Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Welcome to the Resolution Room. I'm joined with two guests today, Dr. Tim McDonald. Welcome. Thank you. And Vanessa Daniel from M-L-C-O-A. Thank you. Listen, I wanna announce, first of all a collaboration between the Resolution room and M-L-C-O-A. So this is a collaboration called Law Medicine and everything in between. And what we're gonna talk about today with Dr. Tim, a psychiatrist is ADHD. It's very much hit the zeitgeist, I mean a, b, C style thunder last night on four corners with an expose on ADHD.
But of course, what could Dr. Norman Swan and the broadcaster tell us that you won't, and the resolution room won't be able to tell us quite, quite a lot, quite so potentially if it's the right one, potentially. That's right. So that's really what we're gonna talk about today with, with you, uh, Dr. Tim, but, and Vanessa as well. And then we're gonna talk about what people really want to know as well, which is practical insights. How is this managed at a workplace level, some of the takeaways that we can leave people. And for that episode, we're joined by Andrew Rich, who's our partner at gadens, is a workplace lawyer. And I'll introduce Andrew in due course as well.
So this is a great collaboration. I've worked with M-L-C-O-A for many years, and M-L-C-O-A is the largest provider of medicolegal services in Australia. It's got over 400 specialists and it bridges the gap between clinical expertise and of course, what lawyers need at the coalface in terms of evidence and, and practical solutions. So, by way of introduction, let me see if I get this right, you're both over ridiculously overqualified. Okay. But let me see if I get this right. Dr. Tim, you're a psychiatrist, you're a fellow of the Australian College. You've got three subspecialties, adult
psychiatry, addiction and consultation and liaison. That's right. And you've been most recently a former director of medical services at Bin Clinic. That's right. That's correct. And now you're at Griffith University and you are a, um, medical-legal expert as well in psychiatry. Yeah. Uh, a senior lecturer with, with Griffith. And, uh, just a, a very small scale medical-legal practise, uh, mostly with M-L-C-O-A. Just joined them. Excellent. And Vanessa, tell me about yourself. I'm the National Customer and legal manager for M-L-C-O-A.
So we work mainly with, um, legal referrals that are complex, guiding people from inception to end, providing insight and empathy and everything else along the way. Alright, so this is called law medicine and everything in between. And when we discussed ADHD as a topic, little did we know, of course, that it was gonna be reported on last night. And as we're recording this on the 21st of April, so this won't come out for a while, but it's really interesting that obviously that part of a broader concern around the
rise in adult diagnosis and of course what this means. So today's episode we're gonna drill down, uh, from a clinical perspective, what is ADHD, how's it diagnosed and how's it treated? Before we talk about some of the workplace strategies. So let's first start with, with you Dr. Tim. Um, you're an adult psychiatrist and you've run a, run a in a medical director at Rumba, which is a private clinic. What are you seeing at the coalface in terms of ADHD? I think over the last 10 or 15 years that, uh, the frequency
of self presentation and referral, uh, rates of ADHD have increased dramatically. We, we see it as a combination of, uh, increased mental health literacy in the community and, and knowledge amongst referrers, uh, the rise of perhaps, uh, social media and people self-educating about potential disorders. 10 or 15 years ago when I used to do talks about, you know, psychiatry, it included things like ADHD,
I had to try to convince people that ADHD existed. Mm-hmm. And now it's more about almost doing the opposite at times. Yeah. But perhaps it's overrepresented in the referral and self-diagnostic sense. And that was, I think, something that was explored more broadly by four corners last night. Particularly the rise of the adult diagnosis. Is that a feature of the fact that it was missed in childhood or perhaps a feature of the better literacy as you called it? I wouldn't consider myself an expert in ADHD just to
mention that, first of all, but I don't, I don't believe in the, the term adult ADHD. It's either you've, you've got ADHD or, or you don't as a child. Uh, some people will develop, it's a neurodevelopmental condition as you become an adult. Some of those symptoms may become less prominent. Uh, some may become more prominent under less structured situations. Uh, I don't think that someone just develops
ADHD as an adult. They can certainly be diagnosed as an adult, but it's always existed at some level is what you're saying. It it would've always existed. Yeah. Somehow, or being contained or subdued somehow through. Through circumstance or, or treatment. I see. And what are some of the common symptoms? What, what do people present with commonly when you say ADHD? other diagnoses because it, it's, it's part of a, a plethora of conditions that, that are often, often superimposed on each other.
But ADHD itself is a, it's athetic construct, so it has a range of inattentive, uh, symptoms, a range of impulsive and hyperactive symptoms. And then there is a, a subtype of it, which is mixed, which is most common. Right. And the genders will present differently. Mm-hmm. So if you're a boy, you're going to present with more hyperactive, impulsive symptoms, uh, and probably
be more likely to carry on some of those symptoms more obviously into adulthood. The mixed or the inattentive subtype can sometimes fly under the radar, and especially if you are female, because the boys, if they're hyperactive and bouncing off the walls and throwing things, they're, they're obviously impaired in some way, or they're, they're easily diagnosed, but the others not so much. And so if you've got someone coming across you in a clinical level, is it, is there a diagnostic tool?
Are you're working through the symptom pattern? I mean, how do you diagnose it? Such a good question because it's a symptom cluster. A-A-D-H-D-I mean, we have a rough idea anatomically and physiologically what might be behind it, but not really what causes it. And so it's, if you're looking at a normal distribution, a lot of ADHD diagnoses are people who have certain traits at the, at the end of those spectrum,
right. Of normal. If you have enough of those symptoms and it's impairing enough and you notice it enough, then it can become a diagnosis. It, it is a clinical diagnosis. There's no test, no. That you can do for ADHD. You can't scan a brain, you can't do a specific questionnaire. You can't do a computer test. No, you can't do a neurological test. It's very much about the judgement of the clinician based on the symptom pattern and what people are reporting.
That's right. And that's why you need to know what roughly normal might be for a specific age group. Yeah. So a DH ADHD is more likely to be diagnosed in. Children who are younger in their year levels at school because they're not as old right as the other kids. Whereas the older children in the same year level are less likely to be diagnosed with ADHD. That might be a good time to bring in you, Vanessa, because what Dr. Tim was referring to is obviously the subjective nature, but the important clinical nature of a diag
of a diagnosis for an for a psychiatric condition that is very prevalent. Can you comment more broadly on that in the medicolegal context and psychiatric injuries, we are seeing a rise in these requests for ADHD assessments as well too. And it's interesting after watching Four Corners, how they were sort of saying that questionnaires and all those things don't provide diagnosis and um, they need a, a special assessment, not necessarily an ADHD assessment. Is that what you think, Tim?
What do you think? That's what I think because if with all due respect to the ADHD assessors, uh, sometimes when all you've got to hammer everything looks like a nail. Mm-hmm. And a generalist approach Yeah. To, to diagnosis is usually a better way to start. Yeah. They were touching on that. I haven't had an opportunity to look at that Vanessa, but one of the things that we're talking about is this clusters and where they formed WA incident. Isn't that fascinating? Fremantle? It's a really interesting cluster. I dunno why, but obviously sometimes it coincides with the level of affluence in terms of parents and
others identifying and having access to it. But one of the things they're referring to on that point was the increased use of telehealth assessments, which is potentially problematic in terms of, in terms of the reliability of the diagnosis. If I can refer it to it as that, I believe that's probably a reliability factor. The in-person assessments are generally more thorough. Someone with ADHD might forget to turn up Yeah. To the appointments that telehealth might be better for them though.
Yeah. But I think from my experience, people with ADHD are far more likely to forget to attend a telehealth appointment because it's not at the forefront. Yeah, yeah. Of their planning for the day and where they need to physically be. And of course with the democratisation of medical information in terms of the, you know, tech and ai, people might self identify the beginning with various symptoms, you know, hyper focus or lack of focus or distraction or, so people probably come to it with a thinking, thinking along the lines of, well,
hey, this sort of fits. Do you see some of that as well? Definitely The self diagnosis like that, they, a lot of them have a lot of challenges in their life and they've undergone a lot of transitions more recently, like to a different job or they had another child, or there's been another, another stimuli that's, that's entered their life that's thrown them off a bit. Uh, and that could explain why perhaps that that threshold. Might then become obvious. So if you were to say the symptom, it's gotta be
presented as a pattern of symptoms based on clinical judgement , based on really interrogating the presentation effectively and understanding it, what would you say would be some of the more common symptoms and how that plays out in people's functioning? The common symptoms of say, uh, some, some are hyperactive. Yeah. Impulsive symptoms are the ones that are, you know, obvious and probably more interesting. Yeah. Uh, and people might complete other people's sentences before they've finished. They'll be impatient. Impatient in traffic, uh, trouble waiting in lines.
Uh, they won't be able to sit still during class or read a book, watch, watch a movie. They might not be able to complete, uh, the, a conversation with someone before they're distracted by another topic that's, that's more or another thing that's more interesting. You know, you're more likely to see, hear the story. Oh, they were always off with the, the butterflies weren't paying attention during class. The acute kid that wasn't really doing much 'cause they weren't listening.
Yeah. Yeah. But weren't causing any trouble. And is there a correlation between the diagnosis and say self-medication and addiction? Yes. So with ADHD, there's probably an issue with dopamine in the brain. Yeah. And if we talk about the dopaminergic, hypotonic parts of the brain that are affected there, you need more stimuli ticket to get those parts of the brain working the way we want to have them working. And so something that's interesting or something
that has salience, uh, or something that, that stimulates like a drug or. Something outside the classroom that's, that's more interesting than what the teacher's saying is going to take salience over. Yeah. Something else. Which is why when people, and you've probably come across it in your friendship circles as well, Vanessa. I certainly have, um, they've identified a, I've had been diagnosed with ADHD, and often you'll find they have a superpower in the sense that it's also gives you amazing focus in, in, in, in what you are really into, so to speak.
And so there's often, as well as it being a, a sort of a negative, uh, identification. It can, it can be quite positive in certain aspects. It's about that balance. Have you seen that? Yeah, I have definitely a bit of perfectionism and stuff. Traits. Something that they're fascinated with. That's right. A hobby or just something they're really interested in and pursuing that. And, and also a bit of partying sometimes as well. Yeah, that's right. That's right. We've seen that. We've seen that. I guess that's how they cope and stuff as well. And it's
a good excuse to exercise your superpower. Definitely. Probably. Well, so you've spoken about dopamine and how it plays out, which is what I, so, so in a sense there's an overstimulation, but yet it's treated his, it's treated commonly by a stimulant. Is that the common treatment pathway? So the brain is less, uh, less active in ADHD. And so things that stimulate the brain will bring the brain levels of activity up to where normal might otherwise be. And so if you give, uh, understimulated brain
stimulants, that then will normalise a lot of the function of the brain. If you look at someone with ADHD, you could almost say that they appear overstimulated, but it's not, they're actually trying to seek stimulator from the environment to to, to increase the level of stimulation of the brain. And am I right in saying that that's stimulant and is the common clinical pathway to treat ADHD? It is, um, excluding comorbidities in assessing and managing comorbidities as well is really important
because there may be some there that you wanna treat first before you treat A-D-H-D-A-D-H-D Treatment is not always synonymous with stimulants though either. Some people think it is. Mm-hmm. There are plenty of really good non-stimulant treatments for ADHD. Uh, they may take a little longer to work, but for some people they can be far more effective than stimulants because they may not have the side effects of stimulants that you want to avoid.
In some people on the four corners, effectively they were saying there's an overdiagnosis potentially and, and maybe a seeking out of stimulants. The other things that was explored was, and it's not very scientifically solid yet, but some concern around one of the side effects being potentially even psychosis. And have you seen that play out, Tim? Have you seen Plenty of times? Yeah. More in public psychiatry than private psychiatry. If you look at the types of. Dopamines in the brain.
You can kind of narrow it down to two types. There's the, there's the tonic phase of dopamine, which is the baseline, and then there's, um, more phasic dopamine changes, and they both serve roles. The, the, the tonic dopamine phase is that can be increased and decreased slightly without any problems. That will, will change someone's attention or, or, or salience or concentration levels. If you give someone enough, uh, or if they take
stimulants on top of it or um, cannabinoids and other psychotomimetic substances on top, then you might actually reach a level of stimulation that would cause aphasic dopamine change. Right. And if that phasic dopamine change is severe enough in someone who's predisposed or not predisposed, then you can see psychotic symptoms emerge. That's at the really bad end of the spectrum, if I can say that. What are the other common side effects from stimulant as a form of treatment?
The common side effects are really quite mild and tolerable. So for people who have ADHD, they might find that they, uh, their, their mouth might be a little bit dry or they might not have as much appetite during the day. The first few days they might not sleep quiet as well. Sometimes rarely a, a headache, a stomach ache. They tend to, to reduce overtime. So the people, if they maintain their treatment for ADHD, those, those side effects tend to diminish.
They tend to be toll, become tolerant. Do you think it's too cynical to say that there is, there is a sense of seeking stimulants in terms of this diagnosis? I think we need to bear it in mind all the time. I think we'd be, uh, silly not to, but I think if we only saw it that way, we'd be, you know, just as blinded to the group of children and adults out there that have potentially one of the most treatable conditions known under humankind. Mm-hmm. Uh, you, if someone has ADHD and if you get the diagnosis
right, you can almost always treat it quite well, usually with medications, but there are other non-medication treatments as well that can manage a lot of the symptoms. Let's talk about that. Uh, Dr. Tim non non-pharmaceutical treatment. I'd like to talk about exercise. Yeah. And greenery. Yeah. Uh, not, not, not cannabis. Yeah. Greenery. Greenery. Generally as a, as a treatment. People with ADHD have been camping, hiking, playing sport, going for a run in the morning.
They tend to be a lot more settled for the day or for the days afterwards. There can be a lot of, uh, planning that goes into, uh, managing. Their symptoms in terms of compensatory mechanisms with, with taking notes, having checklists, having alarms, having enough sleep, having a diet that's, that's well, well balanced. There's really good evidence for fish oil. Mm-hmm. Probably level one evidence, but it's only small. Mm-hmm. There are some other non-medication options as
well that have very, very tiny amounts of evidence that are probably not worth mentioning in psychotherapy, uh, for coexisting conditions. If, if, if you've got someone with ADHD who's a perfectionist, who, who fails exams despite their, their, their ability being, you know, well enough to pass the exams and they, they might need to dial down that. That, that measure of what success or perfection actually is.
Yeah. Or they may need to reassess how they judge themselves as a person or look at their core beliefs. So those other, uh, things that, that, that might do with a, a, a psychologist as well or or an ADHD coach, is there rises in ADHD diagnosis in the increase of social media? Is that what we're seeing? Like, just listening to you talking about the greenery being outside? Is the flip side of that, that we're seeing more of these cases, um, you know, where we're getting the
request too for children to have ADHD assessments. Is it the rise in the social media or is it, you know, like the stresses, like life is complicated at the moment and look at all the external factors. Um, so not just the influence of the social media, but the, the being online, just having online having a, an artificial light stimulus as well. Uh, changing the way that you're going to function outside of that environment. People that are doing gaming and uh, and gambling
online, uh, can be, you know, can be part of a, an impulse dysregulation. And then it disrupts the sleep, your sleep sleeping patterns and rhythms and that all, um, exasperates underlying conditions and stuff as well. It's always interesting when you see someone that you treated mm-hmm. Actually on TikTok. On TikTok or on social media speaking about their treatment or their psychiatrist.
I can hear that. I mean, now that we've got this increased awareness of, say, tech and the addictive nature and some of the policy responses, which I think are welcomed about navigating the addictive forces, it's, you know, there's been class actions of course in the US and Australia's led the charge in many ways. So what we're talking about is, in a sense, putting aside ADHD in the symptom pattern, we are talking about a, a more distractible, um, dopamine addicted sort of environment anyway, aren't we in particularly for our children. Um, which has to play some part, I would've thought
draws a, an absolute contrast if they weren't in that environment. Potentially it wouldn't be noticed. It's an old, it's an old Netflix doco now. But under, um, the social dilemma, I dunno if you saw that, it's years ago it was really fascinating to me that these tech, um, moguls said they wouldn't let any their kids anywhere near social media, which I thought was fascinating with fascinating in itself, but I thought, oh boy, that's quite telling. But so, so what we are, we are talking about is a symptom pattern and also potentially a broader landscape, which, which mightn't help and may play some role.
It's a good question and how it plays out long term, you know. Well then we're seeing the assessments at the, you know, when they're needing intervention. But is there other ways that we can intervene early, you know, help our children, like you mentioned being outside, um, you know, learn, learn from this experience as well too. And even some of the stuff that they touched on in Four Corners, like people might not always realise that when they have ADHD diagnosis that some part
of the diagnosis they were saying, um, they'll go back and look at your childhood. Wanna get statements. Yeah. It's a bit deeper. I'll let you explain more of it. Yeah. 'cause we won't know at this level what was happening back then, but they'll need some type of guidance. Yeah, yeah, yeah. That developmental guidance is, is crucial. But even, even still, you might not get the history that aligns with ADHD entirely from that because they might have lost some of their school reports or their
parents can't remember, or they parents don't believe that ADHD was a problem and might, might give a dis just disingenuous history. So you've got a lot of reasons why you might not get that perfect developmental history for it. Mm-hmm. Um, it doesn't necessarily exclude the diagnosis. It supports it and it, it backs you up in a. Potentially medicolegal sense. Yeah, definitely. Keep your school reports, your school, your school. It's not always a problem though, you know, ADHD like you said, it can be a, a superpower.
And if you are like me, you, you subscribe to some forms of evolutionary psychiatry, it, it can serve a purpose mm-hmm. In every single symptom. And it can serve a purpose. Yeah. Just like they can in other psychiatric disorders. Yeah. It's interesting you should say that. I mean, when I, you know, I'm, I'm old of course. So in the seventies and eighties we talked about the cordial kids or the, and people were saying our kids really hyper, they were saying things like, parents were saying hyper, but no one knew. ADHD, no one would talk about it, but there was a sense
that certain kids didn't fit the norm of school and, and, or they, they were really smart at certain things but didn't, weren't in that compliance bucket that school tends to reward. So what I saw that as a, as a kid now I followed obviously the rise in ADHD and obviously its prevalence. Um, well that was a, that was in a great conversation and I really appreciate this opportunity to collaborate with M-L-C-O-A. I think we can cover off some really interesting conversations, bridging that gap between medicine and, and the practical reality at the workplace.
So stay with us because we are gonna, um, be joined now by, for the next episode by Andrew Rich, who's a partner at Gadens. And Tim, you've also been a leader clinically of a medical services at Bin Clinic. So we really hope to drill down on some of the practical strategies of managing this in terms of the functional way it turns up in workplaces. What is the legal obligation, what is the regulatory landscape? And try to bring it together, but hopefully leave people with some, uh, with some practical
insights and takeaways. So thank you very much. Anything else you need to say, Tim, before we sign off? No, I think that's the extent of my attention. Thank you, Vanessa. No, thank you. Thanks Vanessa. Listen, I really appreciate your expertise. Thank you for joining us today and Tony, and talking about such an interesting topic. Um, and I think this will have broader resonance. I think clearly there is, uh, an increasing awareness of this in the community when you have people like Dr. Norman Swan in four Corners, and we are looking at the, the clusters of diagnosis, the clusters of medication.
I think it's, it's obviously, you know, very relevant. And one of the things we're gonna cover off with Andrew, uh, an employment law partner is how that all marries up with, of course, the right to privacy as well, which is also, uh, something that we need to think about in the workplace setting. So thank you very much for your time and expertise and we'll talk to you soon. No worries. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
What determines recovery after a spinal injury? The answer can be more complex than a scan suggests. I’m joined by neurosurgeon Dr Simon Clark and psychiatrist Dr Shiva Gunapu as part of our collaboration with MLCOA’s...
Ageing at work is one of those topics everyone has an opinion on, but very few people have a clear framework for. Recorded live at the Self-Insurers of South Australia conference in Adelaide, this episode of The...
Chronic pain claims can be some of the most contested and misunderstood matters in personal injury and medico legal work, especially when the pain does not match a neat scan or diagnosis. In this episode of The...
Career reinvention is rarely neat, and it often starts with a quiet question you cannot unhear. In this episode, I’m joined by Joanna Wong, host of the podcast Chasing Waves, to talk about career transitions, leadership...
Mindful leadership is not a wellness trend, it is an attention skill, and in this episode I sit down with Susan Pearse to talk about what that really means in modern work and life. Susan and I have known each other for...