Truth Wanted 08.12 with Jon the Skeptick and Drew Bekius
1 hr 45 minAudio
In today’s episode of the Truth Wanted, Jon the Skeptic and Drew Bekius take a dive into animal rights before realizing the dive was deep enough to encounter octopi of potential alien origins. Connor in UT would like to know the hosts’ opinions on animal rights being an extension of human rights. Jon mentions the struggle associated with soy allergies when going to a plant based diet. As Drew emphasizes the importance of this conversation, he describes the need to exercise mindfulness and gratefulness towards other beings on the planet. What is the best option for animal testing? How can the pain and harm be minimized? Dee in IA says that farmed animals in the future need to reside with local farmers where farm animals are bred for food. If dogs are bred for fighting, does that make it right? What does ethical farming mean and how do we explore these practices? Would it be cool for aliens to come down and have a human farm because we are so tasty? If an animal is bred for a certain purpose, what would make that purpose ethical? Though Industry and employment are important, they are not the right reasons to keep this in practice. Jon in Canada saw a plate move all by itself after having a conversation about ghosts. What is your best explanation for this? How do you go about getting all the information before making the conclusion that it was caused by a ghost? Sometimes taking the position of not knowing is the way to go. John in OH says that he can prove there is no afterlife because the mind is a separate substance from the body and consciousness is a property of the brain that can be turned off. If the mind is a process of the brain that stops when the brain dies, why is this important to theists? Dan in Canada wonders if the awesomeness and weirdness of octopi indicates they might be from other planets. Are there other connections that go beyond this category? How would the disconnect be explained between the animal kingdom and Cephalopods if there are in fact disconnections? How convinced are you that the octopus is not of earth origin? Thank you for tuning in! Kelley Laughlin, our backup host, joins us to close out the show. Question of the week is: What says I am an asshole without saying I am an asshole? Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/truth-wanted--3195473/support.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Speaker 1Thank Mother Nature, who may or may not exist, that spring is now upon us. Spring is seen as a time of rebirth in nature, with the transitioning from winter to life, waking up the natural world. But spring can also be viewed in a spiritual way as a sense of newness in the air. To some, can mean the feeling of powerful energy that may or may not convince folks that an abundance of new energy opens the pathway to the supernatural and with it could come supernatural experiences that may or may not have an adequate explanation. I'll
Speaker 1tell you what. We're about to host a call in show where there's Truth Wanted. So if you have a supernatural claim that you want to discuss with us, maybe you want to convince us that supernatural things are real, but it ghosts or gods or something else, and give us a call because the show is starting now. Good day and welcome to another episode of Truth Wanted. I am your host, John the Skeptic. This is the live call in show that happens every single week Fridays at seven pm Central Time where we talk to people about
Speaker 1what they believe and why. So, if you'd like to give us a call, you can at one five one two nine nine one nine two four to two all through your computer at tiny dot cc slash call tw truth Wanted as a product of the Atheist Community of Austin, a five oh one c three nonprofit organization just dedicated to the promotion of atheism, critical thinking, secular humanism, and the separation of religion and government. And each week on Truth Wanted, the host is joined by someone even more fabulous,
Speaker 1and this week we have Drew Beckius. How's it going, Drew, Hey, not bad?
Speaker 2My man. I gotta tell you, I'm really disappointed that over the last few weeks we've just magically figured out what all of truth is across this country and around the world, and we don't know.
Speaker 1We don't need more truth, right, we know it all.
Speaker 2We've got it all. We've got disappointed, no curiosity.
Speaker 1It's got to be some truth out there that we don't know about yet. This just got to be. Let's hope that we find it today.
Speaker 2Let's find it. Shovels go there.
Speaker 1You go. Before we get started, though, we do want to give you the results from last week's We Want the Truth or the WWTT segment. Last week we asked you make up your own religious counterpart for a science claim, and here are some of our favorite answers. Number three, know what religious counterpart for scientific claim? There's no such thing as gravity, only intelligent falling. Great. I like a little bit of a fun.
Speaker 3A.
Speaker 1Number two Chuck gaid us a religious counterpart for a scientific claim? Dark matter is really the corpses of the angels who died in the war in heaven. They can't be seen, but it's well known that a spirit weighs twenty one grams.
Speaker 4Amen.
Speaker 1Here you go, there you know. And at number one, Miranda Rensburger religious counterpart for a scientific claim? Rather than vaccines, showing your immune system are part of the pathogen so that it can build up antibodies, the vaccine is actually an internal anointing with holy oil, which allows you to fight off the demons that cause disease. That does sound more plausible than anything else I've ever heard. Are you anointing me with water? Right now? You should never throw water at electronic components. That's what I've always learned, right.
Speaker 4I was actually just miming it.
Speaker 1Oh, I believed you. That's some great acting drow.
Speaker 2What was the truth?
Speaker 1I don't know who knows. So this week for the we want the truth, no that we want the truth that I did say it right. The prompt is what says and now listen, I'm going to say this wrong because I'm British. I'm sorry, but I'll say it again the right way for everyone else. What says I'm an asshole without saying I'm an asshole? Or what says I'm an asshole without saying I'm an asshole?
Speaker 5Right?
Speaker 2Any?
Speaker 6Good?
Speaker 2Very well done, very well?
Speaker 1Okay, thanks so dry, We gave you that prompt. Have you got have you got something?
Speaker 4Well?
Speaker 2You know, just yesterday I was telling someone that my partner is actually from Canada, as a Canadian citizen who's here, and they quickly, immediately their impulse was to look absolutely horrified, something like and then they immediately said, are they any illegal? I don't know, fucker, tell me tell me you're an asshole without telling me an asshole.
Speaker 1Wow, that's okay. Well, I'm sorry, but I also feel that as a person not from this country, living in this country, that happens to me more often than you care to imagine. Mine would be a lot less as harsh people correcting grammar Ah yes, and I promise I will try and stop doing that. But you know, I'm an asshole or an asshole I guess. Can wait to see what the audience comes up with. Comment on this video, and your meant may well be read out in next
Speaker 1week's episode. So Drew is here with us this week. Drew, who are you? Where'd you come from? What's she? Inside Lake? All the all of the good stuff. We didn't have to say the inside leg but you know, like.
Speaker 2Did you just ask me just that?
Speaker 1I apologize.
Speaker 2Since I've measured, but you know we that yeah, yeah, yeah, no, So I am Drew as you said, that is me And yeah, you know I'm a former minister. Started my first evangelical Christian nonprofit ministry thing at the age of sixteen, started preaching at seventeen, went off to seminary, picked up a couple theology degrees, pastored a couple of churches, YadA, YadA, YadA, YadA.
Speaker 2About twelve years ago, the my deconversion culminated and I finally realized that yes, I had in d become an atheist. I had already left the church, or at least the ministry at that point in a last ditch effort to try and rekindle my faith. Maybe it would be easier to rekindle my faith if I didn't have the need to care for everybody else's souls. Maybe I could just focus on my own and God would start talking to me again. But a couple months later realized I had indeed had in fact become an atheist, left it all.
Speaker 2A couple of years later discovered the Clergy Project. Had the incredible privilege to work with the Clergy Project for a number of years, first as first as communications director and then as president. It was an incredible experience with an absolutely fantastic organization providing peer support for no longer believing religious leaders around the world. I've been involved in humanism since then in a variety of different ways, and love spending time working with our local humanist community here
Speaker 2in the Twin Cities, which just so happens to be the first community to ever use the term humanist. You know that old, antiquated, like philosophical Renaissance term humanism from the thirteen hundreds. Well, our community was the first one to say, we like that terminology, let's apply it to a nontheistic lens anyway, So great group of folks based here in the Twin Cities, Minneapolis, Saint Paul, Minnesota. And yeah, otherwise, I'm just trying to learn to be a better human, live a healthier humanity, build a better world. That's about it.
Speaker 1It's very difficult as one person I've found. But what I've what I've learned from you, Drew, because we have met in person. Drew has this uncannyability to command a room without even trying. You just have this voice and presence that people just want want to listen to you and gravitate towards and you are a wonderful man to be around.
Speaker 2Until John enters the room.
Speaker 1Whoat just because of a British accent, I have nothing of note to say, whereas you, I think you could talk about like guinea pigs and people go, do you know what, Yeah, Drew's got a point. Guinea pigs tool.
Speaker 2Are pretty pretty fantastic. I like, if you were held a guinea pig.
Speaker 1I used to have guinea pigs. Yeah really yeah.
Speaker 2Their whole life is just in your hands, just right, bum bum bum.
Speaker 1And I lived in a country where you know, there's no real natural predators other than humans, So guinea pigs, people have guinea pigs as pets, and you know, rabbits as pets. There's the occasional fox that might try to get in, but that's very rare. Yeah, no, I used to keep guinea pigs. There you go. That's a little fact about me.
Speaker 2Fun fact. I love it.
Speaker 1I feel like we're all learning something here. We haven't learned your inside leg yet, but we'll get there by the end of the show.
Speaker 2A dangerous journey to find it out, so right, I.
Speaker 1Mean, I've been on shows where we've been talking about circumcision and who's got who's got for skin and all this stuff. You know, who knows where this this show will go. I'll show you later. Well, I've got a video phone, so I'll call you if you want to. If you also have a full skin, feel free to call in and tell us yes, yes, we want to know. So before we get to some calls. We have got
Speaker 1some calls lining up, and there are spaces if you do want to give us a call as well. We want to hear about some truth truth bombs that you might have, or if you believe in stuff that we may not believe in, try and convince us that it's true or you know, it's just hearing about some experiences that maybe you've had. Give us a call. There's plenty of space open. We've got a long show and we want to hear from you. But before we get to some calls, we do need to shout out our patron of the week. Every single week we get to shout out our patron that donates through tiny dot c c slash patron tw for supporting the show. This week's Patron
Speaker 1of the week is Victoria van der Veer. Thank you, Victoria van Dervie, and thank you to everyone else that contributes to the show. Okay, let's have we have we got someone. Yeah, we've got someone ready to go. Are you ready to Let's.
Speaker 4Let's do it.
Speaker 1Let's kick this thing off, shall we. So in the queue right now, we've got Connor pronouns I hear him from Utah. Animal rights are an extension of human rights and would like our opinions on that. Hey, Connor, you're on with John and Drew. How's it going? Hello, Hello, Hey, hey.
Speaker 7Hey, Yeah, I was just you know, just wondering, like you guys's opinions about the idea of like animal rights and how you know, like for me like I feel that there's either a misconception or like you know, more of an invitation for people to like consider animal rights, like there is, of course human rights, but like knowing like how there should be like a continued effort for
Speaker 7animal rights to write.
Speaker 1I'm I'm in I'm going through some stuff right now when it comes to animal rights and eating animals, an internal conflict where where I'm slowly starting to move away from wanting to eat animals and trying to find another another way to get all the nutrients that I need. So I'm with you, but I tell you what I am struggling with getting there. I since moving to the USA, developed a very annoying allergy. I'm allergic to soy, and soy when you're on a plant based diet is quite
Speaker 1abundant I found. So I'm struggling with with that. But I am kind of with you, Connor, and I think there is still a lot of humans almost seem like we're the dominant species and we should we get to eat all these things. And I don't necessarily agree with that, but I mean there are certain species of animals that I sort of lean more towards having a bit of like a protection need for if that makes sense. I don't know about you, Drew.
Speaker 2Yeah, No, I think this is great, And Connor, I really appreciate the call because I think this is It's an important conversation that is not always often had. And you know, I hear about this a lot. So I kind of tend to spend a lot of time within humanist circles. And there was one variety of humanism that oftentimes is kind of kind of maybe misconstrued as a core humanist tenant, and that's this idea that like humans are above and beyond all other species, and that puts
Speaker 2humans as supreme. Most humanists today do not believe anything of the sorts, and it's more just living a healthier humanity, building a better world, and as the species that fucked up so much of the world, taking responsibility for that in building that better world, and focusing on the human in humanism because well, that's us, right, Like how can we live life without living it through our lens? Which makes it inherently focused on being human. So that's why I still like the terminology humanist and the movement humanism
Speaker 2that said, I don't want it sound like I'm digressing because one of the criticisms of humanism is a whole other movement called sentientism. Maybe by chance you're familiar with us heard of this, and the idea there is kind of almost doing everything humanists do, but just shifting it a little wider and saying, listen, we don't just care about humans and humanity's ability to thrive, but we care about all sentient beings. And I think there's a lot of benefit in expanding that conversation. It doesn't flow off
Speaker 2the tongue. I think the branding suffers a little bit with sentientism versus humanism. It's just like what huh for a lot of people, which for anyone not aware, I mean sentientism or sentient beings are those beings who are able to feel pain, may or may not have some level of consciousness but feel pain, right, and so, But then we can ask, you know, connor, maybe the concern is even beyond just sentient beings to all humanity, right and so or I'm sorry, not all human all beings, right. I think these are good questions. I'll be honest, I
Speaker 2don't have any easy answers. I have dabbled in veganism for a long while I was pushing kind of hard to try and incrementally become more and more vegan. I think where I'm at right now, and I by no means claim that this is the best way to do it, but it's kind of where I'm landing is trying to practice more where I'm trying to exercise mindfulness and graciousness towards the sacrifice that other members. And I say members,
Speaker 2I'm just talking about other beings, other animals and beings around you know, a part of the earth, you know, acknowledging their sacrifice within that cycle that I will eventually die and feed into myself. And so that's more where I'm at. Again, I don't claim that that's the best way, and I certainly might not land their long term, but it's where I'm at now, If that's helpful.
Speaker 1And Connor, where are you? I mean, I feel like probably wouldn't have called if you weren't at least vegetarian or you know, exploring veganism. But how do you feel about it?
Speaker 7Well, like, well, this is my first time calling, so I'm a little shaky.
Speaker 8So if I've talked kind.
Speaker 1Of we're very gentle, We're very gentle.
Speaker 8Here, okay, thank you.
Speaker 5Uh.
Speaker 7Well, for me, I've experienced a huge transition for me because, like I am, I go to I go to a class it's about animal philosophy, and it's really tackling with notions of like how do we come about uh in our you know, human mindset of like of like interactions with other sentient beings.
Speaker 8Like for me, I've rastually changed.
Speaker 7My diet in a lot of ways. I've not eaten uh, eggs currently or milk. I've been drinking soy milk instead. And and I think even if you know, you guys have said that like you calcoled like or like how to be vegan or vegetarian like, I think it's a continual process, not just oh like I made it, but it's more like you know, always evolving into.
Speaker 8A better you and you know, diriving.
Speaker 1Yeah, I think I think that's important as well. And I'm one of those that if if something is naturally produced by an animal, I don't see as much of a problem with eating what's being produced as long as it's again done in like a humane cared for way, absolutely fine. But if you know battery hens for example, that they're not treated very well I do not want to encourage that, so I won't purchase eggs from battery farms or I actually stopped eating beef seven or eight
Speaker 1years ago because I didn't agree with with beef farming. So I was like, Okay, what can I do to slowly transition out of this? And that was one of the things I worked on. I kind of feel like, you know, as long as as long as animals are being cared for in the correct way what they produce, we could probably I'm okay personally with ingesting, but you know, if animals are treated terribly, I don't want to encourage that, and anyway, I do not want to keep pushing that
Speaker 1and give people a reason to treat animals that way. And we know fully well that when animals get hurt, they let out. They feel pain, they let out. If I've accidentally stood on my dog several times because she's always just there and she yelps when I accidentally tread on her tail or something, we know that they feel pain. So I feel like I'm desperately trying to do it. Kind of honestly, I'm trying to step away from eating the meats. It's going to be a slow process for me because of my allergies. But you know, I do. I feel like you're doing the right thing by saying,
Speaker 1you know, animals have feelings and maybe we should think about how we ingest them, if we ingest them at all, or what, you know, what what we take from them. So I think you've got a good message there, Connor. I'm all for it, thinks.
Speaker 2So absolutely, I agree. I agree, And any anything you're curious about you want to discuss a little further along.
Speaker 7This line, maybe like I have, I have a hard time with I think that it goes along with animal rights too, like the idea of like animal experimentation, like for like science, scientific purposes, and and I struggle with that.
Speaker 1Because he's still there, Connor, did we leave you? Oh no, I hope we didn't. I was going somewhere and I enjoyed.
Speaker 2Yeah it was so good.
Speaker 1Yeah, well, I mean I think we Oh there we are, it's back again. Don't leave us, Connor.
Speaker 7Oh yeah, I don't know, like the recepts and maybe a little bit off, but yeah, I'm did.
Speaker 8You hear what I said?
Speaker 1Say it again just so we can make sure.
Speaker 7Okay, just to repeat I right now, I having very struggling with the idea of animal experimentation, like like specifically like in scientific terms, because sure there is like some implications to like helping humans to like maybe for certain diseases too, or some cures, but like, like like recently,
Speaker 7like I found out that like there's been alternative ways of not using animal experimentation, like like for instance, like like like I think it was like colle like something like animal a human uh lung like like regenit like some type of replica of the human lungs so that we can like test things out. So yeah, I wonder what what you guys think about that.
Speaker 1Where do we draw the line on on what we test on animals? Because I mean, for the betterment of the human space. He's looking at ways to treat diseases and treat ailments that you know we struggle with as a species. Maybe, but you know, testing for how a hair spray holds your hair and what lipstick looks like. I definitely vary against that. It is a very fine line because how else would we I mean, other than testing on ourselves obviously, how else would we find ways
Speaker 1of treating all of these issues that the human race suffers with. I do think, you know, if people are happy to be tested on, go for it, that'd be great, But there aren't many people that would do that, and so what is the next best best option? And unfortunately, it does seem like that using creatures that have similar DNA sequences to what they're treating for is the only way to do it. But I mean, what do you reckon, Drew. It's a tough one, Yeah, it is.
Speaker 2And I think this is another one of these things where at least I would suggest there's no clear and obvious answer in some of this. But I mean, you know, to some degree, it almost comes down to what the what's the the scenario called with the train tracks right where you flip back and forth and right. So on the one hand, I'm tempted to say that, okay, if like in terms of cancer research, okay, and I confess, profess my ignorance. I don't know exactly all the different
Speaker 2ways that animals are used in testing, but I'm assuming it's it's pretty pervasive, okay, Like everything is my assumption. And so if it's something that is more serious, like you said, John, not hair spray testing the hold of hair spray, but something like cancer research. Right, if there's applications there, I my mind jumps to okay, if the choice is, you know, never testing any cancer research on an animal, or something similar to cancer research on an
Speaker 2animal and continuing to let humanity die of cancer, or if it's I was going to tempted to use the word sacrificing. I don't know if that's the best way. They're not choosing to do it to sacrifice themselves, but if it's using some animals in order to potentially save eradicate cancer from humans, I don't know, But that's the train track thing, right, But I'm the one pulling the switch on those animals, and so that's what then gives me voice to the other sides and right, but is
Speaker 2that our place to make that choice, because they're not choosing it themselves. So it is.
Speaker 4It's tough.
Speaker 2And here's where I would suggest there are no easy answers. I know some from either side would say, yes, the easy answer is mine, And I don't fault those that do find easy answers. I just I can't say it for myself. I see a variety of sides, but I do lean towards really taking seriously and prioritizing animal welfare and the fact that they do have sentience, that they do experience sensation and feeling and pay and respecting that and looking for a way to minimize it while also
Speaker 2seeking to minimize human suffering. And I do kind of feel like any species, when put to the test, is going to prioritize their own species. Now, we have unbelievable strength, and so we need we have a responsibility and ethical responsibility to keep our strength in check, even in defending ourselves. Nonetheless, I do think it's kind of natural that we would lean towards our own species. And so yeah, again I don't know, so Connra, I'd love to hear your thoughts
Speaker 2in response to us, and feel free to disagree, of course, I want to hear the conversation.
Speaker 1Absolutely.
Speaker 7Yeah, In some aspects, I've learned a lot about how in an evolutionary perspective, like I think like maybe seven million years ago or so, that like we were just evolving from I think like astrolypicus.
Speaker 8I can't say it right, but that we used to.
Speaker 7Yeah, And basically it's like knowing like in our own evolutionary perspective, we were once vulnerable to other animals and and like like maybe uh in that aspect and maybe seeing that we can know that we have been vulnerable in in in those times and knowing that in a way we are still vulnerable for ourselves today because we want to like fix all the elements or like want to like like cure yeah, as you mentioned, secure different
Speaker 7cancers and and and may and I disagree, and knowing that I disagree, knowing that it might come to some sort of like in that in the egality with utilitarianism, like the greater good for the greatest number of people, it makes it seem like we have to quote sacrifice some animals for some people, uh, some people that are going through a horrific pain, especially in the humans.
Speaker 1And it's not easy. I mean, if anybody extremely close to me started suffering with something like cancer and the only way for them to be cured was for me to be tested on, I would absolutely do it in place of an animal, you know, And I think a lot of people would stand there. But we just don't have that means right now. And so it does look like, unfortunately we do have to stick with some form of testing on animals. And do I agree with it? Probably not but for now that is all we have, so
Speaker 1just to just to jump on the back of that, all right. I mean that was a great call, and I think we covered a lot of stuff there, Connor. So I appreciate you calling in with all that.
Speaker 8Yeah like that. Yeah, that is a lot of stuff and just like.
Speaker 1That's what we're here for. This is the exactly the kind of thing we want to hear about.
Speaker 2Absolutely, absolutely, we'll appreciate the call.
Speaker 1Yeah, we'll let you jump off there, Connor. But well, yeah, yeah, really appreciate the conversation. Thank you, you have a good one you too. Take care, absolutely, take care. There we go. That was nice, It was I think it is important that we do discuss this because I don't know if there's enough conversation because people are too worried about what they're doing in their own day to day lives, and animals do have feelings. We have pets. I don't know about you, Drew, but I've got a dog and two cats, and they are family members. They're not I don't just I can't throw them outside and leave them out there in a storm or whatever. You know, they're my family.
Speaker 1Sometimes I prefer my animals to people. You know, so I think a lot of people feel the same way.
Speaker 2I've got I don't have any pets at the moment. However, there's this beautiful little squirrel, all white fur, little pink eyes. We've nicknamed her Alberta, and she lives in the neighbor hood. There's a forest across from me and uh, and she's always coming up. We've established a relationship with her. Every time, you know, stick my head outside, I'm like, and she comes running up out of the forest wherever she is, and feed her some nuts, little cashews. I mean, she's great, she recognizes us, she comes right up, almost comes in.
Speaker 2Ut I haven't let her just yet yet. I'm not sure I can trust her in the home I've heard. I'd almost rather she stole the TV than the things I've heard doing in homes. But but yeah, but you see, right there's there's clearly more than I So. I was raised that animals are just like programmed robots. Okay, it's all robot. It's just instinct, which was framed to me as just like they're a robot, they don't have any feelings.
Speaker 2They're just they're working off their program and nothing can deter them from it, and that's just I study and study time and time again has disproven that. But also and adoldally, I think a lot of us have seen it as well.
Speaker 1Absolutely yeah, I've had pets on my life and they are that. There's not ever been a time that I've had a pat and gone, oh, this one's dull, this one's just a robot. You know, they're they're family, They're absolute family. We've got some more calls in the in the cube. We do have to do some little little extra things before we take anymore. Drew, I'm sorry. So then here we go. I'm on. If you want to hear about a content, if you want to hear our content in audio only form, there we go. Please go to tiny dot, cc slash a n podcasts for all
Speaker 1the latest ACA shows. There go. We're also now accepting super chats, which we may read live on air. I did see one pop up, so we'll probably get to that at the end of the show. Obviously, as long as it's YouTube appropriate, that's when we read them out. Have you also, Drew, you may have said this, Have you said to yourself, I really love the content that the ACA creates, but obviously not in a whiny British accent like that you say in a nice call American way, But I wish there was a way I could get it all the time. Well, guess what, Drew, We've got
Speaker 1you covered. We now have two twenty four to seven live streams. AXPTV delivers a constant stream of shows, clips and specials from over the twenty six seasons of The Atheist Experience, and now Heathen TV provides you with clips from Talk Heathen Watch, or simply listen to your favorite hosts and discover some hosts you've never even heard of. Visit tiny dot cc slash AXPTV and tiny dot cc slash Heathen tv to join in all the fun on those and last, but not least, I do want to
Speaker 1thank our lovely, fantastic crew. So if we can bring up the crew down there, it is thank you to all of our video operators and audio operators, mods, note takers and just genuinely lovely people who make sure we look great. Kelly is also a part of that. Kelly is back up for this sh but Kelly's on everything. Kelly is back up extraordinary, so we'll get We'll say thank you to Kelly at the end. Of the show as well.
Speaker 2Goddamn superhero.
Speaker 1He's just I feel like if there was a face of the ACA, it would be Kelly, because Kelly is just there, knows everything, knows everyone. He's awesome. But we'll we'll bring him up later because he's busy. I don't I don't know what he's doing. I just looked down at his camera and it looked very questionable. Anyway, No, I didn't. I'm lying. I'm lying. We do have another call to get to, so if you're ready, Dream, we can jump on in.
Speaker 2I'm ready. Let's do it.
Speaker 1Okay, We've got d She here from Iowa. Farm animals are bread for food. Morality is more in how they are farmed. Okay, Hello, d how are you doing here?
Speaker 5Hi?
Speaker 9Hello, great to talk to you guys.
Speaker 1Likewise, Ella, what have you got Okay?
Speaker 9Well, okay. I grew up in a country, very rural area. Farming was like the local economy. So while I never farmed myself, I you know, grew up with farmers. I visited farms, and uh, I think that I think that the future of our agricultural economy needs to lie with with the local farmer. We've got to start supporting local
Speaker 9farmers more and more because these are the more ethical practitioners for raising farm animal amal animals, animals.
Speaker 8Goodness.
Speaker 9Now, I know that modern family farmers still use some uh you know, like corporate flaughter uh uh, transportation stuff like that. Some uh, some of them that are not in such remote rural areas still use corporate farming methods for those vities. But the farm aminals, I keep saying that, I don't know why.
Speaker 2When the camera is off, I'm just like, yeah.
Speaker 9You know, I might as well just speak. I might just as well as being don't go, you know. But the farm animals that we have now are mostly genetic lines that have been established for hundreds, if not thousands of years. So they are you know, they are food animals. That's what they were created to be. I think the morality that we're looking for is in how they are farmed. You want to start cutting out those corporate farms. We
Speaker 9want to start cutting out allowing maybe the more rural farmers to go back to you know, their own you know, their own butchering. And and there are co ops who who have like co op meat lockers in the rural areas for pork and beef and you know lamb eggs, you know egg laying chickens. We're seeing more ethical communities
Speaker 9come together and make ethical and cruelty free farming more of a reality now than it trending more towards that now than we have in a long time. So I think if we, you know, concentrate on that and try to find ways to fund our local farmers. But I think that vegetarianism could still be an ethical option, And
Speaker 9that's my thought. I've tried a couple of times with a few other people to try to get that thought out and try to fully form it. What do you guys think?
Speaker 1You said something interesting about how you know animals have been bred now for for this, and I'm still I don't. I don't see how that can make it anymore right, because they are still animals that have feelings at the end of the day. So I don't. I don't see that as a pro for for still eating meat and animals because people bred dogs for specifically for fighting, And
Speaker 1does that then make it right that they were forced into fighting each other and one coming out the victor because the other one died? You know, it's there's still we've got to look at how we can maybe move away from Oh, we've got a line of animals here that are a thousand years old, but their grandparents and their grandparents were chopped up and turned into meat. Does that make it right? You know? What about you, Drew?
Speaker 2Yeah, I was I was going to start making similar comments. I think it's it's dangerous to say, you know, just because something has been bred to well, some would say to provide for food. Others would say, and I wouldn't necessarily put it in these words, but some would say, to be murdered. Right, just because your bread to be murdered, to be tortured, doesn't mean it's not painful for them, doesn't mean it's unpleasant for them, and it doesn't mean that
Speaker 2they don't feel it right they have. If one thing we know is that in all of the breeding, which I agree has been done very intentionally the breeding, one thing that was never included, maybe because there isn't a way to do it, or maybe just because they didn't care, is the breeding process did not include eliminating their ability to feel or sense or hurt, be it physically or even emotionally or communally. Right the community that if I understand right, the community that that pigs feel is it's
Speaker 2off the almost off the scales. It's among the highest of of of h in the world, from what I understand, among the highest, but so so being bred for these purposes doesn't necessarily.
Speaker 4Make it ethical.
Speaker 2I do agree, though, at least to some degree, with this idea of exploring ways for more ethical farming. As I mentioned earlier, D I don't know if if you heard the caller before you and our full conversation the three of us, but I shared that I find myself I explored experimented with veganism actually for years, and where I'm at now, I'm in more a different space. I'm not totally sure the best way to describe it. I
Speaker 2don't know that I'll continue being here forever, but this is where I'm at currently. Is this idea of simply being more mindful and and and grateful for the animals, the other creatures of this world, that that I am now gaining strength from as I as they share their inner energy from themselves to me, and then as I eventually die and become food for others in the ground, right, and so kind of looking at it through that type
Speaker 2of a lens. So through that lens, I'm not opposed. I eat beef, I eat eggs, I eat the you know, just about anything. I'm trying to stay away from white carbs these days. But apart from that, in terms of protein, I kind of eat everything, okay, but I try and do it more mindfully, more more intentionally, more gratefully. That said, though, that's where there is a place for that's where there is this place for more sustainable, more ethical farming practices,
Speaker 2so that those animals before they become food, that they can truly enjoy life to some degree. So where it's wide open field, so I only buy grass fed beef, okay, open range, free range eggs from free range chickens. Right, So trying to be more ethical. I don't know that I have all the right answers, but right looking for those who aren't given hormones. So I just while you were talking, D I looked up, Okay, well, what does ethical farming mean. It's not my area of expertise, I confess, right,
Speaker 2So I'm seeing things like, you know, where there's expansive pastures, natural diets, appropriate shelter, right, grass fed beef not corn fed, by the way, I grew up in an agricultural environment similar to yourself, d in rural midwestern Minnesota. My dad grew up on a dairy farm, and I remember him helping out at my grandpa's farm when I.
Speaker 4Was a kid.
Speaker 2We always had a cow in the pasture in the back. I didn't live on a farm, but we did have a pasture and a cow. Okay, so I grow up in this. I'm sympathetic to it, and I know it can be a really emotionally difficult conversation for a lot of people I love in the community I grew up in. But I do think there are more ethical ways that we need to explore in how we farm. So I don't know if that's helpful. I'd love to hear more of your thoughts on this.
Speaker 3D Well.
Speaker 9Yeah, that's that's pretty much exactly. My point is is that we we know that there are better ways to farm our our food animals and and keep them without you know, without cruelty, without adverse you know, uh, pain free, stress free farming. And I know, uh, it's easy for me to say things like this because we are so far into the corporate farming culture now, but I think,
Speaker 9like you say more ethical ways, grass fed beef, free range chickens, cruelty free veal, Uh, the I mean h veal actually cruelty. That's a that's an oxymoron because the deal is baby lambs, right, So cutting up, you know, cut out veal, that's one thing that I am against. But anyway, you know, I'm i'm, i'm, I'm I would like vegans. I would like militant vegans to stop and
Speaker 9consider people who maybe don't have the financial means to eat strict cruelty. It's that that you have that you have a an allergy to soy, and it's so hard to find alternatives without the soy. You know, I just I would just would just like to see the hardcore vegans kind of, you know, get off this. Everybody has to.
Speaker 1R I kind of see where you're coming from, but also about it, just to jump in as well. I do understand it. There's ways of talking about these things, and you know, sometimes it can come across as you know, maybe bullying people into doing it a certain way. And I'm kind of with you there, but I do also on the flip side of that, see why people do speak up about it, because there needs to be some awareness about all these things. So it kind of sometimes does take someone who is what you'd label as hardcore
Speaker 1to really shout out about this and say, look, this is why I see that I feel that this is wrong. Maybe just a conversation about this could could maybe just slightly change your mind on it and maybe make you rethink about these things. You know, I think the conversations are very important. Still, animals, are you know? I was going to say people too. They're not animals, are you know? They have feelings and they you know, some sort of consciousness as well. So do they deserve to be killed to be eaten? I don't know. I did see in
Speaker 1the chat. Just a fun little thought experiment. We try, say the year is twenty thirty, and finally aliens have come down and they take some humans away because they look tasty, and they start a human farm and eventually breed certain humans that have more meat and start farming out humans to the aliens that like to eat them and saying, here you go, this human. We raised them ethically. We put them in a living room and they had a TV, and we made sure they had a good diet.
Speaker 1But we killed them so that we could eat them would how would you feel about that happening?
Speaker 9That is a good question with all With all due respect to the person that brought that up, I think that hypotheticals like that aren't helpful in this discussion.
Speaker 1I'd liked it though, I really enjoyed it, and I'm.
Speaker 9Glad they put it out there, but for me only, it has no relevance, and I did want to kind of push back on one thing. I don't think an equivalency with breeding fighting dogs is equivalent to breeding meat animals or in my argument, in my particular argument, I don't believe that it's relevant eat us ethical treatment and cruelty free treatment is baked into my argument for this, So I don't think that breeding fighting dogs is equivalent.
Speaker 9Having said that, I am very much against fighting dogs.
Speaker 1Right, and I feel like a massive hypocrite here because I still eat certain meats, so I don't want to be because you know, I do feel like animals need to be treated right, but also I like how some animals taste still, and I can't get away from that. But I still think that like animals being bred for a purpose, you know, in this case, is to be eaten. At some point, does the animal have Should the animal animal have a say in being bred just to be
Speaker 1killed to be eaten? Even if it's an ethical way, they're still the the endpoint is still that they're going to not be around anymore to be food for someone.
Speaker 9What are we going to do?
Speaker 5Right?
Speaker 1No, but and that is a good question, Well are we going to do?
Speaker 9If it economy farm economies? What I mean, if if the hardcore vegans have their way, what what are the farmers going to do? Then it's going to be a mass disruption to local economies.
Speaker 2I'd like to jump in with a couple thoughts here on a few different things over the last uh last few minutes here. So I'll just make a shoot out a few different responses to a few different things that have been said here that I think might be helpful lenses to look at a few things with. You know, first of all, talking about okay, the vegans, the vegans, the vegans, they need to understand almost sensing and I don't want to put words in your mouth, but it
Speaker 2almost feels like vegans need to shut up, you know, or something like that. Here's one thing I will always be in favor of, and this is just me feel free to disagree. One thing I will always be in favor of is when a human anyone, if you believe something firmly, passionately, with conviction, If you're all in on something, I want to hear it, and I want you to give me your best shot. So I might not cause I think you owe it to us, because what if it's better. What if your arguments on something I've never
Speaker 2considered before, or what if your arguments and when I'm saying you, I'm not talking about you, I'm talking about all of humanity. What if your arguments on something I am against end up convincing me. What if I've never thought about it that before. Like I truly believe we have an ethical responsibility to loudly and vigilantly and passionately proclaim whatever it is our viewpoint is. So yes, I might not agree. I don't agree with at least not the classic stereoi, typical vague, and at least not them.
Speaker 2I don't agree with their framework or however they whatever they're looking at from certain ways, but I one hundred percent want them to argue their case. I kind of hope they'll allow a little bit of leeway for those of us who agree, But that's a different issue if they want to be assholes, you know Whoever the particular person is definitely not all are. But if somebody who's a vegan wants to be an asshole and not allow for any variability from other people, well that's a different issue. Okay, whatever, be an asshole. But I still want to hear your position on things. You owe it to me, and I
Speaker 2believe that I owe it to you that you hear mine. So that's one thing I want to state, you know, I do want to one way again, It's just four things. That's the first. I want to just shooting out a couple of things here in response to as I've heard d and John, the two of you going back and forth in conversation in the past few minutes. As far as the fighting dogs analogy, the way I heard it, at least was not that John was equating to John. Correct me if I'm wrong, But what I heard was not John equating raising animals for food with raising animals to fighting That's not what I heard. What I believe
Speaker 2I heard was the justification in an animal being bred for a particular purpose, making that purpose ethical right. That is what I think was argued against, and that I one hundred percent believe. Granted, the purpose of breeding a fighting dog is very different than the purpose in raising an animal for food, and one might be ethical and the other one might not. But nonetheless, the correlation of an animal being raised for a purpose bread for a purpose makes it automatically ethical. Is I would suggest, I
Speaker 2would suggest, is absolutely hands down wrong. Okay, that's my second thing. Third thing, moving on real quick, aliens, I actually love it. So here's what and here's where I see the messiness of humanity, the messiness of life is I look at I don't all a grad D. I don't like the equation, and yet I kind of fucking do like because it's beautiful. I do think it absolutely went undred percent applies. I think at one hundred percent is a fantastic thought experiment to this. But here's the thing. Now, I'm going to pickle a proverbial pickle, if you will,
Speaker 2because now I have to sit here and I have to say, well, shit, if animal, if an animal, or I'm sorry, if an alien comes and harvests me and takes me on up. I mean I wouldn't like it. I wouldn't That's true. And I got to sit with that. I don't know that that means that I can't that that means I have to become a vegan or a vegetarian. I don't know that that means that. I mean, I don't think. I don't think, you know, you know other I'm trying to think of, like an animal that would get eaten by an elk. I don't know that an
Speaker 2elk likes being eaten by a lion. That doesn't mean now that's different. What are some meat eating animals that also get meat eaten? You know, I'm I'm sure there's some out there. I can't think of any at the moment, but I'm sure they don't want to be preyed upon, but yet they still got to eat. I suppose the difficulty the gray area here is we don't have to eat meat. That is what makes it messy. Welcome to the messiness of the human experience. But I do think that a one percent applies. And the last thing I'd say is what about the farmers? Yes, I grow up,
Speaker 2and then I'll shut the fuck up. And you want to hear more from each of you. We can continue the conversation, But what about the farmers here again, I empathize. I sympathize. I'm from a farming community. I get it. And as humanity advances, as the world continues, there are industries that grow obsolete. I'm not saying that farming will ever grow obsolete, but certainly if we conclude that it's unethical. Again, I'm not suggesting that it is unethical, but if we would conclude that it is unethical, then that better not
Speaker 2fucking be. We better not let it wag the dog saying, but we need the jobs, so keep doing the unethical thing. Now. Fuck that. That is not how we ethic, That is not how we live if we're living ethical. Again, I don't think all farming is inherently unethical, but we can't let the one drive the other. Okay, we can find other jobs, we can find other things we have to for survival, but we can't say what about this industry because people are employed there there Therefore we have to find a way to justify it, even if it's unethical. No,
Speaker 2So I don't know. I don't want to go on and on. But those were a few smatterings I had I heard in my mind. Sometimes I hear the voices between the two of you, D and John as you are kind of going back and forth there.
Speaker 1Yeah, I appreciate that I've got any closing fools that.
Speaker 9D excuse me, gosh, yeah, a lot of them running around. Yeah, I am not. I am not in any way saying that if the question ever becomes settled of the ethicality of it, is that.
Speaker 10Even a word, I don't know it is now, And.
Speaker 9I would definitely cool cool call up websters for me, guys.
Speaker 4I love it.
Speaker 2I love it.
Speaker 9I would absolutely you know, I would absolutely stop if I ever became convinced of the unethicality of eating meat or consuming eggs or whatever. I'm not I wasn't trying to take it all the way to a logical conclusion. I'm just trying to throw out some ideas.
Speaker 1And it's very much warranted. It's like all opinions are valid in this kind of conversation. I think you did the right thing, absolutely.
Speaker 2And when I say I want to express their deeply held beliefs or thoughts or perspectives frameworks that includes you. D. I'm really glad that you've called and we're having this conversation.
Speaker 9Me too, me too, and I do have fun talking to you guys and pounding out ideas. It's one of my favorite things to do in the world. And I really do. I appreciate all three of you guys's viewpoints, and you did give me a couple of things to think about. So that's good.
Speaker 1That's what we're here for.
Speaker 9For your time. And yeah, thanks for your time and talk to you again. Great weekend.
Speaker 1You two. Don't be a stranger.
Speaker 4D thank you.
Speaker 1All right, that was great. It's really I didn't know that this was the direction of the show today, but I mean, I'm open to it. I mean, I'm still learning a lot about veganism and all this stuff. Nuts not meat, I'll have you know. Today I had peanut butter on toast for my lunch, so hopefully, hopefully that pleases some people. We do have more in the queue, and a regular on the show is John. He him from Canada would like to apologize for his prior behavior.
Speaker 1Hi John, you're on with John and Drew. How's it going?
Speaker 5Oh Drew, Oh, how are you hey?
Speaker 4Doing well?
Speaker 2Good to have you on. John.
Speaker 5Good good, Okay, I'm just going to get straight to it. Spoken before, and at that time we spoke heated. I said something I shouldn't have and I was misbehaved. I didn't behave for the gentleman. I don't apologize for that.
Speaker 1Well, okay, absolutely, Yeah, what I mean, do we want to bring up what was said before and just so we can hash that out and then discuss and then move on.
Speaker 5Okay, I will remind you what we spoke about, but I don't want to get into the right right we've talked about that.
Speaker 1Okay, Well, it's good that you've apologized for it if it got heated. I feel like, you know, there is a time and a place for conversation, but not necessarily for getting angry with each other. You know, we're not. We're just humans at the end of the day. We just want to have conversations and find things out about each other and you know, move on as we can. But John, you have a lot of great things to say. I've heard you many times. So since you're here, do you have something about, let's go supernatural belief that you
Speaker 1wanted to discussed with us?
Speaker 5Oh? Okay, Well, the only supernicial thing I can ever talk to you about if I ever witnessed like once I was at work. Okay, okay, weird thing I was at work. We're having a conversation about ghosts. And half an hour later I was working and I swear to God, our plate just moved by itself. Nothing, There was nothing I could have moved it by itself. I didn't touch it, it didn't fall. It just okay, you know how a frisbee is thrown, right, The plate went off the thing and flew like a frisbee all by itself. And I was the only one who saw it. I have a co worker. Do you see that? He said? See what
Speaker 5he said? Like, maybe the girls hurt us? And I was there a way of showing it. To this day, I can't explain it. Maybe with my imagination. I do not know.
Speaker 1Let's let's okay, I'm going to explore this because this is this is right up my alley. This is the kind of thing left. So I I used to work in a pet store with some people. I was nineteen, and in the back room the ladies that I worked with were convinced that this place was haunted. It was also at a time that I was still a believer in supernatural stuff, so I was fully on board with it being haunted. Terrified me, but I was very on board with it, and they were talking about some supernatural things happening. Bags falling off shelves, which always happened even
Speaker 1when I was there. No one would be around and a bag would fall off, and we had no explanation for it. And they started fabricating these stories about that, the ghosts that potentially could have lived there. One day, in the back storeroom, one of the ladies walked in and a broom was standing up in the middle of the floor, not leaning on anything. It was just standing there. And she came and got a few of us.
Speaker 9Like.
Speaker 1A person was holding the broom. The broom was not leaning on anything. It was just standing there in the middle of the room, and we had no that. We walked around the thing, we eventually moved it, and it was not attached to anything. We had no explanation for it. So what would you if I was, I mean, I am telling you this story, John, I'm telling you this story now, how would you respond to that? What would you think when you hear a story like that and then try and try and give some kind of explanation for it, Because that's what humans do. We hear something,
Speaker 1we go, oh, well, that's obviously X or it's why you know I'm telling you this story now, John, how would you explain that away or would you explain it away?
Speaker 5Well, we would have to referral investigation and see if you were a under the influence of any drugs.
Speaker 2Or that's an excellent question.
Speaker 5We have to rule out any anything that techno technological, for instance, say in Star Trek, any events, any event, any events form res anology or science were pure magical to stormin age people. And even if we were to rule that out, it wouldn't prove the supernatural one of percent. It would just be unexplained.
Speaker 1Okay, So we can take what you've just said there and now apply it to yours. And so, John, were you under the influence of any I don't. I don't need to know that, but you know we can. We can now apply that to what to your experience and what do we conclude?
Speaker 5Well, like I said, I wasn't under any influence of any drugs or anything like that. I was completely saying Silver. I wasn't even thinking about the goals, the conversation about the goals. I was thinking about my work and I saw it. But then again, I'm someone who's open to these kinds of things. I'm into sci fi and stuff like that. So am I saying that? So one am I saying that that's where it comes from? But I swear I was not thinking about that at the time.
Speaker 1So I'm going to ruin my story now, ever so slightly, because for months we all believed that this this thing had happened. And then one of the staff members admitted that they had gone into the storeroom earlier and balanced the room in the middle of the floor. Oh wow, So there was a naturalistic explanation for ours. Yeah, and they showed us how they did it, so it was real. They just like these brooms were old and they had like bristle sticking out so they could perfectly balance. So that, yeah, that was admitted to us. Could it? Could it have
Speaker 1been John, that one of your coworkers maybe knew that you had a belief and thought, ah, this is a great way to get John. Maybe let's try and make a plate fall off fly off aside. He'll think it's a ghost and it'll be hilarious.
Speaker 5I don't think that's the case. I willn't there for very long.
Speaker 1Oh okay, I don't.
Speaker 5When I think, when I think about it. I don't see what when they would have the time to do it, because.
Speaker 1Right likewise, we didn't know when the person would have the time to balance a broom.
Speaker 5That's true.
Speaker 2Yeah, I mean I think that's a lot of what all of this is. John, is it so like for me, I've I'm more boring. I've not seen any ghosts or apparent ghosts, like either of the two Johns have that said to kind of play the other side of things, like, I guess I'm open to seeing a ghost now, I don't believe that ghosts exists. I'm I've never seen any evidence of ghosts, never been convinced by any of the so called documentaries on ghosts or things like that. I
Speaker 2default towards an inclination not to believe that ghosts exist. I have not been convinced by any alleged evidence, including the ex anecdotal kind just shared that said, I guess I'm not opposed to there being evidence if somebody showed up or there was a documentary or something that actually did convince me, I guess I'm open to listen kind of like what the other call, where if somebody really truly believes something passionately or there's evidence for it, they're convinced. I want to hear it to know what I try
Speaker 2and be readily available to correct whatever my perspective may be in everything. So maybe there's ghosts, But I'm kind of skeptical because so far I've made it forty five years, never having seen anything inclining me towards it. So I guess I think from either side, right, it's something I'm struck by, just as I hear your story and some of your discussion with mister skeptic right here is okay. Maybe sort of like John the Skeptics story, he didn't
Speaker 2have all the information right away. Do any of us ever have all the information on anything? Right? And so I think it's maybe the most appropriate response default position is, you know, such as with your story, John, not John the Skeptic, John the caller, is to you know, maybe the best default position is to simply say, you know, yeah, from what I've seen, I think there might be a ghost, And yet I acknowledge that I don't have.
Speaker 4All the info.
Speaker 2Maybe there's some explanation out there, kind of like an unidentified flying object. Well it's I don't know the identity yet. Maybe the identity is an alien. Maybe the identity is you know, some some flesh in the pain of whatever whatever they are, right, some industrialized I don't know. Yeah, go ahead, I'm ranting, I'm rambling. I'm good at it, continued John, I'm.
Speaker 5Sorry, Okay, I want to ask your opinion about this, and I don't want to get but I want to know your opinion. People who claim that they died for a few seconds or minute, they claim they got on to the other side beside Jesus, they come back, they give a detailed description, they could even drop the picture. And then you have people who claim that they had a similar experience and they see the same the same face. For instance, the movie Heaven Is for Real, a boy in the United States who died for a beef moment. He claimed to saw Christ, he drew your picture and condentally, a little gold in France drew the exact same picture,
Speaker 5right to the right, right to the last detail. And keep in mind, these two people lived on opposite side of the ocean, and they never met each other. How would you explain that.
Speaker 1Well, something similar happened in my life. No endes And I will say, though it is funny, not funny, half funny, But it's odd how in near death experiences, the folks who see something generally see the thing that they've already believed in. I have a friend who is an atheist. He died after a ten k run. He was very unhealthy and he ran the ten k he died for I think he was out for six minutes before they
Speaker 1managed to resuscitate him. And being a non believer, he didn't have any recollection of anything. So it does seem to be like, Okay, yeah, this person believes in Jesus. They've now died and now all of a sudden their experience was something to do with Jesus. The thing that I have that's similar to this picture and picture thing when I was very little. I am fortunate in that I never believed in a god, but I was brought up to believe in after life spirits, ghosts, people talking
Speaker 1to me. My grandmother was a clairvoyant, which is you can see that people. I was convinced that by my family that I had the power of Claire audience, because I would hear voices and it was the most horrific thing. But one time, when I was a child, I saw Claire voyance obviously came true for me, and I saw a man from Asia walk through my grandmother's door. Not the door was closed, so he walked through the door
Speaker 1and it terrified them, but jeepers out of me. And I ran and told my mother and my grandmother because who I lived with at the time, and my mother was massively into the whole spirit realm and all this stuff, and she went and visited someone who draws spirit guide. She believed that everybody has a spirit guide, and I'm going to draw your spirit guide. And the picture that this spirit guide artist drew that claimed was my mother's spirit guide was the exact same face of the man
Speaker 1that I saw walk through the door that time, and no expert nation as for why that happened. Could potentially have been like a trauma response. And I saw the picture after I'd had the experience, and then my brain went, that's who you saw, and it all tied up that way. There are there are unexplained things where people can draw. I don't know if it sounded like you said they drew Jesus. Pictures of Jesus have existed, I say, Jesus,
Speaker 1but you know there's an artist's impression of white Jesus has existed for have existed for decades, if not centuries, and so there's almost now a preconceived idea of what Jesus looks like. And so if somebody has a near death experience and goes, oh, I experienced Jesus, this is what they look like, and somebody else did the same thing on the other side of the world, that that wouldn't be spectacular to me because there were already, you know, images of that before they had the.
Speaker 5Experiences where to fire by.
Speaker 1Yeah, probably the same as you.
Speaker 5Yeah. Well, as I said, John, I don't want to pick it too much of it. I want to apologize. And we had a good conversation. Do we have a good conversation today.
Speaker 1I love this conversation. That was great. It was I'm sorry to hear about the plate and I hope that, you know, one day we get some explanation for it, but for now, let's just keep going. I don't know, and it's okay to say I don't know.
Speaker 5Okay, We'll have a good evening you too, Thanks.
Speaker 2John, take care.
Speaker 1That's great. Absolutely there, it's nice. Yeah, this has been very chilled talking about veganism and apologies, you know sometimes from folks that you like. John is a very regular caller and great, I'm really really great that he came in and did that. It takes a big person to do that. We've got some We've got some voicemails that we can do. Where where is the I'm just scrolling scrolling around on the documentary because I'm like, we've got some time to fill, so let's do it. Oh, here
Speaker 1we go. We've got We've got a voicemail that we can now listen to and react to you if you like as a voicemail is where did horses come from?
Speaker 8Okay?
Speaker 10How did something living come from something? There was nothing? There's nothing living? How did life come from non life? And the way the body's made up? What chance would have this body had to be made with your eyes, your heart, your lungs, and being male and female because there's only two genders. And how were they made to breed or to mate to become a baby? And how is everything you know, like, how was cows made? How
Speaker 10was horses made? How it was fish made? You can't prove it. You would have a better chance of, say, hitting the lottery a thousand times in a row using the exact same numbers. It's against all odds.
Speaker 1Okay, against all odds, apparently, I think think my initial reaction is is the language used? How How were cows made? How were horses made? Well, you're already at the point where you think things were made, so you're already searching a reaching because you go there, Well, there's there's got to be a reason that this was made this way. So what made it? You've already you're already on a losing battle there.
Speaker 11I feel like, yeah, absolutely, I mean, for me, the big thing there and yeah, there were several uh phrases comments that were made that could form the basis of whole additional conversations.
Speaker 2But the big thing for me with the with the crux of why the caller and I missed their name if we have it? But why called in? Is okay? Where did where could life have come from? If it wasn't made by another living being? Okay? And so on the one hand, there's another whole trail of okay, well, if life can't come from non life, then where did the life giver get its life from? And it's complete it is a complete bullshit non answer to say, oh well,
Speaker 2but they are were just eternal or they didn't need they were a self giving form of like Okay, that's just that's bullshit. Well then if you can use it for that, why can't you use It's just it's set a cop out. So to go back to the core thing. I mean, do I know the answer? No, I know this. I know there's theories Some scientists propose that writ RNA, the molecule similar to DNA, was the first replicating molecule. Okay, there's other theories that that what. There's these hydro thermal
Speaker 2vents right near deep sea in the water where chemicals and energy could have supported early life. Right, there's other ideas around metabolic networks. Okay, there's all these ideas. I'm not again, I've said this like twenty five thousand times to make not my area of expertise.
Speaker 1Okay, neither of us are biologists, but it doesn't have to be right.
Speaker 2Here's what I know is, I know there's theory. I don't need to know everything. What I do know is saying God did it, but no one created a God isn't helpful. That doesn't answer the question. That's not helpful at all.
Speaker 1Right, And even if we did say that a god did it, Let's just say that it was some creator. How do we know it's this person specific creator that the was the perpetrator in this instance? I'm again I am like Drew, No, I'm not an expert by any means, but I do have friends who are scientists and biologists and all this stuff, and have so many times I've asked this question, like how what do you know as
Speaker 1a scientist? What is your explanation? They always point me to the Yurimiller experiment, which has, you know, the closest current understanding to how it all could have happened. And I am a big fan of that. Let's zapp some chemicals with some electricity in some warm water and see what happens. You know, that's the very dumb down version. It kind of makes sense to me in that it can happen in a way that doesn't need an external force to go here, I'm going to do some magic and make some things happen. If there are naturalistic explanations
Speaker 1for all these things, how where the cows come from, where the horses come from? You know, it has been shown through fossil records that there are common ancestors to all life on Earth, there are records of it. Is that the evolution especially is the most supported theory in science. There is so much evidence, and it's not just fossil records as all the other gubbins that goes with it. Go and speak to a biologist. But yes, okay, evolution
Speaker 1and a biogenesis aren't the same. But you know, he also did say, well, how does the cow get here? How dodors is get here? So you know, I I feel like I'm valid in saying that, but I'm a massive fan of the Yurimilla explanation for how life came to be. So yeah, a media.
Speaker 2If we're if we're going for, well, which which possible origin story hypothesis feels right to me, feels best to me? Okay? Then sure, coming from some eternal being such as a god, it can feel just as good, if not better, as anything else, and that might give it the advantage if we're just looking at it through that lens. What I've been taught, what tradition teaches, what feels comfortable to me, what I feel within the fabric of my internal being. Okay,
Speaker 2if we're looking at evidence, though there are a few different theories scientifically on where life could have started. We don't have a conclusive answer. That's true. That said, every one of them has so much more scientific standing than any kind concept of an eternal God created us, right, And so at the end of the day, I gotta go. I don't have to know the answer, but I'm certainly going to be inclined to the one that has more scientific backing rather than just something I was raised.
Speaker 1With, right, and which one of my I'm least convinced by the creator one as well. There's just there's nothing to back up that. It's just very to me, a very lazy answer. I don't know. God did it? Yeah, God of the gaps, Yeah, exactly anything.
Speaker 2I don't know the answer too, I'm just going to insert God. Well, it's God.
Speaker 1That does happen way more than I care to admit. Even around here, people don't have explanations for something it is. Oh, well, God did that. My mother in law nearly her vehicle was nearly hit by a very large tree in a storm. It missed by six inches, and everybody's been talking about how God had a hand in it. I mean, thanks God for saving my mother in law's car. Now, if you could help explain where life comes from, that'd be great. Instead of, you know, instead of saving a white Toyota,
Speaker 1please can you give us something else? You know, God, God works in mysterious ways, apparently, and saving my mother in law's car was apparently the one. Last week, we do have some call or another call in the in the queue. They're coming up, so we will get to another one. But just wanna again thank you, know Kelly for sticking in and being the backup host. He's always here. He's always here, and I don't know if we can bring him up right now, but Kelly, I just want to thank you for always doing the backups. So far,
Speaker 1we're going to get to at least one more call, but just so far, have you had like a favorite call? Or don't forget to our mute Kelly. You're pretending that he's pretending to No, he has still he's still muted. He's just Kelly. Just he forgets sometimes I thought he was acting. Then oh his MIC's broken. Well for those who can't see, for those he can't see, Kelly's on the screen and he looks very handsome as always, absolutely, but he's not he's amazing he's amazing.
Speaker 2Like I said jokes.
Speaker 1One of one of the faces of the a c A is Kelly, and he's gonna he's now it looks like those who can't see, looks like he's licking his microphone right now, trying to get.
Speaker 5We go.
Speaker 1We do a lot of stuff on truth Wanted. Apparently that we've now hit a new low. We were talking about circumcision and for skins earlier. Now Kelly's looking his microphone. I can only apologize what we're waiting for the calls and the queue as well. We do have some super chats as well to read out. I did see one if the crew or I'm sorry, I'm jumping all over the place crew. I'm not sorry. Atlas die. I can't watch live, but I had to drop in to send a message. It's really good to see you again, Drew. We were with Thatt Liss down there when we were when we were in person.
Speaker 2Yes, we both met Atlas at the same time we met each other.
Speaker 4That's a very big party.
Speaker 1We just need to have a big old group hug again, you know we do.
Speaker 2We need to have a rehash.
Speaker 1It's been too long. To be honest, it would be nice to see you in person, and another one Miranda Rensburger. But is there a naturalistic explanation for how a British circle can float? There are no natural explanations for that. There's not even an explanation for why I take on meat form just to do calling shows like this. Afterwards, I am very tired and I go into my circle booth and become a floating circle once more. It's you know, it's just how it is. I'm glad that I ask the British floating circle, and so, you know, it's a thing.
Speaker 1It's a thing, Drew.
Speaker 2I'm scared to ask.
Speaker 1Have you got anything anything big coming up?
Speaker 2Drew, because you know what, I intentionally have been drawing back and you know, speaking less and doing some less events things like that, conferences and kind of trying to very intentionally just live and embody my own humanity and find spaces where I can contribute in local community. So it's a little less flashy, you know, I have you know,
Speaker 2I don't draw on income from having a pretty face or anything like that. I've got just a regular day job. And when I'm not doing that, I'm just trying to be human. I guess so no, no promos, no promos. You know, I guess by books that have already been written and you know, watch things that have been done.
Speaker 1I do.
Speaker 2I do really enjoy doing shows like this and maybe doing more of them. That said, beyond shows like this, I'm just just being a local human here in the Twin Cities. If you're ever passing through Minneapolis, Saint Paul, Minnesota, make sure to give me a shout say hello. Either come to a local event we're doing, or just drop in and we'll grab a coffee or a whiskey or something.
Speaker 1A coffee. Did you say a coffee? I don't know.
Speaker 2Did I say a coffee?
Speaker 1Coffee that way?
Speaker 2Coffee?
Speaker 1Yeah, no, I don't know.
Speaker 5I don't know.
Speaker 1Here are some things. But all I heard through all of that is that you're denying people those beautiful tones that you have when you talk out. I'm not talking anymore. This is my voice. Kelly should now be working as as a backup host with a working microphone. Kelly, are you there? No, Kelly's broken, Kelly. You enjoyed the party this time, so excited to hear from you.
Speaker 4Doubt came back in.
Speaker 1It's all just gone very wrong.
Speaker 2Don't we have John, don't we have production team. Don't we have like some old audio clip of Kelly. We can just play and he can mouth the.
Speaker 1Words, yeah right, just pretend that'd be great. We could do it. We could play be his voice. That would never work in a million years. So well we have we haven't. This isn't me, I don't think, says Kelly. We were still waiting and there there's some screening screen calls coming through. They're not quite ready to go on yet, so we're going to vamp just for another minute or two, just to see, just to see, because I want to give them a chance. We're here to get the truth drough and I'd like to get some more truth and
Speaker 1the next one, if it goes on to the queue, I really want to hear about because it's definitely something that I'm interested in. Yeah yeah, And you don't get to see any of this.
Speaker 2I have the power, I don't have the tools. I'm just here you hanging out over here, eating in anticipation.
Speaker 1I'm really I'm really confused. I'm really confused. I think something, something weird is going on in call in studio right now, and I need the crew to go uh, I think, I think we're not going to get these calls.
Speaker 2Do we have any stats? Well, if we're if we're just waiting for calls to come in, do we have stats numbers on what what that fundraiser did? There was this incredible fundraiser it was.
Speaker 1We've also got some screenshots of things. Yeah, and so I come on this show every now and then and I say stupid things apparently, and one of the screenshots. I'm going to go with the first one, number one, because it's let's go in order so that the crew look at this horrid, horrid face. Evolution is a theory. That's why it's called the theory of evolution. It's not the fact of evolution or the history of evolution. It's only a theory. That's not me saying that. I don't
Speaker 1think was it? No, And if it was, I must have been saying it in such a way that I was taking on the persona of a non believer. But I was talking about the Bible not belonging in science museums. How do you feel about that?
Speaker 4True?
Speaker 1Because I don't think it should be there.
Speaker 2The Bible in science museums, right, No, not science museums. Maybe history museums or other museums artifacting cultural influences. Sure, if we're taking uh, if we're doing a historical uh, I could I could even see it. This might be a little controversial, but I could see it being present uh in a in a in a piece in a science in an exhibit about historical cultural perspectives on where
Speaker 2things came from life and things like that. Sure, it's a perspective, it's a historical lens. But uh, but not not actual science.
Speaker 1Hell no, So I I agree with that. I'm like, it's there's nothing inside this book that has anything to do with real actual science. There's some claims made about oh look at that book for those there are some people who are audio only, And I just wanted to point out that Drew is holding up what looks like a very well thumbed Bible.
Speaker 2Oh so well thumbed. Yeah, absolutely, I preached out of this Bible.
Speaker 1Did you really look at there's even there's annotations, yeah, oh.
Speaker 4So many, so many.
Speaker 1I'm actually just I'm very proud of my stepdaughter right now because she has been a non believer for a few years now. We've talked about all religions and she's decided that she wants to read the Bible, and she reads a chapter and she'll come to me and say, John, I just read this bit and I think this, and she says some really great things about how silly the book is. And it's coming from a ten year old.
Speaker 2That's really truly amazing.
Speaker 1Well, okay, look, we have a call ready, and they've been talking for a while, so I would like to give them a chance. We have and I'm sorry to do this to you again, Drew, but we have another John from there is an agent of the name, so that makes it a bit easier. Hi, John, you're on with John and Drew. You're saying here that Christianity has it wrong about the afterlife, and you can prove it. There's no mind body dualism. Without that, there is no possible Okay, come on, let's hear this.
Speaker 6Okay, Okay, great, this is awesome. I love it. I can't wait to prove it. Okay, So all right. So mind body dualism states that the there's a there are separate entities, the mind and the body, and the mind is a separate subst from the body. I can prove that that the brain is the source of consciousness. First of all, there is a structure in the brain. There's a There was an experiment which was done where researchers stimulated this part of the brain called the claustrum, and
Speaker 6that caused immediate unconsciousness in subjects. Okay, so that kind of indicates that that consciousness is a property of the brain which can be turned off. And also, I there there is another experiment which was done which they they the researchers were able to actually see memories being formed. And that's another piece of evidence that consciousness and mental
Speaker 6mental processes are properties of the brain and not anything else. Because if you're able to see neurons being formed as you learn, then how could you how could you are you anything else that this this is the process of the brain. Right, So those are two pieces. And I was just wondering what you thought of.
Speaker 2That, drew you go, my brain is I have a clarifying question if I may, John with the h So educate me a little bit here. Okay, take me by the hand and help me see where you're at.
Speaker 4Okay.
Speaker 2So, so mind body dualism, right, So the mind and the body are distinct entities. So you're talking about though, how consciousness is a product of the brain. So is that are you proposing or are you our takes? Because I so, I've I've seen versions of dualism over the years, over the decades, studied it to some degree, but it's been a little while, it's been a good decade since I've really looked at it closely. But so are you proposing suggesting that the mind as a separate entity from the body and the consciousness being a product of the brain,
Speaker 2which is part of the body. Are you suggesting that this mind part part is separate from consciousness or where is the mind connect that from me or disconnected?
Speaker 3No?
Speaker 6No, no, what what I'm what I'm saying. No, what I'm saying is that the mind is a process that the brain, that the brain does in the same way that digestion is a process of the stomach and the int' And.
Speaker 1Like how sight is the process of the eyeballs? What what was that he's saying? Yeah, I'm just just another an equivalence where where sight is like the process of the eyeballs.
Speaker 6Okay, yeah, right.
Speaker 2Would it be similar to that, John, where sight is a process of the eyeballs, consciousness and the mind are a process of the brain, a process of the digestive system, is.
Speaker 6Right, right, It's the same thing as the stomach. The process that the stomach carries out is digestion. Where is the process that the brain carries out is consciousness and mind?
Speaker 2So are you saying that consciousness? Here's I guess part of the distinction that I'd like you to suss out for me, just because I'm right now. I'm just trying to absorb what your position is. Because again, there's lots of forms of dualism. I've seen most of the forms of dualism I'm more more familiar with from a Christian or theistic lens. So I'm just trying to take time to really see where I see you're coming from, rather than cornering you in a box or arguing against something that you don't necessarily believe. But so so, the mind
Speaker 2is a process produced by the brain that is distinct from the body. So right, don't.
Speaker 12Know, I guess, I guess. I'm sure you will see the significance. I'm tempted to say, Okay, digestion is separate from the body. It's not the body itself, but it still happens and it's still real.
Speaker 2I'm tempted. I don't mean this disrespectfully. Well let me let me just finish my comment, and I have a question for you. I do want to hear your thoughts. Just let me get this question out first. It's a clarifying question. So I'm tempted to say, Okay, who cares. What I want you to do is make me care further, clarify, know why it matters, help me care.
Speaker 6But you see, But you see, if consciousness is a process which is carried out by the brain, then it follows logically that when the brain dies, consciousness stops.
Speaker 1Right And I'm fully on board with you there, but but I don't know how that then doesn't prove enough. Just let me get there as well, doesn't disproven off the life because I'm pretty certain that in the belief structure, and not that I hold this, and I could be wrong. But when people believe that they die, it's not that their mind lives on forever. It's that this soul that they believe is in the body is what lives on forever, nothing to do with with mind and processes. It's like a separate entity that they believe is inside them, that
Speaker 1moves on. I don't believe in a soul and I don't, but it's up to the theists to prove that that's what happens and goes on. I kind of I kind of feel like I know where you're going with this, but I just just some clarification, clarification on it would would be helpful.
Speaker 6I haven't I have an answer for that, Okay, okay, So if you look at what is the definition of a soul, which I have looked at all of the characteristics which theists describe as being characteristic of a soul, those are processes of the brain. Those are processes of the mind. And well, I mean it's a process of the processes of the mind, which is which is carried out by the brain. So so what I'm saying is
Speaker 6there is no there is no such thing as a soul because all of the processes, all of the things we can attribute to a soul are actually processes of the of the mind, which is which is carried out by the brain.
Speaker 1Right. And and I'm I'm going to say that I'm fully with you. I can't I understand exactly what you're saying. And I'm not convinced that there's a soul, So I I don't really see a need for for that. But if you think you have a way of disproving a soul, I would write some papers and I would start submitting them because you could be onto some absolute groundbreaking stuff that may not have been spoken about before.
Speaker 6Well, okay, okay, I'm I'm so excited to share share my views with you guys. Okay, I don't have to write papers because papers have already been written. I'm not. I'm not a okay, so I don't. I'm not. I'm not going to write a paper. But that's okay because papers have already been written. Number one, the paper about how the claustrum. If you stimulate the claustrum electrically, it shuts off consciousness, and then when you release that stimulation, the consciousness returns. So I mean, doesn't that tell you
Speaker 6that consciousness is produced by the brain if you can shut it off just by stimulating a certain part.
Speaker 1Yes, you are, I think, I think, and I don't want to speak for everyone, but I feel like you're talking to the folks who will kind of already agree with you. My suggestion would be something like this. Take this to a theist call and show.
Speaker 2Yeah, yeah, along with that John, you know, to both of the John's. You know, I agree if we like what Yeah, yeah, John, If you're more.
Speaker 6Comfortable for me, I'm sorry. I just want to say it's more comfortable to me for me to preach to the choir.
Speaker 1But that's fine. If we're here to help you with that. Great, I'm awfulolutely.
Speaker 2If you're Yeah, and maybe I didn't quite grasp the original setup of the call. Uh, if you're calling to you know which, now it sounds like this was the point of the call. If you're calling to convince us or give us, you know, evidence that when a human dies, their consciousness dies with them. Oh yeah, absolutely already believe that. I believe, you know, I don't have a paper per se, but I believe Dan Dennett has written on that. I mean several things that's been well established in my mind.
Speaker 2But yeah, the now, the term dualism is what threw me off, because I've heard that term used primarily in other contexts. So that that's maybe something to keep in mind. Is sometimes some of those fancy sounding words, uh, philosophical, sometimes they can carry baggage for various audiences that you don't anticipate. For me, it carried some baggage that tricked me up. But no, I think we're all on the same page. I agree with you.
Speaker 1I just I just means do you have a society? Just to let Drew you get that out, but carry on.
Speaker 6Okay, No, here's the last thing. I okay, So the classtrum, when you stimulated electrically, consciousness shuts off. We scientists have been able to see memories being formed. And also my last point, which I love to get out, is that there's there was actually a sixty minutes show which which these researchers were able to They showed the subjects different objects, and they recorded their brain activity while viewing different objects,
Speaker 6and then they were able to without knowing which object the person was viewing, they were able to guess ninety six percent of the time which object the person was viewing. So I mean, you know, I don't even know why you guys have a show, because if consciousness is produced by the brain, then theistic belief is over.
Speaker 1I'll tell you John, because it's.
Speaker 6The brain and so and so when the brain dies, consciousness stops, right. So therefore there there is there can't be a soul in an afterlife. So that's just a fiction. Yeah, And I understand why. I understand why the writers of the Bible wanted to promote this idea. But those people were not neuroscientists. Okay, they didn't know what we know today.
Speaker 1Right, And I'm okay, I mean, I'm glad that we managed to give you a platform to vocalize this, But I do feel like you're maybe in a position now to go and take this to some believers and say, look, this is what I've found out. What do you think about that? Because we're all like, okay, yeah, the brain shots off and where we all agree with you, John to some degree, we're all.
Speaker 6There, yeah, okay, Well then well then how could anybody justify theistic belief? After that? You could see my chain of logic there that consciousness is pretty by the brain. So therefore when the brain dies, consciousness stops, and so I'm getting no soul and no afterlife, So how could anyone believe in Christianity? That's my point.
Speaker 1I mean that that then it becomes a huge jump because there are also like a ton of other religions that people still believe in, regardless of whether or not there's an afterlife or no after life or any of that. So I mean I'm kind of I'm with you on the brain activity side of it. I'm not necessarily with you on the well then that means Christianity is dumb. Yeah, I feel like it is. But you know what I mean, I'm not. I'm not agreeing with it for that reason where I mean.
Speaker 10I don't know.
Speaker 6I don't know, guys, I don't know, I don't know me. I see it as a clear chain of logic.
Speaker 1Okay, right, and that's great. But I honestly do I rather than rehashing stuff because we've got one more call that we do want to get to. I just I think what you've got is some great, great stuff there, John, and I really implore you to go and take it to some believers.
Speaker 2Yeah, love it. Thanks Thanks John, John.
Speaker 6Guys for letting me air my views.
Speaker 1You are more than welcome, appreciated.
Speaker 6Thank you very much.
Speaker 8Thank you.
Speaker 1I'm saying because I live in Kent, So yeah, take care. There you go. That was good. That's good. I mean I like that we're also a platform for folks, but there is one more person to speak to, and this one Drew is is. It looks good. So we've got Dan here from also from Ohio. Pronounce that he him, and he's saying that the DNA of octopi is so different than any than every other DNA that it lends credence to panspermia. Dan, how's it going?
Speaker 3Hey, folks, did you just say Ohio?
Speaker 1It said that, Yeah, that's that's Canada, Canada. Okay, well, wherever you're from, Hello Canada, it's great. I was going to call you neighbor as well, but now I'm not going.
Speaker 13To anyhow, I am calling to talk about alien ideas. So I know you said you're non geneticists or biologists, but if you look at an octopus and the things it can do, and it is so incredibly unlike any other creature on Earth that it just seems to indicate that maybe there is other sources of light other than random generation on Earth. And do you think that.
Speaker 3The octopus being so weird and could be evidence of that, you know, divergent evolution on a planet from something very different. You know what, Octopi just are weird.
Speaker 1I mean, there are plenty of weird creatures right there. There are some creatures that look like mammals have beaks like ducks and lay eggs, and you know, have poisoned spines. There are some creatures that have hundreds of legs, and there are some creatures that only have a couple. You know, there are lots of weird creatures. Would I like it to be kind of some sort of evidence that maybe there's something out there. Absolutely, I'm a big fan of us not being the only life in the entire universe, or maybe even in just the Milky Way galaxy. You know,
Speaker 1there are is it something like two hundred or one hundred billion stars in the Milky Way Galaxy, and each star could have, you know, a set amount of planets, and some of those planets could be in the habitable zone. Then there's there's something like two hundred million possibility possibilities for planets having some kind of life on there. Absolutely, I'm all for that. Do I know that to be the case? Absolutely not. Would I like octopuses to have traveled on a comet or asteroid or something and bumped into Earth and they're DNA landed here and that's why we have OCTOPI absolutely, I'd love it. Is there anything
Speaker 1to suggest really at the moment, I don't know, what do you think, Drew?
Speaker 2Yeah, you know, I mean I think similar to where you're coming from. I mean, I love the idea. I kind of hope that they did come from alien life from some other planet or some other part of the universe or something like that. Like that sounds really fucking cool. I'm not in any way opposed to that being true or uh, you know, feeling a compulsion to to discredit it or that can't be. That said, I do have to ask, right, like, and I haven't dug into it a lot, so I confess my ignorance here. But things
Speaker 2that I would want to ask myself if and when I was looking deeper into it is you know, obviously there's the whole category, the whole category of you know, cephalopods, right, there's cuttlefish, there's squid, right, there's what nautilusts there, and then there's beyond that, there's what molluscs.
Speaker 4I don't think moluks are are.
Speaker 2Cephalopods, but but then you know, from there I would be interested to look at. Okay, so are there other connections that go beyond that whole category where it does connect back further my inclination is if there is this whole movement of people that theorize that that octopus octopi may come from another origination, I would give them the credit benefit of a doubt and say, well, clearly they've
Speaker 2looked into it, and there must appear to be a huge disconnect between cephalopods and all the rest of the animal kingdom. That's it. I find that I'm kind of skeptical that that's the case. I would think we would find some kind of connection, but there must not be one, or why would you conclude that aliens must be involved? So so those are just some of the questions that I would look to, and I'm curious, Dan, if you have answers to those. Are there any connections? Are we sure that they're completely disconnected from the rest of the animal kingdom? And why not cephalopods as all? Why specifically,
Speaker 2just occupy from.
Speaker 3The vague amount of research I have personally done, occupier with the ones that came up with the unique and distinct behaviors and tendencies that were unusual compared to other similar creatures. I'm a lay person looking at things I've heard and ran online, So I mean, you know.
Speaker 1I would suggest Dan reaching out to some folks who know about this stuff. Forrest is on quite a lot on the ACA. Whenever he's here, I would absolutely call into him. He will probably lose his mind and want to talk about it for hours because he gets so excited by this kind of thing. So I absolutely suggest giving a Forest a call when he's on one of our shows.
Speaker 2But it's a great question, and I love the idea, and I so for me personally, I have a hard time believing that there wouldn't be some form of life beyond Earth. How could? They're not right? So the idea that and I know some people were talking earlier on it with another caller about well where did life come from? I mean, there is an argument that a fairly significant amount of people make that life on Earth comes from other planets. Now where does life itself come from?
Speaker 4Well?
Speaker 2That doesn't help with that, but but some would argue that right. I love the idea. I don't see it's implausible, but I also don't see evidence for it either, And so as we're seeking the truth that is wanted, those are questions that I think we need to deal with, grapple with, and think through. But I love that yourself as a layperson, a self professed layperson that you are. I love the curiosity. I love the curiosity, and I love the conversation. So thank you.
Speaker 1Yeah, hopefully that helps a little bit.
Speaker 3Dan, Well, I appreciate the directions for further questioning, and maybe I'll call back When Forrest dot And flowed his brain with this.
Speaker 1Idea, I'm going to want to watch that cool because I could just all I can imagine is Forest just losing his mind to being so excited.
Speaker 2I am curious, Dan, just out of curiosity. Is this a topic, a line of questioning and thought whatnot that you are kind of more or less convinced of, Like do you believe that octopi come originate from another planet or another part of the universe? Or is this sort of just a fun thought experiment that you stumbled upon and wanted to toss it out for a little playful banter. How convinced are you of it?
Speaker 3I think that there's more to it than just simple playful answer. I think that from what I've looked into the life cycle of the octopus and some of the things it does naturally, it's just incredibly unique, like alien unique in my limited views, So maybe it did come from somewhere else. Maybe it just it's in the ocean.
Speaker 2We know so little.
Speaker 3About what's under the surface of the ocean that something could easily just land there and be next to everything else.
Speaker 1Yeah, it's definitely a question that I would like to hear more answers to. I'm not in any position to answer anymore on it, unfortunately.
Speaker 9Dan.
Speaker 3Well, like I said, I just wanted to bring it to you folks, and you know I've got another direction of bailtop questions and other hosts rang. So thank you so much, get back to it.
Speaker 1Thank you, Dan. We appreciate you going in.
Speaker 2Thanks Dan, appreciate you have.
Speaker 1A good one. That was That was a show. We had a lot, We covered a lot of ground on that. I'm so sorry it went on so long, but it was fun. It was They usually much time, me too.
Speaker 6I would do it another.
Speaker 1Four hours, but we do have other things to do. We've got families and stuff. So Drew, Drew, thank you for joining today. We appreciate you being here. It was good fun. Where can where can folks find you?
Speaker 2Yeah? Absolutely so. You know, it seems like everybody's heading to like Blue Sky and some of these others fun. I'm still I don't know if I'm lazy. I don't know if I just don't care about social media enough. But really I'm still kind of hanging out on Facebook. I say kind of because I haven't been real involved in social media for a number of years here, but Facebook and Instagram are the two easiest places to connect with me. I do have my website, Drew Bakiss dot com, which is just spelling my name out as it's written
Speaker 2all one word, uh dot com, so you can connect me on there. You know, I'm not super organized. I apologize. I'm a little bit of a lazy shit.
Speaker 1Okay, just shout out into the ether and Drew might appear, say his name three times in a mirror.
Speaker 2There you go again.
Speaker 1We just want to thank Kelly for backing up. I don't know if he appears, he might wave because we don't know if his microphone works.
Speaker 14Hey, I think I got it fixed.
Speaker 1It fixed.
Speaker 14It was I you know, when I moved my my audio interface a little bit because it was right on the edge of my desk and I was worried it was going to fall off. And when I moved it, I accidentally turned one of the buttons off and didn't even realize.
Speaker 8So that was.
Speaker 2Kelly truth on that.
Speaker 1There you go, Kelly. We're going to do an after show and the discord right we are. Yeah, you can. You can come and join us there if you want the it's tiny dot CC slash ac D discord, if you want to join us there. I'm just gonna also let just remind you that there's the we want the Truth segment. What says I'm an asshole without saying I'm an asshole? And now'll say it the right way. What says I'm an asshole without saying I'm an asshole? Leave it come in on the video and perhaps someone will
Speaker 1read it out next week if it's in our top three. I know I'm not going to give the crew any chance, but I just want to say a big thank you again to the crew. You don't have to bring your crew come up if you don't want to, but we love you and we appreciate you. Thank you for all your hard work, and we're going to sign off and we will see you next week with more truth wanted.
Speaker 4Thanks everyone.
Speaker 15Yeah, watch the non profits and join the hosts in the live chart.
In today's episode of Truth Wanted, ObjectivelyDan welcomes guest Out Of Body Atheist, with The Beard of Empathy on backup, to dig into Reiki, New Age spirituality, homeopathy, and the long road from woo to skepticism!...
In today's episode of Truth Wanted, Jon the Skeptick, Volcy, and Sofia Spina explain why no one can talk to the dead, from Haitian Vodou and grief dreams to Jon's past as a spiritualist! Bob jumps from objective...
In today's episode of Truth Wanted, ObjectivelyDan and Nintendrew, later joined by The Beard of Empathy, tackle a world run on Jesus, the magic of manifesting, and a prayer that actually got answered! Bob in NY, a...
In today's episode of Truth Wanted, ObjectivelyDan, Kelley Laughlin, and The Beard of Empathy tackle standards of evidence, miracle claims, and the false binaries of moral philosophy! Dean in VA questions why skeptics...
In today's episode of Truth Wanted, ObjectivelyDan and Chad Harris tackle Christian nationalism, police brutality, and the uncomfortable truths about racism and immigration. Big E in TN survived police brutality and...