In today’s episode of Truth Wanted, Objectively Dan is joined by Bored Agnostic to explore the complexities of deconstruction, racial religious identity, and the foundations of morality! They dive into the slave morality of the black church, the philosophical pitfalls of personal experience, and why typewriter gods fail the reality test. Can critical thinking bridge the gap between religious tradition and objective truth? Nye in NC asks why cognitive dissonance is prevalent in black Christian communities. Bored Agnostic explains how religious identity often overrides racial identity, creating a slave morality. Will recognizing these roots help break the cycle? Ray in NY presents a typewriter God thought experiment. Dan argues that a being interacting with the sky is still a natural phenomenon, not a prime mover. Ray claims to know God's nature through ecstasy. Can personal feelings prove a deity? Bob in CA, a former atheist, argues for Christianity through objective morality and the cosmological argument. Dan and Bored Agnostic debate moral realism versus evolved biological strategies. Is secular logic a better ground for ethics? Thank you for joining us today! We will see you next time! Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/truth-wanted--3195473/support.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Speaker 1Folks. Objectively Dan here and it's my first time hosting Truth Wanted at its brand new time slot at two forty five Central on Sundays. And I'm so excited to get the show started with you today. So get ready because we are beginning right now. Folks, welcome back to another episode of Truth Wanted again. I am your host, Objectively Dan. It is my pleasure to welcome you to Truth Wanted, the live callin show that happens every week
Speaker 1now at Sundays at two forty five pm. I know this is not the first time Truth wan It's been hosted a Sundays at two forty five. I didn't get to host it at the New Times until now. You might be wondering why why isn't Dan hosting it the new Is it because of scheduling issues? Okay, so I had to cover Talk Heathen in the meantime, and I'm still doing stuff on Talk Heathen, so you can expect me to be on there as well. But for now you can expect me back on Truth Wanted at its brand new time at two forty five pm Sundays. Excited
Speaker 1to be here with you folks again. This is a live call in show, where you can call us at five one two nine nine nine two four to two or call through your computer at ACA dot show slash call. We talk to people about what they believe and why they believe in it, and I want to talk to you. You can also talk to us through TikTok as well. If you come in and you have asked to join, please just let us know that you are above the age of eighteen and you should be good to go. Truth Wanted in cases is your first time watching. Is
Speaker 1a product of the Atheist Comunity of Austin, a five oh one c three nonprofit organization dedicate to the promotion of atheism, critical thinking, secular humanism, the separation of religion and government. And every single week, folks, I always try to have a special guest with me. This week is no different. I have Bored Agnostic joining me today. Hi, everybody, welcome to the show. I hope you're not bored. Jordan definitely not right. Excited to have you on it. How going to be here? Yes, thank you so much for
Speaker 1joining us. Board. You are a streamer, You're a live streamer on TikTok. You also like to talk to people about what they believe and why.
Speaker 2I do I do? I love that question.
Speaker 3I love knowing why people believe what they believe, specifically Christians, and why they believe what they believe. I like being able to pick their brains a little bit and kind of get into the nitty gritty of what led you to conclude that this thing is true, that this belief system is true, or that this God is true.
Speaker 1Yeah, I love it too. Obviously, been been been doing this for a little bit now, But you have been streaming on TikTok for the past two years, is what you told me, And You've gotten into some interesting conversations, and I want to know how did you get started talking to people about this?
Speaker 2Yeah, it was crazy.
Speaker 3It was just one random day I'm scrolling through TikTok and I see a live a TikTok live where people are discussing Christianity. They're talking about is Christianity true?
Speaker 1Is it real?
Speaker 4Is?
Speaker 3Does God exist? And I was hooked ever since, Dan, When I tell you, my mind like exploded with just knowing that a place like this even existed, Right, I had no idea that people were discussing religion or their belief systems in this way. And so I absolutely loved it. I wanted to get involved, and so I created an account within like a week and started joining the panel and started having these types of discussions. And shortly after that, I said, huh, I think I could go live. Yeah,
Speaker 3I think I could do this. Let's give it a whirl. And so it was absolutely amazing.
Speaker 1Yeah, and we were talking a little bit before the show. But one thing that I think is so incredible is if you look at the history of the atheist community of Austina shows, it first start off as a public access television show, so you had to be in a building at a public access you know, television show place in order to get your voice out. And then YouTube comes around and we are able to stream for YouTube, and you know, we're able to run it through computers. Sorry, folks, if you're seeing our screen flashing, we may be having some technical difficulties right now, but we are still live
Speaker 1and coming to you, so so you know, keep watching. So and then nowadays anybody that has a smartphone can just come in and join in on a conversation, and it's it's just really incredible because we're getting content creators like yourself coming in and joining and you can be coming from Australia, you can be coming from the Netherlands, it doesn't matter. You could. You can live in an apartment in the Bronx or you can be in a mansion in la and anybody can come in and have a conversation, for better or worse. I should add I don't know
Speaker 1if everybody's opinions are equal, but you know, you.
Speaker 3It's amazing how the Internet really just connects people and it allows us to like open up our world a little bit more, right, Yeah, be able to hear these different perspectives and conversate with all these different people.
Speaker 2I love that.
Speaker 3Love that about the Internet. I love that about TikTok, and I love that about the ACA. So I'm super excited to be here.
Speaker 1I'm excited that you're here too, and I want to be able to talk to other people about your beliefs. Folks, whether you're a Christian or Buddhist, or atheist or Muslim, come join us and we'd love to have you on the show and talk to you about stuff, or if you want to make it a bit more chill, a little lower stakes, I mean I'm okay with that too. God knows, you know, the world is already having a lot of problems as it is. I'd like to you know, I wouldn't mind having a bit more of a low stakes conversation. But I want to talk to you about you right now board agnostic, because you call yourself board agnostic,
Speaker 1but my understanding is that you were not always a board agnostic. You were yeah, in fact identified as something else.
Speaker 4Yeah.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 2I grew up as a Christian.
Speaker 3I grew up in the Assemblies of God Church, so it's a Pentecostal organization, and I mean I loved it.
Speaker 1I was.
Speaker 3I was so involved. My parents were both super involved. My whole family was super, super, super involved in the church. And as I grew up, I wanted to get more involved. So I would volunteer in the kids ministry and the youth and the young adults and do all these things. I helped plant churches in my neighborhood and then around COVID. You know, nobody's going to church anymore, at least I wasn't. And I saw my church's response to that, and response to you know, people in their community and how they're
Speaker 3just you know, there wasn't a moment in the past before that where I really where they had the opportunity to practice what they preached, And so it wasn't clear to me until that moment that I went, oh, this church is really not taking the opportunities to care for the community in the ways that they should. They're not looking out for one another in the ways that they should.
Speaker 1Wow.
Speaker 3And so I saw those types of like harmful ideologies really, you know, on display, and so.
Speaker 1Yeah, wow, so yeah, so not practicing what they're preaching is really what it done mean. So it wasn't a question of theology for you at this point. It was more of a question of well we say that we do these things and you're not doing these things.
Speaker 3Yeah, it was a lot of It was a lot of at first, well, this just isn't the church for me. These just aren't the people that I'm aligning myself with at first. And then as I went to different churches, I went, oh, you're kind of teaching the Bible differently, and I don't really agree with your interpretation of scripture, and and so then my world started to open up even more to you know, hey, people are interpreting scripture in different ways than how you were taught, you know, right, right, people are viewing this thing in a variety of different ways.
Speaker 1Right, Because when you tell me, oh, you know, my church was ating the best way, the latent Christian part of my brain sort of fires a neuron and it says, well, if I was a Christian, I would have said, well, you probably just didn't go to the right church. If you just found the right church, then I know everything would have been great, right, But it sounds like you actually did. You went to other churches and you tried to figure it out, and they still weren't doing things the way you thought they should be. At least they weren't interpreting the Bible the way you thought they should be exactly one hundred percent.
Speaker 3Yeah, nail on the head. And so then I saw I started to you know, I started to watch this show. I don't I don't know if I can name the name of it, but I started to watch the show and they were talking about they were talking about heaven, what heaven was like. And in this show, the characters finally got to heaven and they could do whatever they want, right, They could like go go kart racing with a monkey, and talk to all of these great philosophers and teachers and they could see all of their loved ones. And after an eternity you know, or you know, billions of
Speaker 3years of that, one of the main characters was like, Hey, I'm kind of bored. You know, I kind of kind of don't really have much to do anymore. You know, I kind of hit everything that I wanted to do. And that idea of like being bored with the Hollywood version of heaven kind of like rock my world, you know. Yeah, because terrifying, oh one hundred, because even like even the Biblical version of heaven is not that way at all. And I was like, oh no, this is I'm I
Speaker 3don't know if I could do that, I'm gonna be bored out of my mind.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 3So then I started thinking, well, will I even be me in heaven, you know, and all these different things, and and it just totally just snowballed, you know, into asking even more questions. And I had never really questioned my belief system like that before, and I wanted to challenge myself and see if it held up to the criticisms that I was, you know, coming up with every day. You know, it's coming up with new questions and new questions, and it was interesting. This is something I didn't share with you. But I had a notebook as I started deconstructing,
Speaker 3and I started to write all of these things down, and like last year, I like finished, I finished the whole entire thing.
Speaker 2And so I have just a notebook full of.
Speaker 3Stuff highlighted versus all all this, you know, contradictions, all the things that I was like struggling with, and so that was like super you were amazing for me.
Speaker 1Let me tell you about somebody who's just been on the other side, just just a little bit longer than you have, just a little bit. You will treasure that, you really will, because one of the best surviving piece of evidences I have is a YouTube video of b talking about my beliefs for about thirty minutes. And I wish I had more. I really do, because your brain really does change. It's so different when you're not a part of that world anymore. And I wish there's some connections in some ways that my brain thought in ways that I just can't make anymore because I'm just I'm
Speaker 1on the other side. I'm not going to church every week, I'm not I'm not filtering things through that lens, and you must relate to that as well now that you're kind of on the other side, because so if I get my timeline, right, so this is post twenty twenty, so this is maybe three four years ago when you're fully deconstructing and saying I don't believe in this anymore.
Speaker 2Yeah, yeah, exactly, yeah, wow.
Speaker 4Yeah.
Speaker 3And I don't think I had even admitted, hey, I don't I don't think this god is real until maybe like two years ago, right, because it just didn't you know, you is such a process. It just didn't even like, yeah, that I should admit.
Speaker 2That to myself, you know. Yeah, definitely bad out loud.
Speaker 1That's a big thing between having those thoughts and then actually saying out loud to have you for the first time, I am this thing, I'm this label, right yeah, and and and so you went from Okay, I'm just now saying this out out for the first time to being like, yeah, let's just go to TikTok and just do it out with some people. So that was your you're you're you're just like you're ready to go.
Speaker 3Yeah, yeah, I said, what a better place than like to the source to the Christians where there is like so many Christians on TikTok and there's so many people that want to talk and want to have genuine conversations with you. And so I said, hey, this is this is the perfect space for me to to kind of try to to.
Speaker 2Work through this, you know.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 3So I started these lives and and I called them Questions for Christians. And I still host these lives twice a week, and so it's been cool to kind of come up with new questions every week to kind of try to you know, talk about wow.
Speaker 1And So since you started doing that, has your shall we say, lack of faith changed in any way? Do you feel more or less confident in your beliefs?
Speaker 5No?
Speaker 3Same, Yeah, I do not believe in this God. I don't think that there is any convincing evidence. I think I think if anything there is there, I have way more reasons not to believe now right, I have way more reasons not to not to go down that past.
Speaker 1So Christians aren't doing their job, then they're not of NotI If anything, they've they've brought you more to that. Why do you say you have even less evidence or less reason to believe? Yeah?
Speaker 3Because you know, each question that comes up, like why are there so many contradictions in the Bible?
Speaker 2Force right you have?
Speaker 3You know you might have one contradiction, but going down the rabbit hole as to why that contradiction exists in the first place will leave you in a place of questioning the Bible in its entirety and the truthfulness of all of its claims. Right, because this Bible is written by fallible human beings, you know they don't get everything correctly. The historosity of these things, you know, are always called into question, and so you know, there's just way more justification as to how this Bible is not one hundred
Speaker 3percent true than to say that the alternative isn't is the case.
Speaker 1I think I would agree with you. I think I would agree with you on that. I certainly. I don't know if i've since people have gone the other way too much either. Maybe I'm a bit more nuanced, but definitely I'm not like the percentage needle has not moved for me towards God. I'll say that much.
Speaker 2That's there is so much nuance. There's so much nuance it's crazy.
Speaker 1Absolutely. So So let me ask you this, because you know Assemblies of God. You know, I didn't grow up Assemblies of God. I grew up sort of Baptist, Methodist. Kind of a long story there. But Assemblies of God, from what I know, is a very community sort of driven church typically, Right, So I imagined you not being a part of that church probably at least rubbed some people the wrong way. What was that like when you're like, hey, I'm kind of having these thoughts. I mean, surely you talk to other members of your community.
Speaker 3You know, when I when I had left that church, it wasn't so much about deconstruction at the time. It wasn't so much about, hey, my my belief in God has changed. It was a lot of, hey, I don't agree with the things that you're saying and the things that you're doing.
Speaker 1Right, you were evaluating the thing the church was doing. Yeah, it wasn't It wasn't about Christianity at that point. It was more just that specific church that makes sense exactly.
Speaker 3Yeah, And so you know, I think like coming out was a huge thing. Like, you know, my mother had passed away at that time, and so seeing you know, seeing my churches and my community's response to the things that I was struggling with at that time, I think was really what was the thing that made me run in the opposite direction? Right because there was no support, there was no love there. In fact, it was a little bit hostile. And so I think, you know, just
Speaker 3for my own mental health, for my own benefit, I had to leave that church.
Speaker 2Had I had to. I had to go.
Speaker 3And then I saw, obviously, like I said, you know the things that they were during doing during COVID and you know, during the Black Lives Matter movement, Like I saw the things that this church was doing and saying, and I said, man, how could I have ever aligned myself with that? You know, of course, hindsight's twenty twenty. As you leave, right then you the thing.
Speaker 1I don't even want to know what my church was doing during Black Lives Matter. I'm sure it wasn't great, you know. I watching that good response, it's crazy man, Oh yeah wow. And so yeah, you're coming on the other side of this, and so yeah, you went to some other churches and you're and you're kind of deconstructing that way. I mean, have people in your community that you know, in your in your personal life, what's what's the reaction been to that now that you're out and talking, are you Are you not super open about that? Do you kind of keep that not?
Speaker 2I haven't been super super open. I've told, of course, my very close friends and family.
Speaker 3Actually, as I'm on this show right now, I posted, maybe two hours before on Facebook and on Instagram, Hey.
Speaker 2I'm going to be on this show.
Speaker 3Oh show so high friends of family, if you're here watching, I'm.
Speaker 1Not a question anymore. Guys. Wow, okay you're coming You're coming up with just some people today probably yeah, yeah, yeah, But I think it's so important to be honest, you know.
Speaker 2And I was just thinking, you know, why haven't I done make you feel?
Speaker 1Does that make you feel nervous? Excited?
Speaker 3I don't think it makes me feel nervous anymore, because I think I no longer rely on their opinion to dictate how I feel about myself and how I feel about the life that I live, right, And so although I love them and I care about them and I'd love to have these conversations with them, I think their influence on my life has changed. And so because of that, I'm not as nervous as I was. In fact, to me, it feels pretty freeing, right, now that's great. Yeah, I love that for you.
Speaker 1Well, yeah, shout outs to the folks who are watching this show for the first time through bored agnostics sharing it on their personal social media. That's fantastic. I have to agree with you. It is a very freeing thing, you know what I tease you about just kind of jumping into the fray as soon as you're kind of putting the dots together. I did the same thing, and I think a lot of people do that because it's like, well, this is exciting, this is very liberating.
Speaker 2Yeah.
Speaker 1I want to know where other people's pats took the in, what other insights they may have and other things. And for me it was a period of learning, but also period of I don't know, just again really exciting figuring things out. A little bit of nerves too, for sure, but I know I quite enjoy the process. I hope we get to talk to some folks today. If you're if you know, bored Agnostic and you want to call in anonymously, you don't want to maybe maybe you know the connection between them, but you don't want to say your name or anything. You want to call in with a different name. I'm sure board would would will be
Speaker 1fine with that and we could probably have a converzation. Would love to see that happen today if that's possible. But until then, yeah, I'm just enjoying talking to you, Bored and and hearing your story. It really is incredible. First, I just before we keep going on, I do want to give a quick shout out to the folks that help make this show happen, and that is the folks that do donations to us on Patreon. So thank you so much to the folks that donate on our truth Wanted Patreon. And we're gonna give a shout out to
Speaker 1the patron of the week right now, and the patron of the week this week is going to be Hugh h Thank you so much, Hugh for donating, and thank you to everybody that donates on that patreon. Go to tiny dot c slash Patreon tw if you'd like to become a patron and we can shout it out as the patron of the week. But for now, I'm gonna turn back to this conversation. Here. We do have some folks I think that want to talk to us, and I have some super chats that came in earlier they're not on my on My Doctor just yet, so I
Speaker 1will get it. I will try to shout out those super chats they came in and if another way to support the show is by sending us super Chance on YouTube if you're on it as well, So thank you for those who are doing that. But yeah, do you do you want to just stump into some calls right now? Actually, let's do it. Let's do it. We have a first caller come in there. It's nine calling it in from I believe it's North Carolina. Nine from North Carolina. You are live on Truth wanted. What do you want to talk to us about today? Hi?
Speaker 6Yes, Hi you guys.
Speaker 7So I was just my question was, why do you think cognitive dissonance is so prevalent in Black Christian communities?
Speaker 6Yeah?
Speaker 7I was gonna say a little bit more, but you know, if y'all have any like, you know, answers to that question directly, more particularly for bored agnostic other than yeah.
Speaker 1No, no, no, please let me let me take the answer to this question, right.
Speaker 7Yeah, absolutely, no, kind of like talk about it over over over them.
Speaker 3But yeah, yeah, that's such a great question. I think cognitive dissonance is so prevalent in the Black community. It beat mostly because our identity for so long has been tied to this religion, right, It's been tied to Christianity. And so I think when we say that, and I don't know if you grew up in a church like this, if you know anybody like this, but I grew up in a church that said you were Christian before you were black.
Speaker 2Right, you were a Christian.
Speaker 3Yeah, you're a Christian before you're a son, a daughter, yeah, a friend, anything, right, number one, you are exactly one hundred percent right, And so yeah, yeah, our identities were first grounded in Christianity. And that runs deep right in black culture. Yeah, in black culture, we can go back to when when we were enslaved, right, we see that Christianity has so much influence on us, right when any
Speaker 3type of spirituality, right, they yeah, I mean they stripped away our our African spirituality and they gave us Christianity and in fact, beat Christianity into us, right, and so.
Speaker 7Really, and they made us think that our own culture was demonic and was witchcraft and they took it from us, and then they gave us some other witchcrafts and they're like, hey, actually give all your worship and praise to this guy and not your ancestors.
Speaker 2Yeah, yeah, isn't that crazy?
Speaker 1Yeah?
Speaker 3And then and then you see things like you know, I mean, at least for me growing up, we saw my parents would tell me things like, you know, we are the authority over you, right, we are. We're doing this because we love you. Because the Bible says so right in terms of spanking, exactly, and that is so ingrained in our culture. Right, And like you know, think think about mental health in black culture, right, it's it's almost non existent.
Speaker 1Right because the church is the answer exactly. Are you do you like?
Speaker 7Are you like thinking about stuff that you don't want to think about?
Speaker 6Just pray about it? I did that.
Speaker 3I did that, Yeah, yeah, to God about it? Just go to God. Just pray about it.
Speaker 6Right, But how I mean to me, not answer to black people?
Speaker 7I guess that's it just doesn't like our wishes don't get answered, but you know other people who you can answered?
Speaker 4Yeah.
Speaker 2But how dismissive is that?
Speaker 4Right?
Speaker 3How dismissive is is that of how like we feel and our experiences and it just doesn't it doesn't produce people that have empathy and care about others, right, and so oh yeah, I think it's.
Speaker 7So heavy on the empathy part, so heavy, like they're just they're detached from this reality and they're just waiting for that their afterlife. That's why when you mentioned stuff like, oh, there's all this, all this is happening, like children are serving, children are dying and everywhere around the world, and this is like what your God did, Like this is what your God did. And they're just like, oh no, this is actually men.
Speaker 6Men are evil. Humans are so evil.
Speaker 7I hate like they hate being human. Like at the end of the day, they don't like being human.
Speaker 6They want to.
Speaker 7Be with God, with their God in heaven doing whatever. Like it's so it's so crazy to me how they like they turn their brain off and they're just like like they just put God in their brain. Like I don't know how it was, but they're just like what would God think about this?
Speaker 6And then they don't think for themselves, like it's it's weird.
Speaker 4This is crazy.
Speaker 6Like I I grew up, I grew up in the church.
Speaker 7You know, I'm fairly young, but I did grow up in the church.
Speaker 6My mom was like on the older side, so you know, an older Christian, they're they're a whole different things. Like they're a whole different.
Speaker 7Like and when they're taking you to church every day and they're just like, yeah, like this God.
Speaker 1Like every day.
Speaker 7Yeah, and yes, they just this God did everything for you. You have to pray all the time or else you want to go to hell. Like imagine learning about hell as a child and just thinking that you might go there if you like, don't believe in this, don't believe in that, don't do this, and don't do that, like and don't let's not let's not even well, I mean, let's talk about how the black community treats like their children, especially their women or their young women.
Speaker 6They're girls, they're black girls.
Speaker 7They're seeing as like fast, they're seeing as like like all.
Speaker 6This other stuff when they're just like expressing themselves.
Speaker 7And you know, I've had I've definitely dealt with trauma like in that range.
Speaker 6So and whenever I was talking.
Speaker 7About my trauma, they would just be like, just just give it to God, Just give out that trauma to God.
Speaker 4And I'm just like I don't even in that.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 3Yeah, but you know that cognitive dissonance is like cognitive dissonance is like a protection mechanism.
Speaker 8Right.
Speaker 3It protects the brain against combating the reality of the world, right, combating combating the facts that, hey, your child is actually hurting right now, your child is in brain and you should do something about it.
Speaker 4Right.
Speaker 3It prevents you from from acknowledging the harm that you could possibly be taking part in, right or are.
Speaker 7Taking it right, And it makes it seem like you're protecting that. Like, it makes it seem like for the parents, it's like, oh, on their side, they're just like, wait, we're just protecting you. We want you to go get into heaven with us, Like don't you want to see your grandma? Don't you want to see all your aunts and your cousins in heaven.
Speaker 6I'm just like, I don't think that's real.
Speaker 7I think they're in the ground. But yeah, that that was really That was really all I had to say.
Speaker 6Because I've watched, like I watched this.
Speaker 7Show all the time, I watched the Atheist Experience and like people like black atheists, because I've been trying to find more community in that realm because literally every other like video or any other like community where I'm at in NC, it's it's just filled with a lot of Black Christians, and they like their minds are I don't want to sound like like their minds are just like so I don't think completely different from.
Speaker 9Mine, but kind of completely different.
Speaker 7Because like it's always like God is always like like sprinkled in like a conversation or like like it's very normalized to just talk about that and be like, oh, well, you know, God saves me today in traffic, and God, you know, saves me today in this and I'm just like like I can't relate to it, and I feel like out like I feel.
Speaker 6Like like I'm not a part of it.
Speaker 7So I'm just like I can't really like say anything back to it.
Speaker 2Or we're here, we're here, we're out here.
Speaker 3You know, not every black person believes in God. We're here, Yeah, tell you show.
Speaker 1I'm incredibly pleased that you called in to talk about this because it's a perspective that I can't speak to it and can't give. But but I'll tell you know, when I was a Christian, right, I never this concept. I can't tell you how many times this is not the first time I've had this conversation where a black content careator has told me, yeah, there's this thing where you're either Christian or you're black, and being Christian is kind of like the more important thing, and if you're not Christian, you're basically not black. I can't tell you how many times I've heard that. It's it's been more than once. And I didn't never heard this before until
Speaker 1I was an atheist talking to other ex Christians, black ex Christians who has this experience, because because I think it's Martin Luther King Junior who said that Sunday morning is the most segregated time in America, right, there's like, yeah, the kind of these separate communities that that go on and have their own issues that ex Christian white creators just can't speak to, and there's there's going to be a gap there in my experience and other creators talking about that. So I'm really glad when I get to
Speaker 1talk to folks like Bord Agnostic and others who can speak to that and tell me, oh, this is what that's like. I have no idea, and I'm so glad that you can make that connection as well. Watching some of the creators do that. Yeah, definitely.
Speaker 7I was so excited when I saw boarding nasics here and when I saw Thinker up here, and when I saw Fee, I'm like, oh my gosh, they're coming, They're from off the woodwork.
Speaker 6I'm so happy.
Speaker 1Yeah, for sure, it's sure that the atheist community at large has been kind of full of guys that look more like me, right, which is unfortunate. I don't there's maybe a lot of reasons why that's the case. I'm glad that's changing now regardless, Right, I definitely want to see less people that look like me talking about these kinds of issues, because I think people that look like me have at their piece on things. Quite frankly, I'm more interested in what bored agnostic has to say, if anything.
Speaker 1But yeah, thanks so much for calling on this topic and I really great stuff.
Speaker 7Yeah, thank Yeah, no problem, Yeah, no problem, Yeah, I just this is also my first time calling into I'm sorry.
Speaker 6If things were like everywhere and I was like, I don't know, if you know.
Speaker 1Every caller coherence and consistent as you, I wouldn't have any issues with any calls ever. Are you kidding me? You have nothing to apologize.
Speaker 6For, Thank you, thank you.
Speaker 7But that yeah, that was really my main question, because you know, I've I listened to a lot of lives, and I just hear like the hatred and the bigotry, because that bigotry is a huge problem in the Black Persian community. Like if you want to talk about the most transphobic and homophobic people, and I'm just like, how can you their minorities and we're also a minority, So how can you like be what how can you try to oppress people.
Speaker 6In your real pressed?
Speaker 7It's it's again.
Speaker 10This is cognitive dissonance.
Speaker 7They don't think it's all connected, but it is. Every single piece of it's connected. Like the first black trans woman, black trans woman Stonewall, like what, it's all connected, but they just they refuse.
Speaker 6They don't want to see it like that.
Speaker 7They don't want to see So.
Speaker 1Yeah, yeah, definitely big stuff to talk about. Big stuff. Yeah, I hope you call it again and I I really appreciate this all.
Speaker 9Thanks again, yank you, Thank you guys so much.
Speaker 7You guys do so much good, Like y'all are the piece of the good in the world that I want to see more of.
Speaker 6Like and y'all, I.
Speaker 7Don't want to say y'all keep me afloat, but that's kind of that's kind of where I'm at right now currently, Like y'all, I'm just like, Okay, there's there's there's reason in the world.
Speaker 6You know, this is going to get better.
Speaker 1But yeah, well I gotta tell you that means the world. You're saying that right now makes me want to keep doing this every week, and I'll keep doing this as long as, like you that it gives support and peace of mind. Right at the very least. God knows we all need that, or you know, the black of God knows we all need that, whatever whatever you want to say to that.
Speaker 7But you know, funny too, because that's so funny because I was hearing you talk about that, and it's so funny how we still use like certain Christian phrases because I'll be saying, I say Jesus Christ all the time. I say oh my God all the time, right, And I don't mean like the actual I think when I use that word, it's like a it's just a placeholder.
Speaker 9For like something.
Speaker 10Yeah, like literally, But but yeah, you guys are super.
Speaker 3Cool still you yeah, right truly like you guys, Yeah, this this is just how it should always be, just people talking and.
Speaker 7You know, thinking about ideas and all and stuff.
Speaker 1But yeah, you guys.
Speaker 4You guys are really cool.
Speaker 1Oh thanks night. Like I said, please call in again. Would love to hear more about your story. You sound like you got a great one when we have time for it. Maybe next time you can call in about that.
Speaker 7Yeah, I mean not really. I just because I'm fairly young, so I don't have much Like I was born.
Speaker 6I mean I was born.
Speaker 7I grew up in the church, but I you know, I'm still fairly young, and I got out of it very young.
Speaker 6I was like when I was ten, I went.
Speaker 7I remember I was in church. Everyone was like praising all of my doping. The doping mean was slow and the seratona was low, and I was feeling happy, and the pastor was like, does anyone want to come down and get like?
Speaker 6I guess I don't know.
Speaker 7What the word is anymore because that's how far away I'm from it.
Speaker 1But boy, I can I ask you and you don't have to give me an exact age, but how how old are you? Approximately?
Speaker 7Yeah, I'm in my twenties, so I'm okay, I'm not that you know twenty experience.
Speaker 1Yeah, yeah, okay, I hate that you said that, and I'll tell you why. I don't want you to ever think that your experience isn't valid or isn't enough to speak to anything. Truly, it's not. You know, I started doing truth wanted when I was twenty two. Okay, oh wow, I didn't anybody that told me that I was too young. I wouldn't give a shit because you know who cares you. You absolutely can speak to some of this stuff. Just because you may not feel confident to have expertise in any particular subject doesn't matter, because you're the expert on
Speaker 1your own experience and nobody can take that away from you. So if I if I can leave you with anything today, I would tell you don't don't ever. I don't ever say I'm too young to do this. In my opinion, doesn't matter. It absolutely does necessarily want to hear it. I'm sure other people do too.
Speaker 3And just think you said that, you said you said that seeing black people talk about this has just opened up your world, right, and you're like super.
Speaker 2Stoked about it and you're excited about it.
Speaker 3You are that person. You are that person who has a voice to encourage other people, right. You are that so incredible.
Speaker 6Thank you, thank you. I appreciate it.
Speaker 1I need to learn.
Speaker 7I need to work on that because literally, again all my life, I've been told that I'm too young for this, you know, stay in the past space. You know, you don't know what you're talking about, you don't understand this.
Speaker 1So I kind of yeah, you know what, and I'm fine the word keeping. Oh, let's I'm fine keeping this conversation going on because it's let's help you on some stuff. You're okay. That's Christianity telling you, giving you that lack of confidence. I think at least a little bit right, right. I know it was for me, right because.
Speaker 7Yeah, my mom definitely was like like, you know, like I have a split thing of it because she passed when I was like fourteen, but she's still kind of the things that I have going on. I can still hear her being like.
Speaker 4You know, you can't do that.
Speaker 6You're too young. You can't do that.
Speaker 7You can't think about that, you can't talk about that.
Speaker 6So I kind of have that in my head a little bit.
Speaker 3Yeah, yeah, I mean, yeah, for sure, when you're raised in religious in a religious household, you're always told to stay in your place, right, but you don't.
Speaker 2You don't have to stay in your place it was.
Speaker 7A lie, It was a lot ye wrong, it was a you know, the voice.
Speaker 1For a reason.
Speaker 3Yeah, right, you have you have experiences that you have every single right to talk about and speak about. I mean that's what led me to be here right now talking with you, right, And so you are I to encourage you, like continue to talk about it, right, because how else? How else do you find that community even in your own hometown if you don't talk about it, if you don't try to, you know, build community where you're at.
Speaker 2Yeah, you got it.
Speaker 7Yeah, that's what that's actually what I want to do too, because I'm in a fairly fairly small town and I'm definitely looking for community to because right now currently I'm sorry, this is kind of a this is kind of a switch, but uh, there's data centers currently. I'm pretty sure a data center is about to be built where I'm at currently, So I'm hoping I can, you know, get out there and like protest because I definitely don't want a data center here.
Speaker 6So this is it sounded like so small.
Speaker 7There's only like a most like less than a thousand people here.
Speaker 9So I'm trying.
Speaker 7I don't want that to happen. So I'm trying to you know, work something, work something out hopefully.
Speaker 1Cool. Yeah, you're you're getting involved politically. That's awesome, really great. A lot of people need that kind of support. There's so many groups that would wish they had more folks like you who are out there, you know, wanting to get stuff done. So yeah, I'm at the same boat as I I'm encouraging you go do your thing. Just back taking one step back of a second, talking about that authority and the structures like in the church, right, because like in Christianity you're taught to there's more people that are spiritually involved and have spiritual authority over you in some ways, right, And they can even dictate your
Speaker 1life if you let them, truly, Like they can tell you what kind of role you're supposed to have as a man or as a woman, what what what kind of person you're supposed to be in your relationship with other people, how you're supposed to treat others right for better or worse. You know, Christianity teaches you that. And and and uh, there's a guy named Friedrich Nietzche. You probably are a hi philosopher, right, he talks about this. He actually calls Christianity a slave morality, and it is. I think he's true in this respect because it does kind of teach you this meekness to not speak out
Speaker 1when you think things are wrong, right when when when things are going the way that you think is right in your heart, And and that's something that you have to overcome when you're deconstructing, for sure. I know I had to, at least if you're a real serious Christian. I think everyone has to kind of deconstruct that a little bit and realize these hierarchies, these these things in place, they're all kind of bullshit and they're all kind of arbitrary. And yeah, maybe that pastor went to like seminary school, but it does he know how to counsel people? Does he know what it best for human psychology? Probably not,
Speaker 1Probably has pretty bad take. Actually. Yeah, So you know, I'm just again happy you're calling it, happy that you're watching, you're get involved, because that sounds like a great start to a very promising life and activism.
Speaker 3So yeah, for you, and I think I think even just to go back, just sorry, just to go back to your original question about why is cognitive dissonance so prevalent in the black community, like this is this is one way to combat that, right, is to have these types of conversations, to speak out against these injustices that we see to be an activist, right, And so that's that's one way that we can combat cognitive discs sentence is through critical thought, right, And so we can one hundred percent you can one hundred percent do that right
Speaker 3because you did it yourself right.
Speaker 1And also, man, we're tag team in here, but now you can speak better to the people in your community than I or any other guy that looks at like me at the ACA ever can truly.
Speaker 4Right.
Speaker 1This is something I said to my other people who are white and in this space when we talk about racism, and I'm like, it's up to us to call this shit out. It is not up to the people who are experiencing this, and we have to go through it right. And the same thing comes when we're talking about like if you're talking about issues in black churches or black communities, I'm not going to be that guy that's ever going to be able to speak as powerfully or as critically or as insightfully as you ever could because you have that lived experience and that's again why I'm encouraging you so much to get your voice out there. Please. It
Speaker 1really breaks broke my heart when you said I don't feel like I can speak to this because you absolutely can't. You're more than qualified to do it.
Speaker 2So okay, you don't need to you don't need a degree to speak.
Speaker 1Yeah, you got it for sure.
Speaker 4Yeah yeah, I need to keep telling myself that for sure.
Speaker 6But also to call in.
Speaker 1Here so you can get a pep talk every week. I'll do it now, I'm serious.
Speaker 2Okay, ahead that I got your back, find me.
Speaker 1We'll fire TikTok.
Speaker 7You on everything board agnostic like truly do like I did, just like see you like recently, and when I saw you that that you were up here, I was like, oh let me let.
Speaker 2Me want to call in and talk sick. Yeah awesome, Yeah, I'm on. I'm on TikTok.
Speaker 3I go live every Wednesdays and Sundays and so yeah, check check me out.
Speaker 2You can.
Speaker 3You can even give it a spin, join the panel and have a conversation with someone.
Speaker 7Oh gosh, public speaking, yeah, you do it. This is pane, but like I don't know, it's like to other people, this is not that much different.
Speaker 1You're just you're talking to other people in another live format, right, true.
Speaker 6Yeah, that's true. That's true.
Speaker 2You're just on the phone. That's it. Yeah, you got it.
Speaker 1Yeah, that's it.
Speaker 4Now.
Speaker 1I have some other colleges that do want to talk to us, so I do. Got to let you go now. But I just want to say again, absolute pleasure talking to you. I really want to hear from you again. Will you call again please?
Speaker 6I really love you.
Speaker 7Guys, And I'll definitely call back in because y'all gave me the courage and.
Speaker 1Yeah, for sure, it's awesome. I love that. Thanks so much. Talk to you later.
Speaker 2Thanks.
Speaker 4Wow.
Speaker 1And if they don't call back, that's fine too. I'm lessly concerned about them calling back and more just I want them to feel get into an environment where they're more encouraged to speak out, right, like if I if I can help them do that, I want to help them do that, right, Yeah, how great is that?
Speaker 11Right?
Speaker 3Just furthering the message of like critical thaw and evacuating your beliefs like it's amazing.
Speaker 1Yeah. I don't know about you, board, but those kind of calls, that's the ship that gets me up in the morning. Right there. Yea, I love that shit, right, that's so exciting. I know, it's so good. Gosh, there's so much to unpack there. I want to talk more about some stuff from there, but we have other people that want to talk to us too, so I think maybe we should move on to some of our the callers and then maybe we maybe go back in a second. I don't know.
Speaker 4I don't know.
Speaker 1Well, we'll see how the flow goes. But for now, let's get to our next caller here. Oh gosh, we got some good ones up man. Man, okay, uh, let's talk to Ray. I. Other callers please keep on the line. We will get you. We're going to talk to Ray from New York. Here, Ray, how are you doing your live on Truth Wanted?
Speaker 4Now?
Speaker 1What's going on?
Speaker 4Okay? I'm great.
Speaker 8I'm going to go real quick because I agree with you on the last caller and I just think, mind, I should do as quick as I can right now because it's going to be more intellectual.
Speaker 1But take the time. Don't feel I don't want you to feel like you're rushed. Please take the time you feel is necessary. I'll let you know if you need to speed it up.
Speaker 4How about that? Yeah, okay, that sounds good.
Speaker 8Okay, So here's the thing. I want to give you a thought experiment, and the thought experiment I call typewriter God.
Speaker 4And what it is is, suddenly one day.
Speaker 8Everyone wakes up, they look up with the sky and they see and there's typewriter, you know, typewritten letters wrong in their own languages, and it says, Hi, I'm God. I know you've been talking about whether I exist, and I came to believe that I need.
Speaker 4To tell you that I do.
Speaker 8And so our first thing we need to do is establish my credentials. So notice everyone around you can also see what you're seeing, and it's all type written, you know, in the sky, they said. But one person says, in the room with you, says, can you make another moon? Right now, it's nighttime, I'm looking up at the moon.
Speaker 4Can you build another one?
Speaker 8And suddenly another moon appears.
Speaker 4Okay.
Speaker 8Now another person does something like that, you know, can you make the building? There's a mattress factory next to me. No one's in it, it's not dangerous. Can you just make it disappear? And boom it disappears.
Speaker 4Okay.
Speaker 8So apparently when you talk to this person after elaborate, elaborate testing. He can create and and at will anything he wants.
Speaker 4Okay, and he says to you, I created you. Guys.
Speaker 8Now, if that evidence were to exist, we both agree it doesn't. Would you believe in God? Would you believe that God existed? Uh?
Speaker 1So, if if if, if, if there was a typewriter God in this guy, I might change my mind on some things. Maybe, I mean, yeah, but.
Speaker 8I'm just trying to get out in my mind there is you're you're absolutely correct that there's no evidence.
Speaker 4Like that for any kind of a guy. Okay. And and so you.
Speaker 8Know factually existing God that you know, it was the idea that you have, an idea that that established the existence of God. Is similar like an electron. Right, you take an electron, and we have reasons why we believe electrons exist.
Speaker 4Okay.
Speaker 8We're the same with corps. And you know, I'm a fan of the standard model.
Speaker 4I'm a fan of uh you.
Speaker 8Know, special general relativity and space and time and the whole scientific which is the result of studying our senses and we come to these conclusions. I believe in them all. That's there, their natural law, the unnatural laws. You know, that's say, the conservation laws, Like, Emily, you know there, you know what I mean?
Speaker 1Emily, I think so, yeah, but I guess like my question is, you know, like, okay, you seem to be in agreeance with us that, hey, Dad, this would be a higher standard of evidence that we currently don't have, right, because.
Speaker 8Here's the point now, okay, too quick, okay, is I don't believe that that's the correct conclusion you're drawing.
Speaker 4I believe that if such evidence existed, then that could not be got okay.
Speaker 8And the reason is that the question you should ask at that point is who made you?
Speaker 4Okay?
Speaker 8Because God usually involves the for the prime mover, which means it's the it's the cause of existence itself. And although God has established that.
Speaker 4He's the cause of the buildings around you and that kind of thing, the universe.
Speaker 8The stars are all that, he's not established that he's the the cause of himself, nor how he could be the cause of himself, And so that could not be God.
Speaker 4So you have the wrong.
Speaker 8Standard because your notion of God is temporal.
Speaker 4It's a it's a do you believe in the God that.
Speaker 8Either could or could not be? That's it's you believe you believe it's.
Speaker 4Possible that God could exist, and it's possible that he couldn't exist, and there's no evidence for his existence, and that's why you're an atheist. That's true.
Speaker 1Well, I mean right there that those senses, I mean, those seem like reasonable sentences to me. You're saying that we God has to be something else entirely, so like these sorts of fact checking wouldn't exist. But here's the thing. If we're first of all God, you said God is usually this. God means a million different things in a million different religions. Sometimes there there there's sprites, sometimes they're monsters. Sometimes they're all prime you know, the prime movers and all kinds of stuff. So God, God means a million different things to a million different religions. Right, Christianity tends
Speaker 1to put it into this binary. But you know when in terms of Christianity, if we're talking about the Christian historical narrative, God absolutely works in temporal spaces. Right in the Book of Joshua, He's he's moving, he's stopping the sun in the air for an hour.
Speaker 4Right.
Speaker 1If you believe that the Noah's Art story is literal, then he's flooding the entire earth, and he's putting a bunch of animals on it. Those all happen in temporal spaces, and and and if they do, then we should be able to look at the physical world and should be able to see evidence of it. In fact, Jesus himself in the New Testament also does these things. He's he's performing miracles for people, He's doing things that naturally would not happen, and that's something that we would be able to observe. So I don't see why asking for that kind of evidence is unreasonable if at every single book
Speaker 1in the Bible is showing these stories about, Hey, here's what happens when you believe in God. Here's what God is doing when he's in the world, right, So why would I expect anything less if I'm asking for evidence of that.
Speaker 8I want to tell you, okay, I will try to tell you the answer to that question.
Speaker 4What you do, okay, Okay.
Speaker 8The first thing is that don't confuse me with someone who believes that Noah's Ark existed, Okay, okay, believe that, Okay, I believe in a distinction, all right, that you can look at.
Speaker 4Anything, say, take anything in your room.
Speaker 8Like the microphones, and you can describe what it is, right.
Speaker 4True or false? Yes? Oh true.
Speaker 8Now you can then turn your mind from a description of what that thing is now look at it, and.
Speaker 4To a description of the fact that it is.
Speaker 1Okay, is this I'm sorry to interrupt you, Ray, but is this just a longer way of saying that Bible uses metaphors sometimes or uses allegory to describe what they're seeing.
Speaker 8No, I'm saying that you've got to hear me through here, or you're going to if you're you're not going to find what you believe in what I believe Okay, you're not going to find you know, my beliefs are different, and now I'm trying to communicate to you a different way.
Speaker 4Of looking at the problem.
Speaker 8Okay, that will help you even with atheism.
Speaker 4Okay.
Speaker 8So my distinction is between nature and the supernatural, or between physics and metaphysics, between sensation and extrasensory experience.
Speaker 4Okay.
Speaker 8And I say to you that it is possible for anyone to turn their attention from the natural world what I call nature my belief now, okay, my belief are highly unusual. But also I'll tell you this you take Saint Thomas Aquinas or any of the intellectual theologians and that it resembles it.
Speaker 3Okay, And let me ask you a question. What do you mean by turning away from nature? What does that mean?
Speaker 4It means no.
Speaker 8Longer considering what it is, but instead considering the.
Speaker 4Fact that it is. Okay, it's a simple switch.
Speaker 1From the what does it mean for the fact.
Speaker 8Thing to the being of the thing? Well, okay, here we go. Good, good question. I claim that the only possible first prime mover, Okay, the only possible candidate for an actual god, real God, is being itself.
Speaker 2Isn't that the nature of the thing.
Speaker 4No, being is not the nature of thing.
Speaker 8The nature of the thing is what is being is that it is, and what it is is not that it is what is?
Speaker 3That would be the nature of a prime mover, though, wouldn't that be the nature of a prime mover?
Speaker 4Okay?
Speaker 8Now that's a good, very good question. Now I'm going to tell you that this is a very good question. It's a prime mode of attack if you want to be an atheist. Okay, And basically I'll give it to you in terms of sartra Okay, John Paul Satra's book Being in Nothingness. In the introduction, the way he looks at it is the phenomenon of being and the being of phenomenon.
Speaker 4Okay. The phenomenon of being is sort of what you're calling the nature of God. Okay.
Speaker 8If you'll make the identity between being and God, then you're asking about the nature of God. Therefore, you're asking about the nature of being.
Speaker 4Okay, being as being.
Speaker 1Yeah, that we are.
Speaker 3Do you think that any human being truly knows the nature of God?
Speaker 4I think that this is what I think can happen. Okay.
Speaker 8I was the road to describe to you how I what happened to me and why I switched my thinking. Okay, is I was in a philosophy course. The reason I was in the philosophy course was I loaded up on the okay, and I needed.
Speaker 4An easy course. I needed a gut.
Speaker 8Next to me in the in the registration line was.
Speaker 4A foot basketball player and he asked.
Speaker 8Doctor Lynch, is this going to be easy? He said, oh, you won't have any problem with it. I literally got into the philosophy life.
Speaker 4Okay. I had no interest in it.
Speaker 8I thought the philosophy was where they parked people who couldn't do math. Okay, So I went there, and the whole time I'm in the classroom, I'm describing to them, Okay, the upper division philosophy course. I'm never taking an introduction, know nothing about it, and I'm describing to them what being is. And it's very simple. It's what you need to assume in order to explain your experiments.
Speaker 4Okay.
Speaker 8So if I if I have a car, Okay, I say, I posit that there exists a car, and then I go out and I look, and yeah, the car is there, you know, in the sense that I see it and the car the positing of the existence of the car, the existence of the car is a posit I make. I posit that existed in order to explain my experience.
Speaker 2But Ray, hold on, I'm sorry to cut you off here.
Speaker 3Ray, It's just that I did ask a question, and I would love it if I had an answer to that.
Speaker 1Okay.
Speaker 3So do you think that any any human No? No, do we know the nature of God? Does any human being know the nature of God?
Speaker 8I spin it very fast. I experienced the nature of God.
Speaker 2Okay, So you know the nature of God? Okay, how do you know the nature of God.
Speaker 4Okay, let's talk about.
Speaker 8No when you experience the nature of God to do more than.
Speaker 1I'm so sorry, Ray, we have this is a call in show and this is not, okay, a philosophy I cannot have. We can't spend an hour on this call, right, we got to do this. I would love ten minutes. It's already seven minutes in though, right, so we got this a little bit.
Speaker 4Thank you.
Speaker 8Here's I was with the teacher. I kept criticizing him, and suddenly I saw it. Okay, I saw the nature of being. And when I did, I was looking at a bookcase.
Speaker 4It looked like it was jewelry.
Speaker 8And my experience I had was on the ecstasy, religious ecstasy, okay. And what I was actually understanding is the fact that it was.
Speaker 4Okay, that's very simple. I just gave it to you.
Speaker 8The fact that it was. I'm not being evasive or that there is no natural phenomena like a truck that is God, the typewriter.
Speaker 4God is a natural phenomena.
Speaker 8And therefore it is not God. Okay, So there's no that's at the end of the conversation.
Speaker 4We can cut me off.
Speaker 1I think, man, that's so crazy, because if I saw a typewriter God type things into the sky, I would think, gosh, that's the most unnatural thing in the world. I don't know why you would make that, senior.
Speaker 8If it were to occur, it would be a part of nature, because you.
Speaker 4Would look up in the sky and you would actually.
Speaker 1So wait, so when Jesus. If if a guy named and I know you're not this kind of Christian, right, but you know if somebody said the name Jesus came in here on earth and and they turned water in the wine, and they got raised a man from the dead, and you saw this, you would just say, oh, well, that's that's just natural. So that's not that's not real. Actually you're not you're not. Actually what I'm.
Speaker 8Yeah, right, And it's that's all that Jesus did. I would agree with what you're saying. But Jesus spoke many things, and he talked about the Father, and Jesus was, well, that's no. No, human beings are are metaphysical. They go human beings. Your brain is natural, okay, but you're experiencing, you have experiencing, and your identity Okay, you have this whole part of your brain that's called the limbic system that you're not even getting involved in when you talk
Speaker 8about God, and God is necessarily most of the things you see in religion are fetishes.
Speaker 2Okay, that we get experiences outside of our brain.
Speaker 8No, no, it's not outside your brain. It's a part of your brain. It's outside of that on the lob.
Speaker 3I think the brain is foundational for all experiences. So I would say that, but I mean part of me and all of my experiences would be my brain.
Speaker 1Yeah, like the front which is natural, yeah, natural, that's yeah.
Speaker 8Yeah, So seeing seeing color is not thinking about what color is.
Speaker 2You agree, sure, I don't have to think about the color in order to see it.
Speaker 8Yeah, you can be blind and think about color because you think about color in the frontal cortext.
Speaker 1I'm not blind. I can't really speak to that. I don't know. Yeah, that's my extra key.
Speaker 8That's neurology, basic neurology. So there's another.
Speaker 4System like you have.
Speaker 1You're a neurologists, right, that's great. You're a philosopher, you're a neurologists. Got a lot of things. I'm sorry, I'm rousing you a little bit because we we we have a few more minutes here, okay, and I want to make sure that this time we have his product. If you're obviously a smart guy. You've talked about your experiences and you've brought some interesting ideas. Can we can we try to get somewhere with them real quick in the time that we have in the next couple of minutes.
Speaker 4Go ahead, thanks for now you lead.
Speaker 1Well, Okay, So I understand you're not a traditional I don't know what you are. You haven't actually told me what you are. I know you're you're you're sometimes ray. I love it if you let me speak. I know you said you'd let me, so I'm going to go ahead and do that. There's you. You describe yourself as a theist and some capacity at least you have some sort of God belief. You seem to have come to this God belief through some sort of experience that you had. So is the way to knowing about God? Is it
Speaker 1through this experience or is it is it purely through this philosophical sort of argumentation that you've lained out, Because I want to know. If it's through experience, then it's going to be hard for me to believe in God. Right, I can't really get there but maybe if we had an argument for it, I could look at that.
Speaker 4Right.
Speaker 8Well, the the the argument for it is simply that being is.
Speaker 1Okay, yeah, that's I'm sorry. That's not good. That's not good enough for me.
Speaker 2How is that an argument?
Speaker 1Yeah?
Speaker 8Well, okay, look, you ever see the cartis you know, the koji our Cartesian cogito I think therefore.
Speaker 1I am, yes, cognito ergo sum I think is what that is?
Speaker 4Yeah, exactly. Now now watch this. Now, that is not like, you know, a syllogism. You need three.
Speaker 8Steps, and in that statement it's one. It's like just the fact of experiencing.
Speaker 1Hey, I'm sorry, great, I noticed when we ask you a question, you kind of bring your answer to a whole other thing. I don't really care about Renee descartes argument about why he exists. We're not talking about that. We're talking about your belief in God.
Speaker 4Right. Yeah, you said it is based on experience.
Speaker 1Okay, that's there. We go, say'st we got someone I've opened for you. It's a bit more straightforward answer, you know, And that's okay, Like I get it. You want to explain yourself, right, because you know, you don't want to be left hanging. But anyway, okay, it is it is through experience. So through experience is how we know.
Speaker 8Through experienced, correct, Okay, not sorry, free experience, a sensory experience, not necessarily censory. I didn't see a God. Okay, it wasn't like I saw a God. In fact, I'm saying that if you if the Buddhists say, if you find the Buddha, kill him, and I'm saying the same thing to you about Christianity. If you see the Christian God, the Creator, kill him, because it's a false God, because if you see him, it's automatically you can.
Speaker 1But so so, if you see him, they they're not real, but if you experience them, it is real.
Speaker 4That's right. That's a good way to say.
Speaker 1Okay, that's so every time anyone ever spoke about God in the Bible, right, and them experiencing him and seeing him and him doing the things, those are all fake. You shouldn't trust that.
Speaker 8If if if you take them literally, all fundamentalism, all literal interpretation of it.
Speaker 1So wait, no, let's know, how how little does this go though?
Speaker 4Right?
Speaker 1What about Jesus Christ himself God or no, yes.
Speaker 8Christ, Jesus Christ himself is a historical figure that you can establish scientific gods. Okay, but okay, whether he's God, now we have to talk about how could a man possibly be God?
Speaker 1Well, we don't have time for I mean, but we're we're probably on the same page there as far as Jesus not being God or maybe you don't think he's God. I don't know. No, I'm really you're you're you're kind of giving a lot of these cases on. Oh well, now we have to talk about this. No, we don't. I just want to know what your thoughts are on it, like whether you believe it or not.
Speaker 4Write in the same way you could be a fireman, okay, but.
Speaker 1Jesus place it's like a title. So like you, I get a salaried and then you can be God that works.
Speaker 4You take up, you take up as a project.
Speaker 8You you, you, you. You constrain your thoughts and your your words and your actions to something inside of you.
Speaker 2I feel, Okay, do you think that Jesus was God?
Speaker 9Do or not?
Speaker 4In that sense, in that very constrained sense.
Speaker 2In any sense, in any sense, was Jesus God?
Speaker 4Yes? I do, Yes, I do?
Speaker 2Oh? Okay, okay, So Jesus and we saw Jesus though we saw him.
Speaker 4People saw him, right, people saw Jesus.
Speaker 1Yeah, okay, but didn't you say earlier, if you see him, because you should kill him. I guess they did that, but like probably not for the same reasons you would have.
Speaker 8No, the non believers killed him, not the believers loved them, and the non believers killed him.
Speaker 1Right, So so, so Jesus got or not God? Because I was told just a few seconds ago that if you see a guy and he's doing stuff in the natural world, right, you should kill him because he's not God.
Speaker 5That's exactly right, Yes, so is But Jesus contradicting yourself here, come right, you're contradicting yourself.
Speaker 3You say you see him not God. People saw Jesus, but he's God.
Speaker 5That's a contradiction, Ray, Yeah, yeah, but not for not for I did you go look inside of your skull and see if you can see you?
Speaker 3But Ray, that seems entirely irrelevant. Yeah, that's what we're talking about, all right.
Speaker 2As a philosopher. As a philosopher, Ray, you.
Speaker 3Know that contradictions don't exist, right, and you have a contradiction in your belief system, how do you reconcile that contradiction.
Speaker 4Ray, I'm going to tell it to you right now. I don't. Here's why.
Speaker 8Okay, So you know why. So they saw his body and his body when it spoke, they heard the words come the sounds coming out of the sounds that he made.
Speaker 1That's what it means to see somebody, Ray, I know what it means to see somebody. Yes, yeah, just in case you guys weren't away, Yeah, yeah, y. You know, when you talk to me over the phone, you're actually it's a series of electrons that's going through a wire that's actually going to my voice. Not really talking to me right now. It's more just you know, a synthesize side there's creating these sort of audio waves like yeah, I understand this process. We don't have to be so analytical with every single individual point, right use. You know
Speaker 1what it sounds like, Ray, when you do that, it sounds like obfuscation. Okay, it doesn't sound authentic because okay, yes, it does sound like that to me.
Speaker 8Ray.
Speaker 1You know why because con artists do that kind of thing all the time. And I don't think you're a con artist, but I think you if you want to make an argument that appeals to people better and appeals to people more. You got to stop sounding like a con artist, because I'm going to call you out on every single definition that you give, just like agnostic is if we're not if we're going to go this route, if you want to be pedantic and want to make all these cases, that's how it's going to go right right.
Speaker 4But you don't understand something. You don't understand that I do.
Speaker 8Not take the stories of the miracles of Jesus as being literally true. I don't think he could do any kindness of the typewriter. God could actually create moons, and you.
Speaker 1Know what, I don't think. I don't think Jesus could do those things either. That's why I don't think he's God. But you do seem to think he's God. So that's kind of weird. I don't know how to make sense.
Speaker 8Of that because you, Okay, here's how you think that what it takes to be a god is to be a powerful creature that can create things.
Speaker 1I think that's part of it, at least in the Judeo Christian traditional sense of that word. Yes, that's that's at least part.
Speaker 4Of it, taken literally.
Speaker 1If you take that tradition lit taken by most Christians from most of most of human history. Actually it's not just you, know, Ray, I'm so glad that you figured this all out when you stared at a bookcase. Okay, but the rest of us and the rest of Christian history has very different ideas about who God is, what he does, and what he's going to continue to do. I suggest that you consult those texts a bit more closely. I know you think you're just as good is Thomas Aquinas, but I think Thomas Aquinas could probably school you on
Speaker 1who God is and what his nature is. Honestly, you seem more interested in talking about how impressive your knowledge set is and how awesome your arguments are than actually making sense in any arguments that you've given me today. So I'm gonna end this call now, but I would love to hear from you again, give you a second chance to try to clean this up, because right now this is sloppy, and this is messy and quite frankly, a waste of my time. And I'll leave it at so thank you. Yeah, that's the call. Wow.
Speaker 2I miss Nie, I miss too, I miss Nio Man.
Speaker 3One easy way to lead us towards truth is to never answer questions directly, really talking about things that are way over there and not the subject at hand. Let's never talk about the topic, and then you guys will totally understand my point.
Speaker 1Yeah. Do you know what's great? I love convincing people that my argument is right by talking about things that totally aren't related and referencing as many philosophers as I can in my conversation. And just you know that that that always convinces people. I mean they always one hundred percent come to my position by doing that, I mean.
Speaker 3It convinced me. I mean, I don't know about you, but yeah.
Speaker 1Right, yeah, for sure. You know we're cheasing you here, Ray, But seriously, you're obviously a smart guy. I'm not taking that away from you. Nobody's here to take that away from you, or that your uniques are unique and special or whatever. You just have to lead us how you got there, and and and and trust that we can follow without having to nitpick at every single thing. If there's something we don't understand, you can explain it to us. But this way of talking to people is not going to get you anywhere. And you know, I would encourage
Speaker 1you to try again and maybe we'll go somewhere next time. But all my thoughts, yeah.
Speaker 3I have had points that lead us there, and then don't explain, say your point and if there's questions, I know Dan's going to ask. I'm going to ask, and then you can clarify and then we can move on to the next point.
Speaker 4Right.
Speaker 3I think maybe you have some more thinking to do to lay out what it is that you believe in.
Speaker 1Why. Yeah, agreed, Yeah, I think we gave our thoughts there. Let's move on, shall we. Let's go to our next caller here. I want to talk to Bob, who's calling in from California. Bob, you are live, untruth wanted. Thanks so much for waiting on the phone there, Thanks for calling to the show. Welcome.
Speaker 10Yeah, thanks for having me Star gets we'll jump right into it. Longtime atheist, it's probably an atheist for a better part of thirty five years. Fell into a bit of an agnosticism after that, and recently became a Christian within the last year. And I guess there's two kinds of things that really moved me into the Christian camp, the first being a morality in itself at least recognized early on when I was an atheist that there really was no way to true up whether or not my moral claims or the things that I thought were morally
Speaker 10right or wrong were actually true right. So it seems like everything just evolves into this moral relativism. So when we talk about things like social justice, you know, like racism, homophobia, all of these things, at least on an atheistic perspective, as far as I can tell, they're completely arbitrary in the sense that my viewpoint is just as valid as the viewpoint of someone else. The other thing that was a little bit convincing to me was just the I guess the cosmological argument, not the argument of itself, but
Speaker 10the fact that it seems that it's really hard to get to an infinite.
Speaker 9So I guess it'd be two different arguments.
Speaker 10And actualizing an actual infinite and then reaching or I guess, adding to an infinite by successive addition, which tends to point towards the universe being finite, which means that the cause of the universe likely has to be you know, immaterial. So I guess those two points are kind of what brought me towards the theistic route, and then obviously there's there's some things that give me to Christianity. But I wanted to get your perspective, like as an atheist, because again, I live this way for a long time. How do you kind of navigate like the moral claims right, like
Speaker 10we ought to do this thing when it seems like it's just completely arbitrary.
Speaker 1Wow? Can I tell you?
Speaker 4Wow?
Speaker 1Bob, thanks so much for being way better of a call than Ray so far. Let me tell you, Oh, this is a this is a relief. Okay, you asked your questions, you side what you need to side, and that's great. I thank you, truly thank you for that. This is a great question. I think this is one of the most important things to talk about as activists, and I think the atheist community has the hardest time in response to that particular question. I think the moral question is the most difficult, in my opinion. I see
Speaker 1Kelly's our backup post, he's shaking his head, he disagrees. This is my opinion. I think it's the hardest. And the reason why is because you can answer this question in a million different ways, and in a million in one ways could be uns satisfying. Because the atheist community as a whole does not heavy consensus on morality, how it works, what's best and what's not best, the is or aughts of it. You know, there's different ideas. You can everything from utilitarianism to deontology right there. There's all kinds of things there. So I can give you my
Speaker 1take on it, but it may not be the definitive, absolute, end all take because I don't know if that exists.
Speaker 4Right.
Speaker 1So, the short of it is, I think we get our morals from a couple of different things. I think we are a species that has evolved over time, and that evolution has brought up strategies to our existence, including altruism and strategies that bring others up, that give interest to beings outside of ourselves. So I think there's an inclination within our biology that points us towards operations of selflessness.
Speaker 4Right.
Speaker 1That doesn't speak to these things being objectively good or objectively bad, objectively right are objectively wrong. I don't personally believe that that's a thing. I think that there are when we use these terms objective or or or subjective whatever. You know, we're talking about end goals and end values, and I just happen to think that most people in most periods of time have a similar sort of cognitive ability to have the same sorts of end goals. But truly,
Speaker 1like we don't always, and that's why there's conflict, right, And there's even some people that have psychopathy or sociopathy that that sort of have those in absentious so they don't reason with those things, and that's why they do the things that they do. So I think it's a happenstance of our biology that we tend to agree on a lot of things, and we tend towards those strategies. I don't think there's anything objective about it. If you ask me, is it objectively right or wrong to kill somebody? For example? I think I could say I value human beings and I don't think you should, and it's because
Speaker 1human beings are valuable. But then when you get into the meta ethics of oh, well, what makes a human being objectively valuable? I don't I value human beings because because I think they're valuable, and I'm a human being as well. So it becomes circular in a sense, right, which is very unsatisfying. But I think that's the reality of the situation now. Thirty more seconds. I promise I'll finish up. I'm sorry, I know this is a long answer, but I'm unsatisfied with Christianity's response because Christianity often touts the idea that they have objective morality and that they know what's right and wrong, and that if you follow
Speaker 1these guidelines, or if you don't know the guidelines, well, at least God knows it, because maybe it's God's nature or perhaps he has a set of ideas that makes it right. And I just think that that has the same problem, but almost worse, because now we have to decipher God's intentions, God's nature, God's rules, and that doesn't get us anywhere closer to the truth. That's just becomes people's opinions on what God's opinions are, essentially at the end of the day. So I don't think Christianity solves issues of morality. I don't think we have an objective account at atheists, but I don't think Christians do either,
Speaker 1So it's it's sort of a neutral for me. But anyway, I'm sorry, that's a long answer, but it's a complex question. I just passing it over to you board. If you have any additional thoughts. Yeah, I oh sorry, I thought it was mean. Go ahead, yeah, go ahead.
Speaker 3Yeah, I believe that morals are objective, and I agree one hundred percent with you that I don't think atheism has any cohesive statement as far as morality is concerned. But yeah, I think I think morals are objective. I think as agents ourselves, we value things. This is this is a philosopher Alan go Worth's argument as well. But as agents we value two things. We value our freedom and our well being, right, because it enables us to act.
Speaker 4Right.
Speaker 3We need to have the freedom to do so, we need to have the well being in order to do the thing that we're trying to do, right, and so these things are necessary in order for us to take any action. And so therefore, as an agent, we value these things. Right, We value our freedom and our well being which enable us to act and do these things, which make us agents. Obviously, and so if we say, hey, my freedom and well being is more important than your freedom and well being, well, then we've found ourselves in a tricky situation.
Speaker 1Right.
Speaker 3We tend to be contradicting ourselves then, and so if we say, well, freedom and well being is important for me and let's say not for Dan. Well, then again, we've found ourselves in that contradictory mode. Right, So in order for us to be consistent and not contradictory, we must also value and protect even the freedom and well being of others. I think that's such a simple way to explain objective morals. But on a broader sense, I believe that objective morals are real. I'm a moral realist,
Speaker 3and so I think that there are these objective morals that exist, and there are many ways for us to come to the knowledge of these moral truths, right, and so one of the easiest and best ways is just through reason. Right, we can use logic and reason in order to get to these moral truths, and alan gorith is one great way for us to be able to do that. But I also agree with Dan that you know morals in terms of Christianity. I don't think that those morals are objective whatsoever. I would disagree one hundred percent.
Speaker 1There you go, Bob, you got two different answers to this question, very different answers because we believe different things about morality. But we both agree at least that Christianity is still not the way there. So so there you go, Bob.
Speaker 10Yeah, I guess in response, maybe I'll respond to both of you. And there was a lot so I may be forgetting. Of course, it sounded like you made an argument, or at least you alluded to the fact that, like, hey, we've evolved, right, so you know, through nature we've learned to do these things. But if evolution is just a random process that never had us in mind, there's no reason to believe that an evolutionary process would be cured at any sort of truth. And I think that you actually conceded.
Speaker 1That point, yes, on your view, right.
Speaker 10Then for the young lady who just spoke, she had mentioned, you know, the you know, we're these agents and we want our well being, but that presupposes again, I don't think it would be contradictory to say, like, hey, I'm an agent and I like my well being, but in order to get the thing that I want, right, I'm willing to violate somebody else's well being because it benefits me, And that takes.
Speaker 1That is a contradictional well being.
Speaker 10I don't I don't necessarily think that is a contradiction. I don't like I guess what is the presupposition though, that well being is even a thing that we should consider, like why why are we Yeah?
Speaker 3Because those those two things are necessary in order for us to act?
Speaker 2Can we act if we don't have freedom and well being in order to do so?
Speaker 1Well?
Speaker 10We can act without having well being? I think, what would what would prevent you from acting?
Speaker 9If we don't have well being?
Speaker 3How can you take an action if you don't have the well being to do so?
Speaker 2Right?
Speaker 1If if, if I.
Speaker 3If I am, if I am beaten, if I am beaten right to the point where I'm injured, let's say my leg is broken, right, then I don't have the well being to run a race, right, I don't have that functionality.
Speaker 2Right. And so if I'm saying, hey, I get to.
Speaker 3Beat others and prevent their well being, you know, their health, their wealth, not wealth, but their health right and their physical bodies. I get to beat them in order to get them to submit to me, then I am then saying, in order for their not to be a contradiction, that it is okay for somebody to beat me in order to prevent me to act, right, And that that is contradictory because when you say something like well, I should restrict somebody else's freedoms in order so I can act. Then in turn, you're saying that the same thing is
Speaker 3true for you, that somebody should restrict your freedoms because they wish to act in whatever manner. And I don't think that's right. I think that's a contradiction. And maybe I'll try to point out you can tell me if I'm wrong. It's today in modern society, right, there are many things that are restricted. Does that mean that you don't have the freedom to act because it's somehow restricting you from acting. No, I don't think that just because there are some restrictions that it prevents us to act obviously not right, there are also restrictions that are in place that help protect us.
Speaker 10Right, Sure, what your point was that, Like, if there are these restrictions, like, for example, if you were to beat somebody, right, like, you may prevent them from running a race, but it's not going to prevent them from getting up, you know, walking to their house, you know, wrapping their leg.
Speaker 9They're still going to have the freedom to make a choice thereafter.
Speaker 10So I'm not really sure how because it could somebody gets beaten, right that therefore.
Speaker 2Did you see how it could prevent them from acting.
Speaker 10It could but eventually they would race right, But like it could be too that you get beat and you're labeled to race right if your leg's not broken. So it seems to me like you're saying that in order for you know, everybody to be able to act in accordance to the way that they want to act, that you can never have anything bad actually happen to them, And that to me doesn't sound correct. It sounds like, I mean, that's just the way the world works, right, Like sometimes you fall down and you're going to get hurt, or you.
Speaker 9Know someone's going to accidentally do something to you.
Speaker 4I don't think of that.
Speaker 1I just want to gage your free all though.
Speaker 2Sorry I hate to interrupt you.
Speaker 3I just want to keep in mind that you said something bad happening to you, which is what we're talking about, right, We're talking about morals. So even you identify that this is something bad that's happening, and when I'm talking about objective morals existing, I am also pointing out, hey, this is something bad that's happening, and that we shouldn't be acting and doing that to one another.
Speaker 10Yeah, but I don't believe that exists in an atheistic world view, like, where are you getting the bad from?
Speaker 3How do you well, I just told you it's a contradiction. Do you think that contradictions are good?
Speaker 10Well, you telling me it's a contradiction doesn't tell me where you get the bad from. Is it just anything that's a contradiction is bad?
Speaker 3Well, I think that good is contradictory to bad. Wouldn't you agree?
Speaker 2Well?
Speaker 10Again, what is good or bad? How do you make that distinction?
Speaker 3We could just say that good is something that is logically consistent, right, something that's beneficial to us. We can have many definitions towards good. Are you saying that when you were an atheist you had no definition of what good was?
Speaker 10Well, when I was an atheist, I felt like I had to borrow from a Christian will Vie because it think that there is some sort of standard that says this thing good, that thing bad, at least not that I can find or can point to you.
Speaker 1Here's why I'll chime in if you don't mind, is so come join the dark side, Bob okay? And that I am. You know, I take a different opinion from board, and I think most atheists, you know, from what I've seen. Right, when they do surveys on philosophers, and particularly philosophers of ethics, most of them believe in objective morality. So I understand that I'm in the minority opinion, but I share some of the same concerns you do as far as how do we define that good or bad? I do think
Speaker 1it's arbitrary. I do think it's arbitrary. It boils down to weird human beings, and we have interests and we're trying to balance out those interests, and some interests we may find more valuable than others. How do you figure out which ones are more valuable than others? You can use some logic, you can use some reason, but there's going to be some limitations.
Speaker 4Right.
Speaker 1It's ultimately going to boil down to what works best for people. And that's my take on it, right, So that's going to be different from somebody who does believe in objective morality and does think that these things can be completely reasoned out. So you know, your results may vary, But I guess the greater point I'm trying to make here is with atheism, there's still ways you can do that and even not believe in objective morality. Obviously, there are atheists that do believe in objective morality, but there's also ways you can do it and not have that similar kind of framework. Does that make sense, No.
Speaker 9It makes sense. So the moral argument was just one of my examples.
Speaker 10I don't know if we've got time to kind of go into the cosmological one and again, do we have times let or should we end it?
Speaker 1So I would say, if we you've spoken with us for ten minutes, we've done about fifteen minutes for each person before, I can give you another five minutes if that works for you, But I'm gonna be strict on that because we got other callers that want to talk to us too.
Speaker 3Okay, Yeah, I have a million more questions for you as well, Bob. Yeah, I hope that you call back at another time when I'm co hosting as well, because I have more questions about you know, God is good?
Speaker 1Then yeah, so let's be quick. So if you could just briefly restate your your cosmological argument here and you can address that.
Speaker 10Yeah, so give the premises. But the premises I think are I mean, they're important, but it's the actualizing an infinite that's important for this conversation. So cosmological argument would be something like, you know, trying to think now with the first two premises, it's something like, if the universe began to exist, it had a cause. From a number two is something like the universe began to exist, and then the conclusion is therefore the.
Speaker 9Universe has a cause something like that.
Speaker 10But I'm less interested because in that conversation, because I mean, like, there's plenty of scientific theory like the Big Bang right that shows or at least tends to show that there is a finite past the universe began to exist at a certain point.
Speaker 4We can talk about thermodynamics.
Speaker 10We're not going to get into all that. My thing was more about having actualizing an infinite right because I think one of the things that a lot of atheist did becot myself included is I would try to escape the finite past of the universe by saying, well, realistically, the universe could be infinite, it could have always existed, which again there's issues with that when you talk about entropy, right, like we probably would have run out of juice at this point. But actualizing an infinite past and or adding to an actual incident so both of those arguments are
Speaker 10independent of one another. If one fails, the other, one's still doubt. It seems to me like it's really hard to actualize an incidite. And the way that I would describe, at least the first premise would be, if you look at time as just a series of events, right, if there were an actual infinite number of events before today, you would never arrive at today now. The addition by or realizing an actual incident. By successive addition would be, if you had an actual infinite deck of cards, how would you add a card at the end of the deck, which would be kind of like the present day.
Speaker 1So well, goodness, Bob. Maybe I was mistaken. Maybe we don't have time to go into this, you know, and that's my bad. I shouldn't have said that we do, because I would, you know, I want to make sure that I'm getting my other calls a chance to speak to Let's just say this point. You know, the cosmological argument has been brought up not just on this show, but also on the Athist Experience. I think other people have talked about it, perhaps even more briefly and succinctly than I will address it here. But my main criticism with most forms of the cosmological argument, because there are many,
Speaker 1but you know, I'll bring this criticism up and maybe we could talk about it at another time is you can talk about whether the universe has a beginning or not and the consequences of that all day, but I don't think that connects you to the God belief or a God claim of really any kind. All it really talks about is that the universe and its origins, and I think the idea that this has to be necessary for a God claim, and then of course later on Christianity as apologists try to bring that in, I think
Speaker 1isn't necessary and and isn't related or relevant actually to the argument's consequence, because whether it does or doesn't again just doesn't lead credence either way. The Bible in particular doesn't talk about any of these ideas. It has a very specific account of origins of nature, and it isn't what anything in cosmology describes, despite what many Christians claim to be. And I'm sorry, I'm sorry to not give you enough time to counter that, but we should probably end things here, just not so we're not getting too
Speaker 1much to the weeds. But again other callers have called in about it. I encourage you looking at those or if you're unsatisfied, hey callin next week. I'll be hosting. I'll give you the time of day. But you know, just for timesake, I think I want to move on, if that's okay with you, Bob, So thank you for calling in. If now just say ditto, yeah, yeah, all right, sounds good, Bob, thanks so much, well mannered, polite, gave us thoughts, complicated thoughts, not pretentious though. Thanks Bob again, I'm sorry, but you know, Ray was on something man,
Speaker 1that was crazy, that that was something else. Keep thinking.
Speaker 3I'd like to see him streamline his thoughts and see what happened.
Speaker 2You know, I'd like to see.
Speaker 1Bob and Ray talk to each other and see how that goes. I'd support Bob in that conversation, I think. But yeah, you know, I agree briefly speak to this because you know, Kelly shaking his head of this. I do think morality is complicated exactly for what happened here, because because Born and I have different ideas about morality, very different. I don't believe it objective morality and you do that that is going to lead us to very different ways of how we argue on this particular point.
Speaker 1That was not two people versus one, that was a three way competition right there on ideas. And I think that's a problem with with atheism. It's a problem with how we can talk about morality because we don't have this consensus and I don't I don't necessarily think we should. I'm just pointing out that this is this is a more complicated issue than a lot of people give it credit for.
Speaker 2So I agree, yeah, I agree, one hundred percent.
Speaker 1Yeah. And so with that, let's let's keep it moving. We have so many great callers today. Before we keep moving, I just want to give a quick shout out to some people. One of course, is the wonderful, fantastic, amazing, stupend is crew that helped make this show happen every single week. Shout outs to the crew. There's our crew, camera, and all the folks that help make the show and folks who aren't on camera as well, who are making the show happen today. Thank you to everybody that does that. You know, this show is part of the production of
Speaker 1a nonprofit organization. Most of us that work on it are volunteers and so we We love doing the work that we do and thank you all for doing it. We really appreciate all of our volunteers. If you like this show and you want to, you know, tell us how much you like it or tell us how much you hate it. You know you can do that too. It's truth at Atheist Hyphencommunity dot org. Or you can reach out to the ACA at TV at Atheist Hyphencommunity dot org and of course see what's going on on our website at Atheist Guess What Hyphencommunity dot org. Those
Speaker 1are ways to do it. Let's check the super chats. We had fort nine nine from a G three three seven three who said the nerds are here to support and gave five dollars. Thank you so much for that super chat. And the other super chat came from It's Christina Carroll who gave two dollars and said board is amazing. I agree, Board is amazing. Yeah, thanks so much for giving the support there. And you've been a great show so far. Really, I shout some people out really quick. Gave your show shout out. Yeah, shout out to the
Speaker 1TikTok crew. You guys are going crazy over there.
Speaker 3I saw all those gifts all those comments flying in all those taps. You guys are absolutely incredible. I so so so appreciate all of the support, and I hope you guys enjoyed the show.
Speaker 2It was absolutely incredible. I loved it.
Speaker 1Heck yeah, well not over yet. We still got at least one of the callers. You want to keep talking to people, right, No, no, Kelly says, no, we don't have talk. I don't have time. Oh I thought we have more time off.
Speaker 2Dan, They're kicking us out.
Speaker 1They're kicking us out. Okay, I'm sorry, we got to wrap things up. I thought we had time for one more. I'm so sorry call with that on the line here. We're gonna save you maybe for the next show here, but we got we gotta wrap things up. See, we didn't have time after all. I thought we could do it. Well, that's me adjusting to this new Sunday schedule. Sorry about that, folks, But in any case, I want to give thanks again to you Board for being on the show with us today. Was great, So much for having me. If people want to find you, where should they go?
Speaker 3Yeah, I'm on TikTok at Board Agnostic, I'm on YouTube at Leaving the Fold I'm on Instagram at Leaving the Fold. Uh, I'm in all of these places, posting constantly. I'm live on TikTok twice a week. Like I said earlier, I do one on one conversation slash debates on Wednesday evenings and then like all day on Sunday. So after the Atheist experience, after truth wanted, after talk Hevan, come hang out with me on TikTok.
Speaker 2I'd love to have you guys all over there.
Speaker 1Hell yeah, and let's bring Let's bring Kelly up real quick, because I know he's been yelling at me this entire time. Tell me the show's over. Sorry, Kelly, I'm not used to the time. I thought we had more time, but that's me. You're right, You're right.
Speaker 11I had to do a quick I just said, don't even bother bringing me up to so no, but.
Speaker 1I'm doing it because you're a backup host today and I got to give you thanks for being a good backup hoost.
Speaker 11I appreciate it, and I appreciate all of you, bored you are incredible today. I had so much I want to talk about, but you know I don't have the time. So thanks everybody for coming and watching the show stick around. He's going to be right back up in a minute, and we're gonna be back next week with another incredible show, hopefully as good as this one.
Speaker 1I hope so too. I think it will be. Well, folks, that's gonna be it for this episode of Truth Wanted. I'm objectively Dan. Remember to always keep one the truth. We'll see you next time. Bye bye, everybody.
Speaker 3M M.
Speaker 1Watch talk ee Than Live Sundays at one pm Central. Visit tiny dot c c slash y t t H and call into the show at five one two nine nine one nine two four two, or connect to the show online at tiny dot c c slash call th H
In today's episode of Truth Wanted, ObjectivelyDan welcomes guest Out Of Body Atheist, with The Beard of Empathy on backup, to dig into Reiki, New Age spirituality, homeopathy, and the long road from woo to skepticism!...
In today's episode of Truth Wanted, Jon the Skeptick, Volcy, and Sofia Spina explain why no one can talk to the dead, from Haitian Vodou and grief dreams to Jon's past as a spiritualist! Bob jumps from objective...
In today's episode of Truth Wanted, ObjectivelyDan and Nintendrew, later joined by The Beard of Empathy, tackle a world run on Jesus, the magic of manifesting, and a prayer that actually got answered! Bob in NY, a...
In today's episode of Truth Wanted, ObjectivelyDan, Kelley Laughlin, and The Beard of Empathy tackle standards of evidence, miracle claims, and the false binaries of moral philosophy! Dean in VA questions why skeptics...
In today's episode of Truth Wanted, ObjectivelyDan and Chad Harris tackle Christian nationalism, police brutality, and the uncomfortable truths about racism and immigration. Big E in TN survived police brutality and...