Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

The Virtual Couch

The Virtual Couch artwork

The Validation Paradox: Why Reassurance Can Feel Lonely

May 15, 202656 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Your partner said all the right things. So why do you feel MORE alone than before you opened up? Welcome to positive invalidation. That strange ache - being reassured into invisibility - has a name. It's what happens when "you're so good at your job, don't even worry about it" lands like a door quietly closing on what you actually feel. In this episode, Tony Overbay unpacks the science of validation, the paradox underneath it, and why the partner who soothes you fastest may be regulating their own nervous system, not seeing yours. Through the story of Archie and Veronica, this episode explores: Why positive invalidation stings more than the obvious kind - and how to spot it inside your own well-meaning reassurances Dr. Marsha Linehan's "kernel of truth" definition of validation, plus Tony's four pillars of a connected conversation David Schnarch's distinction between other-validated and self-validated intimacy - and why needing validation is the real trap The co-regulation research (including the famous fMRI hand-holding study) that explains why your partner's bad day becomes your emergency The four stages of competence, from "unconscious incompetence" to actually living it - and why stage two is where most people quit therapy HALT, upstream versus downstream work, and a surprising tangent into energy landscapes and Buddhist non-self As a licensed marriage and family therapist who's spent decades guiding couples back toward each other, Tony weaves together DBT, ACT, and Schnarch's differentiation work to answer one question: can you give validation as a gift without needing it back? If something here resonates, share it with someone who needs to hear that they're not broken - they're human. Please follow Tony on Instagram @virtual.couch on Tiktok @virtualcouch on Facebook https://www.facebook.com/tonyoverbaylmft and on Substack https://thevirtualcouch.substack.com/ You can reach out to Tony through his website tonyoverbay.com or by emailing contact @ tonyoverbay.com 00:00 Welcome and Disclaimer 02:28 Meet Archie and Veronica 03:07 A Compliment That Hurts 05:08 Positive Invalidation Explained 06:35 Where Invalidation Comes From 09:10 Science of Validation and DBT 09:49 Four Pillars of Connection 12:31 Validation Research and Polarization 14:52 Schnarch and Differentiation 18:05 Self-Validated Intimacy 19:08 Non-Self and Interdependence 22:58 Co-Regulation and Fusion 26:08 When Comfort Is for You 28:11 Co-Regulation as Hope 28:57 When Growth Triggers Chaos 30:03 Energy Landscapes Explained 32:01 Biology of Pushback 35:02 Validation Paradox 38:12 Self-Validated Intimacy 41:12 Building Self-Validation 46:20 Veronica and Archie Revisited 47:09 Upstream vs Downstream 51:37 Four Stages of Change 55:00 Key Takeaways and Wrap

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Hey everybody, welcome to another episode of The Virtual Couch. I am your host, Tony Overbay. I'm a licensed marriage and family therapist, but I am not your therapist. Although, to be fair, I'm a lot of therapist-therapists, so technically there's a chance that I might be your therapist-therapist. Everything I share here is for informational, educational, maybe a little bit of entertainment purpose. This podcast is not meant to diagnose or treat or replace professional mental health care. If you are struggling, please do me a huge favor and reach out to a qualified mental health professional in your area because that is the part that matters the most.

And if you have never done so, you can Google low-cost mental health care in your area and you will find most likely, depending on how rural of an area, some affordable mental health care. Today's episode is based on a real couple, sort of. More accurately, it's based on a carefully blended psychological smoothie of many couples that I've worked with over the years. Couples that maybe I'm working with right now. Probably future couples who just don't know it yet. But while the concepts and patterns and emotions and dynamics are all absolutely real, as per usual,

all identifying details have been changed to protect confidentiality. This content resonates with you. And today's episode is one I've been working on for a little while. It's about validation. I would love to stay connected. So you can find me on Instagram at virtual.couch, TikTok at virtual couch, or over on the virtual couch substack, which is thevirtualcouch.substack.com. And I love getting your stories, your questions. So much of what I talk about on the podcast comes directly from the real things that people are navigating in relationships and parenting and faith transitions

and emotional growth and trying to figure out how to be a human, especially in this day and age. You can also reach out through my website, TonyOverbay.com. While you're there, sign up for the newsletter. And if you are a guy who is trying to become more emotionally mature, check out my men's emotional architects group. And also I am updating my magnetic marriage course. Along with courses on parenting and navigating faith deconstruction. You can just go to TonyOverbay.com and find that out there. Go to TonyOverbay.com slash magnetic if you want to know more about the marriage course itself. Now, let's get to today's show.

And today, the fictional couple, formerly played as Jack and Jill, are going to be replaced today by Archie and Veronica. And if you are unfamiliar, Archie is a well-meaning, occasionally confused, emotionally avoidant redhead from a fictional town of Riverdale who somehow keeps stumbling into all kinds of things. Of course, existential crisis while still looking like he should be selling milkshakes in a 1950s diner. And Veronica is brilliant and very intense and deeply perceptive and at least two or three levels of differentiation or processing levels ahead of everybody

else in the room at all times. So they are a perfect couple for today's episode. And I think that you'll see why. Let's go to the story. Imagine this. So Veronica comes home. It's been a brutal day at work. Her manager pulled her into a meeting. It was supposed to be about a project and it turned into a conversation about her performance and all kinds of things of the way that she was showing up at work and she didn't see it coming. So the whole drive home, she's turned it over in her head. What did she miss? What's the actual concern? More importantly in today's climate, is my job okay? So she walks in the door

and then Archie asked, hey, how was your day? And she tells him and Archie who loves her. and by every available measure and metric is a very good guy. He's probably on the verge of what is known as nice guy syndrome. He just wants to keep the peace and say all the right things. And if he does all the things that he can do for Veronica, then she will love him and adore him and want to be with him. And they will live happily ever after. He's a good guy. So he says, honey, you are so good at your job. You're one of the best ones there. I would imagine your boss probably stressed about something else.

I wouldn't even worry about it. And Veronica kind of nods and says the thanks and then heads upstairs. And she sits down on the edge of the bed, but something just feels off. But she tries to think it through and she says, okay, I just got reassured by the person who I believe knows me best. He said the kind of thing that you're supposed to want to hear. He made the right mouth noises and the facial expressions. So why does she feel more alone than she did in the drive home in the car? So that feeling has a name.

It's invalidation. And the strange part is that it came wrapped inside of a compliment. And I believe wholeheartedly that Archie meant well. So that moment with Veronica is something that I think most of us have lived on both sides of. Somebody tells us something hard and we rush to make it better. We say the kind of thing that sounds like comfort and the person that we love walks away feeling unseen. And then we even turn away from that and think, what on earth is going on? Do they not care about me? We can make it all about ourselves when they're the one that came to us.

Looking for something. There's an article in Psychology Today that is by a psychologist named Jamie Lusk. She said, most of us already recognize what negative invalidation looks like. Things like you're crazy. What's wrong with you? Why are you so needy? Can't you just chill out? Just relax? Not a big deal. And that kind of invalidation stings, but it's obvious. The harder kind is what Lusk calls positive invalidation. And it sounds like, hey, you're great. Why do you have to be so hard on yourself? It's all going to work out. It always does. You don't need to worry about I'm sure he didn't mean to hurt you. You did so well, don't even think about it again.

Because you can also invalidate by agreeing with something that hurts. Maybe you've experienced this where the person that you are pouring your heart and soul out to says, I mean, you're right, you probably weren't their top choice. Or, you know, you're right that you can be a little bit too much. And that kind of agreement can look like solidarity, but it functions more like a verdict. Now, what ties these together is they all close the door on what the person's actually feeling. Now, they might do it gently. They might do it with love, but the result's the same.

The person on the receiving end, the person who poured their heart and soul out, is left holding their experience alone. Often more confused than before because the person that they trusted just told them that their reality was wrong without using those exact words. And that's the kind of invalidation that is the hardest to name because the person doing it is by every visible measure being nice, looking like they really care. And I think that most of the time they do. Most of us don't know what to do with our emotions because if you kind of go back in the time machine, even the best of parents with the best of intentions

told us not to worry about something. Hey, it's not a big deal. Just calm down. Don't worry about this thing that you are coming to me worried about. And what it actually communicates to a kid is that, hey, whatever you're worried about, you shouldn't need to worry about that. So your worry is actually incorrect. Or when you're told to calm down as a kid, what is getting transmitted to that little brain and nervous system is that, hey, calm down. Your emotions are way too much. They're not welcome here. They need to manage them so that a parent can feel better.

Now, that's a good parent doing it, a loving parent, a parent doing their best with what they were handed, what they were modeled when they were a kid. And then for the people that I work with who come out of things like higher demand, religious environments are very strict upbringings. There's an extra layer. They were told to think that there is one right way to think and feel and want, which then naturally implies that anything outside the right way is the wrong way. So if they notice themselves thinking, feeling, or wanting something that didn't match what they'd been taught, they default to, I'm wrong.

I'm thinking the wrong things. I feel the wrong way. And I want to do the things that I'm not supposed to want to do. So you end up with as a whole generation of adults walking around with unhealthy relationships with their own emotions, constantly checking, constantly wondering if what they feel is, is this the right thing to feel? Should I be feeling this way? Constantly looking for somebody else to tell them, yes, that emotion, that one's allowed. Yes, you are seeing your situation correctly, according to me. And yes, I deem that you are okay. Which is funny because that, okay, cool, I'm good. I said the right thing.

But then why do I not necessarily feel better? Or sometimes I do for just a short amount of time. We get set up before we ever walk into an adult relationship to need external validation to know who we are. Kids get their whole sense of self from external validation. And it makes sense. It's part of the way that life works. But when we get older, the hope is that we can learn to find ourselves and not need that external validation. Need it. And we'll talk about that as this episode unfolds.

So, of course, when we get in a relationship, we're going to hand that job to our partner. Our whole sense of self has been built on getting a signal from outside that says, you're reading this right. You're allowed to feel this way. You're okay. It makes sense that we would need our partner to also then tell us that we're going to be okay. So that's the setup before any kind of sciencey things around the behavior, nervous system, the science of validation even enters the room. So now, open the door and welcome in the science of validation. Dr. Marsha Linehan, who built a type of therapy called dialectical behavioral

therapy, or DBT, from the ground up, defines validation as finding the kernel of truth in another person's perspective or situation. And I do enjoy that definition, because it's not about agreeing with all of it, because we will never understand exactly what another person's going through. And validation, again, finding a kernel of truth in their experience. It doesn't even mean that you're endorsing the behavior, but it's finding the part that given where they're standing and what you can only guess or assume they've been through does make some sense.

And this is something I talk about a lot when I'm working with couples or talking about my four pillars of a connected conversation. Pillar one, well, there's a pre-pillar separating observation from judgment. I'm observing that my partner walked by me and didn't say anything. Then the judgment is they don't care about me. You have to learn to separate the observation from the judgment. I'm observing that they walk by me, didn't say anything. And my judgment is that they don't care about me. Separate them because that can get me into pillar one, which is now I'm going to assume good intent that they're not doing it to hurt me.

But there's also a part B to pillar one, which is, or there's a reason why that person's saying you're doing the things they're doing. Because a lot of that, it could be rooted in emotional immaturity that they may feel, even though that they are an adult walking around in adult clothes, driving cars and having jobs and things like that, that that's still the way that they need to communicate their message. I need to show you that I'm angry with you rather than talking about it. But then we get to pillar two and pillar two sits where we're talking about with this episode. It's, it's accepting their perspective that you can't tell somebody that their experience is wrong or that you disagree with the way that they are reading a situation.

Big dramatic pause, even if you genuinely think that they are interpreting it in a way that is not serving them, or in a way that you are acknowledging that you don't believe that you would handle that. In other words, you can't tell somebody that they're wrong, even if you think they are, because that's their perspective. That's their interpretation of events. And I think when you really slow things down that way, the reason is pretty straightforward, because you truly do not know what it feels like to be them. You weren't there for the version of the day that they've had. You weren't standing inside their

body, feeling their nervous system when their manager said the thing. And you don't have access to the 27 other moments from their week that were stacking on top of this one that was downstream that led up to how they felt right now, which is exactly why then pillar three follows naturally. Questions before comments. Hey, tell me more about that. How long you've been feeling that way? What's the hardest part about what you just experienced? Those questions, they're an acknowledgement that you're standing on the outside of an experience that belongs to someone else.

And you care about that person. And the only way to really build and grow in this relationship is to ask, to genuinely, curiously ask about their experience. I think most of us don't think about it this way, but if a friend tells you that they're nervous about, let's say, teaching a Sunday school lesson and you say, hey, don't worry about it. You'll be fine. It's invalidation. You're telling them, hey, where you're feeling, not correct. It's not accurate. And you probably meant it as encouragement, but they hear on some level that what they're feeling isn't the right thing to feel. Once you see it in something that small, you start to see it in a lot of different places.

And the research backs it up. In 2019, a team led by a researcher named Ko ran a study with mothers of adolescents who were self-injuring. And they taught the moms in a single session how to interpersonally validate. Then they put the mothers and teens in a conflict discussion and measured what happened. And the mothers who have been trained in validation showed a lower physiological arousal and less emotional distress during the fight. And that actually led to the teens also having lower emotional distress.

One session, high stakes relationship, but you can see measurable change in the body. Now, Lusk also points out the research showing that validation makes change more likely, not less. And most of us, I think, were taught the opposite. Most of us were taught that if you let somebody's feelings be valid, they'll dig in, they'll move the goalposts, that you are allowing it, that it will just continue to get worse. But the research actually shows that they soften. And this isn't just a couple's problem or a parent-child problem. Research from Barthal and Halpern shows that when entire groups invalidate each other's views.

When one side dismisses the other's reality is not just wrong, but despicable, illegitimate polarization happens and it deepens. Each side digs their heels in and the gap widens and reconciliation gets a lot harder. I think a lot of what we're watching unfold even in the country right now is a macro version of what happens in somebody's living room. It comes out of emotional immaturity, that right, wrong, black, white frame, where if you have a different opinion than I do, that it doesn't mean that we see things differently. It means you think you're right and I'm wrong, which now means I have to attack your position and defend mine.

So there's no room left for curiosity. There's no room for two people to hold genuinely different views and now stay connected or stay in a conversation. So what gets lost, I think, at the national level is the same thing that gets lost in Veronica and Archie's living room. Kernel of truth or trying to understand what that other person's perspective is with the acknowledgement that I don't know what it feels like to be them. The possibility that somebody that you disagree with might be standing on something real given where they came from and what they've lived through. You can find that kernel without endorsing their conclusions.

You can find it without changing your own. And the fix runs in the same direction, I think, on most every scale. And so, this is the part that sounds like the whole story. Validation, good. Practice it. End of episode. Except a man named Dr. David Schnarch spent his career looking at long-term couples and he would walk into the scene with Veronica and Archie and ask a completely different question. I think he wouldn't ask whether Archie validated her well. He would ask why Veronica actually needs Archie's validation to settle herself in the first place. And it's Schnarch's work on differentiation that has become a lot of the backbone

of how I think about long-term relationships now. Differentiation, as he defines it, is the ability to hold onto yourself when the people closest to you are pressuring you intentionally or not to be something else. And it's the ability to stay you while staying connected to another person, especially those who you care about. And one of his core moves is to distinguish two kinds of intimacy. The first he calls other validated intimacy. And it's that expectation that your partner will approve of you, agree with you, reflect you back in the shape that you want to see.

You think that you are a version, a certain version of a human, and you are wanting that person to agree with the version that you think you are. But what is so fascinating to see is that you're saying, hey, you know me, validate this version of me that I think that I am. But if you've been with somebody long enough, they're naturally going to think of examples of things that don't line up with what you're saying. If you say, and I've had this recently in session, when somebody says to their spouse, you know me, I'm honest.

And then I stop right there and I say to the spouse, the partner, what are you thinking about right now? And in this situation, the guy just said, nothing. And I said, oh, no, my friend, I know this game. And, but essentially he said, I'm thinking about the times where she hasn't been very honest. And she took offense and I had to normalize that because that's part of the fascinating thing about how relationships work. And I think when you break it down at that simple of a level, and you can look at that with curiosity, not judgment, not shame. I want this person to think that I'm always honest, but immediately I'm with

this person that has experienced enough life with me that they're immediately thinking of these times where I'm not. And that's why I love saying to a couple that we're going to learn how to communicate. We're going to learn how to say, this is my experience. This is your experience. We're going to learn how to stay in a conversation. We're going to learn how to use I statements and be genuinely curious. What do you think instead of, I think you feel this way. And what you often find is that the person I think I am is fairly based in truth. Hey, I'm always honest, except for those times I'm not, but then I have a good reason why I'm not.

Or you know me, I'm always a fun time, except for, yeah, you could probably point out the times where I haven't been a very fun time, but there are reasons why. And what if all those things are true? But we want this person to see who we are. We want them to validate that we are the certain type of person. We want them again to reflect you back in the shape that you want to see. To comfort you when you're shaky. And it sounds like the goal of a relationship, but Schnarch will argue it's more of a trap. Because the moment that your sense of self depends on somebody else delivering

it to you, you've essentially handed them a steering wheel that was never theirs to hold. Now they have so much power over how you feel about yourself. So that was other validated intimacy. And then he also talks about self-validated intimacy. see. This was a little trickier because it's letting yourself be known without needing your partner to accept what they see. And this is the scary part because our brains are still so wired into this all or nothing, black or white, emotionally immature. If I say this thing and they don't like it, then they will leave me.

That's an all or nothing statement. It's saying the true thing and then handling whatever comes back, which could be silence, disagreement, criticism, and without it dismantling who you are. And David Schnarch is pretty blunt about this. He says that empathy and acceptance when they're coming out of fusion in a relationship are never free. There's always a bill. There's a cost. I'll only do for you if you do for me. And that's not love. That's a transaction. And that transactional model assumes a particular thing about people.

It assumes that you and I are two separate fixed things doing business together. Myself over here, yourself over there, trading empathy for empathy. There's an amazing Buddhist concept, I think, worth bringing in here that kind of pokes at that assumption. It's called anatta or sometimes translated as the non-self or no-self. And before anybody tunes out at the word, I am not hovering above the floor because it doesn't mean that you don't exist. You obviously exist, but boy, sometimes my YouTube rabbit hole would convince me otherwise.

I believe you currently exist and you are listening to this. What it means is that you're not what you always think you are. There's no fixed permanent essence sitting inside of you that is the quote real you. Things exist because of and in relationship to other things. And my favorite phrase with this is nothing stands alone. I've heard this taught with this helicopter image, which I love. When you're flying a helicopter, you don't lock the controls into place and coast. You're using all four limbs the entire time. You're adjusting the throttle, you're adjusting the pitch, you're adjusting direction every second. So, this Buddhist teaching of non-self sees a person the same way.

You're not a static thing being who you are. You are a continual adjustment. Are you more you when you're hungry or when you've just eaten? Maybe when you're rested or when you've been up for three nights working a project? Are you more you in the loving home you grew up in or the moment that a hard thing happened to you as a kid? The answer here is that there is no fix to you. There's only a complex web of these impermanent causes and conditions that if you are going to do a thing, then there's an acceptance that someone is going to react a certain way to that thing.

If I'm so worried about how they might react that I don't do a thing, then I'm going to feel stuck and I am not going to figure out who I am. So what this means is that Veronica coming home shaky is not Veronica being a defective Veronica. She's a person responding to a meeting, a drive home, and 18 other moments piled on top. Same with Archie. Now, he is rushing to fix her mood. That's not Archie being broken, Archie. His nervous system, his learning history, his own causes and conditions, those are all at play.

So, this maybe sounds like it would contradict Schnarch's whole thing about differentiation, but it doesn't. It really deepens it. Differentiation was never about being independent. Nobody is independent. What Shnarsh is saying and what this Buddhist piece are saying are really these related things from different angles, that you exist in a web of relationships. It's interdependent. Nothing stands alone. When I do a thing, my partner will react. And that your sense of who you are can't be borrowed from one node of the web every time you feel uncertain. The web is real.

So is your distinct presence in it. That's what makes this trap of other validated intimacy so specific. It isn't bad because connection with another person's bad. It can be a challenge because it treats the self as this fixed object that has to be confirmed by another fixed object. You know me. If you don't validate this version that I think I am, then all of a sudden, then you don't care about me and nobody likes me versus what if there's no fixed object? There's a continual adjustment. It's the first time that you've been you in that moment with those 18 things

that led to that day and you went to work and your boss said the thing. And there's truth in the fact that maybe your boss was going through a lot and you don't know that. So, is he diffusing his anger, his discomfort onto you? You're in a particular way that day that you can't just go, huh, okay. Now, oh my gosh, am I going to lose my job or what's wrong with me? Or what are the things that I miss? Now you bring that energy home and you got Archie who was just sitting around being Archie and now he feels that. And when you walk in the door and now he's reacting to you. There's continual adjustment in you and your partner and in the relationship.

So, the tension on the table, I think, is this. And Lusk's research says validation calms the body, it builds trust, and it opens change. Schnarch says depending on validation from your partner is one of the things that keeps long-term couples stuck. Both are right. So when Veronica comes home upset, something happened inside of Archie that he probably wasn't even aware of. He definitely wasn't prepared for it. Her distress didn't just land in his ear holes. He felt it in his body.

So Schnarch would say that their nervous systems were doing what fused nervous systems do. The anxiety was actually flowing between them. And then Archie's emotional balance got knocked off the second hers did. There's a lot of research on this concept called co-regulation. And it's actually really solid for a psychology topic. Psychology, you often hear, is more of a soft science, not the medical model. You don't just put a cast on a broken bone and you fix it. Again, soft science. There's so many variables at play.

The most well-known study comes from james cone and his colleagues at the university of virginia was published back in 2006 and as someone that has a challenge not going with jokes constantly i just want you to know i almost want to bell the dean every time i think of a joke about what i want to say as i lay out the dynamics of this study but i'm not going to but they put married women and a fmri scanner so that's where you're you're putting some good old dye in the brain and you're watching things happen in real time. So they put married women in an fMRI scanner under the threat of mild electric

shocks, and then watch what happened in their brains under three conditions, alone, holding the hand of a stranger, or holding their husband's hand. Now, you can see they're starting certain jokes, but hold those to the side. When the women were holding their husband's hand, the threat-related activity in their brains went down, not metaphorically, but measurably. And then in the name of being authentic, I have one mosquito that has been in the office all morning. And there have been many pauses when he flies right in front of my face and

I try to gently grab him so I can escort him outside. If you know what I mean. But the better the marriage, the bigger the effect. And then follow-up studies have shown the same basic thing in other ways. Intimate partners' nervous systems synchronize. Heart rates start to converge during emotional conversations. Skin conductance, the same thing that a polygraph measures, rises and falls together. Cortisol, the stress hormone, can be measured running in parallel between couples in a way that does not happen between strangers.

Oxytocin, the cuddle hormone, starts to run free. And then other researchers put people in a room watching their romantic partner go through a stressful task through a one-way mirror, and that observer's cortisol climbs alongside their partners. And again, if this was the Waking Up the Narcissism podcast, maybe they would have some situations where then the partner would, their happy chemicals would rise, but that's a whole different podcast. But when Veronica walked in the door upset, Archie's body was reading her body before any conscious thought caught up. I think that's one of the key points here.

His system started shifting the direction that hers had shifted. The pull toward reassurance was at least partly biological. It was happening without him even knowing. Get her settled because if he can get her settled down, his nervous system settles down. Which means when Archie said, you are so good at your job, I wouldn't worry about it. He wasn't actually answering what Veronica said. He was managing his own discomfort with her being uncomfortable. So the reassurance wasn't for her, it was for him. And I think this one can be a hard one to sit with because I think most of us,

when we do this, genuinely believe we're being loving. Another version of this is when somebody tells you a really horrific or difficult thing and you answer with, man, I'm so sorry. And that's it. Because then the person telling you the story, it's as if now they're required to then say, it's okay, I'm sure I'll be fine, or thank you. When you see it that way, then when somebody is saying, I'm sorry, it becomes pretty clear that it is more of a them thing. They said the thing, hey, I am so sorry. I want you to know I'm sorry.

So, but keep going and I'll tell you I'm sorry again. And I'll even maybe even say, let me know what I can do to help. So, I said all the stuff, right? Check. Can I take off now? Again, believing though that we're being loving and I believe that that is a, it is a kind thing to do. So, we're not lying to ourselves on purpose. We just, we have this system, one that we now know is measurable in the body that registers a loved one's pain as our pain and then dispatches comfort because that's what gets the temperature down for us. It gets the temperature down for us.

Schnarch has a phrase for the system underneath it. He calls it emotional fusion, togetherness without separateness. It's this persistent emotional link where every move that one person makes will impact, or he says, upsets the other's balance. And then the only way to feel okay again is to get the other person to feel okay first. And fusion, I need you to feel better and I need you to feel better so I can feel better are the same sentence. You just can't tell that from the inside. And I think this is the part where a lot of us, if we're honest, find ourselves on the giving end.

The friend who can't let your bad day be bad, the parent who needs you to be okay so they can sleep tonight, or the partner who keeps reassuring you while you're trying to tell them something difficult, and then us doing it back to them. Now, I want to do a quick tangent here because this co-regulation piece is so fascinating, and it opens up something that I've been chewing on as a couples therapist for a little while since I've been currently obsessed about co-regulation. So this, the biology that I just described, a partner's nervous system synchronizing, it usually shows up in therapy in, I would say, a hopeful way.

One partner starts doing the work, they get a little more grounded, a little less reactive, a little more able to stay with their own experience without needing the other person to fix it. And the other partner will push back a little bit at first, but then often within weeks or months starts to settle too. And they come into alignment or coherence, not because they got drug into therapy, but because the system around them shifted and their nervous system had something different to basically attune to. That's the version that makes co-regulation sound like a beautiful love story. But the version I see a lot less written about is different,

where one partner does that same part, the work. They get grounded, they get present, they become non-reactive, and the other partner gets more dysregulated. And at first, the other partner is typically going to get dysregulated regardless. I call it testing for safety because they've seen their partner say things before, I'm going to change, I'm going to do this different, but they can't trust it. The person is testing for safety, but then over time, when one person calms and comes into coherence, but the other person in another situation,

they become even more and more dysregulated, not less. Sometimes the point of blowing up the whole relationship. And I've just been noting that for quite a while. So I started a conversation with somebody who works in the field of epigenetics that I just absolutely love and I've known for a very long time. We'll call him Jack. We'll bring back Jack here. No Jill, but Jack. What follows, I'm going to share some notes with you. Full transparency, two people tossing ideas around, not running a study. We were not landing on conclusions. We were two curious humans wondering if there's something here. So take it as that.

So the first concept that Jack brought in was from the world of physics, which I know little to nothing about. And he talked about energy landscapes. And it's this idea that systems in physics and in chemistry tend to settle into states that take the least energy to maintain. And this makes sense to me because I know that this is why we form habits. We do things repetitively and then the brain eventually habitualizes it because it takes less electrical activity of the brain. And in the world of the brain is a don't get killed device. The brain is operating from this incorrect assumption that it has a finite amount of electrical activity.

So, it's trying to habitualize everything, thoughts, activities, you name it. But when you get back to these concepts of energy landscapes, Jack said, picture a ball rolling across a series of hills and valleys. The ball never will stop on a hillside. It rolls until it finds a valley, a low point where it can rest without effort. And what he was suggesting was that people might have something like emotional energy landscapes, that we settle into patterns that feel stable, even if those patterns are unhealthy, because stable takes less energy than change.

So, when two people enter a relationship, their individual landscapes combine, and now they make a new shared landscape together. And that shared landscape has its own valleys, its own low energy stable states. And that's where a relationship tends to come to rest. A couple can be settled in a valley that's healthy or settled in a valley that's painful, but it's stable. You both feel normal once you're in them because stable is stable. It becomes the familiar. I think of it often as a couple can actually co-regulate in chaos.

Because change then, by definition, would require going back up a hill, which is going to take work, which means when one partner starts doing the work, it becomes more grounded. They're not just changing themselves, but they're essentially trying to change the shape of this shared landscape. The old valley that everybody has been resting in starts to flatten out, and the system has to find a new equilibrium. Sometimes the system finds a healthier valley. That's the love story. Other times, the partner who isn't necessarily doing the work can't tolerate the climb out of that familiar valley.

Their system, for reasons that may go all the way down into their biology, early adversity, childhood trauma, neural wiring, autonomic patterning that got laid down before they had words, those deeply rutted neuropathways, it registers the destabilization of getting out of this familiar dynamic, this familiar dance, this familiar pattern as a threat, not as an invitation to, hey, let's go find something better. So, they push back, sometimes by leaving, sometimes by escalating, sometimes by blowing the whole thing up. Jack actually used a cell biology image that was wild and fascinating and it

stuck with me, that cells actually respond to signals from neighboring cells. If you think about it, when cells divide and creating life, they're just a bunch of cells. They respond to signals from neighboring cells. They don't operate independently. Some cells, given the right signal, integrate and become something new, some new organ some new it's fascinating the body the human body is a miracle other cells though given the same signal behave destructively some literally self-destruct like i guess viruses and things like that different cells have different thresholds for what they can absorb and then what shatters them so here's my big old speculative leap and i want

to be clear it is a very big leap but what if people are somewhat similar the grounded partner is essentially sending a new signal into the system. Some nervous systems, meaning their partners, can take that signal and adapt. You bet. I'm ready to go be a heart or a liver. Maybe you wouldn't want to be a liver, but I'm ready to change, to be something new, something that is healthier, better for us. But then others can't. Not because they're bad, but because their regulatory capacity built from early childhood adversity, trauma, wiring, all of it.

They don't have room yet for destabilization. And if any of this stuff is even partly true, it changes how I sit with the couple in front to me because the partner who's doing the work isn't doing anything wrong if the relationship comes apart. They're sending this signal to get to this new place in the relationship. But the system as it currently is, as it currently exists, can't yet take in, can't metabolize. And sometimes that feels pretty crummy to say out loud, especially as a couple's therapist, because the temptation is then to make somebody a villain, the partner who left, the partner who escalated, the therapist who should have done more.

But the energy landscape image opens something up completely different. Sometimes a system reaches a place where its current valley doesn't work anymore and the next valley over isn't available. And what's between the two is a climb and the system maybe can't make it right now. Or one of the people is so set in their ways of trauma that they don't want to try. And if their partner tries, it can probably feel like a deep form of abandonment if their partner no longer can remain in the relationship as it is.

But they're willing to go and look for this new energy landscape because they can't put the genie back in the bottle. They can't go back into the unhealthy, toxic dynamic that they have been co-regulating around for so long. Okay. End of the tangent back to the main thread. So how do these two things sit together? So validation is real and validation is powerful. And I think it does get a bad rap. It needs a new PR department because it isn't a negative thing. It can make us feel better and more connected and close. However, needing validation is a trap.

So both of those things are true. So where does that leave someone who is really trying to show up and be a good partner? Let's talk about the word paradox, because to me, if you spend any time around mental health work, you start to notice that the most helpful mental health moves are almost always, and I don't like to use the word always or never, but almost always paradoxical. The things that look like they should make you better often make you worse. And then the things that look like they should make things worse are often where the growth lives.

I talk as often as I can about the negative impacts of shame. I don't think that I've ever worked with anybody where shame has been a component of growth. Yet most people still go to this place of shame that I am bad. Something is wrong with me. If that was the thing that worked, then everybody would be better and I wouldn't have a job. And people would go around shaming each other, shaming themselves, and then live happily ever after. But it's moving away from that, which is so difficult because it's so deeply rooted in us that is the thing that actually helps.

Or I'd say a more obvious example is the concept of discomfort. The human default is to avoid discomfort. We move away from hard conversations, difficult feelings, awkward truths. And the more that we avoid, the more our life gets organized around what do I have to do to avoid? What do I have to do so people won't find out until that avoidance itself is the problem and it gets too big to manage. So the paradox is that growth lives inside the discomfort that we're running from growth from discomfort so when

somebody learns to lean into the thing that they used to dodge it's not because they are a sadist or a masochist but it's because all right i now have the confidence that i'm going to grow through the discomfort that i'm going to be able to make it through this the world is still going to spin people could get upset and frustrated and angry and all those emotions and it's going to be okay now your version of okay we could talk about that, everything continues to move. And I think certainty works the same way. We crave certainty. We want to know that the marriage will last,

that this relationship is going to be worth the time I'm going to spend, that this job, if I change jobs, that it's going to pay off in the long run, that the kids will turn out and the career will work, and that the diagnosis will be benign. The more we need certainty, the less able we are to be present in the actual life that we are in because the actual life that we're in is uncertain by definition. We can make lots of guesses and set amazing, wonderful goals, and then we can work toward those guesses and goals. But somebody forgot to tell life that that's the thing that we're doing.

The paradox is that accepting the uncertainty is what makes you more in the present moment. It makes the present moment more available. You can't be here while you're trying to nail down what's coming next, or I should have known something from the past. I would say then the validation paradox follows that same pattern. The thing that looks like the answer, get validated by your partner. Manage their emotions, make sure everything they're okay in order for me to be okay, is the thing that traps you. So the thing that looks impossible, give validation generously without needing

it back, is the thing that can open up the relationship. Because in order to even give that validation, I need to know and understand what you are experiencing and what you're going through and not how it makes me feel. That resolution then is in differentiation itself because a differentiated person can give validation generously because giving it doesn't cost them anything. They're not bidding for it to come back to them. They're not buying future credit. They're not building up that emotional bank account. They're not soothing their own anxiety by managing their partner's mood.

They're not trying to find the right thing to say so that they can feel okay. They eventually learn to have a quiet enough mind and a calm enough heart, to use Schnarch's phrase, that they can sit with their partner's pain without needing to fix it for their own regulation. A differentiated person can also receive validation when it shows up without it becoming a structural beam of their self-worth. It turns out it becomes a bonus. It's not a verdict of who you are.

And a differentiated person can hear something difficult from their partner, including a refusal to validate them and then stay standing and be okay. Their sense of self doesn't fall apart when their partner doesn't reflect back to them in the way that they want them to. This is the move that Schnarch calls self-validated intimacy. And it's so much harder than what most of us were sold about relationships. Because most of us were sold the idea that the right partner makes you feel seen and valued and safe and it just unfolds and happens naturally.

Schnarch would say the right relationship makes you build the version of yourself that doesn't need to be made to feel those things by another person. There's a line that I keep coming back to that in an adult relationship, you can have love or you can have control. You cannot have both. Validation given as a gift is one of love's truest forms. Validation given as a transaction is control with the better PR firm, the better marketing. So the paradox concept, I think, holds true here. Validate generously, but do it from a place of genuine validation because you are learning about

your partner. You're trying to understand who they are. Don't make your partner responsible for delivering it back, though. Both halves of that sentence have to stay alive at the same time. The moment you try to resolve it cleanly one way or the other, then you lose the power of this differentiation moment. The discomfort that you want to skip is where growth lives. The certainty that you want to know and grab hold of is the thing keeping you out of your own life and being in the present moment. The paradox isn't a problem to solve. It's actually the thing to then welcome and acknowledge.

Oh, okay. The paradoxical thing. It's the thing that I'm probably avoiding the most is telling me something. And then there's one more thing I think to fit in here as well, because none of this works without it. And this is big. If you can't validate yourself, you cannot really give validation away as a gift. You can maybe loan it out, but you're kind of waiting for it to return. The whole structure of self-validated intimacy is built on the floor of self-validation. Now, what does that look like? Because here's where we start getting into the world of cliches.

Usually you'll hear the advice is just to learn to be okay with yourself or just learn to self-validate. And that on its own is kind of useless because if you've already built your entire sense of self on the validation of other people, which most of us have for the reasons that we talked about earlier, then you truly don't actually know who you are without interacting with somebody else who is telling you this is who you are or this is what I think you should do. There really isn't a real deep self in there yet that you can validate. This is where I become an unapologetic acceptance and commitment therapy fanboy

because in ACT, that is the work of figuring out who you actually are. What drives you? What do you actually care about? What are your core values? And again, a value is not something you land at. A value is not to make a million dollars. A value is a North Star. A value is something you can always turn back to, like curiosity, like adventure, like connection. It's what you want your life pointed at, and it will help you discover the things you like. But that last one is kind of sneakier than it sounds. Because if you can't easily answer what you like to read or watch or listen

to or eat or to do when you have time by yourself on a weekend, and I think a lot of adults can't, It's usually not because the answer does not exist, but maybe somewhere along the way, you learn to check what other people would think of your answer before you let yourself have one, which means that even if your taste was being run through this external validation filter, you still weren't necessarily choosing what you like because you're aware that maybe that isn't the right thing to like, which is kind of crazy when you lay it out the way that we're talking about it today. But you're more choosing what was safe to like, which is still a form of needing

external validation. You need somebody else to tell you that the thing that you like or that the thing that you want to do or even the thing that you did is okay. This is where the work starts to come into play. It is your own hero's journey. Going back and forth, figuring out what is actually you. You're not going to know. You're going to start doing and trying and figuring things out. It's this journey to figure out what you actually enjoy, what you'd choose with your time if nobody were watching and nobody were grading you. What matters to you when nobody's going to clap and applaud and say, way to go. So, and then knowing that even the, I don't even know what I like,

or I don't know what my values are, I don't know what my values are, is a story that my brain can still get me fused to and stuck on. I have people that will come in after a couple of weeks or a month and say, man, I still haven't figured out what they even do to start. That's still this fear that I'm going to do the wrong thing. Just start doing. And then that work done over months and years is eventually what gives you something to validate. That kernel of truth that you're looking for in your own experience becomes something you find, you discover because now you have a reference point.

You start to know what you can stand on. It is such a cliche and it is never felt more real. The more that you figure out who you are is that if I don't love myself, I cannot genuinely love another person because I'm trying to figure out how can I get them to love me? Then I'm showing up as any different version of myself, hoping that's going to be the right one to get them to love me and that that will feel good. If I love myself, truly love myself, now I can absolutely love this other person. And back to the Psychology Today article, her piece and I think Shnarsh's first

point of balance are walking up to the same door kind of from two different angles. Shnarsh is talking about knowing who you are without needing anybody else to tell you, being able to confront yourself honestly, staying authentic, figuring out who you are under pressure to be someone else. Self-validation in that sense is not the same as positive self-talk. It's not telling yourself you're amazing. It's the harder move of noticing what you're feeling and recognizing, again, this kernel of truth in it and giving it room to exist without trying to talk yourself out of it. The practice that the author Lusk offers is worth, I think, really kind of slowing down.

She talks about noticing a moment when you've been harsh with yourself. Find where you feel it in your body. Get curious about what that harsh voice is trying to do. Protect you, fix you, motivate you. And where did you first hear that voice? And then once you've actually listened, tell yourself a kinder and more accurate truth. So something like, man, it makes sense that I learned to talk to myself this way because that's the way it was modeled to me. Now I'm going to choose something else. The body piece is worth noting because

most of us live so far up in our heads and trying to intellectualize things that we're trying to argue our way to internal peace. Self-validation, the kind that actually changes anything, usually has to land in the body before the head catches up. And that's the work that lets everything else in this episode become real instead of just theoretical. Because without it, you're just collecting another framework. This, it sounds good. Back to Veronica. She's sitting on the edge of the bed. What could Archie have done differently?

The temptation is to hand him a script and pay attention, reflect what you heard, acknowledge the feeling, ask before solving. And Lusk gives all those tools in her article and their real tools worth practicing. I think a more useful question might be what Archie would have needed to be capable of in order for any of those tools to land. Because he would have needed to stay with her in her pain long enough to actually hear it. without his own nervous system shoving him toward the nearest exit. So even if you hand him a script, tell his nervous system about that.

He would have needed a self solid enough that her bad day didn't become his emergency that he needed to get rid of. The script is downstream. The differentiation is upstream. And I could not wait to work this concept into a podcast because the word upstreams, it's something that I've been using more and more. So when we talk about a reaction, Archie rushing to fix Veronica's mood and Veronica coming home already shaky, what we usually see and we try to work on is the downstream moment,

the reaction itself, the words that you're going to say, the script that we're supposed to use in the middle of the conflict. Upstream is everything that set up that moment. And it could go back days, weeks, months, years, nervous system regulation in the hours and days before the conversation happened. That's looking upstream. And that can be things that are going to sound pretty boring. Sleep, food, hydration, movement, sunlight, time outside, time alone. The mindfulness practice that builds the capacity to notice your own state before it takes over.

Because by the time you're reacting, if I'm being honest, it's already too late. And I'm not saying that like you're doomed, but it just is acceptance. The reaction is happening at a speed that your conscious mind can't catch up to. This is one of the few places where I think the nervous system science, it gets really practical and it's to me helpful to know and to understand. Because if you want a fighter's chance at responding in a moment instead of reacting, you have to give your nervous system the conditions to stay online. And those you're going to actually be able to do the more you learn about where

upstream did this reaction start? Hydrated, slept, fed, moved, outside, even briefly, that boring stuff, that's the upstream stuff. And there's an old acronym in recovery that lands here too, halt, hungry, angry, lonely, tired. If you find yourself reacting bigger than the situation actually calls for, go through those four. It's almost always at least one of those that's at play. And when you find it, and this is so key, it's not an excuse, it's data. The move of, man, I snapped because I hadn't eaten, used to defend yourself

in a conversation, is still outsourcing your stuff to somebody else for validation. You want them to tell you it's okay. The actual upstream move is, I snapped. And when I look back, I noticed that I was running on three hours of sleep and I hadn't eaten since breakfast and it's already almost bedtime. That's good data. That's information about me, about what I need to set up differently next time. And I'm not saying the next time that she walks in and has this bad information from her boss. It's that's going to help set me up to be able to deal with whatever it is that life throws at me.

So the script is downstream, the differentiation upstream. And so is most everything that gives your nervous system more of a chance. And then let's talk about Veronica. So she walks in the door. She's already shaky, already needed something from him to feel okay. Important to note that with that said, she could have been in a state that even if Archie would have said the perfect thing, whatever the perfect thing would have been, there's a chance she would have settled. Maybe, maybe not. And if she would have for tonight, but the underlying setup would still be there. Her piece, depending on him saying the right words, showing up from the right

person at the right time can calm one's anxiety. So a lot of times our brain goes back to, but this one time when I did say the one thing, then it worked. And it did that one time for the one thing, but this is a different time with different things. What if Veronica had walked in the door and she actually was already settled? Not because the day wasn't hard, all the same stuff happened. It was, but because she'd done the work, even in the car on the way home of acknowledging what she actually felt, finding the kernel of truth in it, sitting with her fear without needing to be talked out of it, then she could still share that with Archie.

That's the amazing thing. It's not that you don't need your partner or you want your partner, you're choosing your partner to then process these things with. Then whatever Archie said could have been a bonus connection instead of trying to get rescued or trying to rescue the other person. So both of those moves, Archie building the self that can sit with her pain and then Veronica building the self that doesn't require him to, which again, doesn't mean that we're not going to communicate. But I'm not depending on him to say the right things to make me feel better. And if he doesn't, then he doesn't care and I'm unlovable.

But those things can both be true. You've got that Archie building the self. Creating the container to handle her emotions and Veronica being able to self-soothe, calm her own anxiety so it doesn't require him to do anything. That's the same work, differentiation from both sides of the relationship. And there are stages along this path because I would imagine even some of you are thinking, I don't even really know what this guy just talked about for 45 minutes or an hour. Others are saying, okay, I get it, but man, I don't do it very often.

Some might be patting themselves on the back a little bit saying, all right, I'm starting to do this more than I didn't before. Stages. Stage one. And these stages, you bet. I have been working these in as much as I can because they're really resonating. I hear that from my clients who listen to the podcast. I'm receiving more emails that are talking about this. It's helped me so much. I want to lean into this. Stage one, unconscious incompetence. You don't know what you don't know. An example, you walk into the kitchen, you see dishes in the sink, and you are mad. You don't even know why you're that mad. You just know that your partner in

the moment, they are the worst. They do this all the time. I can't believe it. They don't care about me. The reaction, though, feels justified because you're that mad. You're not even aware that there's another way to be in that situation. Now, stage two, conscious incompetence. You walk in, you see the dishes, and that irritation still flares up in you. Somewhere in the middle of it, maybe you catch yourself. Sometimes you don't, but you're aware. You know, your reaction's probably a little bit over the top. It's a little bigger than what's actually happening. You know, you're not really mad about the dishes, maybe kind of feels that way,

but something else about it, you still can't quite stop it. You grumble, you make the comment anyway. And this is the stage that's the hardest. It's the one where people want to quit. They wish they didn't know what they didn't know because awareness has arrived, but mastery hasn't. And the reason I like laying it out this way is because hopefully when you hear it that way, of course it hasn't. This is all new. You're going through this. You got nervous systems and the need for validation and managing the other person's anxiety and real life happening. Watching yourself do the thing without being able to stop the thing is painful, but you're on the path of growth because soon-ish, eventually.

Stage three, conscious competence. The dishes are there. You notice a little bit of the irritation. You pause. you feel it move through your body. You remind yourself that your partner does a lot of things that you don't always acknowledge. You recognize that nobody's perfect, including you on a Tuesday, and you let it pass without making it everybody else's problem. And you probably put the dishes away and you don't need to say, do you see what I did? Then stage four, unconscious competence. The dishes are there. There's no spiral. There's just noticing they are there. Maybe you load them. Maybe you mention

it later. Maybe you don't. There's no big mood or moment around them. It just is. If you find yourself in stage two right now, aware, but still reacting, welcome to the human experience. It's part of the process that most people quit. It's where they quit going to therapy. They go back to listening to, I don't know, I want to just say fantasy books. I'm not saying that listening to fantasy books is bad, but I know that I hear people often say that they will listen to things like my podcast for a while until it gets frustrating. And it's funny because they'll say to me as almost then I need to do something about that.

My bad. But that just means that it's getting uncomfortable and the person is probably aware, but they're not doing. That part as well, this conscious incompetence is the part that's closer to the other side than it feels. The awareness is landing in the body. It just takes longer than the awareness landing in the head. I'll get it. It'll make sense, but I don't feel it or I'm not doing it yet. So keep going. And what do we learn today? Validation is real. The research is very real. And it is something that we have needed. And now we need to learn to not live off of it.

It is nice to have. Practice it generously. Look for the kernel of truth in the people that you love, even if their reality doesn't match yours. and then keep doing that harder work underneath. Look further upstream. The work of being someone who can give that gift of validation and seeing the other person without needing credit for it and learning how to stand on your own ground, even when it doesn't come back. That is the thing that is going to change the way you show up in a relationship. And that's where intimacy actually lives. I would love your thoughts,

your questions, examples, experiences, anything that you have about this. Share it with somebody if you think that it would help them. And taking this out per usual, the wonderful, the talented Aurora Florence with her song, it's wonderful because dug on it, it really is. We'll see you next time on The Virtual Touch.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Hosts

  • Tony Overbay Host Feed-stated

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. How Childhood Shapes Who You Marry: The Accommodator, Attachment, and Why We Choose the Familiar

    Nov 13, 20261 hr 18 minAudio

    Why do people pleasers and avoidant partners find each other, and why does it seem like such a relief at first? Tony follows Pam and Jim, a composite couple, from childhood to the college campus where they met. Pam...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Nobody Brings a Casserole When You Wake Up to Betrayal: The Accommodator, Gaslighting, and Rebuilding Trust

    Nov 4, 20261 hr 29 minAudio

    Waking up to betrayal, gaslighting, or emotional immaturity rarely comes with a casserole on the porch or a meal train. When someone has a baby or a surgery, people can see the event and show up with dinner. When you...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Nobody Brings a Casserole When You Wake Up to Betrayal: The Accommodator, Gaslighting, and Rebuilding Trust

    Nov 4, 20261 hr 29 minAudio

    Waking up to betrayal, gaslighting, or emotional immaturity rarely comes with a casserole on the porch or a meal train. When someone has a baby or a surgery, people can see the event and show up with dinner. When you...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Your AI Is a Great Hype-Man - A Therapist Has a Few Notes (Plus Live QA)

    Oct 14, 20261 hr 32 minAudio

    Using AI as a therapist? Your chatbot might be building a great plan for the person you’re hoping to become. When a client’s chatbot asked if he was an extroverted go-getter, he answered as the man he’s working toward,...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Why Good People Defend Leaders (and Others) Who Contradict Themselves: Identity, Bias & Belonging

    Sep 24, 202653 minAudio

    Tony starts with a kid raised in an East Coast fishing town and another raised hiking Arizona trails. He uses them to show how beliefs tend to form through family, community, and identity, with the reasons showing up...

    Credit the people on this episode