I have been thinking about these questions for a long time, and on this week’s episode of This Is Democracy, Zachary and I sat down to work through what is happening to American universities. Universities have always been political spaces - think Vietnam protests, anti-apartheid activism, the campus upheavals of the 1980s. But there was always a sense of seclusion, a feeling that the campus offered some separation from the world outside, room to investigate and experiment and argue. That has eroded. From within, DEI bureaucracies replaced inclusion with quota-counting, and students arrived pre-labeled by social media, gravitating toward ideological silos rather than integrated spaces where real disagreement happens. From outside, donors, activists, and now the federal government have made clear they intend to run universities according to agendas that have nothing to do with knowledge or discovery. The result is a chilling effect I have not seen in my career, not primarily through punishment, but through fear. Faculty, students, and university leaders have learned to say nothing rather than risk saying the wrong thing. On Israel-Palestine, on Ukraine, on scientific funding, the instinct has been silence. Silence is not neutrality. It is a position, and it is the wrong one. The material consequences of this moment are still coming into view. NIH and NSF grants - the financial backbone of American bench research - are being cut, and universities are running on fumes. The full damage has not hit yet, but it will. What we built over the last century is genuinely extraordinary: institutions that drew the most talented people from every corner of the world and turned that talent into medicine, technology, and knowledge that belonged to everyone. We are now dismantling the conditions that made that possible. Restricting international students, defunding research, taxing endowments, none of this fixes the legitimate problems critics have identified with university culture. It just destroys the thing itself. The answer to universities that have sometimes lost their way is not to starve them. It is to recommit them to their actual purpose: open inquiry, genuine disagreement, and the kind of integrated intellectual community that a democracy requires. We can return to this mission with better leadership inside and outside universities Click here to listen to the full episode. Democracy of Hope, produced by Jeremi and Zachary Suri, is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support our work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber. Get full access to Democracy of Hope, Jeremi and Zachary Suri at democracyofhope.substack.com/subscribe
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_00This is Democracy.
SPEAKER_03A podcast about the people of the United States. A podcast about citizenship. About engaging with politics and the world around you. A podcast about educating yourself on today's important issues and how to have a voice in what happens next.
SPEAKER_01Hello and welcome to our latest episode of This is Democracy. I'm Zachary Suri. We're joined of course today by Professor Jeremy Suri. Always good to be with you, Mr. Zachary. Good, good. And today we're going to be talking, just the two of us, about a topic that has been in the news a lot of late, that the two of us have been living in different capacities and that many of our listeners have as well, I'm sure, which is the sort of profound changes or seemingly and Profound Changes at Universities in the United States and
to a lesser extent
SPEAKER_01around the world, thinking in particular of shifts in political pressure on universities, but also the political culture of universities. We want to talk about these institutions which are not in any way the sum total of our democracy but clearly play a leading role in shaping our political conversations and our key institutions being shaped by our political conversations. So I think the best place to start would be by trying to get a
sense of what the
SPEAKER_01prevailing culture at universities has been prior to our current moment. So not just pre-second term Trump, but I think pre-COVID maybe is probably the best place to think about this. But what were the sort of prevailing changes as someone who had been at universities for years? My entire life. Decades and decades. My entire life, yes. Centuries and centuries. Millennia upon millennia. What was different about being on a university campus in the
period prior to where we are now?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, so it's a great question, Zachary.
SPEAKER_00I think universities have always been infected by politics, and there's always been a set of controversies outside universities that make their way onto universities. Think about the Vietnam War and some Louisville Rights in the 1960s.
SPEAKER_02Think about anti-apartheid activism in the 1980s on university campuses. And so campuses have always been connected to the wider world. But until recently, they also felt secluded. And the whole idea of a college campus is to create a space where although you're training people for future activities in our society, they also have some separation from society, separation to investigate issues. to discover, to explore, to experiment.
SPEAKER_02And of course, the greatness, but also the worry of university life for most parents was always just that, that kids are experimenting, trying new things out socially, culturally, intellectually. But that feeling of at least some kind of separation has always been important. And that's not only true to elite universities, that's also true even for community colleges. The whole idea of a campus, again, is that even though you might be within a city, that you're stepping off from the city,
SPEAKER_02stepping away from the city and able to have some space. So universities did, I think, have more of a feeling of separation, even though they were still connected and politicized before COVID. One other thing I would say also is that universities had developed over the course of at least half a century since World War II, they had developed procedures, rules and laws for self-governance. And they were jealously guarding those laws of self-governance. So universities would hire,
SPEAKER_02promote and teach what they wished to hire, who they wished to hire, how they wished to promote them and what they wished to teach. And that was largely respected. That's the world of tenure. That's the world of academic freedom. These are not assertions of complete freedom. Tenured faculty don't get to do whatever they want. They still have to follow the rules. And academic freedom does not mean that you can use your And of course powerful and wealthy figures have always found ways to exert influence but there was some barrier there
I think those barriers have come down in the last few years and I think the seclusion of the campus has in some ways been invaded in the last few years and this has happened from multiple points of view and for multiple reasons but I do think there's a sense now that the college campus is less secluded and there's a
SPEAKER_02sense now that tenure and academic freedom are less firm, less strong, and universities don't feel as if they're running themselves any longer, but other people are running them, often people running them with agendas that are not related to the agenda of the university itself.
SPEAKER_01That makes sense. Where do you see what could be described as the rise of DEI and diversity institutions, sort of expansion of HR administration on university campuses? Where does that fit into this story? Is this part of the sort of tearing down of that seclusion? Is this, from your perspective, is this the first, was this the first instance of political intrusion onto campuses in the way that
you've described it.
SPEAKER_00I think a lot of the DEI movement, although inspired by things that were happening in society, particularly efforts at inclusion for groups that had traditionally been not
SPEAKER_02included, including transgender students and others, and also pressures related to, of course, what we all witnessed with the terrible lynching of George Floyd in Minnesota. and evidence of police brutality in some cases. Those external motivators were important. But really what happened, I think, within universities is you had a cohort of university administrators many of whom were hired initially as universities grew in size and needed more of an administrative apparatus for their larger numbers of
students but also for the larger numbers of federal grants and other things that universities were receiving that require administration and also because of all the laws that were being passed for student protection for property protection and things of that sort as you saw
SPEAKER_02administrative staff grow That administrative staff often brought with it a moral commitment to diversity, equity, and inclusion just based on where they were coming from. These were often people who had been trained in those fields, trained to care deeply and sincerely about civil rights and diversity. And so that became more the dominant ideology of people in administration, just as the dominant ideology of people in finance tends to be one of capitalism.
SPEAKER_02Those in human resources, particularly universities, I think this would also be true in the business world, they tend to think very much about diversity, equity, fairness. And then I think in a moment when people were hyper concerned about these issues because of what happened with George Floyd and others, then these concerns became very,
SPEAKER_00very aggressively dominant. on campuses. And I'd love your thoughts on this, Zachary.
SPEAKER_02I remain a proponent of diversity. I remain a proponent of equity and I remain a proponent of inclusion. But I do think a lot of what was done through DEI was Although often, or most often well-intended, I think sometimes did go too far and created a crowding out of other points of view at times. Is that something you felt as a student?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I mean, I think I certainly have entered college campus after the sort of crest or peak of this movement, but I think one of the most bizarre things about our moment on university campuses is that a lot of that Infrastructure, a lot of those people, that sort of administrative push for diversity, equity and inclusion and with all of its, you know, maybe good intentions and ill effects and good effects is still
prevalent. It's still a present force on campus, one that a lot of students feel affinity for, one
SPEAKER_01and that still I think gets a lot of money from university campuses, even if it gets a lot less attention intentionally. And at the same time, the universities are experiencing pressure from outside, and in some cases from the inside, to diversify points of view in the other direction to bring in more conservative voices. Viewpoint diversity. Right. To avoid framing even the very mission of a university in terms of diversity or public service or any kind of
SPEAKER_01any kind of mission statement beyond simply knowledge acquisition. This was a change Yale recently made to basically take any reference to leadership or diversity out of its mission statement and focus on knowledge. So those two efforts, I think, in a strange way still coexist on our campuses, even if one is getting more attention than the other in our current moment. And I think in some ways, in my experience, they both have a similar flaw, which is that they Rather than actually trying to build the kind of culture and
institutions that
SPEAKER_01enable true viewpoint diversity, true inclusion, which doesn't mean no one gets offended. It means people are willing to get offended and still talk and discuss and be in community together. that there's less of a focus actually on doing the real work of creating those communities, those institutions, those spaces, and much more of a focus on posturing and on a sort of like numbers game of how many faculty are conservative, how many faculty are
SPEAKER_00Right. I think that's exactly right. I think in my experience over the last 10 years, what's new is not that there are climates of opinion and viewpoints that are favored by more people than others. That's always been true. And there have always been biases. And I often remind people that if anthropologists tend to be to the left don't forget that a business school faculty tend to be to the right you know and so there it depends where you are but
you could certainly feel as a conservative in an anthropology class you could feel
SPEAKER_00that you were not well represented and you could feel as a As a left-leaning person in a business school class who could probably feel not
SPEAKER_02well represented.
SPEAKER_00That's not a new problem. I think what has happened in the last 10 years is that we've become hyper-focused not on the ideas but on the labels. And I think that has to do with outside entities that are looking to count, as you said.
SPEAKER_02Some of that was a problem with DEI. It's one of the things I oppose in DEI is this kind of quota counting, right? And saying you need to have a certain number of people from one group or another. There are all kinds of reasons why I think that's destructive and anti-intellectual.
SPEAKER_00And I've long thought that. But on the other side now, we have people who want to sort of count the number of quote unquote conservatives.
SPEAKER_02And that's also problematic. First of all, what counts as a conservative? And second, should we be when we're hiring and admitting people? Should that really be what we think about? Or should we think about the person who's doing the most interesting work and have arguments over that?
SPEAKER_00I feel in the last few years in particular, Zachary, we have argued more about the process and argued more about the numbers and argued about the ideas. And what we should be arguing about more to me are classic conservative versus liberal positions.
SPEAKER_02For example, what role should the government play in society? What kind of foreign policy should the United States have? These are liberal versus conservative arguments in some ways, and these are arguments worth having. How should our democracy operate?
SPEAKER_00Should it be more populist? Should the courts play more of a role? These are the kinds of arguments we should have instead of measuring whether we brought X number of conservatives and Y number of liberals to speak to our campuses.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, and I think it's also an issue of siloing on university campuses. I mean, I think one of the biggest issues I see, I don't really, in general, buy the argument that universities have a dominant ideology of one sort or another, of any coherence. But I do think that there's been a problem at elite universities that One can graduate from a place like Yale or UT and come away, particularly if one goes in already with left-wing ideological
points of view,
SPEAKER_01if one comes in hyper-focused on race or on the study of migration, etc., all worthwhile endeavors, but one can very easily, intentionally or even unintentionally, graduate without ever having taken a class where there is a single person in that class who doesn't share that ideology. And I think that's a real problem. And I think part of what the overcorrection has been in recent years is not
SPEAKER_01actually to try and say, maybe we shouldn't be siloing at all, but to say, oh no, we need to build a conservative silo or we need to build a program where people people can go through, you know, University of Texas and get an education in politics or civics and never have to interact with someone who's a Marxist or a left-wing faculty.
SPEAKER_00I couldn't agree more. I think the civics movement, which has certainly been an important movement of the last three years at least, the movement to create more civics courses to emphasize civics education, I'm all for that. There are, as you said, Zachary, too many well-educated Americans who Don't Know Basic Things About Our Society. Just as I think everyone should understand some basic science, everyone should understand the Constitution and what the Constitution means, where it came from, and some basic American history. I say that as a historian, of course.
SPEAKER_00And I think we were dropping the ball on that, not just because of siloing, but because of specializations. So for example, I remember when I was looking at curricular issues years ago here at UT, I had not realized until I did that how many requirements for certification engineers have. and they have almost no time in their schedule. Those who are studying engineering at UT, they have almost no time in their schedule for electives. And so they're so heavily in the specialized area that they're in that they're losing this general civics knowledge.
And so I think it's a very good thing that particularly our campuses and many
SPEAKER_00others are moving towards reemphasizing civics education. I think a core curriculum makes sense for that, right? It would be part of a core that everyone takes a class on the history of the Constitution, for example, right? And so that all makes sense to me.
SPEAKER_02But I think we have to do this in a way that just, as you said, integrates people from different points of view. Students come in now, especially because of social media, with labels they've identified with themselves, even if they don't fully understand it. Most people who call themselves at age 18 a conservative or a liberal don't really know what those things mean. But they take on those labels and they tend to surround themselves with the same affinity groups they've grown up with. So if you've grown up in a conservative suburb, you tend to surround yourself with conservative students. If you've grown up in a left-leaning suburb, you tend to surround yourself with people like
SPEAKER_02like that. And I think it's the job of universities not to create separate silos, which is what I fear we're doing, particularly at UT, and instead create places where people have to interact intentionally, bringing together people from different backgrounds and points of view. One of the things that was most edifying to me as a student at Stanford, as an undergraduate in the 1990s, was living in a dormitory where maybe it was happenstance. But we were living very close together, many of us with people who thought about the world,
SPEAKER_02saw the world very differently from us. And then we were in classes together where these issues came up. and it certainly helped me to understand different points of view. That's actually what viewpoint diversity is. I think we really have to hit this point hard, Zachary, that viewpoint diversity is not simply creating a ledger and saying we have X number of conservatives and X number of liberals and X number of conservative faculty and Y number of liberal faculty and therefore we have viewpoint diversity. Viewpoint diversity is saying we have lots of spaces.
where these points of view are coming together and people are having to listen and
SPEAKER_02learn from one point of view or another. What we try to do on the podcast, in fact. And I don't think there's enough of that. In fact, if I had one overriding criticism, I think there's less of that now on our campuses than there was before. Some of that is the self-selection of students, but some of that is the way universities are organizing themselves to create silos to serve different interest groups and not creating the integrated spaces. Does that resonate with your experience?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, it does. I think that reflects a sort of reality of our campuses, but I think it's not just an internal issue. I think it's important that we talk about the sort of external factors here as well, particularly in the last two or three years. There's been a lot of pressure on universities to push in one direction or another on issues that have traditionally not been the purview of university administration.
SPEAKER_01The most obvious example is on the Israel-Palestine conflict. Pressure from students and activists to make statements or to change fiscal policy at universities to support one side and pressure from donors, other groups of students, faculty to go in the other direction. And I'm curious what you think the effect of that was on our university institutions.
I don't think anyone would say that that was necessarily a healthy process for
SPEAKER_01institutions to go through, but I'm curious whether you think universities have emerged with a better, more clearly defined sense of the role of speech and political discourse on campus, or whether the waters have been so muddied that people don't actually have a clear sense of where, when, if at all, political speech, political pressure is affecting their universities.
SPEAKER_00That's so well said, Zachary. This would be my second criticism after the siloing that we've seen more of in the last few years. I think there has been a chilling of free speech. Most of that is not because people have been penalized for what they've said. Thankfully that's only been in a very few cases, but it's the fear that that would happen. And so what I have noticed in the last year and a half is people are very students, faculty, others, certainly university leaders are very careful not to say
anything that can sound
SPEAKER_00like it has any moral or political position attached to it. And first of all, that's not doable because the absence of political speech is a kind of political speech itself, right? If you are silent when horrible things are happening, um you are in a certain way uh condoning those things none of us would justify the university leaders and faculty of the nazi era who refused to speak up right so you
know there is a role uh an unavoidable role uh of engagement with the issues around
SPEAKER_02you now i think there's a difference between being partisan and being moral. And universities are moral institutions. They stand for education, improvement, what the Germans would call Bildung, right? That we are improving ourselves. So I think universities, particularly in the United States, have to stand for freedom and democracy and free speech and these things, but they shouldn't take partisan positions. So under no circumstances should a university be pro-Palestinian or pro-Israeli. That would make no sense. That would alienate lots of people.
SPEAKER_02and maybe some universities went too far. Certainly some faculty were asking some things that seemed unreasonable of universities to do. I think it's unacceptable to promote the boycotting of people from a country. Ask your university to boycott them. That makes no sense. Academic freedom means that scholars from around the world should always be welcome at our universities. And so universities should not take partisan positions. But universities are institutions about democracy and freedom and learning and knowledge.
SPEAKER_02And we do have to stand up for those things. And that's where I think universities should speak absolutely clearly. So when people are being denied their ability to express themselves as, for instance, people in Ukraine are who are being attacked by Russia. It is not for the university to take a position pro-Ukraine or pro-Russia, but it is for the university to take a position on the rights of people in communities that are being overrun to live with dignity and
express themselves.
SPEAKER_02And so I think those are the kinds of positions we need to take. University leadership should be moral leadership, but it should be moral leadership for principle, not for political positioning. And we've gone away from that too much. If we don't do that, if we're just trying to be neutral, right, then we're countenancing and accepting things that run against the very foundations of knowledge and freedom that we're about. I mean, universities, for example, have to be against book burning. Right, because we are about books. We have to be for science.
SPEAKER_02We can't be defenders of those who attack science, right? But that doesn't mean we have to take a position on the Secretary of Health and Human Services.
SPEAKER_00That's not for the university to take, but it is for the university to take a position on scientific knowledge and scientific verification for things.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I think that's well said. I think it's important. I think one thing that some universities, I think, have taken out at this moment, and some have not, but it's not even a sense that neutrality is the answer, but that There is a difference between the kind of political action and decision making that one demands of one's political leaders and the kind of action and political decision making it is appropriate to demand of one's university leaders. And I think that there is too much, particularly among students, I think there's too much, there has been too much of a sense that
SPEAKER_01That universities don't exist to facilitate conversation, but instead, by their very nature, take one position or another, and that the role of the student body is to push it in the direction that the student body agrees or feels is most necessary. which I think is a kind of, it's not as, it can lead to a kind of mob mentality that doesn't actually, that has the same kind of chilling effect that we're talking about. It makes university leaders feel like the only way to avoid
angering both sides is
SPEAKER_01to take no position whatsoever. Of course that angers both sides.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, so what would I like to see? I think, again, that's very well framed. What would I like to see that we're not seeing? I would like to see pro-Israeli and pro-Palestinian voices, both on campus. I'd like to see them articulated well, and there might be more people on one side or on the other. It doesn't matter. They should both... be given uh fair hearing one side should not be able to shout the other side down um but both sides should not be told to shut up and that's I think what people have heard in the last year they've heard basically don't say
anything and that's wrong
SPEAKER_00then we're not learning right my My pro-Israeli friends need to hear the pro-Palestinian point of view. My pro-Palestinian friends need to hear the pro-Israeli point of view.
SPEAKER_02And of course, there's a lot in between. We should be places for discourse. So what does that mean? It means I don't think people should be able to shout outside someone's dorm when they're trying to sleep.
SPEAKER_00Steve McLaughlin I think extreme Anti-Semitism or anti-Islamic attitudes should not be allowed. But I think people should be able to say things that express their point of view without the intention of insulting others. And that should be encouraged.
SPEAKER_00And I don't think we're doing enough encouraging of that. And I think we're worse off in our knowledge for that reason.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. What about probably the most pressing challenge for universities leaders right now, which is none of this, at least from their perspective, but funding cuts from the federal government, changes to international student visas, and a renewed increased endowment tax for private universities. Is it even possible for universities to do all of these things or to aspire to all of these important civic roles when they're struggling to fund
their cancer
SPEAKER_01research labs? One of the greatest inventions of the last century was the modern research
SPEAKER_00university that we created in the United States. It followed models from various other places. And how do we know these modern research universities were one of the greatest inventions? Well, first of all, they drew talent from around the world that no other set of institutions ever drew. People come to study at our universities that wouldn't study anywhere else because of what our universities offer in terms of quality of talent and resources, and money is a big part of that. Also, these universities have produced almost all of the great
inventions that we look at
SPEAKER_00every day in our lives, right? Some of them we might not like, like our iPhones, but It's coming out of our universities, right? Particularly in medicine, as you referred to. So we don't want to destroy these universities. It doesn't mean that they aren't sometimes spending money. They shouldn't spend and have organizational issues. So far, the funding cuts and the other restrictions on universities, I have not seen that much of an effect yet because there's a lag, right? And I think universities are running on fumes now.
SPEAKER_00But I think what we are doing now is eating our seed corn by reducing investments, particularly investments in lab science, NIH and NSF grants, National Institute for Health and National Science Foundation money, which is some of the biggest money that goes into research in those areas, those reductions will hit hard in the long run.
SPEAKER_02And I fear that we will see if this continues 10 years from now, We Will See A Drop Off In The Quality Of Research That Comes Out Of Universities And We Will Also See We're Starting To See This Talent Go Elsewhere The model that has worked for us, Zachary, is that talented people from India, China, Australia, Uganda, and around the world have come to our campuses,
SPEAKER_00studied, and then stayed and shared their knowledge with us or gone back to their countries and built relationships with us. We're in jeopardy of losing that. And I think universities need to speak out about that. And I think our public needs to think about that. Now, there might be other ways to do the funding. but certainly one of the best ways to use government resources is to invest in research and invest in financial aid for young talented people to go to university there's a lot of talk now about the Trump administration
investing in companies to help them produce weapons more quickly to fill the weapon stocks that we've lost I was just on a seminar about this the other day that is not the best way to do
SPEAKER_00things to give money to businesses businesses are operating in a market They should be hiring talent and taking knowledge from universities to use for their market activities. The money should be going into the bench research at universities where it's non-proprietary and where the research will not be owned by Lockheed, but will be accredited. Steve McLaughlin
SPEAKER_01Yeah, and I would urge also those who maybe share what I think are legitimate concerns about universities straying from their academic mission or universities wasting money, all of these concerns which I think are grounded in legitimate problems. I would urge those people to support, instead of cutting universities or trying to use these problems to attack
SPEAKER_01universities, to invest in going back to basics. I mean, one of the things I think is a lot of frustration among some Americans about you know the talented international students who come and are educated in American universities the sort of feeling I think among some are frustration that like if their kids don't get into you know a place like University of Texas or University of Wisconsin like why should someone from you know Bangladesh come and and get and get a good education I think that's the wrong question to be asking I think the
SPEAKER_01better question is you know What kind of education is that person getting? And if that person is coming to the United States and only taking classes that are necessary towards an engineering certification and not taking a class on American history or something, that's a problem. We should be investing in those kinds of, you know, not just civics courses, but, you know, basic knowledge about American history and American life, not just for international students, but for everyone. I mean, there are plenty of American students who don't understand basic American history, you know, The Yale History Department does not offer an American History
Survey course for
SPEAKER_01undergraduates. And that kind of investment in those kinds of courses, that kind of work, getting more people into the conversation instead of trying to push people out is I think where this frustration and this anger in some cases that comes from a good place or from a benevolent place is better directed than these kinds of punitive measures.
SPEAKER_00I totally agree. And for the record, by the way, the UT History Department offers a survey course. I teach it. I'm one of the faculty who teaches it. So we teach the US History Survey course. In fact, it's my favorite course to teach. I think, just building on what you said though, I think none of our conversation today is designed to pretend that there aren't real issues. There are legitimate sources of concern. People should be concerned. Our universities receive a lot of money and they play a very important role in our society and in a democracy. The public has a right to concerns.
Our universities should not live on ivory towers unconnected to the world.
SPEAKER_00No one is arguing for that. At least we're not arguing for that. But I do think, building on what you said, if we want to improve our universities, we have to be serious about not simply making ideological points, but actually trying to understand the good and the not good work that's being done and how we can improve that. And that involves coming to universities.
SPEAKER_02I am struck, Zachary, repeatedly. This has been true for a long time, and it's true on both sides of the political aisle. People have all kinds of criticisms of how we teach and all kinds of solutions they want to offer. and almost none of the people offering those solutions and criticisms spend any
SPEAKER_00time in a classroom. I would like to see those who are concerned spending more time actually understanding what's going on in its good and bad dimensions before they're trying to offer what end up usually being ideological solutions.
SPEAKER_02Most classrooms are open to anyone who wants to come. My classrooms certainly are. I always have people who visit, usually not administrators,
SPEAKER_00usually not people who are making public criticisms, but anyone is welcome to come and see what we do. And I think that's really important because I think when you see what's happening, you realize that the ideological arguments made one way or another don't match up with the reality. There is still a lot of room for reform.
SPEAKER_02But what is mostly happening on college campuses? Anxious 18 to 21 year olds are showing up half asleep in class, trying to understand the world around them and trying to move on with their lives. They're ambitious, sometimes a little clueless, but ambitious. And faculty are trying their best to teach them. And I know very few faculty who are trying to indoctrinate their students. Again, we can improve. But we should improve off of a real knowledge of what we're doing,
not off of some image that doesn't match the reality of what's really happening on
SPEAKER_00our campuses. And I fear sometimes that the efforts to bring in viewpoint diversity, which I support, because they end up bringing in new silos, a new conservative program, a new DEI program. Those things actually further separate students and further undermine the kinds of interaction, the kinds of learning that we really want. We want many points of view, but we want those points of view to come together in the classroom, in the library, in the laboratory. And so I think we have to spend more time understanding what's
going on before we
SPEAKER_02start throwing out solutions of one kind or another.
SPEAKER_01I think that's exactly correct. And I think that engagement with American universities has to be the start of any effort to reform or change them. And that's not just something that people who are critical of universities to do, but universities need to do a better job engaging with the wider world as well. Absolutely. And that means universities have always done a good job interacting with other highly educated institutions and people and communities. But the question becomes, what is your university doing for the town it's in,
SPEAKER_01the neighborhood it's in, the school district it's in? And Those questions I think should be at the center of what university leaders are thinking about. And I fear that given the current political climate, it's at the very bottom of the list of what they're thinking about. Not because they don't care about it, but because the priorities for a current university president or provost or dean are much more on the sort of financial side, the sort of political survival side, than on thinking about these broader,
SPEAKER_01more important democratic questions.
SPEAKER_00I agree 100% Zachary, I agree 100% Wonderful, well thank you to our listeners for engaging with this university project today and thank you Jeremy and thank you everyone for joining us for this episode of This Is Democracy This podcast is produced by the Liberal Arts ITS Development Studio And
SPEAKER_03the College of Liberal Arts at the University of Texas at Austin The music in this episode was written and recorded by Scott Holmes Stay tuned for a new episode every week You can find This Is Democracy on Apple Podcasts, Spotify and YouTube See you next time
This week I spoke with Julian Zelizer, the Princeton historian and one of our most frequent guests, about the scale of what happened in Tuesday’s midterms. I wanted to know whether this was a strange moment for a...
This week Zachary and I spoke with Sarah Adler Hartman, CEO of The Texas Tribune, whose career took her from founding Spoon University as a Northwestern student to running subscriber products at The New York Times...
This week we spoke with David Sorkin, the Lucy G. Moses Professor of Jewish History at Yale and an old family friend who attended Zachary’s naming ceremony decades ago, about his new book, The Emancipationists. David’s...
In this episode of This is Democracy, Zachary and I sat down with our old friend John Sipher, who spent 28 years in the. CIA’s Clandestine Service before becoming one oft public voices on intelligence. I wanted to...
This week on This is Democracy, I sat down with Daniel Bessner, one of the sharpest critics of American foreign policy writing today, to talk through his new essay collection, Imperialist Realism. Danny’s central claim...