In today's episode of Truth Wanted, ObjectivelyDan and Volcy explore deconstruction journeys, evidence-based thinking, and whether nature or cultural impact can justify God claims. Jon in Canada argues that nature itself is God through a naturalistic pantheist lens, combining Spinoza's philosophy with emergent consciousness. The hosts challenge why the God label is necessary at all. If you're just describing natural phenomena, why add the baggage of a term loaded with supernatural connotations? What does calling nature "God" add to our understanding that simply studying nature doesn't already provide? When you strip away all the traditional attributes of God, what's left that justifies using the word? Antonio in TX argues that God is real because of religion's massive cultural impact on society. The hosts counter that impactful ideas aren't necessarily true or good. Slavery had cultural impact. Harmful religious influences on policy and rights demonstrate that widespread belief doesn't equal truth. If cultural impact made something real, would that make every influential myth throughout history real? What's the difference between something being culturally significant and something being actually true? Thank you for joining us this week! We will see you next time! Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/truth-wanted--3195473/support.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Speaker 1Hey, folks, I hope you're ready to bring that smoke today because today's guest is definitely ready to bring it. I'm gonna be joined by the host of Bring that Smoke, Volsi, on today's episode of Truth Wanted. So get ready because the show is starting right now. Hello, Hello everybody, and welcome back to another episode of Truth Wanted. I am your host, Objectively Dan, and I want to welcome you to the show. This is a live calling show that happens every single week at Sundays at two forty five
Speaker 1pm New Time. Baby Woo love it. We talk to people about what they believe and why. So if you'd like to call us to do that, you can. The lines are open. The number is five one two nine two, or you can call through your computer at acaight do show slash Call. Truth Wanted is a product of the Atheist Community of Austin, a five oh one c three nonprofit organization dedicated to the promotion of atheism, critical thinking, sadanism, the separation of religion and government, and folks, we are try streaming today, so big shout out to our viewers
Speaker 1on TikTok and YouTube mobile.
Speaker 2If you are watching us on tik Talk tonight.
Speaker 1You'd like to talk to us, then, please request to join and we'll bring you up on stage. Please make sure that you are over eighteen years of age before doing so. And Folks, every single week on Truth Wanted, I like to have a special guest with me and this week is no different. We have Falsi joining me today. Falsi will welcome to today's Truth Wanted. How are you doing?
Speaker 3Hey, I'm adorn all right. I appreciate you guys having me on. I want to do this for a very very long time, very very excited, very glad to be here with you, Dan, because I've followed you for a while, so I follow Truth Wanted and all the other flagship shows, so love it. Thank you so much for having me on here and all to be here in the future again.
Speaker 1Awesome. Well, say, I'm excited that you're going to be here with us today as well. You are a host of your own program. And I want to just talk about yourself for a second. If you could describe yourself at a few and says, how would you do it?
Speaker 3I would describe myself as an agnostic atheist and an empathetic humanist, you know, because for me and myself. I am uh in of course right now, to become a mental health counselor.
Speaker 2So that's something that I do want to graduations, Thank you so much.
Speaker 3That's something that I want to help people out with, not just what we're really focusing on, especially my community.
Speaker 2Uh.
Speaker 3I grew up, you know, in a in a working class neighborhood. I was around a lot of people grew up in poverty and everything like that, and I saw how a lot of those issues affected them in their mental health processes, you know what I mean. Yeah, I've seen some some things as a as a as a young man, and I've known people who've seen it even worse, you know, and a lot of times they have no one to speak to. There's not a lot a lot of resources for them, especially if you grew up in poverty, Like there's not a lot of resources for mental health, and poverty can be something that that's not only extremely stressful,
Speaker 3but it's been shown to objectively affect your mental health.
Speaker 1People who are in there.
Speaker 3Yeah, people who are in there, you know, they suffer from post traumatic stress disorder.
Speaker 2Sometimes they're misdiagnosed.
Speaker 3They can be misdiagnosed with schizophrenia, but they actually have PTSD, misdiagnosed with ADHD, but they have something else, you know what I mean. And it happens to people in poverty a lot. And that's that's something I said. Since I've been around this and I've been through it, I've actually want to help out that community and our people to get us to.
Speaker 2A better spot.
Speaker 3And that's why I advocate for some of the stuff that I advocate for over on you know, the political side, but just on the religious side. You know, I believe in getting evidence for what you believe, and I've always believed that getting evidence for what you believe in. That's something that I actually learned in my therapy courses. There are ways to get someone to think about their emotions in a very evidence basedo logical way, like, Okay, you feel this way, this is how you're feeling, but what
Speaker 3show actually shows that to be true? Why should you feel that way? Why do you feel that you're a loser who deserves nothing? Why do you feel that life is not worth living?
Speaker 4Me?
Speaker 3And then we get to people to talk about this things, right, and then you say, Okay, now that you say that this is what you are or this is how life is. Why do you think that what shows you that's how life is? What shows you that this is who you are as a person? You know, it is into a lot of the narrative narratives as well, because one thing I've learned is a it's a common addage to say that, you know, we're all the hero of our own story.
Speaker 2And one thing that.
Speaker 3I've been founding out of our courses is that for a lot of people, they feel that they're the villain in theirs, you know, and that's uh, that gets to a that that affects you a lot, you know.
Speaker 2And I don't want keep rambling on, but.
Speaker 1Man, I have so many thoughts about that, because so so I never I don't talk about this too much in the show. I have diagnosed with the ADHD, diagnosed to the ADHD for a long time. I got diagnosed when I was in second grade, back in the early odds, okay, And I have parents who are in healthcare, who work in healthcare, so they were able to like adequately give me the resources I needed, Like I went to a child psychologist or wherever, you know, because I was struggling in school. They analyzed it or you know, did their stuff and that Okay, here's your prescription.
Speaker 2I got my stuff, and that was my life.
Speaker 1And that's not how most people deal with that, or it hadn't dealt with it then still aren't dealing with it today. That is a result of my own privilege of being able to have those material resources that access. That's something that most people just never have had throughout the entirety of history period.
Speaker 4Right.
Speaker 1And if there's one thing that's changed in my beliefs between when I used to be a Christian and what I am today, is that your material conditions affect everything.
Speaker 5Right.
Speaker 1You can have a belief in God and maybe that helps you get through life, but if you don't have access to the resources that you need, or the community that you need, or the support that you need, that's going to affect you physically and mentally. And and yeah, if I'm having a hard agree with you moment right now, because absolutely, evidence based practice and medicine is how you help people.
Speaker 2Yeah, I'm not.
Speaker 1Saying that religious communities don't offer support. They absolutely do, right there. There is a reality to that, and that's why some people are as involved in their communities as they are.
Speaker 2But it's not everything.
Speaker 1I don't believe that God's going to calm down and heal your depression.
Speaker 2I don't.
Speaker 1I just don't think that's how that works, right. I think it's or it's not gonna you know, make it a focused in school because you know, you just had the right harder. It's just that's not how people's bodies are designed. That's not how human beings work. So good for you for pursuing evidence based medicine. It sounds like you used to be a believer yourself before as well. Yeah that that that that's correct.
Speaker 3And you know what's what's great about what you said is that even Christian therapists even they say that, listen, you can't just pray this away, you know, they even they even tell you that.
Speaker 2You know, and.
Speaker 3Now me just growing up and being Christian, Yeah, it was. It was the same thing. I got a lot of my my family just for my background where from the West Indies. You know, my parents came from Haiti back in the nineteen seventies. And if anyone knows about West Indian culture Caribbean culture, you're you're you're some sort of Christian.
Speaker 2You're either you're the Protestant.
Speaker 3If you're if you're from the anglophone side, or if you're from the Francophone or Hispanic side, you're some sort of Catholic. Yeah, I mean so a lot of Haitians are are Catholic both here in the United States, it's all Catholicism, Held Mary Full of Grace, etcetera, etcetera.
Speaker 4You know.
Speaker 3Now, my parents were a little different. They were Protestant. They were the minority, but they were Protestant. So I grew up the very Christian as well, and kind of on my deconstruction journey. I think as a kid, I was always one of those kids that was inquisitive.
Speaker 4You know.
Speaker 3I was always one of those annoying kids that said why you know. I was one of those kids, you know, you so you told me something. I always ask why, you know? And I got in trouble in school for a little bit for that, but uh, not a logial but a little bit because you know, I was always questioning a teacher.
Speaker 2I always said, Okay, why why is this? Why's that? Why is this? Why is that?
Speaker 4You know?
Speaker 3So when people started, when I first started to really have consciousness to understand, you know, I'm being taught the Bible and everything like that. And they taught me, oh, you know, Adam and Eve fell from grades because they ate the fruit and the thing. And the first question I asked was where did Kane's wife come from? I think that was I think when I started question I started questioning religion, probably when I was like seven, you know. But and and the thing is, if you if you, if you're really inquisitive, you're gonna question it, right. And I think that's at that point where I was kind
Speaker 3of understood, like there's something here that is not right.
Speaker 2Where does caine wife come from?
Speaker 3Because they said Adam, Eve, Cain and Abel, you know, Kine took out able And then the next chapter Kane has a wife where she came from?
Speaker 1You know, did people did you ask that? And did people give you answers on that? Because I heard some answers on that.
Speaker 2Yeah. The answer was gross.
Speaker 3It was either no answer, you know, we'll find out when we go to heaven. Or the second answer is you know that was his sister and I'm Alabama, you know, yes, that's gross. Yeah, you know, of course we learned the story about Noah's ark and everything like that. But the thing is when I was a kid, they teach you, at least for me and my experts, they teach you a sanitized version of Noah's Arc first, and then they teach you the more gross version. And the more sanitized version was that Noah or God simply foresaw a flood coming,
Speaker 3and then that God told Noa to build the arc because he foresaw it. And then when I was around eleven and twelve, that's when they gave me the real story.
Speaker 2He didn't foresee it.
Speaker 3God is the one that sens it to wipe out the entire Earth star all over. But that call that costs two problems for me. All Like number one, yeah, lied to me when I was a kid. Yeah, that A lied to me, you know what I mean. But the second reason is that why did what was the point of that? Why sin got to flood the earth? Like what did the children do at that point?
Speaker 1You know?
Speaker 3I mean, I'm like, okay, so everybody in China died at one point, Like what happened? I don't know, I don't I don't get Are there a billion people over there? How did they rebuild?
Speaker 2What happened?
Speaker 1What do you think about these people that say, oh, well, these stories. You know, they're metaphors. They're not supposed to be taken literally. Was that ever an option for you when you were a Christian?
Speaker 3No, it was all literal. It was all literal. I grew around very very literal Christians, very very Uh. Dinosaurs are in the Bible, They're they're the bluff Iathans they talk about, and I think a very evolution is false. And you know, humans work with dinosaurs type of thing, you know, which I knew was kind of dumb.
Speaker 2Okayn't don't we don't walk with dinosaurs. Yeah, that's that's work for dinosaurs. It was a satan is okay?
Speaker 1And uh.
Speaker 3I grew with people who doubted do you know dinosaur or stuff like that. It was a bunch of different thoughts its on it, But for me, it was never on you know, this is metaphorical.
Speaker 2It was always this literal.
Speaker 3But as I grew older and I started to realize that this can't possibly be true, especially when I started learning like kind of a little bit of marine biology and I found out that the throat of a whale is like this big, so no human can fit in there, right, I was like, okay, so Jonah and the whale is probably some bs, you know, that's probably not true.
Speaker 1Yeah, So you were a Christian and and but you were obviously you were doubting a little bit in some of this, so you were asking some questions. Well, at one point, did you say, I actually am no longer a Christian period, Like I completely reject this because I understand asking questions, but still kind of being there, right, still going to church and still doing it because the family's there, right. Would you say, like even as a kid, you're like, no, I'm one hundred percent not about this, or.
Speaker 3I would say as a kid, I pushed those thoughts to the back of my head because the thought kept on coming forward of you know, this doesn't make any sense and I can do better than this, you know, but that's a very ding that second one is a very dangerous thought because God is supposed to be the most all knowing, all powerful creature to ever exist, right or ever will exist. So if you're you can do better, that's a that's that's a huge issue, you.
Speaker 2Know what I mean?
Speaker 3And I used to you know, religion is the is a thing that really keeps you, uh, keeps you downstrodden.
Speaker 2Like if you have those doubts.
Speaker 3It's super super sinful to have those doubts, to have those type of issues. So I'm always praying hard. I'm always thinking about what's the horrible person I am, because like I believe in this and you know, me doing better than God's almost be a terrible, disgusting, horrible person, you know.
Speaker 2And which is another thing.
Speaker 3That I've uh I figured out about about religion, where it forces you to think that you're a terrible person just for existing.
Speaker 2It's very very it's very abusive to tell you the truth.
Speaker 3So I think when I start to not believe or I started to question more was when I finally went to college and I took a philosophy class. I look at philosophy class because that professor when I first when he told to write an essay of who we are and some person that we are right, and then you know, he was going on on everybody's everybody's papers, everybody's essay, and he came to me and he was like, hey, you know in this paper, you told me what you believe.
Speaker 3You told me who you are and everything like that. You told me what you believe, but you didn't tell me why you believed it. And that right there kind of flipped the switch and I was like, wow, I really don't know why I believe this. This is just something I always grow up on. So I didn't set out on a journey to prove this, like wrong, put myself wrong. I wanted a journey to prove myself right because I was like, Okay, I believe this. My parents told me about it. All my friends are part of this. Every single person that I knew and I know and loved, they all grew up in this. It has to be right.
Speaker 3Let me go ahead and find the evidence of it, right.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 3And of course the first thing I found was, you know, I think was what's what's the name of that book?
Speaker 2The Case for Jesus for Christ? He's for Christ? There we go.
Speaker 3That's That's one of the first books I ran in. So I was like, okay, awesome, I found this book. This is gonna have all the answers for me. And then someone told me, hey, you ever read the Dirry Buddles to it?
Speaker 4Yeah?
Speaker 1Yeah, you know other people have read this too, and actually, you know, don't don't don't think it's all that great. I don't think it's all that great.
Speaker 3Does rebuddles to it, and I was like, oh, okay, so let me read the rebubbles. I'm like, they can't be tibbery rebuttles. And I was like, oh crap, there are rebuttles, all right, So let me look at us something else. Let's let's keep mooking, let's keep searching. It's got to be something that's true about this. I think at that point I already kind of accepted in my mind that most of the Biblical stories were metaphor. You know, Adam and Eve was a metaphor, and No was a metaphor. Jodan Newell's metaphor Tower, it was a metaphor. At that point in my life, I'm thinking, okay, Jesus booking parables.
Speaker 3So these are parables, these are metaphors. These are just stories on.
Speaker 2How to live into your life, right right.
Speaker 3But then I ran into probably one of the most epic series I've seen on YouTube. These are like the first early days of YouTube. I ran into fifteen foundational fosses of creationism. I ran into that, you know, And when I ran into that, I was like when I when I when I watch every single videos like this, things here, I can't deny you know, but.
Speaker 1This Dark Matter twenty five is he that was on raw and Raw That's right?
Speaker 2Okay, yeah, okay, I'll ran into that.
Speaker 1I ran to Raw, Okay, that's what I remember that.
Speaker 3Yeah, And after I ran into R and Raw, that's when I ran to Dark Battery. Okay, it's a dark batter. And because you know the algorithm suggests to you to people. Yeah, after I read, after I ran into that, I started they were concurrent at that time. For sure, for sure they were concurrent. I think what was his name, the one that did why do people laugh at creation?
Speaker 4Iss?
Speaker 2Thunder thereious? I think Thunderfoot.
Speaker 3I ran to Thunderfoot. I ran to people like forty eight Alley non Stamp collector. These basically the early days of atheists YouTube. Yeah, you know, so what I ran into those videos and I started watching them. That's when I started watching stories of deconstruction journeys and I first heard the term deconstruction. I heard it before I heard the term deconstruction. And it was basically encouraging people to look at their faith. And I think one of the big videos that I saw that that made me really question things sincerely was the video why won't God heal amputees,
Speaker 3you know. So yeah, you know that because I've I grew up with a church where you know, people said miracles happening all the time, you know, my cancer is gone and everything like that. But that question, why won't God hel amputees is something I never thought about, you know, because I'm like, yeah, I've never seen you know, someone leg grow.
Speaker 1Out, you know, right, would prey amazing.
Speaker 2And around this time was.
Speaker 3Two thousand and three when we went over to them the least, if you know what I mean. You know what I mean around that time was around that time, so a lot of you know, people were coming home without their limbs, you know, thinking God and everything like that.
Speaker 2But I'm like, well, I won't God heal them?
Speaker 4You know?
Speaker 3So these became very very serious questions in my head. And then I got to a point where I'm like, all right, you know what, I'm not religious anymore, but I'm really really spiritual.
Speaker 1Classics, you're hitting all the classes.
Speaker 2I love it, all the classes, Like these constricts. I'm very very spiritual.
Speaker 3And I just say that, you know, God is the foundation of reality.
Speaker 2Whatever the fuck that.
Speaker 3Means, what it means, whatever the hell that means, you know, God is the foundation of reality. And then I started thinking to myself. It took a few months for me to think about it. I'm like, Okay, I gotta think about this. If if I'm play, if I'm subscribing everything as God, if God is indistinguishable from this water bottle, that's basically no God at all, you know, I mean, because it's like, what, what is institutionable from an all love and all powerful God or a God that created the universe and just
Speaker 3kind of screwed off somewhere to create other universes that doesn't interact with ours?
Speaker 2Why even call that a god? We're here on all anyway.
Speaker 1The result of an all loving God? What's the What does a non loving god look like?
Speaker 4Right?
Speaker 2What does that look? How do we even compare?
Speaker 1I don't understand because I strategedy seem to happen all the time, right, yeah, yeah exactly.
Speaker 3So really started to like really question this, really, like, man, this is this seems really very silly. But then when I when I finally find out, when I finally kind of realized I don't believe anymore. I kind of asked myself essentially two questions. Number One, can I believe in something without any type of proof evidence that is true, none at all, Right, because I realized that at this point there's no evidence for anything. There's no there's no evers for any of this. Yeah, any religion, as a
Speaker 3matter of fact, there's there's no evidence for it. So I like, can I actually sincerely believe something? Can it can be convincing something and have no evidence that is true. If someone tells me that I found a pot of gold and I have a lepro chawn, just trust me, bro.
Speaker 2Am I going to believe that? You know?
Speaker 1I'm probably not? You know, I see that that video. Remember when they drew that picture. He's like, let's go find the Leprechaun. You know, yeah exactly.
Speaker 3Everybody said, yeah, I remember that video.
Speaker 2Yeah.
Speaker 3So I'm like, can I sincerely believe in something without evidence that is true? And I was like, no, I can't. I've never been like that, you know. But I said, Okay, people have community around it. It's given them morals and purpose and drive. Sure, And I said, can I have that without it? Do I need that to have it? And that answer was also no, I don't need it to have it. That's a hard swallow for a lot of people.
Speaker 1I think a lot of people like get as far as you did whoor I did? Where it's like, yeah, I don't know if any of this stuff is true, but like I kind of need this community anyway, because where how does my life have purpose without that? Right exactly?
Speaker 2That's that's really tough. Yeah, And it was. Yeah, it was a it was a hard pill of swallow man.
Speaker 3And I was like, you know what, I don't think I can How.
Speaker 2Did you do it? How did you figure out? Okay, well I don't need this anymore?
Speaker 1Right?
Speaker 2But what was that? What was that answer for you? It was those two questions essentially.
Speaker 3The answer was basically, cannot ask the city believe something without any evidence. And I was like, okay, so you're kind of realizing you can't and me, yeah, you have to regardless, right, you have to follow this route exactly. So at this point I was like, I'm gonna have to let this go because it wasn't easy either.
Speaker 2It was what time was this this happening?
Speaker 3This was around the time I was I think maybe from the ages this this of two years, from the ages of twenty six to twenty eight. I was answered asking myself these questions, like repeatedly, cannot actually believe something without any evidence that it's true, because like, I don't operate that way in any other fashion, no other fashion, do operate that way if you were to come, come up and tell me, Because I think around the time is where manifestation really took off, you know, the law of attraction that thing. Yeah, it really took off, right,
Speaker 3And when I was looking at this all like, y'ah, this is bullshit. You know, there's a whole bunch of crap like this, this, this doesn't make any sense. Yeah, I mean it was around the time where people got really into like blaming everything on the Illuminati, you know what I mean?
Speaker 1Yes, why is Yeah?
Speaker 2That was the thing. Remember back in the early two thousands, in twenty.
Speaker 1Tens, anybody, any celebrity that did like this was was in the Illuminati ch.
Speaker 3Rihanna Albuminati, and I was like, Yo, is that justin Bieber's an Illuminati? You know, I mean all the metal bands are you know, I'm like, Yo, this is bullshit.
Speaker 2There's no evidence it is. This seems kind of crazy, y'all.
Speaker 3And so I'm like, yo, in no other uh, in no other contexts do I just believe without any evidence, but people just telling me that it's true.
Speaker 2You know, no other.
Speaker 3Evidence do I do? No the contexts do I do that? So why am I doing that for?
Speaker 1For religion? Religion?
Speaker 4You know?
Speaker 2I mean, why am I believing?
Speaker 3You know, it is two thousand year book that really there's no evidence for it to be true. Let's say that because a person that I was walking around as like a real guy, say that's true.
Speaker 1Right?
Speaker 2Is there any evidence that we did the miracles? The powers?
Speaker 1You know.
Speaker 2Know that they're really so.
Speaker 1Folks, I'm talking to falsi right now. Valses give me their great, awesome story. I'm loving to hear it. We want to talk to you that. We do have some open lines. So if you want to call it and tell us, hey, God's actually real and false, he's wrong? Hey, come tell us. Okay, well, we're happy to chat with you about it. I've definitely fal see what when when people have told their stories like this, some people have said, well, you know, if you just encountered apologetics, if only you had gotten you know, this particular truth about Christianity, you know,
Speaker 1then you you'd still be a believer. Have you ever gotten it?
Speaker 2Takes like that from people when you tell your story, yeah, all the time, all the time, those like something wance that happened to you in church? Uh you know who.
Speaker 1This is?
Speaker 6This?
Speaker 1You know you went to a bad church, you know, but the beliefs are still real, right, I get that all the time.
Speaker 3And and the thing is what really annoys me about that is that I'll always tell people always also with this, I'm like, y'all, nothing happened to me, right, Like I wasn't hurt by anybody, and not number one, that kind of trivializes people who actually did go through something.
Speaker 2In the church. Yes, So like I love someone.
Speaker 1I love that because it's like, oh, no, you just went to a bad church.
Speaker 2Okay.
Speaker 1So there are bad churches. Then there are churches that abuse people. What what are we doing about that? You know, like, what's going on?
Speaker 2So what's going on with that? Exactly?
Speaker 3I was like, y'all, so if someone if someone left the church because they got abused, They're like, yeah, that's a it's a it's a very very good question.
Speaker 2Why would a loving God take them through that?
Speaker 3While we're loving God, let the let a pastor you know, do stuff with them be bad with children. Everyone understands what I'm saying. You know why I would have loving God do that.
Speaker 2You know. So, uh, that was number one, but number two.
Speaker 3I always tell people like y'all, my greatest fondest memories came from church. You know, like to this day when I think about my my childhood, one of my fondest memories, you know is Christmas time and doing pageants around Christmas time. You know where do I do that at? I did that at church. I used to be in plays. I used to do plays and in the plays that we did every single year was fan them with the opera.
Speaker 2Where I do that? I did that at church?
Speaker 4Church.
Speaker 2Hold on that because that is not very uh christ like play.
Speaker 1I will say, I feel like it's a little easy, but because.
Speaker 3Yeah, it is a little skeasy because we we did it. We did a very very like uh uh, what what would I say? It wasn't all the lines and everything like that. What it would do is it was basically all the couples line up and we kind of formed like a semi circle, and you know, the like the boys and the girls meet in the middle, and you know, we do a little twirl and and and then we enclose a circle and then we open it up, and then in the middle is like the princess, and coming down the aisle is the fandom with like the half mask and everything like that. And then they come down
Speaker 3and they do a dance and we all do a dance and everything like that. And that was all span up with the opera.
Speaker 1Okay, So no, no, no, no things about like having sex with her while she's I don't know that. That's that's the first you never heard Fan of a Christian play version of Fan of the opera. But okay, it was.
Speaker 3Very silly and very corny, very corny, very corny to the other thing I was.
Speaker 2I was a Christian rapper myself.
Speaker 3That was very corny, you know, shot really yeah, yeah, yeah, I was a Christian rapper. They were called the the Gospel gangsters.
Speaker 1Gospel.
Speaker 2Yeah, they were called the gospel.
Speaker 1Case that sounds that sounds like something the onion would make. It's it was real.
Speaker 3It was gospel gainst us like it was a real thing, you know. And I really thought that I was gonna blow up one day, like I was gonna be Okay, I'm gonna be a rapper. I'm gonna change the rap game bringing lives to christ.
Speaker 1And I was like, yeah, man, I'm gonna be like Cray. You know I could. I can make music without cussing. Oh that's all Cray.
Speaker 2He came out like after I left the church. Okay, yeah, that makes it so so. But the thing is actually, actually, don't don't mind on me. Like you said, it is pretty good, pretty good. Listen, Hey, I've said this before. I agree.
Speaker 1I think you bring out any Christian music artists, and you asked me to bring out like who's the best, I would on ironically put La Cray up there.
Speaker 2Yeah, I stand.
Speaker 1With you on that.
Speaker 2Yeah, Locre is actually pretty good.
Speaker 3And and and the thing is like me leaving right, it's not like, you know, I changed as a person. I just don't believe this thing anymore. But if you put on some Kirk Franklin, I'm like, yeah, Kirk, Kirk Franklin, still slap.
Speaker 1It's still slap. Still many Christian artists, right, So it's like, of course there's got some that are good, like just you know, you pull some out of a hat. But the problem is most of them are I feel like, oh god, I don't know. That's a whole other topic. But I do feel like, if you had to pick, I don't know what it is, because it's like, it's not like Christianity says no, you're not allowed to make good music or whatever. I don't know, but I guess people feel creatively limited because it is. It's a creatively limiting religion in a way. You do have to fall astin a lot of rules, and you fall things and
Speaker 1say things a certain way in order to keep up with the culture. Right, So I feel like there must be something to that that makes that makes Christian music not as not as let's say popular as other genres, right.
Speaker 3Yeah, because this is one thing that that dead I've said. I like if every Christian rapper was basically like Lacreate and the then the genre would be more expansive because la Create talks about more than than just you know how much I'm down for Jesus or whatever. He actually talks about, you know, him growing up, going struggles like him going through depression, struggling with identity, I mean, struggling with certain I think.
Speaker 1And he gets pushed back for that because he's not about your personal struggles. It's about how you've overcome those struggles through Jesus. Right, He's like, no, I had struggles though, actually and maybe exactly.
Speaker 3Yeah, he said I have struggles and I still have them, you know also, which is why the reasons I don't I'll remind him.
Speaker 2And not only that the production is good.
Speaker 3Every other Christian rapper I've heard every single song, every single one of them, every time they came out, every single one of them was how much they loved Jesus and how much the world hates them for loving Jesus. It's like, the world don't hate you for loving Jesus, they hate you for being annoying.
Speaker 2Every single songs the same ship.
Speaker 5Bro.
Speaker 1Yeah, it's true. It's true because it's like, Okay, what what new thing are you bringing to the table that every other Christian artist hasn't done? Right, is exactly Jesus and Jesus awesome means the best. Okay, I get it. It's like, you know, but if that's not for you, it's not for you. So I was like, I was like, oh, y'all, y'all, y'all, y'all was boring the ship. Bro, y'all y'all boring me.
Speaker 4Man.
Speaker 2I was like, I've tried you.
Speaker 3I mean, I've really tried to because you know, I'm a huge hip hop fan, you know, big hip hop, and I'm a big rap nerd. So it's like, you know, I want to hear some flows on here, some bars. I want to hear what you got, you know, I mean, tell me, tell me how you're gonna flip this Bible verse into a bar. And I want it gotta be fire, you know, I mean, let me hear it, and then I and then I hear it.
Speaker 2I'm and and everybody's like.
Speaker 3You know, Jesus is the one, He's my dog in the world hates me like hi, bro, Like.
Speaker 1You know, no, it is born. But that's what Like, man, we can't keep talking about the tool. We got to get those callers there because no way, nobody knows what we're talking about here. This is such a specific niche like, we're talking about Christian living and also Christian rap. But like I remember when Chance the Rapper came out with coloring Book. Do you remember that? And I like, this is the best Christian rap album I've ever heard of my life, and it's it's barely even Christian, Like yes, like he talks about the gospel he talks about Jesus and stuff, but he's also talking about uh, I don't know, people killing themselves.
Speaker 3And stuffy all that stuff, and actually actual things that are mattering in our lives, you know, mental health.
Speaker 1I don't know that. I'm not going to say that album was part of my own deconstruction. I think that gives it too much credit. But it was it a part of my life where I was deconstructing. When that came out and I realized how much, uh, like, Christian music was just not going to do it for me.
Speaker 4You know.
Speaker 1It's just like if this is the best that we're doing. And it was good, but it was like this is this is an exception to the.
Speaker 2Rule, you know what I mean? Like most isn't like this, And it's like, why why is it like this?
Speaker 1Why can't people who inspire for the Holy Spirit make inspiring tracks? You know?
Speaker 2And they just don't. I don't know, it doesn't work.
Speaker 3They a lot of times what happens in the church, I think, I think this is the tradition that why like that. It's because they take secular mood on music and then basically put Christianity into it. Remember we're talking about before the show with fifty cent and you said that the most you know fift decent is in the club.
Speaker 2Yeah, that's true, that.
Speaker 1Is what I said.
Speaker 2I'm not a.
Speaker 1Video game. He made it like a weird, a bad video game in the two thousands. It's like Blood on the Sand or something. I think, Yeah, yeah, I love on the Street. I remember that one. It was pretty bad.
Speaker 2But like, don't laugh.
Speaker 3But in that time, you would go to you go, You'll go to a church, especially if it's a black church. Go to a black church, and to get the youth hype. You would hear the Christian version of in the club. And I ain't gonna lie to you. They'll say you could find me in the church, buckets full of Bibles. Yes, say stuff like that.
Speaker 2You could find me in the church.
Speaker 3It was like God, and you thought that it was as a kid, I thought this was the greatest thing I ever heard of my life.
Speaker 2As a kid. It was that remind me, sorry you finished your story. No, no, it was it.
Speaker 3And even now to today, you will find, you know, people who would still take you know, circular music and just put Jesus in there and and everything like that. It's it's hilariously bad. And I think that's why when it comes to like a lot of Christian music, whether it's pop or hip hop or anything like that, you would find them making basically Christian versions of you know, cycle of music.
Speaker 2I remember I saw that before.
Speaker 3I don't know if anyone's swifty here, but Taylor Swift a few years like what was that ten years back, came off with that shake it Off song? That yeah, that song, right, And then a few months later a Christian pop artist came out with a song to leave the world behind You gotta shake, Shake, shake, same thing, the same exact thing, you know. So it's like you just made shake it off and put Jesus in it, you know what I mean, that's what you do.
Speaker 2And it sucks. It sucks.
Speaker 1It's bad.
Speaker 2It's very bad. You know.
Speaker 1Last thing we got to we got we gotta get to call here because I hope people want to talk to you. But man, I got you talk about That story reminded me. I can't remember if I told the story in the show before.
Speaker 4But.
Speaker 1Uh, when when by You at Drank came out, Okay, that was like seven, So I was a kid at that time, and I went to. Uh, that summer, I went to one of those day camp places because my parents worked and stuff, and so I just went to like a Christian day camp during the day and.
Speaker 2They made a music video of buy You at Drank, but it was like that.
Speaker 1I don't even think they changed the lyrics of the song, so I don't know how they got away with that. But they made a music video with like the camp counselors and it was like about a guy buying a girl like a drink from the vending machine. If you ever hear that song, that is a song about a man buying a woman alcohol for sex. And I don't know at this at this at this Christian daycamp I went to, because I'm pretty sure again they did not change like any lyrics.
Speaker 2So I'm gonna take you home with me and everything.
Speaker 1Yeah, I mean the whole the whole nine yards. It was all there. So I don't know how that's great.
Speaker 4Man.
Speaker 2I need, man, I want to listen to more cheesy Christian rap.
Speaker 1Bro you got me in a move that's.
Speaker 2Yeah, yeah, it's it's so bad.
Speaker 1Uh, this is a Collins show, so I think we should start talking to some callers.
Speaker 2What do you think Oh yeah, let's some callers. Let's go ahead. All right, let's do it.
Speaker 1Before we take our first caller, I have some quick announcements I have to make for you. One, we are excited to announce our launch of a twenty twenty five sorry, twenty twenty six. We're in twenty twenty six baby, twenty twenty six back Cruise. It's happening this year August fifteenth at seven pm. Tickets are on sale now and they're going fast. If you don't know, every single year in Austin we do a thing where we go around the waters around here and we go look at the bats that come out of Congress Bridge and it's really cool. We also have a special special guest lecture that's gonna
Speaker 1be happening on that Friday, and a community outing activity on the day during Saturday as well, followed by.
Speaker 2Our annual members town hall.
Speaker 1And also if you're going to be around that week, ed we'll be doing our ACA shows live in the Free Thought Library studio, so come check that out. We're also featuring special guests, generically Modified Skeptic and the Antibot. Tickets are available for that at a dot Show slash Back cruise. And also I need to thank our patron of the week, So let me go ahead and thank our wonderful, awesome patrons that help make this show happen every single week. This week's patron of the week is going to be Trumbelle Priez don Nelson. Thank you so much, Don Nelson, and thank you to everybody that donates on
Speaker 1the Patreon. You guys are amazing. And so with that out of the way, let's take our first caller of the day. We got John calling in from California. John, you are live on Truth wanted what's going on?
Speaker 4Hi?
Speaker 1John? You there? Hello?
Speaker 6Yes, yes, I said Hi.
Speaker 4Can you hear me? Okay?
Speaker 1I don't know if it's on our end, John, but you're a real quiet right I'm gon'll let the figure that out.
Speaker 2Or if you can speak as loud as you.
Speaker 1Can you hear me.
Speaker 2Great.
Speaker 4I'm not muted. I don't think can you hear you?
Speaker 1It's better now I think it was on our end, John, go ahead, Thank you for you.
Speaker 6Pa Okay, I was thinking was I muted or something?
Speaker 1But now well you're good. You're good.
Speaker 2You were just quiet on us.
Speaker 6Go ahead, okay, Sorry, yeah, no, no, Nicole screen or specifically said, don't ask.
Speaker 4Don't ask if they.
Speaker 6Can hear you. But anyway, yeah, sorry.
Speaker 1Sorry, you know the technical difficulties, but we're working through it, so we're ready for you now.
Speaker 6But okay, I want to explain a naturalistic concept of God, why nature is the only real God.
Speaker 1The living God.
Speaker 6Okay, first, I just first, I just want to very quickly say that, unlike both of you guys, I was never a Christian. I became an atheist when I was six years old. I was an atheist for more than sixty years, but my thinking has evolved. Now I believe that Nature is the only real God that has ever existed.
Speaker 1Okay, that's interesting because we just talked about how we don't find arguments like that convincing.
Speaker 2But you know what, let's hear your take. Let's hear what you have to say pantheists arguments.
Speaker 1No, just in general, Like I don't know if you were if you were listening, you may not have been tuned in yet. But actually was just saying how he was considering these ideas of like God being in sort of everything, right, but we couldn't really distinguish what makes God and everything and nothing in everything. So it was kind of a you know, kind of didn't go anywhere for us. But you know, you see what you have to say.
Speaker 6No, no, that God is that God is everything is stupid. No, no, no, okay, I'm not into that us everything God is everything.
Speaker 4Yeah. No, now that's stupid. Okay.
Speaker 6Anyway, I've got three main points.
Speaker 4I'd like to get to all three points as quickly.
Speaker 6As possible, in less than five minutes or six minutes if possible.
Speaker 1Oh, how about we doing one point at a time, because I don't know if I want to you know, we want to have it back.
Speaker 6In right exactly exactly. Point number one takes only thirty seconds, then all.
Speaker 2Okay, that's fair.
Speaker 6See, Okay, First, I want to clarify what I mean by the word nature. I'm not using the terrestrial definition of nature, the common or colloquial definition of nature, the birds and forests and natural phenomena here on Earth. I'm referring to the universal cosmic definition of nature, the entire physical universe, the stars, galaxies, planets, gravity, some atomic articles, all matter, energy, space, natural forces and processes, and the fundamental laws that govern them throughout the universe. That's what
Speaker 6I mean when I'm talking about nature, not the birds and trees and stuff you're on earth.
Speaker 2Sure that makes sense to me.
Speaker 6Okay, and I definitely don't.
Speaker 4Yeah. Not God is everything?
Speaker 6No, okay, good, good good. We got to God as everything out of the way, Okay. So point number two is that's going to take like forty.
Speaker 4Five seconds for me to tell you that one.
Speaker 1But that first one a point that was more of just a clarifying of your definitions.
Speaker 6Then well exactly, yeah, right, it was a definition, right, Okay, okay, So point number two to help establish that nature is the only real God, I'll start by pointing out the most commonly accepted attribute of the Christian God. The primary attribute or role of the Christian God is that it's the creator of the universe. According to the Bible, the Christian God created everything in the universe. But science has shown us that everything in the universe was created through natural forces and natural processes. Created the stars, galaxies, planets,
Speaker 6and everything else, and it did so without any conscious intentional agency. Nature also created life through natural processes such as a biogenesis and natural selection. The universe was created through natural causes rather than supernatural causes.
Speaker 4That's point number two.
Speaker 1Okay, I mean, besides, we're created, you know, that's the that's the only one to be maybe nitpick on because some people and anither we're created, they're like, oh, that implies intent, right, I don't think there's intent implied. I don't think. I'm not sure if that's what you're implying when you used that word. But like I would leave besides that, I think I pretty much agree. I mean, would you agree with Valse with everything's in there.
Speaker 3Yeah, it seems that we pretty much agree with everything that we're saying here.
Speaker 2But I guess you're going to sway this's in point number three.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 3Yeah, let's see what point number three three is because I do have a question here, but go ahead.
Speaker 6Oh and I'm sorry if my talk over you by accident or something. But anyway, so no, oh no, no, let's deal with this implied intent crap. I want to get that out of the way right now. To then here it tats me. Yeah, okay, Uh, you're getting kind of a theological old school But I was going to say for framework, but.
Speaker 1John, no, No.
Speaker 6In physic and the biology, creation is not an act of conscious intent and does not require an intentional agent.
Speaker 4Genesis.
Speaker 6Biogenesis literally is literally the universe creating life.
Speaker 4By transforming non living.
Speaker 6Matter into living organisms.
Speaker 4And there is nothing whatsoever in.
Speaker 6The process of a biogenesis that requires or implies an intentional agent.
Speaker 1You're preaching to the choir, John, We're on the same page there. We have no quality about that.
Speaker 6Because okay, I guess I'll confess that I called tak Heathen. Uh it's five five weeks ago or so and talked to Christian Sophia, and Sophia was, yeah, I couldn't get off that thing that the word create.
Speaker 1I'm not Sophia, I'm not Christie. You're talking to two other people.
Speaker 6So, oh you know, okay, so point so we'll go to point number three. Okay, good, good, Oh okay, we're six minutes in. Okay, good, Okay. I'm sorry, but point number three is more complex and takes two and a half minutes. So I've broken it up into three parts to make it easier for you.
Speaker 1To jump in.
Speaker 2Okay, Well, that's that's just six points.
Speaker 1Then that's that's three points in a trench coat with three other points in it. So you know, I don't know if I like that, but say what you feel like you need to say, and we'll we'll take it from there.
Speaker 6Okay, okay, okay. Nature is a conscious intelligence, sentient, living god that gains knowledge and discovers itself through us. My concept of the living God is the fusion of Spinosa's pantheus god combined with the emergent consciousness of the universe. By putting these two concepts together, we create a whole new way of looking at God, a realistic God, a scientifically provable God. I want to briefly explain Spinosa's God and then explain emergent consciousness.
Speaker 1That's it.
Speaker 4That's it.
Speaker 6That's the hard part.
Speaker 1I guess how also, you feel free to time in at any any point here because.
Speaker 3I need uh, I'm sorry, Can you just repeat that third point one more time please? Because it seems like everything that you said uprom point one to point two was all about it being natural and unintentional, and then once it get to point three, now we reach something with intention.
Speaker 1Yeah, consciousness, that's exactly because you said they're insentient.
Speaker 2So if it's didn't invite means a tent here. Yeah, Well that's a good yeah.
Speaker 6No, that's a good point because the first part of the universe. Yeah, and until until emerging consciousness happened. Yeah, everything was unintentional. But I'll get to that and the third the third part. I'll be talking about emergent constant consciousness in.
Speaker 4The third part of this thing.
Speaker 6So do you want me to go back and say that again or no?
Speaker 2I see what you're saying that.
Speaker 1You're saying that the universe didn't start with a consciousness but now it does have No no, no, no, no, no, no.
Speaker 6No no no, I'm not into pan psychism, none of that trap. No no no, no, no no no. The universe didn didn't have a consciousness to start. No, this is all the evolving universe developed an emergent consciousness.
Speaker 1I will say, you're very very quickly dismissive of pan psychism and some other people's ideas. I mean, your idea is the minority as well, right, so oh yeah, I don't know, yeah, quick to dismiss some of these other people's ideas. And you're like, no, actually, I'm totally right about this when most people probably don't agree with your with your take, you know.
Speaker 6Uh no, no, no, no, no, I know I'm definitely a minority. But no, when you bring up pan psychism, and because no, I want to I want to put the kebash on that right away to explain that emergent consciousness has nothing to do with pan psychism or a high mind kind of thing, or or a supernatural mind.
Speaker 1Okay, you're going to explain that because it seems like they're kind of related to me. You're talking about nature having consciousness.
Speaker 6Right right, right, right, right right, And now we're do you want to now move on to uh, yes, here.
Speaker 1Now, so what do you say?
Speaker 6Oh, yeah, it's okay, Okay, we're almost.
Speaker 1We're almost through.
Speaker 4So I'm going to give you a very.
Speaker 6Quick description of Spinoza's God. Uh this Spinosa's God, and then emerging consciousness. So we've got to get to emerging consciousness. Okay, everything that exists in the universe, operating according to the laws of nature is a self contained, unified system that is God. Nature is God. That's a very short summary of Spinoza's God.
Speaker 1Okay.
Speaker 4Now.
Speaker 6One of the reasons why Spinoza's concept of God is important and valuable is because it teaches us to stop looking at God as a supernatural being that exists outside the laws of nature and start looking at God as a natural universal system that exists within the laws of nature. It replaces supernatural God with natural God. It also teaches us to look at the universe as a unified, interconnected whole. The universe is not a bunch of random objects floating around in space. It's a unified system of forces and processes governed by the laws of nature. Each individual thing
Speaker 6within the universe is an interconnected part of the universe. And it's worth noting that Albert Einstein believed in Spinoza's God. Okay, but the main problem with Spinoza's God is that it's a cold, impersonal concept of God that has no personal characteristics. It's like a machine. It doesn't have a realistic mind or consciousness. It doesn't see or think or feel. But we can solve this problem by combining Spinoza's God with the emergent consciousness of the universe.
Speaker 4And the emergent.
Speaker 6Consciousness that's the good part.
Speaker 1So we're there. We're almost there. Oh, I hope we're almost there. We're taking quite a journey here.
Speaker 3Yeah, life, I've already already have an issue with this. Well, go ahead, yeah, can.
Speaker 1You wrap it up for thirty more seconds and then see where we go from there.
Speaker 6This is sixty seconds for emergent cosmic consciousness.
Speaker 1You go for it.
Speaker 4Okay, I can explain emergent.
Speaker 6Cosmic consciousness in a simple, easy to understand way. For billions of years, Nature was as stupid as a rock. Before Nature created life, the universe had no consciousness, no intelligence at all. The universe was not even aware of its own existence because there was no way for the universe to observe or perceive its own existence. It could have remained a lifeless, unconscious universe for eternity. But Nature has the intrinsic ability to create life, which evolved into conscious, intelligent life that enabled the universe to come alive and be fully conscious. Nature gained the ability to see itself,
Speaker 6to learn about itself, to experience the awesomeness of its cosmic creation through us, through our eyes, through our senses, through our minds. After billions of years of being as stupid and blind as a rock, Nature's unconscious universe opened its eyes and came alive through us. Nature became a living god to us and all the other intelligent beings inhabitable planets throughout the universe. Okay, he did it in under sixty seconds.
Speaker 1He did it, we had the timer on screen. John, congratulations. You may be one of the only only college in the history of the show that actually finished what they need to say in under sixty seconds when we asked him to do it under sixty seconds. Bravo, props.
Speaker 6How much how much gonn I have left?
Speaker 2Here's the thing.
Speaker 1I one thing is normally with these kinds of calls, I'm very wary, okay, because people have a tendency to prattle on. I let you do your thing, because you obviously had some written down ahead of time. You thought about this, and you had some ideas for it, So I let you say your piece. I want to say a few things on this now that you've gotten to the meat and potatoes of it. First of all, thank you for calling in and giving us your thoughts.
Speaker 2On this so far.
Speaker 1It strikes me how much, at least in the first half I agree with you, like, yes, we see to be on the same page. And then of course, right when we get to the when the roader beats the road, that's when we have these these these interesting ideas.
Speaker 2So like what you're saying.
Speaker 1Is is is comprehensible.
Speaker 2But where I fail to understand is why call any of this god?
Speaker 4Right?
Speaker 2What do we need to say?
Speaker 1I mean, we could say the universe observing itself because we're part of the universe, and I get that, but why why call it god? Why not just say we're just a part of the universe and just like leave it at that.
Speaker 2I don't understand.
Speaker 1Because the God is part of it is always going to have that supernatural connotation. It's always going to have this stuff that you you clearly very much don't want.
Speaker 2To be associated with. So why why call this god? I guess this is my first question.
Speaker 3Yeah, I was going to say the exact same thing, because it's like when whenever we talk about these god concepts, right, one thing that I've noticed is that people for God, people either make it a label, a gap, or it's a myth. Yeah, yeah, I mean that's that's always the three things. As a label, a gap, is a myth. And right now, what you're doing is just putting a label on something that is that's already a natural phenomenon. Right, Everything that you're saying already has a name for it, right, physics, nature, except like you know, physics, the laws of physics, fundamental forces,
Speaker 3elementary particles, consciousness, all this already has a word and uses on encompassing all this under the label of God.
Speaker 2But I don't see a reason to do that. Yes, the reason to do that?
Speaker 1Yeah, yeah, well you.
Speaker 6Know I particularly you would say that. So yeah, and I've got ten arguments all set up ready to go. The function argument, the emergent cosmic conscious argument, the reality argument, the ingratitude argument, the you.
Speaker 1Need ten arguments tell us why you call it?
Speaker 4I'm sorry, what's that?
Speaker 1I'm sorry to interrupt you, But do you need ten arguments to tell us why you call it God?
Speaker 6I think ten arguments nail it down from every angle.
Speaker 6Are you looking for like a Twitter? You're looking for like the Twitter version?
Speaker 4I guess.
Speaker 2Not that.
Speaker 3I just what we're looking for is for you to kind of succinctly like kind of elucidy what you're saying, right, Because I don't think we need ten different thirty minutes argument for this.
Speaker 2Yeah, when when.
Speaker 3You say, when do you say, when you put all these things together and call it God?
Speaker 2Why are you doing that?
Speaker 3I think I think that I think one or two paragraphs should be enough for you to explain why. You know what I mean, because I just I get that we're part of the universe, and we're conscious and we're self aware, so us make part of the universe basically means that we are away for the universe to observe and understand itself. Right, I called laws Acan said, I think that's a very beautiful call, Sagan. We are we are the way for the universe to understand itself. That's all getting well, But you wouldn't call us god either. We're we're just humanity, right, So it's like you're putting
Speaker 3the label of God on onto something that doesn't need the label, and we're we're just wondering why do that?
Speaker 6I'm just wondering which of the which is the which are the ten arguments would be best?
Speaker 2But do we need another ten arguments?
Speaker 1Very quickly go with like why is it so hard? Well, I understand you've had so thought up until this point.
Speaker 4Oh yeah, and it's all all written down.
Speaker 1Yeah yeah, yeah, and that because most people that call in don't have stuff written down for us.
Speaker 2But why why not just give us a simple answer?
Speaker 1I mean, we understand that maybe there's nuances to the argument, but can you just give us a baseline here?
Speaker 6Oh, there's all kinds of nuances.
Speaker 4Okay, okay, the function I'll.
Speaker 6Just start with the first one, the function argument. Nature does what a god is supposed to do. Nature creates and sustains all physical reality throughout the universe. The Christian God is supposed to have created the heavens and the earth and all life, but in reality, nature did it.
Speaker 1Well, I'm sorry to interrupt again, but historically, I don't know if that's always what a god is supposed to do. God is always. First of all, God's a different idea in different cultures in different time periods.
Speaker 4Right.
Speaker 2But like also that God.
Speaker 1Is TH's from nature in most cases, right, Like God is is a separately identifying thing. Like he's either the creator of nature or he's he's in nature doing things right. Again, depends on your mythology or folks or what have you. So we go back to this question, why call it God?
Speaker 6Yeah, but I'm not sure how you're gonna get it that you're gonna be talking to us to the listening. I mean, you, I said to Christian God and then you go on the.
Speaker 1Call with us for over ten minutes. Now you you have spoken the majority of the time. Okay, So I don't want to get this, Oh you're not listening thing. Man, This is a call in show. We try to give everybody as much time as we can. You get more than most, okay, So don't give me that no attitude with me, please? You can. You can summarize your ideas I think more succinctly here okay.
Speaker 3But thank God that it depends on your your spiritual tradition, right because like, for example, I'm of Haitian descent and Haitian voodoo gods are part of nature themselves, like they are nature themselves, so they're not a separate part of nature. So are you going more on on that end where the gods are nature part of nature themselves or nature themselves or why is the label there? That's what I'm saying, because you're having the label of God being nature itself.
Speaker 1But why Okay?
Speaker 6By thinking of nature as God, we're showing deep respect, reverence, and gratitude for the miraculous gifts that nature has given us, the priceless gift of human consciousness and intelligence, The priceless gift of life on this beautiful, amazing planet with all of its natural resources, the breatable air that keeps us alive, the beautiful forests and lakes, the gorgeous sunsets. I mean, obviously, the use of the word god is involves a value judgment. By thinking of nature as God, we're putting nature on its proper pedestal and showing that nature is extremely important
Speaker 6to us. We acknowledge that without nature we wouldn't even exist.
Speaker 4We make nature a constant.
Speaker 6Part of our thoughts in our daily life, which is easy for me because I live in the foothills of northern California, surrounded by a dense forest next to a beautiful lake. It may be more difficult for you to experience this on a daily basis if you live in an urban or suburban environments surrounded by concrete, asphalt and man made structures, where humans dominate the landscape and nature seems so small that it's almost non existent.
Speaker 2Okay, all right, John, I respect that.
Speaker 1I respect that you you gave us a direct answer on this.
Speaker 2Finally, this is good. That was excellent. I wish we had that earlier. So I like that answer. What I would say to it earlier, but go ahead, John, you didn't get to it earlier, though you could have read that. You could have said that earlier, but earlier. Listen, listen. I like that answer.
Speaker 1My response to this is this, I think plenty of people in this world have a deep reverence and respect for nature and don't have to call it God, right, A lot of people. I mean, we already mentioned Carl Sagan, I think is a great example of a man who had a very deep respect for nature, more so than most humans on earth, and did not believe in God or call anything God in the slightest didn't use that. And I understand that, you know you mentioned einst earlier. He was one that was more comfortable with that God language. But I think between FALSEI and I, I don't think
Speaker 1we have to have a God language to describe, uh, what nature is and have a reverence and respect for it. I think that a reverence or respect is healthy in that in that sense. But I don't know if I need God to do that, right. I just I just don't see that language. As I say, do you agree with that, Falsey, what do you think?
Speaker 3Yeah, I'll agree with that because that was gonna be my question. The reverence that you're talking about, the gratitude. I feel that all the time, you know. I mean especially when I go out into the to the countryside over in the Caribbean, where you know, there's not a lot of urban areas where you can go out to the countryside, look up at the at the sky and see the Milky Way in its full glory. Like I feel that reverence and you know, the sense of awe of how small I am compared to the rest of the universe.
Speaker 2I feel that all the time.
Speaker 3Right, So the question is do we need to put the navel of God in order to feel that reverence, in order to feel that gratitude? Do you need to put the label of God on nature in order to do that? And if you don't the labelfore yeah, well.
Speaker 2No you don't.
Speaker 6You don't have to use that label. And I know that for you guys, having been Christians and now atheists, but we don't like.
Speaker 1That word God.
Speaker 4It has a lot of maybe has a.
Speaker 6Lot of pain or bad memories or trauma or something, and you don't want to you don't like that work God. At least I've encountered that. But by basically well to me. The semantic argument the word God is too important the word By referring to nature as God, we're not just using the word God as a semantic substitute for nature. It ultimately comes down to the degree of importance, value, and reverence we give to nature. When we refer to nature as merely the word nature, we aren't ascribing a positive value judgment to nature. The word nature is just
Speaker 6a neutral term. But when we get nature the title of God, we are ascribing the highest possible value in respect that a human being can just distill upon anything. Considering that Nature created everything in the universe, created our sacred home, the planet Earth, created of the human species, gave us the priceless gift of life on this amazing planet, gave us the priceless gift of human consciousness and intelligence. It is only right and just and proper that we call Nature the only real God, that the living God. You don't have to call him God. You can be
Speaker 6an ungrateful atheist. I've got the ingratitude argument.
Speaker 1See John, there's that judgment again. It like oooh, that's nasty man. You you, this has happened, this entire call you seem to judge every other person that doesn't have your specific worldview on this. Man, you know, I gotta say, that's kind of turn off.
Speaker 3Yeah, And I was gonna say, man, like us not calling it God, as we know, we don't have gratitude like of course, you know, like if I go onto the forest and I see redwood trees of California, that's going to be amazing to see, right. I would love to see that one day, and I will have gratitude that is feeding me oxygen at the moment. That doesn't mean that, you know, just because I don't say to the redwood trees or the mausoleum network of fungus, is therefore God, they're from ungrateful for from me being alive.
Speaker 2That's kind of silly. Yeah, not great. Yeah, I just don't agree with that framework.
Speaker 1Yeah, And we got to wrap things up here because we've been on this call for a while here, John, But like, here's here's an idea to think about here, And I think you've got enough some stuff to think about, so let me let me try to give you something here. Every person on this earth has a radically different sense of ideas and beliefs.
Speaker 2Okay, but by your framework.
Speaker 1They're also part of nature and therefore part of God and you, I don't know if you'd use the word God's creation, but they're part of that. And so for you to poo poo on every single other person who doesn't have the same exact ideas on you're kind of not giving God the reference there that maybe he deserves something to think about, right, Maybe other people are worthy of the respect and and and their own ideas on how they view nature, and and maybe just because they don't see it the exact same way you do, you don't have to be a dick about it. I don't know something to think about, man, but a little bit.
Speaker 2Yeah, you just said that we what did he say?
Speaker 7False?
Speaker 3He said that we were, Uh, if you can be ungrateful, atheists were ungrateful.
Speaker 1Yeah, I mean I'm ungrateful.
Speaker 3I was not gonna call I'm just gonna I'm gonna call nature God not grateful for nature? Yeah, I mean, like one of my favorite one of my favorite things to eat is salmon. Salmon is part of this part of nature, Right, I'm grateful for that.
Speaker 6Yeah.
Speaker 1And like when we were talking about pan psychism and some other ideas, you were like, oh no, that's that stuff's garbage. It's all terrible. It's like, okay, you know a little harsh.
Speaker 6Oh well, I suppose.
Speaker 4I guess maybe I'm a little.
Speaker 6Defensive, but based on and how it usually is to call in, uh, I mean calling shows.
Speaker 1Maybe you can't judge a book by its cover, right, I'm not I'm not Christy, I'm not Sophia so and this ain't talking heathen.
Speaker 2So I don't know what to tell you.
Speaker 4Man.
Speaker 6No, no, actually no, you've been been totally fair. That didn't Actually that's why I called in uh to you specifically damned, because yeah, you seem seemed different.
Speaker 1Yeah, yeah, yeah, I don't know about that, but I appreciate it regardless.
Speaker 6You wait, you know you don't know about what you're not.
Speaker 1You you you came in here fighting. You were like, oh, these other people are like this, and you were surprised when I said, hey, I'm actually not those people. It's like, and now you're saying, oh, well, that's why I called you.
Speaker 2It's like, well that why did you come in here fighting?
Speaker 4Bro?
Speaker 1Come on, don't do that?
Speaker 6Come on, well I didn't well I didn't guess I didn't realize it was like fighting, or that you guys would take it.
Speaker 4Then.
Speaker 1Yeah, it's almost as if you were judging a book by its cover.
Speaker 4Hm. When something to think about.
Speaker 6I don't know when I say things emphatically, I might not be concerning myself so much with your feelings, you know.
Speaker 4And stuff.
Speaker 6I'm just trying to get my points across and maybe not being maybe not being sensitive enough, sensitive enough to your feelings. I certainly didn't realize you were perceiving what I was saying as harsh or being a dick. I certainly did didn't intend to be a dick.
Speaker 1Well, I appreciate that, John. We got to we do have to wrap up this call, but I'll say this much. Yeah, when when you're present your ideas, and first of all, I mean, seriously, good job.
Speaker 2You had stuff friten ahead of time. You knew what you wanted to say.
Speaker 1Took a little bit to get there, but I respect the fact that you knew what you want to say.
Speaker 4Right.
Speaker 1Perception online and everywhere is everything. Okay, it doesn't matter if you're right. It matters if you're convincing. Okay, you can have the most brilliant argument in the world. But if if people think you're a dick about it, they might not listen to you, and the atheist community has had to learn that.
Speaker 2Lesson the hard way over the years.
Speaker 1Right, a lot of people in our not the best communicators, totally right. I agree one hundred percent on what some people in this space have said, and I absolutely hate the way that they said it. So if I could give you one thing, it would say, hey, man, just chill out, relax, okay, treat other people like human beings and not obstacles.
Speaker 2You got to overcome to get your point across.
Speaker 1And you know, I think you'll find people will be more receptive to you. Not always right, some people are just dicks and that's the way they is. But you know, hey, we were willing to listen and I think you got a lot of your idea. You didn't get all ten of those arguments out, but that was gonna happen anyway. So you know, we only have so much time. But anyway, John, good talking to you. Hope I can talk to you again sometime. You have a good one. And that's it. We're laughing that call up? What'd you think? Falsely?
Speaker 2That was? That was a long haul. We spend a lot of time with John. Yeah, yeah, that was pretty long.
Speaker 3I was I think, I don't think we ever got to the point of why label any of this as a god?
Speaker 2Like I don't see a reason to do that.
Speaker 1Like, yeah, well he gave his points, and his point was if he finally did give his point on that, which I was surprised because I didn't think he would. And what it to give a cursory a summary. It was because when you give something the label of God, inbukes a sense of reverence. It inbukes the sense of this is above other things and should be treated as such. And I get that, I get, you know, but I don't think I need that. And you know what, people say they respect nature, They fucking don't. They really don't.
Speaker 1Hot take, hot take. I'm a vegan, Okay, anytime I talk about animal rights, Oh suddenly everything they do is totally fine. No, we don't need to change anything. Actually, wait, what okay? You know, like I think there's a veneer of like sort of being in tune with nature and stuff that people really like because it makes them seem more in touch with the world. And and most of us aren't we most of us A lot of us live in cities. We do live in these concrete jungles and stuff, and you know, we do what we can. So I don't know if I I don't know if suddenly calling nature God is really going to do much
Speaker 1to change my worldview or my actions for the positive. I can see where it might work for someone like John and you know, good for them, but I just don't see it as necessary, right, Yeah, I don't see it.
Speaker 2It's unnecessary either.
Speaker 3And and and the thing is just like how you said, like people don't really respect nature.
Speaker 2Like I would love for us to.
Speaker 3If we did, we will be living in and living in like a solar punk reality right now.
Speaker 4Yeah.
Speaker 3And when I first got to Solo Punk, I was like, this is this is so awesome, This looks amazing and.
Speaker 2I would love to do it. Yeah, but we don't seem to be doing.
Speaker 1It, folks. We still have some open lines, so please come call us and talk to us. I know IVOLSI wants to talk to you about what you believe and why, and he hosts his own debate on that. Actually I want to ask you about that real quickly. I am going to get another announcement in before we move on here, and that announcement is to tell you to thank you, tell everyone thank you to the amazing, awesome, spectacular crew that helped make the show happen every single week. Let's go to that crew cam and say thanks to everybody
Speaker 1that helps make it work. There it is Boom, there's our group, and that's just the folks who are on camera. Folks, there's a lot of people that help make the show happen. And maybe you could be somebody that helps make the show happen.
Speaker 2If you think you would like to help out, definitely try.
Speaker 1You can email volunteer at Atheist hypomcommunity dot org to get involved. We're always looking for people to do video audio call screening moderating, so please come check it out if you want to be a volunteer. And I'm going to check this real quick. We do have Nope, that's the last week's super chats. So if we do have more super chats crew, let me know and I'll read those out. But I did want to ask you about your show, false because you you talk to people on your own show and you you have debates with folks.
Speaker 2Can you tell people a little bit more about what you do with that?
Speaker 3Oh, yeah, yeah, I switch up every every week. There are someone that have a religion week, some have a politics week. And the way I kind of approach it is like, yeah, I could be a debate in an or debate, but I kind of like to have discussions. What I like to do is, you know, have some certain prompts, just like how we have a prompt up here kind of called you know, why should I believe in a God? Or why should I be a conservative? Things like that, you know, So these kind of invite
Speaker 3people into like give me those good reasons, and we can go by and critically think about those reasons and what they're trying to say. Right because just like how my philosophy professor told me, you told me what you believe, but why do you believe it?
Speaker 2You know?
Speaker 3All right, So my entire thing is to make help people think critically about what they believe. A lot of times I always tell them I'm not up here just to give an epic atheist takedown of the Bible or the Koran or whatever. I just want you to think about why you believe what you believe. You know, if you leave my life, if you leave my desertion of my life and you go away thinking about, Okay, I still believe in this, but I'm thinking harder about why I believe it. Then I think that's that's a success, you know, because now you're you're not just taking everything
Speaker 3as as blindly as you know, my pastor told me this, therefore I believe it. And I've got to know people before when I've asked them questions, proud of them, give them certain certain rebuttals, and they will tell me, you know, I've never thought about this is just what my parents told me or my pastor told me, and that's why it's believed. And I always say, talry about excuse me. I always say, you know, don't do that, because even the Bible has versus against being gullible, you know, don't just believe anything out there, like actually think about what
Speaker 3they're saying, because you never know if the pastor is correct. Because there's been times where you know, I was in church, the pastor told me the Bible says this, I go back and look it up. The Bible ain't say that, you know, So like, never just take things ask fakes value. And I always use the same I alway use the same exactly example to every religious person I talked to.
Speaker 2Ill use the same example.
Speaker 3If I were to tell you that I have ten billion dollars and now saw Bahamas quit your job, follow me there tomorrow and I'm gonna give you fifty million dollars?
Speaker 2Are you going to do that just because I said so?
Speaker 7You know?
Speaker 2And without fail?
Speaker 3Well, it failed sometimes, but ninety eight percent of the times they say no. Now the other two percent, I always tell them, like, you know how, he's sound crazy right now? You you're not gonna follow me to Bamas. But ninety percent of the time they say no, I'm not going to believe you. And I said, okay, apply that to your faith, applying it to everything else. I don't just believe things people tell you right, like right, look it up? You sure that's what you believe?
Speaker 1Is correct? You alluded to that in your story earlier when they're asking the philosophy professor asking you why you know? And that's such a small but crazy important detail. It seems, you know, we have similarities in our show too. There's a tagline of this show is what you believe and why? And that's the most important part. That's every time we have a caller call in, that's the thing we want to know.
Speaker 2The mode is the why.
Speaker 1And half the time either people don't know, or they think they know, or that they maybe they don't and if they're really prepared for it, and then suddenly we just plant our disagree. It's always some variation of this, but like that, that's always the most important in these kinds of discussions in my mind. And well, it makes it interesting, so very cool that you get to talk to people both on the religious side and the political side. I'm sure you have some pretty spicy political conversations with folks especially.
Speaker 3Oh yeah, yeah, it gets uh, it gets pretty you know. I mean if you ever come into into in my political lives, yeah, I get I get spammed the in word all the time. It's it's it gets pretty bad. Yeah, it gets pretty bad. But I'll take it a stride, you know, I mean, doing some calling things. You gotta go ahead and have you know, some thick skin. So yeah, you definitely have to have a little bit of thick skin for sure.
Speaker 1Let's there our next call here, we have Antonio from Texas who wants to talk to us. Antonio, you're live on truth wanted. Thanks for waiting. What's going on?
Speaker 7Hey there, how's it going. I hope you guys are having a good day. I'm happy to be on the show. I guess I was just calling in to argue that in a sense, God is real just because he has produced or it has produced, real effects in the world. Like religion has shaped civilizations. They've shaped the moral systems of people, some laws, even in the past, even now, communities and individuals behavior as well, and countless people have experienced things like addiction, violence, homelessness, other types of crime, despair,
Speaker 7and sometimes faith is what gave them meaning, discipline, a reason to change. It helps them get through the hard times. And I guess I'm not really arguing that like God exists independently of the human mind, right, but it does make God mean something more than just a meaningless fiction that you can pick up that Barnes and Nobles. Right, It's an idea that that possesses like real It's grounded in like real social and psychological reality in the sense
Speaker 7that it has impacted people.
Speaker 1Right. Okay, so meta physically, you'll dispute it. But I think consequences of the God hate God, I hear, Antonio. But let's think about you know about Q and On. Have you heard of that? I don't know what that is. Okay, so maybe that's not the best example. But q and On is this figure a kind of a quasi person, sort of an anonymous Internet poster that has definitely definitely impacted culture, particularly right when culture in the United States, there's people that think that QAnon has the ability to
Speaker 1not only sometimes predict what's happening in the government, but also predict what's happening in the future. And a lot of people, you know, believe that these prophecies happen or are coming true. You know, My point with this is that it's definitely a phenomenon, it's definitely something that impacts culture, but absolutely none of the it is true in a real sense, right, So you know, if you're not familiar with it, then it's not as strong and as example. But you know, you mentioned the idea of God impacting culture. First of all, in every world culture, God is something different. In fact, on many of them, it's not even a God.
Speaker 1It's multiple gods or spirits or different ideas. So to look that all under God, I think is a bit specious.
Speaker 4Right.
Speaker 2On the other hand, we.
Speaker 1Can acknowledge that the ideas can have an impact on culture without saying that they're real in any meaningful sense. Right, So you know, I think like money is real in the sense that people put a value on it, but that value is going to be ultimately somewhat arbitrary at the end of the day. I think we can see the same thing about God and god beliefs. They're going to be arbitrary. They're going to be representative of a time and place, but not necessarily reflect something that exists in our physical reality outside of human beliefs. So I don't know why we have to call God real in
Speaker 1that sense. Does that make any sense? I hear you.
Speaker 7So I heard you say ideas can be impactful without being meaningful in a sense. I would disagree with that statement because I don't think I think you're completing all real in the metaphysical sense versus real in like humans reality. I think ideas can totally be meaningful even if they're not and be impact I.
Speaker 2Don't know if I said that.
Speaker 1If I did say that, I definitely misspoke, Okay, because ideas are definitely meaningful to people. I wouldn't dispute that. It's more just like okay, did Jesus actually walk the earth? Did Jesus actually heal? People are actually going to go to heaven after this? You know that kind of stuff. I mean that that stuff probably can't be real, right, I don't see the way that that could be real.
Speaker 3Yeah, Because I was gonna thing and I was gonna say something a tonio. An idea can be impactful, An idea can be meaningful, That doesn't mean the idea is true.
Speaker 2Yeah, I mean.
Speaker 3And not only that it can be impactful and meaningful, that doesn't mean the idea is good.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 3I mean, for example, let's take the history in the United States. Yeah, I mean, Jim Crow was an idea and it was impactful and it was meaningful to people living around that time. Was it a good idea? I think A lot of times we'll say no, it wasn't. You see what I'm saying. So it being a meaningful and impactful doesn't make it true. Doesn't make it a good idea either, you know what I mean? So we I would need more than this idea being impactful and meaningful for me to believe that it's true. Now, you
Speaker 3can say that when it comes to religion, for example, or the God or the God idea that it's it's it's you can say that it's a good idea because it creates community. But can we create community around almost anything else? Yeah, I mean anything else that could be positive as well? Yeah, I mean I think we can. We'll see that, you know, when it comes to like gaming and sci fi and there's there's communities around you know what you see behind me jinga? Yeah, I mean you'll find Jenga communities all over the place. You'll find pussles community, You'll find jump roping communities. None of these
Speaker 3none of these communities make jump roping or jangle or puzzles god, you know. So it's we don't necessarily have to have some sort of supernatural being in order to create a positive community, do we. So it's like that's what That's the two things that I would say, Like an idea of being meaningful and impactful doesn't make it true, doesn't make it good. And third, we don't necessarily need a god idea in order for us to have community, do we?
Speaker 1Right? Not everybody.
Speaker 7Everybody arrives there in their own their own path, right. But I guess you're kind of taking something that I said and then making a separate argument because I never used the word true. I never said God is or the idea.
Speaker 1Of a god is true.
Speaker 7I'm just saying that it has had real impact on the world. You know, I'm not saying you should be a Christian, but I think a lot of atheists really need to learn. I would say, like to lay off a little bit. I mean, do you approach three year olds and just say, well, actually kind of back blither than real and you know, think pleasure in destroying something that gives people comfort?
Speaker 2And I'm sorry, are you saying we shouldn't.
Speaker 1Are you comparing grown adults that we talked to to three year olds talking to about Santa Claus Because I don't think that's what we do.
Speaker 7Well, No, but a lot of atheists, you know, they take pleasure in that.
Speaker 2And that's why I feel, you know, that's why I'm.
Speaker 7Like, do you really feel compelled to strip adults of a belief that gives them purpose, community, discipline, hope? You know, to me, it's like let people believe, especially when religion can make people better. You know, a lot of people just conflated with bad things, like, for example, something people may consider bad is like taking away a women's right to choose, and a lot of people like what we've heard.
Speaker 2The argument is, oh, sorry, I'm interrupting, Antonio.
Speaker 1So if you had a friend that was just saying, hey, I'm going to go join Scientology, you would just say no, yeah, you should just leave them alone.
Speaker 2That's just fine, you know, let them believe what they want to believe.
Speaker 1You'd be okay with that.
Speaker 7I mean, I'd be curious, like, you know, why do you want to join? And personally, I don't really know much about Planetology. I know that it sounds like a cult, you know, as far as my understanding of it is, So wo.
Speaker 1Warn them up, You're in things are right on that.
Speaker 2I'm just saying, So this idea that.
Speaker 1We need to give reverence to an idea because it's impactful, I think that's what's problematic, right, And this is where I disagree with you, because yeah, I agree and on some level, Okay.
Speaker 2There is there is a boundary.
Speaker 1There is a line where you have to live and let people live. Okay, I'm I'm I'm with you on that. Okay. I'm not saying I'm going up to grandma or I'm going to my grandma's funeral. And saying, actually, guys, my grandma didn't go to heaven. She's she's dead and she's buried in the dirt. I'm not doing that. Okay, I get it, I understand. But these ideas, whether they are impactful or not, sorry, they are impactful and thus have real world consequences, right and and and those consequences are oftentimes very bad. Right now, we're living in a a
Speaker 1a where we're going back to a Christian theocracy at the moment. Right we have all kinds of people and filtrating our public school system with Christian ideas, which is not what I want and not what any of us that you know, volunteer here want. There's all kinds of stuff where religion is intersecting in our lives in a negative way. And that means that we have to talk about those ideas. And that means saying that some of these ideas are bad and some of them are wrong, and I'm not convinced that, oh well, it's impactful, it's helped people. That means I'm just going to leave it alone.
Speaker 1Because I'm not going to leave it alone again. I'm not going to go to someone's funeral and say, actually, they're they're they're not going anywhere. But I am going to talk to people if it means that their beliefs are actively hurting my life, my friends' lives, and even people I don't care about slives because that does matter, but that's my day.
Speaker 2What do you think, Well, yeah, I was going to say the same thing.
Speaker 3The reason why we speak about religion in our first place is because it has an impact on society. Right if if, like, for example, in your example of the three year old believing in Santa Claus, no one goes up to that, to that three year old and say to not believe in Sana Claus anymore, because number one, we know they'll grow out of it. But number two, there's no impact on society. Right if if if, for example, three year olds believing in Santa Claus, and then we had people passing uh like policy like laws saying that
Speaker 3you have to go ahead and go to a store and you have to buy a Santa Claus outfit, or you know, Santa Claus doesn't necessarily have to be on every single home or you know, everybody on on you know, a certain day of the week has to respect the laws of the county around Santa Claus. Then there will be an issue of Okay, we need to go ahead and talk about, you know, Santa Claus and why we should believe it and why we should not believe it, even if it does give five year olds hope and everything like that. We're basically deciding our entire livelihood around
Speaker 3this belief. And not only are citing our retire lively around his belief, but people are kicking their children out of their home because they don't believe these things, you know what I mean. So even on an interpersonal level, it's impactful, you see what I'm saying, And it has negative impact as well. It's not just a positive impact of creating community, of creating.
Speaker 2A hope or discipline, etc.
Speaker 3It also has negative impacts such as taking away people's rights, such as everybody is forced to do this now, ye, I mean, those are negative impacts. And because that's a thing in our society, where in our society is Christianity, and other societies is another thing like Islam, but in our societies Christianity. That's why we talk about that the most, because it has the most power and it has the most impact. And I will tell you this, and I would to kind of lucidate my point. Let me ask you a question. Do you think like in our time
Speaker 3right now, there could be a person that goes to president and not profess Christianity?
Speaker 2Yeah?
Speaker 1Yeah, definitely. I mean Donald Trump can become president?
Speaker 4Why not?
Speaker 1But Donald Trump says he's a Christians as to Christians all the time.
Speaker 7I never said he wasn't a Christian. There's many many problems with Donald Trumph before he became a president that we seemingly ignored. Right, I feel like someone doesn't isn't a deist. That's definitely something else that that people will can ignore.
Speaker 1So yeah, that you asked me, is it possible?
Speaker 6Yeah?
Speaker 1Sure?
Speaker 3Well you think you think that someone can become president and not profess Christianity in America?
Speaker 1I think so.
Speaker 4Yeah.
Speaker 7I think we're becoming a more secular nation the more time goes on. I think people are slowly letting go of Christianity.
Speaker 2Can you tell me why it's never happened then?
Speaker 7Because you're not going to get changed overnight. It doesn't just because people are starting to wake up, you know, to that's wait.
Speaker 1But if we don't need change overnight, then it would happen, right, So it sounds like it can't.
Speaker 2Happen, right, So it's ONNNY.
Speaker 3I'm not saying that maybe in fifteen to twenty years, right, happen right all about right now in our current state, can someone become president?
Speaker 1I understand your.
Speaker 7Question to be ever, I didn't understand it as like now, yeah, yeah, but I mean back to the point. I just think, like where I draw the line is when we start treating people who are of the belief that they're not like intellectually to be taken seriously.
Speaker 1You know.
Speaker 7I understand what you're saying, that your religion shouldn't bleed so much into some of the aspects of our of our life, because when when it can be harmful, you know, And I'm not saying it hasn't been in the past. But at the end of the day, I just think the way that atheists approach and here's my truth, you know, since your show is called Truth Wanted, I think the truth is that God has had so many impacts in our culture and where we are today, and that is the truth. You can't deny that. And I think people need to just lay off so much like you know, those people that you see on the street saying like
Speaker 7you're going to hell if you don't. You know that they have like those big signs. Well, those people are crazy, right, But I also think that atheists that are kind of doing what you said, you know, telling your grandma that God is in real There are atheists like that, and you see them frequently on YouTube, frequently on the street.
Speaker 2Sometimes.
Speaker 1Okay, we'll need to lay off too. Yeah, you're always going to have people like that in every single community. You know what, you don't have in every single community. I don't see any atheists right now that are ruining our public school system and are teaching anti scientific ideas. I don't see atheists in our community taking away abortion rights for people in this country, right, you know what?
Speaker 2I am seeing that from Christians.
Speaker 1I'm also seeing Christians teaching nonsense in public schools. I'm also seeing Christians bring up racist ideas.
Speaker 4Right.
Speaker 1We were talking about Jim Crow earlier. Jim Crow and slavery in this country was in part built by Christians. It's not like America was a less Christian nation back then. Right. People were absolutely justifying this stuff through Christianity and they still do today. So if anybody needs to lead people alone, it's Christians. Okay, Atheists are not the majority in this country. We don't have any political power. We have secular institutions for sure. But if you announce that you're an atheist and I run for president, no shot not happening. You
Speaker 1have to performed as a Christian because Christians control this culture in this country. So the Christians need to lay off. It's not the atheist. I'm sorry that maybe that there's some Christians that got their feelings hurt because an atheist is being extra spicy.
Speaker 2It happens every day, you know.
Speaker 1I'm more mad about the examples like wholst he was given earlier, where people are getting kicked out of their homes for being gay, right because their families are Christian, or people can't participate in their church community because they decide they want to you know, house people or or help people that are considered outsiders in space.
Speaker 2So yeah, I don't know, man, I.
Speaker 1Don't really have much else to say other than that, what do you think both?
Speaker 3Yeah, it's the same thing with me, is like, I don't I'm not sure why. Why is the atheists that have to back off? We're not endove this country, We're not the ones going around knocking on doors saying have you heard the good news of Charles Darwin? We were not the ones doing that, you know what I mean? Those are JOHPA witnesses and Mormons. They're the ones that's that that are that are doing that. They're the ones who designed the laws. There's a one who designed the policies. Why are we the ones that need to back off? Just by telling people, hey, listen, you need to think critically about what you're what you're thinking, and the fact that, hey, this is a two thousand year old comic book. Why
Speaker 3are we even following it? If if we don't even even know any other stuff is true? Why were sending our entire lives around it. We shouldn't be, you know what I mean. Like a lot of this is bs like this. We just got to go ahead and and let them know that. So I don't understand why we're the ones that have to to back off. Yeah, sure, there are atheists people out there who are assholes. Every everyone understands that. Everyone knows that there are atheists out there who are dickheads. I've ran into them before, you know what I mean. So it's not it's not it's not a not a thing that we're fighting you against. We're not saying that there are every single atheist out
Speaker 3there is a nice guy that least people alone. Of course, there are people who are who are very, very abrasive and can be jerk offs. But I'm not sure why we're the ones who need to back off by doing programs or content like this, having people to call in and think about what they believe more and more often, and trying to enshrine secularism in our institutions. Because no one wants a theocracy, you know. I mean, we wouldn't want to live in an islam theocracy, and I don't want to live in a Christian theocracy. Theocracies always impute
Speaker 3on human rights always, So the fact that we have a political environment right now where they're trying to turn it into a techno Christian theocracy with the the you know, the the tech bros ruling everything and pushing Christianity into all the schools now is a time where we should be pushing harder, you see what I'm saying. So I don't get why this is the time for us to back off, and because we're not living in the time where they're backing off of anybody else.
Speaker 1We're not living in those times. Absolutely well, Antny, we have to wrap things up. I know we just spoke for a long time. I'm gonna give you thirty seconds, but we have to end the call after that because we we got to get go into our next show. Go ahead.
Speaker 7Sure well, I mean nobody said that you're the only ones who have the back off. I use the example of the Christians that they're big, you're going to hell times right. But it's this type of rhetoric that divides people into one of two teams. It makes it so that we don't really have a room for compromise. Listen to the way that political rhetoric is going on right now. You've got the left saying, blanket statement, everybody on the right is a Nazi, and you've got the people on the right saying everyone on the left wants to turn everybody trend. When you take it so to such an extreme point and it becomes so binary like this, then
Speaker 7that is when we can't have any type of compromise. Do I think that we should exclusively only teach Christians Christianity in schools?
Speaker 1Absolutely not.
Speaker 7But do I think that maybe we should trying to compromise where maybe we can have religious studies and we can teach people, hey, this is what Christianity is, this is what being a Muslim is, and this is what atheism is, and here's what an agnostic is. And these are all the arguments that they're making. Where we can have it in such a way that we teach people from an objective perspective what all these things mean when having to tell them what the truth is. I think that is a compromise that that we're not looking at right now, because.
Speaker 2Yeah, that's what atheists should happen. Yeah, that's what we should happen.
Speaker 1Yeah, tell that to the people who have the ability to compromise, which is the people in power, not us. Right, you can straw man us all day and say we're doing this stuff. I don't know, man, I never said any of the stuff that you're saying. I get some people are saying it, but like, you know, throw us all in there like that as a collective isn't helping out either. Talking about you know, dividing people on sides. But hey, I did say we gotta we gotta wrap this up. So I'm sorry an Todio.
Speaker 2I gotta let you go.
Speaker 1Thank you for calling. Love you to call again some time we can continue that discussion. What we're going to say a ball before we go.
Speaker 3Yeah, I was gonna I'm gonna say what what he's saying is what what atheists watchually into political sphere pushed for the fact that if we're gonna have a religious studies, that shouldn't be just one religion. Go ahead and study all of them, what they say and what they believe, and leave it up to the person to decide what they're well, at least be informed. They don't have to decide anything, but just be informed on what they all are. No one is pushing for no one ever learns about Christianity or it is ever again, that's.
Speaker 1Kind of silly. Yeah, yeah. Also, I don't want to compromize with fascists either. There are some people I am not going to compromise with on some things, so guven rights, I'm not going to do that, you know, other ideas. Maybe it depends. But on that note, we do have to get things wrapped up today. I want to thank everybody who tuned in to the show today. Thank you so much for those of you that called in especially appreciate you giving us your time. I want to give a special thank you to our backup host, Ben ben Claude Filter for hanging out in the back. Thanks so much, Ben, branging out, given funny faces.
Speaker 2And kolling us you know what's up here. I hope you like today's show, brother.
Speaker 1Yeah, it was fun.
Speaker 5Good calls.
Speaker 1Definitely some frustrating ones.
Speaker 5But I many many years ago, I was a pantheist, so I understand the like the like need to still hold on just the language of a god, at least for me, I realized that like it was just to get theists to leave me alone, because I can feel like, oh yeah, I believe in God too. I just in my head I'd be like he he he, it's act nature and it's everything.
Speaker 1I am so smart.
Speaker 5But eventually I came to terms with like, that's not really how that goes.
Speaker 1So yeah, that makes sense. I want to give a huge, huge shout of the Falsa for being on here. False he is awesome. Falsa is great. Thank you so much for joining us. Friend, Hey, thank thank you all so much. I appreciate y'all. Not out my channel or not it shout it out tell us where do people find you?
Speaker 2Awesome.
Speaker 3You can find me on YouTube, which is falsey thoughts. I've posted a few times in the in the chat link over on on the YouTube, So go ahead and and hit me up. So to me, thank you'all so much for having me on here. I would love to be on any of the other flagship shows that you guys have. Thank y'all so much. Uh TikTok as well. You find me there as falsey thoughts, And I'm on Twitch as well. You can find me there, same thing, falsity thoughts, same thing, but Instagram, same thing for threads, you know what I mean. So I mean on all those socials, I'm not on you know, the Fascister over call, Twitter,
Speaker 3I'm not I'm not on Fascister and more. But I'll see if I can. They have live stream now, so i'll see. Maybe I'll start live streaming on there. Maybe not sure, but because I'll probably get insane calls. You guys can stall me on YouTube and TikTok. Those are my main things that I go live on and I appreciate y'all. Thank y'all so much. Thank you so much today this community Austin for having me on here, I would love to connect more.
Speaker 2I've been, you know, a fan of all of these.
Speaker 3For years now, so this is kind of one of my dream come true things. Thank y'all so much for having me gone, and I'll you know, I can see you guys in the in the future.
Speaker 2I appreciate it. Thank you so much. Absolutely last thing I'll see before we ramp up.
Speaker 1I always like to ask my guests if they have any words of wisdom before we close out the broadcast.
Speaker 2You got any words of wisdom for us? Words of wisdom? Herds of wisdom? What do you think you see?
Speaker 6Oh?
Speaker 3Yeah, I always closed off my shows like this. We didn't have those call type of calls today, but maybe next time we'll have this and something about to say this, We'll have those calls. All right for my young men out there, the red pill lie to you, all right, Red pill lie to you. Every man. Every man should actually be soft. You don't have to be hard, be soft. What that means is be secure, be affectionate, be wise, be flexible, and be trustworthy saw ft. Every man should
Speaker 3be soft. And the reason why that is because we need to reform what masculinity actually is Masculinity is not does not have to be based on dominance or what you can do for other people. You're more than being a provider. You're more than being the protector. You're more than being a stoic tough guy, because stoicism doesn't work. All right, You are a full, full fledged human. You can get in touch with your emotions. That's not a feminine thing. Being in touch with your emotion is not feminine. Its being human. You're human before you are a man,
Speaker 3before you're an alpha.
Speaker 2Okay, so I love thattch to be soft FALSI thank you for those words of wisdom.
Speaker 1Thank you, Thank you for that. That's some good stuff. Thank you to everybody watching today's program. I hope you got something good out of it. Folks, I'm objectively danned. Remember to always keep one the truth and we'll see you next time. Goodbye, everybody you see.
Speaker 8Aw watch talkieth and Live Sundays at one p m. Central.
Speaker 8Visit tiny dot c c slash y t t H and call into the show at five one two nine nine one nine two four two, or connect to the show online at tiny dot c c slash call th
In today's episode of Truth Wanted, ObjectivelyDan welcomes guest Out Of Body Atheist, with The Beard of Empathy on backup, to dig into Reiki, New Age spirituality, homeopathy, and the long road from woo to skepticism!...
In today's episode of Truth Wanted, Jon the Skeptick, Volcy, and Sofia Spina explain why no one can talk to the dead, from Haitian Vodou and grief dreams to Jon's past as a spiritualist! Bob jumps from objective...
In today's episode of Truth Wanted, ObjectivelyDan and Nintendrew, later joined by The Beard of Empathy, tackle a world run on Jesus, the magic of manifesting, and a prayer that actually got answered! Bob in NY, a...
In today's episode of Truth Wanted, ObjectivelyDan, Kelley Laughlin, and The Beard of Empathy tackle standards of evidence, miracle claims, and the false binaries of moral philosophy! Dean in VA questions why skeptics...
In today's episode of Truth Wanted, ObjectivelyDan and Chad Harris tackle Christian nationalism, police brutality, and the uncomfortable truths about racism and immigration. Big E in TN survived police brutality and...