Truth Wanted 07.47 with ObjectivelyDan and Drew Bekius
1 hr 19 minAudio
In today’s episode of the Truth Wanted, Objectively Dan and Drew Bekius gaslight us into believing Dee called to talk about communities, and then we were sidetracked by the sound of musical instruments playing the melodies of church anger. We then realized that we were not being gaslighted but had actually traveled back in time to retrieve a call from Steve to give us a boost back to the present. Dee, a secular Bhuddist in IA and friend of the show, has observed passive aggressive gaslighting when trying to join various communities. Why do people join communities if they do not want to engage? Everyone is looking for different types of communities and connections. Sometimes there is carryover from when people were Christians where they think that a community must be all things for all people. It is important to remember that not one community will meet everyone’s needs. Embrace the community that is right for you. Musical Instruments in the South East USA, had an experience with a hardcore fundamentalist pastor. When questioning things curiously, he was called an agent of the Devil and there was no need for him. Drew describes his experiences when leaving the church and offers some ways to work with anger towards people who have been mean spirited. It may take years for this anger to fade with some people and it is important to remember that you are not alone and connect to resources. Dan talks about the last time he attended church and how that frustration can help build empathy. Can the negativity inspire you to do other things? Steve, in Canada,wants to talk about time travel and asks if the earth would be in the same place if we were to go back in space. Drew has heard that the most flawless movie about time travel is called, “TimeCrimes” that is brilliantly made. Dan also mentions a movie about a group of scientists that build a time machine to go back in time and kill Jesus called, “Assassin 33 A.D.”. Steve ends the call with a plug for Recovering From Religion for anyone that needs to talk: 1-88-Idoubtit. Kelley Laughlin, our wonderful backup host, joins to help close out the show as Dan reminds us about hot sauce. Drew reminds us that tryptophan is in more than just turkey. Thank you for tuning in! Question of the week: What topic will you bring up to change the subject at Thanksgiving? Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/truth-wanted--3195473/support.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Speaker 1Hey, everybody, Objectively Dan here, and have you ever heard of the term gaslighting? One way to define gaslighting is a form of psychological abuse or manipulation in which the abuser attempts to sow self doubt and confusion in their victim's mind. And nowhere does it say that it's disagreeing with somebody misremembering something or even merely lying. Okay, So gaslighting is an ongoing attempt to undermine someone else's sanity. And when people misuse or even overuse this word, I
Speaker 1think it discredits people's real experiences of being emotionally abused. And also I also, you know, not everybody you don't get along with is a narcissist as well, just another pet peeve of mine. But hey, maybe if you disagree, you can call into the show and tell me, because we are starting right now. Hello, Hello everybody, and welcome back to another episode of Truthlanded. I am your host, Objectively Dan. This is the life I have calling show that happens every single week Fridays at SEVENBM Central Time,
Speaker 1when we talk to people about what they believe and whine. If you'd like to call us, you can certainly do so. Lines are open It is at five to one two nine one nine two four to two, or you can call it through your computer at tiny not cc slash call t W and Truth Wanted is a product of the Atheist Community of Austin, a five oh one c three nonprofit organization dedicated to the promotion of atheism, critical thinking, secular humanism, and the separation of religion and government. And every single week I always have a special guest. This week is no different. Drew beckyis joining back on the pod.
Speaker 1What's up, Drew, It's been a mini been a men.
Speaker 2Yeah, it's good to be back. Thank you for having me.
Speaker 1And you didn't get to host with me last time. You hosted with other hosts John the Skeptics, So glad you get to be on with me today. Have you been what you been up to?
Speaker 2Yeah? Doing well, doing well. You know, life keeps trucking along and as they say, and just running around like an idiot. And I think we're all just trying to stay a little sane. Sometimes it's a little bit of work.
Speaker 1That's a good, good way to summarize the last two weeks of living, I'd say. But for those who aren't familiar with you and your work. How would you describe yourself, Drew, Well, you know, give you sell yourself here?
Speaker 2Yes, yes, yeah, absolutely, Well again thanks again for having me on. So I am a former minister, evangelical minister and deconverted about twelve or so years ago. A lot of my focus now over the past decade has been working with folks working with specifically humanist communities as well as other groups. For a while I was working at the Clergy Project for those who might be familiar with that, and so that was some really great work there in
Speaker 2terms of an organization that is doing what it can to help religious leaders who no longer believe transition onto life a new new chats, new professions, et cetera, et cetera. Did some work there, but a lot of my focus over these last couple of years is specifically helping people re examine their sense of ethics. What do my ethics look like after faith? What does my life style look like after faith? And just how do I navigate the twists and turns in the road. A big part of
Speaker 2that for a lot of people's community. And so one of the newer projects I suppose you could say, we're working on here in the twin cities where I'm located, Minneapolis, Saint Paul is in putting together what we're calling post faith house parties, which if you've never been post faith, you've just never been faith period, or you're a supporter of those who don't have faith, maybe you're more lean, more pegan Wick in something along that line, but you're definitely not a fundamentalist. You have to believe what I believe.
Speaker 2It's sort of an all in heretic gathering, is what it is. But the main focus, I suppose is in developing a sense of community, organic community, just hanging out, building life, doing life together, focused on house parties, just kicking back, enjoying one another explicitly twenty one plus and all that comes with that. But it's been good. We've been doing these for a few months now, a little newer, and we're having a great time. So a lot of my furfaces on that as well as other fun things.
Speaker 1Yeah, and you know, it's funny. We were talking about this a little bit before the show. But I think this is a really good thing you talk about because I'm also former Christian right and I had this sort of same I think existential dread that I think you probably face, which is this kind of thing of what do I do now that I don't believe because church, and I say this all the time, it's not just the acceptance of philosophical propositions. It's not oh, I'm I believe in the nice and creed and that Jesus is
Speaker 1Lord and Savior. Yeah, sure, that's part of it. But it is a sense of community, it's a sense of belonging, and for me, as of life purpose, I really didn't know where I was going, what I was doing when I lost my faith, and so like there's this question of like, Okay, well now what And I think like these sort of post faith communities are really awesome for folks who are also in that same boat, right, And I think there's a lot of folks in the sort of skeptic community who kind of wonder what's the point of these And I think they typically come from folks
Speaker 1who didn't have to sort of deconstruct their entire life basically right and figure out what to do next. Because ethics in Bartigula was a huge issue for me. I just legitimately did not know what it meant to be a good person without being a Christian. I just didn't and I kind of needed to be re educated a little bit, which is a humbling thing to admit, but a necessary thing, right.
Speaker 2Absolutely, well. I mean so often we talk about deconstruction, right, and so oftentimes it begins with deconstructing our theology, whether it takes us all the way to non theism or just a few steps along the road, we start pulling pieces apart. Maybe it starts with hell, maybe it starts with whatever. But oftentimes are we deconstruct our theology, our belief in God's stuff, until maybe we no longer believe in god stuff anymore. Deconstructing and then reconstructing theology or philosophy or whatever. Oftentimes that leads to sort of a stairwell,
Speaker 2if you will, of deconstructing one thing after another. Then you're deconstructing maybe whatever your version of politics might be, whatever your version of society. Ethics, right, how does and ethics is a huge part of that? What does it look like to live an ethical, upstanding life as a human? And then from their deconstructing relationships on and on and on it goes on from their relationship structures all of these things, deconstructing, pulling the pieces apart and then saying, Okay, now, how do these fit together in a way that makes sense?
Speaker 2Now now that God has gone and Dogma removed, what does that look like? And a big part of that is community for a lot of folks, And we could go on and on about that, but there's this whole just this evolution, this work of alignment in trying to rebuild what has been for a lot of folks completely destroyed by the absence of faith.
Speaker 3Yeah.
Speaker 1Yeah, And uh, I like that you describe it as post faith because I think people are kind of in different spots. Like, you know, something I think I talk about, at least if I'm consistent, is that, like, the path of deconstruction is not necessarily a linear one. It's not necessarily oh you go from hardcore believer to atheist or whatever. For me, there was some loop de loops in there, right, And some people they're in their own kind of journeys and processes that like, you know, you can be as wide ranging in your media and wide range in your
Speaker 1talking points as possible, but you just can't reach everybody at every point in time. And I feelk like, like actually talking with real human beings about that process is probably good and probably better for people than just like listening to podcasts like parasocially relating to the people that sure list And I say that with the full irony of what I'm doing here, by the way, but just like, you know, there is a really important thing to connecting with other human beings, right like I think that's it's important to the human psyche one, but also just like I don't know, important to life purpose. I feel like
Speaker 1it's hard to find for me, at least a life purpose without defining that within myself in space, in the community of people that I'm a part of it. Now that I'm not part of a Christian community, I do sort of feel part of my life at least with folks like the atheist community of Austin and folks like yourself. And so you know, this question does get asked, like what is the point of these things? And it's for all of that and more right, having these these spaces for people to just kind of, I don't know, figure stuff out and I guess live life the best that they can, right.
Speaker 2Absolutely, I mean, so one thing we hear. So I've always tended to put a big focus on community that said when I was when I was a minister, which I was more it was a progressive evangelical If you're familiar with what at least used to be called the evangelical left, I don't know if there is such a thing anymore, or the emerging church, the emergent church. That was all the space I dwelt in as a pastor and our focus, my focus was on even as a
Speaker 2Christian minister, was this whole notion of building true, organic, vibrant community. And I viewed the purpose of the church is to build and maintain, to foster the community of Jesus followers, and in so doing to build a better world in the name of Jesus. And we can go off on whatever that meant. But the one thing that I kept on the other side of faith then was this whole idea of this restless pursuit of community. And
Speaker 2it's been in recent years I've heard over and over and over again from folks well two different responses. What you alluded to before a little earlier was you have a number of other ex Christians, ex fundamentalists, former fundies where they hear that and they're like, yes, I'm looking for community as well. Like, I hear this all the time. It's not just me. But then from those where maybe they grew up non theistic, they grew up atheist, and oftentimes the response I get. I'm sure there's exceptions, but
Speaker 2oftentimes the response I get is due, I don't get it, like I get messages all the time. So what is it with with you former Christians and you former Christians who are now atheists and you're bent on generating community? Like don't you have friends that is community? It's like, well, yes, but it feels different and it's I I How I connect these dots is when you grow up in an environment i e. The church, church world, and it tends to be I think, the more right word, the more conservative the version, the more fundamentalist the version of Christianity
Speaker 2as well other faith traditions, the more it's ground into you that you have to have community. You're built for community. Whether you use that word or not, I suppose can vary, but that big, big key point not only are you built for community, but the community, but community equals church full stop. There is no true community apart from the church. So then you grow up being constantly told this is the only one you have to have true community. You're built for true community. Two, the only way you can
Speaker 2ever find true community is being a part of the church. And now and now you start to believe it, almost like to an extent where you hear of former Christians that don't even believe Hell exists anymore, but still have this deep seated fear of Hell. I think that's something of a mirror reflection where you just you don't even believe the church is necessary more, but you still have this longing that's been built into you for community. But in your mind still community is church. Well, I don't believe in the church anymore, So how do I find
Speaker 2my community? Yes? I have friends, Yes I have hobbies, Yes I go and I play basketball on the weekends whatever, But that's not community because it doesn't feel like church world. And so there's just this constant pursuit for more of that, and it's not necessarily easy to find the solution to it. One thing I want to say, though, too, is somebody reached out to me, somebody who's becoming a good friend of mine reach out to me a few months ago, and we've gotten to hang out through these post faith house parties, and it was somebody who reached out because
Speaker 2I believe, if I'm remembering right, they reached out to me because they saw me on a YouTube show and they're like, hey, I'm local. And we talk a little bit and it's like, dude, you seeing cool as fun. Let's hang out. And he starts coming to these parties and he texted me last night and he said we're talking and he said this whole community thing. I'm paraphrasing, but said like, I'm blown away. I've been looking for community for so long and I feel like I'm finally he's starting to find some of this in secular community
Speaker 2and it's so refreshing and it's so amazing. And so I asked him a little bit about like, well, what is the what is what you're seeing? Is this secular community? What is it? Is it the house parties? What is it? And and he said he said, it's I believe if I understood right, he said, it's these these types of shows. It's ACA. It's other shows that are similar to it, where they come, they log in, they watch. He might even be logging in tonight. It sounded like he might be coming on. So this becallege.
Speaker 1We got open lines, so you know, that's for anybody, but yeah, he can tell his own story.
Speaker 2But this becomes community, you are, even though it's folks that oftentimes never meet face to face or never shake hands or exchange hugs, this is community even here. It's just maybe a little different look than sitting in a pew side by side or whatnot, singing.
Speaker 1Yeah by ah, Yeah, for sure. I mean the Internet has fostered a new sense of the meaning of community, definitely, for sure. Like the work the Active is, the work that they do as part of the atheist community Boston would not be there if the Internet was it like a thing, right, It's just it's and that's really amazing and really cool. I think that is something that I'm super super grateful for because I had the opportunity to like be in the Austin area at least close enough to it where I could, uh, you know, be a part of it. But I remember what it was like before,
Speaker 1and I remember what it was like when I didn't have that, and it sucked and it was the worst. And I just can't even compare what it felt like being a deconstructing Christian who didn't feel like I could go to anybody about the thoughts I was having and the feelings I was going through, and it was just a Podcasts were like my only friend, at least when I came to that part of it. So I'm super glad that there's folks like yourself who are willing to foster foster these communities, even if it's just a transition space. I recognize that it's a it's a passing space for most people. Even I would argue like for circonstruction, and
Speaker 1that's totally fine. I don't expect a to just be like, hey, this is my thing forever. But if it's a place that you need it and you watch shows like this one for a little bit and then you move on, that's fine too. I consider the work they're done. But yeah, it's just cool. It's really cool. On that note, Drew, we do have a question that we ask every week. It is the question of the week, and we react to your guys's answers to our question. It's that we want the truth segment of course, folks. Last week we
Speaker 1asked you guys, complete the sentence you know it's time to leave church when blank and here are some of our favorite answers Number three comes from Katie Barber four seven, who says it's time to leave church when they're on their third allegation of the month. Ooh, you might be right about that. I think, Katie Barber, four oh seven, you might be right about that. Number two comes from Demeter, who says, you know it's time to leave church when
Speaker 1the collection plate comes out. Yeah, yeah, that's that's the thing as well. Uh, you can donate to us. By the way, it's a it's.
Speaker 2A it's a don't leave.
Speaker 1That's as tectable donation to the ace of the community. Astin does help about the show, so you know what you're saying. But yes, when the collection play comes out, Yeah, that's so the think about. But number one this week comes from Miranda Rensburger, who says, you know it's time to leave church when they start talking about drinking some guy's blood. And you know what, that's fair, That is fair. It is so weird, so so weird in retrospect to think about the literal body and blood stuff. But yeah,
Speaker 1it is also funny when you look at early you know, what's surviving of early critics of Christianity, and that's something they talk about too, and I feel like they kind of even assuage that in the Gospels themselves. I think you're probably wear this year when they talk about the body stuff, like they even talk about, oh yeah, there's rumors about this Jesus guy saying how they drink of his body and stuff, and they kind of like address sit in the text, which is really interesting. How early those you know, those rumors won't around. I guess that they're vampires or something. I don't know. I don't know if they're thinking. So great response is from you guys.
Speaker 1The prompt this week is going to be what topic will you bring up to change the subject at Thanksgiving? Very curious to see next week? We will We already did our pre recorded episode for next week, just fyi, because you know Thanksgiving holiday, so we won't be reading them next week, but we will read them the week after, so look forward to that. But yeah, Drew, what what topic would you bring up for your Thanksgiving holiday to change the subject?
Speaker 2Absolutely? Well, I don't know if you heard about this yet, Dan, but did you see you may have seen a week or two ago that Costco recalled nearly eighty thousand pounds of butter because they because the butter in the ingredients label did not list that it may include milk, and so in an abundance of caution, Costco recalled all eighty thousand pounds of butter just to make sure that everyone
Speaker 2was on the same page about its contents and ingredients.
Speaker 1Okay, well, you know Costco, they got their priorities. I mean, you know that's not that's not my priority. But hey, Costco, do what you gotta do. I guess to avoid legal trouble. I don't know. That's really interesting. That is a great change of topic. I don't know what I would do because I feel like politics and stuff has been on my brain so much these last two weeks. I guess I would talk about when's the new Nintendo Switch coming? Come on, Nintendo, bring it out. It's been eight years, eight years we've had this console. I'm ready Nintendo Switch too.
Speaker 3Let's go.
Speaker 1But I don't know.
Speaker 3Let's go.
Speaker 1Believe you leave your answer below about what you would change and would love to hear it from you guys. I also want to talk about the Patron of the Week, because every single week we are always giving you guys a shout out from the Patreon. All of you guys helped make this show happen and you tell the ACA, hey, this show is a show worth supporting it. Thank you so much for that. And this week's patron of the Week is going to be from Real please that Paul Schneider. Thank you so much, Paul Schneider. Thank you to everybody that donates. If you're interested in supporting the show, you
Speaker 1can go to Patreon, tie it out, DC slash, Patreon tw and just a great shout out to everybody who sports every week. You guys are amazing for that. And with that, Don Drew, I think we should jump on to our first call. What do you say?
Speaker 2Yes, please, please, let's do all.
Speaker 1Right, let's do it. We have a friend of the show, D secular Buddhist calling in from Iowa. I believe d called in a few weeks ago, wanting to talk about some of their experiences. D you are live on truth wanted what's going on?
Speaker 4Hi again?
Speaker 2Dan? Hey de?
Speaker 1What's happening?
Speaker 4By the way. By the way, Drew, actually the escape costco toery to recall that Butter.
Speaker 2Actually, actually, what I was reading today was that though the FDA is receiving a lot of flak for that for them apparently forcing that's what everyone's assuming that the FDA forced them, But actually it's been shown that the FDA has it labeled as a voluntary recall, and that the reason why the reason why Costco. Costco came out and said the reason why they voluntarily did the recall was so that they can help build a brand of
Speaker 2honesty and transparency if they made a mistake and didn't list that milk is in the butter because they had it as cream, but they didn't specify that it was milk cream dairy cream, and so they just wanted to show, hey, you know what, for all who might be seeking to avoid dairy, let's make sure that it's there and that we focus on transparency and honesty.
Speaker 1Hey, as someone who exclusively buys vegan butter, you know, I'll say, I'll appreciate it now growth it I already go, am I go to brands. Okay. So I don't know if I'm going to be if I'm going to be looking up stuff, I'm going to you know, look it up later. But yeah, that I mean, there's something to be said about that. So hey, that's interesting. But I know you didn't call us to talk about budding, to talk to us about.
Speaker 4Well, you started out the show talking about gas lighting, and then Drew said a lot of great things about building community, and I'm I'm trying to I'm trying to revitalize the atheist, freethinker, skeptic community in my area. And so I started joining some other groups, one out on the other side of the state, and you know, I started asking questions and like, what do you guys do?
Speaker 4What what's important to everybody here?
Speaker 2What you know?
Speaker 4What are your stories? What would you like to see in a group? And I started getting some push back and a lot of passive aggressive I don't know, his passive aggressive gaslighting a thing.
Speaker 2I don't know.
Speaker 1Probably I don't know. I'm not a psychologist. I can't tell you exactly. I can only read definitions off the internet and pretend like, you know, I'm smart enough to understand the full consequences of that. But yeah, I don't know.
Speaker 4Yeah, I mean, like a couple of a couple of people are like, well, personally, I'm not interested in community. Okay, fine, you don't have to engage, that's cool. Some people are trying to read what recreate a experience? Okay, and uh, just you know a lot of negativity and I'm thinking, you know, well, if you're not interested in a community, why are you on the Facebook group? I mean pretty
Speaker 4much what people look for, pretty much what people look for when they join a group, you know. I said, you know, that's cool. You don't have to engage. And you know if you think that some people are trying to recreate church and wanted to just come right out and say so to my face, basically.
Speaker 1Yeah, and you know what for me, Yeah, what's cool about doing your own little version of a community is that you can take all the good parts about church and you can take out all the stuff that's like not as cool and do whatever you want with it. I think that's what makes it fun.
Speaker 2It doesn't.
Speaker 1There are some people who really enjoy the structure and the singing and stuff, and that's great for those folks. For me, it's like I I personally enjoyed being in a group of just like minded people that care about stuff.
Speaker 3You know.
Speaker 1So that's the cool thing when there's ostensibly no God is that you can kind of just do what you want with your space right.
Speaker 4Right, not let you know, and not end up getting stoned right, exactly.
Speaker 1Well, you can get stoned if you want. Depends on your state, I think, at least in the US here in ioland.
Speaker 2You know, d something that I hear within your comment is there's different types of community, uh there, And there really are so for some folks. And I guess with you know, having said that, that's okay, right, Sometimes we need to do. Everybody's looking for different types of community, different non theists, different atheists, different doubters, skeptics, heretics of all sorts humans. We're all looking for different types of connection,
Speaker 2different types of community. And sometimes one of the one of the carryovers from a lot of the people building seeking to build atheist community, whatever that might look like. One of the carryovers from many of us being former Christians is when we look to build community, whatever that means, we oftentimes carry with this idea that the community needs to be all things to all people, because that's what the Church was, and so we think of community as
Speaker 2being all things to all people, and so we think our communities should do that as well. And it's a carryover oftentimes from our theology that in a sense is also baked into society as a whole. It seems, but so like one just stating that's okay. We can have different types of community for different types of humans, and no community can meet everyone's needs unless it's some sort of mega org that has several very distinct and very
Speaker 2different branches and programs within it. But even then, if you get two programmed and institutionalized, then is any of it really organic or at least it becomes harder to do that. So again, nothing is going to meet everything. You mentioned atheist church, right, or something smacking of atheist church, and some people really crave that. We actually have actually the first first non theistic group to use the term humanist in a secular sense, or maybe I'll say the first time, because humanists you think of like humanism, philosophical humanism,
Speaker 2you think of Renaissance era humanism. The first time the term humanist was used in a non theistic context as opposed to theism was by a community based here in the Twin Cities. It was, for all intents and purposes, an atheist church, and they were the first ones to use They branded the term religious humanism. That spun off the AGA is secular humanism. The American Humanists Association, and that's the humanist community that I work with, help lead and teach sometimes there and so, but it is it
Speaker 2is atheist church. Like you walk in on Sunday morning, it feels like church, and it's a little too much church for me. But it's singing hymnals, singing out of the hymnal in wooden pews. It is church. But here's the thing though, most atheists former Christians who walk in there or like, they take two steps in and be like, oh, well, no, no thing. They turn around and they walk out and they're looking for a house party instead. For some people, that is what they're looking for. They crave the feeling of church, just without the God stuff. So I won't
Speaker 2go on any more about that, but just to say, embrace whatever feels right for you. Whatever it is you're looking for, will be easiest, will be the most easy for you to build because it's what you are looking for, rather than trying to build what other people are looking for. And then those who are like minded looking for the same thing, that can be a little tougher finding the other people that are also looking for it. It takes some time, but I would focus on that direction and anybody who's like, well, this isn't what I'm looking for. Great, then you go look for what you're looking for. This is what we're doing here though, I don't know if
Speaker 2that's helpful.
Speaker 4But sure, yeah it is, very very much so. And you know, I want to be open and I have I do have specific goals in mind, but I know that we've got to build a foundation first, and I think that, you know, to be oh, what do I want to say? Kind of you know, let everybody have a say, you know, and start start, you know, making those bricks and setting.
Speaker 1Up Yeah, yeah, you know what two d I couldn't tell you the names of the first people of the boarder directors of the community, Austin couldn't tell you, but their work is the reason why I'm here doing stuff today, right, And like that's what's really cool is that being a part of the community and leading a part of a community is also so that it can sustain itself and grow into its old thing, into its own thing, you know, like you don't have to be the one that has to dictate those values. They can come with from the people that are part of it themselves, right and take
Speaker 1part in that. So you don't have to feel this pressure of I got to do everything now. The whole point of community is that you don't have to do everything right. So that's super great that you're doing that work because like we really need that right now. Right I think most of us can agree that's something that definitely should be done. So very cool, very cool. D. Anything else you want to add before we let you go.
Speaker 4No, just thanks for calling me out on the butter thing. It's great to be wrong in front of so many people.
Speaker 2I apologize. I should have been more gentle with that.
Speaker 4You know, no, no, no, no, it's a joke. It's a joke.
Speaker 1Honestly, I'd be awesome if, like you go to the grocery store, are you D from Iowa? That was so funny. You were wrong about the butter thing.
Speaker 4Like you know, yeahs shouldn't I?
Speaker 1Yeah, yeah, yeah for sure.
Speaker 4Thank you so much.
Speaker 5You have a great Thank.
Speaker 2You so much. It was great.
Speaker 1Do you have a great one? Yeah? What a great call? Awesome.
Speaker 2That was awesome.
Speaker 1I love it. I love that people get so inspired to do the work because like, here's the thing, like actually doing the work, like maintaining a nonprofit, for example, it's a lot of boring stuff. It's a lot of paperwork, It's a lot of like stuff that like nobody really wants to do, but like it's so worth it for people to do it so that they can do the fun stuff like like post on Colin shows. Right, So I don't know absolutely Hell yeah, yeah, you know. It's so great hearing you talk, Drew, because I can tell there's a there's a part of my brain, my like
Speaker 1reptile brain from my Christian days that can tell that you used to be a pastor one hundred percent by the way you talk. Do you ever get that a lot from folks?
Speaker 3I do.
Speaker 2I'm apparently the way I speak, like in a talk, you know, at a conference or something like that. Apparently the way that I speak is as it sounds sermon esque. It has a certain cadence to it. So I don't think it's a bad thing.
Speaker 3By the way.
Speaker 1That's a compliment, to be clear.
Speaker 2I think people don't like it though, that's sure.
Speaker 5I can see that.
Speaker 2I like, we don't need any fucking community. You'll have others coming up. You sound like a sermon, and I don't like it. You know, you need to turn it into a lecture. Damn it.
Speaker 1And yeah, sorry, I'm like surer that some people just talk that way. I don't know, it's just kind of a thing. There's a reason why. Uh, very influential speakers. I've been pastors in the past, you know, I mean like Martin Luther King Jr. Or you know, I mean lots of folks from history, honestly. But anyway, that's a whole side tangent. We should talk to some more callers, I think. Before we do get to the next caller real quick, I just want to let you guys know we have initiated Phase two of our brick fundraiser and we are highlighting some of our standout orders from that.
Speaker 1This week's featured brick goes out to Tim and Ronda from Kentucky, who says, in memory of all oppressed people, which is an amazing thing to put on a brick. Thank you so much, Tim and Ronda for your purchase. And if you are interested in literally helping rebuild parts of the ACA and want a brick with whatever you want on it, go to China dout cc ACA Bricks to see your donation put into physical bricks and cool cool a cool collage of other people who have also donated.
Speaker 1It's it's a very very cool thing. I can't wait to post or see the post for the next update on this thing because it's gotten bigger and it is really awesome. Next thing too. If you're in the Austin area, you can follow us on meetup to keep up with some community events. That's a tiny dot cc slash ACA meetup for things like Philosophy under the Stars and game nights and all kinds of stuff. And we also have weekly watch parties at the Free Thought Library on Sundays for a live viewing of Talkithan and Atheists Experience every single Sunday, So doors are open at eleven for that. And speaking of community, it is a great place to
Speaker 1be a part of. One and last, but not least, I'd like to thank the crew for helping out in this little shindig every week. And folks, we're gonna go to the crew cam and let me tell let me tell you guys a story. Okay, because last week we had a donation run and we said if we got to one hundred dollars that the crew would drink hot sauce together. There's one crew member that did not drink hot sauce. And not only that, helped donate to make sure that other crew members drink the hot sauce. And
Speaker 1that is tech lord Jason in the back here, Jason, what do you got for us today? You're gonna redeem yourself today? What do we got? What's that? Show it to the camera, Jason. I can't even read it, but it looks hot. It looks bad, So Jason, buckle up here we go. For those of you listening. In the audio version, Jason is in fact pouring himself some hot sauce in a shot glass, and he's about to shorten his lifespan by at least a day or two. There he goes, Oh, he's just shrugging it off. He thinks he's so cool. He's dying on the inside. Right now,
Speaker 1I can tell thank you, Jason. You have redeemed yourself for drinking that hont sauce. And I think now it's time to get back to regular business. Let's take our next caller, shall we. Let's see we have undecided or no sorry, musical instruments. I think is the name that this or moniker this person has gone by? Their affiliation with God is undecided? I think is what we have on here calling from the southeast US A musical instruments.
Speaker 1You are live, untruth wanded, what's going on?
Speaker 2Hello?
Speaker 6Thank you for taking my call. And to start out, I'm from a different region. It's the Bible Belt, So try to take that in context when you're when you're seeing where I'm coming from.
Speaker 1I have listen. I grew up in Waco, Texas. Okay, I am the I'm in the belt buckle of the Bible Belt, so you won't surprise at all the belt buckle.
Speaker 6Okay, good now, man, I speak to the pastor briefly first before I address.
Speaker 2You, Drew, go right ahead, brother, what you got for me?
Speaker 3Okay?
Speaker 6So, so I grew up what you'd call heathen bohemian household, scientist, artists, painters, poets, went your love, got to drink in and doing drugs, and I found my way into the Christians.
Speaker 3All right.
Speaker 6I did that for a while until I got sober and all that, and did that and and what happened was towards the end of my career there I ran into some really hardcore fundamentalists who and I had some conversations with and we got along just fine. But then I started opening up to this guy, to this pre preacher, and we talked for hours on the phone, and then he just came out of nowhere and he started calling me the devil, a servant of the devil, an agent of the enemy, a servant of the Antichrist, like I'm on the I'm now an enemy. And I didn't talk
Speaker 6to him for a few weeks, and I called him back and he just he said, we don't have any need for you. We need we need soldiers who want to fight, and he just hung up. And I was wondering if you had had a similar experience like that when you left the church, a real stuff like that. Did anything like that happen to you?
Speaker 2Thank you so much for the question. I'm sorry that happened to you. Were you saying, did I connect the dots correctly?
Speaker 1That?
Speaker 3So?
Speaker 2I mean you were Bohemian, you were on that side of things, and then you met Christians started going to church. Did you become a Christian and even as a Christian I got saved?
Speaker 3Yeah?
Speaker 2Yeah, yeah, you were still you were a Christian when he started calling you those names and accusing.
Speaker 6You, Well, yeah, I just I hadn't renounced. I hadn't I just started speaking freely of questioning things and having ideas and all that. Yeah, I hadn't renounced, and that I'm a devil worshiper and anything like that.
Speaker 2Yeah wow, okay, so you hadn't yet renounced your sins. But you're there, you're curious, and he just called you out. And first of all, what an asshole on behalf of all other ministers, pastors whatnot? Like shit, man, I apologize like that is horrible stuff. I think your real question, though, was whether or not I had experienced anything like that when I left the church? Is that right?
Speaker 3Yes? You did you have a bad lash back?
Speaker 6Did you get alienated from people? Did they can so to speak of their social circles out of their lives?
Speaker 2And I mean I did. I definitely had some of that. I've had some of that with family. I had some of that with the churches that I was with. It was maybe a little bit less than what some have experienced. Definitely definitely a lot less than than a lot of the garbage that many many folks have had to face, partly because the church, the second Church, the main church that I was a pastor of, was a little bit more open minded. We considered ourselves evangelical in the sense
Speaker 2that we believed the Bible was the inspired, in errant, authoritative word of God. That said, we interpreted it from about as far left progressive as a lens as you can possibly go. In Like everything, there were people that were a part of the church who were atheists and so and and there are people from the church now that still keep in contact with me and are totally cool and still go to the church. That said, there were also my fair share of folks who totally cut
Speaker 2me off and and were very, very mean spirited, evil condemning. I started blogging shortly after the conversion back in twenty fourteen and received death threats, And so, I guess I've seen both sides, but thankfully it wasn't my norm.
Speaker 6Let me stop you there. I think I need your help. So I did not maintain those friendly ties. And I've had a couple of incidents here. I live in a very Christian area. I guess I need your help kind of killing myself out. I've developed an anti Christian mindset, and I think it's affecting my mental health. I actually I had an incident.
Speaker 3Down by the river.
Speaker 6It almost turned violent and they had guns, and I'm angry at them, not only because they're using that riverland, but because their father is a preacher up at the Rock church up there, and I don't like him. Now, I mean, the whole thing is just getting out of hand, and I need some advice on how to just keep the peace and not be so because I got cast out right, I got alienated, and so now I'm like bitter about it. So how do I undo this anti Christian thing, I've this hatred that I've developed.
Speaker 2Absolutely well, I really really appreciate this question, and yeah, I guess a couple of things. I would offer a couple quick ones. First is, you know, just to keep in mind that it is very common to feel the things you're feeling right now. It is exceptionally common. So you're not alone in that there's nothing wrong with you in feeling those things. Oftentimes when we first deconvert and oftentimes then also for some of us, lingers on for
Speaker 2years after we leave the faith or come to whatever space where we are currently in, and sometimes over the years, the anger, the bitterness, the resentment fades. For others of us, it takes a while longer, and so you're you're not alone in that. Okay. Second thing i'd like to mention real quick is I just want to you mentioned mental health, and I want to make sure that you're connected to resources if you need them, if you don't have them already. There is a fantastic organization called the Secular Therapy Project.
Speaker 3Yes, yes, that I meant all that. Don't worry about that thank.
Speaker 2In recovering from religion. Then I'm assuming as well is another good good space that's connected to the Secular Therapy Project.
Speaker 6Well, I like the reason I go to the chat rooms now is I just like talking to people who have different ideas. And that was always my I guess my limitation in Christianity was that I like to explore ideas and be creative.
Speaker 3And creativity it's.
Speaker 6Pretty frowned upon if you really look at a Christianity.
Speaker 3They don't like it because the.
Speaker 6Father of lies, you know, and it really offended me. Like to be creative and to fabricate and to tell stories. Well, according to the Christians, that's your being the of the devil. And I'm a natural creative person. I like to you know, write and anyway, I'm sorry, I got a sidetrack.
Speaker 3You were helping me after the mental health so you.
Speaker 6Maintain friendly ties with with your ex compatriots.
Speaker 2Well, I think the most helpful thing to do in trying to let go of some of the anti christiananity is keep in mind that Christianity is a wide, wide tent and if there was truth in it, Okay, that there was, you know, the Bible was real and God is that version of God is real. Then sure, then it would follow with that that there's a true version of the one true Christianity. That said, it's not. It's all just different ideas that are loosely connected. There is
Speaker 2no one true version of Christianity, and it's a broad tent. And most Christians, if you look worldwide at all the various forms of Christianity, most Christians don't believe the Bible is literal truth. Most Christians don't believe the most fundamentalist ideas. So something that could be helpful. Different things are helpful for different people. But something that could be helpful is taking some time to consider look at immerse yourself in
Speaker 2the perspectives teachings of more progressive Christians, just to help you see that you know what some people are Christian and they're actually really cool.
Speaker 3Yeah, yeah, yeah.
Speaker 6My mother suggested that to go talk to univerversalss unitarians or whatever. And it's just the area I'm in and I've set myself. I've actually started a little war, a little mini war, and it's bad. But yeah, because of the fundamentalists and my reactionary nature and it's just a mess. But you're right, I need to forget about that. And you're right, you're right.
Speaker 1It's okay. It's not easy to go ahead, Dan, Yeah, I watch them in if you're okay with that, Drew, because like this is really speaking to me because musical instruments. You know, you've probably know my story. I'm from Waco, Texas. My friend David Oliveria has a great saying about Waco. He says there's more Christians than people right in Waco, Texas.
Speaker 3So I remember David Koresh. I remember Koresh. Don't worry. I know we're here.
Speaker 1That's a whole yeah, that's a whole other thing.
Speaker 2You know.
Speaker 1Well, I didn't grow up like that, but I knew a lot of people who were fairly fundamentalist. And I'll tell you about the story. The last time I was voluntarily in a church, and this was when I was still an atheist, okay, right, And you understand this because you know, when it's your only community, right, when it's literally just your friends they go to this church, you can still go to these things even if you're kind of not believing, or maybe you're still kind of trying, but you're just like kind of in that space. And I find out that the church I was going to was brought in a speaker to fund a gay conversion therapy camp. And I talked about it with these folks
Speaker 1at this part, and I said, hey, I actually don't think this is right. I actually think that there's something kind of wrong with this. And I'll be honest, I was kind of raising a little bit of a stink a little bit, and there's a lot of people that were coming and they were kind of joining in on this conversation, and a guy, a leader in our church, he puts a hand on my shoulder and he says, maybe we should talk about this a different time. And that was the moment I knew music that I was not going to have that fucking conversation ever again, because they want to shut that down. And I left the church and I never went back. So, like, you know, you have anti Christian sentiments right now, that's not because
Speaker 1you weren't hurt or because you weren't right. Right. It sounds, at least from your perspective, from you telling me you're absolutely in the right and you are hurt. I say, and I agree with Drew. You can build empathy not just with Christians, but with other groups of people who have been oppressed in their own experiences as well. I used to be that guy that was like, well, what do you mean when you say all white people are X or all men or ex. Right, Oh, you can't just comp all groups of people. But now I understand
Speaker 1that frustration because I know when you're saying I hate all Christians, are all Christians like this way. You probably don't literally mean that in your heart, but that's how it feels in that moment, right. Yeah. So it's like, oh, that helped me understand other people's perspectives, right, Because it's like that helped me build empathy with other people who have been oppressed for way even worse circumstances, right than I've had the privilege in my own upbringing. Right, I think like that can be a healthy thing, right, turn this experience not just into one where it's like I
Speaker 1only look back at this in negativity to being like, wow, this inspired me to do better things. Right, at least that's how I've looked at my own experience with it. But I've been talking for a bit here, musical instruments go ahead.
Speaker 3No, I I both of you.
Speaker 6I just want you to know I just wanted to talk about that.
Speaker 3I hadn't talked about it.
Speaker 6I don't really bring up the religious stuff and mental health. It's kind of we don't talk about that. But yeah, so I was just I'm glad to get to tell y'all the what happened. And that's that's basically, and thank you. I'm gonna I'm gonna tone it down and just try to not engage with these individuals, or if I do, I'm going to try to let go the chip on my shoulder, the resentment.
Speaker 3And just see them as people.
Speaker 6Yeah, and you know, just de escalate the situation because it's all based.
Speaker 3On its resentment.
Speaker 6I'm letting my personal resentment over a few incidents bleed out into this, and you're right, I need to just chill out, and.
Speaker 1You know what, you have no choice in this matter, you really, it's it's two things. You can either kind of just let it bother you or you can choose to be the better person. And that is and that is a lot you've been given in life. And it's not fair, it's not but that's what you have to do, right, It's kind of what we all have to do, unfortunately, and uh, you know, I expect you for it. Uh, and I wish you well in your journey and I hope hopefully our our perspectives were helpful for you today as well. Was there anything else you want to talk about before I let you go?
Speaker 3No, thank you.
Speaker 6I just wanted to tell that story that that what happened and and talk to you about it.
Speaker 1Thank you absolutely, Thanks so much for calling in. Have a great musical rest of your evening.
Speaker 3Uh.
Speaker 1That's real. That's that's somebody every day, oh right, real, for real.
Speaker 2And it can be especially if it's if it's people that are a little bit out of your circle and you choose to go and intersect with them, you know, then there's that. But oftentimes these are folks that we have no choice. They are just in our lives. Yeah, you can't get away from it, and it's it's torture.
Speaker 1Yeah, I will say this. You know, the Christians, I know, the ones that ended up sticking around right in my life because a lot of them did leave my life when I became more outspoken, especially when I started doing stuff online very publicly. But you know, they didn't like it.
Speaker 2They know, yeah, some of them didn't care for it.
Speaker 1But the ones that stuck around, those are my real friends, right because they know what I'm about and they respect that. And some of them, I think I've legitimately helped change their mind on stuff, which is great. And the ones that are still you know, Christian for whatever reason or another, they let me know that there are at least some people out there that I can at least turn to. And it doesn't always have to be atheists all the time, right, because that can be a dangerous mindset too. At the end of the day, there's going to be Christians, right, We can't stop that. There's too many of them, so.
Speaker 2Absolutely, you know, but we can we can encourage Christians who are because sometimes what we do as non theists is the moment we see Christians stop embracing the Bible literally it's like we enjoy having a gotcha moment. We're like, hey, hey, oh you're a Christian, but that's you're embracing something that's anti the Bible, and like we got to gotcha and we feel really good because we proved them wrong. And we can't force them either choose Christianity or let go
Speaker 2of that. But you can't have both. Where maybe maybe the wiser choice is to say, yeah, that's great, Maybe you don't have to follow the Bible in everything. Maybe if we can't get rid of religion, we can just help it, let go encourage being non textual, non biblical. Yeah, let go of those old dogmas. We'll still let you consider yourself. Hell, you can even let go of God and we'll still let you consider yourself a Christian if it helps you feel better.
Speaker 1Yeah, yeah, absolutely, And like there's reasonable spaces for that. I think, like it's just about accommodation, right, Like I'm appreciative of the friends of mine who, obviously I'm never going to convince everybody in my life to think the same way I do. But the ones who can give me the space to be myself and to live my best life, that's what's most important. At the end of the day, I don't need everybody in my life to be atheist. I need people in my life who are willing to accept and love me for who I am. I think that's the most important thing in a relationship. And so you know, if that means that they're a
Speaker 1Christian and they're like a progressive Christian, I'm accepted of that. I will call out bad things and I won't tell people, you know, hey, this isn't write or whatever, and I always do that. But I also know that we live on Earth with over almost eight billion people and it's just inevitable that there's going to be people that think differently about things. So you kind of have to accept that as well in order to be healthy. But that's my take. I'm not a psychologist. Just I think it's the third time I've said that. You know, FYI, that's
Speaker 1probably I don't know. We're just people who talk on the internet. That means yes, yes, just fyll. But yeah, this is this is good conversation. Let's go ahead and take it to our next caller. I want to talk to Steve, who is calling in from Canada. Steve, you are live on Truth Wanted what's going on?
Speaker 3Drough Dan?
Speaker 5How she going? A? A?
Speaker 2Hey, what's going on?
Speaker 1Going? A?
Speaker 4Not?
Speaker 3Wait?
Speaker 1What is what do they say on Letter Kenny?
Speaker 3Like?
Speaker 1Not not much?
Speaker 2What was that?
Speaker 1I can't remember? Watch Letter Kenny? I don't know you know what? I don't.
Speaker 5I don't watch it. That's the funny thing. Even though I'm from you would know me better as ironside from Recovering from.
Speaker 2Religious Yes, that's the Steve I was wondering.
Speaker 1Yes, hello, sir, we got the cameo cameo appearance on the show Going good Steve? What what what did you want to talk to.
Speaker 5A director from Recovering from Religion?
Speaker 3Well?
Speaker 5I did want to talk to you about time travel because I thought, you know, you do like to talk about cool things once in a while when I come to you know, different things that are not religious based. But if you want to say thank you for the shout out earlier Drew for the musical instruments guy there with the RfR shout out, I do also just want to do a shameless plug for yourself.
Speaker 3Drew.
Speaker 5A book called The Rise and Fall of Faith is a really good place to start if anyone is interested in finding out you know, how you can create common ground between people of different belief systems.
Speaker 2Wow, well you know I would not disagree. I am partial to the rise and fall of faith.
Speaker 2Someone on the show is the one that wrote it. Does that make it more acceptable?
Speaker 1I know, I'm just, I'm just, but no.
Speaker 2Thank you for all the work you do with recovering from religion speeds seriously, and it's always good to see a conferences and whatnot.
Speaker 1Yes, and we absolutely advocate Yeah that folks check out religion. That's a long time. Absolutely we love plugging Recovering from religion. Amazing organization. But anyway, Steve, time travel, you got me pequed, you got me curious. What about time travel specifically here?
Speaker 5Well, Drew probably knows this from Facebook, But my son just recently found out about Back to the Future and he's seven years old. So we watched the first one h two nights ago and then last or this tonight actually we watched number two, and I wish I could go back in time and experience the movies again for the very first time, because seeing the way that he, you know, got really upset when Biff is in control and then like you know how he just you know, cheered and said let's go in his gen alpha voice
Speaker 5or you know when when the things rectified themselves and now he's like on a hanger, a cliff a cliffhanger for the third one. So I saw this meme a while ago where you know, I don't know, and I thought I would ask two non experts as well, since I'm a non expert on this on time travel. But to me, when I saw this meme a long time ago, it showed, you know, something like Marty going back to the past and all of a sudden he's in the middle of space because Earth is no longer in the place that it was at that time period. And I'm
Speaker 5just wondering, do you guys think that would happen? Or do you think time and space are intertwined, or what do you think would happen there?
Speaker 1Man, I love this idea of what do you think of this hypothetical that may.
Speaker 2Or may not like even be a.
Speaker 1Feature of y Yeah, I don't know. There's there's so much different philosophical interpretations of time, right. There's a theory of time and b theory of time, right, there's also like like you know, paradoxes, Grandpa paradox or whatever. So I don't know, I have no idea. It's kind of unfathomable to me. I know there's definitely physicists that I definitely believe that some form of time dilation at least or something is possible, but that's really beyond my skill scope. Not only am I not a psychologist, I'm not a
Speaker 1physicist or really a learned individual in any meaningful capacity. So I don't know. That sounds like the lame answer, but really it's like what do I do with this here? Maybe I think maybe there's some room for like, okay, we could go to like the future through like what's that movie that came out a few years ago where they like get stuck in the time thing going to a planet. I don't know, something like that. But I don't know if I closed the past, what's the one with I can't remember?
Speaker 2Hold on, oh, Interstellar, Interstellar.
Speaker 1Thank you Interstellar? Yeah, I remember any Interstellar where they're like, okay, uh, we got to do this thing on this planet and they messed up. It's like that that just cost us thirty one years or something. Yeah, maybe something like that.
Speaker 5That seems like the thing is that you hear the drums, you hear the drums and the music on that and apparently every drum beat is like an hour or something like that. So it's like every drum beat in the song is an hour or it's a day or something like that.
Speaker 1And yeah, it's really neat how they how they did that.
Speaker 5I love that movie. I didn't really expect an answer from you, guys. I just kind of wanted to call and hang out for a little bit and we got to hear what's plug RfR because because work, no.
Speaker 1I want yeah, yeah, I want to hear Drew's take on this first as well my contribution.
Speaker 2So I'm not sure about the time space continuum in all of these things. However, I have heard that the film that nails it, you know, because you watch all these films back Back to the Future is just one of many where it's like, well, wait a minute, is that how it would actually work if time travel was real? Because if wouldn't it already be that way the first time? Like how do you change it otherwise? You know whatever. I have been told that the most flawless the only
Speaker 2flawless movie in terms of its representation of that is a move. It's a it's a film, I believe, a Spanish film called called What Is It True? I just had a Time Crimes. That's the English translation of it. Brilliant film. I would tell you why, but it's kind of a spoiler because you find out at the end. But it's really it truly is unlike any other time travel movie I've ever seen Time Crimes. So maybe check
Speaker 2that out.
Speaker 1Cool, Okay, I'll have to look that up. Yeah, there is a movie awesome that I really want to see that. I've heard about this. I've talked about this another stream. It's called have you heard of this? It is Assassin's Assassin thirty three a d Have you heard about this?
Speaker 2I don't think I have.
Speaker 1This is a movie about a group of scientists that create a time machine and are U and the time machine is being used by extremists to kill Jesus. And so there's one group of people that's trying to like kill Jesus in another group of people that's trying to stop the killing of Jesus so that he can like live out his the death he's supposed to live and like, uh, you know, save people and stuff. It sounds like an amazing plot and I'm pretty sure like it is like a Christian movie and I want to see it, but
Speaker 1I haven't seen it yet. So that's what that made me think of, Wow.
Speaker 5That so funny, that's awesome. There's actually a Mad TV snippet or or a short where they have Determinator going back to save Jesus and Jesus is supposed to Judas. He's like when he brings Judas back to life. Oh, it's so funny.
Speaker 3It's really good.
Speaker 1Wow, Jesus popular character and time travel science fiction. I suppose makes sense, you know.
Speaker 2He's got to say. When I was a teenager, my favorite time travel movie was was Time Cop with Van dam anybody else Time Copbody?
Speaker 1I've seen that amazing. Well, thank you for your questions time travel. Sure, thank you for your questions on time travel. I help us uh experts on the subject. Gave you a lot to think about, ponderings and you know, lectures. Was there anything else you want to add, Steve before we let you go.
Speaker 5Yeah, thanks so much. I will just add that, you know, musical instruments and any of the previous callers that you know, if you need a shoulder to lean on, if you need an ear to listen, or a hand to hold, give RfR a call one eight eight. I doubt it, and you know you can go to w WW dot Recovering from Religion dot org and me and my team are there to help you.
Speaker 1Awesome, awesome, thanks so much, Steve. Thank you for calling in and giving that plug. I was joking earlier. You know, we really liked doing the plug sooner and every once in a while, especially for Recovering from Religion. Okay, there are They are an awesome org and we stand them one hundred percent for sure. Real quickly, I want to talk about the POLE results because we haven't talked about POLE results in a minute. Usually you guys like call in about the poll question, and I feel like we never like talk about the results on air, So I want to talk about what we got so far. The
Speaker 1question was is humanism enough? And I was hoping somebody would call in. Maybe somebody will call and we still have time for somebody to call in and talk about it. Got eighty one percent said yes, in nineteen percent said no, which I think is interesting. So that's about four fifths of people saying yes, it is enough, and one fifth that is saying no. What do you think about those results?
Speaker 2Through Wow, I think I'm not terribly surprised. Actually, I thought more people would say humanism is not enough than what did not necessarily the majority, but more than nineteen percent. I think a lot of it stems down to how do you define humanism? I mean, that's really the big kicker there. I have my definition. I don't know what everyone else is, but I think a lot of people I hear from a lot of people who are like, humanism is just this philosophical thing that rarely actually does anything,
Speaker 2is what I hear. And I'm a huge humanist advocate. Yeah, but yeah, I don't know what's what's your take, Dan, oh Well?
Speaker 1I think I mean, for me, I have a perspective that is not completely unheard of, but I think is a sort of minority opinion because I still think the humanist label applies to ninety five percent to ninety nine percent of what I think. I just choose to use the sentientist label. And I've talked about this before, which is basically just humanism. Plus it's just this idea that I do believe that, you know, a liberation from religion in religious thinking can help promote free thoughts, and can
Speaker 1promote skepticism, and can do all these wonderful things. That human interests should be put first before interests of a god or a hierarchy or anything else. Right, these social structures that we traditionally associate like Christianity, like church, but also really any organization that off usecates itself from criticism right and critical thinking. I think that we should definitely liberate ourselves, but with the sentientis label. The addition to that is I also consider the interests of non human entities as well. I recognize that there are beings on
Speaker 1this earth that aren't human that do have interests, and I don't see necessarily a reason why those interests shouldn't be respected in the same way that another human beings interests should be respected because of things not only my own sense of empathy, but also the recognition that they have a capacity for suffering, just like human beings do, which is why like when people look at stuff like on Facebook and they see, oh, this dog is getting hurt and stuff like, people want to do something for I think a lot of people feel that way. Maybe
Speaker 1they don't always verbalize this such because it would have consequences for other actions that people do. But yeah, that's so. I guess for me the answer is no, is humanism enough technically, but it kind of mostly is. I think it mostly describes my belief in any other way.
Speaker 2What about you, though, word, I think it really does come down to how you define I think most people, unfortunately would define humanism as what would take I think most people who consider themselves humanists are embrace more of what I would call a philosophical humanism, which if you're a fit, which oftentimes is used as a synonym more or less basically to as a non theist. Just if you're not, if your view of the world is not
Speaker 2filled with God's stuff, then it's a humanist view of the world. And if that's how we're defining humanism, then it is sorely, sorely lacking, and no one're even close to enough my take on humanism, I embrace what I refer to as an embodied humanism, where humanism is us working together to build a better world and live out a healthier humanity. That's how I define humanism, is building a better world, living out a healthier humanity, and it's not focused. I would suggest it's a little more an
Speaker 2older school version of humanism that would say we're the center of everything where all that matters. Most of the humanists I know say that the reason why we embrace the term human in humanist is because that's our experience where it's embracing our humanity and using our humanity to build a better world and do things healthier. And that's why I'm a humanist, because my experience is human centered. But I believe that because we're the one that fucked it up, we're the ones that also have to fix it,
Speaker 2and so taking initiative as humans in building that better world and living out that healthier human So if we're doing that, I don't know. Sometimes I wonder. At one time I was asked to give a talk on how humanism saves the world, and one of the first things I said is have you looked at studies lately? I don't know that anything can save this fucking world anymore. Yeah, but I do believe that if anything can, it really does come down to humanism being whether or not you embrace the term.
Speaker 1Yeah, So do you think, like you mentioned a criticism earlier of like humanism, Like what does it really do for people? Like do you embrace that that's a legitimate criticism or do you think it's it's it's a little more complicated.
Speaker 2I mean, I think how most people use the term. I think it's a very a very legit concern and criticism. Because most humanist communities, okay, here's a take. Most humanist communities, uh, embrace what you could be called as country club humanists. Most humanists are country philosophical humanists and country club humanists. Most humanist communities are let's just fucking circle and talk about how much the Bible, how dumb the Bible is. And that's the extent of most humanist communities. Most humanist
Speaker 2communities are sorely lacking, and they are rife with injustice and inequity and just want to embrace just throw some supper club moments and and talk about how much better they are than those who are lacking what they have.
Speaker 1Hot takes getting called out, called out? Uh oh watch cha, No, I agree with you. I think there is a lot of posturing that happens in these communities. And that's not to say that people's heart aren't in the right place. I believe that, but I've heard stories and I have friends who have definitely been burnt out by humanist communities. And that's true for atheist communities and non faith communities or whatever. Just because you don't believe in doesn't inherently make you a better person. It doesn't, right, And you mentioned this idea, I think is interesting, Like there are
Speaker 1institutions you could argue, like the UN or something that are built on humanism, but like a non belief does not mean humanism at all. Period. You can still be subject to nationalism, you can still be subject to racial hierarchies, you know, you can still be subject to a lot of these other sorts of sort of social architecture that can determine your decision making and how you treat other people and stuff. Right, But at the same time, it's also not good enough to just preach the values. You do have to kind of live that authentically in every
Speaker 1facet of your life and your will, and you're organizing, and it's hard to do that. I'm not saying it's easy, but that can be a problem for humanists, I think.
Speaker 2Absolutely undred percent.
Speaker 1Yeah, yeah, but maybe you guys disagreat I don't know. You can feel free to call in and tell me about it. We do have somebody else in mEq right now who wants to talk to us, so maybe we should get to that. Let's talk to Abraham, who is calling from the East Coast as soon as Colin Studio decides to work for me. Wow, Collin Study, you work ninety nine percent of the time and then the one time you don't here we go, Okay, you're a live on the air. Welcome to truth wanted Abraham from the East Coast? What's going on? Abraham? Are you there? Can you hear us? Abraham? Last call? Can you hear us? Oh? Abraham,
Speaker 1Come on, Abraham, Abraham. I'm going to put you back in the queue. That doesn't mean that you're off the air. It just means that the CRUE can maybe work with you. Well, they fix some tech issues on that, And actually I don't have anybody else in the crew. There was somebody else that was calling, but I think they hung up. So we have open lines right now where we're getting close to the end of the show, but we'll take at least another call or two. I know it's a busy time of year. I kind of expected that some of you guys are out doing stuff tonight. But hey, we still have open lines, We still are ready to talk, So bring it to us if you want. For now, though,
Speaker 1I do want to go back to this conversation Drew that I think is interesting about humanism because your perspective, I think is is similar to mine I grew up. I don't want to say I was a progressive Christian growing up. I was probably more centrist in my beliefs, but I was definitely, you know, centrist, conservative, but more relatively more progressive than the Christians around me, and that always caused me dissonance. And you are somebody from a community who is more who came from a more sounds like a more progressive Christian community, right. I find that a lot of folks in the atheist space or the
Speaker 1non theist space tend to come from more conservative or evangelical communities than even I do. Do you find that's true in your experience?
Speaker 2Yeah? Absolutely absolutely, and it seems to be. And we saw this at the Clergy Project as well, which the Clergy Project, for those who aren't aware, is Yeah. It's a nonprofit providing peer support, community assistance, and career transition assistance, community resourcing to religious leaders around the world who no longer believe in God's stuff and now they're trying to figure out how to get out. And you found the same thing there is out of the thousand plus former and current ministers who now become you don't have to
Speaker 2embrace the term atheist to be a part of the Clergy Project, but a naturalist you have to be a naturalist. You can't embrace supernaturalism. Part of this group. And then they provide a place, a space of community and peer support and things like that. And there too, the vast majority of the ministers who deconverted and then joined the Clergy Project looking for community were those who came from fundamentalist faith traditions, or at least more right word those
Speaker 2who but for those where they're already in more left leaning or more mainstream Christian traditions, It like everybody seminary was filled with people who didn't believe in God. Like it's just normal to not really believe all the way. So if you pull the whole band aid off, that's okay, it's not such a huge leap. But what we found over and over and over again consistently. Is that the more right word you come from theologically, the more fundamentalist
Speaker 2you come from. It really is on a trajectory on a spectrum of sorts, where the more right word it is, the more trauma you tend to have, the more just difficult, horrific experience you've had, and the more you tend to pendulum swing all the way and become more of a more of a fundamentalist atheist, if you will. So, the more moderate you seem to be in your theism, the more moderate you tend to be in your atheism, the more easy it is for you to embrace more progressive Christians,
Speaker 2just the easier, smoother it is in everything. And the more yeah, the more hard hard left or hard right you are, the more hard left you go. Where I hated everybody who disagreed with me before, and now I hate everybody who disagrees with me now too. I'm just on the other side. So we really saw a lot of that time and time again, that that a correlation with that variation for whatever the reason may be.
Speaker 1Yeah, I in my anecdotal experience, I think I've you know, felt the same way in the folks that I talked to you, because, like you know, I'm listen, I'm deep in the pain. Okay, I'm in the I'm part of the atheist community of Austin. Okay, I know fucking envieus. Like it's just I know some folks, okay, And it's just like I know that folks who do come from those fundamentals backrounds tend to be very passionate about the injustices because they were witnessing that stuff firsthand. And there's a part of me that wonders, is this a personality thing or is this just because of a background? Is
Speaker 1this because of someone's experiences that causes them to become I don't want to say radical, Well, yeah, I guess kind of radicalized.
Speaker 2Right.
Speaker 1If you become an activist, you're kind of activated in some form. I'm definitely activated in some form. I'm motivated by the injustices I see. But also I recognize that I was not as fundamentalist as some folks, like I always believe in evolution, for example, and that was that was weird for a lot of people growing up because and it's still weird for me today. I don't know how I justified that. I don't think I really fully understood the implication. So, but the point is, right, Like, I wonder, why aren't there more progressive sort of Christians that end up going to the atheist space. And is
Speaker 1it because of a more privileged background or is it a personality thing. I don't know. These are things I kind of think about. Do you have any thoughts about that?
Speaker 2Yeah, I mean I think in terms of you know why, Yeah, the more if you grow up in a setting, if you or if your first experiences with Christianity are in a setting where it is more progressive. I mean, it just tends to be more open minded, and it's less black and white. It's it's more gray. And so you know my impression, my experience again it's it's anecdotal for the most part, but that, yeah, is there's less pressure to choose black or white. Like so I grew up
Speaker 2much more fundamentalist and grew up very much black and white thinking right, it's right, it's wrong, there's no in between. And so with the church that second, the main church that I pastored, part of my big thing was embrace the gray. Very little and I would say very little in the Bible is black and white. It's embracing the gray and embracing the gray in light. And we would teach from that perspective, preach from that perspective, be comfortable not knowing everything about everything. And so if as a
Speaker 2more progressive Christian, like you're in that and now, okay, you just step another another footstep to the left or another footstep away from art and theism, It's just there's there's not the need to Okay, now you have to leave it all together. Now, why would I need to leave it all together? I'm just slightly more progressed in my progressivism, you know. So there's not that force you have to choose, So why choose? It's just more com you know.
Speaker 1Interesting, Yeah, because I guess one thing I think that finally, uh you know, hit did it for me. In terms of deconstruction. One asset I would say is the is the political nature of religion in a way. I do think that like, if you do hold to a fundamentalist version of Christianity, you kind of have to hold to a fundamentalist sort of politic in a way. And I think that really bothered me in some ways because you know, in order to be consistent, I felt like I had to be an asshole in some ways. Right, It's like
Speaker 1and like, I still hold that criticism to Christianity broadly. I recognize that there are lots of sup Christians doing all kinds of stuff with their own interpretations of the work. But that's kind of the problem for me at the end of the day. If it's always going to rely on some interpretation of the you know, history of this text or whatever. Maybe if video it is even the text, even if it's a culture ethic. I mean, that's fine, but I don't really feel inspired by Jesus. I don't think. I don't know if he's the guy for me. You know, So I don't know something I think about, I guess, and something I probably won't have the answers to because
Speaker 1neither of us have hard data on this, I guess, unless you've got to pull something now and be like, actually, I got this study, but I don't know something I've observed here. But folks, we are getting towards the tail end of the show. But don't go away just yet, because we will be having an after show.
Speaker 3You know.
Speaker 1I was saying I was tired and didn't want to do it tonight. I'm gonna be on tonight, I'm gonna be on, and then I think it is also going to be on, so thank you join us on that after show. It's going to be on the fan run discord server linked to that is in the description, but it is tiny out CC slash ACD discord and we'll be going over there in Justice Sect. But before we do, I have to give some thanks, first of all to Drew Beckis for being on tonight's program.
Speaker 2Thank you so much, true Hey again, thank you for having me. It's great to be back.
Speaker 1Of course, of course I love your perspective, wonderful conversations tonight. I also have to give a special thanks to Kelly, who's been hanging out in the background waiting for one of us to drop so he can fill in and take our spots, but we haven't yet. So there he is looking fab tonight. He's got the Fortunately, what's up? You're going to prom Kelly? What's happening?
Speaker 2That's Scarlett letter.
Speaker 1Yeah, he's got the scarlet. You know. I was just saying, you look nice, that's all. Yeah, Thanks so much, Kelly, And we'll see it in the discord in just a second.
Speaker 2And honestly, I only put the jacket on because my office was cold.
Speaker 1That makes sense, That makes sense. I can see that good.
Speaker 2I think Kelly's got a little preacher.
Speaker 1He does have a little preacher going on.
Speaker 2You know, I don't know, you might get sanctioned, but.
Speaker 1Uh yeah, I don't think the I r S would like that if we start uh mixing that up. But yeah, thank you, Kelly. We'll see it in just a bit on the after show discord. I want to remind you, folks, the topic the problem for this week. It is what topic will you bring up to change the subject at Thanksgiving? Leave your comment below and we will read them not next week but the week after, because we do got a pre recorded show for you next week. And we do have some super chats that I've neglected to read. We got actually one right now from Miranda Rensberger, remember
Speaker 1six months who gave ten dollars, Thank you so much, Miranda, who said, so as Dan punishing himself in some way if there are enough super chats tonight, or do only the crew have to sacrifice themselves? And you know what we talked about. We didn't do something today, but my promise, I'll just say my promise to you. I will do something either humiliating or negative to my health or I don't know, whatever you guys want that's entertaining. Okay, at some point I'll do it. I will because I do
Speaker 1appreciate the crew doing what they do. I'm not a hot sauce guy. That's not for me. Maybe not hot sauce. But let's talk about our options. Okay, tell you leave a comment below telling you tell me what you want.
Speaker 2The yeah, shaving your head is that one of the options. Are you one of those guys?
Speaker 1And listen, I got a wedding coming up. Okay, I gotta I gotta stay fresh for that. But we'll talk. Well, I'll consider it. I'll consider do you know what? It depends on the price. There you go. It depends on the price, because I'm willing to do a lot for the A C. A and we'll see, we'll see. But blow for one hundred thousand?
Speaker 2How much if somebody, if somebody contributes one hundred thousand dollars, will you save your head one hundred thousand? Yes, I will do.
Speaker 1It for a hundred thousand. You got it, folks, I'd be an asshole if do it for one hundred thousand. That's crazy.
Speaker 2Yeah, we got one hundred thousand coming your way. Now, we got it. I can sense it.
Speaker 1Please please please don't okay, listen, I know you guys, some generous folks out there do ninety thousands so that it doesn't count and then you still get to donate. That would be great too. But anyway, listen, we do got to wrap things up here again. Special thanks to the crew who helped make this show happen every single week. You guys are awesome for that. And last, but not least, let's talk about words of wisdom. Give any words of wisdom before we sign off today.
Speaker 2Words of wisdom.
Speaker 1You know it's the thing I asked that the hosts aren't ready for because I don't talk about it in the pre show What's up?
Speaker 2You know? Words of wisdom? Words of wisdom would be uh, don't forget tripp to fan is in more than just turkey wisdom wisdom.
Speaker 1I like it, Drew, Thanks so much, and thank you to everybody watching tonight. I am objectively Dan. This has been another episode of truth wanted. Remember to always keep one the truth and I'll see you next time.
In today's episode of Truth Wanted, ObjectivelyDan welcomes guest Out Of Body Atheist, with The Beard of Empathy on backup, to dig into Reiki, New Age spirituality, homeopathy, and the long road from woo to skepticism!...
In today's episode of Truth Wanted, Jon the Skeptick, Volcy, and Sofia Spina explain why no one can talk to the dead, from Haitian Vodou and grief dreams to Jon's past as a spiritualist! Bob jumps from objective...
In today's episode of Truth Wanted, ObjectivelyDan and Nintendrew, later joined by The Beard of Empathy, tackle a world run on Jesus, the magic of manifesting, and a prayer that actually got answered! Bob in NY, a...
In today's episode of Truth Wanted, ObjectivelyDan, Kelley Laughlin, and The Beard of Empathy tackle standards of evidence, miracle claims, and the false binaries of moral philosophy! Dean in VA questions why skeptics...
In today's episode of Truth Wanted, ObjectivelyDan and Chad Harris tackle Christian nationalism, police brutality, and the uncomfortable truths about racism and immigration. Big E in TN survived police brutality and...