In today’s episode of Truth Wanted, ObjectivelyDan and guest GothDamnIt_Jay explore the intersection of alternative subcultures and atheism! They dive into the aesthetics of the dead, the weirdness of being a third-generation atheist, and whether biblical mythology is just a well-funded fantasy franchise. Can secular individuality survive the pressure to stay in line with ancient Christian dogma? Michelle in NY explores Lucifer’s rebellion and spiritual warfare. Dan dismisses these as biblical fanfiction, while Jay views them as entertaining myths like Greek legends. Is there any reason to treat angel hierarchies as more than fantasy? Rudy in TX argues Christianity is true because it is hated and historically accurate. The hosts dismantle the "hatred equals truth" logic and highlight the lack of evidence for the Exodus. Can stories pulled from a "poetry jar" survive history? Thank you for joining us today! We will see you next week and don't forget to add your answer to this week's We Want The Truth question: What is Bigfoot's favorite conspiracy theory? Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/truth-wanted--3195473/support.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Speaker 1Hey, folks. You know, when I was a kid, there's a lot of people that said, hey, being alternative or being emo, or being off, these things were incompatible with Christian values. You know, you're kind of celebrating the sort of aesthetic of the dead, or the aesthetic of satan in some cases. You know, a lot of them were saying Satanism was the same thing as a lot of these sorts of esthetics or ideas, even though they absolutely weren't. And a lot of times it was just people trying to express their individualities in ways that weren't particularly mainstream.
Speaker 1But it doesn't really matter. There's a lot of Christians that say, hey, you have to be this way or not be a Christian, and I just think that's silly. Why not just express yourself or your individual individualism a little bit. But truthfully, I don't think Christianity is very kind to individuals. In fact, I think it wants you to just stay in line and not be your own person at all. But maybe you disagree with that. Maybe you think Christianity is all about expressing yourself, or maybe you think, no, it's not, and that's a good thing. Whether you believe that or not, you should call in
Speaker 1because the show is starting right now. Hello, Hello everybody, and welcome back to another episode of Truth Wanted. I am your host, Objectively Dan and this is the live call in show that happens every single week Fridays at seven pm Central Time where we talk to people about what they believe and why. And if you'd like to call us, you can do that now. The number is five one two nine nine one nine two four to two, or you can call it through your computer at tiny
Speaker 1dot cc slash call tw folks, in case you're new here. Truth Wanted is a product of the Atheist Community of Austin, which is a five oh one c three nonprofit organization dedicated to the promotion of atheism, critical thinking, secular humanism, and the separation of religion and government. And folks, we are try streaming tonight, so big shout out to our viewers on TikTok and YouTube mobile. If you're watching us on TikTok tonight, you can talk to us through there. You can request to join and we'll bring you up
Speaker 1on stage just like we do with our other callers. Just please make sure you are over the age of eighteen before doing so, and folks. Every single week I always have a special guest. This week is no different. Today I have joining me Goth damn It Jay is joining me today. Goth damn It Jay.
Speaker 2Welcome to the broct Hello, I thank you, sir, I appreciate it.
Speaker 1I also said goth damn It Dan, because you were making the joke earlier that you're not the only Dan on here, and then it was like, you know, the puns with your name. I don't know. There's something about that that almost threw me out there.
Speaker 2But I get yelled at a lot, so you know, God right, okay, goddamnit today. So I'm just like, all right, that's fine. Just I'll just make it more my esthetic now. And oh hey yeah, so Jay, if.
Speaker 1You could describe yourself, how would you describe yourself? I'm I'm me.
Speaker 2I am a horror movie enthusiast. I am a third generation. I like to know a lot about the Bible. I love me some science. Science makes me happy. And yeah, I stream on TikTok every once in a great while. I like to do movie reviews and talk about movies over on a different streaming network. And yeah, that's kind of what I do these days and working on a podcast or two three.
Speaker 1Yeah or four. Yeah, there is something that and you mentioned this before the show too, about being a third generation atheist. You know, that's interesting in America. I feel like in other countries that's not that interesting. In America, that's very interesting. You don't hear about that too often. So what was that like growing up as atheist in America? Because I can't relate to that. I didn't become an atheist allow as an adult. I can't imagine. It's just like being a kid.
Speaker 2Yeah, it's kind of a fucking trip because like, so what my grandfather's obituary was an atheist and a five Yeah, and yeah, his his parents came over here from Poland and you know, fleeing the the snotties, and you know, here I am eventually. But it's it's really weird. There's you grew up and you don't know that you're not you don't know like that they're these people who believe
Speaker 2these things. You're just existing, you know, Like I had really no concept at all of religion until one day, you know, I got beaten up because I said the God question wrong, Like you believe God?
Speaker 1Like no, and then you get beaten up, and I'm like, what the hell was that you got beat up because you didn't believe in God? Yeah, that's like the that's like the reverse of like the Columbine thing. You remember the Columnbine myth where they were like, oh yeah, they went around and they asked them if they believed in God and then and then you know, they shot those kids. So you're saying it was the opposite of for people were saying, oh yeah, and then Okay, that's what it was.
Speaker 2It was super weird, like one of my one of the best things that ever happened, and he was finding George Carlin because he helped me find a lot of the words and expressions that I am. And that was a really good place to start because I didn't have any resources. There's no community, There was no community growing up with just a bunch of atheists, so I didn't known, you know, nobody else did. We just again, it kept existing and one day I saw carl and he's like, well, you know, they'll they'll kill you because you answered the God question wrong. He got no dead believe in God? Yes,
Speaker 2do you believe my God? No dead? And like, oh okay, So I found out, Hey, we used to be Jewish. I'm like, oh, okay, we had Jewish heritage. Let me try that out. No, that was the wrong answer too. So after that, I was like, Okay, I need to figure out what's going on here because.
Speaker 1Fucking what? Yeah, likeeah, okay, well what's happening? So like everybody else had this thing going on, why don't I have a thing going Yeah?
Speaker 2I was really confused, and I ended up like grabbing like a couple, you know, kid and teen study Bibles from there, and I learned about it, and you know, that didn't help my belief at all.
Speaker 1It obviously did you start going to church or were you just this was a solo project.
Speaker 2Mine was a solo project. Anytime I went to church, was it was a trap?
Speaker 1Yeah?
Speaker 2Yeah, Like somebody was saying, hey man, we're having a cookout or we're having a cookout. Yeah, cool, I guess I'll go with you. No, it's a two hour sermon and some shitty pizza.
Speaker 1That's how they get that.
Speaker 2I think Apparently, I don't know, it didn't work, but I was just really disappointed.
Speaker 1I mean, like, obviously there's Christians that go to those functions, but I truly think there's a lot of people who are a lot more ambivalent on the whole God thing. But we'll just go, especially in smaller towns, we'll just go to their local church function because that's like one of the only social events that you know is you know, so that's interesting that you know you had to do that too where you were thanks sex girlfriend one of the us.
Speaker 2Did you grow up in, uh, the East East Coast, mostly Southeast Coast and then Kurt and then a little bit of New York So.
Speaker 1Okay, a little bit of New York. Okay, well that's a New York. You know, that's a fairly big melnting plot of different Yeah, that's I was.
Speaker 2I was like a teenager by the time I got up. I got up here, but like I spent like the uh formative years down in Florida and that again it's my buddy was in the cup Scouts or whatever, and I was like, oh, yeah, I'll try the cub Scouts like with my friend.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 2And they're like they're like, no, you can't do that. I'm like, what, like, you know, mom and dad had to explain no, it's because of you know, hashtag no Jesus, and I'm like, what, what's the hashtag?
Speaker 1Hashtag? I like this anacronism. You're you're sorry son hashtag no Jesus in like, yeah, sorry, don't cap bro no CA. Yeah, I can't do it.
Speaker 3Yeah.
Speaker 1A lot of people don't realize that. As a former Boy Scout myself, I can very confidently attest to the fact that, yes, the Boy Scouts is a Christian organization. In fact, there's specific awards you can get for your faith. Although like even by the time I was in there, they were still trying to make it to like it's just a general sort of God belief. I don't know, but it's still very much Christian.
Speaker 2It was still like what like in like like the first couple of pages of the Manual itself.
Speaker 1Right, Yeah, yeah, yeah, definitely, like it was definitely a Christian, you know, scouting thing for boys, and they they definitely, you know, kind of tone that stuff down. I think as it got more popular, as you can imagine, I don't even know if they still talk about Christianity at most Boy Scout events. Uh, we didn't even talk about it too much. It only came up occasionally, but you know, it's definitely there. And also like we meet in the church. That's that's another reason why a lot of Boy Scout troops like do meet churches because they're Christian. So yeah,
Speaker 1that makes sense. M h m hm.
Speaker 2So you know, so I just ended up gravitating towards the things that you know, were.
Speaker 1I guess like eating babies and yeah, watching horror movies. Yeah I can't. You can't do that anymore. I can't do anymore. No, oh no, as it gives you after work, Yeah, I don't know. It looks like you have some I guess those are funk o pops, which you say, look like you might have some babies right there on your shelf in the background.
Speaker 2Those are all those are all upstairs with you know, the body parts and organs and stuff.
Speaker 1You gotta am I right, gotcha? So so so it was atheasm'm from from from birth to now. Then you didn't you didn't stray from the atheist path. You didn't. You weren't like, oh I'm a wicking for a little bit there, or yeah, maybe God Israel A couple of years of that, nothing nothing for you there.
Speaker 2No, I just I just the the closest thing like I ever got to like supernatural type things. Was I you know, I grew up going to be a ghostbuster? Hmm, well it doesn't well, I mean not everybody has their own the flight suit and personalized patch.
Speaker 1Okay, okay, all right, all right.
Speaker 2I'm I'm I am just I'm not obsessive. I'm passionate, damn it.
Speaker 1Do you like actual like ghostbusters like the the media franchise or ghostbusting as in you're going into a haunted hotel at night at you know, at like three o'clock in the morning and your recording.
Speaker 2It's a media franchise because if I could do the if I could do the second one, I wouldn't be here right now, would be outdoing that.
Speaker 1Gotcha gone? Okay, yeah, no, that was the most different.
Speaker 2That was one of the more disappointing things is when you find out, no, that thing you wanted to do, that's that's just not a that's just.
Speaker 1Not a thing. Yeah, you, ghostbusting not a legitimate career path. I mean, in the age of online influencers, you know, I'm sure, I I guarantee you, there's a tech talk niche of dudes going out and you know place where they shouldn't be and recording a weird sound. I mean, I could twenty three skuld do you.
Speaker 2A paranormal you know investigation, you know, I get sippity do yah dieu an exorcism if that, If that's your thing, it's all bullshit though.
Speaker 1Yeah, well of course.
Speaker 2I could throw some you know, cat toys on the ground and if they light up and over there, that means that there's a spirit present walking through. Yeah, look at that, the the EF yeah, EF detectors going off. It has nothing to do with these electrical chords, but it's definitely hold on, yep, that's a ghost for sure.
Speaker 1Yeah, no, totally, that's how that works. So I mean, so you growing up atheists and and you know, religion is something you're always encountering on the outside, not something for yourself. But now you're streaming and you do talk about religion, So what's the interest there.
Speaker 2I ended up kind of looking at it like like Greek mythology for a long time because that was, you know, my kind of view of it was, you know, from the outside, looking at like mythology. And for the record, it is some really cool mythology, Like there's some good like Christianity you mean hell yeah, pun intended? Okay, yeah, tell me what you mean My favorite franchisees Are you kidding me?
Speaker 1That's like awesome versus demons and shit, and.
Speaker 2Like yeah, like like like like God creating the devil and then the Devil's being all pissed off about it because he doesn't like humans, like all of that, like the war in Heaven and Hell and that's all dope as hell. Yeah, pun intended. But you know, if if you're gonna go well, it's also real. No yeah, yeah, that makes you right, so yeah, go ahead, no, no.
Speaker 1Please, Well, I assure what you mean, because it's like, I'm not a Christian anymore, right, but if I was a Christian again, I often thought, well, I probably would be like a Catholic or something, because at least with the Catholic traditions, like esthetically, it's really cool, right, Like all the churches are at like really cool designs and all the artwork is really cool.
Speaker 2It's like at least and stuff like that, and like yeah, kind of like Matt murdocking it up, dude.
Speaker 1There's a sense of tradition and there's a sense of culture there and and genuinely. That's why people like it. Like, that's one of the pros of the thing, you know, I don't think that. I think every religion probably has a pro in there somewhere, right, not all of them, I don't know, maybe not Jonestown or whatever, but you know, like like all the major ones, there's definitely pros, and like, that's one of them, I think, the at least for the Catholic churches. And that's probably why there's so many Christian influencers right now that are like, oh, I'm actually Catholic now, you know, there's like this trad cat sort of revival happening.
Speaker 2Oh yeah, I just thought they had the best hats, that's all.
Speaker 1I don't know. There's been a lot of commentary about it, and people have different ideas. I think it truly is because you know, we're having a time where people are feeling more existentially uh sort of insecure than ever, right, and I think like tying yourself to these sorts of traditions and saying, well, yeah, you're a Christian, but are you a real Christian? Are you a part of the church. You know that there's there's sort of an appeal to that, right, you're part of something bigger than yourself. And and Protestant churches they don't really do that. It's just like, oh, here's your local, you know, second Baptist church down the street,
Speaker 1versus here's here's the thing that's in Rome. You know, it's just like a part of the whole city for it exactly. So yeah, and everybody knows ahead of that one. And yeah, right, so I think I think that's the appeal, So I understand it. Obviously. I don't think it's good, but I know.
Speaker 2Like that's another like interesting thing I guess about, you know, always being atheist, is I like the whole true Scotsman argument for me is like just baked into a Christianity entirely because like there's what forty eight thousand different denominations of Christianity alone. Yeah, yeah, they all disagree on some shit. So yeah, I all say that they're right, right.
Speaker 1I was reading a thing about that recently, how that number is actually kind of skewed a little bit. Yeah, So, like apparently that number comes from like a study that that somebody did just sort of counting out like different churches different and basically the way they got their paperwork was if it was like there if there's a Baptist church in America and then there's like a Canadian Baptist church, like they would count that as two separate churches, even though they might be part of like the same conference or whatever. So like regional places would would count. So
Speaker 1it's a bit of an inflated number, but it's still like a lot. It's still like you know, in the sound still yeah, when it comes to it, there's still a lot for yeah. Yeah, like like it's all based on like one book more or less. It's like yeah, yeah, more or less. That's the other thing too, not even the same book sometimes if you're Catholic, it's a different versions of the book.
Speaker 2Yeah, And then like you know, I don't know what makes a real Christian and I've had people try to explain it to me and I have I haven't gotten there. Like, yeah, I'm a blank slate when it comes to that, because like I know what's in the Bible, but like, do you, right, does that make you a Christian or not? Like, like I don't really get it, because you know, there are
Speaker 2people like I'm absolutely a Christian and they're pretty clearly not, I guess or at least definitely don't follow the teachings of you know, the dude with the sandals and whatnot.
Speaker 1Yeah, yeah, I think I agree with you. It's like, if I became a Christian, I'm not even sure what that means anymore these days, because people do have different ideas, and of course the typical personal response is like you said, well, it's just whatever the Bible says. It's like, yeah, you think that these other churches didn't didn't do that, You think they didn't consider like what the Bible said. Yeah, I don't know, but yeah, I agree. It's it's it's it's complicated. I don't know what that would mean either, but I guess uh. You know, Christians seem to have it all figured out right. They never disagree.
Speaker 2And even the people like within those denominations have their own different you know, thoughts and ideas and visions of what they see. So everybody techting you would have their own different ones. So what the like, what's right?
Speaker 1It's true. The biggest debate I see in the atheist community is whether rocks are atheists or not. You know, that's probably our biggest schism. We have the rockists and the non Denoma rockinists. I don't know, I don't know what you call that, but there's there's gonna be something. We need to have an official schism, I think. And to promote that official schism, let's bring on Flabbergasted real quick so we can talk about our question this week, Flabbergasted. What's going on? My friend? Oh?
Speaker 4Just just chilling. Thank you for letting me out of the closet.
Speaker 1I appreciate that.
Speaker 4It's nice to be given some fresh air every once in a while.
Speaker 1Absolutely, I'm sure get stuff like me or anything. Yeah, it's right. Probably Stuffy in there was sharing it with Kelly too. You know.
Speaker 4So he's sleeping in the back corner of the closet right now. Okay, so he is not available.
Speaker 1What Yeah? So this week, first of all, folks, if you're if you're new to this, we have a thing we do called We Want the Truth. It's a segment where we ask you guys a question or prompt and last week we asked you one flabbergasted. What was it? It was?
Speaker 4Would you swipe right on Jesus?
Speaker 1Yes? Would you swipe right on Jesus? And why?
Speaker 4And why why isn't I'm going to add that that's an important caveat. Why ye swipe on Jesus if you will, of course?
Speaker 1And what were some of our answers for that?
Speaker 4Well, we we have a minor issue with that. I didn't get the document.
Speaker 1Oh he doesn't have the document. That's okay, I'll do it, folks. Number three comes from Chuck Gatos Fire three eight seven, who says Jesus would swipe right on Pope Nicholas, the first for banning meat on Fridays. His fish and Loaves franch hies finally made a prophet that year. So okay, very specific, also historical, i'd say, so.
Speaker 4That Jesus would swipe right on the Pope or the Pope would swipe right on Jesus.
Speaker 1They're saying Jesus would swipe right on the Pope.
Speaker 2Okay, so when he's wipe right on everybody though, because doesn't need love everyone.
Speaker 4Well, I mean not those of us that are taken by Satan.
Speaker 1He didn't swipe right on Judas, probably right, that's not a thing. I don't know. I don't think that's the thing. But number two comes from Anathasia, who says Jesus would swipe right on everyone and then immediately ghost them, which is so freaking funny, so good, such a good joke. Bravo. I really like that one. Thanks for your submission. And number one also comes from Chuck Gaos who says Jesus would swipe right on Santa Claus. Someone should do something
Speaker 1for the children, and it certainly won't be Jesus, which I like that interpretation of, you know, saying they're kind of filling in into the role of Jesus, which I mean, sure, why not just as mythical I guess in a way, just as fantastical if you will. But you know, no death involved, I think, right, No, no blood sacrifices to get presence.
Speaker 4Ye. Well, and actually I just for greater context for everybody. I messed it up. Yeah, I think I don't know the document, but I messed it up.
Speaker 1It wasn't would you swipe on Jesus on what?
Speaker 4And why?
Speaker 1It's who would Jesus swipe right on? Yes, I was trying to. I was trying to see if nobody would notice, and then you know, but now to point out.
Speaker 4So that's why I saw where I was dumb, and I corrected my dumbness. Live to the public so you all need to see that that when I'm wrong, I'll admit it.
Speaker 1Well, Flabber guess we appreciate your public contributions. Yeah, we'll give you your lashings late for that now. Oh okay, well now now I kind of don't want to do them. What's the opposite of giving you lashes? I'm going to make you lash somebody else? Maybe? Is that?
Speaker 4Oh no, No, that's that's all right.
Speaker 1Well, well I have a bag either way, I have a bag I can pull out for this, like trying to get well or after the show. Is for after the show. I don't think Greg will appreciate us talking about this on the air. So now we have to talk about our question for this next week. Flabber guested, So do you have the document up now or should I never got the document? He never got it? Okay, I mentioned that earlier. You always have access to the document. Man, it's Google Docs.
Speaker 4Is it the same document every time?
Speaker 1Yeah, it's the same time every time. Okay, So I'm just I'm a bad person. Wow, wow, my bad I thought. I thought I'm considering developing a shame based religion just so we could shame you. Right now, you know what ah on me, I'm okay with that. Okay, well, you gotta stop being with these does. Come see there we go, it's not working. Okay, I'm going to do this. The problem for this week, folks, is so dirty ideas. Yeah,
Speaker 1the problem for this week. The problem for this week is what is Bigfoot's favorite conspiracy theory? Okay, what is Bigfoot's favorite conspiracy theory? Any ideas from you guys on that? Oh? Yeah, okay, what you got I.
Speaker 2Have been pondering on this one all day, and it's the fake bird conspiracy. The fake bird one.
Speaker 1You mean the ones where they're like the birds are by the government and stuff.
Speaker 2So these are weird because they are technically biologically made, but they're not like the same birds as they work. He knows because they taste completely different. Okay, and he goes, he knows what's up? I could see big Foot being a Bird's not really kind of guy. That makes sense to me. What about you, flabber ascid?
Speaker 4I think his favorite conspiracy theory is that Jesus loves you?
Speaker 1Oh? Okay? Is it? Is it a conspiracy? If most people believe.
Speaker 4He's been around a long time, he met Jesus and from what I heard, Bigfoot kind of thought he was an asshole.
Speaker 1Okay, well, uh, that might be the conspiracy I think, seeing that Jesus is an asshole because I'm pretty sure we got third of the planet, is.
Speaker 4Like we didn't have we didn't have what other people thought. We're just talking about what is his favorite conspiracy.
Speaker 1I guess, so yeah, okay, well all right, those are personal for him. Personal. Yeah, that's true. Those are some creative ideas, gentlemen, those are pretty good. But I I have an idea, okay, and I think that Bigfoot thinks that the footage they made about him was faked. Okay, that's his conspiracy theory. They're like, no, they're trying to cash in on my name. They didn't want to get the rights. Yeah, they didn't want to get the rights to his likeness, so they they they just got a
Speaker 1guy in a costume for it. And he's been pretty pissed about that. But if he shows himself to the world, then other people will, you know, take that, and you know he's very private, so yeah, but.
Speaker 4He does believe in the footage of lock and as monster. That is undeniable as far as Bigfoot's concerned.
Speaker 1That'd be awesome if they were friends. They go, they visit each other and oh no, he knows.
Speaker 4He knows. Bigfoot knows that lock and this monster's not real. That's why he knows.
Speaker 1Can we can we just stick with NeSSI we're trying to move away from the monster the rebranding. Yeah, okay, Well, on that note, folks, leave a comment below, give a better answer than the one we gave to what is Bigfoot hard? Yeah? What is Bigfoot's favorite conspiracy theory? Let us know. I will read our favorite answers next week, but until then, flabbergactid, or maybe not until then. Maybe we'll get you on later. But right now we're putting it back in the closet. Yeah, yeah, back in the closet.
Speaker 2So I'll rest of the little balls for the crossfire game, could you?
Speaker 1Yeah? Yeah, if you could just adjust the I think I left some dry cleaning in there. I don't know if you could fix that for me, but anyway, Yeah, thanks for your time, flabberg Acid, and for being our background post today. On that note, this is a calling show, so it's awesome when we get to talk to callers. Do you want to talk to some callers? Today with me. Jay. Oh well, I suppose we could do that. Yeah, all right, okay, well let's do it. Before we do that, we need to thank the patron of the week real quick. Every single week we're obviously going to shout out to the folks on the Patreon. We of course appreciate everybody who
Speaker 1donates to the show, but this week's patron of the week is going to be that. Are you serious? All right? This is a new one. It's just a period. It's quotation mark, period quotation mark. How am I supposed to say that? I think they made a challenge for me to try to figure this one out up. Well, that's interesting. Thank you quotation mark, period quotation mark for the donation, and I appreciate it, very very nice. So you're the patron of the week, just a period. Very awesome. On
Speaker 1that note, let's go ahead and take our first call, shall we, You know? And done that? All right, we have Michelle who wants to talk to us from New York. Michelle, you are live, untruth wanted. What's going on?
Speaker 4Oh?
Speaker 1Not much? Dan and Jay?
Speaker 5God, damn it, Jay God always always nice to be on with you guys.
Speaker 1You guys are great. Yeah, Thanks for talking Michelle. Always nice to hear from you as well. What kind of topic did you want to talk to us about today?
Speaker 5I was going to bring up but I know something different in mind. But then when I was listening to the show, God Jay said something that piqued my interest about his appreciator, like and I always like to hear because you rarely hear an atheist when they will say, hey, this really kept me coming back to Christianity. You know, this was something that really piqued my interest or caught
Speaker 5my ear. Were something that I yet still find interesting. But the but the rest of it, I could have done it out.
Speaker 6And that was.
Speaker 5Lucifer's Paul and the rebellion and the war in heaven.
Speaker 1Mm hmm, okay, what about it specifically?
Speaker 5Well, some people and God said, well it all it seemed to have all ended. It all seemed to have but ended. But in my opinion, there are some scripture as some scriptures that would indicate the warn heaven didn't end. It merely spilled out onto this plane of exist instance, and it's yeah, I don't still it's still being carried out on a daily basis.
Speaker 1Right, Yeah, No, if you're if you're a Christian, like a real true blooded Christian here, okay, and you grew up in the South, right, you would know that absolutely Satan is still on this earth trying to trick us mortals, you know, into doing his dark deeds, and that it'll all be over after the events and revelation. But like revelation hasn't happened yet, right, So like if you're if you're one of those Christians, which is definitely the Christians I grew up with, then yeah, absolutely there's still spiritual warfare going on. I don't know too many people that are like, yeah, that part's over. I guess there must
Speaker 1be Christians that believe that, but I think that would be the minority opinion amongst most Christians.
Speaker 5Well, it would seem to me from where I've traveled and where I've been that depending on I mean it really you could. I mean even in different churches. It runs the gamut really truly, because like you'll see people saying that, you know, Satan is a defeated foe and we really don't have anything to worry from him and his cohorts, and they're all defeated and under our feet,
Speaker 5so we really shan't think about them. But what there's a scenture that I really much like in the in the Christian Bible, and it says that we have not worry and fight against flesh and blood, but we fight it and wrestle against powers and principalities of the air and heavenly places. And the Bible talks about these angels that fell as having seflichers in heaven and it and
Speaker 5and they had the Bible. The Christian Bible also talks about these angels having seats and positions in heaven. And so I find that such a compelling statement. I find that such a compelling statement, And like what was?
Speaker 1What was?
Speaker 5And Christians just expect us, even though even they expect us to buy into this idea that Lucifer just got pride full and fell and it was his pride is almost no reason for him to fall, really, But in my opinion, I think somewhere along the lines God had to have said to the to the angels and Lucifer, hey, this is my plan to create humankind in my likeness. Yeah.
Speaker 1But you know, here's the thing. Here's the problem. For Schelle. I'm gonna interrupt you right there you're jumping the ball because none of this happened, none of it's real, so it doesn't matter, right, Like it's just the thing. Well, I'm just saying that the reason why the whole Satan and the mythology of heaven and the angels and stuff is so kind of wild in some of its descriptions is because it's very vague and it's very inconsistent. Like you're talking about some stuff where they're talking about these descriptions of ranks and stuff. You see some of that
Speaker 1in Revelation, like almost anywhere else in the Bible, like you you see very little of that. There's there's some linking elements there that implies that there's like some sort of hierarchy with angels and stuff, but pretty much everything we know about these kinds of ideas are all lost to time, like the original text for some of these, specifically even some lost books of the Bible. And I say lost books, I just mean books that are mentioned in the Bible that aren't you know, currently known or out there you know kind of talk about some more
Speaker 1of this, but yeah, you know, it's all it's all kind of fake and just made up, and so like you know, people can write their own fan fictions about it, but at the end of the day, that's kind of what it is. To me at least, it's just kind of biblical fan fiction. But I know, Jay, what do you think exactly that?
Speaker 2As a matter of fact, there all kinds of different angel type things mentioned in the Bible, from the Sarah family to the cherubs and stuff. Those are all different variations of they quote angels, right, Yeah.
Speaker 1So I don't know.
Speaker 2I think the mythology of it is a lot of fun and can be played around with in a lot of fun different ways.
Speaker 1That's why that's why I call it.
Speaker 5That's why I called because you had said that and I wanted to.
Speaker 2But it's I mean it it happens to be a pretty good example of of of a fun, I hate to say, kind of generic, uh story about good and evil. I mean, we've seen an awful lot of archetypes of the bad guy who you know, fell from grace and then was like, you know what, I'm gonna do my own thing here, doctor Doom, and then you know, you know, like there's there's that's that's an archetype at this point.
Speaker 1To be fair, I mean, the Bible is kind of an og in that sense, like you know, it was, it was kind of a genre maker. You know, I'm not saying it's completely original, but I'm saying, you know, they have as much to go on, you know. Yeah, Yeah, there's a lot of awesome Greek stories about right right, right, Yeah. A lot of people, Yeah, the atheists in my conversational right fleet point out, oh, what the Bible took from X y Z. Yeah, I know, I know, it also takes from other people's worst I'm just saying when you're watching it, like the boys right now on TV or whatever,
Speaker 1like you know, they're they're they're also taking ship like from the Bible as well, Like there's no everybody's been doing that for a while. So if you're cut up there adding ship to the Bible, yeah or anything.
Speaker 5I just thought it was so interesting and I find it's so interesting that that that Jay commented that he praised the Bible for having such a grand mythology, and you find that as an uncommon trait in atheists. Atheists are so quick to uh to pick out the thing that all the big things that they don't like in the Bible, and then they leave out some of the really meaty mythology. I mean, seraphim have six wings, just
Speaker 5and they're they're always constantly shielding themselves from the base of God with their wings, which is which I'd find to be quite sad. They're not allowed to look upon the base of God. What does God must think about these seraphim if they're not allowed to look on this vase?
Speaker 1Yeah, I mean that's kind of a you know, it's like an SCP concept almost, you know, it's it's the it's these weird little, you know, sort of fictional storytelling elements there. And and I don't know, I'm not speaking for Jay here, I want to hear his thoughts, but I I get what you're saying. There's definitely a lot of other atheists that are quite critical of the Bible and storytelling, maybe overly so, perhaps perhaps right, I mean, obviously we want to be critical about the values that are presented there, especially in how they pertain to today
Speaker 1culture and society. You know, maybe they were helpful for some people at sometimes they're certainly not helpful for me and the people that I love. But you know, as far as the mythology goes, I think the best parts of the Bible. Yeah, some of it's in there, but a lot of it just comes from other people interpreting the Bible and then like retroactively putting their stuff in there too, right, Like Dante's Inferno is a classic example of that. Dante's Inferno is just a gigantic fan fiction full of all kinds of you know, personal yeah, paradise loss like you know, personal stuff and ideas that yeah,
Speaker 1we're inspired by the Bible, but really aren't you know, biblically based at all. I mean, if you're taking all kinds of writings from Christian writers, then you would believe in like the Phoenix, because Origin writes about the phoenix about being like a real thing and stuff, and so, I don't know, there's there's lots of different ideas there, but the Bible itself is I don't know, it's not a grand read. I'd say, I don't know if anybody's reading the Bible like just raw, you know, they're just looking at Wikipedia and reading some sumber being like, huh, that's that's pretty cool. At least that's my experience in
Speaker 1the most part.
Speaker 5But one thing, why do you guys think, like, hey, what, here's a question, Uh, do you think that it might be a good argument to say that maybe if some especially the scripture, the sacred texts that we draw from or religions and in some of our history, why why do we take some of the correct history in them and throw out all the spirits? Well, the how com
Speaker 5it couldn't they couldn't get any of the spiritual stuff?
Speaker 7Right?
Speaker 1Ah, I have my opinion on that. I guess I can go first few on jams.
Speaker 2Means, well, I'm trying to process the question in the first place.
Speaker 1Because I can't. If you praise the Bible and it's cool parts too much, suddenly you might be accused of a betting Christianity and and and maybe even a betting Fascism on some level. Right. It's like a lot of these guys do this. A lot of grifter types these days are like, oh no, actually, the Bible's really cool, you know, like look at Russell Brand and these guys who are like appealing to this certain demographic, right, And I think that that's that's that's part of it. It's guys who probably didn't like Russell Brand definitely didn't grub Christian,
Speaker 1didn't care about it, and he's probably again reading these like one paragraph summaries about Seraphim on Wikipedia, and it's like, Oh, that's actually sick. You know, the Bible is pretty awesome, and you know, I think that's why people get out of that. I personally, for me, I don't know that I need. I don't think I can get any more spiritual enlightenment from the Bible. I recognize it for what it is. It's the text of its of its time, of multiple times, actually expands quite across a broad range of times, and and I think it can be respected
Speaker 1for that. But I don't I don't need. I don't know. It doesn't really help me in my life. It doesn't really inform me or help me solve any of my problems. There's better resources out there for that. And I don't really need the Bible for it. I think it's a poor way of informing my life of those kinds of things, if anything. But that's my take.
Speaker 2What do you think, Jay, I'm gonna have to go ahead and agree with you on that. I'm not getting anything moral out of the Bible, that's for sure. But you know, I'm if I wanted to look for something that's gonna make my life better in my own personal way. It's you know, I got plenty of other things and stories and movies and comics and everything else to help me go that direction if I so choose, they're better told whatnot and usually fallve a lot less kinocide and whatnot.
Speaker 1Yeah. In real life, yeah.
Speaker 2Star Wars fans can get pretty angry, but I've never seen, you know, a Star Wars fan kill a baby over you know, the less Jedi.
Speaker 5So yeah, you know, and you haven't met every you haven't had every single Star Wars Fanji.
Speaker 1You're saying that that's out there, that's already a thing in the news. Yeah, I feel like that's that's something that wouldn't we would hear about that.
Speaker 5I've seen some fan fiction.
Speaker 1Yeah, well that's there's you know, there's just doesn't make it real. Yeah, I'm just I'm just Michelle. Is there anything else you want to talk to us about before we let you go?
Speaker 5Yeah? I was wondering if Alise said, and a lease is great. By the way, you got to keep Alise around, Uh, she said, maybe to ask you because Kelly made a comment of me at the end of last couple of weeks shows ago that I didn't get to speak to him about and uh, if you could maybe sometime or at the end of this show, if I could stay in the line, if he'd be agreeable to speaking with me for a minute or two.
Speaker 1Kelly, Kelly's not here today. If he was here, he'd be on the show. He's not. So I'm not Kelly's keeper. You know, you'd have to call him when he's on the air. But you know, if if you leave a comment, I'm sure he'll he'll do it, or hey, I'll do you. I'll I'll do you one better, Michelle, because you can always contact anybody at the Truth Wanted Show if you email truth at Atheist Hyphencommunity dot org and you can mail all your inquiries there. I see that stuff, Kelly sees that stuff, and so so you can talk to
Speaker 1him that way. How about that?
Speaker 5Fantastic?
Speaker 1Thank you?
Speaker 5Right and goddamn it, Jay.
Speaker 1Thank you Michelle for Colin. You have a great rest of your weekend. So there you go. That was Michelle, Jay, what'd you think of that? Call? Wonderful?
Speaker 2If anybody out there wants some other good, you know, Christian related media like that, Diablo's awesome. Uh, check out the Prophecy movies fantastic. How do you not love Christopher Walking?
Speaker 1Come on? Yeah, yeah, it's for stuff. Well, I don't know. Christian movies are kind of garbage though. That's the other thing.
Speaker 2It's like, oh no, no, no, no, no Christian mythology movies.
Speaker 1Yeah. But but here's what I'm saying though, Like, you know, Michelle's having this point. He's like, how come if this there's all this cool stuff, how come people aren't like talking about it more and are inspired by it more. It's like, have you ever seen Christians make media out of their own stuff? It's mostly garbage. And you know what, I'm not alone in this. I think most Christians would agree with me genuinely. They would say, yeah, Christian movies kind of suck that they don't watch them either, that's why they do so bad. But you know, there is all this cool stuff, but they choose to focus on, I don't know, the smaller scale stories. They don't really
Speaker 1talk about the war in heaven or whatever.
Speaker 2But right they like all their good meat and cheese, Like, where is the cool movies about the apocalypse? Yeah, the best one we got had Seth Rogan in it. Like, what the hell yeah. Or it was a Nicholas Cage and that one right and Take?
Speaker 1He's in Taken? Right? Am I crazy? The Taken movies? Was that Nicholas Cage? I don't remember that? No? Sorry, not not taken. What's it called? No? The one? Uh no, I'm not that's Taken as a Christian movie would be kind of awesome. Uh there's a there's a bit there to be sure. No, what's the one where I'm thinking of? Uh, left behind? Left Behind? That's some thing. Okay, yeah, left Behind Taken? You can see how I got that confused. No, left Behind is the one about you know, look a
Speaker 1revelation and stuff. Anyway, it's not great. I don't know. Uh No, there's so much Sure Cameron in it. Yeah, yeah, there's that too. I mean, I guess with a two thousand year old book, there's only so many stories you can spend with it too. At the end of the day, you know, you gotta find something again. Would be fucking dope. Yeah, really fun to watch, I guess.
Speaker 4So.
Speaker 1But you know what, even if you wanted to make it cool, there's always gonna be Christians out there that are like, actually, that's not biblical because if you look at the force, it's actually you know that people complain they always do. Yeah, yeah, I I'm not looking for accuracy here, I'm looking for fun. Yeah. No, that's fair for us. It's fine for them. It's like it's real, right, so you know they'd be more concerned about it. Folks, we have open lines right now, so we would like to talk to you. If you want to talk to us on TikTok, you know you can do that. Get that join button and request to join as long as
Speaker 1you are over the age of eight. And of course you can call through our number. It's at the bottom of the screen if you'd like to do that. Before we keep our conversation going, I have a word that I need to share from our fellow host, Jamie the Blind Limey about an exciting event that's happening in May. So check this out.
Speaker 6Jamie the Blind lime here and I've got some interesting news for you. On Saturday, May sixteenth, at six pm, we'll be hosting on twenty four hour We are here live stream and fundraiser to highlight secular.
Speaker 1Voices around the world.
Speaker 6We've invited dozens of your favorite content creators like genetically Modified Skeptic, the Antibot, just in these and more to let the world know that we are here and we're not going anywhere. If you're in Austin, come join us at Free Thought Library at fifteen oh seven West Cain and Lane. Well, we'll be kicking things off in style. And if you're online, do join us on the Atheist Experience channel to check out the stream and join in the fun. So join us from wherever you are in the world, and together we can dedicate ourselves to secular
Speaker 6humanist values wherever we are.
Speaker 1Yeah, so come check it out. If you're gonna be in the Austin area, you know, free to come by and we would love to see you there. Another way to support the show is by sending us super chats. If you get those in, we will read as many as we can as they come on the show, as long as they are of course, YouTube and TikTok appropriate. And last but not least, I need to thank the wonderful, amazing, super stupidous crew that he'll make this show happen every single weekend. There's our crew camp. Oh what's Vern doing.
Speaker 1Vern's always up to some shenanigans. He's got some sort of he's got some sort of machine that he's what's he Why is he holding it so suspiciously? I don't understand. Does he steal that? Is he stealing stuff? I don't know what he's doing? All right, Okay, that Churt's gonna have to figure that out. Uh, Vern's up to some no good. He looked like the hamburglar. He was like trying to get away with something there. I don't know, folks. One thing I have to mention if you want to become a host or a volunteer crew member at the
Speaker 1Atheist Community of Austin, we're always looking for more talent. So if you email volunteer at Atheist Hipocommunity dot org, that lets us know that you want to get involved in Hey, we can try to find a spot for you. Also, I'm gonna tease something here, folks. We are having a major, major, major change happened with Truth wanted, a very big shake up. That's gonna be happy here around the time of the fundraiser. Actually, so I can't actually tell you what's happening yet, but
Speaker 1look forward to that because truth is about to change in a major, major way and for the better. Might I add so we'll see it as it happens. I suppose I want to keep talking to goth damn It Jay here while we have open lines. I started the show by talking about alternative sort of goth emo aesthetics, ideas, subcultures, and Christianity. Right, this is kind of an interesting topic because obviously, you know you're you're you're sort of a
Speaker 1fan of some of these subgenres, at least a few of those, right, you like, you like here and there. I've heen there you dabble, and that makes sense because you're an atheist. But there are people that I knew growing up who would say, well, you know, you can't be a Christian and be a part of these other things because those are kind of of the devil. Did you ever experience that? But did you ever people like when you were a kid, did you still keep that kind of a stick and people were saying, oh, this is ungodly, this is Unchristian.
Speaker 2Yeah, but you know, I just existing out in the world. You know, there's plenty of you know, eye turns and stuff, your head turns and stuff like that.
Speaker 1But you know, I'm not an idiot.
Speaker 2If you dress in all black and you know, wear large jinko pants and you have makeup on, you know, long hair and piercings. People might actually look at you. So you might have to accept that as part of being who you are and what you're doing. And I'm fine with it. But it's you know, the you know, you're satanic or whatever that happens, and you just kind of have to brush it off and laugh. It's like, no, no, Satan's your thing, not mine. Thinks though, you know, most
Speaker 2of the time, I just got confused for you know, hey, are you in a band?
Speaker 1Yeah, but you've never heard of me. Yeah. There is this idea that uh, there is a I don't know. It seems like every time somebody's trying to have fun, Uh, you can't have fun an be a Christian, right, whether it's like playing grand Theft Auto or I don't know, liking some kind of genre of music, it's always satanic. You can't play Dungeons and Dragons. I don't know. It's all all all the cool stuff that people do.
Speaker 2Everything, everything they don't like is satanic, right, Like it's a catch all. You know, it's it's it's satanic, it's it's woke, it's it's whatever. It's whatever whatever buzzword of the week they want it to be.
Speaker 1Yeah. I was trying to look up some Bible verses here to see if I could like tie into a religious justification for being goth. I can't really see anything that, you know, supports my case. But you know what, I don't. I can't find a thing that says you can't either, So I think on that front, they're still good. So all you know goths out there, all you emo kids, you can give your life to Christ and still you know where jenko jeans and chains and get piercings. I
Speaker 1guess Jesus was pierced if you will, yeah, he will. Yeah, So think about that Jesus. I can't imagine if like all the church aesthetics were different because Jesus had just like a giant septum or you know, maybe like.
Speaker 2I think about that kind of stuff all the time, Like what if it was like what if he died some other way? Would that then be like the like the symbol, yeah, like you know, like you know, Gutine got his head cut off or whatever.
Speaker 1Would imagine being like etene on or whatever, like yeah, and and and there eventually become a subculture of Christians that were like xenophobic, homophobic, but also or like pierced as hell. Still like that would that would be a thing, you know, I guess some sick tribal tattoos on. Yeah, yeah, that'd be pretty cool. There. She really into monster. It turns out it's okay, Yeah it's a tribal tab but it's the tribes of Judah, so that's basically cool. I think it'll be from the Book of Kyle, Yeah, exactly.
Speaker 1I got into an argument with a guy in my high school and this was I don't know, this was at a weird time in my life. I don't know if I called myself Christian, uph I was sort of questioning. No, I was definitely still a Christian, I think, I think I still believe, Yeah, I still believe in God. But I was friends with the guy who was I would describe as a very liberal Christian and he had gotten a tattoo. This was like our senior year of high school, so he had just gotten like a tattoo on his arm. He had like a big one right here, and I remember having a spiritual debate with him about whether or
Speaker 1not that was biblical or not, and His idea for me was, well, you know, look at how they treated their temples, right, and you're supposed to be your body is a temple, and the temple is decorated with all kinds of adornments. You know, I'm decorating my temple by getting these tattoos on it. And I was just like, well, damn, that just goes against literally everything I've been taught about tattoos in the Bible ever. But like, I kind of like it, though, you know, it's it's it's not a bad twist on that.
Speaker 2No, that's the same exact excuse I gave to my little great aunt, who was very very super super Catholic, very very very Italian, and that was, well, you're not supposed to do that.
Speaker 1It's God's temple. I'm just decorating the temple. Yeah, I kind of like it. I don't know, it makes sense to me, you know, because I think.
Speaker 2If you're Jewish, you're not allowed to be buried in a Jewish cemetery if you have tattoos and piercings.
Speaker 1I believe. Yeah, well they had like they did tattoos differently, right, but you know, I guess they were still tattoos. And I guess, uh like their tattoos were generally much more religious in nature. So I think the idea was that, like because it wasn't part of uh, you know, this particular religious tradition, it's part of other religious traditions. It's it's it's not something you want to do, right, Like that's because it's an outgrouping group sort of deal. But I don't know if it's like really against the idea of tattoos themselves. Maybe, I mean maybe it was, but
Speaker 1who cares. It doesn't matter, right long, not really? Yeah, yeah, well kind of same places, the same thing's gonna happen, yeah, decay, right, right, But I don't know. I can't imagine, because you're gonna get a new body in heaven anyway, mind as well, you know you would use get here, right. Do you think there's like tattoo parlors in heaven. Well, I don't know. That's another thing you're going to redo suite. Well, because
Speaker 1like I was taught, I was taught the real version of heaven, which is like, oh well, yeah, revelation comes and then we're all going to get sort of in uh limbo for a while, and then not limbo like literally limbo, that's a Catholic thing. But you know, like we're gonna be a just story kind of thing. Well it's a purgatory. That's another controversial thing. So so there's there's there's post millennium lists. There, there's different theological theological ideas about what happens right and whether or not, like where people are in that is sort of the question. But at the end of it, there is an agreement, which is, uh, there's gonna be a new Heaven and
Speaker 1a new heart Earth, and so they won't be separated anymore. It's it's it's gonna be like a new creation. So we're not even gonna be in heaven. We're gonna be in like a third thing. Literally at least that's what that's what it's supposed to be. So if there's people in heaven, now what are they up to? Are they the new Creation? Yeah, well so that's the other thing too, So like well, okay, so so this is a this is a crazy thing. So like people going to heaven right now is not a biblical idea either, Like that's not what they really taught in Christianity, like that they
Speaker 1there's other ideas where you're you're kind of basically dead, and you stay dead until God Jesus returns, and when Jesus returns, then the events and revelation happened, and then people get to go to heaven. But until then, like you're not That's what I was saying like limbo earlier, because it's not really limbo, but you're you're kind of in you know, a stacious sort of like a third thing. Yeah, it's very strange, but you know that that's that's how it is in the Bible. But also these ideas are inconsistent, right, because like there's some verses where Paul talks about like
Speaker 1he makes an offhanded reference to like the seventh layer of Heaven or whatever, and it's like implying that there's like different layers to it and and and different and people have like the circle of Hell but like, yeah, yeah, it's kind of like that. Yeah, And some people are like, oh, well you can be in different parts of have you know, some people could run wild with these ideas, but you know, but there you go.
Speaker 2Yeah, you don't Southwest Heaven. We just kind of sit around chocolate fountains over there.
Speaker 1Sweet. Yeah, I would love it that if that was the thing. But yeah, no streets of gold and I don't know, rubies and gems everywhere kind of gaudy. Honestly, I don't know if I like it, But that's no thank you. Yeah, but tattoo probabs maybe, I don't know. Can you tattoo your new have only body? Is it penetrable if it wouldn't need it? Like, would it hurt? I don't feel like, is there like a bean burrito layer to one of them? I just I don't know.
Speaker 1That's the other thing too. You're supposed to be basically worshiping God for eternity. That sounds awful. I don't know if like that. That sounds terrible.
Speaker 2Like there's a comic series, Join the Homicidal mediac He goes to heaven and it's just a bunch of people sitting around in chairs and he's like, what's going on? They're like, well, we're just content? Yeah, yeah, for eternity. That sounds awful.
Speaker 1Yeah. Maybe maybe if you're psychologically because like, if you really do become a new person, then maybe you are just content. But then are you really the same person? Though? Sort of a star Trek kind of question. I don't know, they don't really answer that too well. In the Bible, the Ship of Theseus, Yeah, it's really it is a ship of Theseus thing.
Speaker 2It's a it's a very vision kind of thing, vision vision kind of.
Speaker 1Yeah. I don't know, I don't know. But anyway, folks, like I said, we have open lines right now. We are just shooting the ship until we can talk to some of you guys. Come, I'm a slate. Yeah, what do you want to talk about? What's on your mind? Oh, lots of stuff. I've I've been.
Speaker 2I did a live recently over at the Tiki Talks just to kind of you know, hone skills a little bit if I could, you know, and uh, I brought up the question what makes a Christian a real Christian or a fake Christian?
Speaker 1And I didn't I didn't get an answer.
Speaker 2I'm not gonna lie, ye, Like it's it's it's they're very very inconsistent.
Speaker 1It's like, well, if they follow the teachings of Christ, It's like, I.
Speaker 2Don't see fucking anybody just out there living in a you know, with nothing, no, you know, nothing material items and just you know, helping others.
Speaker 1M hm. So yeah, so hey, the Hindu monks, I guess are are the teachers of Christ of it? Does that make it? Yeah? For me, it was always well they have just got it right, dude, right, yeah, well, growing up for me, it was always well, they have to have the Holy Spirit in them, right, you have to accept the Holy Spirit and you be saved. And then of course the question is, well, how do you know they have the Holy Spirit in them? It's like, well, because they start to act Christian, so it's like okay, but then you gotta watch out with the big Christians because those are the ones who you know, say they
Speaker 1believe but don't actually. Yeah, it gets real complicated, real fast, exactly.
Speaker 2And for somebody who's you know, always been on the outside of that, I you know, I haven't heard the unteen million rationalizations from you know, professional uh you know, heads of churches.
Speaker 1Yeah at all.
Speaker 2So right, well, I I'm curious as to what gets you know, these theists to this point that they'd go, I'm doing it right, You're doing it wrong.
Speaker 1And here's why I want to know. Yeah, it's funny because I think a lot of them would say, well, at the end of the day, it's up for God to decide right, and you just kind of hope that you're doing the right thing. But that's like, well you could say that for anybody, right, I mean, you know, I.
Speaker 2Hope this sounds like a lousy deity, Like no, just you'll figure it out.
Speaker 1If you fuck up, you'll go to help. It's fine, Yeah, I love you. It's my name on a registry, you know. I mean I guess literally that's what the Book of Life is, right, But it's like, I want to know can I find it? Can I Is there a records index I could find so that I know that I'm good for the whole given thing.
Speaker 2I feel like, if these rules are so important that you're going to roast me for eternity, I should probably have a list of these rules somewhere. Ye, just saying might be helpful.
Speaker 1Yeah, and then like make it accessible. I don't need the whole you know, the whole Bible doesn't. Actually, it's not a very good rule book. That's kind of the problem. There's definitely rules in it, but it's not a good rule book, right Yeah.
Speaker 2Yeah, Like I know that if if a group of children make fun of my bald head, if I if I think real hard enough there might be a group of bears that come around and maul them.
Speaker 1Yeah, that's what I learned. That was what if? What if we don't have any other evidence of God except for that, Like we just in our society, like bald people just could do that thing, and like there probably be a word for it. There'll probably be like videos online about it, you know. And that was that was like the most consistent proof. Wouldn't that be awesome? Oh don't love that? Would you start believing in God? If
Speaker 1there was a guy that could summon bears? And he was like yes, because just one, Well I guess multiple, right, wasn't it.
Speaker 2If I don't get it, then no? What if you got assault you about it? If I got it, then yeah, I'm not saying going to worship them, but you know, yeah that might help a little, at least a little.
Speaker 1It'd be like a point, you know, in the right direction. Yeah, that'd be pretty good. Yeah, I agree. Like it's like, well, that's something I'm sure scientists would be like, Oh, it's it's because of pheromones or something like they try to find some sort of naturalist explanation. Oh he wears Ralph Lee and cologne. Lauren, it's the Ralph Lauren. Yeah, true, true, I don't know it'd be interesting. Still, Yeah, you're right, not a very good God overall, but at least there's
Speaker 1the cool bear thing that's kind of neat. Yeah, you know, there's that, you know, but you know, then there's some Christians who will say, well, the fact that you're living and breathing and you're talking, and you have experiences and emotions like all, that's evidence of God and of itself. So what more do you need? That's that's essentially the lowest bar you can possibly have. Yeah, yeah, I agree, yeah, because it's like, okay, yeah, you and every other god kind.
Speaker 2Of you, the other anything with that like level of brain function.
Speaker 1Yes, yeah, yeah, I don't know. But hey, you know, Jay, you can't find you can't make something from nothing.
Speaker 2Okay, well so I guess I've never tried. Yeah, what is nothing? Anyway? What is nothing? I don't know even that, right, even that's like a hefty concept because you know, I say, you know, in the pop of my hand, there's nothing, but you know, not technically, you know, there's air, there's you know, cells and whatnot, probably through cheeto dust. Anyway, you know, so there's not nothing. And even that we
Speaker 2have you know, dark matter, So who that that's something too.
Speaker 1Mm hmmm mm hmm. Yeah, that's that's something as well. I agree, Yeah, I agree. Yeah, a little bit of an ify concept there for the whole nothing stuff. Yeah, it's it's very filbro stuff. If you go too hard into it, yeah for sure. And I'm not trying to start that debate unless somebody wants to call in and talk about it. I mean, I guess I will do that whole thing. But if you ask me right now, can you make something from nothing? I don't know. I don't think so so. But then they'd be like, well,
Speaker 1then how did the universe start? I guess I don't really know. It's just it was just kind of there. I wasn't there for it.
Speaker 2There was a hippopotamus and he thought real hard. Oh no, it was a giant turtle, right. I think that's a turn mm hmm. He turtles all the way down on that part, for sure.
Speaker 1On that part. We were talking this week about tucking a little bit before the show about this most recent assassination attempt. Okay, and of course not to get too political on this show, we won't get too political, of course, but however, it should be pointing out that it was a bit interesting to me because the manifesto of this particular individual that try to make the attempt mentioned his own Christian faith and sort of cited the Christian faith,
Speaker 1his Christian faith for his actions, which I thought was kind of unusual. I mean, I don't read I'm not up to date on the scholarly literature of manifestos, uh, but I imagine that doesn't come up that often, at least not the ones I've seen. And he was kind of like, yeah, you know, this is this is a this is kind of what you have to do when you're when people are oppressing you. You have to kind of take this sort of radical action or whatever, which, like, I don't know, I don't know a lot of churches
Speaker 1these days that are actually preaching that. A lot of them are just kind of yeah, like, don't you know, don't live with the world. But at the same time, I don't know, don't go and try and kill people, like I don't. I don't know where he got that idea from, but you know, kind of a weird thing. Look, the First Commandment's always been a little you know, to go in the first place, right, Yeah. Yeah, people are kind of fast and loose with that. But I don't know. Yeah, like I said, kind of a weird thing. I don't know how you go from there, but I guess, I
Speaker 1guess when you, you know, have a book as it opened to interpretation as a Bible, you can you can do a lot with it, you know.
Speaker 2Oh yeah, that's almost like it was written by design like that.
Speaker 1You think that was on purpose?
Speaker 2Yeah, of course, like absolutely, yes, on some level.
Speaker 1Yeah, yeah, okay, Yeah, I think.
Speaker 2The idea of it being able to be manipulated in some way, shape or form in order to you know, help somebody else's evil actions, if you will, or any kind of actions is absolutely something that the Bible was probably written to do or at least help in.
Speaker 1Yeah. I mean I think the I think definitely for the individual right. They definitely had like motivations for their own like beliefs and agendas. I don't know if it was like a widespread conspiracy of mass control. I think that's where some people get that, right, They're like, oh, the Bible has written to control people, and I don't, I mean it.
Speaker 2I think it's more like uh, you know, it's think of it like a Logitech controller.
Speaker 1Right.
Speaker 2You can put it on your your p S five, or you can put it on your you know, your Xbox, or you put on your PC. That way, it's you know, more universal, but it's still meant for control.
Speaker 1Yeah, yeah, I can see that for sure. I think it use Logitech though, Yeah, I don't use Logitech, especially if you're driving a submarine or whatever. Oh my god, thank you. Yeah, I know that. That's that's crazy. I'm just still like that much. I'm still on and over that story. But yeah, I like this the scholarship I've read about, particularly you know, in parts of the Old Testament where where they're talking about you know, because because differ parts of the Old Testim are written in different time periods, right, and some of around hundreds of years apart, and so some of it is like sort of a
Speaker 1revisionism of of you know, events that happened that could basically appeal to the kingdom, the Jewish Kingdom at the times favor right and prove that you sort of legitimize their ruling and stuff. So I think like that's the extent I'm willing to go with, Like, oh, the Bible's written to control people, because like, yes, at the time, like it was a very a political piece. We're talking about a Jewish culture, a culture of which, for a large majority of its history was done through oral tradition,
Speaker 1and so by the time it did get stuff written down, you know, they did have the ability to change some things. So yeah, like that that's it for sure. But the people who are like, oh no, this is all this is all done by the Vatican to like to control people and and and do all this stuff, It's like, that's just I don't know that's does make any sense to me.
Speaker 2But I feel like you have to have en awful lot of faith in humanity to go that far are in the first place. Yeah, So trying to get that many people all to agree the same thing the same way and keep it quiet.
Speaker 1Right, Yeah, I don't think that would be the case either. But while we're waiting on folks to come talk to us, I think we're gonna bring Flabbergasted back in so we can chat with him as well. So let's let's get this man. Hey, Flabbergasted, I actually have a good question for you.
Speaker 4It's nice being out of the closet it's good. I found the bag of the instruments for the punishments if you needed. I couldn't find the little marbles you were looking for, though I tried. Kelly might have just realized sleeping back there. I think he's getting kind of hungry. I believe that people feed the people in the claws a little bit more all I'm saying.
Speaker 1Okay, yeah, I gotcha, flowbergasted. What are your thoughts on our conversation so far? Any anything you wanted to add here?
Speaker 4Well, yeah, so you guys we're talking about like, like the vousell not kill thing. I think the most common reading of that is the like shall not murder, and that has a specific type of unjust killing. True, and so it's really easy to twist that as long as you feel you can justify the killing, and then it's no longer, in your opinion, murder. So I don't think that's a really good that's I mean, crusades, Like, so Christians killed every.
Speaker 1I mean, and it's not unique to Christians.
Speaker 4I'm not like throwing Christians under the bus with this, but like, Christians have never had a problem with this commandment because it's centered around this concept of unjust killing.
Speaker 1Oh yeah, you justify it? Yes, yeah, that's a good point. The original From my understanding, the original is supposed to be like murder, so like, yeah, like a premeditated, unlawful killing, right, which is very specific and not like a thing that should be used to justify wars or whatever. Yeah, yeah, but you know, I guess still is.
Speaker 4And then what else?
Speaker 1What other thoughts that I have?
Speaker 4You guys were having the whole talk about bald people summoning bears, and I would find that impressive only if they were she. If they were he bears, I wouldn't find that impressive, because men show up for anything.
Speaker 1Okay, interesting, very would very well like that. I was told them to.
Speaker 4Be punch and pie, right worth the punch and pie.
Speaker 1I heard it was kool aid. I'm here to drink the kool aid, y'all. Actually, I want to ask you something.
Speaker 2Yeah, we brought up we were talking about different different stories and different how far back things have gone as far as like storytelling and tropes and whatnot. Now, as somebody who has studied quite a bit of Asian literature, I would imagine it dates quite a bit before biblical stuff or even tied into but if they were still a close off society, so that being said, they still
Speaker 2had very similar If not, you know, no, they would still have very similar story types and archetypes with heroes and villains and whatnot.
Speaker 1Or would it be something totally.
Speaker 2Different because they were cut off from I would storytelling I would.
Speaker 1It's not even so much about being cut off.
Speaker 4It's that types of storytelling definitely developed with culture and they don't even have to go that far back to find unique ways of telling stories. And for anyone who wants to know what I mean by that, go watch a studio Ghibli movie and then go watch any Western produced film for the same audience. The entire flow of those films is very different. You don't get the same like the Hero's Journey. While you do see things like that outside of Western tradition, it doesn't flow the same way.
Speaker 4You don't get the same tropes of the old man handing you the sword at the beginning and then dying Obi Wan style as it were, right, It's it's a wholly different flow to it. Like Japanese storytelling, which gives my specialty, is uniquely different from Western storytelling. And when it comes to like the history of like written stories that goes back really far. I'm not as a specialist when it comes to literature and storytelling, but even if
Speaker 4you read like the Iliad in the Odyssey, that doesn't read anything like what we read today, and that's still Western tradition, cultural tradition that we still appeal to. And so I think that that says a lot. If you go back and read old Chinese stories, they're not told the same way. Modern Chinese stories aren't told the same way, And so all of this idea that our narratives are all like universal is not really true. You find some common tropes because we're humans, and humans operate in a certain way.
Speaker 1That is why we're all very similar.
Speaker 4We're very inbred species, as it were, not that inbread, but like inbred compared to like other species, not like the British monarchy. But yeah, it's there's common tropes because we're not that different from each other.
Speaker 1But cultures can be very different.
Speaker 4In those shape a lot about how we tell stories, and it's it's not that close.
Speaker 1Listen Flaergad. You know about Jesus. You know Jesus died in Japan, right, you know about this? He also died in Korea. Yeah, it's true.
Speaker 4Yeah, he's died in a lot of place. He also died in America.
Speaker 1If he asked the Mormons, Jay looks like he has a question. Jay, you didn't you didn't know that Jesus, you know, went to Japan and died in Japan and has a grave there. You don't know about this. This is Christ, this is this is Christ. Christian mythology, you know, Oh yeah for sure. Yeah, no, he's sure. Your face right now is so awesome. No, no, there is a there is a myth. Uh, there's a tomb in And I got the Wikipedia, now so had I had to find the detail that that a tomb that was discovered
Speaker 1that is said to be the burial place of Jesus Christ, right, and this guy said he found it in like nineteen thirty five, and it was like, yeah, man, this is this is totally Jesus. And they've been celebrating this tomb for hundreds of years and we've got these documents that prove it and stuff, and people are like, oh, yeah, let's see the documents, and then like you wouldn't show people what these documents were. And then they finally one guy got to look at it was like, yeah, this is fake, this is like a.
Speaker 4Forgery, and then real there's a story like like Jesus. Yeah right, like you want okay, well we got to forget all that stuff and just do it all over again.
Speaker 5Right.
Speaker 4You want to talk about common storytelling tropes, look at the way like Christianity gets adopted into cultures that are vastly different. What you end up getting is a wholly unique version of that type of Christianity. Look at Christianity in Korea, it's not that similar. There are offshoots of Christianity and Korea that are vastly different from what we'd usually considered a traditional Christianity. It doesn't mean traditional Christianity doesn't exist. It's Korea.
Speaker 1Same thing with Japan.
Speaker 4You get these weird offshoots where what they try and do is they try and take this story that that's being sold them they're finding and they're trying to adapt it to their culture and their understanding of the way the world works and the way they tell stories, and you get this holy different, uniquely different, weird religion. Go look up God the Mother. There's like this this Korean Christian sect about God the Mother. They showed up my house one day. I didn't have enough time to talk to him, unfortunately, because it was I was I was just floored by the concept. They're like God's a woman. I'm like, I love this, but also it's still like
Speaker 4I don't believe you, but like.
Speaker 1Way to be progressive, but also exactly yeah, like yeah.
Speaker 2You go girl, but you're not real, Like, no, that's ridiculous because no woman would suck it up this hard.
Speaker 1Come on, yeah, that's true. That's true. I see it. Man. I don't know what it is about Korea, you know, but like their version of everything is just uh way way takes up to an extreme for something, right. It's like they're that Christianity stuff, I know what you're talking about. Like it's just like it's it's if Christianity was like way more radical and like way more weird, and like Christianity is already like pretty weird, right. I don't know. They have like a very very I mean strange ideas. I guess this is the best way to put it.
Speaker 1I don't know if that's my culture, if that's cultural relative isn't coming in there. Maybe it's my judgment into it, But no, it's like, uh, I grew up in this religion too, and like you guys have very different ideas of what this stuff is. I don't know.
Speaker 4Yeah, it's it's fun stuff.
Speaker 1Yeah, it just goes that you can. That was good, like they have fun.
Speaker 4H squirrel. I lost my entire train of thought because that was just that was good.
Speaker 1Well on that note, you know, folks, if you have any super chats, now it's your time to send them in because we're gonna be wrapping up the show here in just a little bit. I thought today's episode is really fun. I of course I want to see you guys try to call into the show more. You still can. We still have a few more minutes, but you got to do that now before uh we wrap things up, because otherwise we're going to stop in here and I want to talk to you. Wants to talk to you.
Speaker 1Come bring Jay to Christ. We have you.
Speaker 4We have a a freshly non religiously tainted individual here, that's right, right, who's willing to be molded by your stories. Come tell Come tell him why he was he he his parents were wrong, Toho have never raised him in Christian tradition.
Speaker 1He should leave. Yeah, he's a religious version. Come come, come ruin that for him, Tell him, tell him a really cool mythology and he might be interested enough to yea might. And importantly, why why we know she has some kind of fun stuff with the with the with the aliens and the volcanoes and ship right, come on, come on, that's the thing. So, like, okay, I've thought about this idea as a show, where like they should have. I thought about this on two levels. One, it's like, okay,
Speaker 1you get a bunch of salespeople who have different products and they all try to compete to sell a guy on one thing. It's kind of like Shark Tank, but in like reverse almost because they're competing at the same thing. All five dollars for the sexy eyeshot of Alicia by Nature. Thanks so much for the five dollars. Really appreciate that. Super chat. Okay, and my other idea for a show is this. You get one atheist guy and you get like a really prominent evangelist, a really prominent Catholic guy, a Muslim guy, hand you guy, and like you get
Speaker 1all the ones and you and they each get to spend like an hour like talking to him, and then they all have to try to move the needle, okay, and then you you add that ship up right, and then you see, Okay, is this guy any more religious or or is leaning towards one of these things? You know? I feel like I feel like there's something there. You could do something. It should be.
Speaker 4It should be where you can all the different religious like like people. And what they're doing is they're having a debate for an audience of one. So instead of one on one that you have a debate format and like four different religion like like you have a Muslim person, a Christian person, a Hindu, a Buddhist, or throw in like like take out the Buddhist and throw in like.
Speaker 1A like a Norse god believer.
Speaker 4There's a few of those still out there in the world, and let them argue amongst themselves about why the atheists should believe them.
Speaker 1Hm hmm, like in a proper debate, why should I come to odin? Yeah?
Speaker 4What if we're ever done for me?
Speaker 1That's what I'm saying, Like, we're the atheists are sort of we're the we're the prettiest bell at the ball. Okay, they're asking us to dance. That's That's how I want this to be they have, they need to come to us. We're the where the fresh meat, okay, and they can come evangelize. And if it's in a space where we're all under the same idea, I think that'd be a good show. I don't know, but yeah, you know, come on, do you believe get on that shit?
Speaker 3Right?
Speaker 1You guys are always getting crazy people on your shows.
Speaker 4I think I do think that the religious people tend to target other religious people before they'll target like active non believers, because they already share a willingness to accept bad reasons to support their beliefs. So all you have to do is just be like, my bad reason is better than their bad reason. You don't have to think about good reasons, okay, just have faith in this new thing that I'm going to appeal to you with with emotional like ties, and I'm gonna think of your heart strings, and then you're gonna want to like listen to me,
Speaker 4and then you're gonna get a credibility because you like the way it sounds or feels. And then I don't have to actually demonstrate anything. I just gotta like poke at your heart strings a little bit and make you cry a little bit and like like.
Speaker 2Set up some of the good men and say, hey, my god sticks bigger than your god's.
Speaker 4You know, but if you if you have God the Mother, then maybe your God doesn't have a dick.
Speaker 1Well, I mean, I'm not going to make any exception assumption. So that's you know, she can buy one. It's fine. What it is. What if you got like a panel of judges, okay, and it's like maybe three or five six people and they're all from different religious backgrounds, you can throw an atheist in there too, right, and maybe an agnostic as well for like double bonus, because it's kind of the same thing. But you know, general audiences don't even know that.
Speaker 4An atheists who doesn't call themselves an agnostic and an agnostic who uses to exception.
Speaker 1Exactly one of those things. And then okay, okay, and then so and each person gets on and this is the shark tank scenario where they come in and they sell their ideas to the judges panel, and then whoever they find the most convincing or at least convincing, they knock out. And then the next round they have maybe they do a series of some sort of rhetorical challenges by which they need to address I don't know ideas, and then and then and then by the end of the show, we'll know which religion is true.
Speaker 4We'll just true.
Speaker 1We'll have it figured out.
Speaker 4We got to make sure we have we have somewhat representative of the the Church of the Jedi there though, because like if you're going to tug at Hard Springs, if you promised me force powers that might that might get and you.
Speaker 1Keep the seasons fresh because you start picking from more and more minor and then they get to they get to compete with the past season's champions. Okay by the end, and so that way you have a super bracket going on. And yeah, I think that.
Speaker 2We have one society representation.
Speaker 1I'll be happy. Yeah, and see everybody gets representation because that's how you get all these different communities together. They're like, all right, let's go Wiganism.
Speaker 4You know. Yeah, it's like it's like it's like it's like football, but like probably gonna get more violent.
Speaker 1Bro, NBC, please just hire me. I'll make this for you. You know, that'd be pretty awesome.
Speaker 4It'd be really like it'd be really nice to see religious people fighting over their beliefs without the murder. So yeah, I think putting that on TV is a great idea, or it.
Speaker 1Could be too. You know, they go through the whole challenge and then at the end of the season it's like, oh, you know, somebody's coming through the door, like the Undertaker with the smoke and stuff from wrestling, but it's just like an atheist guy from Reddit or whatever, and it's like, he's your final boss. You got to fight him, you know.
Speaker 4And I think I think someone else is already coined the term final boss for atheists.
Speaker 1Yeah, exactly what you have. Yeah, he's ready to go. Yeah, that'd be sick. Well actually, yeah, I don't know. Maybe that's a new a c a idea. We should do that. I'll talk to Greg.
Speaker 4Maybe that could be our next maybe maybe for all everyone knows, that could be the news that's going to be along Secrets of the Truth Wanted.
Speaker 1Yeah, is completely free balled right now live on the show.
Speaker 4Is not you, but you don't know, And he could be lying to you right now. Yeah, that'd be he already he already said he can't tell you. So if he's telling you it's not it, that is kind of telling you. Dam so, you can't trust them, Flower, You're a really good hype man right now, this is great.
Speaker 1That's uh. I love that. I also heard.
Speaker 4I also heard that if you throw in more super chats, Dan may be willing to risk physical bodily harm to show off a kiddie.
Speaker 1Oh, I heard that my cat is around? Is he over here? Now he's out of the room, but you know, I might make an exception. We do need to start wrapping this show up in a second, though, I want to thank uh flabbergastid for being off with me today. Thanks so much flabbergasted for joining me on the show. If uh what remind us again, what is our prompt for this week?
Speaker 4Do you remember our prompt for this week is? Yes, I do because I have the document. Because it's the same document is what is Bigfoot's favorite conspiracy theory?
Speaker 1There it is, So leave your comment below if you want to participate and get your answer shouted out. And of course I want to thank the wonderful, awesome golf damn it j joining us on today's show. Thank you so much, say for being here. Well, thank you for having me. It's been an honor. Yeah. Absolutely, If people UH want to find more of your stuff. Where should they go? Pretty much? Just type in guth damn it underscore J and that's me if you're there, all right.
Speaker 4I've heard he has a link tree that I totally didn't find on my own.
Speaker 2I do I do with a tree? Throw some pretty good stuff. I'm not gonna lie.
Speaker 1There you go. I need to do one of those. I think I made one of those, and then I didn't do anything with it. And I don't know what's on there now, probably old stuff that I don't want anything to do with anymore. But I guess we'll.
Speaker 2See spilled Sonic fanfic.
Speaker 1No, Dan, you've never read Sonic fan fake, have you?
Speaker 4No?
Speaker 1I want to read your Sonic fan fash fliber guys. So that's the thing. I don't know if you want to read anybody, So, no, you don't. We get enough patrons, if we get enough super chats, we can make something happen.
Speaker 4I've never written a Sonic fanfit fick, but for for one hundred dollars super chat, I will write one. I will write one hundred page Sonic fanfic as as with as many X rateds as you want it in the super chat for one hundred dollars of super chat, just saying if you throw that out there, I will demean myself for you. For that, I don't think anyone's gonna.
Speaker 1Now, let's okay, hold on, So one hundred dollars, that's a lot.
Speaker 4One hundred pages is a lot. And I won't even use AI.
Speaker 1I won't even use a propec point font Like, what are we talking about? No, I'm talking.
Speaker 4I'm talking twelve point times new Roman word docs. I'm a man of my word. I'm not a cheater.
Speaker 1I'll do the same thing. You got to pick yourself, and it's supernatural. Here's a question you got to ask yourself. Flabber guess why would anybody want to do that? I don't know.
Speaker 4Someone just said they did, so I just figured i'd throw it out there for anybody's one hundred dollars.
Speaker 1Yeah, you said you wanted to read my Sonic fan think.
Speaker 4Is it worth a hundred dollars to you?
Speaker 1I don't know if it's worth I just asked you to do it, and if you said no, I'd be like, Okay, I end it there. I don't know if i'd pay one hundred dollars. You know how many Sonic fan fictions are out there already. Why do I need to pay for it? Or how about that?
Speaker 4How about that, I will do a fanfic for as many pages as you put in dollars for the super chat. Anybody throws them a super Chat, forever many dollars you put in there, I will ride a sonic fanfic for that for the amount, for number of pages to the amount, just saying because I saw someone in the chat say that that that we're getting them to consider blowing their entire paycheck with this offer, So I'm making the offer a little bit more more achievable.
Speaker 1Okay, I do see that. We have a call that's coming in right now, and it's like, man, it's right at the end of the show, really like, now's the time you want to do it? Do you guys want to take a call real quick? Right at the end? Okay? All right, Well, they're still in the screening room here. I think we'll get them out of here in just a second whenever they're ready. Oh, they're actually ready now. Okay, we have somebody who wants to try to prove Christianity to us. Wow, in the eleventh hour. Okay, all right, we're gonna try to do it. I guess we have Rudy talking to us from Texas. Rudy, you are alive,
Speaker 1untruth wanted. What's going on?
Speaker 7How's it going?
Speaker 3Well, Unlike most people, I try my best to see history and looking at the world around me, and I see that more and more proof of Christianity be more true than all the other belief systems.
Speaker 1Okay, well that's an interesting idea. What makes you think that Christianity is more true?
Speaker 3Well, I'm seeing how how they weird likes making fun of Christianity and they count when they come to Midlands any of the other religions. I'm seeing that the fact that more Christians are bringing murdered by other thiefs of other religions.
Speaker 1Okay, all right, I'm not gonna lie to you. Those are not the best reasons I've ever heard. So you're saying, because Hollywood is making fun of Christians, that makes Christianity true more true?
Speaker 7Yes?
Speaker 1How does that work? How does somebody making fun of something make something more true.
Speaker 3More truth because the people hate the truth more than they them lies.
Speaker 1Yeah, But like I don't know. I some people hate pineapple on pizza. That doesn't mean pineapple on pizza is a good thing, right, Like, there's no correlation there, is it? I mean, there's a hey, there's a lot of people in this country that hate Muslims, right, like especially after like nine to eleven, Right, how many people are saying they hate Muslims. It doesn't make Islam true?
Speaker 3Right Essentially when a man reaped the child, I mean, would anybody want?
Speaker 1But what does that have to do with it? Because if truth is correlated to how much people hate it, people hate pedophile, So that means that that makes Islam more true under your understanding, right.
Speaker 7Understand?
Speaker 1Okay, Well that doesn't really seem like good.
Speaker 3Logical Christians there they're being they're being killed by Christians, are being two of it when they're unarmed.
Speaker 5So them, you.
Speaker 1Don't think Muslims are being killed? Yeah? Them? You don't think You don't think there's any countries on Earth where Muslims are persecuted and are being killed Muslims?
Speaker 7Yeah themselves.
Speaker 1No, I'm not. I'm not even talking about that. I'm talking about people persecuted by their their their their government and population. You don't think that's happening to Muslims?
Speaker 7What government is killing their own their own people, with their Muslims.
Speaker 1I mean all kinds of places on earth. I mean, you could look at the news. Several countries in Africa and in the Middle East are doing it all the time.
Speaker 7I haven't heard any of you to say, then, let's really I don't.
Speaker 1Know that the little confident called Palestine. I don't know if you' i've heard about this. It's kind of happening, right.
Speaker 4It's only it's only a genocide.
Speaker 3Yeah, there is no country.
Speaker 1Well yeah, I would expect that somebody like yourself would say something like that. But look, you started off by saying, just.
Speaker 4Because you don't want it to be a country doesn't mean.
Speaker 7It's not it's a country.
Speaker 1You'll want it to be a country, so everybody there can die for Israel. Israel wasn't a country for a long time either, and suddenly it is one. So I don't know what the deal is there. But that's a bit off topic. You started off this call by saying you have looked at all the other religions in the world, and you found out that Christianity is true. And the very first thing you told me was that you know it's true because it's hated and I gave you an example of how Islam is definitely hated. You definitely hate Islam. That's that's not you know, for up for debate. But somehow that doesn't make it more true. So I'm still
Speaker 1stuck on that. How tell me how that works.
Speaker 3That that muslim is shouldn't be worshiping our tom and race and rapists or no.
Speaker 1Okay, so let me let me break this down real simple. I'm gonna be as real simple as I can. Okay, you said something is more true because people hate it and people hate the truth. So how come Islam isn't the truest religion because there's a lot of people that hate Islam.
Speaker 3Not the truth?
Speaker 1Because I would that doesn't okay? You is that first? Yes, it is going over my head because that's that's not this. No, that's no correlation to what we're talking about. That's a totally different thing. Can I flower gas is dying to speak? Here? Go ahead, just just a quick question for you.
Speaker 4Hang up ready, real quick, if I could, I just want to like walk through like just a very short like thing just to make sure we're on the same page of understanding.
Speaker 1Eric.
Speaker 4Can we can we do that for a second, can.
Speaker 1Can you take with me? Do the flower gas?
Speaker 4So, Rudy, Rudy, Rudy, here's my question.
Speaker 1Here's my question.
Speaker 4If I say something right now, right that is just like the worst thing that everyone in the world has ever heard, and everyone hates me and everything I believe because of it, does that make me and everything I believe more true, less true? Or does it have no effect on the truth? I say, no, no, I need to answer that question, not like you said, answer my specific question.
Speaker 1Please no, no, Rudy, Rudy, Rudy.
Speaker 4So if I say something that everybody hates that makes it more true?
Speaker 1Is that correct? Its true?
Speaker 4Rudy, You're not answering my question, and I apologize there's a little bit of a delay, but I feel like i'm when I'm still when I'm finishing my question, you've already started talking, so I don't know if you're actually hearing my question, you're actually understanding what I'm saying. If I create a philosophy right, I create an idea worldview right now, and everybody in the world hates it, literally, every single person in the world hate it, hates it.
Speaker 1Does that make it more true, less true?
Speaker 4Or have no impact on the truth.
Speaker 3It's your philosophy has truth in it, the possibility.
Speaker 1Okay, but that's not my question, Rudy.
Speaker 4My question is about if people hate it because you're basing hang on, Rudy, Rudy, please, let's listen to me. You're saying the statement you made was that one evidence for Christianity is that it's so deeply hated by so many people. It's the most hated religion. People are being killed at by other religious people more than any other religion. Right. So I'm asking you, if I create a worldview right now that is more hated than Christianity that results in its followers being killed more than any other religion, does that make my philosophy, my worldview more true or not.
Speaker 1It's philosophy.
Speaker 4It's based on truth, it so then so then it has nothing to do with how much people like it or hate it. Then, right, it's based on how much of it is based in truth?
Speaker 1Right, exactly? Okay? Cool? Cool?
Speaker 4So So that then the whole point, the whole point Dan was trying to get at, right, is how much someone hates your religion has no bearing on how true.
Speaker 1It is or not. Can we agree with that? No, I feel like we lost all the ground we just.
Speaker 4Gained, all right, So so so, Rudy, here's my next question.
Speaker 1What is more important it.
Speaker 4Being based in the truth or how much people hate it?
Speaker 1Which one's more important? Based on the truth?
Speaker 4Okay?
Speaker 1Cool? So then the question that Dan asked was what is the truth? And and I think.
Speaker 4The important caveat I'm gonna add to this what is the truth that it's based on? And how do we know that's actually true? We don't know it's actually true because people hate it, right, because people hate all kinds of things. People hate the latest Star Wars movies. That doesn't make that Star Wars movie the word.
Speaker 1Well, the latest Star.
Speaker 4Wars movie is the worst. But that's different the last jot, I come on, but yeah, so so, so my question it's not about how much people hate it, right, It's about what it's based on the truth, under the underlying truth. So what is the underlying truth and how do we know that that thing is actually true?
Speaker 3I believe that Christianity is truth because the old testimony is history.
Speaker 7We actually have historical data to prove that that it was right.
Speaker 1What happened? You believe? You believe there.
Speaker 4We'll put it in that. Right, Let's let's put keep going, keep going. There a lot of heavylifting, and you're talking to a historian here, so that I'm loving this.
Speaker 3Keep going, and I'm like most of the other religious texts that you've seen, we've got a lot of proofs that what you can do and what you can't do to prove its truth.
Speaker 1What wait, say that one more time. That didn't make any sense.
Speaker 4I can't if it sounds like you're saying that that that the fact that the rules you think the rules in the Bible are good and that proves that it's true. Is that a fair summary of your second point commandments?
Speaker 1Is okay? Cool?
Speaker 4So I want to hit on that first point, right, I let you finish. I want to hit on that first point. You said the Old Testament is history. Are you saying that everything that is written in the Old Testament happened historically accurately as written in the Old Testament?
Speaker 1Is that?
Speaker 4Is that your understanding?
Speaker 7Pretty much?
Speaker 1Okay?
Speaker 4So are you saying that the Old Testament is completely accurate? There's nothing in the Old Testament that is not perfectly one hundred percent accurate. Is that your taker do you believe there's some interpretation for it is as best as we know it, Okay. So I'm not even going to get into the ridiculous science things on this. I'm gonna stick to the historical stuff because that's my that's my jam. So we're Jewish people mass enslaved in Egypt.
Speaker 3I don't know how many, Yeah.
Speaker 4Okay, I mean it would it would have been a mass It would have to be a massive degree of enslavement, right, because it was. I don't know the numbers off the top of my head, but there was a lot of people that were enslaved, and only the Jewish slaves that were. It was a massive exodus of Jewish slaves out of Egypt, right, There was a massive film undertaking.
Speaker 7There was other people there too.
Speaker 4But but but they didn't they didn't They didn't free the non Jewish slaves. It was only the Jewish slaves. In the in the story of Moses, they only freed the Jewish slaves. Let my people go. It wasn't let all the people go, it was let my people.
Speaker 3Yeah, that was his statement. But the fact is that they did let some of the Jewish other slaves go with them.
Speaker 4Okay, and do you know that? Did you know? I don't know if you know much about Egyptian history at all, but for its time period, they were really good at recording events, like like like really good at recording what was going on at the time within their within their borders. Are you aware of that fact about Egyptian history?
Speaker 1Oh?
Speaker 7Yeah, I'm aware of Yeah.
Speaker 4So why is it that in a in a society where we have really good documentation of events, we have zero documentation or evidence of a mass exodus of slaves leaving the country.
Speaker 6Why?
Speaker 4Why? Why would that be I'm curious you didn't hear names? I'm sorry say that again.
Speaker 3You don't remember Ramsey sat or raised Moses's name, But wouldn't that go along?
Speaker 4You think you also think that Ramsey's was the pharaoh at the that was so so just based off historical timelines, Ramsey would not have been the pharaoh at the time of this, like like that's like completely You're talking completely different time periods. So like, not only are you making a historical historical claim that is in direct contrast everything we understand about this period of history, but you also don't even know the historical timelines of who actually would
Speaker 4have been in charge at the time, the Egyptian But you named a specific pharaoh. I didn't name a specific pharaoh. You made that claim. Do you acknowledge that Ramsey's was not the pharaoh at the time. That was just some like like Book of that was something like Book of Moses, Like like, what was the Prince of Egypt? Fucking story history?
Speaker 1Was he voiced byes? Yeah?
Speaker 4You're taking some Prince of Egypt storytelling the cartoons you watched as a kid, and you're you're transcribing that on actual history, and that's a really bad way to go.
Speaker 7You definitely don't know how to read the Bible.
Speaker 4I know how to read history, my friend. Yeah, I know how to read history, and I read the Bible, and the Bible is not history. Are there things in the Bible that are consistent with history. Absolutely? There are also things in the Ilid, in the Audiency that are consistent with history. But I don't believe that sirens existed the Ilid, in the Odyssey, the Homer's epics. Right, So my point was right, I know how to read history. It's literally what I do. Right, I've taught people how to read history, right, I've read the Bible. The Bible
Speaker 4doesn't read as history. It does have things in the Bible that are consistent with history.
Speaker 1But also, hang on, you got to.
Speaker 4You gotta hear the whole sentence, right, But also the Ill and the Honesty also has things in it that are consistent with history. But I don't believe sirens exist. Right, So just because you have some things in a book that are consistent with history doesn't make all of it consistent with reality. That you you you can't square that circle?
Speaker 1Friend?
Speaker 7Hello, are you there?
Speaker 1Right?
Speaker 4I'm sorry say that one more time?
Speaker 1Is history? Right?
Speaker 4The Old Testament is not history?
Speaker 7No, before there are history, No, the.
Speaker 4Old Testament, the Old Testament, the Old Testament is not history. It does not record historical events in a historically reliable.
Speaker 3Manner history, right, it records Jewish history.
Speaker 4No, it records Jewish mythology and mixed in with Jewish history. All right. So so by that logic, by that logic, Rudy is the Illi in the Odyssey Greek history?
Speaker 1No?
Speaker 4Why not? Why not?
Speaker 1That was? That was just the poetry?
Speaker 4Okay, okay, how do you know it was just poetry?
Speaker 7No, that was just the poetry.
Speaker 4How do you know that.
Speaker 7Because that's where they found it in a poetry.
Speaker 1You are this Is this a real call? Is this even a real call? Right now? They found it in a poetry John, we know that.
Speaker 4I'm sorry, Rudy, Rudy like like that might not have been what you meant, but the way you said that was hilarious. Okay, I apologize you. But but no, they didn't find it any poetry jar. Okay, they didn't pull it out of the poetry jar section of the JAR Library of Ancient Texts, right. We we we consider it poetry, right, and we we consider it a a epic because the way it was written, that's the because it's actually the
Speaker 4Ilia in the Odyssey would have been an oral tradition long before it was written down. The same thing with the Old Testament. The Old Testament was an oral tradition long long before it was written down. And what we know about oral tradition is oral tradition is horribly unreliable, horribly, which is why you end up thinking that Ramses was the Pharaoh when the Jews were enslaved in Egypt, when the Jews weren't really enslaved in Egypt in the way the Bible's presenting it. We have very little evidence that there was even that many Jewish slaves in Egypt in
Speaker 4the first place. What's what's the evidence? Can you give me that source?
Speaker 7They've already found that.
Speaker 1Uh yeah, what's the source? Well they found it. What's the source?
Speaker 7I don't remember where it is.
Speaker 3But I'll start doing my research and I'll start writing it down with you because I don't do that.
Speaker 1Yeah, yeah, grab your sources.
Speaker 4Important to grab your sources and then and then give us a call back. Grab your sources, gather some information that actually supports it instead of instead of it just being you saying I know what they said it somewhere, right, bring those sources in, give us a call back, and let's talk about them.
Speaker 1Right. How does that sound right?
Speaker 3But like I said, the Bible is mostly history.
Speaker 4And and and there is no historian on first that would agree with that statement.
Speaker 7You can say that the fact that the history has been but.
Speaker 2The fact is that now you're concerned about facts, Okay, cool?
Speaker 1Right? Yeah? Also, the thing is, like you know, the Bible spans in storytelling like a thousand years, right, like between the earliest stories and the most recent ones, right, So like there's gonna be characters and people in places that exist. Right, that's not history. Like we're talking about events that were, you know, specifically recorded outside of the Bible, right that we can verify. Right. If it's just in the Bible, that makes it harder to verify because as
Speaker 1far as we know, it's just going to be a story. Right, So we have to find things that can verify the Bible outside of the Bible. Okay, if we just rely on the Bible as our narrative, then guess what that makes you know better than Joseph Smith or the rophet Muhammad that you that you seem to hate so much, Right, because they're doing the exact same shit. They're talking about their texts as being the only text you should follow. And that's a very good way to find truth, right.
Speaker 4And it also puts you in the same position where you have to give equal credibility the bag of the Oh Jesus, I just lost words giving it a job. The bagahavita is how you say it. It gives equal credibility again to the Ilia in the Odyssey. If if we only take the truth from the internal text and say that that's justification enough in any text, then Harry Potter becomes a history book a thousand years from now.
Speaker 1Yeah, right, like nine to eleven happened with Spider Man? There? Does that? Does that? Like Spider Man comic with nine to eleven on? It? Does that? Is that the proof that nine eleven happened?
Speaker 4The fact is, the fact is Rudy genuine genuinely and and Rudy Rudy genuinely right. The fact is is we have a vast amount of contradictory evidence to the quote unquote historical claims in the Old Testament. Right, The only way you can take the Old Testament as as historical fact, as the best interpretation of what actually happened in history is you literally have to throw away the foundations of
Speaker 4everything we understand about how we go through historiography. You have to throw away all of the other sources, all of the archaeological evidence, all of the written history of multiple different cultures, multiple different societies that don't fit in with those things. Now, if you want to take a more liberal, less like strict interpretation of those things and say, well, it's their interpretation of these things. It's not literal history, but it's just how they understood the history. You can get away with all of that, But if you're going to say that it's actually literally exactly what happened, that
Speaker 4does not square with reality as we understand it. Now. It's very possible that everything else that we know about reality is wrong and your book is the only one that gets it right.
Speaker 1But I have very very little reason.
Speaker 4To believe that that's true, because again, we're taking one source and we're comparing it to lots of other sources. All those other sources have to be wrong for your statement about the Bible to be true. Now, if I already believe the Bible is true because I was indoctrinated into that which I was as a child, and if I still believe those things, then it's easy to throw all that stuff away. But when you don't come to the book with this idea that it's it's absolutely, wholly demonstrably true from the get go, before you even examine the other claims, then you are not going to be
Speaker 4able to It just doesn't It just doesn't work, man, It just doesn't work.
Speaker 1Yeah, we're we're we are already way over time here on the show. So any last words you want to tell us before we let you go today?
Speaker 3You know, the atheist lawyer in the world already proved that the Christianity is true.
Speaker 1So I don't know what to tell y'all. Well, wait a minute, who is the best atheist warrior in the world. Lawyer? I think he said, a lawyer. How do you pose that? And also, if he proved that Christianity was true, why is he?
Speaker 4Guy?
Speaker 1He hung up? Who is he? I don't know, I don't know.
Speaker 4I'm I'm not sure. I'm not sure if that was real poetry stars, man.
Speaker 2If you guys didn't also hear it, I would have thought I just had a stroke or something.
Speaker 1Yeah, I don't know. I don't know what's going on there, but uh, very sad. It's a sad individual because not really interested in listening, not really interested in figuring or learning.
Speaker 4And it was just repeating the same thing over and over again. No, no, it's true. You know it's true, right, you know it's historically true, right, you know it's a history book. Right. No, No, I don't you know it's also as the backup. Sorry for like stepping on all over your toes there, But that was that was like, that was my that was my feel I had to.
Speaker 1I mean I I lost it at the poetry jar. That's awesome. We got to make a poetry It took me.
Speaker 4It took me a moment to recollect myself. I almost lost the crew.
Speaker 1We got to make a poetry jar and put it in the back of the studio, you know, and you know what, you know, we should put a Bible in it.
Speaker 4And if someone says something about the Bible being true because it's a history book, we can just crack it over be like, nope, we just got it out of the poetry jar.
Speaker 1So yeah, poetry, we know it's true. It's from the poetry jar right next to the packet drawer. Yeah, that's a that's some good truth wanted floor there. Oh for that, folks. Once again, I want to thank you guys for being on here again. Thanks so much, Flabbergasted for being backup, and also to goth damn It Jay for joining me today. I really appreciate you. Yeah, and thanks for the crew for for sticking with us in the overtime here. I'm definitely worth it, at least in my opinion. That ship was awesome. Uh. I love that. Uh. We are going
Speaker 1to be ramping things up for tonight's broadcast though, So, God damnit Jay, I like to ask my guests for words of wisdom before we wrap up our shows. Do you have any words of wisdom for us? He's thinking, he's contemplating folks, which means they're gonna be a movie.
Speaker 2Is a remake doesn't necessarily make it bad at least try?
Speaker 1Oh? Okay, all right, Oh I like it? You know what you don't what? God damn it, Jay? So why I ask for the words of wisdom? Some people try to get real, real, philosophical, real deep with it, and you're like, no, give freemakes a try. And I stand that absolutely absolutely, Yeah, guys, give remakes a try. I'm objectively Dan, always keep wanting the truth. Okay, and we'll see you next time.
Speaker 8Goodbye, mans, poegy jar everywhere.
Speaker 1Looking at man. Why are there ants in your poetry? Jars? Why is there a poach? Jards? They're around my aunts. Thanks so much, guys, is great. I appreciate you.
Speaker 9Watch Talking and Live Sundays at one pm Central. Visit tiny dot c C, slash y T t H and call into the show at five one two nine two four two, or connect to the show online at tiny dot c c slash called.
Speaker 1T h Okay, I.
Speaker 4I really I'm pretty sure that I'm pretty sure they I'm pretty sure they cut all of our audio before they go to the stree.
In today's episode of Truth Wanted, ObjectivelyDan welcomes guest Out Of Body Atheist, with The Beard of Empathy on backup, to dig into Reiki, New Age spirituality, homeopathy, and the long road from woo to skepticism!...
In today's episode of Truth Wanted, Jon the Skeptick, Volcy, and Sofia Spina explain why no one can talk to the dead, from Haitian Vodou and grief dreams to Jon's past as a spiritualist! Bob jumps from objective...
In today's episode of Truth Wanted, ObjectivelyDan and Nintendrew, later joined by The Beard of Empathy, tackle a world run on Jesus, the magic of manifesting, and a prayer that actually got answered! Bob in NY, a...
In today's episode of Truth Wanted, ObjectivelyDan, Kelley Laughlin, and The Beard of Empathy tackle standards of evidence, miracle claims, and the false binaries of moral philosophy! Dean in VA questions why skeptics...
In today's episode of Truth Wanted, ObjectivelyDan and Chad Harris tackle Christian nationalism, police brutality, and the uncomfortable truths about racism and immigration. Big E in TN survived police brutality and...