Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

The Virtual Couch

The Virtual Couch artwork

What You Don't Know You Don't Know About Meditation (Hint: You Can’t Stop Thoughts or Clear Your Mind!)

Jun 12, 20261 hr 45 minAudio

Mindfulness isn't about emptying your mind or finally feeling calm - and believing it was is probably why you quit. Your emotions fire before your thinking brain ever catches up, which means most of your reactions - the defensiveness, the cravings, the snap judgments - are already in motion before you "decide" anything. In this conversation, Tony unpacks the neuroscience behind that gap and the genuinely doable practice that helps you notice your patterns sooner, build a pause, and respond to your life instead of just reacting to it. In this episode, you'll: Discover why you "feel before you think" - the low road and high road your brain takes, and why emotions fire roughly two and a half times faster than thoughts Learn to build the pause that turns automatic reactions (yes, including the fourth Oreo) into actual choices Untangle the real difference between meditation and mindfulness - and why the practice has roots in everything from Buddhist tradition to Christian contemplative prayer, no conversion required Understand why silence can feel so unbearable that people will choose a mild electric shock over sitting alone with their thoughts - and what that reveals about emotional avoidance Strengthen the "runway" between your internal smoke alarm and your inner fire chief using sleep, breath, and a practice you can start in the next sixty seconds Tony Overbay is a licensed marriage and family therapist and host of The Virtual Couch, drawing on his clinical work and four-plus years of daily practice to make mindfulness feel approachable instead of intimidating. Stay through the end for a short guided practice you can take with you - and remember, you're not failing when your mind wanders. You're not broken. You're human. Start with one breath today. 00:00 One Year Post Fusion 01:02 Trusting Physical Therapy 02:56 From Woo Woo to Mindfulness 05:05 No Magic Beans 10:03 The Pause Changes Everything 14:12 Stick Not Snake Brain 19:09 Oreos and Autopilot 22:07 Mindfulness and Maturity 28:56 Meditation Practice Tiers 30:31 My Daily Practice Origin 34:46 Meditation vs Mindfulness 35:28 Meditation Roots East West 38:02 Skepticism and Ownership 40:20 Meditation Styles Overview 42:34 Mindfulness Misconceptions 45:47 Mindfulness in Daily Life 48:33 Mindfulness History and MBSR 52:10 What Mindfulness Is Not 55:33 Brainwaves and Frequencies 58:47 Entrainment and Binaural Beats 01:02:52 Natural Sounds and Safety 01:05:15 Apophenia Pattern Seeking 01:06:41 Why Silence Feels Hard 01:10:22 Stimulation Dopamine Avoidance 01:11:46 Back to Beats and Apps 01:12:08 Meditation Apps I Use 01:12:26 Monroe Institute Hemi Sync 01:13:51 Gateway Process Hype 01:15:01 Binaural Beats Reality Check 01:16:07 Breathwork Science Basics 01:17:38 Vagus Nerve and HRV 01:19:33 Nasal vs Mouth Breathing 01:22:20 Diaphragmatic Breathing 01:23:43 Neurons Wire Together 01:25:01 Startle Response Runway 01:27:54 Lengthening the Runway 01:30:32 What We Learned Today 01:32:46 Guided Mindfulness Practice 01:38:19 This Too Shall Pass 01:39:54 You Are Not Broken 01:43:04 Closing Breath and Goodbye Please follow Tony on Instagram @virtual.couch on Tiktok @virtualcouch on Facebook https://www.facebook.com/tonyoverbaylmft and on Substack https://thevirtualcouch.substack.com/ You can reach out to Tony through his website tonyoverbay.com or by emailing contact @ tonyoverbay.com

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

So it's been a little over a year since my spinal fusion surgery, ACDF, two-level spinal fusion. From time to time, I still dig up the pictures on my phone of x-rays post-surgery, and it's mind-blowing to me to think that I have that hardware in my neck, screws and a plate and these little cages that help the bone grow. And it's equally wild to think I feel amazing. To go from the type of acute pain that I was in to where I am now is really

easy to take for granted how much I was struggling prior to surgery, especially those last couple of months leading up to surgery. One of the things that I know that I was the most worried about wasn't even the surgery itself. It was the recovery. Because what if I'm not able to do so many of the things that I like doing? I had this amazing surgeon, Dr. Kalsa, who I've interviewed, and I've got an episode that I'm going to share at some point down the road on a lot of additional details around the fear going in the whole recovery process.

But he basically implored me to trust the process. He knew what he was doing and to really dive into physical therapy. That's what I realized I was more worried about because my initial thought was that physical therapy doesn't work. Now, why? Because one time, literally decades before, I had a severely pulled groin muscle and a doctor sent me to a physical therapist. And I did go one time and I did the stretches while I was there. And then I never did them again. and I did not go back and I realized I've created

an entire story in my head that, well, it didn't really work for me. And then I had to step back and say, okay, one of my best friends, Chris Perlow, a guy who I have paced and he has paced me through the dead of night and through sunshine and rain on the Western States 100 mile endurance run, the Super Bowl of 100 milers. This guy who has spent hours and hours with me every year that I ran around a high school track for 24 hours, raising money for charity, this guy who's been my go-to when I've had aches and pains and pulls and tears, is a physical therapist.

But apparently I am very special in my mind. And well, that doesn't work for me, which is fascinating when you think about it, because what I really should have said with the groin injury was I never actually gave it a chance being physical therapy. And even this time recovering from spinal fusion surgery as a 55 year old human at the time, now 56, there were so many moments where the physical therapist, somebody who I was literally paying for help, somebody who clearly knew more about recovery than I did, would tell me to do some exercise or movement that felt weird or pointless

or too small to matter to me. And every part of my brain wanted to say, now, I don't know if this is the thing that's really going to work. But thank goodness, I kept doing it anyway. I graduated from physical therapy. I went and I even still do some of the exercises now. I carry a little resistance band in my bag and I take it with me everywhere. And sometimes I use it. Because now, over a year later, I honestly have to assume that my recovery is as good as it is precisely because I leaned into the process instead of trusting every thought that my brain threw at me in any moment.

And I've noticed the exact same thing recently doing what I jokingly referred to as, we'll call it woo-woo work with a therapist here in Arizona, which if I'm being completely honest, was probably just my clever way of avoiding calling it what it actually was, the woo-woo, which a big part of that is learning how to sit with my feelings and emotions instead of constantly trying to intellectualize them or trying to be the therapist who is going to be able to understand them. But still not necessarily need to truly feel them because I don't even know

what to do with them and I don't even know what they are. And I can't tell you how many times she suggested something where my immediate internal response was, yeah, I don't know, that doesn't make sense. Again, person that I'm going to that has expertise in this area and I'm now, wanting to tell myself, I don't know if you know what you're talking about because it doesn't make sense to me, this thing that I don't know anything about. So it didn't make sense until eventually it did. And oh, my goodness, has it made all the sense and more on that in future episodes as well,

which has made me realize something really important about today's topic, mindfulness and meditation. Even when I just said those two words, I wonder what your first thoughts were. Hard pass or, oh yeah, I know, just breathe or let's start loading up the yeah buts. Well, yeah, but I've tried it and it doesn't work. Or yeah, but I can't stop my thoughts or a dozen other yeah buts. Because most people reject it for the exact same reason that I almost rejected physical therapy this time. Or why I wanted to reject the things about emotions that I was going to someone

who specializes in the concept of emotions was trying to help me understand. And they assume that because something feels unfamiliar, uncomfortable, slow, too difficult to understand, that it probably isn't working and that it's not worth my time. But sometimes the work that changes you the most is the work that does not feel impressive while you're doing it. I remember sitting with a client years ago. They had already been to several therapists trying to stop turning to a particularly unhealthy coping mechanism. And I was talking with him about mindfulness and shame and getting rid of the

shame and self-awareness and all the things that I absolutely believe are foundational parts of recovery. And I could feel him. I could watch him start to mentally check out. So I paused and I checked in with him and asked him, okay, what's coming up with you right now? I'm noticing that you're starting to tune out. And thankfully, he was honest. And we eventually landed on the fact that he had heard versions of all these things that I'm saying before. And he also admitted that he was a guru shopper looking for somebody who would finally tell him something different, some guru that had the magic pill,

the magic bullet, something faster, something more exciting. And I remember joking with him a little bit and saying, ah, so you want me to deliver you a magic bean that you can take and it will immediately change your life. And to his credit, he laughed and basically said, yeah, I guess I kind of do. And I shared with him at that point, I can absolutely tell you what you want to hear, But that would honestly be doing him a disservice because what I was actually asking him to do was trust the process. And this part of the story, I wasn't even sure if I would tell because it's just so fascinating, but it's the way that life works that I would love to tell

you. And he trusted every word I said, and he did amazing work. And within a matter of weeks or maybe a couple of months, everything was fixed and he lived happily ever after. But the true part of the story is we worked together really well for quite a while. And he was making progress from the seat of the professional, me playing the role of professional. But to him, it was slow. And he still desperately wanted it to go quicker and he wanted to do it perfectly. So eventually, therapeutically speaking, he broke up with me.

And honestly, he fell in love with the sales page. One that basically said something like, are you tired of countless therapy sessions without getting the results you want? Are people telling you recovery is a process and it takes as long as it takes? Well, what if I told you that if you follow my system or whatever, my three-step system or my acronym, whatever it is, that in less than three months, you can finally have the life that you know is out there waiting for you. A life where you no longer struggle with, name it, pornography, gambling, food, video games, or whatever has been the unhealthy coping mechanism that has been holding you back from the life that you deserve.

A life where your spouse respects you again, where your dog is not just excited to see you, but brings your slippers to you, where you walk with confidence, where you finally become the person you were meant to be. And honestly, I could go on and on because that kind of messaging is one of my biggest frustrations. And this concept of how people sell the destination. Do you want to be with your family on the beach in Hawaii? And then all of a sudden you have a name of an airline come up as the ads. They're selling you the destination. He was being sold this destination of, do you want these things?

And I realized when I was trying to understand that concept, what I'm doing is trying to sell the plane or not even just the plane. I'm telling you that I have amazing nuts and bolts that hold the plane together. So I'm trying to help him build the vehicle that actually gets you to the destination. And what was he willing to pay for that promise from the sales page? Honestly, in this scenario, I think it was about five grand. And I remember when he left, I genuinely told him that I am here for you if you ever need me. And I also remember that he was trying to console me saying,

hey, you did a great job. We had a good run, but I think it's time for me to, get these things from the sales page. And I just shared that I would always be there for him. And a little over a year later, he did come back. And now it's been years since then. Is he perfect? No. But now he's done the real work, the work that has led him to feel better about himself. And he's in an amazing place now. Is he perfect? No, but he is on the path of healing and growth, which honestly just reinforces the entire point of today's episode. Growth usually looks a whole lot less dramatic than we want it to.

Definitely not as cool as it looks on social media and definitely not as cool as you need it to look in order to sell courses or books or those sorts of things. Because most meaningful change isn't found in some magical breakthrough aha moment. While those are amazing and wonderful and they feel good in the moment, we typically turn eventually back to our home base. And we really need to start slowly changing what that home base looks like. Because real change is usually found in the quiet, repetitive, often unremarkable process,

of learning how to stay present long enough to stop running away from yourself and your thoughts and then going back to whatever it was that is starting to make sense or to click. What if I were to tell you that there really aren't shortcuts to the things in life that create meaningful, lasting change? And the sooner I think that one can recognize that and begin to accept it, the sooner the journey actually begins. And I realize this is a lengthy and maybe a little heavy introduction to a podcast episode about mindfulness and meditation.

But I have wanted to do this episode for a very, very long time. And I continue to write notes and rewrite and change because I genuinely believe this is one of the most important tools that you can develop for every aspect of your life. Mindfulness changes your relationship with your thoughts. It helps you build this pause that right now you may not even realize is missing, or you may recognize that you are so reactive in so many moments that I don't even know how on earth to begin to find that pause.

Because in that pause is where so much of life actually happens, especially the meaningful pieces of change. There's a quote from Viktor Frankl from his book, Man's Search for Meaning. Between stimulus and response, there is a space. And in that space lies our freedom and power to choose our response. And in our response lies our growth and our happiness. There's so much wisdom packed into that idea because so much of our life is lived in reaction. Reaction to stress, reaction to discomfort, reaction to fear and opportunity and conflict and shame and insecurity and loneliness and the uncertainty of all of it.

And when you begin to build even the smallest pause between what happens and how you respond, now all of a sudden, the game looks different. Now you do have a choice. Now, what you often discover pretty quickly, which is so fascinating, but I know it's the path of awakening or growth or healing, is that having the opportunity to choose and And then actually knowing what to choose are very, very different things. And you can't even get to that point if you are still living in this place of reaction and then beating yourself up and shame.

Having that pause and then having this opportunity now to choose, now you get to figure out what matters to you, what are your values, and then consistently making those choices. That's work that's a little bit more downstream. Because first, we have to learn how to get to that space in the first place. I believe there is nothing quite like the individual hero's journey that begins when you truly start leaning into this concept. So there's one of my big goals of this episode today. This episode is going to be a little longer. And I hope you'll stay with me through it.

I also welcome every one of your yeah buts. I want feedback. I want questions through my website or contact at TonyOverbay.com or through social media. Because I want to know what comes up for you. I want to know where your brain pushes back, where it gets uncomfortable, where it says, okay, Tony, all right. Because this really could become one of the most transformative episodes that I think you'll listen to if you allow yourself not just to hear it, but to actually experience it. What does it bring up with you? What are the challenges that you are going to anticipate? I would encourage

you to notice what comes up and stay curious about it instead of immediately trying to solve whatever it is that comes up or escape or run away from it. So with that said, I'll see you right after the theme song. And then let's get to it.

Welcome to another episode of The Virtual Couch. I'm your host, Tony Overbay. I'm a licensed marriage and family therapist. Follow me at virtual.couch on Instagram or on TikTok at virtual couch or Facebook, Tony Overbay LMFT and on Substack, where I'm putting out more and more writing content, thevirtualcouch.substack.com. And you can reach out to me with any questions, thoughts, suggestions, ideas. I'm doing a fair amount of keynote speaking through this upcoming summer. So if you are interested in having me come speak to your organization, let me know. I would love to hear from you. And you can do that through the

website, TonyOverbay.com or email me at contact at TonyOverbay.com. And I forgot to mention in the opening to stay tuned after the episode. And I am also including a short, I think it's maybe seven or eight minute mindfulness exercise because I recognize it may be the first one that you've ever done, or maybe you're a pro. Regardless though, I hope you'll stick around for it. Okay. Story time. you're walking through the woods. It's not a hard hike. It's just a walk. And the trail is clear.

The light is shining through the trees. It's nice. Nothing out of the ordinary, but it's just a beautiful day. Before you know it, you're a few miles in and your mind is somewhere else. Maybe replaying a conversation from the day before, or maybe thinking about what's for dinner. You're just being and doing and the world is safe. But then there's a loud sound off in the distance and you have no idea what it is, a branch, an animal, a person, before you've even finished the thought, your head whips around, your breath catches and you let out a little scream because there on the ground,

half hidden in the brush, is a snake. It's a long, curved, dark snake. And a half second later, your eyes focus and your brain catches up and you realize it's just a stick. It's a long, curvy, snake-shaped stick. But you feel your heart up in your throat and you kind of laugh at yourself a little bit and you shake it off and you keep walking. That tiny moment between the scream and the laugh is one of the most studied things in modern neuroscience.

And this, my friends, is where the fun really begins. So your brain has two different ways of processing what your senses pick up. The first one, it is fast. It is no nonsense. It's crude. Information from your eyeballs hits a little relay station deep in your brain called the thalamus. And from there, it gets shot directly to the amygdala, the small almond-shaped structure that handles threat detection. The amygdala does not care about the details. It just needs to know whether we need to fire up the fight-or-flight system.

This whole route from eyeball through thalamus, amygdala to internal alarm takes, some believe, about 12 milliseconds. That's the route that made you scream. There's a second route. The second route takes longer. Same starting point, eyeballs, maybe your ear holes, but the information goes up to your visual cortex first. We need to get eyes on this, where your brain assembles a very detailed picture of what you're actually looking at. And then that detailed picture gets sent down to the amygdala,

where the first signal at this point kind of does that thing where maybe you've done this. You realize that you and your wife had to drive separately back home from the kid's school after an open house. And you both pull up to the stoplight and you are going to take a right and she's going to go straight. So you text her, hey, I'm not racing, but oh, you are racing. You drive like you're being chased by the cops. And by the time that you get into your neighborhood, you time it just right. So the garage door opens, you pull the car in, you shut the garage door and you pretend to be asleep on the couch. When she walks in, you beat her that bad.

That's what this first route does with the amount of time that it was there first. By the time the second route driver arrives, the amygdala, it has the full story. It's saying, we know it's a stick. You know, sure, go ahead and tell your more detailed story. But the second responder, we took care of it. Crisis averted, not a big deal. A stick, not a snake. False alarm. That route, that second route takes up to 200 milliseconds, which is still insanely fast in human terms. But that unconscious route is about 10 times faster.

And your brain maybe then thinks, you know, if you guys could get more on the same page, that would be great for everybody. And then the first route looks over at the brain and says, what's the big deal? Crisis averted. Then everybody then turns to the signals for the bladder and the bowels, who both look incredibly embarrassed. And the first route says, hey, it was a little bit of pee. And honestly, if this human meat suit that we're trapped in would try eating a salad every now and again, I don't think we would even need a new pair of underwear every time we get spooked. Bottom line, you screamed first, maybe sold yourself just a tiny amount,

and then figured everything out second. But your emotional brain got the news well before your thinking brain even finished reading the email. A guy named Joseph Ledoux is a neuroscientist at NYU, and he mapped this out in the 1990s, and he called those two routes the low road and the high road. Now, enter the book Emotionally Focused Couples Therapy for Dummies, which is a really good couples therapy book. And it summarizes this whole process by saying, you actually feel before you think. Now, modern neurosciences charted the brain's response to these situations and

found that emotions fire two and a half times more rapidly in the brain than the thoughts do. And what we just laid out in that intro is, or it's even faster than that. And they're not saying that emotions are more important than thoughts. In fact, feeling and thinking are actually supposed to team up and work together to make you that much more aware and prepared and capable of making the best decisions and responding in the most helpful way as possible. But understanding that concept was one of the things that personally helped me begin to understand why building more of this pause matters so much.

Or finding a way when possible to respond to a moment rather than to simply react to it. A simple, simple example. After I finished dinner, I want dessert. That became hardwired. I didn't even think about it. It just happened. And as mundane as this may sound, being able to notice that I already have the top of an Oreo twisted off perfectly, not just from one double stuff, but from two in order to make, the underappreciated artery stopping roof of your mouth coating quadruple stuff, being able to notice it is actually progress because typically I'm not even thinking about it.

It just happens. And it's not until later in the evening when I'm complaining about stomach aches that I might pause for just a moment and think, could it have been the half a dozen Oreos? No, it's easier to just say life's not fair. Got these stomach issues. And naturally now I'm going to make sure everybody else in the family knows about it, too. My stomach issues. And they don't want to say, hey, is it the sleeve of Oreos that you eat on a regular basis? And honestly, I think that's part of what mindfulness begins to reveal because so much of our life is happening automatically.

Patterns, reactions, habits, emotional responses, defensiveness, cravings, impulses, most of them are firing long before we consciously think that we've made a decision. Now, mindfulness doesn't magically stop those impulses from showing up, but it does help you notice them sooner. It helps us catch ourselves reaching for the second Oreo before the fourth one is already be assembled in our hand. And once you start noticing that, you begin realizing that this applies to far more than just dessert.

Go back to the concept of unconscious incompetence. At first, we have no idea. We are unconscious about our incompetence, that there are things that we could do. And you start finding out the information, and now we're consciously incompetent. I'm aware, but man, I'm still grabbing the Oreo. And we'll eventually move into conscious competence. I'm aware, and I'm not grabbing the Oreo. And then eventually, I just am. I'm not even thinking about that. Now, I have gone down the rabbit hole of research that can eventually lead you to concepts like the idea that we react to most everything in our lives first,

and then we think about why we react in an effort to believe we're actually more in control of our impulses than we really are. Or you'll find authors who take a much more, we'll call it deterministic view, and would argue that whatever you're reacting to right now was actually set in motion way longer before you even think it was. Maybe it was because I was denied Oreos as a kid that now as a 50 plus year old, they are just there. They are impulsive and I get to have them because I never had them as a child. There's a lot of different theories on why we react the way that we do.

But I think the data is pretty clear that this ability to build the pause becomes incredibly important because in that pause is where you begin to make choices. And I know I mentioned earlier that maybe a little pro tip is when you now build the pause in, you often still don't know what choice to make. What I neglected to say was that I will almost guarantee that by the time you truly reach that point where you're aware of the pause, I think you'll essentially be bought in to the journey. You'll be in on the path of realizing, oh, I did not know what I didn't know.

And now, what do I do? What else don't I know? Which is really just a version of this concept called the Dunning-Kruger effect. It's the idea that when we know very little about something, we often don't yet know enough to realize how much we don't know. And honestly, I think this is part of why hearing certain leaders, politicians, influencers, therapists, content creators, or any type of authority figure constantly tell us, that they're the smartest person in the room, the best at everything,

never wrong, always right, that it can start to feel almost disorienting to some people. I mean, I know it does for me because emotional maturity actually tends to move in the opposite direction. Emotional maturity says things like, oh, I did not know that. Or, okay, what else don't I know? Or I've changed my mind. Or, you know, I did say that before, but I said it before I had all the information I do now. And I can own that. That's, to me, that's confidence rooted in security, not being performative, not confidence rooted in performance.

But emotional immaturity, which is often deeply rooted in insecurity, cannot tolerate being wrong, being questioned, corrected, or challenged. But you have to, if you are in this emotionally immature position, you have to be in the one-up position at all costs. And what's fascinating is that groups often end up emotionally organizing themselves around, I want to say, the most emotionally immature, insecure person in the room. Almost the lowest common denominator of sorts because that person demands certainty.

They demand loyalty and agreement. They surround themselves with yes people. And those yes people are often projecting their own fantasies of wanting to be the one who's always right, always powerful, always certain. Healthy leadership looks very different. Healthy leaders tend to be calm, curious, grounded, and remarkably comfortable saying, I don't know. Because real competence doesn't need to perform certainty in every second. In fact, I think truly capable people usually want other capable people around them because they understand they grow by learning from those who know more than they do.

Otherwise, misinformation, projection, confabulation, and certainty without accountability just starts to feed itself and feed each other until eventually whatever the story is becomes more important than reality itself. And then something shifts. You begin to realize, of course, I didn't understand the things that I've never actually done with any consistency. And I think that realization can become strangely exciting because then the question becomes, wait a second, what else don't I know that I don't know?

And this is exactly why mindfulness becomes so important in the first place, because mindfulness is one of those practices that helps us become aware of the stories that our mind automatically creates, especially the ones built around certainty, defensiveness, ego, fear, or identity. Because without mindfulness, we tend to simply react. We're reacting to life. We're not responding. We hear something uncomfortable and immediately either defend it, attack it, dismiss it, double down or search for evidence that keeps our current worldview intact.

But mindfulness helps us create a pause where we can notice, oh wow, my brain right now, really wants to protect me or oh, I can notice how badly I wanna be right in this moment or even I am realizing that my discomfort is trying to rush me towards certainty and that I am about to act like a big old jerk to get my way. And that's why mindfulness is not about clearing your mind. It's about becoming aware of your mind. It's about learning to observe thoughts instead of immediately obeying them. Because once you can step back and notice your thoughts, instead of fusing with

the stories that you make of them, you become far more capable of being genuinely curious. Curious about your own experience, but definitely curious about others. Allows you this opportunity to act with more humility and grace and accountability and growth, which are all components of emotional maturity and emotional intelligence. You become far more capable of saying, you know, maybe I don't know everything, which turns out to be one of the healthiest and most psychologically flexible things that a person can say. And ironically, that's often the moment real learning finally begins.

Okay, back to the data on our emotions traveling faster than our logical brain. The actual research suggests that that gap can be anywhere from, again, twice as fast to 10 times as fast, depending on what study you look at. And while that number is debated, the phenomenon is not. Your emotions get there first. Now, imagine the same scene, but with a different person walking the trail. This person has been meditating regularly for, we'll just say, close to 10,000 hours. And that number, if it sounds familiar, it's borrowed from Malcolm Gladwell's book, Outliers, which has put forth that popular idea that 10,000 hours of practice

is what separates true mastery from everything else. And fun fact, the 10,000 hour rule is actually disputed if you really look at the academic research, but it's stuck in the zeitgeist or the culture as a marker for somebody who's truly devoted themselves to a thing. And it certainly isn't going to hurt if someone has done a thing for 10,000 hours. My point is, I just want you to know, this person is a full Zen and mindfulness guru, a meditation master, if you will. Here's what's fascinating. The snake-shaped stick is still there.

The loud sound to the right is still loud. And that low road still fires. That's a hardwired survival circuit. And I just want you to know that no amount of meditation removes that survival instinct. this person still startles and they still might even scream and maybe pee just a little bit. But what happens after is what's different. In their brain, the connection between that amygdala and the prefrontal cortex, the regulating part of the brain, has now been wired stronger and faster by years of practice.

Years of practice, a meditation, a mindfulness practice. So this regulator that disseminates the information doesn't have to be consciously summoned. It's already online. The weight that's just a stick arrives almost on top of the scream and a little bit of the pee. The whole nervous system settles back to baseline, I want to say, in even faster milliseconds instead of longer milliseconds. And for somebody with this much practice, the research suggests that regulation has become automatic. It doesn't require conscious effort. It becomes part of the baseline.

And so that's not voodoo or woo-woo or magic. It's your neural wiring, and it's the reason why I am doing this episode today. Now, I am not claiming to be that person. Not yet. I would like to be closer to that and I'm on my way. I've recommended a mindfulness practice to just about every client who sat across from me for the past decade or more. And I've thought a lot about how people respond to that recommendation. And I started to think the responses break down into roughly three groups. About 25% of people aren't going to contemplate it at all.

And I understand that. The word meditation comes out of my mouth and they're already mentally checked out. And we'll maybe talk a little bit later about why. It might just sound like hocus pocus or witchcraft, I really appreciate the honesty that I have a client currently that had said, hey, I just want you to know there's a little bit of, are you trying to lead me astray? A little false prophet vibe here. And I said, thank you so much. If only I was that powerful. I didn't say that part, but the joke brain has to get that out there. But some people will just say, oh, no, that doesn't, I don't, I will never be doing that. Now, about 50% will do a couple of breathing exercises,

maybe download an app or two, run a guided meditation here and there, and convince themselves with the best of intentions that they are well on their way to enlightenment. And that is where they will stay. And I was there for a long time. About 25% will start an actual practice of daily meditation, stick with it, and then the work that I'm doing with them together moves at a noticeably different pace. So if I could hand you a pill, and I want to be really clear that pill doesn't exist, that would show you what your mind could look like a few months or a few years

into a consistent meditation practice, I really am convinced that people would walk out of my office and meditate in the waiting room that day. And then they wouldn't stop because you wouldn't want to go back to the relationship with your thoughts that you had before. For almost a decade, most of my career as a therapist, I was firmly, confidently, completely in that middle 50%. And I want to tell you about that because I think it matters that I'm not just telling the story from the outside. I was in it. You can go back and listen to podcast episodes where I would talk about meditating so often.

And the origin story is that during my intern years, a group of us were challenged to do a 30-day mindfulness practice with an app called Headspace, which I loved. And I took it on with the kind of enthusiasm that made me sound impressive when I talked about it. Downloaded the app. I quickly realized that I would set my phone for 13 minutes, 10 for the meditation, and three for the extra sleep that I would get when I would fall asleep during the intro. The soothing voice would start. Andy, it's amazing. I would take a couple of in-through-the-nose, out-through-the-mouth breaths. We'll get to that a little

bit later as well around the science behind the meditation practices. And I would be unconscious within just a couple of minutes. But I realized on podcasts, I talked about it like I was this meditation master. I had the vocabulary. I had the references. I didn't know what I didn't know. And I actually thought that, oh, this is life-changing. After all, I'd done a 30-day challenge. I was approaching guru status. I did that for years. And then about four years ago, I got invited to the Amen Clinic in the San Francisco Bay Area where they do brain scans with around a dozen other therapists and psychologists for a day of training.

And the facilitator opened the session with a guided meditation. And something about that particular meditation was different. And I got caught up in it in a way that I had not experienced before. When she eventually went around the room and asked each person what their experience was, I could not find my voice. I don't even know what was happening, which honestly, for me, is a relatively rare event. She eventually came back to me and I told the room, hey, I'm having a hard time finding the words. And then she asked me, well, hey, what hurts do you usually meditate to?

And I think I was a little bit immature, a little bit, a lot, or insecure because I had no idea what she was talking about. And like the rental car hurts. And I think I said as much. And then she rephrased it something about what frequency or what sound profile I used in my meditation practice. And I think I'm still giving her a blank stare. So then she gave me an example and I don't remember the exact, I just know the joke that I told after, but let's just say that she said, okay, what do you do? Like 47 Hertz. And at this point I did what I do when I absolutely have no idea what's going

on in a room full of professionals. I reached for a joke. And for anybody who hasn't seen the 1983 Michael Keaton vehicle called Mr. Mom. There's a scene where Keaton's character, Jack, has just been laid off and his wife has gone back to work as the primary breadwinner. And her boss, Ron, shows up at the door, I believe, to pick up his wife. And Jack is desperate to project competence and masculinity. So he greets Ron. Ron's holding a chainsaw and has these safety goggles on. And he starts bragging about how he's using his time off to add a whole new wing to the house and completely rewire the walls himself.

Now, Ron, the boss, who actually knows what he's talking about, casually asks Jack, you know, wire it for 220, which I had to Google, of course, standard high voltage power for heavy appliances. And Jack, who knows nothing about any of this, looks at him dead in the eye and says, yeah, 220, 221, whatever it takes. I think about that line often. It makes me laugh every time. So when the facilitator said 47 Hertz, I am afraid to say that I believe I responded with, yeah, you know, 47, 48, whatever it takes. Looking around, anybody? Oh man, tough crowd. But what I learned that day was very real.

And she walked me through a concept called binaural beats, soundscapes, frequencies, and a half a dozen other concepts I had never come across in the years that I had been pretending to be a meditation guru. So I went home and I started actually exploring and Googling and experimenting. And I found a couple of apps that I genuinely connected with. And what started that week has now turned into roughly four plus years of a daily meditation practice to the point where now I can say it just is. It's part of who I am. And I know I'm not a guru status. I'm nowhere near it. But I know that now in a way that I didn't know it then.

But I know that I'm also on a path I genuinely love. And the deeper I go, the more I want to learn and the more I recognize the impact that the mindfulness practice has made in my life. And I will own my projection that I want that for all of you as well, because it's a game changer. So let's get a couple of definitions out of the way first, because I think this is going to clear up a lot of confusion right from the start. And I'm guessing that I've already used the terms meditation and mindfulness somewhat interchangeably. So meditation and mindfulness are actually not the same thing, even though most people do use the words interchangeably, as I have been doing.

Ironically, or honestly, once you understand the difference, then the whole topic starts to make a lot more sense. Meditation is the bigger umbrella term. Meditation is the name for all kinds of practices that people have been doing for thousands of years to become more aware, more grounded, more present, more connected, spiritually, emotionally, mentally, physically, all of it. And just because I have a strong value of curiosity, I will share a little bit of what I found about history. Because you can trace meditation practices back to Buddhist traditions around

the 5th and 6th centuries BCE. And then there was a type of meditation that developed in China around the same time. And I also want to spend a minute on the fact that a lot of people genuinely don't realize this, but that Christianity has a very deep contemplative and meditative tradition too. Because a lot of people hear the word meditation and then they immediately think, okay, that's Eastern religion. That's not me. And they will put up a wall. But if you look at it from a sense of silent contemplative practices,

those have existed inside Christianity for centuries. If you look back in the third through the fifth centuries, there were these people called the Desert Fathers, and they literally went out into the deserts of Egypt and Syria and spent hours and hours in silence and prayer. And in the Eastern Orthodox tradition, there's a practice that I won't butcher the name, where people repeat the Lord's Prayer over and over, often timed with their breathing, which functions real similarly to a mantra meditation practice.

So, it's more about these moments where people describe feeling deeply present, connected, peace, aware, humbled, grounded, or even just temporarily less consumed by their own constant stream of thoughts and being aware that they are going to step outside of their ego. Moments where they feel more connected to God or to humanity or to nature or just to something bigger than themselves. Somebody might spend time in silent prayer or meditation and then suddenly realize that they aren't as trapped in anxiety or resentment as they normally were,

or they may feel an overwhelming sense of compassion or clarity or gratitude or awe or acceptance. And that doesn't come when you are constantly occupied, especially if your mind is racing with the what's wrong with me, I'm broken, I can't believe people did that to me. So sometimes just being able to come back to the present, breathing, we'll talk about this more, allows you to then make a pivot to gratitude. And sometimes people describe it as feeling fully present for the first time

in their lives instead of constantly replaying the past or worrying about the future. It's more about this idea of slowing down, becoming aware, sitting with yourself, observing your thoughts, noticing your reactions. That's not new. And I think that humans have actually been trying to figure out how to do this for a very, very long time. I cut my teeth in counseling in the Christian community. My internship was for a church organization for several years. I became very aware early on of the skepticism, or a lot of times it was outright

negativity around meditation and mindfulness from maybe we'll call them more staunch conservative Christian clients. And then I've heard feedback from my more conservative Christian listeners. And I think if I'm being really honest, there was a time that I was also in that camp a little bit myself. I already had kind of prejudged anything that came from the East, which now feels a little funny to admit out loud, because at this point in my life, I'm pretty convinced that humans have all been trying to figure out the exact same thing pretty much since the dawn of time. We're all trying to make sense of suffering and discomfort and fear and uncertainty

and relationships and purpose. And why am I here? And where am I going? All of it, because we're wired to try and alleviate discomfort and we desperately seek certainty. And sometimes it feels a whole lot easier, I think, for people to go and try and find a guru, a leader, a pastor, a system, a certainty dealer of some sort and say, okay, just tell me what to do. Because then if things don't work out, we can shrug our shoulders and say, well, I guess happiness and success just weren't in the cards because that can feel a lot safer than taking absolute ownership of your own growth and your life and realizing,

that maybe you actually are capable of far more than you've been led to believe, because I genuinely believe that people are good from the factory. That's their factory setting. And I think that you already have within you so much of what you need. And then your hero's journey is to go and do and explore, but also fail and learn and experience and connect and struggle and grow and slowly figure out who you actually are. But I will be the first to admit that I have spent a lot of emotional calories over the years, operating from this place when I'm trying to talk about these

concepts with a lot of clients where I'm putting off this, hey, I come in peace energy, where. I felt like I needed to first explain Christian roots of mindfulness and meditation before some people would even consider trying it. Otherwise, there was this risk of immediately getting written off as some kind of new age hippie, which honestly, I'm beginning to realize might not be the worst thing in the world to be called. That label may vibe with me more than I've historically been willing to acknowledge. So back to this. Under this big meditation umbrella, there are all kinds of different practices.

Some are focused on calming the mind. Some on absolute awareness. Some on compassion. Some on connection. Some are about learning how to stay in the present moment for eight seconds at a time. You've got concentration meditation where you practice keeping your attention on one thing like you're breathing or a candle or a sound. And every time your mind wanders, which it absolutely will, you gently bring it back. And then there are mantra-based practices like transcendental meditation where you silently repeat a word or a phrase over and over to help settle the mind and quiet some of the mental noise.

That's where you see the stereotypical person chanting OM and you can find your own mantra and it can be anything. It can be a word, a sound, a phrase. And then there's one called Metta, which is loving kindness meditation, which honestly sounds a little bit cheesy until you try it. It's one of my favorite kinds where you are intentionally practicing feelings of compassion and goodwill first toward yourself and then others. And you're repeating phrases like, may I be safe? May I be healthy? May I be at peace? And then extending those same wishes toward other people.

There are visualization practices where you picture calming scenes, meaningful experiences. I've done a little bit of sports therapy. I won't say sports psychology. I'm not a psychologist. I'm a therapist. Where you are, though, picturing what is going to happen, shooting a free throw, making a putt, practicing these meaningful experiences, or even mentally rehearsing becoming the kind of person that you want to be. And you've got movement-based meditations, which are things I want to get more into, like Tai Chi or things like yoga, where the goal is to stay fully present while moving slowly and intentionally through different movements and different breathing patterns.

And then there's contemplative prayer, where instead of talking at God or trying to perform spiritually, people sit quietly and they listen and they reflect and they breathe and they try to become more aware and connected in order to hopefully receive guidance from the divine. And even though all these practices look different on the surface, they share one really important thing in common. They're all training attention. They're helping people become more aware of where their mind goes and what pulls them away from the present moment and then how to gently come back.

Even though they share that mechanism, they're often aiming at very different experiences and even different outcomes. I think one of the biggest misconceptions about mindfulness is that the goal is to stop thinking altogether and somehow completely clear your mind. I don't believe that is actually the goal or that it's even possible. But I can remember one of my favorite podcast hosts, and someone was talking about a mindfulness practice meditation. And I remember that was the first thing that he said, and he has such a large following.

And he said, I've tried it a couple And there's no way I can clear my mind. I can't just stop all my thinking. And then the person on the interview with him said, exactly. That's why I just think that stuff is basically a bunch of hot air. And I thought, oh, man, the scope, the reach that this podcast host has that unfortunately so many people and he trends toward a younger audience. And I thought so many people just heard that and said, you're right. I'm out. I don't need to worry about that. It is not the goal. You can't just stop thinking. Your brain thinks. It's what brains do.

So the goal is not to eliminate thought. The goal is to change your relationship with your thoughts. Because if you are sitting there paying attention to your breathing, noticing the sensation of the air coming in through your nose, feeling your chest expand, noticing the coolness of your breath, feeling your belly rise and fall, and then slowly breathing back out. In that moment, You aren't simultaneously spiraling into the what is wrong with me or why did I say that embarrassing thing years ago or what if everybody secretly hates me?

And granted, there is a huge possibility that the second you stop paying attention to your breathing, your brain may immediately wander right back to those thoughts. And so I can understand because I was there for so long of why someone will think, what's the point? But that is the point and it is such a trusting the practice of meditation or trusting the mindfulness practice, because you're slowly but surely realizing that when you notice that you are spiraling,

that you can catch that process and come back to the present moment before you've already catastrophized everything and before your heart rate is elevated and before you're losing access to your prefrontal cortex. But I could go on that rant for a little bit here. So it's normal to then go back to the thoughts that are unproductive. That is the practice of coming back to the present moment, kind of over and over again. And I sometimes think of it as this catch and release.

You catch yourself getting hooked by a thought, a worry, a memory, a judgment, or a story. And then instead of wrestling with it, trying to fix it or become it, you simply notice it and it's as if you are releasing it. Then you gently bring your attention back to the present moment over and over again. And that repetition is. Is the practice. And we'll get into a whole lot more as we go through this episode. And I'm noticing that I am hoping that made you potentially, yeah, but that all a bit, I would love to know what it is that seems difficult,

challenging, off-putting, or if you lost focus right now and you're not paying attention, then come on back to the present and shoot me an email, contact at TonyOverbay.com and let me know. So back to mindfulness. So mindfulness then is one specific practice under that umbrella of meditation. But it's also a quality of awareness that can show up outside of a formal meditative practice because you can eat mindfully, walk mindfully, wash dishes mindfully, workout mindfully, run ultramarathons mindfully. And I have stories for so many of these that eating mindfully,

this wasn't my experience, but I was working with a couple of therapists at one point in a group practice and they went and did a training. One of them described to me a guy that came in and was talking about ways to be present. And if I remember the story correctly, she said that he talked for about 15 minutes about eating a blueberry. And at first I wanted to make fun of it, but she described that he showed you how you can be so present and just appreciate everything from the smell of the blueberry, the skin of the blueberry, the color of the blueberry.

What does it remind you of when you taste it? You can be so in the moment present and appreciate the taste and feel it go over your taste buds and make this an incredibly present experience. And when I was really getting into mindfulness and it was starting to click. I would notice that even as I would do a push-up, because I really enjoy push-ups, a mindful push-up is you are feeling every bit of the sensation of your muscles contracting and expanding. And where I'm going with this is you find that you can usually do a few more

push-ups when you are looking at it as I am so present in this moment, noticing the way that my body is showing up and reacting, that it also made my workout seem a bit better. And one of the first times that I ran the Tahoe ultra marathon. It's a hundred mile race around Lake Tahoe and then some of the trails there and the elevation is high. And if you don't go acclimate to the elevation. For, I think, a couple of weeks at least, which I didn't have the opportunity to do, your heart is going to feel like it's beating out of your ears.

And there were certain climbs where I would notice that my heart rate was very elevated and my breathing would become labored. And in those moments, I would focus on the feeling in my legs every moment. And it wasn't the feeling of euphoria in my legs. Sometimes it was a feeling of pain in my legs, but it was an embracing of that pain. And you may be wondering at this point, why the ultramarathons? But that is a podcast for another day as I'm learning more and more about my emotions and where they come from, from childhood. What was I running from? But then when my legs would burn, then I would focus on my breathing.

And I did that back and forth for quite a while whenever I would, when I would get to a challenging place in the ultramarathon. You can have a very mindful conversation and be so in the moment and notice that I'm wanting to cue up a response versus be back in the present moment and be curious. Term mindfulness was actually coined back in 1881 by a scholar named T.W. Rhys Davids while translating an old Buddhist word sati. Sati roughly meant to remember, specifically to remember, to bring your attention back to what's actually happening right now.

And the modern clinical version, I think that most people know today, comes from a guy named Jon Kabat-Zinn. He's a fascinating person. He was a molecular biologist and a longtime meditator who then in 1979 founded a program called Mindfulness-Based Stress Reduction, or MBSR, at the University of Massachusetts Medical School. So his goal was pretty straightforward. He wanted to take practices that had helped him personally and then offer them to people struggling with chronic pain and stress in a way that didn't require anybody to adopt a religion or convert to anything.

So when I go a little bit overboard in this episode and try to make sense of the fact that as working in a faith community as a therapist for so long and working with primarily people that are of the Christian faith, when they would see mindfulness or meditation as something that is so. Unfamiliar or foreign that they would often view it as bad, I get the sense that here's Jon Kabat-Zinn saying, this thing that has helped me so much, I want to get it to people, but I don't want them to think that it's crazy. He essentially then stripped away any kind of religious vibe or framing and

then kept the practices and built a basically a standard clinical program around it. The core practices include things like body scans, where you slowly move your awareness through different parts of your body, sitting meditation focused on your breathing, mindful movement that looks a lot like kind of a gentle yoga. And then he is also a big fan of walking meditation. So that is a fun thing as well. You don't actually have your music or audio book on and you are just being so present in moment and noticing things like the sound of the birds and just the sounds around you and the smells and I love a walking meditation as well.

Now, at this point, there are literally thousands of studies looking at mindfulness-based interventions for things like chronic pain and anxiety, depression, sleep, stress, even immune functioning. And I know that there is some research out around how meditation or mindfulness practice is also a huge component in helping people overcome unhealthy coping mechanisms, even addictions like coronography. So when you hear people say things like mindfulness has been shown to reduce anxiety or people are trying to make it more clinical, they're usually talking about the research that has been done around mindfulness-based stress reduction

or one of the offshoots. There's one called mindfulness-based cognitive therapy. I would say the cleanest way to think about all this is all mindfulness meditation is meditation, but not all meditation is mindfulness. But for the rest of the episode, I'm primarily going to focus on mindfulness because that's a practice that I've personally been doing for. I think in a serious way for four or five years now. And then it's where a lot of the clinical research lives. I'm a big fan of explaining things as what they are, but also what they aren't. So let's talk about that. Mindfulness is paying attention to what's happening right now.

Your breath, your body, sounds, sensations, thoughts, without trying to change it or judge it. That's the whole thing. And I think it's one of the most beautiful things where there isn't necessarily a wrong way to do mindfulness. And often the guided meditations that I like, when I first started doing them, I would lay down and I would often think, man, is that okay? Because they would typically say, Hey, sit somewhere and your spine's long and pull your shoulders back. But then I would recognize that the more that I'm doing them,

the more different people that are guiding the meditations would say, or, or whatever, If you're laying down, that's great, but it's really just showing up. And Jon Kabat-Zinn's working definition is paying attention on purpose in the present moment, non-judgmentally. So a quick list of what mindfulness is not, because the misconceptions I think are the reasons that most people quit before they get anywhere. Again, not about stopping thoughts. Your brain produces thoughts the same way your ears produce hearing. They're going to pick up sound whether you want them to or not. The part that you have some sort of control over though is what you do with

what shows up or what you notice or what you focus on or what you cling to or what you ignore, what you make meaning out of. Thoughts work the same way. They arrive. The practice is what do you do with them once they're there? So not about emptying your mind. Same reason, it's not about feeling calm. Some sessions you feel calm. And I got stuck on this for a while is I would think that it was a good meditation or mindfulness session if my heart rate was below a certain, it was like I was gamifying mindfulness. But then one of the most powerful meditations that I had was one where I think a client had canceled.

And I just thought, okay, I haven't meditated today. So, I put my headphones in, I fire up a meditation, and I'm a couple of minutes into it. And then I think, you know what, I should take more advantage of this hour because I have plenty of things to do. And I'm good. I don't need to meditate right now. And that particular meditation, the person guiding it said, and whatever your thought is right now, thank it, and then come back to the present. And my thought was, I think I don't need to do this right now. And then the The person was saying, okay, so now notice that thought and thank

your brain for giving you the thought and then come back and let's do a quick body scan. And I just remember thinking, oh, this, this is a challenge. So it was actually making me feel a little bit more. It wasn't this getting into this calm state and hitting this Hertz particular brain wave electrical Hertz, where I just felt so in the vibe. Oh no, that was a tricky meditation session. Yet I remember it to this day of how powerful it was. So some sessions you will potentially feel agitated, restless, bored, sad, or kind of wired up.

None of that's a failure. The skill that you're building is the noticing, and it's the practice of, not the feeling. And it isn't religious. The roots are Buddhist, but the secular clinical version has been studied in thousands of trials and works regardless of what you believe. What's fascinating is it isn't always an escape. It's actually showing up for you. It's a huge form of self-care. And that's one of the things that has really changed my relationship with a mindfulness practice with meditation is when I say that one of the.

One of the things that we need to do more of is self-care. Self-care is not selfish. It's showing up for yourself. And so therefore, a practice of meditation every day, regardless of how long it is, is a form of self-care. It's something that is going to pay off, even though it doesn't feel like it will at first. It's showing up for yourself. And it isn't a state that you achieve once and own forever. You don't all of a sudden become Zen and it is locked in. It's a practice. And the minute you stop practicing, the muscle will start to fade. There have been times before this current run of a few years where I would start

to gain some ground on changing that relationship with my thoughts to the point of where then I thought I was pretty good at it. So then I would lay off the gas of doing the practice and how quickly your mind can go back to this home base. Now, I would like to say that I've done it long enough now that my home base is more from this place of noticing and building in that pause. So now let's get into the good stuff. these binaural beats and brainwaves and some of the, let's even go down the conspiracy theory rabbit hole, because this is the fun part. This is one of the reasons why I know that this

episode is going to go long, because I just think this stuff's fascinating. So your brain runs on electricity. The cells in your brain, the neurons, they fire in these rhythmic patterns, and those rhythms get measured in cycles per second. And the unit for that is hertz, abbreviated HC. 20 cycles per second would be 20 hertz. And over time, researchers have found that different mental states tend to line up with different dominant brainwave patterns. So as I mentioned in the opening, when the person at the Amen Clinic was asking me, what hertz do you typically try and meditate to?

This is what I learned in starting to look at what that even means. Here's a quick roadmap. Delta waves are around 0.5 to 4 hertz. And those are what are typically showing up during deep dreamless sleep. Theta waves, 4 to 8 hertz, tend to show up in deep meditation, kind of when you're feeling drowsy or those moments right before you drift off to sleep. Alpha waves are around 8 to 13 hertz, and that's when it's a more relaxed alertness. That's a pretty fun vibe to be in.

You're awake, you're calm, you're present, you're maybe sitting quietly at the end of a long day, finally letting your body exhale a little bit. That is an area that I really enjoy that I will sometimes try to find myself in a meditative state. Beta waves, 13 to roughly 30 hertz are active thinking, problem solving, conversations, emails, decision making, mentally juggling life. And then you've got these gamma waves that are above 30 Hertz. And those are typically associated with really high level processing. And interestingly, some long-term meditators show unusually strong gamma activity,

during deep meditation practice, which can seem like a paradox. But I think it's one of the deepest concepts of life where two things can happen at once. One way that I like to think about this is like an old school radio dial. So different radio stations carry different kinds of experiences. There's the loud, fast-paced, urgent talk radio station where everybody's debating and solving problems theoretically and reacting and arguing and analyzing, but essentially trying to win. That's a lot like the beta waves. Then there's a calmer station, maybe late night smooth jazz or acoustic music where your body starts to settle

in a little bit. That's more like alpha wave territory. Then theta is this dreamy, floaty sensation you drift into right before sleep. And then delta waves are basically when the radio station fades into a deep, steady nighttime hum. Maybe it's just the record playing over and over and over and the DJ fell asleep. But the point isn't that one station is good and another is bad because you actually need basically all of them. The problem is that many people are essentially living their entire lives mentally tuned into urgent daytime talk radio.

And then wondering why on earth does my nervous system feel completely exhausted all the time. So mindfulness, meditation, they don't magically erase your thoughts. They help you learn how to change the channel a little bit. Or maybe more accurately, they help you realize that you are allowed to change the channel. Or you might even recognize that, oh, I am on a particular channel. That would make sense why I feel a certain way. And, and I want to talk about this thing called entrainment, and then we'll go a little bit more into the binaural beats. Entrainment is basically what happens when two things that move in rhythm start syncing up with each other.

And one of the earliest examples of this was back in the 1600s. And there was this Dutch scientist named Christian Huggins. He had these two pendulum clocks and they were hanging on the same wall. And he noticed that even if he started them swinging at completely different times, after a while, they would slowly fall into sync with each other. It was like the tiny vibrations moving through the wall were enough to pull them into the same rhythm. And honestly, once you know about entrainment, you start to see it everywhere. I was on a run last week and I had written some of this part of the podcast, the outline, and there were two people that were skating on this trail.

I lived by this trail by a wash in Arizona. And there were two people coming at me and they were roller skating. And it was wild because I saw them coming from so far away and they both, the arms were in rhythm, the feet were It was so fascinating. And then I think I yelled something to that effect when I passed by and they probably thought, what are you saying, old man? But you see it when people start unconsciously matching each other's walking pace or when a crowd at a concert claps in rhythm or when drummers naturally lock into the same tempo without talking about it. And the more you look at the research around entrainment, there was a pretty

funny article I read about fireflies that fireflies are lightning bugs, as some call them. In some parts of the world will literally flash and sink across an entire field. And even babies tend to gradually sink their breathing and heart rate with the parents holding them. This concept of co-regulation that I'm fascinated by, because it's as if humans are rhythm matching creatures. Brainwave entrainment is basically the same idea applied to the brain. The theory is that if your brain is exposed to a steady rhythm, like a sound, or a beat, or even flashing lights, that your brain may begin to sync some of its own electrical activity to that rhythm.

And the most common example that people talk about today is this thing called binaural beats. Simple version of how they work. And I did not understand this at all at first. And I thought that binaural beats were essentially why we like to hear the ocean or a babbling brook, but we'll talk about that. But let's say that you put your headphones on and your left ear, here's a tone at 200 cycles per second. And your right ear, here's a slightly different tone at 210 cycles per second. Your brain essentially, as I understand it, splits the difference and then perceives a third rhythmic pulse at 10 cycles per second or 10 Hertz, which happens to

land right in that relaxed alpha wave range that I mentioned earlier. So the theory is that by listening to these tones, that it might gently nudge the brain toward a calmer, more relaxed state. And here's the part where I think it is, I will own the fact that we're going to separate interesting from a proven miracle, because. If you search the topic of binaural beats online for more than about three or four minutes, you'll quickly find people claiming that they can unlock super human focus, astral projection, manifest abundance, basically become some sort of wizard through specific sound frequencies.

Now, the science appears to be a little more grounded in that the research does not necessarily suggest that that is the case. But here's where we get into things like, I don't know what I don't know, the placebo effect. And if something is working for someone, who on earth am I to say, yeah, that's ridiculous. That doesn't make sense. Because I found a fair amount of research that suggests things like binaural beats may help with things like anxiety reduction, relaxation, pain management. If it gets into that alpha wave range, some studies involving surgical patients

found lower anxiety levels compared to if they just had silence or even just regular music. And there's also some early evidence around stress reduction and relaxation. But when it comes to bigger claims, like you can dial in any mental state on demand or while you sleep or permanently alter consciousness through the frequencies alone, the evidence, I'll just say, gets much weaker and there's a lot less consistency. My honest takeaway is probably this. There does appear to be something real happening, but it's smaller, maybe less dramatic and far less magical than the

marketing or sales pages often make it sound. Wow. Isn't that shocking? Which I think feels like a pretty common theme throughout today's episode. Things that genuinely help us are often less flashy than we want them to be. And they typically take longer than we would like for them to take. Back to these natural sounds. Sounds like ocean waves and rain and wind through the trees or a babbling stream. Those things seem to work through a slightly different mechanism. And I think this is one of those cool places where I want to be careful not to overstate things or drift into bro science or magical thinking.

But here's the basic idea. Steady natural sounds actually are often the sound signature of a stable environment. If you think about it from an evolutionary perspective, birds chirping, leaves rustling, water flowing are actually all signs that nothing disruptive or dangerous has interrupted the environment. Your nervous system isn't necessarily calming down because water sounds are magical, which is part of what I used to think. It's calming down because the environment feels predictable and continuous. The real alarm signal in nature usually isn't the sound itself.

It's the sudden change in the sound. So if you're walking through the woods and you hear birds chirping and the wind moving and leaves rustling, your brain gradually settles in and says, OK, things seem pretty normal. And it's happening maybe in the subconscious. But then if all the birds suddenly stop or there's an unexpected crack of a branch or complete silence where there should be sound, your nervous system immediately perks up because sudden changes in predictable patterns often signal potential danger. And we go back to that's the mechanism of the low road of your brain immediately

saying, heads up, for anyone that's a little bit older, if you ever watched the show called MASH, which was a comedy, but it was based in, I think, the Vietnam War era. There was a guy named radar radar could hear the helicopters off in the distance and so he would always know oh choppers and so they were a medical unit and they would get ready but every now and again in every few episodes there would be a wait do you hear that, and then people would say i don't hear anything oh that's the point and so it's speaking to this or i think there's a scene in one or two of the jurassic park

movies where it was the calm right before then the t-rex lost his mind. Because I would imagine every animal that now realizes that the T-Rex is stomping through the forest just went quiet because they know if they make noise, then they're going to get eaten. So why rain sounds, ocean waves, or streams feel calming is because they're broad and they're repetitive and they're predictable enough that your brain eventually stops scanning them for new information. Your nervous system gets a break. Now that mechanism is actually different from another concept that I thought

was more similar. And I've talked about it on previous episodes. It's called apophenia. Apophenia is the brain's tendency to create meaning or patterns out of random information. And it came from a German psychiatrist named Kloss Conrad back in the 1950s. So apophenia is when the grass moves and your brain immediately thinks snake. Or when three unrelated things happen in the same week and suddenly you're convinced that the universe is trying to send you a message. And maybe it is, but the pattern is fascinating. Or if you see faces in clouds or in electrical outlets or burnt toast or on

the surface of Mars, but that visual version even has its own name, which is pareidolia. And what's really interesting is that the two mechanisms that work here where hearing sounds to make your nervous system feel okay, and then seeing patterns that make your nervous system on high alert are opposites. With calming natural sounds, your nervous system is accurately recognizing stability and relaxing because of it. But with apophenia, your nervous system's actively trying to detect patterns out of uncertainty or randomness as a form of threat detection.

Because from an evolutionary standpoint, it was so much safer for your brain to occasionally overreact and think there might be a snake in the grass than to miss the one time that there really was a very dangerous snake in the grass. So when a babbling brook calms you, that's your nervous system responding to continuity and predictability. When you suddenly think you're seeing your ex's car everywhere after a breakup, that's apophenia. Same nervous system, very different mechanisms. And let me spend a couple minutes too on why we aren't big fans of silence. Then it can even explain more of why the goal is not to clear your mind.

Because this also goes back to evolutionary perspective and a survival instinct. Because the data here sits at this pretty cool intersection of neuroscience and evolution and psychology and learning theory and attachment and modern technology. even on the whole. Because what are we supposed to do? Not listen to a bunch of things when we have so many things that we can listen to so easily and with such amazing quality. But the important thing is not to frame this as people are weak because they can't sit quietly. Our brains were never really designed for the modern level of stimulation that we now live with.

Your brain is basically a prediction engine, a survival machine. It's constantly scanning for problems, threats, opportunities, social standing, uncertainty, discomfort, unfinished business. And when the external stimulation goes quiet, internal stimulation tends to get louder, which means silence often doesn't feel very peaceful, especially at first. It starts to feel more revealing. And there's research showing that many people genuinely dislike being alone with their thoughts. One of the most famous studies out of the University of Virginia found that

when people were left alone in a room with no phones, no distractions, and nothing to do for about 15 minutes, many of the participants found the experience so unpleasant that they choose to give themselves a mild electric shock rather than sit quietly with their thoughts. And honestly, that's kind of funny, kind of disturbing, but really human. From an evolutionary perspective, a constantly scanning brain made sense because our ancestors benefited from hypervigilance. The people who occasionally overreacted to possible danger were more likely

to survive than the people who said, you know, that rustling in the bush, probably not a. So our nervous systems became so good at monitoring for uncertainty and discomfort and is this safe or not. So now layer modern life on top of all that music, podcasts, scrolling, YouTube, social media, TikTok, Instagram, text, notifications, streaming, constant background noise. All of these things provide what neuroscientists sometimes call attentional capture.

They occupy mental bandwidth, which means they can temporarily reduce awareness of uncomfortable internal experiences like anxiety, loneliness, shame, boredom, grief, insecurity, or existential uncertainty. I think you often hear adults, the older ones like myself, say the kids these days, they need to learn how to be bored. But then when they come to a parent and say, I'm bored, then that makes the parent feel anxious. And to get rid of the parent's anxiety, they often then need, they try to figure out a way to entertain the kid. And now you're developing this interesting, I was going to say unhealthy,

but an interesting co-regulation dynamic. That's the normal. That becomes the familiar. But back to the silence piece, it's not inherently, I'm not going to say it's bad that we want to listen to things all the time because podcasts and music and audio books, those things can absolutely enrich your life. And I am literally building a career around hopefully meaningful content that helps people regulate and grow and feel less alone. The issue isn't necessarily the stimulation itself. But I think the issue is whether we still know how to be with ourselves when

the stimulation stops. And I think that requires stopping the stimulation on a regular basis. Because if every quiet moment immediately gets filled, your brain never really learns that it can safely exist without constant external input. And over time, what we're doing, I think, is unintentionally training ourselves to avoid stillness because then stillness becomes associated with discomfort. And I think there's also a dopamine component to all of this. Novelty, unpredictability, and stimulation activate these reward pathways in the brain.

A new song, notification, new clip, headline, or new episode gives the nervous system a little orienting response of, okay, something new. Modern technology has become this infinite buffet of novelty, new, and our brains are highly responsive to the new. And there's a thing that I think is even deeper. For a lot of people, constant stimulation is actually emotional avoidance, but it's dressed up as productivity or just self-care or entertainment. Because the second things get quiet, thoughts show up. Am I okay?

Do people actually like me? What if I'm failing? What do I really fear? Did I say the wrong thing? What if I'm unhappy? What if I don't know who I am without all this noise? Mindfulness starts teaching something radically different. It teaches that thoughts and feelings can be noticed without immediately escaping them, solving them, suppressing them, or distracting from them, which is why mindfulness can initially feel uncomfortable before it starts to become somewhat calming. You're never failing in meditation when your thoughts get loud.

It's actually this avoidance of if somebody is so worried about the fact that they won't be able to stop thinking. You're finally hearing what was always there and learning that you still survive, and this too shall pass. Back to binaural beats, just for a beat, pun intended. Now's the time where I want to do a little conspiratorial work because one of the apps that I do use for meditation, and I've used a lot, so I've enjoyed Headspace. I've used Calm. Currently, I really, if you're a Peloton user, first find me on the Peloton app.

It would be great to be friends. I like the meditation section of the Peloton app. Some of the instructors are so good and calming and present. I think they're very intentional about the music that they put in the background. One of the apps I also use for meditation is one called Expand. And it's by the Monroe Institute. I like Bookspan because of their sound technology. The founder, Robert Monroe, was originally a radio executive back in the 1950s and 60s, and he became fascinated with altered states of consciousness, initially because of his own reported out-of-body experiences,

which depending on your personality type either sounds incredibly fascinating, or immediately makes you want to slowly back away from this conversation and say that, okay, maybe Tony is kind of crazy. But Monroe eventually founded this institute named after him in Virginia in the late 1970s. And he developed something called HemiSync Technology, which is short for hemispheric synchronization, which honestly sounds like super intimidating or scientific more so than I think it is. The basic idea was that certain sound patterns and binaural beats might help

synchronize activity between the two hemispheres of the brain and then guide people into deeper states of relaxation or meditation or awareness. And I have found, I call it, it's swishy sounds. And I do, I can just put the swishy sounds on and without anything else, and that's not even a guided meditation. And I can find myself entering a pretty nice state of awareness or consciousness. And then the Monroe Institute developed these different focus levels, like focus 10, focus 12, focus 15. And I've done a couple of online trainings, done some of these. And it's fascinating because some of it seems, and to me, it can feel or seem

a little hokey, but boy, it really does get me into this state. And each of these, Focus 10, 12, 15, supposedly represent progressively deeper mental states or expanded awareness. So here's where the story gets interesting enough that the internet absolutely goes wild with it. And who's to know what is true? The U.S. Army and the intelligence communities actually did study some of this stuff during the 1980s. And there's even a now declassified Army report called the Gateway Process that explored the Monroe Institute's methods and whether altered states of consciousness could potentially have military and intelligence applications.

And I would imagine for many, because I think I'm there at times as well, the second that we hear CIA gateway process and altered states of consciousness. Now it's like, wait, are we going down the conspiracy theory route here together? And the answer is, I don't, maybe, probably not though. Because while the military apparently found it interesting enough to investigate, the later reviews basically concluded that the effects were too inconsistent to be reliably useful operationally, which is a very government way of saying interesting, but probably not psychic superpowers. But then when I chased this rabbit down its hole a little further,

then you immediately run into the, oh, that means it worked because of course the government doesn't say, nope, nothing to see here. Just ignore it. And meanwhile, we got people astral projecting behind enemy lines and then doing all kinds of crazy things. So I do think it's important to separate maybe the more grounded claims from the more sensational ones. The really big claims, things like unlocking hidden consciousness states or remote viewing or instantly rewiring your brain or getting 10 years of therapy in one session. Those ideas are people's ideas and they may not be supported by mainstream neuroscience and that's okay.

But the more modest claims, those have some science behind them. They may be a lot more reasonable. Can binaural beats help some people relax more deeply? Probably. Can they help people settle into meditation and stay focused for longer? It appears so. Can they encourage calmer brainwave states associated with relaxation? There's some pretty cool evidence pointing in that direction. And I'm good with all of that. Can they allow me to lucid dream and control my dreams? Because there's a section of that in the Moreau Institute, in the Expand app that I have used many times. And I've had some very fascinating

experiences with it and some not. But if something helps you sit still long enough to become more aware of yourself, your thoughts, your nervous system, your reactions, your breathing, your emotions, then I think it has value. It's a mechanism itself doesn't have to be magical for the practice to be really meaningful. Okay, just breathe. That is either one of the most calming and relaxing phrases or one of the most annoying if the people around you are telling you, just take a breath, just breathe. But this is the part with the most solid science. breath is the one input to

your nervous system that you do for the most part, unless something is really happening for you. You have direct voluntary control over. You can't actually decide to lower your heart rate or open up your blood vessels, but you can decide how to breathe. And it turns out that decision cascades into everything else because two systems are running in the background of your body at all times. There's the sympathetic nervous system, and that's like the gas pedal. Fight, flight, mobilize, keep you alert.

It makes your heart rate rise, your pupils dilate, your digestion slows down, your muscles tense. So this is what kicks in when somebody cuts you off in traffic. Then there's the parasympathetic nervous system. And that's more like the break. Rest, digest, recover, repair. Your heart rate is down. Your blood vessels relax. Your digestion is going well. It runs. Your immune system starts to work. This is what kicks in after a good meal when you feel like you could take a nap.

And you want both. And you want them both in balance, responding to what's actually happening around you. And you may have also heard of this thing called the vagus nerve, not like Viva Las Vegas, but Vegas V-A-G-U-S. Think of it like the main highway of the parasympathetic nervous system. It's the break side. It runs from your brainstem down through your neck. It branches out through your heart and your lungs and your gut. And it apparently connects to roughly 75% of all of the parasympathetic signaling.

So when the vagus nerve is firing, your body shifts toward recovery. And then the strength of that signaling, which is significant, is called the vagal tone. So you can think of it like the strength of the brake pedal in your car. A car with really good brakes stops smoothly and quickly when you need it to. But if you have a car with weak brakes, it takes forever to slow down and the ride is kind of jerky. If you have a strong vagal tone, it means that your nervous system can shift out of stress and then into recovery quickly and smoothly. And you can measure your vagal tone indirectly through something called heart

rate variability or HRV. And I think I'm starting to see more HRV numbers on different fitness apps, what that is. So your heart isn't actually beating like a metronome. Even at rest, the time between each beat is slightly different. And sometimes it's just a fraction of a second longer, sometimes a fraction of a second shorter. But that tiny variation, that's the heart rate variability. And then here's the, I would call it the counterintuitive part. More variation is a good thing, which is wild because it seems like one would

want their heart rate to be dialed in in this rhythmic flow. It turns out more variation is good. It means your nervous system is flexible and responsive. So a heart that would beat like a perfect metronome is actually a sign of a stuck nervous system. And the higher your heart rate variability, that generally means you have better vagal tone, which means better recovery and better emotional regulation and better cardiovascular health. Back to the breathing. Nasal breathing in. And I learned a little bit more about this even just doing

the research for this episode. Your nose isn't just an air intake. It actually filters dust and particles and it warms and it humidifies the air before it actually hits your lungs. And I think this is the part that is the science-y part that I think most people don't know, is it produces a chemical called nitric oxide. And nitric oxide gets made in the sinus spaces around your nose and it gets released into your nasal passages when you breathe in. So it kills off germs and it opens up your blood vessels, which then improves how well oxygen gets delivered to your tissues.

Now, when you breathe through your mouth, you skip all of that. And I will admit, insert joke here, I'm a bit of a mouth breather. But research has also shown that nasal breathing creates a small amount of resistance during the breath out, which helps keep your lung volume up and it supports oxygen levels in your blood. Mouth breathing reduces lung volume and reduces how efficiently oxygen gets from your lungs and your bloodstream. Nasal breathing also tends to slow your overall breathing rate, which on its own then activates that parasympathetic system or the break.

Now, exhale. Exhale through your mouth. Breathe in through your nose, out through your mouth. Out through your mouth is more of a practice technique than necessarily a real strict requirement. There's structured breathing exercises. They have number four, seven, an eight breathing or box breathing, breathing in for four seconds, holding for seven seconds, out for eight seconds, rinse and repeat. Or I know there have been a couple of meditations where then it's been stress that I exhale through kind of pursed lips that slows the out breath,

that slows the breathing out and it makes it audible so you can pace it. And it creates just a small amount of resistance that may even engage your diaphragm more fully. Now for everyday breathing in through the nose and out through the nose is fine. But if you're doing an active practice in through the nose and out through the mouth can be a pretty useful tool as well. And we want to exhale longer than you inhale. When you breathe in, your heart rate naturally speeds up a little bit. When you breathe out, it slows down. That's a built-in connection between

your breath and your heartbeat that's controlled by the vagus nerve. So if you make your exhale longer than your inhale, something like, let's say, four seconds in and six seconds out, or five in and seven out, you're spending more time in the slowing down phase of each breath cycle. Over a few minutes, this measurably increases your parasympathetic activity and it decreases anxiety. There was a 2021 study in scientific reports that found that just five minutes of deep, slow breathing with the exhale longer than the inhale increased parasympathetic

activity and then it decreased anxiety in both young and older adults. And I have also heard often about belly breathing. Expand your belly, not your chest. It's also called diaphragmatic breathing. And it's what happens when you let your diaphragm do the work instead of your upper chest. Because the diaphragm is a really big dome-shaped muscle that sits under your lungs, kind of like an upside-down bowl. And so when it contracts, it flattens downward, and then it pulls air into the lower part of your lungs, which then pushes your belly outward.

And then when it relaxes, it domes back up, and it pushes air out. And so most adults under chronic stress have learned to breathe shallowly into their upper chest. They do these quick, small breaths that kind of keep the sympathetic system or the gas pedal mildly activated all day long. Belly breathing will reverse that. Diaphragmatic breathing directly stimulates that vagus nerve. And so then it increases the parasympathetic activity. So when you breathe deeply, the diaphragm moves downward, your lungs expand fully, and your heart rate slows.

And this also triggers a built-in reflex that helps regulate your blood pressure. And a way to feel the difference is you can put one hand on your chest right now, one hand on your belly and breathe normally and notice which hand moves. If it's the chest hand, then you're more of a chest breather. If it's the belly hand, you're already doing it well. The goal in practice is the belly hand moving and the chest hand staying still. And I want to get into what a consistent practice would look like or what benefits it could have. And I start here with a quote, the neurons that fire together, wire together.

The basic idea is that when two neurons keep firing at the same time, then the connection between them gets stronger. The belief is that there are actual physical changes that happen in the cells, making it easier for them to trigger each other in the future. The principle is called heavy in learning or Hebb's rule. I really think the neurons that fire together wire together connects with meditation because every time that you sit down to practice noticing your breath, you're firing a specific set of neurons in a specific pattern. Every time you bring your attention back from the wander, you're firing the

notice and return circuit. So if you repeat that for days, months, years, then your wiring gets stronger. You get better at noticing. You get better at returning. And the skill becomes more automatic. The same principle then in reverse applies to anxious thought patterns. Every time you rehearse the catastrophic story that you are a horrible person or the problem, you wire that deeper as well. Every time that you replay resentment, you carve that groove a little more. And that's why years of a consistent regular practice is not the same as off

and on occasional sessions of meditation because that wiring is built by repetition. I'm acknowledging that I've been meditating regularly for going on four years. And I've paid attention to the things that I'm supposed to pay attention to as well, or at least I'm on that journey. Sleep, hydration, stress load. So by any reasonable measure, I should be a calm and grounded person, and most of the time I am. But I have also noticed my startle response is just right there on the edge. Loud noises, balloons popping, jump scares in movies.

I can be sitting on a couch, perfectly relaxed, and then a door slams, and I will notice that I am jumpy. And so I started really wondering if my fight or flight response isn't actually that far below the surface. Like the startle is just the visible spike of a system that's primed and ready to go. And it's just waiting for the slightest trigger. And I have had the thought that I needed to lengthen my runway. The idea being that if my resting heart rate is high, then I have less buffer between baseline and full activation, a startle, a stressor, a loud noise.

And then I'm airborne before I even know what happened. I began to wonder if I could bring my resting heart rate down overall, then I have more runway or more room to notice what's happening before my nervous system commits to fight or flight. So admittedly, that's been the model that I've been working with. So I decided to try and do as much research as I could to see if that's actually true. What I discovered is that intuition that I think that that might be what's happening, is actually more on target than what I would have guessed. That resting heart rate is one piece of the picture. But the more important

measure that I mentioned earlier is that heart rate variability, that beat-to-beat variation. Higher heart rate variability means your nervous system is flexible and can quickly shift between the gas pedal and the brake, depending on what the situation calls for. And that lower HRV means the system is stuck and usually stuck slightly on the gas with less capacity to shift back down. So there was a study published in 2014 that found that people with low resting heart rate variability showed exaggerated startle responses, even in neutral, harmless stimuli, meaning that their startle system was firing in situations where there really wasn't anything that was very threatening.

And then people with high heart rate variability showed a more appropriate startle response. I mean, they reacted strongly to genuinely threatening things, and they didn't overreact to neutral ones like a balloon popping. You could actually take them to a child's birthday party and they wouldn't be wincing every time a kid was just hanging onto a balloon. The researchers concluded that higher heart rate variability may allow people to more efficiently process emotional information and then better recognize the difference between threat and safety. The runway theory, I think, has a little bit of data behind it.

People with better vagal tone measured through this HRV, then it sounds like they do have a bigger gap between baseline and this full activation. So they startle less to harmless things and they recover faster from real threats. So that runway concept, I think, is real. So then what lengthens the runway? Sleep. Sleep deprivation reliably reduces HRV and it really tips your nervous system toward that gas pedal. And what I was not happy to find is that even one really bad night of sleep can measurably shrink your buffer.

And if you have a chronic sleep problem, then that trains your system to live in sort of a state of a low-grade alarm, exactly the state where the startle response sits just a millimeter below the surface. And then I've always known that hydration was important because even mild dehydration increases your resting heart rate, it increases stress hormones, and it decreases heart rate variability. And the reason is actually pretty simple. Less fluid in your system means your heart has to work harder to push blood around, and then your nervous system compensates by ramping up the gas pedal.

And then good old stress, chronic psychological stress keeps stress hormones elevated, which keeps the gas pedal lightly pressed, which keeps HRV depressed. And this isn't about an acute stressor, something that comes on and it lasts an hour or so. This is more of about a cumulative load that sits in the background for weeks or months. And then meditation itself helps, particularly the slow breathing practice that we just talked about. There was a clinical trial of slow-paced breathing training, and it showed that five weeks of practice increased the connection between two

specific brain regions, the amygdala and the medial prefrontal cortex, as well as the overall connectivity within the brain networks involved in things like emotion. And remembering that the amygdala is where that startle and the fight or flight signals originate. The medial prefrontal cortex is that regulator. So stronger wiring between them means the regulator gets to weigh in faster before the startle commits. And I tried to come up with a relatable example. So think of the amygdala more like a smoke alarm.

Its job is not to calmly assess whether there's actually a fire. Its job is to go off fast and loud and immediately, which honestly makes more sense from an evolutionary standpoint because if our ancestors paused too long to thoughtfully consider whether the rustling in the bushes was the tiger, then they would probably not be our ancestors. And then that medial prefrontal cortex is more like the old experienced fire chief arriving on the scene saying, okay, everybody calm down. Let's assess what's actually happening here. So then what mindfulness and slow

breathing appear to do is strengthen the connection between the alarm and the fire chief. So that the fire chief can weigh in sooner and the amygdala will listen to the fire chief before the entire nervous system has already flipped all the tables over and set the building on fire itself. So if you are even remotely new to the virtual couch, one of my favorite segments that I am somewhat inconsistent with is what have we learned today? And it harkens back to watching cartoons as a kid. And I swear on a Saturday morning cartoon, there was almost always a, what did we learn today?

We learned that kids can get along well, or that we shouldn't treat people unfairly, or it's always good to apologize for something that you've done wrong. All those kind of life lessons. For that portion today, what did we learn today? I think we've learned that mindfulness is the deliberate, repeatable practice of paying attention to what's happening right now without trying to change it. You're not trying to stop thought. You are beginning to notice. You're continuing to notice. And it just is. It's unfolding. It's okay to have a mind that is going a million miles an hour and then bring

it back to some breathing, even if it's just for a millisecond or two. And the science supporting it for anxiety, for emotional regulation, even physiological recovery is solid. The science supporting the more exotic claims, these perfect brain states from binaural beats or hemispheric synchronization, doing this so that it will cause an instant transformation. Maybe there's not as much science there and you don't actually need those exotic claims to start a mindfulness practice.

And if it's the placebo effect and you really do think that you've changed your life within two or three sessions, then who am I to say that there is anything, wrong with that or that just because the data doesn't back that up, that it isn't your experience? And the basic mechanisms are enough. If you want to start, start with the breath in through the nose and then out a little longer through the mouth than you breathed in. Into the belly, ideally, versus the chest. But I would rather have you breathe into your chest than not even try to do this at all.

You can do it today. You can do it tomorrow. You can do it the day after. You can do it for several days, forget about it completely, and come back to it. But if you are able to do it regularly, check that runway, check that startle response. And before we close out today, I want to give you something that you can truly take with you. Not a, here's the things to do moving forward, kind of a checklist, but just a few minutes of practice. Now, if you are driving, you can keep your eyes open and you can let this be

a different kind of listening. But if you're somewhere where you can settle in, I would love to encourage you to try potentially your first mindfulness meditation practice. So there really isn't a way to do it wrong. If you happen to be in a position where you can sit up straight with your shoulders back, your spine is reasonably tall, and your shoulders can actually drop a little bit, that would be ideal. But if you are just sitting anywhere, you're laying down, whatever it is,

it's the right thing to do. And you don't have to sit cross-legged. Just try being where you are. And if you feel safe enough, you can let your eyes close if that feels okay. And I'll try to move away from all of the jokes, but if you're driving, I would not recommend that. If you're in a position or a place where you can, soften your eyes, maybe even let your gaze rest on something neutral, just a little bit off into the distance, or close your eyes.

And so let's begin where one always begins, with the breath. So I'd love for you to take a deep breath and breathe in through your nose. And then let it out slowly through your mouth. Let's try one more of those. In through the nose. And if you can, feel your belly expand.

And then out through the mouth. A little bit longer than you breathed in. And you don't even have to do it in the cadence that I'm suggesting. But I'll give you time to do one more. Slowly inhale. And see if you can get that breath to go into your belly. And if you want to hold it a little bit at the top of that before you let it go, now give that a try. And now a long, soft exhale.

And that was perfect. Now you can return back to your regular breathing. And I want to talk to you for just a minute about why you're here. Because if you've made it this far, I would imagine some part of you is curious. Some part of you wonders if maybe, maybe this could work for you. And maybe there's even another part of you that's already coming up with reasons why it won't work. And those can be all the reasons. I don't have the time. I can't sit still.

I don't like the way this feels. I'm not the meditation type. And I've heard every one of them. And I've said those myself to myself. And here's what I've learned. Those thoughts aren't actually proof that meditation isn't for you. They're actually proof that you're a human being whose nervous system has probably been running fast for a long time. And the discomfort that you feel when you try to sit still is the same discomfort,

that this practice is designed to meet. Growth doesn't happen in comfort. Growth happens right there at the edge of comfort. You know, your brain is actually going to do what brains do. It's going to generate thoughts and it's going to generate restlessness. It's going to generate stories about why you should get up right now. There's nothing wrong with that at all. It's not failure. That is the practice.

The noticing is the practice. This is actually something that you're never going to be bad at. Now you might be new at it. There are going to be times where you're going to find this to be a really peaceful experience. And there are going to be times where it won't. And that's perfectly okay. Now let's do a little check-in right now and breathe in through your nose.

And then out. slowly through your mouth. And just to give you a little preview of coming attractions, if you decide to try any kind of a body scan, I would love for you to right now, just relax the muscles in your face. See if right now you can let go of the muscles that are holding your jaw a little tighter.

You might want to slightly open your mouth and let your eyes feel like they're just sinking back into their eye sockets just a little bit more. And right now, breathe in again and through the nose. And only this time when you exhale, see if you can let go of any tension that's in your shoulders. And now I want you to think about something. Whatever it is that you're carrying

today, whatever feeling is sitting in your chest or in your stomach, maybe in your throat, whatever situation is taking up some space in your head, I want you to know something about that. It too will pass. Not because it doesn't matter, because it does. It matters to you right now. But because that is what feelings do. That is what storms do. Underneath every storm that I've ever walked through,

and I've walked through a few, there was eventually a horizon again. There was eventually a rainbow. And the earth kept spinning, and the sun would set and rise again, and I kept breathing. This too shall pass. That phrase alone is older than any of us. The most intense emotion that you've ever felt has passed. The most overwhelming situation that you've ever been in has passed.

And you're still here. And the earth is still spinning. And you have that opportunity right now to keep breathing. In through the nose. Belly fills. and then out through the mouth. So stay with me just another minute or two, because I really want to tell you something that I don't think that you hear enough. You are the only you on the face of the earth.

There has never been another one, and there will never be another one. The way that you see the world, the way that things land in your body, the way joy and fear and love show up for you, that is unique to you. Nobody else has the inside view that you do. And I promise you, it's okay. I promise you that you were born with all the tools that you needed,

to be here and to go and experience life and unlock that inherent eternal goodness that is inside of you, whether or not anyone else has seen that, whether or not you have acknowledged that or trust it, nobody else knows what it feels like to be you. So you're not doing it wrong. You think and feel the way you do because you're you. And you're this amazing, magical combination of your nature,

your nurture, your birth order, your DNA, your abandonment, your fears, your rejections, your hopes, your dreams, the friends you've met and lost, the pets that you've experienced that have been there and that they too have passed. You're a unique combination of every single thing that makes you you. And that's why you think and feel the way that you do. It's not wrong. You're not broken. You're a human.

And if you are thinking what you're thinking and feeling what you're feeling right now, it's because that's what you're thinking. And that's how you're feeling. And you wouldn't be you if you weren't. Your thoughts aren't an inconvenience to be solved. You deserve to be heard and understood. Your thoughts, they're the texture of being you on this particular day. No one else knows what it feels like to be you. And they can't.

They have their own inside view. They have their own weather system going on inside of them. And when anybody tells you how you're supposed to think or how you're supposed to feel or what you should be over by now, bless their pink, squishy hearts. Seriously. They mean well. They're working from inside of their own emotional weather system with their own view,

They're not necessarily bad, but they're not you Only you get to decide what it means to be you Let's take another breath in through the nose, And a long exhale out. So here's what I want you to take with you. The practice will be uncomfortable sometimes. It's not a sign to quit. That's a sign that you're right there at the edge, the edge of growth.

The feelings will be intense sometimes, but then they'll pass. They always do. And other people don't know what it feels like to live in your skin. And bless them when they try to tell you. But every situation like that is a chance eventually for you to come back home to your own breath. Give me one more deep in through the nose. And then out slowly through the mouth. And give me a little pause.

And you did great. You really did. When you're ready, soften your gaze or just start to open your eyes and thank yourself for taking time for yourself to do this practice. You didn't even need to nail the practice today. You did it perfectly. But just come back tomorrow and try again. Thank you for joining me today. I would love your feedback and I'll talk to

you next time on the virtual couch.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Hosts

  • Tony Overbay Host Feed-stated

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. How Childhood Shapes Who You Marry: The Accommodator, Attachment, and Why We Choose the Familiar

    Nov 13, 20261 hr 18 minAudio

    Why do people pleasers and avoidant partners find each other, and why does it seem like such a relief at first? Tony follows Pam and Jim, a composite couple, from childhood to the college campus where they met. Pam...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Nobody Brings a Casserole When You Wake Up to Betrayal: The Accommodator, Gaslighting, and Rebuilding Trust

    Nov 4, 20261 hr 29 minAudio

    Waking up to betrayal, gaslighting, or emotional immaturity rarely comes with a casserole on the porch or a meal train. When someone has a baby or a surgery, people can see the event and show up with dinner. When you...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Nobody Brings a Casserole When You Wake Up to Betrayal: The Accommodator, Gaslighting, and Rebuilding Trust

    Nov 4, 20261 hr 29 minAudio

    Waking up to betrayal, gaslighting, or emotional immaturity rarely comes with a casserole on the porch or a meal train. When someone has a baby or a surgery, people can see the event and show up with dinner. When you...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Your AI Is a Great Hype-Man - A Therapist Has a Few Notes (Plus Live QA)

    Oct 14, 20261 hr 32 minAudio

    Using AI as a therapist? Your chatbot might be building a great plan for the person you’re hoping to become. When a client’s chatbot asked if he was an extroverted go-getter, he answered as the man he’s working toward,...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Why Good People Defend Leaders (and Others) Who Contradict Themselves: Identity, Bias & Belonging

    Sep 24, 202653 minAudio

    Tony starts with a kid raised in an East Coast fishing town and another raised hiking Arizona trails. He uses them to show how beliefs tend to form through family, community, and identity, with the reasons showing up...

    Credit the people on this episode