In today's episode of Truth Wanted, Kelley Laughlin and Rion Cultastic tackle epistemology, biblical morality, and the search for evidence! Adam in NC raises concerns about mythicism and how non-believers can be tricked into false claims. He argues that Jesus likely existed historically despite lacking strong scholarly support for mythicism. How do we separate historical claims from religious ones? What standards of evidence should we apply to ancient figures? Billy in KY challenges the show's claim about worshiping an evil God. The conversation heats up when hosts point to biblical slavery and the flood as examples. Billy defends religious people and shares his Iranian wife's perspective on Middle East conflicts. Can we separate believers from the beliefs they hold? Jake in MD, a deist, asks if there's truly no evidence for or against God. Hosts discuss ignosticism and the lack of a universal God definition. Jake argues for God based on cause and effect, but Kelley introduces indefinite causal order research. Does causality require a first cause? Eugene in WA insists God is all good, not evil. He claims physicists find God through research and that Jesus has more evidence than anything else. Eugene shares a nail gun incident as proof of God's intervention. Do personal experiences count as evidence for everyone? Thank you for joining us this week! We will see you next time! Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/truth-wanted--3195473/support.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Speaker 1You know, the world and life in general is full of all kinds of weird events and stories. His stories about alien visitations and kidnappings, stories of paranormal events like ghosts and poltergeist, weird miracles and coincidences. These kind of stories, they're my bread and butter. This is the kind of things I want to talk about. So if you have one of those stories, give us a call, because our show is starting right now. Hello, and welcome to another
Speaker 1episode of Truth Wanted. I am your host, Kelly Laughlin. I didn't have to check my notes for that, and I want to welcome you to Truth Wanted, the live calling show that happens every Sunday at its new time at two forty five pm in the afternoon Central Time, and we talk to people about what they believe and why they believe it, and if you'd like you could call us. We encourage you to call us at one five one two nine nine nine two four to two, or if you can call us through your computer at
Speaker 1ACA dot show slash call you guys, change that on me, Trip me Up, Truthwin. It is a product of the Atheist Community of Austin, a five oh one c three nonprofit organization dedicated to the promotion of atheism, critical thinking, secular humanism, and the separation of religion and government. And we are try streaming today, So a big shout out to our viewers on TikTok and on YouTube mobile. And if you're watching us on TikTok today, we'd like you
Speaker 1to you. We'd like to talk to you as well. So just request to join and we'll bring you up on the stage. Please make sure you're over the age of eighteen before doing so. And this is the best part. Every week we have a special guest and this week is no different. My special guest today is the Amazing, the Wonderful, the incredible Riot called past that Kiroy and how are you?
Speaker 2Wow? I love that introduction. Can you follow me around? And thank you?
Speaker 1Don't tempt me?
Speaker 2Awesome? Well now that I know, thank you. So great to be here and good to see you again as well.
Speaker 1Yeah, it's been a hot minute.
Speaker 2Yeah, it's been a hot minute, it has. But always a great time with good folks.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 3Yeah.
Speaker 1I was actually really looking forward to this for weeks now because because we haven't seen each other in a while and I always loved hanging out with you. So what have you got going on in your life right now, anything that we should know about.
Speaker 2Well, you know, I'm a pretty boring person. Probably, content creation is the most exciting thing about me. Honestly, I live a pretty plain life, but I have found that content creation basically showing and sharing my life with people how I grew up in a little call you might have heard of called the Jehovah's Witnesses and how it shaped my beliefs and where I am now as an older adult and kind of waking up, if you will,
Speaker 2to the reality of for me, of their not being a god after it being pounded in my head that there was. So even though it might not sound like much to other people, content creation is really exciting for me. It might have made it sound like it's not, but it's actually kind of cool.
Speaker 1Yeah, yeah, I mean, you know you mentioned that your your past with Jehovah's Witnesses. Has your content creation kind of helped you with that? You know, kind of coming to grips with that past?
Speaker 2Absolutely, I have Number One. Just getting things off your chest talking about it is helpful. But number which is something you don't necessarily do as a jatab. You're not allowed to be authentic your authentic self. But number two, you find other people who have the same feelings, the same emotions, or a similar event in their life that you've had, who have now said, oh my god, I didn't know that other people felt like that, feel so alone. So there's and there's even many, you know, things beyond that.
Speaker 2But it's been great therapy really, Like Hanna, I've got like, you know, six thousand therapists out there.
Speaker 1I can imagine it'd be really cathartic, right it is. Now, have you had a lot of other xjw's reach out to you because of your content creation?
Speaker 2Yeah, I've actually met I don't know, almost like a hundred of them in person at this point. I've gone to a couple of the like jw rallies like in Washington, as well as meeting people in person, and we most of us responded immediately. There's something about somebody who knows exactly what you mean when you say worldly, or the conenturration of the of the word demon, like I mean, we get what demon means, but it's it's a little
Speaker 2different when there's a secret kind of language that other people understand.
Speaker 1Yeah, and you kind of like there's that shared trauma too that kind of brings you together as well.
Speaker 2Trauma. Yeah, and every meeting experience is basically trauma bonding because every time you go to the Kingdom Hall or you go to a Bible study or a book study, it's about armageddon an end times and how bad things are going to be. So you walk out of there really going, oh my god, these are the only people I can trust. Life is really bad. But as long as I'm here in this building, I'm going to be safe. That does costend the security.
Speaker 1You know, I never thought about it before until just now, but that has got to be super anxiety building. To have that idea that the world is going to end at any moment, right, that has to be horrible.
Speaker 2Anytime, you know, maybe a little earthquake. Thankfully, like where I live, there's only been tremors really ever felt here. But imagine if you live somewhere where there's tornadoes or earthquakes or whatever, some kind of natural disaster that you would expect from what you're told and what you're taught God to use, you know, fire coming down, floods, what have you you think? Like, Oh, is this it is? This is this the end is Jesus common like, what's happening? And even if you woke up by yourself, like maybe
Speaker 2you woke up to an empty house because your mom was outside gardening or something whatever, Oh my God, did they get taken? It's it really is traumatic. And again that's why it's so important to be able to express these feelings and have other JW's or even you know, Mormons who've kind of had a similar like parallel life.
Speaker 4If you will say, ooh me too right, right, me too right, that compaint, that shared experience has got has got to help too, I would imagine, Oh, it really does you.
Speaker 1Now we've we've been talking about your content creation, and I neglected to ask you to tell us where people can find you at.
Speaker 2So oh okay, well yeah, okay, that would be it makes sense. You can find me here on the YouTube at a goddess. Actually here, I'll just say, hi, guys, So this is me a god is My name is Ryan Here. I use a pseudonym because when I first started making content, I was really afraid that I would be this fellowship. Not that I really care about the religion per se, but just the fact that I might have relatives who wouldn't be able to speak to me again. And I've just I've just stuck with it. So yeah,
Speaker 2here on the YouTube. I have a Twitter as well, which is in my YouTube info if you're interested. But this is where I mostly stick around my bread and butter.
Speaker 1If you will, there you go, there you go, And I encourage everybody to check out her channel. She's amazing. I wouldn't have said her if I didn't mean it.
Speaker 5I don't.
Speaker 1I don't just bullshit people, so well, no, I do bullshit people.
Speaker 2Bullshit me. You can be honest with but I'm not going to bull.
Speaker 1Yeah, I'm not gonna about you. That's that would be the wrong thing to do.
Speaker 2So if you're constructive, I can take it. Kelly, I get all listen, I get death threats, like get all kinds the internet streets. I tell you what. The Christians aren't very christ Like.
Speaker 1No, I know, I know. I had a Christian stoker for a while a few years ago, so yeah, I get I totally.
Speaker 2I had a pastor, a pastor who followed me from TikTok to YouTube just to hassle me. Wow, it's crazy.
Speaker 1Yeah. I had a guy that was going any any place I appeared at on any social media was right there to to start commenting on it. You know. So I know, I understand the dangers of this, but it's not enough enough. Yeah, it's not enough for me to stop. I'll tell you now, I kind of look at those kind of things as a badge of honor. Honestly.
Speaker 2You know, if you don't have haters, you mad.
Speaker 1Yeah, you're not doing this right. Of course, it is.
Speaker 2A badge of honor. You might as well wear it like that because you're gonna get a lot of crap making content. You'll you again, you'll meet a lot of wonderful people who maybe can even educate you. I've learned so much just from the interactions I've been able to have outside of the small little bubble that i've you know, popped, if you will, popped my bubble. But the meanies, the meanies who tell tell you that you put too much rusual. Like just today I read a comment and she said,
Speaker 2good information, too much rouge. Okay, I mean that's fine, That's what I mean, what it is. But you know, you just gotta like take it on the chin, brush your shoulders off, by goodness, Yeah, not very notice.
Speaker 1I'm sorry, I'm still laughing about that.
Speaker 2It's okay. I've had I've had worse. It just made me think of it because I thought, in fact, I was wearing a filter, because sometimes putting a filter from the app will push you out into the algorithm, So do that or use a sound to push me on? Like the fact that people can't tell that it's a filter, I can't help you. They don't know what And I looked like anymore?
Speaker 1So what was there?
Speaker 2No way they'll be able to tell the difference.
Speaker 1What was it that George Carland said? The average intelligence isn't that smart and half the people are dumber than that.
Speaker 2So I missed him? Bring him back? Can we get him resurrected?
Speaker 1I wish, I wish girls and say, I wish everybody had that sense of social consciousness that he had totally totally.
Speaker 2Before his time. I mean, you know, not really, But for me, I knew of him, I knew his comedy, but it wasn't until again I'm here woken up at this age where I'm like, oh, he was really saying some stuff, like he was really spitting some.
Speaker 1Facts, yeah, oh yeah, and doing it in a funny way too, you know, right.
Speaker 2It's like, you know, how can you not laugh? And then it's like, oh, it got me. That's kind of like real have you?
Speaker 1Have you noticed that on the other side of the coin, when people that have a problem with you, that they often go to your appearance or some personal insult instead of actually attacking what you're saying. And do you think that's a sign that they don't really have anything to talk to you about, that they got nothing to refute what you're saying.
Speaker 2Yeah, And usually I tell them that I is that all you have to offer? You said nothing about my argument. You have nothing to add to me or even give me some kind of a scripture or proof to argue against it. Now you just say that I'm stupid and demon possessed. Am going to hell?
Speaker 5Yeah?
Speaker 1Yeah, I want I want a good argument back. I really do. I want a good argument back. I don't want to be here. I don't want to be insulted. I always salv or hardened from the foundation and is a big quote violence as the last resource to be incompetent. I've always amended that to be insulting as the last resource of the incompetent, because that seems to be like what it is? You know, I've got nothing else, so I'm just going to attack you personally.
Speaker 2So yeah, and listen, I understand the feeling of scrolling across content and it being something you did not want to see. It happens regularly where a Christian content or song or whatever a meme comes across my for you page if you will, and I'm just like, oh, today's not the day. Today is not the day. And I'm in the comments and the reason that this doesn't even mean, you know, So I've I get in my feels and
Speaker 2I say some things, so I try to have a little patience with people, a couple of little digs like stupid or whatever, like I'll blow off too deep. Then I'm just going to probably do it right back at you because I don't, you know, I'll talk about your mom. I don't sorry, folks, but if you're going to go there, then I'll probably just go low too, because I don't even know if you're a bot.
Speaker 1Yeah, yeah, and there are and there are a lot of those in text chats nowadays. I just you don't know, right, you really really don't know. We need to find a good way to tell I know we can. I know how to do it with phone, with bots on the phone, but I'm not so sure how to do it with bots in the text.
Speaker 2It is a little more difficult. I've had one or two interactions where I've truly felt like it was about Sometimes I feel like, in my mind I'm probably saying it too often like this is a bot, this is a bot, and it's not. But there's been one or two where I felt as though either they just weren't reading what I said, which is altogether possible in my comment, or they're a complete bot and that's why they ignored everything that I've replied to them. And I'm trying to have it in conversation and engage. Like you said, I do want to have this discussion with a lot of people.
Speaker 2If I can help them in some way maybe see my point. But if the if the response is always just Matthew six says, Okay, well, I guess you're not really a person, or or I don't know, you're you're just not listening today, you just want to preach whatever whichever that is.
Speaker 1You're cracking me up here today. I'm having a rough time. I'm actually having a rough time I'm in the if anybody has seen the big fire forest fires.
Speaker 2On uh the Yeah, we've been very smoky here.
Speaker 1Oh is it? It's been like extreme. I'm like right across the lake from them, so it's it's been really bad here, but having a really rough time. So if I do start coffin or anything, you'll understand why I might end up taking in the nealar out and using it. So it's been really bad here. I had a question and I got on that tangent and I forgot what I was going to ask you. Now you know both my brain cells get stuck together all the time. I have to warn people.
Speaker 2If they rubbed too fast together, the friction like they overheat.
Speaker 1Yeah, yeah, starts to come out your ears.
Speaker 2Would be mindful of that, Kelly. At our age, it doesn't take too much to overheat.
Speaker 1Not at all, No, not at all, not at all at all.
Speaker 2I wanted to tell people that I thought was interesting and it might not be interesting to people. But when in your opening you had mentioned like the paranormal and things of that nature. When I was I want to say, thirteen years old, like maybe seventh eighth grade, I collected stuffed animals since I was like a child. But as a Jehovah's witness, we believe that items can be demon possessed. But you know, whatever, whatever happen. So I'm thirteen years old.
Speaker 2I've had a stuffed animal that I have slept with since I was about five years old. It was my favorite, this bright pink elephant. It was probably about three foot hunts like three foot tall. And one night I woke up and you know, I was having a dream of being strangled, and I woke up and this elephant was on top of me, and so you know, I immediately throw the thing off. I like run out of my room. I'm terrified. The next day I get rid of the stuffed animal, and it just I hadn't thought about that.
Speaker 2I had not even thought about that memory for twenty years maybe, and it hit me because I, you know, thinking about this channel and then you reminded me of again.
Speaker 1But sorry, no, no, it's.
Speaker 2Just so funny because I haven't felt the relief of knowing that that was nothing until just now. And I feel a little sad that I didn't keep the stuffed animal, because it really was my favorite stuffed animal. I thought it was choking me. I thought it was. I used to have those dreams where like lucid dreams, and you're also the dreams where you're half awake and you're half asleep and you think somebody standing out at the edge of your bed. I've had and you can't move. All
Speaker 2kinds like I have. My dreams are just weird, so they feel very like I smell things, I can have sex in my dreams. It's it's just a fantastical place. Hey, Ryan, you know it feels very real.
Speaker 1I think most of us have sex in our dreams at one point or another.
Speaker 2I mean, my goodness, if you can't get away with it in the real world, kind of do whatever. Nobody has to know. You know, it's between you and your brain. But I but you know, waking up with that that thing on my face really felt like I was being attacked. I carried that with me for forever, Terrified to go to sleep. I wasn't sure if I should get rid of all the other stuffed animals that I had collected, and you know, my mom reassured me that that was the best thing to do because it was obviously possessed
Speaker 2by a by a deal. You know what else, how else could that be? And now I realized, like, no, girl, you've that's just so funny. How the not that that was carrying that weight. But I just felt relief of going like, oh man, how dumb was that? How dumb was I? I really felt that was really I thought I was being attacked. I thought I was special And.
Speaker 1Refresh my memory on this. Was it the JW's that thought that the Smurfs were possessed by were demons?
Speaker 5Yeah?
Speaker 2It was yeah, And that's the actual story that a smurfed doll. Someone had taken a Smurf doll into the Kingdom Hall and the Smurf doll got up and ran out. So obviously demons can possess spirits can possess items.
Speaker 1Right, I heard the way I heard the story, the smurf did a few more things before you ran out of the church.
Speaker 2Well, you know, as it goes, the story kind of expends. And I've allegedly talked to the person who created that myth if you will, Oh no, kids, they say they're like, I think their name is actually smurfet girl here on on YouTube, and they said they're the ones who came up with the with the idea just all made up because of the whole.
Speaker 1Demon thing, And are they still a j W No, no, no, no, no, awesome. That's awesome. That's that's even better.
Speaker 2Yeah, because now they can tell the tale. Yeah right right, I don't have to hide, they don't have to like keep it in secret to see, like what will happen if I start to spread this rumor? It's spread like it's part of our fulk our full history.
Speaker 1Now, I really I really appreciate that story about your stuffed elephant because what it what it really did for me, is it really illustrated the trauma that religion can cause. Right, I mean here you were just a child thinking you're being attacked by it, by an inanimate object, and you really thought this was real. You know, that's that's herrrendous when you think about it, when you look at the real life. Asked me into that. It's horrendous in.
Speaker 2The moment because I had been all of my life, I had been terrified of sleeping. I never slept really good. I was paralyzed with dreams of demons because like I said, I have very crazy dreams, and that especially the dreams would kind of keep pushing the idea it was almost as if, you know, everything I was eating in real life was coming to fruition in my brain when I was sleeping, just to reinforce the idea. It was almost
Speaker 2as if the stuff I was reading I could now in my stinking wonderful imagination just all the glory. And I used to think that I'd have to off people. I thought that God might tell me i'd have to do that. And if he told me i'd have to that, I would have.
Speaker 1To do it.
Speaker 2Yeah, of course I would hopefully not do that. But as a kid, I don't know. That's what I'm right, right, kind of things for God? Yeah, yeah, yeah, all kinds of things.
Speaker 1There's people in the chat. Oh yeah, I remember the old Smurf in the Gingdom all stories.
Speaker 2Yes, you had dirty little Smurfs. Yeah, come on, one one girl Smurf. It is kind of weird. I get it. But just because Gargamel was a creeper, he's just the old guy who'd like to be on his own, No big deal. Who wasn't like that nowadays? Yeah, yeah, he got a bad rap.
Speaker 1I'm just an old guy that's on his own.
Speaker 2I don't see.
Speaker 6See.
Speaker 2He just wanted to cast his spells and perform his rituals and what.
Speaker 1He did want to steal the Smurf stuff though, right.
Speaker 2Didn't want to make gold or something.
Speaker 1Yeah, right, there was something that I do honestly that was like I was already grown up by the time the Smurf cartoon came on, so I didn't never watch it, but I know he was after something that they had, some magical thing, so.
Speaker 2I think so. Yeah, Anyway, the trauma, thankfully from that is gone. I think you still like, the scars are still there. I feel no fear of demons at all, and kind of feel sad that I carried that for so long and I don't and you know, making content. I can tell other people who maybe they've woken up with a pink elephant on top of them when they were sleeping.
Speaker 1I just how their free thought library flash up, and I was like, is that a subliminal message to go there? What was going on?
Speaker 2I'm afraid to ask anything. The fact that I feel like I talk about something and the next thing I know, I'm getting an advertisement for it. I might be speaking things to an existence. Just I know that's not true. But you know, as a JW you kind of felt like you could speak things into existence when it comes to demons or whatnot. If you're asotiating with say movies that are rated are and they are on the topic
Speaker 2of witchcraft or whatnot, that could get demons attacking you. If you read a book that maybe had a subject in it sexual that to let demons know that you're interested in worldly things. It's really weird to live in such a It's such a small world as a JW because you're all to associate with other people, but it's also a very big world in the imagination. Like it's almost as if all you're living is in these creations
Speaker 2that you're expecting to happen one day someday, right before you die. You're not really living in the present because you're just all these expectations and you just want to be prepared. You know, you're not really living your life because you just want to be prepared and you want other people to be prepared, because if you're not doing that, then you know you're evil too.
Speaker 1I see we have calls starting to come in, and I want to take our first call. But before I do, I want to thank our patron of the week. Every week we gave a shout out to one of our patrons. If I am totally getting tongue tied today. If you would like to donate to us through Patreon, you can at aca dot show slash Patreon. Tw We thank everyone who supports this show. It is all down, It is all nonprofit. None of us get paid to do this.
Speaker 1I just do it because I love hanging out with people like Ryan. You know I get to do. If you got to hang out with people like Ryan and Godless Engineer, wouldn't you do it every week? Come on? And so our special guest this week I'm getting off track again is Lauren Z. Thank you lauren Z, and thank you to everyone else who contributes to the show. I really appreciate you supporting this platform so I could come up there and have fun. I really do. And now you ready to take a call?
Speaker 2Oh? I love to you?
Speaker 5All? Right?
Speaker 1Then we have let me see here I got I'm having a flip between windows. Here we have Adam from North Carolina and he wants to know why non believers are tricked into believing false things. Hello Adam, are you there?
Speaker 5Hello? Dam and Ryan?
Speaker 1Hi Adam, how are you?
Speaker 6Thanks for having me on?
Speaker 7No?
Speaker 1Thanks for coming me.
Speaker 8I guess the biggest thing. So I'll give you my premise right here, and it's a three parter. We can handle all three or you talk about another day. The first thing that I want to bring up is I think people need a strong epistemology, good way to find truth.
Speaker 5So I want to test this out right here. So with the chat, I'm wondering.
Speaker 8If Field can put a one if this is true, or a two of this is false.
Speaker 9And the claim is JD.
Speaker 8Vans did something with a couch. I'm asking this for a reason.
Speaker 1We can't do anything like that with our chatre. I won one C three and we can't do.
Speaker 8Political which it's a claim, it's not an endorsement.
Speaker 5But I'll give you the reason.
Speaker 8I say this because I've spoken to so many people and I don't want to inference on the five O one C three, but there's a lot of people who believe that claim about that person. I don't even want to make it political. Does that make sense? Like I've met so many people who are like that happened and asked them how do they know that happened?
Speaker 5They said, it's in his book. But the thing.
Speaker 8Is is I went and bought the book, and I read the book, you know, people said to me.
Speaker 9Then they said to me, well, it's in.
Speaker 8The first edition. So I found the first edition online and it's not in there. And this reminds me of religious people. And I don't know if you've had this experience, but I think non believers run into this problem too, that they're tricked so easily, and I think this is a major problem. I'm going to bring up something bigger in a moment, but that's my opening premise.
Speaker 1Sure, sure, And I'm going to say I'm going to tell you right off the bat that I'm in agreement with you to a point here, because people have people have a habit of hearing something accepting it as truth without actually going and researching it. I mean, I see this every day on the Internet all the time. I see people making all kinds of crazy claims. Just just the earlier Don dog Key, when somebody made a claim that there was no history of trans people in the United States, and damn, they're sure was. There's a whole
Speaker 1lot of it. So it's people get these ideas and they and a lot of times they fit what they want to believe, and so they just accept them as truth. Does that make any sense?
Speaker 5It does?
Speaker 8But here's my problem, and it became part of the democratic platform. It became there weird like that was the central focus. I thought Tim Waltz was pretty good, but the whole They're weird thing, and it's like, oh, J. D.
Speaker 5Manson is couch.
Speaker 1It's like, let's stay off it. Let's let's use a different example if we can.
Speaker 8Sure, I'll use I'll switch to the prime example. Now, sorry, I really don't mean no, I'm not endorsing or not endorsing anybody. My prime issue, because it is the big one, is mythicism, because when you look into mythicism, it's often misreading the text. Like bart Erhman is an amazing scholar, and I really think Richard carry Or, who I do have respect for, is trying to make his name on mythicism.
Speaker 5And I've watched all the videos. I've seen how they're doing. You know, if you read the text this way and if you take this very very small.
Speaker 8View, then Jesus probably didn't exist. And this argument from silence, and you know, there were things that were minority views in the past that are now majority views. And I just think when we as debaters or people who speak to believers come in and say I don't think Jesus existed. I think that makes us lose credibility, along with previous unmentioned things, like to come into a conversation with views that are not supported by facts, regions, logic. I really think some physical more about mythicism. I don't think there's
Speaker 8good reason to be a mythicist.
Speaker 5If you want to go into that.
Speaker 9I don't know if you're a mythhicist, I don't know, but piece they're.
Speaker 1Own right, I'm on on that one. Ryan, Do you want to take this one first?
Speaker 2Sure, I'm I'm not a myphicist. I wouldn't say that I'm one hundred percent certain that Jesus exists. I just think it's probably more likely that he did. You know he was a real person, being special or remarkable. I don't think so. But yeah, I wouldn't call myself a mythsis I don't believe.
Speaker 9I think I think the.
Speaker 8Issue is is because when you look at the Bible, you would have to pretty much say I think a lot.
Speaker 5Of it's made up, but you almost.
Speaker 8Have to say all of it's made up, Like James and Jude and the people in the Bible are all made up. The history of Mary and Joseph and their lineages and Matthew and Luke. I'm getting the two books right that they're in I think mythicism. So my biggest issue is I think we need to go to scholars, and I think people try to go to views they like. That's my main argument right now is people go to things that make them comfortable or believe, and it's like, wow, Jesus didn't exist, Christianity is completely false because that would follow.
Speaker 8But I don't think there's I don't know, there's not much more to this call.
Speaker 5It's kind of call everything on mythicism.
Speaker 1If you can't tell, yeah, and that's cool, that's cool.
Speaker 5Yeah.
Speaker 1But you know what, I would encourage you later today to call atheist experience because Godless Engineer is going to be on and he actually is a mythicist, so you might have a really good conversation with him. Like I said, I'm out on that. I don't really think it matters whether Jesus is it or not. Honestly, I really don't. He could. He could have been a night itinerant, a rabbi who just went around preaching a doomsday scenario, right, because that seems like basically what he was. Or he
Speaker 1could have been a conglomeration of several different people I'll put into one, and or he might not have existed at all. It could have just been a bunch of ideas that other people had and conglomerated into one. I don't think it matters any of those three things. I don't think it really matters because Christianity is and it is what it is, So whether Jesus exists or not, we still have Christianity and it's still a valid religion because people are believing in it.
Speaker 5Right.
Speaker 2Yeah. I you know me personally, I think it's an interesting road to travel, and I don't think that we should stop traveling it. I think that it's important to kind of push boundaries. Now again, whether I'm diving into that ocean and I'm like, I'm a mythesiside for me, that's probably not going to happen unless there was something crazy on earth. But I just that wouldn't work anyway. I still think that having those conversations are fun. I enjoy having them. I enjoy doing the research just because
Speaker 2I know a lot of things have been you know, as you said, it's it's heard and everybody just believes that it says this when some of the letters that were using as eyewitnesses or not eyewitnesses. They're just eyewitness to somebody who heard something from somebody, which is cool, is better than nothing, right, But it's not as like solid as people want it to be. I guess I should say so.
Speaker 1I think it's important.
Speaker 8Thinks and I think that's the issue. I think, like you're saying, it's not as solid as people want it to be because I really wish I might call integabless engineer, but I wish you'd have a conversation with Airman or someone Irman Airman because I believe he knows. Yeah, I think he's done on his channel. It's carrier's view is done by Baysian and probabilities and if you look, this is my final I we'll speak more after this. But Blake Seanta Famara, Blake Johns, he debated Matt bill Onto years and years ago. He uses Daisy and analysis also to.
Speaker 9That Jesus existed.
Speaker 8And I think cam of Capturing Christianity has an app that uses Basian to show that Christianity is true and Carrier uses Basian to show that, you.
Speaker 5Know, Jesus didn't exist.
Speaker 8And to me, all these people are just taking what they see in the world and morphing it into what they want to see. And that, of course, how I want to go about living. That's my issue and that's my final thoughts.
Speaker 1That that's how I mean, that's how a lot of people live their lives. They believe what they want to believe and all this stuff. I mean, there's there's a large movement in the United States right now to deny a bunch of reality because it doesn't fit what people want to believe, right, I mean, this is something that we I mean, it's a big social social movement in this country that we have to deal with. And it is the thing I mean. And usually, as I mentioned before, it's people who are don't want to try to do research. It's usually and I don't want to I don't want to look down on anybody, but it's usually people who
Speaker 1who you know, I was going to say lazy, but then I started thinking, maybe people just don't have the time to do it. You know, maybe they're just the opposite of lazy. They're so busy all the time, they just don't have the time to do it. So I mean there's I it's hard to say that people are purposely doing this because it could be that just your environment is not giving them the information that they need. And I also something you mentioned earlier about ideas changing over time. You know, over time we do get more information,
Speaker 1so our ideas will change, right. I mean, like right after the Civil War, the South was seen as bad. Then there was the whole like it run the turn of the century, there was a whole movement to make it look like they weren't so bad. And now we're starting to look back at them again and say, hey, you know what, these guys were slave owners. They were the bad guys, you know. So I mean that's just something that changed twice over the last one hundred and fifty years. So I mean, people, things do. Ideas do change as society changes, as our ideals change, as the
Speaker 1things that we consider valuable change. So I mean, that's that's just part of life, isn't it a part of history?
Speaker 8And I encourage everybody to still there.
Speaker 1Yeah, I was sorry, I heard people, I really and.
Speaker 8I appreciate that we change our views over time and maybe one day I'll be anthesis.
Speaker 9But right now the.
Speaker 8Evidence isn't in at all for Jesus existing. We have lots of accounts we have you know, if you read the.
Speaker 1Greek, well, we don't have any contemporary accounts. You know, we have none, or it's hit his head and had a vision. But like I said, we don't have any We don't have any contemporary accounts from anybody that associated empirically with Jesus.
Speaker 8So I guess you Matthew Mark lusing Jahm written ten to thirty years after.
Speaker 1I think, I think that. I think the youngest one is sixty years afterwards.
Speaker 8I think it's Mark. The dating varies from thirty sixty AD a d.
Speaker 5I think from March. You can go in earlier late days scholars or so.
Speaker 1It's honest, but I don't want to send the call.
Speaker 2I appreciate it, but I just wanted to say regarding like when you first started the call, you mentioned epistemology and wanting to get to the truth, and I totally, I really really feel that. I truly feel that because when I first started to almost actually access information that was beyond like all the little books the JAD dubs allow you to look through the little locusts of information. I felt a lot of times angry with what I
Speaker 2was reading because it totally went against my bias, and I was like, hmm, oh, God, that can't be true. The JW's are you know? They lie about this? I got to throw that. It took a while for me to start like swallowing these jagged little pills of truth. Now it's a lot easier. Now I don't mind so much. But I have, you know, gone down long rabbit holes of research which thinking I was going to find a certain answer and I didn't find it, and I had to just accept that I spent a lot a lot of time researching something that didn't turn anything. But you know,
Speaker 2maybe I learned something about researching in that instance. But I like getting to the truth. I want the truth. So that's why I don't mind saying, Listen, I'm not sold on this guy. Jesus. It's probably likely, but was he anything like the guy that's in this book? Doubt it? And I'm okay with that. Like Kelly said, do I really care? No, only because it affects me in my daily life? Did it? If it would not affect me in my daily life? I probably wouldn't. It wouldn't be a topic of conversation at all.
Speaker 8Probably, Thank you guys so much for taking my call. And Ryan, thank you for your thoughts and everything. I'm Kelly too.
Speaker 1Yeah, well thanks for calling. I appreciate it. It was a great call, all right. That wentn't really well.
Speaker 2Truth wanted, and I do the truth even if it sucks. Sometimes It never really does suck sometimes hearing stuff, especially when you've spent days, hours, months researching. But you know, that's how it goes.
Speaker 1That's how it goes.
Speaker 2That's how these theories go sometimes, how these arguments go. You're looking for you know, if I'm creating content, I want to be able to say this is the book, this is the research paper, peers, whatever I'd like to I like to have that information. And if I go searching for it and it's not there, then I'm just not going to present I'm not going to do it. Somebody else can and I probably do. But I really am looking for truth as goofy as I am. If I find that I've been presenting something wrong or it's misinformation,
Speaker 2it's got to go.
Speaker 1You know, Speaking of things going, we have a thing that we're going to be doing. See what I did there?
Speaker 5I like to.
Speaker 1We're excited to announce the launch of the twenty twenty six Back Cruise. Yes, Yes, August fifteenth at seven pm Central. Tickets are on sale now. They're going fast, they always do. It's always a lot of fun. There's going to be all kinds of stuff that happening all weekend long. There's a special guest lecture on Friday. There's going to be community outing and activities all day on Saturday, followed by our annual members town hall. All your favorite ACA shows
Speaker 1will be filmed live from the Free Thought Library on Sunday, so you can come and hang out and meet all your favorite hosts. Most of them will be on the cruise too, so you can just kind of hang out with them. And our feature guests will be genetically Modified Skeptic and the Antipot. What about me? I thought I was the feature guest. I'm really looking forward to hanging out with genetically Modified Skeptic and the Antipot. But tickets are available right now. You should rush over there and get them at ACA Dot Show, Slash Bat Cruise, and
Speaker 1one Thing before we go back to taking our next call. I really want to thank the crew. Let's see the crew cram pull them up. Thank you video operators, the audio operators, the mods, the note takers, the call screeners. Look at all those wonderful, freaking people. Huh they are the best. What an what a good group, good looking group of people. And if you want to be one of you know, every time you join the crew, you just get better looking. So if you want that to happen to you, you can do that as well. And uh,
Speaker 1you get I'm sorry, I'm just losing it today.
Speaker 2I think the cat was the best looking one of them.
Speaker 1Yeah, the cat was. Yah. So you can email volunteer at Atheist typhencommunity dot org to get involved. You know, I did it like six years ago. The first thing I ever did was a call screener. And look where I am now. Geez, you know I'm actually producing this show. Holy shit, it's a wonder to me, believe me. But yeah, get involved. It's a lot I think they're actually looking for call screeners right now. It's a lot of fun. You get to talk to a lot of fun people. And yeah, send him an email if you're really interested
Speaker 1in doing it. I totally encourage it. I really really do. Like I said, I've had just nothing but a blast the last six years.
Speaker 2So put a little help Wanted next to the truth Wanted sign.
Speaker 1And let's take our next caller. Let me see. We got let me Billy from Kentucky. So he wants to know what you mean by worship and evil God the prompt. I'm not sure was that the part of the Hi Billy, how are you?
Speaker 9I'm being good?
Speaker 6Are you all doing today?
Speaker 1I'm doing great? Was that part of the quiz today was the evil Guide?
Speaker 3I was just scrolling around on that saying, now you didn't know what you all meant by that.
Speaker 6I'm just asking.
Speaker 1I didn't put it up, so I'm not positive what you're actually talking about. To be honest with you, on your on your youth.
Speaker 9On your YouTube page, I'm looking at YouTube. It says, uh, you.
Speaker 3Wonnship an evil God pretty much wrong, and I just didn't know what you're.
Speaker 1I'm looking at the YouTube page and it says says truth Wanted zero nine point twenty nine with Kelly Laughlin and Ryan Coltesta.
Speaker 2It's on the vertical stream.
Speaker 1Oh, it's on the vertical.
Speaker 2On the vertical.
Speaker 1They tricked us, Okay, yeah. See, I have no idea what it means, what what who put that up there? But do you know you do you don't think that? Do you think that God does not have any evil aspects?
Speaker 3Or I think people? I think God and what everybody wants God to be. And that's my point of it. I'm not I was born Catholic, I was, and I'm.
Speaker 6Older that I got.
Speaker 3I'm fifty three, so I don't always believe everything from the Bible. Are you going to hit me? But I think God buying that good cup of good people, but.
Speaker 6Don't be buying that evil and people too. So that's my point of view. So I was just asking, just asking, I was just wondering.
Speaker 1I think what was probably meant is that people who do worship the Christian God, they don't realize all the evil things that that God has done over the course of history, or the supposed history that is in the Bible. And I think that's probably what that prompt was about.
Speaker 3I think I don't think God and that I think people do evil and I don't. I don't, well, I don't, I'm not gonna I don't know what God is. I'm kind of that you're going with talking about he kind.
Speaker 9Of didn't know what you wants to prove. I'm the same way. So I'm not making fun of either one of you.
Speaker 6I think you're correct under that I don't.
Speaker 9I'm not gonna blame it on a God that I can't out to prove.
Speaker 6For the own act.
Speaker 1I'm based. I'm based on what I'm saying on what is supposed to be the word of God. Right, the Bible is supposed to be the direct word of God. So if you're a Christian and you believe that is the direct word of God, there's a lot of things evil things that God is in the Bible, Like what how about endorsing slavery? How about yeah, yeah, how about all them the hundreds of thousands of innocent the clod.
Speaker 9Okay, I'm not I'm going asking.
Speaker 6I'm not going to.
Speaker 3Argue you do and things we're in the Bible to to say that slavery is good.
Speaker 1It says it in Leviticus, and it says it in uh numbers. Is that correct? It says that that that the people of Israel are to buy their slaves from the nations around them, and that they can keep them as property and leave them to their children. And then it also in another part of the Bible says that you could beat your slave as long and as long as he can get up three days later, that it's okay. Basically, you could beat your slave half to death and it's okay.
Speaker 6And not exactly what it says, but.
Speaker 1That's exactly what it says. That is exactly. We're almost a word for word, what's to do it?
Speaker 2It tells you how you have to do it.
Speaker 3You're want to blame, okay, you want made atainment. Only when I last call, when you made a statement about how the South was wrong but slaving on.
Speaker 1I was just I was. What I was talking about is how our views of that have changed over the one hundred and fifty years. I didn't say whether it was wrong or right.
Speaker 6Don't own slaves.
Speaker 1Too, Pardoner.
Speaker 2You know that church's own slaves.
Speaker 1That's I'm We're not, that's that's not the point. That the point isn't you're you're doing what about is? Or now you're just saying hey, because wait, no, no, stop stop stop, you're doing what about ism? That's like when hey, you know this it just because slavery isn't the Bible? You know, these other people have slavery too, so that means it's okay.
Speaker 3Why are you trying to okay? Okay, A lot of good people believe in God. Yeah, actually, why that you want to make sure they they hate? What point are you? I mean, I don't get your point. You're going out like you're intentionally going out to try to say, hey people, Hey guy, you go to sor Cherry Sunday walk, you made your kids right now, But your God is evil and you're evil a once than God. That's what it sounds like.
Speaker 2Well, I sound like that probably because a lot of us might feel that way as well, because of.
Speaker 1You got to remember that. You know, I know you haven't, but you are not everybody and a lot of people have experienced religious trauma. A lot of people's hatred in the world, you know, please, sir, please please let me finish talking. A lot of people see the way that the religious movement is treating people in this country who do not fit what they think is proper right, and they think that that's evil. They look at it again, at things that the God did in the Bible that supposedly we're okay, and they look at that as being
Speaker 1evil and That is why they're making this judgment that God is evil, because because they're looking at the facts that we already have. And I realize there are a lot of good people who are Christians, but there's a lot of people who aren't that are Christians as well.
Speaker 6In America. Mult of them are good. You are not.
Speaker 1I wouldn't go that far, but I definitely wouldn't go that far. No, I don't. I don't believe that he would.
Speaker 3You really don't think that multi Christians are good people in America.
Speaker 1I think that most Christians believe they're good people. But I think that as long as they believe in the Bible, as long as they take the Bible as at its word, I don't think that's good.
Speaker 3I mean that you you, you, you you're you're taking somebody's beliefs and dongrading them.
Speaker 6Does it make any kind of racist?
Speaker 1No? Because number one, a belief is not a race. I mean, that's the big that's the big thing right there. A belief is not a race.
Speaker 3My wife, my white my white people, my wife, my wife and.
Speaker 6Iran and Iranian immigrant.
Speaker 3She's been over here for twenty five years, okay, okay, and she gets mad at media right now we're going on in Iran and he's full of going on Iran and people talking to people like you talk.
Speaker 9About holy legend I don't believe.
Speaker 6And not really knowing what's going on.
Speaker 1Why are why are we over in Iran right now? What did Pete Hexas say we're doing on?
Speaker 5Wait?
Speaker 1No, no, no, what did Pete Hexas say we're doing over there? He said, we're on a crusade. We are, we are literally over The guy who's atarted the department, Please don't over talk me. I didn't say a word while you were talking. Please do not want to talk to me at the head of our department of war has said that we are on a crusade. We are over there to stop Islam. This is a religious war.
Speaker 9And my wife and not religious at all.
Speaker 1That doesn't matter what your wife is. It doesn't matter, it doesn't matter, it doesn't matter what one person thinks.
Speaker 6What's going on over there?
Speaker 1You know why because people have been dying on it for you, So kill more people.
Speaker 9You're gonna You're going to kill somebody that lived in that country.
Speaker 1And this is the kind of thing what I think religious people are bad because they think it's okay to kill more people exactly. You are making my point for me. You are making my points for me.
Speaker 7You're make my point for you.
Speaker 6My wife lived there, you live there.
Speaker 1One person doesn't matter, and people are getting killed one way, you look at it one way or another. You look at it.
Speaker 9People are thinking killed.
Speaker 1I don't need to be there to know that people are being killed.
Speaker 9You don't need it. They have home, want it out.
Speaker 1So you think it's okay to kill people because some because their government is bad. Do you think it would be okay for them to come over here and kill American because they don't like the American governor? Now you know what you're You're doing it again, and I'm good. If you do it one more time, I'm going to drop this call. If you keep over talking, I will drop this You hypocute.
Speaker 3You are a hippo quick.
Speaker 9You are a hypoqute.
Speaker 7You are lile.
Speaker 1I'm gonna ask you one more time to.
Speaker 7Not over.
Speaker 6You call my wife the lyle.
Speaker 1No I didn't, No, I didn't, I never did. I said one person's opinion.
Speaker 2No, you were not trying to invalidate his wife's Oh gosh, that was great. That's not all what you did, what you said was true. Her experience does not make up for everybody's experience.
Speaker 1You can't guess that's what I was saying, that one person's experience doesn't matter, or one person's opinion doesn't matter to the world. It just doesn't.
Speaker 2So No, that was interesting that that was not at all where I expected. Kelly. I think it begs begs the question. It begs the comment that you know he was speaking about, like, why are you talking about God and God being evil? Well, there is no diplomacy with the God of the Bible, and I feel like that's exactly what we're witnessing right now. Zero diplomacy, zero democracy. We have a tyrant who you know, spits things from the Bible and it has to be listened to. So
Speaker 2it's kind of feels like we live in that state all the time because it's what we were exposed to in the Bible. We're used to. This is how it has to be. There's no exception. And by the way, you do have freedom to choose. You can go to Hell or you can live, right. I mean, it just feels like that's how we're living right now.
Speaker 1Well, that was fun.
Speaker 2That's why I feel like you can't. That's why it's occult, as you were saying, to say they're good people if their morality is based on a God who is not diploma and it has no diplomacy, and wouldn't just kill people because he feels like that's how you free them.
Speaker 1Mhm mm hm.
Speaker 2That's not a solution. Anybody can do that. Anybody with a real can do those things.
Speaker 1We have more calls, should we see if we have another one just as full?
Speaker 2Please? Please?
Speaker 1Okay, we got Jake. He's a deist and he's from Maryland, and once to all, if we agree that there is no evidence for or against God, Hi, Jake, how are you?
Speaker 10Hi?
Speaker 2Good?
Speaker 1I'm good, Thanks for calling. Yeah, thank you for calling.
Speaker 7So, I mean the from my question is a just I mean first I should start by, I mean asking, do you guys, would you agree that there's no evidence for as whether there's no evidence?
Speaker 1Again, well, I'm an igtheist and I don't think. I don't think that we have a universal definition of what God is, so that any conversation about the existence of God is moot.
Speaker 7Just for me, I'm sorry, I'm not even we should too short? What is means.
Speaker 1I'm I'm sorry, Well I'm having your connection, isn't Yeah, I.
Speaker 2Said, I'm not.
Speaker 11I'm not exactly sure what.
Speaker 5An atheist means.
Speaker 1Well, I think this as somebody who thinks that because we don't have a unambiguous definition of what God is, than any question of whether that God exists or no, or whether a God exists or not is basically meaningless because we don't know what God is. Yeah, you know, it's been my it's been my experience that even the people sitting in the same pew in the same church don't have one hundred percent don't agree on what God is.
Speaker 2So yeah, yeah, so that's what I'm kind of like a theist to. I kind of slip and slide through those words, but you know, I'm just kind of like whatever, that is what it is.
Speaker 11I mean, I mean, just to be honest, that was a really profound I've never heard of it. I'm not even really too sure how to say the word, but uh, that was a profound statement. I mean to tell you, the truth has kind.
Speaker 6Of left me stuck.
Speaker 11I do agree with that statement, and I've never actually I'm explained it to myself in that way.
Speaker 7So to tell you the truth.
Speaker 11I mean, that's really genuinely left me stuck, like I kind of because it's kind of the same argument that I was essentially.
Speaker 5Going to make, just in a different in a different way.
Speaker 11I mean, I really my initial questions stem from just the fact that I mean, like, I don't really believe.
Speaker 9There is any.
Speaker 11Evidence, or I don't believe there is there isn't any evidence, which is I actually I'll go as a agnostic theists, so truthfully, nobody knows. I do choose, however, to believe there is a God for just personal reasons. But I always find it interesting when I like to be atheists and.
Speaker 9They say there is no God with such definitive.
Speaker 1Conviction. Right, Not all atheists say that, but there are some that do. We used to refer to those as anti theists.
Speaker 11Okay, yeah, so I mean, because I mean, the permise of what I was saying is is that even scientifically, like, you get to a point in our history at the Big Bang where I mean, everything we know essentially breaks down. And at that point, I mean, I was what I think of the reason I choose to believe.
Speaker 6I don't have a God that I believe in or.
Speaker 11Can't subscribe to any religion.
Speaker 1I just believe that there's.
Speaker 11An intelligent power of sorts, if you could say that primary just because just because of the law of cause and effects. And that's the main reason why I choose to believe that.
Speaker 9I don't what.
Speaker 1Is it about cause and effect that makes you believe that.
Speaker 11I mean, if you look in I mean just throughout the world and science, nothing just happens.
Speaker 1Just that's that's not true. You got to you got to keep up with science, man, And like, is it two thousand and six or twenty twelve.
Speaker 5We have science.
Speaker 11Society means I have done research, but feel.
Speaker 1Free to lot well check out in definite causal order if you'd like. It's a quantum effect where we found out that the cause and effect are actually super positional and the effect that happened before the cause. And this is new science. It's within the last it's within the last twenty years.
Speaker 9It's a it's more of a theory than it is proved.
Speaker 1I don't think that's true. I think they have done been able to prove that well.
Speaker 11I mean I will as well, but I would also say you might want to, you know, relook at that because I have done research recently, but as far as I'm concerned, there is no They cannot say that that's a fact.
Speaker 1All right, all get very you know.
Speaker 11I mean the people who are the statisicists and all that. That's where a lot of them go with. There's people physicists who don't subscribe to that, mostly because of the fact that they can't definitely prove it. With our laws of physics, our laws of math. You get to a point where you can no longer definitely prove that, and we haven't advanced.
Speaker 7In quantum theory enough to It.
Speaker 1Was first conceptualized in twenty twelve. And yes, scientists have successfully proven the existence of the indefinite causal order. So yeah, I'm looking I'm looking it up right now. So significant breakthrough in twenty twenty five, just last year. Like I said, this is all new science, but yeah, it's real and it's been proven.
Speaker 3All right.
Speaker 11I would before I because I honestly want to disagree to agree, but before I go that far, I would ask what exactly you're saying? Essentially that there's nothing forgive me for dumbing it down, but there's nothing an empty space and something can just come from.
Speaker 1Well that's how we're finding out isn't true. That's exactly what we're finding out isn't true. And there is no such thing as empty space. There is no such thing as nothing. Even by giving nothing a name, we make it into something.
Speaker 11Oh yeah, I mean, there's no scientific nothings.
Speaker 9But I'm not.
Speaker 11I have to speak in like the terms that I dumb down terms. Like I said, I'm not a scientist, so you can't spit it the same way they do. But from my understanding, yeah, like you said, there's a point that's an empty void or whatever you want to call it, that there's laws that still existed or quantum theories that existed at that time. But like I said, I mean, I'll have to do my research. I'm not and I'll argue with you if I don't. If I don't have that look, uh, I can see in front
Speaker 11of me. But I will just end with saying that what I've research and what I've seen, there is no in the sense that like something just I don't I don't even know how to phrase it, but there is no definitive editor of it is that our world and there's you get to a point where everything we know breaks down if you're telling me that there just came out with research that disproves that. And like I said, I have to do my research before I can continue to speak confronted.
Speaker 1Yeah, that's like I said, that's new. So it's and and I don't blame you for keeping up on scientific research. Most people don't, so I don't blame you for that at all. But it is out there that if you want the information. And again I'll it's called indefinite causal order I c O for short, M so I mean goud look and I encourage you to go, you know, do some research and check it out. And it kind of blew me away. When I found out about it, I was like, holy shit, you.
Speaker 9Know, I mean, I can't even lie.
Speaker 11That's another like some stuck one. And I'm like, I really have That's what that if you don't, because I mean, I know you probably I don't know if you are a scientist or not, but I know you probably may not have the full scope of that research. Did they mention anything by chance?
Speaker 9On? But how those laws like they just.
Speaker 7I mean, I have to do my research.
Speaker 11I feel free to leave because, like I said, I'm kind of in a range where I'm speaking on something I don't know. So I appreciate your time, I appreciate the statements you have said and the information you're giving me, and I'm definitely gonna go, like I said, do my own research, follow up.
Speaker 1On that, and cool, maybe one day we'll talk again. Cool. I encourage people to look it up because it's really out there, and like I say, it's new science, and I often find that and I'm not saying that I don't think you're guilty of this, but I also I often find a lot of people who call in, a lot of the Theists and Christians and Muslims who call in, they don't seem like they're keeping up with science, and they use a lot of these old, these old arguments that we've already disproven, We've been just proven decades ago. So I mean, it's just the thing that happens with us.
Speaker 1And I don't think that I don't think you're doing that. But you know, like I said, this is brand new, twenty twenty five, so I can't I can't blame you for not knowing what it is. But I do encourage everybody to check it out, do some research. It's pretty amazing stuff.
Speaker 9Absolutely, thank you again, appreciate.
Speaker 1It, No, thank you? That was that was fun.
Speaker 2Yeah, you know, and I know research the definitely cause the harder.
Speaker 1I know, it's it's it's mind blowing. And it's one more gap that God can't live in anymore, you know, It's one more gap that's taken away.
Speaker 2So I'm tired of people filling my gaps with God.
Speaker 1That's all I you know what. I love to have a caller be so open minded like that, you know, that was that was really awesome to me. That, Yeah, I love that.
Speaker 2This is a new term for me as well. I think within the past couple of years as the first time I had heard it. And usually I just say atheists because people kind of know what an atheist is. It's not a religion, but atheist. Most people don't know. But yeah, God, what is that? You could ask one person what God is, and you could ask another person and they would all have different explanations definitions.
Speaker 1For us. Us theists are but few now, but soon we shall cover the earth.
Speaker 2I hope. So that's I'm trying to spread the joy. It's the good news of there's no God. Before I spread the good news of the truth, which was a lie, and now I can spread the actual.
Speaker 1We have got a ton of calls, so I mean, I want to and hang out. I would love to sit and hang out with just you, Ryan, but I feel like i'd be, you know, neglecting all these people.
Speaker 2Who are calling us.
Speaker 1So you can do that. I should, yeah, I know, I shouldn't.
Speaker 2Don't be bad hosts.
Speaker 1Okay, So let's go to the next caller then, and we pull this. I got to keep changing windows. So and we got huge Gene from Washington, Seattle. He's a theist and he says that, uh, we're wrong, that he doesn't worship an evil god. God is all goodness. Hi, Eugene, how are you?
Speaker 9Oh?
Speaker 7Well, how are you?
Speaker 1I'm good?
Speaker 5How are you?
Speaker 7So?
Speaker 1What what's your beef?
Speaker 7Well, God is our evil God. And I've listened to one of your calls. I missed the beginning half of the previous one, so I'm not one hundred percent sure what scientific research you are referencing. However, as far as I'm aware, and I've been in the science game a very long time. The further you get, the further a researcher gets into researching the physics of the universe, the further come to the realization of or the closer their company to the realization of, Yes, there is a God.
Speaker 1That's absolutely false. That is absolutely false. The vast majority of physicists are are atheists. That's absolutely false. I mean, if you don't believe me, please I encourage you to go look it up. The vast majority of astrophysicists and physicists are atheists or agnostics.
Speaker 7That's a fair statement to make. But what what is your claim against the validity of Jesus Christ's life, because there is not more evidence.
Speaker 1I need you to explain that question, Jesus Christ. I need you to explain that that a little bit more like what about the life of Jesus.
Speaker 7So there is more evidence substantiating the existence and the life of Jesus Christ than there is of anything else. You cannot prove.
Speaker 1That's not true. That's not true because we have we have writings from people who were alive during Lincoln's time. We have writings from people who knew Lincoln. We have speeches that Lincoln made, that that we have witnesses that he made those speeches. We have photographs of Abraham Lincoln, right, we don't have any of that stuff for Jesus, none of it. We have no empirical evidence at all for Jesus Christ that that was contemporary with his lifetime.
Speaker 7Okay, okay, what do you take the Gospel of Paul? For Paul met out there prosecuting you like other Christians, and.
Speaker 1I'll never Paull never met Jesus. And just because somebody finds just because somebody is doing one grift and they find a better grift doesn't mean that they're doing it out of sincerity.
Speaker 7So let me ask you this. Do you think Jesus Christ was a real person?
Speaker 1We already went through this with the first call. I don't really care if he was or not there were. Religion is still valid. People still worship him, whether he actually existed or not.
Speaker 7His moot. Okay, do you believe that he existed?
Speaker 1I don't care. I don't. I don't. I'm out on the I'm out on it until I see better evidence. I'm not going to make a judgment because right now there's not enough evidence. God, pardon, have you ever prayed to a god when I was a kid?
Speaker 7Yeah, okay, okay, Well let me ask you this. Have you ever heard of the Korean tribe.
Speaker 1In South America.
Speaker 7No, they were Pacific Islanders, the archipelago of Islands just northwest of.
Speaker 5Australia, okay.
Speaker 7And their origin story is very similar to Genesis.
Speaker 1Almost all origin stories are similar to Genesis. I don't get what the point is, not.
Speaker 7Quite but their origin story is very similar Genesis. God created all of this. We lost all this and information and our God figurehead is called yawan, which is very similar to the word yahweh, which is okay. Uh. You know, early Jews in Hebrew called you know, I am who I am, which is ya okay.
Speaker 1What's the point of this? What's the point of this?
Speaker 2I am who I am is not yahweh? Just so you know, it's a yeah. If you read.
Speaker 7I appreciate it, thank you. The whole point of this is after the flood, there was a group of people that spread out into the rest of the world as they were commanded to do, and there.
Speaker 1Was like, what's your what's your proof of that?
Speaker 7The what do you mean, what is the proof of that?
Speaker 1What's your proof of Number one the flood and number two that people who were all killed during the flood spread out.
Speaker 7Okay, Well, the first, but the flood everywhere you go, every single culture you go.
Speaker 1Yeah, just be careful on this point because I'm a geologist, so I've seen the physical evidence that there was never a flood.
Speaker 7So what do you have you been to Washington.
Speaker 1To Washington State. You're talking about the big flood when, uh, when the glacial lake burst? Because we know about that. It was a glacial lake that burst after the melting of the of the Ice Age glakes, the last Ice Age glaciers. We know what that was. Sure, But Okay, so that's not that's not a global flood.
Speaker 7Everywhere has a flood story.
Speaker 1Yeah, and everywhere has had a flood. What's your point?
Speaker 2People gather around water sources. That's kind of local.
Speaker 1Yeah, everybody has a flood for everybody had a flood.
Speaker 2Have your resources, right, So it's kind of.
Speaker 1Okay, if I if I if I live along the Euphrates River, or if I live along the Indus River, or I live along the Nile River and it floods, how is the story going to differ whichever it is of those three rivers? How will the story differ?
Speaker 7Okay, Well, having a river flooding, that's what like every twenty five years that occurs.
Speaker 1Not that's that's not the point. I'm asking you, Well, how the story would differ between the three floods.
Speaker 5Okay, So I.
Speaker 7Don't know if you're familiar with Bran Hancock, but he traveled home.
Speaker 1Yeah, I'm familiar with Graham Hancock, and I just and whenever I see here Graham Hancock's name mentioned, a little part of me inside dies.
Speaker 7Okay, well that was my first like, hey, holy shit, every single place has a flood story, Like, there's got to be more to this than every single person.
Speaker 1Says Graham Hancock has not been able to prove any of the bullshit he spouts. He has not been able to prove any of the bullshit he spouts, none of it.
Speaker 7That's fine, But I'm more more so referencing the fact that he went tried to tribe, and every single tribe had more or less the same story of Hey, the gods were angry at us, they wanted to life the South, they wanted upon, et cetera.
Speaker 1And every everywhere has a big flood like once every hundred years. What's the I don't get your point.
Speaker 7The Bible has the flood.
Speaker 1Yeah, every story has a flood. Every almost every has the flood, even in China. They have some flood stories. They don't think the whole world flooded, but they do have stories of places in China flooding in ancient China. But they don't have a story of all of ancient China flooding. Okay, So how do you explain.
Speaker 7That characters depicting I forgot what exactly word it was, but they have Chinese characters mirroring the Genesis story?
Speaker 1Are you and who told you this? Graham Hancock? No, you've actually had Chinese people tell you this, correct? Okay? And were these Chinese people Christians too? Were these Chinese people Christians too? Or were they members of or did they follow some of the traditional Chinese.
Speaker 7So they're all like inguish and linguistics, like relationships everything else.
Speaker 1That didn't answer my question. Were they also Christian Chinese after.
Speaker 7They had discovered this they had converted?
Speaker 1Yes, how do you know it was before or after?
Speaker 7Simply by the testimony?
Speaker 1Okay, So you don't really know. They could be lying to you. You don't really know they could be They could be relating misinformation to boost their own to boost themselves in the eyes of other Christian followers, like, oh wow, look how holy this guy was. Do you think that could have happened?
Speaker 7You can say that about anybody, about anything.
Speaker 1Sure you could, Sure you could. That's why. That's why you look for empirical evidence. That's why you do research, and you look for evidence that you can find that has actually be You can see it or you can read it right that. That's why evidence is so important. Anybody can say anything this is true.
Speaker 7Okay, So let me ask you this. If you met a person that said, Hey, I was declared brain dead at the hospital. They left me alone, and after half an hour of no medical treatment, I came back to life and I had this experience with Christ in the after life during my death period. Would you consider that any sort of balid testimony.
Speaker 1I would consider the fact that since there was suffering from hypoxia, you know, lack of oxygen to the brain at some point, and that produces hallucinations, I would come to the conclusion that they could have either seen Jesus or they could have just had an hallucination of Jesus for thirty minutes.
Speaker 7You would expect to see brain damage after that.
Speaker 1I don't know that the person was dead for thirty minutes. That's just the claim that they're making. I don't know of anybody who's been dead for thirty minutes and came back. I don't know of anybody who was dead for thirty minutes and came back a few minutes. Yeah, yeah, a few minutes. No, not for thirty minutes.
Speaker 10Okay.
Speaker 7I like, in this scenario, the person was medically legally declared dead thirty Well, that's so they say the medical intervention.
Speaker 1So they say, which they come back.
Speaker 7To life with no medical intervention? Would you in this scenario heed of their words of hey I met Christ, this is the truth.
Speaker 1Would I'd have to? I would have to again again? And I don't. It's like you're not accepting my answer. No, I would not accept that because I would need more evidence. I would need more data I would need before I believe that this person was dead for thirty minutes. I would want them to present the medical records to show that they were dead for thirty minutes. Well, in this hypothetical question, PreTect and hypothetically, I would still ask for that evidence. Why are you not understanding this?
Speaker 9No?
Speaker 7I am understanding that. Like, let's pretend that you did receive this evidence, Like, I just want to get down to the point of do you resist the existence of Christ and of God because of a lack of evidence or because you don't want to accept it. That's kind of what.
Speaker 1I used to believe in God, and then when I got older, I realized that I had no reason. There was no evidence that God existed, and that's why I don't believe it. That's why I personally don't believe in a God, because I have never seen any of any evidence whatsoever that God existed. Brian, I feel like I'm doing all of this. You want to take it.
Speaker 2For a minute, I forget what the question is at this point to be here.
Speaker 7Of somebody's a male speaking earlier, like, I did not believe in God for a very long time. It was about fifteen years of my life. I just I refuse to believe any of it. I prayed a while and I received evidence. And that's that.
Speaker 1It sounds like you were mad at God instead of not believing in God.
Speaker 2What I've heard from people who have God that I.
Speaker 7Received from the school, I'm sorry, go ahead, and I.
Speaker 2Wish but the people who have had those experiences that I have seen for myself because I used to watch like those TV. All of them seem to have their afterlife experience or whatever you'd like to call that, very similar to what they've been told in their life about their religious belief system. So I feel like as Kelly was saying, what our brain does to protect itself and the chemicals and whatnot. Now, I wouldn't take away their experience,
Speaker 2Like I understand that that probably would have felt very real, just like the dreams that I've had are very real. And if you're a believer, I understand that. But for me that wouldn't. That's still not enough evidence for me. I would need more.
Speaker 7Information, very fair statement and feeling to have. If you don't mind, I'd like to share my experience and what happened. It was not a near death thing, Okay, So do you know roughly ten years?
Speaker 1Go ahead, I about to say, do you know what little Wood's law is? I do not, okay, because most of the time when I hear these things, it did little Wood's Law pretty much covers them. But go ahead, and then I'll explain to you afterwards if it does. If it does cover this.
Speaker 7Well, do you mind explaining what Little Wood's law is prior to me.
Speaker 1Yeah, something that is something that can happen, something that has a one in a million chants of happening, if you're awake and alert eight hours a day, can happen to you, has the ability to happen to you once every thirty four days, and a lot of people look at these coincidences as miracles.
Speaker 7I'm not familiar with this. I'd like to do more research. I appreciate you sharing that from well.
Speaker 1I just teaching everybody today, aren't I everybody?
Speaker 5Yeah?
Speaker 7No, man, it was like tenish years ago. It's like twenty eighteen, you know, early twenties, mitche ties. And I'm thinking to myself, at this point in time, I'm doing trim compentry work on spec homes. So i walk around with the nail gun Ti Tan air air compressor and I'm just nailing trim on nailing base on whatever. It is very common, not super common, but it's it's common enough to where when you're walking between rooms, your inner host gets caught on something and then if you know,
Speaker 7it's like, ah, got to stop you know whatever, Yeah, untangle it, unstuck it. And I was working in a room a pretty big room, and I was thinking to myself, like, hey, you know, like what is this God thing? Like, does God really exist? I don't really know or have any actual evidence, Like none of this is like batually based in science. And I'm a science person, you know, so like I have to have some sort of physical, visible evidence that this thing exists because the science says it
Speaker 7all started from nothing. That's we all.
Speaker 1That's not that's not what. That's not even close to what the big bank says. Go ahead, the bang is. Yeah, the Big Bang is the beginning of time as we know it. It does The Big Bang does not does not say anything about what happened before the Big Bang nothing. It has nothing to do with the time we get the.
Speaker 7Curd prior, you know. But let me continue on my the you know, my thought process, like the sciences, we came from nothing. No, it doesn't nothing, and at the end of time, this is this is just my thought process at this occurrence.
Speaker 1Right, Okay, Well I'm showing you why your thought process is wrong right off the.
Speaker 7Bad Okay, Well, sure, well I'm walking from one room into a hallway, around a corner, around another corner into a room. I get about halfway into this room. And about this point is when I'm thinking to myself, like I need some sort of proof that a god exists. I need something, you know. And at that instant, my nail gun flies out of my pots it, which has never occurred before, I get just flies out, and I'm like, Okay, that's weird. I got caught on something. So I followed
Speaker 7my air holes around and it was in the exact perfect center of every single doorway, hallway, entryway point. It was that minimum twenty inches away from anything it could have possibly caught on. And after Okay, I was like, all right, that's pretty weird, you know, So I continue.
Speaker 1We got to move this up. Eugene. I hate I hate the Russia, but we're going to be running out of time. So we got that show. That was the end of it, you know, like Okay.
Speaker 7That was my like beginning to oh, holy shit, maybe there is a God. And I continue my journey, and a number of things happened afterwards that was like, all right, no, this is real. I received a vision of a stairway of heaven many years later in the middle of the prayer, and then like a week later, I read about Israel receiving a vision of heaven. And I know things that I've experience that I cannot deny.
Speaker 1I had a vision of heaven, did you Yeah, I was on LSD. Seriously, seriously, the first time I ever took LSD, I had a vision of heavn I thought I had met God. I thought I seriously, I thought I was hugging God. Okay, it doesn't mean.
Speaker 7I was so for forty months, fifty months at this point driving into work, Okay, So I don't know. It was the most real thing I've ever experienced, and in my personal life.
Speaker 1I'm wondering how you were able to keep driving while you were having a vision.
Speaker 7It happened in a split second, but it lasted for multiple seconds.
Speaker 1Oh you know, I don't want, Eugene. I want to keep this call going for hours, believe me, but I just can't do it. We've got to end the show. I want to think, man, I want to thank you for calling in. I want to encourage you to call us back. And uh, there's other people, other hosts you can talk to, So maybe you'll find somebody that's pardon Yeah. Sure, if you want to make a closing statement, sure, go ahead. Sure, go ahead.
Speaker 7Anybody listening to this, I imp you to please read the Gospel of Luke and that's it.
Speaker 1All right, all right. I think a lot of people here have But Ryan, what were you going to say?
Speaker 2I just said, by the Eugene, we appreciate you calling. Thank you very much.
Speaker 1Yeah, thank you very much.
Speaker 7I appreciate coming across this. You know.
Speaker 9I hope I can shape the minds.
Speaker 7If not, it is what it is.
Speaker 1Well, I hope you call back and talk to some of the other hosts too.
Speaker 7Yeah, I may have a blessing. Thank you.
Speaker 2Bye.
Speaker 1I I have a call here I want to take so bad, so so bad, and we're out of it, and we're running out of time, and we I've only got a couple of minutes, and this call deserts so much more than a couple of minutes. But I want to encourage. I want to encourage everybody who's on the line right now, Jordan, James, Aaron and through. I think Kelly's still on the line, stay on the line. We're going to become a going into atheist experience right after this, and they will take these calls. They want to talk about these very same topics with you. So I encourage
Speaker 1you to stay on the line. You can talk to you godless engineer, and I think Thinker. I think Thinker is on MP today. So yeah, please please stay on the line and talk to them. You don't want to talk to me anyway, I'm not the best post. Actually, you want to talk to Ryan, That's who you really wanted to talk to you. But I want I want to before we go, I want to thank again the whole crew for doing this, and I really really want to thank one special person and that is Jamie the
Speaker 1Blind MythBuster for joining us as our coup post today.
Speaker 10Jamie want Yeah, I just thought i'd put a beret in some glasses on to complete the look. And I'm thinking that most of those myths are pretty much busted. And here's here's the reason why. For all of the people that are offering anecdotes, offering testimony as their like Eugene and everyone before them, I always like to use this methodology, this rubric. Let's say two people have a
Speaker 10near death experience like you like, say that they somehow miraculously came back after thirty minutes of brain death, which I don't think is physically possible, but anyway, they come back and one of them saw God, one of them actually met Jesus and up to heaven and met Jesus for really reals, and the other one just hallucinated it. How do I tell the difference what they're telling me the same story? How do I know which one is,
Speaker 10which one is telling me an actual truth, and which one is mistaken?
Speaker 1A good point, A very good point. Help Thanks for that, Jamie. That was an awesome good point. Ryan. I want to before we end the show, I want you to tell everybody where they can find you at. Again.
Speaker 2You can find me here on YouTube at a Goddess. I'm here in the chat. I just typed hello and again. I have a Twitter, it's a nat Yahoo, but you can find that in my bio on YouTube. Come come hang out with me. I make all kinds of crazy content, and maybe some of it is up your alley. And I'm looking for friends too.
Speaker 1So I've enjoyed a lot of your content. I'll be honest with you. I've enjoyed a lot of stuff. You know, the video who should do with being a little girl? Here in the Jesus things is? Are those are flood Jesus? Oh Man those have made me laugh so hard.
Speaker 2Thank you, Kelly, I truly appreciate it.
Speaker 1Well, I thank you for doing what you do. I totally appreciate that. And before we leave, we every week we ask each one of our guests for some parting words of wisdom. Right, so what what? What kind of words of wisdom can you leave us with?
Speaker 2Question everything? Do not be afraid to ask questions and seek the answer, because you're gonna find the truth. That's what we all should want it to. It's the truth.
Speaker 1So do it cool, Jamie, you got any words of wisdom for the week? If in doubt more loob, I don't even.
Speaker 6Know how to.
Speaker 1I don't even know how to, don't even know how to follow that. And with that, I'm gonna say goodbye. Thank you all for viewing. We really appreciate you coming every week and always always remember to keep wanting the truth.
Speaker 8Watch Talkie Than Live Sundays at one pm Central and call into the show at five one two nine nine one nine two four two, or connect to the
In today's episode of Truth Wanted, ObjectivelyDan welcomes guest Out Of Body Atheist, with The Beard of Empathy on backup, to dig into Reiki, New Age spirituality, homeopathy, and the long road from woo to skepticism!...
In today's episode of Truth Wanted, Jon the Skeptick, Volcy, and Sofia Spina explain why no one can talk to the dead, from Haitian Vodou and grief dreams to Jon's past as a spiritualist! Bob jumps from objective...
In today's episode of Truth Wanted, ObjectivelyDan and Nintendrew, later joined by The Beard of Empathy, tackle a world run on Jesus, the magic of manifesting, and a prayer that actually got answered! Bob in NY, a...
In today's episode of Truth Wanted, ObjectivelyDan, Kelley Laughlin, and The Beard of Empathy tackle standards of evidence, miracle claims, and the false binaries of moral philosophy! Dean in VA questions why skeptics...
In today's episode of Truth Wanted, ObjectivelyDan and Chad Harris tackle Christian nationalism, police brutality, and the uncomfortable truths about racism and immigration. Big E in TN survived police brutality and...