This is Democracy – Episode 325: Monuments and History
40 minAudio
This week on This Is Democracy, I spoke with Dr. Vaneesa Cook, a historian and former student whose new book, Empire and Liberty: The Tied Histories of Two American Landmarks, offers a dual biography of the Statue of Liberty and the Empire State Building as a lens for understanding one of America’s oldest tensions. As we approach the 250th anniversary of the Declaration of Independence, Vaneesa’s book reminded me that the struggle to reconcile empire and liberty is a founding contradiction, and one that Jefferson himself named when he coined the phrase “empire of liberty.” What struck me most in our conversation was how Vaneesa shows that these monuments were never fixed in meaning. The Statue of Liberty, gifted by French Republicans who admired America’s ability to sustain a republic through civil war, was immediately contested - by women denied the vote, by African Americans denied full citizenship, by Asian Americans excluded from its promise. The Empire State Building, built in just over a year as a deliberate symbol of American economic power, gradually shed that imperial identity in favor of romance and nostalgia. Both monuments, Vaneesa argues, have always meant different things to different people, and that instability is precisely what makes them endure. As we mark this anniversary in a divisive moment, her core message stays with me: liberty is not self-sustaining. It has to be actively defended, collectively, and on behalf of everyone, not just those who already have it. Click here to listen to the full episode. Democracy of Hope, produced by Jeremi and Zachary Suri, is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support our work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber. Get full access to Democracy of Hope, Jeremi and Zachary Suri at democracyofhope.substack.com/subscribe
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_01This is Democracy A podcast about the people of the United States A podcast
SPEAKER_00about citizenship About engaging with politics and the world around you A podcast
SPEAKER_01about educating yourself on today's important issues and how to have a voice in what happens next
SPEAKER_00Welcome to our new episode of This is Democracy. This week, we are going to talk about the 250th anniversary of our country, 250 years since the Declaration of Independence, and we're going to talk in particular about monuments and the and the ways we mark and design our built environment around that history to reflect values and ideas and experiences. And we are really very fortunate to be joined today by a friend, a former student, a great scholar, and recent author of her second book,
SPEAKER_00our second published book I know she's written other books too that are coming out and this is Dr. Venisa Cook Venisa thank you for joining us today thank you for having me we of course have Mr. Zachary Suri on as well how are you Zachary? I'm doing well good afternoon Dr. Vanessa Cook received her PhD in US history at the University of Wisconsin-Madison. She's the author of Empire and Liberty, which is her new book that we're going to talk about today, The Tied Histories of Two American Landmarks.
SPEAKER_00Before this, she wrote her first book, which was spectacular. This is a spectacular book. the book too, but I have a deep affection for her first book, Spiritual Socialists, Religion and the American Left. That was published by the University of Pennsylvania Press. Her most recent book, Empire and Liberty, is available in all good bookstores today. It was published by Beacon Press. Vanessa has also written articles on social movements, religious thought, politics, protest activities. She's written for the Washington Post, for dissent, for religion and politics and many, many
SPEAKER_00other places. So we're really very fortunate to have an opportunity to talk about this broader topic with Vanessa and to pull out some of the real unique insights in her book. I thought we'd start, Vanessa, with just a very basic question. Your book, Empire and Liberty, which really builds a larger history of American society around the Statue of Liberty and the Empire State Building. Why did you write this book? Clearly, these are monuments people have written about before.
SPEAKER_00Why did you write this book now?
SPEAKER_01Well, as a U.S. historian, I definitely knew of the narrative of the tensions between empire and liberty
SPEAKER_02that have existed throughout U.S. history since the founding, becoming an empire across the continent, and then more globally after 1898. So I knew that narrative from researching and teaching
SPEAKER_01U.S. history for so many years. But then I had this eureka moment a few years ago when I realized
SPEAKER_02that there are these two landmarks in New York City that I've been fond of my whole life, the Empire State Building and the Statue of Liberty. And I had the idea of writing this dual biography, if you will, through the conception reception of these monuments. And when I realized, like, oh, one represents empire and the other represents liberty or symbolizes those two concepts, it really excited me that I could use this novel format of telling that U.S.
SPEAKER_02history narrative of empire and liberty through these two landmarks. that was the start of the book. And I know that U.S. historians or historians more generally, that's not a new story for them. We know that story and we teach it and write about it often.
SPEAKER_01But I think the general public still doesn't really think of the United States as an empire or doesn't know how long that story has been going on.
SPEAKER_02And maybe they don't know about that effort to reconcile empire and liberty throughout history.
SPEAKER_00Before we get to Zachary's question, I just want to follow up. What do you mean by empire when you say the United States is an empire?
SPEAKER_01Well, from the very beginning, even during and right after the American Revolution,
SPEAKER_02the founding fathers like Washington, Jefferson, Franklin, they all talked about this sort of mission to extend American control of the North American continent. What we know of now is the continental United States from the eastern seaboard. you know through pushing the frontier further westward to the Pacific and so that was in their minds from the late 1700s and they started to execute that plan into the 1800s with things like the Louisiana Purchase
SPEAKER_02etc. And then at the end of the 1800s there were these opportunities to start to expand as a global empire. There was talk about annexing Hawaii in the late 1800s but then the war of 1898 is really what transformed the United States into a global empire within a matter of months fighting the Spanish and then controlling the former Spanish colonies in Puerto Rico, Guam,
SPEAKER_02Philippines, and then also just taking Hawaii as well, ending that debate over whether to do that. And then all of a sudden, the United States and Americans had to deal with, you know, how do we reconcile empire being a global empire? Um, which had existed, you know, other empires had existed and competed with the United States but how do we still maintain our dedication to liberty when we're controlling these other territories around the world?
SPEAKER_03Zachary? It's interesting to me that that unlike the sort of typical histories as you described it, the way that historians would describe both these aspects of empire and liberty in American history, that these aren't just descriptive terms. These are aspirations that Americans set forth. These are monuments. What do you think it means for a country to aspire to both liberty and empire at the same time?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, so a lot of the, you know, what we would call the typical founding fathers terminology.
SPEAKER_02Jefferson even coined the phrase empire of liberty to have this distinctive way of thinking about the United States and how it might balance these two seemingly opposite concepts because empire is about control. You know, that's the denotation of that word. And liberty is about liberating people from control and from authority.
SPEAKER_01And so there has been this effort to do that throughout history. I think that what's fascinating to me, and one of the points that I wanted to get across in the book, is that empires in history throughout human history have not been new.
SPEAKER_02That's not unique, right? There have been so many powerful empires throughout history that have risen and fallen. And there have been so many strong militaries that have come and gone. But I think what is unique is the dedication to liberty part. So the United States being an empire I don't think is anything exceptional, but being dedicated to liberty is what makes it exceptional, even if it's been unfulfilled and limited at times.
SPEAKER_00That seems like a good place to go to your first chapter and really where you open the book with the Statue of Liberty and its construction in France, its arrival in the United States. Why is that story important today? Why does the Statue of Liberty stand out for you, especially in a time when there seems to be a lot of sentiment against immigrants and against opening our borders? Why do you see this as so important?
SPEAKER_01I think the story of the Statue of Liberty and why France in particular wanted
SPEAKER_02to gift it to the United States in the 1800s is important because it shows that the rest of the world had their eyes on the United States and they were really admiring the United States for being able to maintain a republic since the late 1700s. And during the U.S. Civil War, you know, that was up in the air that, you know, people were watching to see whether the nation would break apart, if the republic would stand or fall. You know, Lincoln had that in his rhetoric as well. But the world was watching.
SPEAKER_02And after the U.S. Civil War came to a close, the republic continued. And also liberty was extended to more people, you know, after and Emancipation and the vote being extended to former slaves. There was a celebration among French Republicans, people like Edward Laboulaye, who had long admired the United States and he was a political theorist in France and considered himself a real friend of the United States. He loved Lincoln and he really wanted to celebrate Lincoln and mourn his death as well.
SPEAKER_02He sent a medallion to Mary Todd that was a token of his appreciation for what Lincoln had done to preserve the republic. But then he talked about this idea of a large statue that the French, his circle of republican friends in France might gift the United States. And it was important because, I don't know if jealous is the right way, maybe admiration is the better word, but these French republicans really wanted a republic in France, but they had not been able to maintain it.
SPEAKER_02Zachary
SPEAKER_03And how did this statue become such an iconic piece of Americana as well as such an important symbol of American life? I mean, we forget about it because we're all so used to the story, but it is kind of remarkable that a statue that is built in a foreign country and is given as this sort of gesture by another society becomes such an important part of our identity.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. And I talk about how, you know, Americans weren't so sure that they wanted it, to be honest.
SPEAKER_02I found some, even some humorous editorials and opinion pieces in newspapers where Americans Americans were saying, hey,
SPEAKER_01we don't know that we're living up to this grand gesture that you're giving us and you want us to pay for the pedestal.
SPEAKER_02You know, that was part of the deal. And so it took a lot longer to get the ball rolling on raising funds for the pedestal that she eventually was raised upon. as the sculptor Bartholdi was finishing up the statue in Paris. But I think once she arrived in New York City and there was the Dedication Day in 1886, I think immediately the American public started to give it meaning, to take that symbol and give it their own meaning.
SPEAKER_02And that's why she means so many different things to different people. I think that's why immigrants coming over, gravitated towards the symbolism of this new opportunity and more freedom in this land of opportunity than they had had in there in Europe
SPEAKER_01or wherever they were coming from. So I think the fact that The statue could take on so many different meanings individually and collectively, but also shed light on the hypocrisy too. And I talk a lot about the limits of liberty and how people criticize the statue, even if they loved the statue and wanted to believe in the promise of liberty.
SPEAKER_02they felt left out of that promise and so you had women protesting on the dedication day the statue of liberty in this form of a woman when women in the United States couldn't even vote you had African Americans writing saying this was a sham this was an insult to them because they didn't have the full extension of liberty. Asian Americans wrote about how they were also insulted by it. And so I guess I didn't realize how much criticism the statue took as sort of a lightning rod for these debates.
SPEAKER_02But that was certainly part of the story and even occupying the island, Liberty Island, by protest groups in the 20th century as well.
SPEAKER_00So you give us a really compelling account of how central the Statue of Liberty is to these debates about liberty and concerns about liberty in the late 19th and, of course, through the 20th century. And as you point out, its placement in an area where immigrants in large numbers are coming in really brings this to the fore. Just four decades or so, four or five decades after the placement of the Statue of Liberty in the Hudson River. We then have the building not too far away.
SPEAKER_00I think it's a couple of miles away. You say maybe five miles away of the Empire State Building. And interestingly, this is a project that's pushed, according to you, by Al Smith, the Democratic governor of New York, FDR's predecessor. Tell us that story. And why do you see this as a building to empire, not a building to liberty?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, so John Raskob, who was a well-known financial expert in the 1920s,
SPEAKER_02he made a lot of money and was also part of the Democratic Party's financial engine
SPEAKER_01as well. After Al Smith lost the election to Herbert Hoover in 1928, Al Smith kind of thought his political career might be over and was a little bit... looking around for something else to do. Well, John Raskop came to him and said, hey, don't worry, Al.
SPEAKER_02I have this project that you'd be perfect for. I'm going to build the largest skyscraper in New York City and you're
SPEAKER_01the perfect person to promote it because of Al Smith's long-term association with the city being governor for so long and growing up there. And so they partnered on this project in the late 1920s, right before the Great Depression. The plans were announced, in fact, not too long before that stock market crash in October of 1929. But they had to continue with it or did continue with it. And the building was raised in a little over a year. And so even though the Statue of Liberty took a long time to come to fruition,
SPEAKER_01the Empire State Building did not. That was a very quick build process. But it was definitely a symbol of empire. It was in the rhetoric of the promoters like Al Smith. It was in their promotional booklets. He referred to it on opening day on May 1st, 1931. But I got the sense that when I was talking about this book with friends and colleagues when I first started writing it, and I said, you know, it's about how the Empire State Building represents empire and the Statue
SPEAKER_01of Liberty represents empire. Liberty, I got some quizzical looks and people said,
SPEAKER_02what do you mean the Empire State Building represents empire? And I said, well, it's in the name, first of all.
SPEAKER_01But I guess I had to kind of grapple with that. Like, why don't people think of the Empire State Building as symbolizing empire anymore when it was so clearly that was the message that was getting through in 1931 when it opened.
SPEAKER_02Um, And that was definitely the intended purpose that New York City was the hub of the economic power engine of the United States and their economic empire.
SPEAKER_01But I think that that changed just like the Statue of Liberty's symbolism changed over time. The Empire State Building, I think, took on a more romanticized image over the decades, maybe a more innocent image, particularly after the World Trade Centers went up in the early 70s. And so I do talk about that as well. Also, you know, going back to Zachary's question as well, these two landmarks show up in so many ways. Pop culture references, movies,
SPEAKER_02television shows, posters, political cartoons, you know, political campaigns. So just that exposure as well, I think, built that iconic status over time. But that image of them changes over time. And I think the Empire State Building going from this like hard power, economic power symbol of empire to this more romanticized image in romance movies, really, is a great example of that.
SPEAKER_00That was one of the things I really loved about your book and I think one of the really innovative things you do and I hope all of our listeners will read your book to have this experience as well. You show how these monuments built in the late 19th and early 20th century In a sense, they change in their meanings in different times. You have a chapter on the Depression, a chapter on World War II, a chapter on the Cold War. And it seems to me that in each of these settings,
SPEAKER_00these monuments mean something different to people. Is that an accurate reading, and how should one think about that?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I think going back to the Statue of Liberty and your reference to immigration, for example, that association with immigration built over time. At the opening ceremony, when the sculptor Frederick Bartholdi, he was there to help celebrate this achievement. He kind of took issue with over the years with its association with immigration because he intended it
SPEAKER_02as this very generalized symbol of liberty and celebrating the republic or republican values and so he didn't want it to be like pigeonholed to just one interest group or one group of people or one meaning but especially after Ellis Island opened and that was not open in 1886 as a processing center for immigrants in New York but once that opened Um, it became so much more clearly connected, you know, being very, very close to Liberty Island.
SPEAKER_02So immigrants could even look at the Lady Liberty as they were, you know, entering Ellis Island in the processing center. But the fact that the ships had to come in through the harbor that way, um, People in Europe who were planning to come over and visit or immigrate here, they would get letters back from relatives who had already come to the United States and they would tell them, hey, look for Lady Liberty when you come in. And so they would have this emotional expectation and there was this gratitude
SPEAKER_02to finally be in America and be greeted by this statue and symbol of liberty. So those generational expectations meanings, I think, built over time. The Lazarus poem, the Emma Lazarus poem also made that point, you know, the huddled masses, bring me your huddled masses. That kind of language also made that connection to immigration clearer. But, you know, there were the French Republicans who didn't think of immigration in particular when they were coming up with this idea.
SPEAKER_03One of the things that seems so unique about these monuments to me is that they are unlike most of the monuments that I think Americans think of when we think of the great American monuments you know The Washington Monument, the Lincoln Memorial, the War Memorials in Washington, the ones that were paid for by the state. These were monuments that were either donated by a private organization, different country, or created by business.
SPEAKER_03And I'm wondering if that's part of why you were drawn to these two monuments for this book is that they seem to be a little bit more organic or more reflective of American values. Is that accurate at all?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I think so. I never thought about it in those terms, but definitely some of the speakers at Dedication Day on the day that Liberty was unveiled in 1886, like President Grover Cleveland, he made this comment about how, isn't it great that we have this grand monument now that's peaceful? and represents peace and liberty rather than the warlike memorials
SPEAKER_02that other countries have and celebrate. And, you know, of course, he just kind of didn't even mention the Washington Monument or some of our own throwbacks to ancient war glory that were existing in the country at the time. But he really made this distinction that the Statue of Liberty was special because she did represent peace instead of war or war heroes. So I think that's why a lot of people still gravitate toward her.
SPEAKER_00One of the interesting parts of your book to me, there are many interesting parts, but one is when you talk about around page 170 or so about the ways in which the Empire State Building gets associated with liberty as well. For instance, the installation of Freedom Lights in 1956. You know, and I think of the way it's such a convenient place building to light up for different purposes. So how do you think about that? Is that a disguising of its purpose?
SPEAKER_00Is that an effective use of the monument? I think this is a general question, right? I mean, how should we think of the appropriate uses of monuments in our society?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, that was actually one of the most surprising discoveries when I was researching and writing this book, because when I started out, I thought, well, most people think of these two monuments or landmarks separately, even though they're in close proximity to each other. And I really expected that I would have to make these connections
SPEAKER_02and maybe even force connections between them to compare and contrast or to make these associations. But when I came to realize about the Freedom Lights that were installed in the 1950s in
SPEAKER_01the early Cold War years. That connection was being made at that time very, very clearly. So the Freedom Lights were installed and they're not the lights that,
SPEAKER_02you know, the different colored lights that we're used to seeing now at the top of the Empire State Building to celebrate things like the Knicks winning. or whatever.
SPEAKER_00That's a perfectly appropriate use.
SPEAKER_01Yes, that is. I agree. Or often red, white and blue, you know, will be illuminated at the top. That's not what we're talking about. The freedom lights were pretty much just four huge beams, like white beams of light that were put at, you know, like headlights or spotlights that were put at the top of the Empire State Building in the 1950s. And the whole purpose, intended purpose of it was to
SPEAKER_02Symbolize Freedom, Freedomites, in the midst of the Cold War, you know, when the United States was trying to show that it was the true protector
SPEAKER_01of democracy and liberty around the world and not the Soviet Union. And so there was that bipolar battle over rhetoric and symbolism surrounding things like freedom. And so I say in the book, pretty much the Empire State Building was pressed into service and recruited into the Cold War in that way. But I found it also interesting that some people were a little upset and thought that the Empire State Building should not be co-opting the message of the Statue of Liberty. And there were letters to the editor of the New York Times along those lines
SPEAKER_01where they said, hey, why are you pretty much taking the meaning that belongs to the Statue of Liberty?
SPEAKER_02And The answer from the promoters of the Freedom Lights was, well, you know, back in the 1800s, most people arrived in New York by steamship, but now they come in from planes. And so it's more appropriate for them to see the symbol of freedom from the air. And so they thought this Empire State Building was more appropriate for that.
SPEAKER_01I don't know. I don't really take issue with that. I would like to hear your opinion. I also have questions about in the book there were concerns about the overuse of
SPEAKER_02the Statue of Liberty and we're used to that, right? We see it in insurance commercials and every political ad, right? But there were people who thought that that was diluting her dignity to be overused, overexposed in political campaigns or whatnot. So I don't know. How do you guys, do you think that that affects the dignity of the meaning of these buildings?
SPEAKER_03Zachary, what do you think? I think that's also part of the point of having a symbol like this or a monument like this is that it is something that becomes kitschy. But I do feel like it's part of the point. of having a monument in the first place is it comes to stand in for so many different things that it becomes ubiquitous to the point that, you know, any American could recognize the Statue of Liberty even though they've never, even though many of them have never set foot in New York City or actually.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Mm-hmm.
SPEAKER_00And I think these monuments, as you show, they become inspirational even in ways that their builders did not intend. So the Statue of Liberty, of course, it becomes inspirational for generations of immigrants and remains, I think, one of the preeminent symbols, whether we're talking about immigrants from Mexico or Eastern Europe or Vietnam. And the Empire State Building, despite, as you say, its very corporatist origins,
SPEAKER_00I do think it becomes, for many people, as you show, right, a symbol of progress. And if you believe that progress can be good, I mean, it's interesting, much of your book, we haven't gotten into this yet, talks about progressive thinkers like Jane Addams and John Dewey. I know why you do this, because these are people you love, Vanessa. But in a way, the business implications for some get disaggregated from the progressive implications of the building And that's how I grew up,
SPEAKER_00thinking of the Empire State Building as a symbol of progress Not necessarily empire, but not anti-empire either Do you agree with that?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, so first I was going to ask you, because you grew up in New York City Did you... Were you drawn to one or the other more so? Were they important landmarks for you growing up?
SPEAKER_00Yes. I mean, in a strange way, I think the Empire State Building is more built into the everyday world. activities of New Yorkers because it's in Manhattan and it is also used for business purposes the Statue of Liberty you see it but in terms of visiting it and really thinking about it that that's a tourist activity and most often one would do that when visitors come to New York but you could very well be working or living in New York and walk by the Empire State Building or potentially even go there used to be a bank in
SPEAKER_00the building There were offices in the building So it's more part of the everyday activities in the city In the way that I would say the Capitol building is in DC But the Lincoln Memorial isn't The Lincoln Memorial is a site of reverence Yeah,
SPEAKER_02definitely
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I definitely also, you know, growing up just two hours west of New York City and going to the city, I would see the Empire State Building a lot more often on the city skyline.
SPEAKER_02If you're just in the general area, then, you know, if you're going to Lady Liberty.
SPEAKER_01But yeah, I think progress and even cooperation as well, I would throw in there. Because, as I mentioned, the Empire State Building was built so quickly,
SPEAKER_02you know, and there was an engine of money, corporate money behind that. but the fact that it went up so quickly I think really spoke to the ingenuity of Americans but also the hustle and the cooperation that Americans could come together from all different backgrounds and build this and I kind of make that point that maybe even Franklin Roosevelt noticed that and saw how Americans could work together Absolutely and you make reference
SPEAKER_00of course to FDR a number of times in the book Zachary, please.
SPEAKER_03I'm curious what you think, what lessons we can draw from the history of these two monuments as we prepare to mark the 250th anniversary of the Declaration of Independence. President Trump has already proposed erecting new monuments, but I think the kind of memorializing that most of us are going to engage in in the next few weeks leading into the 4th of July is not going to take the form of massive buildings or statues.
SPEAKER_03But what do you think that this history tells us about the smaller ways that we memorialize and commemorate our history and our values?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, so I would say, again, there's going to be a lot of patriotism surrounding, you know, the U.S. as an empire and a global influencer and a strong military. But I would hope that, you know, the liberty part would not be forgotten or underestimated. And I definitely think that we can learn from our history that liberty should not be taken for granted. When you think about progress,
SPEAKER_02I think there can be an assumption that once liberties are granted or gained or achieved, that they might stay that way. But I think we've seen in history and even in the current moment that that's not the case, that liberty, people can push back on that. Liberties can be violated and limited again and taken away. So I think the The message is to, as Americans, I think, rededicate ourselves to liberty and not just see it in terms of ourselves
SPEAKER_02and our individual liberties, but the fact that collectively we have to look out for the liberty of everyone. And so if one group's liberties are being violated, that should matter to us.
SPEAKER_00How do you think in this very divisive, polarized moment, are there ways that you think that these monuments and others can bring people together?
SPEAKER_01I think so. And I think that the people, the French Republicans and the Americans at the time in the late 1800s knew that the United States might find itself at a crossroads or that they might go through struggles to maintain the republic. There were references to that. You know, Lavallée said, you know, someday I'll be dead and gone, but hopefully the statue will continue to encourage or inspire Americans and people around the world. to value liberty.
SPEAKER_01So they definitely, I think, had that in mind. It was a way not to just bring Americans together, but the whole world. And I think that the world can put pressure on the United States to live up to that.
SPEAKER_02They have done so throughout history in recent times. And I think that they can continue to remind us not to take it for granted as well.
SPEAKER_01So... And I just want to say this book is a lot about people,
SPEAKER_02even though we've been talking a lot about the structures and these inanimate symbolism objects.
SPEAKER_01There are a lot of vignettes or anecdotes about people connected to either one of the landmarks or if they've written about empire or liberty in either positive or negative ways. So a lot of well-known historical figures from Henry Ford to Frank Baum to Helen Keller, all the president, you know, from going back to George Washington through Franklin Roosevelt, as you said, JFK. Trump is mentioned because he was partially an owner of the Empire State Building in the 1990s.
SPEAKER_01And there was a lot of controversy about that ownership. So that I think vignette is kind of interesting. And then a lot of pop culture references as well, movies like King Kong, which helped make the Empire State Building more famous Yes, of course, of course Sorry,
SPEAKER_00go ahead That's okay,
SPEAKER_01I just want people to know that this is a story about people connecting to these landmarks
SPEAKER_00Yeah, and I think one of the great strengths of this book is, again, you show how ubiquitous they are in the lives of people and in different periods. Zachary, just turning to you, I mean, do you think these monuments and others like them resonate with your generation? Venisa's sort of shown how they've, over the course of the 20th century, resonated with different generations. Does it continue to be the case in the 21st century?
SPEAKER_03Yeah, I mean, I think the sort of The grandeur and scale of these monuments is always impressive to everyone. And I think you'd be hard pressed to find a young person who goes to New York City for the first time who doesn't want to visit either of these two monuments or doesn't plan to or doesn't try to. I just, I think that they're beyond the point of being symbols. They're just sort of places that that are awe-inspiring.
SPEAKER_03And I think that that's part of what draws people to them is that they have a quality of grandeur that draws people to them before they understand or think about the symbolism or the history or the people that are connected to them.
SPEAKER_00Right, right. And I was going to ask both of you to close this really wonderful discussion. I'll start with you, Zachary, then we'll give you the last word, Vinice. What's the case to listeners to go and look at these monuments again in a world where we can see images of them, you know, on our screens easily. What's the difference in just as you described Zachary and going and making a pilgrimage in a sense to these monuments, particularly on the 250th anniversary of the declaration?
SPEAKER_03That's a good question. I mean, I guess one, it's a small part of what it's like, but I think I went very recently, I think about a year and a half, two years ago, to the Statue of Liberty for the first time, in person to Liberty Island. I think one of the most remarkable things to see and one of the most powerful things is how many people from around the world, let alone around the country, come just to look at this monument and they spend their entire day for the most part taking a rocky ferry out into the middle of New York Harbor to see this more than a century old copper statue and I think that's pretty special.
SPEAKER_03Yes, so it's the experience with others. Go ahead, Vanessa.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I was going to say something very similar because it might hit a little differently if you were able to just go to Liberty Island by yourself. You know, it still might be this, you know, impressive structure and you might be able to reflect on that in a different way, but... You know, when I've gone over on the ferry and been on the island,
SPEAKER_02I had the same impression as Zachary that just all these people from all over the world taking selfies and group pictures and group pictures from every angle because they want to get it from every angle.
SPEAKER_01There's this happiness and joy that you see on people's faces when they're there. And tour guides have mentioned that, that you don't have to remind people to smile when they're going to the Statue of Liberty. I don't really know why. I don't really know. I can't put into words, I guess, why that has that effect on people. Maybe people have that thrilling feeling when they're going up the elevators in the Empire State Building and they get to the top. I love being at the top of the Empire State Building as well, and I encourage people to do it.
SPEAKER_02Even though you're above this bustling city, there is, I think, a sense of peace and calm up there. and it's just a wonderful view of the entire city surroundings. But I think there's just this feeling of peace and calm when you're up there as well, which maybe you wouldn't expect, unless you're afraid of heights.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah. I can't resist asking, do you find it romantic? Have you been up there with your husband, Daniel? Do you find it a romantic setting?
SPEAKER_01Yes, I've been up there with Dan. I've been up there with friends. I've been up there with high school groups. I've been up there by myself. I haven't been to the 102nd floor yet. That's not an open-air observatory, so I don't find that quite as interesting. But yeah, I definitely love going to the top of the Empire State Building. And for some reason throughout my life, I've always favored the Empire State Building over the Chrysler Building, which is also a beautiful Art Deco design, or the Rockefeller Center.
SPEAKER_01So I've never been to the top of any other skyscraper in New York except Empire State Building. also Statue of Liberty in the acknowledgments I have this little story about going there with my grandfather and as an 8 or 9 year old I wanted to go up to the crown but he said oh there are a bunch of windy stairs and it's rickety and it's you know whatever and he talked me out of it so I didn't go up to the crown until two years ago my husband and I got our tickets and went up there and I was as giddy as a kid so I loved it but one of my hopes of writing this book is that
SPEAKER_02The powers that be at the National Park Service will let me go up to the torch,
SPEAKER_01which has been closed off to tourism since World War I when it was damaged. But I know that there must still be a way up there for maintenance, so maybe they will let me go up there.
SPEAKER_00Well, let's hope so. Let's hope when they listen to this, they will do that. This has been a phenomenal episode, particularly because for the first time, Zachary, I think we've combined history with romantic advice on sites for dates and things to do with other people. So showing once again that history is useful in all kinds of ways. I want to encourage all of our listeners to read Venisa's wonderful book It's titled Empire and Liberty The Tide Histories of Two American Landmarks And it's a book that really rewards you in
SPEAKER_00the historical knowledge it provides But also really a way to think about the moment we're in right now And what monuments like these and others mean to us in our society Venisa, thank you so much for joining us today
SPEAKER_01Thank you very much Zachary,
SPEAKER_00thank you for your insights as always and thank you most of all to our loyal listeners and our loyal subscribers to our Substack for joining us for this episode of This Is Democracy This podcast is produced by
SPEAKER_03the Liberal Arts ITS Development Studio and the College of Liberal Arts at
SPEAKER_00the University of Texas at Austin
SPEAKER_03The music in this episode was written and recorded by Scott Holmes Stay tuned for a new episode every week You can find This Is Democracy on Apple Podcasts,
This week I spoke with Julian Zelizer, the Princeton historian and one of our most frequent guests, about the scale of what happened in Tuesday’s midterms. I wanted to know whether this was a strange moment for a...
This week Zachary and I spoke with Sarah Adler Hartman, CEO of The Texas Tribune, whose career took her from founding Spoon University as a Northwestern student to running subscriber products at The New York Times...
This week we spoke with David Sorkin, the Lucy G. Moses Professor of Jewish History at Yale and an old family friend who attended Zachary’s naming ceremony decades ago, about his new book, The Emancipationists. David’s...
In this episode of This is Democracy, Zachary and I sat down with our old friend John Sipher, who spent 28 years in the. CIA’s Clandestine Service before becoming one oft public voices on intelligence. I wanted to...
This week on This is Democracy, I sat down with Daniel Bessner, one of the sharpest critics of American foreign policy writing today, to talk through his new essay collection, Imperialist Realism. Danny’s central claim...