Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

The Resolution Room

The Resolution Room artwork

The Data Behind Your Workplace Culture with David Talbot of Talbot Mills Research

Mar 24, 202621 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

I sat down with researcher and political pollster David Talbot (Talbot Mills/The Enactor Group) to discuss his background in politics and polling, including his work with Jacinda Ardern during COVID. We also unpacked his workplace culture survey and what it means for generational engagement and leadership. David explained the methodology: around 1,000 Australians were surveyed using a weighted, census-matched representative sample. We discussed how pay and job security remain the top drivers when choosing a job across all age groups, including those aged 18-29 (pay 56%, security 51%), pushing back on myths that workplace perks attract Gen Z. We explored what respondents define as a ‘good workplace culture’ - a non-toxic environment (19%), mutual respect (17%), and teamwork (15%) - and why most people are positive about their current workplaces despite nearly half dreading work and concerns about office politics. We also covered how under-30s prioritise career development and mobility, as well as the sharp AI anxiety among younger workers, with 62% expecting their job could be replaced within five years, with implications for morale, retention, and policy.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

David Talbot, welcome to the Resolution Room. Thank you very much. I wanna talk to you about your recent research and what that tells you around culture, generational engagement, et cetera. But let's talk first about your backstory. You've been in the research game, your part of Talbot Mills, the Enactor Group. Uh, you've been around politics, the back rooms. Dark arts, you've worked for, uh, Jacinda Hearn in a previous life and you're very familiar with both the Australian and New Zealand and international landscape.

Is that a fair summary? David? Have I missed anything? No, that's good. The gag I usually tell is that I, um, come from a kind of a, a medical background, a medical family, but really, uh, didn't like blood at all. Um, switched to cycling. Um, really decided I didn't like blood and cycling at all as well, and so I found myself almost accidentally in politics. And you were worked for Jacinda Hearn, what role did you have with her? So I worked for sort of a series of unsuccessful, um, labour leaders prior to her arrival on the scene.

Um, I was already running the polling company at the time that she became the Prime Minister, but through that COVID period, um, sort of worked far more closely with her and her staffers than had been the case previously. What drew you to research in particular, Dave? Why that? I think I've always been resonated with how people see the world and yeah, the opportunity to kind of connect that to the sort of political things that I was interesting in was always massively appealing. So I come from a sort of a communications and campaigning background and when I

got the call one day from my, um, former business partner to kind of join the, the polling company, I jumped at the chance. That's fantastic. So now you're part of. A bespoke research business and the enact group. And I've got in front of me a workplace culture survey report. So let's drill down on that. But before we do talk about the general methodology of the research you undertook. So what we often do when we are surveying is we look for a representative sample of Australians.

And so what that means, you know, there's kind of good surveys and there's poor surveys. They're often determined by the robustness of the methodology that's employed to collect the information. Um, in this case, we surveyed around a thousand Australians. Um, but what we do is we try very hard to make sure that, that it's a representative group. It's not like a kind of an online survey. You might see the results of where people have logged into a news website and voted yes or no to whether they like somebody. It's a far more robust and scientific process. So the thousand people are a representative, um, weighted sample of

the Australian public that match the demographics, um, of the census in terms of gender and location and age, and a, um, a number of other kind of features. So we can have very high confidence, um, in the kind of reliability of the figures that we present. Well, that's really interesting because when I looked at it and we discussed it, there were some surprises and I want to go through that. The purpose of this conversation is to sort of drill down on what the numbers tell us from a generational perspective and how that feeds into

leadership and leadership strategies. Let's start with the first page. One of the thing I thought was really interesting was the question, how important are the following to get right when deciding on a new job? Pay and job security. The old chestnuts are really quite high, particularly in the modern cultural speak where people talk about other cultural attributes. But the core issue still of pay and security still loom really large. That's absolutely right.

I mean, those dominated across all the age groups. And I think you, like me, have probably heard that sort of myth that, you know, the way to attract Gen Z is a few beanbags and a foosball table. Um, this kind of survey, the results we've got here, I think really dispel that myth as the way to appeal to kind of younger members of a workplace. Yeah, I thought it was all about kombucha and stilled water. Uh. M and m machines, but apparently not. That's right.

I was in an office of a tech company a week or so ago, elsewhere in the world. They had a Muley of the week, uh, which I thought was, you know, um, you know, fantastic, I guess if you like muley, but perhaps peripheral to the kind of core things that people are telling us they really care about and want prioritised. Yeah, and it really drilled down. The next slide really summed it up as well, because in the age group, 18 to 29, which is, you know, that generation. You know, my, my son who's starting out in law is in that category, 56%.

Rated pay, 51% rated job security in terms of what were the factors to get Right. So again, that's really age specific and really interesting. It is, and I, I think values and culture sort of are part of the mix for people across the age groups. They are something that, that matters to younger respondents as well, but they're just not a substitute for the basics. So I think that, you know, in terms of sort of what businesses and business leaders need to hear is that, you know, it is kind of about balance.

Um, it is about appreciating the need for kind of culture, it's supportive work environment, you know, clear lines of accountability, all those kind of things. But you can't actually think that those are a substitute for the security, um, the advancement opportunities and the base pay. I thought that was fascinating, particularly because of that myth that we spoke about. Let's talk a bit about what makes a good workplace culture, but before I do, I know you have a broader political landscape. Do you think that those numbers are a feature of the cost of living

crisis, if I could call it that? Perhaps that's a bit too much Hyper Bowl, the crisis, but the cost of living issues that we see, pay and security, so front and centre. We've done surveys like this elsewhere in the world. Previously, even prior to COVID, and the results are actually quite consistent between what we're seeing now and the ones we've seen previously, even though the geographical markets weren't quite the same. Um, so I think that it's quite likely that, as you say, those features

could be somewhat heightened. In the current climate. Um, but I think that fundamentally what young people starting out are telling us is that, you know, the pay, the security and the advancement opportunities, you know, are the things that are of primary importance. You know, almost irrespective of kind of when you measure them. And as I said before, that's not to say that those other things aren't important, but just that they're not a substitute. Yeah. It really goes to the point that the next generation or this generation, the younger people aren't that different perhaps than my own or yours.

Quite possibly. Quite possibly. And I think there is often a temptation to think that, you know, people who are coming through the next generation are entirely different. You know, we see a lot of it in politics. People talk about the crisis of the youth vote that young people aren't voting. But, you know, a lot of research seems to show, um, that, you know, young people tend not to vote at the start of their lives when they're a bit less connected to communities and, you know, some of the decisions that government are making. But that, that engagement, you know, often rises over time as you get a mortgage, get a job, and get other responsibilities and a focus.

So I think it is quite easy to say that, you know, young people are sort of vastly different. Um, but you know. Perhaps it's about a bit about life stage. Perhaps it's about some fundamental things that, you know, make us human beings. Yeah. The next slide was also important. What is the most important when it comes to having a good workplace culture? And what I thought was interesting was that there wasn't a standout. In this slide, if you look at sort of a non-toxic environment, 19% mutual respect, 17% teamwork and relationships with an ex at 15%, a number of other

factors, but pay conditions and balance in that sense was only 6%. What did you make of that in terms of your analysis of what makes a good workplace culture? This is an interesting example of how asking the question can. In a different way can really determine the kind of focus that a respondent brings to the response they give. And so we often do a combination of things. In a survey, we ask a prompted list of features, and we ask people to rank the importance of those.

And then we might ask an open-ended question that, uh, that tries to give a bit more colour. To some of the answers or some of the nuances of the topic. And I think what, what's happening here is that when we're asking specifically about what makes good workplace culture, even using the word culture probably pulls people into a slightly different frame than if we were talking about, you know, kind of career advancement opportunities and money. And so what bubbles up to the top is this kind of collection of ideas that we would see as.

All contributions to the culture of a workplace, and you see that then distributed amongst those answers that you've read out. I didn't think any of those attributes were startling, really things that we know about that makes a good workplace culture. You know, respect communication concepts around psychological safety, et cetera. Yeah, like, I think that's right, but I think for people who are in charge of workplaces who are running workplaces, making sure that there's a, a list that includes all of those things so that none are being neglected and the knowledge

that, you know, different things might be important to different people. And so what you'd be trying to do is to look through that list that you've got there in front of you and make sure that you are ticking the box off, essentially. Um, are people getting the support they need? You know, are there clear lines of accountability? Um, do people feel like, um, their contribution is valued? And if any of those things start to slip off the radar, I think that's the time when you'd have a, you know, potential problem on your hands. Absolutely. The next thing, which I thought was comforting in a way, was that most

people are reasonably positive about their current workplace cultures, despite the hyperbolic end perhaps. That's right. Like I think we saw about three quarters, I think it was, um, of respondents were positive about their current workplace culture. I guess the sort of watch out is that, you know, the outliers were some people working in sales roles where it was a bit lower, it was closer to half. So, you know, potentially some of those kind of pressures and the kind of fast moving nature of that environment, um, is having an impact on that figure. But like a really strong. Figure that I think, you know, kind of businesses around the

country can be quite proud of. Um, but as you say, like, uh, room for improvement on some metrics, um, I think we had just over half 56% saying that was often a bit too much office politics, you know, and we had almost half saying, I, I frequently dread going to work. So, you know, people are happy with office culture, but there are some things beneath the surface that are probably worth keeping an eye on. Absolutely. Not much differentiation on age too, when you looked at that metric. No, and I think that's one of the kind of interesting things throughout the

survey was that some of those things that I probably expected to see around big differences on some of the factors based on sort of life stage or age just just weren't evident in the results. And the next question I guess for you is, what do men like hanging out with colleagues? More than women. What's that about? Quite, quite a strange one there. Yeah. That's where we'd sort of, um, you know, we'd always recommend pairing, um, qualitative research with the quantitative research and what you often see in quant is sort of interesting or surprising.

Things pop up, you know, it'd be great to get a group of men around a table and talk to them about the differences in their kind of working environments than some of the women and see if there was a, a kind of something real going on there. Uh, be fascinating. That was really interesting. I thought that was fascinating. When you look at workplace agreement by age, the question was posed, how strongly do you agree or disagree with the following about your workplace? And interestingly, again, looking at the age differentiation, when

you looked at factors like, I feel supported by my colleagues, that was pretty, uh, non-specific or in terms of age that was fairly, uh, generic. What did you think of those factors? Was there anything there that jumped out at you in terms of a generational analysis? I thought the stuff, um, it might be on the next page, um, that really kind of stood out. In terms of the, the generations for the under thirties that they seem to approach, kind of work with that more sort of mobility, first mindset, and

I guess that is probably just, you know, about career stage as much as it is about age, but they ranked career development opportunities quite a bit higher in terms of importance and they were also much more open to changing jobs and more actively scanning the market. Than other age bands were. And so I guess the watch out there for employers is that, um, we all need to be doing more probably to nurture and retain talent at a time when they're a bit less

connected to their current workplace, probably, and always on the lookout. For new opportunities, um, you know, is what they seem to be telling us in this, in this survey. I agree. And I thought as a former leader in professional services is that with younger people, the importance of career development and having those conversations early and mapping out a pathway, and I don't think we're doing that nearly well enough. I think there's the old.

Analysis that the rule book traditionally applies and people will float to the, the top and, and they don't need, they'll learn by osmosis and, but really what we're seeing here is. The younger generation want a sense of a career path and development and that notion of progression? I think so. And the kind of like more active support to kind of make it happen? Um, you know, not just because of the results of the survey, but. Um, I've brought into our business a former colleague whose specific job now

will be sort of pastoral care and career development with some of the younger staff that we've brought on board because they were kind of telling us in a variety of ways and not through the survey, um, but, you know, um, conversations really that they were interested in sort of other opportunities in the business and ways to get involved in a wider range of things. So we're trying to more actively kind of manage that process than we have in the past. I think that's a great learning. And in my former role, I was reminded of the fact that we often had a blind

spot, which is we thought that careers were developed like OO had developed. But I think that craving for variety, uh, for other opportunities, change in progression, um, is, is really quite important. I think so. And you know, the other thing, um, you know, that really stood out in this survey was that there seems to be disquiet building around the impacts of AI in the workforce. You know, and that was, that came through much more strongly from the younger respondents in the survey than the older ones.

And that's going to be another force that kind of speaks to exactly what you. Let's talk about ai. I dunno if you saw yesterday, Thomson Reuters share price. A legal tech provider tanked a bit. I think it's anthropic and a big AI business spawned out of open AI is coming into this space. What I thought from another survey you sent was, there was probably not as much pessimism around AI as I perhaps expected. Is that a fair summary? I think so. I think, you know, people are broadly, and I'm sort of talking in generalisations and

then I can unpack it a bit in detail, but broadly, kind of, they do see benefits and a lot of people who are using AI in their personal lives and in their workplaces. Are seeing efficiencies and seeing kind of personal benefits that they find it quite easy to point to. So, you know, people, if you talk to them in a focus group, might talk about, you know, um. Help with proofreading or writing email or, you know, dealing with first draughts of reports or in their personal life it might be, you know, counselling, it might be somebody to talk to. Yeah.

Recipes or travel advice. So no shortage of those kinds of things. But on the other side, they're also worried about sort of some existential stuff. You know, if it, you know, if, if AI would've become sentient, you know, would it wipe us out? We often see sort of well above 50% of people saying that's a serious concern to them. You know, a bunch of AI experts that I talk to sometimes tell me that that's not the most sort of proximate threat, but, you know, um, it's clearly on people's minds. They also worry about missing and disinformation and some of the ways that AI might be used, you know, in kind of, um, those kind of scenarios.

Another segment who are worried about their own jobs. So no shortage of positives, no shortage of negatives, and people kind of often in two minds about where they land from the perspective of professional services. I'm seeing, for example, pull back on the clerkship, junior talent pool. We saw Baker Mackenzie yesterday make job cuts. Do you think that that's affecting a sense of morale and the future amongst the young people, and how do we keep them engaged and develop the professional skills?

That they need in an AI en environment. I, I think that's a absolutely key challenge. I, I don't have an easy answer, but you are absolutely right to identify that as a concern. You know, I, I mentioned the sort of disquiet that was building in that generation around the effects of ai and these are people, you know, a lot of young people would, would be the first to put up their hand and say, you know, it's a fantastic tool and it drives efficiencies and I can see how it would be great for both me and the economy. But when we asked in the survey, well over half, 62% of those under

30 agreed with the statement, my job will likely be replaced by tech or AI in the next five years. So you've got six in 10, you've got over six in 10 young people saying that they expect their job to disappear in the next five years. And so again, you'd want to investigate that qualitatively, but it will impact morale, it will impact planning. It will impact commitment. You know, it will have massive effects. And also the broader political landscape because those people more likely to feel locked out of the housing market as well.

And then the idea that a regular job won't lead to a house. But even the regular job, if I can call it, that, might be under threat and that sort of sense. I think that, you know, the real worry is we, we talked to a segment of, you know, predominantly young men in some focus groups a little while ago who were, a lot of them were sort of quite active in the tech sector as coders and programmers. You know, they were already seeing really significant disruption. Um, in their kind of sector, um, they felt like they'd done the right thing.

They've been told, you know, 10 years ago that, you know, if you could learn to code, that would be the future. That was going to be the place that innovation was being driven from. They were excited about it. They've now got student loans. They've kind of like invested heavily in this career and they can see it kind of, um, disappearing around them. So anxiety levels are high, they're feeling insecure. You know, they might have to retrain, there'll be, you know, policy questions there for government about kind of how you manage that as well as the kind of, you know, the kind of potential fractures that occur when people feel

like they've followed the rules but are now being an inverted comm penalised. Um, huge challenges. Absolutely. David. I've gotta wrap it up, but I really appreciate your time and expertise and I hope in due course when this pod is released, we'll talk further about those numbers and what they tell us and perhaps give some headlines for people to draw on. Absolutely. Love to. Real pleasure to talk to you. Thanks David. All the best. See you.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Beyond the Spinal Injury: Mental Health and the Claim

    Nov 17, 202635 minAudio

    What determines recovery after a spinal injury? The answer can be more complex than a scan suggests. I’m joined by neurosurgeon Dr Simon Clark and psychiatrist Dr Shiva Gunapu as part of our collaboration with MLCOA’s...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Normal Ageing or Something More? Medicolegal Panel on Fitness for Work & Legal Obligations

    Nov 3, 202652 minAudio

    Ageing at work is one of those topics everyone has an opinion on, but very few people have a clear framework for. Recorded live at the Self-Insurers of South Australia conference in Adelaide, this episode of The...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Chronic Pain in the Medicolegal Arena: The Medicine of Last Resort with Pain Specialist Dr Joseph Kluver

    Oct 20, 202639 minAudio

    Chronic pain claims can be some of the most contested and misunderstood matters in personal injury and medico legal work, especially when the pain does not match a neat scan or diagnosis. In this episode of The...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Meta-morphosis: Career Reinvention, Leadership Lessons & the Power of Quitting with Joanna Wong

    Oct 6, 202643 minAudio

    Career reinvention is rarely neat, and it often starts with a quiet question you cannot unhear. In this episode, I’m joined by Joanna Wong, host of the podcast Chasing Waves, to talk about career transitions, leadership...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Neuroscience, AI & Attention Management: Susan Pearse on Rewiring Leadership

    Sep 22, 202633 minAudio

    Mindful leadership is not a wellness trend, it is an attention skill, and in this episode I sit down with Susan Pearse to talk about what that really means in modern work and life. Susan and I have known each other for...

    Credit the people on this episode