Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

This is Democracy

This is Democracy artwork

This is Democracy – Episode 323: “Christian Nation”?

May 21, 202640 minAudio

I invited Dan Hummel to our This is Democracy conversation because this phrase keeps showing up in public discourse around the 250th anniversary, and people deserve to understand what’s actually being argued. Dan’s research traces how “Christian nation” rhetoric exploded in the 1970s, not because it was historically accurate, but because conservative Christians felt culturally threatened by demographic change, immigration, and the upheavals of the 1960s. Before that moment, Christian identity in America was so assumed among elites that it didn’t need defending. The 1950s civic religion - “In God We Trust” on currency, “under God” in the Pledge - wasn’t contested because it wasn’t exclusionary. Eisenhower’s “Judeo-Christian” framing was broad, not a boundary marker. What changed in the ‘70s was the emergence of an explicitly exclusionary version: “Christian nation” as a weapon to delegitimize feminism, LGBTQ equality, and religious pluralism as “un-American.” By the 1980s, this narrative had hardened into a cottage industry of revisionist history, David Barton and others rewriting founders like Jefferson as evangelical Christians, which is just flatly wrong. Jefferson was a deist. Washington’s “Almighty” wasn’t code for evangelical Protestantism. These distortions now circulate in self-sustaining echo chambers, reinforced from kindergarten through college in certain communities. Trump didn’t invent this, but he weaponized it. Unlike Reagan or Bush, who took evangelical votes without centering their theology, Trump surrounded himself with dominionists and postmillennialists who believe America must build God’s kingdom now. Dan’s distinction between exclusionary and inclusionary invocations of Christianity is crucial. Martin Luther King Jr. rooted his vision in biblical justice and human dignity made in the image of God, but his Christianity opened doors. The exclusionary version uses the same language to shrink the circle of who counts as American. That’s the litmus test: does invoking Christian values lead toward inclusion or exclusion? Zachary’s Tocquevillian point lands well: the real story is about religious pluralism and voluntary association as engines of democracy, not Christian hegemony. Disestablishment didn’t weaken American religion, it supercharged it by forcing churches to compete in a marketplace of ideas rather than relying on state backing. That dynamism produced abolition, feminism, civil rights, and also nativism and Christian nationalism. The same freedom cuts both ways. Click here to listen to the full episode or read the transcript. Democracy of Hope, produced by Jeremi and Zachary Suri, is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support our work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber. Get full access to Democracy of Hope, Jeremi and Zachary Suri at democracyofhope.substack.com/subscribe

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

This is Democracy A podcast about the people of the United States A podcast about citizenship About engaging with politics and the world around you A podcast about educating yourself on today's important issues and how to have a voice in what

SPEAKER_03happens next

SPEAKER_01Welcome to our new episode of This Is Democracy. Today we are going to address the phrase Christian nation, a phrase that seems to be more ubiquitous these days, especially around some of the celebrations for the 250th anniversary of the US Declaration of Independence. More and more groups seem to be claiming that the United States is a Christian nation while others dispute that claim Today we're going to address what that claim

SPEAKER_01means, where it comes from and just get more historical perspective on it So we can make better decisions ourselves as we think about what the United States is and what democracy means in the 21st century We are very fortunate to be joined by a friend, former student and leading scholar of the topic and religious history and intellectual ideas in general, Dr. Daniel Hummel. Dan, thanks for joining us today.

SPEAKER_03It's great to be with you again.

SPEAKER_01Daniel Hummel is the director of the Lumen Center in Madison, Wisconsin, and he's also a research fellow in the Department of History at the University of Wisconsin-Madison. His research and writing, as our listeners should know from prior episodes, his research and writing cover American evangelicals, theology, politics, and culture. and Dan has written a number of very important books that we've discussed on the podcast and books that I proudly assign to many of my students. Thank you. It's my pleasure.

SPEAKER_01Your books, Dan, always showcase, first of all, first-rate research and they always provoke a worthwhile discussion. Dan's most recent book that I highly encourage everyone to read if they haven't read it already, The Rise and Fall of Dispensationalism, How the Evangelical Battle Over the End Times Shaped a Nation. And Dan writes very frequently for Christianity Today, New Lines Magazine, The Washington Post and various other outlets. So he's clearly one of the very best people to discuss this topic today.

SPEAKER_01We're also joined of course by Mr. Zachary Suri. Hello, good morning everyone. How are you, Zachary? I'm doing well.

SPEAKER_02Excited for this discussion.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, I think we all are. I think we all are. So Dan, to get us started, where does this phrase Christian nation come from? What is the etymology, the history of this phrase?

SPEAKER_00Well, it is a phrase that really took up steam in the 1970s. And that's part of the interesting story is we really start debating as a culture, the identity of the American nation in a lot of ways when we're celebrating the 200th anniversary in 1976 and the years around that. And the term comes or People are claiming that America is a Christian nation at a particular historical moment in the 70s where there is a lot of uncertainty and

perceived upheaval in society based around changing demographics and immigration in the country,

SPEAKER_00changing patterns of religion in the country, a sense by many conservatives that the values of the nation that had been with the nation since its founding had been supplanted or thrown in the air in the 1960s and the radicalism of that decade. And so you start getting strident writing, sermonizing, and politicians who pick up on this as well that start asserting a distinct sort of Christian identity to America's founding.

SPEAKER_00And That becomes part of what we tend to call in the 1980s, the culture war, sort of a deeper sense of where's the center of American culture? Is it religious? Is it secular? Is it something in between? And what is the future of the country?

SPEAKER_02That makes sense. I'm curious about maybe an earlier phenomenon that seems to be part of this story, which is the sort of moment in American history, which I am not going to have an exact sense of when this is, and I'm sure you can explain to us better, but the moment when so many of our sort of founding mottos or ideas shift into or are shifted into a religious frame. I think this is in the early Cold War when we add in God we trust as our motto instead of e pluribus unum. or the addition of under God to the Pledge of Allegiance.

SPEAKER_02Do you see that as a similar phenomenon or is that a different story?

SPEAKER_03Yeah, thanks for pointing me to those. So I mean, in some sense, the term Christian nation comes about,

SPEAKER_00like I said, in the 70s, in part because that's one of the first times that that's actually a question in culture. So you can go back certainly to the 19th century, certainly Certainly to eras of wartime. And you can see a pretty much assumed Christian identity to the country, not just Christian, but Protestant identity among American elites that is so ubiquitous, you could say, and certainly historians have documented this, so ubiquitous that it's not really a question.

SPEAKER_00It's assumed. And when we get to the 1950s, this is just the era before you get this strong push toward what sociologists and historians call civic religion which is not necessarily tied to a particular organized religious body but is a sense of a sort of quasi-religious way of talking about the nation and so the civic religion of the US in the early Cold War is quite Christian but you can think of that almost as

the leaders of that time just resorting to what was sort of to them the obvious

SPEAKER_00tools in the toolbox of constructing a civil religion. And so you get the reference to in our money, all has in God we trust on it. You get under God added to the Pledge of Allegiance. You have very overt sort of civic religious pageantry around the swearing in of a new president around various public functions. And at that point in our history,

there wasn't a strong contestation to that.

SPEAKER_00We start seeing that in a reaction to that in the early 60s. There's a number of court cases brought to the Supreme Court by People who found this to be disconcerting in some way, atheists and others who start pushing it back against the ubiquity of prayer, of sort of quasi-religious, or not quasi-religious, but general prayers in schools not linked to a certain denomination. of Bible reading in schools and things like that sort of get pushed back in the 60s. But by the 1950s,

SPEAKER_00that is sort of just the assumed sort of elite culture in the U.S. And we see that ramped up a bit in the 50s as well because of the the sense of global crisis with communism being seen as the antithesis to a Christian nation or a Christian culture. Communism is atheistic. It doesn't value human rights the way that Christian culture supposedly does. So those contrasts are being made and amplified through the

civic religion at the time.

SPEAKER_01And Dan, there was in the 1950s this phrase civic religion that you've just used or civil religion was a common phrase. Is that similar to Christian nation or is that different from Christian nation?

SPEAKER_00It doesn't have to be. I think most cultures have a civil or civic religion. Most nations, I should say, have a civil or civic religion. And there's a famous or infamous saying, quote from Eisenhower in the 1950s, President Eisenhower, who declares that the US's religion or basis is Judeo-Christian religion. But it didn't have to be. It could have been something else. And you get a sense there of sort of the way that civil religion works,

which is part of the construction of a nation is you have to sacralize or create

SPEAKER_00sort of transcendent meaning And so different societies, different nations will be drawing on different sort of preinstalled religious resources. You can imagine a Muslim nation would have a much different civil religion than a Muslim nation. predominantly Muslim nation, full of people who practice Islam would have a different civil religion than the US, which in the 1950s was still predominantly Protestant. So for the US, it's been a largely Christian civil religion,

SPEAKER_00but it doesn't necessarily have to be. And there's been a lot of You know, pushback from theologians and others who find it somewhat distasteful that the U.S. civil religion traffics so much in Christian symbols and Christian language when that language and symbols are often being used for things that at least these theologians and pastors and others would see as actually quite unchristian, marshalling Christian imagery or symbols to, you know, commit, prosecute wars or implement policies that for various

Christians seem very unchristian. But that's sort of the nature of civil religion is it uses much more powerful

SPEAKER_00symbols that come out of these Much longer traditions of various religions, including Christianity, to make the case or to gain credibility for the nation, which is often much younger and doesn't have that sense of transcendent value to it or is trying to sort of rift off of that.

SPEAKER_02That makes sense. How does that civil religion, or at least the discourse of Christianity in American society as you're describing it, one that isn't necessarily inherently theological, but more cultural or about civic values, how does that conversation translate into a politics of Christian nationalism or of Christian nationhood in the 70s and 80s and in later decades?

SPEAKER_00Right, so a lot of this is debating the history of the U.S. and various sort of competing interpretations of America's founding in the 18th century and then the sort of nature of U.S. society in the 19th century and then what are the implications of

SPEAKER_03the history for the 1980s and after. And these debates tend not to be among professional historians, but between, you could say,

SPEAKER_00amateur historians or historians more in the public space and some professional historians as well. But the things under debate here are to what extent were the founding fathers motivated by Christianity in founding the U.S.?

SPEAKER_03To what extent are the values of America as a nation based on Christianity and the Bible. And then to what extent can the society sort of diverge from that or become more diverse while remaining true to that interpretation of the past?

SPEAKER_00And so by the time you get to the 1980s, you have a lot of conservative Christians arguing that the pressing issues of the day around gender and sexuality, around LGBTQ, Communities around feminism are deviations from the Christian tradition of the United States, that they don't reflect biblical values, they don't reflect broader Christian values, and so they must be opposed because they are inherently

un-American if America is

SPEAKER_00equated with Christian. You also have in the 1980s, at least the first half of the 1980s, you have a ramp up in opposition to communism around the globe, what's sometimes called the New Cold War. And you have the confrontations between the US and the Soviet Union. You have Reagan calling the Soviet Union Evil Empire at actually a gathering of the National Association of Evangelicals in 1983 and so there's obviously a religious

component to that but you

SPEAKER_00also have Reagan and the Reagan administration supporting all types of anti-communist activity in Latin America and elsewhere and at root of that or part of the calculus there is an understanding of the obligation of a Christian society like the US to be opposing an atheistic ideology like communism. So I think you can, it's a little more, I think of someone like Lauren Turek, who's written a lot on the sort of evangelical advocacy for

human rights in the

SPEAKER_001980s as well as they understood human rights. And that was really tied to an idea that Human Rights are Christian and America is a Christian nation and so America has an obligation to uphold human rights as they understood it. So I think you can see implications in both the sort of domestic sphere as well as the foreign policy world. And so why, Dan, do you think this rhetoric has ticked up again in recent years? Why under President Donald Trump is the term Christian nation

being used more

SPEAKER_01frequently by all kinds of politicians?

SPEAKER_03Yeah, I think there's a few reasons. I mean, a reason that would tie back to the 1970s is the US continues to diversify in who is an American in all types of ways that create those anxieties that were there in

SPEAKER_00the 70s are there among those same demographics of people. Today. And so there is a continuing sense among conservatives, among a lot of conservative Christians, that the fate of American society is up for grabs and that the Christian identity of the US is a real core part of what makes the US exceptional, what makes it special. I think there's also been this development of this,

I mentioned this sort of like debate over history that started in the 70s. That cottage industry is, I mean, it's bigger than the cottage industry now.

SPEAKER_00It's a full blown industry. There's a lot of material. There's a lot of media and books that one could read if one were disposed to think of America as a Christian nation that can really bolster that view. And there's so much of it that you could probably subsist on that and not need to consult other perspectives if you didn't want to. And so that's a story that is part of the polarization of our society today. But there are very big echo chambers that have had decades now to develop

and that's one of them on the conservative side has been the Christian nation. We sometimes talk about Christian nationalism as a sort of political project that

SPEAKER_03comes out of believing that the US is a Christian nation. And from, you know, great, just think of education from kindergarten through college, depending on which college you go to, you can get that as your primary perspective throughout your entire education.

SPEAKER_00And of course, many parents are interested in that as well.

SPEAKER_03And then the last thing I'll say is I think, you know, Trump is a unique figure in a lot of ways, but he, the coalition that got him elected and competitive in 2016, 2015, 2016, that has remained with him is, you know, obviously a very eclectic and interesting coalition, but the evangelical leaders that were early in supporting Trump and have been the most consistent in supporting him have come out of sectors of the American church that are

really primed to think

SPEAKER_03of the U.S. as a Christian nation. Not just in the past, not just in the sense of interpreting the founding era as one of sort of Christian values, but one that sees what is happening today as part of a larger eschatology, a sense of the end The End of the World, where the ultimate destiny of the U.S. is to be part of the kingdom of God in the next eschaton. And that sounds very far-fetched, but a lot of the significant people around Trump, including Paula White,

SPEAKER_00who has spent his spiritual Advisor for a long time now, subscribe to this.

SPEAKER_03It's often called dominionism or in the more theological sense, post-millennialism, the sense that the U.S. is supposed to be building the kingdom of God right now. And that kingdom, of course, has a certain set of values that are very Christian. So Trump's put in prominent places people around him who espouse this in a way that even previous conservative presidents, Republican presidents like Reagan or George W. Bush didn't surround themselves with people like this. They might have taken their votes. They might have thrown them bones here and there,

but they didn't fundamentally see themselves allied with those types of people.

SPEAKER_00Trump is a different person. These have been his most consistent supporters, and he's rewarded them for that over his political career.

SPEAKER_02I'm curious if you could give us a sense of how large a group is. I think we have a sense of how strong a political force Christian nationalism and those who espouse the belief that America as a Christian nation are today. But I'm curious, in terms of the larger picture of American Christianity, How large of a sector is this? Especially given the current administration's feuding with the Catholic Church and a number of other Protestant ministers who have spoken out against their

SPEAKER_02immigration policy. Where does the Christian nationalist sector actually fit in the broader picture of American Christianity?

SPEAKER_03Yeah,

SPEAKER_00I mean this is a very contested topic right now among scholars, let alone journalists and others.

SPEAKER_03In part, it really depends how you define Christian nationalism. So one reason I mentioned the 70s as this sort of inflection point as when people start being concerned about this is, as I mentioned before, but up until that point, there wasn't a lot of debate about this. So it wasn't like a politically polarized debate in even the 1960s about the US being a Christian nation. Martin Luther King Jr., constantly references America as a Christian nation.

SPEAKER_03And so do segregationists. That's just not a point of debate. And of course, we wouldn't want to group Martin Luther King Jr. in with today's right-wing Christian nationalists. But there is a sense where if you're defining Christian nationalism as something broader than... a sort of right-wing ideology and you're just concerned about Christians who think their faith should matter in politics or something like that,

SPEAKER_03you're going to get a huge number of people who agree with that. In fact, when this Christian nationalism term came around in the late 2010s, there were a lot of good sociologists trying to do polling on this and they would often find that the two groups that polled highest on Sort of their markers for Christian nationalism were white evangelicals and then black Protestants. Because there's a similarity in how both communities for very different reasons invoke the Christian values when they think about politics.

SPEAKER_03So depending on how you define it, you get a really big number of people who are Christian nationalists, or you would get a narrower group if you're trying to zero in on a more, one way I try to think about it is there's a very exclusionary or exclusionary version of Christian nationalism that is about shrinking the pool of sort of true Americans or true Christians down to a gendered, or not gendered, but racial subcategory of true Americans.

SPEAKER_03And there you're talking about, it's really hard to know exactly how many people and whether they matter politically as much as their numbers would count, but you're talking about millions of Americans would be in that group. but they're only one sort of sector of people who think about Christianity and politics together. So that's been one of the frustrations I think by certainly historians who know about the ubiquity of Christian in earlier parts of our nation's history and by people who are

trying to be more splitters than lumpers today on the scene is that it really hinges on how you

SPEAKER_03define Christian nationalism. I think if we're Often this is politically motivated conversation, right? It's trying to understand, well, who's supporting Trump and who's against him? I think there you're in the millions of people. I think if you were just interested in who in our country who votes thinks that their Christian faith Right.

SPEAKER_01Right. I guess for me, Dan, as an observer of this, right, and trying to be a historian and not a political observer per se, it strikes me that one of the differences between different people who invoke this term is some would say we're a Christian nation because Christianity is part of our history, and that's certainly true. And then there are others, it seems to me, who are using Christian nation in a more exclusive way to exclude, for example, Muslims.

SPEAKER_01And I do think that's a difference, right? I mean, when you say Christian nation, do you mean that we're therefore not a Muslim nation? Or when you say Christian nation, do you mean we're a Christian and Muslim and Hindu and Jewish and Buddhist nation? And how should we think about that? Is that a fair way of looking at the uses of the term today?

SPEAKER_03Yeah, without simplifying it too much, I think you could think of that there's two broad categories of people who invoke Christianity when they're talking about our nation or politics. There's the exclusionary invocation and there's the inclusionary invocation. Both would have certain claims on history and how we should interpret that history, but the implications would be very different. I think of someone like MLK Jr. as someone who would be in that inclusionary category who wants

to acknowledge the centrality of certain Christian values or even biblical passages on the founding of the country and the Civil War and the rededication of the second founding in the 1870s and would want to affirm all that and not make a move to try to secularize

SPEAKER_03that history but to say Actually, these values about human dignity, about equality, about justice, lead us today to want to have a more inclusive society. So that would be a sort of inclusionary way. And then we have plenty of examples of exclusionary same invocations of some of the same history that the implications would be a certain type of Christian needs to be in power for the U.S. to be truly fulfilling its destiny or something like that.

SPEAKER_03So I think both of those would count, depending on how you're thinking about it, as it's just so loaded now. It'd be hard to count MLK as a Christian nationalist, but you could see how there's similarity there. And that would be something, you know, for for listeners, for anyone who's sort of listening to the rhetoric in our politics, to not simply sort of have a visceral reaction when someone invokes a Like a religion in general. And I think that there's a certain,

and this was one of the anxieties that these people in the 70s had that might be

SPEAKER_03more rooted in something I could at least affirm, which is that there became a bisexuality. David Pérez, Ph.D. scholarly interpretation, but there were certainly popular interpretations that pushed that. And that would not be the right way to respond to Christian

nationalism in our discourse. It would be to be more nuanced and more careful about how we understand religion functioning and to also just pay attention to the very valuable influences and ideas that come from Christianity and other religions that lead toward a more

SPEAKER_03inclusive society today.

SPEAKER_01That's exactly where I wanted to go, Dan. You've given us a really wonderful intellectual and religious history of the concept of Christian nationalism and Christian nation and a very nuanced and varied history. It has many different origins and many different meanings. How should those of us who hear the term used in exclusionary ways by some how what is the best way to respond to that because I agree fully with you as any historian would that you cannot talk about American history

without the presence of religion and the presence of Christianity but on the other hand from our very

SPEAKER_01beginning there's been a self-conscious effort by many, including George Washington, Thomas Jefferson, and we can go on and on, including Dwight Eisenhower, who we referred to before in the 1950s, right? To make sure that this is a more inclusionary notion of religion, not exclusionary. So how should we respond without sounding as if we are condescending to those who are religious believers? Right. Well, if you want to spend the time, there is a historical conversation to be had.

SPEAKER_03I think the typical... Exclusionary Christian Nationalist Interpretation of American History is often just bad history. And my colleague here at the Lumen Center, John Fia, has spent a long time debating some of these major sort of revolutions Visionist Historians. Probably the most popular one is named David Barton, who's written a number of books that have sold a lot of copies, where he is interpreting people like Thomas Jefferson as crypto evangelicals.

SPEAKER_03that evangelical Christians today could identify with. And that's just not true. That's not who Thomas Jefferson was. Thomas Jefferson was a deist, quite proudly a deist, quite proudly someone who, when he put creator in the Declaration of Independence, was not trying to signal to conservative Christians that he had their back. He was trying to assert a certain deistic understanding of creator in that. And so part of the conversation would be around the history and around understanding what really motivated the founding fathers.

SPEAKER_03Now, it's really complicated. So certain founding fathers, someone like John Jay, seems to have been motivated by a pietistic Protestantism for a lot of his sort of vision of what America could be. But others like Jefferson and Washington had just much more complicated relationships with religious identities. with Christianity and a sort of proper way of thinking about the past and its implications would require that conversation. The other thing I would encourage anyone today who is engaging

or coming across the

SPEAKER_03more exclusivist language, I think there's a way to affirm without going into the history that the importance of Christianity to American values that can at least throw a bridge to the other side without going all the way down the road toward an exclusionary implication for that. And I think that can be affirming or just acknowledging how Something like, and this isn't unique to Christianity,

SPEAKER_03Judaism has this too, but something like humans being made in the image of God, which is in the book of Genesis, one of the first passages in the Bible, talks about how God made humans in his image, and how throughout history this has bestowed some type of unique dignity on humans, that that societies that have been animated by Judaism and Christianity have really sought to uphold. That's something we can see in some of the values of the American founding, certainly in the struggle over slavery and equal rights and emancipation,

SPEAKER_03we can see those values. And that's something where you can talk about a sort of Christian influence on American society and affirm that that's actually something That is really important to understanding American history, but is not implicated in the same way in how we need to move forward into the future. So I think that would be sort of throwing a sort of commonality around the importance of religion and of Christianity to the American founding and to American society since then.

SPEAKER_03might be a way to at least create a shared way of talking about this. But not to end on a pessimistic note, but I mentioned earlier that there are major, large ecosystems, echo chambers around these things. So someone like David Barton, who I'm guessing has never been assigned in a UT Austin or UW Madison classroom as sort of a textbook, has a lot of people who really go to him as the primary source on understanding the founding. And that's just one of these realities around our polarized society.

SPEAKER_03that we have to deal with and have to find ways that sometimes they're intellectual, sometimes they're just relational ways to try to chip away at that and introduce what I believe to be more true to the historical record and more beneficial values for moving forward.

SPEAKER_01That makes a lot of sense. And actually, I think that does sound helpful because it comes back to what we do as historians, which is expose people, particularly young people, to the documents and to good scholarship. But the documents themselves, I mean, we're seeing how Jefferson and Washington and others use these words and recognizing in them that when they say almighty, for example, as Washington does in his his letters, right? He is quite clearly not referring only to a Christian God, though that would be his God. Zachary,

I wanted to ask you as someone who's a religious Jew, you're more religious than I am.

SPEAKER_01How do you think about this? When you hear people invoking Christian nation, you obviously understand the importance of Christianity in American history, but you're not Christian, right? So how do you think about this?

SPEAKER_02Well, I think it's exactly what Dan was saying. It's about having a nuanced understanding of the role of religion in American society. I think maybe a more useful way of thinking about the historical question of the role of Christianity in American society is what is the role of religion in American life? Because I think a lot of our most important founding documents and early historical texts, Alexis de Tocqueville, for example, his Democracy in America, is all about the importance and centrality of religious organization,

SPEAKER_02religious Communities to American Democracy. And I don't think that those connections between religion and democracy, religion and democratic society are exclusive to any particular religion, but they're distinct about American life in the sense that the combination of religious institutions, the role of religious institutions in American society and American democracy is in a large sense unique and not something that is present in

most other advanced

SPEAKER_02democracies around the world. And I think acknowledging that, celebrating that, recognizing its limitations at the same time is something that everyone should be able to do. And I think it's important in particular for those who aren't religious to be able to do that. And Christianity plays a central role in that story, but so do other religions. And it's certainly not a uniform picture of Christianity, even if we were just to take Christianity as a whole. I mean, Diversity of American Christian life is enormous as well.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, it's a very Tocquevillean perspective that the religious associations of one kind or another, mosques, synagogues, churches are so central to American democracy. Do you buy that, Dan? Is that, to sort of close us out, is that an effective way of thinking about this?

SPEAKER_03Well, I would never say something against Tocqueville. I mean, he's one of my heroes. So yes, I mean, of course, I think that's a really interesting way to think about it. I also think it raises just this really fascinating – it seems like a paradox on the face of it, but it's a really interesting historical dynamic where – We do have disestablishment of religion in the US, and that's been with at least the federal government since the beginning, and for most states, for most of our history.

SPEAKER_03And yet the US is a uniquely religiously observant society. Many people back when the disestablishment was being established found that to be really concerning. You can go back and read that if America is not claiming to be a Christian nation from the beginning, We Will Somehow Become Less Religious And The Exact Opposite Happened And That's Just A Fascinating Example Where You Can Look Today At All Types Of Sort Of Surveys

And Graphs Of Religious Observance And Related Issues And You Can See That The U.S.

SPEAKER_03Just Sort Of Does Not Follow Its Peer Group In Western Europe And in a lot of the religious observance categories. Now, things are changing and the US is secularizing and diversifying in all types of ways. But up until now, there's been this sort of really interesting question about what is different. And many historians have pointed to the disestablishment of religion as actually, ironically, the thing that has made religion much more relevant to our society. I think Tocqueville was catching on that much earlier than a lot of other people were.

SPEAKER_03I think that's a really interesting way to think about it, whether you're religious or not, to really appreciate how these values, like Zachary mentioned, volunteerism. This is a very American Practice, at least that's what Tocqueville was talking about, where Americans just like form societies and advocacy groups and affinity groups like crazy in the 19th century. There's something quite Protestant about doing that.

And that's an interesting thing to interrogate is how do those things connect?

SPEAKER_03And then of course, how does volunteerism actually unlock a lot of different types of activism and visions of the world that change American society fundamentally going forward after that? So I affirm that and think that's a very useful way to try to get at this question.

SPEAKER_01I think it's so interesting, because I agree too, I'm less of an expert than you are, Dan, but it certainly seems to me that the disestablishment of religion and making America not an official Christian nation actually led to this of Christianity within the United States and the spread of other religions. And that would fit with a more marketplace understanding of the spread of ideas, a sort of John Stuart Mill version than a more centralized canonical way of thinking about things. And I think it's really a really powerful way to think about this.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, and just to maybe throw another book recommendation, I just finished reading Matthew Sutton's newest book called Chosen Land, which is a history of religion and politics in America going all the way back to

SPEAKER_00the pre-colonial times up to the present. And he really hits this point hard in the early chapters about already the just

SPEAKER_03dizzying diversity of religion, particularly when you include indigenous religion in the early eras of religion. American History. And then the disestablishment in the late 18th century just sort of supercharges a lot of different Christians to basically not Leave that up to the state to Christianize American society. But it was interpreted as it's on the Christians themselves to do that.

SPEAKER_03And that galvanized all types of things, everything from, you could say, a sort of Christian nationalism type imposition of Christianity. Christian Values to the Abolitionist Movement to First Wave Feminism and many other movements who often had very pious, devout Christians who understood their actions Less as political or less as exclusively political, but as somehow an expression of their Christian faith. So it's an interesting sort of dynamic to American history.

Matt Sutton does a great job of sort of showing the very diverse ways that

SPEAKER_03Catholics versus Presbyterians versus Restorationists, you know,

SPEAKER_00sort of think about that over the last hundreds of years. But that's another just recent book that is exploring the same territory.

SPEAKER_01That's a great suggestion. This is Matthew Avery Sutton, who I think we've had on the podcast as well, and clearly we should have him on to talk about his new book as well. Dan, you've given us really the historical context and a meaty analysis of this and also some, I think, very useful ways of... using that history to open, as you said, bridges for conversation around these issues, which is, of course, our goal on the podcast. I want to encourage all of our listeners to read Daniel Hummel's work, which appears everywhere.

It's ubiquitous, but particularly his most recent book, The Rise and Fall of Dispensationalism.

SPEAKER_01Dan, thank you so much for taking the time today. And Zachary, thank you for your comments and insights and thank you most of all to our loyal listeners and loyal subscribers to our Substack for joining us for this week of This Is Democracy This podcast is produced by the Liberal Arts ITS Development Studio And the College of Liberal Arts at the University of Texas at Austin The music in

SPEAKER_02this episode was written and recorded by Scott Holmes Stay tuned for a new episode every week. You can find This is Democracy on Apple Podcasts, Spotify and YouTube. See you next time.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. This is Democracy – Episode 332: Midterm Elections, 2026

    Nov 17, 202632 minAudio

    This week I spoke with Julian Zelizer, the Princeton historian and one of our most frequent guests, about the scale of what happened in Tuesday’s midterms. I wanted to know whether this was a strange moment for a...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. This is Democracy Episode 331 – Nonprofit News

    Oct 21, 202642 minAudio

    This week Zachary and I spoke with Sarah Adler Hartman, CEO of The Texas Tribune, whose career took her from founding Spoon University as a Northwestern student to running subscriber products at The New York Times...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. This is Democracy – Episode 330: Jewish Politics Since the 19th Century

    Oct 8, 202638 minAudio

    This week we spoke with David Sorkin, the Lucy G. Moses Professor of Jewish History at Yale and an old family friend who attended Zachary’s naming ceremony decades ago, about his new book, The Emancipationists. David’s...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. This is Democracy – Episode 329: Intelligence: Past and Present

    Sep 22, 202630 minAudio

    In this episode of This is Democracy, Zachary and I sat down with our old friend John Sipher, who spent 28 years in the. CIA’s Clandestine Service before becoming one oft public voices on intelligence. I wanted to...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. This is Democracy – Episode 328: Imperialist Realism

    Sep 10, 202638 minAudio

    This week on This is Democracy, I sat down with Daniel Bessner, one of the sharpest critics of American foreign policy writing today, to talk through his new essay collection, Imperialist Realism. Danny’s central claim...

    Credit the people on this episode