow, that's quite a while.

Speaker 3Wow. I would have given you maybe a twenty four hours. It's something I would have thought about maybe, like people might say a week. But we can't talk about Charlie Kirk's politics for a year after he's dead.

Speaker 1That's what you meant right now?

Speaker 3Is and is that the rule for everybody? Like if your neighbor dies, we can't talk about their politics for a year. If if if any sort of like for example, we had what was her name, uh so Horman Hortman, thank you in Minnesota or yea died, we can't talk about her politics for a year when she was assassinated. Why why is this? Why can't we Why can't we reflect upon somebody's politics after they've died for a year.

Speaker 3What's the justification?

Speaker 2Okay, we could talk about his politics if it was if it was equal, because the conservative people are are turning by on him. I guarantee you if he was a liberal, people will be saying he was a wonderful person. He braves, Well, I would.

Speaker 1I would think I would think that liberals would be saying that, just like conservatives are saying that right now. But I don't think conservatives would be saying that. I think that the people who would follow him and agree with him would be say saying that. I don't think. I don't think it would be like everybody just because he was a liberal. That doesn't make any sense at all, does it really?

Speaker 2Do you think that's exactly what a double standard?

Speaker 3Well, sure, no, it's not at all.

Speaker 1It's it's the standard people people agree with the people that think the same way they do. So because Charlie Kirk was a conservative, conservatives are grieving him more than a liberal would. If Charlie Kirk had been a liberal. You're right, liberals would be grieving him more. What conservatives would not be because he doesn't fit their their frame of mind, just like he doesn't fit the liberals frame of Ryan right now. And I just want to point out that the person who did this, that that that

Speaker 1I don't want to say, did that, did do it, that allegedly did this is allegedly a conservative, was a Trump supporter. Yeah, and I don't know. I don't know how to. I don't know how how to.

Speaker 3In your point of view now, So yeah, I think that we should realize that there is this race to sort of point it go. Okay, the shooter was this, the shooter was that, and I think we can all agree the shooter was unstable to do this right. Your claim that there is a double standard amongst somebody somewhere, the media or whoever. The usual suspects are about what's proper and how people condemn each other after these events and all this stuff is an utter false narrative. The

Speaker 3conservative Christian movement loves this persecution complex. They have to say, oh, well, we can't say bad thing. All the bad things we say about liberals were condemned about, but then you guys say bad things about these people, et cetera, et cetera, which is not even what we're talking about. We're talking about not talking about Charlie Cook, the person. We're talking about his politics. But if you want to go on the record, we've had Melissa Hortman assassinated. The Conservatives were fine with that, and pardon them. All the people the

Speaker 3liberal judge had her son executed by a conservative. Nobody said anything about that. On the right, we had period, we had the guy from Florida sending pipe bombs to the White House and Charlie Kirk says a patriot should bail that man out, and nobody said anything about this. It goes on and on and on. So don't give me this false double standard narrative. It is horrific on both sides to attack the person and to say, like Charlie Kirk did, that, Hey, we should bail out somebody who nearly murdered a politician's husband, but instead we should

Speaker 3revere him when he dies, that a we must come together, that we can't talk about his politics for a year, and that we must unite in mourning him. That's a double standard, if there's anything. So, I'm sorry I sort of got a little hot under the collar there, but if you're going to bring this information to bear, you better be ready to recognize that humans as a whole tender run to their corners when this sort of shit happens in a useless way and start pointing fingers at each other instead of really trying to solve the problem,

Speaker 3which is we're in a state now where political violence is becoming more and more normal, and that is because on many sides there is amped up rhetoric and increased threats to people's very being. And that is an unfortunate state of affairs. And if anybody, including Charlie Kirk, contributes to that atmosphere, we should be allowed to talk about that, and whether or not we cared about the person, we should be able to talk about his politics. Put another way,

Speaker 3are people who like Charlie Kirk allowed to talk about his politics for a year after he dies? Yeah? Okay, so there's your double standard. I can't hear you. Kelly. By the way, I'm not sure if I'm doing all right here.

Speaker 1No, that was my bad. Okay, I muted my mic because I coughed. That was my bad. I was totally wrong. Again. Well, I got a really good double standard in this. In this particular case, though, you're asking us to have empathy for somebody who said that empathy didn't exist.

Speaker 3That's true, that's true. Empathy is a made up.

Speaker 2New age word, you guys to realize right now, you're laughing about dead Man, right you don't.

Speaker 1No, No, we're laughing about we're laughing about the standard We're not laughing at Charlie Kirk. We're laughing at the double standard. John. We're laughing at the fact that people, and it's not just you, it's many people that believe what you believe, and you have the right to believe that. I don't have any problem with that, but many people who are that are on your side are calling for the people who don't like Charlie Kirk to have empathy for Charlie Kirk. When Charlie Kirk said that empathy didn't exist.

Speaker 1That's what I'm laughing at. It had nothing to do with Charlie Kirk himself. And as we were laughing at the double standard, excellent point.

Speaker 2Don't you realize I didn't realize that the Finnish speech can be at risk now because if that's what you can speak in public.

Speaker 1Hey, I don't know how how can freedom of speech be at risk?

Speaker 2Now?

Speaker 3Define define freedom of.

Speaker 2Speech being able to say what you want to say without fear of being killed.

Speaker 3As mister Kirk was, that's not freedom of speech the way that ninety nine point ninety nine percent of the people use that phrase. So I suggest you rephrase it and don't use freedom of speech as a shorthand for that, because freedom of speech means, on the common parlance and in every possible way in public discourse, it means the government cannot control your speech, It can't compel you to take a position or speak, and it cannot suppress your speech in a unconstitutional way. At least here in the

Speaker 3United States, and other governments have made interestingly different decisions from a legal perspective and from a public policy perspective because of what you're expressing a concern about many other countries. In fact, most other countries do not have the freedom of speech that we have in the US exactly because of the political violence that we're seeing here in the United States. I'm not talking just about Charlie Kirk, but they recognize that hurtful speech is something that can get people very angry and can also harm people psychologically. For example,

Speaker 3if you're in the UK, most people view it as sort of like a sister country. Everything's fine. If you go over there and use a racial slur, you can end up in jail, convicted of a crime and stay there for months. That would be crazy here in the United States. So that is what we're to mean by freedom of speech. The government cannot come in and control you. What you're talking about is I'm crazy. I'm worried that we have such access to guns and such low mental health care in this country, and people are so stressed out in their lives about what's going on in this

Speaker 3country right now that controversial figures will get shot. That's what you're worried about. It's not freedom of speech. It's on a powder keg, and people who are controversial are gonna be easy targets. Does that make sense.

Speaker 2It does make sense, but it's not.

Speaker 3Let's not get into the gun control problem. It is one factor, Okay, it is absolutely one factor you can have. You can have the same societies around the world, and the deaths per gun per capita, per capita, again are insanely low compared to the United States. So one element. If you can't even admit that one element of the gun violence in America has to do with the prevalence of guns in America, I can't take you seriously. I didn't say it was the only thing. I listed a whole bunch of things, and you jumped on guns as

Speaker 3if that's the really important part here. The important part is it's a powder Keg. There's political violence and people are scared of speaking out in a controversial way, and we have to address that as a country. What's your proposed.

Speaker 2Solution people can't speak see I think.

Speaker 3What's your proposed solution? I agree it's a problem. It's about we don't want to live like this. This is not the country I grew up in. What is your proposed solution to this powder keg situation where people are worried that if they speak out publicly with their genuine let's let's give them the benefit of the doubt, genuinely held radical, somewhat radical, what people would call radical beliefs, that they will be physically attacked. What's your solution.

Speaker 2Well, it may seem a bit naive, but we need better people. I'm sure you two would never that's fair education, that's true.

Speaker 3I would think you would shoot anybody that I disagree with. I agree, and I don't think you would either. John. I've I've taken calls from you over the time. You seem like a very level headed person, if not sort of passionate about what you talk about. Most people I know would not do this, and I think most people who end up committing these sort of heinous acts. A disproportionate amount of them have mental health issues. I don't tend to run to the corner and say he was a this or he was a that. It's okay, what happened in this person's life that led them to this decision?

Speaker 3Oh wow, they were radicalized by this organization. They were radicalized over here. They had mental health issues. You may have seen the video down in North Carolina, a guy stabbing a woman on a train. What do you find when you get past the finger pointing. Oh, his mother tried to have him committed to a health care facility involuntarily multiple times, and there wasn't enough money to do that, and he ends up killing people. So if you get past the finger pointing, if you get past the politics

Speaker 3and you look to root causes, I think we can have genuine conversations where we try to come up with solutions, where we don't have to say things like, oh, we shouldn't talk about the politics of the dead. Well, people are dying every day. If we followed your rule, we couldn't talk about politics constantly. So I think we should instead talk about the politics and see where we can tweak them to come up with a solution where we don't have to live in fear that a bomb's going to go off when I go to the mall.

Speaker 2No one have to live in fear.

Speaker 1Correct, You're right, I agree, I agree, and I think I think we can both agree that extremist ideology is a problem, right, And I think one of the things that Cross Examiner was trying to get across is that because of the the scenario that we are living in right now, our current paradigm is driving more and more people to those extremist views. And that's a problem. And unfortunately, when we have a country and you're in Canada, so you don't really have this problem, but if you have

Speaker 1a country where people where we have as free access to weapons, with people who are extremists and are already hateful and spewing hate and are willing to act violently on that hate, that's a problem that those people are getting those guns. I'm not saying all guns are bad. I own guns, John, I was an avid hunter most of my life. I have a whole collection of guns for hunting. I am not against guns, but I am against hateful extremist people, whether right or left, getting guns

Speaker 1when they shouldn't have them.

Speaker 3Yeah, I agree. I have banned on my social media platform. Over the last two days, I have banned and blocked, and my wife will testify to this, at least one hundred people, all of them liberals. All of them liberals, not because of hate. I haven't seen too much hate. There was one person who came out was like, I'm so glad this happened that guy got banned. Most of it was conspiracy theory bullshit. Oh, this was a false flag stuff. Oh look at this guy that's standing behind Kirk and he's doing this weird thing and where he's just adjusting his hat. That's a false Like. I have

Speaker 3no patience for this anymore. I have no patience for the bullshit politics, self affirming confirmation bubble that the social media algorithms have produced in this country, where the instant anything bad happens, we run to our corners, we self confirm whatever preconceived notions we have by accepting conspiracy bullshit. We've got a gullible generation of people that have been trained by the algorithm to believe any sort of nonsense rather than do the hard fucking work of talking about the politics of this country. The politics of the country.

Speaker 3The is the discussion. It is the lifeblood of the country. It is what our country was founded on, is what our forefathers did. Is a as almost a pastime. Right, Let's talk and debate about how to make everybody's life better. So, yes, let's talk about politics, but let's not shoot each other in the process. And I think we all agree on that. But when you come in and you tell us that we must mourn somebody who wanted through who through their politics,

Speaker 3wanted to disenfranchise people, take rights away, imply that people were lesser, van cite the Bible that said, hey, gay people, you know God's perfect law. Bringing it back to religion, God's perfect law is that gay people should be stoned to death. When we're advocating that that, hey, I'm not saying I do it, but God says you should kill gay people. When they've got people out there making these stances, I think we need to talk about it both before they die and after they die. I talked about it

Speaker 3after Jerry Fallwell died. I didn't mourn him, and I found that his politics were repulsive. Jerry Fallwell did one great thing, and he filed suit against Hustler when a hustler satirized him with a rude cartoon and Hustler won. So thank you Jerry Fallwell for shoring up free speech in America in Hustler, in Fallwell versus Hustler. So he did a great thing there. But I'm not gonna I'm not going to not talk about a person's politics because

Speaker 3somebody else wants to clutch pearls and say, how dare you? This is not the time. This is the time. It's always the time. That is what we should do as a society. We have short lives. We're here to make our lives better, to make the lives we want. And if we want just people to get out of the way so we can live our lives, I want those people to get out of the way and stop trotting on those people who are less fortunate than I. So yes, let's talk about politics, and no, thank you, I will decline your insistence that I don't talk about politics after somebody dies. Sorry for the rant there, but we've spoken

Speaker 3a lot. We should probably let John reply.

Speaker 2Go ahead, John, okay, Well, first of all, Charlie never said killing you one. He was only speaking the truth that men are men and are women, and men don't believe the spaces and he wants to put the Bible up to him.

Speaker 1But I'm saying is that he did advocate violence. John, you got to admit he did advocate violence, making making jokes about people who attack other people as advocating violence.

Speaker 2He didn't deserve what happened. We all agree that.

Speaker 1That's not what I said.

Speaker 3I agree with, That's not what I said.

Speaker 1You're You're absolutely right. Nobody deserves what happened to Charlie Kirk. Nobody does, including Charlie Kirk. What I said was Charlie Kirk did advocate for violence. That's all I said. He thought that ALGBTQ people should be killed.

Speaker 3He did advocate to violent followers to bail that person out and call that person a patriot.

Speaker 1That's all I'm saying. I don't think he deserved what happened to him, but he did advocate for violence. That's all I'm saying.

Speaker 2Well, I get it's a sad day in America where anyone who dies he's kirk ser of liberal, or whoever dies or violes a threaten and people run through the corners and either considered a victory. I don't you agree absolutely?

Speaker 3I think can you keep coming back to that point? And we agreed to that in the first two minutes of this call. I think we're all on the same page. I just went on like a five minute rant condemning people who ran to their corners, telling you I was blocking people who were conspiracy theorists, and celebrating him. Like, we're all on the same page about that. But that is a separate issue from the debate goes on. We can't stop every time somebody is the victim of violence, who is a political figure, for fear of offending somebody

Speaker 3by continuing to talk about their politics, because if not Charlie, who, now somebody's going to take up his banner. Somebody is going to hold those positions and try to make that the law of the land. There are people actively trying to make this a Christian nation. When he I don't know if you know the context of the Hey, you know God's perfect laws that we should stone gaze. He was addressing a fellow Christian, a Christian who called in or submitted a video of woman who said God is love, God doesn't want us to harm anybody, And he said, uh,

Speaker 3uh uh, God's perfect law says that, and he cited the scripture a man who lays with a man should be stoned to death. So his point was we should tell people that truth and oh, by way, that law is perfect. He didn't I agree. He didn't explicitly say, hey, everybody, go grab stones and kill somebody. He just said, oh, by the way, if you're a Christian and you think God's all about love, you're wrong. He also has a law where we should kill people. And oh, by the way, that law is good, and that is God's love.

Speaker 1Hey, in this.

Speaker 3Country world, and it's called stochastic terrorism.

Speaker 1I'm gonna cut you off for a second because I got a supertruth here. We got a super chat from Kelly King, the Detroit atheist queen, for ten dollars. After Charlie Kirk was assassinated, several HBCU college campuses received death threats because his platform targeted black people because it was assumed that the shooter was black. Originally assumed that he was. So that's the chat from the super chat from Kelly King. And my supertruth for that is is that a blue

Speaker 1whale's heart is so large that a human could actually crawl through the arteries. So there you go.

Speaker 3That is great. Yeah, you're absolutely right, Thank you, Yeah, thank you for that super chat. That was Alabama State University, Hampton University, and Virginia State University all had to go on lockdown within hours after the Kirk shooting because people made assumptions, and I condemned that as well. They shouldn't do that. This is what we're talking about, right, conspiracy theory, not only low information no information conclusions by people, anti factual conclusions by people because it all serves their own

Speaker 3self confirmation bubble of I'm right, everybody else is wrong. If you're wrong, then you hate me and you're a lesser than right. And that is what we're dealing with with talking about the politics of those who support somebody who says, yeah, trans people should be killed by the government and that law that says you should stone people is perfect and it is love. So yeah, I'm going to talk about that because we have people rising up in his name targeting who minorities. The tweet I saw

Speaker 3from a black woman on Twitter was went right to us and we don't have shit to do with it. Right on Q Like it's like right, it's predictable. And it's very very sad. What were you saying, John, Well, you know what that means.

Speaker 2It means not that mister Kirk is dead. That means he's now a murder which means a person who did the shooting act, he did him a favor.

Speaker 3There is there, absolutely is a view there that yes, this is another reason reason number one hundred and twentieth on the list. Reason number one is it's just morally reprehensible. But yes, don't kill politicians because you create a counter movement in their favor. There is very sympathetic if if you're a horrible person, this is a message for you. If you're a horrible person and you're considering political violence of any kind, throwing bricks at somebody or shooting somebody, maybe that that reason we'll sink. Then don't do it.

Speaker 1Right.

Speaker 3You kill a politician and all of a sudden they gain all sorts of fame and sympathy and all sorts of things, and it creates a martyr. I agree with you, John, John.

Speaker 1I hate to say this, but we've been on this call for quite a while. I need to move on. I got some other I've got some announcements. I got to make I have other calls, and as always, John, I'm really happy to talk to you. I know we often disagree, but I think you and I always have some really good conversations. So I hope next time i'm here you call me back again. Okay, John, Okay, Yeah, thank you very much.

Speaker 3John. And I know I got a little hot onto the collar there, but I was vehemently agreeing with most of what you said. Yeah, I just disagree with the part where we have to hold off on the conversation because then we'll always be holding off on the conversation.

Speaker 1I think I was in agreement with a lot of what you were saying as well, John, So I think maybe at some points we were just talking past each other. So I really appreciate your collin, John, and I'll talk to you next time I'm on Okay, Yeah, Dan, I was just about to say, and I hope you have a really good night tonight, John, and a great day tomorrow. Have a great weekend. Hell, have a good weekend.

Speaker 3That's great.

Speaker 1Bye bye. All right, and uh, that was a pretty pretty good call. I gotta say. I do have some things I need to say, though, like like once every week we talk about or we honor one of our Patreon members, somebody who donates money to keep this show going. None of us make any money off of it. All the money goes to the show. We're all volunteers here. So I want to think this week's patron of the week, and it is the Victoria Vanderveer. Yes, thank you Victoria,

Speaker 1and thank you to everybody else who donates to us through Patreon at tiny dot cc Patreon tw So, I really, we all really appreciate it because I think this show is worth some He too, I really love this show. Of course I kind of have to say that, but I still think it's worth and supporting.

Speaker 3No, I love this show. It's a little more laid back. Things don't get as crazy, and you get you know, calls about UFOs if anybody wants to talk about what happened this week. We had a UFO video in Congress. Nonethelest.

Speaker 1I was totally expected at the call. I have some announcements I'd like to make real quick. A great way to support us is by sending super chats. We did go one from Kelly King. Hi, Kelly, I appreciate you. Get him in and we'll read him as we can we'll give you a supertruth back for sending us a super chat so that that'll happen. The Atheisticommunity dot org has printable flyers. You can go there and get these flyers. You can put them up with permission. Don't just put

Speaker 1them up anywhere, but you put them on community billboards so that people know to call our show. I have one on the billboard right inside my store. I've gone to like six of them now from people pulling a ta off. I and I when I drove down to Texas, I actually brought some with me and I had three of them. I should have brought more because I had, they were all gone on the first day. So I go, I hung them up in different places. I'm gonna bring more next year. So absolutely, and you know, we really want to hear from you. I really want to hear from you. I want to get some feedback on the

Speaker 1on the Truth bombs and so email us at truth at Atheist Typhoncommunity dot org. That's truth at Atheist Typhoncommunity dot org. Or you can reach out to TV at Atheist Hyphencommunity dot org and at our website at ace Atheist at Atheists.

Speaker 3Atheist Community hyphen community dot org and I forget that to say it seven times fast, Kelly.

Speaker 1To about toybout toy bo to do that. So yeah, I mean, I really do. I really want to get your feedback, you know, if you send us an email put some comments down below. I was really hoping to get some feed back on the on the truth bomb last week. I got absolutely nun So helped me out here.

Speaker 3Man, you need to you need to give me some context because you you jumped in this truth bomb. Somebody made this great comment and then you followed up with the blue whale heart thing, and I was just like, so, it's just random. Yeah, They're just random random, all right, got it? I'm in. I'm in on it, and like the most.

Speaker 1Important announcement that I could make here, seriously, the very most important one is that I want to thank the crew. The crew is freaking awesome. Let's get the crew cam up. Without them, I would look like a jib. They are They are the real magic people and the people who make this all work. So I just come in here and talk. I don't do anything else.

Speaker 3It just so I just focused right in on on Greg's dog. To be honest, puppies. Thanks guys. I got to meet a lot of those folks when we came down, and it was great to I got to see so for people watching, I got to see what happens in the control room.

Speaker 1There's your super chat. That one's for you.

Speaker 3That's for me.

Speaker 1Yeah.

Speaker 3How do I invest in relic futures? So now I have to do some sort of trivia thing.

Speaker 1Yeah, give us a trivia thing.

Speaker 3All right, trivia boy, I'm being put on the spot. Can I think about it for a minute.

Speaker 1No, you got to.

Speaker 3I was a division one of men's and women's volleyball referee when I was younger.

Speaker 1All right, that's good trivia. There you go. I'll count that you were talking about something before I cut you off, though.

Speaker 3That's all right. I was just running in my mouth. I don't remember what it was. It was something interesting but cool.

Speaker 1I didn't remember either, so it was probably.

Speaker 3About Greg's dog, that's all I think. Oh yeah, it was everybody down there, and I wanted to tell the viewers. You would be stunned at how much activity there is. They've got a very big control room in a very little house, and they're making so much happen with so little budget that it's me shilling. Yeah, please do if you can donate to this organization. They do a lot of good. This is, i think, other than the Freedom From a Religion Foundation has a podcast, but it's all promoting their stuff. They don't really do these sorts of debates.

Speaker 3I can't think of another charity organization that's doing this for nonprofit. There's obviously other shows out here that do this for a profit. They're free to be much more political than we are, et cetera. But as a charity where everybody here is a volunteer, this place is amazing. So any dollar you can give goes a long way to continuing the work of the ACA.

Speaker 1Well, second that really that really is a labor of love over here. We really is. And with that, I think, take another call. What do you think?

Speaker 3Absolutely this one looks.

Speaker 1Kind of interesting. It's a Catholic traditionalist. He him says that God is real, has an argument, and if we answer his questions, we'll be admitting the existence of God. I have a question sure.

Speaker 3If we answer God's questions or if we answer the callers questions, Because if we can't answer the callers questions, then it's going to be a real short call.

Speaker 1Yeah, So how you doing Catholic Traditionalists?

Speaker 5Yes, I'm doing very good.

Speaker 1How you doing good?

Speaker 5Good?

Speaker 3Did I get the relic tier system?

Speaker 5Right? That was for you?

Speaker 3Can I call you CT for Catholic Traditionalists?

Speaker 2Sure?

Speaker 3Okay? So did you hear our previous discussion about the relic tier system the tier one, Tier two, Tier three relics for the Catholic Church? No?

Speaker 5No, but that's not why I'm here.

Speaker 4I know.

Speaker 3I just was hoping that you had heard and I could get some immediate verification. So what's up?

Speaker 1You have the floor? Did we lose him?

Speaker 3I don't know. Are you there? CT? It's a miracle God intervened and prevented the call.

Speaker 1Yeah, I was. I don't know what happened and did he drop? You know, I'm going to return him to the queue for a minute, and we'll see what happens. We'll try to pick him up here in a minute. Hopefully it's not just a technical problem. Yeah, that's hopefully it is just like a slight technical problem.

Speaker 3Right, be interested in chatting?

Speaker 1Yeah? I was hoping to too. I was wanting to see what his questions were going to be. I had a feeling they were going to be kind of loaded questions that didn't have that, and he wasn't going to get the answers he was looking for. I was kind of that might have happened.

Speaker 3If you answer the questions, you you lose. The argument feels like presuppositionalism. It sort of feels like, hey, logic can't exist without God, and so if you're using logic to answer questions, you admit that God exists type of thing. But that's just my guess. I'd be interested to hear what he has.

Speaker 1I would love to I would love to hear that. So we'll see. We'll keep an eye on the crew chat here and see if they can work that out. Maybe or maybe we just lost them, who knows here. We'll see what we can do.

Speaker 3So I heard from a producer that they're calling back going back in.

Speaker 1Yeah, you see that too. So in the meantime, let's talk about your podcast a little bit more.

Speaker 3Okay, sure, okay, So what would you like to know?

Speaker 1First of all, I guess I was thinking, how long have you been doing your podcast?

Speaker 3I've got two seasons out, so about two years. I'd usually do a handful of eight to ten episodes a season. Like I said, I've been on hiatus both because it's hard to do as somebody who has to hold down a full time job and has a kid in college and has a kid who's on the autism spectrum and all of these things going on in life. But I've recently been sort of reignited with my passion. I had a lot of plans for this coming season, so I've been doing it for about two years. I've learned a lot in those times, and I do think there's a

Speaker 3space in the internet, the blogovers, the podovers for people who are interested in teaching other people. I think that's my interest, and I do think there's a space. I do see videos from other people like Dan McClellan, especially who creates content that is educational and polite and straightforward that is getting a lot of traction, and I think the next generation will be very hungry for that sort of information.

Speaker 1I have to cut you off because we got another super chat and it's again for Kelly King love it. I love it, and she don't edge of five dollars and says, you guys make a great call host team. Well, thank you, Kelly, I appreciate that that was awesome, and I as a you know, the dogs developed that puppy eyes expression just to manipulate humans. They didn't have that original like wolves don't have that.

Speaker 3I've heard that that is a great truth bomb. I also heard that cats don't normally meou in the wild. I don't know if that's a urban legend, though. I heard that cats developed a particular meow to manipulate humans. But I will ran, I will willingly be manipulated by any cat dog, prairie dog. I've been seeing baby skunk videos online that are hilarious, but yeah, I will buy into any of that.

Speaker 1I'm just checking in to see if we're ready for the call.

Speaker 3Oh, looks like we might have that caller back here.

Speaker 1Yeah, it looks like checking in with the crew. I'm a bad typist. Typhing.

Speaker 3We roll the bones and see what happens the relic bones.

Speaker 1So yeah, the relic research and relics. That someone was like Buddhists tooth Oh yeah nice, who would have figured, right? So they say that he is ready to cook. So let's bring Catholic Catholic traditional news back. How you doing? Sorry about that?

Speaker 5Can you hear me?

Speaker 2Now?

Speaker 1Yeah, totally can hear you? Sorry about that?

Speaker 5Okay? Yeah, because I could still hear you guys, and I didn't see that the call ended, so I don't know why.

Speaker 1Yeah, that was weird. It might have been a problem with our with our call in programs, so that it does happen sometimes.

Speaker 3So what you got for CT?

Speaker 5Yeah? So you guys are atheists? Right? You claim to be atheists?

Speaker 1Well?

Speaker 3I always always claim to me, I guess I claim.

Speaker 5What do you do?

Speaker 1I always label myself as an atheist? But fair enough?

Speaker 3Why don't we get Why don't we skip the label word and ask like specific questions because I think the word atheist is loaded and people use it differently. Should I should we tell you what we actually believe?

Speaker 2Yeah?

Speaker 4What? What?

Speaker 1Uh?

Speaker 2Now?

Speaker 5With regards to whatever god it is that you don't believe in? Could you define that god that you don't know?

Speaker 2No?

Speaker 3I can't because on this show, and I'm sure Kelly can confirm this, I get presented almost every single caller has a slightly different God that they present us, they propose to us. There's losts of gods out.

Speaker 1There, which is why I'm an igtheist.

Speaker 3And what is igtheist? I'm not familiar with.

Speaker 1Fish is the idea that the question of the existence of God really has no meaning because no two people have the exact definition of what God is. Basically, there's no unambiguous definition of God that everybody uses, so we can't really define whether or not that God exists. If we can't define the God first.

Speaker 3That's great, that's a great term. My position's a little different. My position is I have yet to be convinced that there are any gods, but I am open to being convinced. So I'm not saying I am convinced that there are no God. I have just yet to be convinced that there are any So everybody who's presented me with some model of a God I have found wanting. And that's if you want to call that an atheist, so be it. Some people prefer the term agnostic, but I think linguistically

Speaker 3there's a problem with that. But that's my position for want of a better word. Do you understand where we come from, CT.

Speaker 5Yeah, that's fine, So for the sake of discussion, I'll go ahead and give you my definition of God. And by the way, there are more than two people that share this definition, Like, for example, I'm sure, you're familiar with Darth Darkins, right, and Thatt Slick.

Speaker 1Yeah, But I bet if you and you and him were together, you wouldn't agree on everything one hundred percent. I would guarantee it that you would not one hundred percent guarantee it. And and I'm going to ask you, right, I'm going to say, right now, I hope you are not using a Dark Dawkins argument.

Speaker 5Well, with regards to the nature of God, we would be in agreement. Now, perhaps with regards to teachings, Biblical teachings, we might not be in agreement. But with regards well that's true.

Speaker 1Well, there you go. Then that's what I'm talking about. You're not totally in agreement. And that's and I don't know two people that are even the people who are sitting next to each other in the same pew in the same church, are not going to agree one hundred percent.

Speaker 2Sure, sure, but with regards to.

Speaker 5The nature of God. I've spoke to Matt Slick and Darth Darkins many times and we're one hundred percent in agreement.

Speaker 1But you're not one hundred percent in agreement about everything about God. And that's my point. You can say you're one hundred percent in agreement about this one thing of God, but not one hundred percent about all of God. And that's the point I'm trying to make. And you keep saying, no, that's not right. We still agree on this one point. Well, I'm not talking about one point. I'm talking about the whole big picture.

Speaker 5Sure, I understand, but there are people that do share my view because I'm a traditional Catholic and there's other traditional Catholic.

Speaker 1And I'm ensure that those people do not agree with you one percent.

Speaker 5Speaking without being interrupted? Am I going to be interrupted every single time?

Speaker 1If you're going to keep saying the same thing over and over, I'm going to interrupt you to tell you yourself. I'm going to tell you the same thing I just told you before. So let's not repeat ourselves about.

Speaker 5Other traditional Catholics, or I'm not going to be able to make that point. You're not going to allow me to make that point.

Speaker 1Well, did you believe the same thing other traditional Catholics? Sure you can make that claim.

Speaker 3I don't believe it is that core to your discussion. How many people agree with you?

Speaker 5Well, just refuting the fact that the individual said, you won't find two people that believe the same thing with regards.

Speaker 1To God, and that.

Speaker 3I mean, I could make the sure I could make the same argument about you won't find two people who believe exactly the same thing about George Washington. Right, The visualization in one's mind is unique to oneself, if you want to get deep about it. Right, So it's kind of an interesting position from an actual like what do we know and how much can we actually like? How much does language limit our ability to convey meaning to each other? And so we what is our ability to even check to see if we have identical beliefs about

Speaker 3a concept. So we've got to inguistic limitations. But we also just have a physical problem of two brains are physically different things, and the way that you model and thought in your brain chemically is going to be different from person to person. So I think we should probably move past that concept to to what your point of your call is.

Speaker 1Yeah, let's get to your question.

Speaker 5We could we could do that, but I was simply refuting his claim and showing that yes, if you.

Speaker 1Have let's yeah, but you called with some questions. Let's get to your questions.

Speaker 5Okay, I understand you want to move past this because I was refuting your earlier claim.

Speaker 3Okay, we want to move past conversation.

Speaker 1Be any fucking proof at all. You didn't refute shit, Okay, you didn't. You just made You just made a counterclaim, and okay, I accepted your counterclaim. I even said that, let's move on.

Speaker 5Now, right, So let's move on. Don't get calmed down. No need to get angry and upset.

Speaker 3All right, no need for before before we move on. But before we move on, I think we need to level set here, all right. I took the time to give you an example of what I meant, or what could be meant, about the physical and logical impossibility of two people to hold the exact same idea at the same time. Okay, I took the time to explain that out. You then got all snarky and started making snide remarks about Kelly and his response and lack of response, and are you gonna let me? I very strongly suspect, based

Speaker 3on this whole thing so far, that you are not an honest interlocutor, You have no interest in actual conversation. So I'm going to level set and pretend like this is a brand new call, and I would hope that it's going to be productive. I genuinely tried to engage with you, and you ignored my whole explanation and just kept pointing at Kelly. So let's start again. You called in to tell us something about an argument for God. Could you please tell us what that is?

Speaker 5Sure, I'll be happy to do that. So with regards to God, I'll go ahead and find God. For the sake of discussion, Let's say generally God is an intelligent agent who has the power ability to instantiate and impose all states of affairs, and didn't have a beginning like you and I, in other words, not a creative being. Now, you don't believe that God exists.

Speaker 3Right, I'm not convinced that such a being exists. Are you going to present any evidence of this being?

Speaker 1Yeah, I don't accept the existence from God because I haven't seen sufficient evidence. But I'm not saying that there is no God, just that I haven't seen.

Speaker 3You're going that's not how this works, Godla, there's a game. Knowing who you cited when you called in, I am guessing you're going to make some sort of pre supplisitionalist argument that try to shift the burden of proof. So Let's be clear. Let's be clear about how burden of proof works. All right, I'm an attorney. One of the things I've studied in my studies is where does law come from? For example, the common law of England dating back to the Magna Carta. It is a set of

Speaker 3rules that we've established that is seeking to find truth using the best systems we can when there's a dispute. And one of the things that have come to rise out of this are the rules of evidence, the Federal Rules of Evidence, a sort of the written down version of what we've learned over the last eight hundred to one thousand years about what can constitute reliable evidence and unreliable evidence. And at a trial, the person making the claim, just like in logic, the person asserting, the plaintiff or

Speaker 3the state who is making the claim, i e. I'm guilty of murder, or you stole the potato chips, or you put your driveway on my land and you need to move it. That person has the burden of proof. They are the ones who must present evidence to convince the finder of fact who is the judge or the jury, as to the veracity of their claims. And if they fail to do that, the verdict is for the defendant. The default position of somebody becoming un or remaining unconvinced

Speaker 3that the plaintiff is right. That is the world we live in. The reason that the courts do this is it is the absolute best system we have to make sure that we don't make conclusions that are false. We don't start with the presupposition that the defendant is guilty and then work backwards and have somebody prove the otherwise. So, if you are not going to actually produce evidence for your claim and then try to walk away like you claim to victory, you do not understand logic, You do

Speaker 3not understand history, and you do not understand how humanity works to make the best systems in the world that we can for coming to these sorts of conclusions. So, given all that, do you have any evidence for your God?

Speaker 5Yes?

Speaker 2I do.

Speaker 3Okay, let's hear it.

Speaker 5Yes, And remember the premise of this conversation from the very beginning was that you said you were going to accept answering my questions, and that by answering my questions I did not it was going to show that God does exist.

Speaker 1Yes, say, I.

Speaker 3Would accept answering your questions. Did you say that, Kelly, No, No, we did not say we would accept answering your questions. So stoppening words in our mouth, I.

Speaker 1Had a feeling that maybe we might not give the answers you want. So, but let's go ahead.

Speaker 5Just Dan, You guys want to look to drop me because you're not going to be able to answer these questions because they will prove that God exists. So you're looking for an excuse to run away.

Speaker 3So where's where's your where's your Nobel Prize in philosophy? Yeah, so it's a tactic that here's your where's your chair? Where's your chair? At a university for logic, reason, math, religion, because if you've got.

Speaker 1To any smarter than anybody else.

Speaker 3If you've got a fool proof proof of God, then you either have to believe a conspiracy theorist to say, yep, this is some sort of proof of God. I'm about to give on this call in show from the atheist community of Austin. That should convince anybody that God exists and prove in fact that God exists. But there's a conspiracy in the world to suppress and deny it. So that's the one position or you're full of shit. There's a flaw on the argument, one or the other. So instead of beating your chest and claiming repression and censorship

Speaker 3and trying to claim a win without even having an argument, when you know that we're going to actually be skeptical of your claims, why don't you tell me why you are calling this show and not writing up a paper and proving to the world that you have irrefutable proof that God exists.

Speaker 1You've spent ten minutes arguing and not giving your argument at all. I don't know, and then you're saying it's our fault, but you haven't and we've asked you to get start questions like three times.

Speaker 5Yeah. I was told by the call prompter that you would agree to answer my questions.

Speaker 1I am not the call prompter.

Speaker 3You're not going to address anything. I just said I.

Speaker 1Would agree to hear your questions. But you're not even asking the questions. All you're doing is complaining about other shit. Just answer the just to ask the fucking questions. There, I think he hung up on us.

Speaker 5Yeah, I'm still here.

Speaker 1Oh there we are here. Okay, Well, what's what's question number one?

Speaker 3Yeah, let's just cut to the chase.

Speaker 5We will know that my questions been from the beginning.

Speaker 1You know I'm getting ready. I am getting ready to cut you off because we have been from the beginning. I asked you three times to start your questions.

Speaker 3I have a question. I have an honest question again for you, cet. Do you think that the way you're behaving I e trying to get your debate let's call it a debate partner to accept some sort of weird sentence like you accept that you will answer my questions up front at the beginning of some sort of argument. Is a is a representation of what it's like to have an honest conversation. Why are you being so evasive about that call?

Speaker 5Yeah, that's what the call prompter. When I had the conversation with this individual, he said.

Speaker 3That you're not on the call right now, and we're not in. We are not h him, We're not him. And the phrasing is what I'm asking about. You're asking if we accept to answer questions, will I answer your questions?

Speaker 2Yes?

Speaker 3Is that all you want from me is to say yes, I will answer your questions as I have been all along. Or is this weird wording of accept that I will answer my questions. Is your argument rely on that? If not, then what the fuck are you doing? Can you just please be an honest person, get off some sort of script, and just have a conversation about what evidence you have of God.

Speaker 5Now, guys, if you're going to go ahead and keep putting me on mute and then taking me off from you, you got to tell me when you take me over.

Speaker 1I haven't muted you once. You have been muting me.

Speaker 5I know for a fact, you guys have been muting me.

Speaker 1No, have not muted you once. You know what, you know what. I'm done with this call because you did not call to hand a conversation. You called the wine when you called to wine and complain, and I'm not going to sit.

Speaker 2Time.

Speaker 3It's been eleven minutes and forty eight seconds in the second call I dropped him. It's eleven minutes and forty eight seconds without like wanting to get us to agree to some sort of weird thing.

Speaker 1No, it was eleven minutes of him complaining that we didn't want to hear the questions that I asked him four times to ask. Yep, that's what then, that's why I dropped his call because I asked him four times to ask his questions. All you could do was complain, and we weren't asking him to ask his questions.

Speaker 3I will go back to what I asked about before. If you're going to call in a small internet talk show out of Austin, Texas with absolute proof that God exists, why why are you not writing it up as a professional paper and winning all sorts of philosophy, religion, science awards, Like if you could prove that God exists, go do it. If you're going to call in here and play word games for eleven minutes about whether or not we agree

Speaker 3to it or we accept that, we will answer questions to try to put us into some sort of word trap about presuppositionalism, I mean, quite frankly, you're just a drain on society.

Speaker 1Man.

Speaker 3I don't know what you're doing on a Friday night doing that. I'm here for honest conversations, not people trying to do some sort of you know, it's kind of like those people who do magic tricks by saying think of a number and multiply to this and haha, I got what your number is. It's like I set up the entire thing so you will say yes to some weird verbiage, and then later I'm going to try to call you on something. Rather than saying, okay, let's go back and amend my answer, let's go back and redefine things. And when you run into that, it's shocking that he would not just engage with us. Yeah, and you know

Speaker 3what the purpose was at the end, right.

Speaker 1I yeah, you know what, he had a script and we weren't paying. We weren't on his script, so that it was blown his whole thing. That was obviously what the problem was. We weren't getting near the end of the show anyway, so I'm not too sorry for cutting them off. I don't think we would have gotten all the way through his questions before we ran out of time. For the most part. Anyway, I would like to do something real quick though, before we do anything else, and that's I'd like to bring John back up if we absolutely Yeah, Hi, John, how you.

Speaker 3Doing that was like a pot was?

Speaker 1Yeah? That was that was difficult. Like the meta of that call.

Speaker 4It was nothing but meta, by the way, just constant complaining just about you know, the interaction, instead of like the actual questions that he was wanted to ask. Which if it was dwkins like script. I mean, everybody knows what script team runs, and it was pretty much the script that he ran. I mean, it's call in complain about getting interrupted or silenced or something like that. And I think the only difference is he couldn't threaten to drop you like.

Speaker 5That was.

Speaker 1What got me was that he kept saying we weren't let letting him talk, and I was like, kept asking him. He just wouldn't. I mean, why even should We had thirty minutes of dead air waiting for him to ask.

Speaker 3Yeah. My advice to people who want to engage in this sort of stuff on either side, when you're asked to present your evidence, when you're asked to ask your questions or make a statement, do it right. This is to put on your big boy and big girl pants and do it. If you were in a court and a judge says all right, your witness, and you get up and say, judge, I really don't think it's fair that the sun is this, and the judge will be like, excuse me, are you going to ask questions or not? No, okay, that's it, case over. You didn't ask any questions. That's

Speaker 3what you're dealing with Okay, we don't have unlimited time. It is our show. We will accept the calls we want, whether you believe it or not. I have a board up here that I can see calls. You were never muted. So if you just want to call in and be a victim, realize that you are a child trying to play it in an adult's game. An adult comes in who has a prepared argument and is an open mind and willing to explore the contours of their argument in in an intellectually honest way. I have friends where I could go. You know, here's the presuppruisitionalist argument. Let's explore it.

Speaker 3I'll take the pro side, and you can play with the idea and figure out where the flaws are and what the pros are and the cons are. I love that. If you want to call in and do that, let's do it. But if you're just going to call in and say I'm going to complain until they just have had enough of me and then walk away like I won, you don't understand the difference. As Forrest VALKEI said, with I think you godless when you were talking to somebody. You don't understand the difference between can't and won't. It's not that I can't put up with your shit, it's I won't put up with your shit.

Speaker 1So did you have any other thoughts about the show? John?

Speaker 4Yeah? Okay, so like I really thought that the conversation on the press prepose prepos yeah, the funny.

Speaker 1Yeah.

Speaker 4So now my question is, and if anybody feel free to answer this, Okay, in like Dark Souls and everything like that, like you have like things that you can wear, right, they give you certain special abilities. And I'm thinking, like the preface, right, what what if it's like a ring and you know you you wear it. What kind of magical abilities could you get from wearing Jesus' foreskin? I mean, I think I think that would be interesting.

Speaker 1Would it work like a ring of viagra?

Speaker 3Oh, that's a good one. Like in Dark Souls, it would definitely.

Speaker 2Uh.

Speaker 1I don't know.

Speaker 3There's some levels where you could walk on harmful stuff, like you know, spike spots, so maybe the walking on water thing you could not get wounded there. Or maybe it's more like you know how in the Gospels or some rules. No, it's it's exodus or levit because it's Old Testament stuff where they say, men who have had their genitals crushed are not allowed to go to church. So maybe this exempts you from that if you've got if you've gotten crushed genitals, but you've got the foreskin of power, you can still go to church. Maybe that's it, the for skin of power.

Speaker 1I love that relic.

Speaker 3By the way, Tier one, that was great.

Speaker 1That was great. So before we leave, though, John, can you remind us what the prompt is for next week?

Speaker 2Oh?

Speaker 4Yeah, yes, I definitely can hold. I'm so sorry I put that down for a second. So the problem for this week that you'll be answering for next week is what is a job that you could get in heaven?

Speaker 1We all want to know. I'm probably a chair. Remember to put your comments below in the COI were your suggestions below in the comments, not in the chat, So we'll see them and we'll read out the top three next week. So I think Dan, I'll be back to do that for you. What was I going to say? Oh yeah, I was going to ask you for any words of wisdom?

Speaker 4Me words of wisdom?

Speaker 3You know what?

Speaker 1How about either one of you? Let's get words of.

Speaker 3Wisdom first, and John can think of things. Since we have the seqel To Spinal Tap coming out, which may or may not be good the reviews yet. I will quote their keyboardist at the end of the first movie and he said, have a good time, all the time. Words of wisdom to live by John.

Speaker 4Uh don't don't step on a cracker you might break your mother's back.

Speaker 1That was something I always paid attention to you for a good chunk an early part of my life. So and uh, my words of wisdom is don't uh, don't take anything for granted, and always always keep wanting the truth.

Speaker 1Watch the nonprofits and join the hosts in the life shot. Visit tiny dot cisy slash YTNP

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Truth Wanted 9.46 with ObjectivelyDan and Out Of Body Atheist

    Nov 16, 20261 hr 31 minAudio

    In today's episode of Truth Wanted, ObjectivelyDan welcomes guest Out Of Body Atheist, with The Beard of Empathy on backup, to dig into Reiki, New Age spirituality, homeopathy, and the long road from woo to skepticism!...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Truth Wanted 9.45 with Jon The Skeptick and Volcy

    Nov 9, 20261 hr 23 minAudio

    In today's episode of Truth Wanted, Jon the Skeptick, Volcy, and Sofia Spina explain why no one can talk to the dead, from Haitian Vodou and grief dreams to Jon's past as a spiritualist! Bob jumps from objective...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Truth Wanted 9.44 with ObjectivelyDan and Nintendrew

    Nov 2, 20261 hr 29 minAudio

    In today's episode of Truth Wanted, ObjectivelyDan and Nintendrew, later joined by The Beard of Empathy, tackle a world run on Jesus, the magic of manifesting, and a prayer that actually got answered! Bob in NY, a...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Truth Wanted 9.43 with ObjectivelyDan and Kelley Laughlin

    Oct 26, 20261 hr 28 minAudio

    In today's episode of Truth Wanted, ObjectivelyDan, Kelley Laughlin, and The Beard of Empathy tackle standards of evidence, miracle claims, and the false binaries of moral philosophy! Dean in VA questions why skeptics...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Truth Wanted 9.41 with ObjectivelyDan and Chad Harris

    Oct 12, 20261 hr 32 minAudio

    In today's episode of Truth Wanted, ObjectivelyDan and Chad Harris tackle Christian nationalism, police brutality, and the uncomfortable truths about racism and immigration. Big E in TN survived police brutality and...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode