Show notes will be posted upon receipt. Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/truth-wanted--3195473/support.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Speaker 1Hey, everybody, Welcome to Truth Wanted, the show where beliefs get questions, claims get challenged, and the truth is what we're after no matter where it leads. I'm your host, objectively Dan, and this is the place where we take your calls, hear your stories, and dig deep into what you believe and why. And get ready because the show is starting right now. Hello, everybody, welcome back to another episode of Truth Wanted. I am your host again, objectively Dan. Again. This is the live call in show that happens every
Speaker 1single week Fridays at seven pm Central Time, where we talk to people about what they believe and why. And if you'd like to call us, you should do that right now because we have open lines. The number is five P one two nine nine four two, or you can call through your computer a tiny dot cc slash call tw and has always Truth Wanted is a product of the Atheist Community of Austin, a five to one C three nonprofit organization dedicades to the promotion of atheism, critical thinking, secular humanism, and the separation of religion and government. In every single week, I always have a special guest
Speaker 1with me. This week is no different. It is Cynthia McDonald folks back again on the show, Cynthia, how are you?
Speaker 2I'm well, objectively Dan, how are you?
Speaker 1I'm good. You were questioning that Tyler earlier saying you're like, I don't know if you're objectively Dan anymore?
Speaker 2Are you?
Speaker 1I think you're subjectively Dan, which is like, I think you're maybe the one hundredth person in my life that's made that joke. But that's okay because you're Cynthia McDonald's, so that's it's all right. But welcome back. How have you been? What's up with you?
Speaker 2Oh my goodness, Well I have been a busy person. I just started a new job.
Speaker 3Still doing the whole mommy thing. Yeah, and yeah, that's goings. That's going, it's going, I tell you. He a matter of fact, my my little one is going through a mini graduation.
Speaker 2It's going to get like a cap. I don't know about a gown.
Speaker 3But he's also going to get a little little certificate that says I graduated from preschool.
Speaker 4Nice.
Speaker 1Yeah I didn't get a cap, you know, I graduate from preschool. Yeah. I guess that's a new a new thing they're doing. Well, that's great. Good for him.
Speaker 2You know the finishers medal, I suppose, but yeah.
Speaker 1I mean, hey, you know it's it's it's worth celebrating. I guess you know, I'm not against it.
Speaker 2I got a bunch of finishing medals. I was addicted to them at one time, so I'm really okay with that as well.
Speaker 1I got I got literal participation trophies when I was dude soccer growing up, So so fun thing you fucked about me because I'm a giant monster person, right, And so my parents I think they they wanted to utilize that and thought that I was going to be a talented athlete. I did not end up being the case. But but when I was in elementary school, they put a bunch of different sports and uh, when I I remember getting the participation trophy because like, I don't think our team ever said anything good. Remember my dad like actually going on a rant about participation trophies and stuff
Speaker 1like that. That's that's a that's a great early memory of mine. So there you go. I tells you a little bit about my upbringing. But it you know, it is what it is, folks. Every week we are asking you guys a question or a prompt. Uh, and we want to talk about what we asked you last week on the segment We want the Truth, and to do that, we're going to bring Kelly onto the stage with us to talk about that. Kelly, what's up, hi?
Speaker 5How you doing that?
Speaker 1Doing good? Doing good? Did you get participation trophies or you know, probably for that? Yeah, yeah, probably just like they like, here, we'll throw you outside and if you get hit by a car, that's on you.
Speaker 6Right exactly, literally literal for you, right right, Hey, You're probably just like, hey, I'm going to go hiking with my friends at this dumpster for a weekend, and they're probably like, cool, see you be a time in school on.
Speaker 1Monday, right exactly, pretty.
Speaker 5Much pretty much. Yeah, our parents just let us do anything back in the day. The things that I actually as I got older, I was like in my thirties and I told my mom there's some of the ship I did as a child. She was totally floored by some of it. So but then I found out she was a big amiss after she died, So oh yeah.
Speaker 1That okay, Well all right, all right, Kelly, So you're just going to drop that on that show, and then you're just gonna let us I know we've talked about it before, but I don't know if that's public knowledge. I think you just dropped that first.
Speaker 2Absolutely, it absolutely is not, because Kelly and I have worked with each other for a very long time, and this is the first time I've ever hearing about this.
Speaker 1I remember you talking about this a couple of years ago, but I don't think you've ever talked about on the show. Do you I get to tell this story now, because now I feel like you have to.
Speaker 5Tell Okay, I will tell the story, Okay, Okay. When after my mother died, my mother and my father split up when I was very young. I was about a year and a half, and apparently she married somebody else, but she never divorced my father. And we were going we were going through her papers, and my sister pulled up the some Oh, here's your papers from when mom divorced her father and she starts reading them and I have a son that's seven and a half years old, and I was like, no, I was only a year and a half. That's wrong. And she looked at the day and she's like, no, you were seven and a
Speaker 5half according to the state. And she had already been married to my stepfather for five years at that point, so man and we had the marriage license for that marriage right with us with the whole stack.
Speaker 1That's a whole ass Reddit post.
Speaker 5She was the bigness for five years that we didn't know about until after she died.
Speaker 1Dang, that's like, that's am I the asshole for finding out my mom's five years. That's the kind of shit you read about, don't mind, Kelly, that's crazy.
Speaker 5We found out is she married my father in Mexico and she actually lied about her age. She was too young to get married.
Speaker 1Oh okay, right now, Yeah, this is crazy. I realized it was Judy, what's going on? What are we doing?
Speaker 7Well?
Speaker 5Now you know I come from a online of rubbles, you know why I am.
Speaker 1Oh my gosh, Oh we're about to talk about reality calling the show that's your family and they're gonna want to talk to you and argue with you on there. That's gonna be crazy. Kelly and I just sit here like we should get back to the probably good for views though, honestly, maybe we should encourage that. You know, you related to Kelly and you believe what he's saying.
Speaker 1He's actually correct, you know, give us a call. The lines are open anyway. On that note.
Speaker 5Last, right, so we should get back to the show.
Speaker 1Get back to the show. That's okay, that's okay.
Speaker 2Let's find to find aeg for that one.
Speaker 1Right, right.
Speaker 5So last week we asked you what do inner circle atheists not want you to know? Apparently that my mother was a big amis then you're our our favorite answers number three from know what they don't want you to the atheist inner circle doesn't want you to know that looking at the trees totally convinced them, which is a.
Speaker 1Good that's such a good one, Like can you imagine if one of us, like hang, I would like a tell all was like, and you know what it was that brought me back to Christ? It was ray comforty those trees. I felt something in my heart like, I don't know how funny would that be?
Speaker 2I literally was Saturday, I was, yeah, yeah, Sturday it was. And then the eye thing, the eye thing as well, yeah.
Speaker 1Oh yeah, the greatness of the eye and all that. Yeah.
Speaker 2Oh yeah, right, I said, why do I wear glasses?
Speaker 1That's funny?
Speaker 5Number two from Shrewsbury Brewery one eighty three. That was a hard for me to say they don't want you to know that John from Canada has actually been a paid chill from Big Atheist all this time.
Speaker 1Can you imagine if if we did that, if like we created John. It has been accused before that John from Canada is a character. I'm gonna be on the record and say that if he is a character, he's not from us. I'll tell you that that he's his own thing. So is a bit of a character? Yeah, yeah, I mean he is a bit of a character, that's true. But like, is he a bit though?
Speaker 4Is he?
Speaker 1Is he a Are we doing it for laughs? No, I'll put that on the record that he is not is not a fake caller. But anyway, as far as I know, I'll say that.
Speaker 3Much as far as I know, he's not either could be about I think John from Canada is a bot.
Speaker 5From Canada, man, I really, I always have. I think I think he's all right. Number one though from Chuck Gatos, the Atheist Dinner Circle doesn't want it known that the huge distances between ours is actually proof of the God, that the God of the gaps exists, right, I.
Speaker 1Like that a lot. Well, thank you for giving us those great, great answers this week and for your tell all family drama some more you know, but tell us some more stuff next week. What you're gonna figure out your ancestors were I don't know, part of some crazy cult or something like.
Speaker 5I actually have something for you on that one.
Speaker 1You can't, Kelly, hold on.
Speaker 5Till next week.
Speaker 2Holds of that one. Please, I'm not gonna.
Speaker 5Be hosting were to be here next week.
Speaker 1I'll tell you you I'll have to tell that story without me. I guess we'll see.
Speaker 5I'll tell you right now. True short, my father's uncle was Harry Laughlin. You can you can go. He's got his own wiki page. Hitler really liked his ideas, So.
Speaker 1Kelly, don't no, I don't tell me that.
Speaker 5No, it's one of the it's one of the It's actually one of the reasons why I've been an activist all my life. I kind of felt guilty and wanted to make up for some of the pet ship my face.
Speaker 1Sins, the sins of the uncle. Is that what's happening right now? Trying to make up for Kelly? Come on, man, I feel like.
Speaker 5A psychological need. It's just you know, it's gotta be you gotta bounce things out, you know what I mean.
Speaker 2I just looked that name up and the first few captions is jaw dropping. Yeah, I say, just just just google the name, and my god.
Speaker 5Yeah he's not He was not a nice person.
Speaker 8Oh no, yeah, okay, when the when the wiki info bar has eugenics, yeah on the side, it's not going to be a good article, no.
Speaker 1Kelly, No, God.
Speaker 2Goodness, it starts off all nice. He was an American educator and a eugenicist.
Speaker 1Yeah, okay, I'm gonna sell you this right now. You're doing a much better job as a human being than your uncle. I don't even know your uncle. I just I just I've seen enough. He was.
Speaker 5He was my father's uncle. I never met the guy, fortunately, but.
Speaker 1Yeah, it's good yea. Oh geez. Okay, well all right, God for that, you successfully derailed this thing two times now, so I'll let you put it back on the rails again and tell us what is the question of the week this week?
Speaker 5For next week? We want you to tell us what can you say to your psychic but not to your spouse Cynthia? Do you have an idea?
Speaker 1Oh my god, I would say, hey, you can tumpet, your uncle of my supremacist maybe and maybe not maybe not your spouse. I don't know.
Speaker 3I I could tell my spouse my psychic. Can you guess what the past is about my father's uncle?
Speaker 1What's my mother a big amiss?
Speaker 2What's my uncle genesis?
Speaker 1Yeah? What's my directly a genesis? What other five dollars words can we come up with for Kelly's family members? I mean, what how far does this tree go?
Speaker 2I know, I like, yeah, like you know, like, how did do we go to the rabbit hole?
Speaker 1Yeah?
Speaker 5I dig up something else that we really tried a.
Speaker 1New recurring bit where it's just a new lore about Kelly's family everywhere.
Speaker 2Yes, I know by Kelly laugh.
Speaker 5She's done a lot of digging into our family. So I see, I see what else the skeletons I can dig up from her?
Speaker 1Well, dear Kellys skeletons, you know that's what call it. It'll be great.
Speaker 5So for that, Dan, what can you say to your psychic but not your spouse?
Speaker 1Oh? I mean, uh say your psyched out of your spouse. I actually wasn't prepared for this bit. I like the idea of asking you about your family treat though, like, hey, which which which member of my family was possibly a Nazi? And if you get it right, if you can guess great uncle, then you might have incredibility.
Speaker 2Right, exactly exactly. I was wanting to say something like totally benign, like is this your card and like you know, pull up like hearts or something like that.
Speaker 1That's true. I thinks of a number between one and the thousand, right, real simple stuff. I have a really bad answer. Okay, what's your answer? Kelly?
Speaker 5You're right?
Speaker 1What are you in your right? Wait?
Speaker 5One, that's something you can say to your psychicpouse.
Speaker 1You're right? All right? Well, all right, well this has been answer. We want the true segments in a while. Thank you Kelly for that, Thank you, thank you, appreciate you. We'll play go ahead and get you back to the backstage. Uh man, how do you segue from that? Goddamn? I don't know.
Speaker 2Is this your card?
Speaker 1Oh?
Speaker 2No?
Speaker 1Man, Well, welcome back to truth wanted I know in a minute. Since you've been on man, so there's just been a lot of things happening in the news, and I feel like we keep saying that every single week, especially on this show, and you have been on a show with part of the ACA that talks about the news, so it is relevant to you and you still keep up with the news. One of the things we were talking about we can't I think more talk about this was the Johnson Amendment, because we didn't talk about this as much last week, but it did happen sort of
Speaker 1last week where the I R. S Is refusing to I think prosecute uh, you know, churches that are endorsing candidates, which since the Johnson Amendment, which is amendment that was uh basically I think it was executive order right, pleasured by Lenda B. Johnson. It was an executive order. It was it was the proposal he made. We're saying, hey, actually, you know, you can't do that, right, And it turns out the church is like maybe the sixth you know, branch of government here we got going on. I don't know,
Speaker 1there's but they tend to have a lot of sway in America. They do they and it seems like a lot of people are okay with that, which is bothersome. I don't know. Obviously you have some thoughts on that. I imagine, well, I.
Speaker 3Do objectively subjectively, Dan, I I I actually was listening to another podcast today when they were talking about it, and the I R s just came out with that story concerning the Johnson Amendment. But the crazy thing about it is that they only will not prosecute religious institutions, right.
Speaker 1That was that was my takeaway from reading about it too, was its specifically the exemption is for religious organizations and not nonprofits. Yes, aka US, So the rules for THEE not for me, right, sort of classic thing there.
Speaker 2Yeah, yeah, that's that's that's wild.
Speaker 3At first, Like when they were reading it, I was going to say, oh, so this means that all five O one C threes.
Speaker 2Including the ACA can endorse candidates, right, And it was like no.
Speaker 1But like, at the same time, I kind of don't want to have a political discussions with the AJA hosts on air. I feel like that's a recipe for disaster because we're all very opinionated people we are, and that would be messy, but also it would be really funny. It's worked out as a good rule for us. I'm kind of glad that we have the rule in a way because I want everybody. I want to live in a world where everybody's following the rule. Obviously that's not the case and hasn't been the case for a while. And I guess the RS is just like screw it, We're just kind of we're not even gonna We're not
Speaker 1even gonna follow through with it.
Speaker 3So I mean to just think about it, Dan, there's so many since so many institutions do it anyway, right, the churches that do it right, And and I think that it's I think that we know that the I R S and of itself is like badly understaffed, right, It's like badly understaffed, so they wouldn't even have the capacity to even pull up bring up charges in the first place. And I think that you can like count
Speaker 3on one hand how many churches have been prosecuted via the Johnson Amendment since it's been like enacted.
Speaker 1Yeah, you'd have to you have to be like, well, like a really really bad church. And that's not even saying that bad jurches like get away with it. They definitely do. It's just like I agree, like from the publicly for the ones I know about, at least, it's very small, like it's it's not a lot of organizations, right, And.
Speaker 3Even though like you do have like some of the churches that actually believe in the Johnson Amendment, and they follow the Johnson Amendment, and they wish that their other compatriots would do the same, but it seems like they're in the minority at this time.
Speaker 1Yeah, I agree with you there, And so, like one are the merits of this. On the one hand, we have this idea of free speech in this country, right, and we like to think that it applies universally to everywhere in every situation. It doesn't, but we like to think that it does. And one of those situations we'd like to think it the wise too, is churches. There are countries that completely banned churches, completely banned some that kind of freedom of worship and stuff, and there's an interesting debate about that. And so it's kind of interesting that not only do we allow it, we wanted to flourish ostensibly right Americans tend to be really good with that,
Speaker 1but like, we don't want to affect politics somehow, even though it's pretty much always been the case that your religious views are probably going to inform your political views, right, Like they kind of seem hand in hand together. I think it'd be weird if you're religious views didn't inform your politics.
Speaker 2In some way, right, I mean I agree with that. I remember specifically when I was like a card carrying Christian, and that was my identity. Like everything that I did, how I thought, what informed my behavior, and what even told me what decisions that I should make or not, what I should go left or right, was really based on my belief, my faith. Sure, it wasn't until I
Speaker 2came on this side of the secular aisle that my identity is not even wrapped. It's not completely wrapped up with my non belief. It's a part of me, but it doesn't. But there's several factors in my life that would determine what kind of decision I would make, how I would proceed with life, even who I would consider that I want to you date like so, but before that was not the case, even like how I would
Speaker 2you know what even like what type of activism that I would do? Right, So, it's it's interesting, like how I would listen to even apologists, Christian apologists specifically try to put this false equivalence on you know, people who happen to be non believers, that our identity is completely wrapped up in being an atheist. And I try to make the case to say that not no, no, it's
Speaker 2not it's a it's it's not it's not a it's not a religion.
Speaker 3It's it's a it's a it's a position. That's all it is. Do you believe in a god or gods?
Speaker 2Nah?
Speaker 1Yeah, I mean your motivation from active for activism isn't inherently informed by your atheism, right, because there's there's tons of atheists that don't give a shit. They just can't live their life and do whatever.
Speaker 4Right.
Speaker 1I think I think that, I think there's a certain personality that maybe wants gets you more involved in activism, but also maybe a particular kind of understanding of your world right, the worldview rather so I totally get that. But yeah, as a Christian, though, like you, kind of implicitly, and at least when I was a Christian, there's a kind of implicit goal to be a good Christian, and to be a good Christian means to have the right kind of practices, to have the right kind of thinking, you know, and the right worldview in a sense. Right, So,
Speaker 1like that is inherently going to be political in some way. Like Jesus was definitely a political figure of his time. Well, you don't really think about him that way today, but like he absolutely influenced and had opinions about the politics of his time. So he was political, like I you know, so it's gonna it's going to affect the way you view politics today. Whether it's correct or not, that's a different story, right, whether it's legitimately what Jesus thought or whatever. Like, it's still an influence for sure.
Speaker 3Yeah, And we are even seeing today when that whole thing is brought up about, you know, Jesus being a political figure, how he would look at our you know, politics in world today and what his stance would be, right, And you know, some people feel that, you know, Jesus was kind of a lefty, right, and he would probably be a little bit more left leaning. But then there are some like Christian nationalists who feel that Jesus was not a lefty and they still use his his name
Speaker 3to endorse their point of view.
Speaker 2So it's it's I don't know, it's it's just like, I.
Speaker 3Don't know, it's kind of weird to me because because like I know that at the end of the day, when it comes to like whatever your stances in the political phrase, it's more so whatever your interests are, and whatever your interest are is going to be, You're going to take from whatever you can in order to to say why you are right?
Speaker 2You know the true?
Speaker 1Yeah, yeah, Americans. Americans like to be a political They like they like to pretend to have the veneer of a political miss they really do. They really like to have a divide between the two and a clean cutoff. And they like to say, oh, I don't put these politics in here, but like it's it's always been a front. It's always never been a clear divide. It's like you're again, if you're going to church and you're hearing a particular message, it's it's probably political, and you may not view it in that lens, but like subconsciously it can still affect the way that you view other issues. Right, So I'd
Speaker 1rather a church be honest. And if we're gonna say, hey, this rule isn't gonna apply, it shouldn't apply to nonprofits, right, Like we should be exempt from that as well. Like if we're gonna just gonna do it, we should just go with it all the way and not this half assed bullshit because it doesn't make any sense because the protection seem to be gone right like that that that separation church stay thing, it's not a thing anymore. Like we're kind of done with that whole.
Speaker 3Yeah, it's what I mean. Even Justice Soda Mayer said that the Lemon test is dead, and that's what they used to, you know, to basically judge whether if whatever type of like you know, case is a violation of you know, religion and government, church and state. And right now what we're seeing is I mean, and it was even before we we changed from from back there to up here, like case after case, like going over nonprofits, and we would like look at like some of the
Speaker 3cases that come that came from the Supreme Court, and there was you know, I could think of that one with coach Kennedy who was who was a coach, a football coach in Canada and not Canada, I'm sorry, Alabama. And he was his his contract at his job because at first, like you know, people say, oh, he got fired. No, he didn't get fired. His contract at the school that he was at did not get renewed because he was
Speaker 3inviting kids to pray on the fifty yard line after games and the school kept asking him.
Speaker 2Hey, can you think you don't want to do that.
Speaker 3Please, And he was like, no, my Lord and Jesus Savior mastered blah blah blah, YadA, YadA YadA, says I'm supposed to do this, even though my question to him would have been, like, you know, I thought that like Jesus said that. You know, you're not supposed to pray in public in an inveighing way, like the like the like the.
Speaker 2The lawmakers and the sadducees. Do you're supposed to pray in your causing and secret and you were supposed to say the our father who are have a bahblah blah. Yeah, but you know, but like what's that whole Bible versus I don't care? Yeah, And then but then, but remember that they said one of the justices who wrote the concurrence was saying that, oh, his religious his his his freedom to practice his religion was violated, and therefore you have to give him his job back. And he only taught for a year because he didn't even live in
Speaker 2Alabama anymore. He lived in Florida, so they shouldn't even took up the case in the first place. And then he was and then he yeah, he played for just that for one game I think that they lost and did he quit?
Speaker 1Wow? Man, So it didn't even God didn't even help him out with the game. It wasn't even worth it. Now, I mean you should have invoked some other deity exactly, like you know, maybe Siva or something. Yeah, exactly, one of more games if you just prayed.
Speaker 2But yeah, exactly.
Speaker 1And this is like, not to put too fine a point, that's because I think we should probably move on to get to calls. But like you know, this whole idea, this whole freedom from religion, uh, and just separation of church and state, it's always been tenuous. It's always always been tenuous because you can kind of believe in anything and make that the rule. Now, so it's like, oh, this is my belief you have to respect. And this is what Christian nationalists have been doing the last few years. By the way, they've taken advantage of this fact by saying, oh, well, my nationalism means that we have to support proselytizing to
Speaker 1people or that we want to have a white Christian neighborhood or whatever. Right, Like you know, they won't put it in such oblique words, but you know, it's it's kind of implied and kind of what the aend goal is for some of these guys. So it's like, you know, I don't know what the solution is. I'm not going to be here. I'm not going to be the guy that says, hey, here's how we fix it, because I'm just as lost as the rest of us.
Speaker 2But yeah, I don't know either.
Speaker 1I don't know something. But maybe our callers can tell us what to do. Here. In fact, we should talk to some because this is a college show. So let's let's get to that, Cynthia. You're ready to talk to some people, yes, Okay, Before we do, we have to think the patrons of the week is ever well, patron of the week be patrons. We always think it, but every single week we're always giving a shout out to at least one person on that patriot and I of course want to thank everybody that donates, You're all amazing. But this week's Patron of the week is going to
Speaker 1be kal Levi Halvetti. Thank you so much, Calllevi Helvetti, and thank you to everybody that donates on the Truth Wanted Patreon. You guys rock and ore and we had a super chat that came in earlier. We are reading super chants if you guys are donating that, So thank you to Godwin Absurdu who gave a dollar ninety nine and said it's Godwin Underscore seven changed my name. Guys, Thanks Aca, thank you Godwin Underscore. I like how I said his name, and then I read the rest of the message saying he changed his name, So I guess
Speaker 1it's I don't know that it is what it is, but yes, we are reading super chats, so if you like to donate, we will read those messages as long as they are YouTube appropriate. So with that out of the way, let's get to our first caller of the night. We have John from California, who wants to talk to us. John, you are live on truth wanted what's going on? Hello? John from California? Are you there?
Speaker 4Can you hear me?
Speaker 1I'm here, Yes, we can hear it. Go ahead, John, Okay?
Speaker 4Perfect? How you guys doing.
Speaker 1We're doing great. John. It's a beautiful Friday today in Austin, Texas. I hope it's goodiful where you're at. You how can we help you?
Speaker 4So I'm calling and I'm called in before and you guys thought I was a troll. Well, I didn't want to, like, I didn't just like call back in like, you know, right the next week, right immediately. I don't want to give that impression, because I honestly believe this is like one of the most entertaining calls you guys, like this is I don't even kind of know where to start. It's so many things have happened.
Speaker 1Well, let's start with this. See from the call screener, you said that you watched the atheist experience and that gave you the inspiration to be a Christian. Yes, that is I'll be honest, You're the first person I've ever heard say that. Have you ever heard that, Cynthia, I don't know if I've ever heard anybody say that.
Speaker 3This is the first time that I ever heard and say that, And I would love to hear.
Speaker 2How that happened.
Speaker 1Please tell us what what tell us about that? I'd love to know.
Speaker 4I genuinely believe that the flying spaghetti monster thing is the real interpretation of the Bible, as crazy as it sounds, I went back through when I read the Bible with the idea that Jesus, you know, I didn't like, I didn't take it as a joke. At first it was, but then as I kept doing it, I kept taking it more and more seriously. Just for entertainment. I went through the New Testament. I just like pictured Jesus as the flying spaghetti monster. It turned out to be like a religiously transformative experience for me. It makes sense. The Bible didn't really make sense to me before. Now it
Speaker 4makes sense. Jesus is the flying spaghetti monster. I'm here to defend them.
Speaker 1Okay, I mean I I remember, I remember talking to you. Now, I remember you mentioning something about this, and obviously I think you can see why people would think this is the troll, right, is a troll call. But I'm going to take my face value, I guess, and I want to. I want to figure this out.
Speaker 4So it's even good.
Speaker 1You're you're you're you're looking at the Bible, You're you're having this Exegesus right, you're reinterpreting scripture here, and and you're figuring out that this flying spaghetti monster makes sense in history, like literally, the flying skating monster was there two thousand years ago, rose from the dead, Like, tell me about this the specifics here.
Speaker 4Yeah, pretty much Like so if you go through the New Testament and you picture have you ever seen ed n and Eddie?
Speaker 1Hell, yeah, I love that shit.
Speaker 4Yes, hey you know plank.
Speaker 1Yes, I do no plank For those who don't know, each is a I did a character that does not talk and is literally a painted piece of wood that everybody pretends it's real.
Speaker 4So yes, exactly. So if you well, my idea was, if you go through the New Testament and you just start picturing Jesus as plank, basically it's a sack of flour, or it's like a head of wheat, it's some type of grain. It actually makes more sense than if you think he's a human and everybody does that makes more sense hallucinating because it's like Ergo rod or something.
Speaker 1Tell me why that makes more sense, because that doesn't make more sense to me.
Speaker 4An example, off the top of my head, will do his first miracle turning water into wine. I don't know how a human being could scientifically turn water into wine. If though we accept it, Jesus was like rotting, like grain, fermenting grain. That makes perfect sense. That's right there. A big Jesus quote is bread is my body, wine is my blood. To take that literally, don't put what you want to believe in there. Just take Jesus at its words. What did Jesus say, How is it possible for his bread, for his body to be bred, and his wine to
Speaker 4be blood unless it's like flour, at which point that makes perfect sense.
Speaker 1John, you are stretching my my suspension of the disbelief to the it's maximum capacity here, because if you are in a troll. This is one of the strangest calls I think I've had on this show, and I've had a lot of strange calls. Okay, so this is my genuine belief. Cynthia, What do you want to do with this because there's a couple of different angles here. Oh you're viewed right now, Cynthia, go ahead if you can.
Speaker 3I'm sorry I had a question for John. So, John, you know I want to go back to this whole wh thing. You know, Jesus's blood.
Speaker 2Are you saying that one of the reasons why you think that Jesus, because I don't want to misrepresent you, is the flying spaghetti monster, it's because his blood is like wine, and you compare pasta very well with wine.
Speaker 4That could be an interpret It's an inclusive legit. So if you want to see it that way, go ahead. I was just taking it literally at its words. Red is my body, Wine is my blood. That sounds a lot like glucose.
Speaker 2Would it be a pino in the water, a pino, a cabernet? Uh, you know, a red blend? What kind of wine are we talking about here?
Speaker 4Every single wine? That's what's amazing about Christ.
Speaker 2Okay, but you know, but but you know, Okay, So if there's a red wine and there's a white wine, are we doing reds or whites? Or what are we doing? Are we doing a rose? I mean, what are we doing here?
Speaker 1We're losing the flood here.
Speaker 4It's up to you. It's up to you. That's think about Christ. Christ comes to us in our own point. We all have our own personal Jesus. Some people liked bear, some people like wine. No reason.
Speaker 1I just need to understand, because again there's different forms of So the Gnostics, the early Christians, early Christian. They're now seen as heretical, but they are an early Christian interpretation. They basically saw Jesus not as a literal person, but sort of a divine figure that gave these sorts of divine truths, right, So they had this kind of interesting, sort of different possibly ahistorical, It's hard to know the rusty of Jesus, but regardless, you know, they had a different take of Christianity. So in some ways your view isn't exactly unprecedented, which is fascinating. But what I've hung
Speaker 1up on, okay, is that were there twelve dudes in the desert that just walked around with the like a flying spaghetti monster and just like hung out with him? Like I do you think it was it like a literal sort of events here that occurred, or is the New Testament just supposed to be a sort of reinterpretive metaphorical book a series of books rather.
Speaker 4I like picturing it as it was a sack of flower and they all got everybody around it, got ergo rot, and they just did what they did.
Speaker 1I think even if.
Speaker 4You're an atheist, maybe it doesn't inspire you to faith if you read the New Testament. Imagining that and then imagining the historical context of what the New Testament became. I think it's hilary. It's one of the most entertaining things I've ever done.
Speaker 2I mean, I'm sorry, I want another question.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 2So where hold on, I got a question for you, sir. Where do you see in the Bible the historical context of looking at Jesus like a sack of flower or the flying spaghetti monster.
Speaker 1Yeah? Well that's a good question, Cynthia, because like, why sack of flower? And why not literally anything else?
Speaker 4It could be any type of plan at least that they had in Judea.
Speaker 1Why though?
Speaker 2Yeah? Why? Why specifically that? I mean because you specifically said that.
Speaker 4A multiple things. But the two things that really inspire me are the bread is my body, Wine is my blood quote, and the immaculate conception. The immaculate conception doesn't make sense if he's actually a human. I'm sorry, it just doesn't.
Speaker 1So why if he's a sack of flower? Though?
Speaker 2I don't know.
Speaker 4Yeah, hear me out, hear me out, hear.
Speaker 1Me out, hear me out.
Speaker 7Hear me out.
Speaker 4Okay, let's say Mary was like a little bit Mary. You know, there's like twelve year old there's like a twelve year old girl and like a backwoods province of like you know, the Roman Roman Empire. At that point, I'm going to assume they didn't have like, you know, the best like mental health resources, and they didn't necessarily know what to do with it. You know, it's like a twelve year old there's a little off. What if Mary just went around saying that this sack of flower was her baby? It was kind of like embarrassing, Like that's why originally dose it wasn't going to marry her. And it's like okay, and it just goes along with it. But then the sack of flowers starts performing miracles and
Speaker 4it starts getting fun. That's how I read the New Testament.
Speaker 1I think this is a great creative writing prompt. I don't know, I don't know why you would view this literally as history, Like I just don't. I don't think you've sufficiently answered this question of why a sack of flowers over anything else? I mean, I get it because it's funny, right, but like a lot of things could be funny, here are a lot of things.
Speaker 4Could be I have a practical answer to that. Okay, consider and this is probably the perfect show to make this point, to consider how much history, how much better history would have been if from the first century a d. The Catholic Church had been had been dedicated to one goal, and one goal alone free beer and free popcorn for everybody every day. When I say everybody, I mean everybody. What if that's what the church did instead of whatever it does.
Speaker 1That Hey see it's like you say that, sub John, and it's like I just yeah again, you've already you already suspended my belief is now beyond the point of suspension actual religion.
Speaker 4No, it's amazing, all right, Well, how can you take religious people seriously and say that this couldn't be. But that's what the church should do is just feed everybody free beer and free popcorn for as much carbohydrates as as far as I can tell.
Speaker 1I mean, if that was the case and that was the goal, we wouldn't be here. I'd be at the church. I'd be at the church right now, getting you know what I'm saying, Like, that's not that's.
Speaker 4Just not real.
Speaker 2I would get popcorn right now, right. I mean, like, I'm.
Speaker 1Cool with churches.
Speaker 4Should do this.
Speaker 2I mean, I'm cool with churches feeding people. You know, I'm cool with churches doing as much charity work as possible, especially for those who are not able to, you know, get certain things because of like you know, payment, you know, not necessarily having a lot of money, et cetera, et cetera. But you know, I don't.
Speaker 3Know, John, Can I just tell you where my disconnect is?
Speaker 2Is it okay?
Speaker 3If I ask you so? My disconnect specifically is that I'm not still seeing how you're connecting, like this the recific spaghetti monster to Jesus because he said that his body is the bread and his blood is one I'm having.
Speaker 2I'm not seeing the thorough road here. You know, I'm not seeing the connection to where you got this. I mean, like if you want to say that it's a funny thing, like you know, a funny entertaining story, like ha, how would this be a funny thing?
Speaker 4Okay, but it is, but it talks some more profound don't take the words name the bank.
Speaker 2Where's the profound part, John, That's what I'm wanting to know. Where's the profundity. I would love for you to to to tell Dan and I.
Speaker 4On a spiritual level. On a spiritual level, I think that there is a lot of profoundity and a lot of a lot that can be learned about life by realizing nothing we do is possible without carbohydrates and water. Things we can't create, things that that's our Lord and savior right there, that came. That was a gift.
Speaker 2How can you wait? Wait? Wait are you before you? Before you go on? How how is that spiritual?
Speaker 4It alters your ego, It alters the way. The part that I didn't get to was that and that these things are provided to us, that we can't create the amount of thin air create them ourselves. I think that that's an important thing spiritually, as it humbles our ego, makes us realize that without God's help we are nothing. We can't you know, we can't sit here and pretend that we're doing this all ourselves. I think that's important.
Speaker 1I mean, I mean, but like you know, longer than we have.
Speaker 2I mean, but like you you you get flour from grinding grain, and you get grain from planting seeds, and the ones who usually do the seeds, the seed and harvest blah blah blah, farmers, you know, So like humans are.
Speaker 4Good people with that.
Speaker 1Look, yeah, let me let me jump in, because I don't know how much more we can do with this, John, because like so, so I have to understand history through uh material evidence, right, I like, if you're telling me Europeans used to fight dragons for example, if it's let's say somebody says that Atlantis is real. Okay, I need I need something to sort of substantiate believe in the dragons thing. Okay, well that's a that's a separate.
Speaker 4You go through all of human history from a sociological please let me finish here. That's what society are farmers farming?
Speaker 2Kay?
Speaker 4With the Neolithic revolution took cough and we figured out farming. It's all about farming, the whole fiction thing. It's like a scarecrow, right, Like there's a new Testament.
Speaker 1Right, I am going to mutube because I need to finish this.
Speaker 4Mayst.
Speaker 1I don't know, John, this is I'm just this is just giving troll vibes. That's all. From the very beginning. This is troll vibes. It's hard for me to take it seriously. But again, if i'm if I'm going to take you seriously. It's one thing to take a metaphorical reading of history in which many Christians are done again, You're not completely unprecedented in this new understanding of Jesus and his motivations and what he seeks seeks to teach us through story, right, I mean that that's one conversation, But like, I don't understand how that could be interpreted literally in any way whatsoever. I just think this is
Speaker 1just it just doesn't make any sense. I don't I don't think that really works out in reality. But I don't know. I kind of I kind of need something more than just well, if you get you can find look at it like this, and you can also look at it like this, and then if you take the carbohydrates, say like, yeah, I get it, I get it. You find some meaning in reading that. But how do I know this is true? How do I know that this is the correct interpretation over other kinds of interpretations. I understand interpretation can be subjective, but like, there has to be some sort of merit to this, right, And I'm
Speaker 1gonna unmutue now, John, and let you say your piece. But then after this, I don't know, we'll see. All right, John, you are unmuted. Go ahead.
Speaker 4So I had something that I before we got to a sidetracked, I had something specific that I wanted to talk about today.
Speaker 1And I have an I need you to answer my question because we can't keep going on side tangents. Okay, how can we know that this interpretation of reality is more true than other interpretations of reality.
Speaker 4Here's here's a test. The past ten years been pretty crazy, right like, And no matter who you are, no matter what you believe, most people can agree the past ten years of politics, life, sport, it's like it's been pretty nuts, right like.
Speaker 1Give you that for free, for sort whatever. Yep, what would be?
Speaker 4What would you say if somebody had been able to predict all of the events that took place in twenty fifteen, twenty twenty five in exact detail in twenty twelve, would you believe their model? Do you think maybe they had something to it?
Speaker 1I think they're probably a con artist, first of all, but I guess i'd entertain them. I'd see how they'd proposed to do that.
Speaker 4My grand my grandfather, who was the one that inspired a lot of this belief, had this idea himself. A part of my goal, if we ever get to it, would be to explain, you know, who my grandpa was, what this religion did for his life. But we'll get there later. He was able to predict basically. He passed away in twenty fifteen to two in peace, but that significant, Like the start of it, he was able to predict the past ten years of history based only on the following three assumption? Are you ready for them?
Speaker 1No? Because I asked you a question and you said that you're going to answer it, and you didn't answer it. So you're now losing credibility in my eyes very rapidly. Okay. I would just like to know how do you interpret your model of reality over other people's models of reality? Because everybody has a little bit of a different idea, right, especially when it comes to the Bible and what's true about it?
Speaker 4Right?
Speaker 1What makes yours true? Why should I believe.
Speaker 4You if someone was able to predict the past. That was my attempt to answer the question, was if someone was able to predict the past ten years like three years out, that, like you, you kind of trust their model over other models.
Speaker 2No.
Speaker 1Was your grandpa saying that Jesus was a sack of flower though, because I don't think he was right. This is something you can do.
Speaker 4Oh dude, this guy was amazing. You don't even get it.
Speaker 1But no, but this isn't the story that you. Yeah, you said earlier, you said that you came to this conclusion after watching the atheists experience. I did.
Speaker 4I arrived at these beliefs myself spontaneously, and then after that happened, my grandma sat down and talked to me and was just amazed. We had to have like a family conversation over this. But we have the prediction thing is pretty cool. You want to hear the model that was able to predict the past ten years of history.
Speaker 1I don't think I have time. Unfortunately, we've on this call for nineteen minutes now, and you should have led with that. Honestly, if you had that, that would have been more impressive than talking about Jesus as a toaster strudle or whatever. I like. I don't know, man, no flower days. Yeah, I know it's a second flower. I'm just being I'm being dramatic for a fact. But the point is, John, if you want to call in again and talk about it, that's fine. We don't have any time anymore, though. We got to talk to some other people, okay, And that's gonna be my question. I'll ask you again
Speaker 1when you call in, how can I know that your idea of reality is more true than other people's ideas? And let's let's start with that next time, Okay, But I will let you go. I hope you have a great rest of your weekend and enjoy life. Cynthia, I'm gonna bang my head against this wall here for a bit and you can just do a one up of you for a bit. No, just kidd, We're not gonna do that. I'm just okay.
Speaker 2I have to say. I can understand why you want to do that. I'm still I don't know. I was you know what I really wanted to ask, right, what's that? Uh? What hallucin?
Speaker 1Yeah there is what what were you and your grandpa? What carbohydrates? Were you and your grandpa? Right? Because that's what's happening right now, and you know, California makes sense. I get a lot of stuff over there. I don't know, John, I don't know, because like if your troll, it's a weird troll, I'll give you that. Is it entertaining? Sure, but you called them several times and you had a different you had an interesting ideas last time too, So
Speaker 1like I don't know, but it But also I don't know what I'm supposed to do with this, Cynthia.
Speaker 3I don't know if I can do it, you know, Dan, I think that what we should all do is breathe in for four seconds.
Speaker 2In four seconds, so we're gonna let's breathe in.
Speaker 1All right, every day home, if you're listen, just just take a deep breath. Let's just do this together, a little meditaid session. Ready, breathe in. It's here, it's here. Okay, we're good.
Speaker 2All right, Yes, yes, thank you for that, no problem, thank you.
Speaker 1Appreciate it.
Speaker 2Social worker, and that's what we do.
Speaker 1That's yeah, that's good. That's good. Shout outs to social workers, Shout outs to your craft, amazing stuff. Before we move on to whatever the hell that was, we're going to talk about the Backers. Backers is comming up, folks. August sixteenth. Okay, tickets are selling quickly. They might be out by this time next week because we're getting pretty close. I don't know, maybe not, Maybe we still have some more. We'll see either way. Uh, you go, you should get your tickets like it's because they have run out in the past before the actual date. So I would highly recommend if
Speaker 1you want to come to Austin, come hang out with me, Come hang out with j Mike, coming out with Forrest Valki and a bunch of other folks that are coming down to see Cynthia, you're gonna make it this year? You coming down?
Speaker 2No start a new job?
Speaker 1Oh yeah, that's why you shore new job. Well, Cidy's not going to make it, but you know the rest was to go be there, So go check it out, tie it out CC slashback crews if you want to get your tickets on that, And if you're not able to attend but you still want to, how about you can actually donate. Under the live chat you purchase a ticket for one of our hosts or crew and sponsor them to go. So a cool thing to do if you are interested in that. And as always, if you want to hear a content and audio only form, you can go tiny out cc slash an Podcasts to catch up on the latest ACA shows. We do have another
Speaker 1super chat I want to read real quick from Daisy given ten dollars saying the Flying Spaghetti Monster compels you to place Mari and Era parmesan and a regged note upon their oily noodles and you will be touched by their non existence. Thank you for the ten dollars there. I've been a yeah it's flying Spaghetti Monster.
Speaker 2Thing, you know, I haven't had dinner yet. I might make me some spaghetti with marnara.
Speaker 1That's the flying spaghetti monster compelling you to.
Speaker 2It is he's pulling upon my heart.
Speaker 1Praise be, Praise be. And on that note, one last thing before we get to our next caller, I need to thank the awesome, amazing crew that helped put up with the bullshit that we deal with every week. Look at that awesome crew with the camera. Lots of lots of things happening on screen right now. So thank you for all the stuff that you do. And folks, let's get back to this little Collins show that we got going on. Speaking of Daisy, I think it's the same Daisy that just donated that is calling us right now.
Speaker 1It's Daisy from Washington, Seattle. Daisy, you're live on truth wanted. What's going on?
Speaker 4Hi?
Speaker 7Hi, Yeah, I'm here. I'm Daisy and I did have a question.
Speaker 1Yeah, okay, ready for you, Daisy? Go ahead.
Speaker 7My question is is anti theism or anti religion bigotry?
Speaker 1Oh? Great question? Question? Do you have thoughts? What are your thoughts? Daisy? Okay?
Speaker 7What I mean by anti theism is that I believe that humanity would be better off if people would be skeptics, but I don't prefer any enforcement behind that. Like, I support religious freedom. I want people to be able to believe whatever they want to believe. But I have a specific reference that there wasn't religions in the world. Does that specifically make me a bigot?
Speaker 1I think that's a great question. This is a really nuanced one too. I have a lot of thoughts about this, but Cinthy, you want to start with this one because you know we could dissect this for a while.
Speaker 3Yeah, we can, and I wouldn't mind doing that, especially after you know, thinking about spaghetti, monsters and red wine. But so my thoughts I'm just going to repeat, is anti theism? Are anti religion being anti religious bigotry? Did I get that question correct? Is that what that question was? I just want to make sure that I said this question correctly.
Speaker 7There is one qualifier there that I do support religious freedom, okay, So it's it's that I'm anti feist. However, I support people's ability to do that, okay, And so like, if you look at the definition of bigotry, well there's lots of definitions for that, but as I understand it, bigotry is defined as obstinate or unreasonable attachment to a belief, opinion, or faction in a particular prejudice against person or people on the basis of their membership of particular group. Like
Speaker 7like my qualifier that I don't specific I claim that I'm anti ideas, but I support people's right to have a belief. I don't know, Like, would you still qualify me as a biggot in that sense?
Speaker 2I would say no. And and the reason being is because it's not like you're not saying that if you are a theist or if you are a religious person, that you should not exist and you should not believe what you should believe or what you do believe. It's just that I am not on your I'm not of your thought level. I'm not the person. I'm not a person who like agrees with you that said you know, uh said, theological belief is a thing or should be
Speaker 2a thing. I support your I support your ability to be able to to worship or or or believe what it is that you believe.
Speaker 3It's just that I am not of that same thought And so because like you're not saying that churches should not exist and mosques should not exist or anything like or any of that stuff. Right, You're just basically saying that, you know, even though that I support your belief, like I support you believe in what you believe, I just don't agree with you. And and and my preference would be that if for everyone to be able to lean
Speaker 3on skepticism and critical thinking instead of like you know, you know, believing in something that we cannot prove is a thing at all. We can't prove that God exists. God is unfalsifiable. We can't even we even look at the Bible and of itself. And oftentimes what people use is.
Speaker 2The Bible in order for it to be the thing that they say is, hey, this thing exists because the Bible said And I was like, well, you can't prove the Bible with the Bible, Like, what is the outside empirical evidence that says that this is a thing? Right?
Speaker 1Yeah?
Speaker 3Yeah, so I so I I And I would even say, I am a person who who was a Christian.
Speaker 2I am no longer that. But I do not tell other Christians that you should not be a Christian. I'm not going to deal with you.
Speaker 3I'm not gonna you know, be your friend or or come to the cookout, you know, because you put raisins in your potatoes side.
Speaker 2I'm sorry, that's not that here north there. But I'm not going to come against your right, your existence, right, I'm not I'm not going to do that. I'm just gonna I'm just gonna say that I don't agree with your position. I don't agree with your and I have reasons for that, ye, But yeah, I just leave it at that.
Speaker 1Well, this is That's why I think Dais's question is really interesting because this really goes into the heart of what we do. What is our goal? Are we anti theists in our activism? What does that mean exactly? I think there's a problem of scope there for one, right, Daisy, because religion can mean a lot of things. We were just talking about this. I believe you could believe that Jesus is a sack of flower, for example, just putting that out there, so like, you know, what do we mean while we say we're anti theists? So so one that there's a definitional problem there. But on the other hand, well,
Speaker 1we're here, we're talking about stuff, so what do we think I tend to be on the same wavelength as Cynthia and that we aren't Christian anymore both of us and we think that we're not Christians for good reason. We'd like to tell other people about those reasons. But like I want people to approach it on their own terms. I'm not going to make anybody become an atheist. I don't want state atheism. Literally, every country that has ever practiced state atheism is not a country I want to live in personally, Right, So I want people to I do endore secular values, and I guess one of my
Speaker 1secular values is a level of tolerance that I would want to and expect other people to have. And if a religion, if if a religious belief sort of uh, doesn't coincide with that tolerance, then I'm not going to tolerate, right. I don't think it's it's it's worth having. So in that sense, I am anti theists. I am anti theist against any religion that you know doesn't tolerate on the level that I want Hoaks to tolerate. Right is intolerant because I think groups that have shown to be intolerant
Speaker 1you know of people or other people you know, and various capacities have generally shown to be a bad idea. Right, But you know, that's uh, that's a complicated thing, right. Uh So I don't know, that's a lot of there's my scattershot thoughts on that, Daisy, what do you think?
Speaker 7Well, Okay, Like in previous conversations I've had there there has been a comparison made because I I am a trans woman, and the comparison was made where people were saying, Okay, so you're saying that you're anti feist, but you wouldn't enforce it, would you hold the same view about somebody who was anti trans? And then I got emotional because I was like, are you saying that I just believe
Speaker 7that I'm a woman or is it that you know? Like are you are you comparing these two things? Because in my opinion, I think like I've met a lot of people at least that changed their religious beliefs over time a lot, you know, but at least in my experience, I wasn't able to change my being a trans woman. Like it wasn't a choice for me. It was just sort of something that was like I don't have a choice about that, but you do have a choice about a religion. So like I'm wondering the difference between those
Speaker 7two things.
Speaker 1Like well, let's think about that. But I do because that's an interesting proposition there. Do people have a choice in what they believe? Because I've historically been of the opinion that that's not as concrete, right, Like I believe that the Earth is round. I don't know that I could choose to believe that the Earth is flat at this point, just based on my experience, based on what I know, based on other people I've talked to, Like, there's a lot of factors in there that would have
Speaker 1to change in order for me to change my belief. Right, So, even though it is a belief that I consciously hold, I'm not sure how appliable that belief really is, right, and so on that. By that same token, when we talk about people's religious beliefs, we sometimes talk about it in the language that, yeah, people should change their minds about this, but there may be factors at play that make it psychologically difficult for people to change their minds in such a way where we may view it as
Speaker 1being outside of their control. I don't know if that's making sense there, but you know there is something to be said about that.
Speaker 7Yeah, yeah, I mean people can be indoctrinated into religions, and so they don't necessarily have a choice because that is that they're going to necessarily have to believe because their parents are telling them this, that everybody around them is telling them this, and then they have this necessary belief. But at least from a trans like from the standpoint of somebody who is trans, I this wasn't external. This was something that was internal that I just believed about myself from my own Like, nobody told.
Speaker 1Me to be trans.
Speaker 7Nobody nobody was around me saying like, oh, you should be a woman even though you were born male. So I see that there's a difference there. I don't specifically know if this, Like I really detest being called a bigot, but I don't want to be a bigot, and if I am, I don't I don't want to be presented as one. So like it, Like if anti theism is bigotry, I don't want to do it. But at the same time, like I see all these that are being caused by
Speaker 7religion that are directly affecting me specifically as a transgender Like ironically it affects me as a transgender person because the religious ideals are affecting me legally and medically, So I'm not sure.
Speaker 3Yeah, Daisy, If I may say, I have a hard time taking the argument of if you're anti FIS, you are a bigot, just like if you're anti trans you are a theater, are our bigot?
Speaker 2I think that these are two very very different things.
Speaker 3And and part of it is because I'm of your mindset that if you are a person who happens to be transgender, it's not a choice, It's just who you are, Okay. I have been fortunate in my line of work that I've worked with you know, and I've got resources for transgender women, and I've had hours and hours of conversations with transgender women, and especially because part of my job
Speaker 3was to help them get hormones, help them navigate through different medical processes.
Speaker 2That they were choosing to do. If they you know that that that could be an elected or even like you know, when it came to even how to pay for you know, procedures, if they wanted to go that route. But I know that from what they were talking to me about is that this is just who they were. And we even know statistically that very few people, if they happened to go through a transition with their gender that very few people transitioned back to the gender that
Speaker 2they were signed at birth. It's like it's like in a high ninety percent, right, So this whole thing, but I regret it is it's not it's not like a very large populace of trans people who were to say that they've done that. So and you are right that oftentimes beliefs informed behavior, and we are seeing specifically laws that are overtly oppressing to trans people. We have right
Speaker 2now in the federal government in that just passed a in this last bill that in my opinion, is now beautiful that they were really defunding and taking away you know, gender affirming care, medical care, even though you've had hours of doctors coming to the hill testifying that this is this is this is healthcare, this is medically this is medical necessity.
Speaker 3This is not just because you know, somebody on a whim decided to do this, No, do you know. And and but unfortunately, because belief systems are so intertwined these the as we were just talking about, how like the separation of church and government is like such a it's such a muddied line now to the point where it doesn't even exist that people are legislating based on their beliefs and not about on empiricism, so and and and
Speaker 3so like, and I know that, like you always here sometimes propaganda talking about like the transgender agenda, and I was like, I don't know what that means unless you're saying that if you have an agenda to say that you need medical care. Okay, I'm with that, you know, but it's not that we have.
Speaker 2Uh people that's in power, that are who are who are supporting that right, we don't and and so like, even and even if like I think it's perfectly fine, you know, for a person who has been experiencing firsthand how these belief systems are harmful to say that I'm anti that because I because I feel that way as well. I want to like pull out my extensions, Daisy. Every
Speaker 2time I hear these horrible arguments about keeping you know, transgender people away from care or even you know, passing bills that actually come against their specific existence. That's not right. Yeah, I got on a soapbox for moment.
Speaker 1No, it's okay. I like, Daisy has a really nuanced position here and is really trying to communicate something that I think is I don't want to be missed because what she's saying is from my understanding, is like, you know, there are people who are anti trans right who we would say clearly display bigotry. Are we doing the same thing as anti theists? Or if we take an anti theis position, are we doing the same thing in some kind of way?
Speaker 7Right?
Speaker 1To get to the heart of that, like, why am I here? What are we doing here? I figured out that Christian he really wasn't real one day, right, and so I sought out a community and resources to help me through that. And the ACA was one of those folks, right, And so that's why I do what I do. And if that makes me anti theist, then it is what it is. But I didn't get here because somebody made me get here. I didn't get here because somebody forced me to change my beliefs. I didn't even get here because somebody called me a bigot. I got here because
Speaker 1I figured out that something wasn't true. And by my understanding of true meaning matching reality, and as Cynthia mentioned, it does matching empirically right, matching logically, it seems to fall through with these things, right, And you could say the same thing for folks who don't understand trans people. They don't understand the lived experiences of trans people, the reality of trans people, the various you know, life experiences, and also science and circumstances that all go into that. And so it's a failure of acknowledging reality. Is how
Speaker 1we would, you know, kind of understand that the same way that I think most bigots kind of failed to understand reality. Right, So is it a lack of education what we would call lack of education? Is it ignorance? I think so. I think I think a bigotry comes from an ignorance. And I don't think as anti theists or folks who are sort of against the honestly bigotry that comes from religious communities that makes so signorant. In fact, we approach it with the full knowledge of what the extent of the harm that's done. Right, And that's how I've always been. I've never knocked on people's churches and
Speaker 1told people you need to stop being a Christian. I don't think I've ever told anybody on this show in the years i've been doing this, you need to stop being a Christian because that's a bad thing. I think I've always tried to approach it from the sense of, well, how can we figure out what's true? But it's not true, right, So I think as long as you take that stance, Daisy, I don't think that makes you a bigot, right, I think that makes you somebody who's concerned about other people's well being, including your own, and you want to see what's best for people. And sometimes that means walking away from a religious institution. But sometimes christian isn't the problem.
Speaker 1Sometimes it's a people problem, you know what I mean. Sometimes it literally is just people are just dicks. And then so you know, like it is what it is. I don't know, I think that's that's that's all I could think of to say on that, Daisy, What do you think.
Speaker 7Well, no, I totally understand. It's just it's just I don't want any harm to come.
Speaker 1To anybody at all.
Speaker 7I mean, like, I don't want harm to come to people who have religion. And when I think of bigotry, I think of people who do want harm towards me. Yeah, And like that's not what I'm like, perhaps I'm using the wrong label, Like maybe anti FeAs is not the best way to present it, Like I'm not saying I don't want you to be religious. Well, okay, I'm not saying I don't. I don't like religious people. Like I have plenty of religious friends. There are some of the most loved people in my life, but like, I have
Speaker 7a preference that religion wasn't the thing because I think people should like you.
Speaker 1When you recognize the institutional harms that religion brings, right, and you see that as a net negative on society. I think I think that's what an anti theist would be, is somebody who says that that religion overall is a net negative, right, or theism is a net negative. You know.
Speaker 7Yeah, but but but don't you think that the word anti theists could be kind of conflated to seeing that you're somebody who like who's religious people?
Speaker 1Well, yeah, I'm to some people's minds, I'm probably allegedly an anti theist. And I'm sure not one hundred percent sure what that means, right, I still don't know. It's it seems to be a pretty loaded term. Yeah, so it's it's not really a term I would use to describe myself because I don't I don't fully know what that means to be honest with you. But religious people definitely might use that as a way to discredit me. For sure.
Speaker 7Yeah, I'm the same boat, like I just I'm not trying like it's.
Speaker 1You're trying to figure it out. You're trying to you want to here, here's here's my thing on this. Maybe you don't need a label for yourself, right, Maybe you don't need that category. Maybe maybe just be free in recognizing that your opinions are nuanced and don't have a great label for them, right, you know, why put yourself in a box. I'm sure in your experience of figuring out that you were a trans person, right, you had to think outside the box a little bit. Right, Maybe this is the same thing. Maybe it's like, hey, I'm still figuring out my feelings on this, or maybe there's not a great label for this, and you know, like
Speaker 1you just live with that. Maybe we don't have to be anti theist or anti whatever to give it an umbrella term for who we are. Maybe we just are who we are.
Speaker 3I don't know, And if I just can jump in, I will a daisy, I don't I don't know, if you just don't mind just me saying that I just the fact that you're actually trying to work this out because you really care about making sure that you're not causing harm to people to others, right because you're empathetic.
Speaker 2Yeah, tells me all that I need to know.
Speaker 3And I think that if the person and I do apologize for the music playing in the background, you know, we've got toddlers here. But I what I think that happened is that whomever knows that you are a person who does not believe in a god or god's and you know, may have used antitheis in the past or whatever is trying to fall, you know, conflate those terms between you know, being for anti trans versus anti theis,
Speaker 3and I don't think that they go together at all. I think that those are two very different things. And from even like my Google definition is, you know, anti fas is a person who disopposes a god or god a belief in a god or God's you know, Now, if it means more than that, I don't know. That's just what I got. But you know, from what I'm hearing from you specifically, is that you are a person that cares, that you are thoughtful and that you really
Speaker 3want to be a person that is living a life where you are being honest and helpful to others, And from my standpoint, that is far from being a bigot.
Speaker 7I agree, you know, that makes a lot of sense. Like I mean, I I don't want any harm done to any religious person. I mean, like I have this remote like non like I don't want to enforce this in any way. I would prefer that people didn't have religions. However, like I understand that people do and that you know, I don't. I'm friends with a lot of these people, and so I don't want anything bad to happen them. I just have this sort of like underlying feeling that
Speaker 7like if the world didn't have religion, it would be a little bit of a better place because people would be basing their decisions off of like rational thinking, you know, or skeptical thinking. And I don't know if that is necessarily I mean, yeah, I still feel a little bit bad because like, like I don't want to demean people believe necessarily, because if they believe a certain thing, I don't want to like come up to them and be like, hey, you shouldn't believe this thing, Like I think that that's wrong,
Speaker 7Like people should be able to believe. I wish that they wouldn't, but I.
Speaker 1Don't want to.
Speaker 7I don't I don't necessarily want to put anything behind that and say like, oh, we shouldn't force that, Like I mean, that's the exact type of thing that I'm trying to fight against.
Speaker 1But this is the kind of nuance that is hard to go ahead Daysia interrupted you Oh.
Speaker 7No, no, no, no ahead, I'm sorry.
Speaker 1Well, this is so it's hard about our community because we don't have a clear consensus on this issue. I think you're you're again, you're really good at getting to the heart of something that is hard to parse out because there's a couple of them, like you mentioned this and blsit and assumption here, which is interesting that this idea that people without religion are going to be better off, right, And I think that's an idea that implicitly a lot of atheists actually hold and may not necessarily say out loud, but may inform why they do what they do. And I think that that's interesting because I've definitely known some
Speaker 1people who didn't believe in God at all and are still assholes, right, like you know, so, like there's definitely a correlation between those who are part of organized religious groups and the oppression surely that no contests there. Whether people aren't going to be overall better off in every situation, that's a harder thing to prove. It is the harder thing to convince people of what I would instead think of it as, at least for me personally, Sorry, there's a gnat just right in my face. Oh my god, it's distracting the hell out of me, and it's trying
Speaker 1to get in my mouth while I'm talking. So what I would say personally is, regardless of whether people are better off with religious beliefs, there are institutions right now that are religious in nature that are actively causing harm in people's lives, and I would like to dismantle those institutions if possible. Right, So that's the way I would think about it, because at the end of the day, I know great I know people in my life. At least one dude, who guy I've known for years and years, is still a Christian despite the many conversations I've had
Speaker 1with him, still a Christian and still one of the best dudes I know when it comes to helping out with other people. And you know, if there's going to be other people like that with him in the world. I'm going to be okay with that, right. It's it's the folks that are making an organized effort to do otherwise that there is always going to be the top of my concern at least. But I don't know, what do you think, Daisy.
Speaker 7Well, I just think that there is a distinction to be made between religious beliefs that are active and powerful and religious beliefs that are like but and not powerful or not not trying to change anybody else's beliefs, you know. And I think there's a distinction there where, like you like, yes, some some religious beliefs may not be as harmful as others. So it's kind of like you have to, like, you know, base your opinion about those things. Like I wouldn't advocate
Speaker 7for like a blanket law that says like nobody can have religion Like that just sounds horrible and like authoritarian, and I would never advocate for that. But like the specific religious beliefs that are linking up towards power, towards government and are doing things like I mean, if you talk about a place like Iran or like, you know, a lot of these theocracies you know. I mean the religion is actively like people in there every single day,
Speaker 7and so I think that there's there's definitely a scale and like a spectrum to it.
Speaker 1So yeah, but those are those institutions I'm talking about, right, those are the ones I want to dismantle. Like, I'm against that, right and I'm always going to fight against that. So we're on the same page there. And again, if that makes me an antitheist, then it is what it is. But I'll know, I'll tell you one thing. I'm not doing it because I'm bigoted. I'm not doing it because I hate Christians or think they're inferior or Muslims or whatever. I do it because I want to liberate people, right. I mean, that's always going to be my stance on it. And if you feel the same way, then I think
Speaker 1we're in good company. Right. But you know, we can't have other people dictate how I feel or think about things just because maybe it has a negative connotation to it, right, I don't know. Some people may misunderstand my motivations and maybe they'll misunderstand yours too, But like Cynthia said, I think you're good. I don't know you. I think You're a good person though, based on what I talk to you from. So you know, as long as that's your forefront, the label's just gonna be a label, right, Yeah.
Speaker 2And if I were just to tell you, Daisy, like.
Speaker 3And if I can just just just tell you, you know something, Daisy, that I know that people may try to misrepresent you and put you into a box just because of like you know, maybe like a stance that you have, but you know, just you know, keep keep on doing you.
Speaker 2Yeah, Hey, Kelly, keep on doing you, do you? Yeah?
Speaker 3And because because I think that, yeah, just just just keep doing you. Just keep living your life and and keep being empathetic and thoughtful and and and even like if you want to go ahead and continue to have these like thoughtful conversations where it could even be something that could spark something to somebody else, to keep doing it.
Speaker 2Yeah, I think you're doing the right thing, to be honest with you.
Speaker 7Yeah, that makes so much. Thanks so much, Cynthia, And thanks so much objectively then, like really love talking to you about this. That it did elucidate a lot of things for me. So so thank you.
Speaker 1Great. I hope so I hope, I hope we can get Claire, because I'll be honest with you, this is something I still struggle with myself, right, exactly what we're doing here? How do we define that? What are the limits of what I believe and don't believe about this kind of thing? Right? And I'm I've left it with this idea that I'm okay with this being an open question. I'm okay with still figuring stuff out and not knowing all the answers on this, as long as I know my motivations for why I'm doing it, which is to help other people, right, and to do what I can
Speaker 1with that. So I think I think that's the thing we have to rely on at the end of the day. At least that's what I'm choosing to believe. Daisy, I don't know, but always great talking to you as well. I hope you have a great rest of your weekend. And I'll let you go for now. Thanks for calling in Gosh, there's flies in here right now. It's summer in Texas. Yes, Shar'd be crazy, Cynthia.
Speaker 2I had the same problem here in the in the city of wind So I feel you subjectively objectively.
Speaker 1Data They came out of nowhere. We've been we've been like being really good about cleaning stuff. We're putting all the garbage in the can, not even in the trash can in the case, we're trying to get rid of it and that. And they just popped up and they're flying all over my face.
Speaker 2Maybe maybe they were manifested by an open wine bottle with a sack of flower.
Speaker 1Yeah. Maybe let's go with the interpretation that Jesus was actually a fly was trying to buzz around with his good news.
Speaker 2Good news.
Speaker 1Yeah, that was very good. That's very good. Oh on that? Wow, how do you follow that up? Folks? I don't know. We'll take it to Kelli here in just a second. Before we do, I need to give to some more super chats. We have ten dollars from Miranda Rensberger. Thank you for that. Saying disagree with people's harmful beliefs and actions,
Speaker 1or even wanting them to stop holding those beliefs, doesn't make you a bigot. The problem is the harm, not opposing them. I like this idea, right because, like, we all have religious people in our lives that we probably cared be about, right, Like, so you know, we love these people who they are, and we don't necessarily want them to change everything about themselves. But there's going to be some problems, right if my friends don't fuck with trans people, they're they're not loving my friends, you know. So like there's there's got to be limits to that.
Speaker 1Everybody has to navigate that, right.
Speaker 2So yeah, boundaries people.
Speaker 1Yeah, for sure, bounderies are a good thing.
Speaker 2They are.
Speaker 1They are. And another of five dollars from Kelly Detroit atheist Queen King that he says, Hey, Cynthia, so there you go there, Kelly response.
Speaker 3There, that's my that's my fellow being black non believer in Detroit area.
Speaker 2Very good friend of mine. Thank you very much for the five, and thank you for the ten. Thank you for the fifteen.
Speaker 3How about I just give you a high ten and and that's fifteen.
Speaker 2Bam, there you go.
Speaker 1That's great. And speaking of of being great, let's bring Kelly back on again real quickly, just say thanks again Kelly for the very entertaining opening and giving us all something to think about. Let's put it that way. I'm glad you got to tell them. I'm expecting more family drama stories when I get back. I won't.
Speaker 5I'm telling you, I'm gonna I'm gonna check with my sister.
Speaker 1She's the one who does I want the family. So I want you to go to ancestry dot com and pull up some tea. Okay, I need I know this, But can you remind folks what the question this week is.
Speaker 5I can't do that if you believe it or not. Yeah, I'm looking at the back cruise freaking uh. Notice what can you say to your psychic but not your spouse? Yes, I was gonna say you put your answer below, not in the in the comments on the side, but down below so we can read it out next week.
Speaker 1Read it down below and we'll be happy to take a look at that. What I won't, but Kelly will probably next week. And Cynthia, thanks so much for being on the show today. You are great for that. We are going to be doing an after show here as well in just a second if you want to join us for that, so go to the Atheistmmunity Austin fan discord. Link to that is in the description if you want to hang out in just a little bit here, Cynthia, we're about to close out today's program. Thanks for being with us. Any words of wisdom for us before we
Speaker 1wrap it up?
Speaker 2Boundaries are good. Keep being good yep yep, and.
Speaker 3Make sure that you are not making your sack of flower bread with bloody wine.
Speaker 1I like that words to live by. Thank you, Cynthia, Thank you to the crew, Thank you to everybody watching the show. Remember to always keep wanting the truth and we'll see you next time. Watch the non profits and
Speaker 1join the hosts in the live chart. Visit tiny dot c cy slash y t n b
In today's episode of Truth Wanted, ObjectivelyDan welcomes guest Out Of Body Atheist, with The Beard of Empathy on backup, to dig into Reiki, New Age spirituality, homeopathy, and the long road from woo to skepticism!...
In today's episode of Truth Wanted, Jon the Skeptick, Volcy, and Sofia Spina explain why no one can talk to the dead, from Haitian Vodou and grief dreams to Jon's past as a spiritualist! Bob jumps from objective...
In today's episode of Truth Wanted, ObjectivelyDan and Nintendrew, later joined by The Beard of Empathy, tackle a world run on Jesus, the magic of manifesting, and a prayer that actually got answered! Bob in NY, a...
In today's episode of Truth Wanted, ObjectivelyDan, Kelley Laughlin, and The Beard of Empathy tackle standards of evidence, miracle claims, and the false binaries of moral philosophy! Dean in VA questions why skeptics...
In today's episode of Truth Wanted, ObjectivelyDan and Chad Harris tackle Christian nationalism, police brutality, and the uncomfortable truths about racism and immigration. Big E in TN survived police brutality and...