Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Here I am at the Adelaide Entertainment Centre for the Self-Insure of South Australia conference. The Resolution Room podcast in collaboration with M-L-C-O-A is on the road in Adelaide. We've got a great panel conversation coming up between a psychiatrist, a neuropsychologist and occupation physician, and a lawyer talking about cognition, the ageing workplace, and all those pressure and pain points. Let's get into it. Please welcome Damien Van Bru shot.
Let me introduce our sterling panel. Welcome to the stage, uh, Dr. Tim Huang. Tim is an occupational physician. He's a fellow of the Australian Faculty of Occupational and Environmental Medicine, and he's worked both in-house in places like Ford and at Melbourne Airport. And now he has a extensive private consulting career. Occupational medicine is such an interesting discipline. It brings together all things about work, the broad variety of work and the interplay between capacity, and we are gonna really pick his brains
about that, particularly in the context of an ageing population and some of the case studies in front of us. So thanks for your time, Tim, and good luck tomorrow. Tim's competing on a TaeKwonDo competition, so good luck tomorrow as well, Tim, for that. Thank you very much. Okay, welcome to the stage Shiva Pu. Dr. Shiva Gunna is a psychiatrist and he's an adult psychiatrist. We are gonna pick his brain about the mental aspect, uh, of return to work, what that means. And of course, we all know across all schemes there's a rise of
secondary psychological injuries causing a lot of pressure. The de-stigmatization of mental health is great, but it it has come at a cost of course, and we're gonna be examining some of those issues in these case studies. Dr. GPA as well as being an extensive medicolegal consultant now also has an executive hat on. He works for Ramsay Health in an executive capacity, which is a large private hospital in mental health. So thank you, Dr. Shiva for your time and expertise. Neuropsychologist, Dr. Sarah Lucas, welcome to the stage. I like this.
I didn't expect to do the, the welcome, but now they're backstage. I think it adds dramatic effect, so I'm, I'm glad to do it this way. Dr. Sarah Lucas has a PhD, a doctorate in neuropsychology. What a wonderful discipline that is. We are gonna talk to Dr. Lucas about age, cognition, attention, memory, all the wonderful things. I'm 55 and I'm looking down the barrel of it at times, so this is a really important conversation. Dr. Lucas has an extensive medicolegal practise assessing capacity. For example, testamentary capacity.
She works across South Australia, nt and also in some of the eastern states as well. Has been doing this for a long time. She did have a background in a hospital setting as well before recently, um, branching out for some years now as, as an expert. Last but not least now, I've, I've left Allison last because she wasn't included in the brochure and she's not at all precious about it, but we're gonna make a big deal of her. Thank you Alison, for coming. Allison is our, um. Allison is our resident lawyer for my sins.
I'm also a lawyer but not an employment one. Perhaps in my next life I'll come back as an employment lawyer because what Allison brings is unique. As an employment lawyer, you look at all things in the workplace, such a broad field. One of the wonderful things about her work is that you do a broad range of clients. You works for public sector, private clients. They're quite different, quite different sectors, quite different ways of looking at the world and a lot of the advice you give as an employment lawyer is very strategic and commercial. You obviously know the law, you know the legal landscape, but you're often navigating some really commercial imperatives and understanding the client.
Allison has been a Hall and Wilcox for 20 years and as an expert in that uh, space, she's been recognised in best lawyers and in Doyles for her unique expertise in employment law. So welcome Alison. Uh, now you don't feel like you've missed out on the on the schedule. Alright guys, we've got a case study. I'm gonna take a seat, but I'll read out this case study quickly. The case study is only intended to stimulate conversations. There's a lot of unknowns, but let's go David. He's 62, Michael's 39. They work in similar occupa operational roles for a large self-insured employer.
Both sustain relatively uncomplicated lower back injuries involving similar physical restrictions. It seems strikes to me as a soft tissue type injury. Uncomplicated, neither surgery. David the senior, has worked in his role for 34, 24 years. Sorry. He's initially frustrated by the injury but wants to remain connected, um, to work. He accepts modified duty, gradually increases his activity and tells his manager, I know I'm not 30 anymore, I just need to work out what I can safely do. Michael, the junior 39, he's been with the organisation for six years.
He becomes increasingly concerned about re-injury. So his path is different. He avoids lifting, bending and prolonged sitting and believes returning before he's completely pain free, could cause permanent damage. So we have a level of anxiety surfacing. He's sleeping poorly, he's increasingly anxious. His treating team continues to certify significant restrictions. So there you go. Four months later, David's Mr. 62-year-old getting back to work. Perhaps he's a bit concerned about being on the scrap heap, but he's had a long term in this work and Michael remains largely absent from work.
Okay, that's the case study. We've got limited time so I don't wanna linger too much on it. There is a question I think who would you have predicted would've had more difficult recovery when the injuries first occurred? So David, uh, Michael, don't you dunno? Enough, et cetera. For what it's worth, I'm in the category of, I don't quite know enough, but maybe that's just the lawyer in me. There we go. There we go. The numbers, understandably, people think David, I mean, 60 two's, um, pretty old to have an injury and it can be pretty life changing.
As I said, I'm probably on the, there's not enough information bandwagon, but anyway, Michael, the 39-year-old and about the same. So there you go. There's some interesting numbers there. Alright, so that's the case study. To stimulate the conversation, I might start with you Dr. Tim Huang, two similar injuries. Why do we have such different outcomes? So this is a scenario that I think, uh, a lot of us have seen before in that people with the same or similar injuries end up having quite different outcomes.
What it highlights is that the diagnosis, um, of one particular injury does not really tell us how they're gonna respond, how they're gonna return to work, um, and the long-term outcome. Obviously, there are many, many factors affecting how someone responds to an injury and their recovery and the return to work. As an occupational physician, I'm not an expert in, uh, deciphering all the individual psychosocial type of factors, but on the other hand, I have to be
aware of these things and be able to recognise it and make a note of these things so that they can be addressed. In terms of, uh, factors that affect how people respond, there's individual factors, there's factors such as, um, negative, uh, input, negative reinforcement messages that people have been getting, uh, motivation, fear. So, um, what we've got here is, um, in one case, someone who feels
that they shouldn't be getting back to doing anything until their pain, free pain is a threat. If I do something that is painful, it is going to, uh, retard my recovery and make things worse. On the other hand, we've got, um, David, the older gentleman who seems to have a fairly common sense approach. He doesn't seem to be, uh. Uh, trying to be a hero.
Um, but he wants to find out what he can do and maximise his, uh, capacity. So on one hand we can see people who are really, really scared, and on the other hand, we might be at risk of seeing people who are so driven that they want to get back and push themselves too hard. That's right. And that was a good example of that, his, his, his mindset of getting back, bringing in Dr. Shiver here. In terms of the psychiatric component, we're seeing some signs here, uh, poor sleep, anxiety, Dr. Tim mentioned, uh, the subjective nature of pain.
What are you picking up in this case study that could, you could see potentially emerge? I know it's early days and we probably don't have enough information. And just from the poll and how the room polled for this question and, and generally what we see, um, sometimes outcomes can surprises and that sort of highlights the point around mind of a matter what is going on in your mind, uh, inside your head and how you look at the injury, how you process it is a big factor. It does have influence on functional outcomes and general outcomes.
So one concept we, I'm sure many in the room know about it is that whole, um, fear avoidance cycle. You catastrophize what might be the best or what might be the worst of this situation, of this particular injury. You build on it and you become vigilant around whatever triggers those or brings on that pain. So then you start avoiding it and that's reinforcing because you find some comfort. There's no anxiety. So it's like a vicious cycle. You are vigilant, you're avoiding, and then you're less anxious,
therefore you keep doing that. The moment you push yourself, the vigilance increases, you become more anxious, more painful. So there's a natural fear avoidance cycle which builds up. So that could be one issue which might be playing here. The other concept, again, many of in the room might know about it. It's originally described by Professor Polowski, who was an Adelaide University professor from seventies up until nineties. So, and this model became quite popular in the psychiatric um, academy and then later on in clinical is the model of illness behaviours.
So everyone, all of us, when we get sick day to day, we get a flu, we get an injury. We, we, we have a bug. We all take on a role. We deal with it differently. It's our way of dealing with illness. Some people might just decide to lay down in the bed and read a book. Some might just go for a light jog, some might go watch tv. So it's the way we, we take on a role, it's called a sick role. It's nothing abnormal about it. It's, it's a role you take on when you're told you're sick or you believe you're sick.
So that role you take on is very normative. It helps in healing and, and recovery. But when that becomes abnormal or you start taking on that role much more persistently, a lot more seriously, and for prolonged periods of time, that's when it becomes an abnormal illness behaviour, a IB. So we kind of, when, when we look at cases like this, we look at what is the potential of this progressing into an abnormal illness behaviour and how do you cut that off at the past? I mean, it's very early days, but you don't want to, you don't
wanna solidify the identity of the illness behaviour early. So this is the interesting part in cases like this and, and it's very surprising when I do the work, I actually ask, I see patients, obviously, uh, claimant's patients say two years down the track, sometimes six months, sometimes five years down the track. And it's very fascinating the question when I ask them. What do you think is causing you this pain? And it's fascinating. The answer you get is completely different from what's been in the reports, what's been told by the gp.
It's, they just develop their own illness model. It doesn't sometimes doesn't fit anatomy doesn't fit physiology, it doesn't fit common sense. Sometimes it's, it's just an exaggerated understanding of what's happened. And it's fascinating when you break it down, that's the first step. You say, well, hang on, that, that doesn't make sense and surely anxious about this. This must not be that bad. I mean, there's all sorts of language, like you said, they've been given feedback and, and they add their own knowledge to that. So that's a good starting point.
Thanks for that, Dr. Shiva. Now I'm gonna bring in the neuropsychologist, Dr. Lucas here. Can you help us explain why pain, anxiety, uh, medication and poor sleep can affect attention, memory and concentration? Is there something happening here? Yeah, so I guess there's a few elements to it. Firstly, we do know from a lot of research that's been done that they, these can, people with these conditions will experience cognitive difficulties, and that is on objective measures sometimes. The other element to it though, is the subjective. So their experience.
And of course, if you are in pain, if you're highly anxious and you're thinking about something repeatedly, you don't have room in your brain for other aspects that you need to be focusing on. So that's why we'll often see people who report, uh, problems with, you know, concentrating at work, uh, difficulties, remembering information that they need. They'll say, I went into a meeting and I came out and I just can't remember anything from the meeting because their mind goes elsewhere to focusing on the other issues that they're experiencing. Um, sometimes in pain conditions, it also depends on medications.
So we do know that the medications, if they're on strong medications, can also have an impact on cognition, but we often see a really significant discrepancy in these cases between objective cognition and subjective cognition. And so often it's a matter of, I guess, ruling out that there's anything more serious going on, but then helping that person understand why they're having troubles focusing. Um, and a lot of the issues that come up in chronic pain come up in other areas. So, um, you know, concussion obviously is a big one. Persisting concussion.
Um, also long COVID, um, a lot of these other conditions that can have nothing to do sometimes with how the brain is even working. And people will still experience problems with concentration and memory. Thank you so much for that. Now, last but not least, the lawyer in the room and lawyers, why do we always come in last and clean up the mess? But a question for you, Alison. Um, what are the risks, uh, for this employer? If they assume that David, Mr. Senior needs greater protection simply because he's 62, are there, what, what does that bring to, into play?
Thanks, Damien. It jumps out straight away that they're making a decision on the basis of David's age and age is a protected attribute. So if you're making a decision on the basis of a protected attribute, it sounds like it's discrimination. Um, and there are a number of avenues that David could take against the employer, um, whether it's under state legislation or, uh, the Federal Age Discrimination Act, or even, um, under the federal court system through the Fair Work Act as a general protections claim.
So making a decision on the basis of age is highly problematic. Listening to my fellow panel members, you know, they're talking about actually working through the individual circumstances. So I think don't focus on particular attributes, actually look at what are the key considerations here around, um, first of all, what are your obligations under workers' compensation laws to assist people to be able to return to work and make sure you meet all of those obligations. And then assessing what are the requirements of the role
and can the individual perform those inherent requirements? And it seems like David was a real success story in that he was able to perform the role. Um, I think the other person was Michael. Yeah. Um, Michael, um, sounds like he was struggling far more. So at some point you get to the stage where you say, well, have we met all our requirements under workers' compensation law? And if you have and Michael's still not returning to the workplace, then is that something now we need to manage?
Is it having a bigger impact on the workplace because we've got a staff member who's not at work and not able to do their role. And so that then lends itself to other considerations around when Michael might be able to perform the role and come back to work and do it successfully. And if it's a long term issue, then you can look at whether or not he will in the foreseeable future be able to perform the role and if not manage that process. But even manageing that requires appropriate medical evidence.
Yep. And looking at each of the aspects of the requirements of the role, assessing Michael's capacity against that before you would make a decision. That's right. And there's obviously a lot of employment law that needs to be followed if you were to exit Michael from the organisation, so it's early days, but down the track, you'd want to assess that with objective medical evidence from say, an OC fears about the inherent requirements of the job, for example. Correct. And it would need to be separate to how you've managed the workers' compensation claim because it has a slightly different focus. It's not about returning to work, it's then about going forward.
Can he perform the inherent requirements? Absolutely. Alright, well that's case study one. Thank you Allison. Thank you for that. Uh, that was useful. Now obviously the key, uh, takeaway if there is one, is don't predict capacity from the workers' age or even from a diagnosis. As useful as a diagnosis may be as a label, you've gotta understand the individual factors influencing recovery and that case study brings that to the fore. And as I said, there's lots of, um, information that we don't know, but that's useful. And as I said, we will have some time at the end for some questions
'cause we've got some great experts here and I want you to be able to ask the questions you needed. Let's go to, uh, case study two. The worker hasn't changed. His job has, or sorry, her job has, this is a scenario. Susan is 59. She's worked for the organisation for 22 years and has consistently been regarded as an excellent employee Following a restructure, her role changes substantially. New digital platform is introduced. There you go. Change reporting requirements, increase decisions are expected more quickly.
She has multiple communication channels. I know what that's like as a bit of a boomer, you know, teams Slack email. I thought it's hard enough for me to manage an inbox operating simultaneously. And as they're manageing a younger team accustomed to very different ways of working, Susan starts making occasional errors and takes longer to learn the new systems. Her manager says she has become resistant to change and increasingly rigid. Susan, of course, sees it very differently. The story she's telling herself is, I've done this job successfully for 22 years.
What's the fuss about? Suddenly I'm told I'm the problem. She's increasingly anxious about work. She's sleeping poorly. She's feeling her younger colleagues are dismissive of her experience, her judgement , her expertise, and her manager, of course wonders whether Susan is simply struggling because of her age. Okay. The question then, for the audience, what do you think is most likely happening? A normal ageing BA performance management issue.
She certainly seems to be struggling with this new change. C, psychological distress. There's anxiety there, there's poor sleeping. Here we go. The numbers are coming in. I feel like I'm an election night. Um, d early cognitive impairment. E the job has changed beyond Susan's, Susan's current ca capability and we don't know enough yet. Okay. Where are we sitting? Seems to be the large majority of the job has changed beyond Susan's current capacity or capability. It seems to jump out potentially at you. Numbers are coming in on the, we don't know, and another seems to be reducing and fluctuating.
Psychological distress is up there. Uh, performance management issue. That's interesting that it's as low as that, but I get that normal ageing, um, et cetera. So there you go. That's a good scenario. Thanks. Thanks for that. Let's get the experts involved in this case study. The psychiatrist in the room, Dr. Gunna p um. Can people become less psychologically flexible as they age? Yeah. Good, good question. And on the face of it, it looks like a pejorative question, but we, let's, let's look at it, uh, biologically there is, there is a change.
Human body ages changes, muscles change, tissues change, brain changes. We know we, we find it easy to accept. We have muscle, you know, degradation or weakness as we age. Similarly, brain does do its thing. One of the things which is notable in, uh, ageing brain, normal, normal ageing, um, is that set, we call it set shifting. Set shifting is an executive function. It involves the prefrontal cortex, so front of the brain, the cortex, the prefrontal, the part of it, the side, and the, this part of it,
um, is involved in set shifting. It's, it's where you learn new rules of the game. Where, where, when you suddenly the rules of the game change or the formula change, or you have to do things differently. You just have to stop the, always start the new waste. That set shifting is an issue. Uh, and, and you can adapt to it. It, it's not a permanent, uh, brain's still neuro adaptable. It is neuroplastic, it's less so, but it is still neuroplastic. So you could train with appropriate supports and, and all that.
And I think, uh, Sarah will speak more about that. So that's, yes, that does happen. Before I bring in, Sarah, I'll just bring in Dr. Huang on this question. You do a lot of functional capacity assessments. A job that's often given to an occupational physician saying, Hey, as Allison foreshadowed earlier, if you've got a situation that's playing out at the end of it and you're wanting to assess your options as an employer, you might go down that path, understandably. And you need it to be based on evidence. So what are we missing here? 'cause has the job changed? I mean, are we, can we assess the current capacity of the old job or the new job?
What do we do in this scenario? 'cause it's potentially, it's pretty different job, isn't it? At some level, what we've got here is, uh, someone who's asked to do a job that, um, seems to be different. This example is, um, obviously to do with cognitive and to a certain degree, uh, learning. I can draw a parallel to physical limitations as well. In cases such as someone working in a warehouse, for example, who's expected
to do certain things, and then a change in process comes and they need to start double handling things, um, moving apart perhaps two to three times because of a change of workflow. And suddenly they get pain in their shoulders, pain in the neck. So at what stage Is it an injury or at what stage is it simply that the, uh, required task exceeds what is reasonably expected of someone?
So this is always an important question. Just because you don't have an injury doesn't mean you don't get pain. And you can perform at a very high level. At some stage when we perform at a certain level, we'll get some difficulties and pains. Thank you for that doctor. Now, Dr. Sarah, this is where you come into, we've got someone here who's struggling with a different cognitive load, a level of flexibility required to process and learn something quite new in a job that she's been very comfortable with and has been held in relatively high esteem.
It seems what's going on, uh, what could be going on? Talk us through it from a ageing and a cognitive, uh, perspective. If we could go back to that slide with the ageing, that'd be great. I just wanted to highlight with this slide, not to depress everybody in the room, but just really to highlight, I guess what does happen with normal ageing. Um, and so as Shiva had commented on, there are areas of cognition that unfortunately do decline. Uh. Memory goes downhill from about the age of 30.
Um, and really when we hit that, as you can see from the slide, when we hit that 65, age 65 onwards, then you do get more decline in especially those areas of memory and processing speed. And as Shiva was explaining before, what we would call executive function, so it's referred to as reasoning in this particular slide, but we do become more inflexible. Um, and we do have more trouble reasoning in certain areas. I guess the thing is though, that in a lot of, um, jobs that's not really necessarily gonna be that noticeable. It is often when the goalposts move, um, especially when people are being
compared to much younger people. 'cause of course we know processing speed is much better at age 25 than age 65. Um, so there are those elements, but it is also then a question of course of whether this is a clinic, a, a, a medically significant problem, which is where we would come in versus a, a problem of within the workplace. Um, I will throw back to Shiva about the, um, intergenerational bias aspect you were talking about before. Yeah, yeah. So one thing which struck me in this case also just, just being aware that normal ageing, healthy ageing, normative ageing is where you have a natural
tendency to, while you acquire a lot of wisdom, having lived life and seen a lot of things and been through a lot of changes and all that, and there's a natural force in all of us to give that past that wisdom to the next generation. You know, we want to nurture the next generation, pass our wisdom knowledge and it's a very normative thing. But in this case, for example, there is that block of that this stagnation that creates a lot of internal anxiety because now it's the other way around. You are being now asked to learn something. You are not wise.
This is the wrong way of doing the job. So that creates the internal anxiety. And there is that intergenerational bias around, oh, if you are old, you're probably not digitally fluent, which is a bias, rightly or wrongly. In this case, we don't know enough details of how much this person knew or used technology beforehand, but this, this awareness that this natural flow, wisdom and knowledge is not happening, it's kind of the other way around, creates the tension. Anxiety is, is an important sort of point also. Um, once the anxiety sets in, so now you're going to work every day, you've
already been flagged with concerns and now you have performance anxiety. So you can add another 20, 30% level of cognitive problems just from that anxiety. So that, that's probably is happening in this case as well. Yeah, yeah, for sure. Anything to add? Yeah, I just wanted to say, um, I think the thing to remember is that a lot of, um, older people and, and people of all different level, 'cause sometimes jobs change and it's beyond their own intellectual capabilities as well, or, or it's gonna be a challenge for them. So they might just need a bit more time, a bit more support, um, a bit
more, you know, individual training and then that might be enough for them. Um, but if they're not able to access that or they feel that they're going to be singled out, if they access that, then that can be where it can become quite tricky as well. So I think it's just really important to consider, you know, is this maybe beyond a person's capabilities for whatever reason, whether it's ageing or another reason, um, or can they learn with some extra strategies and supports? And that's certainly something that I often get asked in some of the assessments that I do. Yeah, it goes to the heart of it, doesn't it?
Um, well now we'll bring in Allison. Um, I'm Susan's manager, Allison, I've, I just think she can't get with the programme, can't work out this new system. So I'm gonna take her aside. I'm gonna say, Susan, you've had a fantastic career. Um, have you thought about whether it's time to retire now? Um, is that problematic if I approach her on that basis? Alison. I think it is problematic. Um, I don't think an employer should ever be the first to raise a retirement question.
I think that should be the employee who, um, brings that into the equation. I think with this matter, there's a couple of things that play from an employer perspective and a risk, um, exposure perspective. And that is, first of all, has the role actually changed so much that it's a different role. And if it's a different role, it's actually probably not satisfactory to expect that Suzanne can can do the role. So, um, perhaps it needed to be that the employer, um, before implementing
the new digital platform did an assessment as to whether or not it is a restructure and it's a different role. And if that was the case, there are requirements under industrial laws to go through consultation with impacted staff and also now more than ever under work health and safety law to consider the psychosocial hazards and risks that come with certain changes in workplaces. So I think it may have been the case that consultation was needed if it's that it's not that substantial a change.
It's still Susan's role, but she's now struggling with it. Um, then it comes down to as some of the things, um, that have been mentioned around appropriate support and training. Um, and employers do have obligations to look after the psychosocial health of their staff. And that means training staff when you're in introducing, you know, new ways of doing work so that they feel supported. If it gets to the point where Susan is just not performing in the role.
So it, it's the employer's done everything they can to try and support her, but she's not performing, then it becomes a performance management issue. And that again, needs to be appropriately managed with, um, proper procedural fairness, um, and, you know, proper direction and assistance to Susan. Yeah. Thank you for that. Um, I think that's a really useful, uh, case study that highlights the reality around ageing, the cognitive issues that play a very different role.
What does that mean legally? What does that mean from the perspective of fitness for work and capacity? And I get some comfort from someone who's approaching, uh, five years away from 60 that although my processing speed might decline, my strategy and judgement skills can still be at a four, which I'm gonna dine out on in for the next 15 years as a mediator. So, uh, that's, there's some good news there. Alright, let's go on to, um, case study three. Is this normal ageing or something else?
Now this is a scenario involving Robert. He's, uh, 64. He's a highly regarded senior manager who has been with his organisation for 30 years. Bit of a lifer over the past 12 months. His team has noticed small changes. He occasionally forgets discussions. He asked for information to be repeated. He takes longer to make decisions and increasingly relies on established processes rather than adapting when the circumstances change. His executive noticed that Robert has become more irritable when challenged
behaviour that seemed out of character. There's no catastrophic mistakes I might add. There's no single incident. And of course Robert believes that nothing's really wrong. Hell, I'm 64, everyone forgets things. I'm not 24 anymore. Uh, he's also sleeping poorly and he's had a cardiovascular episode six months earlier from which he was medically, he has medically recovered in the sense that he's back at work. There might be other issues at play, but anyway, he's back. His manager doesn't know whether they are witnessing normal ageing
stress, poor sleep, potentially performance problem rearing its head or something more significant. Now, the question posed of you as you are Robert's manager, what would you do next? A, nothing. B, commence performance management. C. Suggest C is gp. D. Seek as fitness for work capacity assessment, discuss retirement. E. Well, thanks Allison for covering that off last time. And F I'm not sure, I'm not surprised too much by this.
Um. You know, he's been with you for 30 years and there's something that that's a bit amiss. So you, you'd wanna check if he's okay. Huh? So I can understand why a lot of people are landing on, see his gp. Um, other people say there's nothing much of a problem here. You know, he's 64, give him some slack. I'll assume there's, there's a 14% at the moment saying, seek a fitness for work capacity assessment. Um, I don't know. We'll have to pick Allison's brain and others as whether that's potentially too early for that or whether you need to do some things first.
But I understand that perspective as well. Let's get into this case study. It's about, I guess, ageing more generally, but someone who's very well regarded, 30 years. Um, but irritability jumps out at me some anxiety, poor sleep. It's an interesting health issue, a cardiovascular episode. What does that mean? What, what does that place in from a health perspective? I think, uh, Dr. Lucas, you've already introduced the idea of what actually happens to cognition as we age. What are you picking up in this case study in terms of dealing with Robert?
Yeah. Um, well I guess there are, um, firstly if, and again, coming at it from a medical viewpoint rather than a legal viewpoint, I would, um, often want to have seen that they've, you know, if there are concerns that it might be a medical issue. Um, and given he is had the cardiovascular. Um, condition that raises the possibility of, um, vascular or cerebrovascular in particular, which is small brain changes that can occur. It would be helpful if he's seen his GP and had any reversible causes of cognitive difficulty ruled out, and that would include things
like, um, depression, um, sometimes certain, um, vitamin deficiencies. There can be quite a few different causes. Obviously the other element for women can be menopause, so that can have an impact on memory, sleep, brain fog, all those sorts of symptoms as well, which is certainly being recognised a bit more these days. Um, often I'm down the track so people come to me when there's really continuing concern and it might be that things have been tried in the workplace and they haven't worked, uh, and there's still cognitive concerns.
So that's when they'll come to me for the question of, is this a something organic? Is this some sort of neurodegenerative condition or, uh, other medical, other medical condition, or is this part of normal ageing normal processes? In which case then it would go down the performance management side. Um, if the issues are continuing, I guess within that age bracket, especially that again, that sort of 65 ish to 69 age bracket, um, about 1% of people will be diagnosed with dementia during that time.
Um, unfortunately earlier onset dementias have increased, um, in the last few decades. It could also be, you know, silent stroke effects. Again, again, especially in someone with cardiovascular. So there are medical aspects that do need to be explored and ruled out. Um, what MyFitness for duty assessments would really help with is determining is there an objective cognitive impairment or a cognitive problem and what does that look like and what might it indicate? Obviously, depending on how much medical information I have, sometimes I have none. Sometimes I have quite a lot.
That would also help determine what might be going on and then I'd be making recommendations around what is going to help clarify that particular situation. Um, but I guess the, the thing is that there are other various conditions that need to be ruled out before we jump to, you know, dementia. Um, but that is unfortunately a consideration that we do see sometimes. Thank you for that. Dr. Sarah. Um, Dr. Gunna Poo, if I can bring you in here, irritability, some personality changes, anxiety, poor sleep.
What's, uh, jumping out at you in this case study? It's a case where I think you rightly said at the, at the top, uh, someone's been doing so well, something's different. People are picking on it. So something's changed and I think the majority voted for a, a medical screening and go and see your gp. I think that's a good call. In terms of the number of reversible things, I mean, it could be thyroid issues, it could be, could be alcoholism, we don't know. Silent, you know, closet drinking sometimes can be missed at work. You know, it can can be the case.
These are all reversible. So there are reversible causes like, um, alcoholism, nutritional vitamin B deficiency. Sometimes you see very low B12, especially if they change their diet, et cetera, B12, B one. And that can cause surprisingly, uh, problematic cognitive. It's so surprising to see that just as a thymine levels can be low and you can just change your cognitions. So all those needs to be ruled out. That's striking out. So I would definitely get a GP involved. Get all the screens. We know after a cardiovascular episode, within the first six weeks,
there are higher rates of depression anxiety, and within the first six to 12 months, there's two to three times likely compared to a normal person who doesn't have a cardiovascular episode. Chances of anxiety or depression, particularly depression, it's multifactorial depression from combination of being sick, losing functionality, and coming close to death and on all those sort of factors play into that. So that may be a thing to be addressed by the GP at the onset to see how much anxiety lies around that. How bad was the cardiovascular episode?
Was it, was it really a near miss sort of a situation? Is that the worrying the person and is losing sleep about it? I've seen few cases where people simply can't sleep because they're worried about the chest pain coming and they imagine they have chest pain at night and something will go wrong when they're sleeping. So that's not an uncommon scenario. The other pointer I wanted to bring out around early, I mean dementia, we need to know generally is a progressive condition. So I'll underline the word. It's progressive, so it is going to progress, it's going to keep getting worse, right?
That's the first thing about dementia. The second thing about dementia is it'll be there in all circumstances, home. Outside home work when they're on recreational, when they're on holiday travelling. So if it's dementia like picture and it's not work related stress, that's one way of looking at it. Whether it's global, whether it's progressive. The other point with Sarah raised about early dementia, there are, we are getting better at picking up dementia earlier and earlier. One of the ways to pick up dementia early is what we call a soft science.
Uh, behavioural changes, uh, early behavioural changes. So one of the things which is striking and probably 30 to 40% of people, if you really look closely once they're diagnosed dementia and you go back in time and look at it, one of the things you'll see and commonly up to 30% is apathy. Apathy is like, I don't care. Don't care what happens. Dunno not that interested. Do you want to do this? Uh, it's okay. It's not depression. You won't see it as someone withdrawn and crying and sad.
You see that as a case of me, kind of a feeling about what they used to be passionate about or what they did regularly. So you see apathy as a common presentation. Uh, so we are getting good at that sort of thing so that we'll keep that in mind in this case as well. Other common thing, the second common thing is depression, anxiety, which might be anxiety, is already in this case, uh, irritability can be in 20% of people, uh, getting, losing, cool, frustrated than they've never been. I mean that can be part of depression as well. Irritability, uh, and sleep changes are also, can be an early change of dementia.
Then smell change in inability to smell like they used to. Losing that, uh, visual accuracy, like the perception of some other visual depth or clarity. This can be some early signs. We, in psychiatry, always, when we have cases like this, we always think of a concept called pseudo dementia. So it looks like dementia, but it's not dementia. We have to rule out. The assumption is it's pseudo dementia. We never jump to that diagnosis. We always go, this might be a false dementia. It looks like dementia, but it's not dementia. Let's look at all the reversible.
Let's look at all the early changes. Let's look at any psychiatric conditions which may be existing. Is it nutritional? Is it hormonal, cardiovascular? Is there a stroke? Is that just from the cardiovascular? Is it fear of death and dying and seeing death close and, and how bad it was, the recovery. So those would be the issues which will, I would like to get a good grasp on that. Yeah, so I think medical screening is a good idea to start. Yeah. Thank you for that, Shiva. 'cause obviously Robert believes he can do his job. But his employer isn't so sure, and maybe it's too early to know, but who is right?
Is this the sort of work you would do in due course doing a, a work capacity assessment? So cases like this, um, in, in this case we've got a few elements. We've got, um, psychological, um, cognitive behavioural, and the concern is being raised in the work environment. Usually a case like this would be sent for assessment by a psychiatrist or neuropsychologist. Yeah. Due to the nature of the symptoms. However, um, as pointed out, um, by Sarah and Shiva, um, there are medical
courses, so my involvement in such cases may be, um, as an extra assessor to look at medical courses working carefully together to determine whether there are medical courses for this. Um, when I see a case like this, I would also be mindful of what's happening in the background at work. This is a referral from a manager who has raised his concerns. Um, but does he really have such concerns at home?
Is there anything happening at work? Could he be irritable because of certain things that are changing at work? Uh, other people irritable? It could be a whole workforce that have become irritable, um, due to certain things. Um, workplace conflict. So there are so many different things to explore, but uh, we have to take into consideration the input of information from all sources. Absolutely. Yeah. Thanks for that doctor. And you're right, it probably falls more squarely in the domain, this
case in terms of expertise of a neuropsychologist and a psychiatrist. But we're bringing Allison now for the legal minefield here because obviously Allison has explained that yeah, it's 64. We've gotta be careful around age discrimination, but there's also some privacy issues at play here, aren't they, in terms of he might wanna protect, um, his own health concerns around his cardiac episode. So what should the employer do here in a case like this? Allison? Yeah, it is a sensitive issue, particularly if Robert's sort
of not receptive to hearing that maybe his behaviour is changing. And I think an employer has to address that and if they've got safety and health concerns, they've got obligations under work health and safety law to address it with Robert. But I think doing it in a really sensitive way, making sure that any of his health information is kept confidential, um, and only people within the organisation who need to have access to it do have access to it. Making sure that they have Robert's consent, um, in terms
of getting information from his treating general practitioner. Um, and also just, yeah, I think really having a conversation with him, if it gets to the point where they've got real concerns about his health and he's not receptive to addressing it, well then you move more into, well, it's a lawful and reasonable direction now that you go and see your general practitioner, um, and you're required to make an appointment and you go through all of that process, but you know, you wanna manage it in a very sensitive way.
And Robert's been there for 30 years, so, um, that in itself I think requires a certain amount of respect towards Robert. Absolutely. But if there are real health and safety concerns, they have to be addressed. Thank you, Allison. Alright, well those are the case studies. Thank you for your participation in them. Well, it's not every day that you'll have a neuropsychologist, an occupational physician, a lawyer, and a psychiatrist together. Have we got any questions from the floor either pertaining to these case studies or to other questions relevant to their expertise?
How much does menopause impact a woman's cognition and how can employers support this stage of life for their female employees? That's a great question. Perhaps it's more in the domain of, uh, you, um, Dr. Sarah and you, Dr. Shiva. Look, it varies a lot from, um, between women. Some are not really affected much at all. Others, um, are maybe affected more. Again, there are studies which have shown, especially as the oestrogen levels really change, that you can detect, um, memory decline. It is not significant.
Well, it is significant at an individual level for some people, but overall in terms of um, you know, group studies, it's not that significant, but it is noticeable. And when you add it to the sleep issues and the, um, hot flushes, which can be very distracting and all the other factors that can come into play, it can really sig uh, really impact on some women. Um, in terms of employers supporting, um, at that stage in life. I think that is a bit trickier and probably a bit more of your question for you, I would say. Yeah, it's a very good question.
Yeah, and again, I think it's quite a personal issue, so it needs to be dealt with in a sensitive way. Um, again, it might be if, if an employer's noticing a real difference in how, um, a woman's presenting at work, then perhaps their manager just talks to them and says, is there anything going on? How can we support? And then I think it's up to the individual to raise, um, those issues. Um, but if they do, then I think an employer has obligations to make reasonable accommodations, um, if somebody's dealing
with some health issues. And so it might be talking about flexible work arrangements, um, changing their workload if that's what they need. But it's a consultation process, I think, and really making sure the individual's engaged in that. Yeah, it's a very good question. Dr. Shi, have you got anything to add on that? Yeah, I was, uh, just going to add subjectively for the person experiencing it, uh, it might feel like a brain fog. It may not feel like intense memory loss, but it's a sense of brain fog. Things are not as clear as before.
You have to look at things, few more extra times to kind of retain it. Uh, that may be the subjective experience. Um, but it does matter if you had an really high cognitive demand task. Or a role versus a low cognitive demand role. So it's, it's a relative drop, even if it's a 5% drop, that can bring on stress. The other important thing about menopause, which is under-recognized, is the correlation between menopausal related psychiatric symptoms like anxiety, depression do not, do not correlate with hormone levels.
They can predate by three to four years. There's a lot of prospective studies they've looked at, followed up to 20,000 plus Australian studies study, which they looked at prospectively looking following, tracking these women. And they found that if we were really tuned into the anxiety depression side, it would have been a good marker three to four years, even prior to the hormone levels dropping. So similarly, the brain fog effects can even just predate even couple of years before the actual hormone levels drop. So that's an interesting finding.
Thank you, Dr. Shiva. While you've got the mic, uh, I think this question is in your domain, how much does anxiety play a part in pain? Such subjective pain. Is it possible to feel something that technically isn't there? That's the title of my next book, but, so I will try to give you a two minute version of it. Look, there's a very valid point. You, you could imagine. Can you imagine pain is, is the first one, you know, if you imagine pain,
absolutely there's no reason for it and you're completely imagining it. You, you could be delusional. I mean, we are looking at that extreme as well. There are hypochondriac, uh, delusions. We know that. So there is small people. Imagine they have bugs crawling on there. People imagine their things in the joint. People imagine lots of things. I mean, it could be that extreme. That's a very clear cut case. But there are the softer side of that where, where there's a correlation between, I think I talked about that vigilance. The moment you bring your mind and put it there, wherever the
injuries, it changes the dynamic. It's how then you look at it, you'll be more vigilant, be more perceptive. You'll take more medications for it. Um, you'll be less distracted and therefore that happens. Now the question is all of this, is it conscious or unconscious? Is the person doing it to themselves or is it such a powerful unknown background force in their mind, which is kind of doing that unconsciously,
unwillingly, even against the person's wish they don't want to. So that is where the assessment comes into it. I guess delineating, is it conscious? Is it unconscious? Is it a habitual thing? Is it a, is it a wrong information thing? Um, yes, but general rule anxiety will amplify the pain experience. The pain scores will go up by at least 30 to 40% minimum if you have bout of anxiety. And you'll find that sometimes patient will give you a wonderful description.
The I have panic, I'm anxious, I'm worried my pain's gone up. I'm using more pain medication. Thank you for that. And shameless plug for the podcast I've had a pain specialist on in the resolution room, so check that out as well. Thank you so much. That was a really great session. Dr. Tim Huang. Thank you. Uh, thank you Dr. Shiva. Thank you Dr. Sarah. Thank you Allison. Um. I really appreciate your time and expertise. Um, I'm proud of the collaboration with M-L-C-O-A and the Resolution Room podcast.
I'm always in the market for new subscribers on YouTube for the podcast, um, as I build a platform. So check it out. We cover off the intersection of law, medicine and everything in between, as the title suggests. Thanks for your time, everyone. Have a good rest of the day. Thank you.
What determines recovery after a spinal injury? The answer can be more complex than a scan suggests. I’m joined by neurosurgeon Dr Simon Clark and psychiatrist Dr Shiva Gunapu as part of our collaboration with MLCOA’s...
Chronic pain claims can be some of the most contested and misunderstood matters in personal injury and medico legal work, especially when the pain does not match a neat scan or diagnosis. In this episode of The...
Career reinvention is rarely neat, and it often starts with a quiet question you cannot unhear. In this episode, I’m joined by Joanna Wong, host of the podcast Chasing Waves, to talk about career transitions, leadership...
Mindful leadership is not a wellness trend, it is an attention skill, and in this episode I sit down with Susan Pearse to talk about what that really means in modern work and life. Susan and I have known each other for...
Vicarious trauma is one of the most overlooked psychosocial hazards at work, especially in high exposure roles like law, insurance, health, and frontline services. In this episode of The Resolution Room, I’m joined by...