Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

The Virtual Couch

The Virtual Couch artwork

Taking the Long Way Home: Homer as Your Therapist, The Odyssey as Your Map

Aug 14, 20261 hr 7 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Emotional maturity takes the long way home, and Homer's Odyssey has been quietly saying so for 2,800 years. Underneath Christopher Nolan's new adaptation sits a poem that Tony thinks is one of the best pieces of therapy literature ever written, and almost nobody reads it that way. The monsters aren't the point - they're the muse. Every obstacle Odysseus meets is asking whether he's willing to become somebody different, and if you've been away too long from your sense of self, from the marriage you thought you'd have, from the body you used to trust, from the faith that used to hand you certainty, or from the person you were sure you'd be by now, this one tends to land. In this episode: Meet the Lotus Eaters as experiential avoidance - coping that doesn't start as self-sabotage, it starts because it works, and then it quietly moves the destination Borrow a rule from Tony's ultra-running days, beware of the chair, and notice how many races end beside a space heater rather than on a cliff Tie yourself to the mast with a Ulysses contract, the decision your calm Tuesday afternoon self makes on behalf of your 11 p.m. Friday night self Watch the Cyclops moment show up in a marriage, when "See, I told you so" reaches back and drags a conflict you'd already escaped into your future Sit with David Schnarch's differentiation, and the difference between other-validated and self-validated intimacy Tony Overbay is a licensed marriage and family therapist who has spent over twenty years watching people discover they didn't know what they didn't know. This is part one - part two takes on Schnarch's four points of balance. If the poem stirred something up for you, send it Tony's way and it may end up in the next episode. Please follow Tony on Instagram @virtual.couch on Tiktok @virtualcouch on Facebook https://www.facebook.com/tonyoverbaylmft and on Substack https://thevirtualcouch.substack.com/ You can reach out to Tony through his website tonyoverbay.com or by emailing contact @ tonyoverbay.com

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Sing to me of the man, muse. The man of twists and turns, driven time and again off course. Now, where does that line come from? I want you to hang onto that question for just a minute because I wanna start somewhere else, but we will get back to that. Hey, everybody. Welcome to another episode of The Virtual Couch and probably waking up to narcissism, 'cause this is gonna be one of those episodes that I've been working on for a little while. I think it's so packed full of information, I wanna share it with both audiences, and we're gonna make sure we hit on some narcissistic traits and tendencies, emotional immaturity, marriage related things, you name it.

My name is Tony Overbay. I'm a licensed marriage and family therapist. You can find me on Instagram @virtual.couch, on TikTok @virtualcouch, all one word, on Facebook at Tony Overbay License and Tony Overbay Licensed Marriage and Family Therapist. Go to my website, tonyoverbay.com, sign up for the newsletter, and find me on Substack. There's a lot of content on Substack that is growing and growing and growing I have an Emotional Architects group for men who are trying to wake up to their own emotional maturity. I've got a private women's Facebook group for women who are in narcissist-- for women who are in relationships with narcissistic fill in the blanks, could

be a spouse, a boss, a friend, a pet. Let's get to today's show because if you've listened to my podcast for any length of time, you more than likely heard me call something my muse. A client's question becomes my muse sometimes for an entire episode. I literally had a session earlier today with a client, and they were just bringing some not just gentle, but pretty, pretty intense awareness around a concept of their parent saying to them "You made your bed, now lie in it." And we were breaking that down, so we were going to such depths, and then all

of a sudden I just said, "Or what if you just… What if you're ready to get a new bed, and you want the one that has all the different settings, and it has memory foam and a cooling pillow?" What-- I know it's not just that easy, but it's just fascinating, and it's had me thinking about that for a few hours, so that is something that is a muse, something that I want to interact with, I want to think about more. My kids, all adults now, often become my muse, and I think I say it so often that I now have clients, people I sit across from every week, stop me in the middle of a session when I start waxing on about today's muse and ask,

which I appreciate more than anything, "What is a muse again?" Because I think that's a very fair question. In Greek mythology, the muses were nine goddesses. They were these daughters of Zeus, and each one of them was responsible for inspiring a different type of art. Could be poetry, music, history, dance. So when a poet sat down to create something, the first thing that they did was they would ask the muse of poetry, Calliope, to work through them to create poetry. So this poet was just the vessel, and then their job was to be open enough

to receive what the muse was offering to pick up what the muse was putting down to buy what the muse was selling. And that's a really cool concept in and of itself because if you are not open and curious and able to acknowledge that, "Okay, I don't know everything, and I wanna know what I don't know," then you won't be open to the inspiration that a muse has to offer And now over time, the word has changed into the way that I think we use it today, or at least very much the way I use it today, where a muse can be anything at all.

It can be a person, a piece of art, a sunset, a smell. And I was trying to resist this. My-- I'm filming this from my office in Arizona, and in Arizona, I'm in a set of salon suites, and the smell of permanent solution and burnt hair is strong today. And that does… It takes me back to my grandma's house. It is a muse right there. So a smell can be a muse, a burrito, a story, a movie, a joke. So basically any experience or anything that sparks insight or creativity or just has you think about things in within you is your muse.

A songwriter's muse might be a breakup, and I'm curious if you thought of a particular songwriter, if you happen to be a Swiftie, for example a painter's muse might be a landscape or a sunset and a therapist's muse or this therapist's muse is usually whatever walks into my office that week. And I'll even acknowledge or own the fact that there can be some good old confirmation bias happening, where if I'm thinking about something, I'm probably seeing it more in therapy. And sometimes I find myself seeing themes throughout the day. I've even toyed with the idea of creating this content around what

is the theme of the day, because it sure seems like something. And what's pretty fascinating about that is I do think the concept of confirmation bias can come through, that if that's what I'm looking for, if I'm looking for a particular thing, therapeutic technique or skill or challenge or issue or problem, am I gonna see more of that? So for example, one day last week, it was when I was actually starting to lay out this outline, I noticed that that day's muse seemed to be people shutting down when they were asked questions. And there is a form of that that is one of my favorite concepts of

emotional immaturity, where if you don't answer, eventually the person asking the question will move on, and you'll live to fight another day. If you hunker down into the bunker and you wait for the storm to pass, , it will pass. This isn't an all or nothing statement, but when you dig into that pattern and you stay with it, you often find that the person grew up with a lot of criticism, or they worried that they were often gonna say the wrong thing, because most likely, you were often told that wasn't the right thing to say. So rather than simply saying a thing, they would just wait, and then eventually the

parent might say, "Okay, well, think about that," or, "Well, I don't want you doing it again." , And if somebody takes offense at the thing that somebody says, because eventually I believe it's perfectly okay to be able to express yourself, to say a thing as an adult, and that other person takes offense in a more emotionally mature way, then tell me more about it. Tell me what it was about the thing that I said that bothers you. I really wanna know, because that's far more mature than just, "I won't say anything." And, I think I've become obsessed with the concept and muse of

co-regulation, where we're nervous systems that are interacting with each other. I work with individuals as well, but I see this so often in couples as a couples therapist because I have many, many examples come into my office every day. The, the couples I work with essentially become my inspiration. So I get to watch a couple talk sometimes maturely and with curiosity, and often for the first time in a long time, they didn't know what they didn't know. They didn't have the tools to communicate productively or maturely.

Then one of them will say something, and I watch the other person just pull back and recoil like they just got a strong whiff of the permanent solution that I'm smelling right now, or maybe better described, some spoiled milk. So the person who said the thing they said it, and then the other person responded and reacted. The person who says the thing they look terrified, and they'll look over at me often and just say, "Okay, help me. What did I say wrong?" So here's a, a very real example from just a few days ago. I'm gonna change enough of the details that of course no one

will be able to identify the couple that I'm talking about. And if you are a couple that's working with me now and you think it's about you, I believe the great Carly Simon said, "You're so vain," that I-- you probably think this song's about you, so this isn't about you. But as a muse, so there was a husband, and he was making space for his wife's experience and emotions like he had never done that before. In the past, he's been very reactive. He was very immature, would get very big and loud. So in this scenario, he really was not being reactive. He was learning to respond. He was calm. He was grounded. He was showing up.

And he said I truly can't imagine how hard that must have been for his wife to experience him as this person that he had been for so long in the relationship, and he said that he was sorry that it had taken him so long to begin showing up differently and figuring things out. And while he had said these things before, now he was embodying it. Now she could feel it 'cause he felt it. And he seemed genuinely curious about what she was saying. He wanted to understand her experience. And then he said and it was powerful, , I am working hard to be more consistent

and to show up as the person I wanna be. Somebody that you'll be able to rely on, somebody who follows through, somebody who keeps their word." And I really do think for a moment that I could hear a, a swelling in the background, music coming from somewhere in my office I didn't even know existed. It seemed like we were about to have an insanely cool moment. It's one of the most satisfying moments that you can experience as a therapist. And it was as if his hair started to blow back a little bit. I don't have a wind machine, but thank you, Arizona. I have a couple of fans blowing in different directions, and it was

like they came together at exactly the right time for dramatic effect. And then out of the corner of my eye, peeking through the blinds in the window beside my door, is that a leprechaun? And it looks like he's holding a pot of gold in one hand, and he's got a unicorn on a bedazzled leash in the other hand, frantically trying to catch my eye. And I think, "Now, boss? We come in now?" And I'm waving him off because all I'm thinking is, "This is the perfect couple's moment." I only make those jokes because I have been told on numerous occasions that when I start talking about this is really what can happen in couples therapy,

it's hard for people to hear sometimes. They wanna think that that is a fairy tale. It is not as common as I would like, but it can be a thing. I like it to be out there in the universe, in the zeitgeist so people do know that people can learn things they didn't know and learn to deal with discomfort and uncertainty and sit there and make space for their spouse's emotions. So things were heading in a direction that felt that perfect and that fairy tale-like, and then the guy looked directly into his wife's eyes and he said, "You just need to tell me when I'm doing something that bothers

you And that was it at that moment. Now I was thinking, "Okay, where in the set of salon suites is there a DJ?" 'Cause I'm hearing a record scratch, but not the cool kind, because his wife recoiled, and now it was as if she could smell rotten milk emanating from him. And if you're confused about why a moment that was headed toward rainbow unicorn leprechaun pot of gold celebration of , what he said, why that was what took it south, you just need to tell me when I'm doing something bad.

I wanna say that if you know, you already know, and if not, let me provide you with a muse. Because remember, this muse is co-regulation. He was startled by her reaction. She was triggered, and he immediately became heightened. Now, I was noticing, thankfully, not reacting. That was the point where in the past, before my obsession with co-regulation, I might have then reacted to his reaction to her reaction, and I would have met them in the chaos, and I probably would have tried to quickly correct him so he would calm down, so she would chill out, and so they would both feel better about the

session, and so they would like me, and so I would feel like a good therapist. In the past, that might have calmed everybody down. Okay. And we landed the plane, and we put a pretty bow on it because I wanted all the sessions to end with everybody like, "That was good." Because if not, they're gonna think it's bad, and then they're gonna think I'm bad. And in the past, sure, people might have left the session feeling better, but they would have had no idea what the heck just happened. And even more importantly, they would not have any ability to recognize the pattern

of what just happened, because I guarantee you it has happened plenty before, and it's gonna happen in the future. And they certainly wouldn't know what to do when it happened again, because it's going to happen again and again and again. But if I can stay grounded, I'm essentially modeling for them what the concept of co-regulation is. The best example of that is a newborn, a, a newborn baby is born, hence the name newborn. A baby is born, and it is pink and squishy and smells nice-ish, and it's--

it can't regulate its own emotions, so it cries and moves and wails. So a mom or dad is gonna hold the baby and essentially say, " You can borrow my nervous system because you can't get a handle on yours 'cause you're a baby. So borrow my nervous system and we will co-regulate." So I'm essentially modeling for them in the room, this couple, "Hey guys, you're paying me the big bucks. You can model my nervous system. I have plenty to spare. I'm confident in what I'm seeing and what we're doing." And I'm confident sitting here with the tools that I have, and I've seen this so many times,

probably more than once that day. So let's borrow my nervous system, co-regulate, slow things down, and now let's look at the pattern. Let's look at what just happened. Talk about an incredible muse for me to remain open to, allow to flow through me and to use to become a better therapist and turns out to be a better human, a better father, better husband in general. And since this episode itself may become a muse for somebody listening, let me explain really what was happening underneath the hood of that exchange So for anybody curious about why that example is significant, the husband,

along with so many guys that I've worked with and continue to work with, is a classic nice guy, as in a concept called nice guy syndrome. So when he says, "You just need to tell me when I'm doing something that bothers you," he genuinely believes that he's being open and cooperative and accountable because it is so much better than the version of him in the past that was angry and reactive and shut down and gaslit and diffuse and put stuff back onto her. He feels like this is significant growth and there's a version of him after he's become grounded and shown a lot of consistency where that could actually

be a perfectly reasonable request. But up to this point, that dynamic has been the basis of their relationship. Basically him saying, "What am I supposed to do? She didn't tell me that I was doing anything wrong." Because he, he isn't capable at this point of connecting his own dots or figuring things out on his own. Sounds open and cooperative and accountable, but what she hears is, "Hey, so I am here, and I'm gonna figure all this out, and I wanna be this new person, but you still need to monitor me and identify the problems and figure out what needs to change.

Hand me the instructions then." So without realizing it, he's still handing the responsibility for his growth right back to his wife. She remains in the role of manager, teacher, and mother holding the clipboard and carrying the mental load for both of them and probably for , the other people in the family. Meanwhile, he gets to be the well-meaning employee waiting for his next assignment and waiting for a raise or a bonus or a pat on the head or a cookie or a trophy or intimacy if he does well She doesn't want another employee. She doesn't want another child to manage who, who deserves a

treat when he does what she asks. She can't be his mother and his lover, although I think that's a lot of what Freud talks about. Oh, no, she was hoping that he had reached the point where he trusted himself and knew himself well enough to connect his own dots, notice the needs around him, take initiative, and begin his own hero's journey of emotional growth, even if he was going to be tested for safety or it wasn't going to be exactly what other people expected of him. His own hero's journey, which now brings us back to the opening line, "Sing to me of the man, Muse." That, my friends, is the first line of

Homer's Odyssey, one of the oldest stories that human beings have and one of the original hero's journeys home. The, the poet or the bard literally opens the poem by asking the muse, "Tell me a story." So the very first word of one of the most foundational works of Western literature is a request for inspiration. Tell me a story. Help me understand what I don't understand. I love it because the poem begins with the poet admitting, "I do not have it all figured out. I do not know what I don't know." And that is a powerful

concept that has been around as long as people have been telling stories. Now, who was Homer? That's a fun journey to take i- in and of itself. Short answer, we're not entirely sure, although you can find people that are pretty confident. And I think that's part of the charm What I discovered is that Homer is traditionally credited as the author of "The Iliad" and "The Odyssey," two epic poems composed somewhere around the eighth century BCE, roughly 2,800 years ago. If you're my age, mid-50s, probably read the CliffsNotes, and then apparently

they were SparkNotes, and then I think it turned essentially into the internet. In high school, instead of reading the book, I ran into a couple of people that really enjoyed the book, loved the book and it was a game changer for them. But for others, this might be the first exposure that you're having to it via the Christopher Nolan film. But before I go there, the poems weren't written the way books are written today, which I think is part of the reason there's still a controversy about who Homer was, because they came out of an oral tradition. Think of an endless generational game of telephone.

So for centuries poets memorized and then they performed the stories out loud. And I would imagine, that then they padded them and added to them because that's the way our memory works. You recall a memory and you add to it based on whatever you're going through at that moment. Whatever the situation is emotionally or just situationally you add those bits and pieces to your memory when you file that memory back away. So when you bring the memory back up, it has those bits and pieces from before that are a part of it. So for example, if one of the storytellers had been somebody like me, they probably

would have added to the story, "And the hero stood five seven, five eight with sandals on, and he was bald, and everybody appreciated the fact that he was bald, and they found it quite fetching. And the hero went on tangents often, which was what the people loved about this hero." So they would pass the stories down the line, and then people would add to them long before anybody wrote down a word. So Homer might have been one person, one man, or the name attached to an entire tradition of storytellers. But either way, when the poems were finally written down, they became the bedrock of Greek education and eventually Western storytelling itself.

So most every long journey home, hero's journey story that you've ever loved from one of my favorites, "Oh Brother, Where Art Thou?" To "Finding Nemo," also a good one, to half or more of all the country songs that you've probably heard is running on Homer's foundation. So why bring this up now? Because right now, this poem is everywhere. Again, Christopher Nolan, director of "Oppenheimer" and "Inception" and "Interstellar," just released his film adaptation of "The Odyssey,"

and it has been long awaited. Matt Damon plays Odysseus the protagonist. Anne Hathaway is Penelope, his wife. Tom Holland plays their son, Telemachus. Zendaya or Zendaya is the goddess Athena. And it has been, to put it gently, a topic of conversation. So before anybody had actually even seen a single frame, people were already arguing about the casting and the accents and the dialogue and how the Trojan horse was integrated and portrayed. So at the time, I looked it up, and this was right before the release, but the final trailer had collected more than a half a million dislikes.

Now meanwhile early reviews were calling the film staggering movie of the year. And I did, I saw it. I loved it. I absolutely loved it. I've watched several breakdowns of the movie and so many of the pre-movie controversies were somewhat put to rest once people actually had the context of the actual film. And I made sure that this was a challenge where I wanted to watch both sides of the argument, and it was just really interesting to see. But it was easy to see that people had not been adhering to the pre-pillar of my beloved four pillars of a connected conversation, which is the need to

separate observation from judgment. They would see a character cast in a certain role. That is an observation and that's fair. And then they would make a judgment about what that meant or how it would most likely be experienced, and then move forward with such certainty that if you didn't agree, then you weren't being honest with yourself. So that would-- they would create a, a tremendous amount of content about something that they hadn't even viewed yet. Projection, anybody? Or it's the old, "If I think it, then it's true," so now you have to defend it, which is one of the most common forms of emotional immaturity.

And I do think for the most part we all do it don't get me wrong. The ex-example is somebody says "I'm pretty sure you're mad at me." Now the person being accused is actually the one who gets to check in with themselves, okay? They might say, " Not aware of being mad at you, but thank you for asking or telling me. I can check in with myself and hopefully alleviate your worry. Yep, I'm not mad at you, and I would hate for you to carry that with you when it isn't true." So then the person making the accusation can say, " That just doesn't feel like that's true. I don't think you're telling the truth, and I still think you're

mad at me." So they're essentially communicating "Now you need to make me feel better about something that I think or feel, which I asked you about and you told me wasn't true. I don't believe you though so go. Start dancing. I need you to try to make me feel better. I'm not even sure what it's gonna take to do so." I've been on the receiving end of that many times throughout my life in, in family situations out in the wild, any kind of relationship, including the therapeutic relationship. I will never forget one of my favorite clients who has long since passed away, an elderly woman who had very gorgeous long hair, which is not

common for someone that was her age. I have had no hair for so long, not even joking, that I definitely don't criticize people's choices in hairdos, hair don'ts, hairstyles, because I have not had one to speak of Now, I have had plenty of criticism for being bald. My go-to line used to be, "I was bald before bald was cool." And at some point people started saying, "Is it cool?" But I think it's far more acceptable now than it was when I first became bald. Now, this woman who I had worked with for a long time once said something

about me criticizing her hair. She said, "I know that you don't like it a certain way, long." And she said, "You've told me that." And I said, "I have actually never done that." Because if there's one thing that I feel confident that I don't do, it's criticize people's haircuts or hairstyles against, again, in context, because that has been a sore spot for me for a long time until it wasn't. Not having any hair I might walk around with a soup bowl haircut or something completely crazy on my head if I had the choice. I don't even have the choice to make it look bad. I know I had not criticized her hair.

But she said, "Oh, you have. You've done it plenty of times." And that was so hard for me to hear because I, I believed I was the only one who actually knew. You could accuse me of other things, and I could say, "you know what? You're right. My memory, who knows? I can't say you're wrong." But with this, I had to adopt my beloved four pillars. Pillar one, assume good intent. She wasn't trying to hurt me. There was a reason she was saying what she was saying. Pillar two, I couldn't tell her that she was wrong or ridiculous or that I didn't believe her, even though, big dramatic pause, I thought it was wrong and kind of ridiculous, and I definitely didn't believe her.

I had to move into pillar three. Tell me more. That, that form of emotional immaturity is so prevalent. Somebody says, "No, you're mad," then it's "Oh man, I didn't even realize I was mad. I mean, I'm not, and I don't feel like I am, but I guess I better prove myself to you." A-and when you think about it that way, the whole relationship game becomes absolutely rigged because you're trying to prove something that isn't true. Anyway, let's get back to The Odyssey. So what I find so fascinating is that this is a story that is 28 centuries old, and we're still fighting about who gets to tell it and how. Nobody fights that hard over something that doesn't matter.

So the controversy is proof of the poem's power. Something in this story still touches a nerve. It still feels like ours, and it still feels worth protecting. So that, my friends, is an incredible muse, which starts again with the line, "Sing to me of the man, muse, the man of twists and turns, driven time and again off course." But I am not actually here to review the movie. I'm here because the poem underneath it is also one of the best pieces of therapy literature I think ever written and I don't think it's typically looked at that way let me give you the story in about 90 seconds.

So you got Odysseus, played by Matt Damon in the movie, is a Greek king. He's clever, he's famous, and he's the guy who came up with the Trojan horse. When the Trojan War ends, all he wants to do is sail home to the island of Ithaca and to his beautiful wife, Penelope, played by Anne Hathaway, his infant son, Telemachus, Tom Holland, AKA Spider-Man. So the trip should only take a few weeks, and instead it takes 10 years because as Homer wrote, "Nary an airplane or Uber was yet to exist." But add the 10 years of war , before he won and tried to go home, , and this man has gone from home for two decades, 20 years.

And along the way, he faces a one-eyed giant and a witch who turns his men into pigs, and sirens whose song lure sailors to their deaths, and a six-headed monster, and a whirlpool, and a goddess who holds him on her island for seven years and offers him immortality if he'll just stay. He loses every ship. He loses every single man under his command, and when he finally washes up on Ithaca alone, old and unrecognizable, he finds his house overrun by men trying to marry his wife and take everything that he built. And his son , is now a grown man that he's never known.

Even then, he can't just walk in the front door. He has to enter his own home disguised as a beggar. The, the most famous man in Greece pretending to be a nobody and slowly, carefully find his way back to his own life. Now, meanwhile, Penelope is, has held the line at home for 20 years with zero proof that he's even alive. So when he finally stands in front of her, she doesn't fall into his arms. She tests him first. She isn't taking anyone else's word for who he is. So at its core, the poem is about a man who was away from home far too

long and took the long way back. And I would bet that that line alone could be an incredible muse for anybody listening. Away too long from your sense of self, from the marriage that you thought you'd have, from the body that you used to trust, from the career that you thought you'd have by now, from the faith that used to provide answers and certainty that is no longer doing so, from the parent that you believed you would be, from the version of yourself that you were certain you would have become by now. A-and maybe lately you're starting to understand things you never understood before, and you're waking up to patterns and dynamics and your own story.

With that waking up, though, comes a familiar ache. Why couldn't I have seen this 10 years ago or 20 years ago? Think of what I could have saved. Think of how much further along I could be. And that ache makes sense. And I don't say this as a cute therapist cliché. I mean it as literally as I can mean anything. Y-you truly are right here, right now. It's where you are. It's where you needed to be. You're not doing any of this wrong. Yet we have such a strong tendency to beat ourselves up over and over about who we thought we would be As if shame would somehow inspire us to do better, and it doesn't.

If it did, I wouldn't have a job, and we'd all be perfect and rich and fulfilled because shame is still at the core of so many people. They beat themselves up, and they call themselves stupid or idiots or think that they should have known something that they didn't know. And if you think about that, you didn't know it. So should-ing on yourself for not knowing something is not very productive. I mean, it makes sense. That's what we do because we think that we're doing something by beating ourselves up and ruminating. But the unfolding of your life is taking exactly as long as it takes, and maybe that's the real reason that The Odyssey has stayed relevant

for over twenty-eight hundred years. Though, though you-- your empires rise and fall, tell me that you just thought of the king in Hamilton. But through every translation and every adaptation and every controversial movie, it has never once suggested there is a shorter route. Now, a couple of weeks ago, I did a, a podcast episode that I did not expect the positive response that, that I received. I talked a lot about how change and growth and healing take a whole lot longer than advertised, because it's fascinating to think that a story like

The Odyssey has been here the entire time communicating "Buckle up, everybody. Nothing is gonna go quite the way that you thought it would in life, and it's gonna take you places you had no idea you'd go and didn't anticipate, and it's gonna present you with a whole lot of challenges, and it's gonna take a long time. That's the hero's journey. So let's go. Let's do this. Let's see where this takes us." There, there are no scenes in The Odyssey where Odysseus continues to ruminate for years and years, beats himself up, does nothing, scrolls on his literal tablet, or continually tells the kids around him about his high school jousting days. , One of the things that makes The Odyssey feel so timeless is that the

monsters that Odysseus encounters aren't really the main point. They are muses. They're very cool. In the movie, they are grade A intense magical movie-making scenes. But in the story itself, the monsters reveal something about the people who encounter them. Every obstacle becomes an invitation either to become somebody different, which is your hero's journey, literally Or remain exactly the same and, spoiler alert, be eaten by a Cyclops or by giants or die in a storm, et cetera, et cetera. ' Cause I think it's easy to recognize yourself somewhere in the story because every one of us eventually finds ourselves standing in front

of something that asks more from us than we thought that we had to give. That is what's fascinating because how often maybe we put ourselves in situations we're projecting and we say, "Put me in that situation, I know exactly what I would do." Now, not necessarily interacting with a Cyclops but as a couples therapist, I often hear people talk about things like betrayal and say, "Man, if I was that person, I would never take them back. I would never stay in that kind of a relationship," or, "Of course, I would go to therapy if that happened to me." And then you actually find yourself in the situation, and you discover what you're made of.

You can project what you think you would do, but when the moment of truth comes, will you actually do it? I've told this next story on the podcast before, so part of me repeating it is a little bit of validation-seeking because it was significant to me. I've never really had to protect my wife or kids in a physical sense from an attacker, although I have this false sense of confidence that I could, where if I had to throw down and get violent I, even though I haven't before, oh, it would be on. But when my wife and I were selling our house in California before we moved to Arizona, we were at my office because the realtor had asked us to clear out

while somebody came to see the house. We brought our two dogs, a small multi Yorkie-Poo mix and a nearly blind miniature Australian shepherd who was supposed to be my running dog, but he'd become our wonderfully special dog with what I affectionately call his lucky feet. We were walking them near my office. There's a parking lot and a school just through a clearing and we get there and suddenly I saw what looked like two giant dogs and a horse running our way. Turned out to be some sort of Great Dane and a couple of German shepherds, and they took off in a dead run toward us.

Now, they were still pretty far away, and their owner was yelling. At first, I thought he was yelling, "Hey, guys, come back," but as I listened more closely it sounded more like, "Not safe," or, "You guys go." So that was an interesting moment because I had never thought it through or practiced for what was happening in that moment. And as soon as we realized what was happening, I grabbed one or both of the dogs. I think I had the bigger dog, the Australian shepherd, and my wife and I started to head back to my office. Now, I realized, and thank goodness it was instinctive, that I needed to put myself between my wife and the dogs.

These dogs were barreling toward us. My wife was behind me, and I began reali- well, I realized that the dogs are gonna catch us. They're incredibly fast. And I stopped, held my ground, and I moved toward the dogs, which somebody might be listening now and saying that was insane, but I was yelling at them. Now, I'm glad that my wife didn't record this because I think I was probably not yelling in a real masculine way. It was probably more of a high-pitched scream. But I yelled toward them But in that moment, the question became, did I rise to the occasion or did I freeze and allow us to be attacked and then

say, "Well, what was I supposed to do?" And I understand freezing. I- if something like that has happened to you, I understand, and I'm not trying to say, "Didn't I handle that great?" I simply think that it's interesting to discover what you do in a moment that you never anticipated. Because sometimes we hit a moment like that and we fuse with a story, "I don't even know what to do," when the answer may be almost anything other than continuing to do nothing because then that means somebody else is gonna have to do something. There's a version of that in therapy as well. People rarely walk into my office and they say, "Hey how can I become more emotionally mature?" Although I do get those people occasionally, and

I think it's amazing when somebody reaches out with that question. And if you are one of those people, by the way, reach out to me, seriously, because I am recognizing that if somebody has that kind of awareness and they connect with my content, we can do some pretty amazing work if you're already there and you're in that position and you're ready to learn all about emotional maturity. But people usually come into my office because they're anxious and their marriage is struggling and they're grieving and they feel disconnected from themselves and they don't know how to parent as their children got older or younger, or they can't stop repeating the same argument with their spouse, or they are slowly

starting to feel less connected to their faith community that have brought them so much certainty for so long, or they suddenly just realize, "Oh my gosh, I just said something exactly like my mom or dad, and that is not who I wanted to be." But the presenting problem is almost never the deepest problem because as the work unfolds, it becomes apparent that the, the obstacle isn't simply something to get around. It's what is revealing the work that needs to be done. If I had frozen and opened myself up to being attacked by those dogs, we would probably wanna figure out why. What was that all about?

So I want to break down a few stops from Odysseus' journey and look at what each one is showing us. So let's start, for example, with the Lotus Eaters. And again, this isn't based on the movie. The movie had to make movie-related choices, so we are going back to the original, to the OG story. So the first stop in Odysseus' journey is the land of the Lotus Eaters. So the people there eat the fruit of the lotus plant, and the fruit doesn't make them sick. It doesn't poison them. It doesn't make them violent. It causes them to forget So they forget home.

They forget why they ever began their journey. They lose desire to keep moving forward because in that moment, everything feels comfortable enough. And I think it's a really interesting metaphor because I deal a lot in the world of people who turn to unhealthy coping mechanisms, and they rarely begin as acts of self-destruction, of self-sabotage. They begin because they work. They help you forget. They reduce anxiety. They numb grief. They soften the edges of shame. They quiet loneliness. They provide relief, sometimes almost immediately. So the problem isn't that they don't work. The problem is that they work so well in the short term that they

quietly pull a person further and further away from what they want or if they don't know what they want. The coping mechanism gives them a way to numb, and they might tell themselves, "You know, after I just tune out for a little bit, then I'm gonna figure out what I need to do." So it's essentially kicking the can down the road. And I work with people who turn to unhealthy coping mechanisms, and I often say that they do so because they don't typically feel connected in maybe their marriage or their relationships, their parenting, their health, their faith, their career. And so instead of dealing with the discomfort of maybe not knowing what to do next, they're gonna tune out, and they're gonna cope, and they're gonna

tell themselves, "This is the last time though. I'm gonna really get on whatever it is I need to get on after this," on Monday, for example, or next month It's changed my life, and it has a concept that speaks to this, and it's called experiential avoidance. Now, that i- is the understandable natural human tendency to organize your life around avoiding uncomfortable internal experiences, that we don't like to be uncomfortable. We run away from it. We avoid discomfort at all costs, and often the cost is moving toward life, moving toward experiences, things of value, a, a North Star, and the things

that will give us a sense of purpose. And honestly, like I'm confident that most people don't truly have a handle on what they want in life or what they value. It has taken me forever to figure that out. If you ask them, sometimes they'll recite values they believe they're supposed to have, which in ACT is called socially compliant goals. "I know I should care about this. I know this should be one of my values," but it's not. And that's why I love talking about the example of honesty as a value, because it sounds like a value of honesty should be the core value of every single person. But if honesty is absolutely your core value, there's a reason why.

Maybe you grew up in a home where there was zero honesty. But then if somebody asks you whether somebody looks fat in those jeans, you say, "Oh, yeah. I, I think you do." Then comes what I call the yeah-buts. "Well, yeah, but the person asking might crumble into a puddle of goo, and they may not like you again, and that might just destroy them." But if honesty really is your core value above all else, I'm not even arguing if that's a true or false statement w- because that's not a productive thought, because this person's value is honesty above everything. Now, if you value compassion, perhaps because you grew up in a home where brutal

honesty was weaponized, then, "Oh my gosh, yeah, you look amazing in those jeans. Matter of fact, I wish I looked that good in those jeans. And where did you get those jeans?" So the yeah-but is that you don't actually think they look that great, and you will never, and I'm talking ever, be caught dead wearing jeans like those. To which you would say, "Not even arguing that. It's not a productive thought for my value of compassion." So exper- experiential avoidance often shows up when you don't really know who you are. Let's say you can't stand your job. It scratches zero value-based itches. So when you're there, rather than doing the thing that you're supposed

to do or think you're supposed to do, You're just gonna check your email real fast, and then you're gonna take a company-paid ten to fifteen-minute bathroom break, only getting up when you realize that your legs have fallen asleep. When you don't like what you believe you're supposed to do, then life can gradually become organized around moving away from discomfort and finding anything else to do besides the socially compliant goal in front of you that you think you're supposed to care about. So you turn toward e-experiential avoidance because you would rather do almost anything than the thing that you think you're supposed to do.

The, the destination then changes without anybody consciously deciding to change it. Now, on the other hand, if you're all dialed in, enjoy what you do, act on your values, or have found a way to weave your values into your workplace, you are less likely to experientially avoid because you like what you're doing for the most part. Gives you a bit of a sense of purpose. Back in the height of my ultra-running days, we had a phrase for this which was essentially, "Beware of the chair." You may come into a aid station at mile seventy of a hundred-mile race, and it's in the middle of the night, and somebody hands you warm soup, and at this point you're gonna fill one full water bottle with straight Coke 'cause you want the caffeine to keep you awake

and the other with water, and you have a pacer, and they thank all the volunteers, and they try to move you through the aid station as quickly as possible. But what's that over there? Is that a, is that a folding chair? And is that next to a heater? Maybe. I'm just gonna sit down for one second, m-maybe two, maybe thirty, maybe a minute. , And I can admit I have not succumbed to the beware of the chair concept, but I have known many runners whose races, races that they've trained for for months if not years, , ended right there in the chair, not on the side of a cliff, not in a storm, not because of a twisted ankle or because they were chased by a bobcat.

The race ended in a comfy chair beside a space heater while they ate warm chicken noodle soup. It wasn't because the chair was bad or evil or held them down. It's because the chair worked. The chair was the lotus fruit. The lotus fruit can look like alcohol pornography, gambling, drugs, but it can just as easily show up in socially acceptable ways. Work can become a lotus fruit. Constant busyness can become a lotus fruit. Endless scrolling, gaming, shopping, over-training, emotional eating, a-and even an, an obsession with productivity can serve the same purpose.

So the activity itself isn't necessarily the problem. The question is whether it has become a way of avoiding the life waiting on the other side of discomfort. Growth comes from discomfort, no matter how you slice it. If you don't know who you are and you don't know what to do or don't know what you believe in, or you think that you have to do something you don't wanna do, you can maybe see why you might turn toward the lotus fruit of experiential avoidance. Now watch how this plays out in a marriage. One partner says, "I miss you. Wish we had more time together." The other partner hears, "You're failing

So instead of becoming curious about the loneliness underneath the words of the partner, they stay later at work. They pick up another project. They work overtime. They disappear into YouTube videos, and they spend another Saturday trying to stay gone or to play golf or to convince themselves, "I gotta do this. I have to provide for the family," even if the family is financially okay and what they really want is more time with that person. Those choices don't necessarily come from a lack of love. More often, they come from an inability to remain present with the discomfort that intimacy or being known, being understood, putting yourself out there, or saying a difficult thing requires.

Staying present in that moment might sound like this. "So man, when you say you miss me, which I'm so grateful that you're telling me, part of me hears, 'Hey, you're blowing it.'" And I notice that I wanna defend myself. I wanna say, "Well, I miss you too, and you aren't doing anything about it." But instead, tell me more about the part where you miss me. That response doesn't fix anything. It doesn't even have to lead to a resolution, but it keeps you at the table to have the conversation instead of sending you back to the office or to the golf course or thinking, "Man, I am just blowing it." That's the shame. Instead of "I'm noticing that this is uncomfortable," it's, "I am bad.

I'm doing something wrong because my partner just said this uncomfortable thing." Being able to stay at the table to have the conversation is the assignment in that moment. You don't have to work everything through to a resolution. Learn how to stay in the conversation. Vulnerability can sound like, "I don't really know what to say right now, but I'm here," or, "I really appreciate you sharing how you're feeling." Because emotional maturity isn't learning how to eliminate the discomfort, it's becoming willing to experience discomfort in the service of becoming the partner or parent or person that you wanna be, even if you don't know exactly what that looks like yet. Because you have to show up in order to discover what you don't know.

One drink tonight won't really matter. We're celebrating," or, "You've earned this," or "What am I supposed to do? It's a birthday. The cake isn't gonna eat itself. Nobody's ever gonna know." "She's never gonna change anyway, so why keep trying?" Or the one that I think that that I've heard often is, well, you know, "You can't actually quit something on a Thursday. We'll start over on Monday, so I might as well go out with a bang over the weekend." But the siren song is not "Hey, come wreck your life on these rocks," or it isn't "How about you break your sobriety?" Or, "Come out tonight being incredibly flirtatious and see if you can lead somebody on, and it's not a big deal."

The siren song is usually in your own voice, and it sounds like a pretty good point at the time, sounds very reasonable, makes a lot of sense. So we're back to recognizing and being honest about what's happening, leaning into the uncomfortable feeling, the monster or the challenge, and recognizing that is my muse. And I will make the point that you, you're not doing it wrong. It's giving you an opportunity to know yourself, to confront yourself and grow, but you have to be honest with yourself. And I think so often that's one of the most difficult things because it's

gonna show you what you need to know. It's gonna show you where you're not in alignment, where you're not coming from a place of integrity. So Odysseus knows something important about himself before he even gets close enough to hear the sirens. He knows the version of himself listening to their voices will not think as clearly as the version of himself making the plan ahead of time, and I think that one might sound familiar. He knows, "When I get close to the sirens, I don't know whether I can trust myself." So he tells his crew, "Tie me to the mast of the ship and do not untie me no matter what I say, no matter how convincing I become, and no matter how desperately I

beg." And it-- this is actually a thing. In the field of behavioral science they have found this move so foundational that they've named a concept after Odysseus, and it's basically a pre-commitment device. It's making that decision before you're put in an environment which when it works, it's wonderful because at least you're aware of that. There are also times where somebody makes a commitment that, "Okay, I'm gonna go to the party but once I'm there, I will not drink," and then until they get there, and then they may feel , all of a sudden this need to fit in or peer pressure.

But fundamentally, this concept is it's a decision made by your clear-headed self to protect you from your future emotionally hijacked, overwhelmed self, and it's called a Ulysses contract, because Ulysses is the Roman name for Odysseus. So every accountability structure in recovery work or conversations with a partner when the waters are calm where promises are made to say difficult things before resentment grows, "Hey, we'll talk about it next time," right? It's a version of this. It's the calm, clear Tuesday afternoon version of you making decisions on

behalf of the 11:00 PM on a Friday night version of you, who will not nearly be as present and clear-minded or interested in your values. And I'm not even talking about if it's because you have been drinking, but if you are emotionally exhausted or you're now in the company of peers, it can be hard to make a rational decision in those moments. So it is nice to at least have an idea or make a commitment to what you are going to do ahead of time. Emotionally mature people gradually learn that willpower alone is pretty inconsistent, and you can say something, you can make the right mouth sound

in a moment that that is something I would never do until you're in that moment, and then you have to accept the fact that, okay, I'm here now and then what is this showing me? You can have the best intentions, and they can disappear under enough stress, loneliness, fatigue, shame, or fear. And add to that a good old HALT if you're hungry, angry, lonely, or tired. I mean, there are just countless variables that can impact your internal state. Which, speaking of your internal state, I heard a neurologist say something not long ago that, that really speaks to this, and I think about this often.

, He said that your thoughts aren't necessarily your own. You're reacting to things, at least not in the way that we tend to imagine the way that they are. Your brain isn't sitting there manufacturing every thought like a little factory inside your head. It may be more helpful to think of your brain as a radio that's constantly receiving and interpreting signals. So you're responding to a moment, , this is the very first time that you've ever been in this exact moment with this particular combination of circumstances, your emotions, your memories, your sensations, your experiences. So rather than immediately assuming that every thought must mean something

important because it was generated from the factory, it's actually you interpreting the data that's coming at you that you're dealing with for the very first time, and that helps you step back and notice, "Well, that's interesting. This is what I'm thinking right now. This is how I'm feeling. This is what I'm saying." So this neurologist said that sights and sounds and even thoughts exist as patterns of energy. So the brain takes those patterns, and then it turns them into an internal experience. And it does that with all of our five senses. So a signal comes in as energy, and then something in the body or the

brain transduces or then converts that energy into a particular signal that the brain can then interpret. I thought that was such a easy way , to explain that. But then he said the transducer for thought is more complicated, which means that the signal itself is less stable. Because let's take our mobile phone, for example. If you look at your phone, it appears to be the same phone every time we see it. When other people look at the same phone, even if it's a different brand, their experience of it will be roughly similar to ours. We know that's a phone. Our thoughts don't actually work that way because they can appear wildly

different from one moment to the next, depending on our internal state, because that state gives our thoughts different characters, different plot lines, different tones, different settings. So the same situation can produce an entirely different thought depending on whether we are tired, anxious, calm, lonely, excited, ashamed, or even if we are secure within ourselves. Because in so many ways, our emotional state then determines the tuning of the radio that is our brain. Because once you understand that, I think it can become easier to navigate

what's happening inside of you without assuming that every single thought needs to be believed or obeyed or turned into a story about who you are. So rather than trusting that y- your future emotions will automatically lead to wise decisions, I think that emotionally mature people begin building structure that supports the life that they want before the moments arrive. And, you know, I keep coming back to how important it is to know what matters to you and how to identify your values, because I think it's so much easier to hold on to a structure when you have an idea of what truly matters to you. It's so much easier to come back to the present moment when you know who you are,

you like what you're doing you know what you stand for, as cliché as that sounds. But at the same time, maintaining psychological flexibility and remembering that every moment is the first time you've ever been you in that moment. If I go back to the role of a couples therapist, healthy couples, they do the same thing. They decide in advance how conflict will be handled because the middle of an argument is a pretty crummy place to start making up new rules, even though that's when most people do it. And and I think on that note, reach out to me if you're interested in knowing when my new marriage course is released, because , I have this solid framework, a, a structure you can rely on.

It will help build trust and help you have difficult conversations. It's my beloved four pillars of a connected conversation. Because healthy couples can agree that either person may ask for a break when emotions start to become overwhelming. They can decide in advance that contempt and name-calling and threats won't be part of the conversation. And on that note, as a practicing marriage therapist, can I just say Don't yell at your spouse. Don't tell your spouse to shut up. Don't call them names. Seriously, and I know that it happens and you may not even be aware of

why it happens, and it just happens. And with that said, I would love to encourage you to not let yourself off the hook by just telling yourself, "I won't do it again," only to do it again and then explain that, "Well, that was because of what the other person did." That's the only reason that I did it. Because there's a small place where you can begin your own hero's journey right now why do I do that? If I mock my spouse or I call them names, why do I do it? More importantly, how can I work on that? How can I stop? And if you simply tell yourself, "I just, I know I need to stop," but how

many times have you already said that? , And let's at least get that kind of talk out of your relationship. Because if you don't, your children will most likely learn that yelling at each other and calling each other horrific names are available options and that they're part of a relationship. I-if you can work to eliminate that behavior and then no longer model it in front of your kids, then later, if they find themselves with somebody who calls them names, hopefully that will feel so unfamiliar and so off-putting such a what in the heck is that about kind of an experience, that they won't tolerate it.

They won't think it's acceptable to be in a relationship with somebody who treats them that way. Back to healthy couples. So healthy couples create habits of checking in, of repairing things after a conflict, and then returning to difficult conversations instead of avoiding them. And none of these agreements eliminates uncomfortable feelings or tension or intensity or discomfort, but they create a framework sturdy enough to hold those feelings. And that's what I think tying yourself to the mast looks like in a relationship, because it's not about doubting yourself.

It's about understanding yourself well enough to prepare for moments when your emotions will be louder than your hopes and your dreams and your values. One of the most intense scenes in Homer's Odyssey is the encounter with the Cyclops. And I also think it's one of the coolest and clearest illustrations of how ego can quietly undermine your growth. So we've got Odysseus and this is so different from the way that it was showed in the movie, but he develops… Not so different, but it is different. He develops this very ingenious plan to escape from the Cyclops.

I believe his name is Polyphemus, and forgive the pronunciation. But so when Polyphemus asks his name, as Odysseus is wrecking this guy, Odysseus tells him his name is Nobody or , No One, depending on the translation. So after Odysseus and his men blind the Cyclops, spoiler alert, Polyphemus cries out for help. And this is, again, not what's shown in the movie, but in the poem, there are other Cyclopses, and they ask, "Hey, who's attacking you?" And so Polyphemus answers, "Nobody." Now, that was pretty clever.

They assume no person is harming him, decide he's fine, and leave him alone, and the plan works. So Odysseus and his surviving men escape from the cave by hiding under the Cyclops' sheep, and then they make it back to their ship, and they have survived, and the obstacle is behind them, and it's time to move on. But Odysseus can't leave it there. So as the ship moves away, Odysseus begins shouting back at the Cyclops and mocking him. So Polyphemus tears away part of a mountain and throws it toward the sound of Odysseus' voice, almost driving the ship back onto the shore, where I'm sure

they would have been eaten by a Cyclops. Odysseus' men beg him, "Hey, knock it off. Stop it. Leave well enough alone. We escaped. We're alive. Please quit talking." But Odysseus can't resist. He wants him to know, "I wasn't defeated by nobody. It was me, you piece of Cyclops. I'm the one who defeated you. I am Odysseus, son of Laertes, King of Ithaca." Odysseus wants recognition. He wants credit. He wants validation. He wants the victory attached to his name, and that's when everything changes. Because turns out Polyphemus is son of Poseidon, who happens to know a

thing or two about the ocean and now he knows exactly who blinded him because Odysseus just yelled it across the water. He prays to his dad and essentially says, "Hey Pops, can you make sure Odysseus never makes it home? Or if the fates require him to return, can you make sure he arrives late after losing all of his companions on board somebody else's ship only to find more trouble waiting for him when he gets there? Pretty please. Amen." So the obstacle was behind Odysseus, but his ego was so big that he reached back and he pulled it all back into his future.

And I think that pattern unfolds in relationships way more often than people realize. So let's say you have a difficult conversation, and over time it starts to move toward connection, which it can be an amazing thing. Both partners are now softening. Somebody finally feels heard. Accountability is emerging, and the other person begins thinking, "I think I can trust this person." Then, almost reflexively, the person who finally feels heard has to add, "See? This is what I've been trying to get you to understand for years."

Or, "Hey, now can you finally admit that I was right and that you've been a, a huge problem for so long?" Or, "I appreciate this. This is what I've always wanted, but honestly, if you'd listened to me back in the day, we wouldn't even be here." So the conversation had already been moving toward connection. The ship had left the shore. The Cyclops already had his eye poked out. The danger was behind them. Nothing more needed to be won, but the desire to receive credit quietly becomes more important than protecting the connection that was

starting to form in the relationship. So just like Odysseus shouting his name back across the water, the person reactivates the conflict they had just escaped. Sometimes emotional maturity means recognizing that you have reached the outcome that you said you wanted. This is all I've wanted. If only we could get to a place of connection. But now you're there, and suddenly you feel an urge to make sure everybody knows , that you were the one who got them there, or to say, "Yeah, it's about time." So once Odysseus and his men were safely on the ship, the most important question was no longer, "How do I make sure the Cyclops understands who defeated him?" He knew that he defeated him.

The more useful question was, "Okay, what helps us keep moving toward home?" And I think those are the kind of questions that point in very different directions, because one leads Odysseus to turn around and shout his name, "Give me the credit." The other would have allowed him to keep sailing forward and his men possibly not die So the same shift needs to happen in relationships. So instead of continuing to ask, "How can I finally get this person to understand that I was right?" Emotional maturity starts to ask, "What keeps us moving toward the relationship that, that we're trying to build?"

There are gonna be moments when saying one more true thing may satisfy your ego and simultaneously break down connection or emotional intimacy. Because emotional maturity and wisdom don't require you to ignore the reality and pretend that something never happened or abandon your perspective or agree to a version of events that you don't believe. Emotional maturity, it involves recognizing that not everything needs to be said in every moment simply because you feel like it. Sometimes the truth has already done its job, and you have to know that.

You've wanted the other person to know it for so long, but through the process of trying to communicate it, you have come to know yourself. That's the kind of knowledge that helps you remain grounded and embodied. So the point's been made. Understanding has begun to emerge. Adding, "See, I told you so. This is what I've been trying to tell you," doesn't get you anything, doesn't create more understanding. It doesn't make the person go, "Oh my gosh, I think it, I believe you even more now." It reveals a clingy energy, a moment where you're still desperately seeking validation. You need to learn to validate yourself in the moment.

That's what internal validation sounds like. Otherwise, a moment of connection turns back into criticism a contest, a, a litigation where you still need to make sure they know you were right and they were wrong, and that is not conducive to a healthy, intimate relationship. This is where one of my favorite concepts, it's David Schnarch's concepts of differentiation fits in so well. Schnarch describes differentiation as developing the ability to remain emotionally connected to another person without losing yourself in the relationship. You're figuring out who you are in the relationship.

That's why relationships are people-growing machines. It's the ability to care deeply about what somebody else thinks and feels without requiring them to think and feel exactly what you need them to think and feel in order for you to be okay. Schnarch contrasted other validated intimacy with self-validated intimacy. Other validated intimacy is essentially, I can only be okay if you're okay. I need you to be okay or else I won't be okay. Because everybody around you feels that pressure. So now they have to try to figure out, "Okay, how can I make sure that

you're okay? Because if you aren't okay, ultimately I'm not gonna be okay." Schnarch described human beings as living with two powerful drives that are so deep within us. We want attachment and closeness and connection with somebody else, and we want to matter to them. We want to be understood by them and feel that they're emotionally available to us. At the same time, as we move through life, we're gonna recognize that we have our own thoughts and feelings and emotions, and we need to figure ourselves out. We wanna be individuals and be known for who we are, even while we're still trying to discover who that is.

We wanna be able to make our own choices and hold our own opinions, but often we don't even know what those opinions are yet, so we test them out on somebody else. Now, usually we test them on the person close to us, the person who believes they already know who we are in a particular way. So when you begin expressing new opinions or allowing yourself to be known more fully by the other person, they're gonna react. Then comes the familiar anxiety. "Oh no, if they aren't okay, then I'm not okay. Maybe I shouldn't have said that. Maybe I really don't think that." But eventually, if you do the work, you discover that you're okay. It's okay for you to direct the course of your own life and allow

the other person to do the same, even while you're in a relationship. Differentiation isn't choosing independence over connection or connection over independence. It's developing the ability to hold both. And it's one of those concepts that it doesn't make a lick of sense until it does. And when it does, it's incredible to recognize, "I didn't know that I didn't know." I can be frustrated, and I can also still love you. I can not have known something and acknowledge fault, and I can commit to learning new things. . All of them are true You realize that both of you were playing off of

each other and your nervous systems were just reacting to each other. And at that point, you've been codependent, you've been enmeshed, and now you're stepping out into this void, this great abyss, and begin developing and expressing your own opinions, and it's okay for the other person to be upset or curious, which is gonna feel like criticism. In fact, when somebody is simply curious about your opinion, it will most likely be interpreted as criticism, and you may not want to share anything. There's just so much here to work with, and I think that's why

I've spent the last three or four years weaving differentiation into so many podcast episodes. Because over time, the concept can lead to emotional autonomy and healthy interdependence in a relationship. Emotional autonomy doesn't mean you don't need anybody. It doesn't mean that you're gonna become cold or detached or proudly announce that you no longer care what your partner thinks. Now, for a while, it will feel that way, because when you stop playing your familiar role of playing small or being overly reactive or just agreeing in order to escape the discomfort of the moment the proverbial, "I'm just gonna go along to get along," and when you start expressing opinions, it may

feel as though something is wrong. You may hear things like, "You don't seem like you care anymore." And for a while, that might be all it takes to pull you back into enmeshment. But if your partner isn't doing this work alongside you, they will notice the shift, and they may experience it as emotional distancing. And you may know you're beginning to figure things out and becoming more independent or stronger and more confident, so you can show up better in the relationship, but it still doesn't take much to probably pull you back into the old enmeshment. Differentiation says, "I care what you think because you matter to me, and I would love for you to understand where I'm coming from.

But my identity, my stability, and my ability to act like the person that I want to be can't depend entirely on whether or not you give me the response I was hoping for or whether or not I said the right thing." And that's why I say as often as I can that right and wrong are often hindsight principles. I can do something, and depending on how my partner's feeling, they might say, "I really like what you did." And then I think, "Okay, good. I did the right thing." But they may have had an incredibly hectic day and been caught up in their own emotions, and I can do the exact same thing, and this time they don't like it.

And all of a sudden, does that mean I did the wrong thing? No. I just did a thing. But if I'm not differentiated, I may decide whether it was right or wrong based entirely on somebody else's reaction now, that does not mean you never advocate for yourself or hope for accountability, because you can do that. But there comes a point where repeatedly demanding that another person confirm what you think or your reality, it becomes a very grandiose way of continuing to seek validation. I am not okay unless you tell me that you understand exactly what I'm experiencing and I would love for you to understand what I'm experiencing.

But the therapist in me knows that no one will ever truly understand exactly what it feels like to be you, and I will never know exactly what it feels like to be them. So if I say, "I'm still not buying what you're telling me," that's, that is a me thing when we desperately seek and continually seek validation, we no longer simply are sharing something that we know about ourselves. We're asking the other person to make it real for us if it isn't their experience, that's okay. So when that demand becomes really intense, it can come across as emotionally immature and needy and clingy, and that's not because having needs is immature.

We all have them and in healthy relationships, they do. They include reassurance and empathy and affection and responsiveness and even validation. I really think validation's getting a pretty bad rap right now. I think it needs a new public relations department because it's okay to want validation. What isn't necessarily as healthy is seeing yourself entirely through what everybody else validates the version of you that you believe you are. The problem is when the message is, "I can't settle myself inside until you agree that I'm right. Can't move forward until you admit that I saw this first.

I can't move forward until you admit what you were doing and apologize for it," even if that isn't your experience. It's like saying, "I cannot trust what I know unless you repeat it back to me in exactly the right way and it makes me feel better. And 95% of the time I will find a hole in the way you repeat it back, and then I get to say you don't care about me and what's wrong with me." That pressure doesn't tend to build trust or intimacy. It just keeps the old pattern going because the other person is once again responsible for regulating your internal world. As long as they have that job, you will keep chasing them for

the response that finally lets you feel that everything's okay. Meanwhile, they may keep defending and withdrawing and minimizing and resisting because the conversation feels less like an invitation to know you and to be understood and to understand them and it's more like a demand. "Hey, repeat this back to me so you can make me feel better about myself." And Schnarch contrasted other-validated intimacy with self-validated. ' Cause again, other-validated, I will show you this part of myself, but I need you to respond with the acceptable agreement, empathy, reassurance,

mouth sound, whatever it is, so I can feel safe about showing it to you. I will only be okay if you tell me I'm okay in exactly the right way, and I'm not even sure what that way is yet, but you better make me feel as though you get it. So that disclosure becomes dependent on, on what comes back, on what you receive in response to what you're putting out. Now, when we're operating primarily from this other-validated intimacy, Then we're gonna be far more in a mode of self-presentation, trying to figure out how to present this so that you will then agree with me, instead of self-disclosure, of this is who I am, this is what I think. And we try to figure out how to say something so that the other

person will reflect it back and tell us we're right instead of simply saying, "This is what I think. This is what I feel." And when you're presenting a version of yourself that you hope the other person will validate you're managing what you show them in order to produce a, a particular response. You're reading them and the situation in hopes that you can emphasize certain facts and soften others and say it in the way that you think that you will get the validation. You're performing the role of vulnerability, and you're telling the story in a way that makes it really difficult for the other person to respond with anything other than agreement. 'Cause in those situations, you aren't allowing them to know your-- what you really think and how you really feel, 'cause that's scary.

But when you begin doing that consistently, you can let the other person truly know you. Sometimes it will be amazing and wonderful, and sometimes they won't understand, and both outcomes actually are okay So often the person is just presenting a version of themselves for approval. And so if you think about this concept of self-disclosure, self-disclosure is different from what we might assume just from the name. Self-disclosure is saying, "This is what's true for me. This is what I feel. This is what I think. This is what I've done. This is what I'm afraid of. This is what I want, and I'm willing to let you see it without controlling what you do with it." I need it basically in the relationship record

so that I know that I've said it. We don't even have to break it down right now. You can sit with it because I may be putting it out there for the first time. That is far more vulnerable because I'm not hiding behind a, a managed version of myself, and I'm not requiring you to give me the right response that makes the disclosure feel more comfortable. Self-validated intimacy means I can support myself while allowing myself to be known and understood, and it also means I, I have the right to change my mind. I can tell you what's true for me, and I can maintain my identity and my self-worth even when your first response is defensive or disappointed or confused or simply

different than what I was expecting. And I know I still struggle with this because if I'm trying to let myself be known by my wife of almost 36 years, and she gives me a certain puzzled look, I still find myself wanting to say, "No, ne- never mind." But her puzzled look doesn't mean I need to scramble to find a different way to say it. I can ask, "Hey, help me understand what is it making sense to you?" ' Cause that doesn't mean that your response doesn't matter. It actually matters a lot, and your response gives me a lot of information about you and the safety of the relationship or what may or may not be possible between us in-- from a connection standpoint.

But your response does not determine whether my experience is real or whether I'm allowed to have it. That's the key. So self-validated intimacy sounds more like, "I want you to understand this because I want to feel closer to you. I'm gonna show this part of me to you. But I'm not gonna abandon what I know about my experience just because you don't understand it yet. I really want this to work. I wanna stay in it. I want us to figure out how we can both sit with each other's discomfort, even when something doesn't make sense to either one of us. But I'm also not gonna attack you. I'm not gonna call you names. I'm not gonna chase you down. I'm not gonna try to aggressively defend myself, or I'm not gonna collapse

if you don't immediately respond the way I hoped and Schnarch organized this whole process around what he calls these four points of balance. And I like the word balance a lot because none of these things are things we master once and then we just permanently possess and never have to worry about again. They aren't checkboxes. They are capacities that we begin to develop, and then we'll lose access to them under stress and then practice returning to again and again and again. So his first point that he talks about is developing a solid but flexible sense of self. And and you know what? Let's talk about that on part two.

I appreciate you taking the time to listen, taking us out per usual, the wonderful, the talented Aurora Florence with her song "It's Wonderful" because, because it is. If you have questions or comments about this episode or you had your own insights to The Odyssey, send them my way. I would love to include those in a part two or answer any of your questions around that as well. I appreciate the support, and I will see you next time on The Virtual Couch and Waking Up to Narcissism

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Hosts

  • Tony Overbay Host Feed-stated

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. How Childhood Shapes Who You Marry: The Accommodator, Attachment, and Why We Choose the Familiar

    Nov 13, 20261 hr 18 minAudio

    Why do people pleasers and avoidant partners find each other, and why does it seem like such a relief at first? Tony follows Pam and Jim, a composite couple, from childhood to the college campus where they met. Pam...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Nobody Brings a Casserole When You Wake Up to Betrayal: The Accommodator, Gaslighting, and Rebuilding Trust

    Nov 4, 20261 hr 29 minAudio

    Waking up to betrayal, gaslighting, or emotional immaturity rarely comes with a casserole on the porch or a meal train. When someone has a baby or a surgery, people can see the event and show up with dinner. When you...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Nobody Brings a Casserole When You Wake Up to Betrayal: The Accommodator, Gaslighting, and Rebuilding Trust

    Nov 4, 20261 hr 29 minAudio

    Waking up to betrayal, gaslighting, or emotional immaturity rarely comes with a casserole on the porch or a meal train. When someone has a baby or a surgery, people can see the event and show up with dinner. When you...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Your AI Is a Great Hype-Man - A Therapist Has a Few Notes (Plus Live QA)

    Oct 14, 20261 hr 32 minAudio

    Using AI as a therapist? Your chatbot might be building a great plan for the person you’re hoping to become. When a client’s chatbot asked if he was an extroverted go-getter, he answered as the man he’s working toward,...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Why Good People Defend Leaders (and Others) Who Contradict Themselves: Identity, Bias & Belonging

    Sep 24, 202653 minAudio

    Tony starts with a kid raised in an East Coast fishing town and another raised hiking Arizona trails. He uses them to show how beliefs tend to form through family, community, and identity, with the reasons showing up...

    Credit the people on this episode