Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Welcome to the Resolution Room podcast. This is part of my collaboration with M-L-C-O-A law Medicine and everything in between. I'm joined by Vanessa Daniel of M-L-C-O-A. Thanks for joining us, Vanessa. Thank you. Damien. M-L-C-O-A is one of the largest medicolegal providers, um, in Australia with 300 specialists on their books. And I have two with me today. The topic today is Spine In the Mind, what really determines Recovery To address this issue, we have two specialists. We have Dr. Simon Clark, who's a neurosurgeon. Welcome Simon Morning, and we have Shiver pu a psychiatrist.
Good morning. Now, I don't wanna spend the whole podcast talking about Dr. Simon Clark's qualifications, but I will give you some, uh, the highlight reel. Uh, Dr. Simon Clark is a neurosurgeon with expertise in complex spinal disorders. He's dual qualified. He has is a fellow of the Royal College in Edinburgh and also in Australia. He works here in Adelaide as a consultant. He also works out at the Prince Alfred Hospital in Melbourne. He does a extensive medicolegal, uh, uh, practise as well addressing personal injury, uh, medical negligence and the like as well of, of course, still
conducting complex spinal surgery. Is that a fair summary of your, sounds busier than it really is, isn't it? But I suppose it is. And shiver Gutter, whos with us? Uh, I met Shiva yesterday. We did a, a session with, with Shiva in, in a part of a conference. He's a psychiatrist, a fellow of the, of course, of the college has a private practise as well as works for Ramsay Health, which is a large private health provider and mental health. He and his wife also have a really interesting business called Mind Speak, looking at workplace wellness training and the like.
And that stems from a personal interest growing up as a doctor and seeing how things could be done better or differently in your workplace, in your early training. Indeed, that was influential. Absolutely. And Vanessa, of course, who she's a regular guest here. I am. So thanks for joining us. Vanessa Vanessa's work is a liaison officer at M-L-C-O-A. So she's the person that people go to ask various questions around. For example, what specialists should I use? What are the type of issues that are alive in this case? And Vanessa directs traffic accordingly. Is that a fair? That's right. Fair summary. Alright, Simon, because we're talking about the spine and the mine, let's
of course start with the spine. Um, which is your area, what spinal injuries commonly come across your desk? Um, and in, in what respect are they commonly work related? Spinal disorders are super common. So if you think about everyone in the world as a, as a generalisation, everyone's gonna have sciatica, leg pain at some point. Everyone's gonna have back pain at some point, and everyone who comes across with all of these problems, the issue therefore is, was this a work-related injury? Yeah. Was it preexisting?
What does a scan mean? What does the patient understand? And then we've gotta kind of explore all these little bits. The problem I have in a lot of, a lot of cases, and, and we were talking about this before, trying to connect the, like the psychological mind side of things with the spinal side of things is the patient perception. Yeah. And so a lot of my job, unfortunately, and I, and I, and I say that in, in a real way, unfortunately, is trying to unpack what has happened before they've come to see me as a spinal expert. Yeah. And so therefore, the amount of information on the internet is a
fantastic thing, and the amount of thing on the internet is a terrible thing. Yeah. And that is the, the real problem we have, isn't it? It's that dichotomy of too much information and misinformation. So your normal person, unfortunately, will not go to see their GP or their specialist for information discussion. They'll get it from a AI source. Yeah. And what does that mean? AI source, when it is regulated, when it is within a framework, is incredibly useful.
I use it to look at, uh, journal articles, papers, and all this sort of stuff. When it's thrown out there, it picks up Reddit, it picks up all of the other things. It picks up the forums where it's not necessarily regulated as much. And so therefore the patient comes to see me with a perception of what their problem is. And perhaps in terms of bringing in shiver in terms of the pain aspect, perhaps with an identification aspect of a diagnosis, as helpful as a diagnosis may be, there might, will be an undue identification with it, which may
impede recovery at sometimes the issue. Mainly, uh, and I, and I totally agree with that. The issue mainly for me is the diagnosis. Yeah. So look, as doctors and, you know, we, we were always trained the same way. Myself, Shiva, everyone, you see a patient, you take a history, you do an examination, you formulate a plan, you get a diagnosis, and then you use all the other stuff. Unfortunately, we're in the world of instant diagnosis and access to scans and access to information. So therefore, some of this bit in the middle gets muddied and actually
bringing people back to, well, what is the history behind this? What happened? What's the examination? Does it fit yes or no? What special tests can I use to try and get a diagnosis will inform me and the patient and then your treatment stems from that. Unfortunately, if there's a less than adequate assessment. We don't really know the history. Multiple scans are done. The patient turns up with scan reports, um, from various
sources and misinformation. We are at the wrong end of the spectrum here. We're not starting with this patient focused, patient centred. What happened to you? How does it affect you? What is the examination? We've got some imaging and a person. Yeah. And remember that if you scan everyone in this room, we will all have a degree of degeneration in our spine. Yeah. Yeah. That's the issue. There's this great study back in 2015, I think, where they, uh, took
loads of, uh, papers and of people with a little bit of back pain, but not presenting to their GP for that reason, and looked at all of the scans. And by the time you get to 50, 50% of people will have degenerative change on the scan. Yeah. And so if you add that into a injured worker Yeah. What, what are we, what are we doing here? This is, this is a mess of preexisting degeneration with some exacerbation. So that history, that examination is key because the scans Yeah. Are going to show problems.
So on that point, uh, Dr. Simon, the scans are of course really important for, I love the way you say Dr. Simon. That's such an, that's such an Australian thing. Australian in It's very Australian. It's very Australian, isn't it? Yeah. Because we're very informal, but we still put the doctor in and I'm, I'm still trying to get my head around. I've been here like five years. I still can't work it out. Sorry. The, the scans are the best diagnostic tool still in terms of MRIs, but they're still to be treated with a level of caution. Because what you're saying is you treat the patient in front of you in terms of their symptomatology, their history, what they tell you.
Oh, a hundred percent. Yeah, a hundred percent. And the mistake is to skip from some of these, uh, steps at the start, not get the, and, and psychiatry is, is exactly the same, just with the scans are even less useful. Yeah. But that is, that is key consistent with my work as a mediator and a lawyer. A lot of the questions that then pos to you in the medicolegal context around issues of causation, of course. Yes. Unfortunately, because you, you take on one view of it in the lawyer, of course, you take your plaintiff as you find them, as, you know, we're all got a level of degeneration.
I'm not, I'm comforted by the fact that 55, I'm, I've got a level of degeneration, I dunno about. You take your plan because you find, but you have to assess forensically to what extent, say a mechanism of injury may have produced an aggravation, an exacerbation. Yes. To what extent those symptoms may have developed in any event is always a relevant question. And, and it and it is, and remember that degeneration disc prolapses and all that sort of thing is rarely due to one event. Yeah. It's cumulative events over time. Now that might be entirely relevant to the medical legal sphere in that they've been doing this job and exposing their spine to this a
thousand times over the last 15 years. That's fine. But it's very rarely Mr. X slipped over in coals Yeah. On a grape and suddenly has got this massive disc prolapse. Yeah. That's not a thing. Yeah. But is that the straw that brought the camels back on the background of the, all the degeneration and that's why it's really hard. Yeah, that's right. It's tough and tough for lawyers too in that space as well. And I think probably like dis degeneration or those terms create a lot of anxiety. Yes. For people as well too. They don't know how to interpret it. And that's another thing we have to manage, isn't it?
Um, yes. Dr. Shiva. Yeah. Yes, yes indeed. Very valid points. Um, some, um, importantly what I find striking when I, when I see, uh, people with spinal injuries or any chronic injuries particularly, is the, is the model of. Illness they have in the head. Yeah, definitely. It, it, it's, it's not necessarily what is actually happened anatomically or physiologically or through the mechanism or the biomechanics of the injury can explain.
So it's interesting that illness model is very crucial and how that's evolved. Is it through wrong information? Is it through, uh, getting wrong source of information or is it being just they, they just didn't have the sophistication or guidance to put all the information together? They just put it in a way that makes sense to them. Yeah, number of times. Seen, I, I've seen, uh, patients five years into the claim, two years into the claim or post-injury or, you know, six months post-injury. Everyone has, uh, interesting understanding of how, what the injury is.
Yeah. Yeah. You ask them this, oh, I have nerve damage. Yeah. You ask them, for example, they say, I have nerve damage. And then you see there's actually no nerve damage. Uh, what's happened? Oh, I think my, my disc is worn out or something. But yeah, I hear that a lot too. Um, but then when you look at it, it's some soft tissue injury, for example, is what has happened. So it's the illness model that's very crucial and that, like you said, um, illness model generates that anxiety. I've got this, this is chronic, this is bad, it's not getting better. One of the things, uh, we also look at is hypervigilance.
So once you have a symptom, which has not been the case for some years, for example, if it's a, like someone was saying they, they might have had a level of degeneration, they have fall and then that, that sets off pain for the first time ever, for instance. So they're pain-free, relatively pain-free, and then you have the pain and they've been told all this, um, information about what's wrong with them, then you're going to be vigilant. So you're constantly scanning that and you know, back or yeah, thinking about it, processing it.
How is it, how are you sitting, how are you standing? And then you're making your own interpretation of, of what aggravates it without that appropriate guidance. So the initial, um, understanding of what is their illness model is such a crucial aspect. When I intervene or when I try to understand these cases, that's where I start usually. Yeah. What do you think is wrong? Can you explain to me in your terms, forget about all this technical jargon, just tell me what is happened to you. What do you think is going wrong?
Yeah. Yeah. And that's a good starting point for a psychiatrist to look at. And do you think that, um, once they've identified with those words or the terms, it inhibits recovery as well too? Absolutely. If we can't change it, change the norms then. So there's an identification as well. Yeah. And yes, this is the interesting part of pain, right? It's experienced in the brain. At the end of the day, there's a pathological tissue damage of somewhere in spine or nerves or the bones, uh uh, or anywhere between the spine and the brain, right?
It could be any at any level. And but pain perception happens in the brain. Mm-hmm. So therefore the brain, which is then absorbing what's happening in their social circumstances. Yeah. What has changing in their psychological circumstances, it's absorbing that. This pain is being experienced in that context. Yeah. So the pain amplification when the brain is already anxious is a very non phenomenon. Right? So, so what, what we call as disproportionate pain experience, right? Yeah. So, which can sometimes be abnormal illness behaviour or in the
old speak somatoform disorder. Yes. Yes. The understanding of unexplained symptoms dates back to ancient history, right? Like the, you know, uh, Greek, uh, people called it the wandering womb. The hysteria. Yeah. Yeah. They did. For women. For women they said women in pain. We could get into this. I think we have to do another episode ship about women in pain. I can tell you wandering, what do they call wandering room? Hysteria. You know, the unexplained behaviours of including pain. Hysterical, there's a word for it. Uh, so that, that took, uh, I guess it stayed in that way for years.
Um. Until French, Dr. Quet, he tried to reason it out, saying there are a group of people who have unexplained symptoms early 19th century. Then, um, that was the case in 20th century. Freud then brings up the con concept of conversion. Yeah. That is, oh, you can have emotional distress, which can manifest as physical. Right. The mind and the body are so connected. They're connected. They're not, this is not necessarily hysteria or in a
classic sense, unexplainable. There's some sort of explanation and then come to DSM three, DSM four, DSM five, seventies and eighties, and later on, uh, the current version we have using the term somatoform. Yeah, okay. Somato of the body. Of the body. Somatoform, yeah. Soma meaning body. So it is a bodily manifestation of psychological distress. That's the, that's the, that's the explanation. The thing we have stepped away from, from, say, from DSM four and DSM three, there was, um, a concept of medically unexplainable.
Right. Right. Now in the Somatoform context, we think of even if there is a medical explanation for the pain, if it is disproportionate and if it's beyond what is expected and disabling the person's has associated anxiety, it still can be somatoform disorder on top of actually a genuine, some sort of a injury pathology or, or, so the disproportionate of that response is still under. So we've, we've kind of stepped away from that.
It doesn't have to be no medical problems. Yeah. You can still have a somatoform aspect. Um, on top of that, and to what extent does work serve such an important social function and provide purpose? To what extent does, do you see people in both your practises that are away from work for a variety of reasons, usually from a spinal injury or from a secondary psychological, does that really impact the ability to not work? Does that really adversely impact? Does that make you more prone to spiral?
Yeah, absolutely. Absolutely. Work is such a strong feedback to who you are. Yeah. Okay. Identification. Identification and what your purpose and meaning. It's an automatic purpose. You don't have to think about it. You have a schedule, you have a automatic sort of a set schedule. You, you know the meaning of the day. You want to get this eight hours of the day done, and then there's rest of life. Right. Once that changes, you're throwing the circadian rhythm outta whack. Yeah. When they sleep, when they, how much exhaustion they have through the day. Yeah. Through the normal workday.
So that throws up the sleep patterns. Then there's pain medication involved, right. That changes the cognitions that can D down can bring on some dysphoria. You can have withdrawals from strong pain medications, even if they're prescribed. You can have minor withdrawals for a few hours that can mess up your mood. And then the, not for everyone, but particularly some group of people strongly identify with the sense of being the provider. Yeah, yeah. In the, in the household or in the family context. They strongly rooted to that.
That could be cultural, that could be their own background, what they've seen their parents do. And it's very much becomes a very much strong unconscious part. And that loss of that capacity feeds into that. Then, I mean, Simon could speak about the deconditioning aspects, it itself not working and what happens to your Yeah, I think all of this is incredibly, uh, insightful and very important. I think what we see and, and we can obviously just almost do a case study on the rest of our practises. So if you see people in private practise who have.
Just had a degenerative problem and have a disc prolapse, for instance, the communist thing that we see who get to see you soon. Get the information early. Yeah. No delays, get the appropriate investigations. Don't have this psychological spiralling Yeah. Their outcome is better. Yeah. That's been tried and tested for years. Yeah. In the medical legal space as either as an independent medical examiner where you're seeing people maybe 6, 12, 18 months down the line. Yeah. Where you're seeing all these problems that have been stored up, or even when you're seeing a work cover patient at three to six months, by the time they've
got to there, all of the psychological time bombers started ticking. Yeah. The misinformations there psychologically they're, as you say, they're not a provider for the family anymore. They've got money worries, they've got anxiety. They've lost that sense of self. Yeah. Because that's their, their importance in their family or cultural group, whatever. And so you can almost, you can almost pick these people and you know that the medical-legal ones at 18 months as an IME Yeah. Have significant problems and probably the symptoms or the issue that they
had at the start has gone away. Yeah. Yeah. That's probably, that's probably well healed up. The soft tissue injury or the bulging disco one. All these things that's just gone away. However, all of this catastrophization, all of this heightened anxiety is to such a level now that these people are disabled. Yeah, yeah. Physically disabled because of the psychological issue of having a claim too, of a, a delayed claim. And we know that ongoing claim is a massive factor. It it is indeed. Isn't for them not getting over these things. Yeah.
That claim experience invalidating that in that, that that drive that. Yeah. I am actually experiencing these, I'm in distress. Yeah. Yeah. Which may be psychological more than physical. Yeah. Yes. But the language in the head for the person is that I'm in distress. It is from the injury. Yeah. They're unable to tease out that there is and people need to, believe me, believe me. That invalidating part of it then pushes, and then there's this litigation attached to it. Then that drives them to have a narration of how bad they are
actually, how the language as well of what they then complain of. And then they're repeatedly saying the same thing. It's, it's almost like I have to be consistent. I am actually suffering, therefore I'm having these symptoms. And that builds on and there's the litigation pressures of, you know, and you wonder how that that identity then moves from. Them being the worker in the workplace providing to the injured worker. Injured worker. Yeah, that's right. A badly injured worker. The bad injured worker. Yeah. Yeah. Who's not gonna get over it? Who is just in the middle of this process.
Yeah. That it's when you're like a kid and you, you know, you injure your arm or something and because you have no context of things just getting better, you think this is gonna last forever, don't you? Yeah. You know, or you sprain your ankle as a child. Oh my goodness. That's it. Yeah. I'm never gonna be able to play footy again. Yeah. These are, I think these injured workers fall into this like deep, dark hole of depression or anxiety, whatever they are, because they don't know where the end is. Yeah. No, they, they've not had the information to say, this is a normal response. You will get better in a couple of months. Your scans are fine, we can deal with the anxiety and we can
bring you down off the ceiling. They're just in this hole of IME followed by IME, followed by all of these specialists. So, and talking about it, reliving it Yeah. And stuff as well. And what could we do better? Do they do adjustment to injury counselling in sa Do they, is that part of the scheme? Is there stuff we can do early, we can do to help them? Can early is exactly the, the key. I reckon it's the early, like Yeah, yeah. So early access to a sensible opinion. Yeah. Yeah. And appropriate investigations. Investigations, yeah. Lack of inappropriate, you know, bombarding scatter gun investigations.
And really people have gotta use the right language here. So you mentioned it before. Yeah. If you start telling someone they have degenerative disc disease, suddenly you've got a disease. No, you've not, you've got normal wear and tear that we all have. Yeah. You, you call it a language that promotes agency in a sense, or promotes, and you, you've, you know, you get a, you get a, a scan report. Oh, it's severe on this scan report, but it's just moderate on this scan report. But people don't understand A scan is like anything else. It's a perception. It's, I see. I go to an art gallery and I see a painting differently
from you and you Yeah. It's about, that's all it is. Perception. It's a radiologist in a dark room looking at a picture saying what they think. It's not scientific really. Yeah, it's not emotional. Yeah. But the patient takes it very emotional. So I am severe, I have disease, therefore I am injured, therefore I am validated. Yeah. Yeah. Whereas opposed to actually, you know what? That's pretty normal. We, we all have that, so don't worry about it. So to explore Vanessa's point, um, earlier intervention, the right opinion, the targeted investigations, getting someone across your desk sooner rather than later.
What about from a psychological perspective? Yeah, I think, I think people dealing with case managers or whoever's seeing early gps, et cetera, they need to be a little bit more perceptive about the person's psychological profile. Yeah, I agree. If they're vulnerable, individuals look vulnerable. The social situation's already vulnerable, they've been already struggling. Maybe they have preexisting conditions, maybe they don't, sometimes you don't have to have a psychiatric illness. You can tell someone's in a vulnerable social space and their jobs in jeopardy. Jobs in jeopardy, yeah. Those all the other things, and it's probably cumulative injury
of some form, but it's not looking good or whatever that might be. It's that ability to tease that out early on and say there needs some clear language, which is, doesn't catastrophize because the whole thing about pain is that pain avoidance, fear avoidance cycle. You know, we don't want to set off fear. No, no. If you can't or threat the, if you can't smoothen that out, don't bring fear into the equation. Yeah. If you can do that early on, you know.
Right. Advise. Uh. Right. Professionals even in, you know, they're eligible for psychology sessions, so, so four four, they get four sessions irrespective of the status of the claim. Help them. Yeah. Yeah. Um, finding that right information. Once the fear sets in, then the avoidance will set in. Yes. Then the hypervigilance sets in and then they just need to get that. One bit of bad information and then the illness model develops and then the psychological stuff comes in and then that's a trap. It doesn't take long. So it's early intervention.
Right. Information, right language. Avoid that fear from evolving into the situation. That's the key. Yeah. And try to try to step in early before that becomes the story that people are telling, telling themselves. So to go back to your medicolegal experience, then, Dr. Simon, I'll use that again. 'cause you liked it. Um, uh, the, I'm not sure it did. Please. You, you, you talk a lot about, um, or your ask opinion a lot about the causation aspect. Yeah. It's so critical and because we've all gone underlying degenerative conditions.
Um, so, so you use to, to provide that opinion. You look at, for example, the mechanism of injury, what the scans will tell you what the patient tells you, and knowing it's imprecise, but you do your best to provide an honest opinion addressing those types of aspects. I do. I I just have to do it. Um, you know, in the standards balance of probabilities, legal tests, don't I? Yeah, yeah. This is, this is civil law. So that's the, that's where I fall. Um, and I have to just give my, my honest appraisal and honest opinion of, of where the claimant client patient is at that particular point.
I think the, it's interesting the independent me medical examiner kind of place, uh, in, in the world here because coming from a different space in the UK where there isn't a work cover scheme. Yeah. So my work was predominantly, um, high value medical negligence work. Yeah. And in fact, the causation arguments there are very, very different. Yeah. They, because it's very, it's, it's not easier. It's difficult sometimes, but at least there's a chronology of something
might have gone wrong, something was missed, all that sort of thing. Yeah. And so there's usually a sentinel event or two, uh, that will lead it down this path to causation. Whereas the medical-legal space here with injured workers is very, very difficult because of all this, uh, physical, psychological package that we have to deal with and a claims process that can Yeah. Yeah. But the, the claims process, I, I mean, I, I feel for the, for the patients, because I think by the time they get to see experts like us in our medical legal world.
All of this stuff is entrenched. Mm-hmm. The, the, the, the illness model is, is well and truly stamped. They've bought the illness model and is there Yeah. The physical side of things, even if there is still an ongoing physical side of things, no matter what I do, it's probably not gonna work now. Yeah. Until all of the psychological stuff has been, uh, has been dealt with. Yeah. And I, and I think we see a lot of that with work injuries. When the claim has gone on two and three years and they've seen multiple experts, um, oh, I'll, I'll see a shoulder surgeon and a knee surgeon and an ankle surgeon
and a left hand surgeon and a right hand surgeon and a spine and a brain. And by the time they've gone through all of this process and said the same thing 400 times, they're, they're believing everything they say. Exactly. And I should say, as a mediator, I believe you too, because I have to read all the reports. So, and there's lots of them from all different specialties. That's quite common in protracted claims. You, you're quite right about that. Uh, 'cause people are constantly then in the illness model looking for an answer, aren't they? So, and their lawyers are doing their best to go, well where is this? And so you often find there's multiple experts that have, that have looked
at and it's not helpful in the majority of cases because your primary diagnosis probably was never there. However, you've got a huge psychological component now, which overrides everything. Yeah, yeah, yeah. It's the biggest one now. And, and sending someone for a shoulder reconstruction or they're gonna tinker away this and this. It's just not the right way to do it. The deescalating, the psychological harm, the catastrophization, all of that stuff is the, has to be the primary mechanism of treating these people. And then you can start picking out what's the problem and what the primary driver was.
You, you can't start, you know, operating here, there, and everywhere in a person who clearly needs a psychiatrist. Yeah. And expecting, expecting this all to go away. Yeah. Expecting all of this, all of this baggage just to disappear into the ether, because it's not going to, it's too entrenched. And even in your world of psychological injury, secondary psych, you might have p you might have, for example, adjustment disorder that stems or another diagnosis. You've also gotta disentangle causation too, in terms of, but it's more difficult too in terms of people's vulnerabilities potentially driven from
adverse childhood experiences or other, um, other sort of background issues. How do you disentangle? Yeah. Yeah. That, that's quite complex. It's very complex work. It's very complex work usually, you know, um, it involves first of, I guess to, to very clearly make sure there is nothing diagnostically which has been missed. Yeah. And sometimes if, if there's a, you know, serious injury car crash and the sort of things PTSD sometimes can be missed, um, may have been missed, I make sure
that part is sort of looked after first. Uh, I make sure that there's no serious diagnosis missed. Consequently, sometimes from the injury over a period of time through the litigation process or, or waiting for things to happen, they can have major depressive disorder. Mm. Yeah. Um, or treatable, uh, conditions which have evolved during the process of the claim. So one thing is to make sure what I'm seeing today, when the patient present, when the claimant presence to me is not because they're sick.
From an actual condition, which is impairing how they're presenting. So that'll be my first bit to rule out, make sure that's sort of apportioned. Am I seeing a person with PTS who's not been picked up before? Yeah. You know, or depression. So that, that's one bit. I, I look at, um, the substance abuse that can be in the closet, sometimes missed easily, you know, you know, can be easily missed, easily missed. So I may spend some time understanding there's such a, once you have substances in the mix, it influences everything.
You know, sleep, recovery, mood, motivation, and interaction with medications, pain medications that can be prescribed. Medications, overuse or alcohol or other substances. We look into that, make sure that is not playing a part in it. And then I tend to, um, beyond that look at any other medication side effects, which may be influencing their mood and stuff so forth. And then the backstory is so crucial, you know, how did they come to this point?
What was going on preceding, what were the stresses and strains in their life and why did this snap from this apparently minuscule? For example, if it is a minuscule injury, why did this snap so badly? Did they have injuries before and how did they recover from it? It tells you so much if they have previous injuries. Yeah. Uh, childhood, youth, other, other, and how did they recover? What's the difference? And then, um, lots of times when we have such a detailed chat, I mean, I could be having a 90 minute interview, it's probably, uh, one of
the longest interviews they might have had with a specialist, for example. And then slowly stuff comes up for the first, I have heard stories of trauma. Things which then get unravelled and, and, and things come up. And it becomes then apparent that some of the background stuff's kind of feeding into that, the sense of helplessness, which they may have experienced before at various points in say, bad relationships or Yeah. Yeah. Parental abuse. That sense of helplessness has kicked back after long, long time after being
dormant, dormant for 20, 30 years. They were highly functional, motivated, had a sense of purpose being a provider or doing things. And then that helplessness, I used to work, um, one of the public hospital rehab units and sometimes spinal injuries or, or serious leg injuries, patients have to be immobile really for four weeks to months. Right. And it's very fascinating for me to see that all the ancient traumas and stresses and un 'cause they're sitting in the bed.
Yeah. I mean now in modern day hospitals, we have television. It's a bit of distraction. But how much television can you watch? Not much. Eventually then they, they, they, we used to get referrals saying, yeah, this patient, patient's remembering this, they're dreaming about this stuff. They're not sleeping. And then yeah. The demons so speak, they come, come surface because the first time in life they're immobile. Yeah, yeah, yeah. And trapped in that. That's all. Yeah. Role. That makes sense. Isn't isn't it fascinating though that, uh, I was reading this book the other day and, and it's all about the, the natural way that the brain works.
So the brain's natural state is chaos and entropy. And so therefore we're using all these other distractions. And you might, you may or might not believe this as a psychiatrist, but I thought it quite fascinating. We're using all these other distractions and the all things are life purpose, work, exercise, all of the things we do to stop the mind getting back to this chaos. Because as soon as we remove it and you're lying in a hospital bed with a broken leg or a broken spine and know things, your mind starts doing these things and replaying all the childhood drama traumas and all that sort of thing.
And I think that's what we see in this medical-legal space of injured workers because their identity's gone. Everything is gone. And the mind just feeds into all of this paranoia and this entropy and chaos. Yeah. And actually what we need is we need purpose to stop the chaos. Yeah. Which is why we go out and work, or you go out and exercise or exercise and do all of these things and, and you need to do things that keep us busy. Yeah. Yeah. And do you think that, um, once claims close, people do recover? Does it help once the claim's over or look if they return?
Um, uh, just so that's another thing we don't really talk about. I don't, well, we don't, I don't know. But you, because can say it. Yeah. Yeah. And I give my opinion and I sense, I hope they do. Yeah. And actually right here, I'll sometimes pick up things that have been missed by other specialists just because that's life and it happens both ways. So that is a good sense. Check having an IME to do that. I don't think so, because I think by the time they've gone through this process as good as the, and well-meaning that the process is, when it's designed, it takes too long. Yeah. The horse has bolted, so to speak.
It's too hard to get back. Sadly. We've, we've run outta time almost Vanessa. Um, that was an amazing conversation. I really appreciate your time and expertise. What some of my key takeaways are, obviously about very individual factors that drive recovery here. Yeah. Um, and we, I hope we, we explored and canvas some of that and, and the interplay between Simon's world of the spine and your world of the mine and that w we were hoping to draw out. So thank you for your honesty and expertise. Thank you for giving your morning up to be with us and hopefully there's
some key takeaways for case managers. Absolutely. You can find in terms of their medicolegal work. You can find both Dr. Simon and Dr. Shiva through, um, M-L-C-O-A. And I'd like to thank M-L-C-O-A for their collaboration. This is the law medicine and everything in between series. Uh, thank you Dr. Simon Clark and Dr uh, Shiva gpu. Thank you very much. Thank you. All the best. Yeah. Thank you very much. Thank you.
Ageing at work is one of those topics everyone has an opinion on, but very few people have a clear framework for. Recorded live at the Self-Insurers of South Australia conference in Adelaide, this episode of The...
Chronic pain claims can be some of the most contested and misunderstood matters in personal injury and medico legal work, especially when the pain does not match a neat scan or diagnosis. In this episode of The...
Career reinvention is rarely neat, and it often starts with a quiet question you cannot unhear. In this episode, I’m joined by Joanna Wong, host of the podcast Chasing Waves, to talk about career transitions, leadership...
Mindful leadership is not a wellness trend, it is an attention skill, and in this episode I sit down with Susan Pearse to talk about what that really means in modern work and life. Susan and I have known each other for...
Vicarious trauma is one of the most overlooked psychosocial hazards at work, especially in high exposure roles like law, insurance, health, and frontline services. In this episode of The Resolution Room, I’m joined by...