Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

This is Democracy

This is Democracy artwork

This is Democracy Episode 331 – Nonprofit News

Oct 21, 202642 minAudio

This week Zachary and I spoke with Sarah Adler Hartman, CEO of The Texas Tribune, whose career took her from founding Spoon University as a Northwestern student to running subscriber products at The New York Times before she came to lead one of the most consequential nonprofit newsrooms in the country. I wanted to understand why nonprofit journalism has become such an important model, and Sarah explained the core problem to us quite directly: market incentives push news organizations toward ever-bigger national audiences, which leaves local and state coverage starved of resources. The Tribune solved that by treating journalism as a public good funded through philanthropy, the same way a community funds its libraries or its opera house, and that model has since spread to hundreds of nonprofit newsrooms nationally. Her account of fact-checking rigor as the difference between real journalism and the noise that surrounds it online was particularly insightful, and her insistence that no donor’s comfort matters more than the newsroom’s editorial independence. One of the most illuminating parts of our conversation surrounded AI, which Sarah sees as both the greatest risk and the greatest opportunity journalism has faced in her lifetime. Rather than playing defense, she wants newsrooms to use AI to give readers the fuller context that a single article never can, while preserving an editor’s interpretive judgment about what a story means and whose decisions it connects to whose lives. Zachary made a point late in the conversation that I think gets at something true about human nature itself: that we have never found a society without some craving to tell its own story, going back to Herodotus and Thucydides writing contemporary accounts of their world. As early voting begins across the country this month, this conversation is a good reminder of why that work, done honestly and locally, still matters enormously to how we govern ourselves. Click here to listen to the full episode or read the transcript. Democracy of Hope, produced by Jeremi and Zachary Suri, is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support our work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber. Get full access to Democracy of Hope, Jeremi and Zachary Suri at democracyofhope.substack.com/subscribe

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_00This is Democracy. A podcast about the people of the United States. A podcast about citizenship. About engaging with politics and the world around you. A podcast about educating yourself on today's important issues and how to have a voice in what happens next.

SPEAKER_03Welcome to our new episode of This Is Democracy. This week is another special week. We have another terrific guest with us, someone I've been looking forward to speaking with for a long time because I've heard so much about her from many people, including her dad, who's a friend and former mayor of Austin. This is Sarah Adler Hartman. Welcome, Sarah.

SPEAKER_01I'm so happy to be here. Thank you for having me.

SPEAKER_03We're delighted to have you. Sarah is the chief executive officer of the Texas Tribune, which, as we'll talk about today, is one of the most important state and local news sources in the United States today and a model for many others. Before coming to the Texas Tribune, before we were lucky enough to recruit her here, she was the head of product and news subscriber services at the New York Times. And among other things, she focused on engaging and retaining subscribers to the New York Times. It's true. That's amazing. You started really early.

SPEAKER_03Really early. Wow, so this is in your blood in a sense, right? We are so fortunate to have Sarah with us today. Of course, we're also joined by Mr. Zachary Suri.

SPEAKER_03How are you today, Zachary? Doing well. Good morning. Good afternoon. Whatever time of day it is. So, Sarah, the Texas Tribune is a really unique organization, as I mentioned already. It's a not-for-profit that provides really very detailed coverage of news for the state of Texas. It covers a lot of local news as well. Just maybe tell us a little bit about what makes this organization unique.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, of course. So when the Tribune was founded in about 2008, 2009, the idea behind it was that journalism is a public good, that it's necessary for democracy, for people to have access to information and make decisions and to have that information be accurate. And the problem with journalism is that there are a lot of market forces that are Pushing journalism and news organizations into places that make it

SPEAKER_01a lot less helpful for democracy. If you're incentivized to have bigger and bigger audiences, you're incentivized to cover And so John Thornton, who was one of the founders of the Texas Tribune,

SPEAKER_01Started the Tribune as a nonprofit so that you could use philanthropy to subsidize that business model. And the idea was that communities in the same way that they fund their libraries and their operas and art museums, they should also fund news organizations. And it was one of the first nonprofit news organizations. And then since the Trib has kind of grown as an example of what's possible, there are now hundreds of nonprofit news organizations all over the country.

SPEAKER_03Fantastic. Zachary, I know you have a question about this.

SPEAKER_02One of the problems I think with, or one of the challenges that news organizations often face, particularly for-profit news organizations, but I'm sure it also applies to non-profit news organizations as well, is that when you do good journalism, you often piss off a lot of people, to put it bluntly. How do you sustain the goodwill of readership and of donors and others to support this kind of work when you're doing really hard-hitting journalism that hopefully at least ruffles some feathers?

SPEAKER_01I mean, that's a real challenge. And there are definitely, you know, like I, as someone who is now responsible for fundraising for a nonprofit that does hard-hitting accountability journalism, I look around at my nonprofit CEO peers that are fundraising for things that are a lot less controversial. And I'm like, that looks so much better. And, but what's fascinating is that I talk to them and even they talk about navigating their own politics. And so, you know, I think part of it is just like, Fundraising is always hard and fundraising is always really emotional.

SPEAKER_01And so part of it is just you have to figure out how to navigate emotions and politics in fundraising kind of regardless of what you're fundraising for. And then within the Texas Tribune, I think one of the most important things is just that we're always sure that We will prioritize the journalism over any source of funding. So I haven't had, I mean, I've only been CEO since January. So I haven't had any kind of, I haven't run into any issues yet in my tenure. Just you wait.

SPEAKER_01Where I've had to like, you know, offer to return someone's money. But I know that my predecessors have run into circumstances where there's been a donor that's been really upset about some coverage and they've had to say, okay, well, If you're that upset, you can have your money back. And at the end of the day, you have to pick the independence and editorial integrity of the newsroom over everything else, or you have nothing. And I think that, honestly, a lot of people who are willing to be significant donors and supporters of independent journalism respect that backbone more than they want coverage

SPEAKER_01that Sure.

SPEAKER_03They want real journalism, not propaganda. And I guess that leads to my question, which is, how do you differentiate really good journalism? I think that's what you publish every day. How do you distinguish that from what is not really journalism, but more puff pieces, marketing, things of that kind?

SPEAKER_01Well, I mean, I think there's one, like what's the difference in like, what's the actual difference in how that's produced? And then two, like how do consumers tell the difference between those two things maybe? I think what's the actual difference is that the rigor that goes into actual reporting is so intense. And there's, you know, every fact has to be checked. When I was in journalism school at Northwestern, if you had one – If you had one incorrect fact in the story, you could get what's called a Medill F. And that included a misspelling of a name.

SPEAKER_01And you would just fail the entire assignment. And I think that, you know, like there's a certain kind of like journalists who see themselves as part of more like institutional and kind of, you know, legacy journalism, I think, are all kind of believe in that ethic that you really have to check every single fact and make sure that You're telling stories with nuance and without caricature and that editors are then like reading the whole story and double checking everything. And for, you know, pieces that we turn around quickly at the Tribune that are,

SPEAKER_01you know, like when in the aftermath of the of the ice shooting in Houston, as an example, we are trying to really quickly turn around stories about what was happening in Houston and Looking at all the video footage that we could access and there were like, you know, a team of 10 people looking at that and fact checking everything and looking at the timestamps in the videos and making sure that all the language that we used, that a couple people reviewed the language that was used to talk about what was happening in the videos. And so I think that like that kind of rigor really differentiates what the actual product is.

SPEAKER_01The problem is once something is published on Instagram or once an article is published on the internet, Right. Right. Right. And that's a really hard problem. I think the journalism organizations need to do a lot better job showing their homework and showing the rigor of the work so

SPEAKER_01that people can start to tell more of a difference.

SPEAKER_03This is like the page the New York Times has started publishing the last few years where they actually talked to the journalists about how they did their reporting on a particular issue. That's what you have in mind, right?

SPEAKER_01Well, and like the Times has actually done a lot. Right, right.

SPEAKER_03Footnotes, which we love as historians, of course.

SPEAKER_01But at the top.

SPEAKER_03Zachary, you did some of this reporting. You've done it in many places, but particularly this summer at the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel. Does this resonate with you, what Sarah's talking about? No, certainly.

SPEAKER_02I mean, the transparency of the reporting process, it's one of the biggest challenges is, you know, You can't always make clear all the people you talk to that you didn't write about, all the perspectives you got that don't make it into a story. And that often can contribute or can be in service of people who might want to characterize the work as incomplete or biased. But I also think that one of the real advantages

SPEAKER_02that news organizations often have is a sort of really on the ground local focus. And I'm curious, like the Texas Tribune, It takes the state as it's sort of the whole state of Texas as its beat and its main area of focus and isn't a traditional news organization in the sense that it's not grounded in one particular city or in coverage of one particular community. I'm curious how you navigate that challenge of not, you know, obviously the Tribune has its own, has its big office downtown Austin and a lot of reporters all across the state.

SPEAKER_02But does it change the journalism you think to have a statewide focus rather than a local focus like a traditional newspaper?

SPEAKER_01For what it's worth, I would actually say that we were very grounded in place and topic when we were founded because we weren't supposed to cover all of Texas. We were supposed to cover the state house. So we were supposed to cover the state capitol because if you looked at the press box of the capitol during the legislative session, it was dwindling beyond repair. And even now on 10 p.m. on a Friday during the legislative session, we'll see what it's like. Well, they're all at the

SPEAKER_03bar, though. They're all at the Driscoll.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, that's true. But sometimes it's just a Tribune reporter. Right. And for one of the biggest economies in the world, people should be really afraid of that. But anyway, back to the kind of like being of a place. And I think that when we started out, we were really focused on the statehouse, the state capital, state policy and politics. But what I think... It becomes problematic and became problematic for the Texas Tribune with that was

SPEAKER_01that when you're covering state policy and politics, but you are only covering it from Austin, then you are actually not covering state policy and politics well. And to cover the statehouse well, we actually needed to cover more of Texas well. And that's why we launched the regional team a few years ago, where we actually have regional reporters now embedded in regions of Texas so they can be on the ground. And I think part of the misunderstanding of that team was that it was supposed

SPEAKER_01to explain the state policy and politics to people outside of Austin, when really I think one of the big focuses of the team is to elevate the stories from elsewhere in Texas to the state agenda. And one of my favorite examples of that is that... Last summer, I think we did 35 stories on water use from all across the state at a time where the state was considering landmark water legislation. And I think that a lot of our stories were cited in bills that were passed.

SPEAKER_01And I think that that's how much we were able to empower people. Lawmakers with the information that they needed to be able to make more informed decisions on behalf of everyone in Texas. Like that's also a big part of what, you know, what it means to embed in places outside of Austin and to represent those places in coverage.

SPEAKER_03Maybe coming at Zachary's question from the other side, how do you protect against being just the Austin view of the state? Your reporters tend to be highly educated individuals. They tend to come from urban environments, right? And I've quite often heard the criticism. I don't agree with it. But I've heard the criticism that, you know, the Texas Tribune is not really telling the story of the state, but telling the story of a particular kind of person in the state.

SPEAKER_01Well, I think, again, like I think that part of that criticism, part of what the Regents team was designed to do was to Was to help us solve for the legitimate roots at the seed of that criticism. You know what I mean? And because I think it's almost impossible to do that if everybody's based in Austin and doesn't look like the rest of the state of Texas. And so now that we actually have reporters, we actually have a lot of people that aren't based in Austin. And we have reporters that are based here, obviously, but we also have education reporters in Houston and Waco and Austin.

SPEAKER_01And we have We have a reporter in the Valley. We have a reporter in the Panhandle. And, you know, we're covering immigration from the Valley. And I think that, like, the fact that we have reporters that are from those places on the ground in those places does a lot to make sure we have a more nuanced perspective in

SPEAKER_02the report. Sure, sure. Zachary? I'm curious also, you know, one of the things the Tribune seems to really pioneer to these kind of partnerships between nonprofit newsrooms, you know, I worked at the at NPR's Texas Newsroom in Austin for a summer two years ago, and a lot of the stories were collaborations or or The team that I was working on often highlighted Tribune work, etc. I'm curious if you can speak to that a little bit, like what it looks like as the big name politics publication of the state to support a lot of local reporting or incorporate that kind of local reporting in your work

SPEAKER_02as well.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, well, I mean, I think that, you know, again, part of the reframe of a news organization being a nonprofit and journalism being kind of public infrastructure or public good means that it's our job to make sure that the report that we can use philanthropy to subsidize the creation of reporting and make sure that reporting gets as far as it possibly can. And so we do a lot of things with that reporting counter to. And so that allows for those news organizations to be able to keep supporting themselves and

SPEAKER_01We get to reach community members there that might not go to texastribune.org, but will open up their newspaper because that's the relationship that they have. And we hope that they see that it comes from the Texas Tribune. We hope that that means that they recognize our brand and that one day they might go to texastribune.org so that we can continue to build the relationship with them and inform them. And hopefully one day maybe they'll toss us five bucks and pay back into the system. But a big part of how we measure success is in how far that journalism goes.

SPEAKER_01And we measure that across all platforms, including the platforms that we're not monetizing. And that also goes to now that we're in this new information ecosystem where last year we had 30 million unique visitors come to the website for the Texas Tribune over the course of the year. About half of that traffic came from Google, Google search. A lot of people asking questions about Texas. Sure. Because we don't have a paywall,

SPEAKER_01we're a great source of news for Google to serve because people can see the coverage without a paywall. And we have a very big audience relative to other statewide events. News organizations, especially organizations that specifically cover policy and politics. But like all news organizations, we're seeing significant declines in Google search referrals because Google now has those summaries they put at the top of the page

SPEAKER_01that summarize the answer and then you don't need to click through to the news organization.

SPEAKER_03Often inaccurately, actually.

SPEAKER_01I actually think it's not inaccurate that often. The New York Times did a kind of assessment of this and said that it was inaccurate like That's true. That's true.

SPEAKER_02Go ahead, Zachary. Oh, I didn't have a specific question, but I think that the challenge of AI is one that I'm sure you guys have been thinking through probably more thoroughly than other news organizations that might be still wedded either to a print model or to a kind of daily paper model. I'm curious what you see the steps forward being for those kinds of news organizations and for yourself, you know, addressing these challenges that AI poses and potentially new opportunities as well.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, of course. I... See AI as one of the biggest risks and opportunities for journalism in my lifetime, both. And I think that it's really easy to spend a lot of time focusing on the risks, and there are a ton of them. I am not sure. I don't think that playing defensively with AI is going to buy us a whole lot as an industry. Mm-hmm. And so I think that it's the gains from trying to be first to market on what

SPEAKER_01the opportunities are and how we can figure out how we can actually use AI to fundamentally reshape the economics of how journalism is produced and therefore how many communities all across the state of Texas and all across the country can now possibly afford Investigative and accountability journalism, especially communities that frankly don't have it at all anymore. Like how might we use AI to solve for some of those kinds of problems instead of focusing on, you know, the kind of, you know, very urgent problem of, you know,

SPEAKER_01massive traffic declines that we're also, I'm also spending a lot of energy thinking about, but I'm trying to make sure that we're kind of equally and appropriately focused on what some of the opportunities are. I'm very, um, Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm.

SPEAKER_01And I think this also comes from the fact that I, you know, have a technical background. I built all the software for the company that I started. I was the CTO throughout my career in journalism. I've worked on the technology side. So I also think it helps that I, you know, have like spent plenty of time vibe coding my own products. So I'm like more familiar with how this technology works, I think, than most people in my position.

SPEAKER_03Sure. And that's unique for someone in your role, isn't it?

SPEAKER_01Yeah. Yeah. I think it definitely is. And so right now at the Texas Tribune, you know, we're navigating this like any newsroom. And there are a lot of people in the newsroom that are very skeptical of the technology. I'm not like making anybody use AI who doesn't want to use it. But there are also a lot of people that are really innovative and experimental. And, you know, we have a reporter in Waco who vibe coded a tool to Get the logs from the McLennan County Jail and build a database of ICE detainees

SPEAKER_01for reporting purposes. And like, that's really cool. He wouldn't have been able to do that without a team of engineers previously. And like, how might we think about what the possibilities could be like that? You know, we have tons of ideas and not enough resources always at the Texas Tribune. How can we think about technology as enabling us to do some of those things that previously we couldn't Have imagined actually doing. And how can we now build products that previously we assumed

SPEAKER_01the audience was too small to allow for that product to be built? Like the costs of building new products is now so low that we can build products for more, for smaller, we can build more bespoke products for smaller audiences now that I think could actually serve people news in a way that they need information. And, you know, I would argue that one of the problems with news organizations in general is just that especially if you look at like the format of the article,

SPEAKER_01like who is that even for? You know, like when you think about like who the Texas Tribune audience is, we serve so many different kinds of people with so many different needs. And the article is like trying to serve all of them and serving none of them quite well enough.

SPEAKER_03Right. Well, and I guess that was sort of the question I wanted us to come to. I mean, what is the purpose of journalism, especially local and state journalism, in 2016? I mean, traditionally, we think of journalism as one being a fourth branch of government, right? A check on the bad behavior, the Woodward and Bernstein story, right? And uncovering Nixon's lawbreaking. We also think about it as... What other ways do you think there are to hold officials accountable?

SPEAKER_03Well, I mean, many of the things you described, right, other individuals are doing on their own. You don't need to be a journalistic entity, right? Some of the most interesting insights that we've gained on whatever the topic is, whether it's ICE, DOGE, whatever it is, it's the young kid in his or her garage, right?

SPEAKER_01Yeah.

SPEAKER_03You know, doing the kind of coding you just described. I guess that is a kind of journalism, but it doesn't have to be done by the New York Times or the Texas Tribune necessarily, right?

SPEAKER_01Yes. I was talking to somebody recently who said, you know, it's really amazing to see kind of the democratization of journalism in so many ways. Many more people are empowered now to become reporters, but when everyone's a reporter, you really learn to miss editors. Right. And I thought that that was a really good way of kind of explaining what the purpose of a journalism organization is. And like reporting is critical and you're on the ground and you're telling stories.

SPEAKER_01But what editors do is they look at the stories that you're telling comprehensively and like how relevant. How representative are you of different viewpoints and how fair are you being? And they are really important checks on what the overall arc of the story is. And I think one of the biggest problems is that that's what people like news people believe about journalism organizations. And that only really works if readers are completionists.

SPEAKER_01In order for my argument for the fairness of the Texas Tribune to be... I get that that article didn't cover that angle, but over the course of all of the Texas Tribune reporting, we cover that. You just didn't read those five stories that covered that angle, but that's not a fair expectation of readers. And so I think part of the problem is how can we deliver to someone a more complete view of Maybe it's the same way...

SPEAKER_03A different way of saying what you're saying, but I would have put it that it's more about the interpretive work that an editor does, right? I mean, there is the just the facts element of reporting, and that's probably where AI can do a lot of the shoe leather work, right? Especially if we're dealing with large quantities of legislative records or data.

SPEAKER_01AI is driven by people still. I also want to be clear that I'm talking about AI as people tools, not AI as autonomous agent tools.

SPEAKER_03Right, right. Well, you could have a bit of both, right? But I guess it seems to me the role of an editor is, yes, are you telling the full story, but also the editor is the one who's saying, what does this really mean? Are we getting at the core of the story, right? I mean, the famous accounts of Ben Bradley at the Washington Post is constantly pushing his reporters. What is the real story here? Don't just tell me what you're finding. What's really there? And I fear that in a world where we have citizen journalism in the way we do,

SPEAKER_03that we're uncovering a lot of bits and pieces here and there, but we're often missing the bigger story. I think we struggle with that. We miss it in part also because there are so many stories out there. What is the story for Trump that we should tell? Which story? What is the story for the 2026 election? There are a lot of different things going on at the same time. And at some point, an editor has a point of view. They have a perspective on this. It's not that they're biased to be left or right, but they have an interpretive way of thinking about What stories are,

SPEAKER_03what their audience should care about. At some level, I think you kind of have to own that, right?

SPEAKER_01What altitude are you looking at it? I think that there's also a question of, you know, it's really hard. It's hard for any one person to do any of this by themselves. That's also why an institution is like bigger than any one person's perspective. It's bigger than any one person's. Like level of altitude or any one person's work or bias or anything else. And that's also something that's really helpful, you know, like it can stand the test of time in a way that a person can't.

SPEAKER_03Right, right. So at some level, the Texas Tribune, the story is about, is the government serving the people, right? That is your fundamental interpretive frame, right? That's what you care about, right?

SPEAKER_01Well, I think it's both. Is the government serving the people? How can we check on that? And what information does the government need in order to Make the decisions that they're making both. Like I think that and when we talk about our audience at the Texas Tribune, we actually talk about our professional audience and our civilian audience. Our professional audience being the people who read the Texas Tribune for their jobs. A lot of politicians or staffers or people who are lobbyists. Good point. Good point. People whose jobs are impacted by the government like superintendents or CEOs of

SPEAKER_01a rural nonprofit or whatever it is, you know. And then there's the civilian audience, people that are reading the Texas Tribune in order to be Zachary, actually, I'm curious your point of view on this since you've been a reporter and you also were one of the editors at the Yale Daily News. What do you see as the differences?

SPEAKER_02I mean, I think that there's a really important point in this, which is that the job of the reporter, particularly someone covering policy and politics, is not just to report the facts or ask questions at press conferences and press gaggles. But the real purpose of a political journalist is to connect people to politics. And that does go in both directions, you know. The policymaker who's spending their entire time in a room thinking about pension plan doesn't necessarily ever have time to actually go out and speak

SPEAKER_02with the people who are impacted by those choices. And nor do the people who are actually impacted by that. Those choices usually know what that person in the room is is doing. And really, the job of a political reporter in that context is to connect the two. And I think that that's where I think the sort of impact of technology or maybe the scary part of AI scares me the least, actually, is because that's the kind of work, the kind of on the ground political reporting, asking people what they think,

SPEAKER_02asking people how they make decisions that really It has to be done in a human way and by a human being. And I think that's the real value when it comes to local journalism. You know, national coverage is super important and we all rely on really good national journalists. But in our local communities, to understand, you know, decisions that are being made and how they impact us, we need good local reporters.

SPEAKER_03So that's what success looks like for you? Helping people to better understand the issues? Yeah, I mean, I think there's also an accountability element there too, though.

SPEAKER_02You know, it's important that, as we were talking about, that a paper have editorial vision because if there's no sense that, you know, we have... Meaningful, important interpretive frameworks that we're viewing these political decisions and elections, etc. through, then one can very easily be tricked into repeating the narrative of one particular person in And ignore the important places where the facts disagree

SPEAKER_02or contradict that narrative. So the kind of constructive element of journalism or editing where you're constructing a narrative that's compelling and interesting and nuanced importantly, that's really important. And we can't outsource that as journalists or as editors.

SPEAKER_03Right. Right. And just the historian in me says that all newspapers until recently were founded with an editorial point of view. Often they were founded by a political party or by a rich guy who had a particular point of view. I mean, the Texas Tribune was founded by a rich guy, too, but one who wanted a different kind of approach. Right. And so I think there's progress in moving away from being, you know, the William Randolph Hearst newspaper. But there's also concern about a kind of false objectivity. Right.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. Yeah. And that is always really challenging. It's also hard because I think that people, you know, it just feels so personal. Stories feel so personal. Narrative feels so personal. And I still, you know, talk to people who, you know, want to talk about the bias of the Texas Tribune. And usually I'll like, you know, kind of I'll try to push on that so I can better understand like where they're coming from and what they've read that That made them feel that way.

SPEAKER_01And often it'll be very specific examples that, you know, like either it'll be like a few years old and they won't have read the Tribune in several years or it'll be like a very specific example and you can hear in it the like confirmation bias from their own perspective of like. They read that story looking for the example of our bias.

SPEAKER_03Or maybe there wasn't a bias, but it's their bias. I mean, I hear this all the time from people who criticize the New York Times. So they'll say, well, the New York Times, I've heard people say it's too pro-Israel and I've heard people say it's too pro-Palestine. And that Right. Right. Right. Right. Right. Right.

SPEAKER_02And being willing to approach the same issue and the same politician and the same policy question from many different angles and with many different storylines, like journalism isn't just a day by day activity, but one that's pieced together over months and years and being willing to approach and to approach the same issue two, three, four times from different angles and with different perspectives involved is kind of probably the most important test of Objectivity, if you want to call it that.

SPEAKER_01I completely agree with that. And I think then we get back to the completionist. Right. You know what I mean? Like now you're talking about like really the best way for us to be objective is to be, is to almost like build the collage across lots of different perspectives so that you can capture more nuance. But as a reader, that puts a lot of burden on the reader to understand, to then engage with all of those different pieces of the collage, you know?

SPEAKER_03Right. Right.

SPEAKER_01Which is part of the challenge.

SPEAKER_03So I guess the question I wanted us to close on, and it's led to this beautifully. You've given us so many insights here, Sarah, and how things work and how one thinks this through. Is the Texas Tribune a model for other states? I think one has to say it's been a success. In the 15 years I've lived in Austin, I've become so much better informed. About what happens in this state, particularly what happens in the legislature, but elsewhere, through the Texas Tribune. And I find in my research, I'm coming back to it in part because it's not a gated source,

SPEAKER_03but also because a lot of the reporting stands the test of time. And I'm sure when we look back and write the history of the 2026 election, regardless of what happens in our governor's race and Senate races, the Texas Tribune's reporting is going to be a main primary source for us. So I think it's been a success, there's no doubt. Is it a model for other states, so many states, so many cities, where Zachary is, for instance, in Connecticut, right? They struggle to have even mediocre coverage of day-to-day news.

SPEAKER_03Is this a model?

SPEAKER_01I think that the problem is that the Texas Tribune was a model 16, 17 years ago and has been a model for 17 years. And now that model is 17 years old.

SPEAKER_03Spoken like a tech entrepreneur, right? That's ancient history for you.

SPEAKER_01It is ancient history in the information ecosystem now. So much has changed in 17 years. I'm not even sure it's history.

SPEAKER_03I'm a historian.

SPEAKER_01We are now in a totally new world. And so I think that the challenge in front of the Texas Tribune now is that I think we are in such a – relative to so much of the news industry, in such a position of privilege with the resources that we have and the fantastic talent that we have and the faith that readers and the rest of the news industry puts in the Texas Tribune. I think we are uniquely positioned to – If I could push you, in addition to AI, you've talked about that eloquently.

SPEAKER_01What are some other areas you see creativity coming in? I mean, I think we need a lot more creativity in how we make money and revenue. I think that the,

SPEAKER_01you know, it's really helpful to subsidize our business model with philanthropy, but we are still subsidizing a failing business model. And as somebody who comes from a for-profit business background, the lack of recurring revenue in a non-profit industry is terrible for my health and my sleep habits. It makes it impossible to plan. It makes it impossible to grow. You have to re-earn your growth year over year.

SPEAKER_01And so I think we need, and this is a longer kind of cultural thing in news organizations, but I think that like You know, there's always been the news organizations have been continually trying to like reimagine how you can make money in a way that doesn't feel like truly dirty. And especially to journalists. And and I think that we need to approach revenue with real creativity as well.

SPEAKER_03That makes sense. Zachary, what are your thoughts on this?

SPEAKER_02Yeah, I mean, I think that the truth is that the changes in technology, I think, will make people crave like real, interesting, creative human stories more than ever. And also, I mean, at a very basic level, like the new technology, AI language models in particular need that kind of material as the sort of input for what they do. So I guess I'm optimistic at the very least that there would demand for this kind of writing, whether it can be monetized or not, I'm not necessarily in the best position to say.

SPEAKER_02But I'm also hopeful. I think there are a lot of young people every year who are fascinated by and passionate about engaging in this industry and becoming journalists. That's really hopeful. And I think many of them are taking huge pay cuts to do it, but they really care about the work. And that's really important. And we shouldn't discount it.

SPEAKER_03Yeah. Yeah. I think one of the lessons over millennia of human history is that human beings crave reporting about themselves. There's no society we have found that doesn't have that in one form. And much of what we look at as history today was initially journalistic reporting, Herodotus, Thucydides, right? They were writing contemporary accounts of their world. They were telling the stories of the good and the bad all around them. So I think you're right, Zachary. I think there's something within us as humans that That craves reading about this

SPEAKER_03and producing it in one way or another. And it's just a matter of figuring out what the right media is for that. I guess just to close us out, Sarah, what are you most excited and optimistic about?

SPEAKER_01Honestly, Zachary, it's kind of what you said. Like, I think that. There's so much. It's really interesting. When I talk to people, a lot of what I've been doing for the past year, since I started in January, is just going on a listening tour all over Texas with people who have been involved in the Texas Tribune and some people that haven't yet. And you can feel a real kind of generational divide. Like a lot of the older people that I talk to are feeling really concerned, existentially concerned about a lot of things.

SPEAKER_01And I... And a lot of the younger people that I talk to, their whole life experience has been in a world that is unrecognizable to some of the older people that I talk to. The whole worldview that has shaped their perspective on the world and they still remain really hopeful about it. Their own empowerment and agency. And I think if we can fan the flames of all the young and hopeful people who still believe that we can make the world a better place,

SPEAKER_01I think that's the whole thing. Totally.

SPEAKER_03Totally. You have to get in the game. And I do think there are a lot of young people who want to get in the game one way or another. And it's a good moment to remind everyone listening to this that it's time to vote. In Texas, we start voting on October 19th. And throughout most of the country, early voting is starting not in November, but in October. So we do hope everyone is voting and being a part of the process, reading the Texas Tribune and other news sources as they vote.

SPEAKER_01Be informed. Engage. Exactly. Show up.

SPEAKER_03Show up. Sarah Adler-Hartman, thank you so much for joining us today. It's been a real pleasure.

SPEAKER_01Thanks to y'all. It has. This has been so fun.

SPEAKER_03And I hope everyone will look to the Texas Tribune and start reading it assiduously as Zachary and I did.

SPEAKER_01And become a member.

SPEAKER_03And become a member.

SPEAKER_01TexasTribune.org slash support.

SPEAKER_03You know, we're not supposed to advertise, but we can talk about the Texas Tribune. They are associated with the university. Please contribute to the Texas Tribune. Everyone should, even a dollar a month makes a difference, right?

SPEAKER_01Huge difference.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, yeah. Thank you, Zachary, of course, for your insights. It's fun to talk about this, isn't it, Zachary? Yes, definitely. And thank you most of all to our loyal listeners and loyal subscribers to our Substack for joining us for this week of This Is Democracy.

SPEAKER_00This podcast is produced by the Liberal Arts ITS Development Studio and the College of Liberal Arts at the University of Texas at Austin. The music in this episode was written and recorded by Scott Holmes. Stay tuned for a new episode every week. You can find This is Democracy on Apple Podcasts, Spotify and YouTube. See you next time.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. This is Democracy – Episode 332: Midterm Elections, 2026

    Nov 17, 202632 minAudio

    This week I spoke with Julian Zelizer, the Princeton historian and one of our most frequent guests, about the scale of what happened in Tuesday’s midterms. I wanted to know whether this was a strange moment for a...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. This is Democracy – Episode 330: Jewish Politics Since the 19th Century

    Oct 8, 202638 minAudio

    This week we spoke with David Sorkin, the Lucy G. Moses Professor of Jewish History at Yale and an old family friend who attended Zachary’s naming ceremony decades ago, about his new book, The Emancipationists. David’s...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. This is Democracy – Episode 329: Intelligence: Past and Present

    Sep 22, 202630 minAudio

    In this episode of This is Democracy, Zachary and I sat down with our old friend John Sipher, who spent 28 years in the. CIA’s Clandestine Service before becoming one oft public voices on intelligence. I wanted to...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. This is Democracy – Episode 328: Imperialist Realism

    Sep 10, 202638 minAudio

    This week on This is Democracy, I sat down with Daniel Bessner, one of the sharpest critics of American foreign policy writing today, to talk through his new essay collection, Imperialist Realism. Danny’s central claim...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. This is Democracy – Episode 327: Local Journalism

    Aug 19, 202637 minAudio

    This week, Zachary, back from a summer reporting assignment for the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel, and I sat down to dig into a problem I think cuts across nearly every American community: local journalism is collapsing as...

    Credit the people on this episode