Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

The Virtual Couch

The Virtual Couch artwork

Murder on the Couch: When "I Did It For You" Is a Lie

Jun 4, 20261 hr 1 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

A heads-up before you press play: this is a bonus crossover from my true crime podcast, Murder on the Couch, dropping into your Virtual Couch / Waking Up to Narcissism feed. It's heavier than usual and opens with a disturbing familicide case that I don't sugarcoat, so if that's not where you are right now, it's completely okay to sit this one out and come back when you're ready. If you stay, I use the case to get at the things we talk about all the time - shame, compartmentalization, the altruistic defense, emotional immaturity, and differentiation - because the behavior is horrific, but the psychology underneath it is deeply human. John List killed his wife, his mother, and his three children - then walked away convinced God would understand. Murder on the Couch is back. Licensed therapist Tony Overbay reopens one of true crime's most chilling family annihilation cases, but not for the manhunt or the famous 18 years List spent hiding in plain sight as "Bob Clark." Tony sits with the question that actually keeps him up at night: how does a devout, rule-following Sunday school teacher reach a place where murder becomes, in his own mind, the most loving thing he could do? If you've ever performed "fine" while something was quietly falling apart inside you, this one lands closer to home than you'd expect. In this episode: Untangle guilt ("I did something bad") from shame ("I am bad") - and why shame left in the dark only grows heavier Spot the "altruistic defense": how control and harm get repackaged as love, devotion, and protection See how rigidity, compartmentalization, and a performed self can hollow a person out long before any crisis hits Learn the ACT distinction between the conceptualized self (the story) and the observing self (the awareness) - and why List had no one home to catch him when the story collapsed Drawing on acceptance and commitment therapy, David Schnarch's work on differentiation, and Richard Rohr's reframe of shame, Tony brings 600-plus episodes of clinical insight to the cases that won't let him go. Shame grows in concealment and shrinks in connection. And Tony's looking for a co-host - if a case has gotten under your skin and you know why, email contact@tonyoverbay.com and pitch it. 00:00 Bonus Episode Setup 00:21 Murder on the Couch Returns 02:56 Content Warning and Themes 05:53 John List Case Opens 08:46 Show Relaunch and Co-Host Invite 12:40 John List Background and Unraveling 17:31 Compartmentalization Explained 19:53 Shame Versus Guilt 24:21 ACT Defusion and Healing 25:47 Shame Architecture of John List 28:21 Altruistic Defense and Covert Narcissism 30:49 Narcissistic Injury 31:26 Altruistic Defense 35:32 Love Versus Control 36:29 Rigidity Explained 38:08 Rules And Fragility 42:06 Eighteen Years Hidden 45:40 Conceptualized Self 48:35 Excavating The Self 52:56 Why This Case Haunts 54:31 Faith And Performance 58:07 Tell The Truth 59:41 Closing And Co-Hosts Please follow Tony on Instagram @virtual.couch on Tiktok @virtualcouch on Facebook https://www.facebook.com/tonyoverbaylmft and on Substack https://thevirtualcouch.substack.com/ You can reach out to Tony through his website tonyoverbay.com or by emailing contact @ tonyoverbay.com

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Hey, everybody. Welcome to a bonus episode of , you may be listening to The Virtual Couch, maybe Waking Up to Narcissism, maybe even Love ADHD. However you arrived, first and foremost, thank you. I am Tony Overbay. I'm a licensed marriage and family therapist and host of the, the aforementioned podcast, and I'm really glad that you are here today because I wanna share something a little different with you. Some of you may remember, if you've been around for a little while, that back in twenty-twenty two and twenty-twenty three, my daughter Sydney and I started a podcast called Murder on the Couch.

, The concept , was pretty simple: take true crime cases and run them through a therapist lens, or maybe even more specifically, I like true crime a lot. I listen to podcasts, I watch documentaries and interrogation videos, and I find myself continually wondering and wishing that I had that person or that couple on my couch, so I could really try and understand not just what happened, , but really the why. W-what was going on psychologically? What was the runway or the ramp that led up to why the person did what they did?

Because I think there are so many variables that go into why people do the things that they do. What does it say about shame, or their attachment, or their family system? Did they have a, a hole in their need-for-validation bucket, so that bucket was never gonna be filled, or did they have such deep dad issues that it wasn't gonna matter who they interacted with in their personal lives, , there was eventually gonna be a breaking point. And my daughter Sid is one of the funniest and most clever and truly enjoyable humans that I have spent time with, so honestly, , it was a fun experience to record those.

And then what was wild was the reception to those first five episodes was phenomenal, and I don't think that Sid or I even realized where that podcast was potentially heading from a growth standpoint. But then life happened, and other projects got in the way, and Sid decided to take a step back, and the last episode went out in October of twenty twenty-three. So it's been a minute, as I don't think the kids are still saying. But I've realized that I never stopped doing the thing that started or at least my involvement in that project in the first place.

, I'm still watching true crime documentaries and interrogation videos and catching myself forty-five minutes deep into a psychological case conceptualization and wondering what the subject of that case , would think about, , emotional immaturity concepts or my latest fixation, co-regulation, or the dance of two people's nervous systems, or I'm noticing that person sure seemed to display an incredible presentation of an anxiously attached, , attachment style. So no wonder their partner would withdraw even more, causing their anxiety to ramp up more to the point of, uh, true crime.

So I decided to bring Murder on the Couch back , and I think I have some exciting news that I'll share inside the episode about my search for, let's say, a temporary co-host , or maybe a few co-hosts, , all while still keeping the seat warm for Syd because whenever and if ever she's ready, that chair is hers. So before we jump in, I do wanna give you a heads-up, especially if you are not a regular true crime listener. This is probably not one to just all of a sudden say, "Well, you know, what's this true crime stuff all about?" , Not one to cut your teeth on because this episode opens with a pretty intense case.

, it involves a familicide, , a man who killed his wife, his mother, and then their teenage children, and he claimed that God was perfectly fine with his decision the details are pretty disturbing and, and I don't sugarcoat them. If that's not something that you are in a place to hear right now, honestly, I completely understand. , Take care of yourself first. , This episode will be here if and whenever you're ready. But if you do stay, then here's , what I want you to know about where this goes. I'm not just covering the crime. I, I decided to use this case to dig into some concepts that I think are

gonna feel pretty familiar to a lot of my listeners, whether it's Virtual Couch or Waking Up to Narcissism. Things like, uh, compartmentalization or, or what happens when we seal off the parts of ourselves that we don't want anybody else to see, or the difference between shame and guilt and how shame gets installed in childhood before we really have tools to understand what's happening. And I talk about something called, , the altruistic defense, which is when somebody reframes a-an act of self-protection that can be pretty, pretty intense as an act

of love, and then why that dynamic or how that dynamic shows up in my office regularly, minus the true crime part. , I talk about emotional immaturity and rigidity and cognitive fusion and, , differentiation. And then a concept out of, uh, my beloved acceptance and commitment therapy that I think is, , one of the most hopeful things in psychology, which is this difference between the story that you've been telling yourself and then the part of you that's been observing or watching the story the whole time. And, , just to be clear, I'm not saying that anybody listening is heading toward a life of crime.

, But many of the concepts that, that we explore today, the shame, the rigidity, the performing a version of yourself for other people, the sealing off of things that you don't want anybody to know, I think those exist in most all of us at… in some form, , a far, far less intense form. And so I think that's what makes a case like this worth sitting with, not because the behavior is anywhere near relatable. It's horrific. But I think the psychology underneath it is a big part of the human experience. And then I, I often think that understanding it at this extreme level

or magnification can actually help us see things in our own lives that are a lot harder to spot up close. 'Cause one of the things I think is the most helpful to do is to learn how to look inward, , introspection, self-confrontation. So that's what you're getting today. Definitely heavier than a normal Virtual Couch or Waking Up to Narcissism episode. , But I think it's worth it, and I genuinely am excited to share this with you. And if you like it, please do me a huge favor and go subscribe to Murder on the Couch wherever you listen to podcasts. That would mean a lot. , Not to spoil the surprise inside, but maybe I'll be talking with you, the

listener, about a case in the future. Okay. Let's get into it. Here is Murder on the Couch and the case of John List, who was a Sunday school teacher, and the psychology of shame So picture this. It's December nineteen seventy-one. A postal worker in Westfield, New Jersey, starts noticing something odd about the big Victorian mansion at the end of Hillside Avenue. The lights are on, all of them, every single night.

The mail is piling up, and there's this faint sound coming from inside. It's classical music, and it's playing very softly, like the house itself is humming, but to nobody in particular. Neighbors mention it to each other. There's a lot of talk in the neighborhood. And then finally, somebody goes up and knocks on the door, but nobody answers. This goes on for over a month, a teacher calls the police. Two officers eventually show up. They step inside, and they find in a house with the thermostat turned down to

near freezing the bodies of five people: a wife, a mother, three teenagers, each one of them shot in the head. Carefully laid out on sleeping bags in the mansion's grand ballroom. The mother was in the kitchen where she'd fallen. There was no sign of a break-in, no struggle, no robbery. But what there was, sitting neatly on the desk of the family patriarch, a five-page handwritten letter addressed to his pastor, and in it, the man explained exactly what he had done and why God would understand and why he was confident

that his family was now safe in heaven. And then that man, John List, forty-six years old, devout Lutheran, Sunday school teacher, former army officer, apparently a devoted family man, walked out of that house, got in his car, and disappeared so completely that it would take eighteen years to find him. This is one of the cases that stopped me in my tracks because the question that I just can't seem to shake, the one that I want to spend this episode sitting with is: how does it happen?

Not the logistics, but let's talk about the psychology. How does a man get to a place where killing the five people that he supposedly loved the most in the world becomes, in his mind, the most loving thing that he could do? And how does somebody's internal world become so sealed off, so rigid, so fused with shame and fear that this is the exit ramp? And that also that he is convinced that God is gonna be perfectly fine with what he did. That's what we're talking about today. My name is Tony Overbay.

I'm a licensed marriage and family therapist, host of The Virtual Couch, Waking Up to Narcissism. But today, you're listening to Murder on the Couch. Let's get into it. Hey, everybody. Welcome to Murder on the Couch. I'm your host, Tony Overbay. I'm a licensed marriage and family therapist and somebody who cannot watch a true crime documentary Or a, an interrogation video without narrating this running psychological commentary in my head. Quite frankly, whether anybody wants to hear it or not.

If you are a longtime listener and -- it needs to be pretty long ago, thanks for still being here. Thanks for showing up again. It's been a while. If you've been around from the beginning, you know that this podcast, Murder on the Couch, was initially a collaboration between my daughter Sydney and me, and those episodes with her are genuinely one of my favorite things that I've ever done. Meanwhile, I've done over four hundred and fifty episodes of a mental health podcast called The Virtual Couch. Throw in another one hundred and fifty plus of Waking Up to Narcissism, but this one is the thing that took off like a rocket ship and

and then came to an abrupt halt. But she's taking a break right now, and I hope, I hope that she'll rejoin me in the not-too-distant future. But in the meantime, I've been doing what I do all the time. I watch a lot of true crime documentaries listen to some true crime podcasts. I have a YouTube feed absolutely full of interrogation videos, and I do the thing where I'm supposed to be just consuming content like a normal human person, but instead I'm forty-five minutes in with a full case conceptualization running in my head and wondering the psychological makeup and who hurt this

person as a child and why wouldn't somebody just give this person validation? Could it have fixed this whole thing? And also, admittedly, there are times where I'm saying out loud, "I would really like to work with that person, just to get inside their head," because I love what I do as a therapist. But all of a sudden, I'll look around and, hey, there's my wife maybe an adult child or two looking at me a little strange, like I need a hobby that also isn't isn't my profession. So here we are because because true crime when you look at it through the therapeutic lens is not just disturbing or even just compelling.

It's instructive. And I'm not talking about here's how you do it, but it shows you sometimes the most extreme magnification what happens inside human beings when things like shame go unexamined or when connection gets replaced by performance or when the interior life, what it feels like to be you on the inside, honest to goodness, never gets the attention that it needs, and maybe doesn't even know what it needs so that attention-seeking game was rigged to begin with. But before I get to the case, I want to make an offer, because I've spent a lot

of time thinking about how I want to move this podcast forward, and I landed on something that felt more exciting to me than just picking up where we left off. I would like for you to be my co-host, and I mean that. And here's what I'm envisioning. If you are somebody who has ever gone down a A true crime rabbit hole. And I mean really down the rabbit hole, the kind where it's the middle of the night and you're reading the-- even chasing down the court documents and you're watching all kinds of hot takes by attorneys and other podcasters, and you found yourself thinking not just about what happened, but really the why about what was going on psychologically about the…

Does the case talk about shame or attachment wounds or family systems or, or identify any of the things that that we talk about on this show or on any of my other podcasts, then I genuinely wanna hear from you. Reach out to me at contact@tonyoverbay.com and tell me about the case that you're interested in covering. Tell me a little bit about yourself, give me a sense of the angles that you would want to explore. What draws you to it, maybe even from a therapeutic lens or psychologically? What questions do you think that the case is really asking? Or what does it even bring up in you? Let's talk about a little transference maybe some projection.

And it does not need to be polished. \ Doesn't have to be a formal pitch. Just tell me what's got you hooked and why. And if it feels like a fit, I'll reach out, and we will figure out how to make an episode together. Maybe it's one, maybe it's a few. And honestly, if the right person's out there and we click and no one else reaches out, maybe maybe it's something more ongoing than that. But let's get into today's case. And I do really think this one is going to stay with you, and I probably should have already given you a little bit of a trigger warning because that was quite the opening. But let's start with the facts. John Emil List was born in Bay City, Michigan in 1925.

He was described as a quiet, serious kid, deeply shaped by his mother, Alma, who was intensely religious and intensely devoted to John. He served in World War II and Korea. He got a degree in business and then a master's degree in accounting. So on paper, he was doing everything just great, building the life that his faith and his upbringing told him that a good, God-fearing Christian man was supposed to build. He married Helen in 1951, she was already a widow with a daughter, Patricia, and they had two more children together, John Jr.

and Frederick. And then they settled into a modest churchgoing life, and for a while it worked. It held. It held together nicely. Then in 1965, he got a VP of finance job at a bank in New Jersey, and the family moved into this enormous Victorian mansion in Westfield called Breeze Knoll. It had 19 rooms. It was built in 1896, and it was too big, and it was too expensive for what John List could actually afford. But he moved his family in anyway, and this is where the slow unraveling begins.

, This bank job that he had fell through within a year List then bounced between positions, and then he began doing what people who can't tolerate the gap between who they believe they are and who they actually are often do. He started lying, a lot, about everything, impulsively, compulsively. He lied to his wife, his mom, his neighbors, his pastor. He started liquidating accounts. He stole from his elderly mother's bank account. She lived on the third floor of the mansion, and he would intercept mail so that Helen wouldn't see the bills.

So for years, he kept up this performance. Years. That took a lot of work, but he looked and performed the role of this stable, successful, God-fearing patriarch, even as everything underneath him started to collapse. His teenagers were teenagers, and they did the things that teenagers do. His daughter, Patty, sixteen, was interested in theater, and she had friends, and she had opinions, and she was becoming her own person the way sixteen-year-olds are supposed to. He had a son, Johnny. At that point, he was fifteen. He had started pulling away from the rigid church-going

structure of his dad's household. So the family was starting to crack open in honestly pretty completely normal, healthy ways that families do when children start to differentiate, when they start to try to figure out who they are and John List, a man who had spent his entire adult life managing appearances of trying to appear as a version o-of himself that he thought he was supposed to be, was also, as he's doing that, trying to seal off a lot of shame. But over time, he couldn't keep it up.

So on November ninth, nineteen seventy-one, he got up and did what he'd apparently been planning for quite a while. He killed his wife, Helen, in the kitchen. Then he went upstairs, and he killed his mother, Alma. He called his children's schools, and he told them that the kids wouldn't be in. And then, one by one, as his children came home, he killed them, too. Patty first, then Frederick, then Johnny last because Johnny was coming home late because he had football practice. . He sat down and wrote his pastor that letter, five pages, very, very neat handwriting, explaining that he had done what a loving father had to do to

protect his family from a world that would shame them, from immoral corruption creeping into his children's lives. He was confident that they were all in heaven, and he asked for prayers from the pastor and the community. And he noted almost administratively, that he didn't really think he'd be able to attend his own mother's funeral. Then he turned on the lights. He turned on the classical music station. He turned down the thermostat. He got in his car, and he drove to Denver. Now most coverage pivots here to the manhunt, the famous nineteen eighty-nine America's Most Wanted episode with the forensic sculptor who

age progressed a bust of John List. And then there was a neighbor in Richmond, Virginia, who saw the broadcast- looked out her window at a quiet churchgoing accountant who lived next door named Bob Clark, and she made the call. He was arrested at his office, 63 years old, remarried. His new wife had no idea. He was eventually convicted in 1990, and he died in prison in 2008. But I don't even necessarily care to spend much time in the capture,

but more so in the 18 years that he lived just a completely normal life. Because I think that's what tells us something that the manhunt never could. Because what John List did wasn't just a crime. It was the end product of a very specific psychological architecture that was built brick by brick by brick out of shame, out of being rigid, out of a fused identity, and about a faith tradition that he bent into something that could no longer hold any grace. So let's dive into that architecture.

And before we do that, I want to start with a question, and I would love for you to just sit with this for a second. Have you ever had something going on in your life, something embarrassing or scary or very deeply shameful, and you just didn't want to tell anybody? So you continue to show up, you go to work, you smile at the right moments, you show up and perform at school. Maybe there's a school play, maybe there's a church potluck and you perform being fine so convincingly that you almost believe it yourself. Everything's okay. It's like you're just kicking the can down the road further and further.

And I'm guessing that the answer is yes, because that is a human thing, not just a monster thing. And I'm not starting there to make you feel like John List. I'm starting there more because the most important thing that we can do on a podcast like this is resist the idea that the people that we talk about are simply other. The, at least I'm not that person. Because the truth is, and I think this is what makes cases like this genuinely unsettling, that John List was operating from a deeply catastrophically amplified version of something that I think a lot of people do, and that is

something called compartmentalization. Because that's a defense mechanism, and I mean that quite literally. The mind defending itself, saying, "This information is incompatible with my ability to function, so I am going to seal it off and then continue operating and conducting my life as if this thing that I'm also doing or thinking doesn't exist." And in small doses, it's pretty adaptive. A surgeon sets aside any anxiety in an operating room, or you're going through a divorce, but you have a presentation to deliver at work.

That's human flexibility, and it's a form of compartmentalization. But compartmentalization becomes dangerous when it stops being a temporary tool and it becomes part of your permanent architecture of yourself. When this sealed-off room that you seal off these things that you don't want to deal with or maybe don't want to acknowledge or admit doesn't just hold, "Hey, I'm nervous about this surgery," but it holds, "I am a complete failure, and if anybody ever found out who I actually am, then my entire existence would collapse."

Because at that point, that's not a tool anymore. That's a load-bearing wall, and then everything gets built on top of it, and everything is propping it up to, to try to keep it intact. Let's dive into shame versus guilt, one of the things that I think I could talk about on every podcast anytime that I speak to really distinguish or differentiate between the two. Because shame is what fills a sealed room like this, and I wanna be really intentional about this because shame and guilt get conflated constantly,

and they are not the same thing. Guilt says, "I did something bad." Shame says, "I am bad." Guilt is more often about behavior, but shame is more about identity. And guilt can, at times, motivate repair. "I did something wrong," or, "I wanna make something right. I did something that I'm not really proud of, and now that I've done it, I wanna take ownership of it." So it comes from this feeling of guilt. Shame does not motivate repair, no matter how much that we like to think that it does. Shame motivates hiding, because if the problem isn't what I did,

but it's who I am or who I think I am, then there's nothing to fix. There's only something to conceal. And shame does not arrive in adulthood. Shame gets installed early, before you have the cognitive architecture to even be aware of it or to process it. Because where did that shame come from? I don't think that it always starts in a church. I think it starts in a kitchen or in a living room or on a car ride home from school. I shared this on a podcast about sin and guilt and shame recently, so I'm

gonna take an excerpt from there. But think about it. You're four years old, and you're doing what four-year-olds do. You're moving through the world impulsively, curiously, probably clumsily. Let's say you knock something over, or you say something that you were told not to say, or you do something that your parent told you not to do, even though you honestly don't fully understand why you were told not to do it in the first place, because you're four. And now your parent's upset, and they need something from you. They need to see that you understand that what you did was wrong. They need the apology.

They need you to hang your head down. They need the, they need to see the face. They need you to look sad or sorry or scared because, and I'm saying this with absolute compassion for the parent as well, because they're running their own inherited programming of what they think you need to do to be a good kid, to be a better parent. Because if you don't look like you feel bad, then what does that say about them as a parent? If the kid isn't showing remorse, are they, i- is the parent even doing their job? So the kid learns over time to perform the kid learns to read the room. They figure out what expression makes this scary moment stop, and maybe at this

day and age gets me back to my tablet or lets me go play with my friends. But here's where actually the damage happens, and it's so subtle that people don't even notice it. A four-year-old does not have the cognitive architecture to separate, "I did a bad thing," from, "I am bad." And at that moment, those two concepts are fused. They're one thing. In that moment, shame gets installed, not guilt. Guilt says, "I did something I wanna repair," but shame says, "I am fundamentally broken." And that shame, in that moment, becomes the operating system.

And then what happens? That kid grows up, and maybe now they do walk into a church with the best of intentions. And somebody says, "Hey, we're all sinners. You're a sinner." And it doesn't actually feel new. It feels familiar because it confirms what they believed about themselves since they were small. "Well, of course I am. I am a sinner, and I gotta confess things. A-and of course, something's wrong with me." And then, unfortunately, the whole system reinforces the wound instead of healing it. This Franciscan priest, Richard Rohr, has some amazing content around

that, and that's where he says that we're getting to this place where this is where it's intergenerational because it's not one person's sin. In this scenario, it's a pattern. It's inherited. The parent who needed you to perform remorse, well, they learned it from their parent, who learned it from theirs. And somewhere along the way, we built entire institutions around the idea that this cycle of shame and confession and judgment was the path to healing. And you've got this Franciscan priest, Richard Rohr, who's operating from inside one of those institutions, and I love that he says "I don't think that's it.

I think the path is recognizing brokenness and then requesting healing. It's not about performing penance." And if you think of this example I'm laying out, it's about performing the right behaviors to hopefully get your parent to buy in that you get the fact that you're bad. You did the bad thing. So Rohr says it's not about performing penance. It's not about trying to prove that you're sorry enough. Healing, and I am a huge acceptance and commitment therapy fan. That's my modality of choice as a therapist, in the ACT lens, this

is where it gets pretty clean because what is shame clinically? Shame is this cognitive fusion. I am fusing to this story at its most destructive. It's not, I'm having a thought or I'm noticing that I messed up. It's I am messed up. And so at that moment, the thought and the self become one thing. And what does the traditional sin framework ask you to do? It asks you now to walk into a room and declare you are a sinner. It asks you to fuse with the most painful story that you can tell about yourself, and then it tells you that doing this is the path to freedom.

That what healing requires, though, in my opinion, is defusion. It's enough space to notice the thought and hold it out away from you, hold it with curiosity instead of becoming it. To be able to say, "I'm having the thought that something is wrong with me. I can notice that this thought's been with me a long time, and in that moment, I can choose with my adult brain instead of my four-year-old one to respond differently." Because that is not avoiding accountability. It's actually a deeper form of it. You're not just owning a behavior, you're owning the whole pattern, and that's a

way to heal this intergenerational trauma. Sure, it will be uncomfortable, but it's better than sealing this thing off and then pretending that it doesn't exist. So back to John List. So he was one of, I think, in my opinion, looking back over this case, one of the most shame-saturated people that you'll probably ever encounter in a true crime case because his entire sense of self was constructed on a really brittle foundation. "I'm the provider. I'm the patriarch. I'm the man of God. I am in control." That was the load-bearing wall.

And then he had a mother, Alma, who handed him a self before he was even old enough to choose one, and that self was built on performance, on duty, on being a certain thing for a parent who needed him to be that thing. It was on being righteous, on being God-fearing, on being perfect. And he carried that performed, shame-organized, rigid self into his adulthood, into his marriage, into fatherhood, into his work, into that 19-room Victorian house. And so by 1971, his reality was dismantling it brick by brick.

Job gone, money gone, house about to be foreclosed, kids becoming actually real complicated individual human beings who are not gonna just quietly perform the roles that his architecture required. And here's what shame does in that situation. Shame doesn't say, "You know, things have gone a little bit south here. I think I need some help." Shame says, "If anybody sees this, I will cease to exist as the person I believe myself to be." That's actually how , the shame-based psyche experiences any kind of i-internal or vulnerable

exposure, not as embarrassment, but as complete annihilation. So the nervous system responds to it the way it responds to a physical threat, to physical danger, because a-at the level of the psyche, oh, it is. That is a tiger that is chasing you. And there's a particular danger in shame that lives only in the dark, only in the shadows, because shame that gets examined or brought into a room with another person and witnessed, like a therapist not fixed, but just witnessed, it loses power When you bring it from the shadows into the light, it isn't as scary.

It becomes more workable. But shame that never gets examined just grows. It fills every room, and it gets bigger and heavier and more defended with every passing year until the gap between performance and then what's happening in reality cannot hold. It cannot exist. So when John List's system could not hold anymore or anything else, he did not reach out. He didn't let anybody in. He sealed that room one final time. And then so he wouldn't have a complete collapse i-in his

psyche, he called it love. I wanna start this next segment with something that might feel a little bit uncomfortable as well. Stay with me here. The discomfort is the point. There's growth from discomfort. Think about a time in a relationship with a parent or a partner when somebody did something that hurt you, and when you tried to say, "Hey, that that, that hurt. That landed hard," and the response was some version of, "You know, that was actually more difficult for me," or, "I did that for you. I was trying to help. I did it actually because I love you." And if you've ever had that experience, you're

left standing there with this bizarre double reality, the pain on one side and trying to express it, and then this in-insistence that the person who caused it was actually the hero of the story. Now, I think most everybody has experienced some version of that, and understanding the psychology underneath it is a really important thing that I think I can offer today because what John List did is not separate from that experience, although he did it in the most catastrophic possible

expression of that kind of experience or that mechanism, and that mechanism is called an altruistic defense. Let me even back up a little bit here, let's compare it with a narcissistic injury. So when most people hear narcissism, they picture the, the loud, swaggering, grandiose type. But there's another presentation I see far more often, and I think the one that describes John List would fit into this category. It's quieter, it-- but it's more rigid, and it often wraps itself in virtue and duty and faith and self-sacrifice. And this is sometimes called a covert or a vulnerable narcissist.

The core wound in both versions is the same. It's a self that was never allowed to be real. Somewhere in development, and in John List's case, I'd point right to his mom, Alma, the message got delivered. And by the way, that doesn't mean I'm blaming his mom because h-his lack of a strong father figure played a role in this. The church that Alma grew up and went to, which most likely gave her a sense of security or maybe even peace, that these are just all components that play into this. But the message that got delivered was that who you actually are is not enough.

There's a version of you you need to be, and what that- That speaks especially to a kid is that love is conditional on how you perform, that your value is located entirely in what you produce and how you appear. So when a child grows up with that message, they don't develop a real self. They develop a performed self, and that performed self is extraordinarily fragile because it has no interior foundation. It's all basically this facade. It's the masks that the person needs to wear. Now, narcissistic injury is what happens when that facade gets threatened.

When reality intrudes in a way that can't be managed or it can't be denied, then the internal experience of that person isn't embarrassment. It goes back to this concept where John List felt like all of these things were an attack. And the nervous system responds to that like it is an attack to physical danger because the only self that this person has ever had is under the threat of collapse. They're gonna get discovered, and they're gonna be found out. So the altruistic defense is exactly what it sounds like.

A person reframes an act of self-protection, even if it's aggressive, as an act of love, of altruism, of they're being loving and caring. And this often is not conscious. It's the psyche that has to construct this narrative that preserves the self-image. It allows that person to remain, in their own story, the good guy. John List could not, absolutely could not be the man who failed his family. That identity wasn't available to him. So instead, he became the man who saved his family, the man who loved

his children so much he spared them the suffering of watching their father fall apart, the man so devoted to God that he sent his family ahead to heaven instead of let them be corrupted by what he was having to deal with. He took an act entirely about protecting his own ego, and then he had to dress it in the language of selfless love. And then I'm guessing, he walked out of that house and then genuinely inhabited that narrative. Now, I'm not saying that John List was not responsible. He absolutely was, one hundred percent. Psychological understanding is not a psychological excuse.

Those aren't the same thing. But the altruistic defense in its non-criminal expressions is probably one of the most common and damaging dynamics that I see in my clinical work. Because think about the parent who controls every aspect of their kid's life and calls it protection. I have worked with more than one parent who puts off when their kid drives or goes to school or gets electronic devices as long as they possibly can, and they say that it's because I'm protecting my kid. But really, a lot of times it's more about the parent not recognizing that

I don't know how to help them manage what they're gonna experience because I don't even know if I can manage my own. So it becomes this form of projection the, the partner who monitors your friendships and then frames it as care, I see that in my clinical work. The person who makes a major decision that's gonna affect you without your input and then explains with genuine sincerity that they did it to spare your pain. In each one of these cases, an act that's fundamentally about the actor's needs, the person's needs, their anxiety, their ego, their need for control, they repackage

it as love, and then the recipient is left trying to hold their own reality against what is starting to feel like a very airtight counter-narrative. So this is why on my Waking Up to Narcissism podcast, I spend so much time talking about the confusion that partners and family members experience. Because when the person causing harm is also the person most loudly proclaiming their love and their sacrifice, it creates a psychological type of vertigo because you start questioning your own perception. You start wondering, "Wait, a-am I being ungrateful?" And your brain ties itself into knots trying to reconcile the impact that you're

feeling with the intention that they're declaring, they don't fit together. It can be a real challenge to learn to trust your own experience of impact, even when somebody else insists that is not what's happening, and that's one of the most important pieces of work that you can do in a therapist's office. And then there's one more layer here. John List's children were beginning to, to differentiate, to individuate, and in healthy families, that's just what happens. It's, it can actually be a bit of a celebration. You watch your kid become a real person with opinions different from

yours, and you can even feel pride. But in a narcissistically organized family, individuation or differentiation is experienced as betrayal. You are going against us. It's that all or nothing, black or white mentality, 'cause if your child becomes fully themselves, they stop being an extension of your performed identity, and they start being a witness to it, a witness who can now see the gap between who you claim to be and who you actually are. David Schnarch is a psychologist who I go back to his work constantly. He talks about differentiation, and it's this capacity to be a fully separate self in the presence of another person, to tolerate

somebody else's separateness without feeling like it's gonna destroy you. John List had e-essentially zero differentiation capabilities. He had enmeshment and he masqueraded that as devotion, and when the people that he was enmeshed with started to become real complex individuals, real humans, his system had no idea what to do with it, so he ended them, and he called it love. So here's what I would love for you to take from this segment alone. Love, real love, requires the other person to actually exist as a completely separate human.

It requires them to be separate from you, to have their own interior world, their own trajectory, and you don't get to control it. Real love tolerates that. So this altruistic defense produces care as control. It, it produces devotion as possession, and in its mildest forms it erodes relationships really slowly One cut at a time, the death by a thousand cuts scenario. In its most extreme form, it destroys them in a most literal sense. So the question that I challenge people with o-often is the relationship

in your life or are the, all the relationships in your life, are you being loved for who you actually are, or are you being loved for the role you play in somebody else's story? 'Cause those are not the same thing. You can have love or control in an adult relationship, not both, and knowing the difference might be one of the most important things that you can figure out. , So for this next section, I want to start with a word that sounds almost too mild for what we're talking about today, but it's, I think it's one of the most clinically precise words that we can use to describe John List. And I've said it a couple times in this episode, but let's dig in on it.

This word is rigid. Not evil, not monstrous, but rigid. But if we just land on monster and we call it done, I think we miss the entire lesson. And there is a lesson here, something in John List's psychology that if we're, I think, being honest, maybe we can find traces of in our own lives, our own relationships or the family systems that we grew up in. So let me talk a little bit about what emotional immaturity actually looks like. It's not just a grown-up throwing a tantrum, although that certainly is a thing. It can also look almost like stone-faced stoicism, this ironclad self-control.

You know, a man who never raises his voice, who follows every rule, who shows up to church every Sunday and sits in the same pew And never, not once, gives anybody visible reason to worry. Because emotional immaturity isn't fundamentally about behavior, it's about internal capacity. So whether a person can actually experience their emotional life, again, emotional immaturity. Do they even know what emotions are there for? Can they tolerate what's happening in their emotional life? Can they feel it, tolerate it, process it, versus whether they learned early and out of necessity to simply shut it down.

John List shut his emotions down so completely, so early, that by adulthood, there really wasn't much emotional interior left to access. What was there, , had been bricked over by performance and rigidity and a set of rules that told him exactly who to be at all times and left no room for the messy business of being a real human being. Back to acceptance and commitment therapy, in ACT, psychological flexibility is considered one of the cornerstones of the modality, and I think it's one of the cornerstones of mental health in general.

Psychological flexibility. It's the ability to be in contact with the present moment, including difficult emotions, difficult realities, without being overwhelmed by them or, or rigidly defending against them The opposite psychological inflexibility shows up in a few ways that I think are easy to recognize. One of them is called experiential avoidance, meaning I am, I'm avoiding, I am avoiding whatever has happened and doing whatever it takes to not feel the uncomfortable thing. Staying busy, staying controlled, sealing off the room, not allowing yourself to even think about things without having music or a podcast or

something blasting in the background. So you've got that experiential avoidance. I'm gonna do anything other than be here in the - in the present moment because I don't even know how I feel, and I don't know what to do with any of the emotions or feelings. And then there's another term called cognitive fusion, merging with a story so completely that you can't see it as a story anymore. And I've got a couple other concepts and then we'll , make sense of these. Another one's rule-governed rigidity, and this is the piece most specific to John List. Rule-governed rigidity is a way of moving through the world organized

almost entirely around rules, explicit rules, implicit rules, religious rules, social rules, family rules. And what's interesting is the psychological function of those rules is it makes sense. It's there, the rules are there to eliminate uncertainty, to make the world so predictable that nothing unexpected can get in. And the theory is that that will make me feel better, and then I can go through life. But there's a, a fundamental difference between somebody who holds their rules lightly, who can adjust when the situation calls for it, and then somebody who holds them as though their very survival depends on them.

John List held his rules as though his survival depended on them because a- as we've identified, at the level of his psyche, it did. His rules told him who he was, the good provider, the faithful husband, the church elder. Th-those aren't values. They were the architecture of his self, the only thing standing between him and the terrifying void of not knowing who he was at all. And what's fascinating about this is you are going through life for the very first time as you, and you are the only version of you that's ever existed on the planet Earth. And you are this unique combination of your nature and nurture and birth order and abandonment and DNA and hopes and dreams and fears.

So you're actually reacting to things the way you are because that's how you're reacting to them. And if you don't feel comfortable in your own skin or as you are, then it would make sense that you're turning to someone else to say, "Hey, how should I feel about this thing? How should I think about this thing? What should I do?" And you rely so, so inherently on, on the validation of others, on external validation, that at some point, just what it feels like to be you is I need to be told what to do in every situation because then I don't have to take ownership or accountability of if my life didn't

go the way that I thought it would. I can say, "Well, the pastor said," or, "My parents said," or, "God said," instead of just being and doing and existing and figuring things out on your own. And then what rigidity does to a family, so if a parent organizes their interior world around these rigid rules, then the family stops being a living, dynamic system, and it starts being all about performance. Kids learn early that their job is not to be themselves. Their job is to maintain this performance , don't rock the boat. Don't bring anything into the room that might destabilize this very fragile architecture that the most immature person in the room, often

the most emotionally immature narcissistic parent, has constructed. And the cruel irony is that the most inflexible person in the room is the most fragile. The rigidity is not a strength. It's a symptom of how much internal terror is being held at bay. So John List's iron control was the behavior of a person one crack away from internal collapse at almost any given moment until that crack appeared. So I would imagine, I was gonna say guarantee, but I can't go back in time, that his kids, his wife, his mom felt that. It was the, "Oh man, which version of John do we have walking in

today? Just something seems off. He seems a little bit tense." Let's talk about the 18-year period. After November 9th, 1971, then John List drove to Denver. He became Bob Clark. He got a job. He joined another church. He became a church elder. He married a woman, Dolores, who described him as gentle and kind, and I cannot even imagine what that would be like for Dolores whenever she discovered what had happened. But he lived this completely normal life for 18 years. How? Because John List had been living exactly like this his entire life,

the capacity to seal off an interior reality and just continue to perform. He had been doing that since childhood. November 9th wasn't a rupture in his psychological functioning. It was, in a deeply disturbing way, pretty consistent with it. He didn't flee and rebuild because he was resilient. He fled and rebuilt because he had never actually built anything in the first place. He'd only performed. And performing, that's portable. You can do it as John List in New Jersey and as Bob Clark in Virginia, and the machinery works pretty much the same because it was

never connected to anything real. I see this when people divorce a, a true narcissistic person, and then that person moves into a different relationship, and all of a sudden they're doing everything that they said they would never do in the relationship with the person that I'm now working with post-divorce because they just pick up the sense of self of whatever they need to be in that moment., Never connected to anything real. Emotional immaturity is not a nothing. It's an active, ongoing, energy-consuming process of keeping reality at bay, and that process has costs, not always for the person doing it, because for

them that, that's just what they do. But it has a cost for the people around them because you cannot be in a genuine relationship with a performance. You can't actually be loved by somebody who has never developed the capacity to see you as a real, separate, complex human being because they don't know who they are. I work with a lot of people who grew up w-with someone like this, not a murderer obviously, but somebody with the same emotional architecture, the rigidity, the rules, the complete unavailability of a genuine interior life. And the thing that I hear over and over is, "I always felt like I was

supposed to be something for him. I, you know, I never felt like I could just be me." And so I have the people in my office now trying to even figure out at thirty, forty, fifty somebody in their seventies trying to say, "I don't even know who I am," but now is the time to find out. I sometimes call this the legacy of emotional immaturity. Not always dramatic, not always even visible from the outside, but deeply and quietly kind of persistently shaping what children believe love is supposed to feel like, what they believe they are allowed to be. The work of undoing that, that's probably some of the most important therapeutic work there is, but it does start with naming what happened, understanding that

the unavailability wasn't your fault. It's not a reflection of your worth as a kid, not something you could have fixed by being smaller or quieter or performing better. You couldn't have fixed it because as much as it feels like it was about us, it never was about you. It was always entirely about them. A client asked me a question a few years ago that I think about often. We were deep in a session, somebody who had spent the better part of their adult life performing a version of themselves built by other people, going through a nice faith deconstruction, a faith crisis, and at one point

they looked over at me and said, "What if there's nothing underneath? What if I've been performing so long that there's actually nobody in here? , This is just who I am. What if I am the chameleon?" Sit there with that one for a second before you connect it to John List, because I hear this one often, and I think it's one of the most important questions that you can ask yourself. The answer is the beginning of something genuinely hopeful, but John List is, in a terrible way, a case study in what happens when somebody asks a version of that question and they get the worst possible answer. In ACT there's a distinction between the conceptualized

self and the observing self. The conceptualized self is the story. It's the collection of roles and labels and narratives. "I am provider. I am a good father. I am devout. I am in control." It's the content of your identity. It's the what of who you are. Now, the observing self is different. It's the part that notices the story, that can step back and watch your own thoughts and patterns without being consumed by them. It's the awareness itself instead of what's being observed. It's, , a beautiful concept called self as context instead of yourself as content.

John List had the conceptualized self that was extraordinarily elaborate and extraordinarily brittle, and he had, I'd argue, no observing self or the abi-ability to step back and see himself in these moments. No capacity to step back and say, "Oh, this, this story is in trouble, and I need to take a look at that." When reality dismantled the story, all of a sudden he's losing his job, his home, he can't go, "Well, check that out. This version of me that I thought that this is how things would play out, that's not happening." And so now I can look and say, "What's the story my brain , tells me?

That I needed to be perfect. Oh, it's the old I need to be perfect story. I'm noticing that. I can step away from it." When reality dismantled the story, there was nothing underneath to catch him, no grounded awareness that could say, "Oh, this story's falling apart, but I'm still here. The world's still spinning. I can survive this." Just the story, and with the story falling apart and him making The most catastrophic possible attempt to hold it together because he , didn't change, he relocated. , It's kinda haunting that after everything, John List built a new conceptualized self,

new story, new roles, gentle husband, reliable employee, devoted church elder, and by all accounts, he then inhabited it with exactly the same completeness, the same apparent conviction, the same absence of internal conflict as the old one. He didn't rebuild himself. He just picked up a new story and put it on, kinda like changing clothes. Genuine change doesn't happen at the level of the story. You can't swap out one narrative for another and then call it transformation. The self you're running from comes with you until you turn around and face it. You get into a relationship with your own interior experience, your own

history, your own capacity for harm. The new story in his scenario is just a new facade over the same unexamined foundation. I see people do versions of this often. They leave a marriage and immediately enter a new relationship and wonder, "Why did, why on earth did the same pattern show up? I left the bad relationship, and this one seems so good." Or they move to a new city, and they reinvent their wardrobe and change their friend group and slowly find themselves feeling exactly the same, stuck, unseen, performing, and afraid because they changed the story, but they didn't do the work of examining the storyteller, and the storyteller comes with you every single time.

Now, there are examples of this where you do go to a new place, and you have this opportunity to reinvent yourself, to become the new version of you, but that is successful when you've done the work internally to figure out why it is that you show up the way that you do. So that's the real work. What does that excavation look like? And I, I wanna resist making it sound easier and tidier than it is 'cause it's not just a weekend workshop or a journaling exercise or just taking a few deep breaths. It's the slow, nonlinear, frequently uncomfortable process of learning to be

in genuine contact with your own internal experience, developing the capacity to feel what you actually feel instead of what you think you're supposed to feel. It's building enough psychological safety inside yourself first that you can look at the most painful, most shameful, most sealed-off parts of your history and be with them. It's gonna sound like nothing but woo-woo at first. It's the feel the feelings, and it doesn't make a lot of sense until it does, I've had to go through it myself as a therapist working with my own

therapist, that at first we even have to know where do we feel the things that we feel, and we need to allow them to be. It gets, so ethereal and all the words I've heard, hippy-dippy, woo-woo, you name it. But you have to allow yourself to feel. You breathe into the feelings, you thank the feelings for being there, you give them time, and sometimes you don't do anything with them, and the world spins, and the feelings eventually dissipate. At some point then, you're gonna listen to them, and they're gonna tell you stories, and most likely your first reaction is gonna be to want to get rid of them, to intellectualize them, to try to make sense of them.

And often the way you're trying to make sense of them is still gonna be of something, a blame yourself thing, and that goes back to that, programming that got inherited as a kid that, "Well, it must be my fault. It must be something I'm doing wrong," versus, "Oh, this feeling could be providing me a roadmap that this, I this situation doesn't feel safe. This doesn't feel like the right thing for me to do right now." So learning to look at these most painful, , most shameful, most sealed off parts of your history and be with them and not fix them, and sit with them and acknowledge them, not perform a new story about them, just be with them.

And eventually, they actually do start telling you stories. It's your own intuition. It's your gut. , This is acceptance. It's not approval. It- it's more of a willingness to make contact with your experience as it actually is. And here's what that acceptance makes possible. When you can learn to actually be with your own experience, you free up an enormous amount of interior resources, your emotional calories being burnt on trying to ruminate and beat yourself up and figure out what's going on. You'll recognize how much time you spend on that, and those are resources that

are now available to go toward genuine connection, toward actually showing up as a full, present, complex human being instead of this curated performance of who you think you're supposed to be. You become somebody who can be known, and being known, genuinely known, in all your complexity and all your messiness, is the only foundation that real, real intimacy can be built on. Takes a lot of courage , to be known, and it takes a lot of courage to genuinely know somebody and realize that we're two wonderfully flawed

human beings going through life for the first time experiencing things. John List was never known, not by his first wife, not by his children, not by his mom, not by his second wife, because the real self was locked in a room he refused to open for anybody, including himself. His second wife, Dolores, said after the arrest she had no idea that the man that she married was gentle and warm and that she had felt genuine love. And I believe her, because within the limits of his architecture, he probably was a reasonably attentive partner, but it just wasn't enough, because the

intimacy was constructed on a total false foundation on concealment The man that she was married to did not exist. Real intimacy cannot be built on concealment. Real love can't survive the fundamental unavailability of the person that you believe you love. That question that my client asked earlier, "What if there's nothing underneath?" Here's what I've come to believe. There's always something underneath. Always. The observing self doesn't disappear just because it's been buried under decades of performance.

It doesn't go away because nobody ever made it safe to come out. It's there. It's always been there. So the work isn't about constructing a self. The work is about excavating a self. One that was already there. John List never did that work. He didn't even know that work existed. He died in prison at 82, having been genuinely unknown even to himself for his entire life. So let's bring this thing home. Why does a story like this reach inside of us and grab something?

Why can't we just file it under disturbed individual, next case, and move on? Because the cases that stay with us are touching something, making contact with some part of our own interior landscape that recognizes, even if it doesn't want to admit it, that sometimes the distance between us and the person that we're reading about isn't always as vast as we'd like. Now, not in behavior. The behavior is horrific, absolutely. But the psychology underneath, the shame, the rigidity, the performance, the terror of being truly known, that psychology isn't alien. That psychology is human, and that's what true crime at its best does for us.

Not just to titillate, not to horrify, but it illuminates things. Here's what I think the John List case is really about. What happens when a person spends an entire lifetime refusing the fundamental vulnerability of being a real human being? Everything that we talked about today, the shame, the compartmentalization, the narcissistic injury, the altruistic defense, the emotional immaturity, the identity built on performance, all of it is downstream of that, that one refusal, the refusal to be real, to be known, to let the gap between who you're supposed to be and who you actually are, and then becoming that person

becoming something that you can sit with, grieve, and then eventually integrate. But the refusal is not inevitable. Patterns can be interrupted. These architectures built on shame and performance can be slowly, painfully, with the right tools and support, dismantled and rebuilt on something honest. That's what therapy's for. I deal with a lot of people that are navigating their faith journeys, their faith deconstructions, and I wanna touch on that real quick here, the faith piece. John List's Lutheran faith was not incidental to what he did. It was central, and I'm not saying this from a blame standpoint.

I just think that it provided the language for the altruistic defense the framework for his rigidity, and then the most painful irony at the heart of the story because the tradition that he drew on, Christianity in its most generous expression is built around the exact opposite message, - that you are known fully and loved anyway, that the gap between who you are and who you're supposed to be isn't something to conceal, but something to bring into the light, to let your light so shine. The message itself that grace is offered in the mess, not earned through performance. John List had access to that message his entire life.

He sat in church every Sunday, and it never sank in because the shame was too thick. The architecture was too rigid. If you grew up in a religious environment where faith was a performance standard instead of a refuge, where God was a scorekeeper instead of a presence, I want to say something directly to you. I think the version that you might have been handed isn't the only version. You're allowed to renegotiate that relationship with, with the Almighty. You're allowed to find a version that has room for your actual self, your messy, complicated, entirely human self. You're allowed to be known, and you are allowed to be loved in the knowing.

If I'm speaking fluent Christianity to someone of that faith, the concept of God's the same yesterday, today, and tomorrow, and his love is unconditional means that he loves you because he does. And that means that he is probably the most differentiated parental figure, literally or figuratively, that there could be. So then when we mess up, and I am air quoting that, and we say, "Man, God must be mad at me," that's a me thing, because if I'm turning back to that God who's the same yesterday, today, and tomorrow and who loves me

then it's a me thing, and I would turn back to that person whenever I could. And I deal often with people navigating faith journey, faith deconstruction, where sometimes there's a really fascinating concept of where the more you begin to love yourself, the more you realize your relationship with God changes. That when you are a little kid and you don't like yourself, or if you are going through and experiencing tremendous amounts of shame and guilt and fear, you then project that out to God. But when you love yourself it's funny. It's almost ironic to see how your relationship with God changes.

So John List was handed a self before he was old enough to choose one. He never developed the capacity to tolerate shame. He never built the observing self that could stand outside of his story and say, "Hey, this story is not working. Let me look at that honestly. Let me ask for help. Let me grieve what I'm losing instead of destroy it before anybody else can see me lose it." He built this fortress instead, then he defended it in the most devastating way imaginable. Walked away, built another fortress, lived inside of it for 18 years until a TV show and a woman looking out her window said, "I think I know who that is." He maintained it to the end that what he had done was an act of love.

That fortress held even at the very end, because cracking it would have meant becoming real, and becoming real was the one thing that he spent his entire life refusing to do. Now, before I let you go, I meant what I said at the top. I'm looking for co-hosts. If you followed this episode, you found yourself thinking about the psychological underpinnings of what you were hearing. If you have a case that's gotten under your skin and you know why, maybe even you don't know why Email me at contact at tonyoverbay.com. Tell me who you are, the case you want to cover, and anything else that you think would be helpful, the therapeutic angles you think are worth exploring.

And I will share this on the virtual couch and waking up to narcissism too. I look forward to hearing from hopefully a lot of you that might find this to be a pretty interesting experience. As directly as I know how, shame grows in concealment and it shrinks in connection. The thing that you're most afraid for people to know about you, the failure, the debt, the marriage that's falling apart, the identity that's starting to crack, whether you like or don't like your job, if you feel very vulnerable as a parent, or if you don't know, if you're struggling with your faith, having a good old faith deconstruction, that thing does not become more manageable when you seal it off.

It doesn't get better eventually. Be aware of magical thinking that, oh, it'll be better later. It becomes more powerful, actually, the more that you don't bring it out into the light. It becomes this load-bearing wall. But the antidote, and I know this sounds almost insultingly simple for everything that we've been through today, but I mean it with everything I have, the antidote is starting to tell the truth. And that can be to somebody safe. And sometimes it starts with telling the truth to yourself. Not everybody's safe. You don't owe your interior life to everybody. But somebody, a therapist, a trusted friend, a partner who has earned the

right to the real you, Somebody who can receive who you actually are.. Because here's what happens over and over again in my office. People finally do that when they bring the sealed-off thing into the room and let another person witness it. It does not destroy them. It doesn't confirm the worst thing that they feared. What happens is they feel less alone than they felt in years, sometimes decades, sometimes ever. The most threatening thing becomes, in the light of genuine human connection, something that can actually be worked with, grieved, understood, integrated. That's the exit ramp John List never took.

It was always there. He drove past it every time. But you don't have to. Thanks for spending this time with me. If you're sitting with something after listening, something personal, something uncomfortable, stay with it for a second. Don't seal it off. That discomfort is information. If this episode resonated, share it. Go leave a review wherever you listen to podcasts. Subscribe, like, all those wonderful things. And if you want more of the therapeutic frameworks we talked about today, ACT, differentiation, narcissistic injury, emotional immaturity, come find me at The Virtual Couch or Waking Up to Narcissism or reach out to me at contact at tonyoverbay.com. Thank you so much for joining me.

This has been Murder on the Couch. Have an amazing week. next time that you see another episode come up, it will be with my first co-host. Take care and have an amazing week. We'll see you next time on Murder on the Couch.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Hosts

  • Tony Overbay Host Feed-stated

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. How Childhood Shapes Who You Marry: The Accommodator, Attachment, and Why We Choose the Familiar

    Nov 13, 20261 hr 18 minAudio

    Why do people pleasers and avoidant partners find each other, and why does it seem like such a relief at first? Tony follows Pam and Jim, a composite couple, from childhood to the college campus where they met. Pam...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Nobody Brings a Casserole When You Wake Up to Betrayal: The Accommodator, Gaslighting, and Rebuilding Trust

    Nov 4, 20261 hr 29 minAudio

    Waking up to betrayal, gaslighting, or emotional immaturity rarely comes with a casserole on the porch or a meal train. When someone has a baby or a surgery, people can see the event and show up with dinner. When you...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Nobody Brings a Casserole When You Wake Up to Betrayal: The Accommodator, Gaslighting, and Rebuilding Trust

    Nov 4, 20261 hr 29 minAudio

    Waking up to betrayal, gaslighting, or emotional immaturity rarely comes with a casserole on the porch or a meal train. When someone has a baby or a surgery, people can see the event and show up with dinner. When you...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Your AI Is a Great Hype-Man - A Therapist Has a Few Notes (Plus Live QA)

    Oct 14, 20261 hr 32 minAudio

    Using AI as a therapist? Your chatbot might be building a great plan for the person you’re hoping to become. When a client’s chatbot asked if he was an extroverted go-getter, he answered as the man he’s working toward,...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Why Good People Defend Leaders (and Others) Who Contradict Themselves: Identity, Bias & Belonging

    Sep 24, 202653 minAudio

    Tony starts with a kid raised in an East Coast fishing town and another raised hiking Arizona trails. He uses them to show how beliefs tend to form through family, community, and identity, with the reasons showing up...

    Credit the people on this episode