From Lawyer to Mediator: Reflections on My First Two Years in the Chair
9 minAudio
As my second Christmas as a mediator approaches, I’ve found myself reflecting on the lessons and surprises this role has brought. Transitioning from lawyer to mediator has required new skills, a different mindset and a willingness to keep learning. Today I’m sharing some of my key reflections so far. The most striking realisation has been that mediation is its own discipline, distinct from legal practice. Even after years of acting as an advocate in mediations, stepping into the mediator’s chair revealed how much dedicated training and feedback matter. Building trust and rapport is at the heart of the process. Credibility helps but it’s the relationships formed with lawyers and clients, often during those quieter moments, that make the work meaningful and productive. Patience and optimism are indispensable, especially when negotiations stall or doubts creep in. I’ve learned that maintaining a positive, solution-focused mindset can keep everyone moving forward, even when energy in the room is flagging. Emotional intelligence sits at the core of effective mediation and recognising the emotional currents that run beneath the surface is essential. It’s about helping participants acknowledge these feelings of fear, frustration and uncertainty without letting them derail the process. Preparation is also vital, though it looks different from advocacy. Mediators must know the issues and the people but also remain flexible and ready to adapt as dynamics shift. Three common mistakes I see in approaching negotiations include insufficient preparation, an over-formal approach that misses the more collaborative tone of mediation and treating negotiation as a mere platform for argument rather than a process of mutual discovery. I’m grateful to the legal community for the encouragement and support during this career transition and I look forward to more opportunities to learn and collaborate in the coming year. Wishing everyone a restful Christmas and a positive start to the new year. Links: Website | LinkedIn | YouTube
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
As I approach my second Christmas as a mediator, I've reflected on the story so far, um, the experience and the insights I've gained, and I wanna share with you some key reflections. These are five things that come to mind for me. Firstly. Uh, and I've said this in in podcasts and had some guests, it's really jumped out at me. Of course, that mediation is a distinct and separate skillset and needs to be treated as such, so I've really enjoyed investing in the training.
And development in this space, recognizing it's quite separate than the, than the law I've practiced, even though I've been a participant in many mediations. As an advocate, it's still very different. And of course, to get better at something you need a combination of practice and feedback, and I've been seeking feedback. On my experience as a mediator, both formally and Ally, and that will continue. I've certainly enjoyed investing in a different skillset and am looking forward to spending the next 20 years of my life health permitting, continuing to make.
That investment. The second reflection is mediation is very much a game of trust and rapport, and of course that comes with credibility in the profession, but rapport is also important more broadly. So I've really liked getting to know lots of different lawyers and lots of different clients and get to know them a bit, not only inside the profession, but aspects outside because there is a quite a bit of downtime in mediation and developing that trust and rapport. Uh, uh, really holds you in good stead, and I've really enjoyed
actually dealing with a broad cross section of the profession. When you are a senior solicitor, sometimes your life gets a bit narrower, and I've really enjoyed this broad, uh, spectrum approach in dealing with lots of different people. The third reflection, uh, is that patience and persistence. Absolutely matter as a mediator, energetically, we are trying to be optimistic. We're trying to, come on guys, we're gonna be constructive. We're gonna work towards a solution. And so you really need a, a mindset of patience and you
need a mindset of persistence. You need to be really dogged because you know you're gonna get energy in the room. A lot of people throwing in the towel and saying, this is all too hard. We're too far apart. So don't underestimate the importance of persistence. Patience and optimism. And fortunately, those that know me say that I am, uh, prone to, uh, excessive optimism and, but probably that's a good skillset in the mediation space. Fourth, reflection. Emotional intelligence is obviously critical.
Uh, it's important as a mediator that you're really alive to the emotional undercurrents that are present in every room. It may be fear, it may be stress, it may be uncertainty, and you've really gotta. Acknowledge and work with these emotional drivers. Uh, a lot of the work I do, educating people in mediation is about understanding and tapping in to these drivers. Not being rule by them, but allowing them space, uh, because they're really important and they need to be acknowledged and not neglected.
The fifth. Uh, reflection is that preparation is a little bit different as a mediator, obviously, you've gotta be across the material, you've gotta know the arguments, you've gotta have a sense of where people are coming from. But preparation is different in the sense that as an advocate. You are wanting to advise and provide the answer. Uh, as a mediator, you're wanting to understand the levers and understand the issues and the people, and that's really important. So good mediators are always prepared, but preparation needs to be met with
psychological flexibility because you need to meet people in the moment and don't preempt exactly where they're coming from. It's slightly different mindset in preparing as an advocate. And as a mediator, I'll now turn to three common mistakes that I see for those in the arena, practicing as an advocate, a solicitor, or a barrister. Three common mistakes that I see as a mediator in approaching. Uh, negotiations and I hope this is useful for you.
Now, the first, sorry guys. No hacks. No shortcuts here. The first is pretty obvious, which is insufficient preparation. Um, all the hard work is often done before you get into the mediation room, understanding the strengths and weaknesses, and you see that fall down when, oh, except that we're all time poor. But insufficient preparation is such an important factor, and it's really important in preparing. I think as a lawyer, uh, not just to be across. The legal issues. And that's a lot of work just doing that obviously, and the factual
issues, but actually being across the people and the specific risk appetite. 'cause that's an equally important driver in these sort of matters. So, sorry guys. No hack here. There's no substitute as a negotiator for thorough preparation. Thoughtful preparation in which you, uh, prepare for both the issues and the people, including an assessment of. Uh, your client's risk appetite. A second point of feedback, I think, and I think this is, we are getting better at this, particularly in Queensland with such common use of a DR and
conferences, is being overly formal at times or too much of a barrister in your. Advocacy or submissions in a mediation process. I'm not saying you don't have to hit the high notes, but remember that you're talking to people, not in a courtroom setting, but in a boardroom setting. So you want to be sufficiently persuasive and influential in that room, and that involves often being a bit more short and concise. And really meeting people where they're at and acknowledging baps at times,
um, some of the difficulties that they may have encountered, and the fact that you may agree to disagree, really, uh, being alive to the fact that you're dealing with people not in a formal setting, but in a less formal setting, while, while acknowledging that it's still an important process. And I've, I think that's. In the profession and improvement in that space. But at times I think that's a good bit of feedback to keep in mind. And a third and related point is good negotiators, uh, treat a mediation or a negotiation process.
As a process of discovery. So it's much more about what you wanna learn, as much as what you wanna say, and you can see good negotiators come into an environment understanding that prerogative really being alive to what they want to learn. Because really, if you look at your work as an advocate, it's. Advising on risk, uh, of a litigation. And that changes as things progress. That's an evolving concept of risk, if you like.
So use the process even though sure, you're prepared. For what you wanna say and the position you want to adopt and you've got your client on board for all that, that's great. But really take the opportunity. Don't waste the opportunity to find out what you wanna learn, because that will obviously give, make you a far better advisor in advising on the evolving. Nature of risk. So there's some feedback for you and hopefully some points you can take in terms of good lessons. As a negotiator, I'd like to take this opportunity to thank the profession
for their support and encouragement. It's quite a big move as a senior solicitor to make a transition. It's not the most common path, and I'm really grateful, the support I've received from other members of the profession and solicitor branch and the barristers, uh, that have helped me. I've, I've shadowed. A key barrister as well. So I've been really met with a lot of assistance, uh, in the profession, a lot of collegiality, and I'm very grateful for your continued support. So look forward to working with you in next year and beyond, and hope you find this useful.
Have a great Christmas. Enjoy some r and r with the family and friends. All the best.
What determines recovery after a spinal injury? The answer can be more complex than a scan suggests. I’m joined by neurosurgeon Dr Simon Clark and psychiatrist Dr Shiva Gunapu as part of our collaboration with MLCOA’s...
Ageing at work is one of those topics everyone has an opinion on, but very few people have a clear framework for. Recorded live at the Self-Insurers of South Australia conference in Adelaide, this episode of The...
Chronic pain claims can be some of the most contested and misunderstood matters in personal injury and medico legal work, especially when the pain does not match a neat scan or diagnosis. In this episode of The...
Career reinvention is rarely neat, and it often starts with a quiet question you cannot unhear. In this episode, I’m joined by Joanna Wong, host of the podcast Chasing Waves, to talk about career transitions, leadership...
Mindful leadership is not a wellness trend, it is an attention skill, and in this episode I sit down with Susan Pearse to talk about what that really means in modern work and life. Susan and I have known each other for...