In today’s episode of the Truth Wanted, ObjectivelyDan and Kayse Melone jump into hell to find it does not exist. They then sort through ways of telling people they are wrong and the merits of an atheist evangelizing in a church. Sven in WA has some questions about the value of the soul from a Christian point of view and god as an entity vs. a mind. How useful is it to believe in the concept of a soul? Sven also has a second question about the Pope’s belief in hell and the infernalist mindset causing religious trauma. How would things change if masses of people stopped believing in hell? There is plenty of suffering in the here and now; how can we focus on easing that suffering now? Bob in MS wants to know how to tell someone wrong in a good way, a flip on our question of the week. Starting with common ground and using empathy will get you further than picking apart the logic. When we start with empathetic questions, we find similarities. Understanding how people get their truths matters, and if you can examine a claim together by asking how they got to the claim can be effective. These types of conversations are not encouraged in church environments. Giving people tools to help them realize where their ideas are coming from can help them liberate themselves from their false beliefs, even if it takes some time. Check yourself: What is the purpose of telling someone they are wrong? Billy Pilgrim in TX reminds us of how hard it is to get people to believe the truth when they want to believe in other things. People have an investment in these beliefs and oftentimes feel trapped. They may not have a concept of what it is like to be an atheist and do good things. What kind of bandwidth and time does it take to be a truth seeker? How would an atheist within a church provide a benefit? Thank you for tuning in this week! Kelley Laughlin, our backup host joins to close us out and deliver the We Want The Truth segment of the week: What is a bad way to tell someone that they are wrong? We will see you next time! Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/truth-wanted--3195473/support.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Speaker 1Hey, everybody, Objectively Dan here, And so the new pope just got elected. And I'm not sure if I'm supposed to like him or be afraid of him, because on the one hand, he's supposed to be a woke Marxist pope who loves immigrants that is supremely progressive, at least by Catholic standards.
Speaker 2And then on the other hand.
Speaker 1He's reported by some Peruvian news sources who have said less than affirming things about gay people and may or may not have had knowledge about the many, many scandals that.
Speaker 2The church has faced. So how's this new pope going to turn out?
Speaker 1Let me know, because the show is starting right now. Hello, Hello everybody, and welcome back to another episode of Truth Wanted.
Speaker 2I am your host, Objectively Dan.
Speaker 1This is the live calling show that happens every single week Fridays at seven pm Central Time, where we talk to people about what they believe and why, and if you'd like to call us, you can absolutely do that. The number is five to one two nine nine two four two, or you can call through your computer at tiny dot cc slash call tw Truth Wanted is a product of the Atheist Community of Austin, a five oh one c three nonprofit organization dedicated to the promotion of atheism, critical thinking, secular humanism, and the separation of religion and government.
Speaker 2And every single week I always have a special guest with you. This week is no different. It is Casey Belone joining me today. Casey. Welcome to Truth Wanted.
Speaker 3Thank you so much for having me. I'm very excited to be here. Hello Truth Wanted Crowd, Hello Objectively.
Speaker 2Dan, Hello, Hello Casey.
Speaker 1For the folks at home who don't know who you are, how would you describe yourself?
Speaker 3Well, let's see if I can do that succinctly. I am an atheist as of Honestly, I think I claimed that term maybe within since the beginning of this year. However, I deconstructed from evangelical Christianity about twelve years ago. I grew up quite indoctrinated in evangelical Christianity, went to the church, went to a megachurch where I grew up in Tulsa, Oklahoma. When to the Bible based private school affiliated with said megachurch.
Speaker 3So I was there every day of the week, loved to see it, got a lot of scriptures up here in the noggin, but took a lot of time to really think about that really took some critical thinking to heart. Right, we love some skepticism in this house. And about twelve thirteen years ago, I stopped identifying as a Christian. I know it's different for everyone who kind of like walked away from the faith, but I did have a capital M moment that I remember very vividly, and it's just so fascinating that it started as a moment of recognizing
Speaker 3that I was not a Christian anymore. And then about twelve years later I realized that, oh, I am in fact an atheist. So that's something I talk about in my content a lot and in my conversations is just how much of a journey it actually is to go from A to B. And it looks different for everyone. But now I'm hanging out on YouTube, I do daily live streams centered around these conversations. Particularly, I would say in response to a lot of the almost political landscape,
Speaker 3I guess you could say a lot of the ideological landscape that is kind of really scaring people, really difficult for a lot a lot of people, and realizing that, you know what, if I can bring people together, if we can kind of find some common ground, and talk about some of these bigger issues. Then I will feel like I'm doing my part. So that is what I mean.
Speaker 2Amen, Yeah, amen from the crowd for that.
Speaker 1Amen to Casey on that one. That's that's fascinating. So twelve years. Actually, let's start with this. Let's start with that capital M moment there, because I think you're right. I think there are some atheists. I definitely hear they have stories and there.
Speaker 2Is a moment. There's maybe a moment for me, but like for a large.
Speaker 1Part of people, it was kind of a slower process. But you have a capital M moment in your story. Can you tell me about that?
Speaker 3Yeah, yeah, I want to hear about your too. But it certainly was still a process like it did take time. Started with my questioning of the infallibility of the Bible, of the inerrancy of the Bible, whether or not it was actually divinely inspired. And it's so this is actually really interesting because I was reading two books kind of in conjunction that brought me to the level of cognitive dissonance that allowed me to finally walk away. And the
Speaker 3two authors were C. S. Lewis, who, if anyone isn't familiar is very much a Christian writer, and in conjunction with Ein Rand, which is very much not a Christian writer.
Speaker 2Okay, yes, all right, yeah, I'm fascinated.
Speaker 3It was so jarring, and I think, you know, obviously there are there are Okay, maybe it's not obvious. There are many things that iron Rand believed in and promoted that I don't align with with. One of the easiest examples for me to bring up is she was actively not a feminist. She is quoted saying the ideal man is a hero and the ideal woman is a hero worshiper, so I should yeah, yeah, yeah, they're in the you know, there's certainly other things too, And of course I don't
Speaker 3agree with everything that C. S Lewis, you know, talks about. But what got me was how I was reading both of their fiction works.
Speaker 2So C.
Speaker 3S Lewis, for some of you who you probably have heard of the Chronicles of Narnia, which is like a fantasy for young adults, and he also Screwtabele Wow my gosh, flashback, but he wrote a sci fi trilogy more geared toward adults. And it was just the idea of them both able to infuse their preferred ideology into fiction. That had me look at the Bible and it just broke down and I was just like, okay, so books written by people
Speaker 3or their own agendas was really what brought me to the That was like the last thread for my deconstruction journey was the infallibility of the Bible. And when that broke down, I mean it was just gone. I just couldn't do it right.
Speaker 1Yeah, okay, So so you came to the conclusion that the Bible as a whole is written by people who are interested in creating fiction, and that's your view of the Bible on.
Speaker 3That, yes, and more so just that they had agendas behind why they were writing, right, And then I couldn't square the fact that they were divinely inspired anymore.
Speaker 2Yeah.
Speaker 1So, like biblical errancy is just out the window for you, right, because there's there's some weird stuff going on there, and you couldn't be a Christian without the.
Speaker 3Bible correct for me?
Speaker 1Okay, yeah, yeah, okay, that makes sense. So okay, so you kind of figured out So that was moment. Wait that was part one. There's another part, right? Or was that the whole story there?
Speaker 4Oh?
Speaker 3Well, I mean the capital m moment was I was reading Iron Rand and C. S. Lewis, and I remember like walking through the college campus where I was coming to this realization and looking around and accepting, like, you know, as I'm processing all of this and accepting that the Bible is not the divinely inspired word of.
Speaker 2Red, it's that Marxist college campus that.
Speaker 3Got Yeah, you know, it was the brainwashing of me trying.
Speaker 2A grand of all people.
Speaker 1Yeah, Marxist famous for leading into ain Rand, which is like.
Speaker 2Yeah, that's that is so funny.
Speaker 1I've read The fountain Head and I knew a girl in college who was really in ain Rand, and that was like and she was crazy.
Speaker 2So that's my exerience, Okrand, I guess. But so that that's pretty wild.
Speaker 1So you have this moment and you're like, Okay, I can't be a part of this anymore. Then you say, twelve years later, now you're using this label atheist, So tell me about that.
Speaker 3It's so interesting because I think I was technically I was an atheist as far as like what leads me to call myself one for a couple of years now, and I just didn't kind of embrace the term.
Speaker 4Uh.
Speaker 3In large part because I didn't feel the need to. It didn't really have a purpose. But when I started really trying to be serious about the content I was creating and the story I was telling, I thought it was going to be more authentic if I was realistic with my audience. And that, by the way, like technically I am an atheist, Like technically I do not believe and that there is enough evidence for a creator being, for the supernatural, et cetera. But yeah, in large part I probably have been for years. And you know, I
Speaker 3did the thing where I like started out right after Christianity as like a deist for like a couple of years, you know, or then the spiritual not religious, not really.
Speaker 2It didn't have to be with just Jesus.
Speaker 1It could also be with you know, maybe some other spiritual I don't know, forest nymphs or.
Speaker 3You know, yeah, yeah, you've got it, you've you got it around.
Speaker 2So soundly, there was a hesitancy there to use the atheist label then.
Speaker 3Almost in a sense just in the sense of being shy about labels in general, right like and put it, you know, is this just going to become another box that I put myself in. And it's so funny because I get a lot of when I talk about the story of going from essentially these two extremes, I'm constantly getting told like, oh, so you you left one cult to join another, and I'm like, yep, you got me. That's it. I'm a gotam commie marks. Yeah, you know, terrible woke, woke cult or whatever they say these days.
Speaker 3And I get it. I totally do, because that's what I was hesitant about probably the most.
Speaker 1You know, so you were you were hesitant that people were going to put you in a box, that they were going to kind of these ideas about you because use the slabel for yourself.
Speaker 3Yeah, I would also say maybe just internally, because you know, the idea of adhering to any kind of objective of truth or absolute reality is really scary for someone who thought that truth was this one thing their whole life and then they start questioning it. You know, my relationship with truth had to change, if that makes scent, If that makes sense.
Speaker 1Definitely, definitely makes sense because because I mean, deconstruction from your religious ideology, especially if you're growing up in Oklahoma right where, let's be real, that's everywhere, right, Like, you know, you're isolated in some sense probably, and also like you start to have a real skittish relationship with any other idea because it's like listen, I was attached to at least for me speaking from my own experience, it's like I was attached to this thing for a long time. I can't start getting attached to this other stuffy right, And so you know, I definitely had the same kind
Speaker 1of hesitancy there with the atheist label.
Speaker 2But now you're comfortable with that label, I think.
Speaker 3So. Yeah, it surprised me too, you know, but I'm curious about your capital m moment. You said you might have one.
Speaker 2Oh yeah, well yeah, I've.
Speaker 1Told my story on the show before, but a lot of people know me. For those who don't know, a lot of people say this is my capital of him. There's a guy named Anthony Magnamosco who goes out and talks to people.
Speaker 2Have you heard of him before? He does a thing called street epistemology.
Speaker 3Oh that actually does ring a bell?
Speaker 2Okay, Yeah, so he came out.
Speaker 1He had a conversation with me on my college campus when I was a part of a college group at the time, and that conversation got put on YouTube.
Speaker 2So there's a.
Speaker 1Conversation of me in college, like a thirty forty minute conversation with me talking about my Christianity and my faith and stuff, and I'm having this whole conversation with him and he was just asking really basic questions about my faith that I felt.
Speaker 2Like I didn't really have great answers to. And it was probably a year later I started called myself an athies, maybe a little longer than that.
Speaker 1So yeah, that was that was kind of a weird thing for me because I have a thing that's like out there and online and people can like look at it, you know, and so yeah, it can be different kinds of things like that. You know, sometimes it's for most people to a private moment, right and you kind of have revelation to yourself and then you start to think about all the other stuff doesn't make sense, right, So there's definitely some stuff there. I want to talk to you more about your story, but before we do that, Casey, we have to talk about our We Want the Truth segment, because every single week we are asking you guys a
Speaker 1question or a prompt and to talk about that is our backup host, Kelly, who is joining us here Hello, Kelly Man.
Speaker 5You know that was a great video, the one you just mentioned on Anthony, and you did a follow up video with Anthony that I thought was even better. And I hope if the first, I know, the first one's still posted, I hope the second one is still there because I thought it was better. And I'm gonna I'm gonna fanboy on your first second.
Speaker 1Dan.
Speaker 5I saw those two videos and then I saw you as a guest on XP one day and I was like, Hey, it's that guy from those two videos on Street Epistemology. And then you said you were going to start this show, and I've been watching this show ever since the first episode.
Speaker 1My goodness, Kelly's trying to embarrass Stop it stop.
Speaker 6Because I've had so much fun with its Cail.
Speaker 2We're always glad to have you, Kelly.
Speaker 1And on that note, I think you should tell us what the prompts this week.
Speaker 2I will.
Speaker 5Last week, we asked you name something people worry about too much, and here are our favorite answers, chosen by Johnny p Angel.
Speaker 1I want to make a special note here because Johnny p Angel picked comment or Chuck Gatos. Chuck Gatos has been featured in our top comments before Chuck Gatos is all three of our top comments. I don't think Johnny says he didn't realize it until later, but we already got the screenshots for you here, so there's no turning back.
Speaker 2So here we go. Chuck Gatos, your contributor this week.
Speaker 6Thank you are the man.
Speaker 2This week.
Speaker 5Number three from Chuck Gatos. People spend too much time worrying about alien abduction. You know, the anal probes aren't overly painful.
Speaker 2Oh my god. Well, okay, all right, I.
Speaker 3Mean that's fair though, that's experience. I don't know my business business.
Speaker 5Yeah yeah, head Number two from Chuck Gaos. People spend too much time worrying about bigfoot rumors. They get along fine without.
Speaker 6Little foot rumors. We could learn from them.
Speaker 5And number one from the incredible Chuck Gato's. People spend too much time worrying about demonic possession. It's just the role playing gamer in Hell, playing places and people.
Speaker 6It won't last very long.
Speaker 1Oh my gosh, Places and people is awesome.
Speaker 2It is a very good thing. Thank you for thanks.
Speaker 5I can see what Johnny picked three of us, though, yeah, we're all really good.
Speaker 3Amazing, amazing.
Speaker 5Ampt for next week is, what is a bad way to tell someone that they're wrong?
Speaker 6What do you think, Casey m.
Speaker 3My knee jerk response is just angrily right out of anger. I don't know how many problems that will actually solve. But you know, my second response would be like on a date, you know, or in a romantic situation, don't don't uh, don't bring it up. Then I don't know.
Speaker 1Yeah, I'm gonna say, maybe don't tell people God's not really Grandma's funeral. Yeah, Like, I think there's a time to place to have these conversations, and maybe we don't have to be you know, people are like, oh, I'm just speaking the truth.
Speaker 2I'm just I'm just being honest. It's like yeah, and you know, yeah, you can also be an asshole. Things don't have to be mutually exclusive. So I don't know, you.
Speaker 3Gotta do it. Vibecheck, you gotta do a check. Absolutely frehand.
Speaker 6Speaking of vibes the internet, bad vibe and means trying to.
Speaker 2Yeah, look at you, you're learning out over here. That's crazy.
Speaker 6I'm gonna let you get back to the show. Thanks for letting me out, all.
Speaker 2Right, thanks Kelly.
Speaker 1Yeah, so in the comments below, what is a bad way to tell someone they're wrong? If you're watching in the chat, don't put in the chat, put it in the comments section and we will read those next week. But back to Casey, Casey, you and by the way, lines are open.
Speaker 2We have open lines.
Speaker 1We've got a couple of callers, but we can happily get a few more callers in the queue if you want to talk to us. So in case you you have this experience saying the Bible, don't think any of this.
Speaker 2Is really real, right at least I think it's fictional. I think people disturbret it. I think people are using it for stuff, you know, all these kinds of things.
Speaker 1And then this year you're calling yourself in any of this, and now you're streaming about it in politics and some other stuff. So what happened this year that was like, all right, this is the time, got to do this.
Speaker 7You know.
Speaker 3The easiest answer to that is the was just a genuine response to the new United States administration, I mean honestly, and a lot of people in my personal life started immediately feeling the effects and their lives were getting overturned immediately, right, And there's a lot of, of course, different forms of activism. There are a lot of different ways to participate in building a better society. And I think that I'd been chewing on that, specifically from a deconstruction point of view
Speaker 3for a long time. Okay, so you know, the way I was raised, I don't believe in it anymore. That's where all my community was. That's why I found my meaning and purpose, and I knew there were a lot of people out there who related to Okay, so what's next? Like what can we do now? And I think just the way that the essentially political landscape has been so tumultuous this year really spurred me in to Okay, we got to start building this now. We have got to find each other and start, you know, collectively organizing and
Speaker 3whatever way that looks like now. And the way in which I knew I could most effectively build some of this community is through essentially storytelling, right, and connecting and having these kinds of conversations is probably the most sixteenth way to put that.
Speaker 2But yeah, you know, it definitely makes sense. I am.
Speaker 1That makes me so interested to hear about that, because like, I've seen this trend habit more and more, and I think it's a good thing. I think it's a thing that should be going on. But you know, the atheist community has not always been seen too kindly by the world, and sometimes for good reason, not all the time. Sometimes for good reason, okay, because they can be brashed, they can you know, think their not alls and you know, maybe not always have the best taste on things.
Speaker 2But I've been seeing what I.
Speaker 1Think is a larger crop of people who are realizing what the act, this part of it is really all about, which is this overreach that comes in through you know, religious powers really violating that church state separation, something that you know, is one of the founding principles of.
Speaker 2Why the atheist Comunity of Austin exists.
Speaker 1What we talk about that is because we want to make sure that, hey, that that's absolutely separated. And now that people are really seeing the effects of that happen, maybe more so, certainly more so than ever in my lifetime.
Speaker 2Right, Like, I think.
Speaker 1There's more and more people who are like, hey, maybe like we need to react to this, and maybe we need to actually talk about this and be frank about our discussions, particularly with not just Christianity and like Christian political power, but also just Christianity itself. I think it goes both ways. Honestly, I think there's both that conversation. But yeah, so it's it's interesting that you mentioned this as this you felt like this is your time to speak because I feel like there's a lot of people who are doing the same thing right now.
Speaker 3H Yeah, well, I think you know. I always say there are really two main reasons I've been building the community I've been building. One is to connect with my version of myself ten years ago or other people who are just starting their deconstruction journey and saying, hey, you don't have to be alone. I didn't have communities like this. I wasn't online.
Speaker 2You know.
Speaker 3Finding other people is one of the reasons. And the other reason is to start building something better. Is to actually start saying, Okay, if we don't believe in a divinely mandated or a religious authority dictating what our meaning and purpose is, what does that actually look like? How can we build something? Which is something that I think even had me hold back from the label of an atheist for a long time because there is this assumption of the atheist community, that it's harder to build meaning
Speaker 3and purpose, and that's something that a lot of people, I think are kind of afraid of. I was personally until I really started digging in, of course, et cetera, et cetera. So, but it's interesting because my content, specifically, my conversations specifically do deal with politics, and as you say, like in an effort to push back against the separation of church and state. Yeah, and so I get a lot of you know, people all over the political spectrum like, why are you talking about religion and politics? And the answer is because I was raised both religiously and politically, absolutely,
Speaker 3and my upbringing they went hand in hand.
Speaker 1You know. No, I've always been because I've gotten the same complaints from people, Right, why are you talking about this because an analysis particularly of Christianity, particularly in America is incomplete, It is incomplete within our analysis of politics, they are that they're one in the same. Of course, there's you know, the old diet tribe that, oh, people have used religion to I don't know, you have power over the people and stuff, right, and like that's kind of like really basic in stuff, and I don't really
Speaker 1fall into that camp.
Speaker 2Broadly. I think there's a lot of conspiracy.
Speaker 1Folks that like kind of use that as justification for all kinds of things. But it isn't to conspiracy to say that religious authorities, again, particularly in the US, have absolutely used their institutions to make policy decisions in this country. And again it's happening more and more every day right now under the current administration. So yeah, anybody who doesn't like the politics of it, you need to get out of this conversation, because to me, that's going to be one of the most important things to talk about.
Speaker 2It's one of the reasons why I talk about it because.
Speaker 1The creator is just you know, because you know, it's like that mean because gestures vaguely at the current situation, right, It's like, yeah, that's because of what's happening. But yeah, so I'm with you full force there, Casey. You know, got to look at both things for sure.
Speaker 3Yeah, yeah, that was well said. I think that what's important to me in the conversations I'm having and the work that I'm doing, is not just focusing on not just focusing on the truth, right, the truth matters. We need a consensus, We need an academic consensus, right, we need to trust experts, et cetera. But to me, I'm very much interested in actually improving the material conditions in this reality for people, right, And so can truth lead to that? Yes, it's just very much like a first
Speaker 3step to me, and I'm here to kind of like try and take people a little bit further and myself included. Right, what does this actually look like for the inequality to be lessened?
Speaker 4Right?
Speaker 3Absolutely, So that's where I'm at with that. So that was very well said.
Speaker 2Yeah, I love it. I love it, same thing, right, But improving material.
Speaker 1Conditions is also I mean part and parcel with I mean, we could talk a lot about that.
Speaker 2There's a lot of connections to be made there.
Speaker 1But this is a call in show, so I think maybe we should talk to some callers that want to talk to us.
Speaker 2How about that?
Speaker 3I would love that?
Speaker 2Okay, great.
Speaker 1Before we get to that casey, I have to thank the patron of the week because every single week I'm always giving a shout out to the folks on Patreon who donate to the program. As a reminder, I'm a volunteer and so are most of the people that work on this show, so that money gets to the Atheist Community of Austin and tells them, Hey, Truth Wanted is a show that's really worth supporting. So thank you to everybody that donates, and in particular our patron of the week, our patrio of the Week this week is.
Speaker 2Waiting for it, waiting for it. Not on the screen yet, lauren Z. Thank you so much, lauren Z, and thank you to.
Speaker 1Everybody that donates. You guys are amazing. And with that being said, let's get to our first call. We have a theist calling us from Washington. We have Sven on the line with us.
Speaker 2Spen. You are live on Truth Wanted. What's going on?
Speaker 4Good evening, Happy Friday.
Speaker 2Happy Friday, Spen. How can we help you today?
Speaker 4All right? So, I was just kind of a wondering instagras had any involves on. I know none of you or not that you believe in the soul, but if there was one, in like a question and a theos traditional Christian point of view, they're going to say, a you soul was the creation of God, and then universals like redness, appleness, plantness, blah blah blah are also going to be just creations in the mind of God. Since God is a mind, So do you think that makes souls kind of equivalent to all other abstract concepts and
Speaker 4they like the Christian view, whereas like Plato would say, the third or the third man, or like the one exists separate from the realm of forms, because and like souls and that tradition are able to live in the material world and have access to a cor reflection of the realm of the forms, not really so much connected to the one.
Speaker 1Yeah, that's a really interesting question that I'm I'm going to be limited in my answer because I'm not a Christian anymore. So, like how can I talk about my opinion on something that I don't really have? Right, I can tell you what I thought of growing up. I think growing up there was sort of an immaterial idea. I don't know like where the idea comes from as far as like who, well, I don't know if like Thomas Aquinas was writing about this or what. But basically, you know that there is a soul that's separate from the body, right, and like that soul is, you know,
Speaker 1is the thing that gets to go to heaven and live on echartlie and stuff, or go to hell, you know, depending on what I do in life and stuff, right, and so like that's sort of separate from the mind, but also maybe is a part of the mind. To be honest, it's always been kind of vague. I don't know if it's ever really been made super clear to the same thing with like the Holy Spirit. Like I don't know if the Spirit is like possessing me in that sense or just inspiring me. It's really kind of hard to say. I think the soul has always been kind of a vague idea, to be honest with you, I don't know what the common Christian consensus would be
Speaker 1on that. I don't know, Casey, this was kind of a tough question.
Speaker 2What do you think?
Speaker 3That is a tough question as far as like the am I understanding correctly?
Speaker 1Sorry?
Speaker 3I think I kind of broke up some of the audio there that the question is about the relationship between the mind and the soul, like the Christian idea of a soul. Is that kind of where we're at? Okay?
Speaker 4So I was actually from God's mind like everything else? Is it kind of equivalent then, like a classical sensation of a soul, whereas God isn't a mind, It's just an entity that exists on the opposite side of the realm of the forms and souls are separate in so I feel like it kind of limits the value of a soul from a class or a traditional Christian point of view.
Speaker 3Yeah, so I guess I kind of have two perspectives here. One is what I was taught about the soul, again not specifically in relation to what you're talking about with Plato's forms, but actually with Aristotle, who in my Bible class we talked about a little bit and his idea of how humans being like in my in my teachings, are the third most evolved beings on this planet, from plants who are essentially like one dimensional to animals who have the physical body or the physical form as well
Speaker 3as the mental cognition of emotions and you know, social dynamics, et cetera. And then humans have this third entity internally called the soul. So I don't even know that almost feels like it's almost evolution kind of teaching now that I'm looking back at it, But that's what I was taught. And then another just thing that I'll kind of remember here for us is how when I was going through kind of my decade of coming to terms with what I thought about souls and God in the universe, et cetera.
Speaker 3Was just kind of wondering to myself how useful some of my beliefs might be, how actually beneficial it is for me to believe in the concept of a soul, even in relation to divinity itself. One thing that really helped me and brought me a little bit comfort of comfort was this idea of every person being just an iteration of the universe contained in a single body. And in that sense, I think it's what a lot of people might call a soul. And so, but that, you know,
Speaker 3my understanding of that evolved too. I don't know if that really helps. As far as your answer, I'm not sure I'm educated enough super unlike Plato's forms, I know what you're talking about. But yeah, did that did that ring? Did that ring true for anyone? I don't know.
Speaker 4It certainly did. Both you and Dan mentioned. Dan mentioned Aquinas, and I'll see you mentioned Aristotle. And that's kind of the problem with finding these kind of debates is it has been ran by Aristotelian since Platinus and Aquinas for over.
Speaker 2Two thousand years.
Speaker 4So I appreciate the insights I mean, do you understand it's a limited conversation. What do we have a five or ten minutes to have ask a question about the pope? Or it's not bore the audience too much?
Speaker 1Maybe yeah, what depends on the question, what do you got worries?
Speaker 4I just noticed some people saying, like the last pope when he told the child that his father didn't necessarily go to or he could have gone to heaven even though he didn't believe in Christ, and so that was like saying the way Jesus may not be the only way to heaven. And some people are saying, like in his passing, that that's a bare minimum. But I I kind of feel like infernalism or the concept of hell is why a lot of people have religious trauma. So I don't know if like in a world run by Christianity and that's kind of what would you agree that it is kind of a big deal to kind of
Speaker 4let go of like this infernalist mindset and to accept the other people or all people could go to heaven or do you think that's a bare minimum unfortunately that we're having to give.
Speaker 1People well from an atheist perspective, yes, I mean absolutely, I mean religious trauma. There is a mistake that Christians make that all atheists relieve religion because of religious trauma. And the truth is there's plenty of Christians that have religious trauma too, right, Like, you don't have to be an atheist to have religious trauma in that sense. And yeah, that the fear of Hell is definitely one of those things.
Speaker 2Now, of course, you.
Speaker 1Know, I won't go into the whole thing about why that concept of hell is problematic, but the short of it is, there's a lot of and I'm sure you're aware of this spend, but for our audience, there's a lot of sort of later additions to this idea of how that may or may not probably have not existed at the beginning of Christianity, that sort of, you know, make up our current understandings of it, part of it being like what our eternal life after is even supposed to be, right, even our concept of that is kind of flawed at least, you know, it was when I was a Christian and it is for many Christians. So yes,
Speaker 1do I think it should be getting gotten rid of. Absolutely? You know, I don't want it to affect anybody, right, I had dreams about going to hell, and certainly thought my eternal soul was up for damnation as soon as I blasphemed, which in some circles is considered the unforgivable sin, right, even just talking against.
Speaker 2The Holy Spirit.
Speaker 1So yeah, I'm definitely against the idea. I don't think it's a good one. I imagine Casey you feel the same way. I'd be surprised if you didn't.
Speaker 3But you know, yeah, no, I certainly concur surprise.
Speaker 4No.
Speaker 3I Hell is a really really difficult one because I love the Shakespeare quote not to you know whatever, but Hell is empty and all the devils are here, right And to me, what that speaks to is the fact that there is plenty of suffering in the here and now on this planet, in this reality that I think is so difficult to come to terms with. That's why we have a lot of these conversations about if there is a benevolent God, why does this god allow suffering to exist? It's that's that's a very real starting point
Speaker 3for a lot of these kinds of conversations. And what I what I understand, what I have empathy for, is the desire to believe in a perfectly blissful afterlife because of all of the suffering in the here and now on this planet. Life is hard, so we all go through our own version of suffering, and I understand the comfort or the blanket, you know, the comfort of believing in a better afterlife. Unfortunately that again, uh, I know
Speaker 3a little bit about what you're talking about, Dan, with the idea of hell being added later, right at least biblically, you know, as far as like referencing.
Speaker 1Certain pagan sources right among other things.
Speaker 3Right, yeah, yeah, So that's just what like my perspective on it is like I really understand the draw for wanting a have to go to a heaven after this, and then how that evolved into this concept of a oh well, if there's this perfect place, then maybe there needs to be this terrible place. And now it's turned into this almost like mechanism to really make it even difficult for anyone to question the belief system that believes in a hell, because I get you know, I get
Speaker 3Pascal's wager. I do, I really get it. So it's just but my thing is like, there's so much in the here and like we have enough suffering, like we do. I'd i'd like I like to focus on on on easing the suffering of people here and now, whether or not there is an afterlife, you know at the end of the day. But so so to answer the question is like, yeah, I think perpetuating the idea of infernalism and hell is not serving the greater good in any stretch of the imagination.
Speaker 1So here goes Spen. That that answer your question. I think that one was definitely more definitive from us.
Speaker 4Yeah, you know, big agree is across the board. Thank you guys so much.
Speaker 2Thank you Spen.
Speaker 1You have a great rest of your weekend, and hope you had a good time talking to us.
Speaker 2Great couple questions there, very intellectual questions.
Speaker 1Yeah, I bet that's interesting tough with us there, Yeah, but uh yeah, I don't know, it's it's it's kind of interesting, like what's my thoughts about the correct opinion of a soul or the correct concept of a soul?
Speaker 2But I don't really think it's correct at all. It's kind of hay to say.
Speaker 3Yeah, I haven't thought about a soul in a long time. That was a nice intellectual challenge to remember what I think about them.
Speaker 1There was this professor I didn't go to Baylor, but I went. I hung out at Baylor because it was in Waco, Texas, where I'm from. And there was this professor that taught engineering and he was showing this.
Speaker 2The song lyrics that were created by AI.
Speaker 1Right, and this is twenty fifteen, so this was the chat GPT and stuff, you know, because they were doing there was projects out there, but they weren't really publicly available and stuff, right, And he was making fun of it. He was saying, look how terrible this is. This isn't great. You see the machines they can't capture the human soul. I thought that was really interesting because it was kind of bullshit. It was like, hey, listen, this machine that you're talking about right now that made this like didn't exist a few years ago, and what's going to happen in the extra years and now, like what ten years more more later, we're getting even closer and closer to like,
Speaker 1you know, these crazy things they are. Obviously it's taking from human results, right, I'm not disputing that, but I don't know, it muddles the idea of a soul a little bit. You know, Like if I lead this soul, I really have to wonder what the current trends in AI and stuff are doing to that.
Speaker 2I don't know. That was just my thought because we had that.
Speaker 3That's an interesting point as far as and I've thought about that too, as far as the relation to AI's capability. It's so easy to want to deny, deny, deny that AI could ever be as alive as a human, right, Like, that's just our instinct to say no, no, no, humans are special or life is special at the very least. Right, that kind of evolved naturally in this universe. But that's an interesting take, Like I hadn't thought about it in relation to a soul.
Speaker 1Yeah, well, you know, because that's the thing, right, how do we what makes humans human? That's kind of been the debate forever, right, And like we keep getting diminishing returns on the definitions we've.
Speaker 2Had for a long time. Well so I think, So, I don't know.
Speaker 1Before we get to another caller here, I have to do a quick announcement for you guys.
Speaker 2One thing is, of course superchance.
Speaker 1We are reading super Chance if you got them for us, haven't gotten any yet this stream, but if we do get them, we will read them live on the air as long as they are YouTube appropriate of course, and well, so I want to let you guys know if you want to help support the show.
Speaker 2I haven't talked about this.
Speaker 1In a few weeks, but hey, we do have flyers, so as long as you can post them in an area where you have permission to do so, like a community bulletin board or etc. You want more people to call in and you want to help us out, you absolutely can. We have printibal call in flyers that you can give to people, of course, with.
Speaker 2Whatever community's position permission you need with that.
Speaker 1If you have any inquiries into the show, Truth at Atheist Hyphancommunity dot org is the email, or you can reach out at TV at Atheist Hipeancommunity dot org and see what's going on on our website at Atheist Hyphencommunity dot org.
Speaker 2Big surprise there, I know.
Speaker 1Last, but not least, before we move on, I need to thank the wonderful, amazing, spectacular crew that helped make the show happen every single week and are hard at work making sure our audio and stuff works before every show and have to listen to us ramble on every week at least me and somehow don't get tired of it and just helped make the show happen, and edit and post and call screed and do all the things that helped make the show happen. So thank you crew for doing what you do. And on that note, let's move on to our next caller. We got Bob from Mississippi.
Speaker 2Wanted to talk to us. Bob, you are live untruth, wanted what's up?
Speaker 7And thank you so much for having me on the show. Also, I will echo a big thanks to the crew and the call screeners, etc. That's all part of activism and creating a community. So thank thanks to those folks for doing all that they do.
Speaker 2Hell yeah, hell yeah, Bob, what you got for us?
Speaker 7Okay, so the prom for next week is a bad way to tell someone they're wrong? I guess maybe think my call here, what's a good way to tell someone they're wrong? And kind of throwing throw it into that. And also Brandolini's law which you mentioned last week, and we'll eventually define that and talk about that.
Speaker 2Brat Yeah for sure.
Speaker 1So Brandonaliney's law is something I mentioned last week because we're talking about we were talking about what we were talking about in context, it was we were just talking about I think basic bullshit.
Speaker 2I don't think there was a specific thing, but it's.
Speaker 1The amount of energy needed to refute bullshit is in order of magnitude, bigger than needed to produce it.
Speaker 2Okay, that's friendly.
Speaker 1As we're reaching a disinformation age, right, every other TikTok you come across, if you're in the political tiktoks, they all have just a minute worth of crap that you can't respond to without making like an hour long response video. And it just becomes too much to respond to. And that's kind of the age that we're living in. And so we're encountering people every day that are wrong about things.
Speaker 2How do we deal with that?
Speaker 1Going back to basics here, I have my own ideas about it. But you know, Casey, why don't you start this conversation off what do you think?
Speaker 3I love this question, Bob. I love that you flipped that question because it's a great one, and it's one that I've actually seen circulating a lot right now. Is how can we change minds in a way that's actually productive and effective that doesn't and this is key, that doesn't perpetuate the harm of what it's like to evangelize or proselytize. Right, and one of the takes that I have seen that I resonate with the most is this
Speaker 3idea of there's a few different ways to label it, but it's called heart centered or empathy first, or maybe more easily said as finding starting with common ground, right, starting with the similarities between yourself and this person who needs to be told that they're wrong in some form.
Speaker 2Right.
Speaker 3I think that it's really easy to start with picking apart the logic of something that is illogical. It's really easy to start there because once you have done that cognitive process yourself, once you have done that work, it's so easy to be like, no, man, that's bullshit, what are you talking about? And starting there is going to immediately because we're humans and we don't want to feel like we're wrong. We want to be accepted. We're social creatures. We're going to put up a wall right immediately, emotionally
Speaker 3in a sense almost, and we're not going to be as open to what the logic quote says or what it's saying. And so this idea of starting with the commonality is something that I have found really powerful, and on my channel, we've reacted to some videos of people having conversations with someone who has a completely different perspective on these very real, very difficult subjects, and starting with the hey, what is what do you care about? What is your value? What is important to you? And what
Speaker 3we find when we start with those heart centered or more empathetic questions first is similarities like, well, I want people to feel free, I want people to feel safe, I want people to X, Y, and z, and starting from there and then working to okay, so what does that look like practically in your life? What does it mean for someone to be free? What does it mean for someone to feel safe or protected or have equal access to opportunity? What does that look like? And then when you start to run into the tension between the
Speaker 3differences of how maybe they are consuming information that goes against what you think is more logical or what is correct or right, that's when you can start to make some real progress. But in my perspective and what I've seen some of these other creators and some really good writers that I read their newsletters, starting with that commonality starts the solidarity of hey, let's remember that we're both human, and if we can actually come to a consensus here and now, maybe we can actually make progress for everyone,
Speaker 3not just you and not just me. So that's kind of where I've been looking into this a lot. I've been very interested in how to tell someone they're wrong, the good way to tell someone that they're wrong. So that's a great question.
Speaker 2Yeah, you know, this is go ahead, Bob.
Speaker 7I think the examination of the move is important because the case that I was that I'm referring to, or what triggered this, was a woman who posted a Bob Dylan quote that essentially was a tribute to the passing of Pope Francis. And I'm not going to go into the story of chasing it down, but I understand the motivation for why the Facebook friend of mine posted this because Bob Dylan is a hero of hers, and so it's the Pope Francis, and so for it's like chocolate and peanut butter. She was motivated to post this on her wall because she thought that a hero of hers was saying nice things about another hero of hers. And
Speaker 7I'm sure that she would love that to be the reality. You know, perhaps she would prefer to live in a world where Pope where Bob Dylan is saying nice things about Pope Francis. Someone jumped in immediately when when she posted this and said, I don't believe you. Yeah, you know, that's one choice, and I kind of waited. I was observing, and then she actually provided a source if she did her due diligence. She said, no, I found the quote.
Speaker 2It was.
Speaker 7It was in this story. She posted the length of the story, and I want to entering the conversation is kind of chasing it down, you know. Actually I wrote to the person who wrote the story, said hey, where'd you get that Bob Dylan quote? And kind of chased it down that way. And at that point then my friend removed the thing from a wall, and that's in my mind, I'm sort of ashamed because I was trying to model the process as far as how can we actually figure out what is actually the reality here? You claim that Bob Dylan said this. This other person jumped in and said he didn't. I want to know what the truth is, and I think a lot of them do.
Speaker 7But I'm not convinced that everybody prioritizes reality. Some people, I think, would prefer to live in a world where Bob Dylan is saying nice things about the pope, and yeah, that's becomes a really tough thing because then how do you you can agree in reality? Then how can you have a conversation not just reality?
Speaker 2Bob? You know?
Speaker 1So, I think people prioritize their social connections with other people than they do through some time too. And what I mean by that too is sometimes people just don't want to rock the boat with.
Speaker 2The people that they love and care about. Too.
Speaker 1It's rude to tell somebody on their Facebook, hey, you're wrong for posting this, this is bad information. Right, You're right, right, You're absolutely right, and they shouldn't be posting misinformation or misattributes.
Speaker 2But to a lot of people that's considered rue. There's a social cost.
Speaker 1To that, and some people don't even want to explore just because of that. I think, I like, you know, it's it's really hard, what a tough thing because I gotten to the point where I'm at in my life because of a lifelong education, you know, and trying and prioritizing this, and to get to somebody to expect them to be where I'm at and after a single conversation with them, that's that would be hubris on my part. I can't do that. Nobody can do that. So we have to start with the little things. I actually think what you're talking about here is a great example, because that's such a small thing to examine how people get
Speaker 1to their claims. How do people understand knowledge? You know, not everybody understands claims through a scientific lens. Science is not always a means by which people say that they know things, and maybe say that they know things because they have personal experience it's on something, or maybe they've had deeply religious experiences that inform themselves right, something that's outside of these sorts of view. I think understanding how people consume and get their truth really matters.
Speaker 2Maybe they get their it's truth from Fox News.
Speaker 1They watch Fox News every day and that's something that they value as a source of true information. You know, I guess I'm sort of rambling here, but the point is, you know, we all live in these media ecosystems that can support us in any kind of lie that we want to live in. It's getting harder and harder. But I think little things like that where you can sort of examine a claim together and say, hey, that's interesting, where did you get this information? How did you know that this was true? What source did you get this from starting a conversation. From there, it's actually a really
Speaker 1good gateway into a larger conversation because that's something with fairly minor stakes, right.
Speaker 2Like Bob Dowlan and the Pope quote.
Speaker 1That's not going to end n one's life, you know what I mean, That's not going to like, you know, irreparable harm, right, But misinformation about COVID or other kinds of things maybe could, right.
Speaker 2So yeah, there's something to that, Bob.
Speaker 3Yeah, I really liked the idea.
Speaker 7I say, I will tease if anybody's planning on going to Danacon, I'll be doing a work shop there in July called working with Interface Partners. And this is an ongoing question. I don't necessarily have a lot of answers here, but I would love to hear more people's opinions as far as how do you continue conversations about what is real, especially when your work, when you're trying to talk to somebody who is approaching reality with a different perspective.
Speaker 2Yeah.
Speaker 1Well, you know, when I was in college and I had that conversation with Anthony Magnebosco that I was telling you about, I didn't know how I figured out whether things were true I didn't read the news at the time.
Speaker 2I wasn't like as informed about the world.
Speaker 1I just kind of had my own channels of communication with the world and with people that I relied on, and I didn't have anybody asked me those questions to examine myself in that way. Nobody had really asked me those kinds of things before. It's it's not really typically encouraged in church. Environment's funny. Funnily enough, I don't know why you would wonder why.
Speaker 7So it's like, I think it's actually it's a very it's a very human and compassionate thing to do.
Speaker 2Yeah.
Speaker 7Absolutely, you answer to your question because you know, again, I prioritize I value knowing reality, and I want to hear that that same passion for knowing reality with other people and in my mind, quite obviously asking of questions that really can help someone find their way.
Speaker 1Yeah, I think maybe maybe it comes from a place of motivation, maybe because you mentioned we don't want to be evangelists, right, maybe it's less about us trying to get the other person to come to our conclusion and more about giving people the tools and the freedom to examine their own claims themselves.
Speaker 2Because it's a very liberating thing. I personally see atheism as.
Speaker 1A liberating thing really honestly for me as a former Christian, because and now I'm in a place where I can question a lot of stuff without the hassle of people judging me or people giving me all kinds of crap. I mean, there's a lot of left the folks that will judge people too, Don't get me wrong, that's definitely a thing too. But the point is that the freedom of discussion is still there that I didn't have before. And I think, like, honestly, people just don't always have these tools to examine that. So maybe it's just about just asking those gentle questions at first so people can
Speaker 1help maybe realize where there stuff's coming from. Because you know, a lifetime of misinformation. It's going to take a long time than just a single conversation, But every journey starts with a single step, right, So I don't know. I think that's all I can say on the topic.
Speaker 2Casey, you have any other thoughts.
Speaker 3I really like the idea of examining the motivations of people's actions. I think, you know, we as atheists it can be so we love our objective reality. We love our rationalism, we love being the realist, you know, right, But to approach some of these conversations without understanding these subjective experiences of these people and why why their subjective experience is shaping their understanding of objective reality, It's like
Speaker 3we're missing half of the conversation, right, And so I think that's a really interesting perspective to kind of like move forward with. And I kind of like that you started again, as Dan was saying, like on a small scale, like, hey, how can we kind of you know, come together on a maybe more less of a misinformation and more of an accurate quoting of the you know, Bob, Dylan, Pope, whatever. So that's really interesting.
Speaker 1Yeah, great conversation, Bob. Any final thoughts before I let you go.
Speaker 7Non No, thank you so much for taking my call. I appreciate it, And it said Nantacon and leads to the.
Speaker 1Line alrighty, Bob, thanks so much for being on this call with us and giving us a great topic for conversation. I hope you have a great rest of your weekend and go join Bob at nanocon.
Speaker 2I guess if you want to do that. Great. Yeah, it's one of my favorite.
Speaker 1Questions because I think I give a slightly different answer every time, you know, because we just think about it more. I have a little bit more experience, a little more conversations with folks.
Speaker 2But what you said at the end there was beautiful.
Speaker 1I think you really do have to examine people's subjective experiences first and foremost, because no matter how wrong somebody is, there's still a person experiencing things and still think at least you know, they have their own reasons for thinking why something is true or not true.
Speaker 2You have to start with that. Otherwise, how can they go anywhere? Right?
Speaker 1If there are a million miles away from you, You got to make that bridge somewhere. Otherwise you just got to keep you know, floating apart in our information spheres, which is what's happening.
Speaker 2Yeah, yeah, what's going to continue to happen? I think. But I know, what'd you think of that?
Speaker 3That was a great question. You you've certainly probably had more experience examining this question over the years. It's something that I'm kind of new to exploring. But the last thing I wonder is like the purpose of telling someone they're wrong, Like I would want to examine internally, why am I trying to change this person's mind. Is it to validate my own understanding, my own rationale or again it goes back to like, are we trying to improve quality of life whatever for everyone? You know, just by generally combating misinformation like Bob was talking about. So that's
Speaker 3something I'd be checking myself on.
Speaker 1Yeah, I'm glad that about that, because I think something we all have to check ourselves on. I kind of I've used this analogy a lot, and I'll wrap it up here. I think that these conversations when talking to people are kind of like therapy, because when you go to a therapist, they're not going to fix all your problems in one counseling session, right, It's.
Speaker 2Going to take some self reflection, it's good, take some stuff. A therapist is there to.
Speaker 1Help give you the tools so that you can do the work yourself away from that hour, right, And maybe that's what we have to do as activists, I think, is when you do get to have that opportunity to speak with somebody, that you just give somebody the right tools and the right perspective to kind of look at things a different way, and it's up to them to do at work lead a horse and water can't make him drink it?
Speaker 7Right?
Speaker 2But there it is great stuff. I love it. Let's goalk to some more people. We have.
Speaker 1Billy Pilgrim calling us from Texas. Billy Pilgrim, you are alive on truth wanted. How can we help you?
Speaker 8Hey, Hey, Casey, Hey Dan?
Speaker 2How are you guys doing great? Billy? How about you?
Speaker 8Very well? And happy National Gecko Appreciation Day?
Speaker 2Wow? Is it that time? That time? Already? I didn't get a gift for my local gecko. I need to think about that.
Speaker 8Wow, anyway made up just that we have, that's totally made up. There's just so many of those silly things we have. Now you you bought it. You bought it right.
Speaker 1I bought a Billy to absolutely convinced me that that was the thing. I was like, Man, I was so busy buying a card from my mother for Mother's Day. I didn't think about Gecko Day. I mean, gosh, how I consider it? But you know, but you know.
Speaker 8You could have glued a dead gecko to the card.
Speaker 4Well.
Speaker 1See, now you're a faucet of misinformation, Bill, So I don't know.
Speaker 2We might have to we might have to censor you. I think is what's happening. I'm just kidding. So what do you want to talk to see today?
Speaker 8Well, I first wanted to say Casey Malone is that is a great name for an Australian outlaw folk hero.
Speaker 2Macey Malone, Casey Malone. I like it, Thank you.
Speaker 8See I can see her on horseback robbing banks truly. Yeah, I'll get right to it. Boy, Bob just stole your last call, which was fantastic, just stole many of my talking points about how when people want to believe things, it's pretty much fucking impossible to convince them otherwise.
Speaker 2M Yeah, yeah, I think so. But uh yeah, go ahead, I won't I want to interrupt you.
Speaker 8Here, Billy, Well, yeah, I'll be brief. Roswell. The Roswell quote incident is the move thoroughly investigated and thoroughly explained in the bone of all the UFO stuff. We've got the crystal skull, you know, the skull, which is thoroughly debunked and thoroughly explained. But yet the more you provide actual information, the more you become part of the conspiracy to cover it.
Speaker 2Yeah, it's true, it's true.
Speaker 1I think it's an investment people make into these ideas, right, Like, it's harder to say I don't want to do anything with this anymore. You know, there's a lot of people who have a very unhealthy relationship with their church because they maybe want to leave, but they don't have a good way out because maybe all their friends and family go there, or maybe they don't know really what an atheist is, or don't really have a concept of what it means to live a good life outside of a Christian one, And it can really trap.
Speaker 2Us some of these ideas. I think part of it is just the pathways.
Speaker 1Like, you know, you get worried or scared that all this time you've invested to this idea makes you look like a fool too.
Speaker 2You know.
Speaker 8Well, community is certainly a huge part of the audistic community. And I'm the I'm the atheist jerk asshole who rejoined his church of origin because I thought they needed an atheist s up there. And I'm the guy who points out that the part of the part of Mark that talks about picking up serpents and drinking poison that was added much later. I'm the guy who points out that we don't know who wrote the Gospels, and most of my well not all, but most of my objections and
Speaker 8comments provoke thoughts. They provoked question, how.
Speaker 2Did that work for you? Get any converts?
Speaker 8That's not my No, no, no, no, And I wouldn't. I'm not up there to do that. This is my church of origin. And this is a very liberal, progressive church. Okay, we're all GBT positive. We're not scriptural in errants. Is that a word? No, this a This is a Disciples of Christ. We're very moderate, vanilla public service kind of church. And I think what is a better place for a local atheist to be put in the progressive church? And I've caught a lot of ship from that from other atheists.
Speaker 2Yeah, I don't know. You mayn't ship from me, Billy.
Speaker 1Not to say that you don't have a right to go or do as you please, But like, I don't know if I want to support churches as an institution period, right, even the most liberal ones, I just don't think that they need to be around, not just because they don't think they're for me. But even the most progressive church spaces can still harbor assholes. I mean they really can, right, And And I don't know your.
Speaker 2Church, I don't know your community.
Speaker 1I don't know your people, but I would rather give place people or encourage people to conform in more secular ways than a church way. To be honest, I just don't think, well, I don't think you need it, but churches, you know, they have all kinds of problems, and I don't know if it's a it's an institution we really need.
Speaker 2But I don't know. That's just my opinion.
Speaker 3What do you think, Casey, Yeah, that's that's true. Going back to what we were kind of talking about earlier about how community is such a big part of why people stay in religious environments. Like, I totally understand that draw, especially for people who have children in their families, right, Like, I totally understand that draw, But I kind of do agree with Dan, just on the premise of giving power to the institution, right, the idea of continually perpetuating this
Speaker 3system that I think more than even just the idea of it being inherently evil. You know, if evil is such a thing or not, is at the very least at the end of its life cycle of being healthy and viable for the human species on our path of evolution. Right, So I do push back against the institution as a whole, I do try to always clarify about not pushing, you know, villainizing everyday Christians, et cetera. Because one thing that I try to remind myself of is how as far as
Speaker 3where truth seeking goes, kind of going to what you were started at the beginning of your call, Billy, was the idea of truth seeking in general. I have to remind myself that in a lot of ways it is kind of a privilege. It is there are there is research that shows that the largest demographic of like atheists in the United States at least are white men, and there's a lot to that, but I think in large part number one, it's almost kind of validating to like look at it this way. But I think in large part,
Speaker 3when you're not as worried about putting the food on the table, you have time and mental bandwidth to be a truth seeker, to question the powers that be and the belief systems were taught, et cetera. And so in a way like I do, like I commend you for your work and like going out there and asking the hard questions and encouraging free thought. I totally you know, commend that, but I do remind myself, Like I, it is a privilege to be an atheist and to, as Dan was saying earlier, enjoy the liberation that comes along with that and encouraging that amongst the species. I love
Speaker 3that absolutely vibes immaculate, and it's just something that I try to be mindful of when I'm looking at people. You know, maybe they have four kids, they've worken two jobs, Like I understand why the information they're getting that their algorithms are feeding them more and more conspiracy related content. You know, I understand why maybe they're not taking the time to check sources and fact check, et cetera. And it's it's hard to kind of square that. I don't
Speaker 3think it's an easy thing to approach, but you know, I do commend you for bringing it up. It is something that I try to remember.
Speaker 2What are your thoughts on that, Billy Well?
Speaker 8I appreciate Casey's opinion, but she didn't address the fact that an atheist in a progressive church is a good positioning. I'm tearing it down from within.
Speaker 3I get that. I get that, and you know what, you know what, I relate to that as a woman because as women have moved through a man's world, we have more experience, I think, aligning with power that maybe we don't want to align with in order to do our best. So I totally relate. I'm not sure. I'm not sure if I like the idea of giving power to those spaces anymore. To be completely honest, it's something that I think a lot of us are working through though, So I understand. I do recognize what you're saying, Like I understand the concept. I just I'm kind of like
Speaker 3no contact with the Christian Church, I guess you could say, personally speaking.
Speaker 1So yeah, I'm actually I think you've made a great point, Billy, because I'm of two minds of this now, because on the one hand, we just talked about how it's hard to leave because you don't have a bridge, and you could be a bridge for somebody, right.
Speaker 2You absolutely could. That's very viable.
Speaker 1On the other hand, I'm also listening to Casey's point about how my atheism is a privilege, and I one hundred percent agree with her on that because I went to call college and I had and I and I got an education, and I went to a back I you know, got to study and have a background and all kinds of learning and got to have that time to develop and look at myself in a way because I wasn't working all the time, and I wasn't trying to provide for my own family. I wasn't trying to just make men's meet and do all these things. So I think there's like.
Speaker 2It kind of it's a hard balance, isn't it. How do you do that? I don't know.
Speaker 1On the one hand, I commend you for sticking to your principles and wanted to tear down stuff from within. I get that, But I wonder, you know, as a representation of our community, is it gonna be? Is it going to look the best that were in other people's spaces doing that? I mean, like if a Christian was at the Atheist community of Austin every week because they wanted to convert me to Christianity, how would I feel about that?
Speaker 2I don't know.
Speaker 1I mean, I guess I would appreciate the conversation, but at some point I kind of know what they're about and it kind of makes me tune out a little bit. Right, So, like I wonder if peop would feel the same way if I was doing that at a church environment, right, I don't know.
Speaker 2What do you think, Billy.
Speaker 8A couple of things. First of all, I'm not in their face at all. This is my church of origin. At three reasons. I went back there a couple of years ago. I told them, all of them up front, I'm an atheist, I'm a secularist, I'm a skeptic. Tell me not to come. If you don't want me to come, I won't come. This is my church of origin. That's number one. It's community. I'm in a town of ten thousand people. I've known some of these families all my life.
Speaker 2Okay.
Speaker 8For two, our church is wonderful at doing community good. We distributed food, clothing, we painted houses last weekend. Number three, I was a religion major, so I know more about the Bible and other religionship than practically anybody up there. So it's an opportunity to both learn and to teach. So I can't find a better place for myself. I've looked at other secular outlets. Didn't work for me. This is the best place for me.
Speaker 1Yeah, I hear you saying, you know it's a place for you to learn, But what do you learning?
Speaker 2What are you getting from that?
Speaker 4Oh?
Speaker 8Plenty.
Speaker 7I haven't.
Speaker 8I haven't got to talk serious religion with people in years and years. I'm learning My pastor is a bright divinity student. He knows a lot about religion.
Speaker 1Okay, so you are actually you're getting an academic understanding of religion, and that's something that you're getting from that.
Speaker 8I'm getting an academically enhanced understanding. We talk, we talk about you know, how often do you talk to sit down and talk to people about scripture who believe it.
Speaker 1Well, I mean almost every week sometimes, but I'm kind of the exception.
Speaker 2I don't know if I'm the best person to ask about that. Billy.
Speaker 3I totally see where you're coming from, Billy, And I again I commend you for like sticking to what you think is important to you. And at the end of the day, it really you are really going to be the person who knows best where your work, your time, your energy is going to matter, is going to move the new in any direction towards progress, secularism, et cetera. So in that sense, you know, hats off to you. I think that, uh, And it also makes me again think about what some of the conversations we've been having tonight. What are our intentions as far as moving that needle
Speaker 3and working towards a more reasonable, tolerant society, et cetera. If we almost like reverse villainize and do the US versus them, that's something that I honestly am trying to navigate myself. I don't I'm not saying I have an answer, but I'm trying. I feel you as far as like, well, I don't want to keep myself secluded if if the if I grew up being told to never you know, have connections with an atheist, like I don't want to continue that cycle. So I get I'm still navigating that too,
Speaker 3So I guess that's where I'm at with that.
Speaker 2Yeah, I want to.
Speaker 1More address your rebuttal fully because I think Billy you made another great point. This is this is a community that you're very familiar with and they're very familiar with you. You're not invading a space, right, yes, sort of thing. So I think that that an additional context does make the argument a bit different, right, Because when a salesman comes to your door, they want something from you.
Speaker 2You don't want anything to do with them.
Speaker 1That's why it's annoying, right, So it's like you know, I you know, it sounds like you're cultivating relationships where there's an even trade there. Right, You're getting something from the people there and they're getting something from you. And that's important to me than just hey, I'm an atheist evangelist. I'm coming here and I'm tearing it all down and this is where I've stopped. And you know you can't stop with that, like you know, like again, more you do what you want with your life. But like, I think that makes more sense knowing that, hey, this is this is people that you know and like you can you are free to have these conversations with them. I
Speaker 1would much rather people be doing that than us becoming the next door to door atheists, right going to churches and being like, hey, have you heard about this.
Speaker 2Whole believing in Jesus' thing? Right, Like, so you know there's something to that there.
Speaker 4Billy, Well, thank you, thank you.
Speaker 8For your time. The next time I call, I want to talk about the myth that theismonious Smithsonian Institute is dumping giant bones into the ocean.
Speaker 2I love that.
Speaker 1I love that. That's an awesome one. I would love to talk to you about that.
Speaker 2Billy. We can definitely do that next time you call.
Speaker 1But until that, I hope you have a great rest of your weekend, and hey, can't wait to hear from you again. Yeah, that's a fun one. I don't know if you've heard about that, but the Smithsonian is in cahoots with secret world powers denying the existence of giants, right of course.
Speaker 3Right, Yeah, I forgot about that one, but I did. I did see all of those.
Speaker 1Studies, because if the Bible is real, Casey, then giants have to be real.
Speaker 3The nephile em is that the right word.
Speaker 2Absolutely always about the nephlum. They hit him in Iraq.
Speaker 3Oh oh, I forgot.
Speaker 2Right, that's what Iraq was about.
Speaker 3Gotcha, that's crazy. That was funny a minute ago talking about the doorder door salesman. I do cringe sometimes when I whenever I'm like talking with someone who's gone through deconstruction in my personal like actual community, right, and I'll be like, they're struggling with connecting with people, they're struggling with how to rebuild their life, all of this stuff, and then I hit them with the you know, there's this art night on Mondays that I think you'd really enjoy. Everyone they're super nice, you know about us, Like I do make myself cringe sometimes, Like, but it is what
Speaker 3it is. It's part of it.
Speaker 1Yeah, my evangelizing because I was part of a sort of evangelist tradition. And the thing I regret the most is I went on a mission trip to a Native American reservation. And the trip was fine.
Speaker 2I mean, you know, we.
Speaker 1Were just high school kids or whatever, and like we helped paint stuff and do whatever. But in retrospect, I'm mortified because I basically did neo colonialism and I don't like that, you know, so like that that's kind of a bummer thinking about that.
Speaker 2Yeah, I got.
Speaker 1Atone for my sin in a way. I guess that's what the show is, penance for sure for doing that.
Speaker 3Yeah, that's a difficult one to come to terms with for sure.
Speaker 1That were you part of a tradition that you know had to you know, do that kind of stuff, do you you know, have to go door to door or anything stuff like that.
Speaker 3You know, there were mission trips in my church that I fortunately never went on, but I did. There are multiple people who I evangelized just at college, you know, and my family whatever brought them into the Christian Church. Then when I walked away later, I'm getting messages from more than one of them like, hey, I'm still this very devout Christian. What happened? Casey? Like what do you mean? You don't believe in teacht anymore? And it's so embarrassing. I feel so guilty, and I'm just like, yeah, so
Speaker 3there's that.
Speaker 1Oh man, I have a thought to that. Before I go on that thought, I just saw our mind.
Speaker 2Folks.
Speaker 1We have open lines right now. You know, we got like fifteen more minutes till the end of the show. If anybody wants to call it and and talk to us, you certainly can while the lines are open. But on that thought, you know, I think that's part of the reason why it's hard to support a church, or why church can be almost insidious in a way, is because they literally build community centers, like literally they call them community centers, And like youth group was a place for me to hang out and see all of my friends and do these things. It's like, oh, well, I want
Speaker 1to hang out this friend. Why not hang out with them at the youth group event, you know, where we go play basketball and then go worship.
Speaker 2God for a bit. That sounds like a bit, but it's that was the reality, right.
Speaker 1It was like, you know, so I want to be able to have secular alternatives to that, And how hard is it these days when everything's shut down that isn't a church, you know what I mean?
Speaker 2Where's our third places? One hundred was talking about this.
Speaker 3Yeah, yeah, look, I totally relate to the youth group thing. I don't want to docs the church I grew up in, but you might do it.
Speaker 2No, no, no.
Speaker 3We had a basketball court, We had dozens of video game consoles. It was a multi story built. Yeah, I mean, and even just the very smaller like microcosm of like you know, in elementary school getting candy if you went to church like there there is like a I agree that it's a bit sinister as far as like motivation for getting involved in some of in some of the church while young.
Speaker 1You know, while young, you haven't lived unless you stayed up till like three in the morning at a church lockdown.
Speaker 2A locked with the boys.
Speaker 1That was that was great. It was good time. But then also I don't know, it gave me stuff I had to work out.
Speaker 3Yeah, yeah, I am, I don't know.
Speaker 2It wasn't all good. I mean it was fun.
Speaker 1Then, but you know then I had anxious streams about going to Hell after deconstructing. So where did that come from? Did it come from the youth group lockdown?
Speaker 4So?
Speaker 2But maybe, I mean, I guess getting from a lifetime of conditioning. I don't know.
Speaker 1That's why it's hard, because it's like, I can't you don't know what happens to a church.
Speaker 2You don't even know what happens financially.
Speaker 1I mean, they don't even have to report all that stuff publicly, right, so it's like, yeah, you don't know who you're supporting or what. Like I'm trying to think if I have my own kid, you know, and he wanted to go to some friends youth group thing maybe for a night, I let him. I don't know, but it's like what if I want to keep going?
Speaker 3Yeah?
Speaker 2Is that right for me to do that? I don't know. I yeah, I don't know.
Speaker 3No, that's hard. I can't imagine having kids here in Tulsa where I'm at and like trying to socialize them. That's another thing that I do talk about as far as like how it's weird looking back on my personal upbringing because I went to this private school, and like, the student teacher ratio was really great. We were very safe, Our resources at the school were spot on, and in a large sense of the matter, it is a privilege to go to this school, right, and I have to
Speaker 3recognize that while also remembering the brainwashing aspect, you know, the indoctrination, And I think that it one of the benefits that I try and remind myself of is the fact that like knowing the same people going to this smaller school and then seeing them at church and seeing them at youth group, all this stuff is one thing the church gets right, is socializing children, like teaching them how to navigate social dynamics, which in so many ways because of individualization of Western society and you know, capitalism,
Speaker 3all of the things. Like loneliness is a real thing the world. I think it's like the World Health Organization called the loneliness an actual epidemic that we're dealing with. Don't quote me on that, some organization somebody.
Speaker 2I believe it.
Speaker 3I just checking, of course, of course. Yeah, so yeah, it's a real thing. And like, uh, there are a lot of atheists in my community who are kind of tuning into my stuff. Who ask about that and they're wondering, like, Okay, so how can I make friends outside of church? Yeah, and uh, I think we're all navigating that in our own ways. I don't think stand up comedies for everyone, but that was my background. That's how I, you know, met a lot of people. But interest based groups. I
Speaker 3try to tell people D and D you know, video games, running clubs, rock climbing, photography clubs. I don't know, that's kind of gardening. Yeah, meetup dot com, I think is what it is. There's there's got to be something that you might like, so I try to, you know, try to speak to that. But you're right, those community centers, they are sure are a significant draw.
Speaker 2Yeah.
Speaker 1Absolutely no, you're hitting the nail on the head here. I mean, that's what makes it so difficult. You and I are both from Southern states, so I think we probably relate to that even more as far as what our local infrastructure looks like for people to just hang out and do stuff like you know, it's not it's not uncommon for or something to be at a church, whether it's a church based event or not.
Speaker 2It's just it's part of the infrastructure, right, And.
Speaker 1It still is there's a lot of people that I think are surprised at gen Z because they thought, oh, I thought gen Z was supposed to be like absolutely not religious at all, and you know, they're probably gonna be the most secular generation in some ways, that's true. But you look at TikTok and they're like the biggest proponents of like the trad cat stuff going on, Like they're all about it because hey, that's social infrastructure that hasn't changed.
Speaker 2All that's still there.
Speaker 1You know, outside the Internet, there's a physical reality out there of where people are going to meet and have these connections, and a lot of it is through these churches and and you know online spaces too, But like you can't neglect that that physical reality as well, the material reality.
Speaker 3Yeah, no, you're you're making great points. I think the Pew Research Center kind of published some findings about how gen Z as a whole maybe the most religiously unaffiliated generation we've seen. But in large part that is the one of the biggest breaks there among that demographic that age group is women are less religiously affiliated than gen Z men, who, as you're speaking to, are buying hard
Speaker 3into a lot of the trad life, manosphere, you know, Redpill, all of that stuff. And I you know Britt Hartley, she's an atheist content creator. She talks about this a little bit too, as far as how I think women is a lot easier for us to build community because we're kind of conditioned to be horizontally emotionally connected in a lot of ways. So leaving the church, we're still going to brunch, We're still going to coffee shops with the girls. You know, in a lot of ways, the
Speaker 3infrastructure that you're talking about might not be serving young men, right, who if they don't like sports, how are they going to connect? You know what I mean? Like, Yeah, yeah, there's a lot to that that I think is really really impactful, and it's something that i'd like, I'd like to kind of focus on and or I like to focus on and try and build community and build connection and hang out with people.
Speaker 1So it's interesting you point that out because statistically there are more atheist men than there are Yeah, yeah, wow, And like there seems to be the trends that I've seen, there's always been at least a.
Speaker 2Little bit more women that are in church.
Speaker 1It's like my five percent or so they go to church than men as well, so that there's something happening there that sociologists can debate on.
Speaker 3Yeah, and I might be referring to, like specifically the split between men and gen Z men and women who have left the church, you know, like how there's like different like not just are generally religiously unaffiliated, but specifically left the church, Like what's it called switching? Religious switching?
Speaker 2Yes?
Speaker 3So so yeah, there's there's a lot to that for sure.
Speaker 1There's another Yeah, that's another problem with this, and it's all always been a problem with the atheist community, is studying the even even understanding the vocabulary that is to define religiously unaffiliated people, because even that is.
Speaker 2Kind of problematic.
Speaker 1You know, like what, how what is a pagan person's perspective? How do they turn up in national demographic surveys?
Speaker 2Right?
Speaker 1Are they going to be religiously unaffiliated? Are they going to be just another category that's meaningless?
Speaker 3Right?
Speaker 1So yeah, and then also like what people say they're agnostic, but maybe they really mean atheists to some people, or they say atheists and they really have a God belief. I've heard that too. You know, it's it's always a hard thing to study with this kind of stuff.
Speaker 2But yeah, I don't know. People are weird and you don't do so much.
Speaker 3I guess, yeah, and everyone's doing their best. But it's funny you say that because I remember seeing in that Pew research study that seven percent of atheists who were surveyed claim to believe in a god. So it's like, what are we doing with that? What's happening here?
Speaker 2I didn't make that up. People say that, isn't that weird? I don't know them. I don't know.
Speaker 1Like I guess every once in a while I get a call like that, but most people in our space who are like online talking.
Speaker 2About this, I don't know anybody. Yeah, yeah, yeah, so I don't know.
Speaker 3I don't know. Labels are weird, man, I get it.
Speaker 2Yeah, labels are weird. That's true.
Speaker 3Indeed.
Speaker 1On the note, Casey, I think now is a good time for us to talk about you and say, first of all, thank you for being.
Speaker 2On today's program. I had a great time with you.
Speaker 1I think I'm going to keep having a great time with you because you still want to you want to come.
Speaker 2To our after show here in just a second.
Speaker 3Okay, let's let's keep it going mom.
Speaker 2That's great, folks.
Speaker 1If you don't know, on the Atheist and Austin fan run Discord Server, we do an after show. We're going to be doing that in just a second, so if you're watching this live, come check us out and we'll hang out in that space and just a bit here. But before we do that, Casey, thanks again for being on the show today. If people want to find you and and find out more of your stuff, where should they go?
Speaker 7Oh?
Speaker 3All over the place. My website's kind of a nice hub. It's www dot Kcmalone dot com. The spelling's weird. You can see it right there right now, right yeah.
Speaker 1For audio listeners it is ka y se so get it right.
Speaker 3And Malone is me e. It's Casey yes m e lo ay. That's another tricky one. Just make it difficult. You gotta be difficult. But that's a good starting point. I'm on YouTube, I'm on Twitch live streaming every morning if anyone wants to further these conversations.
Speaker 2So yeah, heck yeah, heck yeah.
Speaker 1Speaking of furthering conversations, I want to know again about that prompt.
Speaker 2This week, let's bring Kelly back in.
Speaker 1Kelly, thanks so much for being our backup host today.
Speaker 2Oh you got a book? What's that? Kelly?
Speaker 1Are you muted right now? My friend, you should unmute yourself. There, Yep, yep, he's realizing he's getting it.
Speaker 6Yeah, I'm still fuzzy.
Speaker 5I had a book, and I was going to pretend like I was a front door evangelist.
Speaker 6But it's a copy. It's a copy of the Songlfish Gene. I was gonna say something like, hey, if you heard the good word Dan, you don't.
Speaker 4Have to believe anymore.
Speaker 6Kind of blew my joke being all fuzzy.
Speaker 1But if I had, if I had a nickel anyway.
Speaker 6Why didn't I be five sons richer?
Speaker 2Yeah?
Speaker 5Our pro for next week is I'm sorry, I'm just laughing too hard. What is a bad way to tell someone that they're wrong?
Speaker 2Yes, to leave your.
Speaker 5Comments in the comments below someone besides not in the chat.
Speaker 2But that's right, although Chuck is.
Speaker 6You know, Chuck, you're still wanting to put in one.
Speaker 9Yeah, absolutely, no, we appreciate check there. That's so funny to me that has never happened in this show ever, that we have all three top comments for the same person.
Speaker 2But Sneaky Chuck, they're good. Yeah, they were. They were pretty good.
Speaker 1Kelly, thanks so much for being back up today, even though you're blurry right now and there's definitely a delay going on, but you know what, we love you anyway. But we'll put you in the back and we'll see you in the discord in just a second. They skin to everybody watching today's program. Uh, it's been a great, great show. Before we go, Casey, I always like to ask my guests about words of wisdom. Do you have any words of wisdom for us before we end tonight's program.
Speaker 3I would say that as far as the wisdom across cultures and traditions goes, breathing exercises and meditation has always, uh always talked about. So you want to look at wisdom, look at look at some breathing exerts. I had to do breathing exercises at work earlier this week. Sometimes it really just helps to to center and bring us back to reality.
Speaker 2So sometimes it really just helps to breathe. I like it.
Speaker 3Yeah, that's that's what I want to end up.
Speaker 1Also, awkward time, I should have done this before. We did get a super chat earlier from Bob. I believe the same Bob we called in said pa sign emoji that was their whole message.
Speaker 2And gave two dollars. Thanks so much for that super chat Bob appreciate it. Should have read that earlier.
Speaker 1Almost forgot, but yes, folks, remember to breathe and also remember to always keep one the truth.
Speaker 2That's it. Everybody will see you next time
Speaker 1Watch the nonprofits and joined the hosts in the live chat VC tiny dot, cc slash ytn b
In today's episode of Truth Wanted, ObjectivelyDan welcomes guest Out Of Body Atheist, with The Beard of Empathy on backup, to dig into Reiki, New Age spirituality, homeopathy, and the long road from woo to skepticism!...
In today's episode of Truth Wanted, Jon the Skeptick, Volcy, and Sofia Spina explain why no one can talk to the dead, from Haitian Vodou and grief dreams to Jon's past as a spiritualist! Bob jumps from objective...
In today's episode of Truth Wanted, ObjectivelyDan and Nintendrew, later joined by The Beard of Empathy, tackle a world run on Jesus, the magic of manifesting, and a prayer that actually got answered! Bob in NY, a...
In today's episode of Truth Wanted, ObjectivelyDan, Kelley Laughlin, and The Beard of Empathy tackle standards of evidence, miracle claims, and the false binaries of moral philosophy! Dean in VA questions why skeptics...
In today's episode of Truth Wanted, ObjectivelyDan and Chad Harris tackle Christian nationalism, police brutality, and the uncomfortable truths about racism and immigration. Big E in TN survived police brutality and...