Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

The Virtual Couch

The Virtual Couch artwork

How Childhood Shapes Who You Marry: The Accommodator, Attachment, and Why We Choose the Familiar

Nov 13, 20261 hr 18 minAudio

Why do people pleasers and avoidant partners find each other, and why does it seem like such a relief at first? Tony follows Pam and Jim, a composite couple, from childhood to the college campus where they met. Pam learned to read her dad’s mood by the sound of the garage door, and Jim learned that his feelings were corrected while his achievements were noticed. Starting with Tim Burton’s Big Eyes, Tony explores how two kids answered the same question: what happens in this house when I have a feeling, and why the nervous system goes looking for the familiar. In this episode: Trace how a child ends up co-regulating a parent, and how repair that runs back toward the parent leaves the kid doing the repairing Learn how John Bowlby’s internal working model becomes the instruction manual you bring into marriage Explore the research on why anxious and avoidant partners pair up far more often than chance would predict Recognize yourself in Pam’s reread texts or Jim’s “I’m fine” that comes out before he’s checked, and get curious about whether those settings fit the house you live in now Hear Ed Tronick’s finding that repair predicts security more than perfection does, and why one partner getting steadier can change a relationship Tony Overbay, LMFT, has worked with well over 1,500 couples over more than 20 years and has advanced training in betrayal trauma. This is part two of three, and it stands on its own. If you’re the one who reads the room before walking all the way in, or the one who says “I’m fine” before checking, this may be a good one to listen to together, and I’ll see you in part three. Please follow Tony on Instagram @virtual.couch on Tiktok @virtualcouch on Facebook https://www.facebook.com/tonyoverbaylmft and on Substack https://thevirtualcouch.substack.com/ You can reach out to Tony through his website tonyoverbay.com or by emailing contact @ tonyoverbay.com 00:00 GoodNurtrition electrolyte ad 01:32 Show Intro and Part Two 03:06 Big Eyes Story Setup 04:39 Credit Stolen and Control 07:11 Escape and Courtroom Paint Off 09:39 Accommodator Pattern Recap 10:10 Why We Self-Abandon 12:57 Pam and Jim Marriage Snapshot 14:56 Pam Childhood Hypervigilance 17:52 Parentified Repair and Shame 22:33 Anxious Attachment and People Pleasing 25:14 AJR Lyrics Identity Crisis 28:46 Differentiation and Boundaries 31:53 Jim Childhood Emotional Dismissal 35:07 Achievement and Validation Loop 37:20 Anxious Avoidant Dynamic Explained 38:59 Pam Feelings as a Job 39:39 Pam’s Hypervigilance 40:19 Jim Learns to Shut Down 42:26 From Surviving to Thriving 43:22 Hydration Sponsor Break 46:15 Why Familiar Patterns Stick 48:56 Therapy and Awareness Work 54:34 Anxious-Avoidant Loop 57:35 Self-Validated Intimacy 01:00:21 Internal Working Models 01:03:42 How Pam and Jim Meet 01:11:42 Research on Attachment Pairing 01:15:57 Part Three Teaser and Wrap

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

This episode is brought to you by Good Nutrition, the amazingly tasty electrolyte drink that I cannot actually get enough of. And it helps me stay hydrated when I'm in my new sauna throughout a regular day and on my runs since moving to the surface of the sun. And by that, I mean Arizona. And by Arizona law, I'm required to say that it's a dry heat. And I actually wasn't even going to say much more right now, but Arizona weather, Trauma bond. In the summer, it never lets up. 100 degrees at night, things melt in my car constantly.

I think I made it maybe two hours this past summer without checking the outside temperature or saying to anybody that would listen of how hot it was. But now the winter has hit. And I want to air quote winter because it's amazing. It's almost like if summer never happened and now I don't want to live anywhere else. So I am trauma bonded to the weather. The same thing that gives you the punishment. it also provides you with the rewards. Maybe this ad should be, you don't even have to be trauma-bonded to the state of Arizona to enjoy a tasty, low-calorie, zero-sugar electrolyte beverage.

Go to thegoodnutrition.com and use coupon code virtualcouch, all one word, for 15% off your entire order, plus free shipping. Now, let's get to the show.

Hey everybody, welcome to another episode of, and this is definitely going to go on both waking up to narcissism and the virtual couch because that is what I did last time and the feedback was amazing. So thank you for all those who wrote in. There were some amazing comments. It's actually made it so that this is part two and I'm going to just plow right on through and I have a part three ready as well. Follow me on social media at virtual couch on TikTok at virtual.couch on Instagram or find me on Substack. A lot of content is going there. Send me an email, contact at tonyoverbay.com. I'm looking for people's stories,

their examples, their questions about their relationships. In a perfect world, I would get something from each of you from both sides of the equation. And I would love to do an episode where I take each of your perspectives and then I relate both of them. So often as a couples therapist, what you're seeing are people that are asking somewhat for similar things, but in ways that don't look at all the same. And we'll actually talk about that a fair amount in today's episode, which is part two. Now, if you did not listen to part one, it's actually okay. It would help for

context, but I made sure that each one of these could stand on its own. With that said, let's dive in. So there's a Tim Burton movie from 2014 called Big Eyes, and the story goes something like this. It's 1958, and a woman named Margaret leaves her husband and puts her young daughter Jane in the car and drives to San Francisco. And she gets a job at a furniture factory painting illustrations. And then on weekends, she does portraits at an outdoor art show, and that's where she meets Walter Keene. Walter sells paintings of Parisian street scenes, and he makes his real money in real estate.

And they portray Walter as charming, and so the two of them become very close. Then her ex-husband asks for custody of Jane as part of the divorce, and Margaret is terrified. And Walter proposes. They marry, they honeymoon in Hawaii, and she keeps her daughter. Seems like everything's going okay. But neither of them can really get their work into a real art gallery. So Walter talks to the owner of a jazz club and asks him if he can rent some wall space, and the wall space turns out to be toward the back by the bathrooms.

So one night, a customer falls in love with one of Margaret's paintings. It's this child with enormous sad eyes, and her husband buys it for her. The husband assumes that Walter painted the picture. Walter doesn't correct him. A little later, Walter gets into a fight with the club owner and puts the man's head through one of Margaret's canvases, which makes the front page of the paper, which then starts packing the club with people who want to see the art that made grown men fight. A gossip columnist shows up and asks Walter about his paintings of the big-eyed

children, and Walter goes along with that too. And then he comes home, and he shows Margaret how much money he made. And then he suggests that they have an arrangement, that she stays home, and she paints, and he takes the credit and handles the publicity and the sales. And she says, yeah, sure. Because from inside her world, that yes made a lot of sense, because she had been a single mom who was recently afraid of losing her child to her ex. Her work was hanging next to a bathroom just a few months ago,

and now somebody is finally paying for it. I can only imagine that that seemed like, sure, fine. It probably isn't going to work anyway. The real Margaret Keene said about those years that at least the paintings were being shown. So eventually enough are sold that Walter opens up a gallery and he figures that cheap reproductions of her paintings will sell even more, maybe even by the thousands. And it turns out they do. And they find their way into department stores all over the country. And the family moves into a mansion.

And Walter spends his evenings with the celebrities hobnobbing with the rich and famous. and Margaret spends hers in a room in the house painting, painting more and more and painting alone. Now, from the outside view, it looks like this is working. It looks like success. And Walter even asked Margaret to lie about the paintings and how the whole thing works to Jane. And then one day, she finds one of his Parisian street scenes. And they are in a box. I think he had a shipment come over of them.

And every one of them in the box is signed by somebody else, and it's somebody that she's never even heard of. And she realizes, I've actually never seen Walter paint. And it turns out that he had been painting over another artist's signature. Now, when she confronts him, he tells her he always wanted to be an artist and he never had the talent. I think that the movie means for us to feel something for him at that moment. And then you kind of do, but then she still has to go back to the room and paint. Now, she eventually tells him that she's losing interest in keeping up the whole charade.

And he, and I don't know how much of it is the true story or the based on a true story, but he threatens to have her killed. And he wants to feature a painting at the New York World's Fair. So he tells her to paint a masterpiece. And while she's working on it, Jane, actually their child sneaks into the studio and tells her mom, she already knows the gig is up, which is kind of funny because that's kids typically know more than we think they do. And then she paints the masterpiece. The painting actually gets a brutal review.

The fair declines to show it. Walter comes home drunk and he blames Margaret and it gets a little bit violent. She and Jane lock themselves in the studio and he starts pushing lit matches through the keyhole. Now they get out, they get to the car, they drive away. A year later, they're in Honolulu. And Walter's terms for a divorce are that she sign over the rights to every painting and that she actually produce a hundred more. Kind of like the audacity of them. But at first she agrees. But then in the film, her growing faith convinces her that honesty matters more than the deal. And she signs a batch of paintings with her own name. And she goes on a radio

show and says that the big-eyed children were always hers. The columnist then prints Walter's response, which is that Margaret is delusional. And it's actually Jane, who's gotten older at this point, suggests that they sue Walter. So at the trial, Walter represents himself, which insert joke about emotionally immature or narcissistic person there. At least my experience has been that. But Walter represents himself and he's apparently using what he has picked up from TV crime shows, maybe a little Law & Order. I don't know that for a fact. And at one point, he cross-examines himself. Now, the judge,

who at that point had had enough, and this is the part that it's real, but it sounds like just out of a movie script, orders them to have a paint-off. They need to both paint a picture right there in the courtroom. Margaret paints, and Walter, lo and behold, the timing was just ironic. His arm hurt. Too much for him to hold the brush. Can you believe the timing? So she wins, and as she's leaving, a fan asks her to sign a copy of Walter's coffee table book of pictures. The epilogue says Walter kept insisting that he was the artist for the rest of his life.

He never painted another picture and he died broke as a failed artist. Margaret remarried. She moved back to San Francisco. She opened a gallery. Now the movie does compress things, the timeline. In real life, she left them in 1964. The radio show was around 1970. The courtroom was in 1986. So the years in between were a lot longer than the film lets on. But for more than a decade, Here's this woman with all of that inside of her, standing next to the person getting credit for her work and not advocating for herself.

And I can only guess that she was being accurate about what it would cost to say otherwise. She'd been able to paint the entire time. And what took 30 years was getting her version of the story out in the public and allowed in. And there are still people that believe his version of the story. And that is the place that we left things in the last episode. You've got this accommodator, the person who I mentioned can detect a change in mood from the way that somebody loads a dishwasher and they can begin preparing

an apology before they've even figured out what's happened. It's just second nature to them. And the main takeaway from part one was what happens when you've spent so much time making room for everybody else's experience that you're not even sure how much room there is for yours or what your experience even is. So today, I'm going to follow that question back a little bit further. How or where do we learn that in order to maintain a connection or a relationship with somebody that we care about, we have to be the ones that are willing to adjust ourselves or hold back on what we really think, or possibly be pretty used to not actually knowing what

it is that we think or what it is we believe, because our job has been to make things easier for everybody else. And what is it about relationships that might initially feel so reassuring, so familiar to be with somebody whose way of moving through the world is actually different than ours? And then what happens when the roles that seem to fit so well at the beginning of a relationship start leaving one person doing more and more of the heavy lifting in the world of emotional labor?

And this will address some of you that are maybe trying to decide whether you stay in a relationship or whether you leave a relationship or maybe you're trying to rebuild after betrayal or you're beginning to recognize a pattern and you don't even know what to call it. Just something feels off. So wherever you're listening from today, we're going to get really curious about how you got here without turning your history or how things have unfolded into another reason to blame yourself. Because more than likely, you're pretty good at taking the blame for things

that you probably don't even need to take the blame for. But the truth is, we all find ourselves in relationships for a reason. You might have been drawn to somebody and you weren't sure why, because there may not be exact words for it. And I do often wonder if it's more of a feeling, one that we're not even aware of, a feeling of something that felt familiar. And sometimes what comes with that familiarity might be that you're the one who finds themselves managing other people's emotional experiences at the cost of your own. Maybe that's the familiar feeling. What was the cost of speaking up in the family that you grew up in?

And I'm not even talking about it being met with anger. You may have asked questions and there was always, always an answer. You didn't see modeled. I'm not sure, but that's a great question. Or why don't we figure this out together? So you might have been drawn to somebody who always had answers. Because whether or not the person's answers were correct, that's almost irrelevant if you grew up. And the familiar experience that you had was that you asked something and somebody told you the answer. Always. And you didn't even think to question the answer, even if it went against what you might have thought about the question that was asked.

And I'm talking about situations where there's room to do it safely because if expressing a concern brings threats, intimidation or retaliation, then getting support from somebody who understands abuse is a more useful next step than trying to test the waters, test for safety or figure out a better way to say something. You really don't have to put yourself at risk to practice what we're gonna talk about today. So I just want that to be up front. So to explore what this can look like, imagine a couple and we're calling them Pam and Jim.

And we're going to follow their story from the homes that they grew up in to the conversations that they are having now. So we can see how these patterns might develop and what it could look like to respond differently. They're based, it's accumulation of couples that I've worked with, but everything that I'm going to share today is based in truth and a reality. So for this composite, Pam and Jim, they've been married 25 years. They have three kids. They have a dog who takes a tremendous amount of medications. They have a shared calendar that Pam is in charge of and Jim generally knows about.

But let's jump right in here. He knows that the calendar exists. He has seen it. And he may have even attended the weekly planning meetings where they go over the calendar. But if he misses an event, he is quick to ask, why didn't she remind him? And if she reminds him, he's pretty quick to say, I already knew. And you don't have to be my mom. And when she tries to talk about that, sometimes he agrees, no, you're right. And I'll do better. And sometimes he starts to describe everything that he's got going on, all the heavy load he's carrying. And she eventually finds herself thanking him for how hard he works and he leaves the scene.

Now, their friends would probably tell you that Pam is warm and thoughtful and Jim is funny and he's capable and he's the guy that you call when something needs done. Jim runs a successful company. He serves on a couple of different boards in the area. He's held leadership positions in his church and those are very real and important parts of him. So is the experience that Pam has at home, where trying to explain that she's overwhelmed eventually leads her reassuring him that she does appreciate what he does and the opportunities that's afforded her.

And when she tried to tell her family that she was frustrated, especially her dad, her dad cut her right off and said, hey, he's a heck of a man, Pam. And it's not going to really be good to talk bad about him with all that he does for you. So she gets the sense that, okay, that is not a safe conversation to have. And then to understand how familiar that can feel, we need to go back into, let's start with her childhood. And if you heard a Jack and Jill episode quite a while ago, where I talked about the anxious and the avoidantly attached and their origin story, some of this will sound familiar because I see versions of these scenes in my

office truly on a daily basis. So, Pam grew up with a dad whose mood... Always arrive before he did. So she really did grow up learning to pay attention to the garage door and how hard it opened or closed the car door, his footsteps, and then the first few words out of his mouth. And she became so good at anticipating what that meant for her and for the entire family dynamic. So by the time that she was a little girl, she was learning whether dinner would be a conversation or something that she needed to manage.

To keep it light, to pass the roles, ask dad about his day, tell him I can't even imagine how hard it is that he works, or do I need to perform and tell him how good I did in school today? Her brother would often do a similar thing and, okay, do I need to be the tough guy or somebody that was really good at sports? But basically, people are managing the dinner conversations around dad's mood. We got to see if we can get everybody through the evening comfortably. And Pam really did feel like it was more her job. Sometimes he was home, but emotionally he was typically somewhere else.

In this scenario, Pam remembers bringing home a ribbon. And I recently, when I was cleaning out things after my mom passed away, I did find a box and there were a lot of ribbons. I did not realize what a ribbon-based society we were at some point. So this one echoed true to me, but Pam brought home a ribbon from a science fair. It's one that she had really hoped that he would attend. And he did glance up from the TV and say, oh, that's nice. But he went to all of her brother's games. But he told her, you know, science isn't really my thing. So then she would

take the ribbon, put it upstairs, put it in a drawer and feel disappointed, but then feel bad about being disappointed. Now, he was probably tired or at least he hadn't yelled about anything. And he did say that was nice. And maybe she should have been better at sports. And then sometimes he would come up to her doorway later and he would look upset and she would be terrified trying to figure out, okay, what did I do wrong? But in those moments, it was typically he would say, man, I'm a bad dad. I'm a terrible father. Did I do okay? I didn't even go to your science fair. I didn't look at your ribbon.

You must think I don't even care about you. And in that moment, that's the point where then she knew what to do. No, you're a great dad. And I know you've got a lot going on. And then here is this adult human getting validation from his, I hate to call it that, but emotional support animal in Pam. And then he's saying, do you really think so? Okay, thanks. Hug. And she gives him a hug. He feels better about himself. And she just did another round of, I'm learning how to manage other people's emotions at the extent of mine.

Now, if you did listen to part one, you might remember I talked about Now, shame is the moment that a lot of kids finally get seen. That point where they revert all the way back to I'm a bad person can be the cue to get somebody to say, no, no, you're okay. And my guess is that's what her dad was reaching for in that doorway. He's reaching for the, man, I'm just a bad dad. I'm a bad person. So somebody will tell him he's not, that he's actually a good boy. And the somebody was nine years old. Little Pam did it. She would comfort him. It's okay, dad. I know you're tired. I know you care.

She might even rub his back. And I wonder whether some part of her was hoping, is that a little junior version of projection? I would love for somebody to rub my back. But he would leave feeling reassured. The ribbon would still be in the drawer. They had talked about his fear that he was disappointing her as a dad, but he didn't ask her any questions. They hadn't got any further into her experience of being a disappointed daughter. She wasn't allowed to be disappointed. And then last time also, I got into the concept of co-regulation. Co-regulating as a calm parent, settling a crying baby. In Pam's house on those nights, it was the child that had to co-regulate or

settle the parent's nervous system. And I honestly believe that he genuinely felt bad and he wanted to reconnect, but he doesn't know what to do with his own discomfort, his own distress. And so then it becomes Pam's to settle. So Pam learned something about what happened when she had a feeling. Sometimes it went unnoticed. Sometimes it became the beginning of somebody else's emotional emergency and her mom adjusted around the dad, too. So from inside her home, her experience, that's what she grew up just thinking,

this is how families are. This is what we do. And if you asked Pam's dad, I think he would tell you that he came back and he made everything okay because he did come back, which is good. More like good, but I mean, it's better than somebody not coming back or maybe we even remove better and say it brings different challenges because there's actually some pretty fascinating data on kids and parents. And I suggest that coming back to repair is one of the biggest things separating a secure childhood from more of an insecure one. But I think the assumption with that data is that the repair involves the parent

coming back and taking ownership of their own part, acknowledging what they did instead of offering just a blanket, hey, sorry about that, champ. And then, and I know I'm getting a little bold here, the parent that does the work to avoid putting their kid in the role of the emotional support animal again, that I think is the assumption made about repair. So you can see that there are several steps involved for the parent who at the very least has the awareness that it wasn't cool to dismiss their kids experience and what the trigger was for them later to come back to it. I'm not sure.

But I want to give that parent big props for that, or I think the phrase currently in rotation is give them their flowers. And if you're unfamiliar, Google that or AI it or whatever the kids do these days. But when Pam's dad went back for repair, it turned out to be more of the I feel bad and I'm worried that I was a bad dad kind. The kind where the parent does, in fact, want the kid to tell them it's okay. Maybe it's his own projection of he wanted somebody to tell his nine-year-old self that he's still a good boy and that it's okay when you hurt somebody's feelings.

So it was dad that needed comforting. So Pam got a version of repair where she was the one doing the repair. And I would guess that's part of why decades later, an apology from Jim can leave her thanking him for being so brave to come back and want to fix things, after he may have said things that weren't very helpful to be said in the first place. And gentlemen, as a male human being myself, if I may be so bold, might I recommend that one does something about those bursts of anger, period, end of story.

You may erupt and then ignore it and hope the family forgets, but they carry those experiences with them. And if it happens enough, their minds may try to forget, but their nervous systems continue to react and respond. That distress, it's going to show up in things like IBS, I'm no doctor, connective tissue issues. Sensitive skin outbreaks, turning to unhealthy coping mechanisms, disappearing into their phones, seeking love in all the wrong places. You can learn to deal with your anger, even when you feel misunderstood or slighted or disrespected.

Being understood and seen and respected isn't going to come through anger and fear. You'll get a performative version of those things, which does not build long-term connection. And I can't help turning to humor here for a very brief moment. I remember a friend whose clip went viral and they were talking about going to therapy as a young adult and having their parents pay for it because they had grown up hearing their parents say, if you broke it, you pay for it. And I wish I had the sound effects to insert snare drum there. And maybe by the time I put this on YouTube, I will figure that out. But back to Pam, though, the lesson that she carried forward might have sounded

something like if I pay close enough attention, I can help keep us connected. If somebody pulls away, I should find out what I did. My feelings may be difficult for other people, so I better make sure that they are OK before I even think to bring up mine. And even then, they will be run through a filter. So being needed gave her a job that she knew how to do. And sometimes that was the closest thing that she had to feeling secure. Or that's what it felt like to be secure to her. That can resemble an anxiously attached person or an anxious attachment pattern

where uncertainty about connection leads somebody to watch closely for signs of distance and to work really hard to restore closeness. And I'm describing a pattern and people can respond differently across relationships and over time. But it is a pattern that I often see and one that I am quite familiar with myself. A quick text reply or willingness to volunteer doesn't necessarily tell us somebody's attachment history. But what matters here is that Pam believes that she has to do all the work to keep a relationship available to her. And then what happens inside her when she can't. From the outside,

it looks pretty darn impressive. It can look like she's competent. She's thoughtful. She remembers things. She notices who needs help. She may have been called an old soul when she was still young enough to need somebody to remind her to brush her teeth, and I think this is like learning a second language from the time you're little she's fluent she isn't translating she's simply responding so by the time she's 12 she has. Far more than the 10,000 hours of practice of managing other people's emotions, technically making her an expert. So ideally, at that point, she'd be an expert in, I don't know, rollerblading, a cool video game, making get ready with me videos,

instead of managing an adult's emotional experience of the world. So when so much of her attention goes toward figuring out how to survive, she's most likely not spending that time developing her own opinions about the latest teeny bop band or fashion trend. I watched this back when I worked or did some therapy with teenagers. You'd ask a question and they would either immediately reply with an opinion or you could see it in their eyes as they kind of locked in trying to figure out what were they supposed to say? What answer were you looking for? I remember literally playing Jenga when I was doing kid therapy in my practicum in grad school and either having a kid try to beat me.

Like no one's been beat before or one that I remember this kid at one point that essentially purposely bumped the Jenga tower. Because I think that he was afraid to win. And I still remember to this day of, oh, I don't think he was allowed to win. I think he had to let his parents win in Jenga. So back to Pam, her opinion was essentially, whatever you need it to be, I will make it my opinion. Now, my favorite band, AJR, has a song called 2085. The lyrics are powerful. And I will quote a few here because I think that they're

applicable. At one point, they say, I smile when I cry to hide what I felt. I'm doing fine. Speak for yourself I should have just asked for help. Only for a little kid, I don't even know if they know that they need help because that is what it feels like to be them in their home. It's familiar. Another part of the song says, go tell your grandson to go tell his grandson you don't have to try so hard, you know, because I spent my whole life trying to be so liked that only made him hate me more. And that line speaks to me. That is, it's when one is desperately trying to figure out who they think that they are supposed to be when eventually they're

going to get it wrong because it's a guessing game. And over time, and I wonder if we all know or experience certain personality types where bless their heart, but you just want them to tell you what they think rather than play in the middle of the road all the time. Or you can watch them change their mind at the drop of a hat if you happen to change yours. Now, toward the end of the song, they sing, did I make you proud that I screwed this up? Sing with me loud. It's all that I've got to know if I did or not. Talk about somebody living their life for others and understanding that all

you have to know to know if you did your best was if somebody else let you know that you made them proud. How about figuring out your own self? Make yourself proud. And it sounds probably therapist cliched, sounds great, maybe, but how? How do you make yourself proud? The end of the song is deep, and I'm talking Mariana Trench level deep. They sing, I'd hate to have to die before I get my head together. And then they sing this haunting line, you've got to get better, you're all that I've got. Don't take forever, you're not here for long.

You've got to get better, you're all that I've got. And then here's why I brought this into this episode. This line, this is the one that I was thinking about. I wish I was me, whoever that is. I could just be and not give a crap. Only replace the explicit word, but I don't want to check the explicit box. And then, hey, I'll be whatever makes you a fan because I don't know who the heck I am. And then they end with, and I think it's too late to figure this out. If I could be me, I would have been it by now. So if this is me, which that alone, If I could have been me,

I would have figured it out by now. So if who I am is the person that is being whoever everyone else needs me to be. So if this is me, then I'll do my best. I'll take all the crap so you never have to. You can be you and I'll be the rest. Yeah, maybe that's who the heck I am. That is, it's powerful. And it's also unfortunate because I think that so many people that I work with are essentially going through life thinking, I can be whoever you need me to be. And maybe that's who I am. And I can be me so you can be you.

And that way I never have to figure out who I am. And then they end by saying, you've got to get better. You're all that I've got. Don't take forever. You're not here for long. And then it says it again. You've got to get better. You're all that I've got. Don't take forever. You're not here for long. And then it goes from you're all that I have to then one line, I've got to get better. I'm all that I've got for two or three minutes and then I'm gone and the song ends and it just brings me to tears. Because I remember the first time that I caught that change in the lyric that

you got to get better. You're all that I've got. Basically saying you're the one that's going to help me understand who I am. And then almost as if it's too late figuring out, wait a minute, I got to get better because I'm all that I have. It is time to figure yourself out. It is game changing to learn that what if my job isn't to manage other people's emotions and to try and make everyone else happy. A friend once described accommodating as giving her a sense of control. And I've thought about that a lot too, because I think it speaks to a need that

we do have to try and make sense of things. If I can be easy enough and useful enough and attentive enough, maybe I can keep connection from disappearing. And that is an understandable hope, especially for a kid who had very little power over what happens next. And part of what I shared in the last episode is that it also, it took me well into my career as a therapist to recognize how familiar that job was in my relationship with my mom. I knew I cared or I believed I cared, whatever the definition of caring was. And I still wonder at times whether it was more that this was what I did.

And then I told myself the story that, no, I must have cared because that's what it means to care. The self-sacrifice. What if it was just the familiar? What if it was simply what I knew to do? But then there I was still trying to prove I cared when she would get upset because caring, as it had been modeled for me, meant stuffing your own feelings and emotions down to the very bottom, showing up, and then giving that upset person whatever they needed to no longer be upset. It really does feel like you're trying to appease a toddler. No, buddy, it's okay. It's okay. You don't have to do that. I'm sorry.

And I can't even say that I was even remotely aware of the mental and physical toll that it took on my psyche, on my body, because it was what I knew to do. That's what it felt like to be me. And then when you start down the differentiation journey of learning who you are through your relationships and you begin stepping out of the familiar role that you play, people don't make you cookies. You don't get a trophy. Oh, no. They tell you that you seem different, that you seem like you don't care anymore because you're stepping out of the familiar role in the relationship,

which was sacrificing your own needs and managing everyone else's emotions, just putting your head down and going back out to plow the field, doing whatever it took. And then if you finally spoke up and wanted your needs met, people would. They knew the buttons to push to, geez, oh gosh, calm down. You seem like, what are you, you seem kind of upset right now. And if you were that constant accommodator or people pleaser, then the reaction is, oh my gosh, I didn't, sorry, I didn't even know I was doing that. But over time with my mom, I could notice that she was upset while also noticing

my discomfort and my immediate pull to get rid of that discomfort by easing her distress. The whole concept of differentiation helped me notice the difference between caring about her experience and needing her to feel better before I was allowed to feel better. Now, sometimes that required legitimate boundaries, not ultimatums. Hey, you can't talk to me that way because, oh, they can. And now they know that that matters. But the boundary is a me thing. If she is talking to me that way, then I need to take a break. And there were times where I left early when I was trying to help.

But I learned I could be unsettled, concerned, or sad and still feel steady in who I was. And it took practice. And apparently, I needed considerably more than one inspirational quote to get there. Now, let's spend a little time with our guy, Jim. Jim. Grew up in a quieter house, but that quiet could be just as hard to navigate because picture Jim at 10 coming home from a baseball game where he'd struck out a couple of times, to be fair, the pitcher for the other team already was shaving. And I think he pulled up to the game in a Camaro listening to 70s hair bands,

but Jim holds it together until he gets to the kitchen. And then that's when tears come. And his mom says, what's wrong with you? It's a game. Why do you have to be such a baby? Why do you make everything such a big deal? And that is what I hear people talk about, that their parents did talk to them that way. His mom said, try caring for you guys all day. That's something to cry about. Afterward, there's a stretch of clip dancers and emotional distance. Jim apologizes under his breath, and unlike Pam, he doesn't try to make it better. He disappears. Dinner is still on the table. People still go to work and school,

but Jim senses that something about him needs correcting, and he's supposed to figure out what it is. So apparently, striking out twice in front of the girl watching the game, the one in his math class who almost grazed his shoulder once when they were getting on the bus for a field trip, meaning she obviously wanted to get married. Apparently, that wasn't a big deal, according to his mom. There was no curiosity about his experience. It was just, that's not a big deal. Get over it. I don't know what you're crying about. And here he thought it was a big deal. Turns out his feelings were, once again, incorrect. So far, the only time he could remember his feelings being correct was when

he was telling his mom what a great cook she was, or what an amazing student she sounded like she had been at his age, and what a complete buffoon he was by comparison. Now, his dad had his own ways of dealing with the tension at home. He tended to meet difficult moments with a joke and a subject change. And humor helped his dad tolerate the discomfort at home. And even though he was Jim's dad, Jim did think that he was pretty funny. But on the occasions when Jim couldn't hold in a laugh at something his dad said, oh, his mom would turn to him and say, seriously, you think that's funny? Your dad's not funny. He's ridiculous. He's immature.

And once again, apparently even Jim's sense of humor was incorrect. All the while, he's learning that he needs somebody else to tell him how he feels. And when somebody asks something of him, it's typically because he did something wrong. So words coming toward him are starting to land as criticism and accusations on a regular basis. And better yet, from Jim's perspective, there isn't much point in trying to make sense of what happened in his home because by now he has so much data. And what he can make of that data is that his feelings and emotions are incorrect. Stuff them.

And then somebody else can tell you which ones are correct and when they're welcome to be expressed. Meanwhile, give whatever the dust up was a day or two or three and things return to normal. Nobody comes back to the conversation. There's that complete lack of repair, which differed from Pam's dad's attempt at repair. Jim isn't just learning this. He's embodying it. He's integrating it. He's feeling it. He's operating from a default setting that says, keep your feelings contained. Work it out yourself. You're alone in this. If somebody's unhappy with you.

Okay, maybe try to explain it quickly and see whether you can get the situation settled. If not, retreat, go back into your shell. Don't even think about coming out until the coast is clear. It's a survival instinct. And then act as if nothing ever happened. Nothing to see here. Keep it moving. So he becomes really good at explaining. And then he discovers something else. The thing that does get him noticed and at the very least keeps him from being abandoned is achievement. That gets a response. And he knows how to recognize that. Teachers like him. Coaches give him responsibility. Later, people at work and

at church appreciate his effort. And they tell him he's a good boy. So chasing validation and approval more and more becomes the breath of life for Jim. It becomes the energy he needs to live. Validation and approval. When there's a severe deficit, can also land in a place that's been hungry for it for such a long time. And at this point, welcome to sort of a version of the trauma bond. The intermittent reinforcement that I talked about at the top of the hour with the Arizona weather.

And now I realize that was maybe not the greatest moment for humor because people experiencing trauma bonds, it's not very funny because it's the person who provides you with the punishment is also the one who can potentially give you the reward. And so now the game is on to try to get that bump of a reward. He may keep hoping the next achievement will help him feel secure in who he is. But I wonder if he's just chasing another little shot of hope of, hey, you're okay, champ. And I work with a lot of people that struggle with this. And by this or this type of person, I mean, I even mean to a point,

the me types seeking validation to the point of achieving even a modicum of, I will air quote, success only to find out, nope, that doesn't quite fill the bottomless pit of validation in my soul. You know, maybe another 100,000 podcast downloads, another viral video on Instagram or TikTok, a new pair of running shoes. And so many people I'm working with have their own versions of this. Maybe it's the next promotion or a bigger house or a bigger car or another leadership role at church, another vacation that he can give his family. Then he gets home and Pam wants to talk about how disconnected she feels.

Now, he has been useful and admired all day at work, chasing the validation, chasing the next hit. And now he's in a conversation that he doesn't know how to handle, being told to him he's not enough. And then what comes out is, you know, it'd be nice to get a little credit for this vacation. And then underneath that, there might be a much more vulnerable question that he's not even aware of. Do you see how hard I'm trying? Do I matter to you? I'm not about to say it out loud because thank you, mother, that will absolutely get criticized. Some of Jim's responses resemble then an avoidant attachment strategy where

distance and self-reliance or becoming a human doing can feel so much more manageable than sharing your emotions or depending on the emotions of somebody else. Of saying anything at all. And that doesn't mean that avoidant attachment causes, someone to be dishonest or that men occupy one role and women the other, but I'm using Pam and Jim to follow a particular pattern. And I work with people in a variety of relationships who recognize themselves on either side of this anxious and avoidant attachment style. I am by far more anxiously attached. I have noticed when I, especially when

I speak to men's groups, that a large percentage of the men that I interact with are more avoidantly attached. And what I also think is fascinating is I think it helps to notice that Pam and Jim both answered the same question, but it's a different answer, but it's understandable based on how they're showing up in the relationship. Because when you hear the full context of their experience, it makes more sense that that question is, what happens in this house when I have a feeling, an emotion, or heaven forbid, a need or a want? Because a kid just doesn't ask it in words. They're just running these little

experiments a few thousand times, and they're keeping whatever works, whatever keeps them alive. It's adaptive. It's survival. And what it's not allowing the person to do is simply to be, to exist. And they're not being asked genuinely curious questions about their experiences where there isn't a wrong answer. So they are wired to view the question as criticism, and there is a wrong answer. And that means there's a right answer. So they have to figure it out. Or sometimes if they don't say anything, they will be told the answer that they should have thought. So in Pam's house, a feeling of her own tended to go one of two ways.

Either nobody notices it or it turned into somebody else's emergency that then she needed to handle. So she worked out pretty reasonably that feelings in general are a job, something to be fixed or managed. If something sad shows up in the room, somebody's got to take care of it ASAP. Get that sadness out of here stat. And she's good at that. And being good at it is one way she feels close to her dad. And let me add air quotes there because that's what closeness looked like in her family. So she moves toward. She reads the room. And you know what?

If you think about it, she's AI before AI was a thing. She's a large, I don't like the way that was starting to sound. Her behavior sounds like the description of a large language model and that she anticipates what the next word is going to be. So she laughs or she doesn't. She explains why her little brother was being rude while kicking him under the table and recognizing in that very moment that she will not be doing her homework tonight. She'll need to sit with him and listen to how mean mom and dad are until he's calm, because if he's not calm, then it's going to impact the entire family system. So Pam's learned that closeness is something she earns by paying attention.

She is desperately trying to figure out how to control the environment for safety and trying to maintain that control can bring feelings of anxiety and become part maybe even of the origin story of things like OCD or perfectionism and even more. In Jim's house, feelings tend to get corrected and he cries in the kitchen. And then that message is that something about him needs to be fixed. And then there's a stretch of quiet and then it blows over and nobody comes back to it. So he worked out also pretty reasonably that a feeling is a liability. Plus, it's inherently wrong unless somebody's told you which emotion to have

and when you're allowed to have it. You don't realize it yet, but that game, Jim, is rigged. You'll hear later that you didn't show emotion at a tender moment in a movie or at your grandma's funeral. And then you'll feel bad about that, but not too bad. Because remember, if you show that you feel bad. You're going to be told that you don't, well, you don't need to feel bad. I just was letting you know. Can't you take a little criticism? So Jim learned that the safest place to have a feeling or an emotion is buried deep down, way deep down to the point where he couldn't excavate it if he had to. So even when somebody tries to get him to talk, he can wait him out all day.

It's what he do. Now, if you do want to be close to people, even though you're not entirely sure why someone would want to be, then you need to be useful and impressive. Because approval that comes with a visible scoreboard like cars, abs, money, status, technically can't be used against you, or at least you're kind of counting on that. But, oh, just you wait until you hit the upper rungs of the social and corporate ladder. And that's a topic for my men's emotional architects group in a future podcast. So he moves away, or more accurately, he moves toward achievement,

which from the inside can feel like the same thing as connection. And I am quite confident that neither Pam nor Jim has experienced this as a decision. It's more like a thermostat setting where you can't get the app to load. So you're stuck with a particular temperature. Sometimes 70 is great and sometimes it's too cold. But by the time they're 12, Pam's nervous system is set to watch closely and move in, manage, appease, and sacrifice. And Jim's is set to hold still, turn inward, wait till the. So both of those settings fit the houses that they were in. How do we know?

Because they worked. Because Jim and Pam are alive. Thank you, inner children. You did good. But now, how about we let the big kids take over with the understanding that they're actually just little versions of you wearing larger sizes of, most likely, the same style of clothing. This is why I start from a place of we are all emotionally mature, all of us. Those little kid versions of us did great. And that's what I would love for you to remind yourself. You did it, champ. Let's go from surviving, though, now to thriving. And I know, buddy, I know you don't know what that even looks like. What used to sound scary, that nobody is going to rescue you,

but you is eventually going to be one of the greatest things that you'll ever come to understand, that nobody is going to rescue you, but you. Welcome to the first day of school for healing your inner child. And this is why some adults tell me about the things that they still like to do or that they consider immature and how they worry about being found out. Everything from literal drinking out of juice boxes to picking their noses. And I'm talking about getting up in there knuckle deep. I mean, we've all seen the guy at the stoplight and they don't just flick those bad boys and I'll just kind of leave it at that.

Or they're still playing games on their phone in between buying and selling companies. No judgment, maybe a little bit with the booger thing. I want to take a minute for a real live commercial break and talk to you about something I'm pretty excited about. And I opened up with this at the beginning of the show and it is hydration. So this episode is brought to you by Good Nutrition. Go to thegoodnutrition.com, use coupon code virtualcouch, all one word. For 15% off your entire order. Shipping is free. And if you're watching your sodium, check with your doctor first. Now. Why Good Nutrition's electrolyte drink? It's story time.

When I was in my mid-20s and I was working in the computer industry, and this is a very true story, I'd just run my first or maybe my second marathon. And I met an older guy at a trade show. And by older, I realized younger than I am now. But I was in my 20s and at that time, 40 was old. Now, if I have a client sitting across from me who says they're 40, I now have to suppress an existential crisis that I think were essentially BFFs, but they're probably looking at me like their dad or their grandpa. but I digress. But this guy at the trade show had run a lot in his life. He'd had kidney stones more than once, something I now look back at and I find odd that he brought

up that early in our first conversation at a computer trade show. But I do remember him looking at me very intensely and saying in a very dramatic tone that whatever I did, stay hydrated. And then he described what passing a kidney stone is like for a man and a level of detail that I'm still recovering from some 30 years later. Now, I have no idea if the science of that is true or if it's that simple, but it never left me. And add to that a book an ultra running friend gave me years ago on my birthday, which I thought was a pretty crummy birthday gift at the time. But I now realize some 20 plus years later, that is something I still have on my shelf.

So sorry, Jeffrey, my bad. If I look less than thrilled when I opened it, the book is called You're Not Sick, You're Thirsty. Now add something. Two plus years of my 30 years of running now, as I mentioned previously, on the face of the sun or the Arizona heat. And again, by Arizona law, I'm required to say, but it's a dry heat. And I may have a slightly unhealthy relationship with hydration. I sweat like a horse. And I know the phrase is commonly sweat like a pig, but I looked it up and then, trust me, 30 minutes of Google searches later, where the research had me looking

up gestation periods for the deep sea octopus, which is 53 months, by the way. Talk about a failure to launch. But it turns out that pigs barely sweat at all. So I've been insulting pigs for years. So pigs, I owe you an apology. But horses, watch out because I'm coming for you. And it turns out to be your sweaty selves. But finding water I want to drink has been a life quest. And good nutrition is what I drink now. Before, during, and after runs as well as in the sauna. And I even routinely sprinkle some of it on yogurt in the morning. And it's my version of gourmet. And it really is good.

It has 1,000 milligrams of sodium, zero sugar, no artificial sweeteners. They sent me a pineapple mango and after trying it, I bought the starter trio with my own money so I could tell you that I really like it and that I had some skin in the game, so to speak. And I've actually ordered another pack and I'm only remembering now that I think they maybe said they would send me more if I do an ad. But go to thegoodnutrition.com, use code virtualcouch, all one word for 15% off your entire order. Shipping is free and if you're watching your sodium, check with your doctor first. So there's some research behind why these settings stick with us from childhood.

And if you're keeping track, I'm sure we're starting to push double digits in my use of the word familiar because we know what we know because we know it. That's part of what the familiar is. And I'm going to talk about it a lot. That's what we saw, we felt, and experienced, whether or not we recognized it as something of significance. It can be as simple as growing up in a home where people take their shoes off every single time they walk inside. If that was what was done, period, end of story, and it was never challenged or even explained, everybody just did it. Then that becomes part of what it feels like to be in your family.

If your parents' friends came over and questioned it and you watched your parents not even remotely act put out when they insisted, oh yeah, it's a rule, then being part of your family just meant you take your shoes off when you go inside. You could have just gotten your butt kicked in a fight with a bully at the park and you run in with a fat bloody lip and your mom and dad come running in from the den and they're halfway through asking what happened when one says, I'll grab ice for his lips and the other says, I'll get his shoes off. Ridiculous, you might think, and that is absolutely okay to think. Thank you. But it's also a very real story, one that a client and I came back to quite

a while later when he was beginning to connect some of his OCD behaviors around germs and floors with his earlier experiences. But my point is that kids borrow their parents' nervous systems before they build their own. John Bowlby, who gave us attachment theory, called it having a safe haven, somebody to come to when you're upset and a secure base, somebody steady enough and reliable enough that you can go out and explore what it feels like to be you and know you can come back to this secure home base. A child who regularly experiences that safe haven, that secure base, and that steady person gradually embodies or integrates that steadiness within

themselves. It becomes part of who they are. They grew up without thinking that it's their responsibility to manage another person's emotions, and they provide steadiness and calm to those around them. And I will maintain that I don't think very many of us, dare I say any of us, grew up with that consistently securely attached parent or parents because it just wasn't discussed that openly. We're talking about feelings and emotions. And unless it was consistently modeled, it often takes going through a tremendous amount of trauma, things in life, difficult life experiences,

that kind of thing to even begin asking, is there another way to do this? That takes introspection, self-confrontation. That awareness requires a deep desire to look inward. And I'm not talking about the what's wrong with me version of introspection. I mean something more like, why do I care about this thing? And why do I react this way? And not again, from a place of something I'm doing is wrong, but what does it do for me? What is it serving me? Or what am I trying to avoid? What is it about this situation or that person that feels threatening to me that I'm reacting to?

Because at that point, you can start your own hero's journey. When you become aware of how relationships impact you and you begin exploring your experience as a you thing. That's when the work really starts to get interesting. People often think that awareness is going to bring with it a solution or unending bouts of joy. But awareness doesn't even signify the middle part of the journey. Oh, no, it's more like, now that I'm aware, now let the games begin.

Because now that you're aware, now you start to realize, oh, I don't know what I'm doing or what to do next. And then even when you start doing something different, it will challenge, dare I say, threaten the homeostasis in your current relationships, you and your partner, you and your kids, you and your church community, whether you know it or not, you're very used to a certain pattern of interaction. It's familiar, like you have your own dance of emotions. I get to see it hour after hour, day after day. I get to play a role in each client and each couple's dance. And that's yet another reason I think therapy is powerful. why it works when

someone comes in curious about themselves, their patterns, their relationships, and how they got to where they are. They're expressing all of that to somebody who hopefully has the knowledge and enough experience to bring awareness to those patterns, not just out in the wild, but even in the room, in the therapy room, in a safe enough way that they can begin to step back and explore. You can start to view yourself in the context of that moment, that relationship, that situation, and give yourself some grace as you start to recognize, oh, this is what I'm doing. This is what I was trying to achieve. This is what I was hoping the other person might do, even the therapist, based on my projection of what I think they must

be thinking, what they believe, et cetera, et cetera, et cetera. That's one of the most beautiful things about therapy, when somebody has that courage to be known, to express themselves, to say, what do you mean by that? Or, okay, when you just said that, Mr. Therapist or Mrs. Therapist, this is where I went with that. There are so many variables, and it becomes so fascinating to explore who you are when you can slow things down and begin to look at yourself with compassion and grace as somebody who did what they did to survive and it worked. You're here. And again, you can thank your inner child. They did great. And now it's time to let that bigger version of you take the wheel because now

you can actually reach the pedals. They may not know where to go next, but they know how to read a map or how to plug words into their map app. And then they can start to drive. Or if they're in a fully autonomous car, they can tell it where to go and sit back and play on their phone. But Pam borrowed a nervous system that needed her to constantly play the role of manager to other people's nervous systems, which included settling an entire room at the expense of her own needs and wants and opinions and desires. And she was good at it. Jim had one available for math and baseball. His nervous system allowed him to perform and achieve external accomplishments

in the hope that somebody would say, attaboy, good job. But instead, he continually received either nothing in return or reminders that he still struck out after those two home runs. And that a 94% on the math test is how much less than 100? See, you can do math. So why on earth did you miss two questions? I expect better from you, and you should expect better from yourself. Dang it, thought Jim. I was actually pretty happy because the teacher told me that I continually break the curve that nobody else got above an 80. So I was actually feeling good, but there it is. My feelings were apparently wrong. I guess I'm glad my parents corrected me and let me know that I shouldn't

feel good about anything less than perfect. Got it. Imprint that into Jim's little nervous system. And what it feels like to be him is to expect criticism, even when he does something really good. And when he expresses emotions, then absolutely expect the criticism. The message becomes your emotions are incorrect and you need somebody else to tell you when they're allowed and which ones you may express. And if you perform well enough and don't express a need, maybe then people will, naturally appreciate you, tell you that you did a great job and give you what you need. Probably not. You'll probably still find out that you could have done better.

You won't have to say or feel anything. You can just do and do and do. So isn't that amazing though, when you slow it down, that Pam and Jim actually want similar things and they have no idea what those things are or how to get them. They want to be seen. They want to be considered without being rejected. They want praise and validation and love without having to even ask for it, especially not to beg for it. But they have no idea what that even feels like or how to receive those things in a healthy way because they didn't receive them consistently in a healthy way. They received scraps of validation when they went all the way into the depths of shame.

Finally, somebody would notice them and use a decently soft tone, maybe even give them a hug, probably a side hug, and tell them that they weren't bad. They were just a big disappointment. Now go do better so I won't have to make you feel bad again. Like, that's crazy. And before that last tangent, when quoting Bowlby, I said steady enough and reliably enough because the research is pretty clear that perfection has nothing to do with this. Ed Tronick, who studied parents and infants for decades, found that even well-attuned parents and babies are still out of sync a surprising amount of the time.

And I love knowing that because you could do everything as best as you can and you're still interacting with another nervous system, another human, even the tiny ones that smell okay. What predicts security is whether somebody comes back and repairs. And in Jim's house, nobody came back. Jim spent days in silence trying to make sense of what happened in ways only a little kid can, which eventually lands in the, I'm the problem. And in Pam's house, what we went through there, when somebody did come back for repair, the repair ran in one direction, back toward the parent. And it was Pam's responsibility. In other words, I am the problem.

In Jim's home, I am the problem. In Pam's home, I am the problem. There's a familiar idea. There's a through line starting to be established. And putting this as simply, and humanly as possible, Jim's version of the I am a problem, I am the problem, is lived as so hunker down, wait out the storm, this too shall pass, and live to fight another day. So for Jim, life becomes a constant checklist of things to do that he thinks will make everybody okay. When he gets into a relationship, if the person he's with asks for something from him, expressing what they really need, criticism.

Then the familiar programming kicks in, weather the storm, get out of discomfort, dump the anger or frustration back onto his partner because it feels like an attack. Pam, the anxiously attached partner, that's familiar. If she expresses a need, a want, or desire, and Jim, the avoidantly attached partner, views it as criticism, rather than meeting it with curiosity, he'll tell Pam how hard it is to hear from her, how she must not understand, how she comes across, and she knows that pattern well. She'll apologize and she'll get to work. She'll remember that feeling that she needs to do more, work more, say less, and make sure everybody else is okay.

In that exchange, Jim was able to get out of the discomfort, but I don't think he's continuing to think about what Pam asked for because that was not his survival strategy when he was young. His parents might have said, go think about what you did, but he's in there not thinking about that. He'll now escape into his inner world, his checklist, his phone, his shows, his YouTube, his doing things for everybody else, the checklist things that he can do. And Pam's version of the, I am the problem is lived as, so therefore I better do everything I can to fix everybody around me and make everybody else comfortable.

Then not only will they all be okay, but I'll be okay because I'm only okay if everybody else is okay. But over time, especially in the relationship with Jim, when the anxiously attached partner is with the avoidantly attached partner, the more they're unable to discuss what they would actually like. If they're even able to identify what that is, the harder they try to fix the issue through self-sacrifice. Eventually, they come to a point where they stop caring. Their own body is trying to tell them enough is enough. The familiar message becomes, the harder you try to be seen, the more of a problem you become.

It's the pattern from your childhood. And the avoidantly attached partner is running a similar story. The more somebody asks of you, the more you shut down. So when the anxious and the avoidant partner get together, when they partner up, it's for a reason. And so you can heal those childhood adaptations that kept you alive. You couldn't heal them in your home. They occurred because of your home. And that's from an acceptance doesn't mean apathy. It means to take in without defense because now we can do something about it. Concept. Bless their heart. They were modeling. They were following what they learned.

But I worry that what I see so often is that the anxious partner pursues and the avoidant partner withdraws. The avoidant partner viewing the anxious partner's request as criticism shuts down further, goes quiet or silent, or puts it back on the anxious partner. They're out of the hot seat, and the anxious partner will continue trying to figure out how to fix it. And so often, the avoidant partner's version of fixing it is an adult version of the game Kick the Can. They're incredibly good at kicking the can down the road with good intentions to work on things later. But later is now.

The anxiously attached people that I work with, and I include myself in that group, can eventually learn to soothe themselves, ask for things in the relationship from a place of calm, confident, from a place of desire for their partner, from choosing themselves and now choosing their partner for the relationship. They're still unsure though what it will look like moving forward, but they have finally chosen themselves. And now they're choosing you, the avoidantly attached person to explore life together. But I worry that so many of the avoidantly attached people I work with eventually learn to make the reassuring mouth sound that appeases their partner and gets them out of the moment.

And then they believe themselves in those moments that they will do the work. They do want to fix things, but there's not a lot written about how the avoidantly attached partner, the one whose survival is dependent on waiting out the storm and living to fight another day, learns to start thinking about something that they're not thinking about. Because thinking about it when they were young wasn't helpful. It only led to the message that you're not doing it right, whatever it was. This is where I want to encourage the avoidantly attached partners listening to do a little self-reflection and ask themselves, am I making promises in the relationship?

And do I follow through on them? What work am I doing? And what would it look like to share that with my partner? Sharing that work can be healing. And to the anxiously attached folks, you're not off the hook either. Sure, you can become aware. You can recognize your reach for certainty. Are we okay? Yeah. Okay, cool. But then five minutes later, not sure we're okay. You would tell me though, right? Yeah. Okay, cool. It's been another 10 minutes. You're not jumping up and down and adoring me. So I'm guessing things are really bad. Am I right? Or they are now. Now they're bad because I keep pushing you? I knew it. Why didn't you tell me that things weren't going okay?

So we can do our own self-check. Why am I wanting reassurance? What if I'm feeling okay, but my spouse just looks like they smelled curdled milk and a healthy relationship I can ask. And if they tell me they're fine, even though their face doesn't seem to agree, I need to begin learning how to be okay with myself, even when my partner doesn't appear to be okay. It's called self-validated intimacy. I can be okay, even if they aren't okay. I would love to share experiences and hopes and dreams and even frustrations, approaching things as us versus the world, us versus the problem, rather than me versus you.

But there's our emotionally immature self appearing yet again, unsure what to do with our own emotions. So let's make them somebody else's responsibility. Because then if I feel good, they're happy too. If I don't feel good, I can blame it on them too. All of this is so incredibly normal. And even if it's hard to see in yourself, I will allow you for now to at least start recognizing the moments when you've seen this right now in others, in your partner. I used to call that to don't listen with your elbow. Hey, you hear what he's

saying? But right now, sure, to listen a little bit with your elbow. But ultimately, the goal is to look inward so you can heal outward. In part one, I talked about the instruction manual for the relationship, the one that shows up before you've even decided what you need. And I'm not saying it's an instruction manual that will serve you productively for your entire life. It's more of a survival manual at first. I'm talking about the one that Dr. Frankenstein would have written after he created the monster, essentially saying, I tried my best. It's alive. Here's how it works. But it's on you to make any tenement improvements.

Bowlby had a name for that. He called it the internal working model. And I think of it more like a pair of glasses with their own unique tint. You will see everything through those lenses. Or if we're sticking with the instruction manual idea, PAMs might say something like, connection will be uncertain and ever changing, and you'll have to stay vigilant to secure it. You can take your foot off the gas of trying to figure out how to maintain it. The rules will change. There are no guarantees, and it's your fault if you lose connection. And then gyms might say, connection is risky. It's going to feel like an attack where you're fighting for your life, and you'll actually do best if you don't

say much and you don't need much. And internally, you'll still feel like you're in danger of being alone, which will feel like an existential crisis. But to the outside world, you will appear cold, maybe calm, aloof, distant, and uncaring. But don't try to explain that to anybody because again, anything that they say next will come across to you as aggressive and dismissive. Neither of them would put it that way. They would just tell you, Pam is thoughtful, fun, sometimes a handful. Jim is chill, more calm, a real thinker, self-sufficient, and you never quite know what's going on in his head.

Also known as Pam is a hoot and you know Jim, Jim's Jim. So now the quest is to find each other subconsciously. So you can heal the childhood wounds that you aren't even aware of, the ones that are essentially the air you breathe and that you don't know how to heal. So let me bring this into the present for a second, because I don't think that one needs a science fair ribbon to recognize one's self in this pattern. If you're more like Pam, you probably know or think you know what every word of a text from your spouse really means. You can tell your spouse's mood from the way that they're lying in bed while they're still asleep.

You reread a text that you're about to send over and over again to check the tone. And when somebody goes quiet, the first place your mind goes is what you did. And an unanswered message is a problem that you need to solve because they're obviously very angry. Quick side note on projection, because if you don't text somebody back, it's often because you want them to know you're frustrated. So therefore, that must be what they're doing too. If you're more like Jim, you can tell me exactly what you got done this week and you'd have a hard time telling me what you felt on Tuesday. I'm fine comes out before you've checked followed by how about you because if

I can get them to talk about themselves then I'm out of the hot seat when a hard conversation ends because the other person gave up you notice something that feels a lot like relief and you don't love what that says about you. And you're at your best when the expectations are written down or somebody tells you exactly what they need or what you need to do because you can do it and be done and subconsciously you can still harbor resentment if you did it and they aren't happy because well you did what they asked you to do. So if you recognize yourself in either of those, I would offer you are a human going through life.

You were responding accurately to the house you grew up in. And the question now is whether those settings fit the house you currently live in or the relationship that you're in. And they may have until they no longer did until a second and often a third or fourth and fifth nervous system is added, pets and kids included. And let me go back and set the table even more. Now. Picture the two of them meeting in college. Jim has recently returned from a two-year Latter-day Saint mission in South America. And we'll get to more of why that's important in part three, I realize.

But near the end of his service, a leader that he respected told him he had a special future in church leadership. He was one of the chosen few and that God would be disappointed in him if he achieved anything less than a successful career, a beautiful wife, lots of kids and positions of authority in the church leadership. That's all. No pressure for Jim. But for a young man who lacked a lot of parental support, who had felt criticized at every turn as a kid and learned to disappear, he actually felt a sense of purpose. And what his mission president said, he had not realized how truly special he was. And I can promise you, and I'm not trying to say that any of this was bad

or good. It just was what happened. If I was pushed to judge, I think it allowed Jim to go through a period of growth that he wouldn't have discovered had he not had this experience. We get our sense of self from validation, from external validation of others, or until if we ever learn to be okay with ourselves as we are. That's the true hero's journey. So the church in this situation helped Jim grab hold of a purpose and meaning and gave him a source of validation that he had never had before. Now, was it setting the bar too high? Maybe. We'll have to stay tuned to see

how someone's life unfolds because for Jim at that time, it simply was. It was the bar. It was validation and he wanted more. And he found approval through doing well, for achieving, for doing. Do more, get praise, do better, get validation. Rinse, lather, repeat when one still has hair. For a young man whose instruction manual says approval comes with a scoreboard, it's a very specific kind of fuel. He comes home with a sense of direction, a plan, and people telling him he's special. He's going places. Even now, he watched his mom and dad have a little spring in their step at his homecoming.

He looked sharp, spoke a different language, and people were telling them that they did a great job raising Jim because look what Jim did. So here are two people in college now, Jim and Pam, neither of them necessarily aware of their childhood and how it's subconsciously driving them toward each other. Pam dates a fair amount of guys and so many of them seem clingy and they talk a big talk and they try desperately to impress her and they tell her how pretty she is and they text her and she texts back and then they don't text again for a while. And she finds a deep connection early with one guy and it ends abruptly and

another and another. And she seems to keep running into guys where relationships seem like a year is packed into a very long weekend. Things seem to be going so good until that person drops off the face of the earth. They ghost her sometimes. And it seems like they pursue, pursue, pursue, and then sometimes they push past a boundary or two, and then when they do, they disappear. So to make matters even worse, she continually wonders what she's doing wrong, or in an effort to try and make sense of something that doesn't make a lot of sense, maybe God's mad at her for relaxing her boundaries or giving in to her human desires.

Regardless, it keeps coming back to Pam's internal programming. She needs to figure out how to get guys to stay and continue to beat herself up for what's happening. She keeps trying to be whoever she needs to be, depending on what the guy she dates likes. She can be a country girl or sophisticated or sporty or smart, whatever she needs to be. And then she meets Jim. He's the roommate of her roommate's boyfriend. There's something different about Jim. Seems a little more calm, less drama. He doesn't talk a lot, which to her comes across as he's a good listener. He likes to go do things with Pam. He's up for most anything. He's not pushy.

He'll text her back, not in great detail, not right away, but he doesn't make her wait like a lot of the guys did. So Pam sees somebody steady. She has some drama with one of her friends and she comes to him overly emotional and he's calm under pressure. He doesn't say much other than how great he thinks she is, how pretty she is, and they watch a movie. But Jim doesn't fall apart. So to Pam, after spending her childhood continually reading the room, trying to figure out who she needed to be and having the experience in previous relationships, like apparently she's too much, yet she can't seem to dial herself back.

She was starting to trust that Jim could handle her emotions. It felt like her entire body could exhale a little bit. And I would guess a part of her is thinking, finally, somebody that I won't continually have to try to figure out. What if I can just be me and that's okay? And most of this is happening well below the level of consciousness for Pam. And Jim sees somebody warm who asks questions and remembers the answers. And she texts him and says, good morning and have a good day. And how is he doing? And for a guy who got seen mainly when he did something being interesting to

someone for no reason, that might be the most startling thing that's ever happened to him. And she came to him with a bunch of problems that he has no idea what to do with. But it turns out that the more he doesn't say anything, the more she says, thank you for just being here. So now he's actually getting praise and validation for doing the thing that he had to do to survive as a kid. So there were times where Jim said, I would think to myself, is that what I'm doing? I'm being supportive by just not saying anything. Sweet. Yeah, whatever you need. You're amazing. Let's watch a movie. You're pretty. That sounds hard.

So there's affection in this and humor and shared faith and attraction and hope and their histories are part of the picture, but they aren't aware of what those histories do, how they brought them together. They aren't the whole explanation for why two people fall in love. And I've noticed over a lot of years that the thing that draws two people together tends to be some of the things that they'll eventually have struggles with in the future. It's easy when how is your day comes from Pam. It is a question. And later.

10, 15 years down the road, how was your day? We'll go back to the familiar, being viewed as criticism. Now, Pam chose the opposite of her dad, she believes. Someone calm, non-reactive. And his steadiness, that calm has an alter ego called avoidant or dismissive or why don't you care? But that will not come into play for quite a bit later, much later. That comes when her expressing her feelings, her emotional bids, when those don't get an answer. And then bingo, there we have it. That is the familiar.

Pam will need to perform to try and get Jim to respond. Pam will wonder what's wrong with her when he doesn't tell her how much he loves her. Pam will begin to think things are wrong when he doesn't talk in the car. Now, let's go back to Jim. Jim chose the opposite of his mom. Somebody who is paying a lot of attention to him. And over time, Pam's attention is going to start feeling on a bad night, like being watched, like being scrutinized, like judgment. Like criticism, like he's doing things wrong and he wasn't even aware of the

things he was supposed to be doing. And to Jim, there it is. There's the familiar. Neither one of them would have in a million years thought that they would have done anything close to marrying the parent that they had the most struggles with. But based on my experience, I think the nervous system went looking for the familiar. It's what it knows. It's what it's comfortable. It's familiar. And at the most core level, it lets each one of them know that they exist, that they matter in a really odd way, because that's the way we know we exist with our parents.

It's what it feels like to be us, to either be the pursuer or the withdrawer, the anxious or the avoidant, which makes it so fascinating because I think once we recognize patterns, then we can start to do something with them. Then we can start to recognize the absolute universally complex paradoxical beauty of this design because it turns out that we find the familiar because of course we do. What if that's part of the master plan, the bigger picture? What if it's so that we can heal the things that we didn't get from the very relationships that helped us become who we are, flaws and all,

and the relationships that we find ourselves in as adults? Our inner child had no chance of advocating for themselves. They didn't have the mental capacity, the awareness of what the heck is even happening. Forget about the ability to be able to go on a seven-year-old hero's journey and discover who they really were as kids because they were exactly who they needed to be to their parents or to the family system that they grew up in. I'll give you a little research here because this is a very well-studied pattern. Back in 1987, two researchers named Cindy Hazen and Philip Shaver put a quiz in a newspaper that got about 600 responses.

And a little over half the people described themselves as secure in relationships. And about a quarter sounded like Jim, the avoidantly attached, and about a fifth sounded like Pam, the anxiously attached. The strongest predictor of which group somebody landed in was how they remembered their parents, available and responsive or distant rejecting or anxious and inconsistent. And the secure group's relationships had lasted on average about twice as long as the other two. A few years later, Lee Kirkpatrick and Keith Davis followed a few hundred dating couples for three years. And in that whole group, they did not find a single couple where both people were anxious and not a single couple where both people were avoidant.

Anxious and avoidant people paired up with each other far more often than any kind of chance would predict. The couples that look like Pam and Jim were about as likely to still be together three years later as the secure couples were. And that idea has been pretty consistent. Murray Bowen, one of the OGs of differentiation, noticed the same thing in his office decades later. People tend to choose a partner at or at about their own level of differentiation. Or maybe it's easier to think of it as similar levels of emotional maturity or what I'm trying to call the familiar. Familiarity, even when the two of them look like opposites.

One moves in, one moves away. And underneath, they're handling about the same amount of anxiety as being close. There were so many movies from my high school days that dealt with this. The star athlete and the girl from across the tracks or vice versa. Those types of movies were of interest because they don't actually happen according to the data, or at least they only happen a fraction of the time. We marry somebody who's roughly at the same level of maturity, of the same level of differentiation. If there's too large of a gap, it would feel far too unfamiliar and you wouldn't be attracted or drawn to that other person.

And then a study just a few years ago pooled data on more than 500 newlywed couples and followed them for, I think it was three or four years. And when both partners were insecure, satisfaction started lower and it fell faster. And those couples were more likely to divorce. But when one partner was secure, it buffered the other one, which is a good sign because it means one person getting steadier does have a potential to change the relationship. It's no guarantee that. But I work with plenty of people who come in for individual work, who tried desperately to get their spouse to come in for couples work. When I first created my magnetic marriage course, my co-creator,

the person who helped me a lot with it, named Preston, and I had this conversation regularly. Do we encourage individuals on the live cohorts that we were doing at that time, or do we keep it for couples? And we eventually decided to let individuals take the live version of the course. And I can honestly say that there were some situations where the individual brought the material back to, the relationship and they eventually did the work and lived happily ever after, as well as an example or two where the individual did the work, brought it back into the couple's relationship, and it did not fix the marriage. But the person who did the course, did the work, was able to make some difficult

decisions that eventually led to their finding peace and happiness. So people will ask me whether all of this is inevitable or fixable, or is our attachment type set in stone? So what's the point? And I don't think any of that is the case. Because about half the adults in those early studies describe themselves as secure, and there's a whole body of research on people whose childhoods looked a whole lot like Pam and Jim's, who eventually did the work and found themselves feeling more secure, eventually finding themselves in securely attached relationships. I don't think that they came out of the gate secure, but they've done the work

to become securely attached, to know who they are without needing somebody else to tell them, to be able to calm their own anxiety, to grow through the discomfort, to not overly react, but also to not play small, to take ownership of the things that they need to take ownership of without projecting it onto their partner and then actually making a meaningful effort for change. So the childhood doesn't decide it. What the research does suggest, though, is the pairing is common and that it's a lot more common than chance. And that once an anxious strategy and an avoidance strategy move in together,

the loop they create is about as predictable as anything. And I see it so often in my office, her reaching, and it can be him reaching. I am the anxious in my relationship. But in this scenario, her reaching reads to him as pressure. His pulling back reads to her as abandonment and leaving. And each of them responds to the other's protection as if it were the original wound from childhood, only now they're in these big adult bodies. That part I will call darn close to mechanical. And the way out of a mechanical loop is usually one of them doing something that the loop doesn't expect, which is where we're headed.

We're going to get there in part three. So far, we followed Pam and Jim from a science fair ribbon in a drawer and a 10-year-old crying in the kitchen after a baseball game. And insert the League of Their Own Tom Hanks clip, there's no crying in baseball right there. All the way to the college campus, where two people who learned very different answers to the same question found each other. And each of them found something that seemed like relief. Now, next time we follow them into the marriage, the kids, the busy parts of life, and the conversations that start to go sideways. And then we do get into betrayal, which is what I started with in section one

that we didn't talk much about today. A burner phone, what it can look like for two people to begin doing something that their loop doesn't expect. Until then, I wonder what you noticed about your own instruction manual as you listened to today's episode. Maybe it's the way that you read a room before you walked all the way into it, or the way I'm fine comes out before you've had a chance to even check in with yourself. Whatever showed up for you, my guess is it made a lot of sense in the house you grew up in. and you get to be curious about whether that still fits in the house you live in now. As per usual, thank you so much for spending this time with me.

Send me any of your questions, your comments and I cannot wait to see you next on, I want to jokingly say, insert waking up to narcissism or the virtual couch or love ADHD or mind in the mirror or murder on the couch or you name it. But I'll see you next time on one of your shows. Compressed emotions flying past our heads in the.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Hosts

  • Tony Overbay Host Feed-stated

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Nobody Brings a Casserole When You Wake Up to Betrayal: The Accommodator, Gaslighting, and Rebuilding Trust

    Nov 4, 20261 hr 29 minAudio

    Waking up to betrayal, gaslighting, or emotional immaturity rarely comes with a casserole on the porch or a meal train. When someone has a baby or a surgery, people can see the event and show up with dinner. When you...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Nobody Brings a Casserole When You Wake Up to Betrayal: The Accommodator, Gaslighting, and Rebuilding Trust

    Nov 4, 20261 hr 29 minAudio

    Waking up to betrayal, gaslighting, or emotional immaturity rarely comes with a casserole on the porch or a meal train. When someone has a baby or a surgery, people can see the event and show up with dinner. When you...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Your AI Is a Great Hype-Man - A Therapist Has a Few Notes (Plus Live QA)

    Oct 14, 20261 hr 32 minAudio

    Using AI as a therapist? Your chatbot might be building a great plan for the person you’re hoping to become. When a client’s chatbot asked if he was an extroverted go-getter, he answered as the man he’s working toward,...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Why Good People Defend Leaders (and Others) Who Contradict Themselves: Identity, Bias & Belonging

    Sep 24, 202653 minAudio

    Tony starts with a kid raised in an East Coast fishing town and another raised hiking Arizona trails. He uses them to show how beliefs tend to form through family, community, and identity, with the reasons showing up...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. If You Can't Say No, Your Yes Doesn't Mean Anything: The Truth About Desire and Intimacy in Marriage

    Sep 23, 20261 hr 18 minAudio

    Most couples sign an unwritten contract about sex and intimacy, and the terms rarely get said out loud. Greg and Amy Langford, certified marriage and intimacy coaches and hosts of the “Undressing Intimacy” podcast,...

    Credit the people on this episode