In June 2015, Dr Teresa Sievers flew home early from a family holiday in New York to see her patients. The next morning, she didn’t turn up at her Florida clinic. A family friend went to check on her at her home in Bonita Springs. He found her in the kitchen. She had been struck at least 17 times with a claw hammer. Teresa was a respected and much-loved physician whose career was on the rise, and her family was popular in the local community. So who would want her dead? Author, professor and psychoanalyst Mikita Brottman has unpacked the case in detail in her book, In this episode, she takes Gemma through the brutal crime and the investigation that followed, and the secrets that sat beneath the surface of a seemingly enviable family. Purchase Mikita Brottman Book, A Double Life: The Anatomy of a Premeditated Killer here. GET IN TOUCH Follow us on Instagram and TikTok @truecrimeconversations Want us to cover a case on the podcast? Email us at truecrime@mamamia.com.au or send us a voice note. MAMAMIA OFFERS: Subscribe here for 30% off your annual Mamamia subscription for Black Friday with code BLACK30. Code applied at the checkout. Offer ends November 30. Make sure to leave us a rating and review on Apple & Spotify to let us know how you're liking the episodes. CREDITS Host & Executive Producer: Gemma Bath Guests: Mikita Brottman Produced by Ella Maitland Video Editor: Lisa Chen Mamamia acknowledges the traditional owners of the land on which we have recorded this podcast. Become a Mamamia subscriber: https://www.mamamia.com.au/subscribe
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Speaker 1It's a Monday morning in June 2015 and Dr Teresa Seaver's office manager at her Florida clinic can't get a hold of her. She knows the doctor flew back from a family trip early to see patients. So where is she? Her 9.30am appointment is starting to get impatient. The manager texts Teresa's husband Mark and he locates her phone remotely. It's at their home. So he sends a friend over to check on her. He pulls up in front of the property and knocks on the door. Nothing. Teresa! He yells.
Speaker 2Nothing.
Speaker 1He peeks in the living room window. He can see Teresa's purse on a stool. Alarmed, he pins in the code to the garage Mark has given him. Her car is there and oddly, next to it is her suitcase with its contents strewn across the floor. As he walks through to the small laundry room that leads into the kitchen, he sees her. She's face down, her dress hitched up to her thighs. There's blood everywhere. And as he leans down to touch her, she's cold. Leaping back in horror,
Speaker 1he dials 911. 911, what is your emergency?
Speaker 2I'm at a friend's house.
Speaker 1He's out of town.
Speaker 2And I came here to check on his wife.
Speaker 1And she's dead on the floor. I'm Gemma Bath and you're listening to True Crime Conversations, a podcast exploring the world's most notorious crimes by speaking to the people who know the most about them. The violence of this crime is indescribable. Teresa had been hit at least 17 times with a claw hammer to the head, which was found near her body, wrapped in hair. I'm not going to include how the autopsy report described the damage inflicted on
Speaker 1Teresa during that frenzied attack, but I am sure you can imagine. Four or five blows would have killed her, but 17? It was unnecessary and gruesomely violent. By all accounts, Teresa was a much-loved, accomplished and generous woman. Her star in the medical world was rising and her family was popular, outgoing and beloved in the community. Who would want her dead? Makeda Brotman is an author, a professor and a psychoanalyst. In her book, A Double Life... She unpacks this case
Speaker 1in detail. Let's get into it. Makeda, can you tell us about Teresa and her family? She was quite well known in the community, wasn't she, as a respected doctor?
Speaker 2That's right. She was a traditional MD. She was an internist, so she trained in internal medicine. But as she got older, she became more and more interested in anti-aging and holistic methods of healing and was particularly interested in different kinds of techniques like chelation and using different kinds of supplements. And she really had a desire to become like a
Speaker 2kind of celebrity alternative boutique healer. But she also was extremely well liked in the community. It was a very wealthy community, Bonita Beach in Florida. And it was the aging population. So that was a good place for a healer to set up shop. She had a great reputation. Sometimes she was known as Mother Teresa. She would go out to people in the middle of the night. She had many great relationships with many of her patients. She had a great bedside manner. She was very well known.
Speaker 2She was very popular. She was involved in various charities connected with the Catholic Church. She helped children, women particularly, who'd been involved in sex trafficking. I mean, she was just a very popular, well-rounded, funny, lively individual.
Speaker 1And her family, they were quite well-liked too, right? She had two little girls. She had a husband. They kind of had this picture-perfect looking life.
Speaker 2Yeah. Her husband, Mark, was a trained nurse, but he wasn't licensed. He didn't keep his license up in Florida, but he ran the office. So he did all the kind of HIPAA work and he ran the back management of the office. He did billing with the patients. He coordinated with patients. And he also homeschooled the couple's two children. And he was a very hands-on dad. He was very popular. You know, he took them to their karate lessons and their violin lessons and was very devoted to bringing them up in a sort of very free liberal atmosphere. But
Speaker 2at the same time, he was very protected of them. And both, you know, the couple had lots of friends in the community. The kids had friends in the community. Mark's mother had moved down there to live with them. So... I mean, it wasn't picture perfect, but from the outside, it seemed to be a thriving, well-liked family.
Speaker 1Was crime a big thing there, especially murder?
Speaker 2Not at all. This was a very unusual eventuality. The crime was a little bit higher than usual in Florida because it was a tourist town, so at certain times of the year during the tourist season, there was a little bit more crime than usual, but homicide, particularly what seemed to be an unmotivated homicide was particularly rare. And in what seemed to be a burglary gone wrong in this very prosperous house, it was very perplexing because it
Speaker 2was the biggest house on the street, but there was a big privacy fence. There were plenty of other properties that were more easily accessible. And there had been other crimes in the community, but they were mostly gang-related or drug-related. So nothing like this with a middle-aged physician with no known enemies. It was quite shocking.
Speaker 1Can you tell us a bit more about the days leading up to Teresa's murder? Because she had been out of town with her family, right?
Speaker 2Right. She'd been out of town with Mark and her family on a family trip to upstate New York, and because she was very devoted to her patients, she had to leave a couple of days early and come back to Bonita Springs, leaving Mark and the kids in New York with her mother, Mark's mother-in-law, so they could spend more time with their cousins. So they just had this very fun, warm get-together. They rented a house with a pool,
Speaker 2and the kids had a great time. And as Before Teresa got on the plane, Mark called her and they said their prayers by FaceTime. And she returned alone. She called Mark to let him know that she'd arrived safely. And that was the last time he heard from her.
Speaker 1Can you tell us about the crime scene that was discovered on June 29th? Because reading the description, it sounds like something from a crime show. Like it was so graphic. There was so much evidence. What did it look like? for the investigators who arrived?
Speaker 2Well, Teresa's body was actually found by a friend of theirs, a surgeon. Mark hadn't been able to reach Teresa, so he called a friend of theirs to drop by and see if she was okay. This friend of theirs discovered Teresa's body lying on the floor of the kitchen. She was clearly dead. there was sort of dried blood all around her. So it was clear that she'd been dead for quite a while. As he leant down to touch the body to find out what had happened, he saw
Speaker 2that the back of her head had been beaten in and nearby he saw a hammer lying on the floor and twisted in the ends of the hammer with some of Teresa's hair. So it was a really ghastly, horrible scene. And There wasn't that much blood, but some of Teresa's belongings were scattered around. So it certainly seemed like she'd been taken by surprise. And, you know, everyone was absolutely horrified.
Speaker 1Because Mark was informed of his wife's death while he was still away, right? And he was actually with her mother at the time.
Speaker 2That's right. So they both flew back with the children, Mark and Teresa's mother and the children, and So Mark and Teresa's mother had been informed by the police of what had happened, but the children didn't know. So it must have been a very tense and difficult flight, you know, knowing that Teresa was dead, not knowing exactly what had happened, flying back from New York, trying to keep calm for the sake of the children, not revealing anything to the children. And also the police asked for, you know, Teresa's sister
Speaker 2to come down as well so that they could talk to the family and get to know more about the circumstances. But You know, by all accounts, it was just absolutely devastating and even worse to be out of town when the news broke.
Speaker 1You mentioned earlier breaking gone wrong. So is that what the investigators first assumed?
Speaker 2They did. A door had been broken down. A door to the garage had been broken down. And so a first investigator assumed that people had broken in. But very quickly it became clear that that wasn't what had happened. Nothing had been taken from the house and there were plenty of things openly available. There had been, Teresa's suitcase had been ruffled through and some things strewn around, but that showed the police, that really indicated that it was more like someone leaving the house in a hurry, hurriedly
Speaker 2attempting to make it look like a burglary. Also, Teresa had a lot of jewelry on her body that was quite valuable. She liked to wear jewelry. None of that had been taken. There was a lot of cash lying around. There was actually about $ 70, 000 cash in a drawer upstairs. Mark had a gun collection. I mean, nothing had been taken. So obviously it wasn't motivated by robbery.
Speaker 1Obviously when something like this happens and there's no obvious kind of place to start, you look at the people closest to the victim. So everyone in her life was interviewed and Can you tell us about that first interview with Mark? What was his behaviour like?
Speaker 2You know, people react to news like this in very different ways. I mean, there's no correct way to show your grief. Sometimes people become very tense and unable to speak. Some people are extremely emotional. Some people cry. Some people don't. Some people get tense and nervous. Mark was extremely agitated. When the police left him in the interview room, he would talk to himself. He would talk to Teresa or what he imagined Teresa's spirit. He would hit the wall.
Speaker 2He would reprimand himself for not being there and not being able to save her. He was very much interested, like Teresa, in holistic medicine. So he would do gestures that were supposed to calm the body and so on. He would stand up. He would sit down. He would pant, he would gasp, he would get short of breath. I mean, it looked like he was having a nervous breakdown, actually.
Speaker 1Was that seen as suspicious or was that just seen as an emotional reaction to death?
Speaker 2In that first interview, it wasn't really seen as suspicious. I mean, like I said, it's hard to know what's an appropriate way to act in such circumstances. And also police were still looking at some other avenues of investigation. For example... Teresa had been involved in some transgender surgery. The police were looking at, could it have been an angry parent or an activist? She was involved in this organization called Our Mother's Home, which helped children who'd been
Speaker 2in sex trafficking. And sometimes Teresa had let those children stay at the house. The police wondered whether one of those children had been in touch with a pimp or someone on the wrong side of the law and given them information about the house. Certainly Mark wasn't being looked at as a suspect. I mean, he certainly had a very sort of extroverted, dramatic personality, so this way of grieving wasn't really out of character for him. So police were continuing to investigate other leads.
Speaker 1Up next, Makita tells us about the initial suspects in Teresa's murder and what Mark was like during their marriage. You delved into... in detail into their relationship and their marriage and really painted a picture of what this couple was like. Can you tell us a bit more about the dynamic between them? She seems to have been the more dominant personality.
Speaker 2Yeah, I mean, that was one of the things that really got me interested in the story to begin with was the character psychology because they're such compelling characters. And like you said, they seem to be on the surface a very well-loved and successful couple but as with many relationships there were cracks beneath the surface once the police began to investigate um Teresa was a very dominant personality she had a very loud voice she uh those who knew her say that she liked to swear and um
Speaker 2she was impatient she had a bit of a temper Mark was a lot more submissive at least in in terms of the marriage he was um you know, like I said, he took care of the homeschooling, but she was very demanding about things like groceries and getting him to park a car for her. And sometimes he, you know, he said that he felt like a valet. But in other respects, he was so in love with her that there was something almost masochistic in his character and that he didn't seem to, I mean, he saw this as
Speaker 2a manifestation of love and he was absolutely devoted to her. His Facebook page profile was a picture of Teresa. He was constantly boasting about her, how beautiful she was, how successful she was. He was her biggest supporter in terms of her career. So yeah, she certainly was the dominant member of the partnership, but people thought, well, that's just how it works. You know, couples have their own particular dynamics. And in this case, Teresa was by far the dominant party.
Speaker 1And like you say, that's not a bad thing. Like You talk about him being forgetful. She had a short fuse. No person or couple is perfect. Everyone has their positives and negatives. And it seems like for the most part, for most of their marriage at least, they made that work. They seemed to love each other. They had a very fruitful sex life. There didn't seem to be a lot of cracks until nearing the murder.
Speaker 2Yeah. Right, I mean, one thing that the police discovered quite quickly because they took Mark's cell phone is that Mark and Teresa were swingers and they liked to experiment with having other women join them in the bedroom. And like you said, they did have a very dynamic sex life and they liked kind of videotaping themselves. And Teresa was more interested in women than men. So she didn't have relationships with any other men But she was happy
Speaker 2for women to join them and she was happy for Mark to have relationships with other women, partly because his sex drive was much, much bigger than hers. And she was going through menopause, so she needed someone to kind of take some of the slack, so to speak. But again, that in itself didn't, I mean, it seemed to be working for them. You know, they were adults. They had their own predilections. They were adventurous. They were mature. There didn't seem to be, I mean, there's nothing wrong with opening your marriage in that way. Many couples do, particularly
Speaker 2when they get older and they try and recapture some of the sparks. But again, it also seemed like they had some financial difficulties or they seemed very prosperous on the surface. The more police looked the more they realized that they were actually living far beyond their means. And at certain times, their bank accounts were very low. The mortgage company had foreclosed on their home at one point. So at this particular point in time, it didn't seem as though they were, you know, the reality didn't match
Speaker 2the surface, let's say.
Speaker 1Another tension. that you explored seemed to be as Teresa's fame grew, like you mentioned, she was trying to become a bit of a celebrity doctor. So she was getting busier and busier and busier. And Mark was like, well, what about us? And like, where's my time? Do you think that that also was a big tension that started to grow?
Speaker 2It was, I mean, there was a couple of things were involved. One is that what Teresa was doing was it was not unethical, but she was mixing with some kind of dodgy, healers and, you know, self-proclaimed holistic gurus. And she was doing things like she was being paid by a supplement company to sell supplements from the doctor's office, which is, you know, there's nothing wrong with it, but it's not really considered particularly good practice. There were questions
Speaker 2about their insurance policies. And also, As she was becoming more successful, well, she wasn't actually becoming successful, she was trying to become successful. And so they were spending a lot of money on videographers and trying to get her a television show and so on. And Mark felt she was kind of leaving him behind in a way. He was left sort of, you know, cleaning up after her, packing her clothes when she went on trips, helping, you know,
Speaker 2do her hair and so on. but he wasn't really involved in this, this new life of hers. She was also becoming very, very close to a male doctor who was part of the anti-aging and anti-aging big wig. And Mark had never experienced anything like that before when she'd been close to other people, it was always women, but this was a man he couldn't really compete with someone who was a doctor who was very active in the wellness community. Someone that Teresa really looked up to. He was,
Speaker 2you know, um, very, he was a bit older than Mark, but he was very built, muscular, worked out. And so Mark was also becoming very jealous of this man.
Speaker 1Which is a bit of a double standard, isn't it? Because he was sleeping with other women. He was flirting with other women. And like all of a sudden he had an issue with someone that, and she was very open about her interest in this person. And she thought it was part of their open relationship dynamic.
Speaker 2Right. And there was nothing sexual between them at all. I mean, they would meet at conferences, they would flirt, they would, you know, he would give her a back rub, but they never had any kind of sexual contact. And Mark admitted to himself, you know, that one of the interesting things about this case is how much material there was because Mark was like an obsessive texter and he would text, even he'd text himself, he would record video messages and audio message to himself constantly. And all of that material was available to me. So, you know, he
Speaker 2admitted to himself often that this was hypocritical. He was constantly having sexual relationships with other women. Teresa was fine with that. This wasn't even a sexual relationship. It was good for her career. There was nothing, it was not reprehensible at all, but he just couldn't deal with it. You know, it put him in the state of mind of a teenage boy.
Speaker 1I want to pause for a minute and bring in Curtis Wayne Wright Jr., who you refer to just as Wayne. Tell us about how he comes into this story because he's kind of linked, well, very much linked to Mark. Tell us about them and their history together.
Speaker 2Well, another of the interesting things that got me interested in this case in the first place is this really uncanny relationship between Mark and his childhood friend, Wayne. Even though Mark had become successful, he was married to a doctor, he lived in Bonita Springs, he was really into holistic health, he'd actually been born and brought up in a much less prosperous environment in the outskirts of St. Louis. And he'd actually kept quite in quite close touch with many of his friends there, particularly this childhood friend, Wayne, who
Speaker 2certainly was nowhere near as successful as Mark. In fact, Wayne lived in a trailer. He'd been in prison for meth dealing. He was kind of a dodgy character. He was constantly unemployed. He was actually the lead suspect in the unsolved murder of a local preacher and So it seemed very strange that these men kept so closely in contact. But what was even stranger is that they looked exactly like each other. I mean, they could have been twins. They were both bald. They were both squat. They both
Speaker 2had similar faces, similar facial hair. And when they were at weddings or public ceremonies, they liked to ham it up and dress in exactly the same way. And people would often mix them up. And they seemed to sort of enjoy this closeness. They would also constantly text each other. Their texts were not exactly homosexual, but homosocial, certainly. But their relationship was far, far closer than most male buddies would be. Mark would send Wayne sexual pictures of Teresa.
Speaker 2He would boast about her. Wayne would boast about his girlfriend. And once the police looked at these texts, there was definitely... a very uncanny relationship between these two lookalikes.
Speaker 1What do you mean by homosocial?
Speaker 2Well, there was no evidence of homosexuality between them, but for example, they were happy to be in threesomes if there was a girl there. So they came very close together. to being homosexual without actually, I guess, admitting it or coming out or confronting it. And they also loved spending so much time together. It seemed like their social relationship
Speaker 2was homosexual, if not their sexual relationship, but it all seemed to be mixed together in this subliminal sort of self-identification they saw in each other, almost as if they wanted to to be each other or they wanted to switch places. You know, one was really a mirror image of the other. So their kind of obsession with each other was really sort of a self-interest in a way, an obsession with themselves.
Speaker 1Because I looked at the photos of the two of them and it really is eerie. They are the same person. They look exactly the same. It was you know, reading about their similarities doesn't quite prepare you for seeing it in real life. They do look exactly the same. They also, they're very intimate in the way they talk. They call each other baby and sugar and sunshine. And yeah, that does seem to, I can imagine for you, especially, you know, you've got that psychoanalyst side of your profession. That must
Speaker 1have been fascinating for you to unpack.
Speaker 2Yeah, it was sort of endlessly interesting. I mean, To some extent, even though Mark had become very successful, to some extent he was sort of emasculated in his role. He was the Mr. Mom, the child carer, the cook. He sort of pandered to his wife's needs. And he was a very macho guy. He was a wrestler. He had a motorcycle. He collected guns. He was very interested in macho pursuits. And it seems to me that perhaps
Speaker 2feeling emasculated in Florida, when he was back with Wayne, he could enjoy the sort of macho side of his personality. And the same for Wayne. Wayne was unemployed. He had almost no money. But when he was around Mark, Mark had money. They could drink. They could go out to eat. They could get drunk together. They could enjoy this sort of braggadocio that men often enjoy. But in their case, it just went so much further, partly because they'd known each other for so long, but it was almost as
Speaker 2though the other one's life represented the path not taken. Because Wayne, even though he was unemployed, he had no money, he was his own man. You know, he could do what he wanted. He didn't have to go to work every day. He didn't have to kowtow to a wife. He didn't have to pander to people the way that Mark did.
Speaker 1Makeda, take us to 2014, because... Obviously, these two men were very involved in each other's lives, but it kind of ramped up then when Wayne was hired by Mark and Teresa.
Speaker 2Yeah, Wayne was a sort of wizard at computer technology and Mark and Teresa needed a tech person for their practice. They weren't satisfied with the tech person they have. So Mark suggested, well, why not hire Wayne? He can actually access most of the servers from from St. Louis, but he could also come down a lot and they could visit. And so at that point, Mark and Wayne started spending a lot more time together. They saw each other regularly. They, you know, Wayne had a reason to come down to
Speaker 2Florida all the time. He was getting money from Mark. So at that point, they came not even closer, but that Wayne was actually, you know, physically around a lot more. And Teresa was also very fond of Wayne.
Speaker 1Yeah, I was going to ask that. She liked their relationship. She liked Wayne.
Speaker 2Yeah, she liked Wayne. I think she liked someone who would kind of take Mark off her hands for a while. The kids liked Wayne too. He was, you know, a fun guy to have around. He would join the family on their, you know, they would often go to the zoo or amusement parks and Wayne would come along with them. He's a popular member of the family. Uncle Wayne, the kids called him.
Speaker 1So if we skip forward to 2015, the relationship between Mark and Teresa was starting to sour quite a bit, wasn't it?
Speaker 2It was starting to sour and Mark was feeling more and more like they were headed for divorce and that she was going to leave him. He was also worried that she might hook up with this doctor that she was involved with. She might take the children. There was rather a large insurance policy on her life. he, yeah, he was feeling more and more emasculated, but he also still adored her. You know, he was still kind of obsessed with her, still found her beautiful, still wanted sex
Speaker 2with her regularly. And so not long before Teresa's death, Wayne got married. And so Mark went to St. Louis for Wayne's wedding, where he, re-met with all of his old friends. It was a very raucous time. There was lots and lots of drinking going on. And at the wedding, Mark said he wanted to talk to Wayne in private. It was very difficult for them to get time together because Wayne, they had this raucous bachelor party and then
Speaker 2Wayne was, they were setting up for the wedding the next day. But they did get some time to speak together. Wayne had left some meat in a storage facility that he needed to drive and pick up, and Mark decided to go with him. Well, basically, at Wayne's wedding, these two men dressed identically in their tuxedo. It was looking identical. Mark said to Wayne that Teresa was going to leave him. He was going to lose the children. He was going to lose everything. They tried counseling. He was not in
Speaker 2an emotional or financial place to get divorced. And he said the only thing to do was to get rid of Teresa. And Wayne, you know, was pretty shocked. He didn't realize things had got that far. But for him, you know, Mark was more than his brother. What Mark said, Wayne did. And so Wayne, you know, after some discussions said, okay, what's the timeframe? And Mark said, as soon as possible.
Speaker 2And at that point, they drive back to the wedding and Wayne takes his marriage vows. So it's a really bizarre circumstance. Mark is very careful that they should buy burner phones so that there's no trace of their communication. He's clearly thought this through very carefully. And so they both start to communicate on burner phones and arrange a date for Wayne to come down when Mark's away. So Mark's got a perfect alibi. And for Wayne to murder
Speaker 2his wife.
Speaker 1Two things. One, why would Wayne agree to murder someone so quickly? And two, I am really shocked as to how Mark jumped. Well, to be honest, how any man jumps from, oh, she's going to leave me. I need to murder her. I know.
Speaker 2It's crazy. I mean, what's wrong with divorce? What's wrong with divorce? Yeah. Supposing they get divorced, the standard of living would have changed, but they'd still have the kids. They'd still have the sunshine in Florida. They'd get used to it. They might even be more stable and happier.
Speaker 1And happy.
Speaker 2For Mark, I think it's he depended on Teresa so much. He identified with her so much. She'd already kind of emasculated him and he was so identified with her. I think that he felt unconsciously that if he didn't, it would be like a kind of castration without her, that there would be sort of no point in him existing. He couldn't exist with the knowledge that she and the children were there in the world and didn't want him. I think it was purely personal, deep, deep selfishness. There
Speaker 2also was an insurance policy. I mean, the jury actually found that the crime wasn't committed for the money, but there was a significant amount of money involved. And Mark did promise Wayne $ 100, 000. So that was part of Wayne's incentive, perhaps a significant part. But again, I think the other reasons were that Wayne would do what Mark told him to do, And also I think that once Teresa was out of the picture, Mark had talked about coming back to Missouri, moving back to his hometown, being close to Wayne.
Speaker 1It's really terrifying reading about this couple's life and this man because it appears that he was not a violent man. He'd never done anything abusive or anything like that. And then he's planning this really violent murder of his wife wife that he apparently loves.
Speaker 2Yeah, I think there's a lot of arrogance on Mark's part. Obviously, he's convinced that he can get away with it. He makes very sure that he cannot be traced to that crime scene at all. Like you said, he's not a violent person. He's never abused anyone. He's very gentle towards the children and the pets. And he abstracts himself from the scene so that he doesn't have to be involved with the violence at all. All he has to do
Speaker 2is purportedly learn that his wife has been killed. And it's interesting that he actually got the death penalty and is on death row right now. Whereas Wayne and the other assassin in the case, a guy called Jimmy the Hammer, actually got lesser sentences. I mean, Wayne actually took a plea deal, but Mark's crime, masterminding this terrible crime, was
Speaker 2taken much more seriously than the crimes of those who actually perpetrated it. And I think rightly so, really.
Speaker 1Yeah, no, I agree. Let's bring in Jimmy because Wayne kind of recruited a second to help him commit this crime. So his real name is Jimmy Ray Rogers, known as Jimmy the Hammer. Tell us about him and how he knows Wayne.
Speaker 2Jimmy's a rather sad character, actually. He had an incredibly abusive childhood. He was sort of abandoned as a kid. His mother committed suicide. He was brought up by his older brother, who was in the army for a long time. He really had no money. He wasn't close to anyone in his family. They died before he was out of his teens. He started to get a criminal record as a young man, firstly for speeding, and then secondly for
Speaker 2having his father's guns in his home. And he started doing short prison sentences early. And it was during these prison sentences that one of them, that he met Wayne, they met in prison. And Jimmy, Wayne was about 20 years older and Jimmy really looks up to him. He thought he was like a real tough guy. He was a kickboxer, supposedly a cage fighter. Wayne talked about how he'd been involved in murder for hire. Jimmy said he had too, although I think that these were just empty
Speaker 2boasts on behalf of both of these men. But they became quite close. Wayne thought that Jimmy was just a poor kid who just got a bad deal. Like I said, Jimmy took advice from Wayne. Jimmy was always short of money. So when they got out of prison, every time Wayne wanted He would help Jimmy. He'd take him for job interviews and so on. He would help him move. But when Wayne said to Jimmy that he had a job that involved a murder, Jimmy was going, oh, he didn't
Speaker 2even ask who it was or what it was about. And Jimmy was sort of very kind of reckless and thoughtless and needed, constantly needed money. But at the same time, He was supposed to be a very hard worker. His boss said he was one of the best workers in the facility. He took in his girlfriend, Taylor, who had three different kids by three different men. Jimmy looked after them, brought them up, cared for them. Taylor said he was,
Speaker 2you know, he was just a real gentleman to her all the time. So there was this kind of really contradictory nature, I think, as many people do. But it's also significant that Mark did not know Jimmy. He knew nothing about the fact that Wayne was bringing Jimmy along because he didn't, you know, he told Wayne, this is out of my hands. I don't want to know about the details. Go ahead and do what you want. So Wayne had fibromyalgia. They were driving straight from Missouri to Florida. He needed someone to take over the wheel. Jimmy was
Speaker 2a lot younger. Jimmy said he'd killed before. I mean, Wayne thought he would be the perfect person to be there. the co-hitman in this case. So they were a very, in some ways, mismatched pair. In some ways, they had a lot of similarities.
Speaker 1Tell us about the day of the murder because, as you mentioned, the two of them drove to Florida and then they had this weird, like, lovely morning sightseeing and having lunch and, you know, like wrecking the house and then going in and committing this absolutely horrific crime.
Speaker 2I know it was so bungled. They, they didn't even have a plan like where they were going to kill her or how they were going to kill her. They debated on the way down. They pulled up maps of the house and the doctor's office, which was absurd because the police could get hold of this GPS and see where they'd been looking. They, you know, Wayne was going to put her in a karate grip and then strangle her and they were still sort of debating what to do.
Speaker 2And when they arrived in Florida, they'd been driving for a long time. They checked out the house, wanted to see if the dogs would welcome them, wanted to turn off the alarm. They slept in the car for a while. And then they had to kill the day before the murder. They go to the beach. Jimmy's never seen the sea before. He's never been out of Missouri. They try out all the beaches, up and down the bay. They get something to eat. They have a drink. Jimmy buys some souvenirs.
Speaker 2Jimmy hasn't got water shoes. So they take a shopping trip to Walmart, buy some water shoes, another t-shirt for Jimmy. He gets some fancy dress shoes. Wayne gets some new water shoes. They get things they might need for the murder, like some wipe ups and plastic bags. I mean, it's just absolutely thoughtless. It's almost as if they wanted to get caught because they didn't realize or recognize the fact that they were going to be caught on surveillance camera
Speaker 2at Walmart picking up these goodies for the beach. I mean, it's just absurd. And even when they got to the house, they'd mistimed the time that Teresa was supposed to be coming back. She came back earlier than they expected. They were just hanging out in the garage looking at Mark's motorbike. And that's one of the reasons why the murder was so horrifying is that they just hadn't finalized their plans And so when Teresa came back, they just had to grab what they could find. And that happened to be
Speaker 2ironically a hammer. So the murders were committed with, with hammers, which was supposed to be Jimmy's favorite weapon, which is how he got that nickname. So whether it was, you know, his intention all along, but it was just absolutely unnecessary and gratuitous, um, abysmal horror.
Speaker 1Coming up, Makita takes us through Mark's arrest and the trial. I think, obviously, it all makes me sick, but what makes me really sick is hearing about their day beforehand. You know, kind of like this, you describe it as like a boy's adventure, playing assassins like they're in a TV show. There doesn't seem to be a single moment where these two men pause and think about the life that they're about to take, about the children they're about to have, deprive of a mother. There's no empathy. There's
Speaker 1no thought. Right.
Speaker 2And the sort of bungled trip to Walmart, it seems like there's an aspect of it that seems comic. But then when you realize what that in that they're actually going to murder someone and they seem to put that on the same level as like buying new beach shoes without thinking, particularly for Wayne, like this is a woman who has paid him to work on her computers, who's had him as a guest at her house When he
Speaker 2comes down, she's always like, because they have a meatless household, she's always like buying bacon and sausages for Wayne and wondering if they need to get some coffee creamer in for him. And just being a really generous, kind guest. He's also, you know, the children know him as their uncle. So he's going to be making these children motherless. He's going to be murdering a woman who's In the prime of her life, who's beloved, he's going to be taking
Speaker 2from the community this nurturing doctor. I mean, there's absolutely no thought except I've never been to the beach before. Let's check it out. It's horrifying.
Speaker 1It is horrifying. I told listeners earlier about the crime itself because I think it's important for people to know about the fact that there were 17 blows because it's it shows the violence, the level of violence. Do we know who actually held that hammer, who murdered her?
Speaker 2Well, it's interesting. And I think you're right about the violence. I mean, I think it's important. I mean, some people think that you've obviously had this conversation before that true crime can be very lurid and it can, but I think it's also important to know what people are capable of and the kinds of things that happen without kind of glossing over it to actually face it head on. So after a while, once Wayne realized the police arrested them pretty easily, once Wayne realized they had him on
Speaker 2surveillance video, there was no way he was going to get away with this. He turned state's evidence, he turned against Mark and he got a sentence of 25 years and he was in his fifties at the time. So, you know, he may get out of prison. So he confessed to the police, but he did so through a series of long roundabout series of lies. And first he said, Jimmy committed the crime. He was just the lookout, which was ridiculous. Then he said, yes, okay, I was in the kitchen, but I didn't strike any blows, which was
Speaker 2even more absurd. Finally, he told the truth that they both had hammers. Wayne struck the first blows. Jimmy followed through later that they were you know, in terms of like actually committing, physically committing the crime, they had pretty much equal responsibility.
Speaker 1Mark, on the other hand, it took them quite a while to kind of link him and arrest him and have evidence to arrest him. How did they eventually get him? Was it that plea deal you mentioned with Wayne?
Speaker 2Yeah, I mean, it took Wayne quite a long time. Wayne and Mark stayed close to each other. They weren't allowed to to see each other, of course, but Mark defended Wayne and said, Mark told everyone, oh, they would look for the husband. They can't find the husband. So they arrest the husband's best friend and they're going to frame me and was very loyal to Wayne. But as time passed, I think Wayne started to, the bond between them started to break because they hadn't seen each other in so long. And I think Wayne started to realize that,
Speaker 2you know, he was, there was no way a jury was going to believe him. So, but the police had no evidence against Mark. If you think about it, there was one text on the burner phone that said, you know, I have something to talk, can we talk in private? And that was pretty much it. So it was, everyone knew that Mark was responsible, but there was absolutely no evidence against him because in some ways, compared to these
Speaker 2two bunglers, he'd been quite thoughtful and sophisticated about it. not getting involved. And Wayne said, after the crime, Wayne tried to speak to Mark about it. And Mark just wouldn't speak about it. He wanted nothing to do with it. And he told Wayne that he'd compartmentalized so much that he couldn't actually acknowledge or recognize that he was involved in any way, partly because he wanted to pass a lie detector test. He didn't want to let that into his head. He was very good at denial. And even
Speaker 2now he claims that he was innocent. But, yeah, it was very hard to tie Mark to the crime. And it was only when Wayne told the truth that Mark could actually be picked up and arrested. But, you know, everyone knew that he was involved.
Speaker 1Yeah, by the time he was arrested, everyone kind of was already blaming him. And you kind of picked up on all of the instances where people in his life kind of turned around and had these retrospective like aha moments that he wasn't such a good guy. Can you talk about that? Because it's very interesting that, you know, prior to this murder, Mark was an amazing guy. And then after he starts to become a suspect, all these stories come out.
Speaker 2Yeah, and I'm not sure how true many of those stories were because people... you know, if you find out that a friend of yours who you were close to has been convicted of a murder, it's very tempting to start to think, hmm, maybe he wasn't telling the truth. Or yeah, I think he actually may have stolen a book from my house. Or, you know, he did say something suspicious and start to look in retrospect at ways that they behaved that seemed to imply that that nefariousness
Speaker 2was there all along. And I think it's a, a natural human tendency, but I also think that it's part of it is a desire to, to make it seem as though you weren't hoodwinked, you know, you weren't fooled like everyone else was. You had a certain knowledge that you'd noticed things about this person that made you suspicious and you hadn't been, you know, sucked in by their sweet,
Speaker 2friendly personality that you'd seen beneath the surface. And I think, like I said, that's a natural tendency, but that kind of retrospective suspicion I think will sometimes sort of fabricate incidents that didn't actually happen or exaggerate at least.
Speaker 1We should mention that this case in Florida got basically like wall-to-wall media coverage. It was enormous in terms of the attention that What did you make of the trial? Because there was a lot of attention on Mark's trial in particular. Wayne obviously took a plea deal. He didn't have a trial. Jimmy had a trial. There wasn't so much interest there. But Mark's, looking back at that trial and seeing how it played out, what did you make of it?
Speaker 2I think the case did get enormous coverage. But like many law-ridden, spectacular cases, the coverage is pretty superficial because there's always another case coming along. And The media obviously only has so much time. So, I mean, that's one of the reasons I wanted to write the book. I wanted to go beneath the surface and go into depth and have more time to analyze what was really going on in these cases. But, you know, Mark's I feel
Speaker 2like Mark was was doomed from the start. I mean, the the press was against him. The sheriff was against him. It was such a horrible murder that once Jimmy, Jimmy's trial was first, once Jimmy had been found guilty, I don't think Mark had a chance at all. And he really didn't have any supporters. I mean, pretty much everyone had turned on him. He appeared in nicely dressed in a suit, appeared to be jotting down notes all the
Speaker 2way through. He didn't take the stand. He didn't testify. I think it was pretty much a foregone conclusion. I mean, Nobody was surprised when he was found guilty. I think there were a few surprises when he was given the death penalty, partly because he wasn't actually at the crime scene. He didn't lift a weapon. He didn't touch the victim in that way. But I think that he set everything in motion and it was his wife. So there may
Speaker 2have been a few surprises that he got the death penalty, but perhaps not many.
Speaker 1What does the death penalty look like in Florida? Will he sit on death row for years and years and years or how does it work?
Speaker 2He probably will. I mean, people think it's like in the movies, it's a row of cages where guys are taken to the death chamber, but it's actually more like a kind of poorly funded assisted living facility. There's huge numbers of men who've been on death row for you know, 15, 20 years. There's so much bureaucracy to get through. People have appeal after appeal after appeal. It can take an enormous amount of time. I think the average time spent on death row is more than 20 years. So most
Speaker 2men die of natural causes on death row before getting executed. That might happen to Mark. Because this was such a notorious case, there might be more pressure for him to be executed. before he might normally be. He had a post-conviction, hearing where he tried to get the death penalty overturned, which didn't work. He was recently, about a month ago, he was attacked and injured quite seriously. So, you know,
Speaker 2something like that might happen. He might get killed by a I imagine that he'll be there for quite a long time.
Speaker 1Well, he is still trying to do appeals, even what, like, quite recently, this year, he was denied a new trial.
Speaker 2Yeah, the judge's response came last year. That was a post-conviction hearing, which I actually attended in Fort Myers. And he was hoping to get his conviction overturned. He was suggesting that there was improper evidence and and the mitigation wasn't conducted correctly and so on. But I don't think there was any chance. I mean, there's so much evidence
Speaker 2against him from Wayne's testimony, and the crime was so heinous that it's very, very difficult to imagine him getting any amount of clemency from any quarter.
Speaker 1Makeda... I just think about Teresa's girls, about those little girls that were old enough to understand what happened. Do we know if they're all right? Do we know if they're being looked after?
Speaker 2The children were taken by Teresa's mother, got custody of them. And so they're being brought up by her mother, Teresa's sister, and they have absolutely no contact with Mark. They're not permitted to, and they don't want to. And I have no idea whether that, I mean, obviously this is a terrible trauma, but from as far as I know, they have lots of loving family around them.
Speaker 1After immersing yourself in this crime and in the relationships between Mark and Teresa and Wayne, what do you make of this case and this story now after all the research you've done looking back? Because for me, I mean, I've done a lot of crime stories now and this one, I can't get it out of my head because it is just so hard to wrap yourself around how this happened, the motive, the lack of thought, all of it. What do you make of it?
Speaker 2Yeah, that's one of the reasons that drew me to it because it just seems so wasteful and so easily could not have happened, so unnecessary and motivated. But most, like I live in Baltimore, there's probably two murders a week in Baltimore, but they're the kind of murders people are afraid unfortunately not interested in. It's gangland perpetrators, it's drugs, it's street warfare. And one day's victim One day's perpetrator
Speaker 2is the next day's victim. So it's like territorial warfare. So it's very difficult to separate victim and perpetrator. And people don't like that. They want to read true crime where there is the good person and the evil person. And there's these really strong binaries, which is not actually how things are. And so what interested me among other things about this case is that it is typical in the fact that most women are killed not by a stranger or a random perpetrator, but by the person that
Speaker 2loves them, the husband or someone that they're close to. And it's really important to remember that these ideas of random serial killers out there are sort of subterfuged so that we can deny the fact that we're actually much more in danger of being killed in our own home. So that was one of the things that... In some ways, in that sense, the case was typical. And the fact,
Speaker 2I mean, people are really interested in crimes that occur in white middle-class communities that are, where the victim is a woman, that are premeditated. So it did have all of those aspects to it. So it was both typical and atypical in many ways. But I think what stands out is the kind of the bizarreness, Mark and Wayne connection, and also the the futility of it. And yes, it's unforgettable, these characters and the sort of duality between Florida and St.
Speaker 2Louis and between Mark and Wayne. I mean, it's almost like this symmetrical kind of case.
Speaker 1You're so right, though, that it is typical, unfortunately, because women dying at the hands of their former or current partner is happening every, I mean, it's happening every week here. I'm sure it's similar numbers over there. Yeah. Well, thank you for joining us, Makeda. I really appreciate it. And thank you for analysing this because it's so important, I think, for us to kind of dig into these crimes and these people and try to understand what drives them.
Speaker 2Right, exactly. It's important not just to enjoy the gory surface details, but to actually understand take it seriously and look underneath and see how this is a part of the human character, human psychology, even among people who seem innocuous.
Speaker 1Thank you to Makita for helping us tell this story. You'll find a link to her book in our show notes. If you liked this episode and want to hear more from guests like this, send us an email at truecrime at mamamia.com.au. Thanks so much for listening. I'll be back next week with another True Crime Conversation.
Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander listeners are advised that this episode names a person who has died and includes descriptions of violence. In line with Warlpiri custom, he is referred to as Kumanjayi Walker. In...
This episode is an update on the case of Elly Warren, the young Australian woman who died in Mozambique. Since Elly’s death, her father Paul has refused to accept silence. With few answers from authorities, he has spent...
For years Jason lived a double life as an undercover police officer, working inside the criminal underworld. No two jobs were the same, and the danger was always there. The toll of that work didn’t end when he left the...
In July 2026, Anastasia Treharne sat in a Sydney courtroom waiting to hear her rapist’s sentence. She had been through a gruelling trial and cross-examined at length, and a jury had found him guilty. The maximum penalty...
In 2008, Kristi McVee was a new mum flicking through the newspaper when a WA Police recruitment ad caught her eye. Less than two years later, she was sworn in as a police officer. Kristi went on to build a career...