Special Episode: We Are Here 24 hour fundraiser! https://aca.show/wearehere This episode was extracted from our 24hour fundraiser live stream on May 16-17. We apologize for the delayed posting! In today’s episode of Truth Wanted, Jamie the Blind Limey and Zenamae dive into the complexities of observed reality and the impact of religion on minority communities! From the "chain" of colonial faith to the whimsy of a conscious earth, the hosts challenge callers to ground their worldview in evidence rather than comfortable fictions. Sarah in IN wants nature to be conscious to soothe climate anxiety. Hosts warn that "half-truths" remove human responsibility and could lead to cults. If the earth is sentient, why let itself be harmed? Is this just a comforting fiction? Aji 337 asks about believers who never read their holy books. Zena finds it jarring when people pretend to know the text but ignore its contradictions. They discuss the dangerous cycle of pastoral authority. What happens when faith hits reality? Thank you for joining us today! We will see you next time! Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/truth-wanted--3195473/support.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Speaker 1Truth's a weird thing. We don't get much of it these days. And by truth I mean that which comports most closely to observed reality. There's so much of misinformation being banded about. It's very difficult to know what's truth these days. And I personally want to know as many truth things as possible and not believe as many false things as possible. So if you have a truth, a belief that you believe is true, and an argument to back it up or some evidence, then we would really
Speaker 1really like to know it because I want to know all the truth things I possibly can. Because the show is starting now. Hello, They're lovely people out there in streaming land. You join us on Sunday, May seventeenth on our twenty four hour live stream and at the new Time for Truth Wanted. So from now this is where
Speaker 1you're gonna get your big dollop of truth. I am Jamie the Blind Liamey, and today we are joined by very special guest Zena May. Hello, Welcome, Hi, thank you Jamie.
Speaker 2How are you.
Speaker 1I'm short? Answer good, long answer is long, but I'm doing all right. Just before we get going, I do have to announce a couple of things. This as Ever is a product of the Atheist Community of Bustin, a five zero one C three nonprofit organization dedicated to atheism, critical thinking, and the separation of religion and government. It is a life call in show. We have open lines. You can get in contact with us via telephone at
Speaker 1five one two ninety nine one nine two four to two, or if you want to do it computer styly, you can go to the link tiny dot c C forward slash call tw Either way is fine for us. We are still looking for people to give us donations to get us towards our targets on this fundraising drive. We've already raised quite a bit, but we've got some time left and I've just been kind of buzzing around. I've been kind of since six o'clock yesterday, just getting on
Speaker 1with it. So back to Tuesday now, Zenna, Xena. I'm totally Xena.
Speaker 2You know, I get I get to make sure I get Zenna Zename, Zename. So as long as you get the gist.
Speaker 1Right, So, uh, what brings you to the atheist community of Boston. Tell us a bit more about yourself.
Speaker 3Well, I one really love the platform. It is something so cool to see a group of atheist people who genuinely want to just do good for the community number one.
Speaker 2So definitely happy to be a part of that.
Speaker 3I do have a plat hormre on TikTok where I talk about, you know, issues surrounding Christianity that specifically kind of harm the black community. I also fundraise for several people in our community at any given time. I work with nonprofits and just really community oriented.
Speaker 1Fantastic And yeah, I was, I was having a look at the you stream earlier on TikTok, and the emblazoning of God is useless. I'm like, well, that's a that's a bold thing to put up there, but you do need to sometimes. So I mean, what kind of specific interests do you have when it comes to this kind of work. I mean, there are any topics you mentioned when Christianity does harms the black community. I mean, what kind of what kind of problems do you see and what are you trying to fight against?
Speaker 3Yeah, you know, with Christianity, Jamie, it is a part of black culture. It is it's so hard to separate like your blackness from you know, growing up going to church, growing up with those rituals, and you know, I was talking to my friends the other night we were playing gospel music and how it's hard not to kind of get into that rhythm with it, right but knowing what it's really, what the real core message is, and also
Speaker 3just kind of the blunt truth about it that this religion.
Speaker 2Is the reason why I'm speaking English. This religion is the.
Speaker 3Reason why my people were colonized, like you know, So it's really mind boggling to me that people still don't see the issue with it. And this thing called black liberation is something that is starting to take hold in our community where they believe that you can use the Bible to break free from these oppressive systems that are bogging us down. And it's just like, how are you going to use the chain to break the chain? It doesn't make sense. So I really press on that when we talk on TikTok and other social media.
Speaker 1Yeah, and of course I have not lived that experience. If I was any more pasty, I would be a jar of mayonnaise. But and of course people that looked and sounded a lot like me are kind of responsible for all that shit that went down several hundred years ago. Souls by the way, But I do find it heartening that there does seem to be a wave of of atheism and the pushing away of religion in more minority
Speaker 1groups and in the Black community. There's other prominent sort of people coming on TikTok, like the Thinker and things like that. Where are voices for that particular community and against these particular issues that people like myself who've been atheists most of my life and have definitely not been in the Black community, I wouldn't know about it, Like I wouldn't know the first thing to how to approach that kind of thing. So I rely on folks like you,
Speaker 1as unfair as it is to teach me, like how could I be a good ally? How can I not put my foot in my mouth and do something stupid? And how better to support this cause?
Speaker 3Yeah, and I you know, I absolutely understand the challenge because there is a sort of walking on eggshells you have to kind of do when it comes to the Black community, because a lot of us don't know that history, right. They don't know about the dim diverses, right, They don't know about the Canary Islands and.
Speaker 2What the Pope did there.
Speaker 3They have no clue how systematic this oppression is you know, they see it on the surface, Oh the President says something crazy, or you know, we have jerry mandering happening. But to understand how we even got to that point, a lot of my people won't even crack open the Bible, the book.
Speaker 2To see that.
Speaker 3They are literally just playing out the game plan in the book. And when you're teaching your children these things, you know, a man died for your sins.
Speaker 2You're literally putting them.
Speaker 3Into a blood cult without their permission, right, You're.
Speaker 2Doctrinating them into a blood clet.
Speaker 3And you don't understand that you don't need this to have community. You don't need this to raise your children, you know, in a certain way, right, they can be good adults, good people that benefit society without putting this extra guilt, because that seems like an issue in the black community, this guilt that we have, you know, for numerous reasons. Yeah, it is hard though, when you're on
Speaker 3the outside looking in. And I'll give you an example if you don't mind.
Speaker 2There's a lady that was on.
Speaker 3TikTok and it was a predominantly white excuse me, black panel, right, but she was white, and she asked a very poigant question, and she said, why are you serving a god that allowed you to be enslaved? And they all jumped on her and they said, no, no, no, you don't understand. We're Deuteronomy twenty six people. We've got the promise, we're you know.
Speaker 2And it's just like, but she's.
Speaker 3Not wrong, right, And I can't even fault other people for asking black people that question, you.
Speaker 2Know what I mean?
Speaker 1Yeah, And it behooves us who are on the outside to have a thick skin. And except that if we are going to be entering into these spaces and trying to be helpful an ally to people who's lived experience differs from ours so massively, if I put my foot in it, if I say something wrong, and if I ruffle feathers inadvertently, I should own that and apologize and not add to the problem. I think one of the problems that we do have, especially when we're trying to
Speaker 1affect good change, is we are just so precious about ourselves and we're not willing to be a little bit uncomfortable sometimes and allow other people to have their voice. So and understand that while we may nominally be aligned, I have to trust that yourself or the people that I'm talking to will be able to show me the differences that I need to be aware of in our
Speaker 1experiences and how our best I can help. And it's fantastic that you're getting on board. I mean, I always love seeing people, and specially younger people, getting up and being right on about this because one of the most frustrating things that I've seen, especially recently, is that bad people getting away with things because no one will stand up and stop them, say anything about it, Like we're normalizing craziness and cruelty just by staying quiet. So be loud. Yes,
Speaker 1I think that's say. It's excellent.
Speaker 2I have to agree with you, Jamie.
Speaker 3I think I always battle with the term ally, right, this is just me personally because.
Speaker 2A lot of times.
Speaker 3I think it's used so loosely, right, Like, are you really an ally? Do you really understand the nuance of what it is to be a person of color or to be black and to have been fed this not just you, but generations before you. And then you're not only trying to kind of break those generational curses if you will, but you want to take other people's you know, culture, and they how they see the religion into consideration as well,
Speaker 3so as an ally, the grace has to be given. I think a lot of times for people of color, right, and for black people, because a lot of us are, just like I said, so ignorant to this thing, and we want to learn.
Speaker 2I love learning from people, you know, And.
Speaker 3Sometimes there are super hard pills to swallow, but if given with a nice cold cup of milk, you know, it's easier to take it down than just with the dry mouth.
Speaker 1And it's one thing that you well, I always try and avoid is like talking over and minimizing someone. Like if someone tells me something about their life, about their experience, or about their beliefs, it is on me to believe them and not to dismiss what they're saying, especially when it comes to exploring cultural differences that you know that I am. I am on the outside of and I'm
Speaker 1coming into. So if you were to tell me about certain aspects of being religious and black and the problems that come with that that are particularly unique, I'm just going to believe you, because I am not the expert in this in this field, and I would very much defer to more experienced voices. Though speaking of experienced voices, since we still have open lines and we would like to hear from all you'all out there. If you want to call in five one two two four two or
Speaker 1tiny do'd cc ford slash call tw perhaps we can pull up our backup post. We have another person in the wings.
Speaker 4Hi, Hey, Kelly Corrier.
Speaker 1Do okay? Chief? How about yourself? Have you been watching much of the stream?
Speaker 4I have been watching almost all of the stream, So yeah, I'm feeling the same way you are. I'm a little burnt out right now.
Speaker 2You guys are doing all later.
Speaker 1Pretty much pretty much. So basically, we on this show we deal with the broader topic of truth rather than just religion. Religion obviously comes into it quite a lot. But here's a question I like asking people, and I'll ask you Wordsina. Are there any beliefs that you hold that you know are irrational but you can't let go of even small ones? Because I've got a couple. I think. I don't think anyone is impervious to irrationality. Is there
Speaker 1anything anything that you you still might think of in the back of your mind, or a superstition or anything that you have in trouble? You can have trouble shaking free of.
Speaker 3It's funny that you asked me, Jamie, because I was talking to my boyfriend about this, if you're gonna be silly for a second, mermaids okay, so hear me out, hear me out. When I was younger, do you guys remember the movie Splash?
Speaker 2Okay?
Speaker 3Yes, I legitimately thought that that was evidence of Mermaids until my ultra religious mother savy down. It was like, you know, your mad aren't real, right, And I'm like, what do you She's right on the screen, like what are you talking about?
Speaker 2Yes she is, and she's like, dude.
Speaker 3No, Like that's myth, that's demonic, Like you know, you can't you know, you can't believe in that. And what's funny is like, in my culture, right on the African side of me, right, we do.
Speaker 2Believe in mermaids. We believe, like you know, in water spirits basically, right, So like eat down in my little dark black heart, Like I really.
Speaker 3Do believe that there may be some murfuck in Atlantis, you know, swimming around.
Speaker 2I don't know, finger scouts, I don't know.
Speaker 1Yeah, And I think as long as we have the self awareness to know that that's some Some these beliefs are kind of irrational, it is still fun to have them. I don't I don't want to like beat people around the head and neck for having any irrationality in their minds. I mean, my big thing is because I'm a massive nerd obviously gamer is dice. Like, I don't like other people rolling my dice for me. I want to roll
Speaker 1my own dice. And I don't want people touching my dice because you know you'll you'll ruin the mojo. And I'm like, no, you won't ruin the mojo. There is no mojo, there is no proofable. It doesn't matter who touches my dice. They're just objects. But it just feels icky, like hmmm, I don't like it, and I recognize that as an irrationality. And the problem is is that what I encourage, or what I try and encourage with these shows and with these talks and people calling in, is
Speaker 1not to try and deconstruct someone's religion or someone's belief but to try an engender rational thought, like I'm not going to tell you that you're wrong. I mean, even if I can provide evidence or proofs that you're coming at something from a bad perspective. I would much rather equip people with the with tools to come to those conclusions themselves, because I think that that rational thought and a humanist outlook naturally leads to things like escaping from
Speaker 1religious dogma and that kind of thing. It just makes more sense. What do you think about that? I mean, is that kind of an approach you take or how do you go for that?
Speaker 2Yeah? And you know you guys have had this guess them before. Her name is Phi. We call it a theology.
Speaker 3And what Fee has taught me to do is instead of attacking all the time, right, because sometimes it's just like you don't know what you're talking about, But what's their epistemology?
Speaker 2Right?
Speaker 3How do you know what you know? Why do you believe what you believe? Where did you get this from? Does it make sense to you? Let's let's go through the steps of Okay, you believe this thing?
Speaker 2Could it be wrong? Is there is that even a possibility to you?
Speaker 3Right?
Speaker 2And what would you do if you were wrong?
Speaker 3You know? Like exploring those alternatives with people allow them to kind of think outside of the box. Not that I'm attacking you, but I'm exploring your brain I want to know how you you got to this conclusion. Can I get to that conclusion with you? You know what I'm saying?
Speaker 2And if we disagree towards the end, that's fine.
Speaker 3But I think a lot of times people just have these preconceived notions about things, or you know, they read one article, they ever bothered to do any critical research, and it's just like, let's do it together.
Speaker 2Then how about that?
Speaker 1Yeah, I don't know, Kelly, You've had interactions with people who have irrationalities because your your minerals business can is a bit of a magnet for the for the WU. Any stories around that that come to mind.
Speaker 4Yeah, I'll get it. Yeah, I get a lot of crystal wou here a lot of it. We do have a sign hanging up in our store that says that our crystals are guaranteed not to have healing powers whatsoever, and if you are healed by one of them, we'll give you your money back if you haven't known from your doctor saying the crystal heeled you. So now that's shot. Sign's been hanging up for six years and we haven't paid anybody from their money back yet.
Speaker 1So no, no, But the h.
Speaker 4I get a lot of times, like like Xeno was saying, I get a lot of people that don't. They start talking and they don't realize that they don't really understand what they're talking about, you know, And I'll often Don'll often talk about the energy and the crystals. So I'll ask them, you know, what is it that you mean by energy? Because when I think of energy, I think of the capacity to do work. Right, that's what energy. That's what energy means to me as a scientist. And they'll often agree with that, Yeah, okay, that's the reasonable thing. And I was like, okay, so if it's doing work,
Speaker 4we should be able to measure the amount of work that it's doing. And we can't do that with the crystals. So is that the same kind of energy? What what are you when you say energy? What are you talking about? Exactly? And it actually gets some to start to wonder about it, some of them, anyway, you know, other people are just so stuck. And you know, I mean you've seen theists that are the same way Christians and Muslims are the same way that they're so stuck in their ideas that no matter what you say, no matter what evidence you put in front of them, They're just not going to see it or believe it.
Speaker 1Yeah, And the double edged sword of these shows is that, and I'm sure you've experienced these as well streaming on TikTok Zena, is that often people approach it as a fight like they're coming to win. They want to win against us, want to own the atheists and debunk us, and and they're like, and there's some catharsis to be had there. I mean, that's kind of where I started mentally before, when I was first getting into this, I was like, oh man, all these people talking all these bollocks.
Speaker 1I really want to give them a piece of my mind. But those kinds of conversations, while entertaining, aren't always useful. I mean, have you found that, Zena that you're skewing more towards trying to have a conversation or are you still indulging into bidity old verbal fisticuffs.
Speaker 3You know, Jamie, I truly do whenever I have a conversation, And thank you for that question. I genuinely am there to learn, Like I genuinely am like, if you can teach me something, teach it, teach me, you know, Like I don't want to beat you down. And I always tell them I am not trying to take your religion away from you because some of you guys are psychopaths and you need this religion, you.
Speaker 2Need a god watching you.
Speaker 3From this guy that says, I, I don't steal that far of candy, right, but you know that joke aside, like genuinely, like maybe I haven't thought of it the way you have, right, Like, what makes you believe that this book that is two thousand plus years old is something that we should follow today. I don't see the benefit of it. Show me what benefits you do, see, let's run that together. But a lot of times they
Speaker 3think that we have ulterior to motives, right, like we want to take something from them, right, And as if I have the power as a stranger.
Speaker 2On TikTok to do so. And I'm like, I don't have that power.
Speaker 3If you're secure in this religion, if you're securing your leave.
Speaker 2Keep it.
Speaker 4But we just we're going to steal their souls, right.
Speaker 3I've had somebody say that to me too. I'm not gonna hold you, and I'm just like, how.
Speaker 2You know?
Speaker 3But I want I want you to know that, like I'm not your enemy. Friend, I'd rather us come together fight injustices.
Speaker 2In the world.
Speaker 3We can deal with the religiosity later. Right, how can we meet in the middle?
Speaker 2Right? Does your Bible help us do this?
Speaker 1Yeah, I've been saying this quite regularly, and I was talking about it earlier in the in the live stream as well. That Weirdly, especially in the last year or so, I've been going to bat for the faithful more often than not, because as much as I can disagree with the epistemology behind their belief, like I feel it's irrational seeing bad actors bastardize religion for their own political ends
Speaker 1and get away with it. I'm like it would be highly hypocriptical of me to sit back on my laurels and not make mention of it. Because we need allies in general in these trying times, people who are humanists, people who are forward thinking, people who are who are progressive. And if those people happen to have a god belief, as long as we are still nominally aligned on human rights and trans rights and you know, and all that
Speaker 1kind of stuff, then I'm gonna link ham in arm with them and we can we can discuss how real their God is. Over beers once fascism is dead.
Speaker 2So yeah, yeah.
Speaker 1And there is one other thing that I would like to say as a corollary to that question about are you having a conversation or are you having a fight. What I don't want to encourage anyone who's getting involved with them with this, and yourself is to is you don't have to be a doormat either. If someone is acting the Fall and he's saying heinous shit, I don't think it's rude of us to match their energy and and and take them down a rongo two verbally, because again,
Speaker 1a lot of these people bad actors prey on are tolerance. They want they want to come up say all their heinous crap and get away with it. And I don't think that we should be expected to be meek and polite and not push back.
Speaker 2I had I.
Speaker 3Had a guy come up Mama Bash's life today and that the prompt was, you know, are you trustworthy?
Speaker 2You know as a Christian?
Speaker 3Right basically right like, and I don't even understand how we got to this topic, but he basically confessed that he slept with his girlfriend's daughter, and I.
Speaker 2Was like, excuse me, what?
Speaker 3And I know that was said to get a reaction right, like, sorry, I'm sorry.
Speaker 2The topic was did Jesus die to free you from sin? Or make sin free?
Speaker 3And again, I don't even know how we got onto the fact that he slept with his girlfriend's daughter and her being twenty five made it better. And I'm like, do you expect for me not to call you a predator? Do you expect for me, as an atheist to want to hear you out? And he did it as a Christian? Guys?
Speaker 2How about that?
Speaker 1Yeah?
Speaker 3And how am I supposed to look at you as an example? Are you know what I'm saying? Like, is this what your religion is about? Being forgiven for doing something heinous like this?
Speaker 4I think he's most interpreting what Christian love means.
Speaker 3Right?
Speaker 2That's so gross? Yeah.
Speaker 1And the thing is is that one of the problems that we have with these conversations and again, if you want to have a conversation with us, do do you give us a call? Our lines are still open, is that when you start getting into the religious texts and and what what the baggage that comes with being a Christian or a Muslim or Jewish, you're having people then having to defend stuff like slavery and genocide, and it's
Speaker 1like and some of the mental gymnastics, the sort of mental backflips they have to do to go no, no, no, no, God's good and Jesus is good and stuff forget. But the slavery thing was, it was it was a style of the time, you know, And so really and really can make can make good people bad and bad people worse in lots of ways. And because the justification and what were you saying anything about it on that one's you.
Speaker 2Know, no, I was saying absolutely, like I I agree with you.
Speaker 3There's a question that we often run about what you're going to do in the day of the Lord every single time, Oh, I'm going to be with God. I'm going to be in the army of the Lord. Oh so you're going to be pillaging and and doing all these things. And then they have to sit and think. But yeah, I agree with you, because of course, in reality, they would never harm somebody. They're not going to come
Speaker 3into my house and hurt my son and you know, do things to me.
Speaker 2They're not going to do that.
Speaker 3But God is what you imagine him to be, and he's always going to have a good reason for it right, and that reason makes you an untrustworthy person, makes you kind of scary.
Speaker 1Yeah, I mean it doesn't help their optics when not a day goes by where we don't hear youth pastor jail for heinous thing, you know, clergyman found with illicit person. You know, just the headlines that keep on coming out. It is difficult to trust religious people these days. It used to be back back in the day that you would trust your priest or whatever, because it wasn't so obvious.
Speaker 1It wasn't so clear that these organizations have corruption running through them, shut through them. Even though it was kind of like known, it wasn't quite as obvious. I also find find it's similar with the police. I have trust, I have trust issues with the police these days. It used to be when I was a kid, it's like, well, your local bob, your local bobby down a corner, and your local priest, they will be nice to you. You can trust them. They're trustworthy guys. They were not trustworthy guys.
Speaker 1So I mean, how how would you suggest that, uh, these people could build trust? I mean, is there anything that they can do now to make religion feel like it should be trusted?
Speaker 2Burn the Bible.
Speaker 3But you know, and I'll say, this is where it would be very hard for me to trust somebody who looks in a book and sees where God is literally talking about Israel as a previous us in child and saying.
Speaker 2That's a great leader.
Speaker 3You should follow them, Like I would have to ask them, do you hold like is this true to you?
Speaker 2Right?
Speaker 3Do you use it as perhaps you know, a guide for your life?
Speaker 2Right?
Speaker 3Maybe there's some things to hear that you you know, you know, choose me, spit the bones out type deal, right, And I could possibly write deal with somebody like that. But somebody who one hundred and ten percent believes that a snake was slithering around talking in the garden seduced a woman to eat an apple, and that's why we're all screwed. Like I can't trust somebody who's mind.
Speaker 4Wait, wait, are you telling me that didn't happen?
Speaker 3You know, not not in this reality if you kind of go to the spiritual round, you know, metaphysically, you know, because that's what we get.
Speaker 2Like, I'm just like.
Speaker 3Want to talk about but yeah, like that's such a great question, because Jamie, I've asked before, like can atheists and Christians sit down at a table together and solve the world's solutions, I mean problems.
Speaker 2And it does.
Speaker 3Come down to what I'm talking about right here, what do you hold to be true?
Speaker 2Are we sharing the same reality? Or are you living and never never land?
Speaker 3And this book is it's so harmful and it's kind of to what we were talking about earlier, just with people of color and black people. It's specifically been detrimental to me personally, right, And if you're going to take something like this and say that, yep, it happened, yep, my God is real, Yep, I'll do anything for him as soon as.
Speaker 2We finish this, you know, hurdle, go over this hurdle.
Speaker 3You might just stab me in the back for the that I just you know, that didn't help us overcome you needed need to do that, and.
Speaker 2Now you're back at it.
Speaker 3So it's so hard, and I think it's just on an individual basis, right, an individual level.
Speaker 1And obviously and clearly and justifiably you have beef with Christianity specifically, and you know, burn the Bible. As hilarious as the thought is, you know, it is such a harmful book or collection of books do you think, though, and again this is not like this is a completely open question for both of you, that religion of any kind, be it, even if it's not Christianity, does it? Does
Speaker 1religion at all have a place in a future or should we be trying for complete secularity like no religions of any kind?
Speaker 4I don't think it does. I have not seen a religion yet there wasn't a result of bad thinking. And I'm including some of the New Age religions too, and I often get kicked back on that. Well, I don't see any wickens killing people. Well, Christians didn't kill anybody for the first four hundred Jersey either, So you know, I.
Speaker 1I think what it was put to me as and and let me know what you think about this guy, is that religion is inherently dishonest because it almost always hinges on a on an unprovable fiction that is held as truth, be it some guy who was holy, or some event that happened, or some metaphysical confluence of events
Speaker 1that we hold the sacred but cannot prove cannot prove to be true. So do you think that that there's just an inherent dishonesty in all religion and is that is that it's achilles heel.
Speaker 4Not to me. I'm sorry to see I should have let you go first. I don't I see dishonesty. I'm not sure if I see it in the same place, though. I think the dishonesty is that, to me, religion is based on a promise, right, and it's a promise that can that we can't. We don't know if it can ever be kept because it's a promise about what happens after we die. And I have not met a single person that has die jet and come back. You know. People say they have nds all the time, but those are near death experiences. They're not dead, right, They're just
Speaker 4all moss fed. So yeah, I don't. I think that's where the inherent dishonesty is, is that they're promising something they can't they can't give.
Speaker 1What's your thoughts on it? So you now, we do have a call currently being screened, but I would like to get your thoughts on this dishonesty and religion before we move forward.
Speaker 3Yeah, I totally agree with you guys. You have to be able to manipulate people in order for them to feed it into whatever you're talking about. And if it's coming out of your brain, right, it's not something objective, right that you know when if we're not here or not, it still remains true.
Speaker 2Like, I think there's something kind of icky about that.
Speaker 3It inherently so when it comes to any religion, I always ask what's the motivation behind this?
Speaker 2Who's benefiting from this? Right? But yeah, no, I agree with what you guys said.
Speaker 4That's a really good question. At I wish more conspiracy theorists would ask that question, get the motive behind this conspiracy?
Speaker 1Yeah, who benefits? Well, it looks like we have someone waiting to call, and I don't want to have been actually screened yet, but I might try and bring them in. Sarah from Indiana wants to talk about irrational beliefs with us, So I'm going to hit the talk button and hopefully this will work. Can you hear Sarah?
Speaker 5Hello?
Speaker 1Hi? Hey, right, Oh, so you're on with the Jamie, Zeena and Kelly. So what's on your mind?
Speaker 6Well, I was just thinking about what you guys were talking about earlier in the show about irrational beliefs that you hold and yeah, everything. I was like, I've got one that I sort of hold, but not really I thought it might be interesting to talk to you.
Speaker 4Guys about, So go ahead.
Speaker 6I like the idea that like all the natural parts of the earth are like connected and like communicate with each other. And I guess in one way they kind of do, right, Like they you know, there's like networks of trees and mushrooms and you know how ecosystems work and stuff. But I don't know. I guess there's a part of me that's like, oh, it would be cool if there was like this I don't know, supernatural.
Speaker 4Sort of like a consciousness of nature as a whole.
Speaker 6I think that would be really.
Speaker 3That way.
Speaker 6That way it can be like, oh, hey, hey, trees, other trees. I don't like what these people are doing. You know.
Speaker 1I'm kind of like more of the.
Speaker 6Rings and type of situation, you know, just like when I have like a fighting chance to fight back. You know what.
Speaker 1While while we could like going to like picking like picking a belief apart, my main thought and my main question for you, Sarah is why would assuming that you would like it to be the case that that this panpsychism kind of thing happens, that the nature is a communicative thing, why would you want that to be the case.
Speaker 6It would just be it would make me feel better about like the condition of the earth since us humans are not very kind to it, you know, and we all, you know, all the climate change is mostly nthropogenic right now? Where where the we're the problem right where? And it's it's mostly like large industries and capitalism and that whole package, you know, and having a feeling of sorry.
Speaker 4I was going to ask if you think part of that is like being overwhelmed by it. I mean, like like you and I as individuals, we can't really fight back against these corporations that are destroying and so I mean when we get this idea of like nature having this consciousness and being able to fight back on its own, is that just you know, like I guess hopeful hopeful thinking for.
Speaker 6Absolutely, Oh yeah, that would That's definitely it Where it's like, you know, as an individual or as like my family, you know, there's only so much we can do to like, you know, do our share and try to encourage others to you know, make environmentally friendly choices. But you know, at the end of the day, it's like what a what a beast to try to fight as a as a person, right So here's.
Speaker 1Question, here's a question that's popping up on mine. I don't like to get your take on this as well as in a the it sounds Sarah like you are you wouldn't mind engaging in a little bit of of h of this irrational thinking or thing as as a way to encourage people to do better. I'd be more environmentally conscious that kind of thing. Do any of us think that it should ever be justified? Two deal in half truths or fantasies or irrationalities in the pursuit of
Speaker 1of of a higher purpose? What do you all think?
Speaker 4Are you asking if the ends justifies them?
Speaker 2Yeah?
Speaker 1Ends justify the means? I mean, do you think do you think it would be a pro to to engage in that for a higher purpose?
Speaker 2What would be the higher purpose?
Speaker 1Like, well, in this example, it's it's a more and more conscientious environmentalism brought about by convincing, perhaps convincing people that yes, the Earth is like a conscious being that you can communicate with in it, and that being bad to the environment is quintessentially harming a creature. You are you are injuring the planet by being by not being environmentally conscious, even though these are concepts we can't really prove.
Speaker 4It's just going back forward. We were just talking what we started talking about though, you know, like spreading bad thinking, bad thought, right, and all that's going to do is just nurture more bad thinking.
Speaker 6Right.
Speaker 3That's something outside of you has control, and I think that just makes people feel better.
Speaker 5It.
Speaker 3It reminds me of I hate to say it, but God, right, you know that something outside of us can control this environment that we all share and live in.
Speaker 2But we know that's not reality. So I do think that might.
Speaker 3Kind of lead to like dangerous thinking, and it could lead to like a cult leader saying they can communicate with such thing, right, they can make it bend to its own will?
Speaker 2And what would be the benefit for something like that? Right? You know?
Speaker 3It reminds me of Also, what is that movie with the Pandora planet.
Speaker 2Avatar?
Speaker 3Yeah, and how so many people were happy to see Iowa or I think it was its name, But it's like, what was IWA doing when people were getting like mirked all over the place?
Speaker 1Right?
Speaker 2You know?
Speaker 3And I don't know, giving consciousness to something like that, it feels like it takes the responsibility away from us as humans onto something else.
Speaker 2I don't know.
Speaker 1Yeahs of point, what do you think? What do you think about that sort of aspect and serah of your thoughts?
Speaker 6Yeah, I definitely agree. I mean, any any kind of belief that isn't verifiable or you know, doesn't isn't actually tied to reality, it does more harm than good. That's my opinion at least. And so yeah, especially with the idea of it would put that a lot of people could then put the onus on the others, right, So it's like, oh, well, there will take care of themselves. It's fine. It's like, exactly, you can't do that. So yeah,
Speaker 6it's it's not really a belief I have. It's just something that everyone's in. Why I think, Man, I wish every other, say, living thing on this planet outside of.
Speaker 4It's it's more like you want to have And I understand that. I fully understand that, because that's if I want to have to, I really do.
Speaker 1We're not we're not we're not the whimsy police here. We're not trying to the harsh people's mellow. But the other thing, the other aspect that comes to mind when it when it comes to like trying to convince people to do things, even good things, by using fantasy or using using irrationality or lies, is that if something isn't founded in reality, it can potentially be debunked and shown to be false. And I'm sure you've had conversations with
Speaker 1people about Zena and Kelly definitely has. When someone's worldview breaks and they have to deconstruct from this fantasy, that's trauma. That's hard core trauma. We've heard stories upon stories of people who realize that their religion is no longer a viable thing or true thing, but there's so much wrapped up in it that it's that it's a the whole organizations recovering from religion, for example, that exist solely to
Speaker 1help people through that trauma. So yeah, I would, I would definitely comment on that. So anything else on your mind, Sarah while we have you?
Speaker 6Oh no, thought that was fun? Fun thoughts? Maybe?
Speaker 1Yeah, thoughts? Well, I said, we're not going to try and take him away from anybody as long as we, as I say, have the introspection to know that we are just being a little bit silly, and that's fine, right, So I'll let you go and thank you very much for your call.
Speaker 6Thank you all so much.
Speaker 1Prop I was very nice, very nice indeed, But yeah, I mean I always feel a little bit. I been called a killjoy many times now by people, ever since I started really getting into the whole anti apologetics thing and and fighting against the rationality because a lot of my family are very well, they're all like hippies and ravers, so they're all very varying flavors of oh, wouldn't it
Speaker 1be nicey if? Or wouldn't it be great if? And on the one hand, I'm like, yeah, it would be lovely if you could talk to protons or whatever, but you can't let us have our fun. And I'm like, is it?
Speaker 4Is it?
Speaker 5Though?
Speaker 1Because you seem to be going a little bit too far in my mind?
Speaker 3And don't you think that's like how religions are started? Like I know she's joking, right, but that's literally how like religions are started.
Speaker 2Like what if I can't speak to.
Speaker 3The deer that's running in the forest and tell it to go left and right in whatever way I want?
Speaker 2What if I claim that I do have that ability.
Speaker 3Right, like you know, and then you get somebody else to do it, and then you convince somebody else that they could do it and if another person can't do it, oh, you're just not the chosen one. You're not a part of the chosen people. You're not special, you know. So busting that bubble might be saving the world, Jamie, I.
Speaker 1Don't know, you might be helping us out. Oh I'm no savior. Oh not at all, not at all. But what we do try and do here is just trying engender better thinking without harshing people's male or if we possibly can help it. So yeah, again, Sarah was a very pleasant call, and if anyone else wants to call up, and then we are here with open lines still. I think we've got a little bit of time left. But while we are having this little repose, pardon me just
Speaker 1mentioning again that this is a fundraiser we are doing. We have been streaming since six pm yesterday and we will be continuing to stream all the way to six pm today, rounding out the twenty four hour live stream event with the Atheist Experience, which will be coming up after this show. So, if you want to donate, you can do so either by scanning the QR code that's on the screen. You can go to the link in the description donate through Zephi, and if you do donate, then your name will flash up with your message on
Speaker 1the ticket at the bottom of the screen, and then.
Speaker 4And I will be very very grateful.
Speaker 1Yes, yes, we are well. We literally can't do what we do without the contributions of the public. We you know, we have our normal sort of vectors of giving. You know, we have our patreons and the like, and what little pittance we can get from YouTube these days, but these kinds of these generous acts from people really do keep us going. And as a charity, as a five zero one c three, our community is our lifeblood. Like we
Speaker 1wouldn't be anything or anyone without your war. So everyone who's contributed from if it was one dollar, one hundred dollars, one thousand dollars, all of it is appreciated. All of it is going to go to good causes. We are very much shifting our paradigm from just a content creation organization to an outreach organization. We have got people in person, we've got boots on the ground doing actual good work in the often area and soon beyond. I'm extremely proud
Speaker 1to be part of it. It's some wonderful, wonderful people that have been working with us and we have had a bit of an influx of volunteers recently, so we want to keep that momentum going. So YEP, hopefully we'll be able to reach our target of twenty thousand dollars today. I don't know if I have our current donation titles. We'd cracked twelve thousand earlier today, but I don't know where we are right now, but we will have our
Speaker 1final total totted up at the end of the of the last year.
Speaker 4You mentioned volunteers, Jamie, and I just want to say I started volunteering with the ACA about five and a half years ago, and I've this has been the best, most wonderful, greatest group of people I have ever worked with in my life. And if you really want to do something fun on a Sunday, volunteer, because you will not regret it.
Speaker 1He's absolutely And we've been getting support from other organizations as well. We've been propped up by the American Humanists Association. That was a Fish Stark and his crew secularizing us SR down in the Tennessee. We've had Metroplex Atheists on. They're propping up the the fighting the good Fight over in Dallas Fort Worth area. We've got so so free
Speaker 1the Ontario, Canada, all the way up in the Great White North of free thinkers who have been supporting us as well. And this is one of the things we've been trying to do. We've been trying to get outreach and become part of a bigger thing. And what I'm being held I've been given a number. It is a big number. Our current total is twelve two hundred and
Speaker 1seventy three dollars, which is fan freak fantastic. You could buy a you could buy a lightly you a lightly use jetter for that, but every single bottle of that has come from a very generous donation. There are not enough words to thank everyone for their generosity with that, and mate continue to be so the stream ain't over yet.
Speaker 4I was about to say the best thing about that is is that there's still enough time to make it to.
Speaker 1Twenty thoive Sky's the limit, Baby Sky is the limit.
Speaker 2This is such a great community.
Speaker 3Like I was watching last night with Justin, Sarah and Thinker, and it was a blast with those games that were being played.
Speaker 2They were hilarious. I think Sarah had like the Jesus blesh. It was like the blood of.
Speaker 3Jesus bleshing thinker had the anointing oil. I forgot what Justin had, but it was so funny. I was cracking up. So Yes, definitely, definitely, definitely love the community.
Speaker 1Yeah, comedy is something that we're trying to inject. We try and inject a little bit into some of the work that we do because it's I've found it's very easy to take yourself too seriously when you're when you're doing something you feel is you know, important. And as much as we can admire those that have come before us, though some of them have kind of gone off the deep end a little bit, and I'm talking about you, Dawkins, they were very sort of stodgy like Stantorian guys, glowering
Speaker 1down from a stage and being very self serious about certain things. And I think it humanizes us to be seen as a little bit silly and a little bit a little bit funny, because it means that we're human and h and that's that's that's what I'd like to portray to.
Speaker 4You.
Speaker 2Got start rules.
Speaker 1I am an ambulatory mushroom, but but the I think and again and feel free to disagree with me or agree with me. You guys that I'd like for believers to find me approachable. I want to have these conversations with you about your faith and about rational thoughts. I mean, do you do you have any specific thoughts or technique
Speaker 1Xena on being an approachable person on encouraging people to interact with him.
Speaker 2Yeah, Like.
Speaker 3I usually start off as like, I think we kind of touched this earlier, Jamie. I'm not your enemy. I don't want to take this from you. I understand how impactful it has been in your life. I don't want to hurt harm you in that way. I just want to sit down, grab some tea, and let's just chat. Let's just you know, it's just us getting to know each other, right, us exploring this world that we share
Speaker 3together through your lens. And I think when I give them the ball, Like, the best conversations I've ever had is when I just shut up and I give them the ball to say what they want to say, and I take notes and then I go back and I empathize.
Speaker 2I say, you know what, I've never ridden a horse.
Speaker 3But I can imagine how that can feel, right, to have a powerful animal, you know, surrender to you and to obey you and to be in sync with you is something that must feel a little magical, right, Like I want them to know that I'm present and I'm listening to what they're saying. When you when you do that for somebody, it disarms them. It lets them know that, Okay, maybe they can have the conversation with me, you know,
Speaker 3But sometimes I curse.
Speaker 1Oh, it's necessary sometimes, and I am actually of the opinion it's sometimes an unpopular way of going about things. But even if a person is talking completely out of their ass, I would prefer to let them talk a little bit at least, because either I'll find some understanding and what they're saying, or they'll just be laying out enough rope to hang themselves with. Basically, because when you call into one of these shows, if you are espousing
Speaker 1some harmful rhetoric, if you are trying to like defend Bible slavery for example, or whatever, or no, it wasn't too about being at and Amalachi. I'm sure it was fine, had that very very bad day, but really and the goat. But but if I can either find some understanding, but
Speaker 1I think that the words speak for themselves and the kinds of people that watch these shows are not going to be convinced by you by your rhetoric. So, and the way that I say is, if I can't make a connection, I'll make an example. Yeah, pardon me, I'm slowly falling apart here, pardon me. But yeah. So, Also, all that to say is that I just hope that people keep calling in, and I hope the believers keep
Speaker 1calling in with the thought that we want to have a conversation first rather than a fight, and that I am generally a friendly person, like I want to hear your story. I'm not just here to try and browbeat you, and I'm not here to definitely not here to make myself look clever. For goodness sake, I think we need to sometimes take our ego out of it. The mission is bigger than the person.
Speaker 3Yeah, yeah, big time, big time. I think sorry about that. I think that is one hundred percent truth.
Speaker 2I think that.
Speaker 3I think demeaning somebody is never a good way to get them to open that door. You know, I may feel like I know exactly what you're talking about. I'm better than you, I what what happened, But you're never going to have that open conversation you desire where they can talk about their irrational thought and you can actually break it down, like you said Jamie and Kelly, and you can bring them to the shared reality versus Narnia
Speaker 3that they're living in.
Speaker 2Right. There is no language in a wardrobe.
Speaker 3It's just you know what I say, in a war that's happening in English, there's nothing.
Speaker 2There's nothing like that happening.
Speaker 1Right.
Speaker 3But it's so hard when they've not met anybody like you. Until I came to TikTok, I did not realize that there was more than five atheists in the world. I'm not gonna hold you. I didn't realize that. I didn't know that. I was just like, dude, it's so rare. But then I came across Live after Live after Live after Live.
Speaker 1And it grew indeed, And I mean I of course, I grew up in a more sort of secular society, and a lot of my friends and family were either not believer as in God or had left faith, and so atheism wasn't as alien to me as it otherwise would have been. But the religiosity of America was a bit of a stunner. It was kind of like a culture shock when I moved here to see it everywhere?
Speaker 2And when did you move from jamis?
Speaker 1I am originally from Birmingham in England, and so I've been in Texas for ten years and there's just certain things that I'm probably never going to get used to, and like taxis.
Speaker 6Right, and.
Speaker 1I just can't get rid of all this brisket anyway.
Speaker 2Is the best part.
Speaker 1Yes, it is one of the It's one of the things I would miss if I ever moved back to England. I wouldn't miss the healthcare system, but I definitely missed the burnt ends. But we have another caller getting rigged up. Let me just see here specifically to ask Zena a question. So AG three three seven wanted to ask a question about non believers and then reading the Bible, So I'll bring them up. Hello, can you hear us?
Speaker 2I can hear you. How are you?
Speaker 1I'm doing alright? So go ahead ask you a question.
Speaker 5Hey, Xena, Hey everybody, but I have a question for you. Do you find it difficult when you're talking to Christians and believers that have not read their Holy Book and when you point out something that they've never seen before, then they want to try and turn around and explain it to you.
Speaker 2Uh, excellent question. Yes and no, And here's why.
Speaker 3Do I think that it's absolutely bonkers to join a cult that you don't know about? Yes, given, but I can I can definitely give grace to people who say, you know, hey.
Speaker 2I haven't read this book. I you know, this is what I was born into.
Speaker 3You know what I mean, This is just what my family believed, my grandma's grandma's grandma.
Speaker 2The annoying side.
Speaker 3To this is when they pretend that they have read the book and they try to correct me on what I know and what I myself have read and researched. Right, that's the crappy part to me. That's the part where like, Okay, now I'm about to get into your ass because you can't tell me that you don't see contradictions or that you know Jesus is all loving or God is all merciful,
Speaker 3and that's just not what's exemplified. So to your question, it can be super jarring. If you've ever seen me on TikTok, you know that, Like, I don't have patience for things like that, like because I'm here to learn if you can teach me something about this book, teach me. But if you haven't cracked it open, and now you're trying to indoctrinate your children off of what a pastor says.
Speaker 2Absolutely not, I don't.
Speaker 5No, absolutely yeah, I agree and you know, yeah, we watch you all the time, so you rock. Thank you.
Speaker 1All right, thank you you too?
Speaker 2Man.
Speaker 1Absolutely love. I know they lovely caller and a lovely one to uh to round us out on and I'm just gonna get back down.
Speaker 4You'll go.
Speaker 1We a lovely, lovely thing. And yes, it is crazy when people I mean, I haven't read all the Bible yet, I'm trying. It's a very it's a very dry book.
Speaker 4It's really tough.
Speaker 1But when people, yeah, believe in something without having it's like it's like owning a car and not reading the instruction manual. I mean, how far are you going to get?
Speaker 4Uh?
Speaker 1And they get blindsided. It's weird to see someone get blindsided by something that's in their Holy Book that I obviously wouldn't agree with because they just never they have never encountered it. It's a strange thing to see. But I think with that we may be winding this little segment down. But don't go anywhere because we have upcoming shows to complete the live stream. We've only got a few hours left of our fundraisers to go. We are
Speaker 1fundraising not only for the atheist community of Boston, but also for so Free up in Canada. So if you don't feel comfortable with your money going to an American organization right now, we have some lovely Canadians also benefiting and so get your donations in at Zephi or at the link below. I would very much like to thank you Zena for coming on. I'm hoping we'll see more of you and tell the good people again where they can find you.
Speaker 3Yes, so you can find me on TikTok as Zena made Graham Baby shout out to my Grandma. You can also find me on YouTube's innovat point two. I'm working on Instagram and whatnot. But those are my two socials that I.
Speaker 2Have right now.
Speaker 1Fantastic, fantastic, and thank you again for sort of backup slash co hosting with us. Kelly. Always a pleasure to have you well with your magnificent tie collection.
Speaker 4Thanks for having me up it was it was a real pleasure of meeting you. Today's you know it's awesome. I had a really good time hanging out with you.
Speaker 1Yep. So in lieu of any ops coming up to get open in our faces, we had some lovely, lovely little chats with a couple of callers, And that just leads me to say thank you for watching Truth Wanted at its new slot time. Now come back next week for more and as ever, don't stop wanting the truth.
Speaker 1M Watch talk Ethan live Sundays at one pm Central. Visit tiny dot c c slash y t t H and call into the show at five one two nine
Speaker 1nine one nine two four two, or connect to the show online at tiny dot c c slash call th H
In today's episode of Truth Wanted, ObjectivelyDan welcomes guest Out Of Body Atheist, with The Beard of Empathy on backup, to dig into Reiki, New Age spirituality, homeopathy, and the long road from woo to skepticism!...
In today's episode of Truth Wanted, Jon the Skeptick, Volcy, and Sofia Spina explain why no one can talk to the dead, from Haitian Vodou and grief dreams to Jon's past as a spiritualist! Bob jumps from objective...
In today's episode of Truth Wanted, ObjectivelyDan and Nintendrew, later joined by The Beard of Empathy, tackle a world run on Jesus, the magic of manifesting, and a prayer that actually got answered! Bob in NY, a...
In today's episode of Truth Wanted, ObjectivelyDan, Kelley Laughlin, and The Beard of Empathy tackle standards of evidence, miracle claims, and the false binaries of moral philosophy! Dean in VA questions why skeptics...
In today's episode of Truth Wanted, ObjectivelyDan and Chad Harris tackle Christian nationalism, police brutality, and the uncomfortable truths about racism and immigration. Big E in TN survived police brutality and...