Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Truth Wanted

Truth Wanted artwork

Truth Wanted 09.21with Kelley Laughlin and Ember

May 25, 20261 hr 23 minAudio
  • Apple Podcasts

In today’s episode of Truth Wanted, Jamie the Blind Limey and Doctor Ben explore the intersection of medical ethics and religious traditions! Joined by guest Kelley Laughlin, they dismantle the absurdity of Chick tracts and discuss the secular nature of community. Can critical thinking overcome the dangers of ancient burial rituals and end-of-the-world fantasies? Rebecca in CA asks where aid workers should draw the line between respecting burial customs and preventing Ebola outbreaks. Jamie and Ben discuss prioritizing public health over spiritual rituals. Will logic save communities from faith? Thank you for joining us today! We will see you next time! Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/truth-wanted--3195473/support.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Speaker 1You know, I'm often intrigued that the things that people tell me that they believe, and sometimes even more when they explain to me why they actually believe it. So I'd like to put out the challenge to everyone out there to intrigue me. Give me a call and ask me Colin, tell me whatever you believe in and why you believe it, whether it be religious or paranormal, and tell us what it was that actually convinced you on that topic. Because the show is starting right now. Hello,

Speaker 1and welcome to another episode of Truth Wanted. I am your os Kelly Laughlin and usually have to chuck my notes to see that, and I want to welcome you to Truth Wanted, the live calling show that happens every single week at its brand new time on Sunday at two forty five pm, where we talk to people about what they believe and why they believe it, and if you'd like to call us you can. We encourage it actually, so give us a call at one five one two nine two four to two, or you can call us

Speaker 1through your computer at tiny dot cc slash call tw Truth Wanted is a product of the Atheist Community of Austin, a fiveh one c three nonprofit organization dedicated to the promotion of atheism, critical thinking, secular humanism, and the separation of religion and government. And we are try streaming today, So a big shout out to all of our viewers on TikTok and YouTube mobile. If you're watching us on TikTok today and you'd like to talk to us, then

Speaker 1request to join. We'll bring you up on stage. Please make sure though, that you are over eighteen years of age before doing so. And every week, this is the best part about Truth Wanted. Every week we have a special guest and this week is no different. We have Ember with us. Ember, how you do it?

Speaker 2Hello, lovely to see you again. It's been a few minutes, Kelly.

Speaker 1Yeah, it's I mean since we've actually seen each other in person. It's been quite been almost a year now, it's true. Yeah, yeah, So how have you been? I you know, I love I love your content, I really do. And honestly, I'm and I am a little I'm a little uh. I have a little worried because you are I think one of the smartest people that I know. So I've so I feel like I'm going to get overshadowed today.

Speaker 2It depends on what we talk about. I I I'm not sure how to respond to that one. So I'll just smile a nod and remind you that you have far more rocks than I do.

Speaker 1Oh, I'll give you that. Maybe you got me. I got you on one topic at me.

Speaker 2So also, ties, I thought, since you know you're trying to be festive to match my look, I should try to be somewhat fun. But I only have I only have the one Ti Kelly. I'm I'm just.

Speaker 1I have probably and this, and I'm not ex acduate. I probably have close to one hundred and fifty.

Speaker 2Now, it's amazing you have more tithes than I have hats, and that is impressive.

Speaker 1So i'd want to talk to you about about your you know, your show. What is it that you usually you know, what kind of content do you produce?

Speaker 2Well, it's it's hard to sum up human rights. It specifically trans rights, intersex rights, women's rights, victims, advocacy, human rights for all humans, and that entails debunking conspiracy theories and pseudoscience and all that sort of stuff. There's a whole lot of counter apologetics mixed in, but it's a mixed bag. The emphasis is on human rights.

Speaker 1Awesome, awesome, And how long have you been doing this now?

Speaker 2Well, a little over three years. It was October December twenty something. It's been a minute.

Speaker 1I'll be honest with you. I didn't find you until after I met you.

Speaker 2That makes sense, that happens. That's one of the reasons that connecting with people is so very important, because we understand there's hundreds, if not dozens of creators running around on the YouTube, but it's only once we actually connect with someone, Once we see someone or especially meet someone that we engage in, we're like, I like the cut of that person's jib, and so we go, you know, find them and see what else they're up to, and then meet all the cool people that they know, and

Speaker 2it just kind of it spreads like a spiderweb.

Speaker 1Yeah right, right, yeah right. That's a great way to look at it. That's awesome. So what do you what do you have any plans in the future that you're things that you're gonna do in the way of activism or anything like that. Well, I think we're both gonna end up in the same place in July. Again, I think it.

Speaker 2Seems it seems likely. Probably, I'm I'm I don't know, because there's there's two things happening in July, right, and I'm only I've only been invited to one of them, so I'm gotcha. Yeah.

Speaker 1I actually I actually put it out to Joe that I was willing to speak at the art protests, so I am, I'm gonna end up being a speaker there, so maybe talk to them, you know, if that you're something, that's something you're interested in.

Speaker 2I don't know, it's it's it's a complicated situation, but there, Okay.

Speaker 1Okay, I won't go into it. I won't go into it. I know there's a lot. I know there are two things happening in July. I can only do one at one of the two. So that's and I had a lot of fun at the art protests last year, so I'm going to do it again. It was so hot last year, though, Oh my goodness.

Speaker 2It was we were we were all dying, and in fact, we're all dead now we're ghosts. We're ghosts. We can we can wrap up and go home. Proof of this supernatural done.

Speaker 1I had a lot of fun there. There was a lot of a lot of celebrities there.

Speaker 3I had.

Speaker 1It was a really good time to network with people. I got to meet so many people that I did watch, you know, content creators that I was watching. I got to meet so many more. I've made a lot of good, lot of many many friendships there that day. You know, I got to meet both the Kelly's, so you know, then that was cool, so that, you know, I had a really good time.

Speaker 2Yeah. Likewise, godless Granny for for example, you know, i'd engaged with her. I think we'd been on a panel or two together at one point, but I actually got to see her in person, and then it's a different situation. And of course other Kelly. I literally met Kelly, the Detroit atheist queen for the very first time the night before the art protest. We were hanging out at uh uh the president of the Tri State Freethinkers and Mendisa Thomas was there, and Mendisa of course, when Mandisa speaks,

Speaker 2you listen. Yeah, Mensa is Ember, you have to meet my friend Kelly. Awesome.

Speaker 1I you know, I met Mendsa that weekend too, and I'll be I feel kind of embarrassed because I kind of fan boyd while when I'm meeting her, so yeah, I know. Would she speaks you listen? Yeah, I love Mandisa. She's awesome.

Speaker 2Yeah, so yeah, Kelly. That's that's how I met Kelly and have been doing. Kelly and I have gotten close. We all get close to some degree or other with our online things and whatnot. But as you you were probably aware, channels of a certain size can have custom emojis, and Kelly is one of the emojis on my channel. Oh really, yeah, really, she has her own emoji. That's awesome.

Speaker 1That's awesome. I think I have my own hair. I don't think anybody has ever used it. I wouldn't want to.

Speaker 2I can't begin to say. But I have heard a rumor that, in fact, today we have someone else in in the Kelly hole, because you, Kelly, are not in the Kelly hole today. You're you're in You're in the driver's seat.

Speaker 1Yeah, yeah, we do. We do have a Kelly on the crew today. Yeah, we are but few now, but soon us Kelly's will cover the earth like flies.

Speaker 2Then you then you'll have your own events. In July, you'll have Kelly Khan.

Speaker 1Yeah, yeah, we'll have Kelly Vania that we that we can all move to be awesome. We can have a Kelly's government.

Speaker 2Mm hmm and Kelly based culture like like, I don't know what would you call a food based in in Kelly Sylvania. Would it be like Kelly Q or or Barbia Kelly.

Speaker 1Barbie Kelly sounds good? That sounds good. It awesome.

Speaker 2Just kind of going with things here. You know, it's it's an adventure, so let's see what what kind of I have some hypotheticals for you. Okay, because chronically over prepare for things. It's it's sort of in my nature. That's pretty So first of all, a reminder to everybody, Pride Month is coming some in your demons now or hell will be full. Just just throwing that out there. You don't want you don't want to end up with like a little sprite minion thing because the you know,

Speaker 2the great big Lord of the Abyss is already reserved. Get your summons in. Let's see there. There are a few conspiracy theories running around that are are not super harmful. They're they're just silly people speculating about silly things for you know, fun and profit, mostly fun. One of my favorite is that the reason we got so invested in the space race in the fifties and sixties was not

Speaker 2because of the battle of two great economic systems, but because astronomers observed an alien spaceship crashing on the Moon, and so the superpowers were in a race to get to that alien technology. And that's where our technology, like cell phones. Can you imagine it's we're reverse engineering alien technology, all these rfid'd chips.

Speaker 1Yeah, but they all landed in so many different places. I mean, they well that was probably part of it. You know, they were trying to hide where they were actually getting this stuff right, so they landed in all different places. Yeah, it makes sense.

Speaker 2That's that's how you got to cover things up. Is you've got like, you know, whoever's got the information, it's probably a group of people, because deciphering alien languages is going to take like a whole university department or something. So they've got all the technical manuals of all the alien technology, and they're like just sending letters to all the different inventors around the world. Hey, you know, if we take this this existing radio technology and we combine it with the signal hopping frequency that Hettie Lamar came up with, then we can we can make bluetooth stuff

Speaker 2ta da and they just they just patented and then it's out there. Yeah.

Speaker 1See that's the kind of stuff that scares me about you that you know, Like about Hetty Lamar doing the missiles. I don't know too many people that know that.

Speaker 2Of course I know about Eddie Lamar. We just we just did Women's History Month like two months ago. Do you know about Skunk Baxter that doesn't ring a bell? He was guitars for the Doobie Brothers and he also became a military expert, believe it or not. Hmmm, I think and I think it was in missile I think it was some type of missile technology. I'm not positive, but yeah, another another uh entertainer that ended up breaking into that field, which is really really a weird cross to me. It's I guess when you're a professional musician

Speaker 2you do science as a hobby. Because there's Brian May, the guitarist from Queen right who I mean, he doesn't do a lot of like rocket research kind of stuff, but he is a PhD level astrophysicist and he has published work. So it's not.

Speaker 1Nothing, yeah, right right, right, right right, yeah, Yeah, It's.

Speaker 2Like just just a side hobby when you have millions upon millions of dollars.

Speaker 1Kind of science started out as a side hobby for me, honestly, and eventually I just immersed myself in it. So that's why I was just on another show this week and I was talking about gatekeeping knowledge, and I don't think we should gatekeep knowledge. And you can. You can become an expert in anything you want to become an expert in. You might not be recognized by people who have degrees in that field, but if you can also break through through and be recognized by them too as well, like I do not I say it all the time. I

Speaker 1don't have a degree in geology, but I've been published six times in per review journals. So I mean, you can't get recognition from people in the field that you just want to learn how to learn about it, honestly. So there you go.

Speaker 2Yeah. Interestingly enough, going back to conspiracy theories, that was the originator of modern flat earthism was a fellow named Samuel Robotham, and that was his big complaint was that science was becoming gentrified. It was accessible to the very wealthy who had the leisure time and the money to afford the equipment and getting big mad about that. He was like, you should be able to do science with just your senses and what you can observe for yourself.

Speaker 2Of course, you can do science with just what you can observe for yourself. We learned a lot of things that way even today. But that doesn't mean electron microscopes aren't used to you.

Speaker 4Know, right right, I would love to own one of those, man when the local university is up here sold when a few years back they got a new one and it was way more than I could afford.

Speaker 1But I dream, I had a dream, you know, I have my own electron microscope.

Speaker 2Oh yeah, some of the toy. That's one of the reasons people go get PhDs is so that they can get on university staff and then get the permits to play with the university equipment. Because there's nobody short of Elon Musk and you know a handful of other people can afford this kind of stuff. It requires a major corporation with huge multimillion dollar endowments to get these these colliders in things. I mean, you know, even the non governmental organizations like cern A Center for European Research Nuclear

Speaker 2It requires multiple nations to support their budget, you know. So yeah, some people want to, you know, just smash some protons together and see what falls out.

Speaker 1Yeah, I would love to. I once got a tour through Fermi Lab in Illinois that was really interesting, and they didn't bring us to like the newer collider, but they brought us to the original collider. And now I'm gonna say this was some twenty years ago, and I was really surprised that they were still running it with the big giant computer banks, with the reels of magnetic tape. It was amazing.

Speaker 2I mean, it works.

Speaker 1They were in the process of switching over to actual communit modern day computers at the time I was there, but I just thought it was so cool that they were still running that type of computers.

Speaker 2I mean, it's reverse compatible with it's itself. But yeah, there's there's a couple of different factors that go into that. The first is that it does work. We're switching over to something newer, no guarantee it'll actually function. And then there's the claw because you only have a certain amount of budget, and if you can get a bigger laser or a different kind of computer, you're gonna get more results with the bigger laser, the newer computers just easier data crunching.

Speaker 1Because because contrary to what many many conspiracy theorists believe, science doesn't make you know, scientists don't make a ton of money. We're not out there trying to gather grant money. And even if we if we do get grant money, as Ember just stated, there's never enough of it for to do all the research that's needed.

Speaker 2So goodness, no, no, I.

Speaker 1Wish there was more money in science, but I think would make the world a better place. I really do. Mm hm, And it's what what what is what? I'm getting all tungue tied today. A good trend that I see though, happening over the over my lifetime was is there's more and more and more people doing science. So as a result, we're getting more and more and better results, which I which I've really really appreciated throughout my lifetime seeing that happen.

Speaker 2Yas we're we're getting we're getting citizens scientists in a whole bunch of different fields. Now just a couple of quick examples, there's there's amateur astronomers all over the world that are using these new telescopes that are coming out, like the the Mini Dwarf and the c Star. There's there's a TikTok creator who also visits us over at doctor Ben's on here on YouTube named Cosmic Kyle, and he's been starting to get awards for his astrophotography so good. It's it's amazing stuff. And even though they don't have

Speaker 2like the Hubble or the James Web or something, they're capturing a ton of night sky data and that's letting us detect near Earth objects at amazing rates. Like before it was just if someone happens to see it, but now that more people are looking more often, we notice lights that aren't where they're supposed to be and we go, oh, that that is a asteroid and it's heading in our general direction. And then we do a few more measurements and it's the size of a school bus and we shrug, but we have found it.

Speaker 1You know, first we got to get everybody paranoid through the media before we just shrug.

Speaker 2Right, that's right. We need to do a few more movies like don't look up in things. But the other way is there's I forget the name of the program off hand, but it's a citizen computer cycle donation thing for live protein folding experiments. There's digital programs that experiment with different waste proteins can be folded, and people can like log into the university that's running this and just leave their computer running on standby while it's connected to

Speaker 2the system, and it will use their computer cycles to help process more protein folding stuff to help with like research into new medicines and whatnot. And more people have more computers with more free time, and it's it's making all that research go so much faster. And those are just two ways that regular people can help without even really putting in any effort.

Speaker 1You know. Remember, we have a call, so I'd like to take the call, but before we do, I want to do one thing real quick. I want to shout out to you. Every week we shout out to one of our patrons that donates through Patreon, and our patron of the week this week is go talg g o t og. Thank you, go talg, and thanks to everyone else who contributes to the show. And if you're interested in doing it yourself, you can at tiny dot c c slash, Patreon. Tw we really encourage it. This is a nonprofit, none of us get paid for doing this.

Speaker 1It's all volunteer. It just keeps the show going and it helps finance the Free Thought Library in Texas, which is an incredible place and has all kinds of cool things happening all the time. Philosophy night, game night. It's really worth checking it out if you live in the area or are passing through. That was pretty good, Bell.

Speaker 2Yeah, you need more libraries, Yeah, specifically free thought ones in the sage of book bands and.

Speaker 1Right, right, so let's let's take this call. Oh, what's going on here?

Speaker 2I'm having a friends.

Speaker 1I'm having a hard time with my uh oh, there we go, there we go. Sorry, And this is Ben He him from Texas. Hello Ben, how are you?

Speaker 2Yeah?

Speaker 3Doing well?

Speaker 5How are you, Kelly? And very pleasure to be on with you.

Speaker 1Oh, it's a pleasure to talk to you. And it's what I got here. It says, you want advice, I'm talking to someone who fervently believes in the supernatural. Yeah.

Speaker 5I spend a not insignificant amount of time discussing these kind of things with people, and it's always kind of flummis me when someone's talking about like aliens are ghosts and it gets down to like they're convinced they had like a personal experience with something supernatural, And I was just wondering if you guys had any advice on like especially if it's like a family member or something like that, And it keeps coming up, and it's like when family gets together, you're running into this that they believe in

Speaker 5ghosts or aliens, and that kind of feeds other conspiracies that they're into, and it's all kind of predicated. They're deeply convinced that they had a personal experience. What would you guys say to someone like me or what kind of advice could you give to me in my the audience on how to address that with someone?

Speaker 1Remember, you want to go first.

Speaker 2Sure, it's a difficult situation because because there's someone who's close to you, you know, a family member, close friend, whatever, you don't want to hurt their feelings, Whereas when it's a random person on the internet, it's a lot easier to say, right, I get that you had an experience, but do you have any reason to believe that's true? Because there's other people who have other experiences that conflict with yours. Like a big one we run into very often is near death experiences. We've got some people who see the light at the end of the tunnel and there's Jesus, and other people see Mohammed, and other people

Speaker 2see Vishnu, and clearly they're having experience. It's a product of the brain rather than something objective they're experiencing. But when it's someone that we know, we need well, assuming we want to preserve the relationship, we need to be a little bit more sensitive, We need to be a little bit more caring, and so it can be very tricky, and it depends on the person. I don't have a best practice as guide for this. You really do have to play it by ear. But the key in my experience,

Speaker 2and you know, I realize we're refuting personal experience with personal experience, But in my experience, you're much better off focusing on the epistemology why do you think so? And bringing up other examples to show that what they believe may have happened isn't necessarily the case. Or you can go with a different direction and say, listen, you saw a ghost. I love that for you, but that does not mean the earth is any particular shape. Like all

Speaker 2these conspiracy theories are not entailed to the thing that you experienced, you know, but it really depends on the person.

Speaker 1One of the things that it. I in my experience, a lot of these experiences, these paranormal or supernatural experiences, tend to be coincidental things. And I like to point out, I don't know if you've ever heard of it before, but Littlewood's law. Littlewood was an English mathematician, and he figured if something had a one in a million chance of happening, if you were conscious for eight hours a day, and you have an experience every second of that time period. Of that eight hours, what you do every second is

Speaker 1an experience. At the end of thirty four and a half days or somewhere about that, you would have had a one or you would have had the ability to have a one in a million chance thing happened to you. So I think a lot of times when I hear about these paranormal experiences, I think they can pretty much be written off by little Woods law. And I like to explain how that works to people, and it does seem to at least make them consider the fact that what had happened to them wasn't paranormal, that it might

Speaker 1have just been coincidental.

Speaker 5Ah, little Woods law. I've never heard of that before, and that's really interesting.

Speaker 2It's a really good one, yeah, little Wood.

Speaker 1Yeah, it is a good one, it really is. And it's it's so such a good explanation for a lot of things that happened, a lot of religious experiences the same thing. They end up being coincidences. You know, people will say, well, I prayed for this to happen, and then two days later would happen. Well, you know that's your one on a million chances that could have happened every thirty four days, you know, so.

Speaker 2We we should, in fact expect more miracles than we see in our everyday life.

Speaker 1Yeah, right, right right, we should, We really should exactly.

Speaker 5So it's actually enough peple are just not noticing the coincidental stuff that it didn't actually have more of them out there.

Speaker 1It's not that it does happen every thirty four days, it's just that it has the ability to happen every thirty four days. So you might go, you know, one hundred and twenty eight days before you have some type of coincidence, you know what the kind of coincidence? Ayev All the time I'll be typing and listening to something something at the same time I'm typing a word, they say it that happens to me like all the time, right, And that's that's the kind of little coincidences that I'm talking about. How you know, how what's the chance of that happening? And I know that's happened to me dozens of times.

Speaker 2So yeah, sometimes they bunch up on you because you know, statistics are on average, and so you're gonna have less odds of miracles coming to your attention while you're sleeping. But sometimes you'll notice the time happens to be eleven eleven, and then you'll notice the time is twelve twelve, and then you'll notice the time is one to eleven or thirteen thirteen, depending on how your clock is set up and so forth, and it just it's weird, But if you live long enough, it becomes inevitable you'll have a

Speaker 2day like that.

Speaker 1Another thing I like to point out about paranormal experience is if there if they are happening, if they're real, they should be happening on some kind of a pattern, or you would expect some kind of a pattern to be happening. You know, if if you did something and it triggered this experience, you should be able to do that thing again to retrigger that experience. And it doesn't seem like it works that way with paranormal things or religious things for that matter. They just seem to like happen there, just seemed like happenstance.

Speaker 5So interesting, like if they were reporting like, well, you just you weren't in the right frame of mind to elicit the response from the spirits or what have you.

Speaker 1Yeah, right, right, well, yeah, right exactly. Oh yeah, well I can almost I can get the spirits normally, but today, you know, something that the car was not right or I'm just not feeling it today, you know, the energy is not working correctly today, you know. So they always have excuses about why it doesn't work when it comes down to them having to make it actually work in front of people, sometimes in front of people who aren't gullible anyway, Right.

Speaker 5And okay.

Speaker 2Another thing to consider is depending on the specific thing, like in this case it's spirits that have been mentioned, going into the history of where these beliefs come from, like the spiritualism movement of the nineteenth century, the Fox Sisters. You know, why do people think this stuff. Where do these ideas come from? And once you start to explain that these aren't ancient ideas that humans have held through all of history, that specific un artists invented them just

Speaker 2one hundred or so years ago closer to two hundred now, but details it becomes less. Oh, I observed something supernatural and my brain jumped to a conclusion based on things I've heard from TikTok or something.

Speaker 5Oh okay, men, the Fox Sisters? Who were they?

Speaker 2Are? You? You know what?

Speaker 1I make notes that talk bring up later And look, I made a note of fox sisters. I know who they were, but I thought it would be cool to go into who they were. So amor you want to talk about the Fox Sisters?

Speaker 2Sure, I so. I normally when I like go in a deep dive direction, I go prepare notes and whatnot. But I know some about them because they lived near me. I lived just up the road from where you kidd discovered the Golden Plates of Mormonism and all the fun, cool spiritual stuff happened nearby me. Basically, they I can't remember exactly what the financial issue was. The farm was in trouble, or daddy died or whatever the case may be,

Speaker 2But suddenly they discovered the younger sister had spiritual powers, and it was just stuff like parlor tricks, you know, like people sounds knocking out of the room and ve vasus wiggling, and chandeliers brightening and dimming and all this sort of stuff. But what was remarkable about them, as opposed to a bunch of the other connartists doing the same grift at the same time, was they could do stuff that was more like a street magician's art. They could go into your home and have a private seance

Speaker 2with you and still make cool stuff happen in your living room, not their parlor where it's pre prepared like modern day psychics, but just walk into your living room and make stuff levitate or something. It was. It was pretty impressive they were getting.

Speaker 1They were doing a lot of knockings on tables and answering questions from the dead, and it turned out that what they had, what they had learned to do and had practiced a lot, was to crack their to and make loud knocking noises, so they were nothing. Nobody was ever knocking on tables. These girls were just cracking their toes underneath the table and imitating the knocking some cut type of knocking. So yeah, they were they were. They were con women basically so, and one of the sisters

Speaker 1came out eventually, at least one of them came out eventually and admitted to that they were cons.

Speaker 2So yeah, that can be an addition or to the grift.

Speaker 5Yeah, as as a veteran who like every joint cracks, at some point, I feel like I've not been taking advantage of the full potential.

Speaker 2Uh is that right.

Speaker 5In my body?

Speaker 2Yeah? I mean it's it's pre wig board stuff. It's it's you know, knock once for yes, knock twice for no. I mean, ghost hunters today still do a similar thing with the partially unscrewed flashlights, right, like this flashlight is for us and this splash light is for no. The difference is they can't actually control those the way a person with the knocking or joint cracking could do.

Speaker 1So I'm thinking in the back of my head they had some kind of backstory too, about a wandering salesman that was murdered on their property that was the one that showed them how to reach the spirits. That this goes to this wandering salesman I'm not I'm not positive about that, but in the back of my head, I'm thinking that was part of the whole Fox Sister story.

Speaker 2So there's a lot to it, for sure. Oh yeah, it's it's fascinating. They became world famous for a little while. Oh yeah, and they made some decent money at it.

Speaker 1They they basically started the whole spiritualist.

Speaker 2Movement popularized it anyway. Yeah, they made it, you know, front page news kind of thing. But the point is that once a person who's into spiritualism learns the history where it came from, why it, why people say the things they do, it kind of loses. Is that that that hines sequa about it, that makes people go, there's something real here, I'm tapping into the powers of the universe. No, it's it's it's just some a scam that people made up several years ago, and and other people still believe

Speaker 2for some reason. That's all.

Speaker 1Hope, Yeah, hope.

Speaker 2In some ways, it's a lot like other religions. You know, a lot of people get invested because they want to believe, motivated reasoning that their lost loved ones are somewhere waiting for them, whether it's Heaven, whether it's the other side of the veil. They get that motivated reasoning and invest emotionally in that concept of comfort. Not only for fear of what will happen to them after death. Am I going to go to heaven? Am I going to go to the other side? Am I just going to face oblivion?

Speaker 2But also for that idea of meeting the lost loved ones again. They want to believe, and they will however they need to.

Speaker 5There was like a whole extra psychological level to a lot of us.

Speaker 1Oh yes, oh yeah, oh yeah, oh yeah, I mean this was I used to believe all this stuff myself up until fifteen twenty years ago. So yeah, I mean I believed that as much as somebody believes in Jesus that there was you know, that there were spirits that did some cosmic energy to float throughout all of the universe that we were all tapped into. You know, I was a damn hippie. I mean, I was just basically hippie psychology, right. But yeah, after I started realizing, I

Speaker 1started becoming more science based and realizing that these things didn't have anything that backing them up. These were just ideas. They were thoughts, and they were wishes and hopes, right, And that's what a lot of it is. It's a lot, a lot of a lot of these ideas in my experience, and I'm not going to say all of them, but quite a bit of them came from people who had gotten them out of organized religions, mostly Christianity, and that's where they turned to because there still looking for some kind of spirituality in their life, right, so they find it in New Age thoughts and spirituality, and spirituality is

Speaker 1very much a religion. In fact, one of our regular hosts are on Truth Wanted, was raised as a spiritualist and from the little child he was, he was taught he was being taught to be convinced that he could talk to the dead.

Speaker 2So that sounds like a certain circle, we know.

Speaker 1Yeah, one of our one of our one of our co hosts here on Truth Wanted, and he'll talk about it. It's it's John John a skeptic because he's talked about it many times in public, So I don't mind mentioning his name with it.

Speaker 2Yeah, the source of all love rings. I realized he gives all all praise to Lisa the Rainbow Geria athlete. Hump Yeah, I mean, the circles come from the circle. That's it's it's a circular argument, but we can't defeat.

Speaker 5It, right, That makes sense. Went and where you were mentioning earlier, the epistemic or epismological side of things, What did you mean by like how to assess their epistemology.

Speaker 2Well, what we've been getting in in that kind of situation is rather than addressing the ontology of it, what the thing is, but more why do you believe this? Like we're not questioning whether the thing you believe is true, it's why do you believe it? And if a person starts to explore that, oftentimes not always, but often, you won't even have to talk them out of whatever it is that may be interfering with the function of their life,

Speaker 2because that's that's what we care about, is the connection to all these other conspiracy theories and how it may be diminishing their ability to live a full and happy life. And instead of just fighting that directly, you say, why do you believe this? Let's examine that, Let's see why you're drawing these connections that you are. People are still rational beings, and once they start to see there's there's broken connections in their logic, they can start to deprogram themselves. We know this because most of the people in these

Speaker 2atheist communities had to deprogram themselves from similarly unhelpful beliefs. That's fair interesting, Yeah, it's it's a longer process, but it might make things easier, and not even so much easier, but more likely to be successful because if a person starts to deconvert from complicated, harm potentially harmful beliefs on their own, then you're the good friend who's there to

Speaker 2support them rather than the jerk who's telling them ghosts aren't real and you're a bad person for thinking. So you know, right, you're.

Speaker 5Telling me calling people dumb doesn't work.

Speaker 1Yeah, right, you know I always say people calling me names and yelling at me never convinced me of anything ever, not once in my life. So it's always better to be nice to somebody and talk to him and get them to come to the understand the point of view than it is to yell at him and call them names. So it depends on what you're trying to do. I mean, if you're trying to make yourself feel better, are you actually trying to change minds? Right?

Speaker 5That's a point. So that's like, take the time to it.

Speaker 1I'm sorry, what was that.

Speaker 5So it's like trying to, you know, just center yourself what you're wanting to get out of the conversation before you even die to it.

Speaker 1Yeah, exactly, exactly. Yeah, why why why did you start the conversation with the You know, they came and they told you about this, So why did you start the conversation with them after they told you the experience they had? And I think, and honestly, I think it's a good idea to to like crush these bad ideas, just like Ember said, we got because if you crush that idea, you're crushing other bad thinking down the lane, right, If you can get somebody to think more critically and more logically. I hate to use the word logically because it's kind

Speaker 1of if he you know, but it's kind of a wooy word. But uh, I've seen some really bad logic. That's why I say that. But if you can convince somebody to think more critically, I think that's a better way of saying it, that you'll prevent them from thinking other bad ideas later. So that that's it's it's sort of like going into the epistemology is almost like getting somebody to examine why they think about things, and then

Speaker 1and and and examining why they think about other things in the future. Right, I mean, they get in a sound basis for predictability. I always talk about predictability as a scientist. A sound basis for for being able to explain what's happening through a physical and empirical way on ambiguous empirical reason for something happening. That's what I want to have, and I think everybody does that, even religious and pure normal people that with those beliefs except for

Speaker 1those things. Right, the person who believes that that believes in UFOs and nothing else. Silly, Right, Well, we'll want empirical, unambiguous evidence for anything else they believe in except UFOs. For some reason, I don't understand that one. It's kind of always kind of freaks me out a little bit.

Speaker 2Double standards, You're got to love them. Hey, if it weren't for double standards, some people would have no standards at all. But you get that slippery slope problem, you know, like once a person is convinced that the Earth is only six thousand years old, and there's a grand conspiracy to hide the truth for some reason. Then they're also primed to believe in any conspiracy that shares that same reason,

Speaker 2depending on who you're talking to and who's doing the sales pitch or whatever. Like say, just for example, we'll take a silly thing. People are lying about the true age of the Earth, and all of geology, all of astronomy, all of biology, all every science is wrong. We're lying about the age of the Earth so that nobody can find out that the Earth is actually hollow and ruled by underground lizard people or something, or crab people. Let's go with crab people, because crabs are tasty and everybody, you know carsonization. Everybody will be a crab someday. It's inevitable.

Speaker 2That's how biology works. So we're hiding the crab people. And once you accept that that the Earth is six thousand years old because you have a magic book that says so, because of the crab people, now every other conspiracy that also involves the crab people must be true because of your circular reasoning insisting as a starting point for your epistemology that the Earth must be six thousand years old, and that creates some huge problems. I mean,

Speaker 2you've already thrown all of science out the window, so's there's zero epistemic barrier to believing any kind of crazy nonsense. And as I think it was Christopher Hitchins who said, if you can convince people to believe absurdities, you can get them to commit atrocities. And that's a big problem.

Speaker 3You know.

Speaker 5Yeah, I've noticed the correlation between like the members of my family starting to believe different like seemingly innocuous like aliens and ghosts and spirits and things like that, and then some like then later years later, there's some they're wrapped up in like Christian nationalism and saying that we're a constitutional republic now that the democratic republic and spouting off that stuff.

Speaker 1Yeah, bad thinking just leads to more bad thinking, you know. That's that's the thing. And I, you know, my son and I were just having a conversation about this, about how experts in some fields will and and what came up was a person that had brought some artifacts to a native artifacts to somebody who was an expert in them, and he didn't And I'm not an expert, but I knew these things weren't real artifacts that this person was just kind of squinting and turning her head sideways and seeing things that in it, you know. And the person, the expert when was looking at these objects, these these objects,

Speaker 1that these artifacts, and and said to the person, well, it could be this, And I'm like, no, don't tell her that, because she's just going to keep believing now that I was right, this is an artifact, and she's going to go keeping looking for more crap like this, right. And I see it all the time with experts, because they don't want to hurt people's feelings, and I think that's wrong. I think I always say I'm a professional bubble burster. I don't mind. I don't mind hurting your feelings if I'm going to be telling you the truth. So believe me, I have to go with the rock shop.

Speaker 1I have to do it all the time. People bring in diamonds and gold all the time, and meteors that aren't a weekly basis. So everybody thinks they're gonna get rich from a rock they found.

Speaker 2So oh for.

Speaker 5Sure, it's always py right, yeah.

Speaker 1Pyrite courts. Yeah, it's never anything that's that's worth anything.

Speaker 2So yeah, I don't even run a rock shop, and I run into that issue. So here in my part of New York State, a few hours away in the other direction, we have a place called Herkimer, and among other things, it's famous for the Herkimer Diamond Mine, which is where they mind Herkimer diamonds, which are not the same as diamonds. They're quartz. They're just quarts that grow in a fun shave, but they call them Herkimer diamond People go to this tourist attraction and they did they

Speaker 2dig these things up for themselves, because that's what it is. It's a dig your own kind of thing, and they find these big honkin crystals and they're like, oh my god, I found a giant Herkimer diamond. It must be worth millions. It's not actually a diamond, bestie.

Speaker 1I have a Herkiber diamond in my hand, right.

Speaker 2Yeah.

Speaker 1I've been the Herkimer. I've actually been there mining crystals. So yeah.

Speaker 2Yeah. So people get confused that the motivated reasoning kicks in. It's a miracle. All my bills are going to be paid from now to eternity or or whatever.

Speaker 5You know, early retirement. Here we come. I managed to get a diamond.

Speaker 2The sad fact is, even if you did find a real diamond, it wouldn't do as much good as people like to think, unless it's something like the Hope Diamond where you can get private collectors directly interested in.

Speaker 1One of the things that like people go out and that they're gonna find a gemstone and make a bunch of money because they found something in the wild, and honestly, like rough gems aren't worth that much money. A lot of a lot of the value goes into turning them into a gemstone, you know, like the cutting and polishing of the stone. So I mean that's like ninety eighty to ninety percent of the value of a gemstone is the work that went into it, not the stone itself. So that's I don't know why I brought that up, but you know, there you go. So it's it's a

Speaker 1it's a bad uh idea that a lot of people have that I'm gonna go find a big garnet out in the wild and I'll be rich. You know, it just doesn't happen. It doesn't work that way.

Speaker 2Yeah, you could, you could find all kinds of In fact, you probably do find all kinds of stuff there's depending on what features are around you. Near me, for example, because long long, long ago, this is a volcanically active region, and we had some ice age stuff, the glaciers moving big old piles of dirt. That's why we have the finger lakes. The glaciers cut things out, so there's a lot of garnets, so you can find you can just scoop up some soil and there's there's just garnets in the soil, you know, but they're they're tiny and and

Speaker 2they're so common. It's just it's just sand and dirt at this point, right.

Speaker 1I found that in Colorado. It's a big chunk of topaz. That's probably the most valuable thing I found in my entire life.

Speaker 2So, yeah, now, fossil hunting for fossil.

Speaker 1Pardon, what was that? You didn't find any topaz?

Speaker 5Yeah, I grew up in Colorado. You find out where the good topaz locations are.

Speaker 1Oh, where was I I'm trying to remember where I was at.

Speaker 5Oh, don't worry, it was much.

Speaker 1It was about it was about thirty miles thirty miles west of Florissance, Okay. And talking about fossils, Flora'sance is famous for fossils.

Speaker 5So yeah, we used to get couitationed in Clarksville, Tennessee at Fort Campbell and that area has a lot of clay with a bunch of like old fossils from there was an ocean there at one point and people would find some coral or like it with an ammonite fossil and they'd be like, I'm gonna be rich. This thing's gonna be sphere. It's so much money. Like, no, they're they're kind of everywhere. Man, I'm sorry.

Speaker 2Yeah, yeah, we do love we do love our fossils. I mean you can always donate them to researchers, universities, grad students like the science people can never get enough fossils, I assure you, even though museums have backlogs that go decades. I have a one of the science friends here on YouTube that you may sometimes see on some of the science channels like guts It Gibbon or Daprey Dinosaur. His name is Doc Dino. Not to be confused with the convicted textavator. It's but he went on a fossil hunt

Speaker 2some years ago and he found some fossils. And the reason he was on the hunt was because he was volunteering in a museum to clean old bones and whatnot, and he came across a bone from like fifty sixty years ago that there was according to the notes, the rest of the fossil was still out there, but they were only just now getting to this bone from fifty sixty years ago, and so he wasn't sure exactly where the bone was or where the rest of the fossil was,

Speaker 2and so he went on an expedition to go find the rest of this this. I guess it was a dinosaur. He would know better than I because that's literally his field. But still so yeah, but neat stuff like that happened. Science happens because of fossil. Don't not to disparage rocks. Rocks are very cool and we get a lot of cool science from them. I just showed the rock. I make my own rocks. This is an artificial sapphire. It was my first try, and I forgot to add color, so it's it's absolutely clear, but it is a sapphire,

Speaker 2which is just aluminum oxide. Really yeah, and there, I mean, I wanted to make like a really really pretty blue because like, h I'm not wearing blue today because it's almost Pride month, so pride stuff. But like people tell me, I look really good in blue. But I wanted to keep this one around because there's that old old adage in a paradox the paradox? Can God make a stone so heavy he can't lift it? Well, we don't even

Speaker 2need to go that far, because I made a stone that so far God hasn't been able to lift. I keep watching it, though.

Speaker 1It's like, oh, right on, yeah, I've got five dollars waiting for Jesus to come and take it to help feed the poor. And it's been sitting there for a year and a half.

Speaker 5And yet the miracles don't happen. I suppose, like the just the odds of a coincidence we were talking about earlier, there's always the chance.

Speaker 1There's always that hope. There's always that because if there's because if that can happen, other good things can happen just to me. Right, Well, there you go, yeah, I mean that's part of that's part of the psychology behind it. If anything can happen, then good things can happen to me. Finally, damn it.

Speaker 2Right, it's a hope. I mean, you can never rule it out and that's that's it's a useful trick for for therapists, for psychologists. I mean, you know this would be Chrissy's expertise, but it's still, yeah, hold out hope. Like there there there are in museums, there are displays of people who are in a duel and the bullets met in mid air, like impossible things. Seemingly impossible things can happen, and so it's it's we don't want to

Speaker 2have false hope. We don't want to expect impossible things to happen, but we can't rule out that they might. So there's always hope any even in a seemingly hopeless situation.

Speaker 1Yes, I might win the lottery.

Speaker 2You might, although it helps if you buy a ticket.

Speaker 5That's probably kind of useful there. Well, I won't. I won't keep you guys any longer. I really appreciate your advice. I take it's notes down. I'm going to definitely look up to Box Sisters and the epistemology around like why we believe things in Littlewood. It means a lot.

Speaker 1In little Wood too, the mathematician little.

Speaker 5Yeah, I'll definitely look that up. I appreciate you guys' time. I'll let you get back to here to what you guys were talking about. Thank you so much for having me on.

Speaker 1Oh, thank you for calling. I really appreciated your call. That was amazing. And thank you for letting to go up on all these weird tangents earn the call, you know, like talking.

Speaker 5About rock of the stuff you guys do. I appreciate that one.

Speaker 2Thank Yeah, it's what we do. I mean literally, people say on my channel that they I go off on tangents and and they say, we come here for the tangents Like that's an emoji I have too, you know, that's a.

Speaker 1That's a product of my add ADHD mind. So oh boy. Somebody says they have hundreds of not thousands of bullets to class in midyear from World War One. That's amazing you actually own those. I mean I I have seen, like I have seen a photograph of one, but I do I've never knew that there were thousands of them. It had to be it had to be pretty uncommon to happen, I would think. But then millions and millions

Speaker 1of bullets. Let's go back to Littlewood's law. You know, millions and millions and bullets are fired, right.

Speaker 2Yeah, I mean machine guns right, like that was a thing I think starting in the Civil War. That's that's not my area of history. But yeah, by World War two, machine guns everywhere, and so yeah, you're gonna run into a few bullets just blooping each other. Blooping what a descriptor for the middle of a war zone.

Speaker 1Sounds like a good adjective to me. That would be a verb. Sorry, and I'm supposed to be an English major.

Speaker 2Yeah, this is the blooping range. I don't know, sometimes things come to me. It's divine inspiration, folks.

Speaker 1So yeah, I know you said you had a few topics you wanted to talk about. What else you got for us?

Speaker 2Oh?

Speaker 1Well, you know what's going on a tangent.

Speaker 2Sure, there's nothing we have to talk about. It's it's just icronically over prepare for stuff. And so I made some notes before we get started. So the top of my note, I noticed that just from Canada, how to rule an Asteroid is in the side chat. She's also been untruth wanted before, and I was talking with her the other day, possibly a week ago what is time anyway, And we were discussing the possibility that aliens had visited Earth, and so I wanted to run this scenario past you

Speaker 2could aliens possibly have visited Earth. The Milky Way galaxy is approximately one hundred thousand light years across in diameter, which means that it's a It's just shy of eight trillion square light years in total area if you imagine it as a disc. Of course, there's a vertical component to it too, but it's pretty thin, so let's call it a disc eight trillion square light years. Life was possible on Earth approximately a billion years ago. We've had

Speaker 2some setbacks though, there have been mass extinctions. So assume an Earth like Earth, because you know you need a well, we number our stars backwards. Our star is a population one star, and the next generation of stars backwards in time is a population two star, and the first ones after the Big Bang, or the population three stars, whatever you suffice it to say, you need a third generation

Speaker 2star like ours to have an Earth like planet because you need all the various elements and whatnot. They get produced in supernovas, like uranium, for example, and all the carbon is helpful too, all this stuff, so we need the supernovas to get an earth like world to get life. So you, our Sun is about four billion years old. If you take a sun like sun, assuming it starts at the same time as early as you can get it, and you get an earth like world around it, and life appears as early as you can get it and onlike our Earth, they don't have to deal with mass

Speaker 2extinctions every few million years. They just go directly to intelligent species with space ships as fast as biologically possible. In fact, let's say they just appear that way poofed into being already capable of light speed travel. They just they just have the technology. They still have to search eight trillion light years of space every year for a billion years. They have to check eight square light years,

Speaker 2and that's space is mostly empty. But that's no sneeze.

Speaker 3You know.

Speaker 2For example, around our sun fairly rural patch of sky, there's still five stellar systems within eight light years, and this is fairly rural. There's our Solar System, there's Alpha Centauri, there's Barnard Star, there's the Wise System, and there's Wolf three five nine. And you can't just peek through telescope from the next system over. You know, back when we lost launch the Voyager probes, Carl Sagan suggested that we turn the probe around and look at Earth and see if we could detect intelligent life on Earth, the one

Speaker 2planet where we knew we should be able to find it. Because if we couldn't determine a positive result for Earth, a planet with a known value, how could we possibly find it anywhere else. So you need to have a certain level of sufficiently advanced technology, and you have to be looking for the technology that you're trying to detect. You can't just look at a planet and be like, oh, well, I see lights or something, you know, like you have to get really close for those, by the way, because as we also found out later on from NASA, when

Speaker 2you get outwards, you know, somewhere around the orbit of Saturn, you turn around, you look back, and it's a pixel. Earth is a pixel. You can't make out city lights from that distance. Even if we took the Hubble Space telescope out to the order orbit of Saturn and looked back at Earth, it would still just be a few pixels. It's space is very big. You can't tell from a long ways. Right now, you may be thinking, what about all our radio noise? We're very loud here on this planet. Our TV broadcasts and all this stuff. Somewhere out in

Speaker 2the cosmos, aliens are watching just now receiving the nineteen thirty six Olympics. But because of signal attenuation, we have a really hard time communicating with those same voyager probes, which are barely at the edge of our own solar system right now, a few light years out, all of our noise fades to a whisper. So visually we're limited a radio, we're limited. And additionally, we take this hypothetical light speed traveling civilization that poofed into being at the

Speaker 2very first instant they possibly could. Even if they came across Earth, if they came here more than twelve thousand years ago, humans would look a lot like any other mammal, Like, what would they be looking for. We'd have no technology, we had no farming, we barely had fire. There's no radio towers, there's no big telescopes. So now we're not just looking over the course of the past billion years. We need these aliens to drop by within the last twelve thousand years, and the amount of space you have

Speaker 2to cover in that amount of time, it's not impossible. The Drake equation makes it clear that life existing somewhere else is probable. You know, We've been finding all through space on comets and asteroids like crazy, all the nucleotides, so many amino acids and sugars and all these things. It seems like the universe is fine tuned, if you will, for life to spontaneously pop up everywhere it can virtually immediately. But finding each other that's gonna take a minute. So,

Speaker 2given all that background, what are your thoughts, Kelly on the possibility, the mathematical possibility that aliens may have visited our planet.

Speaker 1I you know, I don't think they have. I'll be honest with you. I really, honestly don't think they have. I see all this stuff, like from the ancient Aliens, things on the History Channel. I usually have a thing I usually say to History Channel. I'm not going to do it. I was about to though, where the truth is history?

Speaker 2Oh no, you're not wrong, though, my.

Speaker 1Good I know, right, So, but I you know, I see that, and I look at the dubious evidence that they present, and it just doesn't convince me at all. And I don't think I've ever seen anything at all. And I'm gonna say this, I'm gonna admit to this. Back in nineteen seventy five, sixteen years old, and my mother gave me Chariots of the Gods to read, and I totally believed it. So this was all part of things that I was convinced we're reality at one time.

Speaker 1But I you know, looking at even all the evidence that Bondanak can presented it just when you really look at it and examine it and research it, none of it holds up. None of it does. So I'm not convinced that all of aliens have been here.

Speaker 2Like I said, we can't rule it out, but mathematically it seems improbable, at least for organics. Now, if we want to change the equation a little bit, if we want to start with say one probe and give it the ability to reproduce itself, because like you know, biological stuff can reproduce as it moves through space, but you need a ship to be on right, so it's not like it'll just spread out on its own. But a probe a machine that has the ability to make more

Speaker 2copies of itself using the materials that it finds lying around that that could it can go to the next solar system over and build a bunch of copies, and then they can all go to different solar systems. And then they can all go to different solar systems, and you're still limited by the speed of light, but you can cover ground exponentially, and eventually you'll end up with these machines in every possible solar system, checking every possible planet.

Speaker 2Now I have to wonder what might such a machine look like, because you'd want to make it simple. You'd want to make it something microscopic, because that way it doesn't require much energy to accelerate. You can get it up to high speeds very small, so there's a very tiny chance of it hitting something and being destroyed as it moves through interstellar space across the galaxy. So maybe you'd make it just a single chemical, a single chemical

Speaker 2with the ability to reproduce wherever it lands. I wonder what such a chemical might look like, and maybe we'd find it on you know, asteroids and things. Hmmm. Now, I'm not suggesting that that RNA is an interstellar pro machine. It's just a fun idea.

Speaker 1It is a fun idea. Yeah, it is something I never thought of before. That that is a fun idea. Out it really is yeah, I don't. Do you mind if we bring up our backup post.

Speaker 2Sure nobody should be stuck in the kellyhole all show?

Speaker 1Yeah, right, let's bring up Usually I'm the one that's stuck back in the cake. But there he is. There's Jamie the Blind Lney. Hi, Jamie, how are you hello there? Well? I don't thought we'd bring you up and say have you converse with us, just like you did with me last show.

Speaker 3M a couple of things in my mind. One thing I knew there would be gathering gathering children. Listen, listen closely. Do you hear that? That's the sound of every coincidence, every happenstance, every prayer not being answered right now, because every second that passes by is a second that something miraculous could happen and isn't. And the other thing like, because you know you're talking about them, has alien life

Speaker 3or have extraterrestrials visited Earth? And of course my first though is, oh, for me, paradox of the Drake equation? But that's not quite the case. It's not that does it exist out there somewhere? Has it come and said hello? And it's the thought that came into my head. The parallel was like even on this planet, even the Earth is so big, it'd be like saying, oh, yes, you could find your soulmate, your perfect partner, the one who would be the perfect person to be with you forever. Unfortunately,

Speaker 3my perfect person's name was Jimbay and heally in sixteenth century Japan and has been dead for four hundred years. Oops, sorry about that timing. So yeah, it's all about the time. It's about the timing and the position. And it's like even on a planetary scale, like having the all of these confluencing things that have to come together to make it happen. It's just so astronomically improbable. Though still again

Speaker 3I was I was lamenting about this on the last show. To remain properly skeptical and to remain properly honest in my thinking and epistemology, I must leave a gap that anything is possible in some way unless it has been proven to be actually factually impossible. I must leave a gap for it. And that's where people go, oh, oh, so so God could be real. Then I'm like, I mean, technically yes, but no, And and it does annoy me

Speaker 3that people out there will take those tiny gaps where you have to admit that you can't say for certain that certain things haven't happened or didn't exist or don't exist, and then just say, well, then then then it has then No, that's that's not how thought works. And that's my major frustration with this whole thing.

Speaker 2It's valid, because it's totally valid, we get, oh my goodness, there's so many applications for that kind of poor epistemology. You can't prove it didn't happen. We run into it all the time with all sorts of stuff. Now people understand that, like in a criminal courtroom kind of situation, you have you have the burden of proof and you have to demonstrate beyond a reasonable doubt, but they don't practice that in their everyday lives. It doesn't So many people are like, well, this person said so great, can

Speaker 2you demonstrate the thing they said holds up? Because right now you've just got a claim and I don't have a reason to believe that person. You know, it's just and unfortunately it permeates so much of culture. For example, in the sciences, like we were talking about earlier, it isn't just conspiracy theory. People who think electro and microscopes are for losers. It's people who get emotionally invested in their preferred model of how the universe should work. And

Speaker 2if you point out a problem anywhere in the model, well, the fact you can demonstrate there's an issue should be ignored because they're invested in the model and the model has to be protected. Now, as you know, our friend in yours Forest Velki often says, every model is wrong, but some of them are useful. Starting with the presumption that you are wrong is how you science. And when you can demonstrate how you're wrong, cool, you've learned something new,

Speaker 2You've advanced our knowledge. But people get so invested in these ideas of no, it must be this way for emotional reasons. It's the same sort of thinking we see with the creationists. If you can't explain how humans evolve placentas you personally can't explain that, then that means all the baggage the earth is six thousand years old. There was a literal Adam and Eve created out of dust and a rib, respectively, and there was a serpent and an apple, and all of it worldwide flood. The whole

Speaker 2shebang are entailed by the fact that you personally can't explain how humans and other mammals developed placentas through natural selection a billion years ago, or whatever the case may be. It's it's wild the degree of the uneven burden of proof here, you know, but people will do it, even real scientists do it.

Speaker 3Is a question. I always let's ask people when they're coming at me with a thought or a theory or a belief that isn't entirely substantiated, or they hold very close but they're not having a good time convincing me of its truth, and I will ask them, do you want this to be true? Do you want there to be a god? Do you want there to be an afterlife? Do you want the world to be six thousand years old? I'm not even asking them why they would want that, but just is that a desire of theirs? And if

Speaker 3they say yes, I'm like, then you're going about it wrong because I don't want anything to be true. I accept that which is true, whether I want it to be true or not. And I do not beg of the question. Because if you want a particular outcome and then you're going to try and find evidence for that outcome, that's begging the question. That's putting the cart before the horse. And that's the thing. I would urge everybody out there, if there is something you believe because you want to

Speaker 3be true, question that, question your motivation as to why you want it to be true, and take your ego out of it. It is either true or it isn't. Your wishes matter not.

Speaker 2But but if if if we clap really hard and believe with all our hearts, can can we can we make? Can we make the thing? What? Okay? What about? What about the other direction? Quantum physics?

Speaker 3Right, use the word around me, young lady, otherwise we'll have problems.

Speaker 2We're gonna we're gonna throw down.

Speaker 1That said, if you think you understand quantum physics, you don't understand quantum physics.

Speaker 2The only person I'm not sure, friend of.

Speaker 3The show, Dr Blitz, who is an actual physicist. He goes, yeah, that if you think you know, you don't know. No, it's all very strange and I barely understand it myself, and I'll be trained in it. I'm like, yeah, see if anyone else who quantum moved anything, anyone wh says the word quantum just unless you have multiple PhDs you can just fuck it right off, Thank you very much. You don't know what you're talking about.

Speaker 2But Deepek Chopras said.

Speaker 3Depact my choperas. Fuck you.

Speaker 1You were so right and right on about that. Jamie though about wanting to believe in something, because when I was all wrapped up in Newidge ideas. You know, I always say new ways is one word Newidge, so at rhymes with sewage. But when I was wrapped up in that, it was stuff I wanted to believe. I wanted to believe that all these crystals had powers, right, I wanted I still want to believe that. I don't believe it. I don't think it's possible, but I wanted to happen. I think it would be so incredible that if these things had healing powers, how awesome that would be for humanity. Unfortunately,

Speaker 1it just doesn't work that way. I wish it did, but it just doesn't.

Speaker 3That level of introspection is something that we can engeneer. And this is again why we do these shows. I'm not going to try and tell you, O believer in whatever your beliefs are wrong. I could do that until I'm blue in the face and have that in the past. But what I will do instead is have a conversation with you and try, just try, at the very least, to have you think more about why you believe what you believe, and can you actually back it up and engender some critical thinking. If you can think critically, you'll come to the correct conclusions eventually. I hope.

Speaker 1That's what I think. Partner to teach people how to think more critically. That's why I think it is so important.

Speaker 2Right right, As I often say when dealing with stuff like Young Earth creation and other weird conspiracy theories, whether you believe the Earth is six thousand years old or not, for good reason or bad, it doesn't really affect everybody's material life on a day to day basis. It doesn't really affect anything in and of itself. But once you disable your critical thinking, once you manually turn off your brain's ability to sort fantasy from fact, you're now vulnerable

Speaker 2to all manner of manipulations. Because you can't you don't have a functioning basis for determining what's true and what's false. It's all based on what you wish were the case, and you put yourself in some very bad places. It potentially hurt people around you that way.

Speaker 3No one is I mean to rational thinking, and there is no minimum safe dose of bullshit. Anyway, Thanks for having me up again. Good conversation was had with the caller earlier when some wealth tangents. Uh, I'm here for the tangents, and we's here for the co signs and the signs as well. That's a math joke.

Speaker 2But any if you believe in sin, you mean.

Speaker 3I believe in I believe in cause over time.

Speaker 1Nerd, I think I've seen Jamie Sin.

Speaker 2Oh oh yeah, oh yeah, I think he's seen me. Do so.

Speaker 3We've definitely seen each other sin. But I'm so cute. You just can't blame me.

Speaker 1I'm I'm just old.

Speaker 3Yeah, we're we're all very old.

Speaker 2Speak for yourself.

Speaker 1Yeah right, yeah, I am, though, I really am. I'm not positive, but I think I might be the oldest host at the A c A.

Speaker 2I'm the one with the cane.

Speaker 1I have a.

Speaker 3Collection of them, I do. I really we're on the race to the bottom here. People like, don't get too comfortable with us all hosting these shows and stuff. We won't be here forever. We're all like that far away from kegling over anyway.

Speaker 2Well, you know, one of the neat things about the ACA, just as a for example, the Internet more broadly, but the ACA in particular, is that a lot of this stuff it exists outside of time, you might say, because while it's created in the moment, while it is brought to you live, while we're here, you know, people can call in and talk to us. We can the people in the live chat are interacting right now. This moment will be captured for as far into eternity as humans

Speaker 2have the ability and want to. Because one of the reasons so many of us are here is because these ACA shows they go back decades, back to public broadcast TV whatever the heck it's called, you know, television. Who remembered next you're going to pull up a corded telephone member, my goodness, telegraphs even but there were shows back then, and those are still archived on the ACAS channels. And sure,

Speaker 2YouTube isn't going to last forever the same way public access probably didn't last forever. Maybe it's still around, who knows, But as long as there's people who care that media, those moments, those discussions, those discoveries, all of it, it will continue to be archived on the next thing. It will still be findable, it will still be searchable as long as the organization exists, because that's part of what we all do here, is try to put ideas out

Speaker 2there so that they might help people. And that's one of the reasons that the diversity of hosts, the diversity of people on the internet, broadly, in our communities, in our personal lives matters so much because you never know what weird idea or what concept, what connection is going to get through to somebody. A hundred people might try to deconvert a hardcore Young earthor but then it's one person who comes along and talks to them about aliens and they go, oh, this is all nonsense. I'm afree.

Speaker 2You never know what it's going to be, and we need as many voices and as many brains ideating as we can get, and organizations like this help make that happen by bringing people together. And that's a pretty cool thing too.

Speaker 1Now, Yeah, community is so important, just like you were talking about earlier when I mentioned that where I met you about going out and meeting people and doing things like that. That's that is It's so important. It really is, It really is, and man, you know you say that, And I was thinking, like, one hundred years up the road, I can't imagine somebody watching me and thinking, well, look I was cool. I just can't imagine that. But I would hope one hundred years from now everybody would think the same way I do, at least about you know,

Speaker 1like bad bad thinking, not about anything else, just about bad thinking. You know, they're trying to look at it more critically and stuff. So hopefully, like religion and paranormal ideas would just die off after a while. I think we'd be better off, and humanity would be better off if it did, if we got rid of bad thinking.

Speaker 3It is important people have a more advanced thought pattern. When hundred years down I thought about time in a linear fashion.

Speaker 2Trouble es an, But we're getting near the end here.

Speaker 1One of the things I didn't do and I should have what should always be done, is I want to thank the crew. The crew are freaking awesome. They're the ones who do the actual magic here. I just come and show up and talk, and I haven't even been doing that very well today. So I would like to see if we can get the crew cam up there they are and what awesome people they are. And you know, if you want to be part of the crew, and who wouldn't want to be part of the crew. Let's face it, if you want to be one of those awesome, attractive crew members, be a guest on one of the shows, or eventually even become a host, We're always looking for

Speaker 1people interested in being a part of the productions. So email volunteer at Atheist Hyphencommunity dot org to get involved. And that's what you know, the more people that get involved in this program and other programs to make people think better, just as we were just saying, it's going to be nothing but better for humanity in the long run.

Speaker 2So you might say it'd be better than Ember.

Speaker 1It would be better than Ember. You might say that. And you know, speaking of that, where would people you know, that's your channel name, we're people would find from here on YouTube? How often do you do you publish? I happen to know, but I'm gonna I'm gonna make you say something.

Speaker 2Well, it's it's it's difficult. So I used to do a daily morning show and every weekday at eleven am Eastern, but I had to give it up because my health has been getting bad.

Speaker 1I'm sorry.

Speaker 2Sorry, So it's understand when I can. I usually do at least one live show a week and recorded videos as possible, but sometimes more often. And I'll also I show up here and there, as you know, people ask me to come join their channel to talk about you know, intersect stuff or genetics or or physics or one of my other specialties. And so I'm here and there. But as far as my own channel, it's when I can

Speaker 2at the moment, and hopefully my health will get better. I I don't know.

Speaker 1And again, yeah, it's better than Ember the channel name, so everybody can check it out. I mean, obviously, if you have never seen Umber before, you've just seen her here for the first time, you've seen how awesome she is, go check her out. I totally encourage you to do so. One of the things we always ask our guests to do at the end of the show, Umber is give us some words of wisdom. Do you have any words of wisdom for us?

Speaker 2I do. I was actually ready for this part, and so I depending on how the show went, I had two possibilities set aside, but I'm going to go with option one, which is in the words of Ee Cummings. The bravest thing you can be is yourself.

Speaker 1That's awesome. That's awesome. What about you, Jamie? You want to contribute some words of wisdom.

Speaker 3Of all the things I've lost in life, I miss my mind the most. All right, osi osbit.

Speaker 1And remember, I just want to thank everybody tuning it into our new time. I want to thank Ember for being just an amazing guest today. Thank you Jamie for doing the backup and stepping up for me at the last minute so I could do something else on a social level. And I want to end with this everyone, everyone, always, always keep wanting the truth. Watch Talk Even live Sunday's

Speaker 1at one pm Central.

Speaker 3Visit tiny dot c c slash y t t H and call into the show at five one two nine nine one nine two four two, or connect to the show online at tiny dot c c slash call th H

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Truth Wanted 9.46 with ObjectivelyDan and Out Of Body Atheist

    Nov 16, 20261 hr 31 minAudio

    In today's episode of Truth Wanted, ObjectivelyDan welcomes guest Out Of Body Atheist, with The Beard of Empathy on backup, to dig into Reiki, New Age spirituality, homeopathy, and the long road from woo to skepticism!...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Truth Wanted 9.45 with Jon The Skeptick and Volcy

    Nov 9, 20261 hr 23 minAudio

    In today's episode of Truth Wanted, Jon the Skeptick, Volcy, and Sofia Spina explain why no one can talk to the dead, from Haitian Vodou and grief dreams to Jon's past as a spiritualist! Bob jumps from objective...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Truth Wanted 9.44 with ObjectivelyDan and Nintendrew

    Nov 2, 20261 hr 29 minAudio

    In today's episode of Truth Wanted, ObjectivelyDan and Nintendrew, later joined by The Beard of Empathy, tackle a world run on Jesus, the magic of manifesting, and a prayer that actually got answered! Bob in NY, a...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Truth Wanted 9.43 with ObjectivelyDan and Kelley Laughlin

    Oct 26, 20261 hr 28 minAudio

    In today's episode of Truth Wanted, ObjectivelyDan, Kelley Laughlin, and The Beard of Empathy tackle standards of evidence, miracle claims, and the false binaries of moral philosophy! Dean in VA questions why skeptics...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Truth Wanted 9.41 with ObjectivelyDan and Chad Harris

    Oct 12, 20261 hr 32 minAudio

    In today's episode of Truth Wanted, ObjectivelyDan and Chad Harris tackle Christian nationalism, police brutality, and the uncomfortable truths about racism and immigration. Big E in TN survived police brutality and...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode