Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

The Virtual Couch

The Virtual Couch artwork

“Killed Them All, Of Course": The Mind of Robert Durst w/Attorney Kate

Aug 6, 20261 hr 31 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Content warning: This episode includes discussion of homicide, dismemberment, and domestic violence. Listener discretion advised. Robert Durst confessed on a hot mic - but the real story is watching a man confabulate in real time, for decades, and nearly get away with it. In the first-ever Murder on the Couch guest episode, Tony is joined by his friend Kate, a civil attorney and lifelong true crime devotee, to break down the case behind HBO's The Jinx. Kate presents the case - the 1982 disappearance of Kathie Durst, the murder of Susan Berman, the Morris Black acquittal that still defies belief - while Tony reacts in real time with the psychology underneath it all: confabulation, childhood adaptations, and what actually happens when someone is finally confronted with a lie they can't tap-dance out of. In this episode, you'll discover: Why memory is "adorable and fallible" - and how the legal system's hierarchy of evidence accounts for exactly that How Durst's defense team built reasonable doubt around an admitted dismemberment (and why the missing evidence mattered more than the conceded facts) The difference between psychopathy and sociopathy - nature vs. nurture, charm vs. rage, and why nonviolent sociopaths walk among us What a masterful cross-examination and an eight-hour couples intensive have in common: staying with someone's discomfort until the adaptation collapses Why breakthroughs so often have a "shelf life" - and what it takes for real change to stick Tony Overbay is a licensed marriage and family therapist who has spent decades watching people confabulate, deflect, and defend in real time - just usually not on the witness stand. If you've ever watched someone rewrite reality right in front of you and wondered how they believe their own story, this episode is for you. Please follow Tony on Instagram @virtual.couch on Tiktok @virtualcouch on Facebook https://www.facebook.com/tonyoverbaylmft and on Substack https://thevirtualcouch.substack.com/ You can reach out to Tony through his website tonyoverbay.com or by emailing contact @ tonyoverbay.com Content warning: This episode includes discussion of homicide, dismemberment, and domestic violence. Listener discretion advised. Robert Durst confessed on a hot mic - but the real story is watching a man confabulate in real time, for decades, and nearly get away with it. In the first-ever Murder on the Couch guest episode, Tony is joined by his friend Kate, a civil attorney and lifelong true crime devotee, to break down the case behind HBO's The Jinx. Kate presents the case - the 1982 disappearance of Kathie Durst, the murder of Susan Berman, the Morris Black acquittal that still defies belief - while Tony reacts in real time with the psychology underneath it all: confabulation, childhood adaptations, and what actually happens when someone is finally confronted with a lie they can't tap-dance out of. In this episode, you'll discover: Why memory is "adorable and fallible" - and how the legal system's hierarchy of evidence accounts for exactly that How Durst's defense team built reasonable doubt around an admitted dismemberment (and why the missing evidence mattered more than the conceded facts) The difference between psychopathy and sociopathy - nature vs. nurture, charm vs. rage, and why nonviolent sociopaths walk among us What a masterful cross-examination and an eight-hour couples intensive have in common: staying with someone's discomfort until the adaptation collapses Why breakthroughs so often have a "shelf life" - and what it takes for real change to stick Tony Overbay is a licensed marriage and family therapist who has spent decades watching people confabulate, deflect, and defend in real time - just usually not on the witness stand. If you've ever watched someone rewrite reality right in front of you and wondered how they believe their own story, this episode is for you. Please follow Tony on Instagram @virtual.couch on Tiktok @virtualcouch on Facebook https://www.facebook.com/tonyoverbaylmft and on Substack https://thevirtualcouch.substack.com/ You can reach out to Tony through his website tonyoverbay.com or by emailing contact @ tonyoverbay.com

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Hey, everybody. Welcome back to another episode of Murder on the Couch. I am your host, Tony Overbay. I'm a licensed marriage and family therapist and host of the Waking Up to Narcissism and The Virtual Couch podcast. , Today is a first for Murder on the Couch, and, , I have been so excited to get this episode out to you. So for the , long-time listeners of Murder on the Couch, my co-hosting seat belongs to my daughter, Sydney. She built the show with me, and that co-hosting position will stay warm for her, but she's currently taking a break. But in the meantime, I want to share it with you, the listener, as well

as a friend or two who have already let me know that they are interested. So today, we start with a friend. Her name is Kate. She's actually an attorney, not a criminal defense attorney. , I believe, and it probably would've been a great idea to clarify before I recorded the intro, but I'm pretty sure that Kate , is a labor attorney, and, she is one of the, the most relentlessly, intentionally positive people that I know, which makes, makes it all the more delightful that she is also a massive true crime fan, and she is one who has done the deep dive on today's episode. So for today, we get into the legal side even more than I think a lot

of the podcasts do, thanks to the dynamic that Kate brought into the recording, and we certainly hit the therapeutic side as well. The format today, Kate brought the case in, and I, I told her I don't really wanna know much about what she's gonna bring into the episode. But then it turns out I was familiar with the case. I recognized the name, but I didn't remember the details, so that was by design. I told her I really wanted to react to it in real time. So Kate lays out the case. I respond with whatever comes up therapeutically or psychologically and emotionally, and what she brought is, is an amazing one. It's a case with money and power and family dynamics and good attorneys,

and one of the wildest endings in true crime history, which that is the part that I did remember it. It's the Robert Durst case, the one behind HBO's The Jinx, if you are familiar with that. Before we get into the episode, just a quick update on the co-host search because the response has, has really blown me away. , A lot of people have already written in, and they've suggested amazing cases, and I've been so impressed. , Some have pitched cases I've never even heard of, and, and now I have been deep diving on a lot of these different cases, and I think they're gonna be amazing. So thank you for that.

But a couple housekeeping notes as well. If you wrote in and you haven't heard back from me yet, please do me a favor and resend your message. I'm, I'm working through them, and I don't want any of them slipping through the cracks. And then second, if you have been listening to this even for a second thought, "That might actually be fun," and then immediately talked yourself out of it, I call that the yeah-buts, I would love to gently push back on that because growth comes from the discomfort. So lean in and at the very least, put together an email and send it to me at contact@tonyoverbay.com. Let me know that you're interested. You can even tell me that I'm just kicking around the idea and, and tell

me what case that you would wanna cover, or you can even say, "I'm interested, and I'll get back to you , on a case." , It doesn't need to be polished. It doesn't need to be a formal pitch because, I think just sending the email itself is, is a growth step because whether or not we will record together, you will have done the thing, the, the hard thing, and lived, and the world will still spin. And make sure to listen to and subscribe to my other podcast, The Virtual Couch, as well as Waking Up to Narcissism, and please follow me on Instagram at virtual.couch and on TikTok at virtualcouch. So let's get into The Jinx with my friend Kate

My good friend Kate, my good friend Tony, how are you doing? How I am doing? Amazing. Thank you for being a Guinea pig. Okay. For the murder in, on the couch. I appreciate you selecting me as the Guinea pig. I'm so excited. Yeah. And so bye now I will have put out a solo episode where I made this announcement that I want you to be my co-host, meaning whoever's listening, but there's either no one's gonna respond, and then you're gonna end up being my permanent co-host. So just prepare yourself for that, or we're gonna have such a fun time.

I would love to have you come on regularly because when we talk about this stuff and we're not filming, which has been every single time except for now. Yeah. I just, I get such a kick out of it, no pressure, but I'm so excited about this. I feel like a lot of people are gonna wanna be your cohost Tony, 'cause you're so wonderful and the subject matter is so interesting. It really is. Okay. , Is your dog willing to be named or should I keep him? Yeah. Okay. Trying so hard to get in this podcast, so like, wanna does, I'm gonna talk about the true crime.

Here's Russell. Russell's one of my favorite. He's known to wear some pretty, pretty outlandish outfits. I think his 4th of July is my favorite. Yeah, his 4th of July is pretty good. And he also has a pretty good golf outfit. Okay. Yeah. But he's excited. He's, he, I've subjected him to so much true crime. It's crazy. So he's an expert. Okay. So what I'm excited about is I went out on a limb here and so I asked Kate and Kate's all on board and I told Kate that I love reacting to things, I went all

in on the, I don't wanna know anything. And and Kate knows everything. And then hopefully as she presents the case that she's gonna present today, then I will have hilarious and also in-depth psychological thoughts and therapy reactions. Yeah. Are we ready for that? Yeah, we are for sure ready for that. , So I looked into this case, Tony so I should give you a bit of background about the case, but I should also tell you that there is currently active litigation surrounding Oh, this case. Yeah. So we actually, we gotta be careful, we gotta present admonitions that so speak.

So one, we're not acting within our professional capacities in any way, shape, or form. We're not diagnosing no. Providing legal advice. No. This is all purely entertainment. Yeah, for sure. And everything we say to the best of our knowledge is predicated on open facts that are known to the public. We don't have any underlying info that nobody, that we did our own research and our asserting facts based on that. And then it's all our opinion, so we should say that too. Yeah. I'm so grateful that my first guest is , an attorney. Thank you, Kate, for the civil attorney, which is what their lawsuit is.

I have no criminal law background. Okay. Okay. Yeah. So on that note, , I am curious when you decided you wanted be an attorney, did you know what you wanted to do with that? Oh gosh. I just knew I wanted financial security. Okay. So I didn't know, didn't really care where that took me. Yeah. And I, but I did have a strong calling to , sense of justice, a strong calling to the law. Mm-hmm. But nothing like altruistic in the sense that, oh my gosh, I'm really interested in, pro bono work or that's all come subsequent to becoming an attorney.

Fascinating. But yeah. Yeah. So, no, I wish I was one of those people who, like the prosecutors in this case. Had a strong calling to do the good work and, prosecute claims on behalf of the people. But not, that was not my calling, so. Okay. I'm excited to talk to you about it, but yeah so there's an active case for, so we should go back to the beginning where I was listening to Murder on the Couch and I was talking to you about it. And then we started talking about what could we do if we were co-hosting and I. Thank you. Gotta go to the Jinx, which is the HBO special on Robert Durst.

Yes. Have you, have you seen the Jinx? Here's the fun part, Kate, and I am I feel safe with you. Okay. Yeah. I'm gonna pretend that no one will ever listen to this. I, this is one of those things that I've had to really come to grips with of I love watching and consuming all kinds of content. And I realize, and I'm not even gonna pull the, my memory is so bad card, but I, I watched it and at the time I thought it was amazing. Yeah. But I don't remember a whole lot about it, which is a normal thing for me, which I also, good was kind of a normal thing for humans, but I can't tell you how many people I work with that will think that they must remember

everything or else there, already experiencing symptoms of dementia Yeah. You know, and that, and I think that's why I make so much fun of memory and the mechanisms of memory and memory's adorable and it's fallible. Which, okay. Quick attorney question for you. Yeah, for sure. Because you guys in, in the world of law memory . Is important and significant. Super crucial. Yeah. , , it's like one of my superpowers. But you can, there are so many memory tricks that you'll just learn as you go and you'll recognize if you are good at writing , or you writing down that,

functions as a long-term memory mm-hmm. Gain like that you'll just over index on writing everything down. Or if you're somebody who like me, I have a pretty strong memory, but I just am really organized with my notes. That's my little bit of a superpower. I just take a ton of notes ,, so where I go with that . 'cause I love what you're saying because you're right. I could probably do a better job and not that it's saying that I don't want to remember more, that would sound funny, but I think where I go with it is that testimony is built off of memory. And then if somebody has a different recollection of something years

later, then that's a bad thing, ? Mm-hmm. Is that true? Mm. And there's a hierarchy of evidence and nothing I'm representing is indica of what I, as an attorney, in my practice areas would say. But just generally, contemporaneous records are really key. That's the hierarchy. It like highest status of evidence in it that you'd encounter in your practice. So if you had some type of diary entry, for instance Gotcha. From the time of, in this case, a murder. Yeah, that would be perfect. One of the other things is best practice if you had an email to yourself and you could show the case like, oh, the metadata.

That's what they were thinking at that time. That's perfect. , People are aware that , if you're in front of a jury or if you're in front of a court, that memory is fallible and that you can't actually trust it as much. I'm sure you've seen witness statements for identifying people. Like going and doing a lineup. Those are really not always the most accurate evidence. You'll be able to present just because this witness thought this was this person doesn't mean it was that person. Yeah. Okay. That, I love that. The hierarchy , now the jinx. So that was a long, I'll try not to answer every single thing that way.

No, for sure. But The only thing I remember about it, and maybe I hang on to this, for those who don't know it, is the way that this person got caught, which was. Fascinating to me, if I remember this correctly. Yeah. . Okay. Where do we go today? That's why it's the best. Okay. So I'll refresh your recollection on the Jinx. So the Jinx is the six part HBO series. And it's not surprising you don't remember it because it came out over 10 years ago. Okay. So it's been a while and it was, a follow up from this director, Andrew Jarecki. Mm-hmm. And he had made a fictionalized movie, about the disappearance

of this gentleman, Robert Dursts wife, and their relationship. And he was making the documentary to try and showcase here's the husband's take on what happened and get to know him. And in the course of, oh, interviewing Robert Durst, the documentary transitions into a true crime series there I uncovering information that. Prosecutors didn't have, the detectives didn't have their crossing narratives over.

They're interviewing witnesses and then it becomes an active part of the criminal investigation against Robert Durst. So we'll have spoilers going on, but that's what ends up happening. It, that's why it's the best true crime because it's just you're in real time seeing the detective work and you feel like you're a part of it. And then at the end they have that big reveal. Okay, , I did not know that. So the guy doing the documentary was really genuinely trying to just get Robert Dursts side about his wife who was missing because he did a fictionalized movie of her.

Going missing. I, yeah, it was called All Good Things in, so Ryan Gosling and I think it's Kristen Dun. I haven't actually seen that 'cause I'm way more interested. The, this is one of those things where the facts are stranger than fiction. , I don't even wanna see the movie. I'm sure it's great and I've heard got really good reviews. But , the docuseries is so good and as I've been going deep diving the case itself, the case is unreal and the docuseries doesn't even obviously the big reveal is a big reveal, but the docuseries going deeper and deeper,

, it doesn't even touch on everything that's so wild about this case. It's the perfect confluence of a man who has all the resources in the world. He's from a incredibly prestigious real estate family in New York, so they're worth . Probably over a billion dollars at this point, but hundreds of millions at least. He's aired this huge estate and then it has the best lawyers that money can buy. Really? And then, yeah, for sure. And then it has, in my opinion, and then it has the best ultimately,

some of the best prosecutors that you could ever want on the other side of the V. Like prosecuting a case for the people and it's got mob ties. Oh, it's got, yeah. It's so good. It's so crazy. When you asked me like what true crime I'd wanna do, it's gotta be all day. If you haven't done the Jinx, you gotta do the jinx. Okay. Okay. So should I tell you about Yes. So the backstory on the Jinx, so the origination story is okay, Robert Durst, he's a suspect in his wife's disappearance in the early eighties. In 1982, his wife, Kathy goes missing.

Then fast forward to present day, Robert Durst is implicated in the. Alleged murder of his neighbor, Morris Black in Galveston, Texas. I remember this and this is really not good at all. Okay, Kate? The memory's coming back. Okay. Yeah. Tell me more. Okay so that's where the rubber meets the road in the docuseries. So Morris Black has been murdered and Robert Durst becomes a suspect right away, like really early. Because what happens is the detectives who are working up the case in Galveston

come to realize that Morris Black is this deceased man who's been dismembered and found in this Galveston Bay. And they find amongst his body parts, which is pretty disturbing to think about they find a newspaper that has his address on it. So they go to his address and they find out that Morris Black is neighbors with this deaf mute woman Uhhuh. But it makes no sense that , that he lives next to this deaf mute woman because the deaf mute woman is never there. She's incredibly wealthy.

And she's not classically attractive. So it becomes pretty apparent that it's a man dressed up as a woman, , oh, right away. Yeah. And they go into the woman's house and they find no evidence that a woman even lives there. And then they find all these drop claws, on the floor of the kitchen where this woman, Dorothy Snyder, which is an alias for Robert Durst lives, they pull up the drop cloth, , they find out that there's cuts on the floor, and then they pull up the linoleum and they find out that there's blood. And when they DNA test that it's Morris Black's blood.

So they're finding out that Morris Black was dismembered in Dorothy Snyder's house, and not only is it not Dorothy Snyder, but it's a alias for Robert Durst. So they go and they find out like, oh my God, where, what, what's happening? Who's this Robert Durst gentleman? And they go through his trash and they find an eyeglasses receipt. Tony, I hope this is jogging your memory. Oh yeah. They find an, yeah, they find this eyeglasses receipt and the detective is so just text charming. And he goes this man is supposed Robert Durst is supposed to

pick up these eyeglasses. There's no way if he's just dismembered a person that he's actually gonna go through and pick up some prescription glasses. And he, he says, Vegas wouldn't touch these odds, but I'm gonna go to the eyeglasses shop and I'll tell them that I'm waiting for I, if Robert Durst comes by and picks up these glasses I'd like to them to contact me. And then he does it. Robert Durst does it. He's just literally dismembered a body. Wow. He, this is admitted he dismembers a body, but he still goes to pick up

his prescription glasses , within a couple days of this dismemberment. And so the eyeglass place actually ends up calling the detective. I think his co name's Cody. Let me pick up Russell. 'cause he really wants to be a part of this exciting moment. But but so the detective Cody goes to the eyeglasses shop. They end up finding Robert Durst. As he's leaving, he's pulling outta the parking lot. They flip on the lights, pull him over, and in the back of his car, he has a bow saw. Oh, why? Yeah. He's got this bow saw. They arrest him on suspicion of murder.

They take him and they process him. They hold him. And is this on Kate? Is there body cam footage or do you see this part at all? I don't think so. 'cause this is, at the time of Morris Black murder is, this murder happened , 2002 or 2003 I think so I don't think they had body, at least it, I haven't seen anything. I would love to see body cam footage, but I haven't seen anything. , So he gets arrested, he's held on bail, his bail set at a quarter of a million dollars. And he says, he, they say, okay, well what, he goes, well, what

should I do to de to Detective Cody? And he goes, I don't know. Do you have. Two $50,000. And Robert just kindly goes, well, not on me. And then that's where the show starts taking off because the detective's like, who has a response like that? , So he calls to New York, he calls his wife Deborah, who's currently the one involved, I think it's this state that's involved in the wrongful death lawsuit, but we'll get to that. But And then Deborah, so the, his first wife is the one that she's already been missing. And did they ever figure that out yet?

It's There's a big question mark, ? The civil case is pending for wrongful death, Uhhuh, but there's a big question mark. I don't that trials are, it's not set. They just had some motion work yesterday. I didn't click on it. Really? Mm-hmm. Yeah. It's active litigation happening right now. Wow. And I'm so excited for the, I hope they make a third juice. But anyway so they arrest Robert Durst, he gets out on bail. He calls his then wife Deborah, not the one who disappeared, his subsequent wife. and he gets out and he leaves Galveston , he just starts going about his business.

He's just living his life, even though he's gonna be arraigned for murder. Would normally ca and I don't know if this is like a, you as an attorney will know, or is it just, would it normally be the case that somebody bails out of, murder and they wouldn't be able to travel or. Yeah, usually you're held, you're supposed to stay, at least within the states, don't, I think they tell you you can't leave. Yeah. Sometimes they, I think they will tell you you can't leave the county, but in Robert Dursts case, he is not necessarily man who observes court, right.

Orders, yes. Right. And so , what ends up happening is he's set out on bail for 250 K and he skipped his arraignment. He skipped out on his bail. Oh, so normally you put up poster bail money and if you show up, you're fine. You get that money back, but it's or at least you get that minus a fee. But, but yeah, he ends up skipping out and going on the run. Wow. And , , that's where the documentary really kicks off is they're like really The prosecutors in New York were really wanting to see what would

happen with the Morse Black case because they had, they were unable to prosecute his wife's disappearance. 'cause they never found a body. They don't actually, she's just a missing person still at that point. Wow. So, so yeah, so they're trying to get eyes on him and he just full on bails, he just doesn't show up. And , there's a warrant out for his arrest 'cause he is missed a court date. And, , and so anyway, he gets arrested. They find him, I can't remember if they find him in Pennsylvania. I should have looked this up before, , or Louisiana for this one. But they end up finding him because he stole.

A sandwich out of a Wegmans, I think it's Pennsylvania. Yeah. And so they he got arrested by like a mall cop basically. And then they, . He's just, it, the thought process, the disconnects Tony, that this man is I don't know if he just thinks he can act with impunity because he's super wealthy or because this is where you come in. Yep. 'cause he might have underlying mental condition. I have no idea. I'm sure it's, it's right. It's funny because then you want to go, okay, we got a narcissistic personality sort play then. But they also are, is maybe potentially he's on the spectrum as well and

he's just unaware of what decorum and social cues or I, but I wouldn't think that, but stealing a sandwich when you can pay two 50 grand to bail out. I don't know how to make that link. Not only did he have 250, I mean he's multiple, multiple millionaire, beyond that. But he had on his person, 'cause he is on the rent at this point. He can't be using his debit card. Right. Yeah. But he had on his person like over $500 in cash and in the car, the rental vehicle he had, 'cause they arrest him obviously. So they indexed everything that he had.

He had like $33,000 in cash just in his trunk. Oh gosh. Along, along with some firearms and some, some other paraphernalia. , So he had the means to pay for this, they call it a hogie in the docuseries. I know, I know the hogie from back, , back in my days back east and I guess short of that thing costing about 35 grand then. . It seems like he could have afforded it. And then makes me wonder, does he just want the thrill or is it entitlement? I shouldn't have to pay for a sandwich, but I don't want one. Okay. I will reserve my man, I some serious thoughts on it, but I,

okay. Well, anything right now, you already know the, do we need to kinda let this thing unfold? We gotta let it unfold because that's fair. We gotta get it in the hour. So anyway, so the docuseries it kicks off when he, so he's gone at this point. He's being tried for Morris Box murders. They're not gonna let him out on barrel. Now he's held okay. He's, he's held at the jail and and so he's arrested. He doesn't fight his extradition to Texas. He goes back to Texas and they begin the murder like prosecution in Texas for Morris Black. And it turns out, so he gets this gentleman, dick DeGuerin, who's a

really, I do know that you know him. Yeah. Where's, where's he from? That is he, was he like an OJ Simpson attorney or anything? He's been on a few high profile cases. I'm trying to remember what, he's really well known for the Jinx, he's definitely done some high profile work, but he's a really well known attorney in Texas. In the nation and he does a lot of commentary. He used to do a lot of commentary. . He's a little older now, so it's not as active, but he used to do some online commentary and then I think the other guy's name is John Ramsey. , Lesser known, but still an excellent defense attorney. And so he hires both of them because he can't decide which

one he wants to go with. He and his wife can't decide which one's better. So they just hire both and they end up paying like, $1.8 million that they disclose. Wow. In the documentary to. Fund his defense. Wow. But it had to be so much more than that. 'cause as I was looking into it, Dick DeGuerin did two mock juries. I, so like he was prepared out the wazoo for this case. And it shows they, I feel bad for the Texas prosecutors. I don't, I don't know the ins and outs of what happened, but the Texas

prosecutors were up against probably some of the best lawyers money could buy. And then they came up with an amazing way of presenting reasonable doubt on behalf of Robert Dur. Even though he had dismembered this guy they presented a reasonable doubt for his murder, the murder force Black. How did they do that? . . So what ends up happening is they never find the head in Galveston, bay of Morris Black.

The detectives find the entire body, but for the head. And you know what's crazy, Tony, as I was looking into this Uhhuh, so Robert Durst dismembered Morris Black. That's not in dispute. That's a fact. That's conceded. He admitted to dismembering him. That's okay. So that's admitted in court. That is yeah, not okay. He, it's part of his defense. It's like he just kind of freaked out and Oh, it was like, what do I do because I'm a suspect and my wife's disappearance and a purported mur murder. I don't wanna go to the cops with the fact that.

Morris Black is now dead in my kitchen, so I just dismember him and throw him in Galveston Bay. It's insane. , So here's something crazy. So when I was looking into this, he dismembers the body and he puts him, it's so callous, but he puts him in trash bags, so it's like there's a leg in a trash bag because he can't take him all out at once. 'cause it's at this juncture. Morris Black was in his seventies. Robert Durst was in his fifties, I think his like late fifties. Mm. So he was still spry, but not super strong guy. It wasn't like aging like Arnold Schwarzenegger kind of guy.

Yeah. Like he was aging like a regular gentleman of, , gentleman of leisure. And so, and he, yeah. So he was unable to move Morris Flack. And he had said this, he said, I thought about rolling him up in a sleeping bag or or some type of way to transport him. But he is like, I couldn't do it. I physically couldn't do it, and that's why I had to dismember him. Ugh. Wow. So he puts 'em into trash bags. And the trash bags that they recovered, a lot of them had slices in them. So I think the suspicion is, and this is again my opinion, I don't

know the, and I didn't come up with this, I'm not that smart, but he. Was looking for the head after he realized that the trash bags weren't sinking in the bay, ? You just throw somebody's body in the bay and it doesn't necessarily float to the bottom. So he was looking the thing, he was looking in the trash bags to see which one contained the head. Wow. Pulled out the head and threw it, dispose of it somewhere else. Some they could never find the crime. And anyway, cl the clever lawyers, I don't know, they will assert that this was done, that this is the right story, ? Their defense is that

Robert Durst went into his apartment, Morris Black was in the apartment, that they were friendly neighbors. Morris Black was able to come and go as he placed. I think he even had a key is the story. And that Robert Durst saw Morris with his gun in his kitchen. And that there was an altercation of a shuffle and that the gun went off and, inadvertently shot Morris in the face.

Okay. And and then , that's how the murder a or not murder, but that's how the death actually happened, so that he's being prosecuted for murder. But his position is, look, it's actually self-defense. Wow. And then, what Dick DeGuerin and Ramsey say is, look, you can't not prove that that's the story because you never located the head. Oh gosh. And so then, yeah, and so then we're not on this jury. But anyway, the jury totally believed that story.

And Dick DeGuerin on cross of the Detective Cody, who was just that charming Texan that I told you at the outset, said Vegas wouldn't take these odds. Yeah. They, he asked him point blank, he said, , did you find any evidence to contradict the self-defense the, this story, the self-defense story? And he goes, no, sir. And he said, you understand that it's the obligation of the prosecution to prove beyond a reasonable doubt that this was a murder and not self-defense. And he said, yes, sir. And so that was really persuasive, I think to the jury.

I think I adverse that. But it's really like, that's ultimately what happened because they couldn't find the head. And that was such a persuasive narrative to the jury. They acquitted him of murder. So he gets charged with dismembering a body or something like that. I think he even pled to that, pled to skipping bail. Okay, so, so no time, sir. Caught up mentally then. So he I'm having a hard time even wrapping my head around that. So he got acquitted of murder. Yeah. But then, but he admitted that he dismembered the body dis and then mm-hmm. And it's funny, not funny.

Wild to think that, so that. So that, is a separate crime. 'cause you can dismember a body even if you didn't murder it. Apparently. That is a Yeah. A law on the books. So that just in case somebody's out doing some dismembering, then, um, yeah. Okay. Yeah, for sure. You could yeah, definitely get in trouble for like, disposing a body. Definitely get in trouble. , Okay, there are different laws on point for that, but the cra it was just so crazy. It's, they had charged him with murder and they couldn't prove beyond a reasonable doubt that he murdered him and

Wow. Yeah. So anyway, so that's what happened and , and so that's where. Andrew Jarre, and then , the docuseries of J takes off. They're talking to him, they're like, what happened? How did this, what, what's going on? And Robert Durst is just talking to them about it. He's talking to 'em about the disappearance of his wife, Kathy, about this Morrise black thing and and all of the kind of weirdness surrounding that. Mm-hmm. And then it comes out that he had actually had a very good friend named

Susan Berman who lived in Los Angeles, who was also murdered or killed under very unusual circumstances. And when, when did that happen? How long ago was that? That happened? The craziest thing, Tony, is that happens like a year before Morris Black's murder. And how long is that After his first wife had disappeared? Almost 20 years. Oh, wow. Okay. Yeah. There's a whole gap in the chronology of what happened between Kathy Dursts disappearance, his first wife, Uhhuh, then the second weird

coincidental death of Susan Berman, and then the death of Morris Black. Wow. There's a lot of unaccounted for time there. And for a part of it, when I was researching this, Robert Durst is just living a normal-ish life of an heir in New York. , After Kathy's disappearance, he's kind of described as being disassociated and pretty , unaffected by her disappearance. In fact, Robert Durst doesn't report her missing for five days. Wow. Mm-hmm.

Okay. Yeah. And then and then with. He continues going to his real estate, the Durst organization's workplace in New York doing his own thing there. But he's just so strange. It's so strange. Tony. Like some of the stuff he does, it's just bizarre conduct. Apparently he stopped showing up to work at his at the Durst organization, but apparently there's a story like of him getting really upset with his brother and just like urinating in his brother's trash can at work, in the office.

Oh wow. That's, yeah, he's just doing odd stuff. And then and then he just falls off the radar. He, he's in New York living a normal life. He meets his second wife, Deborah Sheridan, and and then just they get married right before the Morris Black stuff, or Right. Actually before the Susan Berman. Disappear. The Susan Berman death. Yeah. Killing. And then and then he just kind of starts going off the rails. He just, there's the Susan Berman murder, then he moves to Galveston. He is in Galveston. The Morrise black murder gets acquitted.

And then he's just doing very odd things. He does this Andrew Jari documentary, but he also , goes in front of his brother's house and is kind of stalking, allegedly his brother. Hmm. So it's weird. He's just got, in my opinion, it's beyond a personality disorder. It's a very, he's a very strange individual in my opinion. And Okay. And I just yeah. So I just interviewed on my virtual couch podcast. I just interviewed my dentist 'cause I wanted to talk about mental health. Yeah. And, and regular careers. And, but part of it was, I just wanted this one.

Concept down where I would say that, if somebody is pretending that they, or they say, oh, I floss my teeth all the time, their dentist knows they aren't flossing their teeth. Yeah. And I, I like that example because when or, you know, you're gonna know if you're what if you're doing, if you're questioning somebody and you know these inconsistencies 'cause of the job you do. Yeah. I was just thinking about that, where all these things show up as patterns over time. And then people that are in certain fields, they recognize patterns more of like this pattern recognition. 'cause I will see somebody that is showing up a certain way, and again, I'm not

trying to say that there's a normal or there's a right way to do it, but there's this concept called impression management, which is when people try to control how others perceive them by presenting what they think is the right image. And I, we kind of all do that to some degree, but for sure. But it's, it's almost cramming for a test and you can get the answers right. Mm-hmm. But then you forget the data, or and so it doesn't, it doesn't. It's not consistent. And so what's mm-hmm. Wild is that he is, he has so many wild different things. There's no pattern at all.

So I haven't, yeah. I'm fixated on this pattern, recognition concept. But yeah, you normally, the guy isn't dismembering somebody and then also not caring about the, this friend who goes missing and go urinate Yep. In your brother's trash can and also stealing. Although now for putting all that together, that's, yeah. There's a lot of craziness there. Maybe that is the pattern. Yeah. I think, yeah, for sure. I think the pattern that I was picking up on a lot is he's consistent in his inconsistencies, ? Yeah. Like he's just, he is really, he's really a bold face.

He will lie. He will lie. Mm. At no point in the story was he contradicting the fact that if he were put in a position where it could hurt him, he was comfortable lying. And in fact, he admits that on the stand in the subsequent trial. Mm. So, so fast. So fast forward. So the Jinx is happening. They've done the Morris Black thing. He, they've, he's been acquitted. He's meeting with Andrew Jarecki. They're talking about his wife Kathy's disappearance. They're talking about his friend Susan Berman.

And what happens at the end of the Jinx is that there's a revelation on what happened with Susan Berman. So with Susan Berman, she was murdered in her home in Beverly Hills. 9 0 2 1 oh, real fancy zip code. Yeah. She gets murdered mobbed. So she was the daughter of a mob, a well-known mobster in la or not in LA in Vegas. And and so how she died was like a gun to the shot to the back of the head, which apparently, I don't, I didn't know that, but I guess i's a mob killing style.

So Robert Durst is not suspected in that murder at the outset, I don't think. But I, he could have been a suspect. He was friends with her, but there's no reason to think he was going to be in Los Angeles. There were no records of him being in Los Angeles. Funnily enough, he actually flew into San Francisco that it was, she was murdered around Christmas time. But, no records of him being in LA at the time. And so anyway, she's smarter, execution style. It could have been a mob hit. And not a lot of there, there. What ends up happening in the course of the Jinx is that.

Robert had written to Susan, letters o over the years. And and so they, they had been communicating just via the mail. And after Susan Berman was murdered, there was a letter posted to the Beverly Hills Police Department anonymously. And it just is written in block letters and it says, police Beverly Hills police. And then the letter inside says Susan Berman's address. And then it says cadaver. Oh, written.

And then that's what the Beverly Hills that's one of the, her neighbors called in for wellness check. But that's they knew there was a cadaver. They, they had a letter that only the killer could have written, arguably. And it's hand and handwritten and it's handwritten. Boy. Okay. And so what happens at the end of the jinx is because they had been going through all the documents. They found that the way Robert Durst wrote Susan's letters mirrored the letter of the cadaver note, the letters used in the cadaver note, it's block letters.

It's so, it's so consistent. It's crazy the way Andrew Jarecki post it at the end too. Tony, is he posts it to Robert Durst in a sense so I'm gonna ask you, did you write this letter to the police or did you write this letter to Susan Berman? He's like, I wrote the letter to Susan Berman. I did not write the letter to the police. And then he has a piece of paper where he. Zoomed in on just the way Beverly is spelled. It's misspelled too in both of the letters. Like he misspelled it. . And he goes, can you tell me which one of these you wrote and which one you didn't?

And Robert Durst says, no. 'cause he can't tell the difference in the writing. 'cause it's so similar. It's so eerily similar. , And so that's the last clip of the last episode of the Jinx Uhhuh. But then he has a microphone on him, Tony. Okay. I was about say, wait, am I crazy about that? Okay. This part. Go as slow as you want on this cake. 'cause this is phenomenal. Oh, thanks. So I didn't realize that that was right after he did the handwriting. That makes so much sense now. Okay. Or Yes. . . So he goes into the bathroom wearing a hot mic, like they have not taken off any of his recording. And he says, well there it is.

You're caught. . And he goes, he's like burping. It's so strange. And he's Ugh, but you can't imagine. And then he's whispering him to himself and he goes, I want this. And then he says, and he makes like a groaning noise. And he goes, killed them all, of course. And then Andrew Jarecki slowly turns off the lights in the room in such a Hollywood production, like close to the whole series. It's so crazy. So at the end, so they said, there it is, you're caught. And then what'd you do?

Kill them all. Of course. So that's How weird is that Uhhuh? I thought that was so bizarre because like I talk to myself. Yeah. But I don't talk to myself like I'm. I talk to myself sometimes, like I'm dialoguing, but not like I'm dialoguing with other persons. Right. Like, that was so strange to me. It really was , yeah. Giving me dissociative identity disorder. Yes. Multiple personalities. Yeah. Whatever you wanna refer to it as. Man. So weird. And then as I was digging into this, Robert Durst was, so his mom killed

herself when he was a young man. Like he was only seven Oh. When his mom died. And he began , I don't know when he started acting out, but he began acting out against his dad and his brother. His family members, very young, not long after as long was, you know, she killed herself. And and they. I had seen several psychiatrists and one said that he was , experiencing personality decomposition, Tony, which I don't know what that is. . . It was so strange. And then it said could be schizophrenia.

Tell me about it. I have no idea. I was like, what is that? So, oh, I was, that could be what he's doing. He's dialoguing with himself. Or it could be schizophrenia or it could just be he's a he is somebody who has some mental health disorder and I don't, or he could just be talking to himself. Who knows. Well, it's, it's fascinating because, okay, so decompensation, and psychology in general is the breakdown of defense mechanisms. So then you can't manage stress. Then it leads to a worsening of psychiatric symptoms and then a decline in daily functioning.

But then it, it's when all of their coping strategies, their defense mechanisms fail, and then they it causes an acute crisis. So there could be, I mean, I could see then in that scenario, he got, caught at a level where he couldn't get out of. Yeah. So I could see that being this decompensation. And then he just had a break. At that point, because it is wild that he is talking out loud, and I don't know if he does that all the time or, but it's, I think he does. Yeah, he must. Yeah, he must. I think he does. Yeah.

'cause he, it was weird 'cause there was another instance of a hot mic earlier in the show and his lawyer actually goes up and says, Hey, you're talking to yourself. And he's like, oh, I was just practicing on how to say it. But yeah, with the hot mic in the bathroom, he just essentially admits it to, he goes, what did you do? Kill them all. Of course. And so it's Wow, just so crazy. Yeah. And he ends up going to trial because of that cadaver note to the Beverly Hills police and the similar handwriting and the, that's new evidence.

So that leads to him, that coupled with that recording leads to him being prosecuted in Los Angeles County for the murder of Susan Berman. And that's what the Jinx season two is about. Okay. And it's fantastic. I didn't know if I was gonna end up doing this or not, but now I couldn't help myself. And so I did do a little Googling about, , do it. The key details about his mental state, we got the childhood trauma that you just mentioned. Yeah. And personality, . Decomposition and possibly even schizophrenia, behavioral issues. Mm-hmm. His brother described him as a true psychopath.

Mm-hmm. And he got alleged sociopathy, former girlfriend was advised by a professor to end her relationship with him in the sixties because he was identified as a sociopath. That's wild. Yeah. Did you know that one? No, I didn't know that. That's new information to me. But, . It tracks. And then the one that I feel a little bit, because when I was saying this earlier, I thought, oh man, look at me, judge. Mcj, Jerson. But then they, his team also his legal team said he potentially had Asperger's, so Yeah. Which was, now it falls in the autism spectrum. Yeah. So that is fascinating. I was so impressed with you coming out with that at the very beginning, because

that was in the second, so that's, that comes out in the murder of Susan Berman. , That actual case. Okay. They say, look, he has, he got diagnosed with Asperger's. He's autistic and that's why he has trouble with, interpersonal relationships. And it's just okay. But he's now implicated in two murders that we're tracking to and the disappearance of his first wife. And there are also a number of missing persons that they think he is a person of suspicion in that's not really talked about,

in the docuseries. But in the second one it is. , , Can I own my Googling now? And then just throw random things out. Please do. , I was just, I followed a link while I was just looking at this and I do want to know your take on this. , This first thing I pulled up is saying , that the jinx has ignited a debate over journalistic ethics, whether interviewers should remind a source that he or is being recorded even in the bathroom. Mm-hmm. How soon to bring evidence to the police. Mm-hmm. Even if it could spoil the Danis of your true crime narrative. So I'm curious, do you have hot takes on that, that one about should I remind

somebody that they're being recorded? It seems like that one would be such a hindsight principle, but mm-hmm. But I dunno, do you have any thoughts on that ? No, to be honest, for me, he knew he was being recorded. He consented to being recorded at the outset and Yeah. Like should they have told him to take off his mic? But it's just, it's just you're living your life. Yes. If you've consented at the beginning, like, I consented to this recording here, I, I don't need to be refreshed that I'm recording. Yeah. Maybe if I get up and leave and I come back hours later and I'm still

being recorded, maybe there's like a. Presumption when I leave that, that's the end of that recording consent. But, at that juncture, I don't think you really had an obligation to, 'cause it's just, again, it's just normal life. Normal life's messy. Yeah. You, you, in hindsight, could you always be giving people notices and admonitions? For sure. But , how practical is that? I don't know. Yeah, I like that. Not really that. And then how do you know much about that when this question is saying how soon to bring evidence to the police? Because what, yeah. Do you know what that timeframe was after they did that?

Yeah. , They actually went to Marsha Cross, who was the prosecutor for the OJ Simpson case as counsel to talk about Hey, what should we do? When they discovered the Beverly letter with the, to the police and then the one written by Robert Durst and they, she said, you could go to the police. She was, she was great. The interviews with her were great. But, but she, she talked about the fact, Marcia, can I Marcia Yeah, go ahead. You, you had mentioned Marsha cross, Marsha Clark. Right. I just wanna like get Oh, Clark. Clark. Oh, thank you. And you No, it's, and the only reason I say that is I know that maybe somebody

will end brighten in, but did you know that she writes legal thrillers? Have you ever read any of this? Oh yeah. I really enjoy them. That's so cool. Isn't that , she's written She a bunch. . Which is really funny. She seems great. , , I thought she was great. But she, she said look, you're not an agent of the police. You're just interviewing him. You're actually, she gave them really sound advice. Again, it's that practical advice versus the legal advice. She gave them advice that said essentially you can continue with your wow. Your own documentary and you're not an agent of the prosecution.

And ideally would they have gone and just handed that over. Yeah, for sure. But but they were balancing it with, , making the movie and they were balancing it with the fact that they actually aren't agents of the police and everything that you, you don't have to Mirandize Robert Durst if you're not acting as an agent for the cops, right? You don't have those evidentiary obligations that we expect from our government. You're just a person talking to another person. And so, so I don't know, integrity wise, if it was me, I would've taken it to the police, but I don't Yeah.

But but I don't think that what they did was wrong. And actually in the interest of justice, probably what they did was right in a way, because I, they probably, you probably would not have had him. Actually admit to what he admitted to. Yeah. And then that hot mic would've never occurred, which, what a trip. Yeah. So, and Dunno. I was, I'm with you Kate. I think, and maybe I'm just doing the projection thing, but I would assume that I would take it to the police. But then what I love throwing in I know that I try to get you on board with my love of acceptance and commitment therapy at all costs.

Yeah. But I've never been a filmmaker filming an HBO series, having that fish that you're reeling in and then all of a sudden, I can't imagine what that must have felt like when they got that. And do you know, did they, is that something they took months? They learned. Oh, did it? Okay. It took months for them to get him to come back for another interview. , So they had wrapped, they spent six days with him, following him around, interviewing him. And and then they, the son, he's not the biological son, but the son of Susan Berman finds the letter and he calls them and is like, what, I'm not,

I can't believe I found this, but his match perfectly to the cadaver note. And then they try and get Robert on that second interview and he just dips, dives and dodges them for weeks on end. Wow. Finally they get him and then they do this cadaver note comparator and that's when the hot mic happens, and that's when he admits to running one versus the other. I don't exactly remember the timing on when they take the cadaver note to the cops. Or to the prosecutor. But I think it's after that. And yeah, I mean , it's debated, but I don't know.

I just think. Everybody's, you can debate it, but it, it worked out in the end. 'cause they ultimately, they got 'em. But , yeah, I'm a goodie two shoes. I think you probably are too. Like, I would've taken that to, I'd be like, here you go. I can't, I didn't touch this. I would've put on gloves. Like, I would've like, oh no. . , Do you know how long , it took from that to then produce the documentary? Were they sitting on that for years? From the time they found the cadaver note to the time they released the Jinx, I think was, , not that long because the Jink, so the Jinx comes out in 2015.

And I think, they had talked to him for the whole time. I don't think it was that long. , But I do think it was some months. But I don't know. I guess, I don't know. I should just say that we should Google it. Yeah. But I don't know it. Yeah. Isn't that fun? It's so fun. It's, it's so fascinating. And Kate, , I'm digging this, by the way. Thank you. First ever guest host. 'cause now we're, this is fun. This is flowing. 'cause now I think I'm learning on the job of Yeah, I think we can Google things if we want and we can Yeah, we can. Things this is any flow, right? Yeah. Okay. So where do you go? Where do you go next? I'm on, I'm all in. So you've gotta go to the prosecution of, for of Robert Durst.

For Susan Berman's murder. That's the drinks second season. Okay. So what happens is the Jinx production team hands over that cadaver note, and that's number one. , They hand that over I think around the time they're releasing the Jinx. , The prosecution in LA and the FBI are tracking that Robert Durst is out there and he's in Louisiana , I think he might be in New York at the beginning or maybe in Hu Houston. He's in Houston and he's watching the Jinx season one.

Like you and I are watching The Jinx season one. Oh. Like, his council knows that he's been met with the cadaver letter, but I think that happens not that far ahead of the actual release of the series. Wow. And they're trying as hard as they can, his defense counsel is trying to get the records from. And the team at HBO. And he is like, no, there's no subpoena. There's no active litiga. He's not, they're not suing a, i, at least to my knowledge, they weren't suing hbo.

Like they, they aren't able to just get the film. So they don't know what's gonna happen and they watch it. The team, Robert Durst, everybody watches it as it's coming out, just like you and I. So episode one, Robert Durst is feeling good. Episode one is all about his wife Kathie's disappearance. And then episode two is all about his mom's, suicide and how that impacted him as a kid. And that, the personality deposition. Yeah. Decomposition. Yeah. Yeah. And the schizophrenia diagnosis or potential diagnosis as a kid.

And then episode three comes out and he's starting to feel a little I, he, I don't know if this is gonna go my way. Episodes one and two are in Robert DURs favor. You're thinking , oh, wow, this guy, he could be unlucky. He, yeah. He could have just been defending himself, I guess. Yeah. Against a 70-year-old man. And then he just had to dismember him. You know, but then later on it becomes pretty clear that there's some suspicions around Robert Durst and Susan Berman. And then as.

Episode five comes out and episode six comes out. It's just like in or episode five. It's indisputable that they're gonna reveal that cadaver letter. And Robert Durst must've known that. I can only speculate. He's since passed away. Oh, yeah. Robert Durst died, I think in, during COVID. He didn't make it outta the, he didn't, I don't think he died from COVID. I think he died from like some cardiac complication, but yeah, he's, he died. But anyway, he, I mean, he was old. He lived a long life, but older. But anyway so as he's watching this, he goes on the run again and

'cause because he knows, he knows this cadaver note's gonna come out. So the FBI starts, but they're, they've got the cadaver note and they know they've got the hot mic. Yeah. So they know, we're gonna watch and see if he flees. He does, he goes to, he gets caught in Louisiana because he called his voicemail from a phone, a hotel, the J JW Marriott in New Orleans. And he ultimately gets caught there with, I wanna say it's hundreds of thousands of dollars in cash, Tony.

Wow. Again, again, a a lot of, some, you know, non-pharmaceutical drugs. And I think he gets, has a revolver on him again, a gun, but he calls it a revolver, which I love. , And then he, he, he's there with a movie grade prosthetic mask and and a map of Cuba. Oh yeah. So is he gonna jump in a boat and head over there . Yep. Or swim. That's the suspicion. . The prosecutor, John Lewin, who I'm obsessed with now, , who prosecutes the Susan Berman murder trial down in Los Angeles.

He's a cold case prosecutor. That's all he does is murders that are over 10 years old. Wow. He, and he's got a 10 out of 10 conviction rate. He al he's always getting this guy. Yeah. He's so good. Including Rob, Robert Durst. Spoiler. He does get, yeah. But anyway, he's he says, Tony goes. Andrew Directi goes, what do you think about the mask? What is, what's the deal with that? And he goes, I think he was gonna flee the country. It wasn't Halloween. It was such a good line. That's, that is good. Oh I would hope that I would say something clever like that.

That would be me too, right? It was, it was. Can I tell you there, there's a, I found a quote by him. Tell me and I tell, I don't know. Durst said he would never admit to killing Susan Berman even if he had done so. And then there's a quote that I found and it says, mm-hmm. Did you kill Susan Berman is strictly a hypothetical. Durst said, I did not kill Susan Berman, but if I had, I would lie about it. And I remember with OJ Simpson , that he wrote a whole book of if I would've done it. And there's another case going on right now where somebody saying, you know what I would've done though if I would've. And I thought about that concept, so I didn't know that Durst said that as well. And the, is that projection, or , I'm putting out there, I mean, if I would,

I guess this is how I would do it. And they think that that. Is not suspicious. I go back to the pattern recognition and yeah. If, if I didn't do it, I am not gonna talk about it again. You know? Mm-hmm. Yeah. I would want to get so far away from it. I can't imagine somebody being accused of something and it being such a big thing and then saying, you know what, though? Now that you bring it to my attention, I wonder how I would've done it. Had I, it just isn't the thing I mean, or maybe Okay. I don't think so. Yeah, I don't know. I've never been, it's never been alleged that I had , been involved in anything,

so I. So I can't even say Kate, you know, if you were gonna murder somebody, tell me how you would do it, because I haven't really spent a lot of thoughts on it, but if all of a sudden you gave me like this dead stare and then told me about it, then that might be concerning, I guess. Yeah, for sure. It's just a concerning. Yeah, I mean, I'd be concerned. I, it's so weird to think, , I feel like you almost have to. Have that defense of what you said at the beginning where he interprets the world differently from everybody else. Yes. Whether it's from if he suffers from autism because it's so far

removed from how you or I would actually respond to that question. Yeah. And it's , if you, you were asked, well, if you did do it you would lie about it. Right. And you would say, if I did do, I would never do this. Yeah. That would be your answer. You wouldn't say , I wouldn't, you would say, I would never do this, therefore I would never have to lie about it. At least I hope I would like, that would be my response. And okay, Kate, tell me from your lawyer position. Because I, I did just hear a, I don't know the particular case, but I've thought about this.

I still love watching interrogation videos, but the main reason I do is yeah, when people get tripped up because Yeah, I think it's this pattern recognition thing, and there was a case I was watching , and they go very quickly through, let's say the husband had been accused of the wife's murder, and they're saying, you, we've got all this information that says you did it. And he's uh, no, you don't. I didn't. And then, and they're like, yes, you did. And then he's like, Nope, I'm good. And then they bring him back in and they have him in there for hours. And it was basically like he was saying, yeah. I still didn't do it. So I could do this all day.

I would like to think, yeah, I would be that guy. Yeah. , And then they ended up finding the real killer and, but I just thought that concept of pressuring somebody into a confession and I've got a, I've got a client that I really just, I love to death. Who's ? A cop and I was asking him about this 'cause I was saying those interrogation techniques, sometimes seems a little shady to me. And then it was funny 'cause his first thing he said was, but most of the people that you do that to, they're like, I, but I didn't still, and I just didn't. Mm-hmm. So have you, is interrogated the right word? Have you ever done that?

Have you ever questioned somebody? Yeah. And then you know that they're absolutely lying? Or do you know that you can tell right away, oh, this person , they truly didn't do it because have you had that experience? I've never depo. So in civil lawsuits we're just deposing somebody. Deposits. Okay. Yeah. But even then, I, I would say it's hard. Credibility assessments are hard. Okay. and I'm not trying to force you to, or not force, but I'm not, and I don't wanna

say coerce, but I'm not interrogating you to get to the truth of a matter. Yeah. In the sense that a cop is it's just such a different That makes sense. . And so I think if I were deposing somebody, I would just ask 'em the question as many different ways as I could to try and get them to respond in a way that gave me the answers to what I need to prove or disprove this case. With Robert DURs or any criminal defendant, , and they're not even defendants at that juncture. Any suspect I think you just, I think they just have a different call to action, right?

Yeah. Like cops need to know they're there to keep society safe As a civil lawyer, you're just there to try and get the answer to your question. Okay. And I guess maybe the, a question for you is, , if you're deposing someone, is it pretty obvious when they appear to be lying? Yeah, sometimes. But some people are good liars. That's true. Some people are really good liars. And some people have been really well coached and they just are. So it's hard. It's just like you, you really do. That's why those, that hierarchy of evidence is really important. Mm-hmm. Contemporaneous records are super important.

And being able to kind of go back and recall , well, that was an inconsistent statement, or you have a motivation to lie here because you could suffer some civil liability. Yeah. Something like that. Those factors are important and they come into play. If you do have a case that would go before a jury or a finder of fact. That deals with credibility, like he said, she said cases versus just on the papers you can make the motion to win or lose the case, right? Yeah. I don't know. , It's just such a, who convinced who better. Yeah. And yeah some attorneys are really good at that.

They just have a good instinct for whether or not someone's telling the truth. But I don't know. For me, I'm not, I don't think I'm that good. I think I. I think like personally, I really, really rely on what the evidence actually shows. and I also will really, really rely on sit, I just kind of sit with it and I believe people a lot of the time. Yeah. I don't know about you. Yeah. I believe people I have a tendency to. . Yeah. Which maybe that's oh, I guess it just is. Okay, now that I have my friend Kate here and , I want some clips outta this thing.

'cause I've got thoughts, Kate, and I want, I'm curious, I ask you one other line of questioning and then I want to go back to the case. Yeah. So I've been involved lately in more cases where I'm working with somebody that's in the, they're, let's say they're divorcing, and emotionally mature slash narcissistic partner. Yeah. And I've found myself. Working with a client and then I'm almost there for support. So I will, yeah, I will attend some type of hearing and I've been noticing, I wrote something about this and I, I don't know what to do

with it right now, but it seems like. Somebody can be accused of something that isn't true, and then they have to defend themselves about the thing that they didn't do. And yeah, I've watched, I've watched like this one attorney that I was not a big fan of, where he's just saying, is it true that this and the mm-hmm. And the person saying no, and then he is saying, mm-hmm. You're, it's not really, that's not the case. And doing it until the person gets upset. Yeah. And then once they got upset, then he's saying, what this, is this your normal behavior?

Or are and just it seems so mean, but the, it started from this person having to defend a thing that isn't true, which is so wild. . Yeah. I don't know if I asked a question there or not. No. But I totally understand what you're saying. And again the area I practice is so far removed from this. Okay. But it's I, but what I have seen again is like it goes back to my earlier statements where it's just if I were doing that I just believe. I believe what you're saying, I, it, I, it's almost as if I'm a jury member. Yeah. Not a lawyer. Yeah. If you sitting there, Tony can tell that that lawyer on cross examination

of that witness is instigating. It's not like they're, that's it. They're not, yeah. They're not like actually getting, they're just trying to get them worked up. Yep. I, I don't know, sometimes I think that plays well to a jury. Mm-hmm. But sometimes I think, it's just like you and I sitting there and saying like, well, I believe this person. You just, it just varies from case to case. You can really only can tell when you're in, it, it, some people think that's a good strategy to try and trip people up. Personally, I just, I really don't, I really over index on

being respectful and professional. And if you're telling the truth, I, I have to rely on the fact that juries are smart. They'll catch that too. I like that. Or judges. Yeah. Yeah. It's funny you say that because this was a, what do they call, a bench trial? Or you bench trial. Yeah, for sure. It's just before the judge. Yeah. And then to find out later that the judge didn't they absolutely didn't buy that. Yeah, so that was, that did feel like justice. But for the time between it happening and then the ruling, I felt so bad for my client because they just thought they just blew it.

And I'm trying to say no. Anyway. Okay. Back to the case. 'cause this is back to Robert Durst. Yeah. Robert Durst cross examine by John Lewin. So he gets he just, he testifies in his own defense in the Susan Bourbon murder trial. So he, oh wait, gets called. Yeah. Is that, he gets called to the witness stand. Is, is that crazy? It's atypical. Okay. Normally defendants don't testify unless you're, because for the reasons that you just. Articulated in that family court case. Yeah. And what we were talking about with credibility, where we just kinda believe

people, unless you're not believable. Yeah. , So it's a strategy. It's ultimately the defendant's call and Robert Durst. I bet you wanted to be up there. . I don't know. , I, it sure he's got that. He literally got away with, with murder, Alleged murder. Oh yeah. Thank you. Thank you. Yeah. He literally got away with the dismemberment. He did not get found guilty. He was vindicated on Morris Black. He was found not guilty on murdering Morris Black. Okay. For the record, I'm editing out the part that I said, 'cause I now Yes, for sure. Yes. Yeah.

So that's okay. But but yeah, so he gets found not guilty on the Morris Black murder. He's a free man. The only thing that could go awry is if somehow new evidence is found in Kath Dursts disappearance or new evidence is found in. The the murder of his friend Susan Berman, the lady who was killed Mob style. Yeah. So in going and getting interviewed, you're kind of kicking up dust, ? It's settled , he's been a free man Oh. For over 10 years since that case.

He's out. So , why would you do this? You're just opening yourself up to new critiques. Soki testifies in the Morris Black case and in Susan Berman's case, John Lewin crosses him for nine days. Nine. Can you imagine? No. And I think it's check, check me. Fact check me. Yeah. British. But that is a wild. It must. . And it was during COVID, my friend Hayden and I were watching , 'cause it was on court tv and we were just like, this is nuts. And so it's crazy. . So he gets direct examination.

Dick DeGuerin is his counsel again. Wow. . In the Susan Berman case. Nine days. Kate, you are correct. Nice. Oh, thanks. I wanna go watch highlights. I'm sure there are amazing clips. You have got to watch highlights. It's so crazy. 'cause John Lewin again, , it's this a team prosecutor literally only does cold cases. We were talking about your motivations to go into the legal field at the beginning. Yeah. This guy, he went to Hastings over here in San Francisco. Mm-hmm. And he just has a call to justice and he's indisputably one of the best.

Then on the other side of the v indisputably, some of the best defense counsel and they've already got this guy off in a murder case before. I shouldn't say got him off, but not guilty. Yeah. How much of, how much do you think is egos of attorneys even at that point? Competing against each other? I would say both from what I saw as a, just a viewer. Both were incredibly professional. Oh, okay. Like, I do not know that Dick DeGuerin . Was ego flexing at all? . I don't know if they were ego flexing. I really think just weight of the scales.

I didn't feel that there was a lot of even hostility between them. I felt that Dick DeGuerin was not a California practitioner, and that really did him a disservice. I think they should have associated very closely with California counsel. Our California has very particular evidence code. Oh. And I, and not to say again, like I'm not half, I'm not even a thimble full of quality attorney that Dick DeGuerin is, that guy's brilliant. The lawyer, , but yeah, I think that that was something he admitted, like really frustrated him, was just not being as familiar with the California

evidence because it's just peculiar. . Do you know , like an example of what that might look like to the layman or person, lay person? When you object in California, , , you can't have speaking objections aren't, uh, as like common, but you have to object. So you have to object federal law houses too, but you have to object on the grounds that California evidence allows you to. It's just different than federal. So it's you have to say, dude, after you have to say objection. This is character evidence under, oh, California evidence code.

You, I don't even remember if it's 4 0 3. I can't remember. California Criminal code. , So things like that, like character evidence is treated incredibly different in California or , there are common objections like misstates testimony, but I, in that case, I just remember him objecting, maybe hearsay, grounds would be, there's separate exceptions to hearsay. Maybe it was something like that. But he would get overruled. They would object and he get overruled all the time. Or he would object and he would not state any grounds. That would happen consistently. So it was just . Misfires a little bit.

, And that could be a strategy too. It could, it might not be a misfire, it could have been intentional just to break John Lewin's flow. Which happens. Have I ever told you my story of being objected to in a courtroom? No. Okay. I was working with a guy and. And it was family court and his wife, I'm thinking, okay, I'll keep it so generic. And it was years ago, but his wife, there was a lot going on there. And , I was there to be, I think a character witness for the husband. And yeah, the wife had already fired two or three different attorneys.

And so a couple of times I've got the, my half day off, and then that morning they cancel the trial. And so then that day, apparently she tried again, and then the judge said, no, you're we're doing this. Mm. So then she represented herself. So then I'm there and she's asking questions. And it was really fascinating because, she was just saying, do you know the two of us? And I'd never talked to her in my life. And is it true you diagnosed me as this? And I'm saying, Nope, never did or anything. And then I mm-hmm. I said something and she just says, objection. And then the judge says, uh, yeah, the judge says On what grounds, basically.

And she just said, literally, I don't know, I just. I've heard people do that before. And then I know then the judges just kinda looks at me and and he said, continue. But then it was wrapped up pretty quickly. But I know you're so nice because you're like, your hands if anybody says listening to the audio, Kate just put her hand on her heart. She's like, oh. And I'm sitting there thinking, oh no, she was not a nice person and trying to, ruin my, yeah. My client, and yeah. But it was really fascinating though, because it seemed so, it was funny, but it wasn't the right place for it to be funny.

But no, for sure. . There were a lot of funny things in this Robert Durst, the actual prosecution from Robert Durst versus bourbons. There were like moments of levity, like they were laughing. Yeah. There were moments of levity when, in the first case of Morris Black, where he is I had a, it was so morbid, but he was like, well, I was wearing a woman's hairpiece, he had a wig on. And he was like, and I had put on a loose sweater and he goes, what was I gonna do? I can't talk, as a woman, I have this deep raspy voice, so I had to be mute.

And the, I think the the audience, the jury gallery, laughed and it was at that point where I think when there, there's laughter. You have somebody. Yeah. And and you're engaging them. I'd say like Robert Durst, I, when they say he is the sociopath, I don't know anything about sociopaths, but he's funny. He's charming in some instances. He's got charisma in a way that you're like, but this is a person who, where there's smoke, there's fire, and he could be dangerous. Yeah. So it was really strange. But yeah, there were Mormon where the jury laughs for sure.

And the Robert Durst trial, both of 'em it's crazy. Wow. Yeah, for sure. I, I just saw the thing too that said so, so the nine days and then, and he was 78 years old at the time, , that's mm-hmm. That's a long time. Yeah. And he was not doing well and it was during COVID and he had , a shunt, in his head. So they shaved his head at the outside and were looking for sympathy. And he was definitely, he was acting as if he couldn't hear, he was reading the transcript. Everything was live transcribed onto this little tablet for him.

But he could hear there, there were very clear moments where he responded to the question without reading the tablet. He's just very okay with stretching the truth, is very okay I've got kinda a go-to note of you've got psychopathy is largely genetic nature. Sociopathy is typically driven by environmental factors or childhood trauma or abuse, nurture. Psychopaths are calculated, charming, meticulous planners who maintain a normal facade. Sociopaths are erratic, compulsive, and prone to rage. Psychopaths have almost no empathy or remorse. Sociopaths may have limited empathy for specific people and can feel slight

guilt, though it rarely guides action. And I, there's a belief in the, I work in this world of emotional maturity and then the cluster b personality disorders, narcissism, borderline histrionic, but then sociopathy is often thought, oh, that there's a belief that there are a lot of. Sociopaths that are nonviolent, that are just out among us, Uhhuh and and they lack that empathy piece. Yeah. And so they just don't understand why I had one, one time and there had been some domestic violence.

Mm-hmm. And, and it was fascinating because he really got under my skin because he was saying, well, you would've done the same thing of what I did. And I was saying, no, no, how dare you. And I wouldn't have, but you could tell that he genuinely didn't understand because he, he thought it was okay for him to block this exit. And so then, it, it was almost like, no, what was I supposed to do? I told her, don't, you can't get out. Where mm-hmm. Where then the belief is then the psychopath has a sadistic, quality where they derive enjoyment off of seeing someone suffer.

so he would fit this sociopathic part, but then he sure does. The murder part is interesting though, yeah, he sure does. The, but it's like that erratic, impulsive, yeah. , Like the Cody, I wish I could remember his last name, . The but the gentleman who was the Texas detective, the Texas, . . He says at the outset, I don't, I, he didn't know if Robert Durst was somebody who would actively go and kill people. But what he said was, I think if you put him back him into a corner and you

threaten him and you threaten his liberty that he will kill you, that's he, in his opinion, he, that he would've killed you. , . So almost kinda like what I'm mentioning with this other person where this person felt that they thought, well what was I supposed to do? And then Yeah. And to them it wasn't even a, you're watching 'em confabulate in real time of I couldn't be the person that did it was like, no, I, yeah, I did it, but what was I supposed to, I everybody would've done that. But Robert Dur confabulate in real time, like the stories, the lies he tells are just bizarre.

So when Kathy Durst disappears, he says he takes her to a train station and drops her off at a train station. At from, they live in like upstate New York? I think so. So he drops her off at a train station to go back to Manhattan. 'cause she's working at the Einstein Hospital. She's a med student at the time. And he says he drops her off there and then he goes back to his house, but he sees his neighbor outside. And so he goes and talks to his neighbor and then goes back home. When the detectives interview the neighbor, the neighbor's like that never happened.

What are you talking about? What? So , it's weird and the lies he tells are so strange. And then his conduct is so strange. Between the murder of Morris Black and the or maybe it's the murder of Susan Berman and the murder of Morris Black, or the Death of Morris Black, I should say. 'cause he was not found to have murdered him. He, I think it's, I think I have that timeline right. But he goes into a convenience store and like bends over, they have video of this, bends over it, and, but he's actually unzipping his fly and he just pees all over the candy that's in front of the Whoa rash cashier.

He, and then the hogie theft. Yeah. And then he just does things that you're just like, why would you do that? Wow. What are you doing? Why do you think you could just get away with this stuff? And so it's, and then he'll just lie about it. One of the things. So reason, the reason why John Loon's cross after. He, Robert Durst goes and testifies for himself. The reason it last nine days is because John Lewin's so good, he just unravels, he pulls every single string, so he just unravels

every lie that Robert Durst tells. Wow. So one of the lies, tell me how this lands for you, Tony. , One of the things he said about that his mother is , they had a very close relationship, until her, the time of her passing when he was about seven and that he remembers as a young child that it was always Mommy and Robert and Romy and Bobby versus Daddy and Douglas, Douglas is his younger brother. And and so he says, I remember when we were playing Go Fish or Uno or

Frisbee, my mom was always on my side. She was always Team Bobby and then Lyn's . Intro is , so can you tell me how old were you when your mom died? And he goes seven years old. And so he, John Lyn goes, so that would've made it 1950 when your mom died. And he goes, that's correct. And then he goes, are you aware that Uno wast invent invented until 1952 or so? It's or 1970, something like that. And then the Frisbee wasn't invented until like the late fifties. And he is no. And he goes, so those have to be lies, right?

And he is I don't know. He just can, he's just, wow. Yeah. It's so bizarre, Tony. And so like, you get somebody like John Le, it's that's good evidence. Those are that's . Evidence that cannot be controverted. Right? Yep. Like he's saying one thing and you can prove based on just the time of the invention that that didn't happen. You know what's great about that? And I gotta go, I wanna watch those clips now for sure, because I do, I get to see a version of that and even couples therapy, because somebody, I've got these four pillars the way to communicate, but one of the pillars

is you don't tell the other person they're wrong or you disagree even if you think they're wrong or you disagree. And then you go on and you ask questions before you make comments. 'cause it can be, it can also, I always say it'll expose immaturity. And what will often happen is somebody will say, man, okay, yeah. I, I can appreciate what a narrative that tugs at my heart. Thank you for sharing. I I've found out that Uno wasn't invented yet. And then here comes tension. And then you get to see, oh, what does the person do with discomfort? And this is where their childhood adaptation kicks in. Where either they know that they can tap dance out of it until somebody just finally says no.

Okay. I guess you're right. Or, yeah. They just shut down and that's what you'll see on the couch. And then, 'cause maybe the spouse feels finally vindicated that, okay, somebody sees this and then it's it's my job now to go in and try to heal the childhood trauma right there and say, Hey, this is your childhood adaptation. It's maladaptive now. And then you'd let the big kid come in and heal. But then. , If it's gotten to that part in their life, they still cannot admit that they were wrong , and so then even if they do, it's from this just collapse of ego.

And I'm a horrible person because the adaptation is, if I can go victim enough, somebody's gonna tell me it's gonna be okay. And it's so wild to sit there with that discomfort and watch the spouse almost look over at me saying, can we get this to end? Yeah. So that person has, that's the way they live. That is their and here we are trying to, whether it's in a cross examination maybe, or in my office, sometimes I almost think, I don't wanna say it's cruel, but it's, oh, we are working it to this place where you see the collapse. Mm-hmm. And then it's almost okay, now what?

Yeah. Because it's not like that person goes, oh my gosh, I think I get it now. Yeah. I, yeah. It's so wild. They don't, and Robert Durst, he clearly, I think it sets in. Because they have all of his prison phone calls recorded, and . So they interweave those calls and I think it sets in the trial's not going very well for him during the blue and cross. Mm. I think he becomes pretty clear. I think he kind of has to deal with sitting with that discomfort. Yeah. And like sitting, , and so he says to his wife, Deborah, he goes, I

if I'm convicted, I hope that they send me to California prison that has space for old people who are kind of at the end of their life. Wow. He says that. And so I think maybe there's a sense of Yeah. Accepting reality. But I do think he really, at least in everything he presented he never really admitted that he killed Susan. No. He does. I'm gonna say no, but I don't know that, but I'm , I'm just going. Oh my gosh. That makes sense. But were you gonna say what he does? Yeah. He, he does admit to writing the cadaver letter.

He write, he says that he came to California to see Susan around the holidays, 'cause it's around Christmas time that she's ultimately murdered. And and he says , he planned to buy her some furniture and and that he went to her house. He had a key, he lets himself in, and he finds the body and that's why he writes the cadaver note, and then John Lewin says, pulls out , Susan was a meticulous note taker too, and she, but she kept her her day planner, pretty up to date, , I'm doing this.

She didn't have a lot of stuff going on, but or in my opinion, she didn't. But but she never wrote down that Robert Durst was coming to see her. Oh. And then she wrote, a couple days after her death, she wrote Call Bobby. And so the motivation to kill her that the prosecution puts forward is that , she was extorting him for money and had presented that she had facts about the Kathy Durst disappearance. Mm. That would've implicated Robert Durst and her. Wow. You know what, what's fascinating about that story though, from a confabulation

standpoint, is it's almost like he found one that he could then latch into. Mm-hmm. And then now, okay. I try, try, try, and then, oh, that one makes sense. I found her and I, that's why I wrote the note. And almost like the person it, it eases their own discomfort of okay, I found one. Yeah. And now that is it is locked in and Yeah. . It's so weird to see too, him testing out different theories. Yeah. So after. Andrew Jari presents him with a letter, he calls Andrew Jari a day or two later and

is Hey, you know, that was block letters. Anyone could have written that. My defense our defense team and handwriting analysis at the time, showed that that was really the only way you could write block letters that way. And so he is, I don't know, again, I have no insight into the mind of Robert Durst. I have no insight into the cases, but just as a pure true crime fan. Yeah. It is weird to see him kind of do these mental loops, mental gymnastics. , Oh, you're, and you're just , oh, this is crazy. I am in real time seeing somebody who is implicated in the disappearance

and murder of two persons. And he just wow, this is crazy to watch. Thank you. It's so entertaining. What's fun about this whole thing, Kate? And I am so glad that this is the first case going with a guest and that it's you. And then we we're able to lay this thing out this way because I want so bad, badly. Is that a that desperately to make this just a nice flow and everyone here, because I would've never thought about, I get, yeah, I get to see people confabulate in real time in couples therapy and mm-hmm.

I've never thought about that similarity that would happen where, watching somebody on the stand for how many days, 'cause I found myself I will do intensives at times with couples where they'll come in and you spend four hours, six hours, eight hours, and. It still does seem like if you can stay with it and work 'em through their normal ways that they get out of the discomfort, they fall apart, the childhood trauma, the adaptations, that if you can stay with it, go through it and show them that you can make it through and admit that you did something.

And then the world's still spinning and your spouse is still there saying, you know what, I'm, I would rather know this than feel lied to that. Then it feels like there's this big aha moment. But then so often within a couple of weeks, I call it a shelf life. Yeah. The person kind of returns back to their home base of still lying about things. They're still not willing to admit things or, so how deep is this stuff in our psyche and the patterns and yeah. . I have no idea, but , at least in the drinks, it does seem that Robert Durst had a proclivity to lie.

Yeah. And and create . Narratives that benefited him. Yeah. Versus just telling the truth. Say he and that's what the defense was saying. It's Hey, he's telling the truth. Now what happened with Morris Black was that he, they got in tussle and ultimately the gun went off. And that's the truth. But it's just a few months before Morris Black's, death. Susan Perman also killed. Yeah. And he happened to be there. And it's so you have to, if the truth is that he's just the un luckiest

man in the world, which is what his, his story is , just tell the truth. You're much less likely, I think to be found as, somebody who is trying to avoid justice and is. You're much more likely to be presumed innocent, I think if you are telling the truth. Yeah. It's like, well, I found, I found a quote from, , a Lewin quote. It says, testifying at trial is incredibly risky for a defendant, and most lawyers won't put their clients on the stand. Durst testimony Tuesday showed that a history of lies and inconsistent stories made 'em vulnerable. And then here's the quote.

You don't just make up lies for the sake of lying. Lewin said, mm-hmm. You lie in a particular, when there's a reason for you to lie. And generally speaking in this context when it relates to incriminating evidence. Correct. And then he just says, Durst agreed. You know? Yeah. Oh gosh. He just, he, but he's such a good lawyer. It's just so, it was massive. You should totally check it out. I will. And and it is, it's an incredibly entertaining story and Okay. It's sad that it's, it's sad that it's true. Yeah. It's, it's devastatingly sad, for all parties, I, including the Durst family

oh, yeah. You know, clearly this young Robert Durst was. Dramatically impacted by the suicide of his mother. Absolutely. And didn't do well. And it really hurt his family and the people he related with. And and it really obviously hurt the McCormack family, Kathy, his first wife's family. They're the ones who are pursuing that wrongful death. The claim over in, I think it's in New York. Okay. Kate, , we got about seven minutes, there Yeah. Oh, we did it. Are we totally. Are there things that you really wanted to make sure that even we just got out there?

'cause this has been so I, fun. And so amazing and I thank you for putting all the time and effort into the research for this, but are there some things that you wanna make sure that we that we got to, that we didn't or anything from a speed round standpoint? Man. I, one of the things that I was curious about from your position as a therapist is what do you think motivated, if you, just to, just based on what you know, what do you think motivated him to continue to return to the,

yeah, why did he keep circling back? , Why did he feel the need to vindicate himself? Yeah. Like with Andrew Jarecki, that motivation is never made sense. Yeah. And yeah, and oh gosh. And just the way he says to himself, well, there it is, you're caught at the end. It's like he was begging to be caught in some way. And that's when I'm like, did he have multiple identities? And one of them was like, trying to put him up to , coming clean. I have no idea. That's like, that's a good take. I, my, I think my go-to when people do that is that they still, so there's

a fascinating concept of people not wanting someone else to control the narrative of who they're Okay. And and I, any given time, probably this week I had a really heavy couples week and some of 'em are heading toward a dissolution of the marriage. And one of the things that keeps people hanging in there longer is they don't like the fact that their spouse is gonna now go and run with a narrative that they were the problem when they, when the immature, narcissistic spouse is the one that really the, that caused the dissolution of the relationship.

And so this, the, I always call 'em the pathologically kind partner over stays, they're welcome because they so desperately want to be understood or, seen. And so sometimes I do think that maybe people, yeah, they continue to go back to something because they want to almost make sure that the narrative is what they need it to be. But then I like what you said earlier, the kicking up the dust because then. Since it's not based off of a, it's based off of a false self. Mm-hmm. And the person's trying to make themselves believe that they are a

certain person that then going and interacting and trying to ensure that the narrative is what they need it to be. Now they've disturbed the narrative again. And so it just will keep that cycle going. That's just a thought about it. Yeah. No, I appreciate that instinct. I was just like, gosh, I, his lawyers told him not to do it. They told they were there with him. He was, it's just so crazy. And, , the thing with Susan Berman is if I can see, what if she did was training ex extraordinary for money? I don't know. We don't know. Yeah. We'll never know.

Yeah. We'll never know the actual story, but but I can see, you know, that being a motive, I mean, gosh. But he had more money than he knew what to do with and that was his long-term friend. Why I just, the motives to murder are so beyond my, they're just beyond my wheelhouse. I can't even fathom it. I would've been like, don't say that. That's not, I wouldn't, I probably wouldn't have been saying anything to her. I've been like, well, we're not friends anymore. I didn't disappear my wife, why would you allege that? You know what I mean? Right. It's I, it just was so strange and , but he got caught.

But listen to this loophole, Tony. You'll see how this lands with you. So he was appealing the conviction at the end of his life. And because he passed away, he technically isn't found the conclusively guilty at the end. Really? Oh, okay. Yeah. Isn't that something you should Google that? I would, I didn't realize that. I would've thought like, okay, well then you just don't get your appeal and the trial court. All right. I would assume so too. . No I guess not. I guess not. So anyway, so he just does, he was in prison, but yeah, that a free man.

But yeah, you should totally check out John Lewin obsessed. He's so cool. Check out those nine days. He did a great job. But I mean, maybe there were egos between the attorneys, but I they were just very professional. Well, and they were so professional. When you say it that way, it's yeah, the, maybe the that the professionalism, I think in the fact that it's such a high profile case would make sense. And I have heard, so I've had attorney clients criminal defense attorney clients and I think it's fascinating 'cause they all seem to know each other and Oh, really? Yeah. I believe it. Yeah. And so then they go in and then it's, I often think about it

like I'm an old person, Kate. I dunno if you remember, there's a cartoon that used to be, was it a sheep dog? And a. I forget what it was, but they, or was it even the roadrunner in the coyote? But it's they would have these episodes where they carry their lunchboxes in, they clock in and Yeah, then they, then they fight and chase each other. And then at the end of the day they're like, oh, have a great night. And I just love that whole concept because Yeah, it sounds like a lot of the attorneys they're civil, , after hours, they go to the same what Attorney bar and thing and then not bar like take the bar, but and then they go in there and

now they, 'cause one of my friends was telling me that he knows the person's, he knows the strengths and weaknesses of the opposing counsels and yeah. And so then they even, because that's where I think my mind was going of they know this one gets rattled for this or this one does this. And it's wild to think that they are interacting with each other on behalf of their clients. Yeah, right. It's just a interesting man, the bar here. Is small, for the bar I'm a part of, and I know a lot of people within the bar

and I have a lot of respect for people who are on the other side of the bar. And I'm friends with plaintiff's attorneys, but if we were ever adverse, there's just no way. We could be friends during that period. We could be friendly. Yeah. But we could never be, because I have, we're necessarily adverse to each other. So I don't know what it's like in criminal, but I would say it's civil. We're not buddies. And I think when you say we're civil, I bet you're, I bet you're right about it's friendly, not friends. 'cause I can say Yeah, probably not that they're going and hanging out on the weekends, but,

, yeah, I don't know. It's so beyond me, but I have the utmost respect and I think, . I just can't get over how good of attorneys were they were in these cases and it was just so impressive to see. And yeah. I love your take on it, Tony. I wish I had presented it more linearly. Oh no. Not for, for me, my friend Kate, that's, I, that's the way I roll. I love the, I love that. And, okay. Can I throw one more thing out there that I was thinking about? Yeah. When you were saying, because I can't imagine somebody literally taking somebody's life. Either. I can't. I do think about this, I think about this often of things are set in motion

so much earlier, just meaning that when somebody is thought about something and then they're thinking about it more. Or if somebody doesn't care as much about something that somebody else does. And here's the example I think of with this often is I work with a lot of people that are deconstructing their faith, navigating mm-hmm. Out of high demand religion, and a lot of them that have been, it's almost like this polarity or pendulum effect where they've been so orthodox that the pendulum swings all the way over to, atheists. And so that you'll see, it's almost like you'll see more of that kind of a swing. Mm-hmm. And so then I remember one person long ago talking about they, they were being funny

about it, but they just said, what was good was they said they were sworn in a, some sort of court related thing and they had to put their hand on the Bible and, and they just said, man, that would've probably freaked me out in the past. And then now they had no really belief in that. Mm-hmm. And so it was just wild to think about the fact that then somebody else would say they can't lie. They put their hand on the Bible, but then if somebody's saying that, I don't, that doesn't mean anything to me. So then does, does that, do they have an easier time lying, for example,

because that isn't they have a completely different moral code at that point. Do you know what? Yeah. Do you know what I mean? For sure. The thing is, I, that's kind of a you swear to tell the truth, the whole truth and nothing but the truth, right? And is it so help you God still? Is that some say so help you God. Yeah. Yeah, but I don't, but the real. Uh, I mean the physical consequences that are manifest here on earth versus putting your hand on a Yeah. A, some type of biblical text and swearing is that you're

subject to our perjury laws. Yes. Right. That's what you're swearing to. And so , you, there's the physical manifestation is if you perjure yourself, which Robert Durst kind of admits in his testimony with John Lnn, you should totally check it out. Yeah. He says, I committed minor perjury. I just minor a little bit. Yeah. John was like, there's no, what, there's spectrum of perjury. You either did, it's a zero or one. You either did it or not, but he's so quick too. But but the consequences, there are real consequences for perjuring yourself.

Mm-hmm. And, and um, so you can be subject to those consequences. And in his case. I don't know what those consequences would've been, but I assume, if you had found Robert Durst guilty of perjury, it would've been maybe one of the least of his problems, but he would've had a problem nonetheless. Yeah. Almost the old, uh, the John Gotti defense, would they catch him on tax? Yeah. Tax evasion or something like that? Yeah. Or, or exactly. Or what? OJ Simpson, they got him for getting mad at somebody about memorabilia. It wasn't ever Yeah. Right. For sure. And then he goes back to prison for that and it is so crazy.

Trip. . It's just full circle. But , I thought Marsha Clark did a great job. Yeah, she was really good counsel. And I thought her OJ Lutheran was really good and John Lewin also is in LA and he had this, he said, this is gonna be the biggest case I had since OJ that , that our office has had since oj. And he was probably right. It was so good. Okay. So Kate one of these days we will okay. I would love to have you back , this was so fun. And then and maybe that will be our big get someday is Dan John, John Lewin.

John Lewin. The Dan the John for sure. Yeah. Yeah. Right. So John Le Oh my gosh, that'd be so cool if your people hear this. Kate and I would love to have some time. Yeah. Talking to you. I'll be obsessed. Yeah. But thank you so much for having me, Tony, so much. I can't even thank you enough. I'm gonna hit pause, but hang on here real quick here.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Hosts

  • Tony Overbay Host Feed-stated

Guests

  • Kate Guest Feed-stated

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. How Childhood Shapes Who You Marry: The Accommodator, Attachment, and Why We Choose the Familiar

    Nov 13, 20261 hr 18 minAudio

    Why do people pleasers and avoidant partners find each other, and why does it seem like such a relief at first? Tony follows Pam and Jim, a composite couple, from childhood to the college campus where they met. Pam...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Nobody Brings a Casserole When You Wake Up to Betrayal: The Accommodator, Gaslighting, and Rebuilding Trust

    Nov 4, 20261 hr 29 minAudio

    Waking up to betrayal, gaslighting, or emotional immaturity rarely comes with a casserole on the porch or a meal train. When someone has a baby or a surgery, people can see the event and show up with dinner. When you...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Nobody Brings a Casserole When You Wake Up to Betrayal: The Accommodator, Gaslighting, and Rebuilding Trust

    Nov 4, 20261 hr 29 minAudio

    Waking up to betrayal, gaslighting, or emotional immaturity rarely comes with a casserole on the porch or a meal train. When someone has a baby or a surgery, people can see the event and show up with dinner. When you...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Your AI Is a Great Hype-Man - A Therapist Has a Few Notes (Plus Live QA)

    Oct 14, 20261 hr 32 minAudio

    Using AI as a therapist? Your chatbot might be building a great plan for the person you’re hoping to become. When a client’s chatbot asked if he was an extroverted go-getter, he answered as the man he’s working toward,...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Why Good People Defend Leaders (and Others) Who Contradict Themselves: Identity, Bias & Belonging

    Sep 24, 202653 minAudio

    Tony starts with a kid raised in an East Coast fishing town and another raised hiking Arizona trails. He uses them to show how beliefs tend to form through family, community, and identity, with the reasons showing up...

    Credit the people on this episode