Why does certainty feel safer than curiosity - and why does that quietly run so many of our relationships? In this Q&A crossover, Tony answers three listener questions that sound completely unrelated - a spouse who looked through a phone without asking, someone who keeps pulling conversations back to themselves, and why confident, certain voices dominate public life - then reveals the single thread connecting all three: how hard it is to tolerate uncertainty, and why curiosity (not certainty) is where growth actually lives. If you've ever felt the pull to fill in the blanks, win the argument, or get reassurance right now, this one will make you feel seen. In this episode, you'll: Reframe the phone fight using Tony's four pillars of a connected conversation - because it's almost never about the phone. Understand why your brain treats not knowing as a threat (it's a "don't get killed device") and how to stay present in the gray. Build a well inside yourself instead of chasing validation in every conversation - Tony's "emotionally dehydrated" metaphor for growing up with conditional self-worth. Tell the difference between confidence rooted in security and performative certainty that needs an audience. Trade self-monitoring for genuine curiosity using implicit memory and ACT - because you're not broken, you're human. Tony Overbay is a licensed marriage and family therapist with more than two decades of clinical experience helping people become curious rather than defensive. If the noise of everyone being so sure has left you exhausted, press play - there's room here to not know, and to grow from it. 00:00 Q&A Episode Setup 01:34 Three Questions Theme 05:18 Why Curiosity Matters 07:25 Brain Craves Certainty 09:03 Ambiguity Feels Threatening 10:49 Stress Kills Curiosity 13:14 Cognitive Flexibility 14:38 Certainty Gets Rewarded 17:39 Phone Privacy Conflicts 22:40 Four Pillars Framework 26:49 Validation Seeking Habits 28:37 Desert and Thirst Metaphor 31:28 Validation Seeking Pattern 32:04 Curiosity Over Self-Monitoring 34:05 Boundaries With Unavailable People 35:30 You Are Not Broken 36:19 ACT Mindset Shift 37:48 Language Learning Analogy 40:24 From Self-Criticism to Acceptance 42:06 Certainty vs Wisdom 48:27 Insecurity and Emotional Immaturity 50:43 Narcissism as Defense 56:27 Healthy Ego vs Defensive Ego 01:02:27 Leadership and Group Dynamics 01:05:21 Choose Curiosity and Close Please follow Tony on Instagram @virtual.couch on Tiktok @virtualcouch on Facebook https://www.facebook.com/tonyoverbaylmft and on Substack https://thevirtualcouch.substack.com/ You can reach out to Tony through his website tonyoverbay.com or by emailing contact @ tonyoverbay.com
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Hey everybody, welcome to another episode of You're Either Listening to the Virtual Couch or Waking Up to Narcissism Today because today is a Q&A and we have questions and answers about so many things. We've got good old mental health tips, things involving couples, and then we finish big with some good old emotional immaturity slash narcissistic traits and tendencies. And I hope that you'll stick around for that final question because there are a lot of things that I think I've really wanted to get off my chest about
this desire that we have for certainty and how often the person who claims to know everything, can be enticing. But then when you start to really see the inconsistency of someone's message, I really get into why that can feel so off-putting. Because we all crave this certainty. We want to get rid of discomfort. So when you have both of them clashing together, somebody claiming certainty. But man, something just feels off about that. We'll talk about that. So hang in there. That is the third question that I answered
today. I'm your host, Tony Overbay. I'm a licensed marriage and family therapist. Follow me on social media at virtualcouch on TikTok, at virtual.couch on Instagram. And I actually have my sub stack up here in the background. Go to thevirtualcouch.substack.com. And a lot of information there, a lot of information to be read and not listened to. A lot of content going up on Substack. Go to TonyOverbay.com, join my newsletter, courses and programs and all kinds of things coming out soon.
I want to start today's episode actually with a little bit of a riddle. And I'm not good at riddles. And it turns out maybe this isn't actually a riddle. But what do these three questions have in common? Question number one, why do I keep finding ways to pull conversations back toward myself even once I'm aware that I'm doing it and I'm even aware that I don't like it? Question number two, why do couples get stuck arguing about things like looking through each other's phones so much when the argument seems to become something much bigger than the phone itself? And then question number three, why are so many people drawn to certainty?
And people that are presenting certainty as if it was confidence. Why do the loudest, most confident voices often seem to attract the biggest audiences, even when their messaging isn't always consistent? And I think it has a lot to do with actually the fact that certainty itself is part of the problem. Definitely not a riddle. But at first glance, I think that those would sound, like completely different questions because one is more about self-esteem and validation. One, the phone one, is more about trust and your relationship.
And then one is around culture and leadership. And then a lot of what I hear people bringing into my office and what I feel, is just an overall feeling of kind of, I don't know, feeling a little bit icky about all the messaging that we're hearing on social media, in the public, public discourse. But I sat with all of the questions and I realized that these three in particular, and that's why I'm doing a podcast episode about them today. They all brought me back to a very similar place.
They all touch on what happens when we don't feel secure ourselves. What happens when we're looking outside of ourselves for reassurance, whether it's wanting validation in just a simple conversation with somebody else, or whether it's seeking reassurance and not knowing what to do with those feelings. So I'm going to check my spouse's or my partner's phone. Or I, and maybe it's a me thing, but it seems like. Quite some time ago, I could look to people in leadership positions to then,
trust what they're saying and there would be consistency around their messaging and that would make me feel better. But uncertainty, it really does feel uncomfortable. I'm a big fan of talking about the fact that I think we're all essentially emotionally immature and we're on this path of figuring ourselves out to become more emotionally mature and what emotional maturity actually looks like when we're willing to get curious instead of defensive? What happens when uncertainty feels really, really uncomfortable? And what emotional maturity actually looks like when we're willing to get really
curious instead of so defensive? Because I think so much of the challenges that we have in relationships in general is this inability to admit that we may have changed our mind. We might have new data. We might have been wrong about something that we've said in the past. And we'll just dig our heels in and defend it like that is the thing that's going to bring safety in a relationship. Recently, I hosted a live Q&A, haven't done this in a while, and I love doing these so much.
And these are the three questions that I think generated the most thoughtful discussion. As I was going back through the questions and the answers, wanting to pull a few for a podcast, that's where I realized that there was this common thread running through all these questions. So I wanted to share a few excerpts with you today. So we're going to talk about validation and self-worth and trust and relationships, and I'll definitely spend some time on certainty and insecurity and emotional maturity and immaturity, and I'll even touch into narcissistic traits and tendencies. But I think the big through line today is talking about curiosity.
Because in my experience, And curiosity is where a lot of growth lives. Curiosity about someone else's experience is going to help me even understand myself better. So before I even go to today's answers, I want to spend just a couple of minutes talking about curiosity itself. Because it may just be my confirmation by speaking. But to me, it seems like I am hearing more and more people talk about the importance of curiosity, myself included. Be curious and lead with curiosity. And I have a podcast episode on Waking Up to Narcissism where I talk about there are different types of curiosity.
There's curiosity to check a box. Okay, fine. I asked the question. There's curiosity so that then I can tell the person they're wrong. Okay, no, tell me more about that. And now that I have your answer, now I'll tell you why that's wrong. Or there's genuine curiosity. And that can come with a lot of big feelings and emotions. Because if I'm genuinely curious about someone else's experience, I may find out things I didn't know. Or I may find out things that I'm not really comfortable with or I don't even have to agree with. So talking about curiosity is something I think is not going away.
While I hear more and more people talk about curiosity, I'm honestly not sure if I'm seeing curiosity on the rise. And I might even be so bold as to say it seems like the more we're talking about it, the more people are curious. Assuming that, no, I am curious when there's something to be curious about, but these things I know. So I'm going to tell you the things that I know, but I'm open to being curious if I just didn't know all these things. It kind of feels like people are becoming more certain, more dug in, more entrenched, more convinced that they already know what somebody else thinks,
what somebody else means, what somebody else's motives are, what an entire group of people believes. And that really got me curious and wondering if curiosity is such a good thing. And I think most of us would agree that it is. I certainly believe it is. Why don't we do more of it? So I went down a therapist rabbit hole and started looking into everything I could, psychology and the neuroscience and human development and what they all have to say about curiosity. And here is a quick run through of what I have found. The first thing that struck me, and I can't remember the book that talks about
this the most, but our brains are prediction engines. We tend to think of ourselves as simply observing reality and then responding to it. very casually. But that's really not what the brain's doing. The brain is constantly making predictions about what's happening, what people mean, what is likely to happen next. And predictions overall make us feel better because they reduce uncertainty. Uncertainty, not knowing, requires energy. The brain is a don't-get-kill device. It is adorable and pink and squishy, but it operates on this premise that we
have this finite amount of electrical activity. So it is continually trying to save energy, habitualize patterns and things, and predict the future, fill in the gaps. Uncertainty is uncomfortable. Uncertainty means that there might be multiple possible outcomes, and that's going to take a lot of effort to think about. When we don't know what somebody else is thinking, our brains don't naturally respond with, interesting, I don't have enough information yet. I'd like to find out more. Now, that's going to require some additional work. Instead, what our brain typically does in a bless its pink, squishy heart kind of way is it responds with,
interesting, let me fill in the blanks. And then I will be certain and I will feel better and it will require less electrical activity and I will go take a nap. That uncertainty, the blanks are where assumptions come from. That's where we start to create narratives and stories. And then those stories are where certainty comes from. Because the brain would rather have a story that it made up than no story at all, even if the story is wrong. And that is fascinating to me because it means that certainty often feels good, far longer before it's accurate. Okay, the second thing I found is that ambiguity, the gray area,
it activates actually our threat system. Human beings do not love ambiguity. We do not enjoy being in the gray. We like the all or nothing, black or white, much easier. Now, we all vary in how much uncertainty I think that we can tolerate, but the gray area, the ambiguity itself often creates anxiety because ambiguity means we don't know. And I promise you there is a version of life where you can get to where I don't know is actually pretty fascinating and genuinely exciting. Because if I didn't know the things I didn't know before I knew them, what else don't I know?
Can't wait to go on the journey. But currently, I think our default is if I don't know, then I don't know where I stand. And if we don't know what somebody meant, we don't even know if we're safe. Hey, what did you mean by that? That doesn't usually come out in a genuinely curious way. It's more of a, what did you mean by that? You better say the right mouth sounds right now or else these are fighting words and this relationship might be over. Our nervous systems often interpret any kind of uncertainty as a threat, as if I don't even know whether you're upset with me. And if you are, I don't know if I belong. If I don't know whether you're for
me or against me, my nervous system doesn't necessarily experience that as neutral, it's going to go right to, oh, no, that's dangerous, which means curiosity is actually asking us to do something difficult and potentially dangerous. Curiosity is asking us to stay present in the uncomfortable, in the ambiguity, in the uncertainty long enough to learn something. And the things that we may learn are things that we might not agree with. And there we're back to, well, that's scary. So none of this is easy as it sounds. I think there's my through line that it's
okay if we acknowledge the fact that, no, I want to be more curious, but it's also difficult, scary, and it's not our default. The third thing I found is that when we are emotionally activated, when we are starting to get into that fight or flight response, we become far less curious and far more certain. Because when stress levels rise, our brains don't suddenly become more nuanced, they become less nuanced, more black and white, more reactive, more defensive. So if somebody says something that upsets me, curiosity sounds like, hey, help me understand what you mean.
But certainty sounds like, oh, I know what you mean. And whatever you say right now, not buying it. Go ahead and make the mouth sounds, but I know what you mean. That will keep me safe. Because one of those exchanges requires emotional regulation. The other, it's going to give you immediate relief. Say the things I need you to say right now and prove to me that you're safe. And that's one of the reasons that emotionally mature people often appear calmer. And I think we get to this in the answer to one of the questions about this concept of when somebody is mean and rude and like a bully and calling people
names and mocking, it doesn't feel safe. It might feel familiar if you grew up in chaos, but it doesn't feel safe. Emotionally mature people often appear calmer. And that doesn't even necessarily mean that they're smarter, but they're better at tolerating the discomfort of not immediately knowing. And then a fourth thing that stood out, I think I have six total, is that human beings consistently overestimate our ability to know what other people are thinking. I mean, think about how often we do this. We decide that we know why somebody said something. We decide that we know why somebody didn't text us back. We decide that we know
what our spouse meant, even if that's not what they're saying. And this goes into a little bit of the emotional immaturity of if I feel it, it's true. I feel like you're being a jerk. And if I'm not aware that I'm being a jerk, but if you feel it's true, then, oh, I'm sorry. I will apologize for a thing that I'm actually not doing to try to calm your anxiety. But a lot of times it doesn't. We decide that we know what a politician intended. We decide we know what an entire group secretly believes. And once we decide that we know something, then something fascinating happens. We are done gathering data. You can see this even in the true crime stuff, murder investigations,
or when we've found our guy or girl or person, then a lot of times we stop investigating, other areas of interest, which can be one of the biggest causes for appeal later in a case. When we think that we know, we stop asking questions. We stop being curious. Instead, we start now collecting evidence that is confirmation bias to prove that we're right. And once that happens, we're really not trying to understand reality. We're trying to now build a case and defend our conclusions. The fifth thing that I found is that emotional maturity requires a fascinating
concept called cognitive flexibility. The younger you are, a kid thinks naturally in binaries. Who is the good guy? Oh, that means that's the bad guy? All right, which one of these was right? Which one's wrong? Is this person for me or against me? It's normal. But maturity involves learning how to hold multiple truths at once. Maybe somebody hurt me and they actually didn't mean to. Maybe somebody is wrong about this and still a good person. Maybe I only have part of the story. Maybe I'm missing something. Maybe I need more information.
So curiosity thrives more in complexity. Emotional immaturity really likes simplicity. And one of the hallmarks of maturity is developing the overall capacity to tolerate, complexity and uncomfortable feelings without rushing toward certainty. That's when we need somebody to manage our emotions. I'm angry right now, and I'm going to let everybody know about it so they can make me feel better. I'm outsourcing my emotional regulation rather than learning how to regulate my own emotions.
If you can't tolerate any kind of disagreement or question and you have to then cut that person down or you walk out of something because it isn't going the way you think, it's emotional immaturity, like a little kid. And then, and finally, maybe the most fascinating piece of all certainty, actually, as we're noticing, it gets rewarded. Research constantly shows that people tend to perceive confident speakers as more competent, even when the confidence is not supported by expertise or even consistent messaging or data. When you can poke holes in someone's argument over and over and over again,
but they make that argument with such certainty, then our brain will naturally say, well, they must be right. And that's a little unsettling when you think about it, because it means that certainty creates this little shortcut. If somebody sounds confident, then our brains often assume, well, they must know something, which helps explain why I think certainty starts to become performative. The person who says, hey, here's what's really going on, often gets a whole lot more attention than the person who says, you know, based on the available evidence, here are my thoughts. But we're gathering with a bunch of other people to get what they think.
One sounds very definitive. This is what's happening. The other sounds thoughtful. And I go back to what feels familiar. If you grew up in a home where there weren't a lot of people taking ownership or saying, man, I didn't, you're right, I blew that or I was wrong. But it's like, oh, I didn't say that. Or, well, what you don't understand is it feels familiar as an adult. So then unfortunately, thoughtful and open and willing to admit mistakes doesn't always win the room. So when I put all that together, I keep coming back to one thing.
Curiosity requires psychological safety. Curiosity requires emotional regulation and it requires humility. And curiosity requires tolerating uncertainty. So you have to be pretty comfortable in your own skin to be curious because uncertainty is uncomfortable. Somebody claiming certainty that relieves their own uncertainty, at least temporarily, which means curiosity is actually a much higher order emotional skill than I think we even give it credit. It's not difficult because people don't want it or people are unintelligent.
I think it's more difficult because our brains are wired to reduce this uncertainty as quickly as possible. And emotional maturity is learning how to stay in the discomfort of not knowing long enough for your reality to kick in, for reality to actually get a say. And if that's true, then suddenly the three questions that we're going to talk about today sound a lot less different from each other. One person you're going to hear struggling with the need for validation in their overall conversations, wondering why they keep pulling conversations back toward themselves. Another is wrestling with trust and wondering what it means when somebody feels
compelled to look through their phone. And then another is asking why certainty and confidence seems so attractive in our culture, even when it comes at the expense of the truth, of reality, of curiosity. So again, on the surface, I think these seem like completely different questions, but underneath them all is the same challenge. Can I tolerate uncertainty? Can I tolerate discomfort? Can I tolerate the possibility that I don't yet have the whole story? Because that is where curiosity lives. Now, and in my experience,
curiosity is where growth lives too. So with that in mind, let's get to today's questions. Okay, so here's a good one. Tony, my spouse looked through my phone without asking, and now we're both upset. and I feel like my privacy was violated, but they say they only looked because they were feeling anxious and insecure. In a situation like this, who's in the wrong? And what do you tell couples when phone privacy becomes a problem in the relationship? And this is, it's funny, this is a question that we talked about just over the weekend in my family. And it's one that I hear often in my office, or it's one of those that somebody
finds out you're a therapist, they're going to ask you, hey, what do you think about a certain situation? Usually they'll ask something about their kids or the way that they interact with their spouse. And I don't know if you've heard this phrase before. It makes me laugh, but they really don't want me to give them advice. They want their words to come out of my mouth is often the case. But this is one that I've had some really fascinating conversations out in the wild with, because the first thing I would say is that I personally am usually not interested in deciding who is right and who is wrong, not the therapist's job. It's the junior therapist's job or a brand new therapist's. You start to realize, okay, right and wrong is such a hindsight principle.
Because I've had people that will say, well, and then I grabbed his phone and I look through it and I look over at the guy and he's like, yeah, what's he going to do? But I'll have another situation where the same, not the same person, but the spouse will say, and then I grabbed this phone and the guy looks at me like, can you believe that she did that? So you don't even really know what someone's own individual relationship is with that. So that's a story in and of itself. So right and wrong in this scenario is such a hindsight principle. But I know that that is what people often want from a therapist to come in and we will lay out the facts and as if I'm a judge and I'll rule, oh yeah, you shouldn't have done that or that you win.
And I don't know what you get for winning, but they want me to say, oh, your spouse should not have looked or well, you shouldn't have anything to hide. But that typically is going to shut down the more important conversation because what I'm more interested in is what the situation is trying to tell us about the relationship. And even if right then it sounds like I'm saying, cause it's pretty bad, not at all. And I was saying this to a couple not long ago, but I said, hey, I'm going to probably invalidate both of you right now, but stay with me because personally, my strong opinion, I'm not a big fan of couples having completely
private phones where access is this battleground. I'm just not. If my wife wants to look through it, that's fine. What I see, I want to say all the time, but a lot of the times are people feeling this tremendous shame because they looked at their spouse's phone. And honestly, one of the first things I do is normalize that pretty quickly, because I think most people have done it at some point. And if you haven't, great, honestly, I'm not saying you need to. You need to check that box off of your to do list of life. No. A lot of people come in, the most well-meaning people, and then they say,
I know I shouldn't have, and I know what's coming next is I look through a phone or an email or that sort of thing. And really, I love it when people come in and they're saying, okay, then check this out. I look through the phone or I look through the email because they did it because they did it. And there's a reason why. What I think is interesting is that far more often than not, when somebody looks, they actually feel more relief because they don't end up finding anything concerning. Now, if somebody wants to look at their spouse's phone, my preference is that they ask first, which sounds pretty counterintuitive if it's such an uncomfortable thing. Because if you're sitting there and you're saying, hey, I'm feeling really anxious
and uncomfortable, can I look through your phone? Ideally, that would be great. I would love for the partner to say, oh, of course, but hey, tell me what's that bringing up for you? Take me on your train of thought. I mean, that conversation can actually build trust. But if somebody doesn't feel comfortable asking, which I understand, and then the anxiety keeps building, what often happens is eventually they're going to look anyway. And so then at that point, the question that I'm interested in, it's like, hey, yeah, take me on your train of thought. What was going on inside your body, your emotions, your brain that made you feel like, man, this is what I need to do. I need to look because usually it isn't necessarily about the phone.
It's probably more around not feeling safe or, again, it's my own thing. I'm feeling a certain way and I'm thinking that might alleviate my anxiety. It's about uncertainty. We'll talk a lot about uncertainty, I'm sure, over the next few Q&As because that's something I'm just obsessed with, fascinated with. This we have this thought that if I can look at their phone, then I will have certainty and then reassurance and then I will feel calm. So our brain is seeking that because it's about wanting reassurance or maybe it's about feeling disconnected from my partner and not really knowing how to
communicate that or feeling unseen or unheard or not understood, not chosen, not considered in the relationship. So that's where I'm going to want to be in the work. Now, at the same time, if your spouse discovers that you look through their phone. It makes perfect sense that they might feel violated, accused, ashamed, defensive, frustrated, even angry, or like all of a sudden they're on trial. That's fair. It's a fair response. I want to say there isn't a wrong way to react either. Now we have two people who understandably have these emotional experiences that are now colliding with each other. One person saying, I didn't feel safe.
The other person saying, I didn't feel trusted when you did that. Both of those experiences deserve curiosity. So one thing that I like to tell couples is that I am, I'm never going to tell somebody that they should look through their spouse's phone or they shouldn't look through their spouse's phone, but I'm also going to get really curious about what got them there in the first place. And let me, let me go through the lens of my four pillars, four pillars of a connected conversation. what I use with couples. So I start with this pillar one, assume good intent or give somebody the benefit of the doubt. There's a reason why somebody is doing the things that they're doing.
And so I want to assume there's a reason behind the behavior. There's a reason somebody looked and there's a reason also somebody feels upset that their phone was looked through. Neither of those reasons automatically make somebody the villain. Now, when couples get stuck, they usually stay focused on the behavior itself. You look, you shouldn't have looked, you hid things. You don't trust me. But then they begin asking questions like, Like, hey, help me understand what was happening for you. Everything, if they can do that, everything can start to change because these conversations are, again, they're not about the phones. They're conversations about trust and emotional safety and connection and vulnerability.
So when they immediately turn into accusations, shame and defensiveness or threats, and then when the person then reacts or shuts down, that's the pattern. That's the pattern that keeps people stuck. That's how you can tell it's not just about the phone. But when people can slow everything down long enough to try to understand what each person was experiencing, that's where the healing can begin. So pillar two is you can't tell the other person they're wrong or you disagree, or you think what they did is ridiculous. Cue very big, dramatic pause now. Even if you do think what they did was wrong and you do think it was ridiculous and you don't believe what they're telling
you, you have to make space for that. Because the second I say, well, that's ridiculous and I don't believe you and you shouldn't have done that. I'm telling them that their experience is wrong. So pillar two is a stand that you make. You're still going to have those thoughts of, I don't really like what they did and I can't believe they did that. You need to move into pillar three, which is questions before comments. Now I want to know, well, tell me more. Help me understand. Take me on your train of thought. What was it that led up to that? And let's go back in time a little bit. Help me. Take me through your day. Take me through the last couple of days. And I really want to know what has led up to this moment. Because again,
therapist here knows that it's not necessarily even about that moment or that person or the phone. It could be other things as well. That's pillar three, questions before comments. Then pillar four is really important as well. It's not, it's leaning in, it's staying present. It's embracing the discomfort of the conversation. It's not going into a victim mindset. It's not saying, okay, fine. I guess I'm an untrustworthy person there. What else do you not trust me on? Do you not trust that I'm out there earning money for our family? And that victim energy basically brings it back to them. And once the person that did the thing in the first place to now apologize, I know I shouldn't have
done it. You're not a bad person. My apologies. I won't do it again. Okay. Now that person feels better. But the person who actually looked at the phone for whatever reason it was now we didn't get anywhere. And there's the pattern, there's the dance. So when one can look at that with genuine curiosity, then we can start to get somewhere. But I'll go ahead and tell you that there's a fascinating concept that when you start to do the work, use real tools, all those therapy cliches, it's going to open the door to new challenges. And what I mean by that simply is, so let's say that now we do these,
I assume they weren't trying to hurt me by looking at my phone. I don't tell them that they're wrong, even though I kind of think they were. I ask questions, take me on your train of thought, help me understand. and they felt insecure. They, to them, it seemed like we were pulling apart and then I don't go victim. And then I said, man, thank you so much for sharing that. It's, it can be tricky because now my answer can be, that sounds really difficult. And thank you for sharing that. I'm, I wasn't aware of that, that rift in the relationship that you're feeling, because I feel like we're in a good space. So sometimes you get to there and then it's like, well, now what do we do?
And you have to allow yourself for both things to be true for a little bit. Okay. We had the conversation. We didn't resort to the familiar pattern of attack and accuse and shutdown. So now that we've done it, you kind of let that one sit for a little bit because you're training the relationship by what you can tolerate. And we can start to tolerate these uncomfortable conversations. Even if it doesn't lead to resolution, because my four pillars are not about resolving something. It's about learning how to really genuinely understand your partner to be heard.
It takes great courage to be known and to know your partner. So this is an excellent opportunity to just get a round in of learning how to. Help me understand what your position is and I'll share mine. Neither of them is telling the other person that they're wrong. Okay, let's get to the next question. Okay, this one says, Tony, I've noticed that in conversations I often find a way to pull the attention back to myself. I might mention that something was my idea, emphasize my good intent, or add details that aren't really necessary, but somehow make me look a little bit better.
The odd thing is that I know I'm doing it and I don't actually like it. I grew up in a household where my self-worth was pretty conditional. Basically, I needed to prove I was doing enough, and then maybe I would get a little bit of acknowledgement. And I'm guessing that's a part of it. Do you have any suggestions for how to stop needing that validation in the moment? So first of all, I want to say a great question, and welcome to the world of awareness. And I just want to acknowledge how much self-awareness is packed into that question itself, because so many people are just busy defending their behavior,
or they're not even aware of their behavior, but you person asking the question. You are already observing it and you're curious about it, which is a really good place to start. And let me just talk about awareness for a second. Before I reach for any kind of exercise, I do notice myself getting curious about the question itself because there's so much there. Because you're asking me how to stop doing something. And whenever I hear that, I do wonder what that would actually look like in practice. How do you stop doing the thing? Would it mean essentially standing over yourself
during every conversation and then trying to catch yourself before you say something the way that you were going to say it? Because that would require a lot of self-monitoring, evaluating, catching yourself, correcting yourself. And I can't help but notice that sounds an awful lot like the environment that you actually described growing up. And here's a way that I am currently describing something like this in probably a lot of my sessions. And I don't even remember where I first heard it, but imagine somebody who grew up in a desert. Okay. Actually, maybe it's because we have moved to Arizona
and I keep making jokes in my head when it's 115 degrees that I'm living in a desert. There we go. Origin story. Okay. So imagine somebody who grows up in a desert and they don't think about water the same way that somebody who grew up next to a lake does. They are, they are always aware of it. They're always looking for it. So I wonder if emotional validation works in a similar way, because I know that that's something that I have had a challenge with as well. If you grew up emotionally dehydrated, then it makes sense that your attention would keep drifting toward opportunities to feel seen, appreciated, or acknowledged.
It's something that you are constantly looking for. And it's not because you're selfish, but it's because some part of you is still thirsty. And even if you get enough water, at some point, you know, though, it is 115 degrees out here, and I am going to need water again. And sometimes it's really, really difficult to find water. So I'm going to think about it all the time. And when you look at it that way. Then hopefully the goal shifts a little bit because the goal is not to shame yourself for being thirsty. It's to learn how to build a well inside yourself so you're not dependent on
every conversation to provide you with this drink that you're so desperate for. And I heard this recently and it has really sat with me and I have not done enough digging to know if or what the data looks like behind this. But the concept was where if you were lacking something as a child, and let's go with emotional validation. Kids get their whole sense of self from validation. And the main people who can provide that validation when someone is young are the parents.
So, if the parents, and I will go back to the, bless their heart, they don't know what they don't know way, but if they were unable to provide a safe place for your emotions or to provide you with that validation, maybe they have a whole lot going on themselves, or maybe they grew up in a way that they never saw that modeled either. So they don't even know that that's what you require as a kid, because it can even be this interesting form of projection. Well, they didn't get it. So why would you get it? Why would you get this opportunity that they didn't have? But I think so much of that's happening at the subconscious level. But if a kid...
Wasn't getting something that they need from their primary caregiver growing up, they aren't aware of anything other than the fact of what they feel, how they feel, and what they need to do to survive. It's as if their little brains can't even contemplate or tolerate that their primary caregiver, the one that's in charge of keeping them safe, not just physically, but emotionally, spiritually. Financially, but that person is not really that safe. The kid's brain can't tolerate that. So they make it about themselves.
It has to be me that is the problem because they have no concept of that. This caregiver is emotionally unavailable. So then they're going to go out into the world. And then that just, it is their fault. It is their problem. And they now it's familiar to find a partner that is unavailable. So if I'm going to offer an exercise at all, I think it would be more like this. The next time that you notice that you are desperate for this validation to bring the spotlight back to yourself, don't treat it like a problem to solve.
First, we just need to notice it. Maybe even silently think it. Oh, there you are. You are trying to help me feel seen because I didn't feel seen as a kid. And unfortunately, now I'm recognizing this is a pretty familiar pattern. And then see if you can become curious about the person in front of you instead. Kid, ask another question, stay with their story for 15, 30 more seconds and not because you're trying to be good or not that you're not worthy of being known. And it's not even because you're trying to fix yourself, but because genuine
curiosity and self-monitoring tend to compete for the same space. It's competing for certainty. And I was going to say, unfortunately, but right now I just want to say, and it just is the fact that we really don't know, if we're okay or if we exist unless we are interacting with another person. You know, the goal over time is to know that I am okay as I am. But if you slow things down, how on earth would you know that you're okay as you are if you have not received that validation at a very early stage in life?
Because I still don't know. So I'm out there seeking who is going to acknowledge me? Who is going to be curious about me? But what we're starting to do with this question or this exercise, maybe the one that I would propose, is let me be curious about myself. Let me be genuinely curious about this other person, even if just for now, because that is definitely not me monitoring myself and worrying about the thing that I'm going to say. But I'm now noticing that and I'm going to I'm going to create this new relational
frame or this relationship with this thing that I think is wrong with me. And I'm going to now reroute it into, okay, I'm noticing that I am wanting to bring this back to me. And that is me desperately seeking water in the desert. And that energy that I'm going to bring forth now is going to feel pretty desperate to pull it back to me. But the real gold there is that I'm noticing that it's like, I do want someone to see me, to be curious about me, to understand me.
And if I'm having to offer it, this person that I'm interacting with is not curious about me. So I could actually, I could set a boundary. Hey, if this person isn't being curious, then I'm going to treat this like a pretty surface level interaction. But I'm going to stop trying to figure out how to get this person to validate me, how to get this person to like me, because that is, again, me trying to censor myself instead of me being myself and trying to understand who I am. Because at some point, I really want to encourage you to not think that you
are doing your own life wrong. And it's not about, oh, man, what do I need to say? Or how am I saying this? Or I must be saying it wrong versus, oh, I'm noticing that this is a thing that I say. And what is that telling me about this moment? It's this person I'm interacting with. It's probably the familiar that I grew up with and they're not being very curious about me. So the goal here is for me to drop the rope at the tug of war to get this person to understand me. And I can even use it as an exercise for me to be grounded and curious and really want to understand this person. But it's, it's powerful to then recognize I'm, what if I'm not the problem.
Or what if the problem or the challenge is that I'm continually trying to get someone who is not open, willing, or even able to consider me, to be curious about me, to choose me, to do so. Because again, that might sound a lot like the home that I grew up in, and I'm just recreating this familiar dynamic. The ability to heal is to then recognize and not continually try to find water in a desert. This all goes back to that you really are the only version of you that has ever been on the earth.
This wonderful combination of your nature, nurture, birth order, DNA, abandonment, hopes, dreams, fears, rejections, all those things that make you, you. So I promise you, you're not doing you incorrectly. You think and feel the way you do because you do because of all the things that I just shared that you are. And that is one of the things that I think can change someone's view of themselves in the best way. I was going to say the quickest, but it's a pretty slow process to change that interior landscape of your mind, that implicit memory or what it feels like
to be you. And it is based on the slow residue of your lived experience. But I am noticing more and more lately. And let's do a quick ego check. I'm going to come at this from a place of what I like to call healthy ego based on real life experience. The acceptance and commitment therapy principles, that foundation, that modality of therapy that I love, it is game-changing, it's life-changing, and I'm not being dramatic about it. But when you can just notice that you are saying a thing or thinking a thing,
and you go away from the what's wrong with me, my thinking is wrong, because that still is going to require you to outsource. To someone else that, what should I actually be saying, or is that the right thing to say? Versus this is what I'm saying. Operating from that place is a much healthier place to then make changes, make pivots, make new choices in a moment when it's like, oh, I'm noticing that I'm saying this thing. Now, the story my brain's trying to tell me is that I'm doing it the wrong way. But that's just a story that if my brain can hook me to, then I'm still back into that familiar, the feeling of the familiar.
But I promise you that this exercise in and of itself of recognizing that I say and feel the way I do because I do, So check that out and it isn't wrong and there isn't even a wrong and a right way to do it. This is how I am showing up. Someone else may react in a way that then will cause me to think or feel like I'm doing something wrong. I promise you you're not, but there's a lot of data that's happening right there that can help you understand yourself better. And I have been obsessed for years, decades, with people who have learned how
to speak a new language, a foreign language. And a lot of the counseling that I've done earlier in my career was with people that had gone on like a two-year LDS Mormon mission. And the people that would be coming back and navigating a faith crisis, a faith journey. But one of the things that I just found so, so interesting were the people that had gone and learned a new language. So here's a guy or a girl, 18, 19, 20 years old, they go to a foreign country and it can be a pretty tricky language, Russian, Japanese, those sort of things.
And they go with no language experience and then they're immersed in the culture and in the talking with people on a day-to-day basis. And they come back usually fluent in the language. And I really do have a reason where I'm going with this. But it sounds like at first they're overwhelmed and then they start to notice that they're getting better at translating things in real time and practicing the language and then you'll hear that somewhere i don't know six months nine months a year in. That they may recognize they had a dream and they were just speaking the language
they weren't translating things and then they start to notice that they're no longer translating in a conversation with somebody and they're just responding in real time. And again, I've been fascinated by that my whole life. I took two years of college or high school German and two years of college German. And I can speak a little bit of German. I used to go there at trade shows when I was in the computer industry. And I would go there once a year, this place in Hanover, the CBIT trade show. And I would try to practice my German. And apparently, I don't know if it was
just so brutal that then people would to respond back to me in English. One time I was in a cab ride back to the airport with a lady who spoke no English, and then I realized, oh, my German is not good. Nicht gut, mein Deutsch war nicht gut. And I realized, oh, I really have no clue of what it would feel like to be fluent in the language. But this concept and acceptance and commitment therapy of changing your implicit memory or what it feels like to be you based on the slow residue of your lived experience, that it has been years in the making of recognizing that I think
and feel the way that I do because I do. That's why I say this so often in my podcast. I'm projecting it out to the world because, yes, I want others to feel the same way. Maybe it's so that then I will know that I have done a good job when I heal all my parental wounds there. I now don't quite remember, although I know that I spent the majority of my life doing the same thing. What's wrong with me? I said that wrong. I'm so dumb. I shouldn't have done that. And that is gone. So I speak fluent acceptance and commitment therapy now.
And I don't even remember when it happened, but it just is. It's that concept of the path of enlightenment, unconscious incompetence. I didn't even know what I didn't know. I was just saying the things like, oh, I know I shouldn't have said that. I'm so stupid. I can't believe I did that. Man, I suck. And then you become consciously incompetent. Now I'm aware, but kind of keep doing it. And you eventually move into conscious competence. Now I'm definitely noticing that I'm not doing that anymore. And I'm also aware that that step, that path of enlightenment, that part right there, you know, you're there a lot because that's when I wanted
everybody to know that now I was consciously competent. I'm letting everybody know, oh, no, don't beat yourself up like that, which is basically me saying, because I don't anymore. And so validate that. But then that final step on the path of enlightenment or of knowledge or becoming is then unconscious competence. It just is. I just am. And I promise that the person answering that are asking this question, that's where we're headed. So when you're asking me to help you with an exercise to catch yourself so that
you won't be saying a certain thing. Hopefully you can see that's not even in the same ballpark of what I think the work really is to do. It's not to try to not say a thing or stop yourself from saying a thing. It's accepting the fact that this is the thing I want to say and then why. And if I'm continuing to feel that way, then is it because I'm continually interacting with people that are not interested in knowing me as a person. Okay. This question is one that I think I'm going to have to maybe set a timer on my answer.
Because I could go a long time on this one. The person says, Tony, lately, I have found myself feeling exhausted by a lot of public conversations. It seems like everybody already knows the answer. Nobody's asking questions. Nobody's curious. Everybody sounds completely certain. So why does certainty seem so appealing to people? And is it, is certainty actually a sign of emotional health and confidence? So I love the question because what we're really talking about is certainty and uncertainty. And I'll even probably go down a path of narcissistic traits and tendencies
and emotional immaturity. But before we even go there, I do think a lot of people are emotionally exhausted. They are tired of being talked at. I see it as a couples therapist, couples talking at each other, not asking any questions. And I think if you look outward, social media, TV, you name it, that we're all being talked at. And I think we get tired of being told what we are thinking. I'm tired of people presenting their opinions as facts because that is confidence,
and it's mistaken for competence. And certainty is now viewed as wisdom. The person who seems confident and certain is now viewed as this wise old sage. And I think if you listen closely, there are a few phrases that seem to be disappearing from public discourse. Phrases like, I think, or I wonder, or my understanding is, or based on the information I have, or, you know, here's what makes sense to me right now. Or maybe even, I know that I could not have all the facts now. I could even be wrong.
And I get it because those phrases don't make for great soundbites. They don't sound nearly as powerful coming from somebody standing behind a lectern or speaking from a pulpit or somebody sitting behind a microphone, posted on social media, hosting a show. It sounds much more confident to just simply tell people what I know and what I know that other people are saying or doing. Again, not just what you know, but what they should know, or maybe even what they don't know. What you don't even know is, and I know I say that myself, what you don't know that you don't know is... Interestingly, I think it does feel like we've entered an era where people aren't
simply saying, here's my opinion. They're saying, I know the truth. And not only do I know the truth, I know why everybody else is wrong. And not only do I know why everybody else is wrong, I know what they're thinking. I know their motives. I know what they're hiding. And I actually even know what they secretly want. I know what they're not telling you. And if that isn't enough, let me explain why they're not telling you what I know that they know. Somewhere along the way, certainty stops being a conclusion, and it really becomes performative.
Because the truly fascinating thing is that reality is pretty complicated, and people are complicated, and people's motives are complicated. There are so many variables that go into every thought that somebody's having, because life is complicated. But somehow, the most emotionally immature voices among us speak with the greatest certainty about things that no human being could possibly know with that level of confidence. What another person thinks, what another person intended, what an entire group
secretly wants, what everybody on the other side believes, what everybody should think, what everybody should do. And I think that the more certain somebody becomes about things that can't actually be known with certainty... The more curious I become about the need for certainty itself. Because wisdom tends to sound a lot more like curiosity than being certain. To me, wisdom asks questions. Wisdom tolerates ambiguity. Wisdom can hang out in the gray. Wisdom leaves room for new information.
Wisdom says, here's what I think. Immaturity says, I know this. This is an absolute fact. And emotional immaturity is often found in the space between those two things. And I think one of the reasons so much of modern public discourse feels emotionally exhausting is that we're becoming increasingly surrounded by people who confuse certainty with strength. And it can be a lot of different places, leaders, politicians, influencers, pastors, bishops, experts, content creators, psychologists, therapists, myself, people with microphones,
people with platforms, people who have positions of real authority and people pretending that they have authority. People who communicate as though uncertainty or curiosity or questions are weakness and that confidence and certainty are proof that they're somehow better. They're essentially telling us the same story. I'm the smartest person in the room. Nobody knows more about this and I'm talking anything fill in the blank than I do. I have all the answers. I'm never wrong. And anybody who disagrees with me is stupid or dishonest or uninformed or just doesn't get it.
And after a while, that feels exhausting because emotional maturity sounds very different. Emotional maturity sounds like that's interesting. Tell me more. I hadn't thought about it that way. What am I missing? Maybe I need to think about that differently. And perhaps one of the most emotionally mature statements that one can say is, I now realize, based on this new information and. I was incorrect. Or, you know, I did say that before, but now that I have new information that I have now, then I'm going to change my mind.
And you didn't hear it incorrectly. I did say that. And I can understand now why you are confused because I changed my mind or the information, yeah, has been different each time. Those statements don't come from weakness. They actually come from strength, from security. They come from confidence rooted in security, not this performative confidence. And those are such different things. Confidence rooted in security does not need an audience to tell them that they're okay. Confidence rooted in performance does.
Secure people don't need to win every conversation. They don't need to dominate every room. They don't need to be experts on everything because they're secure enough to know that they don't know everything. They're secure enough to learn new things. They're secure enough to be corrected. They're secure enough to not be right. That's what emotional maturity starts to look like. Emotional immaturity, on the other hand, tends to be rooted in insecurity, deep insecurity. And insecurity cannot tolerate uncertainty. It can't tolerate being questioned. It can't tolerate being corrected. It can't tolerate nuance.
It can't tolerate complexity. And most of all, it can't tolerate being wrong. Because if your identity is built on being right about everything, then every question feels like an attack. So emotional immaturity develops a very different strategy. It has to stay in the one-up position. It has to know more, be smarter, be stronger, be better, be more certain, be the best of all time, and continually go back and tear down the people that have gone on before you. Because certainty becomes armor. And once certainty becomes armor, curiosity is dangerous.
Questions are very threatening. Feedback becomes disrespect and disagreement becomes betrayal. And this is where emotional immaturity eventually starts bleeding into something much more defensive. And this is where I think it is important to talk about emotional maturity and emotional immaturity more directly. Because I am a therapist who has built my career helping people recognize emotional immaturity, narcissistic traits, states, tendencies, and patterns in their relationships and in themselves. And this is where I start from a place that we are all emotionally immature
to some degree, every single one of us. Nobody arrives at adulthood having mastered emotional maturity. It's a process and it's what we're here to do. It's something that we're continually growing into. Emotional maturity exists on a spectrum. And on one end is someone who is emotionally mature in and of itself. That's a person who handles things like an adult, using your big boy words, not mocking people, not calling people names, not storming off when you don't get your way, not needing to humiliate somebody else in order to feel better about yourself. Emotional maturity allows you to stay curious when you're uncomfortable.
It allows you to consider the possibility that you might actually be missing something. And it allows you to tolerate uncertainty without rushing toward certainty simply because certainty feels safer. But as we move farther down the spectrum of emotional maturity to emotional immaturity, and when we start entering the territory of emotional immaturity, now it can sound very familiar. It's as if you are interacting with a little kid. And know that if you keep going at the far end of that spectrum, lives pathological defensive narcissism. Now, when I am talking about narcissism,
it's really interesting because there was a time where narcissism, there was a healthy version of it. And I'm not talking about confidence or healthy self-esteem or even necessarily the grandiose version of narcissism. I'm talking more about it as a defense, a defense against these deep feelings of inferiority that began in one's childhood, a childhood where somebody wasn't really seen, a childhood where vulnerability wasn't safe, a childhood where they watched significant people in their lives model never being wrong, never taking accountability and never owning their own mistakes. So underneath all that superiority and arrogance and certainty and grandiosity
is something very different. It is a profound, deep level of insecurity. Because of that insecurity, that person, the emotionally mature, the narcissistic person, they can't tolerate even the possibility that they might not be right, that they might not be the smartest or the best or the most successful. And they must continually put people down in order to feel up. Even the possibility of being wrong feels life-threatening. So they begin recreating stories, narratives in real time. It's a concept called confabulation.
So these people will unconsciously rewrite the story so that somehow they have been right the whole time because reality feels less threatening than being wrong. One of the things I've observed throughout my career is this, that the more somebody has to tell the world how special they are, the more likely it is they are actually trying to convince themselves. And often, the deeper the wound of insecurity is. So what feels like a conversation to you feels like a threat to them because you are either going to validate them, agreeing with them and reinforcing their certainty, or you are against them all or nothing, black or white.
And they will defend against that at all costs because eventually something shifts. We stop trying to prove ourselves. We stop trying to win. And what is I'm going to say supposed to happen is we move away from that as a kid. That's a little child that must be right all the time and you must be wrong because this process of becoming more emotionally mature. The hope is that eventually something shifts and we stop trying to prove ourselves. We stop trying to win every argument. We stop trying to be the smartest person in the room and we become more interested in reality than in being right.
More interested in understanding than in enforcing or performing this version of ourselves. And we're more interested in learning than just continually defending. Everything becomes an attack. And strangely enough, that's actually where life starts to feel bigger. Because the moment you stop defending certainty, now curiosity is available. And curiosity is where growth lives. Curiosity is where connection with others occurs. And curiosity is where healing lives, which kind of brings us back to the question
that emotionally mature people never stop asking. The question that I think keeps us humble or keeps us learning and keeps us connected to reality. If I didn't know what I didn't know, and now I know things that I didn't know before, then what else don't I know that I don't know? And let me, before I jump off this soapbox, I'm going to pull up an article called The Truth About Narcissistic Personality Disorder. I have quoted this many times. It's by Eleanor Greenberg. She's a psychologist. It is from Psychology Today. It's an old article and it is so brilliant.
Eleanor says that narcissistic personality disorder, and this is where I'm going to go into the world of emotional maturity, but it's the name for a series of coping strategies that began as an adaptation to childhood, to a childhood family situation that left the person. With unstable self-esteem, the inability to regulate their self-esteem without needing others, external validation, and it comes with lower empathy. So when somebody grows up with that happening in their life, then they lack whole object relations and object constancy.
And these are fascinating concepts. Whole object relations is the ability to see yourself and others in a stable and integrated way that acknowledges both the person's good and bad qualities. And an object constancy is the ability to maintain positive connection to somebody that you like, even when you're angry, hurt, frustrated, or disappointed by that person's behavior. So without whole object relations and without object constancy, people, and Eleanor says with narcissistic personality disorder, and I will say incredibly emotionally immature people can only see themselves
and other people in one of two ways. Either they are special, they are unique, they are omnipotent, they are perfect, they are entitled, which we call high status, or they're defective and worthless garbage, low status. So that means that the person struggling with emotional immaturity, they can't hold on to their opinion or feelings about somebody if they notice that the other person has a flaw or if the person questions or challenges them. So then that person goes from being special and put on a pedestal and you're the greatest ever to being devalued as not only just nothing special, but a horrible person and accusations are made and attacks are made and the person's mocked.
So the narcissist or the emotionally immature person goes back and forth between those two. When they feel good about you, or actually you have made them feel good about themselves, then you're special and everything's great. But then you do something that they don't like. Maybe say no to a request. Maybe even ask a question about something that they have said. Now you have become all bad and worthless. Later, you might do something that makes them feel good again, and they're back to seeing you as special. And this is where she talks then about the concepts around narcissism.
And I am co-opting her definition of normal, healthy narcissism. Because she says that, and this is where I know it has been a while since anyone I think has thought about narcissism in this way. But she says, unfortunately, in the English language, the word narcissism has come to mean two entirely different things, depending on whether it's being used formally as a diagnosis or informally as a synonym for positive self-regard. So that, that version, I think is that ship has left the port long ago, the healthy narcissism. She makes a distinction between the two. And this is where I'm going to take her definition of normal, healthy narcissism. I'm going to replace the word
narcissism with ego. And I think it is so powerful. So normal, healthy ego is a realistic sense of positive self-regard and it's based on your actual accomplishments. So then it's stable because it's something that you have integrated, embodied, assimilated into your image, your self-image, and it's based on successes that have come from real hard work to overcome real-life obstacles. So I didn't know a thing, and then I worked hard to know the thing, and now I know the thing because I didn't know it before. That's normal, healthy ego.
And because it's based in real achievements, normal, healthy ego is pretty tolerable to the slights and setbacks that we all experience as we go through life. Normal, healthy ego causes you to care about yourself and do things that are in your real self-interest, and it's associated with genuine self-respect. And you can think about it as something that is inside of you, normal, healthy ego. And what I want to add to that is when you know the things you know because you have put in the work and you then say, well.
This is something I know, and you don't pretend to know something about everything, you start to radiate true confidence or safety or a presence. And that can be calming and grounding for those around you. That's why I think that certain emotionally mature leaders are so powerful because you do, you feel this presence because you can trust that when they say, oh, I do know this, that they only say that they know a thing because it's something that they have learned. I know the things I know about mental health because I studied this,
I got my master's degree in counseling, and then I've spent two plus decades in doing this every day. I love it. So I know the things I know because I know them, which then comes with. So obviously, there are things I don't know. I'm not going to claim to know more than an attorney because I have not gone to law school. I'm not going to claim to know more than a doctor because I don't have a medical degree. But I would imagine many people have heard someone who has already made a judgment about somebody else. What does that doctor know anyway, says the non-doctor?
What does that attorney know? And what is that therapist? He's just trying to get you in there to get your money, says the person who doesn't know things about therapy or what can actually come from therapy. No, that's a defense against their own insecurity. If somebody wants to know my opinion about something legal, then I will say, oh, I have no training in this here. I'll take a guess. And so that way it does start to build trust because if we're just going to have a conversation, I'll throw some things out there. But if I'm going to say, oh, no, I know. I know what that person means. I know that that attorney is actually just trying to get your money.
I know that this person is just a part of the radical other side. That is a defense against insecurity, healthy ego. I think people with healthy ego change the world. Jesus, Buddha, Gandhi, Mother Teresa, Martin Luther King. Healthy ego is what will put you in a position where you are going to say things because it's things that you now know and you want to share that information. It moves away from I need validation because of my insecurity to, hey, this is something I now know and I've integrated and embodied it and I want to share it because now when people interact with me, they can attack it.
And I want the data because I'm not trying to defend my fragile ego. I'm trying to integrate things to make me a better person. So I need the interaction. So the opposite of that is pathological defensive narcissism, the opposite of healthy ego. And Eleanor Greenberg said, this is a defense against feelings of inferiority. So the person dons a mask of arrogant superiority in an attempt to convince the world that he or she is special. They are the expert on everything. And inside, that person actually feels very
insecure about their self-worth, but they aren't even aware of that. To them, no. If I tell people I know everything about everything and I know what this person means and what this person says, they think they're selling this confidence that people are buying. And because some people are, because it feels familiar to that person. If that's the home they grew up in or the person hasn't done their own work, to understand that no one knows everything about everything, and people are going to be inconsistent and incorrect and taking ownership of
that is mature, it's healthy. But L.R. Greenberg says, this facade of superiority is so thin that it's like a helium balloon. One little pinprick will deflate it like a question. Like follow-up, like pointing out that there's been inconsistencies in the person's message because that facade of superiority is so thin. So she says, this makes the person hypersensitive to the most minor slights that somebody with healthy ego wouldn't even notice. If somebody's going to say, wait, but you said this other thing, then somebody with a healthy ego is going to say, you know what I did actually?
Or, oh, I did at that point because I didn't have the data I knew now. But somebody with defensive narcissism becomes immediately wounded because of this fragile, tiny ego, this insecurity. So they take any form of disagreement as serious criticism in an attack, and they will lash out and they'll devalue anybody who they think is disagreeing with them. So they're constantly on guard trying to protect their status. Their messaging changes over and over again, and they don't take ownership of the fact. No, you're the one that's wrong.
You're the one that's stupid. You got that wrong. You must be part of the people trying to take me down. It can't be that, oh, yeah, I did change my mind. Pathological defensive narcissism is a protective armor that's on the outside of a person. And it is there because it has to protect that fragile, insecure, emotionally immature ego. It's a little child wearing adult clothes, making big old gestures and mouth noises, thinking that's, I'm pretending that this is what an adult does.
They scream and yell and they claim to know everything about everything. Before I hop off the I just have to say that it's really interesting because groups, and I'm talking about in general, as someone who works in this area of narcissistic family systems, groups often organize themselves around that person who claims certainty. And not because certainty is wisdom, but it can feel safe. So, groups tend to organize themselves around the loudest voice, the strongest opinion, the person least willing to entertain any kind of gray
or ambiguity, the person who is most willing to project confidence. The emotionally immature leader demands loyalty, and they demand agreement, and they demand certainty. And so, they surround themselves with people who reinforce that certainty, the classic yes men, the people who never challenge, who never question, who don't push back. And what's really interesting is that those followers, I think, are often participating in the same emotional process. They're projecting their own fantasy of certainty, their own desire to be right
about everything, their own desire to feel powerful, their own desire to escape uncertainty. And so they're basically surrounding themselves as if they're to their parent, the person who projected that confidence and never took ownership of anything as a kid. It feels familiar. And so now certainty starts feeding certainty. Insecurity starts to feed insecurity and that leads to performance. And now the people in that same orbit as the emotionally immature leader. Then they begin to perform as well. Performance starts feeding performance.
Eventually misinformation, projection, confabulation, and then certainty with no accountability start to feed each other as well. So the story then becomes so much more important than reality. Protecting the narrative becomes more important than discovering the truth. As a matter of fact, the narrative now must be told as if it is the truth. And when that happens, reality itself starts to become optional. And healthy leadership looks so different. Healthy leaders are surprisingly calm because they know who they are.
They don't need to advertise or perform competence. They don't need to remind everybody how smart they are. They just, they show up and project confidence and safety. They don't need to perform certainty every second of every day. Healthy leaders tend to be curious and grounded and flexible and open. And they're remarkably comfortable saying three simple words. Hey, I don't know. I guess it's four words. Because real competence doesn't fear those words. Real competence trusts the words. Real competence understands that admitting what you don't know is often
the fastest path toward learning what you need to know. And truly capable people tend to want other capable people around them. They welcome a challenge. They welcome feedback. They welcome perspective because they understand that growth happens when everyone gets a vote, when reality gets a vote. And eventually, if that kind of work is being done, then something shifts and people realize they stop trying to prove themselves. We stop trying to win every argument. We stop trying to be the smartest person in the room and we become more interested in understanding and in learning and in reality. And we start realizing that, of course, we didn't understand things that we
were never consistently practicing or studying or aware of. Of course, we didn't know what we didn't know. How could we? And strangely enough, that realization, it's not scary. It isn't so discouraging. It's exciting because once you stop defending certainty, now curiosity becomes available. And again, that's where the growth lives. And so that brings us back to the question, the question that emotionally mature people never stop asking, that keeps us humble, that keeps us learning, the question that keeps us connected to reality. What else don't I know that I don't know?
Okay, that's all the time we have today. I would love your questions. If you have thoughts, questions, feel free to send them to contact at TonyOverbay.com. And I would love your feedback. And whether you came here from the virtual couch or waking up to narcissism, thank you so much for being here and taking us out per usual, the wonderful, the talented Aurora Florence with her song, It's Wonderful.
Why do people pleasers and avoidant partners find each other, and why does it seem like such a relief at first? Tony follows Pam and Jim, a composite couple, from childhood to the college campus where they met. Pam...
Waking up to betrayal, gaslighting, or emotional immaturity rarely comes with a casserole on the porch or a meal train. When someone has a baby or a surgery, people can see the event and show up with dinner. When you...
Waking up to betrayal, gaslighting, or emotional immaturity rarely comes with a casserole on the porch or a meal train. When someone has a baby or a surgery, people can see the event and show up with dinner. When you...
Using AI as a therapist? Your chatbot might be building a great plan for the person you’re hoping to become. When a client’s chatbot asked if he was an extroverted go-getter, he answered as the man he’s working toward,...
Tony starts with a kid raised in an East Coast fishing town and another raised hiking Arizona trails. He uses them to show how beliefs tend to form through family, community, and identity, with the reasons showing up...