What If You're Not the Problem You Think You Are in Your Relationship?
1 hr 10 minAudio
What if the reason difficult conversations feel so impossible isn’t because you’re too sensitive, too anxious, or bad at communicating? What if you’ve spent years trying to find the perfect words - only to have your questions dismissed, your feelings turned against you, or the conversation somehow become about everything you did wrong? In this crossover episode of The Virtual Couch and Waking Up to Narcissism, Tony explores what has to happen before you can truly say the difficult thing. He breaks down the difference between ordinary fear and a nervous system that has learned through experience that vulnerability may come at a cost. You’ll learn why explaining yourself more doesn’t always lead to being understood, how emotionally mature and immature people respond differently to difficult conversations, and why your partner’s defensiveness doesn't automatically mean you communicated poorly. Tony also explores the importance of knowing who you are, learning to tolerate discomfort, recognizing when you’re trying to manage someone else’s emotions, and speaking from integrity without making your peace dependent on the other person’s response. This episode isn’t about deciding that everything is someone else’s fault. It’s about becoming honest enough to recognize what belongs to you, what doesn’t, and whether the problem is really who you’ve believed yourself to be - or the relationship pattern you’ve been trying desperately to survive. You'll learn how to: - Recognize the catastrophic "simulations" your brain runs - and why it files imagined disasters right next to real memories - Spot the difference between managing your partner's emotions and actually allowing them their own experience - Say the true thing from a grounded place instead of a needy, validation-seeking one - Understand why the leap is the last step, not the first - and why the "okayness" on the other side is something you build before you jump Drawing on more than two decades as a licensed marriage and family therapist, Tony walks through what actually gets you across the chasm - and it's quieter, slower, and stranger than "just be braver." Part two lands soon - send your questions and situations to contact@tonyoverbay.com and Tony will work them into the next episode. 00:00 Crossover Episode Intro 01:02 Bungee Jumping Story 05:36 Differentiation Explained 09:09 Codependency Fried Clams 12:20 Mature vs Immature Dynamics 17:03 Fine Text Example 22:50 Constructing Your Crucible 25:25 Therapy Gridlock Scripts 27:44 Attack Surface Vulnerability 33:27 Cliff Edge Say It 35:27 Leap of Faith Metaphor 38:41 Why Just Jump Fails 40:53 Advice and Validation Trap 44:47 Fear Is a Story 46:52 Emotional Immaturity Dynamics 49:20 Brain Prediction Machine 58:16 Grounding Before the Leap 01:03:29 Growth Edge vs Safety Data 01:08:13 Wrap Up and Next Steps Please follow Tony on Instagram @virtual.couch, on TikTok @virtualcouch, on Facebook https://www.facebook.com/tonyoverbaylmft, and on Substack https://thevirtualcouch.substack.com/ You can reach out to Tony through his website tonyoverbay.com or by emailing contact @ tonyoverbay.com
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Hey everybody, welcome to another, we'll call it a crossover episode of The Virtual Couch, as well as waking up to narcissism. You will see why in a minute, because I am going to get very creative and fancy and give some emotionally immature responses along with some very emotionally mature therapeutic responses to all the things that we're going to talk about today. I'm your host, Tony Overbay. I'm a licensed marriage and family therapist, a certified mindful habit coach, writer, speaker, husband, father of four, and follow me on social media on Instagram at virtual.couch and on TikTok at virtualcouch.
Join my substack, substack.virtualcouch.com, I believe. I'll have links to that in the show notes. I want to start today with a story that I did Google a little bit because it is so far in the past that I did have to wonder if I have made up some of the events. And I did not, but I did have to go in the Wayback Machine. If you've ever done that on the internet, Google that, the Wayback Machine. It's fascinating because you can look at websites that were around a long time ago. The year was 19, probably 91 or 92.
My wife, Wendy, and I had just been married. We will be celebrating our 36th wedding anniversary soon. So this was truly newly married and you can absolutely insert some sort of hair joke there because I had it. It was so receding at that point already as a 20, 21, 22 year old male human being. And what's even funnier is at the time, I really thought it was because I wore a lot of baseball hats. And it wasn't like genetics hadn't been invented yet, but I definitely didn't put a lot of time into that. But I digress. But Wendy and I drove out to a place in Utah near where we lived in Murray called
the 49th Street Galleria. And if anyone was around there at the time, you're welcome for the nostalgia. It was a place that had arcade, maybe a bowling alley. But on this day, it was all about the bungee tower. I did find out that it was demolished somewhere in the early 2000s. But back then, it had this 80-foot bungee jumping tower, and you could see it from the freeway. And we drove by it several times, and we eventually decided we are going to bungee jump for the very first time.
And in my own mind, I will admittedly say that I fancy myself as a little bit of a daredevil. But in hindsight, I didn't really have much to compare that to because it wasn't like I was one of those kids that would stand up on the seat of his huffy bike, holding out my hands and arms, stretched out wide, just daring the world to do something about it. I wasn't the guy who played what my friends literally called the pain game every single summer where they would launch themselves off the high dive at this community pool, the Pepperwood pool, and literally just land flat on their backs, on their stomachs.
And I had one friend who would just jump up and make it look like he was going to dive head first and then at the very last second, pull his arms into his sides and land on his head on purpose. I would get peer pressured and come on, Tony, do it. And I did not ever do it. I did not succumb to peer pressure because even now thinking about it, it makes me feel a little queasy even just describing it. But I wasn't quite that guy. I was fairly confident. And as Wendy and I climbed that tower, the flight of stairs going up flight after flight, and I was still running up the stairs thinking, oh, I'm going to be amazing at this.
I was a few steps ahead of her the whole way. I was going to hurl myself off into the great unknown, and I was going to show absolutely zero sign of fear. Now, fast forward about 10 or 15 minutes, because that's where the story really begins. I want to insert all kinds of jokes there about at that point. I was wishing I had an adult diaper, but it wasn't that bad. But I'm standing there a few inches from the edge of the ledge, and I am going into real-time, full-body education and the fact that my brain, and I will never forget this, at that particular point in my life was operating,
almost entirely as what I now refer to as a don't-get-kill device. Maybe that's where the origin story was because my brain was saying to me, oh, absolutely not. I don't care what you've read. I don't care what you've seen on TV. There was no internet at the time, but there was zero version of this, where I'm going to let you throw yourself off this perfectly stable, structurally sound tower to what is obviously your death. And I don't care who's gone before you. I don't care that you watched people doing it already. And don't you dare try to tell me this thin little stretchy rope is somehow going to be your salvation.
There was a pad that was wrapped around the bungee cord. And so eventually the guys who were running the whole operation told me that if I wanted, I could just hug the pad with every single bit of strength I had. And they would give me a push off the edge, which they also helpfully mentioned right before they did it is the technique that they use with very old people and very small children. So there's the daredevil that you're dealing with on the other end of this microphone. But I went and I didn't just go once. I did go a couple more times after that. And my wife did just jump out and have an amazing time.
And one detail that is going to come back around, which is that not one single time did I ever get to the edge and throw up the, I want to rock sign with my tongue out and just fall backwards joyfully into open air. That moment, the one I pictured, the whole climb up, it just never, it never came. My body never fully signed off on the idea that any of this was a very good plan. So hang on to that image of me frozen at the edge. Now I want to fast forward to something much more recent than I probably care to admit. Somewhere in the last few years, I found myself deep diving and reading books
and listening to podcasts and just immersing myself into the concepts of differentiation, differentiation of self. And if you listen to any of my episodes, you probably have heard that concept before, but I understand that that is me wanting to understand this. I will say to my clients or I'll ask my clients if they're familiar with differentiation. And usually it's like, I've heard you say that word. But it is a powerful concept that I think is something that I wish I would have known sooner, which is not a very productive thought. I know it now,
which is amazing and wonderful. And the concept I'm talking about with differentiation is primarily from the work of David Schnarch. Now, there's a guy named Murray Bowen, who I think is one of the fathers of differentiation. I love his work. But the Schnarch stuff really landed with me. And Schnarch defines differentiation as people's ability to balance humankind's two most fundamental drives. It's our desire for attachment and connection. That's on one hand. and our desire to be an individual and then direct the course of our own lives on the other. And that part, that's one of the biggest keys because that's the ability to
hold onto yourself when important people in your life pressure you to conform. Differentiation yields autonomy, emotional autonomy, which turns out to be the basis of healthy relationships. It's being interdependent, not codependent. And it really is this foundation for real intimacy in a marriage, in a relationship, in a partnership, in a relationship with a coworker. It's about long-term stability in the relationship because you're not sacrificing yourself in a very moment just to keep the peace, just so that we can get out
of this moment and nobody's going to be really upset. Because we have this fear that if all of a sudden somebody is upset with me or I think I did something wrong, that then the entire relationship is going to collapse. And that's why we spend so much of our time in relationships managing each other's emotions. I didn't want you to think this of me, or I felt bad about doing this thing. And we're not even allowing the other person to have their own emotional experience, which in a way, and this is probably early for me to say this, I want to get more of a buildup here, but it's a little selfish because it is saying that I don't want to feel a certain way, because if you feel a certain
way, it might make me feel bad. So I'm going to manage your emotions. I'm not going to tell you this thing because I'm worried about how you'll take it. But there's also a part of that where it's an, I don't know if I can hold on to myself. If you react a certain way. So I'm going to manage your emotional response. And it might be by not even telling you something difficult. I'm not even allowing you to have your own experience. And we won't get fully into this today, but I will say that there's a version of this that's a middle ground where I'm acknowledging that I'm managing your emotions.
Let's say that I don't want to let you know that I just learned that one of the kids is upset or frustrated with the way that you handled something. So I'm not going to tell you that because I don't want you to get mad. I don't want you to be really sad about what one of the kids said. So I'm going to hold on to that. If I own that, I do have to accept the fact that it comes with consequences or outcomes. It may come at the cost of my kid now thinking that I am choosing not listening to them or I'm invalidating their emotions or their feelings.
Or if later your kid talks to your spouse and says, yeah, I mentioned this to dad a while ago. Now your spouse can be upset with you. why didn't you tell me the sooner? I've been walking around for a week thinking everything was great. There will be occasions where owning that, that, okay, I was managing your emotions. But differentiation is such a fascinating concept because it will feel really different than what you're used to. It will feel like it is not a relationship because when we get into relationships, we are codependent and we are enmeshed and it is a survival instinct because
we meet somebody and we don't even really know who we are yet. They say, do you like something? Do you like, do you like seafood? And if you really don't, but you like this person, then you're going to tell yourself, you know, yeah, I do. I think seafood is great. And if they say, what are your favorite types of seafood? And you say, boy, you name one and I'll tell you. And they say, I don't know, fried clams, which is quite a stretch there. And if you didn't even know they fry clams or didn't even know what it looks like, you put it in a bun. What do you do with that? But you like that person, then you're more likely to say, no, yeah, I've had those. Those are pretty good.
And in your mind, you're thinking, it's not a big deal. I'm sure I would like those, but I'm definitely not going to tell them I don't. because if I tell them that I don't like fried clams, most likely we're going to break up right now. And I would hate for it to happen just over fried clams. So yeah, you bet I like them. And then let's say that we eventually try them and we don't like them. Then we're afraid to be honest. So now every year at your birthday, you're getting this whole fried clam cake and you're just saying, oh my gosh, yeah, another one of these, huh? And she's like, I know how you like the fried clams, even to the point where I put it in this cake. And at some point you're betraying yourself or at some point they're picking
up on this energy as you are just having a little, Why is it every birthday? You just want a little bite. You'll have some later. And then you see the dog sick the next morning because they've eaten an entire fried clam cake. All hypothetical. But differentiation, it is one of the keys to really having an intimate connection. How does that fit into this bungee jumping experience? It's really about learning how to respond to people in your life, learning to hold on to yourself, even in important relationships. It's learning how to know who you are without needing others to tell you, without needing that external validation.
That's learning how to soothe yourself. It's learning how to calm your own anxiety without needing that person to do it. You made me mad. I need you to say something differently to make me feel better versus I'm a grown human being, so I'm going to learn how to soothe myself so I can stay in the conversation. It's learning how to respond to people in your life from a more grounded place instead of a reactive one, instead of going too big. But it's also not withholding how you feel about things and not playing too small. It's learning that growth comes from discomfort. I'm going to take ownership of the things that I'm hearing if they are things I need to take ownership of,
but I'm not going to take ownership of things that I don't even understand or I don't agree with just to calm everybody's anxiety right now. And what it eventually leads to is you learn how to bring things up in a relationship that might be really uncomfortable. You learn how to say things that you've always wanted to say, not as a place of, I want to attack this person, but because I really want to be true to myself and I want to be true to the relationship. And I want to be honest with you about who I am and what you're asking. It's not from this clingy, anxiously attached, just, I mean,
is everything okay? Well, just tell me I'm okay. But it's really coming from more of a calm, subtle place that says, hey, I'm actually learning who I am and I like myself. I'm okay. And I don't need you to tell me that who I am is okay. Now I want your feedback, but I really want to, I want to be me and I want you to be you and I want to know who you are. I want you to really know who I am. Because of this idea of this crossover episode today, waking up to narcissism and virtual couch, I'm going to add another layer today. Because a lot of the time when I describe what healthy or emotionally mature
relationships sound like, primarily to the virtual couch audience, I get a lot of feedback of, okay, man, I'm really working on that. I didn't even know that was a thing. I definitely didn't grow up seeing it that way. My spouse and I are really trying on this together. And then, and this is a generalization, but the waking up the narcissism audience is often about, okay, what do you do though when the other person not only doesn't do those things, but then they use those things against you. They weaponize those things against you. They say, oh, you listen to a podcast now. You think you're so smart. That version of people will say, you know, what planet do those people live
on? And do you really work with people like that? And it's hard because if I'm working with a couple or an individual who is trying to get their spouse to come in for couples therapy, and they have that emotionally immature dynamic, they often do think, are there really people that work on, the relationship together? Is that really a thing? Because it's hard for them to acknowledge or recognize that, oh man, then my relationship might be worse than I think it is. And I get it because I have spent years inside these relationship systems,
as a couple's therapist and even inside my own, lived experience where I've dealt with my own emotional immaturity, narcissistic traits, defensiveness, blame shifting, a lack of knowing how to repair a relationship and where things don't go well. And then you go hunker down in your bunker for a few days and finally somebody pokes their head out and says, hey, are we okay? And you say, yeah, no, okay. Yeah, sorry. Yeah, I'm sorry. I don't know about what, But the absence of bad turns out to be good.
And I know now as a couples therapist and as a person that's navigated this as an individual, as a human, there's so much more for connection in a relationship. And that healthy version can almost sound fake. Today, I am doing something that I wanted to do for a very long time. I want to talk about the, and anytime you hear normal, it's with just think in your mind, air quotes, or emotionally mature version of a principle or a concept. And then I'm going to show you what the emotionally immature or maybe like the narcissistic trait, state, or system, what that reaction often sounds like.
And I will be very careful right from the beginning, because I want you to know if you are listening to this on the virtual couch, and you have heard me talk about waking up to narcissism, but you don't even want to go touch that podcast because of that word narcissism, please know that that entire podcast is built off of the concept that narcissistic personality disorder is a tiny percentage of the population. According to what study you look at, 3%, 4%, 5%, but we toss it around like it's 70% of the population. Everyone's ex, everyone's boss, everyone's cat.
I maintain that we're all emotionally immature. And when you view it from that lens, it sounds a little more hopeful and there's work to be done because one bad sentence or one of these examples doesn't make someone a diagnosable narcissistic person. One defensive moment doesn't mean that you need to go home and create a spreadsheet titled evidence of narcissism. And please do not do that or name it something else if you do. But what we're looking at are patterns, repeated patterns, repeated defensiveness, repeated lack of curiosity, repeated blame shifting, victimhood,
control, and a repeated inability or an unwillingness to repair. How many times do you hear the mouth sounds like, no, fine. Okay, you're right. I blew it. I'll work on it. That feels better. Those are the right words. The mouth sounds to hear, but then the person doesn't go and do anything. One of these points of balance of differentiation is growth through discomfort, taking ownership of the things I need to take ownership with and making effort for change. Because sometimes the person, the more immature narcissistic person, when they realize they are not going to get their way by being angry or by withdrawing
or by mocking or demanding, then sometimes they will say, no, you know what? You're right. I do need to do something different. But the fact that they had to go through all of those to get to that is the problem. And so then if you are asking a deeper question of why did it now, why did it take so long? Why did you have to go through the trying to yell at me and withdraw and pit the kids against me and threaten me financially and spiritually, to now say you get it. Because that's the problem. So, the emotionally mature version is going to say things like, let me look at myself. The emotionally immature version is going to say, this wasn't my fault.
You didn't even tell me. What was I supposed to do? And that difference, that's what matters. I'm going to give a lot of examples of what the emotionally mature and the emotionally immature version of things will look like. So when I talk about differentiation, here's what that might look like in everyday life. It's a moment where your partner says, fine. And now your brain wants to basically debate, hold a whole congressional hearing on what they meant by fine. Now, differentiation is noticing the spike in your body before you start to
cross-examine a one-word text message. And this is what is so fascinating. I've had a script somewhat written out for a while now on I'm sorry you feel that way as the premise of the entire episode. Because even in my more emotionally immature days, I have said, I'm sorry you feel that way. And it has been said with that kind of energy and vibe. And I meant it as, well, that's such a you thing. But then as I have hopefully become more grounded, understood myself more, maybe even understood the times when I have come across a certain way,
then I am genuinely sorry that you do feel that way. And I want to understand more. It doesn't mean that I'm going to fall on the sword and weep and wail and gnash teeth and say, I'm so bad. It's not going to be performative, but it's fascinating at times where it can sound the same or the words are written out the same. I'm sorry you feel that way. It can be so passive aggressive and it can also be very, very embodied that I'm so genuinely sorry that you feel that way because that would be hard if when I say this thing that you look at it in a certain way. And I'm not trying to tell you you're wrong, but I also want you to understand
why I say things the way that I do. And I would love for you to know me because I want to know you. Or another example is when your teenager gives you an eye roll, and instead of turning into a prosecuting attorney and threatening things just at random car keys, turn off the Wi-Fi. College tuition, and those are the things that you're just trying to say, I'm going to throw all these things out at you just to make sure you know I'm serious. The emotionally mature version pauses long enough to remember, I'm actually the adult here, allegedly. And I need to recognize if I need them to calm down, that's a me thing because
I don't know what to do with their emotions. Or if I need them to understand, then is it because I think that they should understand because I told them this thing one time a couple of years ago? The emotionally immature version is putting it back on the other person. The emotionally mature version is it is a me thing. That's the emotionally mature version. It's not perfect. It's not robotic. It's also not pretending that you don't have feelings, but noticing your feelings before before you start writing the courtroom drama. And a lot of times you learn that I'm actually okay. The feelings aren't as overwhelming.
They hit fast, but if I can kind of sit through them, notice them and not need to diffuse them onto my spouse or onto my teen, that moment passes and I still feel a little residual feeling or emotion, but I'm actually okay. Now I can make space for their emotions. I can stay and remain somewhat genuinely curious. So now the emotionally immature version. We go back to your partner says, fine. So let's say your partner says, how are you? Fine. And then you say, hey, are we okay? Now the emotionally mature version comes back and says, oh yeah, no, I think we are, but hey, help me understand what's going on for you.
Because you seem really concerned. And that's genuine. The immature version that, that I often see in my office, is somebody says, the person says, no, fine. And the other person says, are we okay? And then that person that said fine comes back with, whoa, okay. So now I can't even say fine is, this is exactly what I'm talking about. No matter what I say, you turn it into a problem. Maybe I should just stop talking altogether. Or I said fine because it was fine. It looks like you're the one that needs to make everything dramatic. And I shouldn't have to manage your insecurity every time I send a text.
So hopefully you'll see the difference because in a more emotionally mature relationship, clarity and questions and curiosity are absolutely allowed. The floor is always open for questions. You can even say, hey, I noticed I felt a little activated by that word. Are we OK? And the other person doesn't have to love it, but there's at least room for the question. In the emotionally immature relationship, clarity seeking questions get punished. And how many times I've heard somebody say, I hate repeating myself or yeah, I've already said at one time, they shouldn't have to ask. They should know
why I want the person to seek clarification. That's an intimate, real relationship. The question itself in the immature version becomes the problem. There's no curiosity. There's no, oh man, I didn't even think about how that landed for you. So thank you for sharing. It immediately becomes, well, you're too sensitive or you're exhausting and you're the problem. If we go back to the example, maybe the teenager's eye roll, the emotionally mature version is, ooh, I felt that one a little bit in my body, but I still need to be the parent. The emotionally immature version is, oh, you're going to roll your eyes at me
after everything that I do for you? Let's see how you like it having no phone, no car, no friends. That is an emotionally immature version. Or in a marriage, again, it sounds like, oh, there's the look if they roll their eyes. There's a look you always give me. You think you're better than me. You think you're right. You're just like your mom. That's emotional immaturity. One facial expression, one word becomes a character indictment. One moment is the trial. You are on trial now, and now I've got to panic because I don't want to say the wrong thing.
The reaction is so much bigger than the event because the person's not only responding to what happened, they're responding to actually their own shame, their own insecurity. Their own inability to know what to do with your emotions. Their own internal story about what that moment means. And that is going to matter as we come back to this bungee tower and this chasm, this jumping out into the great abyss. We're going to talk about that a lot today because so much of what keeps people frozen in their relationships as themselves and not trying to figure out who they are, it's not just fear of jumping out into the great abyss.
It's the story underneath the fear. Then right in the middle of all of this, I'm really sinking my teeth into Dr. David Schnarch's idea, what he calls constructing your crucible. And this has been such a key concept in helping me in my practice, in my life. I think it's one of the most important concepts that I did not understand, but yet I thought I understood in a long time. Schnarch describes constructing your crucible as taking your unresolved personal issues when you get into gridlock with a partner.
So when you are desperately trying to be understood or trying to explain yourself and your partner or whoever it is, isn't understanding. You are not feeling understood. You guys are at gridlock and no matter how hard it seems like you try, you're not really getting anywhere. We run into the same, situations and the conversation shuts down in the same way. That's gridlock. So you take your unresolved personal issues, the ones that are all tangled up in that gridlock situation, that that place where you guys keep grinding on the same thing and nobody budges
and you confront those issues as an act of integrity. That means you're going to own your own projection, meaning that I am owning my projection that my partner is just never going to understand this. They're not going to get it. There's no way that I can explain myself. So you're owning your projection. I'm projecting the fact that there is no way to be heard or understood here. And you're owning those projections, even when your partner does not reciprocate, even when they don't even try to meet you in the middle or meet you with curiosity at all. Here's the big pivot. You focus on yourself instead of, and I will quote,
air quote here, working on the relationship in that desperate, frantic, how do I get them to finally understand me kind of way. You stop trying to change your partner as the main project of the conversation. So then you say the thing. You say the true thing, or you do the true thing because it's the right thing for you to do. You are a person who says this thing. And I'll give you some examples. But the part that is so easy to miss is then
it needs to be outcome independent. You're not saying it to get a particular reaction out of them. You're not doing it to finally make them change. You maybe understand now a concept and you would love for them to understand. But if they're not being genuinely curious, there's a pretty good chance they're not going understand, but you are going to express yourself because you are now one who expresses themselves. You're doing it because that's simply who you have now decided to be. And I'll give you just such a simple example of this. Let's say that you realize
that your relationship is not improving and you have tried with all your might to convince your spouse that we really need couples therapy. And your spouse goes through a lot of reasons why not. No, I don't want to do that. I don't want to spend the money. We're not going to air out our dirty laundry in front of somebody else. We can just figure things out on our own. Whatever those things are they are things that have been said and they have worked because they have gotten you if you are the person that wants your spouse and you to go to couples therapy to back off so they work,
and over time no matter what you say or do you're going to come up you're going to hear these things over and over i even call them the greatest hits what's the old we can't afford it it's the old what's this therapist going to do to help us anyway it's the old they They are only in it for the money. And you've probably tried to defend those things over and over again. And eventually you're at gridlock. I think that we need to go to couples therapy and you could almost put this in this category of, and I could die on the hill of. So now they can say all the things over and over again, all these greatest hits. I don't think it'll work. You need to go work on yourself.
I'm doing work and you're not all those things. And you no longer react to those things. You've heard them. You've tried to prove and defend, but now you can go. back to the same place over and over and over again. We need to go to couples therapy and you're grounded and you're calm and you're saying it because it's the right thing to say. You now know this is what I am asking for in the relationship. Here's where things get really important in emotionally immature relationships because when you're dealing with somebody who is not being genuinely curious about you, about why you think we need to go to therapy, they're not willing
to self-confront at all and they're genuinely not curious about you. They don't necessarily really want to try to understand about how you're showing up, about what you're actually trying to say. They're more concerned about trying to explain themselves or convince you that you're wrong. And you find yourself explaining yourself over and over. And that does not help you. It actually does the opposite. What it actually does is hand them what I have come to call an attack surface. Because the more you say, the more there is for them to criticize,
to pick apart, twist around on you, if they're not being curious. Now, here's the emotionally mature version. You send a message that says, Hey, I'm trying to explain what happened for me. And I am absolutely open to hearing your experience too. In a healthier relationship, the person may not agree with all of what you're saying, but they can stay with your point. They can be genuinely curious, even if they disagree or they had a different experience. They can say things like, I didn't realize that that hurt you in that way. And tell me more about that. Help me understand rather than immediately going
defensive or even doing the gaslighting thing and just telling you that isn't, that is not what happened. You know, it's not what happened. Here's the emotionally immature version you send because you've tried so desperately to be heard and understood the five paragraph, finally vulnerable, emotionally honest texts, where you're trying so hard to be clear and kind and accountable and mature. And you're so worried about how you're going to say it. And I hope this lands, right? I'm I'm, I don't want this to make things worse, but I can't not say things anymore.
And they may respond if they respond. You may get nothing in that moment. Or they respond to one sentence. That isn't actually, we didn't even go to that place on vacation. Or again, it wasn't Tuesday, that was Wednesday. So now somehow they're trying to just get you to re-engage in a familiar way of, I guess I'm going to defend the calendar instead of talking about what I just put out there, this emotional bid. Or they say, well, first of all, that's not even what happened. If we can't be on the same page, then I don't know how I'm supposed to take the rest of what you just shared seriously. or how do you think that makes me feel?
These are acts of deflection. The vulnerable point that you shared is ignored and then they pick apart these tiny factual details. Those become a battlefield. The emotionally immature person does not have to engage with the pain that they caused you because now they can argue about the time frame or the wording or the tone or whether you used always when technically there was one Thursday in March where they didn't do the thing that you were saying that they did. Suddenly, it's not anywhere near about what your experience was, what the truth was. It's about escape. It's about how do I get out of this uncomfortable
situation? How do I not have to feel these feelings? And I don't even think that they're always aware of it, if ever really consciously aware of that. It's just a reflexive way to get out of the discomfort. It's their childhood, adaptation that has kept them alive to this point, and it is now maladaptive. It's causing a lack of intimacy in the relationship. You say things like, I felt really alone last night. They come back with, how do you think I felt? or, oh, so I guess I'm this horrible person. And there it is, the attack surface. You handed them your heart and they brought a pair of scissors.
The emotionally immature version says, okay, I'm just a horrible spouse. That's what you're saying. I guess nothing I do is ever enough for you. And now you are defending a thing that you weren't even saying. And it's maddening. Or they say something like, interesting, because how do you think I feel? I'm always alone. And I've been meaning to bring this up as well, but apparently only your feelings are the ones it matter and you as maybe the pathologically kind person kindness is amazing but when it becomes pathological it's to your detriment, then do you find yourself then questioning your own reality or you find yourself
now apologizing for having your own emotions or your own experience before you even realize it, a more emotionally mature response would stay with your experience man you felt alone, i i'm so sorry tell me more about that. That does not mean that the other person has no experience of their own. It doesn't mean that they have to accept even a false accusation. It just means that they can stay with the vulnerability for a moment, a period of time, without collapsing into shame or counterattack. But that emotionally immature version, your pain makes them uncomfortable,
and now somehow your job is to make them feel better about the pain that they caused you that you're finally trying to express. It's like an emotional magic trick. Your pain made me feel bad. Now your job is to comfort me and make your pain that you just mentioned disappear. And then I will feel better. And if you lived in that long enough, you start to believe that sharing your feelings are selfish, that having needs is dangerous. And that asking for repair is opening myself up for an attack. And it's not. But in emotionally immature systems, it gets treated that way.
And the other thing that can happen is the more material that you hand them, the more material now they have to nothing you, to give you no response at all, to leave you standing there with all of your vulnerability, hanging out in the open and nothing coming back. And I cannot tell you how often that part is more painful than the argument itself, because at least in an argument, there's some form of engagement. You know you exist, but being nothing, being met with that blank wall after you've taken this risk and told your truth, your feelings, your experience,
That can feel like this emotional disconnect, this emotional free fall out into some void. I remember talking with a client once who had gone through a pretty emotionally devastating breakup and one of their parents came to help them get their things, drive them back to their childhood home. And that sounds amazing. That alone though was a lot for the person going through the breakup. Their parent, and I am saying if I was typing this out, all caps, BLESS THEIR HEART. But they were determined to make this a positive experience. Again, sounds great, but it was as if the parent needed to continue to make
sure that their son was having a good time, that their son recognized how great it was that their dad came out. Hey, we're bonding right now, right, champ? We're still bonding. Isn't this great? We never got a chance to do this. But when you can slow that down, you can see that, let's just say that the parent didn't know what to do if their son was going to be emotional. So this dad needed to make sure that they were having an amazing fun time a while back i was being interviewed on a podcast and i made a joke that that i really believed i i had actually believed it completely and this was quite
a while ago and i said on this in this interview i'm working with a lot of guys and a lot of the guys who come to me individually, are often being told that they're the narcissist or they're the immature partner and the fact that they're coming to me and willing to work on things, kind of says that I'll go with some emotional immaturity, but not narcissistic. And are there wrestling with some sort of people pleasing or what Dr. Robert Glover would call nice guy syndrome? If they stay engaged in the work, I have a lot of confidence. I can help. I can help guys like that a lot because I've been that guy.
I can lead someone where I have been. And these particular guys, they do a lot of work and they're showing up better in their relationships and they're being more grounded and they were more self-aware than they had ever been. But they still it was something was kind of missing they still had not quite found the courage or maybe the full skill set to construct this crucible, to say the thing that they needed to say so they could stop feeling like they are betraying themselves to stay rooted in their own integrity even when it gets uncomfortable. I said on this interview that I kind of felt like I had this whole group of
guys. We're all standing together at the edge of a cliff and we had done all the climbing and we'd done all the hard work to get up there in the first place. And everything that I'm reading and I'm talking about some really amazing books, This Masculine and the Relationship by G.S. Youngblood or Way of the Superior Man by David Dida and No More Mr. Nice Guy by Dr. Robert Glover. Then I start digging into the works of Carl Jung and he was talking about this stuff 150 plus years ago. And I go back and I find some amazing work from the Stoics. Everything I'm reading, I was learning. It was basically telling us the same thing, which was you're here. You're now grounded. You have learned to not react
and to make space for other people's emotions. And now you need to say the thing. Say the thing that you want to say, because you're no longer saying it from a needy, clingy, validation-seeking place. You're saying it because this is how I think, what I feel. In essence, it's saying, all right, We're on the edge of this cliff and now everything I'm reading says, all right, we just jump. I trust me, guys, I'm reading this. You jump out into this great abyss. And when you do, and I'm going to borrow from this guy named Terrence McKenna,
you discover that it's actually, it's a feather bed. Now, who wants to go first? I will be up here. I will coach you guys through it. I will give you amazing attaboys and go get them statements. But yeah, all right, go guys, start jumping. Because secretly I'm sitting there thinking, yeah, this part still seems pretty scary. It all makes sense, but it seems pretty scary. And if I give you the full context of this Terrence McKenna quote, the line, because I think the context matters so much and it means so much more to me now than even when I first started quoting this. He said, nature loves courage. He said, you make the commitment and nature will
respond to that commitment by removing impossible obstacles. So, it's almost like this discomfort or the fear of the yeah buts, as I call them, they're all in the way. But once you say, I am, this is what I'm going to do. And you're doing it from a place of confidence, from a place of being grounded, from a place of I need to go after my dreams. I need to not let others be the ones who tell me what and how I should live life. It's time for me to live life. But then he says, all right, nature will remove those impossible obstacles.
Back to the quote, he says, dream the impossible dream and the world will not grind you up under or it will actually lift you up. He says, this is the trick. This is what all the teachers and philosophers who really counted, who really touched this alchemical gold, this is what they understood. This is the shamanic dance in the waterfall. This is how magic is done. He said, it's by hurling yourself into the abyss and discovering it's a feather bed. Feather bed sounds nice. And so there I was, the guy standing at the top of the cliff, pointing out at all the open air, telling all these guys,
just jump. It's a feather bed, gentlemen. So, kind of think about that for a second. Embody this, if you will, my dear listener, male or female. If you're being really honest with yourself, have you been there as well, where all of a sudden you do feel maybe better about things at times? And now, man, I really want to express this thing. I want to talk about something. I want to share my hopes and dreams or my opinion or maybe even a way that I've been treated with this person that is supposed to care about me and I care about
them. And I'm standing right here. Maybe you're standing there right now at the edge of some big chasm in your own life. And maybe it's a relationship that you genuinely cannot tell. I don't know what to do next in here. Am I supposed to even stay in it? Maybe it's a conversation you've rehearsed a hundred times in your car or in the shower, but you've never actually had it because you are afraid of the outcome. Or maybe it's a decision and you keep almost making it. You're getting right up to the edge of, and then you back away. And everyone around you, it seems like every book or podcast or well-meaning friend in your life is basically standing behind you gently,
or maybe not even so gently, just saying, this is your chance, just jump. In essence, saying it's Featherbed. Meanwhile, your body's doing the exact thing that mine did on top of that 80-foot bungee tower in Utah. It's planting its feet a few inches or more back from the ledge, and it's saying with every fiber of its being, no, I will not be doing that. Here's what I want to do with, I think, the rest of our time today. I want to talk about why just jump almost never actually works and why I think telling people to be braver is actually some of the least helpful advice that
I think that we hand each other. And then because this is a waking up to narcissism episode as well, I want to talk about why just jump can actually even be more complicated when the person on the other side of the conversation is not emotionally safe and is probably the one that's trying to push you. Because sometimes people aren't frozen because they're weak or they lack courage. They're frozen because their body has learned that vulnerability gets mocked and having needs gets punished. And if you're seeking clarity, which is not something crazy to ask for, it's going to get twisted and then repair doesn't come.
So, I want to talk a little bit more about what actually gets you across the chasm. And here's the big warning. And I think this is like so much of the things in mental health or in life in general. It's a lot quieter and it's a lot slower and doesn't make for the most exciting book or course. And it's actually a whole lot stranger than feeling the fear and doing it anyway. Although that can be a real act of courage, growth through the discomfort. But I think there's a few steps missing before you get to that point where you
do it anyway, or before you then take that leap out into the great abyss. Because then I really want to get to the question that I think that so many people that I'm working with are carrying around underneath all of this, which is, how do I know when it is time to construct my crucible, to take this thing out of gridlock in my relationship and conversations and confront it as an act of integrity? Because what if I don't even really know who I am? And I don't even know what I'm anchored to. Let's take a step back and let's talk about advice and asking for someone's opinion and giving advice.
Because if you've ever been one who's stood at the edge of one of these big chasms in your life and you've told somebody, another human being about it, I was gonna say, you already know what they're gonna say. They're gonna say, hey, you gotta be brave. You have to just take the leap. They say the thing that's been on a thousand motivational posters and coffee mugs and offices everywhere. here. The feel the fear and do it anyway, which again is true. I think there's just some steps that can lead before that. However, before I even go down that path that I want to go down,
I do want to do the old, should I get hair plugs in Turkey concept. And this is based on a very real story. Someone very close to me and not me, but if you've seen me in videos, you could say, oh yeah, this is Tony asking for a friend. But it was a genuine experience that I was, I was in the room for. Where someone that I'm close to asked my daughter, who at the time was a cosmetologist, she's now an esthetician, and another daughter of mine that has a very thick head of hair, and then my wife, who also has nice hair.
And then he said, out of the blue, hey, do you guys think I should go to Turkey and get hair plugs? And they immediately all reacted, no, are you crazy? I wouldn't do that. He seemed crushed. And he just, oh man, okay, yeah, I was, I don't know, I was thinking about it. And so then I pulled the therapist card and said, hey, so it sounds like you're going to go to Turkey and get hair plugs because how long have you been thinking about it? Have you already researched it? Do you know how much it costs? Do you have, is your algorithm full of videos of people doing so? Which by the way, then mine became full of that insert. The phone is listening comments there.
And I just pointed out that here's somebody that's been thinking about something. And then they said, Hey, I wrote, I really want to get someone's opinion and I'm going to base a lot of my worth and what I'm going to do next on this instantaneous opinion that this person who's been thinking about this thing for who knows how long already has ideas in their head of what they want to do. And now they're asking somebody that has no idea. Even so, a thick haired female, if this balding male human being should go get hair plugs in Turkey. So what I just asked the person, is it true that maybe what you're looking for
is for them to say the words that you want them to, but out of their mouths? Because is that really more of you're seeking validation? And at first he said, oh, no, no, I really wanted their opinion. Well, okay, you got their instantaneous reaction to a thing that you just threw at them that they have no experience with. So if that was the goal, then there you go. Which maybe that is why it's not so fun to hang around a therapist out in the wild. But I like the idea that if I am asking for somebody else's opinion, because there's a chance I could be at this chasm, ready to jump out into the abyss, and the person is going to say, I wouldn't do it.
And they genuinely maybe wouldn't do what it is that you're thinking about doing because they don't know what it feels like to be you. And there is projection. They're projecting onto you that this is what I would do if I were you. I wouldn't do it. Or they're saying, oh yeah, I'm sure I would do it. But then if they're the one now on top of the bungee tower, they're saying, okay, maybe I didn't know that this is what it would feel like. Maybe I wouldn't do it. So I go back to that, the be afraid and do it anyway, which again, the reason I'm saying this so often is I've done a literal podcast or two with my daughter, Mackie on her mind, the mirror, and me. And then on a Q and a episode, I remember where, oh, we talked a big time about
this. because it is from a growth from discomfort place. So if it's the thing that you do feel drawn toward, if it's in alignment with your values, and you can, yeah, butt your way out of anything, yeah, but I don't know. If it's going to work, yeah, but I'm not even sure how to do it. And those are the things that keep somebody from doing the difficult thing. And that is where the growth from discomfort comes. So I'm talking more in this advice that is genuinely typically well-meaning. I don't think there's ever much sadistic qualities in somebody saying,
oh yeah, I think you should do it because they're thinking to themselves because there's no way that's going to go well. And then I get to say, see, I told you so. And maybe now I get to take over whatever the position is because now you're going to be crushed from doing this thing. I know there's an element of that, but I don't think it's as common. When somebody is giving this advice of, yeah, just do it. Just take the leap. Take the risk. It's really easy for somebody else to say it. Again, not because people that are giving you that advice are wrong about the destination that you're hoping to get to. The other side of the chasm really might be everything that you're hoping it will be. Everything that they're promising.
And I just think, again, it doesn't necessarily work that easily because it skips the most important step when somebody tells you to feel the fear and do it anyway. there's this assumption baked into that sentence. And that assumption is that the fear is the obstacle. That the fear is the thing standing between you and the leap. And so if you could just push through the fear, if you could just override it, if you could just white knuckle your way past the fear, then you will be on the other side. But I don't think that fear is as big of an obstacle as we think. The fear is more of a symptom. It's the smoke, not the fire. Because underneath the fear, there's a story.
This is the key. There's a story that your brain is telling you about what's going to happen when you jump. And it's the story, not the fear that has you frozen a few inches back from the ledge. The fear is the feeling that the story generates. So when somebody tells you to feel the fear and do it anyway, they're telling you to push past the smoke and jump into this fire while the fire may still be burning. So that's the part where your nervous system is way too smart sometimes to fall for that. Other times it is a ginormous leap of faith. And then you may have to accept the fact that, oh, I didn't even think about
there still being fire where I where I jumped into. And let me try to throw a couple of everyday versions of this. You're not just afraid to tell your spouse that, hey, I really want something to change in the relationship. The story underneath that might be, if I say this, they will shut down. Then we're going to fight and then we'll never recover. And I'll be 83 years old eating soup alone next to a cat that doesn't even have any respect for me. Or you're not just afraid to ask your boss for a raise. Your brain has already made the whole movie of what's going to happen.
You ask, they laugh. Right behind you are security guards. They escort you out. Some time now later by dinner, you're living in your car, which is a whole lot, for a conversation that hasn't even happened yet. In a more emotionally mature relationship, you can often say, hey, I'm noticing my brain is making this conversation feel catastrophic. And I'm telling myself this story that this is going to be the end of our relationship. And I want to slow that down. And I really want to talk about, I want to take you on my train of thought. Now, in an emotionally immature relationship, the other person may use concepts
like catastrophe as a control tactic. So you do try to start talking about something and you hear things like, if you bring this up, okay, we're going here. You know how this is going to happen. You're going to ruin the whole night and you always do this. And I'm never enough and you're never satisfied, but go ahead. Say whatever it is you need to say, but don't be surprised if after I hear this, I'm done trying. That's a real different thing because the emotionally mature version owns the story as a story. My brain is catastrophizing.
You are saying words out of your mouth and I'm creating a whole narrative that I need to set aside. I need to step outside of my ego so I can be genuinely present and curious about what you're experiencing. And I can't not think the things I'm thinking, but I need to acknowledge that they are just thoughts. They are stories that my brain is telling me. I'm noticing I'm catastrophizing. Noted. Thank you, brain. I'm even noticing I'm starting to shut down. I'm noticing I'm getting defensive. The emotionally immature version weaponizes the potential possible catastrophe, To teach you a lesson to get rid of their uncomfortable feelings because they
don't know what to do And if you are bringing something up, in in the emotional immaturity world, it's a zero-sum game There's a winner and a loser So if you have a need or a thought or an opinion that is different from theirs Then they think you think you are right and they are wrong and now they need to take that one-up position. Now they are going to defend and attack and not stay in the conversation, not stay curious. If you bring up your needs, your wants, your hopes, your dreams, there will be consequences. That's why people that are in these relationships eventually stop talking and
it trains the relationship. We continually train the relationship by what we tolerate. If you stop trying to express how you feel and your thoughts and opinions and, you do that because you already do, you're projecting, but you know that they're not going to take it well because you have watched that pattern happen over and over again. Unfortunately, you're training the relationship by what is tolerated. And so they are able to say, I didn't even know anything was wrong. Now, I know as a couples therapist, I will raise my hand almost in a session
and say, I'll take that one. It's because whenever he tries to bring that up with you, you shut him down. It's not that someone stops having needs, it's because every need comes with a hidden cost. I go back to this idea of understanding why, hey, just jump doesn't work. You have to understand a little bit about what your brain is actually doing all day long. Because your brain at its core is a prediction machine. It is a meaning making device. It is a don't get killed device. That's its job.
So it's constantly, every second, running simulations of the future and then trying to keep you alive based on what it predicts is coming based off of what has happened in the past. And if we're talking about the meaning making machine, it cannot stand a blank canvas or a blank space. It has such a hard time tolerating not knowing. So it fills in most every gap with a story. Now put those two things together, a prediction machine and a meaning making machine. And now add in there that, and we don't really like gaps. We need to fill in those.
And here's what happens when you walk up to the edge of one of these chasms. Your brain runs the simulation. It says, okay, if I do this, here's how this goes. Here's the catastrophe. We have a negativity bias, by the way. That's what's kept us alive. We go all the way back into the evolutionary biological story of great hunter-gatherers on the plains, in the savannah. They see an impala, a gazelle, an elk, a deer, whatever it is. And if they go hunt that and catch that, not only will they be validated and be the hero, but their village will eat.
But now they see out of the corner of their eye a lion. And they aren't even trying to now calculate, how do I get that thing and make sure that I don't get eaten by the lion? No, because if they get eaten by the lion, if they blow this one time, they're dead. This negativity bias is a default for the brain. In the book, The Buddha's Brain by Rick Hansen, I love the quote, the brain is like Velcro for negative experiences and Teflon for positive. So it takes a lot of extra work to hang on to these positive experiences. We naturally default toward catastrophe. This is the conversation that's going to blow up the family.
Here's the divorce that is going to destroy the kids. Here's the financial ruin that comes if I even try to have this conversation because it hasn't gone well in the past. And loneliness will come with that. Here's the version of this where everything I'm afraid of comes true. And then once your brain has run that simulation over and over, it stops treating it like a prediction. It starts treating it like a memory. And it files this imagined catastrophe right next to the things that have actually happened to you and your body responds to it exactly the same way. I remember one of the first classes in grad school to become a therapist,
a professor talked everyone through eating the lemon and he was so descriptive that he asked how many of us had salivated. Because of the sourness that you were thinking about. And most all of us did. I certainly did. It's fascinating that I was recalling what tasting a sour lemon tasted like. And it's not like I go around sucking on sour lemons all the time. But when you're running this prediction machine and you're filing these things away, these threats as fact, your heart rate does go up. Your palms get sweaty. Your stomach drops the same way it would if the bad thing had already occurred.
You are in a very real sense grieving and panicking over something that hasn't happened and may never happen. And then we wonder why just be brave sometimes doesn't cut it. It's like when somebody texts and they say, can we talk later? And your body has already panicked and it's packed a bag and hired an attorney and you're already looking at selling the house and how much are the calculations going to make and what's the divorce calculator and child support and decide which sad playlist you're going to listen to on your drive home. In a healthy relationship, can we talk later might just mean, can we talk later?
I imagine that the words, meaning words, that's the concept. But in an emotionally immature relationship, ambiguity starts to become leverage. It sounds like, can we talk later? And then when you even check back in and say, Hey, is everything okay? Sometimes you don't hear anything. Sometimes you will hear maybe, or sort of, or I'm not going to text about it. And then they go silent for six hours while you mentally tour every single disaster, just thinking about what it's going to be until you have yourself convinced of the right disaster. A grounded version would be, hey, nothing catastrophic. I just want to talk
about our plans tonight when I'm not in the middle of work. That one sentence, it shows consideration. It shows care. We've had some tragedy in our family over the last few years. And my wife and I are very good about a text that says, hey, can you call me when you have a chance? Everything's okay. Those sentences, divorces they what's the phrase these days they give emotional maturity i don't know if i use that correctly and it costs a few seconds and it can save the other person. Two imaginary divorces and a whole missed day at work thinking about things,
or there's a concept think about the shower arguments you're rehearsing a conversation in the shower and by the time you're drying off you're furious for the thing that that person said in this made-up argument that you entirely had with yourself. Not a conversation, but that is, there's got to be some sort of shampoo and rinse and lather and repeat joke there, but it's been so long since I've used shampoo. I can't pull that currently. The emotionally mature person can say, I'm noticing that I'm rehearsing a whole argument that hasn't happened yet. And that can be just for themselves even. Oh, noted brain, check that out.
I'm going down the path of the, oh, this thing's, this is what this person means story. The emotionally immature person says, I already know what you're going to say. You're play the victim and you're gonna make me the bad guy like you always do. And now the person that wanted to just have a simple conversation, They have to defend a thing that isn't true, that emotionally immature concept of managing other people's emotions. If I think it, it's true. If I feel it, it's true. Well, I already know that I feel like you're mad at me. So I know you are. And if you don't now admit that you are, then you're not even being honest with yourself. No wonder it can be so difficult to try to even have a conversation with somebody
who is unwilling to be curious, to sit with any of their own discomfort, to admit that there are things that they don't even know. And to also acknowledge that while I love the idea of following your gut and listening to your intuition that I also have to make space though for but that is my intuition, my instinct, my gut and I need to be genuinely curious about what the other person's experience is. Because people go to this whole point where this place where they're saying there's no point talking to you because I know this is where it's going to go. And I hope you can see the pattern that I'm feeling so passionate about,
is this is what shuts down conversations and then keeps relationships stuck because it then just perpetuates until finally somebody who has not felt heard or understood in a relationship, their body keeps the score. They eventually just need to say the thing. And so now it comes out pretty heated, because I can't self-betray anymore. I can't keep this under wraps. I can't keep it just to me anymore. And so now they express it in a way that I'll acknowledge is probably a little bit emotionally immature, but if they don't, if they don't come out big, the other person isn't even going to listen. But if they do come out big,
the other person is going to react. They're not responding. They're reacting. You need to come into a conversation curious. And often people are coming in and they're already pre-offended. So you have extra work to try to calm the storm and set it up just right. And that's too much. That's too many emotional calories spent. I want couples to be able to express themselves because that's how they express themselves. And if the other person feels something, oh man, I'm noticing that I'm feeling judged. Well, tell me more about it. I want to understand that. And this is then where projection and confabulation
can show up because they're not responding to you. They're responding to a version of you they've created in their head. And unfortunately, that version has been very busy saying terrible things while they were in the shower. Let me bring you back to the ledge, back to me. 20-something years old, frozen on top of the bungee tower in Utah. You cannot talk a terrified person into jumping. You can't reason with a nervous system that's convinced it's about to die. You basically are going to push it off the tower. That can be traumatic. I could have stood up on top of that tower and recited every statistic about bungee safety. I could have watched 100 people go before me and 100 of them
survive and bounce and laugh and walk away completely fine. And it would not have mattered one bit to the part of my brain that had already decided, this is death because to that part of my brain, just do it does not sound brave. It sounds insane. It sounds like somebody calmly suggesting that I walk out into traffic and see if I can stop a car with my bare hands. And when you're standing at the edge of the real chasm in your life and your whole body is screaming, no. And somebody tells you to just be brave and jump. The reason it lands so flat or the reason that it almost feels insulting is that's what your nervous system
is feeling that in that moment, they are asking you to die. And no amount of pep talk is strong enough have to override that. It may work, but I just want you to know that can come at a cost. I love the Buddhist concept of interdependence, that nothing stands alone. So I can force my partner, my kid to do a thing if I am strong-willed enough and if I am going to get my way. And then I can even tell myself that that was good for them. They'll thank me someday. And I'm not even suggesting that that might be, that could be a case. I still wish somebody would have pushed me on playing a piano or something like
that. Or at least I tell myself that now. However, it just has to come with an acceptance that there may be a cost to the relationship of trust, of safety, of intimacy. So, the answer isn't to be braver. So, if it's not, then what is it? Because I'm not telling you that the chasm doesn't matter or that you should just stay frozen at the edge forever. Or I'm not even telling you if you are someone who is trying to show up and suggest or inspire someone else that you don't do that. But it's just be aware of the pattern. Be aware of the variables that could
be happening in that conversation. What I'm suggesting is that the work or the actual work is not what maybe we've been told it is. It's not to summon more courage. It's not to grit your teeth and override your body to betray your nervous system. I think it's something much quieter. And honestly, when you understand that it's a little bit more doable, and that is to get yourself grounded enough, calm enough, settled enough in yourself that you can finally notice the story that your brain is telling you.
If you have a value of adventure, then the story your brain can be telling you is, this is insane to jump off the ledge. And you can say, totally. It is. Currently, that's not a productive thought to my value of adventure. So I'm going to invite, this is crazy, because it is, to come with me while we do this. Hear your own voice running the simulation. The voice is saying, this is going to go so bad. This is going to be a catastrophe. And to recognize it for what it actually is.
It's not a forecast. It's not a real memory. It's not a fact about the future. It's a story. My brain is telling me a really old, really well-rehearsed, very convincing story from a brain that ultimately, thank you, bless its pink squishy heart, wants to keep me alive. And the moment you can see the story as a story is the moment things start to change. Things start to become more clear. So let's say that you do this work, and we'll still get into that in just a little bit.
You get yourself grounded enough that one day you actually cross over into this place of, oh, I'm noticing stories. I'm accepting the fact that this is scary. Now you can have a conversation or you set a boundary or you make a change or you step off the ledge. And then what people report from the other side, because I've heard it now hundreds of times in the therapy room, and it's a place that I have now gotten to more and more in my own life in therapy rooms, in conversations with my family members or people close to me.
And it's very consistent. Almost nobody crosses that chasm then and comes back saying, that was exactly as catastrophic as I was afraid it would be. And I wish I never would have done it. The report over and over and over again is some version of... Okay, that was not as bad as my brain told me it was going to be. They still did jump into what felt like a bottomless, certain death abyss, and they found out to borrow McKenna's line again. Kind of a feather bed. I do not ever want to be the guy guaranteeing you that it will always be fine.
And I don't think that you would then trust me if I did. Because it's not always a feather bed. Sometimes you cross and that landing is genuinely hard. Sometimes the conversation does go sideways. Sometimes the change does cost you something real. So I'm not promising that the other side is always soft and warm and easy, but it is almost never the freefall that the story promised. And this is coming from someone that for more than two decades talks to people daily for a living who work themselves up to do this jump, to cross this chasm.
It's almost never the specific catastrophe that your prediction machine ran in such vivid, terrifying detail. The thing that actually shows up on the other side and the thing that your brain rehearsed are very different. Now, here's the caveat to this whole episode. And I think what it really kind of hinges on is that then the crossing isn't okay because you white knuckled your way through it. The reason it turns out to be a feather bed or not as bad as what you thought it would be instead of this free fall. It's not that you finally were brave enough or that you just gritted your teeth and forced yourself to jump off the ledge.
The crossing is survivable and sometimes peaceful and always you'll learn something about yourself because of all the work that came before it, you don't earn the feather bed by being fearless you earn the feather bed by learning to be grounded, learning to accept your situation learning to self-confront learning to understand the stories that your brain is telling you learning that asking others for advice is asking others for advice but it doesn't mean that that is now what I must do. The leap is the last step, not the first one. I do think that we have the sequencing wrong.
We have the entire order of operations backwards in our culture because we treat the jump as the brave act and everything else just as procrastination when really the jump ends up being, I don't want to say the easy part, but kind of, because it's all of the quiet, unglamorous internal work that comes before it. That's where courage lives. The courage is to show up at therapy every week. The courage is to read the books, to self-confront, to not just push things away as that's ridiculous because I don't understand it. And I'll add one more layer of honesty because this is something I am still working on myself.
So watch me be so brave. There is such a real important difference between discomfort that you can grow through and your body telling you, oh, heck no. I think there's a real need for more conversations around growth from discomfort, and the body keeps the score because they're not the same thing. And I think one of the big challenges is learning to tell them apart. That might actually end up being the most important skill in all of this. And I don't think you can get there until you start to really understand yourself. Sometimes the discomfort you feel at the edge is your growth edge. It's the good kind. It's the stretch that if you lean into it from a grounded
place, it's going to expand who you are. And there are other times that discomfort is your nervous system giving you genuinely accurate information that something here is not safe and you need to honor that. Let's lock that one in. Let's make it concrete. Growth discomfort might be telling your spouse, I'm overwhelmed and I need help, when they have generally shown that they can hear you. Your voice shakes and your stomach gets upset, but some part of you knows this, is uncomfortable and you're not going to be able to hear it. Not irrational. It might feel as if it's not safe, but it's necessary.
A mature partner may not respond perfectly, but they're going to stay with the bid. You're overwhelmed. What can I do to help? Because a lot of times you won't even know. You just know that you can't keep doing what you're doing. And that's why we get in relationships. We're designed to deal with emotion in concert with another human. It's this collaborative process. When you're two people that are acknowledging we don't know what we don't know. I know what my experience is. I want to know what your experience is. It will make me uncomfortable. That's a me thing. But that emotionally immature version sounds like, oh, you're overwhelmed? Same.
But I don't get to fall apart. That must be nice. Or yeah, I help all the time. You just don't notice because you only focus on what I don't do. So do you notice the move? Now your need is experienced as criticism. Your request, it's now an accusation. And so the need gets dismissed or minimized or flipped back. And over time the person learns it is not safe to have needs here and that is uncomfortable and that can be the growth from discomfort can be expressing your needs and still not having them met. The body keeps the score might be, I have tried this for 20 or 30 years and it is not safe and I'm,
suffering from an autoimmune disease and I get heart palpitations and my nervous system's a wreck every time I try to go back and have this emotional need met or even to express it. But when I take space and I get away from the relationship, I'm calm. There's a big difference there. And I think that's where we're getting into some of the clearest differences between a hard relationship and an emotionally immature one. Hard relationships still allow needs. Emotionally immature relationships punish them. And then there's another version. If you are about to be vulnerable with somebody who has repeatedly mocked it and weaponized it or brought it up later in a fight,
then that absolutely not in your body, that might not be fear of growth. That may be data. The emotionally immature person may say, you're afraid to talk to me. Whoa, that's convenient. So now I'm abusive because you don't want to be accountable. Well, you never listened to me or I only brought that up later because you never listen. If you don't want me to use things against you, maybe you don't say things that prove my point. This is where the emotionally immature person reframes your self-protection as a pathology, as something wrong with you. Your body says, this person has not been safe with my vulnerability for a long time. And they say, no, you're just bringing things up in a bad way,
or you're just being avoidant or dramatic or unforgiving. Or it will sound to me like you're just afraid of accountability. I've told you what to do before. I'm not coming to ask you what to do. I want to be heard and understood. That's why this piece matters so much because sometimes your body's not resisting growth your body's been taking notes and i don't have a real clean tidy formula for telling those two apart every time but i want people to be aware of it, i'm still in the room with people including myself working out where exactly that line lives of growth from discomfort versus body keeps the score, but i think the very fact that we can learn to ask the question is this discomfort
my growth edge or is this my body protecting me that question alone is a sign that you're starting to get grounded enough to do this well. Real quick, a picture of what this looks like in real life. I'll keep it general so it could be any one of us, but imagine somebody who's been dreading a conversation for weeks and losing sleep over it, rehearsing it, and running the simulation again and again where it explodes and everything falls apart. And then one day they finally have it, but they have it from a grounded place, from that settled, I know who I am place that I'm trying to hopefully bring awareness to today. And afterward, almost every time, they say the same thing. They say the dread
was so much bigger than the thing, the actual conversation. The weeks of catastrophizing took up so much more emotional calories and space than the conversation itself did. They get to the other side and it was okay, but only because they had done the work that made them okay first. The okayness on the other side of the chasm wasn't waiting over there for them to discover. They kind of brought it with them. They built it before they jumped. Okay, I just realized that we've crossed the hour mark, and I am going to wrap this up here.
And part two is going to get into a lot of the specific version of what that work looks like. Now, if you have questions after you hear this part one, please get them to me as soon as you can. You can email them directly to contact at TonyOverbay.com or go to my website, TonyOverbay.com, and submit through the comments form. I will include them in the recording of part two. I would love to know what comes up for you. I would love situations. Maybe you're experiencing in your own relationship where you would want to give me all the details and tell me what's difficult. And I will work those into an episode as well.
Thank you so much. Taking us out per usual, the wonderful, the talented Aurora Florence with her song. It's wonderful. So whether you caught this on the virtual couch or on waking up to narcissism, thanks so much for joining me and I will see you next time. Have a great week. Start heading out the other end, the precious.
Why do people pleasers and avoidant partners find each other, and why does it seem like such a relief at first? Tony follows Pam and Jim, a composite couple, from childhood to the college campus where they met. Pam...
Waking up to betrayal, gaslighting, or emotional immaturity rarely comes with a casserole on the porch or a meal train. When someone has a baby or a surgery, people can see the event and show up with dinner. When you...
Waking up to betrayal, gaslighting, or emotional immaturity rarely comes with a casserole on the porch or a meal train. When someone has a baby or a surgery, people can see the event and show up with dinner. When you...
Using AI as a therapist? Your chatbot might be building a great plan for the person you’re hoping to become. When a client’s chatbot asked if he was an extroverted go-getter, he answered as the man he’s working toward,...
Tony starts with a kid raised in an East Coast fishing town and another raised hiking Arizona trails. He uses them to show how beliefs tend to form through family, community, and identity, with the reasons showing up...