Show notes will be posted when available. Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/truth-wanted--3195473/support.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Speaker 1Hey, folks, here on Truth Wanted, we're interested in separating what actually happened from what we've been told happened. Because history is just a list of dates and names. It's a story that's written by people that's full of biases, gaps, and sometimes straight up agendas. So how do we verify it all? Well, call into the show now, because we're going to talk about it right now.
Speaker 2Let's do it.
Speaker 1Hello, Hello, everybody, Welcome back to another episode of Truth Wanted. I am your host, Objectively Dan and this is the live calling show that happens every single week Fridays at seven pm Central Time, where we talk to people about what they believe and why. If you'd like to call us, you should because the lines are open right now the numbers five one two nine nine two four to two, or you can call through your computer at Chinya dot cc slash call t w and hey folks on TikTok. We are now live streaming on TikTok as well. Welcome, Welcome.
Speaker 1You can also call into the show through your phone. Don't worry, you don't have to go to a computer or a different device. If you check the description of this video, you should be able to connect to a link tech and get you into the show and folks, truth on It is a product of the Atheist Community of Austin, a five oh one ce nonprofit or it's five oh one C three. The three is important, folks, don't forget it. Five oh one C three nonprofit organization dedicated to the promotion of atheism, critical thinking, secular humanism, and the separation of religion and government. And every single
Speaker 1week always start to have a special guest with me. This week is no different. I got flabbergas to joining me today as my co hosts flabbergasted. What is going on?
Speaker 3Oh, not much, not much, just really enjoying being here and ready ready for some good calls, really digging us some meat and bone issues.
Speaker 1Yes, I want to thank you Flabbergas, because we did have a different guest lineup for tonight and they had to make some last minute arrangements away, but just stepped up and you're here and you're joining me today, So thank you for doing that.
Speaker 2What's what's been new with you? How's it going pretty good?
Speaker 3I've been working on a new project lately and trying to get back into my social media game and really hitting on the things that matter to me. I've been doing some stuff with with RfR, which is a really important thing for me. And yeah, so just just kind of I fingered a lot of pies.
Speaker 1Like what's RfR for people who don't know what that is?
Speaker 3Recovering from Religion Foundation, Yeah, yeah, and what do they do? Recovering from Religion works with people who are struggling with deconstructing religion or questioning their religious beliefs and creates a space focused around peer support for people to go through that process. So mostly support groups, but there's also a live chat that you can reach out to people on and if you need help immediately.
Speaker 2We have support groups at RfR.
Speaker 3There's more support groups at RfR every month than there are days in the month, so definitely check them out.
Speaker 2Recovering from Religion dot org.
Speaker 3I've been working with them on starting a new TikTok live with RfR called RfR Lives that is going to be on every Tuesday of the first Tuesday of every month midday, so keep an eye out for that.
Speaker 2Nice.
Speaker 1Yeah, we love Recovering from Religion around here, and I'm actually gonna be doing something with Recovering for religion pretty soon, so stay tuned for that if you watch their content. But yeah, that's great making time for all that stuff you said you do more social media stuff. And like social media. I'm so dumb with social media. I've never been more dumb with it, honestly, But you know, it's like still kind of like important to the world and like being a professional, you even have to have a LinkedIn, which is basically like business social media, like if you
Speaker 1want to like apply to jobs or do anything with that. And I don't even want to do that, but everybody keeps making me. I don't know. It's annoying, isn't it.
Speaker 3Yeah, I don't have a link. I mean I probably do somewhere, but it's probably scrubbed.
Speaker 1Yeah, I mean, I haven't updated mine in a while. I'm just saying I hate that it's there. I can't just like I don't know. Don't get me wrong. Obviously, I'm here, I'm streaming, right, I enjoy doing this, and.
Speaker 2You don't like your face being on the end, right exactly.
Speaker 4Yeah.
Speaker 1Yeah, so I get I'm a hypocrite in some ways, but like also at the same time, I don't know, I don't feel a need to do it, you know what I mean in terms of like like posting about my day every day or stuff like that.
Speaker 5I don't know.
Speaker 2To me, that just sounds like, oh.
Speaker 3Yeah, no, I don't. I don't do any of that. I use it mostly for advocacy. I use it for addressing issues that I care about, especially in including issues that we don't get to talk about on this show and with the age with the ACA. But I also, like I'm almost I'm also an advocate for polyamory and relationship related stuff.
Speaker 2Again.
Speaker 3I do stuff with recovering from religion. I do stuff with with people the queer community as well. I'm part of the queer community, and so I'm an advocate for that, and so just all all kinds of stuff.
Speaker 2I just really sink my teath into speaking.
Speaker 1Of all kinds of stuff to sink our teeth into. I want to go back, flabbergasted to my little cold open there, because I want to talk to you specifically about history. You've had a career working in history in the past, and so it's something that you're especially passionate about. And we were talking before you know what to talk about today, and I thought that we came to a great topic, which was this idea of like how do we know what we know about history? And like what's a good sort of way to figure that out? And
Speaker 1I know it's like a complicated question, but we should have a basic way for some people, right, because I get it the world is getting more complicated every single day. But you said something interesting, uh, before we got started here. You said that everybody knows something that they everybody, everybody says they know something to be true. That's absolutely one false when it comes to history. And I thought, I thought that was interesting, So maybe let's start there.
Speaker 2I'd say it quite like that. Okay, all right, I'm faarphrasing here, go ahead.
Speaker 3I said, I said, everybody has some sort of historical fact that they know.
Speaker 2Yeah pH historical quotes here, right, Yeah, that is.
Speaker 3Almost certainly wrong, Okay, and as much as it's.
Speaker 2Not right, so so there might be grains of truth.
Speaker 3So I would never say one hundred percent wrong, because that's that's going to be a really hard hardline, that's right. That's where I kind of I don't know, Okay, maybe I'm the radical. Then I think everybody knows thinks they know something. That's one hundred percent wrong about history. I do most I can't prove that, but that's what I feel in my heart.
Speaker 2Like undred percent true.
Speaker 3That's a lot of not true. Like that means there can even be a kernel of a fraction of a.
Speaker 2Truth in there. Yeah, well that's a lot maybe from a philosophical sense. Can we be certain that we know anything with one hundred percent certain?
Speaker 6Do you know?
Speaker 2Yeah?
Speaker 1Sure, I mean we can go into that. But I just mean, like, I think that, and and it may be like an established historical fact that may not be true, right that, Like a lot of us believe, like I because that happens all the time, right, Like how many things are people say, oh, this is the narrative that we taught about this time period for the last three hundred years, but then oh, we've just made a discovery that kind of overturns that, and now we have to think about things differently, right, Like how many times do you see that headline?
Speaker 3We see the headline all the time, but the headline is almost always exaggerated. They're like, everything we know about this thing is not is wrong, And it's like, no, there's actually a nuanced change of what we know, Like there's a lot of basis of fact that we do still know that that hasn't changed. It's just there's like nuance and context that changes a lot. It's very rare in history for us to take someone that we believe to have been a historical person that we later find out is absolutely not. It happens, but it's a relatively uncommon thing, and it doesn't mean that we accept that
Speaker 3everybody in history that we address as real people absolutely were. But until we can demonstrate that they weren't, we kind of assume that they probably were, because, as I mentioned to you before, in history, the most mundane claim you've ever made is that someone lived.
Speaker 1Yeah, you're you're talking about this idea because this is something again we were talking about before the show, but I'm glad you brought it up. It's this idea of the historical Jesus, right. Many atheists have come on this show and have their takes on its pretty split idea. It's not set in stone. For a lot of atheists, I would say most of us probably think that Jesus was a real person. There's definitely a minority that think that they's not real. You sound like you're on the camp of saying that he is a real person.
Speaker 3I would go with the he's a real person, or potentially an amalgamation of people that are kind of kind of talked about as one person, like that's the possibility that that I think is reasonable, or a person that had put stuff put onto them that wasn't accurate. I think those are more likely scenarios because that's usually what we see, even with the myth characters. Mythical characters are usually still based on a real person. It's the version of the person that we talk about in the myth that probably didn't exist, right, Like Odysseus probably existed. He
Speaker 3almost certainly didn't visit an island of sirens, right, So the version of Odysseus that had interactions with sirens, that version of.
Speaker 2Odysseus didn't exist, But did an Odysseus probably exist, probably, right, And that's kind of that nuance.
Speaker 1Explain me how that works, because when I look kind a guy like Odysseus, I mean, like the Odyssey is full of just fantastical stuff. I mean, it's basically a fantasy story for all intentsive purposes, right, except I mean there was a real like Peloponnesian War. I guess yeah, So how does that work? How do you go from oh, this guy maybe fought in a war to oh, he was fighting one eyed giants and stuff.
Speaker 3Yeah, I mean go Riad Herodotus, right, like the father of history in so many ways, his entire account of history is just saddled with all of this superstition and all of these religious beliefs and attributing things to gods and all of this stuff that's happening in there. But there's also so many things in there that are much more grounded, that are very realistic. So when someone says this country and this country fought against each other, right, that's that's something that we can actually quantify.
Speaker 2We can actually look at those things.
Speaker 3But when someone says, well, this person attacked this person because of you know, they were inspired by by Aris, the god of war. Like I'm being very kind of glib with that, but that's We're not going to take the Ares influence very seriously there, but we are gonna be able to say, well, you know, if there was a war, if there was a fight, we should find record of it. And with the with the ility in the Odyssey, like we have some things that actually track out. We've found a place that is likely to be Troy, Like, these are things that matter.
Speaker 1A Christian might say, well, is the reason why you don't take the Aris thing seriously because you're assuming a secular worldview rights, that's the thing. Apologists say, Well, you're assuming a secular world so of course you can't believe that like miracles happened, right, What would you say to that?
Speaker 3I would say I will happily accept the existence of miracles as soon as they're demonstrated to occur. So when we look back in history, we can't assume that something that happened in history that we can't demonstrate could still happen today is something that actually happened. So we take things that we understand about reality as a whole, and we are going to look at those things when we look back in history with that same length. So when someone says that there was a you know, twenty foot giant that they fought, and we have no record of
Speaker 3anyone being twenty feet, Like, twenty feet is far beyond the largest human that's ever been demonstrated to exist. There's no other creatures or entities that we've ever found and demonstrated to have actually existed that are of that size. So when someone says there's a twenty foot person, Okay, maybe you're exaggerating. Maybe they were just like six foot two, and like you were just really small, and so it felt like a twenty foot person, right, So, like, these are the things that we take. So it's not that I'm coming at it from a secular perspective or that I don't accept miracles. It's that I can't assume that
Speaker 3something happened in the past if we can't also find those things happening in any way, shape or form in a way that we can demonstrate today.
Speaker 2Yeah, I mean that makes sense to me.
Speaker 1But I'm not a Christian anymore, so you know what, I'm a little bit biased myself. But maybe you're a Christian and you're watching this show right now, you definitely should call in if you are, because again we have open lines and we want to everybody, not just Christians, but also if you have other kinds of beliefs about history, maybe that other people don't necessarily believe in. Maybe history actually started. What's that one idea where it's like, oh, it started at like the year eight hundred or something, and then it kept going and everybody everything else is like backfilled. You know what I'm talking about.
Speaker 3The idea that like, like the universe was created in such a way that all the history that happened before that was like fabricated but didn't actually happen exactly.
Speaker 2Yeah, yeah, like that.
Speaker 5I don't know.
Speaker 1There's a lot of weird history sort of rabbit holes when it comes to you know, pseudohistories is.
Speaker 3Under call in with your pseudohistorical claims. Yeah, please, like.
Speaker 2Let's let's talk about them.
Speaker 3If you think that that everything we understand about history is just wrong, that are are are the way we evaluate historical claims is not good, Like let's go, Like, can you talk to me about how we have more evidence for Jesus than Alexander the Great?
Speaker 2Please? Yeah, I'm here for that.
Speaker 1Yeah, I mean we're ready. We want to talk about it. And while we are waiting for some of you guys to talk to us, I want to bring in Kelly real quick. Kelly is our backup host for today and he is doing his thing.
Speaker 2What's up, Kelly? What are you doing?
Speaker 7But I like it when you were the pirate cush oh I gotta go.
Speaker 1Yeah, Kelly's doing bits. He's doing bits on the show. Now, that's crazy. Uh man, that's funny.
Speaker 5Man.
Speaker 2You mean he wasn't actually on the phone. We weren't interrupting. I mean, that's I don't know. I believe it.
Speaker 1I could see it being real. But no, thanks, Ken, it's going good man. Thanks, thanks for joining us. Glad you're ready and prepared to talk to us. You have a good phone.
Speaker 7Call that Yeah, yeah, I was talking to a friend.
Speaker 2A friend. Yeah.
Speaker 1I guess she's not from here though, right from Canada.
Speaker 2Of course you would. You wouldn't know her, Kelly.
Speaker 1Every week we are asking somebody a quest question, and I want to.
Speaker 2Know what was our question that we asked folks. Last week?
Speaker 8We asked, I'm sorry laughing, what biblical transmit mistranslation should be in the Bible. And here's our three favorite answers. Number three from Chuck Gato's Blessed are the Meek, for they shall and hear it? What's left of the earth, which seems a little too realistic.
Speaker 1That's that's real though, that's good. I yes, no notes, no notes on that.
Speaker 8Number two from Ironclad Alibi, what biblical mistranslation should be in the Bible. Jesus said, whenever three or more are gathered in my name and offering plate shall be passed.
Speaker 2That's too accurate, that's.
Speaker 3Yeah, but I was just sure's I'm pretty sure that's actually the original Greek.
Speaker 2I'm pretty sure.
Speaker 1Yeah, that's the coin coin a for sure. Yeah, these are on so far, Kelly, what's our number one?
Speaker 8Number one from blue fifty four sixty nine. That's a new name for us, a biblical mistranslation. It should be in the Bible. You shall lie with the man as with a woman. After you shall get brunchm.
Speaker 1Okay, all right, little little zesty there.
Speaker 2I like it nice.
Speaker 3I like yeah, I feel like I feel like after you lie with someone you should just make him breakfast like they deserve it, you know.
Speaker 1Yeah, yeah, But then what happens when the other person thinks the same thing and then you guys both.
Speaker 7I was just gonna say a number.
Speaker 3It's a very like like kind of romantic sweet gesture.
Speaker 2You said. There, you cook eggs together, you trip over each other.
Speaker 1Okay, all right, yeah there's something to be said about that. Okay, all right, Well, you know these are all really good answers. I like this one's because and you're right, this one was a little too real, a little too real.
Speaker 2Can I can I throw one out? Yeah? Yeah, one for God so loved the world.
Speaker 3He gave up an uncomfortable weekend. Yeah, whoever believes in him shall not perish.
Speaker 1But I've always thought that, even when I was a kid, I was like, it's how much of a sacrifice is for a god? Though, because like he did, he went back and did his thing. I don't know, it didn't seem.
Speaker 3Like what's I'm not the first person to say this, but it's the adage of like like he gave, he sacrificed himself to himself to make up for the rules that he made, and the consequence of that was that he had an uncomfortable weekend. So that way everyone's sins can be forgiven.
Speaker 1Yeah, I don't know. I don't know how I feel about that. But anyway, like I said, not a Christian anymore, so I don't have to worry about it. But Kelly, you have a new prompt for us this week?
Speaker 8Right, I do have a new prompt, Yes I do. How do you know it's time to fact check wrong answers only wrong answers wrongly only.
Speaker 1Yes, I love this one. I think this is gonna be a really good one. So yes, leave your comments below on when you should faction wrong answers only, and we will pick our top three for this next week. You guys got any good answers for that one?
Speaker 8I guess not so I was thinking when the water it's about this high?
Speaker 1Oh yeah, okay, yeah, that's that's a good one. Well, I think our commenters can leave even better ones, So leave a comic below, whether it's on TikTok or on YouTube, and we will try to pick the best ones for this next week. Kelly appreciates you coming up here.
Speaker 8And you I just got one bone to pick. Oh yeah, that's right.
Speaker 1He did say you wanted to.
Speaker 8I didn't like all the other backup posts. Get to go into a closet that I can get back to a cage, and number one, you're not changing the paper, and it's really embarrassing when I have to change clothing.
Speaker 7So I would like to have some walls in a closet myself.
Speaker 2What's that? What's that?
Speaker 3I think we lost Kelly there the audio because the bars of the cage aren't soundproof Kelly.
Speaker 1Well, we'll replace the newspaper in that cage real soon. Okay, just don't worry. Go back to that phone call.
Speaker 2We'll just put a new layer on top of the old one. Yeah. Well, we'll figure something out for you. It's okay.
Speaker 3I'm just saying I was a backup host. I was being put in the closet because I'm queer. So you know what there is that guys?
Speaker 1We need to We need to get higher quality pet food for Kelly. I think we can't keep buying the cheap stuff because.
Speaker 2Costco dental bones aren't good enough.
Speaker 1Yeah, I don't know, maybe a new I don't know this. This bit's gone on long enough.
Speaker 2Let's keep it. Let's keep it rolling, folks.
Speaker 1You know this is a callin show, so I think we should talk to our callers. Hey, what a novel concept. What do you think flower as? Did you want to to?
Speaker 2I think that'd be very on brand.
Speaker 1Okay, Well, before we do, we have to give a shout out to the folks that donate on the Patreon, because every single week we're always giving a shout out to the Patreon donors. Oh and I love how this graphic on TikTok is just like right in front of my face. It's really awesome. This week's patron of the week is going to be you know, move my my, my mouth ver there. That's not gonna work. This is for Steve d. Thank you so much, Steve, you are the truth Wanted patron of the week. And thank you to everybody that donates on the Patreon. You guys are awesome.
Speaker 1And now we've got our shout outs out of the way, let's dive into our first call. And this first one is going to be a little bit special, a little bit different from what we usually do, because folks, how do we build a strong supportive community outside of our religious frameworks. That's what we want to explore on our news segment, which we're calling our community Spotlight, And today's guest is doing just that. We have Christine Retqua calling in and she is one of the co chairs of the Humanists in Action, which is a committee that is
Speaker 1part of Minnesota's Humanist MN organization. She wants to share about this humanist group and some of the important campaign work that they're doing that's based in Minnesota, and so we are going to talk with them now and there you go, Christine, you are live on truth wanted.
Speaker 2What's going on?
Speaker 5He you doing?
Speaker 4What's going on? It is Friday evening, and I'm so glad to be done with the work week.
Speaker 2Yes, me too, Me too, Christine.
Speaker 1I'm really glad that we're doing this segment, and I'm glad that you get to be a part of this segment. So Christine, tell us about what you're doing in the community.
Speaker 4Yeah, thank you so much. I'm enjoying your conversation and appreciate so much. Atheist community of Austin's interesting connecting with our group at the other end of US Highway thirty five. And I really noticed on your information and you reference community, you reference humanism, So I think we are a life minded bunch across these what's going on humanist?
Speaker 1Absolutely, and I thirty five. There's that's a that's a highway that needs a lot of humanism, let me tell you, because a lot of road rage on that highway. You know, it's not the best highway out there. You see a lot of bad stuff. So I'm glad we have that that highway connection. But anyway, please continue.
Speaker 4Yes, go through a lot of a lot of the country, doesn't it all kinds of lots of folks.
Speaker 2Yes, that's right.
Speaker 4Humanists a Man is a chapter of American Humanists Association based in Minnesota, Metro. We call ourselves a non religious or secular community for ethical living, and when I describe that to folks, I'll say, we pursue policies and practices that help all life and the planet thrive. So what we're about we do a lot of the things that I think you folks, and we would do a lot of discussing, a lot of debating, a lot of learning. We also focus a lot on community that includes between
Speaker 4each other and being with lifelinded people forming relationships because that's what it's all about, but also what we can do to help our community and our members of the community, and that's what humanist in action is about. In two angles. One is community service or a lot of projects and particularly the one that we're going to I'm going to highlight today, but also legislative advocacy. We can advocate for campaigns, but being a five oh one C three, we wouldn't
Speaker 4advocate for a person. When I said campaigns, I mean we can advocate on issues, but we wouldn't advocate for a person because we are a five OHO one C three, but we want we want to help build the world that helps all humans thrive, and that's part of how we do it.
Speaker 1Yes, and I love that and obviously you know we share in that mission as well. And it's so great that there's other groups like yourselves that are doing very important work, particularly with this campaign that I know you want to talk to us about today. We're talking about the Food Group, which is a food distributor that distributes food and mutual aid to a tiny different places. Tell us more about what you guys are doing with that.
Speaker 4Yeah, the Food Group has been around in some form or another under a different name for about fifty years. They started as a foodshelf and they ended up buying a large warehouse so they could become a they could purchase in bulk and then break out into quantity is that foodshelves can handle and then distribute it further down the line into two families. And so that's what our group has started a relationship with them years ago that we have a crew every single month and they come and they break out that food so it goes to
Speaker 4the next place to get it closer to the families thousands of pounds every year that we help distribute. So I'm really pleased to help do what we can to help our neighbors. And they've grown right now, it's really important. It's been important certainly, and probably other areas of the country, your area, probably two are realizing and finding the cost of food has gone up and it's affecting. It's affecting probably every community and more people who were perhaps okay
Speaker 4with what the cost of things were before, more are struggling. Folks who were struggling before. It's gotten even harder. So we really really need this as a resource as for now.
Speaker 2Go ahead.
Speaker 4Specifically, you probably all know what's going on in Minnesota. We have immigration agents here, thousands of them, and that's led to families being afraid to be out because these folks are kidnapping first and asking questions later, if at all. So people who look like they might be on their list of interest, doesn't matter if they really are, doesn't matter if they're an actual citizen or have some form of legal status. They will grab them up and detain them.
Speaker 4And so people many are afraid to go to work, but some are going to work. But if you don't go to work, you don't get paid. Some folks might be going to work, but they are afraid to go to the grocery store and so they're not getting the food they need. They're really struggling with that. Food Group has stepped up and built on their relationships with the foodshells and added in mutual aid groups, which is people residents of the community making donations, not through other bigger
Speaker 4food chain. And what the person is the Food Group told me this week is that on the list of folks who are seeking help is twenty seven thousand families. That's the size of a small city. And restaurants are kind of shutting down. Lots of businesses are really hurting because folks are afraid to go out in the community. Wow, the Food Group folks tell me they can get food, but it's getting it then to the families that need it that is the problem. So more people needed because
Speaker 4more people aren't working. And that's what our effort is now. I mean food to the central right, so's to help they need.
Speaker 1It absolutely, And so how can people help out if they want to help out and they are not a part of your organization right now? What if they're listening here in Texas. Can they do anything?
Speaker 4Oh, yes they can, Yes they can. You may have the page that we shared because the Food Group created a campaign page for us for this this donation effort. I don't know. Do you happen to have that?
Speaker 1Yes, we do, and in fact we we should be displaying it. I think we're displaying it right now on our on our screen. So and we also have information in our description as well.
Speaker 4Okay, so there is an address. It's give dot MN forward slash and like Nancy zero, are like Robert p like Peter I likes ice cream, g like George on that campaign page. If that really gets to be a problem the Food Group mn dot org, they'll take it there too. It would maybe connect with the campaign we're doing. But hey, they need that those funds doesn't matter how they come in the door. It's really really appreciated.
Speaker 2Awesome, Christie.
Speaker 1I want to ask you one more question before we let you go today, and thank you so much for talking to us about this opportunity that you that you've been been a part of. You know, you who are a humanist right and so when you're volunteering for this, are you doing this because you're hoping you get to go to heaven afterwards or what's you know, what's the motivation for you.
Speaker 4Let me try to put this into words. I haven't been asked in that way. It's certainly true that I'm not expecting anything in the future. I'm expecting it because these are my neighbors, these are my fellow humans, and when I walk down the street, I always look to make a connection and look them in the eye and give them a little smile. These are our fellow beings on this planet. I can't imagine not helping.
Speaker 2I love that. That's that's that's so great. I was being my answer.
Speaker 1My question was so facetious, and you answered so beautifully. I almost feel bad now for being joking, as.
Speaker 2It was a serious response to a very look.
Speaker 1I know it was just like I'm over here just making jokes, but we're talking about like a really awesome causing Christie. I'm so glad that you got to highlight that with us on the show. Like I said, we'll have more information in this scription of this program, and you know, definitely, folks, if you want to help out with other nonprofits like the Humanists Minnesota and groups like the food group. You know, definitely check it out. And also if you like to shout out your own opportunity that you think would be great to talk about on
Speaker 1this program, you can do that. You can email us at Spotlight at Atheist Hipancommunity dot org and we'd love to share some of your opportunities on the program. So Christine, thanks so much for being on the show today. Anything else you want to say before we let you go.
Speaker 4I thank you so much for this opportunity. I'm so glad that I don't remember which person in atheist community Boston reached out, but I love having connection, just love it. You can. You can never have too many friends. So thank you all. I now have you you all on my radar.
Speaker 3Absolutely, thank you for all the work that you are doing. Yes, we're on a show, you're out there feeding people.
Speaker 1That's right, that's right. We're doing the easy thing. We're inside, you know, talking to the microphones, and you're out there doing stuff. And we want to send as many people as we can your way. So thanks again for talking to us. And shout outs to all the folks in the area in Minnesota right now, who are you know living their best lives or trying to Okay, we see you, we see you. So thanks again, Christy. We're gonna go ahead and let you go and hope to hear from you again sometime. I want to see what's going on with that. Gosh, what great opportunity. And again, folks, if
Speaker 1you have your own opportunity that you want to shout out, check out that email address I mentioned at spotlight at Atheist hyphen Community, because is we want to highlight folks in the community. We want to make sure that we're trying to do our part by at least pointing the way right to things that you can do to help out. What were you going to say to that, clever gestid.
Speaker 3I was just going to say, like, like, if you are out there and you are wanting to help, like we can't all go out and start our own organizations, but we can support the ones that are out there. There are people in Minnesota who are struggling. There are people not just in Minnesota, but especially in Minnesota who are struggling with what's going on in the world right now, and there are absolutely places and people that are out there helping them. And the more you can help and support those organizations, so people are getting food, they're getting you know, any sort of of of legal aid they
Speaker 3may need for whatever issues they may have going on.
Speaker 2Any of that stuff is it's so valuable. It's so valuable.
Speaker 3If you have the means and the ability, please please find find something and and when we find it, we'll we'll let you know about.
Speaker 2It, just like just like we did today.
Speaker 1Yep, that is super super real. So yeah, thanks so much again Christine for being on with us today. I want to go ahead and move on to another caller then just get straight to it. You want to just keep keep it moving. Let's go right, let's get on. We do have now, Kelly, hold on, Kelly before we get to this next call, can I get Kelly back up here again? Sorry, Kelly, you know, I know you're sorry. We just unlocked this cage. Oh there is okay, he's already out there. Hey, Kelly, Kelly you doing good? Man good, I'm good. We had a bet going right, We had
Speaker 1a bet.
Speaker 7Going yes, Yes we did. Yes, we over the terms.
Speaker 2Of this bet Kelly that we had.
Speaker 8You and I I don't think we actually gave heads, you know, like what we were going to do for each other. And I thought that as I recall it, bet was for how long it would take?
Speaker 2Yeah?
Speaker 1Yeah, and what was your what was your prediction?
Speaker 2What was your guess?
Speaker 8I was thinking it was going to take about three months as our call.
Speaker 2Yeah.
Speaker 1What we're talking about, folks, is I'm missing so much contact we do have.
Speaker 2Calling us again? Oh okay?
Speaker 1John Canada said that he was not going to call the show anymore. He said he was done with it, and I said, we'll give it a few months. I wish I wrote down exactly how long it was.
Speaker 8I think we both agreed that it was going to be like six to twelve weeks or so around.
Speaker 1I think it was six and twelve weeks something like that. I don't know if for quite in that time, rage, but we're pretty close. I'd say, John, you you're live on truth. Wanted what's up?
Speaker 9Man?
Speaker 1I thought you were going to call the show anymore?
Speaker 7Hi? John?
Speaker 2Hey John?
Speaker 9Before I answer that question, I want to bet.
Speaker 2I don't you know?
Speaker 1I again, we didn't write down we should we should?
Speaker 7Yeah, we didn't.
Speaker 1We should have put it on poly market because.
Speaker 3I'm gonna put money that Kelly won the bet. That's my bet. I bet that Kelly won the bet you.
Speaker 1I think you were sooner than me. I think my estimate was a bit more conservative. That's what I remember. It doesn't matter, John. But here's here's the thing. We both said that you were going to call back, and you are calling back right now.
Speaker 2So what's the deal?
Speaker 6Man?
Speaker 2I thought you were working. What do we got anymore?
Speaker 9I really meant that. But you know, I miss you guys. Plus I have something important to say.
Speaker 2Cool, Okay, that's it. You just you missed this something important?
Speaker 9Did you miss me?
Speaker 7I did?
Speaker 1I gotta tell you, I explains.
Speaker 2It's hard.
Speaker 1It's hard to say I missed you, and I knew you were going to be coming back, you know, any day now, So you know, it's just it worked itself out.
Speaker 2What can I say? Yeah, But what I'm really curious, what do you What do you got for us? John?
Speaker 3What did I inspire you with my request for pseudo historical claims?
Speaker 9Because like, what I want to say is that the people in New York to make a big mistake in hiring there.
Speaker 2Well, that we that's that's not that's not not what you said you want about John? You want that's also not in the realm of this This plan.
Speaker 3We can't we can't talk about one three. We don't talk about politics here. There are plenty of places.
Speaker 9We'll talk about mystical heroes.
Speaker 1I heard yes earlier. Thank you, thank you for following through with what you told our call screener. You would talk to us about like you should do. Thank you, Thank you.
Speaker 9John.
Speaker 1You've called in maybe more than anybody else. You know the rules. That's how we do things, right. So anyway, tell us about this this idea that you have.
Speaker 9Okay, you speaking, and you're saying that people like Odysseus and well, Odysseus and Ucs are the same person, but people like the Dycus Heracles were may have been real people, but they were what's were looking for it. They were exaggerating me. They look better than they are. Absolutely, And I remember remember imagine five movie Brave Punch, Yes, yeah, okay. In that very film, Bray Park played by Mel Gibson, he's uh leading his troops and none of the troops know how brave part looks like. So when he's there,
Speaker 9they're they're saying like they're saying like okay, when you're sare leaving him, he says, I'm William Wallace, So like that you're not William Wallace. William Wallace is ten feet tall, and and then William wall comes off saying, yes, he's ten feet tall, he can get lays out of his eyes and far after that, meaning meaning that that the stories were exaggerated within that narrative.
Speaker 2So that was within that.
Speaker 3Individual same lifespan too, So like imagine active had a couple of decades or a couple hundred years.
Speaker 9Yeah, that's exactly my point. So I'm assuming that's what just talking about with Jesus, right, I mean, he may have be an ordinary man that was given super human powers by over the years by his followers. I'm assuming that's what you're talking about.
Speaker 3That's what I would find to be the much more plausible and realistic answer to the question of did Jesus exist? Sure, but we have no reason to believe that he was any more anything more than a guy who said things that people liked, and therefore they put him up on a pedestal and exaggerated the hell out of them, just like happens to everyone else who was put up on a pedestal in history.
Speaker 1It doesn't just happen in history, it happens today, And I brought this up a million times before, John, But you know, I'm from the Waco area, and you know David Koresh his followers remember that thing in the nineties.
Speaker 9Some of them ever slive.
Speaker 1Yeah, they're still alive, and a lot of them still live in Waco, and a lot of them still say that he was the Messiah. And you know what, they'll tell you about things that he did that were miraculous, about how he appeared to them in dream and how he touched them, and how they felt better and had these visions. I mean, these are contemporary living people that have these stories. Can you imagine a world free internet free uh act check in prete mass writing and reading, right, what kinds of stories can be told about people? You know,
Speaker 1it's it's really not that hard to imagine when you consider it like that.
Speaker 8And Jesus wasn't the only uniquely the only religious figure that had that happened. You could say the same thing about Mohammed Loudsa. Just about every religious zoro aster also had a lot of about who he was and what he did. So you know, just about every every religious founder has these mythicized myths, thesements.
Speaker 9But here's my find. Here's my find. Interesting in the twentieth and twenty first centuries, we have men men like with the Christ like you just mentioned that can actually convince people, adults that they are gods. How is that boss?
Speaker 1Well, a lot of people to ask themselves that question. I think that's kind of beyond the scope of our expertise. But if you'd ask my opinion, I'd have to say, some people are psychologically vulnerable.
Speaker 2And all people are.
Speaker 1All people are some people more so than others in certain areas, right, And some people have a needs that can be fulfilled in cult communities. You know what people in cults say. People a lot of times they say they're great. A lot of times they say they're happy, you know, and maybe look that they realize things weren't as great. But if you're convinced that you're happy in the moment, you're going to be happy in the moment. I mean, that's that's that's what it is. Cults provide a lot of psychological needs and also material needs for people. Uh so, I you know that that's a big reason
Speaker 1why definitely one of them, I think.
Speaker 5So.
Speaker 3I think it's it's people are are very subject to this, we are or certainly don't seem to have been a species that has come into existence, however you think that happened with the ability to have a very good measure of reality. We're really bad at parsing out fact and fiction, and that explains so much about all of human history. And for us to think that any of us are are above that fault in our cognitive function, it is
Speaker 3I think, kind of a degree of narcissism. Like no one is subject to being right about every or no one is, no one is, no one is capable of not being wrong. Everybody is wrong about something. And that's what we talked about earlier when we talked about historical facts. I was talking about this, if everybody has a historical fact that they know that's probably wrong, almost certainly wrong. And that's not just true about historical facts. That's true about so many things. We are often wrong about our relationships with people, We're wrong about how we remember events happening. We're wrong about everything all the time. The only way
Speaker 3we're ever closer to truth is when we amalgamate all of this information from lots of different people and we put it into a spreadsheet, and then we check it, not literally a spreadsheet be given point.
Speaker 9Yeah, where do you think John is the beetheffs MA team being wrong about something and thinking that someone has divine powers? But what I think is that when someone is weak and vulnerable and they approached someone and they made them feel better, you can pretty much to make them do whatever you want. But we humans were superstitious people, like we believe in full of these clovers. We believe in lucky rabbits when up on star and I guess, I guess cultlers tap into that. But it's really dangerous. Was really dangerous is when this cultler asks someone to
Speaker 9give up their autonomy and eventually their lives for the cause.
Speaker 5Why is it?
Speaker 4Ye?
Speaker 2Sorry?
Speaker 8But when I was in college, I was I was at a party one night and I was with my roommate and we were talking about this jury thing. Why do why do people follow other people? Why do they believe things like that? And he said, you know, you can get anybody to do just about anything as long as you talk with an authoritative voice. And I was like, that's not true, and he goes here, watch this, and he walked into the next room and in a are you authoritative voice? He told everybody they had to get up and walk into the kitchen, and everybody fucking did it. Yeah,
Speaker 8they didn't even question it, they all just did it, you know. So, I mean it's it's kind of like apparently human nature for most people to just listen to authority figures and follow yeah.
Speaker 1Or just everybody saying, hey, this guy's really smart, this guy knows what he's talking about, and people just leave the hype.
Speaker 2How how many times has that happened?
Speaker 5You know?
Speaker 1How many how many startups have started that end up being huge scams because hey, people believe the hype.
Speaker 5You know.
Speaker 1It doesn't have to be religious in nature, right, It can be claims about all kinds of things. I mean, look at the Apostle Paul. That guy didn't even meet Jesus, you know, and he was like, yeah, this guy's awesome. But you know what, he also felt very guilty about stuff. He talks about how he held the coats of the people who stoned Christians to death. Right, so maybe him following Jesus was him sort of atoning for some of that guilt. Again, it goes back to that psychological element. There's a lot of complex reasons why people end.
Speaker 2Up in cults.
Speaker 1You know, it's not just for one or it's going to be a lot, But the fact is it does happen, right, and it's still happening. So people apologize from history. Yes, Jesus is one of those people.
Speaker 3And I think if I was to answer your question directly, John, like, how could you ask how could people believe that people can be gods? How could people give up their autonomy to someone who makes that type of claim. People give up their autonomy to trinkets that they think are imbued with magical properties. People give up their autonomy to lucky rabbit's feet and lucky underwear, Like, why is it such a surprise that people give up their autonomy when they're already primed to believe in supernatural things and that people that there is entities out there that exist, that are deities,
Speaker 3that this one, this person happens to be one of them, and therefore they should have power and control over my life.
Speaker 2It's really not a far stretch.
Speaker 3People give up autonomy to to an entity regularly, especially religious people.
Speaker 2Right, They're constantly giving up their autonomy.
Speaker 3The only difference between the guy in Waco and and the average Christian is at least the people in Waco could point to a person and that person we actually know exists and it actually knows says the things that they said, right, Like, how is it surprising that they give up autonomy there? And it's not just in religion that we see people do this. People do this in business, people do this in in you know, government institutions like like like happens.
Speaker 2All the time.
Speaker 8Another factor might be that almost every major religion teaches that were there's going to be a teacher who comes into future, right, so Messiah in the future, we have the second coming of Jesus, the Mahdi and Islam, Kelki and Hinduism, you know, so a lot of these major religions are teaching that there's going to be this person. So people who follow this religion are going to be on the lookout for this person and they're just being conned by really good convent basically. So, but there are but they're already being conditioned to look for this person
Speaker 8who's going to be this Messiah, this great prophet.
Speaker 2Right, yeah, there you go. Wow, final thoughts on this, John, what do.
Speaker 9You think, Well, we all give up our time in to something with someone for instance, when you join the company, you give up your autonomy to your boss. If you go up your timmy to your commanding officer. When you get married, you go up your timmy to your spouse. I get my marriages. Is that you get what you what you're contracting for. I'll do change.
Speaker 1Well usually, I mean it depends on the marriage. But yeah, I got a two year old.
Speaker 2I didn't. I did not know what I was, what autonomy I was.
Speaker 5Yeah, I didn't.
Speaker 1I didn't sign any contract with my wife that said you know, uh anything like that. But you know, I get your point. I get your point John for sure. Okay, well, so what does this mean John, just me and you're gonna be calling the show again or what?
Speaker 9Let's let's let's go, let's decide where we go from here.
Speaker 1Okay, okay, all right, Kelly, what do you think I'm gonna say within the next five weeks?
Speaker 7I was gonna say three okay, three weeks. I was gonna I was gonna play let me win J.
Speaker 2To you.
Speaker 3So I was going to point out that that in our in our little super secret host only chat, we were told that John actually called in last week, so uh, you know, yeah, But I was, I'd say next week.
Speaker 1Then I wasn't here last week, so I didn't get to see it. So that's that's okay.
Speaker 9Well I hope, I hope I made the day for one of you.
Speaker 2Yes, John, thank you.
Speaker 7John made day.
Speaker 1Yes, I agree. There you go, folks, there's John.
Speaker 8Well, it's so nice to have a have a conversation with John, so like three years ago, the contentious I know, right back and forth that we had.
Speaker 1You know, it's yeah, what an interesting uh turn of events. You know, folks, you can change your mind on things. Can't happen even if you don't think people can.
Speaker 2They can.
Speaker 7But we're all, we're all on a journey.
Speaker 5Man.
Speaker 3I was really hoping he was going to come in and say, like, like Hercules, specifically the Disney version is actually the accurate representation of the store mercules.
Speaker 2Yeah, that's what I was hoping for. I don't know what his ankle was going to be. But then but then he talked about about Braveheart.
Speaker 3Oh my god, I can go on tangents about about Brave Hearts as an absolute garbage historical account.
Speaker 1Yeah you don't say really now, yeah, brave I have I have.
Speaker 3A bone to pick with every historical fiction film that does not state very explicitly that they're playing very fast in.
Speaker 2Those are the rules. I guess, so I maybe, and you know what, you got to have these disclaimers for a reason.
Speaker 1But out of all the like historical movies out there, I I never thought that Brave Heart was exactly the most accurate history. But maybe that's just me. I don't know.
Speaker 3I grew up like like fundy and like like with Passion of the Christ and all that stuff coming out, and like all all that being through through uh mel Gibson as well. Because that mel Gibson did both movies like it gave credibility to a young, dumb me.
Speaker 2I'll tell you that that makes sense. I can see that.
Speaker 1Before we get to our next caller, I need to give a few quick announcements here. One, if you want to support the show, you should check out tight it out to slash merch Aca for shirts, hoodies, mugs, hats, etc. And another way to support us is to send super chats. If you're watching this on YouTube, you should get them in and we will read as many as we can as long as they are YouTube appropriate. Of course, you can also become a channel member by clicking the join button blow of the video, which gives you access to special chat emojis and early access to YouTube shorts and clips. Last,
Speaker 1but not least, I have to give a quick shout out to the wonderful, fantastic, stupendous, amazing crew that helped make the show happen every single week.
Speaker 2Thank you to the.
Speaker 1Video operators, audio operators, the mods, the note takers and call screeners, and just the folks that are around when we need them for last minute tasks and duties, which happens quite a bit. So thank you guys for all that you do. And if you want to be one of these very attractive crew members. They wrote that here in the notes. By the way, didn't I didn't come up with that.
Speaker 2He was actually obligated to say it. Actually, yeah, that's right.
Speaker 1You can be a volunteer or possibly a guest on one of our shows. We're always looking for more people. You go to volunteer at Atheist Hyphencommunity dot org if you want to get involved with that. So thanks again everybody. Let's go to our next caller. We have Jim calling in from Florida who's been patiently waiting on the line with us. Thank you so much, Jim, you are live on truth. Wanted what did you want to talk to us about today?
Speaker 5Awesome? Well, first person, let me comment, Kingdom of Heaven is an amazing show. I don't know if you if you got it and kind of one that is is not biased. I don't know what your perspective is on that.
Speaker 2I have not seen that. Have you guys seen that? Kingdom of Heaven?
Speaker 5I Orlando Bloom?
Speaker 1Okay, all right, I'm looking. I'm googling this.
Speaker 2I see Okay, I'm five. This was post post.
Speaker 1I was about to say Star Wars.
Speaker 5I mean, you guys brought this. I mean it's a it's a factual based account of you know, the the one of one of the you know, the the Ninth Persodes community this year.
Speaker 1So the Wikipedia says, this is a film is a portrayal of the events to the Third Crusade, focusing mainly on the Gallion of Ibelin, who defend who fights to defend the Crusader Kingdom of Jerusalem from the Ayud Sultan Salad Dean. Okay, all right, so absolutely, I have seen this movie.
Speaker 2It is a good movie. It is a fun watch. I am not.
Speaker 3While my background isn't history, I was a history teacher for ten years. I'm not an expert on this particular period of history, but as a historian, as someone of the history background, as someone who's taught history. The issue that I end up having with all of these films is that they take a general thing and they fill in a lot of things with tidbit that help them tell the story they want to tell, and whenever those things don't match historical reality, that's they ignore it. They just kind of push on past it. You get misrepresentation
Speaker 3of historical figures, you get a false timeline of events, all of these things. What we often see is people will see like, oh, well, they made the set and the people look like they're in the right historical setting. Their armor's right, the settings are right, the set and the people all kind of look like they're doing the things like the peasants all look peasanty enough. But when we actually look at what we know about the history of these people, it never ends up panning out accurately. And again, that's fine as long as you're honest about it,
Speaker 3like bluntly honest about it, not like like the generic based on historical events or based on a true story.
Speaker 2That is that is that is such a cop out?
Speaker 5Yeah, I wasn't calling about this, but I mean my perspective. My perspective though, was that at least it portrays solid and it portrayed an equal.
Speaker 2It doesn't.
Speaker 5It's not you know, pro Christian or a pro is long.
Speaker 2You know, I gotcha, I gotcha, and I know you weren't here to call that. Let's get to the topic that you do want to talk about.
Speaker 9I have.
Speaker 5I called about we off an anniversary is two hundred and fifty years of our country coming up, and and so I'd like to get the three gentlemen here, and I'd like to get your perspective since it seems like somehow, some way we're getting driven into that we are a country founded on Christianity.
Speaker 2And that didn't get excited here?
Speaker 1Is that is that your believer that we're a contradition, believe that we are on Christianity.
Speaker 2No, no, no, no, no, no no no no.
Speaker 5I'm a Deist. I've been a Deist. I've been a Deist for twenty years. And so I was raised Greek Orthodox, and you know, I branched out went through my pilgrimage, know where I'm at spiritually and so, and I'd like to get your guy's perspective on this because it seems to be something that is a crux in my boot.
Speaker 4Yeah.
Speaker 1So yeah, I mean there's there's a lot of I mean, so you know, this is something that atheist commentaries had asked about a lot. The first thing that I always talk about is the Treaty at Tripoli, which which explicitly says that America isn't a Christian nation. Now that's not the constitution, right, it's something else. So some people will make that argument. And obviously, obviously, obviously America was very much so culturally Christian at the time, right, there's no argument there. But a lot of people are pointing out that a lot of people who made some of the founding documents, including the Founding fathers, were very much very secular,
Speaker 1very progressive people in many instances for their time. Not all of them, there's a wide range of views, but they certainly weren't all evangelical Christians. So it's hard to say how what we could say when we say it's a Christian nation. If anything, it's an example of a more secular nation being built, and I think that that's what a lot of scholars who have talked about this on end would point to, is that they really made a deliberate effort to try to make this a secular nation, not led by any particular religion. But I know for
Speaker 1fact that flabbergasd has a bone to pic with this topic. So yeah, go ahead, Flabbergas.
Speaker 3I have so many i feel like I'm eating eating fish. I'm just picking the bones out, like yeah, in numbers here and those. First off, Treaty of Tripoli, right, it's not the Constitution, no, but it was drafted under Washington, signed under Atoms, and was unanimously agreed upon by every member of the United States legislation at the time under the phrasing that they are explicitly not a Christian nation. So even if it's not in the Constitution, the understanding of every member of government under Washington and under Adams
Speaker 3at the federal level did not see America as a Christian nation is extremely telling. So so that's the first point. Treat you triple A, the the entire argument that it's a Christian nation because the founders were Christian and they all had Christian ideas, and they had Christian beliefs and all that stuff is really not very well.
Speaker 5I know that because I know that because because most of our founding fathers or Dias, Franklin, Payne, Well, George, George Washington never took communion. Monroe, Madison, and Adams was Unitarians. So I mean, you you have most of them who are founding pothers. I'm tired of us getting split or getting moved to this to this place.
Speaker 2Yeah, yes, I hear you.
Speaker 3Let me let me tell you why though specifically, that's such a bad argument from the other side, right, Like I understand that you you're you're on the same page as me here, right, But it's such a bad argument because everyone was Christian, and they're saying, well, because they were Christian and they created something, that the thing that was created is because of Christianity. But like, if you're going to attribute that, then everything like the Follmer's Almanac was a Christian book by the same period of time, because that was also written and put together and created by Christians or Christian views and Christian doctrine. But when we look at the things that the foundation of the
Speaker 3American system was built on, it was explicitly not Christianity. It was explicitly based on a movement that was a movement away from actively and intentionally away from Christianity and away from religiosity.
Speaker 2It was based off the Enlightenment movement, and the.
Speaker 3Enlightenment movement, while it was almost entirely comprised of Christians, was Christians separating themselves from their Christianity towards more humanistic types of views of the world. So everybody, But you can't say the Enlightenment was Christian because everyone in Europe was Christian, because if you weren't Christian, you were imprisoned, killed, stripped of titles, and rites like you don't get to exist in Europe in the fifteenth and sixteenth and seventeenth century a Christian not in a meaningful way. So like that doesn't tell us anything. The movement is away from Christianity,
Speaker 3away from religiosity, towards humanistic approaches, separating government from religion, separating people from God in so many ways. Even if even if it wasn't it this dissemble beliefs.
Speaker 2Go ahead, Jim right. Sorry.
Speaker 5In my perspective too, is that I think in declaration of Bendependent, I think there's only four mentions of God, and in none of which mentioned anything that has to do with Jesus has to mention with anything above that. It's about a creator, it's about under one God, it's about.
Speaker 1Yes, yes, the Declaration of Independence does. But the US Constitution, in the Constitution, same thing, right now.
Speaker 2Well, there's no mention of God God in the Constitution.
Speaker 1Yeah, right, Okay, that's a critical thing, because the Declaration of Independence is not a legal document, right. I think a lot of Americans get that confused, because.
Speaker 5How we how are we any twisted?
Speaker 2How are we getting get twisted?
Speaker 1Because Christian nationalists have an agenda to make that into the public education in the same way that they have an agenda to teach that evolution isn't real and that you know, the Bible is the way, the truth in the life, and that two.
Speaker 7Yeah, it's only six thousand years old.
Speaker 1If you convince people that America can only exist because of Christian values, then why wouldn't you want to be a Christian?
Speaker 2Right?
Speaker 1Why wouldn't you want to be a part of that?
Speaker 4Right?
Speaker 3It also gives you, It also gives you a way of excluding and pushing out and pushing away anyone who isn't Christian, who isn't going to conform that idea?
Speaker 2Yeah, exactly.
Speaker 1Yeah, it gives people an out to say, if you're not Christian, you're not American.
Speaker 5Right.
Speaker 1I mean this is an implicit bias. It's not set out loud, but how many people post nine to eleven looked at their Muslim neighbors and said, these people aren't American and don't belong here, right? I mean that's just one example. But there is a Christian nationalist bias that is rearing its head again in recent years. It's always been there, but it's become even more prevalent in recent years. And it's it's quite a scary thing.
Speaker 2But that's our take.
Speaker 5Jim, what do you think, Well, it's it's the it's the ten percent of the United States that has the loudest arm. And what's going on right now is you have that, but that population is going down. What happens is if you guys have seen there's MTD moralistic therapeutic deism that is taking spring in the youth that's out there, which wants they want a higher power to believe in.
Speaker 5They want to feel that they can be happy in life and feel good and they want to give back to society and they want to feel that by bringing so they can get to a higher place. I mean that that's basically that, That's basically what it is.
Speaker 6And and and at least the ones you've talked to, right, yeah, yeah, no, no, no, not not what I've talked to, there's been there's been well, well the moralistic therapeutic deism, which.
Speaker 5Was a social it was someone that did they they took a panel. It was a social, it wasn't an it's a non religious. Someone from Notre Dame did this and they they paneled five thousand teams from you know, eighteen to twenty five, you know, five thousand what do you what's important to you? And that's what they come up with, is those those things that they want to do,
Speaker 5they they want but they want that sense of community, they want a sense of giving back, they want a sense of happiness. But they still believe in in that higher you know that they will get to that place. And so you know, that's that's where we are in society. And so we have to decide, you know, how can we bridge that gap? I mean, but we have this division of you know, of this complexity of of where
Speaker 5we are now. And so I'm in a perspective I'm trying to bring deism back and in some some form and fashion, and I and I get it. Like you guys, you know those are that are in a in a position that if you don't, if you don't believe in a higher power, you know, none of us know not you know, none of us know.
Speaker 2So you know why why.
Speaker 5Has? But fifty percent of us are agnostic? So how many of you are agnostic? Look, I've been on your channels before. Some of you are are on the agnostic sides of we're all We're all in this agnostic side because I'm I'm in this agnosis steal, which is which goes back to the start of the mankind, which is, you know, there was a thirteenth God that says that that there was someone who was an unknown God that
Speaker 5we don't know. That's what I believe in.
Speaker 1Okay, Well, Jim, you know, we could talk about the specifics of that belief all day, and that's fine. You know, I'm not particularly interested in doing that right now. We certainly can't. But yeah, here's what I want to know, because you're calling into this show you. You're having friendly conversation with us. Clearly you're agreeing with most of our points. What are you going to do, as as the god believer amongst us, to help us right now? Because you see that there's a problem, right like you do see that Christians by and large are making this nation worse.
Speaker 2I mean, do you agree with that?
Speaker 4Well?
Speaker 5I know that the God that screened me said not to be too you know, relative on but I don't. We can't.
Speaker 1We don't talk about policy ticians, but we can talk.
Speaker 5About I will say, I will say absolutely, of course we're on the second page.
Speaker 1Here, here's the problem, right, I go to the local church. I'm a heretic, I'm a heathen, I'm a hero. Nobody listens to me, right And maybe you have your own heresies, but by and large it sounds like you at least believe in a higher power. You have that connection that Kelly flabbergaid and I are never going to have. So here's what I want to know.
Speaker 2What are you doing about it? Well?
Speaker 5I'm trying to bridge the gap with with my ideas fellowship across the planet and try to because what happens is we're not a religion we're basically a spiritual.
Speaker 3Sorry, just for clarification, if I may, I'm sorry when you say you're trying to bridge the gap? Are you talking about bridging the gap between your position and the Christian nationalist position, our position and the Christian at position, the gap between you and other ds?
Speaker 4Like?
Speaker 2Like, I'm very confused about what gap you're trying to bridge?
Speaker 7And and and as a follow up, how is how do you manifest that?
Speaker 2Yeah?
Speaker 7How do you make that happen?
Speaker 5How do I make that hot? I'm happy?
Speaker 4Well?
Speaker 2First, what what? What gap?
Speaker 5First?
Speaker 7The first explain the gap? What gap it is?
Speaker 5None?
Speaker 7Explain how you how you plan I'm bridging the gap?
Speaker 5I mean, I apologize. I'm like trying to understand the gut. So, so when we're talking about so the fellowship between you know, those that I that I'm part of, there's most so so.
Speaker 1Let me let me break it down for you real quick. Okay, let me let me help you out here. I'm not chill with a lot of Christians right now. Right, I'm chill with Christians in my personal life right but we're talking about Christianity of the national stage. I'm not really thrilled with it. Right, it's not really serving my interests, let alone the interests of my friends and family and people that I care about rights. In fact, it actively seems to make people's lives worse, whether it's restricting people's rights to abortion and other forms of health care, whether it's getting religious ideas into public schools right, or or
Speaker 1taking out scientific curriculum in schools. I mean, I could make the list all day, plus community sure, and and and again, we could make a.
Speaker 2List of grievances all day.
Speaker 1Why should I listen to the deist position on anything if it's not going to help me dismantle you know, the problems at hand, right, I mean.
Speaker 2Maybe there is a God, sure, but what are they good?
Speaker 1What are the people who are believing in God but aren't chill with what's happening? What are they doing about the stuff that's happening?
Speaker 5Right?
Speaker 1Because you already talked about this, you said there's a lot of people that are saying America's forward on a Christian nation, and it's it's driving you crazy because you know it's not true. Right, I would say that's one sin on a list of one hundred that's happening.
Speaker 5Right there, right, So, so so Dan, let me let me ask you, like counting people out there that that say they're spiritual and they're not religious?
Speaker 1Yeah, tons of people absolutely, So so where do you think they fall into in terms of what what.
Speaker 9Do you mean?
Speaker 1Where do you think they fall into their ideas?
Speaker 5There?
Speaker 2Yeah, I wouldn't say that, but they wouldn't I would.
Speaker 5Say at all.
Speaker 7They my mother, she was my mother.
Speaker 5In let in, let in, unless they're spiritual and less and lesser astrologists or lesser focused on icons or there.
Speaker 1That's a million you just listen to a bunch of pogies seriously.
Speaker 5Or anything like that. That that then those people for thirty twenty five percent of Christians in in our ourdeas, they don't realize it because deism has been extinct. Also, if I'm here, I.
Speaker 1Don't let flobber guests to speak in a second here, But you know, you asked ten different people their spiritual not religious? What that means you're going to get eleven different answer. I don't think we can put those people in a box. I think I think they have a right to reflect their own beliefs without you putting the label of oh they're a deist on there.
Speaker 6Right.
Speaker 1I think they have a right to their own identity. I may not like it, I may think it's stupid, but they are right to explain themselves.
Speaker 2I don't think you just get to say they're all deists.
Speaker 7Yes, So I don't think that's an astounch that we could make, Jim.
Speaker 2I think that is part of the problem.
Speaker 3First Right, So first off, you're looking at these people and saying, they say this, but I'm calling, hey on, Jim, give me just the second place.
Speaker 1Place, m hey on, Jim, I said, I want to speak nixt.
Speaker 3I want to try and I want to try and bring this to a point so we can actually address something. Because because we're kind of talking around issues, we're being very vague in such a way it's really hard to address anating immediately, right. And so you're saying that these people are calling themselves this, but you're going to call them something else.
Speaker 2Sure, fine, whatever.
Speaker 3That still doesn't answer the question that I think is a really important one here is going back to the question what gap are we trying to bridge? Because they think that's still what we're trying to get at. Are you and and this is a yes or no question, are you trying to bridge the gap between the parts of society that are not okay with Christian nationalists and Christian nationalists.
Speaker 2Is that the gap you're talking about.
Speaker 5No, I that's now I'm trying to No, it's about the gap between those that I understand that.
Speaker 3Let's keep it, keep it simple and form laying right the gap between A and B. Please, just just so that way we know what we're addressing here, because I think that's something we're really struggling with right now, the gap between this group and which other group.
Speaker 5I'm trying to understand where you're coming from.
Speaker 1Jim, You're the one that said you're bridging gaps with people, and you.
Speaker 3Were talking about deism within that construct right like, you were talking about how deism is relevant in this conversation of bridging gaps. Yeah, and so I need to know what gap we're talking about before I can address how deism relates to it. I have all kinds of thoughts about deism, most of them aren't the nicest, but that they may not be relevant if we're just talking about, Hey, let's get Christian nationalists to be less.
Speaker 2And more like and more like like like a more more amenable to.
Speaker 3The other people in society, and if that's the gap we're talking about, if we're talking about how do we bring Christian nationalists back, and how do we use deism where we appeal to like like vague supernaturalness to get people off of this extremely toxic and harmful version of religiosity. Okay, I think deism is a way you could use that. I don't think it's the best one, but I could see how some people who hold that position might find that as a useful weapon. But if we're talking about something else entirely, I don't know how to address what you're talking about at all.
Speaker 5Well, I thought, well, I mean I I start, okay, So I mean I went from a strict you know, form of of UH Christian UH Greek Orthodox religion. And then and then I thought like, okay, I know that that's not my plight. I went on pilgrimage with with my partner and we went and we visited different places I know I need to move on to. But what
Speaker 5I'm saying is then I moved to Unitarian with which I felt was a good move. And but what I'm saying though is from where we're at in UH like society is is like there there's this place that that we have right now of the children that are growing up Okay, our kids, okay, or we when we were raised,
Speaker 5we were adopted or or we were we were brought up and we were baptized into a certain uh belief system.
Speaker 2And give you fifteen more seconds here, Jim to make your point.
Speaker 7Okay, Jim, Jim, please don't say.
Speaker 2Very very diverse.
Speaker 1Yeah, we come from very different backgrounds. But but yeah, please, if you could just finish your point, thank you.
Speaker 5I get I get it, guys. Anyway, anyways, I'm kind of losing track. But anyways, I I appreciate your time, you know, I Posliz.
Speaker 1That's okay, you know what, And you know it's not fair for you because you got one person on the other line. There's three of us on right now. But I do want to address you real quick.
Speaker 5I didn't let you go. I just I appreciate the banterer. I appreciate the you know you guys talking to me about about this side. I didn't. I didn't effectively this is my first time on here. I'm sorry. I didn't effectually communicate everything.
Speaker 1You know what, that is absolutely okay. You you don't need to apologize for anything?
Speaker 2What what?
Speaker 4I what? I you know what? I?
Speaker 1I sincerely appreciate you calling in because most people don't. Right and you decide you wanted to talk to us, and that means a lot and and and by and large it seems like we have a lot of things that we agree upon. But I just want to leave you with this before you let you go, because we do got to get moving here?
Speaker 5Is that for me?
Speaker 2Right?
Speaker 4For me?
Speaker 1That where where my emotions get up in this conversation is that neutrality always benefits oppressor. Okay, And so a lot of people are being oppressed right now because of Christianity. And when I hear the dast types such as yourself, I'm not saying this is you.
Speaker 7I don't know you.
Speaker 2When I hear this language of we just need.
Speaker 1To bridge gaps and all do kumbai ya and make people understand my version of Christianity or my version of this religion or my version of how things work, that doesn't do it for me. And the reason why it doesn't do it for me is because it doesn't go far enough. It doesn't say categorically that the things that are happening right now and this misinformation and all the stuff we were talking about is wrong and it should be considered wrong. It kind of just says, well, we can all still be Christians, but we need to do things the right way, you know, we need to do things this way.
Speaker 2And to me, that's not enough.
Speaker 1Because I'm already seeing the harm that Christianity is doing right now. So it's really hard for me to make peace with that.
Speaker 5Well, DEAs nothing to do with Christianity. It's as far away from Christianity is possible.
Speaker 2I mean, we're still talking about interacting with questions. Yeah, like so I think what I think.
Speaker 5You should do, know, I mean, desm is is far Okay, I get it.
Speaker 2Yeah, we're just talking about broadly.
Speaker 1Remember I said I wasn't specifically talking about your specific perspective, but this this kind of broad right.
Speaker 2Yeah, that's that's anyway I've said my piece on it. Jim.
Speaker 1I hope you have a wonderful, wonderful weekend, and even more than that, I hope you call again sometime because I think we have we have some great discussions in the future.
Speaker 8And we should really wish well A good a good book to read if you want to explore this subject.
Speaker 7A little bit more. Is the Founding Myth by Andrew Sidell.
Speaker 2Yeah, that's yeah. I want to give a piece of you guys.
Speaker 5Read Thomas Paine The Age of Reason.
Speaker 1Yeah, I have met it, okay, but it was.
Speaker 2A while ago. It wasn't I'll say that.
Speaker 7I know I might recommend get it.
Speaker 5Thanks what. I appreciate what you guys do. I'm serious and I listen to you. I listen to your chainel every day.
Speaker 2Thank you, thank you, thanks so much. Chief.
Speaker 1You have a great one. Oh Chi are you going to say? Flabbergast?
Speaker 3And I hope Jim catches this right, because Jim, what I think you really should do, like go back listen to what you were saying. Right, We were getting a little lost in what you were saying, and I think we definitely way to call back. But when you call back, think about exactly the point you're trying to get at. You talked about Christian nationalism, and then you talked about building bridges, and we were talking about how Christian nationalism was a problem. You were on board with that, you agreed with that. You started talking about bridges with building bridges with theism. What do you what do you mean by that who are you trying to reach? What problems are you trying to solve? Think about those things and
Speaker 3call us back and talk to us about those because we'd love to talk to you about it.
Speaker 1I'd like to know that too. I think we got a little kurt with Jim. And you know what, again, it's not fair because we're doing the three right now instead of the two and three people. That becomes a lot when you're talking to somebody, and we got a little loss in the sauce.
Speaker 3It was just a little hard because it was it was really hard to figure out where he was going. So it felt like all of us were sitting here like confused about different elements about what he's saying, and no one had an idea where it was going.
Speaker 8Yeah, right, Yeah, it was kind of general lives and nebulous. I was having a hard time getting to the point, you know, but I was thinking that when you know, Ireland was founded by pagan celts, and you never heard people say Ireland is a pagan country.
Speaker 1Mm hmm. Yeah that's true, but I mean, you know, it refers. I still see when people. I mean, culturally America was very much a Christian nature, right, I think that's where people get confused. But that's different from saying the founding principles of America are Christian values, right that That's where the apologists really get on that.
Speaker 2And I'm glad we talked about that, and I'm glad Jim agrees with us.
Speaker 1I think he agrees with us.
Speaker 3Yeah, I think we're I think he's I think he's a friend and an ally in this conversation, I think so too.
Speaker 1And you know, I'm being hard on the guy because I'm tired of it. Man, I'm tired of this thing of saying, no, we just need to make more liberal Christianity, that's the solution.
Speaker 2And it's like, oh yeah, liberalism, that's the solution or problems. Right.
Speaker 1Well, I mean I know, and he would say, well, he's not a Christian and I get that, but he's going to be more He's going to be more likely to be invited to church than I am. I'll tell you that, right.
Speaker 3I mean I tell people knocking on my door being like, hey, you want to come to our church, and I'm always like.
Speaker 2Maybe, yeah, maybe.
Speaker 1So with like, you know, since since we started doing Truth Wanted, I feel like it's just like the need for this conversation's got and even more, diary hasn't gone down right, like the Christian nationalist sort of bent on Society has not subsided, it has it has grown, it's it's it's a bit scary, and I want to know that folks like Jim are on our side.
Speaker 2That's what I really need.
Speaker 1If there's any Christians or atheist curious people watching, not sure whatever, the most important thing to me right now is not what you believe or don't believe. It's are you going to help us or hurt us when the time comes down to it? Honestly, right now, that's that's what's feeling more important to me.
Speaker 3Oh yeah, I care far more about your values and how you see everyone else in society than what you think happens after we die. If what you think happens after we die impacts in what I view to be a negative way, the way you interact with reality and those who live in society with you, then I care about those things. Yeah, But like I give me, like give me the progressive Christians who are talking who are on the same page with me about you know, like like healthcare and human rights and all of these issues
Speaker 3that truly matter. Give me those Christians who we can stand hand in hand. We can argue about whether God's real or not tomorrow, but for now, let's address this larger problem of are we going to treat people in our society humanly or not?
Speaker 5Yeah?
Speaker 1Yeap for sure, folks. We are getting towards the tail end of the show, but we're not done yet. I want to thank my co host Flabbergastid for being on with me today. Flabbergascid, thank you so much. And I know that you're also streaming this on your TikTok right, what is that tiktokh.
Speaker 2My TikTok is I'm flabbergasted zero zero one. Check me out.
Speaker 3I haven't been making stuff in a while, but I'm really trying to get back onto doing that, so yeah, please check me out.
Speaker 4I was.
Speaker 3I was in there like as a little thing, and then my TikTok closed because I hadn't touched my screen in a while and closed it. But uh, yeah, I'm Flabbergas and zeros their one yes talk about things and stuff and gods and.
Speaker 1All things and stuff and God and stuff and God.
Speaker 3And I'm starting some projects on getting deep into more historical based topics because that is like, that's my jam.
Speaker 1So fantastic. And I also need to give it thanks to our backup host Kelly for really not being your really tertiary host today instead of back up. Yeah, I'm on air than off air.
Speaker 5I think I was.
Speaker 7Mostly staying quiet on that last call.
Speaker 8I was letting you guys handle it, but there was but I did get confused by a few things. I didn't have to speak up a couple of times. So yeah, But but I always feel like three people on one caller is a little too much, so I tried. I was trying to hold back as much as I could.
Speaker 1So I agree, And you know what, that's uh, you know, we gotta consider in the future. But for now, for now you're here, and I want to thank you for that despite all of your rage.
Speaker 7Well thanks for having me here.
Speaker 2Just a rat Kelly age.
Speaker 1I think I could say that, right, I can, Greg, what's that flower acid?
Speaker 2What do you say?
Speaker 1It's a Kelly in a cage, Kelly in a cage. That's true, make it parody and it's safe. That's a nice has a nice ring to it. Kelly in a cage That sounds like a nice bartender. I'd like to get a Kelly in the cage. Yeah, that sounds what's in ally in the cage?
Speaker 5You think?
Speaker 1Probably something bitter?
Speaker 2I think.
Speaker 5I don't know.
Speaker 7Anyway, I'm going to I'm going to make that.
Speaker 3Yeahs legal in California, but not in other places.
Speaker 2Folks.
Speaker 1We need to start wrapping things up, I think before we go, Kelly, what's our our question this week?
Speaker 2Again?
Speaker 8No propt for this week is how do you know it's time to fact check wrong? Answers only yes.
Speaker 1And so leave your answer down in the comments section and we might pick out that for next week before we head out of here flabbergasted. Any words of wisdom, yeah for us. Oh, just keep looking out for the truth, Keep looking out for the truth. That's it, short and sweet. I love it, folks, I'm objectively damn. This has been another great episode of truth wanted. Remember to always keep wanting the truth, and we'll see you next time.
Speaker 2Bye bye. Watch Talk Ethan Live Sundays at one pm Central.
Speaker 3Visit tiny dot c C, slash y T t H and call into the show at five one two nine four two, or connect to the show online at tiny dot CC slash call th
In today's episode of Truth Wanted, ObjectivelyDan welcomes guest Out Of Body Atheist, with The Beard of Empathy on backup, to dig into Reiki, New Age spirituality, homeopathy, and the long road from woo to skepticism!...
In today's episode of Truth Wanted, Jon the Skeptick, Volcy, and Sofia Spina explain why no one can talk to the dead, from Haitian Vodou and grief dreams to Jon's past as a spiritualist! Bob jumps from objective...
In today's episode of Truth Wanted, ObjectivelyDan and Nintendrew, later joined by The Beard of Empathy, tackle a world run on Jesus, the magic of manifesting, and a prayer that actually got answered! Bob in NY, a...
In today's episode of Truth Wanted, ObjectivelyDan, Kelley Laughlin, and The Beard of Empathy tackle standards of evidence, miracle claims, and the false binaries of moral philosophy! Dean in VA questions why skeptics...
In today's episode of Truth Wanted, ObjectivelyDan and Chad Harris tackle Christian nationalism, police brutality, and the uncomfortable truths about racism and immigration. Big E in TN survived police brutality and...