Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

The Virtual Couch

The Virtual Couch artwork

The Relationship Episode Everyone Needs to Hear: Why We Explain Instead of Understand

Sep 4, 20261 hr 15 minAudio

When someone you love tells you, “Something you did hurt me,” what happens inside of you next? Do you become curious about what it was like to be on the receiving end of you, or does your brain immediately start building the case for why you did what you did, what you meant, what they misunderstood, and what they did first? That difference may quietly shape almost everything that happens in a relationship. In what may be one of the most important episodes of The Virtual Couch for anyone who is in a relationship, has been in one, or hopes to be in one someday, Tony explores the difference between self-explanation and self-examination - and why two people can genuinely love each other, both believe they are “working on themselves,” and still have completely different ideas about what that work actually means. Drawing from more than two decades of couples therapy, Tony looks at what happens when one person is trying to understand while the other person’s nervous system is trying to make discomfort disappear. He explores defensiveness, emotional awareness, overthinking disguised as accountability, internal validation, boundaries, differentiation, people-pleasing, and the uncomfortable reality that sometimes we become so familiar with our story about our partner that we stop being curious about the actual person standing in front of us. And then the conversation moves into one of the most vulnerable places this dynamic can appear: sex and intimacy. Tony walks through how two well-intentioned people can gradually create patterns of expectation, pressure, duty sex, resentment, withdrawal, and loneliness without either person fully understanding how they got there - and what can happen when both people finally become willing to look at the relationship with new eyes. This episode isn’t about deciding who is the problem. It’s about learning how to remain yourself in the presence of someone else’s experience. How to hear something you don’t like without immediately defending against it. How to distinguish discomfort from danger. How to stop searching for the perfect explanation that will make everything okay and begin asking a much more useful question: “What can I learn here?” Because intimacy requires more than knowing someone’s history. It requires remaining curious enough to keep discovering who they are today. Catch the moment your brain files its defense brief, usually before the other person has finished their sentence Tell the difference between self-reflection that finishes and hands you something, and self-reflection that keeps combing the woods for evidence nobody asked you to find Sit with the honest origin story of duty sex and pity sex in long marriages, and how two people build something painful out of materials neither of them was handed Walk through the four pillars of a connected conversation, starting with the pre-pillar of separating observation from judgment Try the week-long assignment: one genuinely curious question before the context, the explanation, or the correction Twenty years and more than 1,500 couples in, Tony has noticed that the tools get far more useful once somebody can say, "I may not really know what this is that I'm doing." A heads-up that the middle stretch talks openly about sex, intimacy, and coercion, so you may want to choose your listening company. Notice which person you identify with as you listen - and reach out through the website, and Tony will send you the PDF summary of everything covered here. Please follow Tony on Instagram @virtual.couch on Tiktok @virtualcouch on Facebook https://www.facebook.com/tonyoverbaylmft and on Substack https://thevirtualcouch.substack.com/ You can reach out to Tony through his website tonyoverbay.com or by emailing contact @ tonyoverbay.com

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Hey, everybody, welcome to another episode of The Virtual Couch. I am your host, Tony Overbay. I'm a licensed marriage and family therapist, host of Waking Up to Narcissism, as well as Murder on the Couch. Follow me on social media. More and more live Q&As are happening on TikTok at virtualcouch, and follow me on Instagram at virtual. Or on Substack, and the Substack link will be in the show notes. Or Google Virtual Couch, Tony Overbay Substack. You'll find it there. Sign up for the newsletter at TonyOverbay.com. Send me all your questions, your comments, especially today.

And I would love to know if this one resonates today in your relationship and which person are you going to identify with? And I would love specific examples. I will run them through some of the frameworks that we're talking about today. You can be the next Jack and Jill example or Wally and Edwina, but let's get to today's content. Somebody wrote into me recently and in the middle of a much longer message, they said this, but that's my surface take, it assumes that both people are emotionally aware, measured, and honest, and I'm curious if many people are in your experience.

So as a couples therapist for over 20 years now, this one, there was something there. I replied back. I told them that I thought that sentence alone was something that I needed to build an entire podcast around. And that was a week or two ago. And it's been sitting inside of me. And I've been jotting down so many notes during sessions and thinking about things after. I think this episode is going to have so much about the couple's dynamic. I think if this were a movie, it's going to go a lot of different directions. It's going to be a rollercoaster ride of emotions. If this is a book,

you're going to think this person did it and then this person did it. And so I would love for you to take this one in and notice your reactions. And if you're thinking about your partner, your spouse, and then at times you're thinking about, wait, maybe I do that. And then watch what happens if all of a sudden you are saying, okay, that could be me in the relationship. Let's just start with the idea of relationship advice, because there is a lot of relationship advice out there, especially as someone who creates content around it. I would say a lot of relationship advice quietly assumes that both people in

the relationship have about the same capacity for looking inward, for self-reflection. And I'm guilty of it as well, saying things like, hey, you both need to learn to communicate better, or you both need to improve your listening skills, or you both really need to own your part and you both need to look introspectively. That would be ideal. And those are absolutely good ideas. Now, underneath that assumption is that when I ask two people to look inward, that they have similar experiences or similar ability to look inward.

But they're two completely different humans and none of us know what it feels like to be somebody else. And so you're hoping that they can have similar capacity, both look inward or a similar willingness to do so. But I also know that it's honestly more rare than you might think to have two people that have both decided to come into couples therapy and say, we're both struggling. We don't really know what we don't know. And we're ready to go on this ride, take the journey. I would say more often than not, somebody is feeling like, I don't know if I

can do this anymore. And then they finally pressure the relationship enough that the other person says, okay, fine, we'll go. We'll go to couples therapy. And you sense that as a couples therapist. So after sitting with couples week after week and year after year, what I notice is a real difference between somebody who is trying to understand what's happening and then somebody whose nervous system is mostly trying to make the bad feelings or the discomfort go away. And I'm going to sound like. I'm overgeneralizing at times because I will be.

And then there will be some details and we'll get into the minutiae throughout this episode as well. So one person is giving off this vibe of, okay, I'm missing something and I'm going to take a leap here and say that you didn't just write those letters behind your name yourself and that you may actually know something that I don't know, even though it's going to be uncomfortable. So let's give it a shot. And then the other person might even be looking right at you as well. When you can tell they're trying to say the right thing to get themselves out of whatever this pickle is that they're in at that moment, or to maybe get a

little more validation from the person that has the letters behind their name. Because often they will look to me to see, did I do that right? Did I do a good job? As if I'm going to be the one that grades them, to tell them if they passed, if they said the right thing. And if I nod approvingly, it's recreating this dynamic probably from their childhood where I play the role as dad and I'm saying, attaboy champ, you did good. You're right. And your partner there on the other side of that couch is wrong. So I actually don't see much need to continue this session. Let me refund you

the money that you just gave me and hey, how's about we go out back and have a catch? Now I say that with absolute compassion for people that are coming in to see me because they truly don't know what they want most of the time. They just want it to be better. And by it, I mean all of it. Marriage, parenting, difficult talks about budgeting and about sex. And can't she just see that her mother is interfering in our relationship? Or can't he just understand that when he comes back from helping his dad in the yard, he's a complete jackhole for the next two hours and the kids and I all feel it?

Or can't you just tell us who's right and who's wrong and what we should do. Okay. But if you actually do, then how dare you take his or her side? And don't you understand that we can't do any of those things that you're suggesting? But again, how dare you not help us after we paid you? Because the truth is most of what I do in the therapy room is closer to the work of a Sherpa. I will often say that I become your Sherpa, but that often comes after you've built at least a little bit of rapport with a couple, or you just watch people shut down.

It's more like saying, hey, I'm somebody who perhaps has been on this stretch of the trail before many, many, many times. And while I know the route quite well down to where the trail narrows, where it might be best to tuck in your laces to avoid the pokey things, the thorns on the bushes. Where you might want to put on a sweater and where you're probably going to want to go single file so you don't fall into that vast chasm of loneliness. The truth is, one of you might think that thorns, hey, they're just a part of life. While your partner may have walked around with a thorn in their heel for so long as a kid that they are absolutely terrified of them.

And telling them that you're not worried about thorns and that they aren't so bad and that you need to deal with the thorns of life and that they shouldn't worry about them either isn't going to help your partner very much. And no, me telling them that they need to trust you and not worry about thorns isn't going to help either, nor is that what I even do because quite frankly, you're giving me data. The fact that thorns don't hurt you probably speaks to the fact that you got a heck of a lot of praise for toughing out getting stuck by thorns as a kid, or maybe you got in absolute trouble for having emotions about being stuck by a thorn,

or maybe it's something we don't even know yet. Your skin cells may all be deemed as little sociopaths and feel nothing to begin with. So it helps to have a Sherpa to guide you. Somebody who not only knows where the thorns are, but who has also facilitated enough conversations around thorns from just about every possible angle to help guide you through that conversation as well. But at the cliched proverbial end of the day, one of you may get it. Recognizing your role and how the two of you traverse the trail of life and

you honestly have your own epiphany about how you might be taking things and how you might be reacting to things. That might even lead to, oh my gosh, I can only imagine what this might be like for my partner to experience. And that might even lead to you wanting to understand your partner more because doggone it, that helps you understand yourself more. And then you look across the couch and your partner is absolutely not having that same experience. If they're still participating, they might just be nodding saying, no, that's fine. So tucking our laces. No, that makes sense.

And you think, how are we having two completely different experiences right now, even though we've been together for as long as we have, and now our experiences are this vastly different. What does that mean for our relationship? And how do I approach this? And actually, Mr. Therapist, if I'm being honest, I think I would like to have a catch after the session, but I'm curious if you charge for that. So not to overly simplify or actually, no, I'm literally about to overly simplify. I often see couples work boiled down to someone beginning to truly digest and take in and look at themselves and how they not only interpret the things that

they hear from their spouse, but they realize that means that their spouse is probably experiencing them a certain way. And they now want to understand more from a deeply genuine place of curiosity and maybe even a little bit of awe, like, oh my gosh, there's nothing like watching a person come up with their own epiphany, but I will maintain you can't give another person their aha moment or their epiphany. And then to then look and see the other person more often than not finding a way to get rid of the discomfort of that moment where they're feeling criticized,

like they're not really getting it and they don't want to feel, like they're not getting it. And we're... They might not now be shutting down or getting angry, but the things that they're saying are still more or less trying to justify versus explain or trying to end the conversation rather than watch things kind of unfold and keep it going. So that difference between understanding and getting rid of discomfort. Can turn into a story about the reflective person and the defensive person or

the anxious and the avoidant or the pursuer and the withdrawer or the red and the yellow or the croquet mallet in the yard dart. And I made that one up. And while I do get the urge or the need to identify and name, I do this myself on occasion as a card carrying anxiously attached ADHD person. At some point, it really just comes down to the individual and what they are able or willing to see, not in their partner, but in themselves. Because defensiveness usually makes sense from inside somebody's world. Because if guilt has this history of going immediately into shame in five seconds

or less, or if saying something that somebody else thinks you shouldn't have said, AKA saying the wrong thing or also known as making a mistake or forgetting something or not understanding something because you're a human. But if doing so, it usually comes with humiliation or if conflict has always meant that somebody was about to withdraw love or get loud or get unpredictable. Well, then the brain has had a ton of practice at making emotional discomfort disappear as quickly as it can and you're most likely not even aware of it.

And that can happen by shutting down, getting loud, making up stories, taking a conversation out into the weeds and a bunch of other ways that bless all of our hearts have kept us alive. If you are listening to this as an alive person. So when somebody says, Hey, when you said that yesterday, I felt sad. And I started wondering if you even liked me or if you want to be here. And then before the other person has really taken that in, the brain has already filed the defense brief.

That isn't what I said or that isn't what I meant. Or you're leaving out what happened before that or what you said that caused me to do that. Or what you actually said the thing first or don't, I mean, you know, I was stressed or you took that so different than the way I intended it. And those things, some of them may be perfectly accurate. An explanation and an examination, though, are two completely different processes. And I've started to think a lot about, when thinking about building this episode,

about that difference as self-explanation and self-examination. And I want to just say those things over and over because I've been trying to bring them into therapy sessions this week as well. Self-explanation and then self-examination. So self-explanation says, let me help you understand why I did what I did. Self-examination is even knowing why I did what I did. I wonder what it was like to be on the receiving end of me doing what I did. Let me put that now in a room with a couple of people. And I use a couple of

composites as I'm bringing this to light. Welcome back, Maris and Ansel. Nobody has to worry if I'm actually talking about them. So Maris says, when you got up and went into the kitchen while I was talking about my dad, I felt alone. And Ansel said, I was getting you water. And then Maris says, I know. And I still ended up sitting on the couch by myself in the middle of me talking about it. Ansel says, you told me you were thirsty though. And so I got up, I got you a glass of water. And now that's something I did to you.

And then she says, I'm not saying that you did it on purpose. And then he says, well, then what are you saying? Because I heard everything that you said. You can ask me anything about that conversation. He's telling the truth. He was getting water. She had asked for it. He was listening. And to his credit, he could pass a quiz on the entire story about her dad. But she's also telling the truth because something happened in her when he stood up and she's still carrying it with her quite a bit later. So self explanation says, I got your water.

Self-examination says, I did get you water and I wonder what it was like to be mid-sentence talking about your dad, having your experience, and then watch me walk out of the room. Now, Ansel can say both, but the second one is the only one where he really learned something that he didn't already know when the conversation started. Because I think it's natural for most of us to reach for self-explanation once we feel criticized or once we're activated enough. And I understand the pull because it's the, if I can explain myself well enough

concept, then maybe you'll stop being hurt. And maybe you'll realize I wasn't trying to do the thing that you think I was doing. And maybe I won't have to sit very long with the possibility that you experienced me in a way that is uncomfortable for me to hear. So the mind gets to work and it can get very, very good at it. And it's reflexive. It takes skill to build in a pause long enough to even have a different response and then not even really understanding what that response could look like.

Some people are so articulate in those moments. I think I've been guilty about that. They can remember the details. They can lay out context. They can point to the inconsistencies and plenty of them know a fair amount of therapy language. They can talk about attachment styles and triggers and boundaries and childhood wounds, and they still have a hard time sitting with the simplest sentence in the room, which is usually something close to something I did hurt somebody that I care about. And that difficulty doesn't tell us much all by itself. Maybe they're ashamed. Maybe they're scared.

Maybe they have no idea what happens next or they honestly don't understand what is happening. Or maybe their experience has taught them that admitting an inch means surrendering the whole mile, the whole argument. And somewhere in the background, the brain is picturing the emotional equivalent of signing away the deed to the house because they forgot to set the garbage cans out. It's like they're saying, okay, if I acknowledge this, then apparently I am now responsible for every one of your unpleasant emotions since the 90s.

Of course, the nervous system is going to push back on that. And this next part comes out of a couple of back-to-back sessions that I felt like the universe handed me, and said, all right, I handed you this first example of what happened in a couple's setting and you didn't take advantage of it. So tell you what, tomorrow, I'll give it to you again. Almost word for word. So it was a couple of back-to-back sessions where the conversations had gone out into the weeds. And I was trying to explain what I mean when I tell somebody, often a husband in the couple's work that I do, to make space in this situation

for his wife's big emotions. And I know how that phrase can land. Hold space for her. Make a container for her emotions. It can sound like I'm asking a guy to sit quietly while somebody just unloads on him and abandon his own experience and agree with whatever arrives and nod in a therapeutic manner at the predetermined intervals. But making space actually starts somewhere else, starts with curiosity. If somebody that I care about, if somebody I love tells me something about their experience and I immediately clarify or correct, explain or defend, well, then I can walk out of that conversation knowing exactly what I already knew when I walked in.

When I can ask, hey, tell me more about that. What was that like for you? How long have you been carrying that? What did you make of what happened? Then I have a chance to learn something about the person I'm with and even about myself. Most of us have a story about our partner that we put together years ago, and then we just keep updating that story with our own assumptions. And there's a fair amount of confirmation bias. We continue to look for the things that they've done in the past to prove there's the thing again. Instead of trying to gather anything new from the person that's sitting across from us.

Curiosity is one of the ways that we stay current in a relationship. It's so much easier to not be curious and to continue to tell the person who I think that they are. Instead of asking the person to help me understand what that's like for you. Think about how easy then it is to stop knowing somebody. Say you've been married 15 or 20 or 30 years. So you say, I know how she is, or I know what he's going to say, or she always gets upset about this and he doesn't care about that. And at some point you're interacting with the model of the person that your

brain has been carrying around more than interacting with the actual person themselves. And what I've realized is it's efficient and our brain loves efficiency. You pull this right out of acceptance and commitment therapy, and the brain is a don't-get-kill device. It doesn't really care about the stories that you're telling it. It just wants to survive, and it believes that it has a finite amount of electrical activity, so it wants to make things simple. It wants to habitualize things. It wants to use less and less electrical activity.

So if you have to take in new information, then your brain, bless its pink, squishy heart, thinks that's going to use up more electrical activity. How about we just go with the version that I think this person is? Finding out who the person is today takes a lot more energy. Hey, what did that mean to you? Or has that changed? Or is there something about this that I've never really understood? Now I'm doing something other than getting through the conversation. I'm discovering the person that I'm in it with. Let me give you this example where you see it maybe the most.

And it's something I haven't talked about a lot in podcasts before. And it's really funny. the story my brain has told me is I will have people write in at times and, hey, I listen to your podcast in the car. And so then I don't find myself talking about sex and intimacy, but that's where I start to see the widest gap between what somebody believes is happening and what their partner is experiencing. And if I was putting this episode out on the waking up the narcissism podcast, I want you to know, I'd probably be talking a whole lot more around coercive control. And we're going to talk about coercion here as well.

But but I'm going to assume good intent from both people in the relationship. And here's the way I'm going to do it. I'm going to frame this around the fact that most of the couples I work with came into the marriage without much of a foundation in sex or intimacy. Their parents didn't talk about it or they maybe talked about it one time and then never again. And I say that as somebody who thought I did it well. My wife and I sat our kids down at 10 and had the conversation. We set it up for a few days in advance and then we took each one of them individually

to their favorite restaurant and we were thoughtful and we were open and we used the real words and we answered questions. And I remember feeling like father of the year. Now they're all adults. And so not that long ago, I asked them what they remembered. And what they remembered is mom and dad taking them out for a nice dinner and then ruining a perfectly good plate of spaghetti at that point and for the rest of their lives by explaining how babies are made. and using the words like penis and vagina. What I would do differently now, probably a little more follow-up.

You know, we treated that as an event, one conversation, well-executed, don't get me wrong, box-checked, a masterclass at age 10, which apparently does not give somebody a working vocabulary for their own desire at 25 or 38 or 50. So two people show up in a marriage, often young, often with a lot of religious framing around sex and very little language for it. And a lot of people come into it, having heard their entire life, bad, it's bad, it's bad. Don't think about it. Don't do it. It's going to be a bad thing. But as soon as you're married,

it's great. It's amazing. Do whatever you want. And so we think, oh, okay, well, it must be pretty darn easy then once you're married. That must be a piece of cake. And then they end up building one of the most vulnerable parts of the relationship out of materials that neither of them were handed. So that's the setup. And then what grows in that soil over 15 or 20 years gets really, really complicated when nobody had the language to talk about it to begin with. Here's the pattern that I see the most often. And my guess is that there are

a lot of people that are living inside it right now who wonder whether they're the only ones. And I want you to know that this is literally me giving you what I see the most, but I've worked with every variation and version of a couple with challenges around sex and intimacy. So here's the main version I get. A lot of the men I work with fit what gets called nice guy syndrome. And the piece of it that matters here is that they don't know how to ask for anything directly, especially not sex or intimacy.

So the strategy becomes indirect. Go slay the dragon at work, try to be the world's best dad, handle everything, stay agreeable, happy wife, happy life. Don't go to bed angry. And then surely his wife will desire him and initiate sex at regular intervals and, and love everything about him and it and all the couples that I've worked with. And again, we're well over 1500 now. I've actually seen that strategy work zero times. So then he'll get frustrated because he's been holding up what he understood the deal to be, even though he kind of had to make it up himself.

And then that frustration doesn't come out as a request because requests were never in his toolkit to begin with. It comes out as pouting or a certain kind of silence or a comment. And now she's living with this low hum of expectation that runs all day, every day. Eventually she starts needing to manage it. And before the pandemic, I remember being in a position where it was as if I was interviewing or preparing what would hopefully be a TEDx talk. And I still remember the premise. It ended up not happening,

but it was around having worked with a large number of couples at that point and having a couple in front of me and the husband saying, it's actually pretty easy. And I tell her all the time, if I'm happy, why not celebrate with sex? If I'm sad, you know what picks me up? Sex. And if I have a headache, nothing like an orgasm instead of and ibuprofen. And he's saying it as if I'm easy. That's like no problem. And then I hear that. And then I remember time after time, looking over at the wife and saying,

what are you hearing? What are you understanding here? And her saying, I'm in charge of everything is happiness. So if I don't do this, then he's upset. And then what it would lead to often is that the wife in that situation wouldn't even want to make eye contact when they're brushing their teeth at night, because then he's trying to see, is there a chance tonight? Or she stops doing what at the time I called the full chest hugs or open mouth kisses because if she does that, then oh, I got a chance.

And so that just creates even more of a divide. So she does. She turns away at night. She goes to bed earlier or later or she's trying to read him for what kind of evening this is going to be. And then when it isn't what he hopes it'll be, he shuts down. He pouts. He doesn't help as much with the kids. And eventually she thinks, okay, I know what I need to do. And then he'll be happy. And then she does it and he is happy. And so then he's so happy that he's like, we should do that more. And that is the origin story of how duty sex and pity sex become a regular part of a marriage.

Nobody sat down and decided on it. definitely wasn't taught that this is the way that you create an intimate bond. It got trained over years by what each person did. We train the relationship by what is tolerated. So continuing down this path, here's what then ends up being discussed in the room so many times. And I'm going to stay with the wife's experience first, because it's the one that usually goes unspoken the longest. She's lying there, maybe starting to fall asleep, and there might be some tickling,

some snuggling, some caressing, and she already knows what it's for. And she's already communicated in every way she knows how, which mostly means maybe rolling over or going quiet or not responding, sometimes saying something and then just hoping it will drop. But at some point, she'll stop resisting and it happens. And what's so fascinating, and the story I hear time and time again, is that at times her body responds and at that point the guy thinks, okay, there we go. And I remember the first woman that ever shared in a therapy session that when

the guy said, and just being very honest, where he said, yeah. And then we got to the promised land and he's smiling and he's ready for this to be a pretty funny moment. And I look at her and I say, and what's that experience for you? And she said, at that point, I feel like my body's even betrayed me. And I remember that was just so powerful. So afterward, she's lying there with something she may not even have a word for yet because it wasn't force and it wasn't a fight. And she said, yes, in a sense that she stopped saying no. And I have talked to enough guys that it's not like they feel that great either,

but they just start to think, I guess this is the way it works. And then she carries that sometimes for 10, 15, 20 years, and it accumulates into something that lives in her body every time he reaches for her. I've watched women say a version of that out loud for the first time in my office on so many occasions. Now, what I've seen happen next over and over again is the look on her husband's face, because a number of these men genuinely did not know. They didn't understand. And they're smart people and they mean well.

You know, he thought, OK, this is the process. He thought some of the time you initiate and she warms up to it. And I guess sometimes she falls asleep and he didn't have a framework for it. And he didn't know the difference between his wife choosing him and his wife giving up. And watching a guy put that together in real time, I remember early on, it was hard to be in the room for that because he goes past defensive and then lands somewhere closer to devastated and he starts apologizing. And in those moments, it's not a performance. He's starting to do the mental math on years of this.

But I've also seen that version where he starts to talk himself out of it, that defensive posture, where he's trying to explain his way around it instead of trying to understand, oh man. That I can't imagine what that was like. And it can be very hard for his wife to believe him, which makes sense. She's had a long time to build an explanation for what was happening. And that explanation has not been that he didn't know, because how could he not?

And I'm not going to tell her, oh, he didn't mean it. That isn't mine to say. And that isn't actually the work. What I can do is stay curious with both of them about what actually happened between them. Because when neither person, has had language for this, those couples can genuinely heal. It can take time. It does take time. And it takes him tolerating how much it hurts to see it clearly without collapsing into shame and then actually feeling so bad about himself that he's handing her one more thing to manage. And it takes her being allowed to not be okay with it. There's the real path,

and I've watched people walk it. Learning that you can survive it. That's a whole other part of learning to make space. That tends to be harder, which is learning that you can survive the discomfort. You may still not be comfortable when somebody you love is angry with you. Criticism may never become pleasant. If you're coming into the session saying, I just need to know how I can do this without feeling bad. Oh, you can't. Your heart rate's still going to go up. Your chest may tighten. Your brain starts shouting that we need to take care of this immediately and explain ourselves.

The work is noticing all of that without automatically reacting to it or obeying that story that your brain's telling you. So here's where we get back to. There's a real difference between reacting and responding. Reacting happens so fast that the stimulus and the response feel fused together. Something comes toward me and my nervous system reads it and I'm already explaining and correcting and withdrawing and escalating or trying to get the conversation to stop. Responding is where we need the pause. We need a little bit of daylight in between. And in that pause, in that daylight, you start noticing the stories that your

brain produces. If I make room for this, it's only going to get worse. Or if I don't defend myself, she'll think that she's completely justified. Or if I acknowledge that he's hurt, he'll think I'm admitting that everything was my fault. Or if I don't push back now, I am going to lose ground. Those thoughts arrive with so much urgency that they seem like they aren't even thoughts. They seem like facts that I need to spew forth. One of the things that I appreciate about acceptance and commitment therapy is learning to notice the difference. My brain is telling me that if I don't defend myself right now, something terrible is about to happen.

Okay, thank you, brain. I can understand why you're nervous, and I don't have to do what you're telling me to do next. Discomfort and danger, those are two completely different things. And part of the work that you learn to do is starting to trust that they are two different things. So the goal here is actually smaller than making the activation disappear. It's learning that I can be activated and I can stay standing, that I can notice what my nervous system is doing and I can still choose how I want to participate in the conversation.

That's differentiation work. And it's where the relationship starts telling me things about myself. You can't start to really self-reflect or introspect until you can get to this place of awareness or building that pause in. Why is this particular sentence so hard for me to hear? Or why do I need her to change her interpretation of what her events were before I can start to settle and look at myself? Why does his disappointment make me want to disappear? Why do I experience her sadness as an accusation?

Why does his confusion make me angry? That information is useful. So now the relationship, it becomes a lab where I get to find out who my partner is and also who I become when closeness activates something in me. The fear that it will get worse. There's a story I hear a lot in this laboratory. If I make space for this, it'll get worse. And I think that fear deserves a whole lot more respect than it usually gets. Picture somebody who learned early on that another person's emotion was something you had to manage. Maybe anger led to chaos or somebody's sadness meant somebody needs rescuing,

or some maybe disappointment was followed by three days of withdrawal or maybe emotional intensity meant the whole house had to reorganize everything around whoever was upset. And then I come along and say, hey, I'd like for you to make room for your partner's big, scary emotions. And the nervous system says, have you lost your mind and I'm paying you for this? Because what it hears is invite in the thing that you've spent your whole life learning how to avoid or contain. They picture what comes next. Validate one emotion and everything changes.

Not in a good way. Make room for one complaint and tomorrow there's gonna be four and the next day there's gonna me eight or say, I can see why that might've hurt. And by next week, you're in a folding chair under a spotlight and you're being interrogated about every single thing that's happened in the marriage. So people get scared. Fear makes sense to me. It's the fear of the unknown. It's the uncertainty. But what I notice when people do make space is something different. Emotions usually don't need nearly as much room as we think they do. And it's the actual resistance of feeling them that is actually what keeps them alive.

Somebody says, I was really sad when you forgot that. And the response is, well, I didn't forget. You never actually told me what time it was. Now we have to establish whether she technically informed him and when and whether the text was clear and whether the calendar invitation counted and whether he saw the calendar invitation and whether a reasonable person should have read the thumbs up emoji as a legally binding acceptance of the event. 20 minutes later, nobody's talking about sadness. We are litigating the metadata. So with enough space, the same conversation is actually a lot simpler.

I was really sad when you weren't there. I can't even imagine what that was like. What happened for you? I started wondering if I even mattered. Okay, I can follow how you got there. And then maybe eventually, he says, I actually thought dinner started at seven. So the facts can still matter and there's room for them. The difference is that they show up as information, not showing up as a fire extinguisher aimed at somebody else's emotions. Which brings me to another place where couples get stuck and that is this whole concept around vulnerability. What does it even mean?

Some of us learned a version of vulnerability that says, you hurt my feelings, so now you need to make my feelings go away. There's an inverse version that says, I'm sorry you felt that way, where I take responsibility for somebody's reaction without ever getting curious about what happened between us. And both actually come out of a similar childhood framework. Somebody reacted, therefore somebody else caused the reaction, therefore we need to find out who caused it and get them to fix it. Blame. Who can we blame? That framework leaves very little room for interpretation, meaning, context, history, nervous systems, intent, people's experiences,

variables, or the literal complexity of two humans that are different trying to communicate. Adult vulnerability, hopefully, is going to sound more grounded. It can sound like, I don't know what to do with what you're telling me, or I'm noticing that I'm getting defensive, but I want to stay here with you, or I am, honestly, I'm confused right now, but I don't want to run away. Or I need a minute because I can start to feel myself getting overwhelmed and,

I want to come back to this. And then maybe the most useful sentence available to any of us, I don't know how to do this. That sentence actually makes a person bigger. It says, I can admit that I don't currently have the skill I need and that doesn't have to become a verdict about who I am for the rest of my life. This came out of a session where I watched somebody get so close to that kind of vulnerability and you could see they're almost there and then they didn't know what to do and they got angry and then anger showed up instead.

And it makes sense. Anger gives us something to do. Confusion and helplessness are harder to sit in. I don't know what to do. Can leave a person feeling really exposed. Anger at least gives the nervous system a direction. So part of becoming more emotionally aware is learning to recognize what might be sitting underneath the first emotion that shows up. And if that first emotion is confusion and I don't like it, or if it's a lack of understanding and I don't know how to sit with that, anger is telling you, hey, I'm good at this.

Let me come in now and just get really mad. And then we won't have to deal with this primary emotion stuff. And let's talk about boundaries because boundaries are a me thing. Because sometimes emotional awareness means recognizing that I have hit my limit. And that's where boundaries come in. A boundary is me noticing what is happening inside of me and deciding what I need to do to stay the version of myself that I want to be in this relationship. That was a lot of I's and me's and you'll see why. Because it's so different than telling someone else what they need to do. It's me.

I'm getting flooded. I need 20 minutes and I want to come back to this. I'm noticing that I'm reacting instead of responding. I need to step away and regulate. Because when the intention is to come back, that keeps the conversation intact. It protects the conversation from the version of me that is about three sentences away from losing my crap and saying something that I will spend the next three weeks regretting and explaining. So a boundary, if I'm starting to feel a certain way, then I need to take a break. Actually keeps me in the relationship instead of building a wall in the middle

of it, which people often think that boundaries are doing. It names what I'm going to do to take care of myself, and it doesn't ask my partner to become a different person before I'm allowed to do it. Let me go back to the original question that we started with, because this is, again, another area where couples work is so fascinating. Sometimes you have two people that can do this well. Neither of them does it well every time. They'll still get activated. They lose the plot. They say things they wish they'd phrased differently. They sometimes end up out in

the weeds, a couple of conversational exits past where they meant to go. But eventually one of them says, hang on, I think we're missing each other. And the other one says, yeah, I think we are. And now there's somewhere to go. I haven't even talked yet about my beloved four pillars of a connected conversation. I love having everyone start from a place of using my four pillars. There's the pre pillar of separating observation from judgment. I am observing that you walked by me and didn't say anything. And I'm making the judgment that you don't care about me. I need to separate those two. We do it. We make judgments on observations,

but if those are fused together, I've already started to issue a judgment toward what we're about to do next, which is pillar one to assume good intent that no one's waking up in the morning thinking I cannot wait to hurt my partner. Pillar two, I cannot tell the other person that they're wrong or crazy or incorrect. Big, dramatic pause. Even if I think that they're wrong, crazy, and incorrect. Because this is their perspective, which leads me to pillar three. I'm going to ask questions before I make any comments. And those are genuinely curious questions. Not, okay, I'll ask a question to

just check a box. And not to ask a question so I can tell that person they're wrong. I want to genuinely understand what they're saying. And pillar four, I cannot go into a victim mindset and say, you're right. I suck. I'm a horrible person because then I'm wanting that person to rescue me. Then there are relationships where the capacities are more uneven. And this is where the work really starts to show capacity. One person hears, you need to own your part. And their brain says, okay, what else am I missing? The other person hears, you both need to own your part, and their brain says,

thank you, I've been trying to get them to see that for years, am I right? Same sentence, two very different internal experiences, which takes me back to that's why generic relationship advice can get confusing for somebody who is already highly self-reflective. If a person has spent years over owning the emotional temperature of the relationship, telling them to remember that they contribute to can send them into another six months of forensic analysis on their own personality while their partner is already comfortably explaining what happened. More self-reflection isn't automatically the goal. Some people have enough self-reflection

to power a small city, but I think there are two different things that are happening that can look almost identical from the outside. One of them produces new information. I go back over a conversation. I noticed something that I haven't seen before and it changes what I do next time. The other one goes back over the same conversation and lands in essentially the same spot every time, which is usually some version of if I can figure out exactly what I did, then maybe I can keep this from happening again.

And that second one looks humble. It sounds like I'm taking ownership. It uses all the right language. It may even include a tremendous amount of genuine self-reflection. But my guess is that underneath it is often less of a search for insight and more of a search for safety. Let's make this very real. Imagine a husband and a wife are having an argument on a Friday night. She's telling him about something difficult to happen with one of the kids. And while she's talking, he just keeps looking down at his phone. Eventually, she says, this is actually what I'm talking about.

I don't really feel like you're here with me when I'm trying to talk to you. So one version of reflection might sound something like this. And I'm talking about self-reflection. We're going to step away from trying to have this conversation together for a moment, because that might be two nervous systems just reacting to each other. But his self-reflection might be, okay, I know that I wasn't trying to dismiss her. And I was checking something that I felt was important in the moment. But I can see that I was splitting my attention. And I'm imagining that would be hard.

If she was trying to share something, it's going to feel like I'm not connected. And I can imagine that looking at my phone probably adds to this feeling that she's carrying everything by herself. And I didn't really look at it that way. I now have new data. So next time, if I notice that I'm wanting to look at my phone, I need to put the phone down. And if I can't do that, I need to own it. And I need to say, hey, I really do want to hear this. And if you can give me a second, instead of just assuming that she knows I'm listening. And then, ideally, the self-reflection more or less ends.

He's taken in the data. He didn't have to defend it or criticize her. He learned something. He doesn't have to establish the fact of, don't you see all the good things that I've been doing? He doesn't have to establish that he's a good husband. He doesn't have to decide that she handled the conversation perfectly. Okay, Miss Perfect. He doesn't have to figure out whose childhood is responsible for this. He found out something about himself that he can use the next time. That's what I mean when I say that reflection that's doing its job tends to finish. It hands you something and then it lets you go.

The other version can start in almost exactly the same place. Okay, I shouldn't have looked at my phone and I do need to work on that. It was just the phone and I, you didn't even ask me what I was looking at and it would have been nice for you to think about me and okay, fine. Maybe it was my tone before that, because I probably, I think I sighed before she started talking. Maybe the sigh made her think I didn't care and okay, fine. I'll apologize for that too, but maybe it goes back to earlier in the day when I didn't text her

back and maybe that made her feel unimportant before she even started talking to me. So I, I, maybe I need to respond faster, but it's not like she does all the time either. But I mean, there've been times where I responded too quickly and she thinks that I'm doing it just because we just talked about it and I shouldn't have to tell you. And so maybe what I need to do is I need to explain, Hey, look, I'm trying to change, but not make it sound like I need credit for it. And then three hours later, he's still mentally reviewing his surveillance footage from a relationship crime scene that actually nobody else was asking him to investigate.

So from the outside, it can look incredibly accountable. It looks as if he's examining his behavior, considering her experience. It may even start to give a little bit of taking ownership. He may even be saying all the things that I would want somebody to become more capable of saying. But somewhere along the way, the question changed and he stopped asking himself, what can I learn from this? He's asking, hey, what do I need to discover so that this doesn't happen again? And I hope you can see the difference. I think that's where reflection can turn

into this search for safety because now he isn't only trying to become a little more emotionally mature or relationally aware. He's trying to reverse engineer the interaction well enough that he can guarantee he won't disappoint her. She won't become upset and they won't end up having another painful conversation and nobody actually can hand him that guarantee. Even if he puts the phone away next Friday, she might be upset about something else. She might misunderstand him. He might misunderstand her. He might be distracted or tired or defensive or hungry or worried about work or simply be a human being having a less than stellar relationship moment.

So then the loop stays open because the thing he's looking for doesn't even really exist. And if you've been listening to this thinking, okay, well, what else should I be owning here? I think that's worth bringing awareness to as well. Let's stay with the same guy one version of owning his part might sound like okay I see the phone thing I also noticed that when she told me that she felt alone My first impulse was to explain that I wasn't ignoring her. That's interesting and I'm and I mean that I am Getting to another layer of self-reflection and I wonder if that was me trying to get myself out of the feeling that I disappointed her,

So there's some work to do I'd like to get better at staying there for a minute before I try to explain myself. There's something to discover there He's not looking for another count on the indictment against himself He's becoming genuinely curious about himself and about a mechanism, When somebody I love is hurt by something I did I apparently feel this urgency to explain my intention I wonder what that's about Now I can blame my parents. That curiosity might actually get him somewhere. The search party version sounds more like, okay, so I looked at the phone and I got defensive and I explained

myself, what else am I missing? What else am I doing to her? Is there something else I need to own? Or was I being invalidating? Or am I avoidant? Or is this my ADHD? Is this my emotional immaturity? Did I learn this from my dad? Am I a narcissist? Have I been doing this our entire marriage? Because all of these things he's asking still needs somebody else to tell him. He's not on his hero's journey. He's still saying, nobody's telling me what I'm supposed to do. So I don't understand why she doesn't feel close to me. He's combing the woods for evidence. And every time somebody says, all right, I think I've got it.

Then number one, you're going to have to go ask the person, which is basically me saying, hey, did I do good? Can you pat me on the head so that I can be done with this? But your own brain is going to say, okay, well, then why doesn't it feel better? I must be missing something. And I want to be compassionate toward that person because I don't think they're necessarily trying to avoid accountability in a strange way. They may be trying to take so much accountability that they can finally become safe from uncertainty. And if they can identify every possible thing they're doing and anticipate every potential thing that could go wrong, then maybe their partner won't be hurt.

But they need so much validation while doing it. And there isn't that kind of certainty available. They're hoping if they can do all of this, then their partner won't become angry. And they're even going to make sure and ask, if I do all these things, will you be mad at me? And then maybe the marriage will feel safe and there might be another layer underneath all of this what if part of his search isn't just what else do i need to do to fix this so it'll be okay but also will somebody eventually tell me that i'm a good boy, does somebody want to go want to go out back and have a catch.

Because if I'm going to spend months looking at myself, going to therapy, listening to podcasts, meditating, catching myself before I become defensive, learning to tolerate discomfort, trying to be more present with my partner, and nobody ever looks at me and says, I see what you're doing, and you're doing a really good job, then did it even count? And I think this is where we start to bump into what internal validation actually looks like. It doesn't mean that praise doesn't feel good or that we suddenly stop wanting people to notice us. Of course, it feels good to be seen. Validation is not the enemy.

It's only if my whole sense of self is built off of the external validation of others. Because at some point, I have to be able to know, independent of somebody else's reaction, that I showed up differently. That I stayed in the conversation when I wanted to defend myself. I listened longer. I now know what genuine curiosity means. I apologize because I recognize something that I did and I want to own it. Not because I need the apology to produce a particular response so we can move on with things. It's the fact that I now know the work I've done because I'm the one that's doing it.

And maybe nobody hands me a certificate at the end of the day saying, congratulations, you are now emotionally mature. Maybe my partner isn't ready to acknowledge it. Because why would they? Because I've said that I've gotten it before over and over again. Or maybe they experienced my growth differently than I do. But I can still know that I'm becoming more aligned with the husband, the father, the partner, the human being that I want to be. And ironically, I think that's when the work starts to feel less like something I'm doing in hopes that somebody will validate me and more like something I'm doing because this is simply who I want to become.

I confidently know because I have been on this hero's journey for a long time now. When you don't know who you are on the inside, you want somebody else to tell you that you're okay. And you don't even know what it's going to look like yet when you finally know yourself, love yourself. Because at that point, it's as if you start getting more genuine validation, because you're not asking for it. You're not begging for it. You're not building your whole sense of self off of it. And the irony there is you're allowing others to be free enough around you that

they do notice something and you hear it. But at that point, you don't need it. It's such a paradox. At some point, you are doing it because you are the one who does these things. So I don't think the difference is really between taking ownership and not taking ownership. Because both versions may contain a lot of ownership. The difference is what the ownership is for. One version is genuinely curious. I wonder what I can learn here. And you can't just say that. You have to embody it.

The other one is quietly asking, please tell me what I need to fix so I can know that we're going to be okay. And it goes back to that other validated intimacy because I'm only okay if you're okay. Instead of self-validated that I can learn to be okay. When we can start noticing that difference, then reflection can go back to doing what it was meant to do. Help us discover something new, give us something useful to carry forward, and then allowing us to keep moving forward. It doesn't go very deep when we're simply trying to make the discomfort go away. It might include a first response

like, I'm sorry, I really am. There, they said it. They are sorry about what you just shared and what that... Is making you feel, period. End of story. And do a little more work, have this conversation a few more times, and it might even be, I'm sorry, and I didn't even realize you felt that way. Okay? As the person that just expressed themselves, thank you for saying that. You're off the hook now. Say it a few more times, and then they may even be able to say, I can imagine that was really hard for you, and I'm really sorry. And it's the right mouth sound, but it doesn't land.

Let's go back to the example of the couple who had that unhealthy relationship with of sex and intimacy. And I'm taking on the example again that I see most often in my office where the guy is the more high desire partner and the wife is the lower desire partner. And I know that while this is the majority of the couples that I see, I have had, currently have and will continue to have couples with the opposite dynamic as well, where the wife is the higher desire partner and the husband's the low desire partner. I went to a training one time, a long time ago, where the psychologist that

was doing the training said, how many of you have the dynamic where the guy's the higher desire and the wife's the lower desire? Everybody raises their hand. And then he said, how many of you have the dynamic where the wife is the higher desire, the husband's the lower desire? Most of us were still able to raise our hand. And he said, have you ever wondered what would happen if you paired the two high desire partners together? There's a chuckle. And then he said, of course, it's been studied numerous occasions, and they will still find their way into a high desire, low desire dynamic. It's the way that we fall into in relationships. I love the work of David Schnarch. And one of the things that he talks about so much is the high desire,

low desire dynamic isn't pathological. Isn't that one person is worse or that they're broken. I like to explain that there are high desire, low desire dynamics throughout a relationship. I am the low desire cleaner in my mind and my wife's relationship while my wife is the high desire cleaner. She may want me to want to clean my side of the bed, but quite frankly, I don't. Now, can I die on the hill if it's my side of the bed and I want to keep it looking similar to a 10-year-old child versus choosing to support my wife in my marriage? No, of course not.

So while I will most likely never lean in enough to be on the same page with her about the virtues of a clutter-free nightstand, I care about her and I choose the relationship. So I'm going to do more than make the right mouth sounds of I'll do better. I can only imagine that must be hard living with somebody who keeps their side of the bed the way you're describing it when you have made an emotional bid to tell me what that feels like for you. No, I can actually self-confront and say, why is it that I seem to have stopped at me saying that I really do want to stay on top of it and I mean it in the

moment, but then I simply don't think about it again. Knowing that's a me thing, I then need to either have the courage to say that I will not be doing anything about my side of the bed. And this is dramatically talking about this because it's a lower charge topic, but because if I'm going to be honest, I have the courage to be known and the courage to know her. Then she can make a real decision about what she wants to do, meaning what version of growth through discomfort she wants to embark on. And I'm again saying that if I'm owning the fact that I am willing to die on this hill, which I'm not, because there's a version where she accepts me as I am.

So she learns to breathe through seeing my side of the bed, stay present and connect with me anyway. Or behind door number two, we have her growing through the discomfort of cleaning my side of the bed herself. If it truly is that important to her and not holding that against me would be the difficult work to be done. Or door number three, initiate divorce proceedings and accept that she'll definitely hear from others and probably me. Really? You divorced him because he didn't clean his side of the bed? But the point being, if somebody says they're going to do something, then they need to go on the hero's journey and actually do it. Or they need to have the courage to say, that isn't something that I'm able to do or willing to do.

And it's a bit unfair to yourself and your partner to continually criticize somebody else for the way that they are doing them. But it's also unfair to tell somebody that something matters to you because you say that it does because you recognize that it matters to them while continuing to show through your actions that it actually doesn't matter much to you if somebody is showing you who they are believe them. And all of this is said from the perspective that this version is at least on the growth side of the equation versus the version where you shut down and you

don't say anything at all or where you mock or make fun of or gaslight the person for the way that they're doing their own life, rather than becoming genuinely curious about their experience and your own. So we are talking about intimacy, also known as sex. And in this scenario, the guy is the higher desire partner. Now the guy has been on a journey of self-discovery around his use of coercion for sex, as we were talking about earlier. Let's say that he has put the couple's sexual relationship on hold. He'll do his healing journey. And his wife has said she wants to repair it as well. So he is assuming she's on her journey as well.

Of course, their journeys are going to be different. He's learning to meditate and build a pause into his impulsive nature and learn to be present in bed with his wife and create safety for her so she doesn't have to worry about whether he's going to be upset if they don't have sex. And he assumes that she's doing things too, maybe reading books or listening to podcasts or talking to a therapist. So a few months pass and he asks if she would like to be intimate. She says how hard it's been processing what's happened in their relationship and how long it's been. It's been so many years and she needs more time and that he obviously doesn't understand how hard this has been for her.

And he agrees and he apologizes and he goes on another round of the hero's journey, more mindfulness, more therapy, more podcasts, more candy crush, more time at the gym, more time with his kids. Six more months pass. and he asks again and she says it's not that easy to heal she mentions the book the body keeps the score and he gets it, no problem hero's journey number three he gets the book he reads the book let's discuss the book she hasn't actually read it yet he reads books on attachment styles he journals more time passes and he makes another bid and she hits him with you don't think i'm working on our relationship,

now at this point admittedly he kind of doesn't but he knows that's not going to be helpful to say. So rinse and repeat and let me interject in here again just because i I don't want there to be any mistake that I work with. I work with women going through this journey of self-discovery as well as playing the role of the higher desire partner. The difficult truth that comes up eventually in this dynamic is that the lower desire partner truly does tend to hold more power because they can continue to have a lower desire and not think about, in this case, sex.

But through all of this, he's learned a lot about himself. He's learned that he's not a bad person for desiring an intimate relationship with his wife. And she's not a bad person for finding herself not thinking much about the sexual relationship with her husband based on all of the things that they've been through. And he also understands that neither of them truly knew what they didn't know. And he can't wait to try to improve or repair the relationship. So when he brings it up, it becomes more of what we discussed earlier. She feels criticized. And now her nervous system wants to get rid of the discomfort.

He asks for her honesty. If she's not interested in a sexual intimate relationship at this point, he would rather know. And she says, no, I am. That's not what I'm saying. So then he says, then help me understand. And she says, it's not as easy as he thinks. And that he doesn't understand what that's like for her. And all of those things are absolutely true. But maybe the more useful question at that stage is whether the reflection is helping her discover something new, or whether it has become another attempt to find the explanation that will finally

make the bad feelings go away. And hopefully the relationship feels safe. But what if the work that he's been doing actually has been creating more safety? And of course, she didn't believe that it would because it hasn't before. And now she recognizes that maybe she hasn't been working on re-engaging with an intimate relationship. And she can't imagine even what that looks like now because she never thought that they would get to this place where he had done those things that he had said he would do. So does she now have the courage to become curious about that?

Can she acknowledge it or talk about it or share what her work has actually been? And I've heard this a lot of times in this situation. Essentially, hey, the fact that I stayed in the relationship is the work that I've been doing. And I want to acknowledge that staying may be the work early on. Sometimes staying and observing and watching for consistency and letting your nervous system discover whether the environment really has changed, it is a tremendous amount of work because it hasn't happened before. But at some point, if the stated goal is to build a new relationship together,

there may need to be another question. What am I doing now to participate in the building of the relationship? The co-creation. Because otherwise, we're going to end up back in something that may look like emotional immaturity. Essentially some version of, I'm not going to engage with this. And what are you going to do about it? And at some point, the answer to that question may no longer be what it once was when both partners were operating both from a more emotionally immature version of themselves. I sit across from couples who only know their own experience because of course they do.

That's the experience that they have access to. But I also get this unusual and fascinating privilege of sitting across from couple after couple and watching what happens over time. And I do get to see couples who genuinely grow together. I also see more often than I ever imagined as I would as a couples therapist, situations where one partner begins doing a tremendous amount of work and growth, while the other partner, bless their heart, may genuinely believe that they are doing the same.

But from where I sit as a third party, I can sometimes see a growing difference between what the two people mean when they say I'm working on myself. And eventually that difference, that gap begins to impact the relationship. And it's often at that point that you start seeing more clearly what may have been underneath the dynamic all along. I'm going to quote a content creator that I really enjoy, Jimmy on relationships, because I've watched a particular reel of his several times after it was initially

sent to me by more than one client. And I've always thought, okay, I want to create my own version of it. But then it's so good that I'll link it in the show notes. But he's talking about dating or marrying a people pleaser, which essentially can be the nice guy or the nice woman personified. And he says, you need to be cautious getting involved with somebody who puts your needs above their own. Somebody who actually seems to enjoy loving and giving and sacrificing for others, even at their own expense. He then talks about how givers can have a low threshold for accepting love,

meaning that a little goes a long way for them. You can essentially give them breadcrumbs and it feels like they're getting the whole loaf. And they can have a very high threshold for neglect, meaning that they may make excuses for your disrespect. They may blame themselves rather than asking what's happening between the two of you. They can tolerate a lot for a very long time. And then what I find fascinating, back to me, not Jimmy, is that I've started paying attention to this with real couples in session. And both partners will often identify themselves as both the people pleaser.

Both people may genuinely see themselves as the one who gives and sacrifices and accommodates and tries to keep everything together. But I think you'll start to see the divide in what Jimmy says next. He says, but here's the dangerous part. Once you invalidate their feelings to the point where they don't even feel safe talking to you anymore. And now I'm going to jump back in here and say, here's where I would add. That from what I see in the therapy room, what if this person is coming to you saying that they've been doing the work and they can't wait to talk about what they've discovered,

because they wanna start creating the next version of the relationship with you, only to hear that you're still not doing it well enough. Or they hear again how difficult it is to be married to them, or they're told what their motives are, or what they're feeling, or what their behavior says about who they are. At some point, that person may stop bringing the work to you. And that's been a person who has wanted to talk about things their entire marriage, granted in an emotionally immature way. Jimmy then says, a switch gets flipped and the trust is gone.

They felt abandoned for so long and they have nothing left to give. And then you might say, well, that's not fair. I thought they were giving from a place of love. If they were expecting something, then it wasn't actually love. And then Jimmy says, okay, I get the logic. And maybe there's some truth in that in certain situations. But the other side is that it isn't necessarily that they want to stop giving and serving altogether. They may have simply reached a place where they no longer want to keep giving in the same way to this particular relationship because they've begun to recognize how little they've been willing to accept and return.

That line lands so hard in sessions because sometimes the person sitting there is acknowledged i didn't know what i didn't know and what they've been quietly hoping for is that their partner will eventually be able to say the some version of you know what i didn't either. And how could we have and now we can actually begin the work it's us versus the world we both didn't know because when Then I do get that dynamic in sessions. It almost, and I'm saying almost, feels like I shouldn't be taking their money.

They're both so excited to figure it out. And the repair is quick and intimacy starts taking off in all kinds of areas. Verbal, they start talking about all kinds of things. Emotional, they can open up about their feelings. It just shows that all of a sudden we're going to get really vulnerable here. Spiritual intimacy, intellectual intimacy. Oh my gosh, I didn't know that's how you felt. And here's what I think about that. And suddenly it's a brand new relationship and the world still spins and the sun comes up and sometimes it feels uncomfortable and sometimes it feels incredible.

Suddenly there's this growing recognition that of course we are two different people and we have inside jokes and we have these shared experiences that we don't want to throw away. Of course we experience things differently. Neither person needs to have been secretly carrying the instruction manual the whole time. We just didn't have a clue what we were doing and sure. We can both blame our parents for a little while because that's always fun But eventually we start recognizing one of the incredible opportunities in a relationship, I have another human being standing close enough to me to show me things about

myself that I can't see on my own And they have blind spots too. Of course they do And now we get to grow together and it's not two halves making a whole We are two whole complete people It's more like a one plus one equals three or five or six. That's the thing. But it only really develops when both people are willing to self-reflect. Back to Jimmy on relationships, because I want to set the table again. That was a little bit of a tangent. When he says a switch gets flipped and trust is gone, they felt abandoned for

so long and they have nothing left to give. And you might say, well, that's not fair. I thought they were giving from a place of love. If they were expecting something, then it wasn't actually love. And he talks about how maybe part of that logic makes sense. But the other half is that they don't necessarily want to stop giving and serving overall. They may simply no longer want to keep giving in a relationship where they have come to recognize they've been surviving on breadcrumbs. And now with the context that I just handed you there, I want you to hear where he goes next because when that switch flips and the person isn't trying to engage anymore, that's when he says, and you might say, I just don't know what they wanted from me.

And if that's the case, I'd challenge you. How often did you ask them? Hey, how can I serve you? How can I help you feel valued and loved and prioritized? Because your feelings and your needs matter to me. Because he says if the answer is zero, that's what they wanted. And I would add that if they were coming to you wanting to improve the verbal intimacy, the emotional intimacy, the physical intimacy. There's a very real possibility that it was coming from a place of finally choosing themselves enough to do the work on themselves so they could choose you. That cliche is real. If I don't love myself, I can't love you because I'm trying

to figure out what's wrong with me and how can I get you to love me so I will feel whole. But if you really do the work, and hopefully if you've stuck with me through this long of this episode, you understand more of what that work is. It's not just a word. It's not just a cliched phrase. But at that point, you realize you're the only version of you walking the face of the earth. You think and feel the way you do because you do, and you didn't have the tools. How could you? You were raised by a group of feral cats. That's too strong.

But you weren't modeled the greatest relationship model. Most likely, we were told that if we felt or thought something, or if our feelings or emotions were big, that we were told not to worry about things and don't think about things. And it's not a big deal when we thought it was. So our emotions don't even know what to do. We don't know what to do with them. We need somebody else to tell us that we're going to be okay. We don't talk about sex. There's so many things that we had going against us when we got married, when we got into a relationship. And a relationship is a people-growing machine.

We're two people that are codependent and enmeshed, and we're supposed to become differentiated, where one person ends and the other begins. And it's an amazing journey that I wish I got to see more people do. And I'm a couples therapist. That just tells you how hard the work can be. But oh my gosh, is it rewarding when you watch it work. When you see a couple learn to love themselves so they can love each other and they can be two completely different humans having shared experiences. Now it's exciting to go through life. I have chosen me and now I'm choosing you.

And the question becomes, did you ever do the work to choose them back? Were you becoming curious about this person in front of you and about the relationship that the two of you could create together? Are we learning to make the right mouth sounds and then getting back to whatever it was you were doing other than actually trying to repair and grow you and the relationship? Which is why I keep coming back to what happens when new information enters the system. Can I hear something that doesn't match my existing story? Can I stay curious when somebody remembers an experience differently than I do? Can I hear that my intention and their experience aren't the same thing?

Can I admit if or when I may not actually be doing what I say that I'm doing? Or am I able to acknowledge that they may truly be doing the work that would benefit the relationship and I'm not giving that work or them a chance to improve the relationship? Can I actually discover something without immediately deciding that my discovery says something about my worth? That's emotional awareness. Nobody has to be caught. Something else happens when resistance drops. So a couple of things, and we'll wrap this up first. You can't do this on somebody else's behalf. Curiosity is contagious more often than I expected when I started doing this work.

And it's also unreliable. Some people soften when the pressure comes off and some people experience the space that you made as room to then relax and spread out. The second is that everything that I've described here is still a me thing, which means it keeps paying you even if it doesn't change the relationship. You hope it will change the relationship, but you learn what you can tolerate. You learn what you want. You learn where your limit actually is and what happens in your body when somebody won't meet you there. That's yours regardless of what the other person decides to do. And the third is that boundaries come in when the invitation keeps getting declined.

A boundary here might sound like, I'm going to step out if this conversation is turning into a cross-examination. And I want to come back when we can both stay in it. That name's what I'm going to do. It leaves the other person free to do whatever they're going to do. And what I notice is that people usually know something long before they're ready to say it out loud. The work in the meantime is staying honest with yourself about what you're seeing instead of running the search party one more time to try to find the version of you that would have made it go differently. So if you have been listening to this whole episode thinking, I have tried being curious and it made things worse, my guess is that's worth

taking seriously instead of trying harder at it. Everything I'm describing here assumes it's reasonably safe to be known by the person across from you. And when it isn't, this is a different kind of work and it usually needs support around you, whether that's a therapist or of your own or people who can see the situation more clearly. This is part of why emotional awareness does matter more than learning communication techniques. I can hand you every tool I know. I can teach you reflective listening and differentiation and boundaries and how to tell a primary emotion from a secondary one and how

to pause and regulate and say what you mean more clearly. The tools get a whole lot more useful though when somebody is willing to say, I may not really even know what this is I'm doing. Every so often, a couple walks into my office with exactly that posture, and they aren't asking me to explain to their spouse why their spouse is the problem. They're saying, we know something isn't working. We've tried, and we don't know what to do next. We're missing something, which is why the Sherpa thing comes back. Because the couple coming in, they actually already have the gear,

and they've been traveling together for years, and they've survived storms and bad weather and terrain that took everything they had. And they have strengths and history that existed long before they ever met me. But now they've reached a stretch of trail they don't recognize and maybe the footing changes and maybe the path narrows and maybe the weather rolls in and they can't see that far ahead or maybe something that worked on every previous part of the journey isn't the tool for this section. And i've been on versions of this stretch a lot so i can say you may want to slow down something about the footing in this section tends to throw people

off that tool that you've been carrying is such a good tool, but you're using it now for something that it wasn't built for or stay close through this part. And then they walk it and then they do the climbing. And eventually they stop needing me to point out every turn because they start recognizing the terrain themselves or they start recognizing that they're going to figure it out. Even if one of them gets activated and one of them says, Hey, I think I'm explaining myself before I really heard you. Can we do a do-over? Or the other person saying, I think I'm asking you to fix

my emotions instead of telling you what's happening inside of me. Somebody says, I need a break, but we'll get back to this. And the other person says, I really don't know what to do here. But I'm glad that we're doing it together. And you get to watch two people build the capacity to navigate terrain that used to send them off to the trail entirely. So where do you start? Emotional awareness doesn't require having any of this already figured out. And I don't think it requires being especially good at talking about emotions either. It starts with enough curiosity to consider that something might be happening and I don't see it yet.

And I can know what I intended and I can still wonder what you experienced. And I can trust my memory-ish and stay very curious about yours. And I can dislike what I'm hearing and I can stay in this conversation long enough to learn something and I can notice my brain crafting a defense and I can actually decide not to deliver it. And when I truly don't know what to do next, I can actually say that out loud. So if you want one thing that you can actually do with all of this, take a week. When the person that you love tells you something about their experience, ask a question before you say anything else. What was that like for you?

Tell me more about that. How long has that been sitting there? One question. Before the context, before the explanation, before the correction. Let's just start there. That's the whole assignment. And my guess is that it will end up being a little bit harder than it sounds because the defense brief, you've been writing that one forever. It's finished. It's already written now by the time they finish the sentence. Staying grounded and curious means discovering I can remain myself in the presence of somebody else's emotional experience. And sometimes that looks like staying and asking another question. And sometimes it's saying, I don't know how to do this and I need you to help

me reach out to me and I will send you a PDF summary of all the things that we talked about today. I am so grateful that you are here. Thank you for going on this very lengthy journey tonight, taking us out per usual. The wonderful, the talented Aurora Florence with her song. It's wonderful because it really can be. Thanks everybody. Pass this along to somebody if you think it'll help them. And I will see you next time on the virtual couch. Compressed emotions flying past our heads and out the other And the pressures

of the daily grind It's wonderful.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Hosts

  • Tony Overbay Host Feed-stated

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. How Childhood Shapes Who You Marry: The Accommodator, Attachment, and Why We Choose the Familiar

    Nov 13, 20261 hr 18 minAudio

    Why do people pleasers and avoidant partners find each other, and why does it seem like such a relief at first? Tony follows Pam and Jim, a composite couple, from childhood to the college campus where they met. Pam...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Nobody Brings a Casserole When You Wake Up to Betrayal: The Accommodator, Gaslighting, and Rebuilding Trust

    Nov 4, 20261 hr 29 minAudio

    Waking up to betrayal, gaslighting, or emotional immaturity rarely comes with a casserole on the porch or a meal train. When someone has a baby or a surgery, people can see the event and show up with dinner. When you...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Nobody Brings a Casserole When You Wake Up to Betrayal: The Accommodator, Gaslighting, and Rebuilding Trust

    Nov 4, 20261 hr 29 minAudio

    Waking up to betrayal, gaslighting, or emotional immaturity rarely comes with a casserole on the porch or a meal train. When someone has a baby or a surgery, people can see the event and show up with dinner. When you...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Your AI Is a Great Hype-Man - A Therapist Has a Few Notes (Plus Live QA)

    Oct 14, 20261 hr 32 minAudio

    Using AI as a therapist? Your chatbot might be building a great plan for the person you’re hoping to become. When a client’s chatbot asked if he was an extroverted go-getter, he answered as the man he’s working toward,...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Why Good People Defend Leaders (and Others) Who Contradict Themselves: Identity, Bias & Belonging

    Sep 24, 202653 minAudio

    Tony starts with a kid raised in an East Coast fishing town and another raised hiking Arizona trails. He uses them to show how beliefs tend to form through family, community, and identity, with the reasons showing up...

    Credit the people on this episode