Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander listeners are advised that this episode names a person who has died and includes descriptions of violence. In line with Warlpiri custom, he is referred to as Kumanjayi Walker. In November 2019, 19-year-old Warlpiri and Luritja man Kumanjayi Walker was shot three times during an attempted arrest at his grandmother’s home in Yuendumu, a remote community north-west of Alice Springs. He died at the Yuendumu police station that night, while his family waited outside asking to be let in. They didn’t learn of his death until the next morning. NT Police Constable Zachary Rolfe was charged with murder and acquitted by a jury. It was the beginning of a six-year legal process, ending in a coronial inquest that shook the Northern Territory Police to its core. Journalist and author Kate Wild features in the new SBS and NITV documentary series 2.6 Seconds: Death in the Outback and has written a book on the case, The Red House. In this episode, she takes Gemma through what happened in Yuendumu that night, the trial and the inquest, and the questions about justice, policing and race that the case continues to raise. Stream 2.6 Seconds: Death in the Outback on SBS On Demand now, with the final two episodes available next week. Purchase Kate's book The Red House by Kate Wild here. GET IN TOUCH Follow us on Instagram and TikTok @truecrimeconversations Want us to cover a case on the podcast? Email us at truecrime@mamamia.com.au or send us a voice note. MAMAMIA OFFERS: Subscribe here for 30% off your annual Mamamia subscription for Black Friday with code BLACK30. Code applied at the checkout. Offer ends November 30. Make sure to leave us a rating and review on Apple & Spotify to let us know how you're liking the episodes. CREDITS Host & Executive Producer: Gemma Bath Guests: Kate Wild Produced by Ella Maitland Video Editor: Lisa Chen Mamamia acknowledges the traditional owners of the land on which we have recorded this podcast. Become a Mamamia subscriber: https://www.mamamia.com.au/subscribe
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Speaker 1We'd like to acknowledge the Gadigal people of the Eora Nation, the traditional custodians of the land we're recording on today. We pay our respects to Elders past and present and extend that respect to any Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people listening. Before we begin, this episode discusses the death of a young Aboriginal man and includes descriptions of violence. Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander listeners, please be aware that it names a person who has died. In line with Welpree custom, He is known as Kumunjai Walker. Kumunjai is
Speaker 1the word used in place of a person's name after they pass. It's a Saturday in November 2019 in Newindamu, a Walpree Indigenous community about 300 kilometres northwest of Alice Springs. Today the town, full of red dirt roads, low houses and deserts stretching out in every direction, is fuller than usual. Families have driven in from across Central Australia for a funeral. The man's grandson, 19-year-old Kumanjay Walker, is hoping to join
Speaker 1the commemorations and pay his respects. But there's one small problem. He is wanted by police. By seven o'clock that evening, four officers from the Alice Springs Immediate Response Team have arrived in the community. Their orders for the night are to patrol the town, be visible and arrest Kumanjai if they come across him. By 7.21pm, they find him in his grandmother's house. Put your hands behind your back, 28-year-old
Speaker 1Constable Zachary Rolfe tells Kumanjai. There's a struggle and Rolfe fires at him. 2.6 seconds later, he fires again and again. I know Gumanjay would be so proud of all of us.
Speaker 2We want Justice for Walker! But this is not the end of his story and this is not the end of our fight. When?
Speaker 1We are going to get.
Speaker 2Justice!
Speaker 1I'm Gemma Bath and this is True Crime Conversations, a podcast exploring the world's most notorious crimes by speaking to the people who know the most about them. Kumunjay Walker died at Yuendumu Police Station at 8.36pm after being shot three times. He died without his family's support, even though they stood outside begging.
Speaker 2To be let in.
Speaker 1They didn't learn about his death until 8am the next morning. Their grief and anger was felt across Australia, sparking national outrage. Then, the police officer involved was charged with murder. It was the start of a six-year court process across a murder trial which resulted in an acquittal and then a shocking coronial inquest that rocked the Northern Territory Police Force to its core. In a landmark SBS and NITV documentary series from Blackfella Films that premiered this week, 2.6 Seconds Death
Speaker 1in the Outback is re-examining Kumunjai's story and the events that followed. Author and journalist Kate Wilde features in the four-part series. and has also written a book on this case. It's called The Red House. I want to acknowledge before we start that Kate and I are two non-Indigenous women. We can't speak to that lived experience, and we're not here to speak for anyone. We're covering it because we think more people need to know about this story. Kate
Speaker 1has sat with Kumajai's family and immersed herself in their community, but to hear directly from them We'll link to the work of Samara Fernandez-Brown in our show notes. She's Kumunjai's cousin and the force behind the Justice for Walker campaign. Here's Kate. Kate, you were living in Sydney in 2019 when Kumunjai was killed by a police officer in 2019. Do you remember that? your first reactions as that news
Speaker 1was breaking?
Speaker 2Vividly. I remember hearing the story on the radio, a very brief news report that a young Aboriginal man had been shot by a police officer in the community of Yuendumu. And I know Yuendumu really well. I've been there a couple of times. And I know that part of the Northern Territory really well. So I could see pictures immediately. I could see the images of what... You could visualise it. Yeah, yeah. And I knew right away that... it would have a national impact because there's something so iconic in our history
Speaker 2and something so essential to our history of an Aboriginal man in particular being shot by a white police officer. And we very soon found out fatally, fatally shot.
Speaker 1Can you give us a bit more context about your involvement up there? Because you'd been living and working in the Northern Territory for quite a number of years.
Speaker 2So I lived in the Northern Territory from 2010 to 2016. I worked for a good deal of that time as a journalist, as an investigative journalist for the ABC, and most of what I covered was stories that involved First Nations communities and First Nations people because a lot of the big news stories involved their communities and involved things that were happening to them. And also I had plenty of friends in those communities. And so my husband, who's
Speaker 2a lawyer and was involved in Aboriginal communities legal aid up there. We both were really involved in everything that was going on in the community. This is probably a.
Speaker 1Big question, but what did living and immersing yourself in those communities, what did it teach you about that part.
Speaker 2Of the world? That it's a different country. It's a different country to the rest of Australia, a fascinating country, a place that you cannot assume you know anything about, and a place where if you don't understand what's going on, you have to spend time working out what is going on because there are so many cultural differences that, you know, I could give you so many examples of times when I would think that a friend from one of the
Speaker 2communities had sort of stood me up or wasn't returning my phone calls or that something strange was going on. And then I would find out later on what the reason was, that they had thought that I didn't want to speak to them anymore, or that they had thought that I wasn't going to be there. There was so often a cultural explanation for why miscommunications happened. And I think that's one of the really big things I learned. The other thing I have taken with me from the Northern Territory is that nothing is straightforward. Nothing is you know,
Speaker 2the cliche black and white, everything is complicated and everything is multi-layered and that's its beauty and also its difficulty.
Speaker 1Yindamu specifically, tell us about that community because it's quite distinct when you look at photos, the bright red dirt, but what's it like there? Give us some.
Speaker 2It's a small place by most people's standards, but it's quite big for an Aboriginal community in the Northern Territory. There's probably anywhere between about 300, 400 people there most of the time, but that can swell to sort of 800 if there's a sports weekend on or if there's a funeral on. Aboriginal people are very mobile in the Territory. People are travelling 300, 500 kilometres a day to visit family or to do various things. Like it's just really not uncommon for someone to say, from Alice Springs, oh, I'm going out to Yuendumu today and that's a 350
Speaker 2kilometre drive. And that's not a big deal for people. So you and Damil, it's a desert community. It's very, very red soil. I write about it in my book as looking like a bunch of buildings sort of tipped out of a dustpan. Everything's a little bit higgledy-piggledy. There are a couple of sort of official buildings, like the council building and the school and PAW, the local media organisation, which have quite high fences and are really locked up. And then there's all the sort of people's homes that
Speaker 2which have sort of waist-high sort of cyclone fencing like we're used to in New South Wales. We're used to having like around a schoolyard. Lots of people live in a house. It's very overcrowded. Lots of dogs running around. Yeah, and you can turn up one day and there's absolutely no one there. It's like a ghost town. Really? And then you can turn up there. There's two shops in Yuendumu and you can turn up in the morning and it feels like everyone in town is at the shop just to catch up on the gossip and get their groceries or fill up on fuel.
Speaker 1So you don't really know what to expect when you rock up.
Speaker 2You never know what to expect.
Speaker 1Well, I'm going to quote you back at you because I just thought this was a beautiful description. You said, Yundamu's physical poverty disguises the depth of its residents' lives.
Speaker 2Absolutely. I have given a lift back to a friend from Yundamu and the whole way along that stretch of road, that 350 kilometres, she would talk to me about the stories and the animals and the plants that belong to each little section of of country that we're passing through. She can tell me stories about her family, about other families, about the geology. I have sat around campfires and been taught how to cook a kangaroo tail and been told fantastical stories about, you know, lightning jumping between clouds, being
Speaker 2like the clouds are talking to each other on the telephone, telling each other not to rain right now because there's someone sitting outside eating their dinner. You and DeMille is one of the places that's quite close in territory terms to Papunya where the Western Desert Art Movement started. They have had a bilingual education, Wolperi English Education Centre. for decades. They have PAW Media, which is where Bush Mechanics, that famous TV show, was made and filmed. It's a really,
Speaker 2really rich place and people have so much knowledge there. But, well, people don't show off about their knowledge. So most people don't ask, so most people don't know it's there.
Speaker 1Can you give us some context of what the relationship was like between police and the community prior to this happening? Because there is a lot of history there, isn't there?
Speaker 2There's a lot of history and it's really hard to tie it down to a certain relationship because, of course, you know, all the police are individuals, all the community members are individuals and some of those people might get on and some of them mightn't. even throughout this whole story of Kumanjai's death, there were a lot of elders in Yundamu who spoke of their fondness for certain police officers and how much they needed the police and cared for them and cared about them. Not these specific police officers involved in this incident, but police who had looked
Speaker 2after their communities for years and who they knew well and who had lived with them and who'd been adopted into families or just cared for. So it's a complicated relationship always. And in the Northern Territory there's also that historical relationship of police having been involved in massacres in the past. You know, in particular for Yuendumu, the Coniston Massacre in 1928, it's often called sort of the last state-sanctioned massacre in Australia. And a police officer led that
Speaker 2and it went for months. So that's very much living history in Yuendumu.
Speaker 1Well, that's not that long ago. It's not that long ago.
Speaker 2Until, you know, 15 years ago, there were still people alive who remembered it as kids, but their families all still know the stories. And even when I was in Alice Springs and Yundamu writing about this story, I had people in their 60s come up to me and tell me about the deaths of family members in that massacre or in other instances, either by white station owners or by police officers.
Speaker 1I was interested to learn that Rolf was ex-military, but there's a lot of ex-military, particularly in the Territory.
Speaker 2Yeah, and I haven't been able to compare it to other states, so I don't know if it's similar in WA, for instance, or if it's similar in the ACT. But going off the top of my head, there's something like, something approaching 20% to 25% of the Northern Territory Police Force has a military background of some sort, has been in a defence force in the past.
Speaker 1That is an enormous... Yeah, it feels big.
Speaker 2That's an enormous number, right? Whether other places have numbers similar or not, that's a big number. That's, you know, one in four cops you see on the street are going to have had a military background of some sort. Kumanjai, can you tell us about him? a bit about his background, his story, who he was. He's a complicated character. He was 19 when he died. He didn't really ever get a proper sort of set of psychological tests to be able to pin down exactly what his cognitive disabilities were.
Speaker 2But a psychologist who worked with him quite a bit has said to me that he had the mental capacity of about a six-year-old.
Speaker 3Mm-hmm.
Speaker 2So he had cognitive disabilities quite likely brought on by fetal alcohol syndrome. His mother was a very heavy drinker. She died when he was less than 12 years old. His father died around the same time. So by the time he was 12, he didn't have parents. He was raised by members of his extended family. So he grew up mostly in Yuendumu. He had family in other remote communities as well who he often visited. But when he... was very young, before he was even one year old,
Speaker 2he was sort of adopted out to a woman in Yuendumu, Leanne Oldfield, who cared for him because there was a lot of substance abuse, mostly alcohol abuse in his family, and members of his family decided it was better for Leanne to bring him up. He still grew up surrounded by a lot of violence and in a very fractured community and a very was sniffing petrol as a young child. He smoked a lot of cannabis by the time he was about 14 and onwards, and he was in and
Speaker 2out of the justice system, in and out of juvenile detention, mostly for breaking into houses in Yuandamu, but also eventually for assaults on a number of girlfriends that he had. So there are two stories I would often get told about Kumanjai, depending on who I was talking to. Many people would say, oh, he was a very friendly young man. He was not violent. He smiled a lot. He would laugh. He loved animals. He loved his family. And I'm sure
Speaker 2that all of that is true. There is another truth, which was that he was very violent towards women in his life and he died quite young and we don't know what that would have become.
Speaker 1Will you explain really well why those family members or the community members would have given a more sanitised version of Kumanjai.
Speaker 2There is a reason. There's a really good reason why Aboriginal people tell the more sanitised version of events in community. Because the intervention, which was brought in by John Howard's government, you know, around sort of the end of 2006, is still talked about as a time of immense horror in the Northern Territory by Aboriginal people in particular, and its impacts are still felt. It came about because there had been reports, you know, media reports of serious child abuse
Speaker 2in remote communities. A very measured report and investigation was done on that by two very well-respected people in the Northern Territory. That report was given to government and Howard's government used it as an excuse to send the army in and, if you hear Aboriginal people tell the story, terrorise their communities.
Speaker 1Mm.
Speaker 2It was in the name of protecting children. It did not have that impact. And so in the eyes of many Aboriginal people who I've spoken to, that's what happens when you tell the truth. You don't get listened to in a compassionate way. You don't get supported and helped. No one asks you what the solutions might be, even though you know very well what the solutions will be. White people just come and jump on you and lock you up and shout at you and tell you you're broken and wrong. So that's a very easy story to
Speaker 2tell about Kumanja because some of that is true, but it's not the whole truth.
Speaker 1No.
Speaker 2And if you tell some of the deficit side of the story, that's all that people hear.
Speaker 1Before his death, police had basically been, and am I right in saying this, basically hunting him?
Speaker 2Look, they're words that have been used. I shy away from hunting because it just sounds, maybe just because it sounds so harsh, but there was certainly a lot more interest in tracking down this particular 19-year-old Aboriginal bloke who had done nothing more than break out of rehab.
Speaker 1Yeah, so that's what they wanted him for.
Speaker 2He'd basically... He'd broken a suspended sentence by breaking out of rehab a week before he was meant to leave. Not the kind of violent incident that you would normally get an entire unit of police officers out to go searching for someone. Not the kind of behaviour that would normally lead to, you know, 12 police officers surrounding a house in a town camp. You know, maybe my reaction to the word hunting is just that it is so, it is such an awful image, but there was a lot more attention paid to catching Kumanjai than was reasonable.
Speaker 1Was part of the justification for that, this axe incident that had happened earlier?
Speaker 2The axe incident, I'm trying to remember, I don't think the axe incident hadn't happened when the police went to the town camp to look for Kumanjai.
Speaker 3Oh.
Speaker 2So the day after he escapes from rehab, a day or two later, there's a whole police unit surrounding Leanne Oldfield's house in the Walpuree camp and he's not there because he's headed off to Yuendumu already. He's hitched a ride with someone. And no one, everyone knows who it was, but no one will say who it was who gave him a ride to Yuendumu. Of course. That will stay buried in history, I think. But it wasn't, from my understanding, I'd have to check this, but it wasn't until a couple of days later that Kumanjai threatened local police officers
Speaker 2in Yuendumu with an axe in order to escape from the house. And I know that because I used to feel this way before I lived in the territory, what I say next will sound like an excuse. but it's one of the cultural differences that I learnt when I was in the Territory. Kumanjai was in his girlfriend's house. Two local police officers from Yuandamu went to knock on the door to say to him that he needed to be arrested because he'd escaped from rehab. He didn't want
Speaker 2to go with them. He wanted to go to his grandfather's funeral in two nights' time. So he pulled a small axe out from under the bed And he raised it above his head and he threatened these two police officers with it. He could have hit them.
Speaker 1He could have easily killed one or desperately injured either of them.
Speaker 2He didn't. They ran out of the house and he ran away. Now, that is an assault and those police officers would have been justified under law to pull their gun and they would have been justified in shooting Kumanjai under our law. They didn't do either of those things because they understood, because they had lived in that community and understood Wolperi culture, he was behaving in the way that a Wolperi man believed he should behave, which was that he was being embarrassed in front of his girlfriend. The police maybe were going to hurt his girlfriend, so
Speaker 2he had to be a big man and make a big show. And also he wanted to escape. He wanted to get away and he knew that threatening them would let him get away. It's called demonstrative violence. Nothing comes of it except a big show. Your bark's a lot bigger than your bite.
Speaker 1So Rolf and the team that came to Yundamu, they didn't have all of that context.
Speaker 2They did have that context. They did, because they were from Alice Springs. They were from Alice Springs. They were supposedly semi-elite unit who were able to respond to events, to sort of emergency events quickly. It was Rolf and the same crew who had gone and surrounded the house in Walpree camp days earlier, looking for Kumanjai. It's known that Rolf watched later on, watched the body-worn video of that axe attack multiple, multiple times. Make what you will
Speaker 2of that. Yeah. So that unit came out to Yundamu. They had been asked to come out as a support unit. The local police had made a plan. that Kumanjai would be arrested at dawn. He would be allowed to go to his grandfather's funeral. He was supposed to then come and hand himself in at the police station, or his family were. That's regular occurrence in small Aboriginal communities, that people will make an agreement with the police when they'll come in and they'll come in. But the cops were pretty sure he wouldn't do that. He didn't. So their backup plan was, we'll arrest him at dawn. We'll go
Speaker 2into the house and we'll get him when he's asleep. Rolf and his crew were meant to come and just do patrols of the community and just keep everything settled down, maybe do some random breath testing. They weren't meant to be part of arresting Kumanjai. They were meant to stand back. They were not even meant to be the people who went in to grab Kumanjai.
Speaker 1While all this was happening, you mentioned his grandfather's funeral. For those that aren't aware of what a First Nations funeral looks like... It's huge.
Speaker 2It can be. Yeah.
Speaker 1And this one was.
Speaker 2And this one was because his grandfather was a very, very important man in Walpurg culture and also very important in non-Indigenous culture. He was a very important artist and very skilled bicultural man. So he had a lot of friends and supporters in the Cartier community, but a lot of people came from lots of really remote places to be there at that funeral. And it's sort of like a day-long affair, you know, there's sort of ceremony all throughout the day and then the burial in the evening.
Speaker 2And it was while people were around the gravesite that phones started ringing in the cemetery to say Kumunja has been shot. So you're standing at a funeral and you hear about the death of a young man.
Speaker 1Well, a family member because his whole family would have been there. Extended family, family.
Speaker 2Yeah, and also Walpree culture has families a much bigger concept than it is for us. You know, Kumanjai had dozens of grandfathers.
Speaker 1From the police point of view, what actually happened? Because they entered the Red House, as it's known, and they came across Kumanjai. What happened?
Speaker 2So what happened was that... Rolf and the team that he was in Yuendumu with were meant to go out and just start looking around Yuendumu and getting a lay of the land. What they did instead was they immediately went looking for Kumjai, even though they knew he wasn't meant to be arrested until dawn. They went looking for him. They went to the houses where they knew he stayed and they asked for him. They went inside and they searched for him. They spoke to people and asked where he was. People told them where he was. They said
Speaker 2they thought he was at either the blue house or the red house next door. And so then Rolf and Iberl, who were partners, Iberl went into the house first. Rolf followed him and Kumanjaya was in the house. They asked him who he was, what his name was. He gave him a false name. And then Rolf sort of pushed Kumanjaya up with his back against the wall. And I've seen the footage, Rolf is holding up his mobile phone
Speaker 2beside Kumanjai's face, trying to get a match, an ID. And that's when Kumanjai pulls a pair of medical scissors or nail scissors out of his pocket and starts swinging at Rolf and ends up stabbing him in the shoulder, at which point Rolf draws his gun and shoots him.
Speaker 1Three times?
Speaker 2Three times. He shoots him once. Iberl then gets Kumanjai in a sort of headlock. and wrestles him to the ground and he's lying on top of Kumanjai. Rolf then leans down and puts his gun very close to Kumanjai's torso and fires two shots in rapid succession at very, very close range.
Speaker 1I've seen the footage too. It's quite hard at that point to see what's going on, which is obviously why everything has happened since.
Speaker 2Yeah.
Speaker 1In the documentary... A lot of the family members talk about what happened next, the ones that were nearby, about watching Kumanjaya being dragged out of that house. They say like a kangaroo and dragged across the floor and they were making the kind of comparison that if Rolf had been shot, there was no way he would have been carried like that.
Speaker 2I know you've seen what I'm talking about. Yeah, it goes back to your use of the word hunting, doesn't it? And I think that is very much how the Aboriginal community can feel or members of the Aboriginal community can feel in the Northern Territory about the way that they are sometimes treated and that physical evidence of being dragged like a kangaroo. I mean, it's all about respect. It's
Speaker 2all about signs of respect and that's another thing that Walpurg people are really big on is showing respect and I think that's one of the, most often repeated. It's more than a complaint that people have had, it's just the lack of respect that has been shown to them throughout this whole story.
Speaker 1Coming up, Kate takes us through the trial process and what it was like in the courtroom. A note I want to make before we move on, there were no medical people in town that day, were there?
Speaker 2No, there weren't. And this is the other side of the story, right? Yeah. This is not the other side of the story. This is part of the complexity of these stories, is kids like the kid that Kumanjai was when he was doing it, break into the shop and break into houses in Yundamu all the time for fun, for something to do, sometimes looking for alcohol, sometimes looking for food, sometimes looking for cigarettes, sometimes just for the kicks.
Speaker 3And.
Speaker 2It can be really terrifying for people who don't live there usually. It can be terrifying for Wolperi people as well, but it can be terrifying for visiting nurses and doctors who are not used to life in a remote community or who are also just not used to having, you know, someone take a crowbar out of their window in the middle of the night. It's very violent. It's violent and it's really frightening. And there had been a spate of break-ins for the week preceding this incident And the nurses had had enough. They were scared and they were pissed off.
Speaker 2And their bosses, they called their bosses in Alice Springs and said, this is what's happened and we're over it. And their bosses ordered them to leave town. So there was no one running the clinic. There was no one at the clinic. All of those staff had left.
Speaker 1So the people trying to save Kumanjaya's life were the officers, including Rolf.
Speaker 2Yeah.
Speaker 1He was taken back to the police station. They worked on him. And we... In the documentary, you get to see it all. You see it all on body camera and it's a challenging watch. Why do you think it is important or do you think it's important for Australians to witness Kumanjai's final hours?
Speaker 2I think Darren Dale and Blackfella Films are some of the most sensitive, thoughtful filmmakers in Australia and I think the way that they have gone about it is... very careful and very respectful. And I think the decisions that they've made to show this are about really bringing it home to people, the violence of a death in custody and the trauma of that situation, the trauma of a
Speaker 2young man lying on the floor of a police cell bleeding out and men older than him trying to then save his life after one of them has shot him. There's such complexity and such trauma and such horror in all of that. And I think the only way to really feel it is to see it.
Speaker 1And unfortunately, sometimes people need to see it to believe it.
Speaker 2Yeah, I think that's true. I think that's true. I don't know how I feel about it personally. I think it's a very intimate thing to Yeah.
Speaker 1Well, his family would have liked that opportunity. to be with him, but they weren't allowed in. No one was allowed in.
Speaker 3No.
Speaker 1What was happening outside the station?
Speaker 2So once news spread through Yundamu very rapidly that Kumunjai had been shot and that the police had taken him back to the station, pretty much the whole town walked or drove to the police station and sat down outside to try and find out what was going on. There was a group of reports said 80 to 100 men armed with traditional and non-traditional weapons walking towards the police station at one point and female members of those men stopped them and took the weapons off them and put them in the boot of the car and the men
Speaker 2went towards the police station. I mention that because that is part of the story and that level of So anger and threat is part of the story. But by all reports and by the vision I've seen, everyone sitting outside the station was pretty calm and pretty relaxed. Well, not relaxed, but pretty calm, and the elders were keeping everyone under control. There were young men throwing rocks on the roof of the police station. People just really wanted to know what was going on. Was Kumanjay alive or dead?
Speaker 2Where was he going to get help? What was going to happen next? Could people go in to see him? And the police locked the doors and wouldn't let anyone in. and there was an Aboriginal police officer, Derek Williams, who's related to Kumanjai, who stood outside with his father and grandfather keeping the crowd under control and police inside the station didn't let Derek know what was going on either.
Speaker 1I just don't understand why.
Speaker 2Because, as the police officers who made the decision explained on the stand during the coronial, they were faced with the decision of telling Derek as a Wolperi uncle to this young man that his nephew had died, which entails a whole lot of cultural obligations for Derek of people who he has to tell and things that he has to do. And telling him as a police officer who could help them contain any blowback and help people understand
Speaker 2what had happened. And police who made those decisions were also very aware that in a lot of ways, They themselves were the most dangerous people in the scenario because they had guns. And if the community found out that Kumonjai was dead, lost control, became angry, attacked the station or started attacking police, police would defend themselves and they would likely use guns and that would likely end up with more deaths.
Speaker 3Yeah.
Speaker 2So there's a very delicate, very morally complicated set of decisions that a couple of police officers are trying to make on behalf of a large number of very angry and frightened people.
Speaker 1And you can kind of see it from both sides, but I can particularly see it from the family's side when an ambulance leaves the station, heads towards the tarmac. The family thinks, oh, great, he's being medevaced out. He's going to get help. Meanwhile, Kumanjai had already died and that was a bit of a, like it was a ruse to try and, it was to get Rolf out, wasn't it?
Speaker 2Yeah, so it wasn't Kumanjai's body in the ambulance going to the Yuandamu airstrip, it was Rolf. And he was being sort of secreted out and the plane that met him on the airstrip was carrying reinforcement police officers from Alice Springs who came in and, some of them with long arms, unfortunately, to provide more police presence in Yuendumu and keep the peace.
Speaker 1But you can see why they'd be angry by that.
Speaker 2Of course. That's really hurtful.
Speaker 1And then the fact that they weren't told about Kumajai until 8am the next morning.
Speaker 2I think it is only absolutely reasonable and deeply human to be furious about that.
Speaker 1Well, it wasn't just Yuendumu. it was Australia. Like Australia was furious.
Speaker 2But that's what makes this story different because mostly people don't get furious. Mostly people don't notice people move on.
Speaker 1So why is it that this one broke through?
Speaker 2I think part of it is because Rolf was charged with murder three days later because police officers don't get charged with murder anywhere, but especially not in Australia and especially not in the Northern Territory. And the fact that Rolf was charged, even though we must say here he was acquitted. Yeah. The fact that he was charged said there's something to see here. And so people who might normally poo-poo a death in custody and say, oh, another one,
Speaker 2it's just a bunch of whinges, or couldn't because something was happening in the legal system. And people who are used to being overlooked and just being quietly angry, were given a bit of hope that something was happening differently this time. And I think that really brought, I think that put a lot of momentum behind this story. And then six months later, George Floyd was killed in the US. And then not long after that, you know, we started
Speaker 2having conversations about the referendum for a voice in Australia. So there's, I feel like it happened, Kumanjai's death happened at a time when a whole lot of forces were building in Australia towards the idea of First Nations people getting a bit of a better share of power and a bit of a voice. And in a way, this conflict between these two men sort of personified the power struggle between black and white.
Speaker 1You say that, but while you were discussing all of those elements and all of that context in your own book, you also talk about this ANU research that came out at the same time, which, to be honest, I was quite shocked by.
Speaker 2Yeah. That said.
Speaker 1Three in four people in Australia hold negative views about First Nations people. Three in four.
Speaker 2Yeah. So even though.
Speaker 1There's all these Australians backing, we've got these stats showing.
Speaker 3And the way that the data that that survey, that paper is based on measures unconsciousness bias and unconscious prejudice.
Speaker 2So it's a reaction to images. It's like a, it's a split second reaction to images. And so what it reflects is a, is a deeply embedded bias. You've got to remember at the same time, you know, a couple of years after Kumanjai's death, so he was shot at the end of 2019, by 20, end of 2020, 2021, all of the surveys that were being done to see how people felt about First Nations people getting a getting a voice to parliament, those surveys were like hitting 80%
Speaker 2yes for about three years in a row. So it was a time of change. We were getting our first Aboriginal judges on the bench in the Northern Territory and elsewhere. Aboriginal languages are being taught again at TAFEs and in schools. There was and there is this groundswell of growth and change and interest And I do feel that this story, this conflict between this young black man and this white
Speaker 2police officer is really, it's like two people playing out those warring desires.
Speaker 1Can you tell us a bit more about Zachary Rolfe?
Speaker 2Who was he?
Speaker 1We mentioned before ex-military. Give us a bit of a background.
Speaker 2Grew up in Canberra, one of three boys. His mum was a lawyer. His dad owned a prestige car dealership in Canberra. Very wealthy people, very active in the philanthropy community. Gave a lot of money to mental health and veteran charities. Zach went to a private school. He was described to me by people he went to school with as a
Speaker 2very blokey bloke who was very keen to sort of prove his masculinity and a bit of a wild child, you know, a risk-taker.
Speaker 1And very attracted to courage, bravery, that kind of.
Speaker 2Yes, the bravery, the idea of physical endurance and courage Physical power being a sign of courage and bravery stands out very strongly to me from Zach, but also from his dad. His dad is very involved with the war memorial in Canberra, gives a lot of money to it, is very into medals and bravery awards.
Speaker 1He was bailed after being charged with murder, and I know that that was a point of real upset for the community. Can you explain why?
Speaker 2Yeah, getting bail... after murder is not that unusual because bail is based on your threat to the community or your threat to other members of the community, perceived threat. A lot of people who kill someone else are only a threat to that person. They're not a threat to anyone else. And while a lot of Aboriginal people say and have said, well, if that was a black person, we wouldn't have gotten bail, They have an argument to
Speaker 2make and I think they're probably right on balance. I don't think there's anything that unusual about Zach getting bail. I know it pisses people off.
Speaker 1Yeah. And you can see why it hurts.
Speaker 2You can absolutely see why it hurts because Aboriginal people in the Northern Territory are used to being locked up for absolutely nothing. They're used to being locked up for yelling on the bus. They're used to being locked up for having a drink and a laugh in public. They're used to being locked up for all sorts of things. And then they see a white police officer kill a He gets charged with murder and he's not locked up. And that is an enormous injustice in their eyes. And I can see why.
Speaker 1So there's the Justice for Walker campaign on one side. So that's his community. And then on the other side.
Speaker 2There's the infamous Facebook page, I Support Constable Zach Rolfe, which was... A wonderful source of information for me in my book, I have to say.
Speaker 1A bit of a treasure trove.
Speaker 2An absolute treasure trove of Australian masculinity.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 2Yeah. It was set up by friends and family of Zach's to support him and to give voice to what ended up mostly being ex-military and ex-police and serving military and police officers to comment on what they thought was going on and also a few local Territorians.
Speaker 1I guess, like, You're allowed to support. Absolutely. But why was this different? For me it was like the merch.
Speaker 2The merch was pretty full on, the I Back Zack T-shirts and stubby holders. Again, it's that very manosphere kind of edge to it. And I think the fact that it was all, there was no respect for the fact on that Facebook page that a young man had lost his life.
Speaker 3Mm-hmm.
Speaker 2No respect at all. There was no awareness of that voiced by anyone. It was just he got what was coming to him and let's just make sure that Zachary Rolfe doesn't go to prison.
Speaker 1The trial eventually got underway. There was lots of delays and pushbacks and it was COVID.
Speaker 2It was COVID. So some of those were COVID.
Speaker 1Yeah. Some of them were not.
Speaker 2Some of them were legal challenges, yeah.
Speaker 1When it finally went ahead... You were there in that courtroom. What was it like?
Speaker 2It was a very unusual courtroom. It was poisonous by the end. The room was poisonous by the end. I was there for every day of the trial, but I left the day before the verdict came down. I just couldn't be in the building anymore. Why? Because the venom... brought into the room by people who were there to
Speaker 2support Zachary Rolfe. And this is not Zachary Rolfe's responsibility. The venom that they brought into the room was just unbearable. It was just, it was inhuman. It was awful. There were so many young men with their chests puffed out, strutting around like roosters. as though they were there to show the world that this was what anyone was up against if they wanted to go after someone like Rolf.
Speaker 2I found it really distasteful. And there were a lot of Wolperi people in court. Most people didn't stay in the courtroom for very long other than Ned Jumperjimper Hargraves, who was there every single day.
Speaker 1Was he?
Speaker 2Every day. And he's an elder from the community? Yeah, he's a very important elder from the community. But it was too hard for most people to be in that room and also the legal system is hard enough for anyone to understand unless you're really used to it. It's even harder to understand if it's being performed in a language that you don't speak or that you're not fluent in and if you don't have great hearing and if you're still traumatised by the death that's being spoken about.
Speaker 2And there was a big police presence outside the courthouse as well as though as though.
Speaker 1They were going to cause trouble?
Speaker 2Yeah.
Speaker 3Yeah.
Speaker 2I think that was one of the most racist things. Not one of the most racist things. That was one of the things that really struck me as being incredibly racist.
Speaker 1In terms of the evidence that was presented, was there anything that surprised you?
Speaker 2Yes, there was something that surprised me in evidence in the murder trial. I think it surprised a lot of people and that was when Zachary Rolfe took the stand and said that Okumunjai had reached for his gun in the Red House and tried to get his gun off him because no one had heard that. It was a year and a half, two years by the time the murder trial came on. That hadn't been mentioned in any of the media interviews that Zach had given to different newspapers or TV outlets.
Speaker 1That's huge. In terms of a piece of evidence?
Speaker 2It's enormous.
Speaker 1It's like intent.
Speaker 2It would be the biggest piece of evidence in your standard, you know. Yeah, it's very big. But it hadn't been mentioned in anyone's statements, any of the other police officers. None of them had said, oh, you know, and Zach said to us after he came out of the Red House that Kumanjai had reached for his gun. So that was a big shock. I think everyone was surprised by that.
Speaker 1Because both sides agreed that the first shot was self-defence.
Speaker 2Yes.
Speaker 1The argument was the next two shots were not necessary. Was that murder? Yeah. As you mentioned earlier, he was acquitted. By the time you got to the end of the trial, you said you left.
Speaker 2Did you know?
Speaker 1Could you have foreseen what that outcome was going to be?
Speaker 2I think you could have foreseen that. If you know the law, if you understand the law and what it takes to prove a charge of murder, you would have known going into that trial that the chances of Zachary Rolfe being found guilty of murder were extremely small. Not zero, but extremely small.
Speaker 1I'm curious, I know you weren't there, but you've obviously seen all of the footage, his reaction, his people's reaction. What was that like?
Speaker 2To the verdict? Yeah.
Speaker 3Um.
Speaker 2I have a very strong memory of Zachary Rolfe's barrister, David Edwardson, and also the president of the Police Association of the Northern Territory, standing on the stairs of the Supreme Court and giving sort of victory speeches, really. Zachary Rolfe himself was very subdued and didn't say anything much, just said that he didn't feel like it was the right time to say anything. Yeah, I think they were
Speaker 2obviously happy with the outcome.
Speaker 1Do you think Kumanjai's family had hope though? Like they were pretty, they were crushed.
Speaker 3Yeah.
Speaker 1So they... They did think that.
Speaker 2It might happen.
Speaker 3Yeah.
Speaker 2And, yeah, they did. And it might have. It wasn't very likely, but it might have happened. But what I also know and understand very deeply from following this case and following the coronial inquest after it and still being in contact with lots of people in the community is that the difference between Wolperi Law and its approach to Kumanjaya's death and what people call cardio law or white law,
Speaker 2those worldviews of how justice is done are so completely different that it just doesn't compute for people that nothing happened to Rolf for taking a life.
Speaker 1That that was the end.
Speaker 2Call it work or call it anything else, that that's the end. It just doesn't compute. And so it doesn't surprise me at all that people were still asking at the coronial, oh, might he go to jail after this?
Speaker 3Yeah.
Speaker 2And no one ever go, you know, that doesn't happen. That's not what a coronial is about. But people just couldn't understand that the process was over without Rolf having been sanctioned in any way.
Speaker 1After the break, Kate tells us about the coronial inquest and takes us through the evidence that was never revealed during the murder trial. Obviously, there's the murder trial, he's acquitted, then it goes to coronial inquest. Not all deaths go to coronial inquest, but is it right that all deaths in custody do? What's right is that all unusual deaths or deaths caused by a police officer or an employee of the state will. So because this was a death
Speaker 1in custody, but Kumanja was killed by a police officer, and so therefore it had to be, there had to.
Speaker 2Be a coronial inquest. You might die in custody, you might die in prison from a heart attack.
Speaker 1There's still one?
Speaker 2There might still be a coronial, but it won't be a big sort of event. It might just be done on the paperwork rather than having a big set of hearings and evidence and witnesses.
Speaker 1Well, this coronial hearing was supposed to be three months. Yes. It went for many years.
Speaker 2It's spread across two years.
Speaker 1Because, like, I don't think people expected what ended up coming out of it.
Speaker 2No, they absolutely did not. I didn't expect a lot of what came out of it.
Speaker 1Let's start with... Rolf, it's so different. He can basically get on that stand and things can be put forward that can't be put forward in a murder trial.
Speaker 2Yes.
Speaker 1So things like his text messages to family and colleagues. Tell us about those because they painted a very clear picture.
Speaker 2So the difference between a murder trial and a coronial case, murder trials and criminal cases are all about limiting the amount of information that you're making a decision on as much as you possibly can.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 2Coronial is the opposite. You talk about everything.
Speaker 1They want everything.
Speaker 2Everything's in. So the police had Zachary Rolfe's mobile phone and they had access to his text messages and they were pretty damning, some that Zach sent, some that were sent to him, and counsel assisting, Peggy Dwyer, led evidence that brought those text messages onto the record and they were read out in court and... People were ashen-faced. It
Speaker 2was shocking. It was so shocking to hear that that sort of language is still used and how easily and how readily and how flippantly.
Speaker 1We're obviously not going to share what those words were, but they were racist slurs.
Speaker 2Racist slurs and sexist slurs and homophobic slurs, basically your general, you know, dickhead Aussie bloke attitude.
Speaker 1And then there was also evidence put forward of a number of other violent incidents that he'd been involved in.
Speaker 2Yeah. So this is where I think it's also really important. You know, we're talking, you know, one of the sort of subtexts or maybe not even subtexts of what we're talking about is racism. Yeah. And I think there's, you know, individuals can be racist or can act in racist ways, but I think it's also really important to understand that in the Territory and in Australia we are working within systems that are deeply racist as well. Mm-hmm. The Northern Territory police forces systems are deeply racist and the disciplinary system is deeply racist. I say that because, you know, 80%, 90%
Speaker 2of people who come before the courts or who are picked up by police are Aboriginal in the Northern Territory, so they are over-policed and over-imprisoned. But if you're a police officer in the Northern Territory and you do something wrong or someone wants to make a complaint about you, such as overusing force or pushing a kid down a hill or whatever it might be, they've got six months to make a complaint. And if they don't complain within that six months, nothing can happen.
Speaker 3Right.
Speaker 2There is no recourse. So if you are being looked after by senior police officers who are letting just stuff go under the radar or they're not noticing or they don't care, you can do all sorts of things and not be disciplined in the way that you might otherwise be if someone was paying attention or if someone was doing their job properly. And there is an argument to say that that was very much the case with Zachary Rolfe. Now, he would defend that. He has defended that in the
Speaker 2past by saying, I never got more than an email. All of those things were looked into again, even after the coronial. No one ever sent me anything more than an email. That's because that's all that's possible after six months have passed. That may be one explanation. Another explanation may be that they found that he didn't do anything wrong.
Speaker 1Yeah. So he gives evidence. Was it after his evidence that did he quit? Did he lose his job?
Speaker 2He was sacked. That's another part of the racist system. It's incredibly hard to sack a police officer in the Northern Territory. Harder in the Northern Territory than anywhere else in Australia. There were many things that Zach had done up until then that might have led to him being disciplined if anyone had been paying attention. But the only thing that the police force could catch him on, breaking the rules by the middle of the inquest, was that he wrote and published a very derogatory letter, open letter,
Speaker 2about the Northern Territory Police Force and its executive and published it in a newspaper.
Speaker 3That.
Speaker 2broke the media rules, the, you know, police engaging with the media rules and a good behaviour bond that he was on at the time and that gave them grounds to sack him.
Speaker 1It just, it feels like the coronial inquests usually go, some of them go under the radar. This one, and this is only the start.
Speaker 2Yeah.
Speaker 1Because Zachary is sacked and then he comes back.
Speaker 2And then he comes back and.
Speaker 1And absolutely blows the lid on the entire Northern Territory police force.
Speaker 2Yes, yes, yes. In quite astonishing fashion, yes. It was shocking? It was absolutely shocking. He took the stand. He gave a lot of very interesting evidence and a lot of it was about how racist everybody else in the Northern Territory Police Force was. He presented what were called examples of the Noogadah Awards, which were also known as the Racial Slur of the Year Awards, and they were... basically
Speaker 2making fun of Aboriginal people and they were given to police officers for being, having bad hygiene, getting drunk, passing out, um, treating women poorly, any number of different kind of things that were supposedly associated with being Indigenous. Um, one of them was printed on, one of the certificates was printed on an Aboriginal flag. Another one showed the body of a deceased Aboriginal man, um, surrounded by images of beer cans.
Speaker 2One was a black and white minstrel.
Speaker 1They're quite shocking to see.
Speaker 2They're really horrendous.
Speaker 1Because Zach brought them in.
Speaker 2Zach brought them in.
Speaker 1Which I think he needed, like to actually hear about them is one thing, to see them. Yeah. To see the imagery. Yeah. And who was involved in this? He was accusing really high levels of the police force.
Speaker 2The TRG, the Territory Response Group, which is the elite, sort of like the SWAT squad in the Northern Territory, very much the heroes of the police force, the really tough guys who do the really, really tricky stuff. And he was saying that these awards had been given out in the TRG for, you know, decades, which seems to be the truth. And. Zach had very much wanted to be a member of the TRG but he had not been accepted. He'd passed
Speaker 2the tests to get in but he had not been given a position. So I guess he went from really wanting to be part of that unit to really wanting to dump on them.
Speaker 1Why do you think that is? Was it trying to point the finger away from him, trying to show that...? I think in.
Speaker 2Zachary's mind he's not the only one. You know, he was being... held up as this individual who was really bad and really racist and done all these things.
Speaker 1Like the bad apple.
Speaker 2The bad guy. And he was saying, hey guys, you know, I'm not the only one and I'm not the worst one. This is all around me and, you know, I'm just not going to sit here and carry this load for everybody in the police force.
Speaker 1Well, when he first kind of gave that evidence about the awards, he didn't have the proof. And some of the Well, did they lie on the stand? They said they didn't know anything about it.
Speaker 2There were senior police officers who were implicated in the Noogata Awards who wrote statutory declarations claiming that the Noogata Awards were not what they appeared to be, that they were about something completely different, that Noogata was making fun of a sort of caveman language and they were always called cavemen because they could lift heavy things and they weren't very smart. And it was all bullshit. But... That only lasted, that facade only lasted about 12 hours.
Speaker 1Did any of them lose their jobs?
Speaker 2Not that I'm aware of, no.
Speaker 1Really? No. Because the findings for that inquest were last year?
Speaker 2Yes, July last year.
Speaker 1They were delivered in Yindamu?
Speaker 2Yes.
Speaker 1There were 700 pages. That was a lot, yes. We're obviously not going to say all 700 pages, but what were the top lines that people took away? from those findings?
Speaker 2That the coroner could not rule out that racism was a factor in Kumanjai Walker's death, that the Northern Territory Police Force suffered from systemic racism, that Zachary Rolfe was racist, that a lot needed to change. Those are the ones that really stick.
Speaker 1Was that validating for the community?
Speaker 2I think, again, it's hard to speak in absolutes. I know that Ned Jumperjimper Hargraves said to me a couple of days later, well, we've been listened to. We got further this time than we've ever gotten before. We got a police officer to court. We got him on trial. We got the coroner to listen to us. That's the other thing that one of the findings was also Ned Jumperjimper Hargraves in particular had asked that police officers not carry guns in remote communities. It used to be the case in the territory that they didn't and now they do.
Speaker 2He wanted to go back to the old days. And the coroner suggested that that should be looked into. But at the end of it all, Ned Hargrave said that he felt really validated. He felt that the community had been listened to. I know that there are other people who sort of left partway through the findings being read out because they felt like it was just a lot of white fellas talking still and nothing changing.
Speaker 1Well, you did mention that that was more than six months ago. That was last year. Yeah. Have we seen any of those findings actually come into practice?
Speaker 2Not that I'm aware of, but I must say I'm not following it really closely. You know, I've had other things.
Speaker 1Of course.
Speaker 2There has been another death in custody, another death of a young Aboriginal man in Coles in Alice Springs in the course of being arrested by an off-duty police officer. So that coronial inquest will, another young man who grew up in Youndamoo, that coronial inquest will beginning March in Alice Springs. So there'll be an opportunity, I guess, at that inquest to see what has been enacted since the last one.
Speaker 1It does feel, though, like it's lots of words, lots of findings, lots of pages, which is often the case in not just inquests like this. You find it in royal commissions, in inquests, in investigations, all over the place, yeah. And it's like, okay... There's the talk, where's the action?
Speaker 2Yeah.
Speaker 1So I guess what do we do? We can put pressure on them to.
Speaker 2I think 2.6 seconds will bring that question home.
Speaker 3Yeah.
Speaker 2I think it will bring the experience for all sorts of Territorians, the experience for police officers who are working in Alice Springs and in communities and in remote places. It will bring the experience of Wolperi and Luritja and Urundur and all sorts of other Indigenous groups in the Territory, it will bring their experiences home. It will bring life in a remote community home. It will bring the complexity of the legal system and that cultural clash home. And
Speaker 2hopefully it will bring that groundswell of support up like it did after Kumanjai shooting and maybe the public and the community can bring some pressure to bear on what happens next.
Speaker 1Because the documentary is remarkable in that you do hear from so many local voices.
Speaker 2Yeah, yeah. Darren Dale is an amazing storyteller. He is so instinctive and so trustworthy and so balanced. He is interested in what that experience was like for everyone. He's not interested in delivering people a line that they have to follow and believe in. He's interested in putting all of the perspectives in front of people and letting an audience make up their own mind. And I think he's done that beautifully.
Speaker 1Obviously, we're talking about holding the police force to account and what are you doing to change? But I'm going to quote you back to yourself again. Because you said in why you've written your book on this story is because Australia's collective view of history was changing and the country was changing with it. So from a society point of view, from a people point of view, do you think that that momentum has continued? Are we changing all these years later?
Speaker 2I do. I think we are still changing. I think it's very easy to get stuck on the horror stories, but the rich, beautiful, cross-cultural, relationship-based work and understanding and growth is still happening. There are so many museums and galleries all around the world that are giving artefacts and ancestors' remains back to Indigenous communities in Australia. And people are
Speaker 2finally able to bury their great-great-grandfathers and grandmothers who've been sitting in a museum drawer for 150 years. Language is being revitalised. Even though the voice referendum didn't pass, so many relationships were built out of that and such incredible things are growing from it, quietly, gently, in little places without any fanfare, and that is where change happens. And I have a lot of faith, and I have a lot of faith in Northern Territorians as being the people
Speaker 2who can show the rest of the country how to do it well and how to do it for real. So there's a lot that's still troublesome and difficult and broken, but it's there. It's totally there and we can do it. We just can't give up. If Ned Jumperjimper Hargraves and the old people in Central Australia are prepared to keep going and keep trying, then nobody else has an excuse for not trying. You're here.
Speaker 1Kate, thank you so much for being here, for helping us tell this story.
Speaker 2Thanks so much for having me.
Speaker 1Thanks so much for listening. I'll be back next week with another True Crime Conversation.
In June 2015, Dr Teresa Sievers flew home early from a family holiday in New York to see her patients. The next morning, she didn’t turn up at her Florida clinic. A family friend went to check on her at her home in...
This episode is an update on the case of Elly Warren, the young Australian woman who died in Mozambique. Since Elly’s death, her father Paul has refused to accept silence. With few answers from authorities, he has spent...
For years Jason lived a double life as an undercover police officer, working inside the criminal underworld. No two jobs were the same, and the danger was always there. The toll of that work didn’t end when he left the...
In July 2026, Anastasia Treharne sat in a Sydney courtroom waiting to hear her rapist’s sentence. She had been through a gruelling trial and cross-examined at length, and a jury had found him guilty. The maximum penalty...
In 2008, Kristi McVee was a new mum flicking through the newspaper when a WA Police recruitment ad caught her eye. Less than two years later, she was sworn in as a police officer. Kristi went on to build a career...