Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

The Virtual Couch

The Virtual Couch artwork

Nobody Brings a Casserole When You Wake Up to Betrayal: The Accommodator, Gaslighting, and Rebuilding Trust

Nov 4, 20261 hr 29 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Waking up to betrayal, gaslighting, or emotional immaturity rarely comes with a casserole on the porch or a meal train. When someone has a baby or a surgery, people can see the event and show up with dinner. When you discover a double life, or realize you have no opinions as an adult because someone spent years telling you how to think and feel, the loss is usually invisible from the street. Tony explores why the person who has spent years reading moods, keeping dinner pleasant, and making the room comfortable for everyone else can struggle to notice that they are the one who needs care right now. In this episode: Meet the accommodator, the pathologically kind partner who can hear “I’m fine” from two rooms away and turn “I wanted Italian” into “Mexican sounds great” before anyone checks a wait time Hear Tony’s “you know me” story from a motor home drive across Nevada with his mom, a cigarette, and a childhood memory that needed revising before it could be accepted Understand why “I should have known” can seem productive, and how acceptance opens up the question of what to do next Learn how staggered disclosure trains a couple to talk about betrayal in pieces from the very first day Start small by noticing a preference before calculating what it will cost to say it out loud Tony Overbay, LMFT, brings more than 20 years as a couples therapist, advanced training in betrayal trauma, and his own experience growing up with an emotionally immature parent. This is part one of two. If this episode put words to something you’ve been carrying, consider sharing a little of it with one person you trust, and join me for part two, where we follow the accommodator and the emotionally immature partner back to their origin stories. Please follow Tony on Instagram @virtual.couch on Tiktok @virtualcouch on Facebook https://www.facebook.com/tonyoverbaylmft and on Substack https://thevirtualcouch.substack.com/ You can reach out to Tony through his website tonyoverbay.com or by emailing contact @ tonyoverbay.com 00:00 Welcome and Setup 00:50 Food Gifts Storytime 05:16 When No One Brings Help 09:56 Betrayal Rewrites Memories 12:41 Gaslighting and Isolation 17:28 Acceptance Over Shame 21:39 What Counts as Betrayal 26:53 Trust After Discovery 36:14 Statements vs Questions 43:05 Holding Space Practice 47:26 Relationship As Mirror 48:49 Blind Spots Not Selfish 50:16 Rebuilding Trust Slowly 51:18 Staggered Disclosure Trap 54:48 Try The Uncomfortable Sentence 57:45 Origin Of The Accommodator 01:01:27 Dinner Negotiation Example 01:04:13 You Know Me Syndrome 01:09:51 Nevada Road Trip Reality Check 01:15:50 Confabulation And Self-Silencing 01:20:36 Finding Your Preferences Again 01:23:37 Small Practices And Closing

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

And or the virtual couch. I will most likely be running it on both because I'm really excited to get to today's topic. Thank you to Riley Hope for her song, Not My Job, as the intro to Waking Up the Narcissism. And I will go ahead and I guess pre-thank the wonderful, the talented Aurora Florence for taking us out maybe an hour from now with her song, It's Wonderful. So we'll do a little bit of both Waking Up the Narcissism and the virtual couch vibe. Follow me on social media at virtual.couch on Instagram or at virtualcouch on

TikTok or find my sub stack. I believe it's virtualcouch.substack.com or the link will be in the show notes and a lot of written word there and some upcoming Q&A information that will be sub stack exclusive. So go check that out as well. So it is story time. The first meal that anybody brought my wife and I after our oldest daughter was born was a sliced ham that had seen better days. It had colors on it that I had not previously associated with ham, rainbow kind of colors.

And while I so appreciated the love behind it, I wasn't really sure that I needed to add a second medical event to that week. And it's been 30 years and I can still picture that. And it probably has tainted my experience with ham. And since that time, I've been on the giving and the receiving end of so many of these kind of experiences, and they are amazing and tender, and they really do touch my heart because you're exhausted. In this scenario, you're trying to keep a tiny human alive and the doorbell rings and somebody is standing there and they have already figured out dinner

for you, something that maybe you had not even thought about. And then on day two, somebody brought a homemade chicken pot pie. I had actually never had chicken pot pie growing up. I also had never been to Disneyland before I was an adult. And in those two things, they compete close to the beginning of my own therapy intake. That particular chicken pot pie was full of onions, which I definitely saw as something to work around to get to the actual food. But I could tell there was some potential, especially with the crust. So then the next day, when a third family brought yet another chicken pot pie, I was in.

I gave it a real shot and it was transformative. So we had welcomed a daughter into the world. I discovered chicken pot pie. And I remember both of those experiences. I was doing my best to give both of those developments the attention that they deserved. And so now to this day, I'll try a chicken pot pie almost anywhere that I'll go. Now, in the same breath, I will admit my openness with food though has limits. I've tried pate and escargot back in my computer days in France and a black egg in Taiwan,

and fish and chips takeaway with little bones in it in the UK or sushi that literally the tail kind of reared up and smacked my hand that was holding the sushi, causing me to literally scream and throw it across the room. And even more, I guess, confusing as I once watched my brother-in-law order a slice of apple pie topped with a piece of melted American cheese, which out of all those things I just described, kind of gives me the feels more than anything. But I know that I've also spent a considerable amount of my professional life,

doing my best to understand and help other people understand the. Other people's perspectives. And then, and I can honestly say that I stand behind the fact that absolutely nobody knows what it feels like to be me or you, the listener. And there's a reason why we do the things that we do. Especially, I know that there's a reason why I do the things that I do, even when those things don't make sense to you, or sometimes even to me for that matter, which I want to acknowledge means that there is probably a reason why you do the things that you do. And even why other people do the things that they do, even when you don't understand

why they do them, or you think that you would never do something the way that that person is doing what they're doing. So people do things in response to something happening for somebody else that we've somewhat agreed on socially. So when somebody has a baby, people can bring food. Before the baby arrives, you have a party called a shower where you give clothes that seems so big at that time that the baby will never fit into them. And then they outgrow them before sometimes they even come home from the hospital. Or when somebody has surgery, people bring casseroles. And when somebody has.

A death in the family, people bring more casseroles. And we may not even know what to say, but there's a nine by 13 inch pan. The first time I learned that that is such a standard size pan and we're willing to put it to work. People will mow other people's lawns. They'll set up meal trains. They'll watch your kids because there's a shared understanding that something significant has happened and your world has been interrupted and you might need somebody to take dinner off your list for a little while. You don't have to make much of a case for why you're struggling. It's like people can see the event.

They've maybe experienced some form of that event themselves and they understand that it comes with a need for care. The doorbell rings and care is standing right there on the porch. For today, I want to talk about how nobody actually does bring a chicken pot pie when you wake up to the emotional immaturity or gaslighting or betrayal in your relationship. There's not even a rainbow-tended slice of leftover ham on the doorstep when you discover. The reason that you have no opinions as an adult is that someone told you your

entire life what the correct way was to think or to feel or to believe. Or when you find out that the person that you've been married to for decades, has been living a double life. I haven't checked the Hallmark store in a while, but I don't remember a section between sympathy and thinking of you that says apparently your marriage experiences, it's only been partially what you thought it was. And your idea of retirement just got really complicated. And your neighbor doesn't think, okay, I need to mow this person's lawn. When they see your spouse storm off in the driveway yelling,

you're just like your mother. Now, they may wonder what happened, or they may want to help, but even then worry about intruding. And then unfortunately, a lot of times the help, and I'm using air quotes, that does show up turns into now a bonus of rumors and false narratives that get spread around the neighborhood or the church community that can start to lead to even more isolation. It's really interesting. Recently, I heard another version of the story of where somebody is coming out of a divorce and then being isolated by their faith or

friend community because now they were single. And there was now this worry that the single person who, again. Not that long ago, had no idea that they would ever be single. That this person might just go and start picking up on everybody's spouse. When that person, the newly unasked for single person, has no idea how to navigate life moving forward and simply just wants a friend. So meanwhile, though, you're trying to make sense of something that has shaken your entire understanding of your life. And life still goes on. And bills need to be paid. And dogs need to be fed.

And plants watered. And dinner still needs to happen. But instead of discovering a new favorite dish, like the aforementioned chicken pot pie, now all of a sudden you're looking at endless days of mac and cheese because that's about as much planning and decision-making as you have left in you trying to navigate all of this unknown. But the kids still need a ride. And then from the outside, it might even look like a pretty ordinary Tuesday afternoon that's happening at your house. But then over the course of who knows how long, you might find yourself with

less contact than before. And a relationship that makes less sense, or maybe it even starts to make more sense than it ever did, which that brings its own kind of pain because now you're seeing things you didn't see before and you're still not sure what to do with this new information or what you know. The people around you probably don't know how to respond either. So, you're all trying to figure out how to move forward. And then somewhere in the middle there, mac and cheese is now developing an association that it didn't actually deserve.

And as much as you'd like to protect your future relationship with mac and cheese, what I'm really talking about today is the care that you need during that time, the time of the awakening, the time of the waking up when something significant has happened, or you've now recognize something that you've always wondered or something's just felt off, whether that's betrayal, betrayal of a partner, the realized betrayal to yourself or betrayal from a parent who, bless their heart, may genuinely not have known what they didn't know,

which doesn't mean that you still can't be frustrated or sad or angry or numb when you find out how certain experiences that you grew up with impacted your life today. So, you're probably just trying to get through the day and people around you may not even and realize how significant what you're dealing with actually is. And I think part of what makes that kind of waking up, that kind of loss so hard to explain, is you're not only trying to understand what happened. Today, you may also be trying to understand what now happened five years ago

or 10 years ago, because something that you just learned has changed now how you see the relationship that you've been living in. Now there's the relationship that you thought you were having, and there's the relationship that you're beginning to understand with the information you didn't have before. And oddly enough, you're the same person, or at least you think you are. But now something feels unsettling and we don't know what to do with those feelings. And when you look back at some of the same memories, now the questions are, were they real or do they not count? Because some of them no longer mean what

you thought that they meant or do they? I've used this plenty, but I think about the movie, The Sixth Sense. And if you haven't seen it, I'm going to spoil the ending. It came out around 1999. So, that's a fairly generous window to watch it. So, you've got Bruce Willis plays Dr. Malcolm Crowe, who's a child psychologist who's trying to help a little boy named Cole. And throughout the movie, you watch Dr. Malcolm struggle to connect with his wife while trying to help this child who famously says, I see dead people. And you piece together what you're seeing from the information that you've been

given. His wife seems really distant. Their relationship seems really, really strained. And you watch him try to reach her. And it's almost like she can't even see him. And he takes that as her not caring. Then you discover that Malcolm has been dead for most of the movie. And then you want to go back and watch it again, because now that dinner with his wife looks completely different because she's literally looking right through him. And now what you understand as her refusing to answer him or to speak to him, now all of a sudden that becomes a scene of her grieving him,

her being there by herself. And you start revisiting the interactions, wondering what else you missed, and then trying to understand how the same scenes can tell such a different story once you know something that you didn't know before. And then when I say, don't even get me started on memory, because we already have a negativity bias. It's a survival thing. And Rick Hansen in his book, Buddha's Brain, The Practical Neuroscience of Happiness says the brain is like Teflon for the positive and Velcro for the negative. And when there's significant betrayal, I swear the brain reaches for super glue to anchor the Velcro.

And then it goes back through every positive memory that you've had one at a time to see whether any of them are real. And it's hard to get any of them to stick. It's like it greases up the Teflon even more. But unlike a movie, when you first learn a betrayal, you can't just simply turn off the TV and go to bed and worry about it some other time or maybe not even revisit it. Because when it's your life, those scenes keep coming back to you. They come back to you while you're trying to go to sleep, while you're driving a kid somewhere, while you're listening to music, or while you are standing over our increasingly unfortunate pot of mac and cheese,

contemplating to hot dog or not to hot dog. Because that is a question. All of a sudden, you remember an argument or a quiet dinner or an unexplained absence. Is that why she kept leaving the room with a smile on her face in the middle of a regular old boring weekend? Or you try to make sense of how asking him about a random fast food receipt that was in his back pocket when I was doing the laundry turned into an inquisition about trust and finances and accountability. Or you're trying to work out what all this new information means for those moments, which the memories still feel very solid. and you think that you have a very

clear memory of what an experience was like. So now what can you trust? You know, a lot of what I do is I sit with people who are somewhere in that process. Maybe they're fresh off a discovery or an admission or an awakening to a pattern that they can finally give a name to. Sometimes they've spent years noticing that something has seemed off and just wondering and assuming, oh, it must be me. Maybe you finally worked up the courage then to ask about something that you've been tracking, you've been clocking for a long time, but now you only find out

that the response was you were actually imagining things. That isn't what happened. Or the conversation then actually shifted to how hurtful it was that you could even think of your spouse that way. So, you came into the conversation hoping to understand something that you could finally put some words to, but now you're back to the familiar position of trying to reassure them, that you know that they're a good person. You shouldn't have even brought it up before long. You are mentally standing at a trophy engraving counter. And it's like, okay, are we going with spouse of the year or world's greatest spouse? And then hoping that there's still enough room to put on the plaque. And I'm sorry I asked.

Or maybe you then just decided that the kind thing or the mature thing or the Christ-like thing was just to let it go. Forgive and forget. And if it comes up again, it's probably on you too, because that's been your job in the family for as long as you can remember. Stuff it. If you finally say it, well, then apologize for having said it. Take ownership of your part. Take ownership of more than your part. Change it and then run it back again and again and again because that's what you do. That's what the relationships are about. That's what you saw modeled when you were growing up. You wanted to believe the person you loved and you may have hoped that trusting

would then help you feel close again. Then later, you learned that at least some of what you had actually noticed and tried to bring up and maybe were even attacked about was real. And now you're trying to make sense of both what happened and what happened when you tried to talk about it before. And then there's a whole part of this where people feel so isolated, so sequestered. Who do you tell about what you're now going through? How do you explain that your spouse screamed that you were crazy or threatened to tell the kids that you were the problem for even asking?

And then you discovered that your concern was actually pretty spot on. And then you probably still love the person and you may worry about what telling somebody else would mean for your spouse. Maybe it damages their reputation, what it'll do to your family, whether you'll be believed or, for a lot of people, whether you end up then having to comfort the person that you tell, because a lot of times when somebody isn't sure what to say, they just say, oh my gosh, I can't even imagine what you're going through. I'm so sorry. I don't even know what to say. And then you as the person who was trying to be heard is saying,

you know, it's, that's okay. It's okay. we'll figure it out. Because even then reaching out for support can feel like just another complicated task, especially if you're already overwhelmed. So then I watch people, not literally, but metaphorically put on some steel-toed boots and kick the can as far down the road as possible and even acknowledge, oh yeah, I'm kicking this can. Because then you hope, once again, that it will magically work itself out. Because in all reality, that actually would be the best case scenario. If we could just kind of ignore it, have it go away, it'll never happen again.

I'll never have these thoughts or feelings or triggers come up and everything will just be fine. That would be ideal, but it isn't the way it works. People can end up carrying betrayal this way. And a similar isolation can happen, with emotional, spiritual, financial, and physical abuse. Because on top of everything that they're already trying to understand, they're probably asking themselves, why didn't I recognize this sooner? Why didn't I have the courage to say something sooner because the reality is sometimes they did notice something. But noticing it and knowing what to do with it are really different.

Or they did try to bring things up and they were told that they were not seeing things correctly. Or they asked and they received an explanation that was decent, kind of made sense. Then it's a lot easier to consider the possibility that, okay, maybe I did misunderstand things. And I'm going to assume that, yeah, that's actually what happened, even though it still doesn't feel right. Because that's that person trying to preserve a relationship because that relationship matters. And it would be easier if it just was okay. Because when you care about somebody and you've built a life together,

there can be a lot riding on the hope that their explanation actually does make sense. So, you're more than willing to give them the benefit of the doubt over and over again, even at the cost of your own nervous system, your own sense of self, the details that you've now put together. And sometimes people convince themselves that they can't even talk to anybody else or reach out for help from a professional or to anyone until they really understand it all, until they have all the details. It's the, once I understand, then I'll do this thing, but I might actually have to do the thing to understand.

And before I get too far away from that thought that I should have known, and I think about this often from an acceptance and commitment therapy lens, that I'm accepting the fact that I didn't know, but I think that our brains want to think that we're doing a thing, a productive thing. And it goes back to. Ruminating. If I can figure this out, if I can figure out why I didn't know and keep telling myself, but I should have known, I am doing a thing. It is occupying my time. It proves to me that I exist, that I'm alive,

but it is definitely an unproductive thought. Because the reason that you didn't know is because you didn't know. That is what happened. That's how things unfolded. And I never want that to sound dismissive because I have this conversation with a client or two probably most every day, when they just keep going back to, right, but I should have known because if I would have known, then I could have handled things differently. And the reality is, sure, let's say that you should have known and then you could have handled things differently.

Okay, but you didn't. So there's an acceptance. And again, acceptance doesn't mean apathy. It doesn't mean to roll over and give up. acceptance means to take in without defense in its entirety. I'm accepting the fact that, man, I didn't know, or I'm accepting the fact that I didn't figure it out in time to change the course of history that led me to where I am now. Rather than I am accepting the fact that I didn't know it happened and here I am. So now what do I do moving forward?

I remember having a close conversation or having a conversation with someone very close to me that was figuring out some things about one of their adult children and they just insisted that I wasn't understanding, that they really should have known. They should have known because if they would have known, they could have done something different. And I said, okay, let's even say that that's absolutely correct. You should have known. What do you do with that now?

And we had a pretty powerful moment where it went back to the fact that the person just feels like they still need to punish themselves. They need to feel bad about something as if that is the answer and that they can only start to heal or move forward once they feel bad enough. And I think that goes so much back to the deep childhood experience of shame. Where shame was one of the times I think in childhood where someone would really

be seen, for lack of a better word. So if somebody just feels bad, man, I blew it, then sometimes they would get ignored still even as a kid. But if they said, I'm a bad person, it's almost like that was the cue that then the parent would say, hey, hey, bud, it's okay. You're going to be okay. So I sometimes wonder if we just default back to this shame of I am bad, because that was the time where someone else could tell us you're okay. But now you, your adult self needs to be able to tell that inner child, hey, you are okay.

This happened. And it might not be the greatest thing that you wanted to happen. And sure, it would have been nice to have known how to handle it differently, but you didn't. So give yourself grace and stay away from that shame spiral that takes you all the way back to this, I'm a bad person, because I think inherently that still is reaching out to someone else to tell you that you're okay. You are okay. You're going through life for the very first time. You reacted in a way. It's a way that impacted other people. It is in a way that you didn't see yourself reacting.

All of those things can be true. And now you get to begin your hero's journey, your healing quest. You're going to be able to figure this out and heal that deep inner child wounding of shame and know that I can do things that I'm not happy about, things that I wish I would have done differently. And now I get to do something different. And I know that the concept of betrayal can mean a lot of different things. And I think that's maybe part of why people are also continuing to try to figure out what's going on.

It feels like their work is not finished because what starts to count as betrayal tends to widen or grow the longer that you look at it. And I think that's where a lot of people begin to wake up to what's been happening in their relationships. And I'm not just talking about infidelity. It may be the discovery that somebody has told you one thing and has done another over very long periods of time. Or it's the gradual recognition that there hasn't been much room for your experience, when it conflicts with theirs.

And as those patterns start to become more clear, you may also look back at times that you felt uneasy. But even talked yourself out of paying attention to how you're feeling or what you're thinking. And then that can bring up even another painful thought. Hey, did I betray myself too? And I think that's where we all need a little extra helping of grace, of self-compassion, because you're going to also discover that you were trying to understand what was happening, while also trying to stay connected to somebody who mattered to you,

somebody who you had built a life with up to that point. And most likely you've already planned out the rest of your life. And I'm guessing that you learned to give their explanation of things, their explanation of events, a lot more weight than you gave your own explanation or your own experience. And so now part of the work is making room for your experience again with the acceptance that you're probably not even exactly sure what you believe or trust about your experience because you've been told that it's been wrong for so long.

And I think about that when people that I work with describe things like stomach trouble or chronic fatigue or headaches or just the overall feeling of tension that they've gotten so used to carrying that they barely even notice it anymore. It almost becomes their baseline or what it feels like to be them. And I know that those symptoms can have a whole lot of different causes, but if I'm continuing to try to unpack or uncover a theme of today's episode, it might be that the person listening to this is used to putting their own needs and their own care, their self-care last.

And I'm not suggesting that a headache or upset tummy always reflects an unhealthy marriage because it could also be, a bad serving of strawberry kiwi yogurt that you found toward the back of the fridge after you'd already thrown away the lid that has the expiration date on it. And you assume that what you were seeing were kiwi seeds, except for then they turned out to not be crunchy. And yogurt is tart to begin with. But doggone it, if this one wasn't tart with a capital T, and then a few days and maybe one vicious bout of diarrhea later, you crack open another tub of that exact same flavor.

And would you look at that? This one does not have the multicolored kiwi seeds in it, and it tastes like strawberry kiwi yogurt. All that is hypothetical, but no, I'm talking more about what somebody experiences when their stomach tightens as they hear the garage door open, or when they realize that they've been holding their breath while trying to figure out the right timing to ask a pretty ordinary question. And I think that's part of what makes this such a feeling of betrayal or loss. Okay, I got to figure out what version of this person is coming in before I

decide who do I need to be? And if you've spent years trying to keep things calm, noticing your own discomfort is probably not where your attention naturally goes. You may be far more practiced at noticing somebody else's mood and anticipating what they need or deciding whether now is a good time to bring something up, slowing down enough to notice, oh, my chest is tight, and I'm feeling afraid and I'm worried about how this conversation is going to go. Because that in and of itself takes practice to have that kind of awareness.

And you don't have to force yourself to sit with more than you can manage. And then even just taking a breath doesn't obligate you to stay in a conversation that feels threatening. But the purpose in just starting to become more aware is to give yourself enough room, enough space to notice your experience and, And even start to just consider what you may need, even if you're not sure what that is. Again, whether that's a pause, some distance, medical care, a bidet,

or somebody that you trust, helping you sort through what is happening. And you don't need a finished explanation before you can share with somebody else what you're going through. And you definitely don't have to make sense of it alone. So we're going to get to an origin story, although I'm starting to recognize that at the rate that I'm going, the origin story is going to need its own episode. So, we'll most likely pick that up in a part two. But in that story, the person who betrayed the relationship, the muse that I'm working from today happens to be the husband,

but betrayal is no respecter of persons. I work with plenty of couples where it's the husband or the wife is the one who disclosed something or whose behavior was discovered that we would call betrayal. But what I'm more interested in is what happens between two people when one of them learns something that changes their understanding of the relationship. A woman once asked me, we were in a couple setting, her husband was sitting right beside her as they were working through a pretty significant betrayal. And she just said, just tell me, is my hope, is my goal? Am I supposed to just let things go?

Because he has apologized. He said he won't do it again. But to me, it feels like if I stop paying attention, how will I know if it will ever happen again? And if I keep checking, I'm actually spending my whole day trying to figure out what else he might be hiding. And I can't stop going back over everything, trying to understand how we got here, or what did I do wrong? There is so much happening in those questions because she's trying to understand the past and she's trying to figure out what she can trust in the present right now. And then she's trying to prevent something from happening in the future. And all of this is happening in the middle of the day. And she still has to

go pick up the kids and has other things going on in her life. And I know, I can understand that her brain is reaching for a very understandable promise that if I can make sense of this, then maybe I can keep it from happening again. If I can identify what I missed, what I should have asked, or what I could have done differently, then maybe I can finally feel settled. Because our brains would like a complete explanation, and it's assuming that then that will give me a lifetime guarantee that what just happened will never happen again.

And because it was so unsettling, I can understand why that's what somebody is asking for. But she's trying to make sense of an experience she actually hasn't had before. With information she still may not be receiving from a person that she thought she knew in a particular way. They built a life together. She knows his routines. She knows his stories. She knows if he does want onions or not on his hamburger. You can know someone so well, well enough to order their lunch or know what they like and what they don't like, and then still discover there were significant

things that you didn't know. That's part of what makes this whole process of betrayal so disorienting. This piece that is familiar, it's still there, but it's also sitting right beside information that seems impossible to fit into what you already knew about this person. And talking about trust, I did an episode about trust quite a while ago, and it was episode 378 of the virtual couch and I told some story about cookies and I'm cutting to the transcript here but I then said the story about cookies is obviously made up.

And it's there just to make a point how quickly trust can be eroded in a relationship and it can feel much heavier when that erosion comes from learning about deep betrayal and fidelity, for example, or learning that your spouse has been looking at pornography in secret while maintaining otherwise for years, or you learn that he or she hasn't been honest about the finances, or you learn that your spouse has been talking about you to a neighbor behind your back and I could go on and on. Then I referenced a transcript from a podcast, season six, episode seven of

the NPR podcast Invisibilia called Trustfall. And I cut there. The host of the podcast said, so people might say, oh, he's in a bad mood that day. But what they don't do is speculate about why. Why is he like this? What's going on inside of his head? And then the author of this book said, and there's a complete absence of speculation about other people's interiorities. The host of the podcast, that they have a fundamental assumption that you don't really know a person. And what that means is if someone betrays you, it's not like such a shock.

Like it doesn't surprise them that a person just does a thing that they didn't think that the person was going to do. And then the author of this book says, when somebody here betrays our trust, what happens is that we have an idea of who they are and they behave in a way that runs against that idea. We say to them, I thought you were different. I thought you weren't like that. How could you do that to me when I had this idea of you? And I will never forget, this is the part that I struggled with at the time. The author then says, it's a tyrannical way to behave. I have this idea of you.

You have to conform to it or our friendship is over. Now. Feels so much heavier than that, depending on the depth of the betrayal. So, then the podcast says, so basically what the author is saying is that we're stuck in this binary. We either totally trust someone or they betray us and then we're done with them. But this other way of thinking, and the author calls it mistrust with a capital M, which is the name of the book that he wrote about this mistrust, it gives you a third option. This is just hard to get your head around. It's basically like saying,

trust people less and it's a more liberating world. And the author then said, have more respect for the fact that you can't know them and that their behavior might sometimes betray you or let you down. So I'm not saying that, well, it was inevitable, but the breaking of trust in one sense is inevitable. When you look at it from that angle of, I trust that this is who you are. And with that trust, I believe that you will never do things that I don't think you will do. It doesn't excuse the behavior, but hopefully it can start to make sense of

why you feel the way that you do about the betrayal. It's as if there's almost going to be an acceptance at some point that trust was broken. But now, where do we go next? What do we do with that? Now's the time to rebuild trust, which comes from a place of transparency, from truth, from not having to pull something out of somebody. Because when something just shakes up the relationship like that. We tend to reach for ways that we already think that we know how to get through a difficult moment. Maybe you learned that if you could explain something thoroughly enough,

almost like a lecture to somebody, then that person would eventually understand, and then you could feel close again. Or maybe you learned to keep asking questions until you got an answer that you liked that then helped you feel more grounded or more settled. Maybe you learned to apologize so quickly and then agree and then wait for the tension to pass. Or maybe you learned that if everybody could identify whose fault something was, that that person could then say sorry, promise to change, and the family could get back to dinner. So, now those familiar moves, they now show up in a situation that needs a whole

lot more than they can provide. One person says, okay, I'm sorry, and I won't do it again. And they sincerely hope that the promise will offer their partner some relief because then that person who got caught or who was doing the apologizing, they can be done. I did it. I said it. I checked the box. But then the other person now, when there's been significant enough betrayal or trust has been broken. Then the other person says, okay, but how do I know? Because you told me before that you would never do something like this again. They're wanting something that they can take to the bank, they can stand on.

And an apology, even a sincere one may not give them the footing that they need. Now, meanwhile, the person who betrayed the relationship may be having their own painful collision of how they understood themselves. I've sat with so many people who have spent years believing that I'm someone who shows up this way, a certain way in my family, just overly generalized that I'm someone who loves my family and I would never do this thing. I'm somebody that people can trust. So therefore I would never do this thing that I've done. And now they're trying to figure out what does that mean about me?

And that distress, that internal collapse can be so real. And then they still have a responsibility for the behavior and the impact it has on their spouse, on the family. Part of their work is learning to face what they did without needing their partner to reassure them that they're still a good person before a conversation can continue. But in the moment, they may reach for an explanation, minimize part of what happened or agree with whatever is being said, because they hope that it's going to help everybody get through the evening. Yep, you're right. I understand. I'll do better.

And then the betrayed partner may hear those words and think, okay, but do you understand? Because again, I've heard you say that before. Are you just trying to get this conversation to end? Which may be a question that they've had in the relationship for a very long time. And so when we slow that part down, the ways that each person learned to handle discomfort, that is going to follow them into these conversations where they're trying to change things. Somebody explains more because being understood feels like the route back to connection. And their partner experiences the explanation as another reason that their pain

isn't being heard or understood. Or somebody agrees to calm the situation and now their partner becomes even more frightened because now they can't tell whether the agreement means anything of value. Both people may desperately want some kind of relief, but the reaching for the relief now is getting way ahead of understanding what repair is going to require. Then they come into my office, understandably, hoping that I can help them get an answer from each other. Hey, can you help them understand why I keep asking? Or can you help her understand that I said I'm sorry?

And so often, before we even get much further at all, then we have to notice what happens between the question and the answer. Can one person describe their experience without the other immediately getting angry, defending, collapsing, or trying to make the feeling, whatever it is, go away? Or can the person who caused the hurt answer honestly and remain present, remain accountable, take an ownership, even though their partner is still hurting. Can we make enough room to understand what happened without expecting one conversation

is going to make the relationship feel secure again? This made me think about having a couple in my office not long ago, and the wife came in upset. She came in hot. Her husband had been on a few trips during a stretch that was shortly after betrayal had been uncovered. And a little bit of the time he had been hard to reach. And so, when she brought it up in couples therapy, his first move was to say, I didn't realize that was so important to you, and I wish you would have told me sooner. And she said something that I hear a lot in a lot of different words that I've

tried to explain or I've tried to ask for these things in the past and it hasn't gone well. Or I shouldn't have to explain this to you. You should know what's important right now. And I want to lightheartedly say at this point, I'm allowing shooting on someone. And then her saying, essentially, I've been asking him to choose me for years, if not decades. And especially with what we're going through now, I don't want to have to continue to ask. I'm done asking. And then somewhere in there, she had thrown out the word selfish because she

then just accused him of being selfish. You were only thinking about yourself. And I want to spend just a couple of minutes on that word because was he thinking about himself? Technically, sure. He was thinking about his trips, his plans, the presentation he was going to make, the people he was going to see. So, she is working from very real information. And at the same time, your being selfish is a statement. And the brain treats a statement very differently than it treats a question. A statement is a closed loop. It gets checked against what the person that is

receiving the statement already believes about themselves or the situation. Sometimes it'll match, but if it doesn't match, it gets rejected. And that happens so fast. So, your being selfish runs through his brain. And then here's what I think the brain does with it. Immediately pulls up every single thing he does for her and for the family that he would define as the opposite of being selfish. The job he's worked for for decades, the long hours, the bills that are paid, the kid stuff, the time he gave up the thing he wanted to do because she asked.

And all of that, again, technically would qualify as being unselfish. So the statement to him doesn't line up and it gets thrown out. And now he's defending, which means she's now watching him defend, and that doesn't feel very good, especially coming out of a discovery, a discovery of a betrayal. And she's thinking, see, there we go again, he's not even hearing me, and this is a time where I really need him to hear me. And it can happen on both sides of the fence. Later in the same conversation,

he had said that over the years, he recognizes that he's pulled away from the marriage because he said she didn't care. That's also a statement. And she ran it through her own brain and about lost her mind. Because that definitely didn't line up. Because she definitely cares. She almost over cares. She cared so much that she spent decades sacrificing her own feelings, her own wants, and her own needs. To keep things stable and comfortable for everybody else in that house,

and maybe even especially him. My guess is that her ability to keep the peace for everybody is a big part of why he was able to go out and slay the proverbial dragon that led to the success, that led to the lifestyle that they had. So, she didn't care, gets checked against her experience, and that one gets strongly rejected. And now she's defending and angry about having to defend when they're here talking about this because of betrayal. So, you have two people both working from something true, both throwing statements

back and forth at each other, like spells in a bad Harry Potter movie, and both getting rejected. Nobody's lying per se, but nobody's getting anywhere for sure. So, I think the question underneath that you're selfish is maybe a different question. The question is, did you consider me? And if you didn't, why? And if that can come from a place of genuine curiosity, then that can be a powerful question. If it's not coming from a place of genuine curiosity, it's probably more of a setup. It would be probably more of the question where the person asking already knows

the answer or the answer that they want to hear. And by want to hear, it isn't that they want to hear that I wasn't thinking about you, but they want to hear an answer that then they can say, yeah, that's right. Now I can explain what a piece of garbage you are. But people feel the difference when something's genuinely curious, because curiosity and a question, it opens the loop back to this couple. So, in this scenario, I turn to him, and I'm kind of checking in, all right, what are you taking in here? And this is somebody that's doing the work.

They recognize, okay, yeah, I need to self-examine more. I'm just trying to explain my way out of this. And he had apologized, but the apology had, I think, in the session, I might have even called it a little stink on it. Because it had a, and here's why I did it. Here's why I did the thing that I did. And so if you're the one apologizing, you can tell yourself the story too, that this is very helpful context. Because context does matter when you're trying to have a connected conversation.

But when you're trying to repair betrayal, when you're trying to provide emotional safety, then it's going to sound like an excuse. If you're on the other side of that, the receiving end, it's going to sound like the The apology came with some expectations as well. Like, you better tell me that you understand and that you see my side of things. And that's not the way that you repair betrayal trauma. So I tried something with him. I said, okay, I wonder if the vulnerable answer for a guy in this spot is.

Probably more of a sentence that most of us may not even be aware of, but we probably don't want to say even if we are aware of it. And the sentence is, I didn't think about that. I didn't think about you. Not, I didn't think about it because I was busy or not. Okay. I didn't think about it, but just, I didn't think about you when I was making these plans, period. And then stay in that discomfort. Because when a guy says, let me explain, it's like he gets to climb out of the hot seat.

The discomfort can go away for him. But he hands it back over to his wife, something that he's most likely been doing without even recognizing it for a long, long time. But she's still then sitting with whatever concern that she brought in. And now it just continues to tell her that I don't feel safe enough to talk about anything. But when he says, I didn't think about you with no, but, oh, he's uncomfortable, but he's also staying in the discomfort,

showing that, okay, I can actually stay here for you and be uncomfortable. Not long ago, I wrote a document that I give to my clients that are in these kind of situations. And this one in particular, I call making space for her emotions and then what you're actually doing when you do this. And I think it's one of those therapist sounding cliches, but to read a little bit out of this document that I wrote, I say, when I say hold space for emotions or make a container for them, I know it sounds vague. Like I'm asking somebody to surrender something. I've had people say, what, I'm just supposed to sit there and take a beating.

Well, that's definitely not the vibe that I would be asking someone to make space for somebody's emotions. But when that happens, you actually learn quite a bit about yourself. You learn a bit about your partner. When you stay genuinely curious, instead of jump into clarifying or correcting, you're going to find out things that you didn't know. Tell me more, help me understand, What was that like for you? How long have you been feeling that way? And those aren't just reflective listening techniques. They're how you get to know the person that you're with. And most of the time we think we know about our partner, but that thing that

we think is often a story that we've built over experiences and the way that we've interpreted their behavior. And then we keep updating it with our own assumptions instead of new information. So curiosity is how you stay current in your relationship or how you keep things up to date and it will feel uncomfortable. And you're also going to start to learn that you can be okay. And I think this is the part that most of the guys that I work with don't expect. You won't suddenly feel okay in the moment. You probably won't at all for a little while.

The work isn't reaching a place where her emotions stop being uncomfortable. It's learning to sit in the discomfort and not react to it. That difference between reacting and responding is everything. And reacting, that's what happens when the stimulus and then your response, they fuse, they fire at the same time. Something lands and then you're already reacting. You're already doing the thing. There isn't any space in between that, no daylight where you can make a different decision. Responding instead of reacting, it requires creating a pause.

That's what you learn about yourself is that, oh, I need to learn how to build in that pause. And building the pause is no small task. It does take practice. It takes being very mindful, intentional meditation, not just sitting quietly, but noticing how your emotions show up in your body, what triggers them, what direction they pull you. And it also will help you identify the protective stories that you tell yourself in order to, up until this point, it's essentially keep you alive. I've heard all of them. If I make space for these emotions, it's going to get

worse. If I don't push back, I'm going to lose ground. If I let this in, I'll never recover. Those are stories, real feeling, well-rehearsed stories that your brain tells you, but they are stories. And part of the work is noticing them in the moment, naming them as stories. They're not facts. You can even thank your brain for telling you those stories because it's doing its best. It's trying to keep you alive. And it's using these adaptations you've brought into the relationship from your childhood. And then those now have become maladaptive.

It learned these patterns when it needed to. But now you're the adult. It's time to let the big kid take over. And those same patterns are getting in the way of the connection that I think you probably really want. Now the promise isn't that the discomfort is going to go away. The promise is that you start to trust that that discomfort isn't actually dangerous. That you can be uncomfortable and still be standing, still be present. You're going to learn that your nervous system can move through activation without

you having to fix or escape the situation. And that's a form of steadiness that's underneath this idea of presence, of staying present and grounded, of being able to offer your nervous system to co-regulate in the relationship. It's not the absence of difficult emotions, But it's the capacity that you're going to build to remain yourself in the presence of somebody who is having big emotions. And I really believe that becomes...

A really powerful type of internal validation. And the part that's almost paradoxical, you're going to learn about yourself through the relationship. The relationship isn't just where you go to get your needs met. It's where you find out who you are. Every moment of activation, every, I don't know what to do here, every, why is this so hard? All of a sudden becomes pretty fascinating data about you, about what you're protecting against, about, what your nervous system learned about the parts of yourself that are still

waiting to be integrated, to be brought out from the shadows and into the light. The relationship is the laboratory. And that's what differentiation is. Everything really is a me thing. And the sooner that you can embrace that and understand, oh, this is my journey. I'm the one who is going to learn to heal myself. Then it actually becomes pretty, maybe exciting isn't the right word at first, but it's something to embrace. Because if you're going to ask yourself, oh, so I do that and then it ends?

No, unfortunately, or actually at some point, fortunately, no, but you are going to learn so much about yourself that then every interaction that I have is an opportunity for me to self confront and grow. You discover what you're protecting against and making space feels intolerable. That's information. Usually means there's a fear underneath. Those fears are worth examining directly instead of working around or trying to avoid them. They're often connected to those childhood adaptations where your emotions were

labeled as too much or irrational or unsafe. So back to this example, then the goal of the husband was not to get rid of his discomfort. Now there's a genuine question on the table for him. Why don't I think about her in those scenarios? Because I do think that's the work. That's the hero's journey, which can sound a little bit grand in this situation, but that's really what it is. It's a guy who can now be curious about his own blind spot instead of just immediately jumping to defend it.

And I really like using the word blind spot better than selfish for a very good reason. I didn't do a thing because I wasn't thinking about a thing. That's a very different problem than knowing and not caring. Because now it has a different solution. You can apologize your way out of a blind spot, but it's just an apology that I didn't think about the thing. Now I can get curious about why I didn't think about it. She asked him directly, why didn't you think about me ahead of time?

And he said, you know what? I honestly, I don't have a good reason. But he said his default setting hasn't been her. He's been occupied with other business. And he's admitted that he now recognizes that's been the way that he's thought about things for a very long time. And he'll own that. He'll apologize for that. And he'll admit it any time that she needs him to say that. Because he wants to rewire that part of his brain and the relationship. And in that moment, a pretty solid move is the wife saying, okay, I appreciate that.

And you are saying the right things, the right mouth sounds. How do I know it'll be different next time? And that's where I jump in often and say, oh, you don't. Here's where there's an acceptance that I may not trust again. And that sounds pretty sad for a little bit. It's that once I accept the fact that I may not trust again, then I'm not trying to figure out what's wrong with me for not trusting. Now I can tap back into my own gut. And now I can start to begin to use the tools that will build trust. Because then there isn't one sentence that answers, how do we rebuild trust?

It gets answered in small, visible ways over an extended period of time, the next trip, the next time he's about to make a plan. And now hopefully there will be a thought that shows up that wasn't there before. Oh, I might want to just let my wife know I want to consider her and see if she has any plans or if there's anything that this is going to make uncomfortable for her. So, now I just want to widen this out a little bit because this couple is working through betrayal and then the pattern that I just described,

the statement and the rejection and the defending shows up in a pretty specific way after betrayal first comes to light. When something's uncovered, especially when the couple doesn't immediately hit pause and go find a therapist who actually works with betrayal trauma, which happens almost 0% of the time, what comes next, almost without exception, is something called the staggered disclosure. And it works a little bit like this. The betrayed partner feels something. And in this scenario, okay, we'll say it's the wife. She has a question. And her partner, from a place of fear or shame or concern or empathy or frustration

or any number of things, tells her a little bit of information, answers the question a little bit. He doesn't want to keep hurting her. He doesn't want to admit to her or sometimes to himself what he actually did. He's probably been telling himself for a long time that this was the last time and he believes it or that he's going to come clean or stop and then he never quite did. So, he's sparing with the details for himself and sometimes he'll tell himself for her. And then what he tells her doesn't always make much sense because there's a lot of gaps in there.

Her brain is also playing a game of, oh, if I can just have the information, if he can answer all these questions, then it will make sense to me. And if it makes sense to me, then I won't feel the way that I feel and we can move on. So her brain's telling her, if I can get all the details, then I'll feel better and we can move through this. So she asks more. And the next answer doesn't maybe quite line up with the last one or the one before that. So then she asks more. And now she's getting kind of frustrated and angry. and sad. And he's watching somebody that he cares about hurt. And a lot of it is because of what he has done.

So he gives her another piece to try and calm her down. Or he might even admit to something that isn't even true and hopes that this will end whatever's happening right now. And that leads to more questions. So the disclosure comes out in pieces. It's staggered. And now every answer that he gives is being checked against the answers before it. And every answer she gets is one more reason to believe there's more that he's hiding. And I bring this up because I think it explains why talking about betrayal is so hard, even for couples who are working hard to get through it. The pattern enters the relationship right there in the beginning,

day one, before anybody has the tools. And we train a relationship by what's tolerated and by how things unfold. So in the first month is question and partial answer and anger and another partial answer. And that becomes essentially the shape of how the two talk about betrayal. And then it's a shape that will produce endless questions and frustration on both sides. Now, there are so much better ways to have these conversations, which is a whole other episode of its own. And I did an episode about betrayal trauma with my former intern,

Marla Christensen, that I will link in the show notes that I think we talked a lot about this. But the short version is that the person who did the hurting has to come to the table with the full picture. But sometimes they don't even want to acknowledge the full picture. As early as they can, the better with help, instead of letting it get pulled out of them one piece at a time. And the person who was hurt gets to ask the questions from a place of real curiosity, not because the other person has earned it, but because curiosity is the thing

that can have the best chance of getting an honest answer back. Sometimes the answer will be, I don't know. I can't make sense of it. And that's why I think people need help navigating this. The next time somebody in your house brings you something that sounds like you didn't think of me, try the uncomfortable sentence. Maybe you're right. I didn't. And then stop and see how long you can sit there before but shows up. And then maybe even notice what it's like to let that go by and stay connected with the person in the room.

And after working with hundreds and hundreds of couples through different forms of betrayal, I've learned that more explaining, more promising, or more pressure to move on typically leaves people exhausted without helping them feel any closer. And I get it because eventually somebody says, I can't keep doing this. And they both try to put it away and then hope things work out, but then work out. Can eventually end up meaning just getting through the week without another painful conversation. And it goes right back to that. The absence of bad does not necessarily mean that things are good. And what I want to help them build is something so they can participate in the

relationship with more honesty, where questions can be answered, even if the answer is I'm not sure. But that doesn't mean I'm done with the answer. That means now my hero's journey is to try to figure that out. Responsibility can be taken. And then trust has an opportunity to grow and to build through what is now happening or what happens next. But even making room for that kind of honesty is going to feel real unfamiliar when you've spent years learning that a difficult conversation ends once you've made everybody else feel better. You may want answers and connection and still notice yourself watching your

partner's face, wondering whether you've asked enough for one evening, if this must be really hard on them and my job is to back off. Because you see their shoulders drop and then the conversation moves on. And maybe there's a little bit of relief in knowing that you can get through dinner and that the night's not going to be totally ruined. And your questions are still there, but you've had so much practice of setting your needs aside. And then before you've even decided what you need, the familiar, the typical instruction manual for the relationship starts to just show up or unfold. Let it go.

Keep the peace. Don't make it weird at dinner. You're probably seeing things. Make it comfortable for everybody else because you've been told time and time again that you are the problem. So meanwhile, just a little south of your brain, your stomach is now churning again. And typically you can still shove it down and you can accommodate and you manage other people's emotions at the expense of your own. And somewhere in there, you've stopped noticing that your stomach has been telling you something for years. I think this is part of why nobody shows up with the casserole because you've spent years making sure nobody can see what's going on. They don't see your losses from the street.

You still kept handling dinner. You kept the evening pleasant. You made sure the kids got where they needed to go. And from the outside, it looked like things were okay. And at times, even you've made sure that your partner feels like it's okay and you will internalize it. That's the skill that you've learned. The same thing that makes you so good at caring for everybody else is what makes it so hard to see that you're the one who needs care right now. I work with a lot of people who are very, very good at making a room comfortable for everybody else.

They've learned to read a mood from the moment their partner pulls in the driveway. They can tell by the sound of the tires on the gravel, by how the car door is closed, which version of their spouse is coming around the corner. It's a survival skill. They learned it young. It comes from growing up in a house where somebody else's feelings dictated the mood. Somebody else's emotions decided what kind of night this is going to be. And as a kid, whether this is the night to ask about the sleepover over the weekend, or is this the time to ask about playing a sport or needing money for something?

You grow up feeling like you really just have one shot. And even if you manage every variable, it's still a crapshoot. Now, in the world of narcissism and emotional immaturity, I've watched the skill carry people all the way up the corporate ladder to the spot right below the narcissistic leader, because the person who grew up in this environment got a whole lot more than the agreed upon 10,000 hours of training to become an expert. We are talking a lifetime of practice from the time someone's little. It's like learning a second language from the time you're young. So it is fluent.

You don't even realize you're not making translations. It's just the way you're showing up. So then managing other people's emotions became reflexive. It's what you do. It's what it feels like to be you. It's part of the co-regulation. Co-regulation is how we help each other settle through our voices, our expressions, our presence. It's like a calm parent comforting a crying baby. We can also pick up on each other's tension, which you probably experienced if you've been enjoying a perfectly pleasant evening and somebody walks into the room in a mood that you can just feel. It's tangible. It's palpable.

So for this accommodator, this people pleaser, this pathologically kind person, paying attention to those shifts has become second nature. It's survival. It's a way to feel safer and to keep the relationship connected. You learn what helps somebody settle, which subjects to approach carefully. And when a change in their expression means you might want to reconsider the sentence that you're literally in the middle of saying. And I think there's often a fine line between that being a superpower and a survival skill, because some of the abilities that this person develops really are impressive.

Somewhere along the way, though, being thoughtful and responsive becomes their full-time job. And now we have the origin story of the accommodator, the pathologically kind, the people pleaser, able to detect the change in mood from the way a dishwasher is being loaded. The accommodator can hear I'm fine from two rooms away and begin preparing three potential apologies. Able to leap over their own preferences in a single bound, they can turn, I was really looking forward to Italian, into Mexican sounds great, before anybody has even started looking at a wait time on a restaurant app.

So with extraordinary emotional radar, they can track a sigh, a raised eyebrow, a cabinet closing with slightly more enthusiasm than usual, all while continuing a conversation about whether there's enough milk for tomorrow. And then through a remarkable feat of conversational agility, they can walk into a conversation finally ready to say why they've been hurt and walk right out of it having apologized, reassuring the other person that they are wonderful and agreed that, yes, they do tend to overreact. Now, with Halloween in mind, at the time of this recording, just a few days

away, I will say that the costume that the person wears is whatever makes everybody else comfortable. Or if I want to go a bit introspective, perhaps they go as a mirror so they can reflect back to anybody they come into contact with, whoever that person needs to see. And if you want to see what all that looks like on an ordinary weeknight, picture a conversation about dinner. One person looks for agreement. The other has gotten very good at providing it. And a question about where to eat now requires the strategic preparation of an international summit. The emotionally immature partner says, I'm hungry.

And the accommodator says, Hey, me too. What sounds good? I don't know, whatever you want. Now, the accommodator has heard this opening before. Now, they have a lot of history that with making a suggestion, it's going to get picked apart, offered another suggestion, and eventually landing wherever their partner actually wanted to go in the first place. So, they developed a little strategy. They suggest something that they don't want because if it gets rejected, at least they've helped eliminate an option of something they don't want. How about breakfast for dinner, they ask, quietly hoping to retire breakfast

for dinner from the conversation because they don't really like that. And their partner says, are you sure? I mean, we can, if that's really what you want. Now the accommodator hears the hesitation and makes the turn. I don't know. I'm not set on it. I don't even know. I'm not even sure what I'm thinking. And then the emotionally immature partner says, I know you like Mexican and you haven't really suggested that in quite a while. So I don't know. Are you afraid to say that for some reason? And the accommodator says, man, you know what? You know me so well. Mexican food sounds great. And now they're getting Mexican breakfast for dinner

has been safely removed from consideration. And everybody appears to agree that the accommodator chose the restaurant and they may even enjoy the meal, but we still haven't actually learned what they wanted because most of their attention went toward finding an answer that would move the evening along comfortably. And I think that's part of what can make this pattern so difficult to recognize, especially from the outside, because it may look like an easygoing person who, you know, I'm happy with whatever. Now from the inside, there may be a remarkable amount of calculation happening

over a very ordinary question, which takes a tremendous amount of emotional calories. So the accommodator has gotten really good at playing their part because that part has helped them navigate not just this relationship, but all relationships. And then as we begin this work, if I'm working with somebody, then I want to make room for a question that they may not have had a whole lot of opportunity to answer. Hey, if you didn't have to manage anybody's response, what would sound good to you? And the number one answer in this version of the game is, I don't know.

And then we stay curious there. We're given a preference, some room to unfold, to develop. And sometimes before you can even answer the question, what do I want? You have to notice how much practice you've had answering a different question. Not what do I want, but that is quickly turned into what does this person need me to say? Now, talk a little bit about my mom, my emotionally immature slash narcissistic traits and tendencies mom. That often showed up for me in something that I eventually started calling the

old you-know-me syndrome. Whatever came after you-know-me was the version of herself that she wanted me to recognize. And my job throughout childhood and then well into adulthood was to confirm that we were talking about the same woman. You know me, Tony, I was so easy to talk to when you were a teenager, when you needed me the most. Now, the first thing I think about are all the times that was absolutely not the occasion. And then I would find myself trying to reconcile that with memories of asking for things that I thought I needed,

but then also learning that apparently i didn't need them because she hadn't had them growing up or it was going to be too inconvenient for her now. My mom made her own clothes in rural Tennessee in the 50s and the 60s, which I do want to acknowledge sounds incredibly resourceful. But somewhere in the translation, her pride in making her own clothes then became my enthusiasm for wearing homemade shorts as a teenage boy in a suburban high school in the 80s. That enthusiasm had essentially been assigned to me.

And trying to understand why is something that we do as humans. If you didn't grow up under the constant experience of being told that your experiences were incorrect, it would be easy to say, oh, how sweet it is that she wanted to share something that had been so important to her. But when it's the lens that you grew up under, I think it came from somewhere else. She didn't have parents who were there for her and she had to make her own clothes. So it had to be the right way to do things. If I did things differently than to a narcissistic or emotionally immature person, that reads as me thinking my way is right and so her way was wrong.

So, I had to be talked out of what I wanted and then I had to admit that I was wrong and that her way was right. All or nothing, black or white. There isn't space for somebody to have a different experience than the one that they needed you to have in order for them to still be correct, for their way to be the right way. And I do think so much of it is subconscious. It's just the air that they breathe. I remember when we shopped for school clothes, I might get a shirt or two. But then we would go to the fabric store to pick out some wacky fabric so she could make my shorts.

This was one of the experiences that I was told that I loved because you know me, Tony, I made everything fun. So she would tell me the version of her that I was supposed to validate. So a lot of my emotional bandwidth was spent trying to figure out what the right way to validate that version of her. Is, even if it wasn't the version that I experienced. From my perspective, I was trying to figure out how to get through the school day without attracting a very specific kind of attention. And what's even more interesting is that I work with so many people who would

eventually say something like, maybe I did like those terry cloth, blue polka dot ill-fitting shorts, and I just don't remember it that way because that's what they would hear enough times. Now, I will say that I'm grateful that my own internal experience was that I didn't question my own reality, but maybe to my detriment, I would on many of an occasion, still try to go in and explain my situation in a better way, thinking that maybe if I say it this way or remind her of this other thing, then she'll remember and acknowledge my experience, which it turns out,

I think is a large reason why I do the work that I do. So in a plot line that could have supported a very powerful afterschool special, I did become the class clown, a class and student body officer a varsity athlete, who changed into shorts, borrowed from wealthier friends in the bathroom before school. Then I would wear whatever my practice uniform was home of whatever sport I was in with both pair of shorts stuffed in my gym bag. I had essentially developed a wardrobe management system that required assistance

from my friends, access to a public restroom, and a conveniently scheduled athletic activity. Because what I hadn't figured out was how to tell my mom that an experience she remembered as fun was difficult for me. And have both of those experiences be okay. And I think then I've swung the pendulum with my own kids to the point of overcorrecting. Now they get everything that I never got, whether they asked for it or not. And my guess is that somewhere underneath it, I'm saying, hey champ, nobody ever came into my room and handed me something that I didn't have to

beg for and feel stupid about asking for. So here you go. It may be less about whether you like it and more about what I wish somebody had done for me. But hey, who knows? A few years before she died, my parents moved from Utah to Northern California by my wife and I and my kids. And by then, my mom was living with severe chronic pain and what I believed had become an opioid addiction, something that she didn't acknowledge. She tracked her medication doses meticulously, and I remember noticing that her expressions of pain sometimes intensified around the time another dose was

due or when a conversation moved away from her. And I couldn't know exactly what she was experiencing internally, but I knew that being with her involved paying close attention to what was happening and then adjusting accordingly. Driving was a particularly challenging assignment. Taking her to an appointment could mean being told what a poor driver you were and hearing that you were apparently targeting potholes on purpose. I was actually unaware that I had developed that level of precision behind the wheel. But if you hesitated to drive her somewhere, then she would say, you know me, I don't care who drives, I'm easy going.

And I would think about that while preparing for another performance review from the passenger seat. But still, I hoped the move would be good for her and good for my dad. And I volunteered to drive her across Nevada in their motorhome. Just the two of us. Road trip. We would split the trip into two days. My wife and my father would drive in the additional cars and we would stop in Winnemucca. Now, I had never driven a motorhome, but I got myself ready and even excited because, well, you know me, I love a good adventure.

Now, apparently, I also like an adventure where the passenger has concerns about my driving before I've learned where all the buttons in a motorhome are. But it was during that trip that the you-know-me concept really came together for me. My mom said that she wanted to hear about my childhood. And I remember still this feeling of hope. Wow, maybe we were going to talk about things that we hadn't been able to talk about before. I'm a therapist, for Pete's sake. I'm a doctor, according to her. Maybe the stretch of desert was going to give us some room to finally understand

each other because we had plenty of time. But as we talked, I started noticing that my memories were just the muse for her to interact with. My recollections seemed to need an adjustment before they could ever be accepted. And if something reflected well on her, we could stay there. It was still going to be different than what I remember. But if it didn't, I had misunderstood. Most likely my dad had been responsible or the event hadn't happened the way that I remembered it. You know, I was hoping to share what being me had been like,

and we kept returning to what being my mom needed to mean about her. One example was smoking. My parents both smoked, and in my memory, they smoked a lot. I grew up in the 70s and the 80s when people smoked in restaurants, in their homes, in their cars on airplanes, which still just seems like such a particularly ambitious place to make everybody secondhand smoke your cigarette. I remember sitting in the backseat of our car on many of an occasion when one parent would light up and then the other one would, and then hoping that somebody

would just crack a window. Eventually my brother, I would ask, and I remember the window opening a little crack and there would be a relief of getting some fresh share, but also this impression that asking had been a real inconvenience. And even now, I'll be honest, cigarette smoke brings up a pretty strong visceral reaction for me. And not that long ago, I noticed something else. Somebody handed me something. I don't remember what it was. And my first move was to smell it. That's something I do. I smell things. I think I have a strong sense of smell.

I love scented lotions, candles, fabric softeners. And when I started thinking about the fabric softener, a whole little chapter of my childhood just came rushing back because by middle school, I had a routine. Before school, I would take my clothes downstairs where we had the washer and dryer, spray them with water, and then put them in the dryer for about 10 minutes with a fabric softener sheet that I had bought myself. Then I'd put them on, they would feel warm and they would smell good and I would head out the door because Because at night, by the end of the night, I could smell cigarettes on my clothes, and I didn't want to go to school smelling like smoke.

So before I was old enough to drive, I developed my own small clothing restoration business. Between the dryer and the shorts exchange, getting dressed was taking up a lot of administrative time, more than I'd ever realized. So during our trip across Nevada, my mom said she needed a cigarette and she didn't want to stop. We were making good time. She didn't want to get out. And she told me that I wouldn't mind if she smoked as long as she cracked a window. So I decided to tell her, hey, can I tell you what I remember about being a kid in the backseat waiting for somebody to let a little air in?

And while holding her cigarette, she said, you know me, Tony, I rarely smoked. I don't even need to do this right now. I don't even really like these things. You know, your dad was the problem. You don't remember that correctly. I knew better than to smoke around you boys. And my dad worked a lot and he hunted and he fished and he bowled. And my brother shared some of those interests with him. My memories of being driven places were mostly memories of my mom. And smoking was a part of those memories. So I tried again. I still had this hope that if I explained it clearly enough,

then we might just have that moment of understanding. I remember you driving me places, mom. And I remember you smoking in the car. And her response was essentially, you know me, my memory is incredible. You were a kid. Now, we had arrived at a familiar place. I could agree with her account, or I could keep trying to explain mine and risk spending the next hundred miles, debating whether I had actually been present for my own childhood. And I remember recognizing that she seemed to need my confirmation of who she had been more than she could make room for what I was telling her.

I could understand that hearing about my discomfort might be painful for her, but the conversation left very little space for that discomfort to have happened at all. There was another memory that I kept coming back to. It was a photograph that she loved to show me. She was nine months pregnant with me, dressed up at a party, smiling at the camera with a cigarette in one hand and a glass of wine in the other. Now, by the time that I really noticed those details, humor was already my preferred way to deal with anything emotional, anything uncomfortable.

So I remember saying, oh, so that's why I'm lucky to be five foot eight on a good day and I can't find a fitted hat that doesn't cut off the circulation to my brain. No, no, mijo, she'd say, drawn on her semester of high school Spanish. That's because you're so smart. And we could laugh, which was something that I knew how to help us do. I also recognize that the understanding of smoking and drinking during pregnancy was different then. As a matter of fact, I've spent time looking into that history because I just wanted to understand the context. But I think the reason the photograph stays with me had more to do with what

happened when I tried to talk about my experiences later. Could we be curious about something that affected me without needing to establish, that it couldn't have been her? After our conversation about smoking, the story kept changing. I heard that actually she rarely smoked, that she didn't like it, and that she had done it because essentially the story confabulated into my dad made her. Eventually, there were stories almost to the point where she would say that he would tell her to, you have to do this, and you must smoke and smoke faster.

It's what I thought of as her confabulation machine because it kept revising the account. And then each revision moved us further from the childhood experience that I had tried to share. Sometimes she would pull me into another room to tell me these newly remembered stories. And she would do it loud enough that my dad could still hear him. Bless his heart, he generally didn't challenge the account. And I can't tell you exactly what he was thinking. But from where I sat, it looked like he had learned something familiar to me. Questioning the story was likely to lead to more story.

And that's part of what I think is so interesting when you think about the accommodator. You may have learned to consider much more than whether you wanted to say something, because you're also considering what would happen after you said it. Now, would you be understood? Probably not. Would you spend the evening reassuring somebody else? Probably. But even more bizarre, would the experience that you share come back later in a version that got even bigger, where you were even worse and they were even better,

where you were ungrateful, confused, or cruel for having brought it up? And after enough of those conversations, whatever you need, whatever you want, becomes so much more understandable. It's a safer way to get through dinner. Then years later, somebody like me sitting across from you in a therapy office says, hey, what is it that you want? And you maybe take a quick look inward and discover that a lot of your attention has still turned toward the other person.

What answer will they be comfortable with? What will require the least amount of explanation? And we can begin by noticing that without turning it into another thing that you should have figured out sooner. You've had a lot of practice making room for somebody else's version of events. Now is the time to start to make room for yours, even if you don't know what those are, including the parts that you're still uncertain about, the feelings you used, humor to move past, and the preferences that you're only beginning to discover. I've sat across from so many people who learned in whatever way was necessary

to stop trying to be understood. And if that meant throwing themselves under the bus, fine. They were also already driving the bus and they were the one that was responsible for keeping up on the maintenance. So, what do you do? You often turn to doing and managing and sacrificing and slowly understanding that the question, but what do you want means I need you to know and do what I want, but can you please say it out of your mouth hole? They can tell you what their partner wants, what their children need.

They'll happily go to a steak restaurant for their birthday dinner, despite the fact that they are a vegetarian, have been for almost a decade, and the restaurant you're going to literally has no vegetarian options. But give them an afternoon with no obligations, and they may have no idea what to do with themselves. They won't know how to just be. They only know how to do, and in particular, to do for others. They've had a lot more practice figuring out where they're needed than trying to figure out where they'd actually like to be.

And I say all of that with affection, because there's often such real kindness in those abilities, real attentiveness, and a sincere desire to make life better for the people that they love. And maybe noticing the mood and adjusting to it helped them preserve any type of connection when they had very little say in what happened next. So then it makes sense that they would keep reaching for something that had helped. But over time, they may have gotten so practiced at organizing themselves around

other people that their own preferences became harder to hear. So, the work, the new work is learning how to use that sensitivity and. Some choice, to notice someone else's disappointment without immediately sacrificing yourself or volunteering to take the blame for it, and to let their own wants have a place in the conversation. The accommodator deserves to discover that they can be caring and thoughtful and loved while occasionally being the person who wants Italian.

We often discover that the accommodating didn't begin with that partner. It's most likely an extension of something they learned far back in childhood. And I now recognize how difficult the following exchange can be. I can be sitting across this person and then I get to deliver what I think is the most exciting news. Drum roll, please. You get to figure out who you are and what matters to you. You get to have preferences. You get to want things. And then one of the most common responses I hear is, oh yeah,

what do you think that is? What do you think I would be good at? I don't really know what I want, which makes so much sense. But then I remember for a little while, I would think, okay, apparently my motivational speech department in my brain was not prepared for that. So hang on, let me get the inspirational music swelling. Maybe we need the wind machine going and let's try to get you, amazing client person, after a lifetime of keeping the peace at your own expense now, you have room to consider what you want. And I'm still getting somebody looking back at me thinking, no, I got it. I'm just curious, like, what do you think that I want?

And that wind is drying out my eyes. Because often what they want to do is keep figuring out what's wrong with them. Why didn't they know sooner? Why did they stay? What have they done to their family? And I think it's because there's something so familiar and also temporarily reassuring about making yourself the explanation. If the problem lives entirely inside of you, then maybe there's something you can change that will make the whole situation better and nobody else has to be uncomfortable.

Okay, I can be more patient. I can need less. I can explain myself more carefully, or I can find a way to stop being so affected by what's happening. I can tell my nervous system that it needs to just relax. Those are probably moves you've been practicing for a very long time. And they offer something that uncertainty definitely doesn't, something that you already know how to do. So you try to set the hurt aside, explain it away, smile and wave, put the anger somewhere that it won't create another problem.

Maybe you go make cookies, although you're cracking the eggs with a level of enthusiasm that the recipe did not request. And you're stirring the ever-living crap out of that batter. You're trying to just carry on, take care of everybody else, and find somewhere for all of that energy to go. Then somebody asks who you are, what you want, or what you believe, and you don't know where to begin. So lately, I've actually been starting from the other end. What do you know that you don't want? What are you tired of doing? What would you be relieved to stop having to manage?

Because sometimes at least those questions give us something to work with. You may not know what a satisfying evening looks like yet, but you know you don't want to spend it studying somebody else's face to find out whether you're allowed to enjoy yourself. Or you don't want to watch another episode of some show that you've pretended that you enjoy. And that's where I think we'll leave things today. Giving your own experience a little bit of room before even asking you to know exactly what to do with it. I always liked the part of the Saturday morning cartoons. What did we learn today?

So you discover a betrayal or you begin recognizing a pattern that you haven't been able to name. Suddenly, you're looking back at your own history with questions that you didn't have before. You may be grieving the relationship that you thought you had or the hope that you could explain yourself clearly enough and it would change everything. The other person would finally understand. And meanwhile, the world is still turning and people need dinner. And there may not be anybody showing up at your door with a casserole because they don't even realize that there's been a loss. And I know that hope, the one that keeps reaching for the next explanation,

and I want to be very gentle with the part of us that has kept reaching for it. So, between now and part two, I would love to give you a couple of things to try, starting with something small enough that you aren't going to have to do necessarily anything external. The next time you notice yourself reaching for whatever you want, just see whether you can pause long enough to ask yourself, do I have a preference here? You may be genuinely happy with whatever the option is, but you may also at least notice that you did have an answer, but immediately started calculating

what it would cost for you to say it. So for now, just notice that moment. You can acknowledge a preference privately and where it feels safe. Practice expressing it in an ordinary situation, low charge topics. Maybe you did want Mexican food. Maybe you would like 20 minutes to yourself. Maybe you would prefer shorts that you don't need to exchange in a public restroom. We can start wherever you are. And if the answer is still, I don't know, sometimes that's the immediate reaction of I'm worried about saying the wrong thing or wanting something that I shouldn't want.

So if that's the case, just be aware of it. Or you may not know how you want to spend an afternoon, but you can acknowledge that you're tired of spending it waiting to find out whether somebody else is in a good mood. That gives you something to be curious about. You're beginning to notice what your day is like for you. And that's a start and it's important information before you know what you want to change. And the other thing I might bring some awareness to is, if you do feel like you're alone or stuck or sequestered or isolated in the

things that you're going through, maybe just start thinking about one trustworthy person that you might be able to open up to and share a little bit more about what you're carrying. Somebody who's shown you that they can listen or they can respect your privacy, and give you room to move at your own pace. You might even say, I'm starting to understand some things about me or my relationship, and I'm having a hard time, but I'm not ready to make decisions, but I could really use somebody to listen. In part two, we're going to go into the accommodator and the emotionally immature person's origin story.

I want to explore how learning to keep connection by adjusting yourself, can shape what feels familiar in your current adult relationship and how can two people settle into roles that seem to work for a while until one person begins noticing how little room there is for them to have a separate experience. We'll follow those patterns into a couple story and then look at what happens when the person who has spent years accommodating starts saying, hey, I'm noticing I don't trust this right now and I want to talk about what I saw. Because I think the more that we dig into those relationships and see how they

develop, we're going to start to be able to identify where responsibility really belongs. Your kindness, your history, your efforts to preserve connection don't. Make you responsible for someone else's deception or their mistreatment. And understanding your part in a familiar pattern can definitely help you discover, more choices moving forward. And you can do that also while still having compassion for what you knew, but what you didn't know how to express or what you had hoped for and what you

were trying to protect at that time. So for now, hopefully you can leave this episode with something smaller than a plan that you have to take action for the rest of your life. You can just notice a preference or acknowledge one experience without explaining it away or let one safe person know that you could use a little company. You spent so much time learning how to make room for other people there's room to begin including yourself in that self-care even while you're still getting to know what that looks like then somewhere down the road, part of what we're building toward is a life where the sound of somebody arriving doesn't require you,

to become anybody than you're already being. Thanks for spending this time with me, taking us out per usual, the wonderful, the talented Aurora Florence with her song, It's Wonderful. And I'll see you back here for part two. Compressed emotions flying past, our heads and out the other end, the pressures of the daily grinding.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Hosts

  • Tony Overbay Host Feed-stated

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. How Childhood Shapes Who You Marry: The Accommodator, Attachment, and Why We Choose the Familiar

    Nov 13, 20261 hr 18 minAudio

    Why do people pleasers and avoidant partners find each other, and why does it seem like such a relief at first? Tony follows Pam and Jim, a composite couple, from childhood to the college campus where they met. Pam...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Nobody Brings a Casserole When You Wake Up to Betrayal: The Accommodator, Gaslighting, and Rebuilding Trust

    Nov 4, 20261 hr 29 minAudio

    Waking up to betrayal, gaslighting, or emotional immaturity rarely comes with a casserole on the porch or a meal train. When someone has a baby or a surgery, people can see the event and show up with dinner. When you...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Your AI Is a Great Hype-Man - A Therapist Has a Few Notes (Plus Live QA)

    Oct 14, 20261 hr 32 minAudio

    Using AI as a therapist? Your chatbot might be building a great plan for the person you’re hoping to become. When a client’s chatbot asked if he was an extroverted go-getter, he answered as the man he’s working toward,...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Why Good People Defend Leaders (and Others) Who Contradict Themselves: Identity, Bias & Belonging

    Sep 24, 202653 minAudio

    Tony starts with a kid raised in an East Coast fishing town and another raised hiking Arizona trails. He uses them to show how beliefs tend to form through family, community, and identity, with the reasons showing up...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. If You Can't Say No, Your Yes Doesn't Mean Anything: The Truth About Desire and Intimacy in Marriage

    Sep 23, 20261 hr 18 minAudio

    Most couples sign an unwritten contract about sex and intimacy, and the terms rarely get said out loud. Greg and Amy Langford, certified marriage and intimacy coaches and hosts of the “Undressing Intimacy” podcast,...

    Credit the people on this episode