Discover the Truth with ObjectivelyDan and Llana DeBare take a deep dive into hell. They discuss hellish medieval art, classic concepts of hell, and a book that Llana has written about hell, Shaken Loose. Llana describes how this book will raise questions such as: How can a just god create or tolerate such an unjust universe? There is no mercy in hell! Dan in Canada calls to talk about demon possession and a story where a police chief confirmed children were possessed. The story had several claims such as children walking up walls and movie type stuff. The Catholic Church will be the first group to tell you that this is a thing and it happens all the time. If you grow up with that understanding, you will start to attribute things to that belief. Sadly, this can be used as a point of discrimination against people with mental illness. What moved you away from the belief of demon possession? Heath, a lifelong atheist in Canada, tells us of an experience he had as a four year old. Another four year old walked over to him and told him that god is always watching us. When Heath responded by telling her that god is not real, it resulted in her mother screaming at Heath and telling him he had a black heart and was going to hell. We are glad that at the age of four you had the sense of self to not take that comment to heart and have empathy for the other four year old. Heath asks the hosts their opinion on habitable planets, and if they exist, how they could increase the likelihood of god or magic existing. This does not increase the likelihood of the Abrahamic god. Maybe if there was a god that clearly gave his intent such as holding a press conference, that would hold some weight. There is a long history of using miracles to prove god and we all look to that, but so far there is nothing that is definitive. What would it take for you to believe in god? Even if you do experience what you think may be a miracle, remember, that people suffer from delusions. How would you tell the difference? Thank you for joining us this week! Prompt of the week is: It is a bad idea to ______at a formal event. If you struggle with the fear of hell, you can visit Recovering from Religion to learn of ways of dealing with this in a healthy manner. See you all next week! Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/truth-wanted--3195473/support.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Speaker 1Hey, everybody, Objectively Dan here, and I got a question for you guys, especially for you Christians out there. What do you think hell is exactly? Is it a place of eternal torment? Is it another death? Is it just a separation from God? I got a couple of different verses here. One of them is from Matthew twenty five, p. Forty one that says, then he will say to those on his left, depart from me, who you who are cursed into the eternal fire prepared for the devil and his angels. And I got another verse from Revelations that basically says, if your name is not found in the
Speaker 1Book of Life, you will be thrown into a lake of fire. And I don't know if that's literal or not, So I gotta know what do you think of these verses? Is this actually a real place that's being described or is this just some sort of metaphor? And honestly, if this is real, is this the act of a loving God or a moral being? I need somebody to clear this up, So please call into the show because it's starting right now. Hello, everybody, welcome back to another episode
Speaker 1of Truth Wanted. I am your host, Objectively Dan This is the live all in show that happens every single week Fridays at seven pm Central Time. We talk to you about what people believe and why. In every single week we always have a special guest. This week is no different. We have Alana Debar joining us today. Alana, Welcome to the show.
Speaker 2Thank you great to be here.
Speaker 1Awesome, awesome. Alana is an author, a journalist, a former journalist, a school starter, a whole bunch of stuff. Very interesting person. Happy to talk to her today about one of her books and also just her life and her interests in hell. Because you have a book about someone going to the Christian hell, which is interesting because you're not a Christian. So we will talk about that in just a second here, But just to get some stuff out of the way. Truth Wanted is a product of the Atheist Community of Austin,
Speaker 1a five o' one three nonprofit organization dedicated to the promotion of atheism, critical thinking, secular humanism, and the separation of religion and government. And if you want to talk to us, you can do it right now. We are live, and there is a number you can call. It is five one two nine nine one nine two four two, or you can call to your computer at tiny not cc slash call t W, So get in there. We would love to talk to you guys in just a bit, but for now I'm gonna be talking to Ilana. Elana, you have a book that's called Shaken Loose, and it's
Speaker 1the story about a young woman who basically finds herself in Hell. This is interesting because you are a Jewish person. You're also identified as an atheist, and how does somebody like yourself actually decide to write a book like this.
Speaker 3Well, first of all, I just want to be totally clear for the audience.
Speaker 2This is fiction. It's a novel.
Speaker 1This is not one of these.
Speaker 3Books where I claim to have died and gone to heaven or Hell and are coming back and writing about it.
Speaker 2This is made up.
Speaker 3And let me just give a real nutshell summary of what the book is about, because then that will help me.
Speaker 2Explain why I wrote it.
Speaker 3But as you said, the main character is a young secular woman from the Bay Area. She dies, goes to Hell and finds herself in a place she never imagined could possibly exist. And it's classic Christian fundamentalist hell. There's fire, there's brimstones, there's satan, everything she knew about the world is wrong. And it's also a terribly unjust place. It's filled with some people who are truly evil, and then many millions of people who simply were not baptized Christians. So there's people there who lived before. There's one character
Speaker 3who's a West African from before colonialism. He never heard of Christianity or Jesus or Hell. There's characters from Asia. There's characters from the hun tribes on the edge of the Roman Empire. There's people who are perfectly good, decent, flawed like the rest of us who were there, but they just weren't Christian. And the place is starting to fall apart. It's unraveling. So that's the concept. It's kind of a dystopic hell. It's a very unjust place, and
Speaker 3all these characters are trying to get out. Why did I write this? I am Jewish, I am an atheist. I didn't grow up with any conception of Hell at all. But I'd written several novels before this one, and the previous ones had been kind of narrow about, say people in you know, a couple in a relationship. I wanted to do something broader. I started thinking about historical novels, which I love, but I got daunted by how much
Speaker 3research it would take to write about a different era. And then I thought, fantasy, You could just make everything up.
Speaker 1Right, Yeah, that makes sense to me, Yeah, just like say.
Speaker 3Except what I didn't realize when I went into it was making. First of all, I had to research the whole concept and history of hell, which is really interesting. We could talk about that a little later. But also I have all these people there from these different societies, all of who whom die with their own beliefs, their own assumptions, their own expectations of what would happen in the afterlife. And so instead of researching one historical era, I ended up spending time researching pre colonial Ebo beliefs, researching what Huns thought about the afterlife, Researching what a
Speaker 3young communist in Shanghai in the nineteen twenties would have thought about the afterlife and what they missed at home, and what their lives were like and their value. So it ended up being a lot of research, and maybe historical fiction was not easier.
Speaker 1Yeah, yeah, it doesn't sound like it now.
Speaker 3But the other the real reason I wrote A wrote pick this topic was I was playing with the I always start a book with a what if idea, and for me, this one was what if everything I knew about the world was wrong? And being who I am, which is a secular person, a science based person, a rational person, it kind of turned into what if the fundamentalists are right and everything I believe is wrong? Evolution is wrong, science is wrong, and Hell exists?
Speaker 2Yeah, and I'm going there.
Speaker 3Yeah, And so in a way, the central character was a surrogate for myself, although she's a very different person and has her own issues in her own story. But that was the original question that I entered it with, was thinking about a world that would be so much the opposite of everything that I had assumed.
Speaker 1Yeah, so you're telling me, in all of your research of Hell, you didn't find it was a pleasant place. That's interesting. You know, I think maybe you'd find some solace in there. Now, I'm just kidding. Yeah, it doesn't sound like it would be a pleasant thing to kind of look at the history of Hell personally speaking, you know, as a Christian formally Christian, not a Christian anymore. But when I grew up as a Christian, there was even a debate even amongst the people that I went to church with about you know what hell. Even as there's kind of these different concepts, one very popular concept, which I think a lot of my family took in, was
Speaker 1it's just a separation from God. This idea that like, look, God's kind of in his own domain. And then there's this other domain where I guess anything goes kind of vague, but it's not necessarily torture. And then there's this other idea where it's like, oh no, it's it is torture. It is a place where you will suffer and you do that for eternity. And then there's another kind of idea where it's like, oh, it's a lake of fire where you just kind of burn and then you cease to exist. So like, there's never been a clear consensus from my understanding in Christian history about what exactly hell is.
Speaker 1Is that true from your understanding?
Speaker 2That's very true.
Speaker 3It's there have been very different conceptions as time has gone on, and then in different versions of Christianity, like if the Catholic version includes a limbo, it includes purgatory, Protestant versions do not have either of those things. So there's a you know, very different views, and I think, you know, if you talk to modern liberal Christians, it's probably more like what you were raised with the idea of hell is separation from God. That the idea of being with God is so wonderful that being deprived of
Speaker 3that is more painful and more of a punishment, or more of a deprivation than than being burning in a lake of fire. But when you go back, you know, say go back one hundred years to two thousand years back, there is a lot of burning and fire that is a common through line, and burning and fire torture Devil's satan.
Speaker 1Yeah, again not super fine. And this is a kind of an interesting idea for me because I have to wonder about the people who know that I was a Christian. I'm not anymore like what they think, like, Oh, their friend is just going to burn forever, and I guess that's just going to be okay. There is like a weird sort of psychological separation you kind of have to have with that idea that I've always personally found fascinating. But back to yourself, because you do identify as Jewish, and I knew you grew up Jewish, and the Jewish
Speaker 1understanding of Hell really is that it's not really a thing. From my understanding of the Jewish understanding of hell, right, there's concept of shiol And, which is kind of a different thing from Hell. It's kind of almost a sort of limbo within itself. But again, there's never been kind of a consistent idea of the afterlife, even in Judaism. From my understanding is that was that kind of your understanding growing up in the faith.
Speaker 2Yeah, that's true.
Speaker 3I mean I think there there is not a single definition or understanding of it. What you can say is that it places a lot less of an emphasis on a punishing after life than Christianity does. It's really almost an afterthought. And in the books of the first five books of the Old Testament, there's no mention of a punishing after life. What they do have is what you call you talked about shall, which is just this kind of shadowy place.
Speaker 2It's almost like the Greek underworld where.
Speaker 3Where nothing bad happened, nothing good happened, or they talk about when they talk about people like Jacob and Abraham dying, they say they went to rest with their ancestors, or you know, their bones were gathered to their ancestors. So it's kind of this vague, shadowy place, maybe kind of underground, where you're buried, but nothing bad happens. And the place where an idea of hell starts to emerge is in the much much later books of the Old Testament, like the Book of Daniel. And then you get into the
Speaker 3early you know, then you get into the early Christian parts of the Bible, where there is much more of an emphasis on punishment, part of which, you know, people who are looking at the Bible historically, whereas a literary document look at it as that's a period when the Jewish people were suffering a lot. They'd been exiled from Jerusalem, they were in exile in Babylonia. Than then they came back, then the temple was destroyed again. They were at the mercy of these really large empires, the Babylonians, the Syrians,
Speaker 3the Greeks, the Romans. And when you're really suffering like that, you're looking for some kind of justice. You're looking for somebody to come to your aid against these big powers that are destroying you. And so, you know, you look to your theology. Maybe you invent a theology where all these bad people who are doing terrible things to you, they will suffer later. I'm you know, I'm suffering now, but they'll suffer later.
Speaker 1Yeah, yeah, for sure. Yeah. And and and you know, as you talked about this already, but you know, even in early Christian development, there's there's still a mixed ideas about it. I know in some parts of the New Testsmen that they even literally use the word hades, thinking of it as a real place. So that was something that always confused me, of course, growing up. And you know already talking about this of what hell even is. But you write this book and you included as a big part of your story, and I'm wondering what drove you to do this because as you mentioned before, like you are a Jewish person. So was it just the
Speaker 1fascination behind the history of it. Was it just the uh, you know, the the the you know, the history of the idea or was it something else?
Speaker 2So it's a bunch of a bunch of different things.
Speaker 3One is, I think whatever your belief or lack of belief is, living in America, Hell is part of the culture. It's yeah, you know, even if you're not religious, people talk about it all the time. It's you know, when hell freezes over. You know, there's this person was hell on wheels. Oh I didn't really want to eat that big piece of chocolate cake, but the devil made.
Speaker 2Me do it.
Speaker 3So it's part of the culture that we swim in, even if we don't really believe in it. So I think we all are affected by it in some way, even if it's not a major way. It's also you know, it has a long tradition in English literature American literature. I was an English major in college.
Speaker 2I'm a writer. Two of the things that.
Speaker 3I drew on in my vision, the vision that I had in my book, were in James Joyce's Portrait of the Artist as a young Man. There's a sermon that he gives the main character, who's kind of a stand in for Joyce as a young man. He's a young Catholic boy in Dublin and he's in a Catholic school and the priests give this horrific sermon that goes on for pages and pages, telling these young children how terrible hell is and how they're going to suffer if they do, you know, these minor things wrong, and that is just
Speaker 3it's very dramatic and very horrific. Another you know crossing the Atlantic Pond. There in the seventeen hundreds there was a revival movement and one of the great preachers of that movement was Jonathan Edwards, and one of his most famous sermons is called Sinners in the Hands of an Angry God, and he lays it on thick too. He talks about you know you are just you are destined for hell fire unless you are one of the elect You are like a spider being dangled over the flames
Speaker 3every minute, and it's only God's mercy that will keep you from falling to the So as someone who read books like literature, lived in American culture, it was all something that I was aware of, I was interested in it was, but for me it was never I did not grow up with an idea of hell. I did not grow up with an idea of an afterlife, and so for me it was kind of a fantasy or even an intellectual interest. It wasn't something I think if I'd grown up with in a family where I was
Speaker 3told that this was going to happen to me, if I sinned, I would have been so traumatized I would not have wanted to write a novel about it. I would have just like gone far away. But because I was that distant from it, I was able to be interested in it as opposed to traumatized by it. But one thing I realized when I was probably I worked on this for about ten years from the time I started thinking about it to the time I actually, you know, it actually came out and was published. And about halfway through I realized that there are ways in which it is a very Jewish book, even though the main character
Speaker 3isn't Jewish. There's barely any mention of anything Jewish in it, but it's a Jewish It's it's a Holocaust book that never mentions the Holocaust, in that it raises the question of how can a supposedly just God tolerate or even create a universe with so much injustice in it. And that's a question that Jews and other theologians have been asking since the Holocaust.
Speaker 2It's also a question that if.
Speaker 3You believe in this kind of hell, the kind of hell that I drew in the book, where people who are perfectly good, moral people but just don't happen to be Christian are punished for eternity, what kind of God would do that?
Speaker 2And is that just God.
Speaker 1Yeah. Yeah, very powerful observation there, I think because speaking in my own story, right, you mentioned I don't think I would write this if I was a Christian. When I was a Christian and when I was leaving the faith, and I've told this story on there before, but the first time I said out loud that I was an atheist to someone that week, I had multiple nightmares about dying and going hell. And I look back at that as one of the worst times in my life. For one, because I'm like deconstructing this idea that I've had for
Speaker 1a really long time about who I was in my identity and my purpose in the universe. But another because I was actually afraid of the consequences of what was going to happen now that I didn't believe, Because you know, the cat was out of the bag at that point. I couldn't just say, oh, I'm just gonna start believing now, right, And it's not really how that works, right, You either believe something or you don't, in my opinion, right, And so like that was a really powerful thing for me because it made me realize how many people are still in this thing because of that belief, because of the
Speaker 1fear the threat of it. It's it's a not zero number, right. It can't be all of them, but it can't be none of them. So I think that's a powerful indicator of like what a belief like that can do to someone. I don't know if it works for moral compliance, but it certainly can scare the crap out of people. At least it scares the crap out of me when I think about it. But real quick, we're going to take a brief break from our conversation and talk about the comments that you guys leave. We're going to talk about the we want the Truth segment here, folks. Every single week we are asking you guys a prompt that we
Speaker 1want your answers to. And last week we asked you guys a question, what's Jesus's best excuse for not showing up? And we have our top three answers for you right here. We're gonna put them on screen. Number three comes from the ms Zus who says Jesus didn't show up because he was hammered, which that's such a dad joke. I don't know, but I really enjoyed that one. That was a good one. Thank you for that Contribution Number two comes from l Jison, who says Jesus didn't show up
Speaker 1yet because he is too embarrassed by the behavior of people who call themselves his followers. And yeah, that's I gotta say, that's a good one. That's a good one. Pretty true in my experience, at least would explain. I justouldn't say it's pretty true because I don't know if he's coming back, but I would see how that could be a plausible reason there. Number one comes from Chuck Gatos, who says Jesus's excuse for not showing up now that he has a crown of thorns, they can't find a volunteer to give birth to him again, which is I
Speaker 1don't know. You guys are crazy, guys. You guys submit some really crazy comments. But thank you guys for your submissions this week. This next week, we have a problem for you, and it's this complete the sentence. It's a bad idea to blank at a formal event. So leave your best answer below and we'll read our our top three favorite comments from last week or this next week. Man, I'm out of it today, but thank you guys so much for your contributions. There I'll ask you, Alta, is it's a bad idea to blink at a formal event?
Speaker 1Any ideas for that prompt.
Speaker 3I think it's a really bad idea to blank at a formal event, which I do. I'm in a crowd and somebody will say, here, this is Charles, and within three seconds I've forgotten Charles's name because of pressure of you know, meeting lots of people. So I think, just like blanking and having a moment of amnesia is a really bad thing to do.
Speaker 1That's so true. I've been blanking tonight. I read my intro out of order. Longtime viewers will probably have noticed because I'm just all over the place tonight. But that's all right. You know, we all have our bad nights, and I'm happy to have a great conversation here with a lot. But a reminder as well. This is a call in show. I see we've got a couple of calls in, but we still have some open lines. So if you want to come talk to us, please, the number is down below in that chevron and we'll get to you guys in just a sec. But for now, I'm going to continue my conversation with you, Alana. So many awesome directions we can go with this conversation, but
Speaker 1something I told you I want to ask you before the show start that I want to talk to you about now. Because I've met several Jewish atheists in my life, I've never met a Christian atheist. I assume they exist, I personally haven't. What do you think it is about the Jewish community that seems to be more comfortable with that atheist label than maybe like the Christian community. Does you know? I've heard different ideas from folks, but I'd love to get your take on what that label means for you.
Speaker 3Well, Judaism is different from Christianity in that it's not just a religion. It's also a culture. And you know, some would argue it's a nationality, but I mean, whether or not you see it as a nationality, it's certainly a culture. And so if you look at it as any other kind of culture, you know, Norwegian culture, you can be a Norwegian believer or a Norwegian atheist. You can be a Jewish believer or Jewish atheist, but it does get bollocked up because it is both a religion and a culture.
Speaker 2You know, for me, the.
Speaker 3Way I approach it is. I don't believe in God. I certainly don't believe in a God with a long white beard and all that stuff. When we but there but the ethics of Judaism, I strongly appreciate. I appreciate how the history of Judaism has been filled with arguments with God. And even if you don't think God exists, I appreciate the concept of a people arguing with their
Speaker 3maker and arguing with this force that controls the universe. I mean going back to you know, Abraham arguing with God over whether it's just to kill the entire city of Sodom because there was some bad guys, and then you know, bargaining him down, Okay, if you can find a certain number of good men, I won't destroy the city. And then Abraham says, well, how about if we find a few less, you know, instead of twenty forty, what if we just find twenty good guys? And God says okay, and what if we find ten good guys? So I love the concept from a sort of mythic, cultural ethical
Speaker 3point of view of a religion that does that. I think it is a very human centered, life centered religion and the parts of it that are talking about God in when I attend services, Basically I take out the word God and I put in universe life. So if we're talking about thanking God for something or other, I'm thinking, I'm thinking life. I'm thanking the universe and feeling gratitude for being here, for being part of a community, for being alive, all that kind of stuff. So that's that's
Speaker 3sort of where I come from with it. But I think for many people, for many Jews, there's an appreciation of history, family, what their ancestors went through, the values behind the holidays. You can look at a holiday like Passover as a holiday about freedom, escaping slavery, working for a more just world, and you can appreciated very much that way, and look at the miracles as folk legends or metaphors or things like that.
Speaker 1Yeah, that's one thing I've personally have been jealous of in the Jewish tradition that I didn't have growing up. Because like, there is an idea of Christian fundamentalism, which we've talked oftentimes on this show about how actually modern the idea of Christian fundamentalism kind of is in many respects. You know, it's not as ancient or a results as many Christians tend to think it depending on the particular kinds of beliefs, but Judaism, from my you know, curse understanding of it, it has never been about one fundamental text that has been the giver of everything. Much Jewish
Speaker 1literature is just arguing. It's just a lot of people who are saying, I'm an expert on the subject, and here's another expert on this subject, and here's my commentary on it, and here's other commentaries on it. A lot of Christians think, oh, yeah, the Old Testament, Yeah, that's that's the Jewish literature. No, it goes the Talmud, these are there's there's there's tons and tons of texts rabbinic literature that really does debate about God, which I think is really fascinating. You don't really see that in the New Testament so much, or in other Christian tests that are similar. It's it's it. There's a perception of authoritativeness
Speaker 1that comes in a lot of the Christian tradition, whereas the Jewish tradition. And from my understand because obviously it's you know, it's varied, but for many Jewish traditions, it's a much more open conversation, which I kind of like, I wish my Christianity was more of an open conversation. I'm sure there's folks that you know, certainly grew up that way, but for many of us who grew up in a more fundamentalist Christian home, that wasn't really the case. It was just kind of like, this is the way it is, and deal with it, you know. So interesting dichotomy there, for sure. But in talking about your book
Speaker 1and in talking about how you spent ten years what you told me in researching this, that's a long time to research a book about. How did it ever like depress you? Like, did it ever kind of you know, make you feel differently about humanity after looking at a you know, research like that.
Speaker 3So ten years wasn't just the research. It was research, it was writing, it was rewriting. It was rewriting, rewriting or writing, finding a publisher, getting the book through the publishing. But yes, it was a long time and it was not at all depressing, and at times it was actually I would retreat into this world because our real world think about that, particularly between twenty sixteen and twenty twenty, which I won't name any names, but I suspect your readers can figure out what was going on. Then there were times where this world was profoundly demoralizing and things
Speaker 3going on that were you that I was depressed by, and I would and it was much nicer to go into Hell. And partly there. There were a couple of things. One is, as a writer, when I was creating this world, I controlled it, and things were happening out here in our country and in the world, I had no control over it. I was you know, I'm sure your listeners feel this way too sometimes that they're you know, you're just like one little drop in three hundred million people. But when I went into writing, I could make things happen.
Speaker 3I could control things. And it's said in Hell, but my characters are wonderful. They are people with flaws, people who made mistakes, people who are confused, but they're trying hard. They're trying, they're connecting with each other, They're they're slowly becoming better people and learning about each other. And so you're there was this very very horrific setting, and there is one very horrific scene in there that some readers have just like put the book down at.
Speaker 2That point, and I you know.
Speaker 3I wish I could tell them, look, just skip those more pages and keep going. It gets better. But the characters were uplifting and so it was not depressing in that way. But I'll tell you what I did find depressing was about a year before the book was going to come out, I decided I needed to do some marketing, because everybody needs to market their books, and I started an Instagram account about images of Hell from classic art,
Speaker 3which started out being a lot of fun because I don't know a lot about art. I was exploring, I was learning stuff, and there's a huge amount of art in European tradition, which for many years art was Christian art in the Middle Ages and then up until the Renaissance that was basically you were planning religious art if you were if you were doing any kind of art, and so huge numbers of depictions of Hell, depictions of you know, people being torned in Hell, and at first it was really interesting, and then after a while that
Speaker 3did get profoundly depressing because it was the same torment over and over and over again, and just painting after painting, or fresco after fresco, or sculpture after sculpture of people suffering in these terrible ways was really depressing. And you know, thinking about the artists who did this, who would spend months or years on a work just showing people being tormented, what that would do to you. You wake up in the morning, you go to the church where you're working on this magnificent painting that takes up a whole wall
Speaker 3of people being stabbed and garretted and burned to death, and you paint it all day and you go home and know what that would be really depressing?
Speaker 1I will be really depressing. You know. I've talked about this before with Christians who called into the show and they say, well, why do you focus on how what about all these other great things about you know, Christianity and this other Stuff's like, yeah, okay, we can talk about something that's stuff, but like, hey, the rest of my eternity, that's kind of a big deal, right, Like I kind of want to know what's up with that. I kind of want to know what's going on there. And it doesn't seem like it's good, doesn't seem like, I don't know, there's a nice way for me to go At best, it's a separation, right whatever that means very vague. I maybe you have more insight into the specifics,
Speaker 1because I've never found a good, you know, understanding of what that really means. And at worst, it's the worst possible thing I could imagine, which, yeah, you know, that has to affect somebody somehow in some way. Maybe some people they don't really think about it, but for me, at least it was kind of a threat there. I will ask you this, is there a favorite version of Hell that you've come to find? Is there one that you like better than others? Well?
Speaker 3Of the visual depictions, I love Hieronymous Bosh and his paintings are some of the most famous because they're just so bizarre. They're really like something from a you know, hallucinatory drug experience. And at one point I actually we were we were in Spain and I got to see the original of it in the Prado Museum, which was amazing. There's so much detail in it that just looking at a little reproduction on your computer you cannot you cannot get there is so much detail in those so visually
Speaker 3he's fantastic, you know, he is like as creative with Hell as J. R. Tolkien was with Middle Earth, maybe even more. But in terms of versions of Hell, the one that was the most influential for me was Milton and people when you when when I would say that I was writing a novel about Hell, people would say, oh, you like the Inferno, Dante's Inferno, because that's really one of the most famous literary depictions of Hell. And so one of the first things I did when I was
Speaker 3working on this was I got a group of friends together to read The Inferno together, because I'd never read it, not in Italian. We read it in English and it's a there's it's long enough, and it's challenging enough that I wanted, I wanted help, I needed friends. And it's a remarkable book for a number of reasons. And one is that he was writing in Italian, not in Latin, and he was one of the first people to do that. And he integrated classical mythology into the into this very
Speaker 3Christian document in a way that was part of the Renaissance that you know, during the Middle Ages, you wouldn't have wanted to have the poet Virgil as your guide through Hell because he was a pagan, and but he started but he really did that, and it's fascinating how he also used it as a contemporary political document, and he got he tried to get revenge on his political enemies. He was very involved in the politics of Florence and there were two sides, and he was on the losing side and he got exiled. But so he takes the people his enemies and he puts them in different places
Speaker 3in hell. You know, this is the level for traders, and this is the level for hypocrites. And it would be like if you were writing, you know, if somebody, if a liberal were writing a book about Hell and he was putting Donald Trump there, if a conservative was writing a book about Hell and he put Joe Biden there, right, So you can read it that way. And it was very you know, I mean, his structure was he had a very structured mind, and so he had all these different levels where each level the punishment corresponded to the kind of sin. But what it wasn't was psychological or
Speaker 3you didn't get it was not about people. It was about ideas. And Milton, who was writing several hundred years later, Paradise Lost, is his retelling of the story of the Fall from the Garden of Eden, and as part of that he's explaining, you know, where Satan came from, and what Satan was trying to do, and he describes this rebellion by angels led by Satan Lucifer. They lost, they were exiled down to Hell. God created this underworld for
Speaker 3them with fire where they'd be exiled. And then Satan rallies the true and goes forth to get revenge on God by tempting Adam and Eve. And what Milton did was he gave Satan a personality. He gave him an Adam and Eve personality. Also, you really it's more like reading a novel today where you understand their motivations and you can sort of see how they're thinking. And Satan is actually a really attractive character. And Milton did not attend to make him that way. Milton was a Puritan,
Speaker 3but his religious beliefs and I think his his writerly, you know, attraction to emotion and drama. We're at war with each other, and his Satan is he's an underdog, he's charismatic. You have this scene where the devils are all floundering in the Sea of Fire, and there they don't know what to do and they're all giving up, and he rallies the troops and he takes on, you know, the little guy going against the big guy, and so to me, that was a much better story, yeah, I guess,
Speaker 3and a compelling character. And that is kind of the kind of Satan. I mean, that's the backstory for my Hell Okay, yeah, you took If you took Satan and you moved, whatever's happened four hundred years instead of the sixteen hundreds were now in the twenty the two thousands. I pick it up from there.
Speaker 1Yeah. I mean, you know, when you have a character that's the two goody two shoes, okay, right, that's not as interesting, right when you have a character like Satan. Who I mean, come on, how many modern depinctions have made Satan? Oh?
Speaker 4Wait?
Speaker 1What if he was actually kind of the good guy, right, you know, giving knowledge to people and stuff. And you point on something too, that's I think interesting from a lot of art from that period that every single painting or statue I have seen of Satan from like the medieval times, it's always like the hottest guy you've ever seen. Like, it's always a really attractive guy. And I guess the idea is supposed to be well, you know, lust or whatever. You know, there's an element to that, but also like, hey, evil can be very attractive to people. I don't know,
Speaker 1or maybe they just want to make good looking men. I don't know what the thought process was there, but that is a funny thought to think about. And Satan is a character in your book or is it? Is it a Satan like character or Satan is in the book?
Speaker 3Okay, okay, But in the book, what's happened is Satan is existentially depressed. He's realized that nothing he does he can do, matters.
Speaker 5Right.
Speaker 3If he tortures humans, he's fulfilling God's will to punish them. If he doesn't torture them, he's being merciful and that's, you know, a Christian virtue, and he doesn't want to do that, so he can't torture. He can't not torture. Whatever he's doing, he's doing God's will. And so he's decided to do nothing, and he's just lying on a gold bench in his big empty palace in a state of you know, lethargy.
Speaker 1That makes sense because you know, in a Christian understanding of the figure of Satan, right, if you believe elation to be a literal accounting of future events, there is an idea that Satan actually you know, is terminated, right, is thrown in that lake of fire, and so there's sort of a predestination for say, so that's kind of one interesting angle to explore. It's like, okay, well, if it's all for not anyway, what's the deal, I don't know why you even try. So, yeah, I can see how it can be an interesting idea to exploit that
Speaker 1sort of existential angst that may come with well being Satan. I guess also doing the work of God. That's an interesting idea for part of that too, right, because if if God wants you, if he's setting it up for you, then yeah, you're kind of doing the work of God there, which is quite interesting. I see that we have some callers that we're trying to call in and looks like we may be having some issues there. If you're calling into the show, just keep trying and we'll try to connect you in there. But for now, I'm just going to keep talking with Ilana because I'm having a great conversation here on the topic of your on your book.
Speaker 1In a sort of message, you actually made a note to me. It's really annoying and when people ask writers about the message of the novel, but you said I could ask it anyway, So I am going to ask you, what do you think is the message of your book overall? If you could give it one.
Speaker 3So yeah, writers hate being asked that because if you can boil it down to one sentence, why did you spend three hundred pages writing it?
Speaker 2And what about the experience of reading through it?
Speaker 3But if I could boil it down to a message, I think it is that hope and connect hope and you know, salvation not in the religious terms, but in our own personal struggles lies in connecting with other people, and my characters who are flawed, who are confused, eventually improve their situation. I won't say how the book ends, but what's really key is making connections across these barriers, across these barriers of time, place, religion, culture, and so
Speaker 3I think that is where I see our hope are quote unquote salvation. You know, there's a I also wrote a sequel which will be coming out next winter, and in the dedication to the sequel, I said, it says to my parents, who placed their faith in people, including their own, including their three children.
Speaker 1I like that. I like that that's really nice, I think to talking about that subject actually is a good segue for another question I have for you here, which is, like, for folks who don't even you know, you never grew up religious, never engaged with Christianity, never had these you know, kinds of fears of hell or anything like that, is there a reason to engage in this book? Is there a reason to engage in this sort of you know, narrative that you've given out, because, like you said, for some people, it might even be traumatic to kind of think about a scenario that you given Even if if
Speaker 1you know in your head it's fictional, that doesn't take away, of course, from the experiences that many of us had, particularly growing up, Like if you know, I think that that's real. So what would you say to folks who are maybe on the fence who have an idea like that?
Speaker 3So I think, first of all, there's a lot of humor in the book. There are funny parts, there are inspiring parts. There's a very good sex scene, and so it's a good read, and it's an easy read, but it's a you know, it's a it's a smooth read that does raise these questions about how can a supposedly just God create or tolerate.
Speaker 2Such an unjust universe.
Speaker 3So it's it's I've had a lot of really nice visits with book groups who found a lot to.
Speaker 2Talk about from the book.
Speaker 3I mean, like like we are today, but talking about issues of justice, of God, of how they were raised with or without religion.
Speaker 2And I think this the whole issue of hell.
Speaker 3If you're someone who doesn't believe, but you end up talking to believers a lot, or maybe you're questioning your own whether you know, you're trying to figure out your own beliefs, I think it's a real sort of entry point for challenging religion, the concept of hell more than heaven, in fact, because everyone wants to believe in heaven. You have a self interest in it. You know, we all want to think of ourselves as good people. We all want to assume that we're going somewhere wonderful. You know, we don't want to die. We hope that there's something.
Speaker 3There's a lot of incentive to want to believe in heaven. With Hell, it's if you think about it, there's less incentive to want to believe in it if you feel like you may be condemned there for making the slightest mistake, or if you're best friend from elementary school who was Muslim or Jewish or Agnostic or Hindu, if they're going to end up in hell because of not choosing the right religion. I think that's a real place where you can start to challenge or think critically about the whole tenet.
Speaker 1Yeah, that totally makes sense to me. And like with your own perspective, right, I imagine you had to have. I mean maybe I don't know if you were, you know, fully atheist before writing this thing, and maybe you're even more atheists now after writing. Have your own views about religion or the afterlife or anything have changed after researching and writing this book?
Speaker 3They actually did a little bit. I mean I went into it pretty committed atheist. I came out committed atheist, so that didn't change, but my understanding of why people would want to believe in hell change. And I went in thinking this is just an oppressive concept. It's something that people in power use to control people who don't have power, whether it's the pope or it's the king. But you know, you threaten people with eternal pain and punishment if they don't do what you want what you want them to do. That's basically it's a coercive concept.
Speaker 3But as I thought about and so I just saw it as completely negative. But as I thought about it and spent more time there, I thought of so many people in history who have suffered, who have miserable lives, who are suffering from other people doing really bad, evil things to them and looking for something to keep them going, and looking for justice.
Speaker 2And I think the idea.
Speaker 3Of justice, I mean, they are social scientists who know a lot more about this than I do. And the question of whether is there a concept of justice that is hardwired into us the way you know it's hardwired to want to have sex or things like is there is there a human desire for justice or a human concept for justice that exists across cultures? And I think there Without any social science background, I think there is. And people yearn for justice, and if they don't see
Speaker 3it around themselves, they look for it in mythology or religion. And so the idea of having a punishing place that will punish people who have done really bad things who are not being punished in life is in a way it's I mean, it's I wouldn't say it's beautiful, but I could understand it, and it wasn't. It wasn't just the do these things that I tell you to do where you're going to burn forever, but it was it was a beautiful human yearning.
Speaker 1M I think. So that's interesting that you call it beautiful, because the beauty is not the first thing that comes to my mind when I think about it. Really. I mean, like, you know, I don't have a punitive understanding of justice anymore. I really think that that was part of my Christian upbringing that kind of instilled that in me, and I think as someone who kind of has a more rehabilitative understanding of justice, Hell is kind of antithetical to that in many ways.
Speaker 3Absolutely, there's no in the in the classic Hell, and in the one that I described in the book, there's no mercy.
Speaker 2And that's my main character.
Speaker 3At one point says that that you know, what kind of world is this where there's punishment, but if you if you change, if you grow, if you repent, if you want to do better, there is no opportunity for that. And I agree. So I don't think Hell is beautiful, but I think the yearning for justice is beautiful, and to the extent that you know, I can see Hell in the light of this yearning for justice, it made a little more sense to me.
Speaker 1Yeah, that's probably I think that's proably the best thing you could say about the concept of Hell. Right, So, yeah, I got to give you problems there, right, if we think about it as I think you're right, maybe as a concept of how can we make sure that people get their just desserts, how can we make sure that there's something for us to at least, you know, rest on at the end of the day. I can see how Hell can fulfill that role. I don't think it does it super well, and you probably don't either, I imagine you don't, but you know, there is something to be
Speaker 1said about that. There is something about the human expression of justice. Hell is an implematic of that, and not just, of course, you know, the Christian understanding of Hell. There's also other religious deterpretations of Hell. There's a lot of people are surprised to know that, Yeah, there is a Hindu and Buddhist concept of hell. That's not always universal, right, but that certain sects and of course, you know, lots of world fates kind of have some idea of a justice that can pretty much only happen in the afterlife, because the world we live in is as cruel as it is. Right, folks at home, we've been watching, thanks
Speaker 1so much. We've been dealing with some stuff. If you try to call into the show now, we should be able to talk to you. And I see we got some folks that are on the line, So we're going to take some calls now, a little bit later in the show than I like, but hey, we're gonna do it anyway. Alana, you want to talk to some.
Speaker 2People, absolutely, I'd love to.
Speaker 1All right, let's get into it then. Before we get started, though, you guys know, I always have to think the patron of the week because every single week I'm always giving you guys a shout out to the folks that donate on that Patreon. So thank you guys so much for donating. This week's patron of the week is going to be Stefan Vaughn dan Berg. Thank you so much, Stefan or Steven. I don't know. They never give me pronunciation guys for these things. You guy should leave like little pronunciation guides on your name on Patreon. I wish Patreon had that feature,
Speaker 1but he kind of does it. But regardless, thank you so much for donating. Thank you to everybody that donates. You guys, Rock and Kelly Laughlin by the way, being cheeky here gifting five Truth Wanted memberships. Kelly always donating here. Kelly, you can't be donating your backup host here. Come on now, come on, thanks thanks for Donan and Kelly. We'll give you that shout out. Anyway, Let's go ahead and talk to some of you guys. Now we have Dan who is calling in from Canada. Dan from Canada, you are live on Truth Wanted. What's going on?
Speaker 5Hey, Dan, Atlanta. I'm doing well. Just got back home after a long time out. And you know, I saw the chat question talking about hell and that got me thinking about demon possession and I thought, hey, i'll give objectively Dan call.
Speaker 1Yeah, it sounds like a good time demon possession. We all love demon possessions here. So what about demon possessions specifically? Did you want to talk about?
Speaker 5Uh, well, there was this BBC story I came across a couple of years ago and I looked it up. It's still up there. Police captain confirmed children possessed by demons.
Speaker 1Yeah, checks out. I have no question. I have no further questions on that story. That seems legit to me. No, nothing to argue about there. But yeah, that's kind of weird.
Speaker 5Well yeah, looking into the story, there was a lot of claims, a lot of weirdness. But somehow, even in twenty fourteen, there was a cell phone video or just some stated reports of children walking up walls and other typical movie possession stuff.
Speaker 1But I just you just thought you thought that was a weird story that you wanted to share. You just want to get my take.
Speaker 5Yeah, kind of both. And I know you were having some technical difficulties, so I figure i'd give you guys a call with something.
Speaker 1Oh yeah, I appreciate that. And yeah, folks, again we have open lines, so please go ahead and call in and we should be able to talk with you guys. But yeah, So, I mean the thing with these possession stories, it's very funny because the Catholic Church is going to be the first group of people to tell you, oh yeah, like possession is still totally a thing, right. I used to think, well, maybe you know, Christians feel differently about this. When I was a Christian and you hear stories about this, it was always like, Okay, well that kind of happened a long time ago, but I don't know if that stuff happens today. But then you talk to the Catholics
Speaker 1and they're like, oh, yeah, that stuff's happening like all the time. What do you mean, Like they do conferences every year training people on how to exercise people from these possessions. So I think if you grow up with that understanding, right, like, you're going to start to attribute things to that belief being real. Right in the same way that I don't think, like skin walkers are real. Right. If I grew up in a tradition group or a group that has a tradition of skinwalkers, I'm going to start seeing skinwalkers. I just I really think that's how it happens with these kinds of things. Same thing with
Speaker 1the possession stuff. Unfortunately, possession of course quite infamously being used to the detriment of the mentally ill. Right, folks who do struggle with mental illness seem to have these signs of demon possession, right, Oh crazy how that turns out. But yeah, it's often been used as a point of discrimination for those who do it. And maybe that's the case here as well. Maybe there's something else going on. I don't know. At the end of the day, though we are living in twenty twenty four. As you mentioned, it is kind of hard for me to believe when people say, oh, yeah, this is totally happening. But yeah,
Speaker 1I don't know. If somebody acting weird on camera wouldn't be the first time that's happened, probably not the last. I wouldn't jump to the demon stuff, but I don't know a lot of I'll bring this over to you demons. You got demons in your book as well.
Speaker 3Maybe I just have devils in hell. A demon possession will have to be a completely different book. Maybe I'll call it the Exorcist.
Speaker 1Yeah, yeah, that's It's like a winner to me. But yeah, was demon possession or any kind of demonic influence? Was that a source of your interest when you were researching and writing it.
Speaker 2I did not get into that now, Yeah, makes.
Speaker 1Sense, makes sense? Well, Dan, I don't know. I think I gave my take. I don't know if a lot of has any more worse than that. But you know, anything else you want to hear from us?
Speaker 5Yeah, just with your poll question up there. I was definitely taught as a child, I was hell bound. Yeah, that did lots of good. Yeah, right, so yeah, the idea of demons and stuff.
Speaker 3Yeah, was that something that was traumatic for you as a child? Were you were you like scared of going to hell or were you confident that you wouldn't and and what what made you move away from that?
Speaker 1Oh?
Speaker 5No, I assumed I was screwed. Yeah, I just yeah, it just always seemed like, no, definitely not going to make the cut. That was a huge fear of mine growing up. I think the thing that finally moved me away from it has been talking with atheists and getting a better approach to things, because, like I'd still say, I have moments where it's like I fear I'm going to Hell. It might all be real and I screwed up. So yeah, it's a long lasting thing.
Speaker 1Yeah, Yeah, for sure, it's That's probably one of the worst aspects of my Christian upbringing, and probably imagine a lot for other people. Besides, like, of course the absolutely real institutional abuses that can occur in people's lives, and sometimes not even just abuses, sometimes just the reality of saying, hey, this thing I believed turns out just isn't true, right. That can be a dramatic experience of in and of itself. And that's not even including when you bring in the supernatural, when you bring in you know, the ideas of being possessed or or hell being a real threat to you.
Speaker 1You know, it's hard for me to take seriously now, but when I was a Christian, it was very real and it was very hard for me to get over that part of it. So I'm glad Dan that you can call this show and talk about your experiences with it, because I imagine there's a lot of viewers that probably still work through that. I mean, if you do work through that, and if you're still working through a police come in and call the show. If you still have fears about it. We've talked to people who you know are still going through that as well. I would love to hear about your experiences and I would love to help tell you that things are going to be okay
Speaker 1and why you can kind of put some of those thoughts to rest. But anyways, Dan, thanks so much for sharing anything else that you want to add.
Speaker 5Not really keep up the good work. Love the show.
Speaker 1Thanks so much, Dan, that's awesome and thanks for sharing that story as well. Yeah, we'll go ahead and let you go, but have a great rest of your night. Wow. Yeah, Steven possessions huh yeah, still happening, I guess you know again, still gonna happen for a long time. I don't know any thoughts on that call, Hannah.
Speaker 3You know, when I've talked to book groups, one of the things I've asked them is about how they grew up and if they grew up with hell and one of the saddest story I mean I heard. I've heard stories like Dan's where they grew up worried that they were screwed, and I think it's a terrible thing to put on children. There is so much as a child that's scary period when without even thinking about this, I mean, it can be scary to be alone in your room at night. It can be scary if mom and dad are fighting. It can be scary. If your home is flooded and you lose your home. It can be scary,
Speaker 3if there's a mean dog. There is like so much that's frightening. And to put on top of that the idea that you might go to this place after you die and be punished forever painfully is just horrible.
Speaker 1YEA.
Speaker 3One of the women I talked to in one of these groups was not Christian. She was the daughter of two scientists who didn't believe in They didn't raise her with any religion, but she had a friend who was Catholic, and she would go have sleep over at her friend's house or spend time with her and go to church with her sometimes and heard started hearing these hell sermons and became convinced that she and her parents were all doomed because they weren't Catholics, and would go home and
Speaker 3she would pray silently by herself in her room that her parents and she wouldn't have to go to Hell.
Speaker 2I mean that's horrible.
Speaker 1Yeah, Yeah, there's nothing good about it. There's nothing good about it. War is there to say? Honestly?
Speaker 5Right?
Speaker 1Yeah? I wish it's if there. I don't want to eradicate people's beliefs. I think I would want to be like Unesco. I would want to have you know, cultural sites for people's beliefs. I think, like you know, there's some stuff that I definitely want to go away for sure, But there is something about the human condition, in human psychology that would fascinate me to, you know, just to look at. That's one of those beliefs though, where it's like maybe it is good that that would just go away, right, Maybe maybe that's one where it doesn't really have a whole lot of benefit and we can work on better
Speaker 1ideas for people. But I don't know. We have some other colleges though, I want to talk to before we do that. Though. It is the top of the hour here, so I got to get some announcements out of the way real quick. One is that you've been hearing a lot about our annual Back Cruise fundraiser. It's happening next week next truth wanted. We're going to be having an awesome in person show with a whole bunch of faces, so check that out when it happens. But if you're going to the Back Cruise, you're going to be seeing Christy Powell, Lacrosse Examiner, Jimmy ju Or, Kelly Laughlin, Secularity,
Speaker 1j Mike, and of course Forrest Valcai all going to be there, and more so, if you haven't got your tickets, unfortunately, you're going to have to be on a waitlist. But maybe maybe if you get on that wait list, you might be able to still get on the boat, So come join us. If you're going to be in the Austin area, back Cruise is going to be a super awesome event. Also, if you want to hear our content and audio only form, you can go to tiny out, cc slash an podcasts for all of the latest ACA shows. You don't have to watch my face if you don't
Speaker 1like it, so go listen to the show if you like that. But if you ever said to yourself, hey, I really like this stuff and I just want to listen to it all the time, every day twenty four to seven, well guess what we have not one, but two different twenty four to seven live streams, one of them for the Atheist Experience, the other one for Talk Heathen that you can listen to. For both, you can go to tiny out, cc slash AXPTV or tiny out cc slash heathen TV to join in on the fine And let me tell you, there's always somebody in those chats that you could talk to. So if you just
Speaker 1want to talk to somebody about some of these ideas that are being talked about, you don't have anywhere else to go. That's a great place to do it. Last, but not least, before we move on, I have to thank the wonderful, fantastic, amazing crew I'll make this show happen every single week, switching that crew camp and of course the dogs that also help make this show happen. That's also great. Thank you to the crew, and thanks to everybody watching for this show because it's really made for you and buy your support. So thanks so much for that. Now let's go ahead and keep going to our next caller. Here, we have another Canadian trying to
Speaker 1talk to us tonight. We have Heath from Canada. Heath, you're live, untruth wanted what's going on hither?
Speaker 4I just kind of since you brought up the sudeviect of Hell, I've kind of wanted to tell you as Nathey, it's kind of like it's something that happened to me on my first day at school, and this was like before actual school. It is like summer school. I was four years old and it was like, except for a few concerts, my parents took me to my first experience with being with a bunch of other kids other than my family, and the first kid I talked to was this other four year old little girl, and she she came up to me, and the first thing she said to me and my brother were God is always watching us,
Speaker 4you know. And we were like, oh, well, God's not real. Uh, there's no such thing. And then she wandered off, and a couple of minutes later, her mom came up to us and started screaming at us, and she I remember just tically what she said. She said, you've got a black heart and you're going to hell. And it's a four year old kid, you know. And and I remember my exact thought at the time, because I have a kind of reactionary memory. I remember my reactions to things and then the rest comes. And my reaction was of
Speaker 4this poor kid, Like, what a terrible parent. I felt so bad for that kid. I didn't feel like I had a black heart and was going to hell. I knew I didn't have a black heart because we only watched documentaries my house. We watched no commercial television, just PBS right, a lot of time documentaries that I knew my heart was and and I didn't believe in hell. So my my reaction was, oh, this poor kid, you know, what a terrible parent, you know, And it's just kind
Speaker 4of a thoughtful people who think that they'd get their their morality from Christianity. And I remember when I was a little older, was seven years old or eight years old, I wanted to join Boy Scouts because my entire social group would go on Wednesday nights to Boy Scouts, and so I saved up my allowance for I think two months in order to be able to buy the little scarf from the shirts so that I could go. And on my first day, we went and did the stuff. My dad was a boat builder, so but not tying and stuff. I already knew I kind of got to
Speaker 4be a hero there. But at the end of the day it was like, Okay, now we're all going to pray to God. And I was like, for reasons I had already gone through whether or not I believed in God, I didn't and I was like, well, no, that's the honest, that's lying, So I'm not going to do it. And they kicked me out at that point, like one day boy Scouts, I have to save up for two months to buy the stuff, and they wouldn't let me back in because I refused to What I thought of at the time is Lyon.
Speaker 1You know. Yeah, yeah, a lot of people don't realize this, but as an Eagle Scout myself, I can tell you. And first of all, by the way, it's handkerchiefs, it is not scarves. You'll get roasted by the Boy Scouts, but being roasted by a boy Scout isn't that big of a deal. But but yeah, Boy Scouts Boy Scouts of America is a Christian organization started by a very Christian man, Lord Maiden Bow, and the United States definitely took on a Christian identity. There are several religious specific awards you can get within the Boy Scouts. So when
Speaker 1a lot of people hear that, I guess they get surprised because I don't know, most people see it as pretty secular. But no, it's an explicitly Christian org for sure. So yeah, that doesn't surprise me that they might take as to your lack of belief there.
Speaker 3I'm just really glad that, at the age of four, I'm just really glad that, at the age of four, you had the confidence and the sense of self that you were able to not take that woman's comment to heart, and that you also had the empathy to feel for her daughter, that's a testament to that your parents were doing something right with you.
Speaker 4I agree, Oh, well, thank you, and I think you'll just be a testament to you don't need religion to get moral as well. Like I remember the voice got Leader or saying to me, we'll pretend to pray. You can just pretend, and I was like, that's a lie. I'm not going to be dishonest. Because I'd gone through this thing where something had come up in the news. My mother had said something had come up about religion, and I remember saying to my mom, well, that wouldn't happen to our family were all atheists, and she said, well,
Speaker 4your dad isn't. I was like, what it's like, Well, no, he was raised as a Christian and he's still gonna believe. So, I mean, we don't push it on you guys, but he's he's a theist. We don't use the we didn't use a face theist back then, and uh. And I thought, well, that's that's five against one. That's not very cool. I'm going to become a theist. And I cried for two weeks. I cried really really hard to believe in God and I just couldn't do it because I don't believe in magic, and that was a benchmark for me. You have to believe in magic first, you know, and and you know,
Speaker 4you hear a story about something true that happens, and you hear a fairy tale, and they have a very different structure. And to me, everything I heard from the Bible was the fairy tale structure. You don't believe that stuff. It's it's got a very obvious, you know, made up to it. So I guess my final question for you guys, is is the Mondy? A year ago I was listening to a podcast about science and technology and about what it would take to get humans out into the galaxy, and uh, and I realized what would actually convince me
Speaker 4that God was real? And a first reaction to that was, wow, I'm being completely unreasonable?
Speaker 1Or am I like?
Speaker 4And so I want to give your opinion? Like I thought, if every time we looked at the new Sun there was a habital planet around it, perfect for humans, that is so unlikely that that would probably convince me that God existed. But that's already not the case. And when I saw it was like, am I opinion an unreasonable prick? I mean, is this a rational you know, So what do you guys think about that?
Speaker 1Let me try understand it hypothetical. You're saying, if it were true that every time we looked at a new star outside of our solar system and we found a habitable planet, not necessarily a lived on planet, but a habitable planet, that would increase your likelihood in the existence of God being real. Is that right?
Speaker 4Yeah, because even a super powerful alien race, because of the constraints of the speed of light and how much energy it would take, it's kind of unreasonable to think that that could be done by anything other than basically magic.
Speaker 1You know, I could see that, I could see I think that would at that point. Wouldn't the aliens be a more reasonable explanation because at least there's some naturalism going on there, right, Like, if we exist, I still don't understand under naturalism why there couldn't be other life forms doing stuff.
Speaker 4Right, aliens are pretty unlikely because you would see a kind of wave of of them moving through the universe. You would still see the planets they hadn't yet reached and stuff like that. And if the aliens were able to just go to every point in the universe at once and create a habitable planet for us. At that point, I'm willing to say that God's at least equals likely.
Speaker 1You know a lot of Neon Genesis Evangelians, So I don't know that could that could be a possibility. I don't know, This is a big hypothetical. I think like the fact that we don't see that, right is maybe more of attachment to that, you know, God not being a thing. Maybe if that was the case, I would say, to be reasonable, I think it could perhaps increase the likelihood of a creator that creates the universe, that is, like, you know, maybe is interested in life. Being sure, maybe it increases the likelihood. But when it comes to the
Speaker 1whole God part, right, because God is a very specific word with very specific connotations for a lot of people, I don't think it increases the Christian God in the slightest for sure, or the Jewish God, or you know, any of the Abrahamic understandings of God. I think it would have to be a kind of different God in general. The Christian God is particularly interested in the Jewish people one, and then you know, eventually Christianity, and then I guess Muslims too. Eventually then you know, so other beings on other planets that wasn't really in the realm of at
Speaker 1least the humans understanding of what God wanted. So it had to be a very either a very different understanding of what the Christian God is or just like a different kind of God altogether. So I don't know. I guess that's the best answer I can come up with for your hypothetical there. But I want to hear Alana's take.
Speaker 3Well, what I'm hearing is that the caller I'm sorry, I forget your name, is trying to come up with a scenario that is in his mind inexplicable by science. And you know, different people with different understandings of science could come up with something like similar. I mean, you could say, oh, my God, if I got a pizza that just came out of the oven with symmetrical little pieces of cheese that all looked like Jesus, that proves
Speaker 3that might prove that God. That proves to me that God exists. And you know, we would we would find a lot of rational reasons for that. The baker was the baker, did it whatever? But I think probably we all have some threshold where if there was something really miraculous that couldn't be explained otherwise. Then you do turn to God, or you turn to a religious explanation. But as Dan said, that's not the universe that we're living in. That's not we don't have habitable planets in everything.
Speaker 4That's kind of my point. So I'm being unreasonable because this is already not the case. We already know that this isn't the thing, you know, So when I say this is my criteria, it's like my criteria would be a two plus two equals three.
Speaker 1Right. You know, you're saying, I get what you're trying to say. Yeah, I don't think I was getting it before, but I'm getting what you're saying. Now. You're saying, is it unreasonable for this to be my my drawing line? Right? For like whether God can be real? And I would say, I think I could come up with some better ideas for reasonable you know, reasonable beliefs. No, I would say reasonable reasons I guess why God could be real? I think you can come up with some better ones. I'll give you some examples right now. If there was a
Speaker 1guy who very clearly gave his intent and did it through a press conference, so that like multiple people. Verified journalists for example, could like do interviews with and collect statements from and we could like look at different news sources and see, oh, yeah, this person definitely said this thing because this source got this. I mean that's I don't think that's that unreasonable. A lot of people will scoff that and say, well, God can't do that, and I said, well why not. Seems like it works for everybody else on earth. I don't know why, you know,
Speaker 1Jesus couldn't come out and give like a press statement or something. I think that would make things more clear. I think if a god came out and just sk just talk to people, you know, just made his intent clear. For some Christians, that's that's too unreasonable. But I don't think that's unreasonable. I think that if I'm a creator of a people and I want them to worship me and have this great relationship with me, I think you got to talk to him every once in a while, right. So I don't know that's my that'ld be my sort of line to drive. If God could just do that, that'd be great, But anything beyond that, I'm gonna be
Speaker 1skeptical a little bit. But I don't know a lot of what do you think.
Speaker 3You know, it's there's a long history of using miracles to prove that somebody is God. It goes back to Exodus when Moses is talking to Pharaoh and he does all these things. He you know, turns the rod into snakes and he things like that, and Pharaoh's magicians copy part of it, and so I think we all kind of look to that, but there's so far nothing that has really been definitive.
Speaker 1Yeah. Yeah, But if you were opposed with the question, right, if somebody's asking what would it take for you to believe in God? You know, what would you answer to that?
Speaker 3You know, I would need to see some kind of miracle that was completely inexplicable, and that was not inexplicable because we didn't understand the science of it yet. I mean, there are things that are inexplicable with quantum physics and with the way the universe works that are still being researched. So just because we don't understand it doesn't mean it's God. But if it were something, you know, if somebody came back from the dead and they were really truly that person and they were staying they're talking to me, that that would be pretty that would shake the way I thought.
Speaker 1Yeah. Yeah, I mean it would shake the way I would think too. Yeah. So I don't know that's the thing, Heath, because like if you when you're talking to somebody who thinks you're the one being unreasonable, I would just say, hey, look at these stories that say that would happen. Why can't they happen to me? Right, I just think that that's a reasonable way to look at it. I have not had a miracle happen to me. I've heard stories of miracles, but that's about it. So I you know, maybe a miracle would change the needle, but overall, there's got to be something more than just well, it's because
Speaker 1the book says so, right, which is what I think a lot of people rely on. But Heath, what do you think?
Speaker 4Yeah, I just I couldn't think of a miracle that wouldn't convince me to make me think of the prestige. Like the book where someone actually does come back from the dead and it turns out that it's actually his twin brother and his other brother was killed, but they have been living at the same person for so long they've lost all sense of their own identity and they just will both live as the same person because they've been doing it every day for decades and they've just lost any individuality, right, And that would be a rational
Speaker 4way of explaining someone coming back that could fool people, right, That would fool me in that scenario. So, knowing that this is possible, I don't even think someone coming back from the dead would would be convinced enough for me. Okay, I haven't explained yet. Like I've had times when I feel like a dream I've had is coming true. And my raction to that is, oh, that that chemical in the brain that squirts when you remember something is squirting at the wrong time. Now, I don't think that I
Speaker 4can fool a feature or dream the future. I just know that my brain is missquirting with chemical and making me believe that, Like, there's probably very little that would make me lean towards magic rather than a rational explanation, if you know what I mean.
Speaker 1I think so too. I think I think you know that's a great point, and I'm glad that you brought it up, because when it comes to miracles, right at least ones that we personally experience, that's also going to be to your own detriment because you know, unless you have other people in on that experience. The thing is people have suffered from delusions. It happens every day. It happens all the time, even in younger, healthier people, right, Like, it can still happen. So some of you just saying, hey, this thing happened to me, that's still not going to be enough, at least for me, right, I think it
Speaker 1has to be something that could at least be somewhat verified through some other process than just well I saw it happen, right Like, I just people say, well, why does it have to be Well, why do you have to use all these methods? Why does it have to go through science or whatever? And it doesn't even have to be like an article written about it or anything. I'm just talking about like something beyond just a fishtail, right, which is what a lot of miracles end up being to me at least, right, Like, oh yeah, it was this big you know, I don't know, but I think you're right on the money there. You know, if anybody's
Speaker 1challenging you about this kind of stuff, I would just say, look, there's lots of ways that could happen, right, he there's a whole book of stuff that I think could happen but doesn't happen to me, and I would just point to that. But I do want to plug something real quick since the crew brought it up, for those who've been listening to the show and it maybe have been struggling with their own beliefs, particularly with hell beliefs. We do often part with an organization called Recovering from Religion that has some great resources on their website and also has some folks that you can talk to on the
Speaker 1phone about what you're going through. So just a quick plug for folks who want to have some of those resources. But for now, I am going to go ahead and let you go any last words you wanted to shout out before you sign off today, I would like to.
Speaker 4Plug the Philip Kate that book Maze of Deaths, which is a book where people figure out the frequency you're broadcast on to actually have their prayers answered. And it's just a fascinating book about what if you could like pray into a radio and actually get them answered. And it's still OK, you can't go wrong, So amats of guests check it out.
Speaker 1OK, Dick, I hear that guy write some good stories here here. He's got a few bangers that flip k dick. But anyway, yeah, Heath appreciate your call, Thanks so much, and gosh, we have some other folks I see in the queue here. But we're getting towards the end of the show. So here's what we're going to do. We are going to the after show in just a page here, which is for the at the Atheist Community of Austin fan run discord server, So link to that is going to be in the description. It's also there on screen. They're tiring out cc slash ACD discord, so bring your calls,
Speaker 1bring your questions to the discord where we'll break for just a few minutes after the show, and then we're going to go into that after show for you guys, if you want to talk to us live but not on the air. That's one of the cool things is if you don't like being recorded and you don't want your conversation all out there, it's a non recorded space for us to hang out. We'll be going there in just a second. But before we you, I need to thank our wonderful guest tonight, Alana de Bear, for being on the show and giving us her fascinating perspective and also interesting interesting stories about the research and writing on
Speaker 1her book, and of course talking about her book is Alana thanks so much for being on the air with us.
Speaker 3Thank you, it's been great. And if people want to get the book, it's on Amazon. The title is Shaken Loose and it's my name, Ilana Debaert, but Shaken Loose on Amazon.
Speaker 1Yeah awesome. And of course want to give you a chance to plug if you have any social media websites stuff where people should go find you if they want to see more of your stuff.
Speaker 3Yeah. I my website is Elanadebaer dot com. I L A N A D E b A r E like in my picture right below me all one word dot com and I don't do you have a did you get the Do you have a meme of the book?
Speaker 1Or I think we have a picture. I think Cruse should be putting it up in just a second, because I have I have.
Speaker 3An actual cop be if people want it. But if you're going.
Speaker 2To be there, it is the fire. But if you actually have have a meme, that's even better.
Speaker 1Yeah, I think so, crew, let me know if we have that. Oh, they don't have it ready for us right now at the moment. But but hey, we got the book on the screen there so you can see exactly what it looks like. It does look like a book about hell to be fair, you know, it's kind of got that good color scheme. So good choice on your publishers on that. But yeah, I want to thanks so much for joining us today, and folks at home, thanks again for putting up with this again today with some of our technical difficulties. Thanks so much for watching. I want to remind you guys about the segment this week. The prompt is complete the sentence. It's a bad idea
Speaker 1to blank at a formal event, and look forward to reading your comments. For next week. Well, we're going to be doing our special in studio show. I also want to give a quick shout out to Kelly for being our backup host, and I thanks so much Kelly for hanging in there. He's going to be in the after show as well if you want to talk to him, and we're gonna be going there now. So without further ado, folks, I'm gonna go ahead and sign off on tonight's program. I'm objectively Dan. Remember to always keep on the truth, and I'll see you next time. Watch the nonprofits and
Speaker 1join the hosts in the live chat. Visit tiny dot cc slash y t n b
In today's episode of Truth Wanted, ObjectivelyDan welcomes guest Out Of Body Atheist, with The Beard of Empathy on backup, to dig into Reiki, New Age spirituality, homeopathy, and the long road from woo to skepticism!...
In today's episode of Truth Wanted, Jon the Skeptick, Volcy, and Sofia Spina explain why no one can talk to the dead, from Haitian Vodou and grief dreams to Jon's past as a spiritualist! Bob jumps from objective...
In today's episode of Truth Wanted, ObjectivelyDan and Nintendrew, later joined by The Beard of Empathy, tackle a world run on Jesus, the magic of manifesting, and a prayer that actually got answered! Bob in NY, a...
In today's episode of Truth Wanted, ObjectivelyDan, Kelley Laughlin, and The Beard of Empathy tackle standards of evidence, miracle claims, and the false binaries of moral philosophy! Dean in VA questions why skeptics...
In today's episode of Truth Wanted, ObjectivelyDan and Chad Harris tackle Christian nationalism, police brutality, and the uncomfortable truths about racism and immigration. Big E in TN survived police brutality and...