Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

True Crime Conversations

True Crime Conversations artwork

Anastasia Was Left Unable To Sit. Her Attacker Didn’t Spend A Single Night In A Cell.

Oct 28, 20261 hr 30 minAudio
  • Apple Podcasts
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

In July 2026, Anastasia Treharne sat in a Sydney courtroom waiting to hear her rapist’s sentence. She had been through a gruelling trial and cross-examined at length, and a jury had found him guilty. The maximum penalty was 14 years in prison. Instead, he was given a three-year community corrections order and 100 hours of community service. He won’t spend a single night behind bars. It wasn’t the first time Anastasia had faced the court system. She was also sexually assaulted at 16, and the two cases played out in very different ways. In this episode, Anastasia tells Gemma about both experiences, from her first assault as a teenager to the sentence she believes is grossly inadequate. She also explains why she refuses to go quietly, and how she is fighting to make sure no one else is let down the way she was. Visit The Echo Campaign's website here. GET IN TOUCH Follow us on Instagram and TikTok @truecrimeconversations Want us to cover a case on the podcast? Email us at truecrime@mamamia.com.au or send us a voice note. MAMAMIA OFFERS: Get access to Very Peri, Mamamia's exclusive perimenopause series, for just $59. 25 world-leading experts, over 20 on-demand sessions, available now. We’ve sorted through the noise so you don't have to. Go to veryperi.com.au today. You hot? Same. Make sure to leave us a rating and review on Apple & Spotify to let us know how you're liking the episodes. CREDITS Host & Executive Producer: Gemma Bath Guests: Anastasia Treharne Produced by Ella Maitland Video Editor: Lisa Chen Mamamia acknowledges the traditional owners of the land on which we have recorded this podcast. Become a Mamamia subscriber: https://www.mamamia.com.au/subscribe

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Speaker 1Anastasia Trahan sits quietly on a cold wooden pew in Sydney's Downing Court. It's July 2026 and her rapist is finally being sentenced today. She sat through a gruelling trial where she was cross-examined at length about the assault that left her unable to walk or sit. A jury found him guilty of one count of rape. The maximum jail sentence he can face is 14 years. But as Judge Justin Smith SC starts to deliver his punishment, Anastasia can't

Speaker 1hold back the tears. A three-year community corrections order and 100 hours of community service, aka not a single night in prison. Anastasia is in shock. How can that be it? The disappointment, the betrayal, the anger, it all feels too much. She lets herself feel all the feels and then she composes herself. This court, this system, this rapist don't know

Speaker 1who they're dealing with. She will not go quietly. I'm Gemma Bath and you're listening to True Crime Conversations, a podcast exploring the world's most notorious crimes by speaking to the people who know the most about them. The judge pointed out that Justin Downs' housemate, who was home at the time, didn't hear any screaming or crying. He pointed

Speaker 1out that the offence wasn't planned. He pointed out that the perpetrator had lost his business and that his mental health had been impacted. The only factor that weighs against him, Judge Smith continued, is his lack of remorse. The criminal justice system is a bizarre world. For Anastasia... The night she was raped by this man has left her devastated. But to a judge, what happened to her was on the lower end of the scale in terms of seriousness.

Speaker 1It's the cruel, brutal reality of court. But Anastasia doesn't accept the sentence that was given to her rapist. She thinks it was grossly inadequate and she wants the world to know what she thinks. She's been let down by our justice system. She's determined to make sure other people don't experience what she did. This is her story. Just a note, Anastasia has unfortunately been through the court system twice.

Speaker 1Once for a sexual assault when she was 16. Once when she was raped as a young woman. Her experience going to trial was vastly different in both cases. We open this chat with her first assault. Anastasia, thank you for joining us on True Crime Conversations. I want to start with your childhood. How did you grow up? Did you grow up in a safe, loving home?

Speaker 2Yeah, it was honestly the absolute best. We lived with my grandparents and my mum and my dad, my brother, and had just really everything that you can imagine as a normal childhood. I was dancing, playing netball, going to school, every after school activity possible. Yeah, it was just a very supportive environment.

Speaker 1Take me to 16-year-old Anastasia. Who was your best friend and what did that relationship look like? Obviously, 16, you know, you're often going over to each other's houses. Were you going on sleepovers a lot? Paint the picture for us.

Speaker 2Yeah, I think throughout my whole childhood, I was going to a lot of sleepovers. I absolutely loved it. I mean, there's the whole joke of let's do a dance for our parents and see if they'll allow us. And I think with my cousins, I had a couple of core best friends from very young, from preschool that I constantly slept over at. My best friend at the time, I met her in year seven. And I was there like every second weekend at her house. And she'd stay at

Speaker 2mine a bit, but we were there a lot. She lived near Macquarie Centre. So we'd like go get our nails done and then go back to hers, go back to the food court, then go back to hers. So yeah, I was there a lot when I was younger.

Speaker 1Were her parents together? Were you at her mum's house, her dad's house? How did it work?

Speaker 2Her parents weren't together. I'd see her mum a bit, but we stayed at her dad's house. Okay.

Speaker 1So when did something change? Was it after you'd been going to sleep over there for a while?

Speaker 2Yeah. I mean, I'd been sleeping over there for years.

Speaker 1Wow.

Speaker 2Okay. It was the first time I'd slept over since I'd turned 16. And yeah, I'd just turned 16. It was... or maybe about three weeks earlier, but it was the first time, my birthday's on Christmas day and it was the 19th of January. So that was the first time I'd been over since. Um, and that's when things completely changed.

Speaker 1What was, cause it was her father.

Speaker 2Yes.

Speaker 1What was her father like with you prior to this?

Speaker 2I mean, he completely normal. He was friends with my mum. He adopted a cat from us. We used to foster cats. Um, Yeah, I think my mum was actually really, really, her trust was so incredibly broken because she saw him as essentially a friend.

Speaker 1As much as you feel comfortable, what can you tell us about that first time when he did assault you?

Speaker 2My best friend was actually in the room. We were sleeping in the lounge room and he leant over the couch and assaulted me and then was trying to convince me to go to his bedroom. And Grace, my friend, was yelling, stop, get off her. And I just remember crawling up into a little wall because he'd already tried to do that earlier in the night. He tried to come over the back of the couch because the couch was kind of facing outwards to the dining room. And

Speaker 2he tried to come over and smack my butt a few times. And so I was like crawled up into a little ball, hoping that like no part of me could be touched and like the most protected. And then I woke up to him coming over again. And then that's when the assault happened. And then I just remember saying to Grace, I just got to go outside and clear my head. And I called the police and I texted her and I said, I'm so sorry. I called the police and she said, that's so fine. I'm coming out now.

Speaker 1Really?

Speaker 2Yeah. Yeah.

Speaker 1So she was asleep?

Speaker 2Yeah, I think she was asleep. I've never read her statement. I've never heard her evidence. But from what I assume, she was asleep.

Speaker 1But for you to... So immediately you walked outside, you called the police?

Speaker 2Yes.

Speaker 1Do you think that that's... Because that's a big thing for a 16-year-old to do, in the home of her best friend, something's just happened.

Speaker 2Yes.

Speaker 1Was there no question in your brain, like, I am calling the police?

Speaker 2Yeah, I think, I mean, that's how I was raised. I think I've always had, to my detriment, a justice complex. When I was younger, my mum used to just be so irritated by it because everything had to be correct and everything had to be just. But I think at that point, I wanted to be a cop already. I wanted to be a detective before it happened. So I had a very strong sense of where I fit in the world and what that looked like. And even before that, I wanted to be a human rights lawyer. So I think for me, that was just what you do and

Speaker 2that's what happens.

Speaker 1You had a strong sense of right and wrong.

Speaker 2Yeah. I'm annoyed that I didn't do something sooner, but I also think, unfortunately, nothing would have really come from him just smacking my butt. So I think I knew that wasn't right and I felt very uncomfortable and I felt paralysed. But something clicked in me as soon as it happened. I just knew I had to get outside. And then as soon as I was outside, I made the phone call to, I believe it was Hornsby police, because that was my local police. And the guy that

Speaker 2answered said, you need to hang up right now and call triple zero. Triple zero felt like a huge commitment that felt like something reserved for someone that was actively unsafe, which obviously I was.

Speaker 1You were.

Speaker 2But in my head, I wasn't dying on the side of the road in a car accident. So therefore, you know, I'd just ring the local police. They'd come to my school before. I'd spoken to them before. So it was a relatable body of people that I could sort of come to. And unfortunately, local police station calls aren't recorded. So that's what is really important about calling triple zero. So fast forward later, my triple zero call doesn't really embody the entire situation because I'd kind of already burst

Speaker 2into tears already. come clean about a lot of things on that other phone call. And I just wanted the police there at that point. But that cop actually did, he was about to retire. He did end up testifying for me saying what I did say. So yeah, I think I knew that I needed to call the police. I knew that I needed help. I don't know why I necessarily knew that. I don't think anyone ever outright told me that. I think that was just, I was very fortunate to grow up with such trust in the police. And I know that that's also not everyone's case.

Speaker 1After you called triple zero, did you wait at the property or did you leave?

Speaker 2I was outside. So it was a big apartment complex that I knew very well. And so I was kind of like on the other side of the pool wall. So if he'd walked out, he probably wouldn't have seen me where I was. My friend had come out and was waiting with me and we were sitting on this little concrete block waiting for them. And they came quite quickly and it was a lot of police cars that rocked up. I remember it's a cul-de-sac and it was just like, I reckon it was like five cars. And cops were just everywhere. And they were asking, like, is he still in there? You know, what's going on? We all whisked away into a normal police car rather than,

Speaker 2you know, obviously. I remember thinking, like, are they going to put me in one with Cage? No. Are they the only police cars that they have? In my head, that's what the case was. And they drove us to a street around the corner and we just waited. until they had gone inside to get him.

Speaker 1So they arrested him?

Speaker 2Yeah, right then and there.

Speaker 1Right then and there? Yeah. What happened next? Did you have to go and give statements straight away?

Speaker 2Yeah, we ended up waiting a while actually because it must have taken them a long time to go and get him. I think I just told the police like briefly, essentially to their body cams, what had happened when they arrived in the cul-de-sac. And then when we got into the other car, we stopped speaking about it. It was a lovely police officer and he started talking to us about our cats and, you know, I think it was distracting us. And purposefully there was no discussion about what had happened because it wasn't a formal situation. Yeah. And then we went back to Eastwood Police Station and the

Speaker 2perpetrator was taken to Ryde. Um, and then they called my parents and I started, um, speaking to them pretty much straight away. There was a probationary constable and she was the only female on. So she was fresh out of the academy. Um, and I actually really want to somehow get in contact with her because the poor thing, I think she was younger than what I am now. Um, and she literally would have just graduated, probably no uni degree and having to deal with, with this. And it was her first one. She'd never dealt with it before. I didn't want any males in the room.

Speaker 1So she interviewed you?

Speaker 2Yeah, she did from beginning to end. And then the detectives came in after, but she did it all. And she did such an incredible job. And they just said she just finished dancing to go to the academy. So in my head, as a dancer, she was probably 19.

Speaker 1But it sounds like you trusted her because she was.

Speaker 2Similar to you. Yeah, 100%. Yeah, absolutely. I think there were some very good cops there and as much as they would have done an incredible job, I think they were very clever in just making the call for her to do that. And ended up giving the statement. And then the detective came down. I think he was at Ride. I think they're at Ride. They're based there. So he drove down. I think my parents were there at that point. An ambulance had been called because I felt so sick.

Speaker 2And then the ambulance went. I wasn't taken to do a sake test.

Speaker 1That's a sexual assault test?

Speaker 2Invested to give kit, I think.

Speaker 1So they didn't do one of those?

Speaker 2No. Okay. And I remember my mum sitting next to me and saying, does she need to go to the hospital? Because obviously at that point she didn't know the extent. She had no idea. And she was like, does she need to go to the hospital? And I remember being like, that's awfully dramatic. Like, calm down. But obviously she meant in the sense of a kit. But they did take my undies and my clothes straight away.

Speaker 1Do you think that was because of your age they didn't do one of those kits? Or why didn't they?

Speaker 2There was no penal penetration. Okay. So I think it was not at all deemed necessary for my age. I think from the get-go they also saw what a competent witness I was. Okay. And I think that's why action was taken so quickly from the beginning. Yeah. I think if a 16-year-old's calling triple zero because of something, they know that this is going to go to court and that the DPP will take it. Um, so there was no concern of, you know, let's take you away from the situation. Let's investigate it. Then we'll arrest him. There

Speaker 2was just, we're going into arrest him.

Speaker 1It was also quick because I've unfortunately interviewed quite a few sexual assault survivors now, but all of them have gone to the police days, weeks, months after the fact. And it does seem that things move a bit slower. It's a bit harder because you were so immediate and it feels like the police were able to mobilise a bit quicker?

Speaker 2Yeah, I think so. I mean, in contrast, my second assault, I went to the police immediately and they didn't move as quickly. It was within context. But I think really I got some very good cops and I think they took me very seriously from the get-go. I also, my mum has always taught me to be so articulate and no language is off limits. You know, we don't call a vagina a flower, you know, anything like that. It's very particular. It's very, this happened and this is exactly

Speaker 2what happened.

Speaker 1Yeah.

Speaker 2And I think from the get-go they saw that and were like, there's no doubt in our mind. But, yeah, I remember taking all of my clothes off and having to put them in evidence bags. Yeah. And his DNA was found on my underwear from what I remember, but they were Grace's underwear. So there's the potential that he's the one washing them. You know, so I think that kind of all got a bit skew-iffed. I remember three years later, I think it was, getting the call that

Speaker 2they were going to throw my clothes out. So if I wanted to come collect them, I needed to come get them now. It was so random. It was just a day. So I just got the bus to Gladesville. I don't know why they were being held at Gladesville and just got handed three evidence bags with the nuclear symbol on them.

Speaker 1That's random.

Speaker 2So random. And then I remember calling my mom crying, being like, can you come pick me up? Like, I don't want to get the bus home. You know, and I still have those bags. I just, I actually remember thinking at the time, you know, if I ever do want them to just say, hey, this is what I was wearing for whatever reason, whether or not that's like a protest, a piece of art, something, maybe even a dance, something like that, that I did want to have them, but they're still just sitting in. They're still sitting in the bags. In the evidence bags.

Speaker 1Can you take me back to that? night and how you felt because obviously you went from an assault straight into this completely foreign environment with police and sirens and evidence bags and your parents being called. What was that like as a 16 year old girl?

Speaker 2Um, I feel like I had already been through a lot to that point of my life. So it wasn't necessarily too shocking, but I'd never experienced the police in that sense. Um, I think it really wasn't that overwhelming purely because every single person at that station had my back. Every single person, all they cared about was my well-being. And I think that's a strong contrast to anyone else's experience. So I think I was absolutely a strong 16-year-old, but

Speaker 2I think I had every factor in my corner. And I can't fully take credit for that because it was just incredible, everyone who was around me. The detective came in and said, this is not just sexual touching without consent. This is sexual assault because he touched a certain part. And I said that in my statement, that he touched a certain part. And he said, I just need to clarify that that's the case because that changes this entirely.

Speaker 1It changes the charge.

Speaker 2It does, yeah. And I clarified it and he was like, yep, no problem. I just needed to know that. And he was the same detective from the beginning until even in my second assault. After my second assault, I reached out to him and he still spoke to me. So, you know, having the consistency of the one detective was incredible. When it went to the DPP after that, they said, do you want to take the plea deal, which was sexual touching without consent? And in order to take the plea deal, I had to change my state.

Speaker 1From assault to touching. I had to physically alter this.

Speaker 2But I had to physically alter the statement and say that did not occur. And I said, I'm not doing that.

Speaker 1Justice complex coming back in for the win.

Speaker 2And my mum said, I think you should take the plea deal. Really? Yeah, and the DPP were like, I think you should take the plea deal. And I said, absolutely not. Under no circumstances will I be doing that. If I have to change my statement, that's not the truth.

Speaker 1What was the plea deal on offer? Was he going to go to prison for it?

Speaker 2They don't necessarily bring in sentencing in plea deals in New South Wales, to my understanding. It was sexual touching without consent. And one of the biggest issues I had with it was he wouldn't go on the child sex offenders register. So for me, that was already, no, that's a lesser charge. Let's fight this. I'm ready to fight this. I think... they were very taken aback by that. They were like, are you sure? Like, I think you don't understand. That was kind of the vibe that I was getting that they just assumed I didn't understand. And they were like, you can think about it, go home and think about it.

Speaker 2And so then I was like, okay, cool. Went home, didn't think about it because I, well, I mean it did, but I knew what my decision was and it wasn't going to change, particularly if I had to actually alter my statement. Yeah. I'm not going to alter my statement. And that was the interesting thing of that. It wasn't even, we're going to take your decision into account. It was, I got to make that call purely because I'm the one that has to alter my statement. And I refused to alter my statement. So they had to go ahead.

Speaker 1So you went to trial. How long did you wait to go to trial?

Speaker 2We pre-recorded a year later, just over a year later, I believe. Okay. it was COVID. So the fact that it was such a short period of time within the justice system and during COVID. I think we pre-recorded October of 2019 and then the trial started March of 2020.

Speaker 1So tell me about pre-recording. Does that mean you didn't physically have to go to court?

Speaker 2No, you do go to court. I chose to testify in the room. Okay. So I wasn't in a separate room. I didn't like the idea that he could see me and I couldn't see him. I didn't like that power dynamic. And regardless, I knew I would be fine in the room. But that, again, was something I really had to fight. I really had to say, no, I'm going to be fine. And even in the second trial, I had to, with my second assault, I had to convince them. And halfway through my evidence, they're calling me saying, it's your evidence, X, Y, Z,

Speaker 2because you're in the room. Is it throwing you off? And I was like, I did it when I was six 16. Why would I have an issue doing it now? I'm fine. I want to be in the room. Yeah. So a pre-record, there's no jury. So I'm just cross-examined evidence in chief and re-examined without a jury. And this happened, my friend as well got to do the same thing. Um, she was in a separate room.

Speaker 1This is the best friend.

Speaker 2Yeah.

Speaker 1Yeah.

Speaker 2She was in a separate room. She was advised legally because obviously testifying against your own family is, is an intense thing to do. Yeah. Um, and she, she did it from the other room, but we, we sort of wait in the same outside area. Um, like until she went, she was still in the outside corridor coming in contact with her dad. Um, and he was in custody the whole time.

Speaker 1Was he?

Speaker 2So that made it a lot easier. At the end of the day, you know, he went through separate entrances and exits. To get in and out, it was more just, you know, she'd see him as we passed, but we were never entering the actual courthouse at the same time. His lawyers were the same lawyers that did the divorce process between his parents. So my friend knew the lawyers well and essentially grew up around them. Yeah, that's really strange. Very odd. And also odd because they're completely different types of lawyers.

Speaker 1Yeah.

Speaker 2Very random.

Speaker 1This is a criminal case.

Speaker 2Yeah, very random. And... I do have to say they did treat me very well. Okay. The solicitor, oh, the barrister, sorry, was very, very well spoken to me and it wasn't in a manipulative way. It was in a genuine way.

Speaker 1Is this in the cross-examination? Yeah.

Speaker 2Constantly just asking if I needed a break was very lovely to me. I think purported my expectation of what and how a victim was treated.

Speaker 1Because usually... victims are not treated well in a cross-examination. Yeah.

Speaker 2I actually had someone that interviewed me before I went into court and asked me what words, like asked me a bunch of questions. I assume they were a psychologist and they worked for the DPP and then made an assessment based on that, which at this point I was 17. Like I guess I was a child, but I wasn't young. And then she sat next to me in the courtroom, like right next to me in the box and and interrupted any question that was asked in any way that was perceived to be not the best way that I

Speaker 2answer questions. So, I mean, it was pretty standard what she ended up saying that I didn't respond well to. It was open questions and... there's a word for it, like when you flip a question and you're trying to get something out of it. She said that I don't respond to those. Well, I don't know who would. Maybe a defense lawyer. I don't know who would respond to them, particularly at that age. And anything, I would look at her and make sure it was all good for me to answer it because she was constantly interrupting, even evidence in chief, even the judge. You know, she filtered every

Speaker 2word that was spoken to me and spoken back. And I did not have to answer anything. They would have to completely reword the question. So they couldn't trick me, essentially.

Speaker 1So who was she? Was she a lawyer? Was she a.

Speaker 2I assume she was a psychologist. I don't even remember her name. I remember what she looks like, but she just showed up on the day, did an assessment with me and then was next to me the whole time I testified.

Speaker 1She sounds incredible.

Speaker 2Yeah, it's also to this day not something I've ever seen. I mean, I was the support person in my cousin's trial and I remember saying, hey, sorry, where's that woman? You know, where's that lady? Can we have her back, please? I had her and my cousin was 12. And I just remember being like, whoa, whoa. I was 17 and I had imaginary lady. At this point, I'm thinking I imagined her because I've never heard of anyone else having this person. I don't know what they are. I don't know.

Speaker 2It was like a fever dream. I don't know. And when my cousin didn't have this person, I was jumping up and down going, what, what? And they're like, oh, you know, it was a regional trial. even though it was technically a district offense, it was done in a local regional court. So they were like, well, we just don't have like the funding for that. It's different here. There was a WASO, a witness assistance officer there, but she was, they'd never met her before, which is so random because a WASO is supposed to know from the beginning to the end. They're supposed to be the communication between you and the DPP. Yeah. Um, they work for

Speaker 2the DPP.

Speaker 1Yeah.

Speaker 2She just rocked up. She So not from the area. Yeah, it was very random. And I just said, what about this? And she's like, oh, that's kind of just like a luxury that happens in Sydney trials in very specific circumstances.

Speaker 1So it must have been part of the pilot trial that's been happening for the last few years in Newcastle and Sydney.

Speaker 2Yeah.

Speaker 1To have a support person there for juvenile trials. He was found guilty.

Speaker 2Yes.

Speaker 1And sentenced to five years.

Speaker 2Yes. You were 17? Yes. I was 16 when the assault happened.

Speaker 1And 17 when he was sentenced?

Speaker 2Yeah.

Speaker 1Did that feel like justice for you at the time?

Speaker 2Not really, no. I'll never forget my mum straight away just saying, well, that's just not enough to the detective. And the detective was like, no, that's actually pretty good. For a sexual assault case? No, no, that's not good enough. And, yeah, kind of just moved on, but it came around so quickly. when he was released and I wasn't told. I think that was the most devastating part of that entire ordeal

Speaker 2was that I was not told that he was going to get parole.

Speaker 1Right.

Speaker 2And I can't even remember how I found out.

Speaker 1Because he would have had time served.

Speaker 2He did, yeah.

Speaker 1So what was released maybe last year?

Speaker 2No, no, so he only ended up serving two and a half years. So that's why it went just so quick. I think he was released, yeah, 2021.

Speaker 1How did you find out? You don't remember.

Speaker 2I just can't remember if my friend found out before and had already given me the heads up or not. But I'm supposed to find out beforehand so I can speak at the hearing if I want to.

Speaker 1The parole hearing?

Speaker 2Yeah, and I remember being devastated that I never got that chance and then even more devastated that there were no repercussions whatsoever For the fact that I didn't get that chance. I was like, well, who do I contact? You can't just say sorry. It doesn't work like that. Why wasn't I told?

Speaker 1Yeah.

Speaker 2And apparently you have to register as a victim with the Department of Justice, which I actually tried to do for my second assault and they told me I couldn't because he's not serving a custodial sentence. Right. So, yeah, no one told me that.

Speaker 1Did your friendship, it sounds like it did, did your friendship survive?

Speaker 2I mean, yeah, her children are my godchildren.

Speaker 1Really?

Speaker 2Yeah. So we're best friends still.

Speaker 1Because I can imagine, you know, she's had a completely different parallel horrible experience finding out this about her dad. Has she spoken to you about it?

Speaker 2We don't really speak about it.

Speaker 1Don't you?

Speaker 2Yeah, it's kind of in a little Pandora's box in the corner and we joke about it. Like we have our own little inside jokes of how we cope with it. I mean she'd given birth I think a week earlier and she came to the sentencing of my second case and I think it was literally she was like five days postpartum. And she turned up and, you know, she was there with her newborn and and her toddler, and my dad said to her, I never said thank you

Speaker 2for taking care of Stasia. And then she came up to me after. She's like, we don't talk about it. No. Wayne, that's in a box. We don't speak about that. Like it's an unspoken thing. And at the time we were told not to speak about it because we couldn't. And I think it just kind of stayed that way. Yeah. I mean, we know, we speak about it in the sense that he still contacts her and she doesn't cope with it sometimes, does cope with it sometimes. But yeah,

Speaker 2we don't speak about any of the details. I don't think it's done anything negative towards our friendship at all. I mean, I think there was a huge part of me for a long time that felt a lot of guilt about that I took her life away from her. She had to stop full-time dancing. She had dropped out of school and gone to work full-time because she had to support her younger brother because her dad going away meant that it was on her now. So I think

Speaker 2there was a lot of guilt towards that. I mean, that whole case, I think I felt most of my trauma came from protecting everyone around me. And that's no one's fault but my own. No one put that on me. I mean, even two of my year 12 projects, my CAF's research project was on the impacts of sexual assault on secondary victims. And so was my science extension project. It was like the impact of adrenaline, which can cause

Speaker 2type two diabetes in secondary victims of sexual assault and domestic abuse. So I think For me, there was that huge factor of everyone around me also being okay. My boyfriend at the time, my mom, and my best friend. And I think when he was released, that all came crashing down. And it was like, wait, I never healed me. I just worried about everyone else. And again, that was nobody's fault but my own. I put that on me. Nobody put that on me. I don't know if that was my way of coping and not dealing with it,

Speaker 2but it all came crashing down. I mean, my relationship ended. We'd been together before. years. My mum and I, we were fine, but we had some talks about it. Things really did come crashing down when I all of a sudden had to deal with it.

Speaker 1When you say crashing down, do you mean like psychologically, like you were just struggling to deal?

Speaker 2Yeah. I mean, I was like half an hour drive meant stopping four times having a panic attack. Okay. Um, yeah, absolutely. Breaking down. I just wasn't coping at all with it. And I felt like I had trained everyone around me to not worry about me and worry about themselves. And I think I all of a sudden was like, Hey guys, no, I need help. Look at me. Why aren't you helping me? Um, And there was a lot of resentment because of that

Speaker 2and because I felt like I'd taken care of everyone else before myself. And I feel like that caused strain on a lot of relationships around me while I was already processing something that I hadn't properly processed previously.

Speaker 1Did you have the time and space to process it before the next assault happened?

Speaker 2Yeah, I think so, yeah.

Speaker 1What did that look like for you? Was it therapy? Was it talking it through with your mom? Was it dance?

Speaker 2I think I haven't actually had much counseling. I don't know. My brain is very zippy. I've got a million and one thoughts happening at once. And I think I just process that internally. I think as much as I did process it over the next year, it was the breakdown of my relationship from 15 to 19 that had seen me through the entire case, that I didn't know who

Speaker 2to be after that and who I was and where I fit into things. And I think I did put myself in more risky situations with partying and with things like that that I would not have normally done and aren't me because of that. So I think as much as I did deal with it, I also... wasn't necessarily as a whole dealing with my mental health during that time. And I was using outlets that I probably shouldn't have been. I also was dancing full time by that point. So

Speaker 2I was training 35 hours a week and working till like 3am at a bar to try and pay for full time. So I think at that point, you know, you've only got so many thoughts you can think in that period of time. But I do truly think I did processes, I think that breakdown allowed me to actually process it. I think I would have just held on until I didn't anymore with that.

Speaker 1So take us to 2022. Who were you by then?

Speaker 2I think I hadn't really figured out who I was. I was in my first year of full-time. I was just trying to navigate not being in a relationship. I hadn't done that since I was like fresh 15. So it none of my friends were dancers so it was about like you know finding friends within full-time dance and and the full-time dance is a lot um and yeah it was kind of just navigating that um navigating who

Speaker 2i wanted to be within the industry if i even wanted to take that leap um and keep pushing because it it's so huge so i think that took a lot of my capacity i think in 2021 I was able to kind of have periods of time of nothing because, I mean, it was COVID. It was a huge lockdown. I did one lockdown as my year 12 year and then the second lockdown was very different and it was very, you know, Zooms with my friends on their birthdays getting drunk and you get so drunk you'd pass out in the bed and the Zoom would still be on.

Speaker 1Coming up after the break, Anastasia tells us about the second time she was sexually assaulted. This time she was a young woman on a date with a man and his attack left her unable to sit or walk. Her experience with the court this time around was very, very different.

Speaker 2It was a very different time, so I think 2022 was like just moving so fast and so intensely that there was... I was purposefully not giving myself time to think in that period. And I definitely don't think I was my best self when... It happened. I think I was already in a pretty bad spot mentally.

Speaker 1So you met him on online dating?

Speaker 2Yeah, on Bumble.

Speaker 1Do you remember those first conversations or.

Speaker 2I've seen them quite recently. I have the screenshots. So very brief, nothing really too... They were just normal conversations, but they weren't deep at all. They weren't... We also didn't, you know, at all allude to anything sexual in those messages. And I think it wouldn't matter if we did, but I think it's just so important to note of the, like,

Speaker 2I just, I don't know where it was ever looked at as okay by him to have, even from his view, if it was just really rough sex, if that's genuinely what he believes. There was nothing in those previous conversations to even allude to that. We were literally just speaking about our days.

Speaker 1The assault, did it happen on the first time you met him?

Speaker 2Yes.

Speaker 1Yeah. What do you remember about the start of that date? Did you get any weird vibes to begin with?

Speaker 2Not at all, no. We were talking. I mean, I remember being a bit turned off, isn't the right word, and not worried, but just a bit, ooh, at him. that he'd broken his leg in a motorcycle accident and he just seemed like he was a very reckless person.

Speaker 1Okay.

Speaker 2A very, like, adrenaline junkie, that sort of thing. And I am very much, you know, don't see myself ever being with a partner that could potentially... die from something like that. So I think that was just like ding, ding, ding in my head, completely unrelated to what did end up happening. Well, not necessarily, but in the sense of the red flags for me were coming from the point of view that I didn't see myself with someone like that. So I was going like, oh, okay.

Speaker 1But more like, oh, this isn't my person. I need to get out.

Speaker 2Absolutely. Yeah. More so from the fact of just like, okay, not seeing myself being in a relationship with this person. Because for me, even if I was going into something, you know, with the guy conversation of it being casual, it probably wasn't. I wasn't. I don't do that well. So I think I was always kind of thinking, well, do I see myself with this person? And for me, it was straight away of like, oh, probably not. But not in a red flag in terms of violence or

Speaker 2anything like that.

Speaker 1You did end up having sex with him consensually and then you no longer wanted to have sex and you told him so.

Speaker 2Yeah, I was screaming stop and no. And one of the defining points during the assault for me was that he had his hand underneath my hair and every time I said stop or no or ow, he released pressure on his hand. So I knew that he could hear me. And I knew that he was not only hearing me and say ignoring me, he was hearing me and absorbing it and reacting. So I think, I mean, I told

Speaker 2the police that even very early on, like to me, he could hear me. There's no room to think that he couldn't because of that release on my hair. And he went and got lube as well. Because of that, I assume. So, yeah, he absolutely could hear me. He absolutely processed that too and afterwards actually said, were you saying stop and no because of the hair pulling or

Speaker 2something else? And I said because of the hair pulling because I wanted to walk out of that building alive. Right. But to even say that, it just shows that you're absolutely aware that I was saying stop and no during that. I mean, it's my understanding and I have a decent amount of guy friends that if a girl even looks uncomfortable, they're stopping. We have affirmative consent laws that mean that if you haven't absolutely said yes, then you've said no, let alone screaming stop and no.

Speaker 1You said you wanted to leave that building alive. Were you scared for your life that night?

Speaker 2I'll never forget that. During it, just calming myself down and saying, you're going to get out if you're alive and you're going to either call your friend and if they don't answer, you're going to call an ambulance and you're going to live. You're going to be fine. Because I felt like I could die. I felt like that if I didn't play my cards right, that I may be in a very, very, very unsafe situation.

Speaker 1How did you get out?

Speaker 2He went to the bathroom. I. Sort of just gathered myself, went to the bathroom after him, burst into tears, had my moment, and then thought about how I was going to get out. I mean, my mum and I always had a secret word or a phrase, like if I was at a sleepover and I wanted to go home, that I could call her and just say that. Or she said, always lie, you know, in that context. Always, you know, you're never going to get in trouble if you say, grandma's died, I've got to go.

Speaker 2And so I texted, I think, three of my friends to see if they were awake. Maybe it was two. One responded straight away. And I just said, I'm in trouble. I need you to call me and pretend to be my mom and say that my grandma's having a stroke. Um, and so I walked out of the bathroom, I texted my other friend to say that I wasn't, I think I just said, I'm not good. And they were like, okay, I'm on the way. Um, my other friend who was the one that ended up calling me said, I am drunk right now, or I would come get you. Um,

Speaker 2but so she's like full, um, you know, at that point I was all up. we'd been friends for a long time, but you know, she was into drama at school and things like that. So I feel like this was her calling. She was like, yeah, no, say less. And she did this full performance on the phone. And it just helped me relax knowing that I could walk out of there and I didn't have to come up with my own excuse. I didn't kind of have to, you know, do anything. I'm not very good at that. You know, I can't look someone dead in the eyes and, and And be like, yeah, no, I won't be convincing.

Speaker 2I just won't be. So I think that just really helped me feel like I could walk out of there, shut the door and run. And I don't know if he really believed it. But I also had the benefit of the doubt. Maybe he just thought I was getting out of, you know, what to him was like bad sex and I wanted to go. Something like that. I was supposed to stay the night. I'd arranged that because I was on my P's and we were drinking, so I wouldn't have been able to drive home. So I

Speaker 2said to him, no, no, I'm just going to drive. No, I'll just Uber or someone's coming to pick me up. I knew I just needed to get out of there. I dumped my stuff in my car and then ran down the street and around the corner so that I was completely out of sight. And then got on the phone with the friend that was on their way. And my phone was about to die, actually, so I was just on the phone with them until... I think it died just before they arrived. Someone actually walked past when I was waiting because I was just like on Coogee

Speaker 2Bay Road, creeped up in a little ball. It wouldn't have even been that late, maybe like before 12, I reckon. So, yeah, it really wasn't that late. I don't know. I think they were just out for a run or something. They didn't look like they were walking back from the club or anything. And he said, are you okay? No, like I'm not leaving you until. I know what's happening. And then my friend on the phone was like, no, no, no, I'm about to come get her. I'm like around the corner. And then that's when he went, okay, okay, as long as you're okay. And I feel like he just went

Speaker 2around the block and just watched because he could clearly tell that I was not okay. I mean, I had like snot, tears, makeup all over my face. My hair was matted. Yeah. So I think I got in the car where I met my friend at a petrol station. which ended up being, I guess, good because there was footage of me meeting them.

Speaker 1CCTV.

Speaker 2Yeah, and it aligned with my story. And got in the car. I wasn't going to– I wasn't speaking. I was like, no, no, I'm not speaking. And they said– well, they pulled over and said, well, we're not moving then until you speak. And then I said, what happened? And then– They said, police or hospital. And I said, I don't want to do it again. I can't do it again.

Speaker 2Let's go to the hospital because then I can make my decision later. I can't go through that again. I'm not doing it again. Went to the hospital. We went to Prince of Wales and then they redirected us to RPA. Went down to their rape clinic, which was literally in the basement. It was so weird. It was a fever dream. I... It was very odd. There were no windows. It was fluorescent lighting, like the rest of the hospital was dimly lit. And then you go down these like rickety stairs. We'd

Speaker 2already been waiting by that point for so long. And it's just one doctor in there in this like really bright room. And then like a psychologist is sitting there. And it was just so odd. And they also didn't call the police, which I thought was a bit weird.

Speaker 1Yeah. Also doesn't feel very comforting for someone that's just survived.

Speaker 2It was so weird. Literally. And then I'm sitting on this like dentist's chair.

Speaker 1Okay.

Speaker 2And I was like, what is going on? And, yeah, that happened. Then we drove back to my friend's house, slept. Um, and then we drove back to get my car the next day and then went straight to the police station.

Speaker 1When you had that initial feeling of, I can't do this again. What was it? You can't do a trial again. You can't go to the police again.

Speaker 2I just can't re-traumatize myself again from beginning to end. I it's, I just knew in that moment that I was letting go of the next few years of my life. Um, And I also knew how lucky I was in the original case. And I just didn't want to be exposed to anything, like someone not believing me or being disappointed by the DPP not taking it. As much as I did have trust in the system, I feel like I

Speaker 2was told again and again and again, this is so rare. You're an anomaly. This is not normal.

Speaker 1Well, it's unique that you had such an experience knowledge of it. Yeah.

Speaker 2Yeah.

Speaker 1You knew what was going to come.

Speaker 2Yeah, absolutely. I think everyone was very careful as well during the second trial to not come across as patronizing because they knew that I knew everything that was going on. But I think the system is so predictable at the same time as being so unpredictable. So, you know, it felt like I was being explained the same things again. It felt like deja vu in certain senses, but in other senses, it was so different and so new to navigate. And there were certain legal issues that I'd just never

Speaker 2even witnessed before. I mean, half of my degree was law and I was really confused as to what was going on. And I felt like I was translating everything to my mom every day. I mean, two of my best friends both did the same degree as me. And they were my support person interchangeably. And so it was just, you know, the three of us trying to kind of explain it to my boyfriend and my mum and just it was very, it was a very complex legal trial, the second one.

Speaker 1What comes to mind as the biggest things that were different, surprisingly different?

Speaker 2The wait period. Okay.

Speaker 1Between charges and trial?

Speaker 2Even between it happening and charges. I mean, we had to wait for the warrant for the pretext phone call. before they could arrest him because they couldn't tip him off that anything had happened because I needed to have that phone call with him.

Speaker 1So they wanted you to kind of call, like do a pretend call with him?

Speaker 2Yeah. The police cannot say anything to you about what they want from the phone call. They can't even necessarily want anything from the phone call. They just have to say, do whatever you want.

Speaker 1Are they trying to get a confession, basically?

Speaker 2They can't admit that. Okay. Yeah.

Speaker 1So how do they, can you call him and just have a conversation? Is that what they say?

Speaker 2Mm-hmm. They just say, just do what you want to do and what you need to do.

Speaker 1What happened in the phone call?

Speaker 2Oh, on the pretext phone call, he said, I'm so sorry if that did happen. You know, I don't remember the night, but it sounds like something I would do. Yeah, it was very odd, that phone call. I remember hanging up and just running. My house is very long. It's like room after room after room, but just long ways. And I was in the lounge room, which is the furthest room to the left. And my parents' room is the furthest room to the right. So I remember just running through the house. straight to my mum's bedroom and just bursting into tears. And my dad didn't know at that point. And this would have been like six weeks,

Speaker 2I want to say, after the assault by the time they'd actually gotten that. Wow. The warrant for that. So then I believe they arrested him after that. I feel like that bit's a bit of a blur, but it was also around Christmas.

Speaker 1Because this is 2022 for context. How old were you? Early 20s?

Speaker 2I think I was 20.

Speaker 1Yeah.

Speaker 2Yeah. Yeah, I was 20. I turned 21 the Christmas of that year. Okay. And, yeah, I remember it all just kind of being up in the air during Christmas. I don't really even remember being explicitly told that he was arrested and that they had him in custody. I remember her saying, we've interviewed him, We've met his lawyers and they're going to fight till the death. They are

Speaker 2going to fight. We are not getting a plea deal. We're not getting anything. They are going to fight this until the end. And then I said, well, okay, it's fine. Really?

Speaker 1Because at this point, once you decided, no, I'm pressing charges, were you in? You were like, I'm readying myself.

Speaker 2I think I just needed to get over myself. Yeah. You know, I think that was.

Speaker 1You don't. You just went through a really serious assault.

Speaker 2Yeah, I think I just needed to get over that hump and once I did, there was no other option. There was no other way forward. That was the only way forward. And I think I knew that by going to the hospital as well. I knew that I was just gathering evidence to ensure when my brain clicked in 24 hours and I had a second to, I don't want to say get over it, but... to process it, that I was going to be going to the police.

Speaker 1Well, it took four years, if I'm right, to actually.

Speaker 2Go to trial. Yes, yes. He kept getting hit by cars. What? Yeah, so every time we got.

Speaker 1That is not what I was expecting you to say.

Speaker 2Yeah, so every time, not every time, there was like... two times that it was, we were either a week out. One time it was the Friday and it was like 4pm and the trial was supposed to start on the Monday morning. And I got the call saying it's been adjourned.

Speaker 1He's in hospital.

Speaker 2Got here by night.

Speaker 1What? Like you said before, you know, you do have to kind of put your life on hold while waiting for this to happen. What was that weight for you like?

Speaker 2I mean, for me, it wasn't even necessarily the weight within itself. You definitely put your trauma processing on hold. Not your trauma on hold, but the processing of it. I was determined to not let it affect my life. But that being said, having the trials adjourned so close to them meant, you know, myself and there was like four or five witnesses in the trial, which is very

Speaker 2unusual for a sexual assault, all took three weeks off work. And then, you know, Friday, the day before, I can't get my work back.

Speaker 1Oh my God.

Speaker 2The friend that picked me up had taken three weeks of annual leave. Can't get that back. And that had happened twice. So by that point, it was, I was asking questions of, well, you know, do I get reimbursed?

Speaker 1My work.

Speaker 2And they said, well, no, you're not testifying. So no. And I said, well, but I had to take this time off or I could be arrested is what the, you know, what the subpoena says. So what does that look like in terms of myself and my four or five friends? Not all of them I was still speaking to, but what does that look like for all of us that are testifying? And you've just messed over for the second time. Luckily, my main job, It just meant that I just was working. But I'd still taken off like

Speaker 2my teaching work and also just like the mental preparation for it. And we're not talking it's adjourned by a few weeks, a month. We're talking six months.

Speaker 1Oh, my God. And that mental preparation shouldn't be underestimated.

Speaker 2No.

Speaker 1To have to gear yourself up, to remember the night over and over in your head, that's a long time between– To remember the intricacies of a night.

Speaker 2And you have to remember the intricacies. Like I was caught up on one tiny detail that I genuinely didn't remember because it was three years ago of whether or not at one very specific point during the alleged assault that I was, if he was on his knees or if he was standing next to the bed. But like either he was just on the edge of the bed on his knees or he was standing next to the bed.

Speaker 1That's so specific.

Speaker 2And she said, well, you've just said something different to what was in your state. But my statement was like 10 pages long and I had four of them. And then I had the pretext phone call as well. So it was just one tiny part. There were four charges of sexual assault. So, yeah, it was one small, I think that was the only thing that was kind of torn apart in that sense. And she just, she tore it to shreds. And I just remember being like, Does

Speaker 2it matter?

Speaker 1Yeah.

Speaker 2If this is all the defence you have, then I guess that speaks to itself.

Speaker 1Was that the worst part of your cross-examination?

Speaker 2Absolutely not. I was on the stand for four or five days. Wow. I was recalled to the stand after I was dismissed. And I remember coming off the stand saying, I'm not done. And the detective admitted that behind my back she was like, what is she on about? Obviously she's done. And I was like, no, I'm not. not everything's been covered. I'm not done. There's no way I'm going to be recalled. I'm going to be recalled. And then I was halfway through auditions at the studio and I got the call. You need to be here in 10.

Speaker 2You're getting recalled to the stand. And then the detective said to me, I have to apologize. I'm so sorry. I, that doesn't happen. You know, I just assumed, but you knew, you knew you were getting recalled. And I was like, yeah, absolutely. I wasn't done. Um, My medical records were pulled apart. I mean, I was questioned about a UTI that I had when I was in year five.

Speaker 1Year five?

Speaker 2Yeah. She was trying to compare my vaginal pain post-assault to the UTI that I had when I was in year five.

Speaker 1Let's talk about the pain post-assault because it was really serious, wasn't it? You had quite a lot of injuries.

Speaker 2Yeah, I had anal tearing. I'll never forget the first time I went to the bathroom after Nobody warned me. I mean, it seems pretty obvious, but I didn't think about it. And I mean, I've never given birth, but I feel like I could... It felt like what I think it would feel like. As much as I can kind of make that comparison, it was just nothing I'd ever felt before. So immediate, so agonizing to use the

Speaker 2bathroom after that. It was just, it was horrific. I... um, had some vaginal bruising, but it wasn't allowed to be used in the trial.

Speaker 1Why?

Speaker 2Um, not a hundred percent sure. Um, there's a few different aspects that come into it. I, um, had hurt my shoulder quite badly. I have Ehlers-Danlos syndrome, so I'm very hypermobile. Um, And I'd had a few shoulder dislocations. So it had put my shoulder in a really horrific spot when I was in prone position and the pressure that was on my shoulder from me trying to push my own body up. So my shoulder was in agonizing pain, my neck. I felt very, very sick afterwards. And we

Speaker 2weren't sure if it was from choking. Cause I'd been given like a pamphlet that said, if you get any of these symptoms and it was sort of all of those symptoms, like the dizziness, I felt so nauseous. Um, my vision was a bit blurry. Um, and so I went back to the hospital with my other friend, um, after the fact, um, and they did like a head CT and I was, they said I was okay, but I think it was the PEP, the anti-aid medication I had to take afterwards that made me so ill. Um,

Speaker 2So I remember being at the police station and just obviously I also was under a lot of stress but I was just so sick. Like I'm not a nauseous person. I don't vomit. I don't, yeah. So I'm so scared of it. I won't. So I remember being so nauseous and, yeah, the only thing I can kind of pin that on is the anti-AIDS medication that I had to take.

Speaker 1When you compare that cross-examination you had in your second trial to the first, was it chalk and cheese?

Speaker 2Yeah, not comparable. It was horrific. She was trying to pin me as a liar because I had been speaking to two guys that I was talking to and telling them lies about where I was that day. Because why would I tell two guys that I am going to see or seeing that I'm going to a guy's house? So I had told one of them that I was going to the studio and one of them that I was going to dinner with my friend in Coogee. And

Speaker 2that friend ended up being the same one that picked me up. So then I did tell a handful of lies sort of before we got to the hospital of, oh, we met at Coogee Pub and then we went back together. Like that's how we got here. And then the minute that I was alone with the police, I said I lied. Here's what I lied about.

Speaker 1They're also really white lies. You were dating.

Speaker 2Yeah. But that was, I mean, it was tricky because so much was off limits in the trial, but they were clearly trying to get me to admit that so that then it could open the can of worms up of my sexual history.

Speaker 1They also tried to use the hair pulling in the defence, didn't they?

Speaker 2No, my, well, not my lawyer, but the state, the DPP, the Crown, asked me to show where He had pulled my hair and I must have just looked absolutely gobsmacked because I was shaking and I was like looking at the judge and looking like, are you going to make me do it? And then the judge stepped in and said, absolutely not. You are not, do not make her do that.

Speaker 1Yeah, wow.

Speaker 2That is absurd. And I mean, I would say my evidence in chief was probably my weakest point. I think I was just... it was a lot harder to relive this one than it was to relive the first one. I think the extent of it, the, how much pain I was enduring, the length of it, it was really hard to relive it. I think by the time I got to cross-examination, I knew I was telling the truth

Speaker 2and I knew that that's all that mattered and that she was not going to break me. And I think it really, really bothered her that she could not break me. Um, And I remember looking over to, you know, like after a couple of remarks, I wasn't being snarky. I wasn't. I was just coming back to things that were stupid and things that you can't play me. You know, she said, well, do you know what teams were playing in the grand final that night? No, I don't. It was three years ago because your client keeps getting hit by a car.

Speaker 2But anyway. she said, well, I do. And I was like, okay, tell us then. Again, I'm in the room. You know, this is a very unique, the jury's sitting right there. This is a very unique setting. She goes, I know, it was Penrith versus the Panthers. The whole room is dead. They're the same team. It's the Penrith Panthers.

Speaker 1It took me a while there. I'm not a sports fan.

Speaker 2No, but I was just like, what? I felt like I was on the office. I was just looking at the judge and, like, I'm looking at some of the jury members and we're all just, and my friend's in the back like, what? And then the judge is like, they're the same team. Oh, my God. And she was like, oh, oh, okay, right. And then even another point, like, she said, well, when you were, you know, lying about saying that you were going to dinner with your friend, Katie, and then I let her go on this whole spiel about Katie. I

Speaker 2was like, I reckon she was speaking for five minutes. And then at the end I said, I'm so sorry. I don't know a Katie. Um, because it was Grace that I'd said, but I just let her, I just let her speak. I just let, I said, I'm so sorry. I don't know a Katie. And she said, oh, Grace, what did I mean? And then, um, The judge was like, you said Katie. And then one of the jurors went, mm-hmm. It was just comedic at some points because I just don't understand. I think she was just getting really flustered that she thought she was going to break me on

Speaker 2the lying. And the DPP said to me, you just owned it. You came in from the get-go and said I lied.

Speaker 1But you also have a confidence about you.

Speaker 2Yeah, I lied.

Speaker 1That is unbreakable.

Speaker 2Yeah, I was like, I lied. Yeah.

Speaker 1At this point, had you been studying criminology as well? Do you think that helped you?

Speaker 2Not in the case of the room. Not really, no. I think if you were studying psychology, you'd probably have a better idea. Even if you were studying law, you wouldn't necessarily have that idea because it comes from interactions with people, I think. And yeah, I'm just not going to... You can't manipulate me. I think that she was just... getting really flustered by that. And she was like stammering her words at different points. And I just was not breaking. Every question was clearly just trying to break me down

Speaker 2to the point where I came out. I genuinely think that his lawyers, both female, did not believe me. And I think it was evident that they didn't and that they were defending their client from the perspective that they didn't. They were not just doing a job from my perspective. I think it's very different in contrast to the first assault where everyone knew something happened and that something regardless was disgusting and that was already accepted. whether it was

Speaker 2legally accepted or not at that point, because technically it wasn't, it was kind of a mutual understanding that this guy is not good. It's just to what extent are we trying to prove that legally? And it was very evident in this case from my perspective and my opinion of being in the room. I think also being in the room you can pick up on a lot of things that you can't necessarily pick up from being in the video chat. But even my friends, it was great to have them in there with such incredible knowledge and experience to then be able to bounce off them later. Because

Speaker 2there's no one else that's allowed in the room. It's closed court. So then to be able to say, well, did you pick up on this? Did you pick up on this? What was that? To have them was great because I could immediately go outside and be like, that was weird, wasn't it? And they understand that. Yeah.

Speaker 1You have someone to debrief with.

Speaker 2A hundred percent. And someone to also help take the load of passing that on to other people outside. True. The only time I broke down was when I heard the pretext phone call. Because I just, it's one of those moments in my life that I can pinpoint exactly how I felt internally. And I just have such a distinct memory of how that felt. And hearing my voice just crackle and break on that call, I just, I broke, like, that was the only time I ever think I properly called a break. I went outside and I broke down.

Speaker 2And I mean, in the first... trial actually my triple zero call was the one that broke me too I think it's it's hearing you back then and hearing in that moment yeah and hearing who I I mean I thought I was king of the world at 19 but I I did not know anything um did no shit so sorry um.

Speaker 1You're allowed to swear on this podcast.

Speaker 2Um yeah I didn't I didn't know anything um I was a little baby and so I think just going back and hearing the innocence of my voice and hearing the pain and I just want to go back and squeeze her and give her a big hug. So I think that's what's really heartbreaking. You know, you're not in the position where you're seeing photos of you at that age. So I think, you know, the voice is the only thing you kind of have to go, whoa, I'm not who I was then and I can protect myself now, but I couldn't protect myself then. And I think that's what was so heartbreaking about hearing that phone call.

Speaker 1How long was the trial in the end?

Speaker 2Three weeks.

Speaker 1If you were on the stand? Three weeks.

Speaker 2Yeah, which is quite a long sexual assault trial.

Speaker 1Yeah, that is enormous.

Speaker 2Yeah. It was Monday to like the three-week Wednesday and then we had a one day off and then we came back for the custodial hearing or something like that. And that was whether or not he was going to be held in custody until sentencing.

Speaker 1And was he? No. By the end of the trial, did you have an inkling what the sentence might be?

Speaker 2By the custodial hearing we did or whatever it's called. By that point... We did because it was said, I'm not confident. The judge said, I'm not confident that he will be given a term of full term imprisonment. So I'm not going to put him in prison now. So that it was my understanding that the guilty verdict occurred and he was to be taken away in cuffs. That was my understanding. And I was very confused when that was not the case. I mean, the defense attorney said, well, I'm just not, I wasn't prepared. As you can understand,

Speaker 2Your Honor, I wasn't prepared for a guilty verdict. So I haven't prepared anything for the custody hearing. I haven't prepared anything for that because I wasn't expecting that. And I'm just sitting there going, what? What do you mean? Why are we giving you lenience for a lack of preparation. Is that not your job? Is that not what he's paying you hundreds of thousands of dollars to do?

Speaker 1Yeah.

Speaker 2To be prepared?

Speaker 1Because there were four charges. Yeah. He was found guilty of one.

Speaker 2Of the third count, yeah.

Speaker 1And then it ended up that he didn't get a custodial sentence.

Speaker 2Yeah.

Speaker 1It was confirmed.

Speaker 2Yeah. I think, look, we had three sentencing hearings. Wow. Which is a lot.

Speaker 1Yeah.

Speaker 2And they were all very spread out. I mean, my victim impact statement was read. Almost a year earlier than when he was sentenced.

Speaker 1Really?

Speaker 2Yeah.

Speaker 1Hang on. Between the trial and sentencing, there was a year?

Speaker 2Well, the trial was August of last year. I read my victim impact statement end of last year. And then the sentencing was, yeah, so it was like eight months. Sentencing was July.

Speaker 1Recently.

Speaker 2Yeah.

Speaker 1That is enormous. Yeah.

Speaker 2It was pushed back to March originally. And that was just another hearing in March. And then in March, it got delayed again. And it's not like it's being delayed. Like we're going into court. I read my victim impact statement and then it was delayed again, like from then on. Even between the last two sentencing hearings, it was two weeks again. And I was just grateful that it was only two weeks. And that was just because the judge said he needed to go over the material. So then we had to reconvene in two weeks.

Speaker 1Up next, Anastasia tells us why she's trying to change the conversation and hopefully one day the sentences for other victim survivors.

Speaker 2In my first case, it was done in one day, sentencing from beginning to end. I read my victim impact statement. We went away for three hours while the judge went through the case and then came back.

Speaker 1Do you think that was because it was a juvenile trial or just a different time?

Speaker 2Just a different judge.

Speaker 1Different case, different judge. He ended up getting no jail time. a three year community corrections order and a hundred hours of community service. What was your reaction to that?

Speaker 2Um, I was being well prepared for that. Yeah. I think that's something that wasn't necessarily covered in the media of that. Unfortunately, that's what the DPP was expecting. Um, we, from the minute that we had that just post trial hearing, it was like, I don't see him getting custodial sentence. Um, It hadn't quite been explained to me the difference between a CCO, a community corrections order, and an ICO, and that ICOs were no longer available for sexual assault cases

Speaker 2because it's not deemed an appropriate sentence.

Speaker 1What's an ICO for our listeners?

Speaker 2Intensive corrections order, it's essentially home detention, and a CCO is just a community corrections order. And the Liberal government put in that an ICO is not available for serious sexual offences because it is not a serious enough punishment. Now, there's the loophole of a CCO and it's only really become evident in my case and Kramer that this loophole is being abused. I was explained by the DPP and

Speaker 2the Attorney General also was like, yep, that's the example that I know of that the only reason that loophole exists is for very unique circumstances where say a 15 and a 16-year-old are in a relationship, the parents report it and the 16-year-old, both of them go, hang on, no, no, this was our consensual. Obviously it's technically not, but we're three months apart in age, you know what I mean? And we just happen to be over those ages and the police go, well, it's a child sex offence, we

Speaker 2have to proceed. And the parents go, no, no, no, don't do that anymore. And then they would have to send him to jail. if that was the case, if there was no loophole. Whereas the CCO exists for circumstances like that where he will then be given a nine-month community corrections order because no one actually was necessarily hurt and things were withdrawn but the police had to proceed legally.

Speaker 1And instead it's being used in cases like this.

Speaker 2Yes, and RV Kramer as well, yeah.

Speaker 1I know that you say you were expecting the sentence but what about You know, when a sentence is given, the judge gives his reasons.

Speaker 2Yeah.

Speaker 1Listening to the reasons, for him saying things like it's on the low end of offending and that perhaps he thought when pulling your hair that you were saying no to the hair pulling, things like that. What was that like?

Speaker 2I mean, I really saw for a second there that it was going to be fine. I think when the media presence was quite obvious... his words changed and his language changed. And I thought, no, we might be okay. Maybe we'll get like nine months. Like it might be. And the TPP were like, no, don't get ahead of yourself. But I really did think he even asked, he said, well,

Speaker 2where do your arguments sit with deterrence? You know, the judge said that to the defense and she had nothing. she had nothing to give. And I'm, I'm looking at my, you know, support people. I mean, I always had like 20 people behind me. It was just, it was the bus. We were joking when the judge said the next sentencing hearing might be out in Penrith that we would have to hire a bus to get everyone there. Um, but yeah, it, the fact that the judge said that and she had nothing and I'm like, okay, maybe, maybe, you know, um,

Speaker 2Even within that sentencing hearing, that was the second last one. Well, it was really the last sentencing hearing and then the final one was just a sentencing. And the judge was doing majority of the defense's work for them, in my opinion. They barely spoke. You know, he was kind of finishing her sentences for her when she was stumbling and things like that. Anyway, fast forward to the last one and everything changed. I don't cry. I'm such a big crier. That's such a lie. I don't cry in front of people. I don't. break down. I mean, the only time I

Speaker 2cried during the trial was when I heard that pretext phone call within the whole three weeks. Obviously, I cried when I went home, but in front of people. And I was sobbing. And I remember my boyfriend being like, we're leaving. I need to get you out of here. I can't. You can't be in here right now. And I was like, I have to listen to every second of this. I can't. I'll regret it if I don't. But it was just so dehumanizing to hear him speak about the assault. Yous cherry pick parts of my statement that worked for him and he thought he believed. It

Speaker 2felt like a game of what he believed, the judge, out of my testimony and not what the jury unanimously decided. He essentially accused me of lying up there and said, well, you know, the victim has said it was 30 minutes and I just don't believe that was the case. But the thing is that I said that the whole assault went for 30 minutes and the whole alleged assault went for 30 minutes and he was only convicted of one of those four counts. So at no point did I

Speaker 2stand up there and say this one count was 30 minutes.

Speaker 1I didn't.

Speaker 2So that was taken completely out of context and, in fact, was a lie on his behalf because that is not correct. Whether or not he lied on purpose or he didn't know, I don't know, but it's his job to know. He's a judge. He's one of the most, you know, the highest professions that we see in our society. So there are very limited excuses for missing things like that. And to say, in his opinion, this is of the lowest level of sexual assault because it started consensually.

Speaker 1Is that why?

Speaker 2Well, that was one of his reasonings, which it's my understanding is not a law.

Speaker 1Yeah.

Speaker 2That is not the case. I could be incorrect, but even if it was, it doesn't matter. I think it felt like because I was not raped at gunpoint behind a dumpster by someone I didn't know, that my experience was being invalidated. Yeah. And he... was just constantly using this low level. Now, I have done enough study to know what judicial discretion is and the importance of discretion within policing and within everything. We cannot remove discretion. It

Speaker 2would be the breakdown of our society. But who are we giving the power to within our society to use said discretion? We have to trust that that discretion will be used correctly and it's not being used. I mean, I know I had my petition out to end community service for sexual assault, but that's not the point of the law. The point of the law is not to remove options like that because then it becomes, well, what do we define serious as? He said mine wasn't. So

Speaker 2then where do we go from there? And it's reviewing who... has the power and the use of discretion? And do we wholeheartedly trust the people that we have given such discretion to? And is their discretion correct? And therefore, is their discretion being reviewed by the right people post that? It's not.

Speaker 1I know you said you cried in that moment, but now I just see a fire in your eyes. I think they messed with the wrong person.

Speaker 2They absolutely did. Yeah, they fucked with the wrong bitch, that's for sure. My mum always says that. I think I don't, ever want to come across as anybody is lesser than somebody else because they've dealt with something differently. I think, I don't necessarily think it's healthy the way I deal with things. I'll be the first to admit that. I don't necessarily think that channeling the three hours that I get at home after work into building the Echo campaign instead of probably what I should be going to

Speaker 2is psychology sessions. I don't necessarily think that's the most healthy thing that I could be doing.

Speaker 1Maybe this is your version of psychology sessions.

Speaker 2Exactly, exactly.

Speaker 1And for listeners, the Echo campaign is what you've built to kind of elevate people's stories. Am I right?

Speaker 2Yeah, it's my, I've ended up registering it as a charity. And yeah, it's sort of the platform that I wanted to officially create something that I could build my advocacy on rather than kind of not knowing what I was doing. I went, you know what, I'm going to do this properly. Um, and having absolutely no idea what I'm doing, um, struggled to even file my own taxes, um, to, you know, writing a constitution to register a charity. It was just

Speaker 2like this whirlwind, um, And I remember getting in a room with my team after and then being like, okay, so we've got to register. And I was like, oh, I did that six months ago. I registered as an incorporated association. And everyone was like, what? That's not normal. Usually you wait a bit for that, but I just got the ball rolling. And yeah, I just think There's no right way to process this. And I think if you're sitting at home and you're just trying to survive

Speaker 2every day, you are just as strong as the person next to you. I think I'm in a very unique situation where not only can I speak out because my job allows me to, it's not jeopardizing that. I am safe. I am confident in doing that. That's within itself very unique. But I also... have the mental capacity to take it on so therefore I see it as I am doing that there is no other option because I can take

Speaker 2it on I am taking it on because I know that there's so many people that can't and I also know that I was that person that couldn't so I'm I'm doing it for myself and for them because there's just no way that it can keep going forward the way it.

Speaker 1Is what is your hope for the echo campaign in the future what do you want it to be.

Speaker 2Um I mean, ideally, I would be able to dedicate like the rest of my life and my career to that. And that would be my, yeah, eventual job. I think there's just so much that needs to be changed. I think there are a lot of advocates right now doing incredible work. And I love that we're all focusing on different things and then coming together and supporting each other for everything. But coming together on certain issues, I think

Speaker 2you do really have to focus on really small things or not small things, I shouldn't say narrow things.

Speaker 1Yeah, it feels like that. In order to change the system, it's like tweaking it one thing at a time.

Speaker 2100%. And right now.

Speaker 1Would you say your focus are these community service orders for sexual assault?

Speaker 2So I originally kind of saw it as that and then pivoted to where did this actually go wrong? Because again, removing discretion is not necessarily the solution. And the DPP did not appeal my case. And at the time I did understand it, the reason that was given. I mean, they don't even need to give me a reason. They, they are just incredible. And my crown prosecutor and the solicitor and both of my wasos, um, absolutely incredible. Um,

Speaker 2they obviously are not the people that make that decision. Yeah. Um, I know that they even used some of the public outcry and unrest to petition for it within the DPP. They had screenshots of comments and of the petition and of other things were genuinely used to convince people above them. And the reasoning that I was given was that it would set a precedent. If the appeal was. Not successful he it could potentially set a precedent um

Speaker 2but then on the other hand rv kramer with maddie lane um they quoted that of that he had completed his 300 hours of community service before it made it to the appellate board and therefore they said yes it was not a correct sentence but we will not overturn the conviction because he has already served his time.

Speaker 1So it's like you need to appeal now.

Speaker 2Well, even if you do appeal now, you only have two weeks to appeal. Even if you do appeal now, it will still take too long to get there. And he only has 100 hours. So the chances of him completing those hours before it gets to the appeals board is obviously quite high. So they said that could also set its own precedent. So... Those two reasonings at the time really did make sense to me. And then I sat down with a few different people and then we looked at it and we went, where did this actually go wrong? The DPP should have appealed it. And if

Speaker 2they were worried about setting a precedent, that's where the legislative change comes in. That's where the Attorney General stands up and says, wait, that's actually not right. We do need to, our entire system from beginning to end did fail you. Because there is supposed to be an appeals board to challenge judicial discretion. So without the challenge of that judicial discretion, you have set a precedent. And it has now been set, and my case can be used as case law, to give serious sexual offences community service.

Speaker 1Because it's happened before.

Speaker 2Because it has literally just set a precedent. Exactly what they didn't want to do. And. Really, where that goes wrong is, you know, I'm jumping up and down saying that we need a judge oversight board, someone that, you know, the Judicial Commission is very specific to if the judge was outright racist to someone or, you know, it was very explicit sexism was used in certain quotes. That's what the Judicial Commission is for, to

Speaker 2report to. It is not to report decisions or... things that can be deemed offensive but aren't necessarily outright. You know, I can't make a report to the Judicial Commission. That's what the Appeals Board is for. And when that doesn't function correctly, if the DPP go to then the Appeals Board and then it doesn't function correctly, that's when politicians can step in and I go, hang on a second, our system has failed beginning to end. But technically who failed me? Unfortunately, the DPP. And who oversees the DPP? Nobody.

Speaker 2They're an independent board who report to no one. And in the United Kingdom, they have an oversight board of the DPP. We do not. We have an oversight board. We have a New South Wales ombudsman. We have an oversight board of the judges, the Judicial Commission. We do not have a DPP ombudsman. We do not have anyone that they report to in any circumstance. In Bronwyn Winfield's case, it was a murder.

Speaker 1She.

Speaker 2Oh, I don't think it was hers. I think it was the one before the podcast before that.

Speaker 1Lynn Dawson?

Speaker 2Yeah, yes. The DPP didn't have to say why they didn't take that case to court. And it came out later that they were basing it off evidence that the mum had seen Lynn and that's why... they weren't going to talk about it. And that's why they weren't going to bring it forward because they were like, well, the mum's cited her. That never happened. But the DPP didn't have to tell anyone that because they do not have to use transparency. And nobody is checking the facts of that case. They don't hand it back to the police with the reasoning. And then the police go, wait a minute,

Speaker 2that actually didn't happen. So then it got to the point where it was like, well, 20 years later, we're finding out that the DPP did not take this because of a signing that never occurred. because nobody was overseeing that. So there's so many circumstances where this is so problematic in that nobody is overseeing the DPP. And where do we create an oversight board that is both enabling them to stay independent and stay as this incredible association that

Speaker 2they are, but also holding them accountable and not only holding them accountable, but giving trust to people. I have no one to go to. The DPP say no. The only person I can go to is the media. There is no other structure, anything in place to support that. I mean, in the UK, not only do they have an oversight board, they also have a victim's rights register that is specific to that and takes into account what victims have to be disclosed and the transparency within that,

Speaker 2that is its own thing that is constantly being adapted and rebuilt. And we don't have anything like that. And so I think for me in, in speaking that things need to be super narrow, that's kind of where at the moment I've, I've gone, I'm a huge advocate for things like independent legal support, but I think Sarah from With You We Can, she's got that covered.

Speaker 1Sarah Rosenberg. Yeah.

Speaker 2She's, she's got that covered. I think I will support her every second of the way through that. Um, Harry James with his good character laws, there's so many different things that everyone's doing. And I think we have to act really narrow and be very specific or it's not going to enact change.

Speaker 1But I think as devastating as all of these things that you talk about are, the fact that we've got you, we've got Harry, we've got Sarah, like they really have messed with the wrong people because how articulate you are, how passionate you are, like surely we're going to fill some cracks here.

Speaker 2I think even just the way that the advocacy world has just welcomed me with open arms, um, I think even Brittany Higgins has sent me the most lovely messages and it's just she's someone that I looked up to when I was younger. Like that was someone to me that I was just like.

Speaker 1It's like the community that you don't want to be a part of but once you're in there.

Speaker 2Yeah, it's not a club you wish to be in.

Speaker 1You want to be in.

Speaker 2Yeah, everyone along the way, even the way that they just want to help, they want to assist and put their hand up. Like all of my friends are like, what can I do? What can I do?

Speaker 1Because we're all sick of it. Yeah, exactly.

Speaker 2We're sick of it.

Speaker 1We want it to change.

Speaker 2Everyone just wants to help. But I think if anyone thinks that they can prevent it from happening entirely, you are wasting resources. We need to absolutely prevent it as much as we can, but there also needs to be an equal distribution of resources to both survivors and victims' families because, unfortunately, people are going to be murdered. That is just the reality. People are going to be raped. And if we think we can stop sexual assault, we are incredibly incorrect. That is just not the case. But

Speaker 2if a victim can be stopped from being re-traumatised post-assault, then we're moving forward as a society. But right now I just think there is so much focus on prevention and I think it's very easy for politicians to jump on the prevention train. Yeah. And I think it helps them tick boxes and say that they... they've done it. They can put their hand on their heart, go home to their kids and family and say, I'm making a change. I'm making a difference. And there are still victims being raped.

Speaker 2Someone was raped yesterday and they are about to go through what I have been through, what everyone's been through and potentially get a very different result, potentially get a similar result. What are we doing for them? What are we doing for the person that's going to be raped tomorrow? Because they're still going to be raped. It doesn't matter if we try our best to prevent it. There's someone that's going to be raped tomorrow. And what are we doing to have something in place for them the next day until, unfortunately, their probably five-year journey?

Speaker 1Obviously, all of these changes that you're trying to get, that you're hoping for, aren't going to be in tomorrow. So what is your message to that person that is raped tomorrow? How do they handle this? How do they get through it?

Speaker 2I think you have to do whatever is right for you. There's no black and white answer. going to the police may not be the right decision and that's okay. Surround yourself with the best support that you possibly can and unfortunately get your own lawyer because right now I can't put my hand on my heart and say the system is going to protect you. So you need to protect yourself first. And I think that's what I would change

Speaker 2if I was to do it again. Not that that's something that I can afford. And I think many people can't. And personally, not something that I could. I mean, even before I went to the press, I tried to get a lawyer just to check through everything, just to make sure I was good to go. And I was quoted at like $ 1, 400 for one session.

Speaker 1They're stupidly expensive.

Speaker 2I mean, there's not even a point where the lawyer can step in really. But I think, unfortunately, this change is not going to happen quickly. So you have to protect yourself.

Speaker 1Anastasia, thank you for joining us. Thank you for sharing your story. And thank you for being so kick-ass. I'm glad we've got you to keep fighting.

Speaker 2I think it's so important, but I also, I think it's healing within itself to do that and to make sure it never happens to someone again.

Speaker 1Thank you to Anastasia for sharing her story with us. You can find a link to the Echo campaign in our show notes. The Sarah Rosenberg you heard us mention is a young Sydney woman who took her alleged rapist to court only for him to be found not guilty. She now uses her advocacy to argue for legal representation for victim survivors. We'll link her episode with True Crime Conversations in our show notes. If you or anyone you know needs to speak with an expert... please contact 1800RESPECT, the National Sexual Assault, Domestic and Family Violence Counselling Service.

Speaker 1If you are in immediate danger, call 000. Thanks so much for listening. I'll be back next week with another true crime conversation.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. The Husband Who Asked His Doppelgänger To Murder His Wife

    Nov 18, 202655 minAudio

    In June 2015, Dr Teresa Sievers flew home early from a family holiday in New York to see her patients. The next morning, she didn’t turn up at her Florida clinic. A family friend went to check on her at her home in...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. A Cop Was Acquitted Over Kumanjayi Walker’s Death. Then A Coroner Read His Texts

    Nov 11, 20261 hr 4 minAudio

    Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander listeners are advised that this episode names a person who has died and includes descriptions of violence. In line with Warlpiri custom, he is referred to as Kumanjayi Walker. In...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. This Dad Went Looking For Answers. He Found A National Problem

    Nov 8, 202619 minAudio

    This episode is an update on the case of Elly Warren, the young Australian woman who died in Mozambique. Since Elly’s death, her father Paul has refused to accept silence. With few answers from authorities, he has spent...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Why Good Undercover Cops Think Like Psychopaths

    Nov 4, 20261 hr 9 minAudio

    For years Jason lived a double life as an undercover police officer, working inside the criminal underworld. No two jobs were the same, and the danger was always there. The toll of that work didn’t end when he left the...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Kristi Locked Up Paedophiles For 10 Years. This Is What She Learnt.

    Oct 21, 20261 hr 9 minAudio

    In 2008, Kristi McVee was a new mum flicking through the newspaper when a WA Police recruitment ad caught her eye. Less than two years later, she was sworn in as a police officer. Kristi went on to build a career...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode