This week we spoke with David Sorkin, the Lucy G. Moses Professor of Jewish History at Yale and an old family friend who attended Zachary’s naming ceremony decades ago, about his new book, The Emancipationists. David’s central argument reframes how we think about Jewish political history: emancipation wasn’t something granted to passive Jewish communities by benevolent governments, the way American history once told the story of Lincoln simply giving slaves their freedom. Jewish lawyers, newspaper editors, and community organizers won it by adapting the political tools of their era - vernacular presses, philanthropic associations, legal advocacy - to force the issue themselves. This directly parallels patterns in American civil rights history, where legal and institutional organizing played the same role decades later. For David, Jewish emancipation was never a finished achievement but an ongoing process, one that could be gained, lost, and gained again, and one he argues is under renewed pressure today. He pushed back hard on the old adage “is it good for the Jews,” arguing instead that the emancipationists understood something more durable, that Jews could never secure equality for themselves without building a society that guaranteed equality for everyone. That insight, rooted in nineteenth-century legal activism, is precisely what later animated American Jewish civil rights lawyers working alongside the NAACP. It’s a conversation that asks us to see minority rights as a political project minorities have always built for themselves, and it carries weight for those of us thinking about the state of constitutional democracy today. Click here to listen to the full episode or read the transcript. Democracy of Hope, produced by Jeremi and Zachary Suri, is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support our work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber. Get full access to Democracy of Hope, Jeremi and Zachary Suri at democracyofhope.substack.com/subscribe
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_03This is Democracy.
SPEAKER_01A podcast about the people of the United States. A podcast about citizenship.
SPEAKER_02About engaging with politics and the world around you.
SPEAKER_00A podcast about educating yourself on today's important issues and how to have a voice in what happens next.
SPEAKER_01Hello and welcome to our latest episode of This is Democracy. Today we have a real treat. Not only are we talking about a very interesting new book, but with a very interesting person as well. Our guest today is Professor David Sorkin. Professor Sorkin is the Lucy G. Moses Professor of Jewish History at Yale University. He has received multiple honors, including the Guggenheim, the National Endowment for the Humanities, and Whitney Humanities Center fellowships, as well as an adventurer.
SPEAKER_01He is the author of the book Jewish Emancipation and most recently the book that we will be discussing with him today, a new book from Yale University Press titled The Emancipationists, 19th Century Jews Campaign for Citizenship. Professor Sorgan, thank you for joining us. Oh, thank you for inviting me. I'm delighted to be here. Well, thank you for joining us. Professor Sorkin is, in addition to all of those many things, my senior thesis advisor.
SPEAKER_01So thank you for suffering through that with me. And he also is our former neighbor in Madison, Wisconsin.
SPEAKER_03That's right. He attended your naming ceremony, Zachary.
SPEAKER_01That's right. Many, many years ago.
SPEAKER_03He has seen the full arc of your early intellectual development. No problem.
SPEAKER_01And of course, as you can tell, we are joined this morning by Professor Jeremy Suri as well. Good morning. Good morning. Before we dive right in, I think it might be useful for some of our listeners who maybe aren't as familiar with Jewish history or Jewish political history as the three of us to understand what this term emancipation means in the first place. And Professor Sorkin, you're obviously the world leading expert on this question. So how would you explain what Jewish emancipation means in this context?
SPEAKER_00Thanks for that question, Zach. I think it's very important to explain it.
SPEAKER_02I think for an American audience, the term emancipation is confusing because it's generally associated with the emancipation of slaves in the United States. In Europe, it's generally associated with the emancipation of serfs. But the term was also applied... In Europe, in the 18th and 19th centuries,
SPEAKER_02to the emancipation of religious groups that had an inferior political status. So one of the most important incidents of this was the emancipation of Catholics in 1828 in England. England had... United with Ireland during the Napoleonic period in order to prevent an invasion.
SPEAKER_02And this led to a major constitutional problem in that the Catholics were not allowed to take the oaths that were necessary in order to vote and to have the vote in England. So that was a constitutional crisis. The Irish mobilized, created a political movement, exerted pressure on parliament.
SPEAKER_02And in 1828, there was a vote to emancipate the Catholics and... Give them political equality, meaning to say the right to vote. From that point onwards, the term was also applied to Jews in Europe who also had an inferior position because Judaism was held to be an inferior religion. Jews were not Christians. They were not allowed to take the oaths or to hold that were necessary for To vote
SPEAKER_02or to hold political office or offices of trust, as they were called. And they were not equal subjects or equal citizens. So the term emancipation is applied to the very long process that unfolds over a number of centuries by which Jews attained equality and became equal citizens.
SPEAKER_01And this process of emancipation, obviously not just for Jews, but in a lot of countries like France, chiefly around the question of Jewish emancipation, isn't just a sort of like footnote in European political history, as I understand it. You see it in particular as critical to the broader development of democracy in Europe.
SPEAKER_00Is that correct? That's right. Well, it's critical to the development, I would say, of constitutional governance.
SPEAKER_02The emancipation of Jews, Jews attaining citizenship, always came at the end of the process for other groups. So, for example, you mentioned France.
SPEAKER_00Protestants were also unequal citizens or subjects after the revocation of the Edict of Nantes in 1685. But in 1787...
SPEAKER_02They were given toleration, meaning to say they then had civic status, they could inherit property, they could register their marriages. The French monarchy was about to undertake to do the same thing for Jews, but then the revolution intervened and instead of being... Granted toleration, Jews were made equal citizens in 1790 and 1791.
SPEAKER_02The same thing happens in England, for example. We talked about the Catholics. It was first Protestant dissenters. Who had to be released from their inferior status. That occurred between the 1790s and the early 1820s when Protestant dissenters, meaning to say Baptists, Anabaptists, Methodists were allowed to vote and to hold political office and to have equal civil status.
SPEAKER_02The same thing occurred in the Habsburg Empire. Jews were emancipated in 1867 when the Habsburg Empire was restructured and became Austria-Hungary, but Protestants had been emancipated in 1864. The emancipation of Jews or Jews becoming citizens and having equality always followed that of other religious groups. So it was part of a larger process of creating a polity
SPEAKER_02with constitutional government, with equality before the law.
SPEAKER_03So, David, one of the really interesting points you make in your book, this new book, does resonate with one pattern in the scholarship on emancipation in the United States as well, which is you argue that until recently, much of the scholarship on Jewish emancipation has, in your words, said that it was given to Jews, where the emancipators, as you call them, We're not at the center of the story, did not have political agency. Of course, that was true in the history of slave emancipation in the United States for
SPEAKER_03a long time. It was largely written as if Lincoln gave the slaves freedom, for example. So this turn in your book to focusing on the Jewish emancipators, how does that change our story?
SPEAKER_00Well,
SPEAKER_02what I'm addressing in the book is Is an overall conception of the nature of Jewish political history in the diaspora. Okay, I don't want to expand the terms and the chronology that I'm talking about too much, but it's impossible not to do so. Jewish political history has
SPEAKER_00been written as if Jews ceased to have a political history from the time they were From the time, from the beginning, from the time, from the destruction of the Second Temple and the destruction of Jewish sovereignty
SPEAKER_02in 70 and 130 CE, when the Romans destroyed Jerusalem and exiled the majority of Jews.
SPEAKER_00And the Jews, only the Jews in the diaspora were then powerless. They had no politics.
SPEAKER_02And it's only with the beginnings of Jewish nationalism and Jewish socialism in the 1880s and 1890s in Eastern Europe that Jews begin to recover or to act politically and to recover power. Now that has become sort of a standard version of Jewish history. It fits very well with the self-understanding of Jewish nationalist movements such
SPEAKER_02as Autonomism and Zionism and also Jewish Socialism, Bundism. But it actually isn't at all historically accurate. Jews in the diaspora, whether it was in Babylonia, in Spain... In Eastern Europe, in Western and Central Europe, in North Africa and the Middle East, Jewish communities as collectives always exercise forms of political power.
SPEAKER_02They had representatives who negotiated with governments, representatives who intervened with governments. They exercise the power of a diaspora minority. You know, it's really been, as you mentioned, Jeremy, about the emancipation of slaves in the United States. It's really been a major turn in historical scholarship of the last half century, the last 75 years,
SPEAKER_02to recognize that minorities in a larger society are able to exercise various forms of political power.
SPEAKER_03Yes.
SPEAKER_02And so I'm really taking those sorts of questions and applying them to Jews, particularly in the long 19th century. Because I think in the writing of Jewish history, the people I call the emancipationists have basically been written out. They've been written out of that story. They've been labeled as assimilationists, as people who were denying their Jewish identity in one way or another,
SPEAKER_02who really just wanted to become part of the larger society, but weren't actively identified with As Jews or participating in a Jewish political project. So by labeling these people emancipationists, what I'm trying to show is the Jews, particularly Jewish leaders across Europe, but also in the United States, mobilized in order to participate in the process of gaining rights.
SPEAKER_02That they made use of the new political methods that were emerging in the 19th century, vernacular press, Law and the courts, philanthropic organizations, educational organizations, lobbying organizations. They adopted all of those methods from the larger society, amalgamated those methods with their inherited values.
SPEAKER_02Practices of diaspora Jewish politics and turn them into powerful means to lobby for their own equal rights and citizenship.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. What were those means that they used to try and gain political power? Very interesting, you divide the book not necessarily by region or even by person, but by method. So I'm wondering if you could speak a little bit to that choice and also if you had to sort of describe in short terms what the ways that they used to gain political power were, what would those be? Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Well, you know... You mentioned that I organize the book according to the means of political power rather
SPEAKER_02than organizing it regionally. And I think that's a very important insight. I really try to show that the political methods that Jewish leaders used were very much the same across Europe and in the United States. So, for example... The first chapter deals with community organization.
SPEAKER_02Now, the view of Jewish political history, which argued that Jewish politics only began in the late 19th century, always asserted that with emancipation, there were no longer active institutions Jewish community organizations which could assert a kind of political power.
SPEAKER_02So I actually go through and show that in fact that's simply not the case. You know, one of the most famous Jewish community organizations was the Consistoire or the Consistory that was created by Napoleon in 1808 after the Parisian Sanhedrin. For one thing, it's usually assumed that Napoleon imposed this organization on the Jews in the same way that he imposed a consistory organization on the Protestants
SPEAKER_02a few years earlier. In fact, it turns out that Jewish community leaders had petitioned the French government and Napoleon to create a new community organization after what had existed in the Achean regime where these corporate organizations were dissolved.
SPEAKER_00So the first thing is it wasn't just an organization imposed on French Jews. French Jewish leaders asked for it. But then it turns out that the French
SPEAKER_02Jewish leaders of the consistory used the consistory to lobby the French government. Napoleon in 1808 after the Sanhedrin... had promulgated a number of decrees restricting Jewish rights, basically turning what had been an unconditional emancipation during the revolution into a conditional emancipation in which there were restrictions on Jewish residential rights and Jewish occupations, the ability to loan money, etc.
SPEAKER_02Those so-called infamous decrees, which were promulgated in 1808, were valid for a decade, but Napoleon had made them
SPEAKER_00renewable, so they came up for renewal in 1818. So in the run-up to 1818, the consistory lobbied the French government, wrote political tracts, which were then published, and really organized a campaign to make sure that the infamous decrees were not renewed. And then it became involved in other
SPEAKER_02issues as well. One of them was... The state paying salaries to rabbis. From the time of the Revolution, the French state had taken over paying the salaries of clergy for the Catholic Church and for Protestants, but not for Jews. So Jews and Judaism became a kind of anomaly. So in 1830, after the revolution of 1830, the consistory lobbied the French government successfully to begin paying
SPEAKER_02the salaries of rabbis. So here again, it was forcefully intervening in order to remove an existing vestige of inequality. I then go on in other chapters to show other new methods that emerge. I have a chapter on lawyers. In the 19th century, you begin to get university Jews who are trained as lawyers at universities
SPEAKER_02in their countries who then use their legal skills to advocate for Jewish emancipation. One of the most famous figures like this in the 19th century was Adolphe Cremieux in France. Who became very famous during the Damascus Affair in lobbying the French government, actually opposing French foreign policy in order to lobby on behalf of Jews against the blood libel.
SPEAKER_02Cremieux went on to become a minister of justice in two French governments. Another figure like that was Gabriel Rieser, who was the champion of Jewish emancipation in the German states. He had studied at the University of Heidelberg, studied law, graduated summa cum laude in canon law
SPEAKER_00and secular law. But because he was Jewish, he couldn't get an academic position. Get instated as a lawyer to practice law. Of course, he did have the option of conversion. The moment he converted, he could have had any kind of career he wanted. But he refused to convert. And instead, he became the public advocate for Jewish emancipation.
SPEAKER_02He wrote his first political tract in 1831, and he continued to lobby on behalf for Jewish equality, engaging in public debates in the 1830s and 40s. In 1848, he was elected to the Frankfurt National Assembly,
SPEAKER_00where the National Assembly elected him second vice president, where he also lobbied on behalf of Jewish emancipation and equality. And eventually in 1860, he was the first Jew in Germany to be appointed a judge.
SPEAKER_02And there were figures, I look at figures, similar figures in the Habsburg lands, in England where Jews are first admitted to the bar in 1833. There's a similar development in Russia which comes later in the century because Russia doesn't, Actually have an independent legal system until 1864. After that Jews train as lawyers and also advocate on behalf of Jewish emancipation in Russia.
SPEAKER_02Yet another method that Jews adopt is that of a vernacular press. The first Jewish newspaper in a vernacular language was founded in 1837 in Germany, the Allgemeine Zeitung des Judentums, the general newspaper of Jews. This became sort of the paper of record in the Jewish world, kind of the gold standard of Jewish journalism. The paper was founded with the goal of advocating for Jewish equality,
SPEAKER_02of achieving emancipation. The editor of the newspaper, a rabbi by the name of Ludwig Philipsen, organized petitions to governments. He Publish news of emancipation and the campaign for equality from across Europe and the United States. He created a kind of Jewish reading public and Jewish public opinion.
SPEAKER_02And he was so well known and so important that he even undertook diplomatic
SPEAKER_00missions, meeting with heads of government. Um, So those are some of the main, and finally I also discuss what I call the philanthropic diplomatic complex. Jews found all kinds of secondary or voluntary associations to promote Jewish education, to promote Jewish occupational restructuring, and eventually also organizations that take over the kind of lobbying and advocacy that individual lawyers were doing and turn it into a collective effort.
SPEAKER_02One of the first organizations of this kind was actually founded in the United States. It's an organization that's been unjustly neglected and forgotten. It was the Board of Delegates of American Israelites founded in 1859. It was actually the first organization of its kind founded by Jews in the United States or in Europe. Textbooks will tell you that the first organization of that kind was the Alliance Israelite Universelle, Founded in France in 1860,
SPEAKER_02but the Board of Delegates preceded it by some seven or eight months.
SPEAKER_00You also then get civil defense organizations. Jews begin to found these in the 1880s.
SPEAKER_02The first is founded in Austria-Hungary, the Österreichische-Israelische Union in the early 1880s. The Zentralverein, the Central Association of Directors, German Citizens of the Jewish Persuasion
SPEAKER_00was founded in 1893. And this is followed by similar organizations in the United States, the American Jewish Committee in 1906, the Anti-Defamation
SPEAKER_02League in 1913. These are all organizations founded to attain emancipation and to defend it once achieved.
SPEAKER_03David, this is such a fascinating story. There's so many interesting characters. One of your arguments that jumped out to me that I think has a lot of relevance for today is your argument about a secular identity of Jewishness. And I think the term you use is that the emancipation is through the sentence you have here is the emancipation has created this secular identity. What do you mean by that? And what do you mean by Jewishness?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, thanks for asking that question. You know, I think, especially since the people I call the emancipationists have
SPEAKER_02generally been kind of tarred and feathered with the appropriate label of being assimilationists. I think it's especially important to see that The people I've talked about, whether lawyers, newspaper editors, activists in Jewish community organizations, philanthropic and educational organizations, civil defense organizations, what these people were doing was actually creating a new way to be Jewish.
SPEAKER_02Not a new form of Judaism, but a form of secular Jewishness. You know, when you look at the biographies of these people,
SPEAKER_00a lot of them had ceased to be praying Jews, synagogue attenders, but they still identified as Jews and were active as Jews, publicly active as Jews, and were seen as community leaders. You know, I quote from a
SPEAKER_02A novel of 1888, Reuben Sachs by Amy Levy. The hero of that novel, Reuben Sachs, is a Cambridge-trained lawyer who has not much use for Jewish religious observance.
SPEAKER_00He'll attend synagogue because his family is attending synagogue on the high holy days. He maybe fasts on Yom Kippur, but maybe not. But he belongs to all of these different Jewish organizations in England. He is a community activist, and that is his form of Jewishness. And at one point, the novelist, Amy Levy, has him say, or proudly declare, I am exceedingly fond of my people.
SPEAKER_00So here he is, strongly identifying as a Jew, active as a Jew, but not necessarily being a religious Jew. So I think it's important to recognize this because this is a pattern that emerges in the 19th century of secular Jewishness. Which for the people I discussed was founded on political activism and which continues to this day.
SPEAKER_00And I think it's relevant for the moment to recognize this as a form of diaspora Jewish politics. That there is a form of diaspora Jewish politics which precedes Zionism in the state of Israel and can and should function independently of those things.
SPEAKER_01I'm curious, you mentioned already the sort of common critique of these or dismissal of these sort of political and legal and cultural figures as assimilationists. I'm wondering what you would make or what your response would be. I think that's a really good point, Zach, and I appreciate that.
SPEAKER_00I think my response to that is that or the problem with that argument is that it is a parochial Jewish argument. It sees the Holocaust as and everything around the Holocaust only in terms of Jewish history. I mean, I think it's important to see that the Holocaust occurred as part of the collapse of constitutional government and democracy across Europe.
SPEAKER_00And that after 1945, constitutional government and democracy were restored. The Holocaust is not the endpoint of European Jewish history. And it's not the final judgment on Jewish emancipation. I think what's important to see about Jewish emancipation is that it was an ongoing process in which Jews could gain rights, lose rights
SPEAKER_02and recover rights. And clearly the Holocaust represents the nadir of Jews losing rights and also, of course, losing their lives. But constitutional government was in fact
SPEAKER_00restored after the Second World War and Jews regained rights across Western and Central Europe. I mean, the Eastern Bloc and Russia is a more complicated story, but even there, they were citizens.
SPEAKER_03It's interesting to me, David, also, it strikes me you're trying to move us away from the notion that Israel is a natural teleology as well, right? Exactly. You talk about Herzl. Yeah, could you explain that?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, no, look, I think that... I think modern Jewish history has conventionally been written, and this is in the textbooks, with 1933 or 1939 to 1945 and 1948 as the endpoints, especially of European Jewish history. And that's simply not the case. Jewish history continues. European Jewish history continues.
SPEAKER_00There are major Jewish communities in England and France and across the continent. Right. I mean, there are more Jews in Berlin now than there were in the days of Moses Mendelssohn. Right. So I think we have to take a longer view. We have to resist that teleology of 1939 to 1945 or 1948. History has continued. The process of emancipation has continued.
SPEAKER_00And in fact, it behooves Jews who live in the diaspora to continue to defend emancipation. Emancipation is once again under attack.
SPEAKER_01I'm curious what you would say the real sort of concrete lessons of this history are for us today. Obviously, this is a topic that you have written about extensively before, but It seems to me like this new book is really much more in conversation with contemporary politics and our moment today as Jews, as non-Jews engaged in constitutional democracy. What are the lessons that we can learn from this politics moving forward?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, that's a really good question. Let me just preface it by saying I didn't write this book as a book of the moment. I started writing it in 2019 and You know, it took me quite a few years to write. But I do think that really nilly, it is a book of the moment. And I think what you're asking about is, you know, what lessons does it have for the moment?
SPEAKER_00I think it has a number of lessons. One lesson is, is that the emancipationists I write about, We're advocating and lobbying on behalf of themselves, but always with a view to the larger society. They realize the Jews could never gain equality unless everyone else gained equality. They realize the Jews could not be equal before the law unless you had constitutional government which recognized the equality of everyone
SPEAKER_00before the law. Right. So, you know, one thing I would say is, you know, there's that old saying, is it good for the Jews? No, I think that is that is a mistaken adage for understanding Jewish politics.
SPEAKER_03You better talk to my grandmother, David. Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Oh, listen, I heard it at home as well. You know, the question is not, is it good for the Jews? The question should be, are we creating a society Which is good for all
SPEAKER_02groups, including the Jews.
SPEAKER_03Amen.
SPEAKER_00And I think one can see this in terms of the history of diaspora Jewish politics. One of the leading
SPEAKER_02rules of thumb Of Jewish diaspora politics is a Talmudic, a Talmudic maxim called the law of the land is law, dina d'malchuta dina. The idea being that if you live in a foreign country, You look at the laws, you judge the laws of the country in which you're living according to the standards of Jewish law.
SPEAKER_02And if those laws are just, then you are obligated to follow them. If something is being done, which according to the standards of Jewish law is unjust, then you have legitimate cause not to follow those laws.
SPEAKER_00What that adage or maxim does, however, is it treats the law of the land as a static entity. The people I looked at, the emancipationists and particularly the lawyers, introduce a major innovation in which they say the law of the land is not static. The law of the land is dynamic and we can participate in changing the law and making it better.
SPEAKER_00We can push notions of equality before the law, make the state adopt that notion of equality before the law and honor it in practice, not just for
SPEAKER_02ourselves, but for everyone.
SPEAKER_03And I think, David, those sentiments are what moved Jewish civil rights activists in the United States, for example.
SPEAKER_00Yes, yes, exactly. I mean, if you look at the American Jewish Congress, the Committee on Law and Social Action, that's exactly
SPEAKER_02what it did beginning in the late 1940s. First, by writing amicus briefs.
SPEAKER_00For suits that the NAACP was bringing, and then by bringing lawsuits of its own. Also by writing, you know, new model legislation for equal opportunity employment, for fair housing. You know, all of those things were first battled out in the courts at the local and state level, and then at the national level.
SPEAKER_03This is Louis Brandeis, Abraham Heschel of figures of that sort. Yeah, it's extraordinary.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah. Well, thank you so much for joining us, Professor Sorkin. I think you've given us not just a wonderful sort of tour de force of this history, but also a kind of call to action at the end here for a renewed commitment If I might do a little bit of interpretation of my own, a renewed commitment to individual rights and the processes of constitutional democracy as the sort of primary protectors of minorities in our world.
SPEAKER_01And, you know, I think moving forward, these questions will be on the mind of many and certainly important. The topics of the day touch on many of these questions or many of these debates. But unfortunately, I don't think this history is brought up enough or discussed as much as it should be as a part of this conversation. So hopefully, for our listeners today, we've been Thank
SPEAKER_01you, Professor Sorkin, for joining us this morning. Well, thank you for inviting me. Wonderful. Thank you. And thank you, Professor Suri, as always, for joining us. Of course, my pleasure. And thank you to all of our listeners for joining us for this episode of This Is Democracy. This podcast is produced by the Liberal Arts ITS Development Studio
SPEAKER_03and the College of Liberal Arts at the University of Texas at Austin.
SPEAKER_01The music in this episode was written and recorded by Scott Holmes. Stay tuned for a new episode every week. You can find This is Democracy on Apple Podcasts, Spotify and YouTube. See you next time.
This week I spoke with Julian Zelizer, the Princeton historian and one of our most frequent guests, about the scale of what happened in Tuesday’s midterms. I wanted to know whether this was a strange moment for a...
This week Zachary and I spoke with Sarah Adler Hartman, CEO of The Texas Tribune, whose career took her from founding Spoon University as a Northwestern student to running subscriber products at The New York Times...
In this episode of This is Democracy, Zachary and I sat down with our old friend John Sipher, who spent 28 years in the. CIA’s Clandestine Service before becoming one oft public voices on intelligence. I wanted to...
This week on This is Democracy, I sat down with Daniel Bessner, one of the sharpest critics of American foreign policy writing today, to talk through his new essay collection, Imperialist Realism. Danny’s central claim...
This week, Zachary, back from a summer reporting assignment for the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel, and I sat down to dig into a problem I think cuts across nearly every American community: local journalism is collapsing as...