In today’s final 2024 episode of Truth Wanted, ObjectivelyDan, Kelley Laughlin, and Jon the Skeptic go to Antarctica and hang out in seminary school to find that the death of Jesus was stolen before spinning in Roman manufactured circles that spiraled them straight to Mars where tiny creatures roam. Race Bannon in Texas calls to talk about The Final Experiment that happened this week where a bunch of people visited Antarctica to prove that the sun does not set. Have we finally put this silly argument to rest? A lot of flat earthers are also young earth creationists because of you guessed it, the Bible. It turns out that feeling strongly about this kind of stuff gets more people to vote than science does and that is the world we live in. Charles in Scotland grew up in a secular household, became a Christian for ten years, and deconverted after going to seminary, earning three theological degrees with a PHD. How did your parents feel about you going down this road? He focused on what the author was trying to say to the audience and realized there were so many problems with the Bible that it was basically myth. Why should we care what the authors of one Biblical book say vs. another? What is different now from when you were a believer? Jesus Tales in NC describes a story in Joshua 10 where a king was hung on a tree and put in a cave with rocks at the entry. Are you saying that the author of Mark borrowed from the author of Joshua? Stories of Jesus can be taken back to other pre-Old Testament stories. Mike in FL calls in to give a different perspective on why man created god and it was as a symbolic representation of specific effects. You understand that we can’t just boil this down to a single sentence, right? How do we get to where the Roman people manufactured Christ? Why do you believe this? We can’t explain why people believe why Jesus died for their sins; there will be tons of answers. Not all Christians follow the Bible to a literal degree. What are you even talking about? Write out what you are going to say first and get yourself together next time. Daniel in Canada calls to talk about some proxy war that is happening between him and another caller that involves using the real name of another caller just to troll him. What is going on guys? Why are you using this show to insult people? Once we get into the reason for the call, Daniel brings up how interesting some of the photos are that we are seeing on Mars, and how NASA is covering up the beings that are going underground on Mars. What do you think is the motive for this cover up? Create a Google Doc for this and share it! Thank you for tuning in this week. Question of the week is: What was the cringiest thing that happened to you in 2024? Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/truth-wanted--3195473/support.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Speaker 1There's a well known story about some ghosts visiting a man at this time of year to help him change his ways. What better way to enjoy the upcoming holidays than for Dan to embody the ghost of the past, John Me to be present, and Kelly to be our ghost of yet to come? Do supernatural visitations happen? Can those visits help folks to change who they are? Have you had an encounter that you can't explain that made you change how you think about everything? Give us a call because the show is about to start.
Speaker 2Oh, poor John John John John John almost never does the intro, and the one time that's the intro, we don't clip away and we don't switch away in the time that we need you. But that's okay.
Speaker 1I like my smile just progressively got bigger. Now my face really hurts.
Speaker 2Can I just say to you? Actually, first, let me introduce myself. I'm objectively Dan. This is Truth Wanted, the live calling show that happens every single week Fridays at seven BM Central time. We talk to you folks at home about what you believe and why, and if you'd like to call us, you can certainly do that. The lines are in fact open. It is five one two nine nine one nine two four two, or you can call through your computer at tiny dot cc slash call tw and Truth Wanted is a product of the Atheist Community of Austin, a five oh one c three nonprofit organization dedicated to the promotion of atheism, critical thinking, secular humanism,
Speaker 2and the separation of religion and government. And every single week, folks, I'm always joined by a special guest. This week's no different. I got two of them on the show with me. We got Kelly Laughlin and John the Skeptic joining me for the last show of twenty twenty four Fellas, how you're doing great intro, John Fantamp.
Speaker 1Really although the pause of my.
Speaker 2Face it was a very dramatic pause, I like that.
Speaker 1I feel like that's just setting me up full next year's hate comments against maw. Here's so, if you listen to this show and you listen to the audio version of the show, like on Spotify, right, they they you know, if you don't have Spotify Premium whatever, like, they'll play ads at the beginning. And John, your voice acting is just so fucking immaculate. I worry that people are going to try to skip ahead as soon as you talk, because they think.
Speaker 2There's another fucking ad going like that's out. No, no, you're just you're so clean with it, dude, Like that intro was I was almost going to do the intro, which is a shame because first of all John wrote it. But also come on, listen to that voice.
Speaker 1Beautiful, beautiful, stop it.
Speaker 2We wouldn't want it any other way. But folks, like I said, this is the last episode of Truth Wanted for twenty twenty four. Next week we'll have a little something special for you, but it will be all stuff that's you know, not live. So if you'll want to get your calls in, if you got your conspiracies, if you got your religious claims or lack thereof, uh, you know, whatever you want, just call in because we want to hear from you. We do have some open lines and we want to talk to you. And of course we've got three people on the pod today, which you know is not something we do every week. So it's a
Speaker 2special time, is what I'm trying to say. So special time should mean a special.
Speaker 1Call, right, I think maybe we will have the call that changes everything for us, as is the way with the Three Ghosts. Visited Scrooge.
Speaker 3Right, maybe this would be the week that we get convinced that ghosts are real.
Speaker 2Yeah, we should have all dressed up as ghosts. We should have Yeah, that could have been cool. Oh well, it's too much, too much planning for a bit that probably wouldn't pay off, I think. But hey, uh, the prompt for this week. Sorry, well, I'm getting ahead of myself because I have to talk to you guys about a little segment that we do every week, and it is that we want the truth segment our ww TT you know, kind of doing a whole WWJD vibe. I don't know if anyone's actually picked up on that, but that's like the intention of why we say that an acronym parbat. Anyway, last week we asked you guys what
Speaker 2really triggered the War on Christmas? And here are our favorite answers from that. Number three comes from Jica atheists, who said, what really started the War on Christmas? The New Jersey drones were taking all of the elves jobs. Incredible, incredible stuff. And I was just saying, I forgot because I meant to read last week's comments and I did not, And I'm sure y'all had some spicy takes about the drone situation and everything else, so maybe we'll talk more about that today. But man, last week was a really killer episode. If you'll have watched last week's they went
Speaker 2a little off the rails. But number two and our answers this week comes from Godwin Underscore seven, who says the War on Christmas obviously began when Saint Nicholas said he was more popular than Jesus, And I wonder is that true today, because you know, they do those polls where it's like, oh McDonald's logo is more recognizable than the Cross, like you think that works with like like Jesus in Santa Claus.
Speaker 1We feel like if you ask that question in March, Jesus is going to win it. But this time of year, I'm sorry, jolly old Nick, he's going to win it.
Speaker 2Yeah.
Speaker 3Yeah, it's hard to say, though. I think a lot of people would lie and say Jesus Ooh.
Speaker 2You know what though, you're probably right, Yeah, that's like a question. People would lie on the poles just to inflate the numbers. Talk about election fraud. That's it right there, pulling for who's more popular. But our number one answer this week is really good comes from know what and they said it began with the forging of the Great Rings. Three were given to the alms, the craftiest and most oppressed of Santis workers. So that's awesome. That is our answer. It's a number one answer. But this last week, thank
Speaker 2you to everybody who contributed to this segment because you all are very funny, of course, and the prompt for this week is going to be what was the cringiest thing that happened to you in twenty twenty four? No political answers, that's part of the prompt. Okay, So that's what we got for this year, or it's our last question for this year. I should say so again if you haven't commented all year, hey, why not do it just this one time, just for us? Please, pretty please you want me to beg because you know we can
Speaker 2do that, and just kid, I'm not gonna beg, but I will ask nicely. You know, it's a good thing to do. What was the cringiest thing that happened to you guys in twenty twenty four?
Speaker 1I I lost my job because I didn't believe in the same thing as the people that fired me. So I guess that's kind of cringey.
Speaker 2Oh man, yeah, I don't have we talked about that on the show. I don't know that you have. Maybe some folks might not be aware of that, but yes, you were. You were in fact persecuted because of your black thereof Yeah. Yeah, yeah, that was pretty cringey. Yeah, I would say so, I would agree with you. Yeah, but you're doing something new now and it's better. Yeah. Okay, so that's good. So there's a happy any of that. Yeah.
Speaker 1Yeah, and it took like nine months, but that's fine. Nine months of tears and worry, that's fine.
Speaker 2Yeah. Well i'm again, I'm I'm happy that you are in a better place then, because when that happened, I, like everybody else, was really shocked, but unfortunately not surprised in some ways, especially for where you're at, well into Kentucky. Yeah, you know, that's definitely thing. What about you, kel you got a cringey thing that happed to you this year?
Speaker 3Yeah, but I don't want to bring everybody down, but yeah, my mom died this year, so that was probably the cree for me.
Speaker 2Oh, Nelly, that's not what cringey means.
Speaker 3It was pretty cringey.
Speaker 2What it's Oh my god.
Speaker 4You know what was.
Speaker 3Really funny was somebody like going through her papers. We were finding out all these things about her that we didn't know, and some of that was pretty cringey, Like we found out that and so I'm including this as like part of my mom dying, but like one of the things we found out that she was a big amiss for six years. What, Yeah, my mom was a big amiss for six years?
Speaker 2How did you figure that out?
Speaker 3Because we found her divorce papers from her first husband, who was my father, And in the divorce papers, it mentioned that they had a son who was seven years old, and I was like, wait a minute, I was that should say seven months. That's a typo because they split up right when, right after I was born. And then we looked at the date on it, and sure enough, she didn't divorce my my father, her first husband until after she had been married to her second husband for six years.
Speaker 2Wow.
Speaker 3Well, yeah, that was kind of cringey. And what was even cringeier was going through some of the letters that she left behind where she like wrote down like explicit sexual things that she had experienced. So that was kind of cringey.
Speaker 2Reading that. That was not what I was expecting to do. You know, I was just gonna say about me saying something stupid on the show or something.
Speaker 5But you know, you take the cake, Kelly, you win, Okay, I can't. I can't beat that. So anyway, Uh, for the folks at home, you should leave your comment below, and please unless it's funny or no, no.
Speaker 2I'm not even his say that. Just I don't involve people dying. Please, you know, that's a real vibe killer. I don't want to have to read the comment next week or no week after and then be like, oh, yeah, this is the thing. Okay, but you know, crany things not political, you know, because we want you to be creative. We want to be something from your personal life. That's the goal here and you know, even below and we'll take a look at it. But damn, Kelly, Okay.
Speaker 3Wow, I don't questions again?
Speaker 6Right all right?
Speaker 2Oh that's uh yeah, that's a lot to follow up on. I'm not gonna lie. How do we transition from that? What do we talk about now?
Speaker 1I could just stare at the camera again for another.
Speaker 2Well, folks, Uh, this is the like I said last show of the year, I have to say this year in terms of truth Wanted has been really interesting. We've had a lot of cool people on the show. We've had a lot of interesting conversations, and a lot of folks that have become like repeat callers this year, which has been really interesting. I don't know, I've been pretty happy with what we've done so far, and we got to twenty five thousand subscribers, so hopefully we do double that this next year. I mean, why not at this point? Right?
Speaker 2Of course, you know have to thank everybody that helps with the atheist medium Austin that helps with the show every single week, but also viewers at home for you guys watching and supporting the show and continue to make this show as awesome as it is, because it wouldn't be anything without any viewers, right, So thank you for that from the bottom of my heart. I don't know what about you, guys, So how do you feel about this year?
Speaker 1I'll give the bottom of my heart too, because it means a lot to me to be able to come on and just hang out with really lovely, like minded people and just talk to people about stuff, and it doesn't matter what the stuff is. It's just a good time. And I'm like, I know, there's not Thanksgiving anymore, We're going on to another holiday.
Speaker 2But I am thankful to be involved with something like this. Yeah, yeah, it's true. And I'm glad you get to come here too, John, especially since you got you got a lot going on with your family right now. You're having to deal with stuff that I'm I'm really glad I don't have to deal with at least right now. So you know, make it it on Friday night. You know that that means a lot. We appreciate.
Speaker 1It's st also a bit of an escape for me, So I'm glad.
Speaker 2Yeah, yeah, I hear.
Speaker 1It's a little bit of time to myself.
Speaker 2Oh we already got a super chat here. Who is responding to our our chat here? It is from Nero who says, cringiest event this year for me drop out of college in spring for financial reasons. Forgot all I learned in debt. Oh no, that it went off the screen there, let me see if maybe no, there we go in debt for twelve thousand dollars for it all, and they gave five dollars. Why are you giving five dollars to us? You need to put that five dollars debt of twelve thousands. Oh my god, thousand. Nero com
Speaker 2gonna be fair.
Speaker 3Five bucks isn't going to put too big of a dentive.
Speaker 2I hear it, But that makes me feel bad now, I man, I appreciate it. I'm not going to refund it or anything, but like, yeah, that all goes the ACA, right, But anyway, take it up with them if you want to back that's all. Say. No, that's a that is a you know what. You went to college, though, and you may think you forgot some stuff, but maybe maybe it's still in there and you just got to activate. Maybe it's got the friends you made along the way. Do you everythink that's.
Speaker 1Also transitioning from short term memory to long term memory?
Speaker 2You just give it a chance, give it a chance, give it a chance, give it a shot. I'm starting to become one of those people where I'm like, maybe college obviously college isn't for everybody, but like the way that I see the job market now these days, I'm just like, man, I don't know if you really do need a college degree for a lot of shit. You really don't. You really don't, So hey, good luck general, hopefully life you know helps you out this next year, twenty twenty five, I'm rooting for you.
Speaker 3It was strange to me, like in the in the nineteen eighties when they started transitioning our economy to a service economy, that they were also encouraging people that they had to go get a college education to work in the service industry. And that was Yeah, it was just seemed like so not smart.
Speaker 2I just, you know, I came from a generation where it was like everybody needs to get a degree, everybody has to get a degree, and if you want to do anything, and all my friends have degrees and are in debt and aren't working the greatest jobs ever. I'm actually really lucky in that regard because I actually I switched to a different person this year and I got a title change and I and twenty twenty four has been really good to me. And I wish that, you know, that blessings, those blessings I've gotten for everybody else because shit's hard. Shit's fucking hard out there, you know, especially
Speaker 2around this time of year. So I don't know, I don't know. I'm not trying to make this intil like a Moblin sort of episode. It's just kind of naturally we can they I think it all stand from Kelly, you know, so I'm blaming with dog.
Speaker 5I'll take it away anyway.
Speaker 2I don't know what the fucking go from here, guys. You guys just want you guys want to jump into some calls. You want to just get right to it.
Speaker 1Let's stop. That's the only way we can go.
Speaker 2All right. Before we get to the calls. I do have to thank the awesome patrons because every single week we're giving a shout out to the patron of the week. We give a shout out to everybody that donates on the patreon. So if you want to become Patron of the week, just donate to the patreon and we'll get to you. But this week's Patron of the Week is going to be down Nelson. Thank you so much, Don Nelson, and thank you to everybody that donates on the patreon. You guys are amazing. And that's tied on cc slash patreon t W. If you want to support the show,
Speaker 2like I said, that doesn't go to me. That goes to the atheist community of Austin and it says, hey, this is a show worth supporting. So if you feel that way, Donating on Patreon is a great way to show your support. And with that out of the way, folks, let's get to our first call of the night. First one we got on the docket. Race Bannon, Race mannon calling in from Texas, Race Band and you are Alive on Truth Wanted, what's going on?
Speaker 7Great name, what a great panel? The Floating Circle, mister Geology and Dan the Man. I'm happy to get great.
Speaker 2It's a panel. It's a panel. I'll tell you that. It is a group of human beings. So happy to hear from you. A race ban and what's going on?
Speaker 7Great covert, great cover on the on the delay there. If I were you, I would have just have sunk down in the chair out of such.
Speaker 1I should have grudually got closer to the camera, just his eyeball.
Speaker 2We're supposed to be dead quiet during those intros, and like I just had to fill the space in with my laughter to help John because it was just getting to that point like a like like a frog in a in a boiler like he was just he was ready to jump.
Speaker 8You know.
Speaker 2Anyway, what can we do for your race?
Speaker 7Well, I wanted to talk about the final experiment that happened this weekend and the general anti science sentiment. But before I do that, I had a challenge for the ACA. I've stumbled across a number of great channels. Holy kool Aid, Simon Dan, the usual Apology, all the regulars, but with somebody at ACA put together a master list of YouTube channels that I should be following. Can somebody do that please?
Speaker 1There is one around somewhere I don't can I can find one to hand it to the a C. So it comes from them and they can vet it. But there is a very comprehensive list around somewhere.
Speaker 2I think that gets really weird really fast, because I don't know if the ACA, as a nonprofit wants to endorse like to individual YouTubers. I think there's an issue with that. We're okay doing it as host because we're like volunteers, right, we don't officially represent the ACA and its position. So I can tell you know who who I think is cool. I just had lunch with Holy kool Aid like a few weeks ago, and he's doing all right, So you know, that's a guy that I definitely think is cool. But you know, I think if you go on the discord which is also a fan run space. There's PROBA probably like people there who could
Speaker 2tell you who to watch, and I'm sure there's they've got something on there, but I don't know.
Speaker 1Of course, as well, there's non profits and Atheist Experience and TOLK.
Speaker 3Yes, right, yeah, so there's a list of those three.
Speaker 2Y yeah, I got we got like six years of truth Want episodes is a backlog, so you know you can start with that. I'd say, okay, well.
Speaker 7The reason I called you most I'm sure all of you are familiar with the Final Experiment, right.
Speaker 2Yeah, yep, yep, very full for those who are artful, we're watching at home. So basically, you know how flat earthers are, like, hey, Antarctica is like not a thing or is a thing, but like is hidden for parts of it whatever. Basically, a group of people paid for a bunch of flat earthers to take a boat and go see Antarctica themselves, and that's that's what just happened recently. So yeah, yeah.
Speaker 7Well and to prove that the sun does not sit this time of.
Speaker 2Year, yes, that was part of it too, yeah yeah, but also just Antartica would be kind of cool as well, Like that's what I would be there for. I already know the sign SATs, you know what I mean. You don't have to do that for me, but I guess for them that's a big deal.
Speaker 7Well, that's that's the tip of the haha, Iceberg. All the photos we have of distant galaxies and detailed photos of planets and et cetera, et cetera, apparently that's all fake. Of course, you spent decades and decades making fake photographs of the Andromeda galaxy and et cetera, et cetera. Why would anyone do that? What's what's the point? If we're under a if we're in a terrarium, if there's a dome affirmament, why would anybody waste the time to convince people that there are extraterrestrial objects? Does it makes no
Speaker 7sense whatsoever?
Speaker 2I do think that's like one of the bigger weaknesses is Yeah, Like that's one of the bigger weaknesses of the flat Earth position, besides the fact that it doesn't make any sense, like besides like the very obvious scientific stuff, like the motivation just isn't there, Like I don't know, like there's a lot of conspiracy theories where you can at least that you can assign a motive, right, But like here, I don't even know what the motive is. What are you saying? Oh, they don't want to know the most common thing I've heard, right is that you know, in the Bible, the Bible says that the Earth is flat.
Speaker 2That's what some of them will say. A lot of flat Earthers are also youngerth creationists. There's like a commingling in that space. So the idea is that as part of Satan's agenda right to teach you of the secular world and to keep you from knowing Christ, is to also teach you of a globe Earth rather than a flat Earth, which is a stretch. But like you know, that's the most that willingly can make sense, I guess, because why would you not why would you cover that up? Otherwise it just doesn't really do anything, doesn't make sense.
Speaker 7Well, anyone else want to speak on that, because I can't believe that they don't know that scientists are hugely competitive. All it would take is one or two scientists to step out and say, look, I approve of the flat Earth. You've all been lied to. That guy would get the Nobel Prize. Scientists constantly try to prove each other wrong. That's how science works.
Speaker 2That's true, that's true. The problem is you become a flat earth. You say that, So you do lose a little bit of credibility, I think, and rightfully so, I'd say.
Speaker 3Scientists are very competitive, though, I will give you that.
Speaker 7Yeah, yeah, yeah, And that is kind of how science works. You don't try to prove yourself right. You try to find ways to make yourself wrong. And if you can't make yourself wrong, it becomes accepted, it becomes accepted as an aposto's theory or fact. But on the in the in the larger view, the incredible upsurge of anti science sentiment has real world effects. Look at the vaccine deniers jeesus, right, you know, not not trusting what we what is established fairly well as reality can kill people.
Speaker 2Yeah, there's definitely that's definitely a big problem with part of it. And people will take advantage of anti vaccine sentiment or vaccine hesitancy as they call it sentiment, right, people who either don't really care either way, right, who care about winning a constituency over I regret not mentioning this last week because there's a lot of competing ideas when talking about the drone sightings that have recently been happening. And one thing that has been cited in the drones favor right or in the drune sidings favor as something
Speaker 2that should be something we should be worried about. Is there a lot of politicians that have come up and said, Hey, this is something we should be worried about. The mayor of such and such and the governor of such and such as all been saying, hey, we need to take this stuff seriously. And the truth is they may actually care and they may not give a shit at all. Because either way, when you appeal to that and you say there's a base that actually cares about this, you are winning over some votes. Right. So there is like a political motive to both anti vaccine you know, sentiment and the drone siding stuff and even an anti science
Speaker 2stuff to a degree because there are people who do feel strongly about that stuff and they will win those votes over. It turns out feeling really strongly about that stuff gets more people to vote then, just like accepting that science is real. So you know, that's the world we live in.
Speaker 7Yeah, Science, for the most part is not is not sexy. It takes a lot of time and a lot of effort to understand some some of where we are in the realm of science these days. And most people would rather watch ancient aliens, you know, they don't they don't want they don't want good explanations. They want fun explanation. Maybe I'm cynical, I don't know.
Speaker 1But that's why we've got great people like Professor Brian Cox who started presenting all this stuff. And I'm just like a bit of a fango when it comes to Professor Brian Cox. I love him and Forest and Forrest right.
Speaker 3Right, people who can really communicate science to others. And what's really good is what's really good is they're able to communicate it well to young people so that they grow up with maybe with a thirst for science. I took my son once to a an open house at the Fermi Lab. We got invitations because I was a local scientist and they sent me some. It was really cool and we got this we got a tour of the collider. It was amazing. But they had a presentation with a guy who was doing the liquid nitrogen, you know,
Speaker 3freezing balloons and breaking them as like as glass and my son was about eight years old and he just stood wide I set wide eyed through the whole presentation. And I was just talking to him a couple of weeks ago and he told me that was what really interested him and being a scientist today. So yeah, it's if you can communicate well the children, like like both of those can, that's a big, big plus to further science in the future that we're building young scientists by doing that kind of a thing. I wish I was much better talking to children than I am, but yeah,
Speaker 3it's good to see people out there doing it.
Speaker 7Yeah, well they're unruly and smelly. You're delicious, it properly cooked. But I have that much use for children. To John's point, yes, Brian Cox is amazing and he in a couple of books available for free on YouTube. Everybody should listen to Brian cox explainer.
Speaker 1I find myself just sitting watching like reel off the reel of actually forest as well, but Brian Cox, the shin numbers of the mouth stars just in the Milky Way galaxy and then like the breakdown of all that information. That's sexy to me. I find that sexy.
Speaker 2Well, you and I have different tastes and testy John, we'll put it out there. But I agree with racist sentiment though that a lot of the majority of like scientists work every day is boring to most people. Right. It's like you get to see, we get the privilege of watching PBS's Spacetime on YouTube because a bunch of people who are doing the work for that for years, you know, like that's we get the fun communication parts of the science. So I don't work as a scientist, and thank goodness, I don't. I'd be terrible at it.
Speaker 2I would get the numbers mixed up and something would go wrong. It would be really bad. So I don't know. I'm thankful for the folks that do do the work that is boring, so that folks like Forrest can have the fun parts of also doing science. So he is a real scientist, does science, but like doing fun YouTube stuff because like, you know, that part's way cooler and more interesting to me than having to type up reports every day on observations. I don't know, That's just me though.
Speaker 7We're lucky to have as many good science communicators as we do, starting with Isaac Asimov and then then Carl Sagan and now Neil Degress Tyson and Brian Knx. It's it's important to break that stuff down so some of us little chickens get a few crumbs.
Speaker 2Right, Yeah, yeah, I agree with you. Hopefully, hopefully the world will also agree with us one day. It doesn't seem to be in our favorite at this point in time, but I don't know. There's waves of these things. I feel like public sentiment can change, and probably will.
Speaker 7People are attracted to the fun stuff, the ancient aliens, you know, the pyramid power, the cryptid sightings, et cetera. And those are fascinating, but they require no mental acuity whatsoever. Real science is much more fascinating to me.
Speaker 2Yeah again, it's the paperwork doesn't for me. Man, I ain't about it. But you know what again, real you want to be on that team. You want to be on that doing that work. That's cool, that's all you. I'll let you do it. Race, not me, though, you know.
Speaker 7I have one last have one last thing, one last thing. Daniel push back on me a little bit last week and last week's show he called me out by name, which I don't mind. That's fine, he uses his name.
Speaker 2You called it to be fair. Race you called him out by name first, Okay, so you know, if anybody who's starting some shit, it was you. Okay, I'm a you know, let's let's call a spade a spade. Okay, ever used mine?
Speaker 7He uses his name, Daniel, I didn't use mine.
Speaker 2Oh yeah, but he was. But you made comments about him though. You were making comments about him, and he responded to your comments, is what I'm saying.
Speaker 7Well, I'm I want then, That's why I want to respond to him. Now. He was all right about the insect TOID. He's all about the insect TOID on Mars. That heed, he sent you photos of the rock formation that he claimed was an insect, and he totally backed off that. He totally went away from the insect on Mars and it's now on some other, some other moon of Jupiter or something. So if he can prove there's an insectoid on Mars which he sent you photos of, I'd like him to respond to that. I'd like him
Speaker 7to reaffirm his belief in an insect being on Mars.
Speaker 2Oh my god, I can't. I might am I hosting a roxy war via call in show right now, because like this is you put me in a weird spot in your race. I'm just a messenger, you understand, Like this needs to be put on an internet for him somewhere.
Speaker 3Okay, this kind of reminds me of This kind of reminds me of the competitiveness among scientists trying to out do.
Speaker 2Through the worst medium possible.
Speaker 9Uh.
Speaker 7Well, last week's show, I said, I'm glad that you're giving him oxygen to continue to espouse his beliefs. So yes, I invite debate.
Speaker 2I mean that's great, race. I just you know, maybe one day, here's what we gotta do. We gotta have like two calls in at the same time and then have the callers just fight it out and then we don't have to do anything that week. That'd be kind of sweet.
Speaker 1Huh, Like when you get cool to foster food chains and do you get them to order from each other like that?
Speaker 9Right?
Speaker 2Exactly, Yes, that's regular needs to be. Here's what he's happened to. I think Daniel should post all of his evidence on it on a web page somewhere. He needs to get and I and listen, the crustier the better, I'm talking like geo cities page up with all the photos, right and like I want handwritten HTML. Okay, Like that's what I want to see and like that way we can all look at it together at the same time and have a discussion on if we leave comments on it, that'd be even better, you know. So I don't know something to think about there. But maybe Daniel will call
Speaker 2back today and also respond to you. We'll see. But Race, I think that's all the time we got for you. Now, anything else you want to add before we let you go.
Speaker 7I do have one quick question for Kelly. Kelly, I think you learned this week about the parrot sculpture on Mars. Do you know about that?
Speaker 3No, that's a good one. Now now you got me totally curious. I'm looking it up right now on parents.
Speaker 7Just google parrots sculpture on Mars. You'll be delighted.
Speaker 3Nice, Thank you so much. I love stuff like this. Oh wow, yeah, look at that.
Speaker 2Than have a great Christmas.
Speaker 7Merry Christmas.
Speaker 2Yeah, you two, you two have a great holiday season. We'll see you. We'll see you next time and next year for that matter, I say Christmas that time too. I didn't even say happy holidays, you know what I mean? Like, I'm not even a good atheist.
Speaker 1About that about that, because the people do get slightly offended when you don't say merry Christmas. Right yeah sure where I where I'm from, Mary means tipsy. So when people wish me a merry Christmas, I'm just like, you want me to get drunk? Okay, yes, but also yeah, okay, I'm telling that that's fine. I'll have a merry Christmas.
Speaker 2I have never I just don't know anybody that gives a ship. Honestly, I don't think I've ever met anybody in my life who actually has ever unoffended or has like been like, oh, we need to change this conversation. I just don't think people care enough.
Speaker 1I do know of one person who does say, no, you've got that wrong.
Speaker 2It's merry Christmas.
Speaker 1It has to be merry Christmas, has to be merry Christmas.
Speaker 2Yeah okay, well yeah, that's the thing. I've only ever heard it the other way. I've only ever heard it has to be a merry Christmas. I've never heard it as oh, like you know, you can't say happy Holidays, or I don't know, it's it's very silly, silly, silly.
Speaker 1But I will have a merry Christmas. This year because I'm not driving.
Speaker 2So there you go. That's how you do it. That's how you do it. But yeah, I don't know how I feel again about being a host of a proxy war between two callers. Listen, I am interested in bug people on Mars, but like we saw the photos and I wasn't impressed. If we have other photos to review, that would be something maybe we could talk about. But yeah, as far as the above people on Mars claim, I'm not I'm not there yet.
Speaker 3You know, I'm not really impressed by the parrot either.
Speaker 2We can we show that on screen, But what does it look like? Kelly here?
Speaker 3We well, you know what, I'll send a picture to the crew and let's see if they can.
Speaker 2Okay, while you're he's doing that, I'm just gonna very quickly talk about some things I need to get out of the way. One of them is about our Uh what what where is it? It's almost here? No, I don't have all my regular stuff here today. Actually, I think, uh, we have super chance. I should probably talk about that. If you guys want to ever donate on the super chance, you know that's always a thing. We will read them out loud in case you already saw the one from earlier. I also want to talk about the merch We do have merchandise right now. We're bringing back some of the
Speaker 2stuff that we've included from earlier this year and from previous years. I think as well, if you go to tiny dot cc slash merch Aca, we usually do this kind of thing around Christmas time. We we kind of bring out a lot of them merger so check that out if you haven't already. And last, but not least, I do have to think the wonderful, amazing crew that do help make this show happen every single week. I gave him a thank so, but you know what, they deserve a double thanks. Check it out. We got John greg in space is the concept of space helping us out tonight? I guess so that's really interesting. So thanks
Speaker 2for that concept of space and everybody else that else the show happened. Uh don't know it was up with that. I think that was Jason, but maybe I don't know. Maybe he wasn't there, he went to the bathroom or something. Anyway, Okay, Kelly, you got you got this set up here? What you got?
Speaker 3I sent a picture to him, so.
Speaker 2Okay, maybe maybe crew can can put a pair crew whenever you want. You know, you can just put that parrot head on screen.
Speaker 3It's the whole parrot, not just the head. It's the whole.
Speaker 2It's a whole parent, It's a whole as parrot.
Speaker 1Okay, tomorrow it's like an elephant eye it comes up, it doesn't, or maybe a blue whale. I don't know if it comes up.
Speaker 3Like I said, I wasn't really impressed. I did a picture too where they had colored in the green parrot body, so.
Speaker 2Oh I see, yeah, yeah, so I know too. We have like a really juicy voicemail that we didn't get to react to last week we had too many callers, but we might do it this week. We'll see. So you know, we always got some screenshots too, so maybe we'll get to that in a bit. But for now that we do have some more callers on the line, So let's talk to some more folks. You guys ready, Yeah, yeah, we have Charles calling from Scotland today. Charles from Scotland. You are live on truth. Wanted what's going on tonight?
Speaker 2Uh Hi?
Speaker 6I just wanted to call it because I was chatting with the couple of people in the atheist experienced stream Kelly, I talked to you a little bit and he asked, he encouraged me to call and I'm calling.
Speaker 2Okay, cool, awesome. Well, what what's up?
Speaker 4Then?
Speaker 2What's uh? What's what can we talk to you about?
Speaker 6Yeah, so a little bit about me. I'm I've been a Christian for about I was a Christian about ten years and during that time I went to earn three theological degrees, including a PhD. But near the end of my PhD, I basically deconverted.
Speaker 2Well, you got all the way to PhD before you deconverted that as wild.
Speaker 6Yeah. Yeah. Part of the reason is because I grew up in a secular household and so kind of the evangelical the emotional qualities of evangelical in my community was quite allurine, and it kind of trapped me for a bit.
Speaker 2Yeah, definitely.
Speaker 1Oh go ahead, John, So you grew up in a secular household, a household, so your parents were not were or are non believers. How did how did they feel with you going down the route of Christianity.
Speaker 6That's a good question. I'm from an ethnic group that really highly values education, and so when I told my parents that when I first became a Christian. They didn't really care that much. They were they were like, oh, you know, he's nicers, it's a good thing. But when I wanted to go to seminary and do more studies, they both they were both my father and mother were both against.
Speaker 1It, right because I mean, I'm from that side of the pond, so I kind of know how families react because largely the UK is secular. It's you know, at least fifty percent secular, and I know how my folks would feel about me doing that, So it's it's interesting to see or hear how how it would go up north as it were.
Speaker 2Johnny, you think your folks would be not supportive if you want to a seminary. Yeah.
Speaker 1I grew up in a largely spiritualist home, I guess, so we didn't have the God belief, but we had the afterlife and speaking to ghosts and all that to deal with. So I think if I was to go down another another strain of it, they might have something to say because it would then take away from the whole coming back. As you know, ghosts and how you can interact with people as and speak to people and give messages and all this stuff, so I think they would. Thankfully that's not an issue for my family. But I
Speaker 1don't even do the speaking to dead people stuff anymore, right, right? Maybe they disappointed with that.
Speaker 2Notably, Yeah, notably. If you still did, this would be a very different dynamic.
Speaker 3I was interested in what changed Charles mind?
Speaker 2Right, Yeah, yeah, tell us more about that, Charles.
Speaker 6H Yeah, just to clarify, I'm actually an American. I'm here, I'm finishing my PhD studies, So okay, gotcha, Oh okay, but uh yeah, what convinced me? It was It's quite interesting because.
Speaker 7You know I did.
Speaker 6I did my studies. You know, I delve deep into the Bible, right, so I wasn't evangelical, and so I really care about the Bible. In seminary, we learn a concept called authorial intent, So what does the author intend to say? So I always carry that that idea into how I read the Bible. And as I did that, I started to focus more on to pick up the perspective of what the author wanted to say to the original audience. And as I did that, more and more and more I read more and more and more. I
Speaker 6realized that most of what we hear in the evangelical Church, at least, is not the authorial intent.
Speaker 7It is.
Speaker 6The contemporary audience, the contemporary pastor even the contemporary Bible scholars. Some of their intent is ready into it, and so this it's hard to approach the original layer. As I approached the original layer, more and more I realized that there are so many problems with the Bible, Like I don't need to mention all of them, but just take a few. The Pentateuch, the first five books of Moses, is basically myths. The historical Jesus the person. The historical Jesus person, if he existed, is not the same as the Jesus Christ that we see in the Gospels. This
Speaker 6is just a small handful of the problems. And once that really hit me, I realized that this thing quickly fell apart because I realized that a lot of it was based on myths. And so I'm Chinese. In my culture, we have a mythical story. If any Chinese series are listening, they'll know this story called Journey's the East. It's a list story about a Buddhist monk who travels west. Aside Journey's the West, who travels west to India from China and on the path. He needs all these kind of challenges,
Speaker 6these goals and demons, and he and his compatriots fite them off. But I thought to myself, I said, I don't take journeys of west I know some list I don't take it as the guy to cond of my life. Why should I take the Old and New Testament? It's also a nor It doesn't make any sense to me.
Speaker 2So yeah, yeah, no, Charles, just real quick, you might be talking a little too close to your phone or your micro wherever you're talking to because you're peaking a little bit. So if you could just move just a little bit away next time we talked to us, that would be awesome. But yeah, what the experience you're talking about is something that I've heard from other folks who have also been to seminary, which is this idea of Yeah, when I actually studied the Bible from an academic perspective, I really have a different view of it. And you really that pastors and priests who do talk about the Bible right are talking about it in a very, very
Speaker 2very different way than from the people who study the Bible in an academic discipline. You're talking about authorial intent, which is also very true. This is a revelation for myself as well. This idea that look, the Bible that we have today is a much more modern idea compared to the people who actually wrote the books individually. They did not intend it as part of a larger collection of works. They did not meet these other people from most of the time who wrote these other books of the Bible. Their version of God and their version of theology was very different from the people who also wrote
Speaker 2in these other times. And if you don't believe me, look at all the books that we don't have that aren't in the Bible. Right. These are also people who are also expressing their own intent. And it wasn't until there was an actual congregation of power within the church now what we call the Catholic Church. But you know, the original Christians, we were Catholic who were saying, hey, we're going to put these books together and we're gonna choose what's right and what's wrong. And that's just how it came to me. And and knowing that history does really change your look on the Bible, because it's like, Okay, why should I care about what the author of the
Speaker 2Book of Daniel says, compared to the author of the Book of Genesis, there are two different people from different time periods, speaking to different issues and interpreting things differently, and and and suddenly this idea of the Bible being God's word as a unique, cohesive unit doesn't really make sense. It's more of a scattered series of blog posts from different times and different authors in perspective. So, yeah, that's it's very interesting that you also had that revelation.
Speaker 6Yeah. Absolutely, I feel that as I got to know more about the authors and the writings of the Bible, you know, in particular, one person I really began to dislike was Paul. And you know, he was necronic, psychopathic guy who wants to divide, and you know, there's there's a lot in there's a lot in the New Testament about how he was, you know, not having a good time with the Jerusalem early First Disciples.
Speaker 2So oh yeah, another if Paul was around today, he would be in the manosphere. We would call him an in cell straight up, that's my take. Okay, we would not like Paul.
Speaker 6Absolutely we would.
Speaker 2And Calvin, yes, yeah, what about those guessing.
Speaker 6I want to say is that I also de converted in part because of my PhD research. So in my research I encountered a lot of Christian nationalists and learn more about the rise of Christian nationalism from the nineteen fifties sixties, roughly as a political movement the moral majority. And to be honest, you know, I don't say this in my research. I'm not allowed to say it, but it disgusted me.
Speaker 2Yeah. I imagine as a thinking person with a regular, normal compass, it would you know, it would. That doesn't surprise me.
Speaker 6Yeah, So, hey, Kelly, I'm the guy in the chat. So who do you want to ask me any questions?
Speaker 10No?
Speaker 3I would just thought your story was kind of interesting, and I thought that I was wondering what seminary did you go to over in Scotland? Just curiosity.
Speaker 6So I did my seminary studies in the US. I went to Bethel Seminary.
Speaker 2Bethel Bethel Seminary. Heard a lot of stories about Bethel, none of them good. Yeah, well man.
Speaker 6Actually Charles til My actually really good. And they they actually earned their PhD in universities too, and they taught us to think critically. But you know, I was a young believer at the time when I went to seminary. I was about three three four years into my Christian faith. So I was very you know, filled with the spirit, so to speak, really gun hole about it. So I just sucked up everything is said in a kind of a faith through a faith less And so anyone who claims that I'm not a real Christian because I be converted is just complete bs. Because I was the ideal Christian.
Speaker 6I had read the Bible thirty to forty time before I went to seminary. I was praying at least two hours a day. I had gone on spiritual retreats, silent retreat I prayed for people. I had this prayer buddy who I prayed for. I prayed with every day, every night, one hour every night. So I was the epitome of a Christian. And when that all fell awagh, It's like it was, it was really slow. It took me a lot longer to fall away than it took me to pick it up. But as a fell way, you know, I turn around as see people who say, who would
Speaker 6consider me not, you know, a false believer? I say it, screw you. I'm a better Christian than you ever were.
Speaker 2What would you say?
Speaker 1What would you say has changed. So you were a non believer, became a believer, then went back to being a non believer. What would you say is different now than when you were a believer?
Speaker 2Is there anything that you'd like?
Speaker 1I'm not doing that because I'm now I've been a believer and now I'm fully like on the other side, what would you say is a big thing that you would or wouldn't do now that you are as a non believer.
Speaker 6That's a really good question. I think the biggest change for me is that I now look at things with a critical lens. I ask is this true? Is this right? Is there any evidence? Now? Kelly in the chat he was a skeptic when I mentioned myself, and he's right. I think he's right to be skeptical. Skeptical. I appreciate that. I think that being skeptical in this day and age is a good thing. Let me argue why, because if you notice nowadays, there's a lot more scams going on, right, romance scams, pig butchering scams. We need to be we need to be careful about what we see today, especially
Speaker 6now with AI and internet social media. We need to have we need to see the evidence for the arguments. If we don't see the evidence, we should really be curious and skeptical about the arguments. So that's probably the biggest thing I learned.
Speaker 2Well, yeah, and I don't think Christianity really endorses that, like really ever. You know, there's some people that say, oh, Christianity informs my scientific worldview, and it's like, really, that's amazing, because I don't think you're getting that from the Bible. You know, maybe you're getting that from the people in your community, who probably have a mix of all kinds of ideas. But I don't think broad skepticism is really much of a value that's ever been held in traditional Christianity. And I think that does solve It does serve as an adherence to finding I don't know, true things you
Speaker 2know kind of can make you believe bullshit. And I'm glad for you, Charles. It sounds like you're doing well for yourself. Sounds like you figured some stuff out, and I'm rooting for you. So what's next for you? Are you gonna are you gonna start deconverting people, Are you going to start, you know, posting online or are you just going to live your life and just have other people kind of figure things out.
Speaker 6Yeah, thanks for asking me. It's tough because I went through this entire process, you know, ten years of studying the theology with the intention of becoming what they call a pastor slash scholar, so it is someone who preaches in the church and also does scholarly work for the seminary or the academy. And I, because of de convert, I de converted so so completely. I feel that it would be completely it would be a lack of integrity for me to preach ever again, to do some rey
Speaker 6teaching ever again, I couldnot myself doing that. I won't deceive myself to do that, I will deceive other people. So I think for me, the path really is the question of what kind of employment can I find, And I'm looking more in the direction of college or university teaching in the field that I do, which is ath apology of religion.
Speaker 2Charcastic Charles.
Speaker 3Have you heard of the Clergy Project?
Speaker 6I have, Yes, Kelly.
Speaker 3I was just thinking that that you might want to contact them and talk to them about, you know, some some things they might be able to help you out with your future h work, right, Yeah, So yeah, I'm not sure. I'm not an ext minister. I've never you know, really got involved with them, but I know that they're a really good, uh organization. I think Darryl Ray might have been involved with it somehow. I'm not positive about that, but I think I think you might want to just get a hold of it. Maybe you can do some good back and forth with each other. You might be
Speaker 3able to help them out too.
Speaker 6So yes, I appreciate that, Thank you for the recommendation. We'll try to get in touch with them at some point in the near future.
Speaker 2Yeah. For those who aren't familiar with it, you know, the Clergy Project is a project that helps folks who are leaving the clergy because it's often found that, hey, when you work in the clergy or in related fields, you don't tend to have the same kind of marketable skill sets that other people have in other trades. And that's a huge problem, especially if you don't believe anymore because you don't because like Charles said, you don't want to deceive people, but you also need to make a living, right, So how do you do that ethically? How do you transition out of that? So that's what the Clergy Project is for those of you who aren't familiar. That is an organization that we've supported in the past, and we
Speaker 2definitely recommend people go check them out because they do some cool stuff there. But Charles, we do have some other folks that want to talk to us, So I am going to let you go now. Is there anything else you want to say before we let you go? No?
Speaker 6Thank you very much, guys, And for anyone who's hearing this and seeing their Christian faith, I encourage you to look for the evidence. Read a bit of critical Common Bible commentaries. Read Araman. Read a Stanton Palou. I think I forgot her name, but I forgot her first name, Francesca. She's the uh supervisor for God the guy excasing right now, but she's she's at the University Exeter. Read these people and think about think about what is being presented here.
Speaker 6I am sure you will come to the same conclusion that many of us have come to.
Speaker 2Thank you very much, Thank you, Charles. Thanks for the excellent call.
Speaker 3Yeah, thanks Charles, thanks for calling in for on my request. I really appreciate it. This was a great call.
Speaker 2So yeah, Kelly, Kelly was was saying he was talking to you, So that's that's good. You're a real person. At least you're not an Kelly was just talking to you senselessly. But yeah, there's something that I want to add to that too. Just that one. I'm so glad that Charles could share his experience because that's not the first time I've heard an experience like that, and it won't be the last, So it's always good to hear that for folks that are going through something similar. But also he went on this tangent that I really appreciate, and he talked about this idea of being a real Christian,
Speaker 2because I've gotten this too, and I know other folks who watched this have gotten this. When you leave the faith, there's this idea that, oh, technically you never were really in the faith because of all these spiritual chests. And usually they're referencing this passage in First John, which, funnily enough, speaking of authorship, we don't even know who wrote First John. It probably wasn't even the apostle John who actually wrote it. But they're talking about these verses that basically say, hey, look, you know, a Christian is always going to be a Christian and they're going to act within the Holy Spirit, and they can't act outside of the Holy Spirit. So if they don't have the Holy Spirit, and then then
Speaker 2they never had it in the first place. Right, So there's this basically this damned if you do, Damned if you don't sort of idea that, look, you were never really a Christian because you couldn't leave the faith if you were a real Christian. And that's just a fucking bullshit. And I'll tell you why. When you grow up in a community and this is all you know, and this is all of your values and all of your friends and family, it's fucking hard to leave that and to be honest with yourself. And for people to say, oh, you never actually represented those values and you weren't a real Christian in the first place, I say, go fuck yourself.
Speaker 2I'm with Charles on that because that's one dehumanizing, but two also completely disregards to the real, authentic trying that people have had with Christianity. People have really tried to believe in this and when they figure out they can't, it's not their fault, right, It's just not It's not their fault. You can't hold them to something that they just can't believe. It's just not how belief works. We can't force it if you honestly believe something or you honestly don't. That's just the way it is. So anyway, that's my tangent to Charles tangent because I think it's an important thing to bring up. But anyway, what did
Speaker 2you guys think about that call? I thought that was great, it was yeah, you know.
Speaker 1It, Well, it's interesting to know life that he said he was from a secular family family, and it interests me, you know, how that as a as a relationship would work, because I feel like if any of my siblings were to say to my parents, you know, oh we found God, my parents would be.
Speaker 2Like, what are you? What's wrong with you?
Speaker 6What?
Speaker 2What?
Speaker 1Where did this come from? It's not like they've ever learned about this stuff. I never really learned about that stuff when I was a kid. I mean, they didn't teach me about speaking to dead people, so I guess, you know, there's some kind of indoctrination. But you know, I just feel like, slowly we're moving away from this whole belief and deity stuff, and so it was just interesting to hear like how his folks responded to it.
Speaker 2Yeah, I was interested in there as well, because it's it's just not that common, right, Like, if you're a Christian, it's usually because your parents are Christian. It's very often not the case that it happens otherwise, unless you're like in a country that's been you know, Colin ized.
Speaker 3I actually I thought he had a really interesting journey. I'm really glad he called.
Speaker 6So.
Speaker 2Yeah, good, good good job, Kelly. Thanks for golden people to call into the show.
Speaker 3I'm trying to go on some deers Chad now, but they don't seem like they want to call us. They're afraid to call us. I guess I don't know.
Speaker 2Come on the last show of the year, guys. Yea, they make a Christmas miracle happen, believers, please, I'd love to hear it. Okay, So we do have one caller that I think maybe from a Christian. The call name is Jesus Tales. I could be wrong about this or maybe maybe not. Actually I think they're calling from North Carolina. Jesus Tales, you're live on Truth wanted, what's going on?
Speaker 8Thanks? What's going on? It's kind of hard to follow that one. That was a pretty intense call there from Charles I hope he finds his true calling in life. But yeah, so what I'm calling about is I've got a bit of a story for you about jes So in the Bible, Jesus killed the can of Jerusalem, phung him on a tree, took him down evening, put him in a cave, and piled large a large pile of rocks in front of that cave, which remains to this day.
Speaker 8And now that's in the Old Testament. It's in the Old Testament that Mark grew up reading because he grew up reading Greek, and the character of Joshua to him with Jesus. See the parallels between the story.
Speaker 2Yeah, go ahead, We thought, Oh, wait, so are we following what's happening here? Because I'm confused. I have no idea. There's a no no. What passages are you referring to Jesus tales?
Speaker 8Okay, so this is Jesus one of none, right, Joshua, some of the none. Everybody knows the story of the conquests and stuff like that. But in chapter ten, he kills the king of Jerusalem and hangs them on the tree. And this is obviously used by Mark in his story of Jesus. Now you can see the parallels taking it down the evening stuff like that.
Speaker 2I gotta see you're talking about uh you talking about the Book of Joshua, chapter ten. Yes, okay, I gotta, I gotta, I gotta remind myself on this one. Joshua Israel blah blah blah went to Aglon and hebron, I said, boring, including the hill country worth of dragons. I know there's some dragons in here somewhere. Actually, I think this is the same chapter where they talk about the sun standing still in the sky. I could be wrong. That's somewhere in Joshua, though. All right, So you point that you're making here is that, look, the author of the New Testament,
Speaker 2one of the authors of the New Testament, was drawing a parallel from this Old Testament story in the Jesus narrative. That's probably plausible. I haven't personally encountered this particular argument before, but I do know that there is scholarship, because we're talking about scholarship that does cite that. Hey, like the New Testament, oftentimes, particularly in Luke and Matthew right, are referencing these stories from the Old Testament in building out the mythology of Jesus right, because they're trying to make
Speaker 2him fulfillment of a prophecy. People often talk about the prophecy in the Book of Daniel right, of Jesus being the Messiah figure. That the Messiah figure is this figure within Jewish sort of mythos that are supposed to come and redeem people of sin. Obviously, Jesus kind of deviates from that a little bit, and that's why they're still Jewish people today because they don't believe it. But you know, that's that's this could be part of that mythos.
Speaker 3Is what you're saying, are you equated distinction?
Speaker 2Okay?
Speaker 3Are you saying that this accounting Joshua is the same account that was written that Mark wrote down for Jesus that he actually copied it?
Speaker 8Is that?
Speaker 3Is that what you're saying?
Speaker 8Yeah, some of it he imitates, some of it he inverts. You know, the concept of being hung on a tree. The Book of Acts describes Jesus as hung on a tree three different times, twice coming from Paul's mouth and once coming from Peter's mouth, you know, putting his body in a cave, Mark says, a tomb. But if you've ever been to Israel. I've never been, but I've seen pictures of the king sins their case. You know, the cave is doug and but here's the here's the distinction. Okay, So this all could be mythology that's layered onto historical Jesus.
Speaker 8But here's the key. Jesus son of Nune did this exactly forty years after his message as fire report was rejected by the Israelites and they threatened to sponge him, and we see that show up in Mark as Nazareth rejects Jesus forty years before Jerusalem is destroyed by the Romans.
Speaker 2Are you? Are you?
Speaker 1I can clarify because I'm My brain is like frying right now because I am.
Speaker 2I don't know what's going on.
Speaker 1Are you opposing this as proof of a supernatural Jesus or just proof that people copied stories?
Speaker 8Okay, so here's the thing. There's terms of evidence of Jesus being copied from Old Testament Jesus is because there's one right but this particular but.
Speaker 1That can also go back to like there's also other things that you can look at where that some of the stories of Jesus can also be taken further back from other completely different religions and just the names slightly changed to you know whatever.
Speaker 2Reason. I think the confusion here is because Joshua also means Jesus. I think that's where the Okay, yeah, yes, you were same thing, so yeah.
Speaker 8I'm saying.
Speaker 6Yeah.
Speaker 8What I'm saying is this is a very Jewish story, but it is just a story, and it's placed in time at thirty CE where Pilot is ruling. Mark puts the story setting at that time period because it's forty years before the destruction of Jerusalem, and it's not the only time in the Old Testament where this happened. Jeremiah is rejected by his hometown of Anathought exactly forty years before Jerusalem is destroyed by netic conness. So this kind of to me, this proves that Jesus has to be
Speaker 8complete literature myth.
Speaker 2I think it can. It can. Well, it's speculative, right, you're making an argument for that. I don't think it it counts as proof in and of itself, but I think the evidence you're putting forth can lend to the argument of that, because what you're saying, and I'm try trying to verify what you're saying because some of what you're saying is new, some of what you're saying is not new to me. Right, So this idea, there's a couple of different things to break down here. One is ponscious pilot, Right, Ponscious Pilot is talked about a lot in the narrative. Why conscious pilot, what's going on there? Because there's some really confusing stuff that's happening at the beginning of Jesus' story. Right,
Speaker 2they're talking about a king that's that's going to hunt down babies and stuff. We don't have any of that in history. Right. Remember this, that's how Jesus starts off. We want to kill him because we know there's a special boy and he's out there, and they don't do it. They don't do it. They've never recorded this, right, the same thing ponncious pilot. Poncious Pilot. We don't have any records of him interacting with Jesus doing all this kinds of stuff. And then there is a prophecy that's talked about that says, hey, this the third Temple is going to the temple, the second Temple of Jerusalem is going to fall, and it does happen, but according to scholars,
Speaker 2this happens before the actual narrative of the New Testament is written, right, and that's part of how we even date the New Testament itself, because they're talking about a prophecy of an event that already happened, right, and this has happened, and other kinds of prophetic literature, So this is what they're care So you're kind of taking all of these points and you're putting it together and you're saying, well, look, all of this is proof that this is a mythological work. And I would say you're kind of preaching to the choir here, like we definitely are on the same page as far as like, yeah, I don't think Jesus was really out there, you know, raising people from the dead
Speaker 2and multiplying fishes and stuff. Okay, Like we're on the same page. So yeah, I don't know. If you want to make your point there, then yeah, you've made it. Congratulations, you've convinced us, you.
Speaker 8Know, Okay, Okay, Yeah. I would also like to say, if you guys have time, Mark wasn't original in doing this. Like the Elijah Elisha story. Elisa just is a theoporic switch between the names of Sasua, and Elisha Yahweh for l So Elijah's like a second coming of Jesus on the non Jesus. Someone jehosted that it is like a second coming of Jesus son on none and Jesus announced the US as a composite of all three of those.
Speaker 2Yeah, yeah, there's definitely some Like without a doubt, I think scholars would agree with you in that there are definitely designed coincidences I'll put it that way, that are put into the New Testament narrative sort of these parallels that are supposed to be made.
Speaker 8Right.
Speaker 2The debate is, you know, how much of that is actually history that we're talking about here, and how much of this is you know, just like rhetorical effect. Right. There are some that even go far as to say that Jesus is completely mythological and that he's not real. I'm not one of those people that goes that far. There's some people that do. But you know, as far as like, is the narrative kind of suss, Yeah, it's absolutely sus It's that definitely post factor.
Speaker 3I have a problem with this because we're looking at like the story of Joshua was supposedly from like thirteen hundred BC, right, and the story of Jesus is thirteen hundred years later. So it seems to me that like some of the details being the same over the course of thirteen hundred years, that doesn't seem that unplausible to me that you had something that happened one year in thirteen hundred years later you had something else that happened that was similar to it. I mean that does that seems well within the realm of coincidence, I guess, or
Speaker 3you know, the realm of possibility to me.
Speaker 1Especially if the story's been told over and over as well, you know you're going to remember certain parts of it.
Speaker 8Yeah, So let me let me propose this idea. Let's say there's a young person who came up and saw the Spider Man movies from the early two thousands, right, and they thought there might be a real person behind us, right, And they start doing research trying to find a Peter Parker that lived in New York City or something like that. Now, if he comes across evidence that there was a guy spinning webs in comic books in the eighties and seventies, he's got to believe that it's pure myth. There's no longer a Peter Parker in two thousands of New York
Speaker 8China sall crimes and dressing up like spinning webs.
Speaker 3You know, Kelly, you're talking about the space of ten years in another space of thirteen hundred years.
Speaker 2Okay to me, fair Kelly, that's the narrative is thirteen hundred But that's not what joshuas written that. That's also it's much closer. Joshua is like closer to like Daniel and stuff, which is like fifth or sixth century BC.
Speaker 1You can look at a modern parallel as well. There's the the you know, the Star Wars story, you know, an orphan who then learns about his magic powers and then defeats the evil and Harry Potter who then there's an orphan who learns he's got magic powers and then defeats the evil.
Speaker 2You know, I don't. I'm really confused. I'm not sure where this is going because right Jesus Tales I I again, I can see the point that Look, we're the writers of the New Testament familiar with Judaism and its writings one hundred percent. There's there's way too much evidence of that to believe otherwise, But I don't think that in its own means that Jesus was created wholesale. You could definitely have Jesus as a historical person and then have myth attributed to him and to like post facto like.
Speaker 2I think that's what a lot of people say. That's why there's so much difference between the Mark narrative and the John narrative, for example, because like they have different goals with what they want to do with Jesus. So I don't I would be very careful if your argument is, look, this is how we know Jesus is completely mythological, because I don't know if you can do that.
Speaker 8I have been very careful. I promise you name anything from Mark and I can tell you what you do mythology it came from.
Speaker 3That doesn't But that still doesn't prove that.
Speaker 2Yeah. Yeah, it's one of those things where we probably won't never really know, you know, and I'm comfortable with that. But it's definitely sure though that these accounts aren't accurate, right, that there's no way that these things happen in history. But as far as like did these people exist, that's kind of outside of the scope. Unfortunately, it's just not a question we can answer. I think that drives some people crazy and they try to answer it. You know, well, let me.
Speaker 8Push back on the Star Wars things. Star Wars and Harry Potters, those are sort of high level things, and those type of parallels exist as well. But these are minute story line features that are just very very well copied, very girl imitated, sometimes very well inverted, just very minute.
Speaker 2But Jesus says, I'm with you on that they did. They did take stuff from that narrative. But here's the thing too, there's also new stuff to the Jesus narrative, right, and like that stuff could also be made up. It probably is, but it could also be at least partly doing taking from stuff that Jesus did. And that's the problem. We just we can't examine that. That's just outside of the ability to examine history, right, Like, we just don't have that. And I think that again it just we have we have.
Speaker 8These are small books, these are small marks a small book, these are pieces of literature, and you're saying that there's things that Jesus did that we're new. I don't know any of them because I looked at Mark chapter one when.
Speaker 2I say new I mean that they're not referencing the strict mythology of the Jewish people right there, Like there's there's there's like like they didn't talk about conscious pilot in Joshua, you know dem just file is a different guy or they you know, multiply.
Speaker 9That's not fair.
Speaker 8That's just studying and time.
Speaker 2That's my point though, that's my point. There's like you can't it's it's not wholesale, if it's anyway, I think I think we're kind of saying some of the same things. I think we mostly agree here. I do want to move on. Was there anything else you want to add before I let you go? Jesus Tales, thank.
Speaker 8You for letting me call. And uh, if anybody's curious, I got a page put up on academic academia and edu Jesus Tales.
Speaker 2But thank you, Okay, okay, all right, thank you, thank you so much for calling. There you go. I got a little confused in that call. I got a little loss in this boss.
Speaker 1And I think a lot of what we do is like you have people coming up to tell you that you're wrong because this, this and this, and that's why I felt like he was coming in saying you're all wrong and this proves.
Speaker 2This, but like he's kind of yeah, I'm with you. Who is he fighting? Who is he fighting? Yeah? I don't know, Yeah, I don't know. I I won't reiterate my points. I'll just keep going. I'll take the next call. Unless you guys have anything else you want to add? No, no, I do you do?
Speaker 3The Mars parrot?
Speaker 2Yeah, let's see a quick picture of the Can we get that crew if they're ready for that?
Speaker 3They said they were ready, So there we go.
Speaker 1Oh, Kelly, I'm sorry for those who can't see. It's just covered Kelly's face, but so Dan and I can be looking.
Speaker 2Yeah, that's okay.
Speaker 3The parent's more important than I is the parrot?
Speaker 2Oh I see? Okay? So the colored bits ye sculpture.
Speaker 1Yeah, if she's come to me and said that there's an elephant ice sculpture on Mars, I'll be like, yeah, there is.
Speaker 3Look at the look at that parrot is really stretching it that that's worse than the face.
Speaker 2Audio listeners, I I don't know what to say. It's a rock, it's a it's a funny looking rock. That's it. Yeah, somebody puts some collar is on and now it's a parrot. I guess parent sculpture I've ever seen.
Speaker 10If if a kid in one of John's uh you know, if a kid that I had to work with gave me that sculpture, I'd give him a d I'd say take it.
Speaker 2Sorry, I don't know.
Speaker 3In the text chest text chat just said Parenthlia.
Speaker 2Man, John is like getting some government interference. John, what's going on?
Speaker 7Dude?
Speaker 2Trying to take you away? While you figure that out. I am going to go ahead and get the next caller on and see what's going on with that. That is a that's a problem right there. I don't know what to tell you on that. Let's see we have a couple of different people. Uh, Kelly, I know you got call screener ope, but who you want to talk to? You?
Speaker 3You know, I was looking at Mike. What do you think about Mike?
Speaker 2Mike? Okay, yeah, that sounds good to be. Let's talk to Mike. Mike, who's calling in from Florida? And Folks, if you're still calling, we probably still have time to get to you. So if you don't mind holding on, we appreciate it. Mike, you are now live on truth wanted what's going on?
Speaker 4Not much, guys. I saw that your Live was coming on today and I wanted to call in with a different.
Speaker 6Perspective for you.
Speaker 2All right, give me that different perspective. I love to hear it.
Speaker 6All right.
Speaker 4Well, I think the very first step is to understand why Man created God Burrow and today we all know them these effects as placebos and no cebos.
Speaker 6Right.
Speaker 4These are the triggering effects of an unknown mechanism that either makes you sick or makes you better. I don't think that's something that's out of the ordinary. People know what they are and uncertain humans have known about it, you know, since the early days. Now today they can't resolve what mechanism is actually at work. Some sub atomic interaction is going on because of human certainty in the outcome.
Speaker 2So you talking about quantum mechanics right now? No?
Speaker 4No, no, I'm just I'm just you know, whatever I'm out there?
Speaker 2So, oh, no, like what seriously, what are you talking about? I don't know what you're talking about right now?
Speaker 4Okay. Man created the gods as a symbolic representation of specific effects, which is why each god had very specific things that they could perform.
Speaker 2Sometimes. Sure, yeah, I mean, I you're you're talking, you're just trying to I can't agree with this idea of why did man make gods? And we just boil that down to a single sentence. I just don't think that's gonna work for me. I just think it's going to be way more complicated than I'm right.
Speaker 4Certainly it is, but I feel kind of rush since she told everybody else that, you know.
Speaker 2Hey, that's fine, I will give you that. This is maybe one reason why, right, can we go that far? Is that cool with you?
Speaker 4Well? Think about it this way. So the Native Americans danced to raign God for thousands of years, and if it had never worked, they wouldn't continue doing it after some point, right, I mean, you can't say the Native Americans were stupid and they didn't get like odds.
Speaker 2Well, I mean I don't like, First of all, there's many different groups when we're talking about Native Americans. Not all Native American groups are the same in their beliefs. They vary quite widely between like their different structures. Usually they're much more local, and certainly not all of them are you know, doing what you're talking about. So, like there is some kinds of rituals. You don't have to single out any group of people. You can point out all kinds of folks who say, hey, this is supposed to be a specific effect that comes from this ritual,
Speaker 2and they expect that effect, or if the effect doesn't happen, then they must not have done it right. You know, it's just kind of a self serving cycle. But again, I'm still not sure where we're going with this.
Speaker 4Okay, the Romans created Christ to disprove that the power of a placebo needs a god as the media like pills in a placebo interaction. You've heard people talk about before that he has performed placebo miracles. Have you ever heard that thesis before?
Speaker 3I mean, sure, yeah, I mean that's with the possibility.
Speaker 2I don't know if if we can specifically say the Roman people as a whole manufactured Christ, that seems like a big stretch. I don't know how we get there.
Speaker 4I don't I don't know how you get the people did full Rome? Listen, I don't Bob a guy named Bob and Rome he created it. Okay, I don't know why you're taking me down that rabbit hole, But let's just take it as an analogy of Rome.
Speaker 2So you're the one that said that it's a Jesus was specifically fabricated by the Roman people, Like I don't I imagine there's a whole in there somewhere.
Speaker 4The Roman people said, Rome.
Speaker 2Yeah, Rome, the Roman people. I don't know what we were splitting hairs here, but yeah, it was is an invention by a specific ethnic group of people or a local group of.
Speaker 3People or or do you mean the leaders of Rome?
Speaker 2Yeah? Do you mean, like the leadership? What do you what are you talking about?
Speaker 4Man, I thought that we were going to have a conversation here. I didn't think we were going to try to get this down to the nanos so you can feel comfortable.
Speaker 2Yeah, I'm going to get this down to the nano until I uncomfortable. Yeah, that's how this is going to happen, because, like, I don't just let people make wild claims about shit and just pretend like, oh, yeah, that's fine whatever, We'll just let it slide like that. That's kind of the whole point of the show is to talk about what people believe and why. So I want to know why you believe that that Jesus Christ is actually a fabrication of the Roman government or whatever about Hello, you have the floor, Mike, I'm listening.
Speaker 4Right, Okay. So it's pretty well known that the Catholic Church or the the uh, the older version of today's Catholic Church, the Holy Roman Church created or assembled.
Speaker 2Not accurate. Yeah, well, yes, by by what we would call the Catholic Church. Yes, that is, by the the earliest assemblage of the Bible comes from what we would call today the Catholic Church. Yeah, that's it's fair.
Speaker 4Okay, all right, So you heard of the accounts of people's talking about something called the Gospel of Christ or Gospel of Jesus.
Speaker 2Yes, true, have you heard about it?
Speaker 4The Muslims they believe that in something called the in Jail, which is also they call the Gospel of Jesus or the.
Speaker 6Good News of Jesus.
Speaker 2Have you heard of that? Sure?
Speaker 4And that they suspect that when the time comes and that's brought out, it's kind of the same as our revelation or like Revelation twenty one, that it will free everyone because the information that was given by God to Jesus will be known to all men.
Speaker 2Have you heard that? Maybe I don't know where we're going with this, but Okay.
Speaker 4My point is is that Jesus Christ was creating and let's just say he really lived, Okay, just to make you feel better. So Jesus Christ really lived and he performed these miracles that were by other people's belief in his abilities. They didn't believe that he was the son of a God. They didn't think he was a god. But oftentimes when they would thank him after his miracle performance, he would say it was your faith that healed you. He didn't say your faith in God, because those people didn't believe in his God.
Speaker 6But what would you call them?
Speaker 2Yeah? That's I mean, this is this is oh my God. So okay, you could have skipped all that stuff about the Muslims in the Catholic Church. That had nothing to do with the argument. I don't know why you brought that up. That was just a waste of all of our time. But second off, you're taking the account of the gospels very literally. You're like saying, oh, these people they believe by faith, because the Gospel said they believe by faith, and Jesus said, if you follow me through faith, then good things will happen. Yeah, that's true. What does that have to do with it? Being manufactured, Like, what
Speaker 2does it have to do with Jesus being a manufactured figure? Like that could be said about all kinds of people who are also real. Like I'm pretty sure David Koresh also said you have to believe in me by faith, and he was like a real dude, you know, I've granted his religion was bullshit, but you get what I'm saying, Like, that doesn't mean that Jesus wasn't a real person, right, Okay, okay, all right, I guess I'm right.
Speaker 4Then, this is the problem with the arguments all the time. The Christians take one side, you guys take another. But no one's actually read the scripture.
Speaker 2Everybody, Oh, I haven't read the scripture? Have I really?
Speaker 3Mike, Yeah, that's yeah, I have, right, so did you. I've actually read the Gospels like six times, way more than most Christians have.
Speaker 6Right, that's great.
Speaker 4So why do people believe that Christ die for sin?
Speaker 3I have no fucking clue. I'm not in the other people's heads. You're asking me to explain what other people are thinking, and I can't do that.
Speaker 2Also, like, that's such a theologically diverse question. You're going to get like eleven different answers from ten different Christians. If you ask that.
Speaker 4It's plain as day in Hebrews.
Speaker 2Yeah, yeah, and guess what he maybe to you, guys opinion.
Speaker 3Yeah, it might be clearest day to you, Mike, but it's not clear as day to all Christians. Otherwise we wouldn't get ten different answers.
Speaker 2Right, Not all Christians followed the Book of Hebrews to a literal degree, Mike.
Speaker 4In Hebrew's nine nine. In Hebrews nine, they're talking about the things that people did Old Testament, people did to retrieve themselves of sin. But it also continues in ninety nine that talks about that those gifts and sacrifices didn't purify their conscience. And then in nine fourteen is a rhetorical statement or question. It says, so how much more shall the blood of Christ urge your conscience from dead works to serve the living God? So Christ wasn't dying for our sin. He was dying for the result of
Speaker 4our sin, which is our defiled or guilty conscience. Now why is that important? Because if you can pure know why.
Speaker 2Is any of this important? Right now? Are we talking about are you making the case that Jesus is manufactured, Like, are we still talking about that? No? You are okay? Then what are you talking about Mike?
Speaker 3Exactly? Where exactly are you going with this?
Speaker 4Mike, I'm going with the same structure with God as I did with Jesus.
Speaker 2No, Mike, I need you to give me a real answer. Where the fuck are we going with this? Give what is the end point? What is the conclusion? What is the thesis?
Speaker 3What's the point you're trying to make.
Speaker 6A minute.
Speaker 2Oh, I'm not going to hear you out. We've already heard you out for the last like foot five minutes, ten minutes. I need you to give me the thesis now so we can decide if we can keep having this call or else. You're wasting our time.
Speaker 4Point fuck yourself, him, Go fuck.
Speaker 2Yourself, he him. Mike and Florida, you're a grown ass man. You called up a guy on a Friday night so you could talk about the gospel quite poorly in fact, and you ended it with go fuck yourself. He him. Yeah, you're really bringing people to Christ through your godliness. I can really tell, Mike.
Speaker 1I kind of wish my camera just say dead for another five minutes.
Speaker 2That was stupid. What a dumb conversation. Look, if you're trying to convince somebody of something, maybe it's best not to call them basically call them stupid, to say that they haven't actually read the Gospel and then make long, arduous points about nothing in particular, and then say that we're wrong because we still haven't heard him out right ridiculous.
Speaker 1I cavince that off way as well, and I feel like I'm probably less confused than you both.
Speaker 2Why we were talking about Jesus not being real, Like he was saying the Roman government made up Jesus, right, but then he didn't. Then he's talking about theology.
Speaker 1I don't like he was going, well, if if Jesus isn't real and the Romans made him up, and then maybe the God isn't real as well.
Speaker 6I don't know.
Speaker 2I don't know where that was going up. Yeah, Mike might be used to Maybe Mike's a pastor and maybe he's used to talking to people where people don't have to ask him questions and talk back to it, or doesn't let them. Yeah, yeah, I would say try harder next time, Mike. You know, here, here's a here's a here's something I would do. Write out what you're going to say first, so you don't go on random tangents about Muslims in the Catholic Church to whatever point you're trying to make. I think that would be helpful.
Speaker 1Stop with what you're trying to achieve from this right there, and then go yeah, because then we will all have a bit of a clue.
Speaker 3I'm good, I believe this, and here here's the proof that I have behind me to that's that would be the way to make the argument.
Speaker 2Yeah, yeah, okay, I do. I want to give some time to Daniel here, if that's okay with you, guys, because you know that fair Dan has been on the line for a minute, and uh, there's there's a proxy war happening right now. You know, we are the sponsors of we are the nation state of Truth Wanted, and we are sponsoring this parxy war. I think Daniel, you're a live on truth Wanted. Some ship has been talked tonight and I and I think you probably have a response to that. Go ahead, Daniel.
Speaker 9Yeah, yeah, Hi, guys. No, I didn't plan on calling in tonight. You know you took my call last week, so I thought you to be no.
Speaker 8But Phil, Phil, he jonged me, so I didn't.
Speaker 9I'm not trying to start a feud. But still everything he sounds like a nice guy.
Speaker 2I like.
Speaker 9I like the names he's using and stuff. It's not vampires so far been my favorite.
Speaker 2And and it's also p like Grace Bannon. That's a nice one. But yes, well, well, uh yeah, you know, I understand I think both of you. I think if you guys met in real life, you'd have a nice, polite conversation. But this is the Internet, where polite conversation doesn't exist, and only violence and screaming can happen. So you know, I understand what's happening. Maybe can I ask uh off the show sometime?
Speaker 3There you go? Can I ask a question real quick? Were you just using his real name just to piss him off because that's what he was complaining about on you call?
Speaker 9Well, I mean I can recognize the guy's Hey.
Speaker 3I'm just saying because because that was what he was complaining about when you when in his call today, is that you were calling him out on his real name when he was using fake names. Thought, So okay, So go back to my original question, did you when you knew that it was upsetting him that you were using his real name. Did you just repeatedly use his real name just to piss him off?
Speaker 6Yeah?
Speaker 9Sure, sure, all right, but but let me respond to what he said though, Like, I know, it's my phone.
Speaker 3Can't you just respond to what he said instead of trying to piss him off? Why did you Why did you feel the need to have to do that?
Speaker 9Because I can recognize his voice.
Speaker 3That's that's not an excuse just because I recognize somebody's voices. I mean I need to piss him off. I mean, I recognize your voice, Daniel. I know I'm probably pissing you off right now, but I recognize your voice every time you call, and I don't try to piss you off every time.
Speaker 2He's being patty. He's being patty. I think I think he recognizes he was being patty.
Speaker 1But I do think it's just been putting the crew chat that if you both called in at the same time, there is a way that we could have you on at the same time and we could just observe this conversation, which I think, as long as that one's being Petsy, might be quite interesting.
Speaker 9I didn't mean anything mean spirited by it. I've mean just control and put him on whatever.
Speaker 8I'm not I reckon.
Speaker 9I just thought he's using interesting names and stuff. And I love the like I said, A snot Vampire was great and Race Bannon is a cool name. I love Johnny Quest.
Speaker 8Sorry I didn't. I apologize that. I've heard his feelings.
Speaker 6I think you know.
Speaker 7I'm sorry.
Speaker 3Uh, it's not that you hurt his feelings. That you use this show to insult somebody. That's what I find distasteful.
Speaker 9Well, I apologize, that's that's what I did. I didn't mean to do that.
Speaker 2I I appreciate that. I think. I think it's up to it's up to uh, it's up to the caller, you know, to accept that apology. But well, well, I I think you're being genuine at least, you know, just throw my hat in the ring there. So I'll just move on. I just want to move I can.
Speaker 3Accept the apology. I'm just telling you why I was pissed off about it.
Speaker 9Yeah.
Speaker 2No, I appreciate you pointing that out, Kelly. You know, we don't want to be we don't be like that on here. So that's that's good. I think we should just move on from it now. But yeah, go ahead.
Speaker 6Daniel yeah, no, but I get to respond to his question.
Speaker 9Like I said, it's my fault because I'm all over the place. It's just it's difficult to talk about the subject. You know, I'm here because I'm an atheist, right because I started watching Listening to the Atheist Experience about twenty twelve or so, and you know, when Matt Delahunty and Tracy Harris were hosting and stuff like that, And it's just I would hear that occasionally the subject of like alien debduction come up, and.
Speaker 6That's the subject.
Speaker 9I was interested in ufology and I always liked responding to it.
Speaker 8I always just.
Speaker 9Wanted to respond to it and share my beliefs on what's happening with the UFO phenomenon. And Mars Mars is just one aspect of it. It's the pictures that have come out from Mars from the Curiosity and the other robots have been very fascinating. And I think NASA is covering up lots of the parent showed earlier. I've seen that before. It's nothing impressive. That sort of looks like a parrot.
Speaker 2Yeah, I hear, Daniel. Look, look, this is the reason why Truth Wanted is a space because I recognize, Hey, there is a space for people that do want to talk about that kind of stuff, and this is the space to talk about it. And that's why I talk to you, because this is the space to do that. And I also recognize that you have a you have a mythos if you will, right to your relief. There's a cosmology in of itself. It's not just bug people on Mars. There's a bunch of other stuff. My introduction to you was bug people on Mars, so I do talk about bug people on Mars, and it's just it's just a great way to introduce you. But you know, it's, yeah,
Speaker 2I recognize that that that it's more complicated than that, that there's other things to it. The problem is we only have so much time on the call in show one. The other thing too, is we just have to take things one step at a time. Right, we can get to the other stuff, but like we still have to talk about what's on the table for us, right, and whether we're talking about the bug people stuff, whether we're talking about NASA conspiracies. We got to tackle things one thing at a time. So you know, when you do call in, I do appreciate that we focus on one topic at a time, and I think that's just the best way that we can have a conversation like this. Right.
Speaker 3I want to make it clear too that I love your calls, Daniel. I don't have anything against you. It was just the action. So I accept your apology, and I and I and I encourage you to keep calling.
Speaker 2And here's another thing too, I think what and I'm not. I don't want to speak for Kelly, So Kelly, you tell me I'm wrong. We take doxing very seriously, right, and so I think that that was kind of seen as an act of of using somebody's name that they don't want to be called by, right, So so you know that's that that's my that's why we might as hosts be particularly sensitive to that.
Speaker 9So okay, but but but again, the matter was that I misidentify. I thought something that looked like an insect was really not an insect. I still think are little beings that are that that live on Mars that are kind of like they live underground and they come up and they seem to be work on the ground and they use tools. And what I thought was an insect face was in fact a mask. I think I think they're some sort of like little mammal or something like that.
Speaker 7I don't know.
Speaker 2I don't know what they are.
Speaker 9I don't know what they have. But I just think NASA is covering it up. I said, doesn't want the public to know about it.
Speaker 1And I would encourage you to find a more evidence for this that you can present and come back and go, look, this is what I found that that demonstrates that people.
Speaker 2That's what I'm saying, Daniel. I think the next best step to the to our conversations is what we were talking about earlier. I was joking, but I wasn't. Actually, we need we need a web page. We need to document everything and because we can show it on screen. If we can, like show everything you've collected so far and then talk about stuff that way, one incredibly entertaining, but two it'll help you make your points better for us, right, because if you just talk about pictures you've seen, there's only so much we can do just talking about it without seeing it. Right, Yeah, yeah, I to your point.
Speaker 9Yeah, No, I'm not very tech savvy, so you know, I'm just I'm just a viewer. I'm just the show.
Speaker 2Or you can do it Danie, I believe you can do it. Yeah, I believe this is what you have to do. Let me, I'll give you exactly what you need to do. You know Google Docs, You've used Google Docs afore. Just make a Google docs page and then just make it public and share the link with us. That's all you got to do. Post your pictures in there, your links, whatever you want. Just put it in a public Google Doc. That's you got to do, you know.
Speaker 3Can I ask you a question, Daniel, you said this was a NASA cover up. What do you think is the motive for that cover up?
Speaker 9I think the motive is that they can't reveal that because it unlock more unlocked the truth of what's behind the whole UFO phenomena that you know, like these hearings that are going underway in Washington, what they because soure.
Speaker 3So you believe these tiny do you believe these tiny creatures on Mars are the large UFOs that we're seeing?
Speaker 8No?
Speaker 9No, no, no, no no no. I believe that if they have to, if they have to reveal them, then I would open up a let's say, a Pandora's box of information that they don't want to come out with isn't.
Speaker 3That Isn't that what the congressional hearings were for though, to open that Pandora's box?
Speaker 9Sure, sure, I know, Yeah, yeah, I'm not they haven't.
Speaker 7I'm not saying they have.
Speaker 3But see I'm confused. I'm confused. So if we're already opening Pandora's box, why would NASA be saying not to open the box if other people are already doing it.
Speaker 2I think I think that that's the time because like I think for Danny and I want to speak for but just for for speeding speeding up the conversations. Like I think what Danny would say is that, like that was an attempt to do it, but it didn't actually reveal anything, like you know, it was just people in Congress trying to do stuff because like congressional hearings happen and stuff doesn't get revealed, Like that's not that's not especially a conspiracy. That just kind of happens, right, So you know, I think I think that's what he would say in this case.
Speaker 6One theory.
Speaker 9One theory is that it's like instead of turning on a light instantly, you just gradually turn up the dimmer.
Speaker 2So maybe kind of warming people up.
Speaker 9Very gradual way they're going to reveal it.
Speaker 2Mm hmm. Moving the Overton window on aliens the general public.
Speaker 6There you go.
Speaker 2I see you, I see you, Okay, Daniel. I don't want to get too far into the NASA thing because I wanted you to say your piece in response to the previous call. Was there anything else you wanted to add to that? Or are we good to go for today?
Speaker 9Oh?
Speaker 6God?
Speaker 9Thanks?
Speaker 2Just uh?
Speaker 6I think you uh did he say.
Speaker 9You loved me last week or something? I think I heard you say that I just wanted to throw some love back at you for the end of the new year.
Speaker 2I think I don't know if I said maybe Kelly said that. I do like hearing from you, Daniel. You do make my dt you really do? You really do? I enjoy I personally enjoy the conversations. I there are comments that spake that that, you know, debate whether our our conversations are fruitful, But I don't care. I like him anyway.
Speaker 9So and I and I want to shout out to the call screeners. I think your colle screeners are great.
Speaker 2Thank you, they are great. Shouts call screeners, shout outs. I think uh uh Kaylin's on today, So shouts Kayln shouts to everybody that does call screening.
Speaker 3I think Jonathan's helping around today.
Speaker 2Too, Jonathan too. Okay, hell yeah, we got a lot of folks who help out and do good stuff. And if anybody who's watching this wants to become a volunteer, you absolutely can. There's a way to do that. But anyway, I am going to let you go, don because we are running out of time. Thank you for calling in, and uh, I wish you luck in the new year. And I hope please don't make a Google doc. Man. Maybe google doc that will upgrade the quality of this show by so much. If you start to be in Google docs, Oh my god, we.
Speaker 1Can put them on the screen. Yeah, we'd see it in live time. That's also just to go just before you take another call. We do know for sure that there are two planets in the in our solar system that are they have things on them, right, they're habitated, if that's the right word. Humans on Earth robots of Mars. We know for sure they're robots of Mars, so that's right.
Speaker 2And the and the mermaid people on the moons of Jupiter. Well obvious, that's number three. Let's not forget they fought for rights. They fought for they have suffrage events, they want to be able to vote people. Did that that sounds right? Yeah, I don't know. I'm just I'm just going on here. There is a super chant I need to get to that I have not read that. The crew is a reminding me that I should get to. And it is from Maranda Rensburger. Lovely Miranda Rensburger, given ten dollars, has been a remembered for months and says
Speaker 2some flat earthers claim there's another whole civilization on the other side of the ice wall that the government is hiding because reasons. And yeah, that's that's something I've heard too in regards to the flat earthers, and that expedition didn't do jack shit, did it. They didn't convince anybody anything. It did.
Speaker 1It did convince one apparently, okay, but only to the point that they've just gone, well, it doesn't prove that the Earth is a globe, but it does raise more questions for us. So we're wrong about the sun setting and over the Antarctic, but some of us still believe in flat Earth.
Speaker 2That's that's kind of what came out of it.
Speaker 3Right, the sun doesn't set, but we still saw the ice wall right right.
Speaker 2We got another super chat from Nero, who gave two dollars. You know, you got to contribute to that debt, man, I don't. I don't want to be responsible. Okay, like that's just anyway. But they gave a super chat and said, forget docs gamble on Excel competitions in Vegas. Okay, that's the thing. I guess I don't know about that, but uh, you should be gambling on anything right now, Nero. That's all I'm saying. But look, oh, and I want to point this out. A special announcement from our from our executive producer, who is confirmed in chat that they will
Speaker 2allow us to have two callers on at the same time to to hash it out. Okay, so that's an option to both of you, Race Bandon and Daniel. Okay, we're putting that. We're putting that out there. We won't be doing a show next week, but you know a week after that, listen, we'll game on kick the.
Speaker 1New Year with a great double head ye.
Speaker 2Like Mike Tyson and Jake Paul. Okay, we'll start advertising it everywhere I'm down for it, Okay, but only if you guys both consent to it. Okay, We're not We're not. I'm not gonna do it. I'm not gonna have one of you on and then surprise you with the other caller. Okay. I want both of you guys to be comfortable with that arrangement. So you know, just f y. I but that's a thing. That's a thing, and we have the technology. Okay, I know we got some of the callers, but man, we are we are already over time. But hey, guess what, We're all going to go to a discord after show,
Speaker 2So if you want to talk to us in the after show, you can do that. It's a China out CC slash a CD discord. For that. I want to thank my guest host Kelly and John for joining me today for the last show of this year. Thanks so much, guys, really.
Speaker 3Pretty much, pleasure. Thank you so much for having me.
Speaker 2Had a good time, super cool. We didn't even get to our funny voicemail. Maybe next year we can we can get to that. But this it was a great, great end of the year show. You know, I was worried because, like it's a slower time of year, but man, y'all start popping off towards the end there. Like, it's always great when we can't get to everybody because that means there's a lot of people that want to talk to us, right, But yeah, if you do want to talk to us, we will be going to that discord in just a moment. But I need to remind you guys about the prompt this week. The prompt this week
Speaker 2is going to be what was the cringiest thing that happened to you in twenty twenty four. Again, no political answers. I want it from your personal experience, leaving. If it's funny, maybe I can be funny. Yes, I really can't be not your not your thing, Kelly.
Speaker 3I'm saying was kind of funny when you think about it, there was a big amiss that was kind of funny.
Speaker 2That is kind of funny. That is a that's a funny thing. I'm glad you could celebrate your mother in that way.
Speaker 3My mom was really awesome.
Speaker 2She really was that. I'm I'm happy that you could talk about it in such show vial times that that that is a good positive sign. But anyway, folks, leave your comments below. Of course, if you don't like doing that or you don't feel creative, hitdn't like or hidden subscribe. It's also, you know, really great shout outs to the folks who listen to us on all the audio format only places. You guys are great for that too. And uh, I think that's all I got in the tank this year. Guys, you got anything, last final words, final words of wisdom?
Speaker 2Okay, Christmas, Happy Holidays. We're going to Christmas.
Speaker 1I said it ironically, so it's okay.
Speaker 2Well, yeah, this is the last time John the Key will be joining us on the program, just kidding. You will definitely see him again in the future. And thank you to everybody who's made this year really really awesome. I'm objectively Dan. This has been another episode of truth wanted. Remember to always keep one the truth and I'll see you next time. Watch the nonprofits and joined the course
Speaker 2in the live chart. Visit tiny dot, ccy, slash yt and b
In today's episode of Truth Wanted, ObjectivelyDan welcomes guest Out Of Body Atheist, with The Beard of Empathy on backup, to dig into Reiki, New Age spirituality, homeopathy, and the long road from woo to skepticism!...
In today's episode of Truth Wanted, Jon the Skeptick, Volcy, and Sofia Spina explain why no one can talk to the dead, from Haitian Vodou and grief dreams to Jon's past as a spiritualist! Bob jumps from objective...
In today's episode of Truth Wanted, ObjectivelyDan and Nintendrew, later joined by The Beard of Empathy, tackle a world run on Jesus, the magic of manifesting, and a prayer that actually got answered! Bob in NY, a...
In today's episode of Truth Wanted, ObjectivelyDan, Kelley Laughlin, and The Beard of Empathy tackle standards of evidence, miracle claims, and the false binaries of moral philosophy! Dean in VA questions why skeptics...
In today's episode of Truth Wanted, ObjectivelyDan and Chad Harris tackle Christian nationalism, police brutality, and the uncomfortable truths about racism and immigration. Big E in TN survived police brutality and...