Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Truth Wanted

Truth Wanted artwork

Truth Wanted 9.31 with ObjectivelyDan and Richard Gilliver

Aug 3, 20261 hr 28 minAudio
  • Apple Podcasts
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

In today's episode of Truth Wanted, ObjectivelyDan, Richard Gilliver, and Kelley Laughlin examine miracles, dreams, and the psychology behind seemingly supernatural experiences. Jacob in ID calls to express his gratitude for the show, explaining how it serves as his secular community after seven years of listening. Living in a rural area without much access to other atheists, he finds connection through the ACA shows. The hosts thank him for his support and encourage him to keep engaging with the community. Katie in VA shares her experiences with precognitive and visitation dreams, keeping a detailed dream journal of coincidental events. She describes dreams about deceased people and specific details that later seemed to come true. The hosts discuss Littlewood's Law, which explains how seemingly miraculous coincidences are statistically inevitable given enough opportunities. They explore the Texas Sharpshooter Fallacy, where people draw targets around bullet holes after the fact, and how memory can be unreliable. What psychological mechanisms might explain these experiences without invoking the supernatural? The conversation touches on how the Catholic Church evaluates miracles, mass hallucinations like Fatima, and the misinformation effect in eyewitness testimony. How do we distinguish between genuine precognition and pattern-seeking brains finding connections that aren't really there? Thank you for joining us this week! We will see you next time! Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/truth-wanted--3195473/support.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Speaker 1Hey, folks, I just want to say that every single miracle that's ever been claimed probably has a simpler explanation, whether it's coincidence or misremembering, or confirmation bias, or just you know, medicine doing its job. The miraculous really has a way of shrinking the closer you look. So if you have a miracle that can't be explained naturally, then call in and show you work. Because the show is starting right now. Hello, Hello, everybody, Welcome back to another

Speaker 1episode of Truth Wanted Baby. I am your host, Objectively Dan and this is the live call in show that happens every single week at our new time Sundays at two forty five pm Central. We talk to people about what they believe and why they believe it. And if you want to call us, you should do it the numbers five one two nine nine one nine two four to two, or you can call it your computer at ACA dot show slash call Now. As always, Truth Wanted is a product of the the Community of Austin, a five o' one c three nonprofit organization dedicates the promotion

Speaker 1of atheism, critical thinking, secular humanism, and the separation of religion and government and folks, we are try streaming today, So a big shout out to our viewers on TikTok and YouTube mobile. If you are watching us on TikTok today and you'd like to call us the request to join and we'll bring you up on stage, and please make sure you are over the age of eighteen before doing so. And of course, every week on Truth one we always have a guest. This week's different. We have Richard Jilliver joining us today. Richard, what's up? What's up?

Speaker 2Richard?

Speaker 3Hello, I'm very excited to be here because of the New Times the you broadcast.

Speaker 2I am actually able to be here, that's right.

Speaker 1I mean, how long do I get to say it's a new time, because it's been the New Time for about a month or two now, and we still we keep saying it's the new time, and I'm like, at some point it's not going to be the new time, right, But how do we I don't know. I don't know when we transition that. Maybe after today we'll see it. Anyway, I'm here with Richard. Richard, you have been on the show before, but it's been a while. It's been how long has it been, Richard? At least that's your two.

Speaker 2Two years Minion since I've lost on here.

Speaker 3I love Truth Wanted, as with all the ACA shows, watch every episode of every show, but I particularly like Truth Wanted because it takes us out of that normal kind of theistic question things and introduces a lot more stuff.

Speaker 2One of the reasons, I don't know if you remember Dan.

Speaker 3The very very very first time I was on Truth Wanted. The reason I was put forward for the show by I think it was the old volunteer Coordinates Angel who first put me forward for the show. It was because I was actually for quite a while a Residents skeptic in a gholstunning group. So I've been out and actually done the stuff, done the work, and you know, been there when people think they've been witnessing things in debunk things. I was literally told to leave a tipping table because

Speaker 3I've figured out how the psychics we weren't using it to answer the questions, and I started answering the questions before they did using the table, and I was literally asked to leave the room until the.

Speaker 1Exercise had finishes.

Speaker 4You know.

Speaker 1So this is this is a show I love.

Speaker 3It's a subject that's close to my heart and you know, I'm very excited to be here.

Speaker 2I we get some great calls.

Speaker 1And I bet we will. And Richard, you know, I always love talking to you and have you on.

Speaker 2Richard.

Speaker 1You're you're an educated may you just recently celebrated a new education milestone. I don't know if how public you are about that, but I'm about you right now about I've.

Speaker 2Not got much much downtime.

Speaker 3Actually, I've just finished a degree in an undergraduate degree religion, philosophy and ethics.

Speaker 2Congratulations, I've got thank you.

Speaker 3I've got literally the period of about a month before I start my next degree, which is a muster's in psychology. Yeah.

Speaker 1Good, And I'm right it's for you. So now when you say you get to talk about religion and philosophy, you can say, I literally have a degree in this.

Speaker 2Yeah, and you've been studying it for the last six years.

Speaker 1So yeah, yeah, I mean, I mean, I mean, good for you for for doing that, man, I mean that makes you more qualified than some other hosts, I mean more qualified than me technically. So you know, hey, maybe you should start hosting this show. I don't know, but I don't know. No point is congratulations really really great out of everything that you learned in those in those four years. What would you say is because because you you like this stuff already, like you that's a topic from from what about you, Richard? You would study this stuff whether you had a degree to your name on it or not. Right exactly, what do you think was

Speaker 1the benefit of getting a degree in it versus just kind of studying this on your own. What do you think that difference makes it for you?

Speaker 2Yeah?

Speaker 3Well, the reason I did the degree in the first place, I've been talking to really just people and people who believe in the supernatural for the plus years.

Speaker 2The reason I did degree in the stuff is because.

Speaker 3My wife, who is very well educated, kind of said, look, just go and do it. You love the stuff, you have knowledge about the stuff, Go and formalize that passion and get it formalized, get a degree out of it, do something useful with it rather than just you know, just chatting to people about it.

Speaker 2Going.

Speaker 3Actually, so that was the reason I first kind of went down the academic route with the degree.

Speaker 2What I've learned about it is the.

Speaker 3Thing that I've most took away from it, which is so so important. And now this is why I would always encourage people into education. I knew the subject matter before anyway, you know, I was always interested in philosophy and different religions, so.

Speaker 1I was really higher than average knowledge for sure.

Speaker 3But yeah, I've been talking to people and I've been studying it and stuff anyway. But the methods of how to correctly do the you know, do the research to you know, to correctly interpret things, to correctly interpret things when your different methods are presented. That is what I learned from the DIGA. I didn't learn the subject from doing the degree. I learned how to properly assess the subject and that is so so so important.

Speaker 1Yeah, yeah, I agree with that as someone who I only have a bachelor's. And when you have a bachelor's you're not a subject matter expert. Okay, you're not. You're not, you know, you don't get that till later, and even then it's like debatable. So it's like, but you you do get to know more, you know some stuff, right, I agree with you, like the more. The most important thing, at least from my studies and communication studies was yes, the subject matter is absolutely important, but it's a lot of theory and and there's a lot of writing that comes with that, So reading all of that, you dedicate

Speaker 1more time to that. I'd say that that's first and foremost, Like you're getting that primary sources. You don't know stuff because read a Wikipedia article. You know stuff because you read the original person that wrote the academic work, right. But the other thing is, like you said, it's like you you you you comparatively you you understand knowledge frameworks and you understand how to analyze, understand sources, how to how to again those comparisons, like how how to actually intelligently analyze something at least when your you know, degree of study, right, And like that's that's a that's a

Speaker 1fascinating and useful skill in itself. That's at least been useful to me in my regular life where I don't you don't necessarily need a communication agree with the job that I do now. But it's like, yeah, I think that's to me, that's probably the best thing from higher education. So hopefully those thousands of dollars I can at least say, you know, at least taught me that in terms of getting a degree. But hey, yeah, again, congratulations to you, and you know, well done. I wish you well in your in your future endeavors on that point. But you know, this is truth one and this is a show where

Speaker 1we like to actually talk to other people besides congratulating ourselves on how how awesome we are. So what do you think do you think we should go onto some people?

Speaker 2I think we should definitely towe some people.

Speaker 1Yeah, okay, great. Before we do that, we have to think the awesome, awesome people that help make this show happen. That's the folks who donate on our patreon. We have a patreon for this. It's an ACA dot show slash Patreon tw and that is the truth Wanted Patreon. Now, let's the folks at the ACA know, hey, Truth Want is the show that's worth supporting. So thank you to everybody that donates that patreon. The patron of the week this week is going to be JP Young. Thank you so much, JP Young, and thank you to everybody that

Speaker 1donates on the patreon. You guys are amazing for that. And with that out of the way, let's get started with our first caller. We have we have a uh man, we got two that I want to do here. I think, oh gosh, this person called first. Let's talk to them first. We got Jacob, who's calling in from Oh my gosh, id what id again? Is it Idaho? That's Idaho, right, Jacob, that's are you calling from Idaho?

Speaker 2Yeah?

Speaker 1You can you hear me? I can hear you. Yeah, you know what. I'm used to knowing state abbreviations, Okay, because you see them all the time on the show. I don't get too many calls from Idaho. Jacob. Well, thanks, thanks for the reminder that Idaho exists, because that's a state I do not think about very much.

Speaker 5Yeah, man, we're you know, we're burning pod on. I don't I don't think you'd get a lot of calls from out here.

Speaker 1Man, I wish I got more. I'm sure Idahoans have great stories to tell. So on that note, what did you want to talk to us today about?

Speaker 5I just wanted to show my gratitude. I listened to you guys every week, and you know, you're awesome and I really appreciate everything you guys do.

Speaker 1Oh thanks, Jacob, thank you so much that that that means a lot. Well, we're really glad that you like the show. What what got you interested in the show?

Speaker 5You know, Uh, printers, I've just we don't have a lot of like secular anything out here. Yeah, you guys are kind of like my community.

Speaker 1I guess that's pretty much it.

Speaker 5I've just been listening on for like seven years now and I've never called in before. I hope that maybe I'll call in when I have like something to talk about.

Speaker 2But that was pretty much it. I love you guys, and oh yeah, well, Jacob, thank you.

Speaker 1I mean, I man, like, that's that's why we do what we do, man, because like I know, when I first got into stuff with the atheist community of Austin, I was floored. I was like, wait, there's people that they come and they talk about this stuff, and they do it every week and they're at least close enough within driving distance. I used to drive two hours every weekend just to go hang out with the folks in Austin. Now I live in Austin, and for for part of the reasons because the ACA is here at others right, but like it it meant a lot when I could

Speaker 1go in person and meeting stuff because for a while I couldn't do that because I also lived in all Probably not I'm i mean, probably not as pro dunk as where you're at Nightdahoe. Okay, but you know it was it was not it was not Austin, right, So yeah, that's that's why we do what we do, man, because we want to be able to give a sense of community to outside of Austin. You know, it's called the atheist community of Austin with these shows, but really it's about the atheist community in general. And I'm glad that we can give you something to listen to every week. Man, Thanks for calling in telling us that really.

Speaker 6Appreciate you guys.

Speaker 1Have a great rest of today.

Speaker 2Thanks Jacob, you two wow wow short.

Speaker 1But yeah, we didn't really talk about anything that super related.

Speaker 2You know. I like how I said Richard.

Speaker 1That we should stop like congratulating ourselves on how smorw we are. And then we go to a caller who's like, hey, thanks for you know, doing the show. But you know what, shout outs to Jacob, because that sucks. That sucks when you feel like you're alone and you're by yourself and you can't talk about these kinds of ideas because you're gonna get shunned or you're gonna you know, people aren't gonna be interested, right right. It really does suck.

Speaker 2Yeah, and that's what we're here for.

Speaker 3I've just come off hosting the Tolkithen just before this show, and you know, the final thing I said on that show was that we are a community here.

Speaker 1We are.

Speaker 3It doesn't matter whether you're physically in Austin. I'm not, I'm five thousand miles away. You know, there is a community here for everyone, and you don't have to agree with everything. You might be a theist, or you might be coming out of theism, you might be a full blown anti theist. There's a community. There's a place in this community for everyone. But we don't all agree on everything, and that's fine, that's perfect. But we're good with good strong community and you know we we are there. Before

Speaker 3before I was a host, I listened to the shows, you know, in my previous job to the one I have now, I did a lot of time on my own and I'll just listen to the entire bat coalog of the ACA shows. Truth wanted to, you know, secular Sexuality of the Law, and it was great. It was you really really do start so to identify with the community and with the people in the community and feel like you get to know the holes and I love that.

Speaker 2I think it's brilliant.

Speaker 1Yeah, I think so too. I'm glad that I get to be a part of it. It really is an amazing opportunity and something I'm very grateful for for sure. So, Jacob Banks, you know your your your call means a lot. But on that note, maybe we should talk to some other people and not pat ourselves on the back too much anymore. Okay, maybe we should stop with that and just keep on rolling, shall we. I want to talk to Katie. Katie seems like she has an interesting call for us. We have Katie calling in from I think

Speaker 1that's Virginia, Va, Virginia, Right, Katie, You're a live on truth wanted. What's up?

Speaker 7Hey, guys my call?

Speaker 2Yeah, thank you for uh what'd you want to talk to us about?

Speaker 7So?

Speaker 4I guess like precognitive dreams and then also dreams from like deceased people.

Speaker 1Okay, so, so precognitive dreams and dreams from deceased people. So I'm confused about that second one can decease people dream.

Speaker 7No, maybe like like visitation dreams, like having dreams?

Speaker 1Oh, oh that makes more sense. Okay, So, so, so dreams in which you talk to people who who have passed. Okay, yeah, okay, cool, Okay, So, like, are they are these two things like experiences that you've you've personally had.

Speaker 2Is that where you want to talk about it?

Speaker 1Yeah?

Speaker 4Definitely. So like my I've always had really vivid dreams, like always.

Speaker 7I remember the first time I had a lucid dream was in like preschool.

Speaker 4I dream every night.

Speaker 7I dream multiple dreams every night, and they're not all significant, like they're mostly I guess, just filters of my day.

Speaker 4But there's some that are so like specific and like detailed that come true.

Speaker 1That it's just it's hard.

Speaker 7To be like that's a coincidence.

Speaker 1Can you give an example, what's something that's happened that you got a detail and a dream that came true?

Speaker 7Okay, So I think that the first two that were like pretty big, they were around the same time. I guess this one would be like a visitation dream for somebody to pass on.

Speaker 4But I had this dream one night.

Speaker 7I was sitting at a table with my dad's friend and he had passed away, and I knew him, but like he wasn't like I wasn't super close with him or anything, and he just told me he was like, hey, I need you to tell and then he told me his granddaughter's name. He said, I need you to tell her that I love her and I'm proud of her.

Speaker 4So I woke up and I was like, Okay, it's weird because he's not significant enough for.

Speaker 1Me to think about.

Speaker 7Or dream about. So I saw my dad the.

Speaker 4Next day and I tell him because also my dad.

Speaker 7Has had, you know, dreams like that with other people. So I told me. He was like yeah, and I described the setting to him and he was like, oh, that's his house. And I had never been in that guy's house. So I was like, like, should I try to contact her? Like I knew the girl, like we're around the same age, but we weren't like friends, like I mean, I would you know, I really didn't know her that well.

Speaker 1Yeah, I know.

Speaker 7It's finding her on Facebook and I messaged her and I was like, hey, I just want to let.

Speaker 4You know I had a dream about your grandpa and.

Speaker 7He told me to tell you that he loved you and he's proud of you. And she was like, I'm actually turning myself.

Speaker 4Into rehab today.

Speaker 7Like I really needed to hear that. Think you much And that was really just the.

Speaker 2End of that.

Speaker 7But like, you know, like that's just very I can't see that as like coincidence.

Speaker 1Yeah, yeah, I could see how that would feel that way, right, because that's that's very I have a similar experience Richard Ever told you this story when I was a kid. So, my grandma died when I was very young. I was I was a preschool age and shortly after my grandma died, I had a dream where I was talking to my grandma and she was like, look, I'm in heaven and everything's good and like this is what we eat in heaven and stuff. And it freaked me out because I was like, oh, I just I just talked to my grandma and my dream and stuff, and I remember that,

Speaker 1you know, I like, you don't really have early memories before like four or five, but like you get one or two flashes.

Speaker 2That's when I very distinctly remember.

Speaker 1And I thought that was so true to me that that was even one thing I had to deconstruct later in my life when I was like kind of not believing Christianity anymore, I was like, but what about this dream though? And for myself, Katie, what I figured was, well, you know, I don't even know if this was I mean, you know, memories are so hard to reconstruct, and dreams are even harder to reconstruct because they're they're they're they're barely even memories at one point. They're they're kind of visions that we kind of get at night, and and you know, most of the time, they don't make any sense and they don't really have any follow with her.

Speaker 1I don't even know if this lady I supposedly talk to my dream was my grandma. I never I don't really remember what my grandma looked like, but I remember what she looked like in my dream because it was so vivid. Right, So, we kind of have these experiences that are really kind of interesting, and when you break it down logically, they kind of don't make sense in a way. So, for example, if my grandma could talk to me, why didn't she talk to my dad or my mom, or my brother or anybody else? Why was it just me? And And I almost think of the same way in your situation, right, you barely knew this girl,

Speaker 1Why didn't she talk Why didn't that person's grandpa talk to her? Why did she need to go to you to kind of get that message long. You know what I mean. I mean, so you know, there's there's explanations for whether or not they speak to you. You know, that's that's a choice you have to make for yourself, Right, But I can see why that would be weird, Right, that would definitely kind of shake me if I had a dream like that. I don't know, that's my thoughts, Richard, what do you think?

Speaker 3Yeah, I've lost both my parents. I've dreamt about both my parents visiting me in various capacities over the years. You know, I ask my dad quite about fourteen years ago, and it's it is a normal part of the grieving process. I think to kind of have these experiences. I think one thing we kind of misunderstand a lot when when people grieving. One thing, we kind of tend to think

Speaker 3of it as is just this emotional experience we're having. It's not just an emotional experience. It's a physiological experience as well, and it can have you know, genuine, genuine physical physical effects on us, including you know, in our brain and you know the way we experience things that can make us physically feel certain ways. So it has it's not just the grieving process isn't just a a

Speaker 3you know, ah, well, you're experiencing this, so you're imagining stuff. It has real, real effects. The interesting thing about to think about your story is the fact that you bare and you the guy.

Speaker 2Yeah, yeah, that's what I was gonna say that.

Speaker 1I was like, I agree with what you're saying, Richard, but that doesn't apply to her at all. Yeah. He doesn't know this person, right, so yeah, and that's what makes it really interesting, the fact that you didn't.

Speaker 3Know that you have no real reason to kind of have this experience. And that's what I find really interesting about this.

Speaker 1That's probably why she remembered it so well. Yeah, yeah, you know, because yeah, I would do. That's really weird. Yeah, so so so Katie. And you're not, Oh go ahead, Katie, you like you're to say something.

Speaker 7Yeah. I was just gonna say, I do I remember my dreams really well, and I do keep a dream journal. So yeah, that's when it's also weird.

Speaker 4When I will write down that I.

Speaker 7Had a dream about something and then it happens in real life. It's like, Okay, I already wrote this down before it happened.

Speaker 2Yeah.

Speaker 1Yeah, so that that gives more credibility for your case because you actually keep track of at least from what you remember when you wake up, right, even then you're still gonna you know, misremember some things, right, but you know that if you were on the pro this is what's actually like, this is somebody contacting you side that would be in your favor, right because you're you're keeping track of what you're dreaming, which is interesting. So you have you have the dream journal entry of that day then of when it happened.

Speaker 7Yeah, Actually, before I called, I was trying to look through my dream journals to see if I could find it, but I have so many. I've been keeping a record for a long time. So yeah, and like I another one that's like it's this was really insignificant, Like it was totally not and that's why it was so weird.

Speaker 4I had a dream that I was I was doing.

Speaker 7A pick up Kroger order and I was making my list and.

Speaker 4At the top of the list I put those like circular peppermint patties, like you know, those those peppermint candies.

Speaker 7I never eat those. Yeah, I was going.

Speaker 1I feel like you're talking about like the white ones with the red stripes, like one of those yes, yeah, yeah, okay.

Speaker 7So they were at the top of my Kroger pickup list.

Speaker 1Whatever.

Speaker 7Weird. The next day I went to clean for somebody I have a cleaning business. Okay, I'd never cleaned for these people before.

Speaker 2Okay, I go.

Speaker 7In, I'm going to dust living room.

Speaker 6They have a big.

Speaker 7Bowl of the Kroger brand peppermint candies.

Speaker 8Okay, So, like stuff like that is just weird, Like, how would I even that is a little bizarre. I guess that one doesn't hit me as strong because what what I think about your dream mean every night almost right, and.

Speaker 7There's a lot of daks and like multiple dreams.

Speaker 1Yeah okay, yeah, so and that's every and and I think that's what they say when they do studies on this, right, turns out people have multiple on average, people have multiple dreams during the night and stuff we kind of forget over time. But you know, when you're training yourself to recall every night, like what you're doing, you tend to remember stuff more. Right, So you're somebody who is already remembering stuff more than other people. You're writing stuff down, You're going to get lots of details on things, and over the course of days, weeks, months. It's going to be inevitable that a weird detail from your dream is

Speaker 1going to match up with your life at some point, right, Like, it would actually be weirder if it didn't happen, right, Like, it would be stranger if absolutely zero things happen. And because but it can be infrequent enough to where you might notice that, right because oh hey, like that's kind of odd, you know, very it's very specific in nature. Right, So I don't know that that one doesn't hit me as much because I feel like, right, that's that's found to happen.

Speaker 2Right, But what do you think, Oh me, yeah, yeah, what do you think?

Speaker 4I think, Well, it's not it's I think that, well, it's not just that, like, it's multiple things, like.

Speaker 7It'll happen to say, maybe like the leak. Like another example, I had a dream.

Speaker 4That I was cleaning up and there was this big.

Speaker 7Ball of hair that had a bunch of blue tinsel in it, like you know.

Speaker 4When people do those hair tinsels.

Speaker 7And I was cleaning and there was a port in the corner of the room a hairball with blue tinsel in it.

Speaker 2Like what mmmm, okay, yeah, I.

Speaker 7Mean Like another time I had a dream that it was cockroaches?

Speaker 1Did you know it was hair tinsel from your dream? And then maybe later you saw the hair tinsel and made that connection.

Speaker 2You see what I mean?

Speaker 1Though, like you know, there may be some there can be some reconstruction happening there.

Speaker 7Well, I guess I wrote it down before I saw the.

Speaker 2Tincol and you wrote down ask tenseil.

Speaker 1Okay, well you know, hey, what do I know?

Speaker 2Right?

Speaker 1So, I mean, good for you for writing this stuff down, you keeping track at least.

Speaker 3Well yeah, well I can't see how many how many details in the dreams that you're having that you wrote down.

Speaker 1Yeah, I'm curious. That's a good question. Yeah, is it? Are you writing down like multiple paragraphs per entry or like what does that look like?

Speaker 7It depends.

Speaker 4Like most of the time, I'll just write like kind of the like.

Speaker 7This the you know, just like a short description. But if I remember things really vividly, like how something looks or like the way something fell.

Speaker 4Like, I will write that down.

Speaker 7But no, it's not normally multiple paragraphs. That'll just be like a couple of sentences.

Speaker 2Hmm.

Speaker 1Okay, that's interesting. I don't know. I think like I don't I think deja vu is just the kind of thing.

Speaker 2I think. It's just I think there's a little bit of retro fitting.

Speaker 1I mean, because like, if it's precognition, it's the worst precognition possible, right, because it's it's not doing anything particularly useful for your life, at least from what you've described so far. Right, It's it's kind of just, hey, this is a thing I saw in my dream and now I'm seeing in real life. You can't really do anything with that other than huh, that's kind of weird, right, I think that. I mean, that's that's pretty much true for every dream story that I've heard, at least except for the ones who are like, no, I'm psychic and I can I can tell you when you're gonna die or whatever, but you're not. That's not happening to you.

Speaker 1You're just you're just kind of seeing like weird details, right, Yeah.

Speaker 6I guess.

Speaker 7Like the only other one that was similar to the first one, and it was around the same time I was in rehab at this at this point, and I had this dream that my friend's dog was like it was weird. The dog was under the tree and she was like telling me goodbye. It was very weird, like like obviously dogs don't talk, so like it was never like a spoken thing, but she was just essentially telling me by and I was like, that's weird. So I don't have social media. I didn't talk to my friend

Speaker 7when I was in rehabit. I did get to call my family, and I called my sister like a couple of days after that, I told her, like, you know, I had this dream about her dog and like it was under the trees. She would tell you buy or whatever. And my sister was like, they just put her down in their backyard under the tree. That was another one that was weird.

Speaker 1And I I want to do something. No, you don't want to do this. Kelly, come on, Kye listen. Kelly has been He's waving his hands at me. He wants to jump in on this. And this is actually this is evidence that Kelly's a psychic because before this show, Kelly was talking about little Wood's Law and actually, I'm gonna let Kelly talk about it. Kelly, you want to come in there, he is, Kelly, come.

Speaker 2On in here.

Speaker 1You're you're you're muted right now. Fraim, you got to you gotta unmute yourself.

Speaker 9Yeah, I realize as soon as I started talking that I was muted. So I was talking about little Wood's law, which is kind of kind of crazy because I kind of thought that something like this would come up today. And John Lewood was an English mathematician and he was looking into miracles, what the very topic is today, and he realized that if everybody was awake and conscious for just eight hours a day, and that you have an experience every second, which you do, you see a sign, you hear a sound, you smell a smell, every second

Speaker 9you have an experience, after about thirty four and a half days, you would have had one million experiences. So your chance of something that had that has a one in a million chance of happening to you has the ability to happen every thirty four and a half days or so.

Speaker 1Yeah, which is interesting idea.

Speaker 9And this would explain most coincidences like you are describing.

Speaker 1And you were saying that you like you when you hung out with some New age and you were in life.

Speaker 9Like Yes, I didn't come out of Christianity. I both came out of like New Age Wick and pagan philosophy and the stories that you're telling me are so common within that world that everybody, everybody has at.

Speaker 6Least two of them. Yeah, at least two of them.

Speaker 1So maybe that just means we're all psychic, though, Kelly, maybe we all have pre cognitive.

Speaker 9Well, I think that would that would be another justification for Littlewood's law, because we all have these one in a million chance experiences. Right, you actually have like a chance of twice in your lifetime of having a one in a billion chance of something happening.

Speaker 6So you know, it's a mirror.

Speaker 9And I used to I used to always think these coincidences were really, really significant, and then I read a book called Coincidence.

Speaker 6I don't want to push a book or anything.

Speaker 9But it talked about about how this, you know, coincidences are just coincidences because there is such a good chance of something like this happening.

Speaker 1Yeah. Interesting. I don't know, Katie, any thoughts on that.

Speaker 4Yeah, I guess I definitely see.

Speaker 7Like you know what he's saying. I think for me, I don't really have like I'm not super solid either way, Like I'm not like, oh, this is like groundbreaky evidence, but it's also kind of like, yeah, it's just a little too weird for me to think that it's coincidental.

Speaker 9When you have when you have one of these experiences, how what is the percentage chance jump that you have, Like say, say I had a twenty percent chance in this belief and this just happened to me. What and now I have a thirty percent chance, like you know, it'd be like a ten chance. What is what is the percentage chance that you that convinced you from one of these experiences would just say?

Speaker 6On the average?

Speaker 1Ill me, Kelly, I'm can I tag on you for that?

Speaker 2Sure? Please?

Speaker 1I want to ask Kelly's question in a different way that I think it's a bit easier, right, So, if you had the opportunity, let's say, you know, you want to evaluate whether this is a true phenomenon, right, whether you're precognitive, or whether this is just a coincidence. What's the first step in determining that for you? What would we have to do to figure that out?

Speaker 6I don't know.

Speaker 2I guess so Kelly's idea is, oh, go ahead, keep yeah.

Speaker 7Sorry, didn't mean frequent. It's not it's not, you know, guaranteed, So it's just kind of yeah, I don't know. I don't know what would take.

Speaker 1Kelly's idea is this. Kelly's idea is, hey, we should assign a statistical value to things. Now, obviously we can't know the exact odds of anything, but there's something called Bay's theorem Bay's ideas of confidence probability. If you look at Bayesian probability, what you can do is you can kind of assign a probability to something, and based on your assumption versus what actually happens, you can actually mathematically figure out kind of a rough idea of how likely

Speaker 1something is. And I think that that might be an idea to think about when you're when these things are happening.

Speaker 2Just give an idea, what do.

Speaker 1You think the odds are that this is a coincidence versus this is something else going on. You may factor in that other people have similar experiences, and hey, that might lean you one way or another. But you know, if you want to figure out whether something's true or not, that might be one way to evaluate it. Are there any does that idea speak to you at all? Or maybe do you have any other ideas of how we could evaluate this to be true?

Speaker 4Yeah, I don't know.

Speaker 7I think that would probably be the best just to like go through like maybe once a month and just be like did this happen or did this not happen? And then yeah, because I mean a lot of the times my dreams are just nonsense and like really don't mean anything, So it's kind of hard to take a part.

Speaker 9Like I'm so awesome. That was such an awesome answer, Katie. And you know that's the that's really the main stuff of having an open mind is going back and looking at the things that have happened to you and re examining them again again. That was freaking awesome way. I love you to hear you say.

Speaker 2So was I.

Speaker 3And I think I think this is really important, Katie, because it ties into something that's very very important to consider.

Speaker 2And what I'd kind.

Speaker 3Of like you to do, adding on to what the other two guys have said, is of all the dreams you write down, I'd like you not just to make a note of the ones that appear to have come true. I want you to make a conscious effort to recognize.

Speaker 2The ones that don't.

Speaker 3Ye what we what we've got, what it sounds to me like is happening here?

Speaker 2Is there is?

Speaker 3You know, we all the way our brains operate is by you know, patterns seeking, and when we're really really good at making mistakes, our brains are really really good at making mistakes. And what these mistakes are called in philosophy is fallacies. And there's a particular fallacy called the Texas sharpshooter fallacy, where what we do is we count the hits that we make on things and we ignore

Speaker 3the missers, and when that happens, it makes it appear like something so amazing. Well, look at this, this is really unlikely, and yet it's happened. But what we're doing is we're ignoring all the misses that have happened as well. And I think this is a It seems to me this is a pretty good explanation of what's happening here.

Speaker 2And what I'd like you to do is to trying to test this.

Speaker 3I'm not saying this is definitely what's happening, but I'd like you to test it yourself and really work through this yourself. Your own reasoning is, every time you write down your dream journals, just make a note a sign a period, like Kelly says, of maybe a month. Right, all of these dreams I've had in this month, how many have appeared to come true and how many haven't. And I suspect that what you'll find is the the vast,

Speaker 3vast majority of them you've not noticed at all. You've had no experience of coming true at all, but you have written them off, you'll have forgotten about them completely. But the ones that do appear to come true, you'll be zoning in and focusing, super focusing on them and saying, Wow, isn't this amazing?

Speaker 2This has come true. But when you look at the picture.

Speaker 3As a whole, what you'll realize is that this is just the way our brains operate. We are just pattern seeking, and that's what you're doing. You're zoning in on these patterns.

Speaker 2Yeah, a lot of thoughts from us, Katie. What do you think?

Speaker 4No, I definitely I agree.

Speaker 7I think that, Yeah, most of them are just really nonsense. It's just my brain, you know, thinking of things while I'm sleeping.

Speaker 4But I would say that the thing that makes me like I feel like most people.

Speaker 7Don't have any dreams that translate into the real life. So that's where I'm also a little like especially with my friends or like my my knees. I talked to her about my dreams a lot, Like they don't really have anything like that. So I think it's even if it.

Speaker 4Was like once or twice, it would.

Speaker 7Be but like it's just the fact that it happens so often. But again, I'm really not that like hardcore about it, Like I'm.

Speaker 1Not like, doesn't sound like.

Speaker 7This is absolutely no, because I mean I'm really a skeptical a skeptical person. I was raised kind of Colosto.

Speaker 4I'd deconstructed I.

Speaker 1Was like fifteen, So.

Speaker 7I believe I've gotten through a lot of the thought process of like I need to think about things critically. I can't just believe in it and then try to, you know, find evidence after that, Like I really need to have evidence and then make a with a conclusion.

Speaker 1Yeah, yeah, and and and and we're not saying, hey, you're you have this really problematic belief that you need to drop or anything where you know, we're we're excited about this with you. We wanted to figure this out because if you do have pre cognitive powers in hell, yeah, that's awesome. You know, I want to get on your talk show when you eventually do that. But you know, but you know, from from my perspective, it's interesting that you have the assumption that other people don't have dreams that connect to their life. And maybe that's true for your friends. You know, that's a that's a sample size

Speaker 1that's kind of small. But I actually I don't know this for a fact either, but I would think that if you ask most people, a lot of people would say, yeah, I had a dream that had something that connected to the life, and maybe they would only be able to tell one or two stories. Though I think that it's such a low frequency of occurring. I think that goes back to my theory on this, which is that when you have so many experiences and exactly like Kelly is saying, eventually some of those that are going to tie to your real life right in a dream. So I just

Speaker 1think the law of large numbers says this. And you're particularly attuned to this because you pay attention to your dreams much more than the average person. So so you of course are going to have this kind of experience. And I think other people that are also as it tuned as you are with your dreams are probably going to report this kind of thing higher, right, and maybe have more to speak to it.

Speaker 2But you know, that's my theory of it.

Speaker 1Maybe you have something else that has a better explanation for what you're saying. I don't know that you do. It sounds like you're kind of exploring, just like we are. But I don't know based on what I'm hearing that that's what makes the most sense to me.

Speaker 3And if I make ati just to tap on before you respond to Dun, just to tap onto what Dun said. Yeah, I wonder how many of your friends, I don't even know if you know this, how many of your friends who you speak to this about, actually keep diligent dream diaries like you do as well? Yeah, yeah, because that is going to be a factor that plays into this, right, right.

Speaker 1Because they maybe they did have one and they forgot about it because you know, these kind of coincidences, they don't add up to anything really in your life, right, so you just kind of forget, you kind of throw it out. So you know, that could be a factor too.

Speaker 7Yeah, I think some people I think I dream more frequently just in general, Like I think I think I have more dreams than those people.

Speaker 4Yeah, I don't know.

Speaker 9I think that we all have like three to six dreams every night. We just don't remember them.

Speaker 6Yeah, I don't.

Speaker 9And it could be that that you're not having more, you're just remembering more of them, Yeah, could be, could be.

Speaker 7Yeah, I think that's right. I think I do just remember more. And I don't know, I don't know why. I just yeah, I've always always remembered my dreams.

Speaker 1Well, you know, it's school that you're exploring this with us. I really appreciate you talking to us about it. Now that we're kind of, you know, closer to the tail end of this conversation, I kind of want to know what where are you at right now, you know, confidence wise? Do you still feel like maybe there's something here that you know, could be leading to something more or are you kind of leading more towards Uh, this is maybe a coincidence. Are you kind of at the same from where you started?

Speaker 7Yeah, I'm kind of at the same where I started, Like I just I think because it's just so personal to me, do you know what I mean, Like, it's kind of hard for me to it's kind of hard to like depatch and be like, well, you know, it just is a coincidence and it's not.

Speaker 4And again, I don't think.

Speaker 7It's necessarily some big, huge, deep meaning, but it's just like, hmm, yeah, I don't know, I don't really know where it would come. Yeah, exactly, Katie.

Speaker 3There were two really helpful books that you might like to read, which I think, uh, my ex might open your mind to kind of uh the psychological explanations for this one is called the uh I forgot the name of it. Uh, It's called The Science of weird Ship by psychologists Chris French. And another one is Paranormal Paranormality by psychologist doctor Richard Wiseman.

Speaker 2They're both in the same vein.

Speaker 3They look at kind of paranormal events, things like precognition and dreams. In fact, Richard Wiseman is one of the world's leading psychological experts on dreams. So you know, it may be paid particular focused to some of the stuff he says, but they really deal with this from the psychological perspective, and they're not they're not combative, they're not they're not dismissive. They're really really like focused on let's understand this. We accept these genuine experiences that people are having,

Speaker 3let's try and understand them from the psychological perspective.

Speaker 2And I think having having a look at.

Speaker 3Those or have an audiobook or whatever you whatever you do to read your books, contume books might be really really interesting for you.

Speaker 2I think it might open your eyes. So I so a lot of this phenomena.

Speaker 7Thank you, I wrote those down. I definitely would like to look more into it because yeah, I'm not yeah, not hard either way. But I also don't like to have beliefs that are not true. You know what I mean?

Speaker 2Yeah, sure, Yeah, that's why we exist. We want to know what's out there, what's true, what's not true?

Speaker 1You know, I think, Uh, I think we've all given our best to give some explanations that we could in the last twenty minutes or so. But you know, ultimately, these personal experiences are yours to have and for you to determine what's real what's not real. But uh, it says a lot about you, Kate that you're willing to call us and talk to us about it, because that expresses a level of humility that is always great. You know that we we like to see. So thank you for opening us to your experiences and letting us talk about them with you.

Speaker 6Yeah, I was really impressed.

Speaker 1Every week.

Speaker 7Yeah, by bye, Katie, I'm just saying I've been listening to you guys every year for or every week for years, so.

Speaker 1We love to hear that. Thanks Katie. If you listen, if you if you find out something about my life, okay, please please call and tell me. Okay, I want to know so that we can look at together. All right. If if my grandma is talking to you, send an email a truth at atheist hypeincommunity dot org and I'd love to see that. Okay.

Speaker 7So all right, Hi, thanks guys, Thanks Katy.

Speaker 1You have a good one.

Speaker 6Thank you. Yeah, thanks Katie. That was an awesome It wasn't.

Speaker 3I think the important thing about that is, you know, and I don't think we can overemphasize this enough. What Katie is experiencing there is not something out of the ordinary to what we all experience.

Speaker 2This is the way our brains work. Yeah, And it's so.

Speaker 3Important when people authentically have these experiences that the interpreter is supernatural. Whether it's pre cognitive dreams or whether it's ghost sightings anything like that, they're genuinely.

Speaker 2Having these experiences.

Speaker 3They are genuinely from their perspective, seeing these things and having these experiences. So it's not a case of dismissing the experience. It's not a case of saying that didn't happen to you. It's a case of let's understand the best way of understanding what that is, because this is the way that we operate on a daily basis as humans.

Speaker 1Yeah, it's true. It's true. For for my work, I'm having I'm brushing up on my analytics because it's my statistical knowledge, because it's it's important for my work.

Speaker 2And I'm i'm I'm.

Speaker 1I keep getting these terms mixed up and I have to I have to study them over and over again. But there's three terms that are thinking about recently, and it's in relation to machine learning.

Speaker 7Right.

Speaker 1So in machine learning technology, they want to be able to find hits and find them accurately, right. But they divide this up differently. So accurately accuracy is how often a machine learning model is overall correct, but precision shows how often a model is correct when predicting something right. And then there's also recall, which is how often they can find all of the hits right. So what's happening here is one there may be more hits out there,

Speaker 1that may be more connections that could make that haven't been made yet, So that's that that would be under recall. What's our recall rate as humans and what's our accuracy as humans as well? Because like, how how many times are we getting those those hits and and how how big of a hit you know?

Speaker 7Is that? Right?

Speaker 1When going back to what Kelly was saying, I think is what resonates the most true to me when you're having so many experiences and you and you're you're gonna get those hits eventually. Right, It's just it's going to happen.

Speaker 4I I I.

Speaker 1Whether dreams are a predictive experience or they're a random experience, you're going to have hits. That's just going to happen. So the accuracy and how how how often you know that occurs, you know, is something to think about because odds are it's it's just it. It probably is going to happen, and it's probably going to stick out when it does. So anyway, I think we've dissected this topic enough gentlemen, but we have open lines right now. So

Speaker 1if you're on TikTok and you're on YouTube or you're on whatever, you want to talk to us, please do because we have open lines. We want to talk to you. We'll want to figure out what's going on. Until then, I'm going to keep chilling and talking to these guys. Yeah, accuracy, precision, and recalls. Ye, I'm already forgetting my shit. I gotta go back my.

Speaker 2Fucking flash cards anyway, doing a lot of stuff for that.

Speaker 6But I have an idea we could do right now.

Speaker 1What's that, Kelly?

Speaker 6We could talk about an upcoming event.

Speaker 2That's true, you know what.

Speaker 1That's what we need to do anyway, So let's do that really quickly. Is that in just the next couple of weeks here, Actually it's like two weeks away. It's it's August fifteenth. We are having our twenty twenty six bat cruise. Baby tickets are on sale for that and they are going fast. In case you're not familiar, it's the thing we do every single freaking year. We got a back cruise that happens in Austin. You get to hang out with folks on a boat on the river here in Austin. It's great. And this year we're doing some other stuff as well. We got a special guest

Speaker 1lecture that's happening on that Friday, and we got some community outings and activities going on during the day on Saturday, followed by our annual members down Hall, and last but not least, on Sunday, you're going to see all of our ACA shows being filled live in the Free Thought Library, So that's going to be, you know, in studio rather than all remotely like what happens with most shows during the week. So some of our confirmed guests this year are going to be genetically modified Skeptic, the anti bought thinker, godless engineer, Seculararity. Myself and Kelly Loughlin are also going

Speaker 1to be there, so engage you like us, you know you should. You should come check us out. So link to that is going to be in the description, but tickets are going to be available at ACA dot show slash Back Crews along with some more details on that, so uh yeah, check that out. And last but not least, I need to think the wonderful, amazing, spectacular, fantastic crew that helped make this show happen every single week. Let's get to that crew cam. Look at all these beautiful, beautiful people. We've got a Stonewall shirt on. We're rocking that.

Speaker 1I love that. You know, Vern's got the Atheists are good without God the classic classic shirt at the point you know we need to do we have that, we to put that back in store, I think, because that's that's probably one of my favorite designs in terms of stuff that we've put out there. But anyway, thank you to the crew. And if you want to become a volunteer and help out, there's ways you can do that. You can email volunteer at atheistsipeingmommunity dot org to get involved with all of our productions, whether it's call screeting or moderating or hey even maybe being a host. So

Speaker 1do that if you'd like to get more involved. And folks, we still have open lines. So you know, I'm just chilling like a villain until anybody else wants to talk to us.

Speaker 9I was gonna say, you know, I started out as a call screener at the ACA. Look where I'm at now. So yeah, get volunteer. And one other thing I'm gonna say this has been I'm old.

Speaker 6I want old man. I've worked with a lot of people. This is the best crew of people I've ever worked with in my life.

Speaker 1Seriously, Yeah, don't have to be in Austin to be a volunteer. Of course, most for volunteers are remote at this point and have been for a while. At this point, I was also I was call screening for atheists experience. That was my first volunteer experience. And you know, it's it's great. It's fun. You get to see in how the sausage is made, and it's pretty cool. It's pretty cool, man. But anyway, you know, like I said, chillin like villains today, today's topic that we were talking about, well, we wanted

Speaker 1folks to call in, but it's okay if you don't want to. You know, it was about miracles. There's some interesting stuff about in roads here about you know, what miracles actually are and what they consisted of in the Bible, at least, because I think that's what most people refer to when they're talking about miracles. They're talking about well, I don't know if it's most of the time in America at least, we associate miracles with Christianity, right, so it's not just the stuff Jesus did, but also the stuff that like could could not have happened based on

Speaker 1the natural laws of physics or whatever. Right, so we're talking about like parting the Red Sea, we're talking about, you know, having the sun stand still in the sky, if you're talking about, you know, some of the stories that occur in the Bible. So I don't know how I felt about miracles when I was a kid. I think I thought that Jesus stuff was probably legit, and then maybe all the other stuff in the Old Testament was maybe a story or maybe real europe kind of methodists, so like it could have gone either way, you know,

Speaker 1But I don't know what about you guys. Were you guys big miracle believers back when you were believers?

Speaker 9I was, but you got to remember I kind of came out of Christianity as an early teenager, So I mean I was young, and I believed anything that a person of authority said to me, right, that's and that's how they get you, that they you know, there's always people of authority that are telling you these things, and you trust them because you're a little kid and you don't know any better. So yeah, yeah, I totally believe the miracles when.

Speaker 3I was a Yeah how about you, Richard, Yeah, I wasn't a believer in any capacity really, So I've come this from this completely outside. I think I think we've got in Christianity, stately Christianity, because.

Speaker 2That's where the majority of ourcohol has come from.

Speaker 3I think it's fair to say that most Christians would define the miracles as something that it's only attributable to a supernatural power or God, what everyone's put it.

Speaker 2But I think when you do, when you look at that in.

Speaker 3Terms of biblical miracles, there's something really interesting that happens.

Speaker 1And the way I actually split.

Speaker 3This into three sections Biblical miracles into three sections. Those which are replicable by other means, for example, Jesus walking on water or changing water into wine.

Speaker 2We've seen magicians do these.

Speaker 3We've seen magicians replicate this, and I don't think any Christian would consider a run of the mill magician, you know divine.

Speaker 7So.

Speaker 2And the second one is those which are exceptionally.

Speaker 3Unlikely, which we've just been talking about the law of you know, little Wood's law, and the law of very large numbers, such as Abraham and Sarah conceiving Isaac in old age. It's not it's not impossible that this might happen, although it is very very unlikely. I think the interesting ones are those which appear to contradict the laws of nature or the laws of logic, like people coming back from the dead, and they're the interesting ones. But not

Speaker 3by any means are all biblical of miracles. What are claimed to be miracles in the Bible. Don't all fall into this category. Aren't only a tributed a tributable to a supernatural power or a divine being? And I think that's really really interesting because from the most part, I don't want you guys think. When I'm talking to Christians, I do get this overarching idea that all these miracle claims are the same thing, They're the same category of things.

Speaker 2It's God. It's God's power which has enabled this to be.

Speaker 3And that raises serious questions for me because I like to ask myself, why aren't they looking at other candidate explanations for these things? And it comes to unlikely events or things that are replicable by repel, replicable by other means. Why is Jesus turning water into wine and miracle and why is it not a magician's trick?

Speaker 2What are they doing to assess this claim?

Speaker 1I don't even know, because like the Jesus stuff that we don't have eyewitness accounts of any of that. We have third party accounts of that, so that may not even been a trick. It could have just not happened, like the whole story at some point.

Speaker 2Right.

Speaker 1What's interesting, what I wish people talked about more was how the Catholic Church actually evaluates miracles today. I don't know if a lot of people, even in the atheist space really actually know, because it's actually very bureaucratic the modern.

Speaker 2Way that they evaluate in miracles.

Speaker 1So they actually have a board of like a medical board review, like when it comes to whether they take these healings or not as as as real. In other words, they have to determine whether or not a natural explanation makes sense again according to this board. Now, of course this board is going to be made up of you know, people that are you know, Catholic and stuff, but I think they do take people that aren't Catholic on the board sometimes like to help with that. So there's like other boards of review that it as well. They have

Speaker 1to have at least two miracles confirmed from a saint to count to somebody as a saint to qualify that. But like that's kind of weird because they don't have to be alive, right, It could be somebody that it has to be somebody that died actually specifically to be called to saint. So somebody that prayed to somebody and then something happened to them, they'll say, oh, that person is a saint. Right, So there's bureaucracy in some of this, okay, Richard, but only if you're a Catholic.

Speaker 2If you're a Protestant, anything fucking goes.

Speaker 1Man. Your grandma just like you know, found a parking space over the big lots and it's like, yeah, man, that's a miracle right there. But I don't know. That's a one point you get to the Catholics because at least they got some paperwork, you know what I mean. But you know, I don't know if it's good paperwork, but it's there, right.

Speaker 9So I think that maybe why people easily fall for believing in miracles is might go back to what I was talking about before about being died, created at an early age, so you've already got this belief that these miraculous things can already happen, and then you have something that you can't really explain, and instead of doing a bunch of work and research and things, you know, the simple explanation is it's a miracle. It's really easy to believe that because I've already I already believe in miracles,

Speaker 9right yeah, and there's there's nothing that can't be done by a miracle, So why not just you know, resort right back to that idea.

Speaker 6That's what I that's the way I see it. Anyway, of course I could be totally wrong. I always have been.

Speaker 7Yeah.

Speaker 1I mean it's interesting that, like to me that there's an emphasis on I think I have no actual data on this, but I have to imagine that the types of miracles that get reported for consideration for the Catholic Church are probably mostly medical in nature and not like, oh man, we saw this rock turn into a cop or something. It's just like, you know, it's somebody id healed for something, right. I think that's like probably the majority of it, which is, like I know, there's so

Speaker 1much we still don't know about the human body. Like of course that has to be the frontier, right because when you don't know, when you can't give an explanation, then that is what becomes a miracle. It's been said before by many people. But as soon as something is a known idea in science and suddenly there's no miracles in it anymore, right, which is I don't know something I think about a lot, but you know, it is what it is. So no miracles for us, boys, I.

Speaker 2Guess, no miracles for us.

Speaker 3I've actually got a quote here from the Catholic Church that says it's talking about medical miracles, and it says for something to qualify as a medical miracle, its must have the properties of being the spontaneous and lasting remission of a serious and life threatening medical condition. The healing must have taken place in ways that the best informed scientific knowledge cannot account for.

Speaker 2And follow prayers to the Holy Person.

Speaker 1Yeah, but I what somebody would say, and what, well, let's talk about that. What do you think about that criteria? Because that seems like a pretty reasonable criteria on the surface, right, would you guys agree?

Speaker 7Yeah?

Speaker 6I like the lasting part too.

Speaker 1Yeah, yeah, I get. I just go back to though, like, well people can also I don't know if they heal from stuff, they heal from stuff, right, Like, how do we know that anything supernatural is happening in that it doesn't differ? Yeah, I think confirmating that, right.

Speaker 2Yeah, it's a bit, it's a bit. That's a built in problem.

Speaker 3I think, yeah, this cognative bias built in, so it uh, you know, healing after prayers isn't demonstrative that the press calls are healing.

Speaker 1Yeah, And I don't know that you can do anything about that, by the way, like I don't know if that's a problem that can be solved, right, because how do you I mean, they have done so there's like was it Templeton studies or whatever that's like, oh, people that you know, we're we're prayed for versus not prayed for. And the folks that were prayed for like actually kind of did a little bit worse because yeah, there's the and they hypothesize because there's more pressure on those populations and stuff.

Speaker 2Maybe it's because they weren't Catholic. I don't know.

Speaker 3Maybe it's because hey, look as off to the Templeton Foundation. They are a Christian organization. But all credit to them. They are really really good putting down these unbiased They have a lot of unbiased reporting in the results. They want to prove this stuff is true. They want to They do a lot of work in this area. They do a lot of work in consciousness as well, because they want to prove that it comes from God. But

Speaker 3they are really really good that down the line when it comes to accurate reporting, which can't be said of all Christian scientific studies, you know, so you know, so soft to them for that.

Speaker 2You can't criticize them at all for that.

Speaker 6Yeah, I got a laugh at of that term Christian science.

Speaker 1Well you know that's what they call themselves. But hey, I you know, because somebody might tell us, well, you guys aren't being reasonable, right, because hey, here's some evidence, here's some things that the Catholic Church is calling miracles. Why don't you consider it? They have a border review, they have these people contributing to it, and I think my answer that would be, well, you know, again, it's about diseases, like where it's never going to be.

Speaker 2Hey, this person got their hand cut off and it grew back, Like it's just it's not the stuff that you just have.

Speaker 1There's always a little bit wiggle room with these things.

Speaker 7Right.

Speaker 1If Jesus really turned water into wine, that would break our known laws of physics, right that, like he would have done nuclear fusion or fission, you know, and and would have I think it's fusion. Actually in that case, I'm not an expert. But the point is some stuff would be fucking wrong about how we understand things, right, Like medicine, we already know we stuff's wrong, Like we're learning every day stuff we know is wrong, Like that's not it's not the same kind of category of miracle, right, And did you know all the great.

Speaker 3Thing about that is And I think this is where religious people kind of get it wrong. Or I think if a miracle like that happened, that appeared to break the laws of logic, that appeared to break the laws of physics, rather than us as skeptical people not talking about atheists on the whole and talking about we kind of examine this stuff, rather than us saying like crying out and trying to say that's wrong, that's wrong, we'd be as excited as they were about it because something unknown,

Speaker 3it's something that's come along and overturned our understanding of something, and far from digging our heads in the stand and like trying to pretend it didn't happen. I do hope that we were on board with it and saying this is amazing, let's have a look at this, because this is really really for me as somebody who studied philosophy. If something starts overturning the laws of logic, I want to be in on that.

Speaker 2I really want so trying and understand why that's the case.

Speaker 1My ex wife, Richard went on, just kidding. I don't have an ex wife, but you know that's what came to mind. Sorry I interrupted you at the end.

Speaker 6You're good, I hear you.

Speaker 2Right, people, I think.

Speaker 1You gotta be real though they're like in our community, there'd be a knee jerk reaction to anything, right, Like if we if if we actually figured out that there was a miracle tomorrow and I go to our slash atheism, there's gonna be a knee drug reaction to like, no, no way, that's real.

Speaker 7Right.

Speaker 1So I don't know, there's there's always gonna be that. But that's that's with any group of people that are invested things right and any topic. Right. Yeah, I don't know. I don't know, but I agree with that, Like I would want to know, like what's up, because that would that would change things. But I think that's the problem is that we keep wanting to know what's up and we never get those answers, do we, or at least not in ways that are particularly satisfying, you know, so I don't know what to do with that, but hey, just to call the action here, folks, we do have open lines. Still want to talk to you. I'm excited

Speaker 1about my next show. I'll be talking with Seth Andrews, which would be really cool on Anything's Experienced, So tune in for that. But hey, you know, don't wait till then talk to us now, you know, we want to talk to you talking about miracles at the moment. I guess none of us have had any miracle experiences in our lives. Huh, We're just that's the problem with us, godless ethens. I guess we don't don't.

Speaker 2Really do that. Yeah, of course it's a funny one though. How do how do we assess what whether a miracle?

Speaker 3How would you assess, you two guys assess if something that did appear to contradict the laws of physics, so the loss of logic happened, and your witnessed it, how would you go about assessing that the probable cause of that?

Speaker 1That totally depends on what kind of miracle we're talking about here, right, Because like, first of all, I'm not an expert in basically anything so I'm not sure I'm the guy that's going to be doing that, right, Like, I think I want to trust the guy with a with a couple of letters next to their name to figure that out. First of all.

Speaker 6Yeah, I was just wondering what units you use to measure miracles?

Speaker 1Yeah, I mean, you know, I'm trying to think the question throughout it. I mean, this is something that gets pointed out, right because if it's truly a miracle and it violates the laws of nature as we know it, then how can we use the laws of nature to verify it?

Speaker 6Right?

Speaker 1So I don't know, I don't know how you do that other than you take what's previously established in scientific theory and you evaluate it against that, and you either have to reevaluate your scientific theory or you find local events of something that just doesn't work. And if it's if it's truly local, right, so in other words, it's not reproducible in other contexts. I think that's how you have to do that, right, Like, Oh, yeah, it's only this guy of this particular faith system when he prays

Speaker 1and when other people have this faith system or whatever can praise about this thing, then this thing happens, then you might be onto something.

Speaker 2But that's that's the only way I can.

Speaker 1Think of that, you know.

Speaker 3Yeah, well, I think this brings us brings up the problem of it is, you know, how do we assess whether a miracle is true as truly happened? You know, if if there were a law, if there are laws, and I'm sure there are, if there were things in science that we are not yet aware of, how do we assess that it might be that against this is a truly supernatural event if we've got no means of measuring either of those things.

Speaker 2Yeah, just fall down to faith.

Speaker 1Kelly, you got your rock. You had something to say before I was no, I was just I was just agreeing, that's all. Yeah. Well, Keller, you're a rock guy.

Speaker 2You like rocks. I think rock a lot.

Speaker 4I do.

Speaker 1Known't for a fact that there are rocks that exist in people's collections, probably yours today, Right, that like scientific people study people don't exactly know the origins of right, or at least you don't know exactly their formation.

Speaker 9Right, Maybe not so much the origins, but we they're like some rocks have properties that we don't fully understand how they do that like I mentioned before the show, I have a rock that bends. I'm going to bring it down to the back creise too, so if you're there, I'll show it to everybody. But why it's a type of sandstone and it's called called ida calamite, and we're not one hundred percent sure why it will bend, right, we have an idea, but we're not positive. So yeah, I mean there are we do have things like that within geology, within all sciences that we're not positively sure about.

Speaker 9But I will say that the more we find out those gaps that god that the gods live and keep getting smaller and smaller and smaller.

Speaker 1But aren't there that there's some rocks like that we don't know because I was talking about origins too, right where it's like we don't know the exact geological processes by which because like like like I'm saying, like you found, there are samples that have been found in places that we don't know why they've been found in the places they've been found, Like that's that's what I was thinking of.

Speaker 9Not so much, but but but you were right about the first thing that we do like agots, we're we're not really one hundred percent positive about how agates form with all the different lines and layers.

Speaker 6We have like three different uh.

Speaker 9Uh hypothesis HYPOTHESI hypothesis about I think it's hypothesis right about how it's done, but we don't know one hundred percent for sure.

Speaker 6Everybody leans more toward one than the other two. So but yeah, we still don't know.

Speaker 1I tell you it's only one hypothesis you need, baby, and that's g O D Okay, that's the big Which which hypothesis is that? Is that number one?

Speaker 2Because it should be?

Speaker 10All right?

Speaker 2God works some mysterious ways, Kelly.

Speaker 6I noticed that Gregson us, we have a question from the audience, so we might want.

Speaker 1Oh, okay, shoot, yeah, let's let's do that question from the audience. Somebody says, I have social anxiety or I'd call in just wondering how you fellows would explain mass hallucinations like Fatima. For the Fatima event is interesting. You guys are familiar with Fatima. For those that aren't aware, I'm mad that Google actually to remind myself on the details. But from what I remember, the idea is basically a lot of people were looking at the sun and they saw they saw something, yes, right, right, yeah, like that's

Speaker 1that's what That's what it was, right. I think it's South America, right, Portugal Portugal? Okay, well that's not South America at all. But anyway, okay, so Portugal kind of the opposite of the world from South America. But fine, uh yeah, like they just man, now I got to google it again because I don't know.

Speaker 2I I remember it's like a lot of people.

Speaker 1It's like a thousand people or right, and they're all staring at something and they all had kind of a vision.

Speaker 6Right there.

Speaker 9There were three kids who claimed that they were talking to the Virgin Mary, and they said that if everybody came that day that they would witness miracle. And apparently everybody was told to look at the sun. And I mean, if you're going to stare at the sun, you're going to probably see stuff, That's all I'm saying. And what some of the there were reports that it went dark, there were reports that the sun danced around. I think there was like three or four different things that supposedly happened, but each person only saw one of those things, right.

Speaker 1Okay, Okay, so I'm reading some stuff on the Wikipedia. This is interesting.

Speaker 2The published memoirs of Sister Lucia.

Speaker 1In the nineteen thirties revealed two secrets that she claimed came from the Virgin Mary, while the third secret was to be revealed by the Catholic Church in nineteen sixty The controversial events at Fatima, including the Miracle the Sun, gained fame due to partly to elements of the secrets, prophecy and eschatological revelations allegedly related to the Second World War and possibly more global wars in the future, particularly the Virgin's request for the consecration of Russia to the emmaculate Heart of Mary. Okay, there's a a lot more to this than I realized. So the sound thing was

Speaker 1just only one part of this actually, so there's other parts of this miracle. So yeah, now I need to do some more research.

Speaker 3Yeah, I think from the psychological point of view as well, we've got a tech into account. There's something called the misinformation effect in psychology, which is essentially where and it can be multiple witnesses as well. And I've just pulled up a paper on it just to read from in a second. But the misinformation effect is when people have witnessed something and facts after the fact distort the actual event. Yeah,

Speaker 3and there's a really good paper from friend of Nicholas Nichols and Loftus from twenty eleven called Current Issues and Advents Advances in Misinformation Research and that was published in Current Directions in Psychological Science and the reviewer case where twenty five people died when the Metrolink commuter train collided with the Union Pacific Crea train neil Los Angeles in September twenty two thousand and eight. And what they found is, after the extensive investigation, this is a direct quote from

Speaker 3the paper, the authorities decided the eyewitnesses were wrong the signal that was read and they thought it was a different color, and the engineer's text message was a major contributor to the effect to the accident. It's possible that all four white eyewitnesses, including a conductor, a security guard, and two railroad enthusiasts, were all mistaken about such a crucial detail. And the answer is yes, eyewitnesses make mistakes. Multiple eyewitnesses can all be wrong, and their erroneous testimony

Speaker 3can have enormous consequences. And it goes on to kind of follow that up with in the wake of more than thirty years of research an ever growing literature, it continues to demonstrate the distorting effects of misleading post event information on memory for words, faces, and details of witnessed events. So it's it's stuff like this is really interesting when you get the cases like Fatima where you get allegedly multiple people seeing the same thing, and then you know,

Speaker 3all it takes is for people to get together and start chatting about the event afterwards, which is a natural human thing to do, and that can start distorting what actually happened in the case.

Speaker 1Yeah, I read. I'm listening to what you're saying. As as as first of all, thanks for sharing that. What's the name of that paper that you're really going to.

Speaker 2Have That paper is just belay with me on second.

Speaker 3Issues, current issues and advances in misinformation research.

Speaker 1That's a good, good, good title. Thank you for that.

Speaker 6It made my in my brain, It made me up.

Speaker 1The the.

Speaker 9The project they hear in the United States where they get people who have been convicted of things that like murder, are on death row, and that they re examine these cases and a lot of these people were convicted because of eyewitness accounts, and then we're able to gather DNA evidence, and these people are being exactly the exoneration project. I knew I was going to figure it out, but we have these people who have been exonerated later because these eyewitness accounts have been wrong.

Speaker 3So it's funny you should mention that because Elizabeth Loftus, who was one of the authors of that paper I've just read from, is literally the world's leading expert in memory and distorted memory effects, and her student, who's now a doctor herself.

Speaker 2Dr Julia's Shaw.

Speaker 3Works with police departments to try and correct the way they interview people because they can implan misleading information to people. Dr Julius showed it a really famous psychological experts women where she implumted false memories into people on purpose as part of this experimen, and they actually they recalled things that had never ever happened. Yeah, you know, it's it's it's as we were saying earlier to the first caller,

Speaker 3it's a normal part of brain function.

Speaker 1This one is though. Okay, I'm so I've been reading this entire time while you guys have been talking, because and I gotta do this thing. Okay, I thought I knew, I thought I knew the Fatima thing. I didn't know that.

Speaker 6It's pretty intense.

Speaker 2It's actually more intense than I realized.

Speaker 1I thought it was the I thought the son thing was the whole thing.

Speaker 2There's oh no, there was.

Speaker 1There's three different visions here, and it's from these three people that are First of all, why is it always how come it no Protestants get any visions of Mary? You know, it's always a Catholics. That's not fair. I feel like I should get a vision.

Speaker 9Because because it's the Catholics who deified Mary.

Speaker 6The other probably not.

Speaker 1I know I know the real reason why. But yeah, I'm just saying I want to have a vision of Mary. But like, this is we need to deep dive on this, Kelly, because there's a lot of war that's happening here. I didn't realize. Did you guys know they released the third secret there was first of all of them were killed early nineteen sixty.

Speaker 2They released that ship in two thousand.

Speaker 6Yes, it was supposedly about the Pope getting shot.

Speaker 1They were like, yeah, we're not going to actually reveal this ever, and then they're like, oh, actually we're going to talk about it. I guess because it reached a bowling point and then like what we just we don't talk about this anymore. That we had this, man, this is a this is some assassin's creed bullshit right here. I'm interested in this. I got a man, Well, this is going to take up my afternoon. All right, I'm bookmarking this. I gotta figure out some more on this. Uh, this is insane. Yeah, I want to give a fuller answer to this question because the question was about Fatcy. But I think, well, it mentioned Fatima. Maybe it was

Speaker 1just mass hallucinations in general, but that now I got to know more of what's going on here. That's just how my brain works, I guess. But I mean, Catholics have coooler lore than.

Speaker 9My mother was convinced that something happened there. Now my mother wasn't real religious, but she was convinced something happened there. And she had actually a book that was exploring the miracle of Fatima and gave it to me to read when I was like fifteen, sixteen years old. So I have a pretty good idea of what happened there, although my memory since then has become way flawed.

Speaker 1But I still have You know, I used to never think that there would be more Catholic converts. But now in recent years they're online, there's been like a cultural like thing happening of like, oh, people who are processing influence becoming Catholic influencers. And you wonder why that is, because you know they have more conservative.

Speaker 2Ideas in general.

Speaker 1I would say, well, maybe that's not always true actually, because sometimes they tend to be more progressive than some process on some issues.

Speaker 2I guess.

Speaker 1And my personal explanation is because Catholic law is just cooler. You got a lot more crazy stories and stuff they get in right, Like there's there's pageantry, there's the symbolism and stuff. What do you get when you're when you're a Baptist, you go to the you go to your uncle's fucking church steeple that has like twenty people and they all read the same you know, the same passages and talk about how they hate gay people. It's not it's you don't get the history of you know this these weird stuff going on.

Speaker 3I don't know anyway, all the Paul there was allegedly and I'm sure Kelly said this PERFOREM not sure about who done there was allegedly a pope who's I don't know whether it was them directly or one of their family members held orgies in the Vatican.

Speaker 9I mean, listen, I don't know, man, it was different times than though, Richard.

Speaker 2I guess.

Speaker 1I like the story about how there was like three popes at the same time. Actually, that's not even the only time apparently in history where there's been like just multiple people just say no, I'm the pope actually and then like having to figure that stuff out.

Speaker 6Right now. Yeah, yeah, so there's a pope in Wisconsin, right, No.

Speaker 1Yeah, I mean, I that's cool, man, I don't know for him, what do you want me to say? I don't know, but I mean, that's the bureaucracy of it fascinates me. I think that the idea of having a bureaucracy for miracles too is is just a fascinating one because at some point along the line, you're letting bullshit in, right, Like, it can't all be like no, we actually we got it right every time. Even if you're a hardcore Catholic, you probably have to wonder, right, because you know they're

Speaker 1getting shit all the time. That's not real. You know they're getting thousands of stuff from people, right, that's like Yeah, my goat was feeling sick and I gave it some medicine and I prayed to marry and it's better. And that's a miracle, right, Like it's probably like how much of it is that I don't know.

Speaker 7But.

Speaker 9Interesting you should mention the medicine. It seems like almost all the medical, the human medical miracles. I hear the person was also going through some medical treatment as well.

Speaker 1Yeah you think, yeah, that's it picks me because it's like, God, you know, you're going to a doctor and you're getting therapy and my god, your cancer is healed. Can you imagine why it's yeah, I know what to do with the doctor or the radios? You know, like, oh no, yeah, that makes sense. I don't know, man, it does go back to the whole wide diseases exist in the first place.

Speaker 10Thing.

Speaker 1You know, there is a little bit of a problem of evil there going on because like I don't know, I guess if you believe in a creationist background, then you understand, well, yeah, it's because you know Adam and Eve and you know, they left the garden and then stuff happened. But then like there's also Catholics that aren't Young Earth creationists. So it's like, okay, well, how does that work then, because then you have to if you understand evolution, then you know, these things happen older than Christianity. So I don't know it makes sense.

Speaker 9But honestly, I don't think I've ever met a Catholic young yourth creationist.

Speaker 1Yeah, it's not really a thing.

Speaker 9Yeah right right, it's you know, Protestant be a uh usher, I'm sure that I Protestant.

Speaker 1So yeah, I one hundred percent believe they exist. I just that's not really a not really, I don't know, they don't really worry about it.

Speaker 6I guess I'm sure there's I'm sure there are. I mean there's one of everything, right, yeah.

Speaker 1Yeah, there's probably some hold out. That's another thing about Catholics is that Catholicism in general, I think that is kind of interesting, is because the more modern well no, there's always been people that have contested decisions in the Catholic Church. I mean, hell, that's why Protestantism is a thing, right, because it was it was Catholics that are like, actually no, but you know, like in more modern times you do see like specific decisions. They'll be like I hate Vatican two. You know, you got like the anti Vatican two Catholics that are like, yeah, every the Catholic Church was good up until the nineteen sixties and then everything beyond that

Speaker 1we don't count anymore because the pope succession is not like I don't know, it gets real complicated and really nuanced. And I like that again. I like the bureaucracy and the weird details of it all. It's great, very fascinating. But you know, uh, if I became a Christian again, I think Catholic would be up there in terms of choices. You know, uh, maybe Eastern Orthodox too, They got some weird stuff going on.

Speaker 7You know.

Speaker 2Mormons, great, Mormon is also primo. That's a promo choice. Because I was thinking of where you.

Speaker 6Want to just go by legends, I'm going Mormon.

Speaker 8Yeah.

Speaker 2Okay, all right, all right, all right, let's wrap this up.

Speaker 1So, so next topic of discussion, because don't think we're gonna any more calls to do out of the show. If you had to become religious again and you have to choose, okay, what would it be if.

Speaker 2It's if we're just talking Christian again, Catholics.

Speaker 10All up there, we're talking Christian If we're let's start with just Christian, okay, because Mormonism is you know, there's some fun stuff with Mors, but Morton is there's a lot of restrictions there too.

Speaker 9Yeah, that's what I think, and I wouldn't work for me at all. I think I'd have to go with Catholic too, because I could do all the things I'm doing today and just go in and confess.

Speaker 2To Yeah, you know, there is that, Yeah, there is that.

Speaker 1You know what about you?

Speaker 2Richard?

Speaker 1Would you be ye?

Speaker 2I'm I'm with Kelly. I I don't really to change the mode.

Speaker 1So yeah, yeah, yeah, you get some cool architecture and yeah you get to say stained glass man. Yeah that's cool. That's cool. Okay, So all right, let's expand this now. Okay, Now you get to be anything that you want. Well, that's already true right now. You have you have the choice to be is something. But you know, obviously you have to have sincere belief. If you if you could brainwash yourself and having sincere belief into any.

Speaker 2Religious idea or religious group, what would it be?

Speaker 1Because I don't know that one Shinto Shinto is cool? Yeah, okay, I'm doing with that? Is there any problematic stuff in Shinto.

Speaker 6I don't think so right now that I know of, but I'm sure there.

Speaker 1When I was in Japan, I saw the shrines, and you know, people just left up stuff they wanted to happen in their lives and stuff I don't know.

Speaker 3Cool.

Speaker 1It really wasn't that big a deal. But that's my that was my only exposure as a white guy in Japan being like, huh, this is neat. So I don't think that qualifies me to say whether it's good or not. But you know, it was fine. I'm still having trouble with this. I don't know, man, maybe oh you know what, Zoroastrianism. That's what I would do, yes, because first of all, Freddie Mercury's cool, but also everything I've ever read about Zoroastrianism is like this is this seems kind of fine. Actually,

Speaker 1I know, like they have some weird stuff like they don't allow like converts and stuff. I think that's one thing. I think you kind of have to be born into it. So that's that's one thing that's not chill.

Speaker 4Uh.

Speaker 1They're probably not cool with Gay's actually, I think I remember that too. So I think if you're homosexual. That might be a problem, But you know, everything else seems kind of cool, right, some cool lord a gnosticism. That's another one that's awesome.

Speaker 6Oh maybe not.

Speaker 1That might be up there for me. The demiurge, you know, pretty neat. I want to get some noses, get some knowledge.

Speaker 2I don't know.

Speaker 1Maybe Okay, now now my tears is changing. I think nacissism is up there for me. I got to contemplate this, Richard, give me your thoughts. Man, You're you've been quiet, You've been steaming over here.

Speaker 3I just going for the lovely new Age just new age. Yeah, I love the music cool. Yeah, some of the music is cool. Some of the music's really good. Some of the music's are like one cold keyboard with which is ship.

Speaker 1So you're not wrong, that's a good point. Culturally, you know, probably has the chillist stuff to listen to, right, like stuff that I'd be most interested. I'm not.

Speaker 2I don't know if i'd want to listen to Zoroastrian worship songs.

Speaker 1Maybe maybe not.

Speaker 2But I listened to some New Age artists a day of the week.

Speaker 1That's true. Yeah, Okay, that seems like cheating almost because new Age you can kind of do anything with that. New Age is like the if if every religion is a lego set, you just got like the big tub at Timmy's house with like all the sets in it, you know what I mean, Like you just kind of got the the minecraft freak creative Scottsman on religions. I don't think that's fair. Actually, I don't know if we can count new Age. Maybe I don't know, but all right,

Speaker 1well this is a fun conversation which probably I I really enjoyed our time today. I want to thank Richard Jullifer for being on. Richard, thanks so much for joining. You're a regular, you know, host on these shows. So I don't know, can I say, hey, what if people want to find you, where should they go? I'll do it anyway. But yeah, talk Keithan, go talk Ethan. You know, Kelly, Kelly, thanks for joining us as well as our backup host turned just regular host actually for most of the show, and.

Speaker 9I got I was asked if my papers were changed in the cage, and yes they were.

Speaker 6They even filled my water dish.

Speaker 2So oh that's good. Yeah, that's that's yeah.

Speaker 1I appreciate that you've been doing some stuff on YouTube recently as well. You know, hey, a little bit, a little bit, a little bit talk about some rocks. Go check out Kelly's rock Talk. You know, that's not what it's called. I can't that just what's called. But it's Yeah. On that note, Uh, let's talk about words of wisdom, folks. We always ask words of wisdom, Richard. If you could give our audience some words of wisdom today, what would it be?

Speaker 7Oh?

Speaker 3Been nice to each other? N Just just be nice to simple You can disagree. Look, I've just come off TALKI then we've just had a call on this way. We disagreed with the caller. There's no need for arguments, there's no need for aggression. All those calls I took today were lovely calls. There were great people to talk to. Just be nice to each other, whether you agree or disagree.

Speaker 1Yeah, okay, that's be nice to people.

Speaker 7I like that.

Speaker 1It's a short, sweet to the point, folks. This has been a great episode of truth. Wanted remember to always keep onaning the truth. I'm objectively Dan. We'll see you next time.

Speaker 6It's Lana.

Speaker 2Good Watch Talkie than Live Sundays at one pm Central

Speaker 2and call into the show. At five one two nine nine one nine two four two, or connect to the show online at ACA dot Show slash call

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Truth Wanted 9.46 with ObjectivelyDan and Out Of Body Atheist

    Nov 16, 20261 hr 31 minAudio

    In today's episode of Truth Wanted, ObjectivelyDan welcomes guest Out Of Body Atheist, with The Beard of Empathy on backup, to dig into Reiki, New Age spirituality, homeopathy, and the long road from woo to skepticism!...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Truth Wanted 9.45 with Jon The Skeptick and Volcy

    Nov 9, 20261 hr 23 minAudio

    In today's episode of Truth Wanted, Jon the Skeptick, Volcy, and Sofia Spina explain why no one can talk to the dead, from Haitian Vodou and grief dreams to Jon's past as a spiritualist! Bob jumps from objective...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Truth Wanted 9.44 with ObjectivelyDan and Nintendrew

    Nov 2, 20261 hr 29 minAudio

    In today's episode of Truth Wanted, ObjectivelyDan and Nintendrew, later joined by The Beard of Empathy, tackle a world run on Jesus, the magic of manifesting, and a prayer that actually got answered! Bob in NY, a...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Truth Wanted 9.43 with ObjectivelyDan and Kelley Laughlin

    Oct 26, 20261 hr 28 minAudio

    In today's episode of Truth Wanted, ObjectivelyDan, Kelley Laughlin, and The Beard of Empathy tackle standards of evidence, miracle claims, and the false binaries of moral philosophy! Dean in VA questions why skeptics...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Truth Wanted 9.41 with ObjectivelyDan and Chad Harris

    Oct 12, 20261 hr 32 minAudio

    In today's episode of Truth Wanted, ObjectivelyDan and Chad Harris tackle Christian nationalism, police brutality, and the uncomfortable truths about racism and immigration. Big E in TN survived police brutality and...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode