Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Truth Wanted

Truth Wanted artwork

Truth Wanted 07-42_with Kelley Laughlin and @ApostateAshley

Oct 19, 20241 hr 22 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Discover the truth today in our latest episode of Truth Wanted! Kelley Laughlin and Apostate Ashley play with high tech grifters as they speak in tongues about graphic footage and how things existed before the claim of god’s creation. Eli Slack, the backup host, joins and offers some icing on some of the calls. Puck in OH wants to talk about high tech grifters that pitch weird quantum stuff who are asking for money and asks the hosts their opinions on what makes these people so appealing. Kelley explains that people may fall for this by feeling special and having knowledge that others do not. Ashley describes how people feel like something bad will happen if they do not jump on whatever is being sold and how any of us have the capability of being duped. Marcus in TX asks Ashley about her Pentecostal background and what she was feeling then compared to now. Looking back, Ashley believes the things that she experienced were probably dopamine highs or having the rush of hormones that are similar to what happens during flight or fight. Now as an atheist, she can speak in tongues anytime she wants and the Holy Spirit still has nothing to do with it. When going through a hard time, having people around you hugging and caring is quite therapeutic and these things were normal for her. People have reached out to Ashley sharing they no longer believe and do not want to be on the wrong side of history. Chase in the USA is curious about using graphic footage to motivate activism. After a while, it could lose its shock value because people are desensitized. Also, the reaction can be more negative than positive depending on how it is presented. This is where context can hugely matter. It is important to remember that some people will need a trigger warning. We need to be careful and understand how triggers work. Is it worth causing harm and triggering PTSD to get your point across? Why would you force people to watch something and cause suffering? A warning will at least help to know when an appropriate time is to watch something. If you do not put a warning, you are shoving it in people’s faces just like what the anti-abortion group does. Horrible graphic scenery will harm or hurt people if it is shoved in their face regardless of the reason. Peter in Canada has proof of god’s non-existence only if he is defined as a conscious entity that created all of material existence. Peter’s reasoning is that consciousness requires existence and the things that are claimed to be god’s existence must have existed before god’s existence. How does this argument work with theists? Why could god not exist and become conscious at the same time? We don’t have proof of god’s non-existence, but we do have logical evidence. This is fitting for one concept of god, but not all the other gods. If we can’t have existence without consciousness, how did the earth exist before anything lived on it? Eli Slack the back up host joins and adds some comments about how we are already outside of the realm of what makes sense when we are talking about divinity. Thank you for joining us this week. Prompt of the week is: What is something that doesn’t sound creepy but is? Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/truth-wanted--3195473/support.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Speaker 1Tonight, I wanted to talk about something that and its role in our society and how it got to be so popular. It does serve several roles within our society, which is why I wanted to talk about it like It creates social interaction through shared experience, fostering a sense of community even with people you haven't met yet, and it can serve as a metaphor for larger societal issues like the pressures of conformity and maintaining individualism in a collective society. Its duality of amusement and annoyance sparks conversations

Speaker 1about humor being used as a coping mechanism, and as it spreads through word of mouth, it demonstrates how memes and social concepts can spread and evolve throughout cultures. It can also play on the ideas of attention and distraction, pointing out how we can be more focused on not thinking about something. So give us a call right now because you just lost the game. Hello, and welcome back

Speaker 1to another episode of the Nonprofits Him Kelly Laughlin. You're probably really annoyed with me right now. And this is a live college show that happens every single week on Friday at seven pm Central, where we talk about what people believe and why they believe it. And if you like to call us, you can right now at one five one two nine nine nine to two four two or through your computer at tiny dot cc slash call tw Truth one. It is a product of the Atheist

Speaker 1Community of Austin, a nonprofit five oh one c three nonprofit organization dedicated to the promotion of atheism, critical thinking, secular humanism, and the separation of religion and governments. And my special guest this week is Apostate Ashley. Hi, Ashley, I'm so glad to be here with you today. Hey, I'm sorry I probably annoyed everybody aroun you before the show started, but hopefully we'll get enough people annoyed that we'll get a lot of calls, So yeah, that'd be

Speaker 1all right. Before we get started, though, I wanted to give you the results results of last week's We Want the Truth or the WWTT segment, and last week we asked you to complete the sentence you know you're screwed when your horoscope says blank, And here are some of our favorite answers. Number three from zech Gatos, You know when you're screwed when your horoscope says you can't go wrong with canned food, guns and ammunition, lots of ammunition. Yeah,

Speaker 1i'd be worried about that.

Speaker 2One.

Speaker 1Number two Alec Julian says, you know you're screwed when your horoscope says candy man, candy man, candy man, candy man. And our number one from job for Tuna. You know you're screwed when your horoscope says, oh damn, you should probably stay in today. I feel like I should probably stay in every day, but I know the pro The prop for this week is what is something that doesn't sound creepy but is? And uh, Ashley, did do you

Speaker 1have an answer for that one?

Speaker 3Oh gosh, I didn't know this question before the show started.

Speaker 1I thought usually yes ahead of time, so I'm sorry to put you on the spot.

Speaker 3Then that's okay, Well, what's the question again?

Speaker 1Asking something that doesn't sound creepy but is Hmmm. I'm having a hard time something of it too, Honestly.

Speaker 3I don't know. Okay, Well, would you like some candy?

Speaker 1Dude?

Speaker 2Yeah?

Speaker 1See that that?

Speaker 2Yeah?

Speaker 3Asking?

Speaker 1Yeah, asking a kid if they want some candy? So this seems like a really hard answer. So We're gonna have to get our viewers to really think about this one, guys, So come up with some good answers. Put them in the comments below, not in the chat to the side, but in the comments below, and maybe we'll read out yours next week. So which gets us too. Talking to you, Ashley, how are you?

Speaker 3I'm doing pretty good.

Speaker 1How about you? I'm doing great. I'm so glad. I'm so happy to work with you. I've been literally looking forward to this. When I found out I was going to do this show with you, I was like, yay, me too. Yeah, thanks, thanks for stoking my ego, my fragile ego. So you've been We talked about this a little bit pre show, and I know you've been posting on Facebook about it. But it seems like you've been having a little bit of a problem dating in the Midwest because you're an atheist in a liberal.

Speaker 3Yes I have. I mean, everybody is just the complete opposite of me around here, and the last couple of guys that I've talked to just couldn't handle that I was an atheist, just wanted to cut things off. And it's it's really hard to just kind of like remain like calm because I kind of want to. I kind of get like very frustrated that they will talk to me or treat me almost like I'm the one that's

Speaker 3being irrational. It's very frustrating. But I don't know any atheist men near me at all.

Speaker 1I'm kind of in the same boat, and I know people's people. We always hear that on the show, and we always say, you know, if you just put your voice out there, you're going to find people I have in my area. And I just found anybody that's mostly the like mind that I am a small handful of us, and we're we were already friends to begin with. To not be honest with you, but we've even tried to have a secular humanist gatherings together, like out in the park so we didn't have to be at somebody's house or a location when we were worried about, you know,

Speaker 1and just nobody showed up. So yeah, I can understand where you're coming from. It does seem to be frustrating sometimes. Of course I live in a very rural area too, so I have that going for me going against me.

Speaker 3Yeah, I mean, I think maybe I need to try to look for some secular humanist groups around here or something, see if there's something going on. I know that my brother in law had tried tried to start one, but there was only like four of us.

Speaker 1Yeah, that's what happened with us too. Yeah, that's what happened with us as well. So I don't know, have you even tried looking at for something on meetup dot com. I'm not sure. I don't even know if I am allowed to say that, but I know, I know there are a lot of organizations that use it to get together and organize meetings.

Speaker 4You know.

Speaker 3I haven't looked to add it in the city that I'm in now, but in the last city there was they would they would go to trivia night at a bar nearby every week. That was pretty cool.

Speaker 1Yeah. Yeah, Like, I know, they have some They have a lot of events done with the Free Thought Library, like a Philosophy nine, and they have watch parties for the shows on Sundays. They have a game night on Fridays. And I think we really need, we really need to build more community like that. That's probably one of the biggest problems that I think we have as a whole as atheist is that we're having a hard time finding each other and building a community. And it's been because of the Internet, it's gotten a lot better. We can at least talk to each other and find each other across long distances. But still, I mean, it's nice to

Speaker 1have that group interaction where you're actually talking and touching people, right.

Speaker 3I know, I know. That's one of the things that I really miss about when I went to church, because it was just a set time every week that I would go and I would see the same people and then like you said, like touching and stuff. You know, you know, naturally we would give each other hugs and say hi. But you know, even at the beginning of church services, after worship, they would always you know, have like a greeting type thing. You go around and you shake hands or say hello, give hugs to the people around you. And I love I always loved that, just

Speaker 3five minutes of saying hi and given hugs.

Speaker 1Yeah, right, right, Yeah, it's a human interaction. That's when I think we need to we need to, like I said, we need to have more of that within our community. I don't know how to do that better. I wish I did, because, like I said, I think it's one of the biggest problems facing our community today. But if if anybody has an idea, please send me an email and I would I'd be happy to try to stop promoting it and getting it working and fixing it, fixing the problems.

Speaker 3So yeah, I know that there's a lot of cities that have the UU churches, the Universalist Unitarian. I don't have any near me, but I know that a lot of people will do that because it's especially like I know in Minneapolis they have just Unitarian, So a lot of the time it'll be an atheist that's speaking.

Speaker 1I actually used to go to a UU church when I was I went back and forth to it while I was going through different difficult times in my life and I was going for that sense of community when I really needed to and I didn't feel like I had that. So it really worked good for me. Nobody ever questioned my atheist ideals. They all knew I was an atheist and still warmly accepted me. I really We used to all get together for breakfast after the services on Sunday too. That was really that was the best part of it, honestly, was hanging out with people and getting to know them and having breakfast with them. That

Speaker 1was my favorite part, so.

Speaker 3Would be nice.

Speaker 5Yeah.

Speaker 1Yeah, So what do you what do you think are some maybe some of the problems that we're facing today just in regards to community. Yeah, yeah, I want to talk about that one.

Speaker 6Do you think we have other ones that are Yeah, I mean obviously right now we have a lot going on politically and just trying to trying to fight misinformation and people being uneducated about certain types of things, even just with gender and oppressing certain groups of people.

Speaker 3I think that's I think that's a big thing. And a lot of the time, like as I became an atheist, especially at the very beginning, I just had the assumption that all of us kind of thought the same. But that's not always the case. At most of us do, but there's quite a few out there that just aren't quite the same in regards to that that. You know, there's a saying sometimes you can take the man out of church, but not always the church out of man. They'll still have those same mentalities. But yeah, I think

Speaker 3I think a big one. You know, like you know, with the election coming up and everything, a lot of that stuff kind of comes up. Those topics come up, and you see the bigotry and the hatred a lot more.

Speaker 1Yeah, yeah, I hate, Yeah, I hear what you're saying. I had something I was going to say in response to something you said, it I forgot it. It's at the very end there. That happens to me. Sometimes I'm getting older and both my brain cells get stuck together more and.

Speaker 3More, both of them. You only have two I want.

Speaker 1So Yeah, I think I think there's always room for improvement, and I think that with I think a lot of atheists, if they can, should go out and try to make a difference in their own community. I don't know that you're going to solve any big problems, but I always say, each small candle light's a dark corner of the world, so it just going out in light and some really dark the small dark corner is always a help. It's anything any little thing you do helps the world in general. So I think I would love to see more atheists

Speaker 1going out and spreading atheists and secular ideals throughout our society. It would be a lot better. Not that you have to do it or that you should pressure people into it. Just go out and be an example. That's all you need to do. I'm an atheist, and look, I'm a good person and I'm doing good things for our community, and I think that's one of the best things we can do.

Speaker 3So yeah, especially if we were able to kind of do like what I used to do back in church, or like outreaches and charitable type things, feeding people, or having what we called like a free store where we would all donate clothes and then people who needed them could come in and just take a bag full of them for free. Yeah, I think it would be I mean, that would be a really cool thing about trying to get a humanist or secular type group together, having community

Speaker 3but also helping the community.

Speaker 1Right right. I know several secular groups throughout the country I've seen over the years doing helping feed the homeless too, going out on the streets and actually bringing food out to homeless people and socks and blankets. I know this organization itself has done it in the past. So yeah, I'd like to see more and more of that. I'd like to get I'd like to see us destroying this thought straw man stereotype of the angry atheist. That's what I would love to see, you know. So maybe someday, maybe won't be able to get rid of that idea.

Speaker 1We do have some calls, though, would you like to take one? Oh yeah, sure, all right, let's uh, let's go over to uh Colin studio. Here, I got Puck, our good old buddy, Pucks Colin. He wants to talk about Ashton Forbes and other high tech prifters. Hi, Puck, how are you hello.

Speaker 5It's good to be talking to you again, Kelly.

Speaker 1No, it's always Puck. It's always a pleasure talking to you. You've always been one of my favorite people.

Speaker 5So uh, and actually I've been following your work for a while. I loved your interviews with a Clergy project. I really appreciate the work you're doing out there.

Speaker 3Well, thank you. Yeah, I remember talking to you before.

Speaker 5Oh yeah, we've got some pats before, all of us have. That's kind of awesome. Today I actually get to talk to you now.

Speaker 3Yeah.

Speaker 1So what do you get for us, Puck?

Speaker 5Okay, So it's come to my attention in the past couple of weeks that there's a grifter out there by the name of Ashton Forbes who I don't want to like give links or anything, but he's out there. If you want to see his stuff, and he's been pitching some really weird quantum stuff. And I think it's fine to like go out and debunk the specific SIDEI itself. But really, more to my interest is what makes grus like this appealing in the first place, Like what is the draw right? Like, you know, you have people like this to say, well, we're only like a little bit

Speaker 5of tech away from having free, unlimited energy for everybody, but big oil is getting in the way of studies and whatnot. It's obviously a grift. They're obviously asking for money. They're not shy that they're asking for money. But what is it about them that comes across as believable and not just followable but supportable in a financial sense?

Speaker 1Are you asking for my opinion?

Speaker 5Yes? And the reason I want to think in that way is if we can figure out what makes them so appealing, maybe we can figure out some way to take the people who are so enraptured by them and more easily turn out. They're not going to get turned around by the facts. You're not going to turn around by saying, well, here, the science doesn't support what this guy is saying, right, because they're caught by something else and I can't figure out why.

Speaker 1Yeah, I think I now, I don't know. I can't say. I'm not a sociologist. It's not something I've studied. It's something that intrigues me. It's something that I have looked up and read about a little bit. Like I said, I haven't really delved into it. Like I said, I'm not a sociologist or anything. But it seems to me that there's several factors that drive the popularity of people like this, and one of them seems to be that if I listen to this person who's bucking the system, who doesn't think that mainstream science is valid, you know, he's, oh,

Speaker 1look this thing over here. If I believe in this, and he can show me, and I'm making air quotes when I say show me, if he can show me how this is working, I can have this special knowledge that nobody else had. I can be smarter than a college professor because I know this. And I think a lot of people who are low information might fall for this quite easily and think that they that they become better people when they get this special knowledge. Does that

Speaker 1make any sense?

Speaker 5It does, But it's weird because they're not actually gaining the special knowledge for themselves. They're just like special knowledge adjacent. They're like knowledgeable by association.

Speaker 2But it falls apart.

Speaker 5The second you actually ask them anything specific about.

Speaker 2What it is that they're talking about. And we saw this happen a few years ago.

Speaker 5Too, with NFTs and cryptocurrency and all the numerous scams that happened from there, And I guess I wonder, like, how do people not look at stuff like zero point energy? And I say, this is literally the same thing.

Speaker 7P T.

Speaker 1Barnum, you know.

Speaker 8P T.

Speaker 1Barnum said there's a sucker born every minute. I there was a reason he said it, as I don't know what else to say that, right.

Speaker 3I wish I had something to offer, but I don't know enough information about this, and I.

Speaker 1Don't know any specific information about this guy, but I'm just going off of you know, the grifter thing, the grifter topic, and that's but I'm just playing off of here.

Speaker 2So I did.

Speaker 1I did pull him up real quick, but then we started talking and I didn't get to see exactly what it was that.

Speaker 5No, he's just the latest, like I said, like, you know, no, not long ago the big thing. Wash uh what I just said the word cryptocurrencies, right, and all the scans came out of there and Bangman Freedom and all that stuff where people are charming and people say this is the future and we're all going to go to the moon and anybody who doubts us are just losers who can't see the thing. But the slightest scrutiny, it all falls apart, and I'm wondering, like, why don't people just do the say is it the hope? Is it the sense that there are so many people around them are

Speaker 5showing the belief, and they don't want to be the one that says, I don't think I quite buy what you're selling, Like I don't know, like we just talked about or you guys just talk about the importance of community. So maybe that sense of belonging, even if it means you have to go along with something you don't fully understand, because that's what it requires to be part of this group. I don't know.

Speaker 1That could be. That could be, you know, you talk about the home thing and I don't know if this helps or anything. And I know I don't normally like to talk about things, you know, personal things, and this isn't really personal to me, but it has to do in my area. There was an old iron mine and they kind of polluted an area outside right along adjacent to the mine. So it's just like this barren flat land now and a company came in and they leased it. It now belongs to the state. They leased it from the state because they were going to build a solar

Speaker 1generator out there. They were going to start collecting solar in and build all these solar panels and collect solar energy. Now, they leased the land almost twenty years ago, and they built a website to talk about it. They never really finished the website and they never did any work at all at all at the actual site. The Michigan Department of Natural Resources took the lease back from them because they never did any work, and some of our local politicians put pressure on the Michigan DNR to renew the lease,

Speaker 1to give them the lease back because they were going to bring all these jobs to the area. There was this hope that once and I don't even know how sold. You know, we don't need people to collect solar energy, so I don't know how what jobs we're going to be brought to the area anyway, But they actually pressured the DNR to give the lease back to this company. This was three years ago and they still haven't even finished the website, let alone done anything out at the actual physical site. So I maybe it is that hope. You know, it's because Pe and I have talked to

Speaker 1people in this area who really think that this thing is going to bring all these jobs here, and we do live in it. I'm in a rural area. It's economically depressed. Jobs are a big deal here, So I don't know, maybe that is it.

Speaker 3Sometimes, like in those scammers, they'll bring like a they'll bring like a sense of urgency or make you feel like you need to financially give or be a part of this because something bad is going to happen if you don't. You know, it could happen at any time if you don't get in on this now. Almost like a salesman type thing, right right.

Speaker 5Like like selling the urgency of it. It's like we're so close to a breakthrough or we can't do this without your support, and we know that we're never going to get like government funding or mainstream support, so it's going to be up to people I can help put it through.

Speaker 1Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, not only yeah, not only, but come up with go ahead, go ahead, Park please.

Speaker 5Well, the best answer that I've been able to come up with is that, like for me, the best thing that I can do for someone who has fallen victim to one of these is that when they do come around, the absolute last thing they need is and I told you so, because they're probably already getting that from a bunch of other people they know. And the best thing you can do, I think is just validate their story, understand why it could have been convincing, and then just move on from there.

Speaker 2Yeah.

Speaker 1I mean, we've all been taking it one time in life for launch, right, the only thing yeah, right, Like I said, we've all been taken at some point in our lives. You know, Let's show somebody the compassion that we wish we had gotten when it happened to us, right, Yeah.

Speaker 5And that's why I think the thing that's going to strengthen our community is the most is things like telling stories and sharing the stories and and validating the experiences that we had where you know, like there's the Clergy Project is doing it, and and other people who do interviews and uh uh, you know, they take the stories of people who are detransitioning or who have deconverted and just validing. Yeah, I understand why you were there, and that's not you know, we don't look down on you for having done that. We don't look down on you for having believed and having this hope and and now that you don't have that, we're not going to badger

Speaker 5you for that. You're just you're a different personnel. We're not going to hold that. We're not gonna it is a clean, slight just thought.

Speaker 3Yeah, any of us are any of us have the capability of being duped. I mean, that's kind of how I view my time in the church is just I was duped. I was duped by people who were also duped. And obviously there are some people out there that are purposely duping, but a lot of the time, it's just something about it makes you feel like you have some sort of identity or belonging or of some special information

Speaker 3that other people don't have, and it's just really easy to be duped no matter how intelligent you are. These people, especially the ones that like you're talking about, the ones that are doing the scamming, they have that charismatic personality that makes you like they know how to speak to you, they know how to be manipulative in that way.

Speaker 5Yeah, and you know, I like to think that I'm immune to being sweet talked into something like that, but I deep down I know I'm not. And deep down I know that it's very, very possible for me to get shilled into something and then, you know, ten thousand dollars in donations later, I have nothing to show for it. I'm not immune. Only difference is I haven't done that yet, right, So, but it's it's possible, and I try to be humble and aware of that.

Speaker 1Yeah, I think it's it's possible for any of us that, like I said, a lot of us have already been duped at one point in our lives, right, I mean, uh how many?

Speaker 4Yeah?

Speaker 1I was going to make a I was going to make a joke about getting married and divorced, but.

Speaker 2Better not.

Speaker 1YEA, Well, thank you guys, understand, I figured, yeah, yeah, you.

Speaker 5Know, yeah, no problem. And as someone who who had to date while atheists in a very conservative area, it's possible. It's out there. It happens, and we're we're we're out there. We just have no convenient we have signaling to each other, like we don't have uh, the the atheist version of being able to sense when somebody.

Speaker 8Is uh uh uh.

Speaker 5You know, I have no idea how to find atheists in the wild. I just happened to and I was very lucky to find a community here where I am in Ohio.

Speaker 3Oh that's good. That makes me feel like I have a little bit of hope.

Speaker 6Yeah.

Speaker 1You're both in the same state anyway, right, so yeah, yeah, so I.

Speaker 2Have a big place tho.

Speaker 5I'm mean, I have to drive two hours just to watch a good ice hockey.

Speaker 1So Columbus is a big Columbus.

Speaker 2Is I've been.

Speaker 5I've been all over as in a entire Yeah. Yeah, I'm in a progressive oasis in an entire sea of conservatism. You go ten miles out of town and you already see that you're going to hell billboards. That's not exaggeration, they're just billboards say he's what you're going to Hew, Maybe don't read this while you're driving. Okay, thank you guys very much for entertaining my thoughts tonight.

Speaker 1Well, thank you Puck, thanks for calling in. Like I said, I always enjoyed talking to you. That was nice talking to night you too good talking Gosh, Puck is is the next host of the show. Actually, oh really yeah yeah, Puck was was one of the I think I'm not positive sure, but I think he was the first person besides to be a host of Truth Wanted. So yeah, I miss Puck. I really do a Puck. Puck's awesome. One thing I forgot to do though, back when before we took Punk's Puck's call, I was called a punk

Speaker 1was taking our patron of the week. So and I'm looking for it on my document and it's I'm not seeing it there. Oh here we go, Here we go. I found it. I'm sorry, guys, I got lost for a minute. So I want to thank our patron of the week this week. I actually I want to thank all of our patrons, but especially our patron of the week. Every single week we get the shout out one of our patron that donates through tiny dot c c slash patreon tw for supporting this show, and we appreciate it.

Speaker 1It makes this show better. I don't make any money for it. It all goes to production of this show. This page. This week's Patreon of the week is Go Talk. Thank you, Go Talk, and thanks you to everyone else that keeps this show rolling, that contributes and keeps the show rolling. We really really appreciate it. We put a lot of work into it, so it's nice to have when people are financing it for us. So it really it makes us feel good that people are helping us do it to bring this to the to the masses. So as while we're talking about other things, as many

Speaker 1of you know, we have initiated Phase two of the Brick fundraiser, we want to highlight some of the standout bricks that we've of the orders that we've already received. This brick, this week's featured brick say that ten times quick comes from Cassie from Louisiana, and it says, drop your faith like a brick. Thank you for your purchase, Cassie, and you can get yours at tiny dot c c ACA bricks. Don't be thick, buy a brick, you'll be

Speaker 1set and you'll be putting your name up on the side of the ACA forever for eternity, and everybody will know what a great person you are for doing that. So, Ashley, though you know Puck mentioned you working with the Clergy Project, why don't you tell us about that, so.

Speaker 3Well, yeah, you know, I mean I haven't really done a whole lot with it. In the last year or so. I was on the board, but I'm not anymore, just because I had gotten so busy with work. But the Clergy Project, for anybody that doesn't know, is a nonprofit for ex clergy or you know, if you're trying to get out and you no longer believe and you still are clergy, you can join and it's completely discreete If

Speaker 3you go to the Clergy Project dot org or Clergy Project dot org website, you can assign up to become a member, and you could have a pseudonym if you don't feel comfortable with your name being out there. We offer I believe it's twelve subsidized counseling sessions with Secular Therapy Project. There's career coaching, you know, if if you're kind of anything like I was, where my entire world

Speaker 3was church and I did that for so long I didn't really have any experience in the real world. And there's a lot of clergy out there that's like that, that doesn't know really quite how to get out there in the real world working, and so they'll work with you with the resume and you know, preparing for interviews and applying for jobs, teaching you the different career branches, things like that, and obviously just the community of it being able to talk with one another. We have a

Speaker 3hidden and private Facebook group. Obviously the website itself has a forum type format. There's a lot of a lot of stories just in the archives from all of the members or a ton of the members, just over the years. I believe, oh, I believe that the Clergy Project's been active if I take a guess, like twelve maybe thirteen years now or so, and it's really really great. If you no longer believe and you don't feel comfortable coming

Speaker 3out and talking about it with anyone, you know, we're here. We're all here, and you don't have to worry about your information getting out there. We're very discreet. We do a screening. Yeah, I forgot about that part. There's a screening process to make sure that basically you're legit. And because we don't, because it's so discreete we don't want just any old person to be able to join. But it's been a really really great community people that I

Speaker 3relate to on a completely different level.

Speaker 1Well, thanks, thanks for all that information. I do want to make one more announcement and then I have a call just for you. So yeah, I know right ied to mention that we do have a bunch of really cool merch at a c at tiny dot c A tiny dot c c slash aca merch, all kinds of cool stuff there. If you want to show off being an atheist, that's the way to do it. And maybe maybe you'll just attract some other atheists who are going to become your friends because you were wearing an atheist

Speaker 1T shirt. Wouldn't that be cool? So now what I want to do, though, is I want to bring up bring up Marcus from Texas, and he says he wants to ask Ashley about her Pentecostal background and if it's if it was actually as crazy as it sounds. LUs, Hello, Marcus, how are you doing good?

Speaker 2Thank you for having me on. Glad to see you here, Ashley. Yeah, I was Catholic myself, so I didn't have a great deal of interaction with Pentecostal people. I just kind of knew them as the people who thought they were speaking in tongues and possibly playing with snakes or things like that. But I didn't do is okay, but you did speak in tongue.

Speaker 3Oh yeah, all the time. I still could right now, but I'm not going to.

Speaker 2Oh, come on, I think everybody wants to hear that.

Speaker 3Just a little bit, I'll say. I'll say this this jokingly, but Botta Mazda should have bought a Honda.

Speaker 2Okay, I'll go with that. I caught that, But no, I did want to I did kind of want to ask. I mean that to me, that's kind of me and my Roman Catholic way of thinking. That was obviously one of the reasons why Pentecostal people were diluted and didn't have the right religion, But as somebody who used to be in it and is now out of it, I did kind of want to ask, what were you feeling when you were in the situation as opposed to what you're feeling now? And are there other things maybe that we're kind of on the same level of odd that

Speaker 2maybe people didn't know about the religion.

Speaker 3Yeah, you know, it kind of took me a while after I had left trying to make sense of what all those different experiences were that I had. You know, I guess the at first it started off with me kind of realizing, you know, we always prayed for feeling for somebody to get better from some sort of sickness or you know, like supernatural like growth of one leg being shorter than the other type of thing, and realizing, okay,

Speaker 3well that never happened. And then especially when some of my former friends from the church would reach out to me and say, actually, how could you leave? You know, after everything that you experienced. What was all that that happened to you then? And at the time I just didn't know. I'm like, I don't know, but I don't think it was a God. And over time I look back on it and I think of how they set up the church services to begin with. You know, there's

Speaker 3a herd mentality and everybody's everybody's doing the same thing, and so in those settings it doesn't feel weird or awkward or not normal because everybody's doing it. But the rush that I would feel when I would speak in tongues or even get like what we thought was like supernatural like laughter or crying or whatever, I really think

Speaker 3that it was like dopamine highs and you know, like oxytocin different things like that kind of almost feels like it was maybe similar to being in like a fight or flight type of mentality where you're just kind of getting a rush of different types of hormones. And you know, that's the best that I can explain it, because you know, being an atheist now, I can still speak in tongues whenever I want, But that doesn't necessarily mean that there

Speaker 3was anything having to do with the Holy Spirit being a part of it. And I don't I don't know. It's strange on this end to look back on that part of my life and think, I can't believe I was doing all that back then. That's wild. It just seems so weird to me now. But at the time it was almost kind of therapeutic. I felt like, I felt like that's what I needed at the time, because whenever I would go through hardships, some of it almost

Speaker 3felt like like very therapeutic to me. You know, I would be able to cry or laugh or you know, we would have alter calls a lot where you would go up to the front of the church at the altar and pray, and people would lay hands on each other and pray, and you know, it felt like God was going to answer our prayers because you know, it says where two or more are gathered, you know, that whole thing, And really it was just very comforting. You know, when you're going through a hard time, you have people

Speaker 3that are around you physically touching you, showing you that they care and hugging you, crying with you. And that's really kind of the conclusion that I've come up with for some of it, and looking back on it, it was strange, but it was my normal back then.

Speaker 2Whilst I kind of wanted to ask a follow up question, which was if now that you're an atheist, and I'm assuming the people of your old church maybe know this to some extent, and I'm assuming you've had a lot of people asking you, well, how can you do this? You were you were such a good religious person and now you're not. But I'm kind of interested in the the other side of that coin. Where are there people who have come up to you, maybe in private, and said, hey, I'm having my own doubts about this, but I'm still

Speaker 2holding onto this. Have anybody from your old church kind of come up and said they doubt all of this, speaking in tonguesy stuff.

Speaker 3And yeah, you know, I've had various conversations with people where a lot of them are they're still They're still the same as they were back then. They were a lot of them were very very upset with me. When I left, I kind of had to fall off the face of the planet for about seven and a half years, you know, no social media, changed my phone number, all that kind of stuff, because people were really kind of pretty hateful. But eventually, when I came back around and I was still saying that I didn't believe and became

Speaker 3a little bit more voistous about why I didn't believe, there were people that eventually started getting a hold of me, calling me, texting or getting hold of me on Facebook, things like that that would say, you know, maybe something along the lines of they didn't, especially around the time of elections and stuff, that they could not be on the wrong side of history and they saw some of the things that I was saying. Then Also there were

Speaker 3people that were just completely admitting to me that they don't believe anymore, and they were scared, and they were they were scared to let go of it. They were, especially when it came to hell, you know, afraid that if they were wrong that they would go to hell. But I've definitely had a few people tell me, you know, Ashley, thank you for being so out and open about it, because I don't believe anymore. I can't tell my family this, but it feels really good to be able to get this off my chest. But it definitely took like quite

Speaker 3a few years before I started hearing some of those things, right.

Speaker 2Yeah, that's I was almost I kind of wonder about that when I hear stories like yours of people who were very, very into their faith and then kind of come out and wondering how the backlash and the maybe the other side of it where you're finding you're not necessarily the only one who had the doubts. But I do appreciate you kind of sharing that with us, and I will let you go on to other calls, but I do have to say I appreciate Kelly's reverse wardrobe tonight. Usually Kelly comes on with a there uh kind of

Speaker 2tame tame jacket and a wonderful tie, but you you switched it up tonight. You came with the crazy the crazy jacket. I'm just wondering where you got that thing from and if they have him in larger sizes thank.

Speaker 1You so much. Yeah, they probably do. I've been had a running joke for the last few months and I keep going to go to buy a plain blue blazer and they keep coming back with these crazy monstrosities. But yeah, I'm pretty sure that they are. Yeah, that you can get him in bigger sizes. Johnny p Angel expressed a desire for me to come in a whole suit to the next back crew, so I'm considering that. So when we find out what kind of a crazy suit I can find.

Speaker 2I will make a pledge if you come. If you find your crazy suit, I will go to the bed. We'll make that deal.

Speaker 1Okay, cool, cool, cool, that sounds all right, I'll make that deal with you.

Speaker 5All right.

Speaker 1Thanks a lot, MICUs.

Speaker 2I appreciate it for having me on the show and have a good night.

Speaker 5Thank you.

Speaker 1So thanks, thanks a lot for calling in. I really appreciate your call. And that was awesome. Actually, that was something. The details you'ed into were great. You're pretty like you expressing your personal experience was great. Was awesome. One of the questions I always I ask a lot of people who spoke in tongues, were you really speaking in tongues? Were you just doing it because you felt like everybody around you felt like you need like everybody around you expected you to do it.

Speaker 3Yeah, there was definitely a pressure.

Speaker 1Yeah, so yeah, I mean, you weren't really speaking in tongues. You were just making stuff up to appease everybody around you. It was basically is that?

Speaker 4What was I mean?

Speaker 3Basically? Because then eventually it happened often enough that it was just oh, okay, I'm doing this now, And a lot of the time for me, it would happen like during praise and worship time, so music was loud, nobody could even hear what I was doing anyway, gotcha.

Speaker 1I just some that I've asked a lot of people who did spoke in tongues, So I don't know why I asked. It's just something I'm curious about.

Speaker 3So kind of just like feels like meditation almost because you're you're not thinking about the words that are coming out of your mouth or the sounds that are coming out of your mouth. It's just gibberish. And they've actually even hooked somebody up to an f MRI, you know, like a functional MRI while they've done this, just to see what's going on in their brain and basically the speech part of their brain is just kind of like nothing's really going on like there would be if I

Speaker 3was hooked.

Speaker 1Up to it right now, gotcha? Well we do. We do have another call that I'd like to get to you, but before we do, I want to thank the wonderful crew. Hey, I just made a poem that was awesome, and there they are. What a great what a great bunch of people there. And I can also see the control room at the Free Thought Library as well, so that's where all the magic happens. So thanks cru thanks for being there, Thanks for making this show work. I mean I just show up and talk, so I look stupid and talk. So you are the guys that really make it happen back there. So I do want to get to this

Speaker 1next call. It's Chase and he he him. He's in the USA, and he wants our opinions and the value of watching graphic footage to educate and motivate activism. So Hi, Chase, how you doing?

Speaker 8Hey, guys doing well? Thanks for having me. Yeah, I guess I want to talk about, you know, get your ideas on where to draw the line, you know, because I don't want to like overwhelm.

Speaker 2People too much.

Speaker 8But you know, like so I do activism for human rights and the animal rights, and you know, I think that showing the graphic footage from time to time, at least, you know, maybe once a week or something on my social media, for example, is one of the forms of activism that Okay, yeah, yeah, that can be effective. You know, there's a lot of different forms of activism that are effective, you know, like showing happy you know, happy people and happy animals and stuff like that. But also I think

Speaker 8it can remain really the violence can be really abstract unless we show the you know, like the footage of the individual victims suffering. I think it helps us connect to the victims. But I also know that, you know, some people are super sensitive, and I used to be super like, even more sensitive than I am now. I used to be really sensitive, and so I had to kind of build up my ability to watch these type of things like police brutality or hospitals being bombed or

Speaker 8you know, slaughter footage. And and now I feel like I'm able to watch it with a bit more ease because I've been somewhat desensitized. But I still I you know, I had PTSD before I started watching this stuff, and it might have furthered my PTSD, but I think it's still a sacrifice I'm willing to make to watch the footage and then share it.

Speaker 1I have different thoughts on it, Like number one. Number one, you brought up like that, you became desensitized to it after a while, So after a while it kind of loses its shock value and doesn't have the fact that you wanted to begin with. Number two. I don't know that it depends on how you present that kind of content, if you're presenting it in a way that people have to see it. Like I remember anti abortion activists with big, giant eight y eight photographs of what borded fetuses on

Speaker 1main street in one of the towns I lived in, And when they all left that day, and none of them were from my town, they just came blitzed it one day, the reaction was more negative than positive because of the pictures that they had line main street with. So I think you have to watch about watch how you're presenting that type of content. If you're forcing people to see it, you may end up affecting your cause in a negative way, then in a positive way. That makes any sense.

Speaker 8Yeah, yeah, I think you make a good point there. I'm not sure exactly how to analyze it right now, but I'm going to keep thinking about that. I think it might have something to do with the legitimacy of the cause as opposed to and also maybe like showing I don't know, there might be a difference between showing you know, dismembered bodies versus showing a lie a living individual in a state of fear. You know, that might strike better but not be so gruesome.

Speaker 1Mmmm yeah, right right, I mean you can, you can, you can show the negative plight of individuals without having to get graphic. Right. I'm trying to think of the photographer that was in California during the depression, that photograph he's got the famous picture, black and white photograph of the woman in the migrant camp. He did a bunch of photographs of the people who were stuck during the big Depression in these migrant camps that had come west from the dust bowl of the Middle on the Middle West,

Speaker 1and he really got people to understand through his pictures in Life magazine what was going on there, right, And there was nothing graphic, but he was still showing what was wrong what these people were going through. So I think we can communicate that message without without blood and gore.

Speaker 8Sure, Ashley, what are your thoughts?

Speaker 3You know me personally, some of my stronger viewpoints I've found was a lot better to share when I made when I had like different platforms. So like, I don't put some of the stuff that I think, especially the really strong viewpoints on my personal Facebook. But you know, I've then made social media specifically for all of my atheist stuff and all of that, because I knew that it wouldn't have the impact that I would I wanted

Speaker 3it to, because, like he's saying, it would be like I'm forcing it on them.

Speaker 1Right our backup post, Eli Slack just put in the text check context matters, And that's exactly exactly what I was trying to communicate it, And I think what actually was trying to communicate too. So Okay, something that would work in one instance might be just the opposite of what you need to work in another instance.

Speaker 3So sometimes it's really hard when you feel very passionately and you want other people to feel what you're feeling, But it is kind of good to maybe separate that out a little bit.

Speaker 8Yeah, I understand, I guess I just I myself have been severely impacted by some hardcore footage. And I know a lot of people who've made huge life changes because of some graphic footage. But I also know that a lot of people are hesitant to even begin to try to watch it. And I think that we underestimate ourselves sometimes, and maybe we should next time something comes up that we're at first afraid to watch, maybe we should power

Speaker 8through and watch it for a bit and see how much we can take in order to get educated and motivated to take action for the many victims of this world, you know, because I feel like if I was one of the ones that was really suffering, that I would hope that somebody would watch the video evidence of what's being done to me, so that they would know and and make that connection to me and strive to make a collective action to represent and liberate me, you know

Speaker 8what I mean?

Speaker 3Yeah, Yeah, I mean you definitely your hurt is in the right place. And how you know how strongly you feel and how sensitive you feel to some of these things. I mean, that's a really really good thing, especially in a world where people can be you know, so hateful.

Speaker 8Yeah, But at the same time, I don't want to make people faint or nothing either, you know, because I know some people are really sensitive to watch, to see blood and stuff like that, you know, so especially in person. But I hesitate to give them a trigger warning on social media, saying you know, because I think that again, like we underestimate ourselves. I think that we usually can see a little bit of this or that, you know whatever, whatever you know, suffering we go through I think pales

Speaker 8in comparison, Like the suffering that we go through by watching a second or two of something violent is nothing compared to what the victim went through.

Speaker 3Yeah, some people need a trigger warning, though. I mean, like there's a lot of things that I can watch or I can hear that I know, like, for instance, like my mom would never be able to He's just way too sensitive about some of that stuff. Does not want to hear about it or see it.

Speaker 1And as somebody that suffers from PTSD myself, it's not something that you get over, it's something you carry with you for the rest of your life. You just get more under control. There are things that will set me off, you know, I'll see something and I'll just be reduced to gibberish because of a news story that I read or I heard something on the radio. So that's that you got to be very careful about things like that. That's really really careful about things like that. And you did mention you suffered from PTSD yourself, so you should probably,

Speaker 1you know, I'm sure you understand that how those triggers work, right.

Speaker 8Yeah. Yeah, it's a tough line to walk, you know, because I guess I just feel that the majority of people can handle watching this. They just don't bel.

Speaker 1But is it but is it work? But is it worth causing harm to the other people to get to the majority that that's the question you have to ask yourself. And that's why I brought up the triggers with PTSD and why you should understand that yourself. I mean, would you want to be triggered out? But would you want your PTSD triggered because of a right wing somebody something that from a right wing cause set or showed you probably not right?

Speaker 3Well?

Speaker 8No, well no, but I think that's different than my PTSD being triggered, which it happens every day pretty much when I scroll through my social media. You know, it's just you know, God's a problem.

Speaker 1You know, Like, yeah, I get what you're saying, but but what you're But what I'm saying is do you want to add on to that?

Speaker 8Well if if necessary to prevent further suffering, then yeah, Like because if I put up if I.

Speaker 1But you're causing suffering by doing it. That's what I'm trying to That's what I'm trying to explain. Yeah, you are, you are. You are like bringing out to suffering to these people, but you're causing suffering to a group of people as well by doing so.

Speaker 8I understand. And when that, like when people share what I believe should be shared and I see it and it bums me out and triggers my PTSD a little bit, that's that's for me to deal with, and I need to, you know. But I'm not going to ignore the suffering of the world just for my own sake. And so I don't. I don't.

Speaker 1That's not what I'm asking you to do.

Speaker 5Mean, I don't hold.

Speaker 8On, hold on, I don't deem what they did a negative thing when they posted this, because if I posted something and included a trigger warning, most people would not watch it, even though they can and that's messed up.

Speaker 1I think it's messed up that you're forcing people to watch something like that, especially when there's people like me who could see something like that and be turned into a gibbering pile of humanity because I watched something like that. And that's what I'm trying to communicate to you. It's like you don't care about this group of people because because they're not most people.

Speaker 8Sorry, I didn't mean to interrupt.

Speaker 1That's okay.

Speaker 8I do care, and I wish I wish I didn't have to share this stuff. And maybe I shouldn't include a trigger warning, but maybe that would be that like that might not be as effective as leaving the trigger warning off. It's something I need to think about some.

Speaker 5More, but sure, I'm sure also.

Speaker 3Think about like maybe like maybe somebody would want to watch it later on, but maybe they're at work in that moment, and you know what if they were triggered while they're at work and they just happen to see it during like a fifteen minute break, or there was some family or they're near their kids, or you know, certain situations like that where it's just not the time and place, But if they had a warning they could maybe like flag that post and go and watch it later when it's a more appropriate time.

Speaker 8Yeah, that's a good thing to think about. You know. Another thing is just that maybe they shouldn't follow me on social media because I have a history of posts and this stuff and they should know, you know, that I'm trying to spread the word and that like I lean towards utilitarianism, which means I am willing to, you know, have some unfortunate things happen for a greater good, which means spreading the word and showing this evidence. You know.

Speaker 1Yeah, I know my posts get out to people who aren't my followers, so I'm not sure that that is a valid, a valid solution to the problem because the post still get out to people who don't follow you. So and that's that's what I'm talking about, is that you're that like when you post something like that, you don't put it trigger warning. You're actually just shoving that into their face, just like those anti abortion people were doing in on Main Street in my town and literally got a negative reaction to it. People people hated those

Speaker 1people more than they hated abortion after they left. And that that's why I kind of brought that up first, is that that you might be pissing off people more than you think you are.

Speaker 8Yeah, I still think that that, Like I'm hearing you.

Speaker 2I hear you.

Speaker 8But I still think that depends on the validity of the cause and like the values of the people that are.

Speaker 1No, it doesn't, No, it does. Like, if you're gonna horrible graphic scenery is horrible graphic scenery. Whether it's for a cause that you believe in or a cause that you're against, it's still horrible graphic scenery that a lot of people don't want to see and will harm or hurt people if it gets shoved in their face. And I keep trying to explain this to you, and you keep making excuses about why it's okay to do it, and I'm telling you that it's simply not okay to

Speaker 1do that. Well, because to cause harm to people is not okay.

Speaker 8Okay, Well, I think that, like I think we might be going around in circles.

Speaker 3You know.

Speaker 8Again, I so I don't want to repeat myself, but I do appreciate your time, uh, and thank you for all the activism that you do. You know, sometimes just a conversation is all that's needed. And there's no need to show graphic footage. And I wish it could be that situation all the time, but you can.

Speaker 1You can also show footage that isn't graphic. There are other ways to get to communicate to your ideas.

Speaker 8Yeah, that's true, that's very true, and I do that a lot as well. But I still think there's time for graphic footage and uh and uh, you know, but I need to rethink whether or not to put a trigger warning on there. So thank you for challenging me on that and making me think.

Speaker 1All right, Thanks Chase. I appreciate I always appreciate kind of stations with you, even if we don't agree. So I mean, you could call in with some great topics, So I appreciate that.

Speaker 2All right, thanks a lot, Thank you.

Speaker 1And we have got you know, I know, we've got some super chats here that we didn't do.

Speaker 3Pun do you have any THEIS callers?

Speaker 1We didn't know, we haven't. I know what's going on. I've been trying. I've been trying to get people to call all week. I've been trying to get people to call. So we'll see what happens. We do have some super chats though, we got five dollars from Puck and he says, minimal affinity for feminine amenities for cinnamon anenemies. Ah, Puck, you still haven't gotten me. We got five dollars from some kind of Dicky and he says, is that blazer visible from space? I don't know. I've never been in space.

Speaker 2I do.

Speaker 1I do have a couple of screenshots though, I thought maybe we might want to do after we finished that call. So I mean, if the crew is ready to do it, that great. So I'll give them a second just to get their shit together. And then I shouldn't say that to get to get to get my shit together. I'm the one and asking them to do stuff. But we can take number one if that's okay with you, And it says the reality is that while there is much evidence to support the Earth being very old, there is much evidence to support it being very young. The problem

Speaker 1is people like this gentleman here, and I think it's funny that he called me a gentleman. They don't talk about all the evidence. They all talk about the evidence that supports their worldview. And this was when I was talking about young Earth creationists. Obviously I am not I am not ignoring your evidence. I'm rejecting your evidence. I have seen the evidence, I have studied it, and I have rejected it for reasons that don't conform to reality. So the problem isn't that I am ignoring your evidence,

Speaker 1is that your evidence isn't providing proof of what you're saying. And this is why I often talk about I don't want your evidence, I want your proof. I want you to take what they're going to bring to me, put it through the evidentiary process first, and show that it is actually proof before you bring it into me, because evidence is often doesn't really get us anywhere. So what do you think about Young Earth creationism? Ashley?

Speaker 3Well, I mean I feel the same way. I mean usually if I'm not bringing up what their quote unquote evidence is is because it's irrelevant to me. You know, when when they mentioned that there's evidence for like worldwide flood and and and different things like that, I think that to me, I mean, even me who's not like super uh like like I probably don't know as much about science as you do, but I at least know

Speaker 3some of the basics as to you know, what that answer is, you know, like like tectonics for instance, you know things like that, like they're basic concepts that people just completely overlook.

Speaker 1Yeah, I think I think that's it too. And and here here is somebody saying that I'm that I'm ignoring the evidence, and he seems to be ignoring all my evidence too, So that's I thought. It was a little bit kind of the kettle callin the what is it? The something calling the other one black.

Speaker 3Kettle?

Speaker 1That's it? Oh my goodness, sometimes my brain again, my brain souls im and really sticking together today. Let's do one more screenshot, and uh, it says when did the physical world come to existence? Most atheists I have encountered do not believe the physical world has always existed. And this was again because I'm talking about Young Earth creationism, and I'm not real sure about what this guy is saying here. Now, I don't know if the physical world

Speaker 1has always existed or not. One of the things that I often say to people who who bring back, oh, is everything had to have a cause, so therefore God did it because God is eternal. Well, how do we know the universe is an eternal? Maybe the physical world has always existed. It's something that I've always said, it was a possibility, So I'm not sure where where you might get the idea that I don't believe the physical world has always existed. I don't believe it has. I think it's possible that it has, and I think it's possible that it hasn't. I know that there's several different

Speaker 1ideas hypotheses about how the about how the universe started. I don't know which one is right. Nobody does not at this point. Anyway, I think it's something that maybe if science may discover at some point in the future, but we're not even close to that yet. So, actually, you got anything you'd like to say on that one?

Speaker 3I mean, when THEUS will ask me questions about that type of stuff, what my thoughts are, you know about how do I feel about how the universe got here, how the Earth got here, how human beings came to be? Things like that. I feel comfortable with saying I don't know. I'm not an expert in that, and I'm not going to fill in the gap with a god did it at any point or any supernatural being did it, and

Speaker 3we just don't know all the answers. It's okay to say, you know, I don't know. I don't know for sure how long the Earth has been here, how long the universe has been here, and for all we know, it could be like a cyclical type thing, could be something that has happened over and over again, or maybe there was just one beginning point. We don't know.

Speaker 1Yeah, yeah, that's it. And I think that's really hard for Cynthias to accept that we that we don't know, so that they like have to have an answer to to how did the universe get there? Well, I know God did it.

Speaker 2It's easy. You know.

Speaker 1I don't need to have an answer to that. I really don't. I honestly, even if I had the positive answer to it tomorrow, I can to change my day to day life than he at all anyway, So you're right, I mean, it's not It's really not so.

Speaker 3And they're just so conditioned to the fact that they're told that they have the answers, that their book gives them the answers. So then that's just the rhetoric that they go with in those conversations is well, I think I have the answer, and you're saying, like, so, if you don't believe in my answer, then you must believe something else. That's the opposite of that, what is it that you think the answer is? And then they're just kind of thrown off a little bit when you're like, I don't know, and I'm fine with not knowing.

Speaker 1Yeah, I am too. That's the thing. I just like again, like even if I did know, it's not going to change my life on a day to day basis. So we did have a call. It was coming up like blank for me. But now I've refreshed and I see it now. So we're going to bring up our bring up our our next call. And it's Peter. He him in Canada, and he says he has proof of God's non existence. So, Hi, Peter, how are you.

Speaker 9I'm doing well, thank.

Speaker 1You, thanks for calling in. What do you got for us?

Speaker 9Well, you know, I have a proof that God does not exist. Only if he's defined as a conscious entity that created all of material existence, that entity cannot possibly exist.

Speaker 1Okay, And what proof do you have of that?

Speaker 9Well, I've got this written down. It's very it's very short. Okay, it goes on. Okay, God has claimed to be a conscious entity that created all materials. Is consciousness requires existence for that consciousness to exist at all? In that the idea of any entity capable of being conscious requires some existence to be conscious of. If there is nothing to perceive, there is nothing to form concepts the very things required to possess any form of consciousness. So, in summary, the

Speaker 9very things that God has claimed to have create that are the very things that were required to exist before God could ever logic logically exist himself. That's it.

Speaker 1You want to you want to tackle that one, Ashley. You look you look like you're in deep in thought. You really did just trying to understand. I don't know that that's proof. Let's say that that's evidence. I don't think you killed God off with that yet. What part of it did you not quite get? Ashley? Maybe we can we can, Maybe we can have Peter explain it a little bit better for us.

Speaker 9Can I repeat that?

Speaker 8Yeah?

Speaker 3Can you just kind of clarify like your your like overall meaning, okay, all of what you said?

Speaker 9Okay, I'm just going to repeat it. Consciousness to have consciousness requires existence for that consciousness to exist at all, And that the idea of any entity capable of being conscious requires some existence to be conscious of. That means you've got to perceive existence to form concepts. If there's nothing to perceive, there is nothing to form concepts the very things required to possess any form of consciousness. So, in a nutshell, the very things that God has claimed

Speaker 9to have created are the very things that were required to exist before God it could ever logically exist himself.

Speaker 3Do you think that if you were to give this argument to a theist that they would not believing in God?

Speaker 9Well, I'll tell you what I posted on Facebook all the time, and I get the I start the post with God not only does not exist, God cannot possibly exist in any logical sense, and then after that I just write down what I told you. Yes, I think most people don't even read past that that all they see is God not only does not exist, God cannot possibly exist in any logical sense. That's as far as they read. They don't read anything else. And I asked

Speaker 9them to steal man my argument. And I've asked at least three hundred theists to steal man my argument. One person tried it and they didn't even do it right because he argued against it while he was steel Man. It's actually quite comical.

Speaker 1No, Eli Slack, my wonderful, our wonderful and amazing backup post Eli Slack posted in the text chat. You know, most theis would claim that God was conscious of his own existence, and so that just creates consciousness all the way down. How do you counter that?

Speaker 9And you know what, I'd say, he can't.

Speaker 1No, And that's why I'm asking.

Speaker 9Yeah, see, they're presupposing his existence that I say, Well, he can't be consciousness of of himself because he can't exist. I've just told you that. So there is no God to be conscious of himself.

Speaker 1Why couldn't he be? Why couldn't he Why couldn't he become kind? Why couldn't he become Why couldn't he be his He exists and become conscious at the exact same.

Speaker 9That's a good question, and it's how could that happen?

Speaker 1I don't know, I mean how could there be a God to begin with?

Speaker 9So, I mean, yeah, something would have to initiate that. Like where in nature could that ever happen?

Speaker 1It's not in nature, it's supernatural?

Speaker 9Say that, but yeah, but then you're then you're presupposing the supernatural.

Speaker 1And you can't I'm just I'm just playing. I'm just playing God's advocate here. I was going to say, Double's advoctate, but I'm really playing God's advocate.

Speaker 3Do you consider yourself like a gnostic?

Speaker 8Like?

Speaker 3What out of curiosity do you can? Of curiosity? Do you consider yourself like a gnostic?

Speaker 9Yes, now that I have to admit that that argument only works if you define God in that way as a conscious blah blah blah.

Speaker 1Okay, so so so so again, we don't really have proof of God's non existence, but we have some logical evidence for it, but not prove.

Speaker 3Does that make sense?

Speaker 1I mean, just like I just said that what you just said is not going to kill God tomorrow. I mean, there's ways to get around it. I just came up with one. You know, I know you think it does. I know you think it does, but I we We've been trying to point out the flaws and what you're saying, and we did point out a couple of them. I thought we did.

Speaker 9Well, you can't be conscious of himself because it can't exist. It takes a presupposition.

Speaker 1And what about it, they came, what if he became came into existence and became conscious at the exact same time. Well, yeah, okay, see that's what I'm saying. And I agree with you. You've got you've got a pretty good logical sequence going here, right, But it doesn't prove anything to be there.

Speaker 9Being conscious of me is being conscious of something, So you have to have the existence there first. You can't have it at the same time. At least, I can't see how that could happen.

Speaker 1It's good, but you don't see how existence can happen without consciousness.

Speaker 9No, you can't have conscienciousness without existence.

Speaker 1Okay, well, what do you call it? Like like wait, wait, wait, hear me out for a minute. Hear me out. Then how did the Earth exist before anything.

Speaker 2Lived on it?

Speaker 9That's got nothing to do with this.

Speaker 1No, because you said something can't exist without consciousness. There was no consciousness on Earth, but the Earth still existed.

Speaker 9Yeah, but then the living entities that arose and evolved came.

Speaker 1I'm talking about before that. I'm talking about before that. There was no consciousness. There was no consciousness on Earth for the first couple hundred million years. But you were saying that something can't exist. You were saying that something can't exist without consciousness. And yet hear the Earth existed without any consciousness.

Speaker 9I didn't say that. I said nothing. Okay, just one second. My summary is the things that God has claimed to have created are the very things that were required to exist before God could ever logically exist him. So people that partially the asistance of God, they say, Okay, this guy lives forever and ever, but there had to be something for God to be conscious of first before he was, before he could exist. Do you understand?

Speaker 8Yeah?

Speaker 1Yeah, but it doesn't. It doesn't have any that doesn't explain away what I just said. The Earth wasn't consciousness, wasn't conscious of its own existence, and yet it still existed.

Speaker 9Yeah, but the Earth is not claimed to have created existence.

Speaker 1It doesn't matter. You're saying that. You were saying that you have to have you have to have existence to have consciousness, because you have to have consciousness for something to exist. Right, Well, the Earth existed and there was no consciousness. You're you're I don't I don't understand why you don't get what I'm saying.

Speaker 9No, because you're not saying what I'm saying. Okay, this is so simple, and this.

Speaker 1Is it's not because it's obviously not, because you have two people here on the show that don't understand what you're saying. So it's obviously not that simple.

Speaker 9This is all I'm saying. You want me to repeat this again. The very things that God claimed to have created are the very things that were required to exist before God could ever logically exist himself, because he is claimed to have created everything everything that exists. They claim God created, but he couldn't be conscious of anything because there was nothing there before him.

Speaker 1Okay, it's just called the prime the light.

Speaker 3When he created the sun and there was now daylight and nighttime, is there consciousness there?

Speaker 9Yeah, that's nothing to do with it. I'm just talking about the very point of creation itself. People claim God existed before everything else existed because he created.

Speaker 1Everything, right, I get what you're saying. I just don't agree with that, and I don't agree that it's proof of the non existence of God. I under I actually do understand what you're saying, but I don't agree with that. I think it's right. I don't think it's proof of the non existence of God.

Speaker 9Okay. The only thing that you could get it out of it is saying that the existence and the consciousness popped into existence at the same time. But that's oh man, come on.

Speaker 1How could that I just don't. And even you, even you yourself, said this only works if you define God in a certain way. You even you said that. So yeah, so, like I said, this doesn't, This doesn't. This doesn't prove the non existence of God.

Speaker 9No, no, no, no, you're not getting that. I don't know why not. God is plain to be No.

Speaker 1No, no, no, Just stop for a minute, Peter, Just stop for a minute. Peter, repeating the same thing over and over. It's not helping. Okay, And and I understand, I understand you want this to be, right, I understand that, but it's fallen flat to me. It doesn't work, and it certainly doesn't prove the non existence of God. It may prove the non existence of a concept, one of the concepts of God, but it certainly doesn't prove the non existence of God altogether.

Speaker 9Well, yeah, okay, he could be Okay, you could say, well God materialized after you know the the verse creator. You know, you have some cosmic consciousness out there. But is that what a theist wants to say as God is. No, they want him to be the beginning of everything. Do you understand.

Speaker 1I don't know. Not all theists think that. I mean Christians think that Muslims think that.

Speaker 9Exactly, I don't.

Speaker 1I don't think anybody who worships thinks that.

Speaker 9So, you know, it's it's you can it all boils down to if the shoe fits type of thing.

Speaker 1Yeah, but it's not fitting. I don't see it fitting. That's the thing. It's fitting. It's fitting a concept of God. It's fitting one God, but it's not fitting on all the other gods.

Speaker 9Okay, exactly, I agree with that.

Speaker 1Okay, yeah, but you want And that's why I'm saying it's not it's not proof of the non existence of God. It just isn't. It's just proof of the non existence of one concept of.

Speaker 7God, exactly.

Speaker 9Okay. That's what I actually came in with and where I ran into this, you know where I ran into this no idea that was shrugged.

Speaker 3I'm sorry.

Speaker 9You know the book Atlas Shrugged.

Speaker 1Yeah, that's why I said, I'm sorry. Yeah, that's why I said, I'm sorry. Get you wasted your time reading that book.

Speaker 9No, no, no, you can't throw away that. There's a lot of things she was full of it about, but a lot of things she wasn't. I always thought that when I.

Speaker 1Read it but I never got anything out of ran and Rand that I couldn't have got somewhere else, so from a better source.

Speaker 3Actually, I don't even know.

Speaker 9If she got that from somebody else or not. That's where I ran into it. But anyway, I can't really add any more to this than what I have already.

Speaker 1And it's been a all right, thanks Pierre. I really appreciate your call. I mean, it was really some food for thought, I definitely. I mean it got me to thinking about some things. I know it got the Eli somethings thinking about some things. And I know I got Ashley completely confused.

Speaker 9So okay, good.

Speaker 1You might want to try to find a better and like a simpler way to communicate the idea, because it's not it's.

Speaker 9Not it's I've shaved this down as much as I could. It was a lot longer than this.

Speaker 1No, I'm not talking about making it shorter. I'm talking about making it simpler to understand. Not that not making it shorter, making it turning it, turning it into language that a ten year old could understand.

Speaker 9Oh, I've never run into that.

Speaker 1Some you've never run into language that a ten year old can understand?

Speaker 9And that well, don't interrupt me. Please, don't interrupt me.

Speaker 1That's it, you're you know what. This is my show, not yours. Okay, so don't start yelling at me about interrupting. And you have over talked me several times already, so I know we've we've over talked to each other. There's a delay problem at times, and that kind of sucks. But don't don't start yelling at me on my own show.

Speaker 9But I understand the impast that we're at and we can't really go any farther than this.

Speaker 1All right, Well, if you'd like to call back and talk to one of the other hosts about it and maybe get a different outlook on it, feel free. But that's I think that's as far we're going to take it this evening. So thanks again Peter for calling in, And uh, it was something that I would like to do before we do anything else. Is I want to bring up our I talked that. I mentioned him twice already, our wonderful, amazing backup post, Eli Slack. I like to bring him on up. Hi Eli, how's it going. I know you had some thoughts about that last call. What do you think?

Speaker 7Yeah, a little bit? So, Yeah, as we started first like a, uh, well, first of all, hey, great show, guys. Uh I think, so, yeah, I've seen enough of your shows. I'm not a post anymore, Kelly.

Speaker 2So yeah.

Speaker 7The first thing we said, like atheist would just say, well, God was conscious of his own existence, and I I acquitated this is just consciousness all the way down. And then we had fun with that in the chat. But the response, as I understood it, was well, no, he would have to be conscious of his own existence before he could exist, which is contradictory to what Peter was saying. I think there was a little bit of a of a mix up because I I didn't hear him say existence requires consciousness. I heard him say consciousness requires existence, which I think I agree with. But when we get

Speaker 7to the point of like we're talking about divinity and like an intelligent creator of the universe with agency, we're already outside of the realm of like what makes sense. So I think trying to describe it in terms of like, well, it wouldn't make sense to be conscious before you existed, Well, obviously it wouldn't make sense, but like neither does anything else in the Bible, So it seems sort of a moot point to try to argue with someone who believes in the triomne god.

Speaker 1Awesome with my thoughts. Wait, what about Chase's call? What did you think about that one?

Speaker 3About graphic Chase?

Speaker 7Yeah, so context is kind of where we landed on that Context manners a lot. I think, as past Ashley pointed out, somebody may see something like, Okay, this is something I will look at later, but right now I'm not in the right, like the appropriate contextual setting to be looking at, like my six year old is over my shoulder, and I don't want to have to explain like why this person's like arm is not attached to their body or stuff like that, or people with PTSD, like we talked about Chase seems to I don't think he said this explicitly, but it he mentioned that, like

Speaker 7he you know, he gets triggered every day. His PTSD is triggered every day, and it sounds like perhaps he has a system where he's pretty successful at kind of managing that and it doesn't interrupt his routine so much, or perhaps his like thought patterns or like doesn't give him too much of it. And he didn't say that, so I might be like I'm kind of extrapolating, and that might be an unfair assumption, But not everybody like he definitely not everybody handles it as well as it sounds like he is, because he's saying like if he just casually is saying like, yeah, I get triggered basically

Speaker 7every day just scrolling through Facebook, and you're just continuing to do that. It sounds like you handle that better than a lot a lot of people do. And so to impose that on others because you know, you think that's best exposure therapy can be effective, but that you can't make that decision for other people like that. That's exposure therapy is effective when a person chooses that, or you know it's directed by a trained person, not you know, just posting on social media exactly.

Speaker 1I feel the same way. I really do. I understand the benefit of it, but again, I don't think you should be shoving into people's faces or putting it somewhere where they're just going to see it without some kind of warning at all. So Ashley, you were freaking awesome.

Speaker 2Man.

Speaker 1I'm so happy I got to do the show with you. I really had a lot of fun. I wish I wish we had more theist callers calling in, you know, but we had some good calls. Actually, I forgot to ask you beforehand. Are you going to be able to hang out with us in the after show at all? And don't feel like you need that you're obligated to.

Speaker 3Yeah, I mean I can, I don't have I don't have one, so they need you to walk me through what I do where I go. I'll try.

Speaker 1Yeah, I'm not sure I can send you a link then, and from that point, I think you might have to sign in and and uh. And if you don't make it, I I totally understand, right, I mean, I'm not, like I said, I'm not going to hold you to it. I understand it. Sometimes we actually go pretty late, and I understand it. Not everybody can do that, and I try not to go too late. I will put a uh. I will put a link in the messenger for you though, so that you can find it.

Speaker 3I mean, those conversations were pretty good, even though we didn't get any theists. I don't really like to talk to theists, but I mean there were just some good discussions in there. Things to think about.

Speaker 1I thought the last two discussed well, this last one was a little confusing. I thought it was a good discussion and maybe not about the actual topic, but about how uh, how about the about the logic of the topic to what the call was described as. I guess so because I.

Speaker 3Mean and and like in regards to like what Chase was talking about too. Sometimes sometimes people are interested in some of those heavier topics. I mean, even when you think of like atheism, talking about religion and things like that, Like you know, maybe some of our viewers who have come out of religion, they a lot of people will watch a lot it kind of binge, watch a lot of episodes and then maybe reach a point where they're kind of like, I need to take a break. It's

Speaker 3too much, it's too heavy, and people just do that in general with heavier content. Some people can handle seeing it whenever, but some people really just they need to take breaks. They need to be in the right headspace.

Speaker 1Yeah, yeah, I agree. And I want to thank you again Ashley for being here. I had so much fun with you. I this was a real honor for me to meet you and to work with you today, so I really appreciate it.

Speaker 3It was nice to meet you too.

Speaker 1Yeah, and I want to read before we leave. I want to reiterate our segment, we want the Truth. The prompt for this week is what is something that doesn't sound creepy but is so Comment on the video your comment, maybe you're right on right on next week's episode, comment below, not next to us in the comments, and stick around because we are going to go to the atheist community of Discord for an after show. At least Eli and I will be there, and hopefully Ashley will be able to join us as well, and we'll be back next week. And in the meantime, we want you to keep wanting

Speaker 1the truth.

Speaker 4Watch the nonprofits, and join the hosts in the live chat. Visit tiny dot, cc slash yt n b

Speaker 1You

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Truth Wanted 9.46 with ObjectivelyDan and Out Of Body Atheist

    Nov 16, 20261 hr 31 minAudio

    In today's episode of Truth Wanted, ObjectivelyDan welcomes guest Out Of Body Atheist, with The Beard of Empathy on backup, to dig into Reiki, New Age spirituality, homeopathy, and the long road from woo to skepticism!...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Truth Wanted 9.45 with Jon The Skeptick and Volcy

    Nov 9, 20261 hr 23 minAudio

    In today's episode of Truth Wanted, Jon the Skeptick, Volcy, and Sofia Spina explain why no one can talk to the dead, from Haitian Vodou and grief dreams to Jon's past as a spiritualist! Bob jumps from objective...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Truth Wanted 9.44 with ObjectivelyDan and Nintendrew

    Nov 2, 20261 hr 29 minAudio

    In today's episode of Truth Wanted, ObjectivelyDan and Nintendrew, later joined by The Beard of Empathy, tackle a world run on Jesus, the magic of manifesting, and a prayer that actually got answered! Bob in NY, a...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Truth Wanted 9.43 with ObjectivelyDan and Kelley Laughlin

    Oct 26, 20261 hr 28 minAudio

    In today's episode of Truth Wanted, ObjectivelyDan, Kelley Laughlin, and The Beard of Empathy tackle standards of evidence, miracle claims, and the false binaries of moral philosophy! Dean in VA questions why skeptics...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Truth Wanted 9.41 with ObjectivelyDan and Chad Harris

    Oct 12, 20261 hr 32 minAudio

    In today's episode of Truth Wanted, ObjectivelyDan and Chad Harris tackle Christian nationalism, police brutality, and the uncomfortable truths about racism and immigration. Big E in TN survived police brutality and...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode