Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

The Real Third World

The Real Third World artwork

The Real Third World Season 3 Episode 3

Oct 17, 202516 minAudio

The Elephant in the Alps

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_00The Real Third World, Season 3, Episode 3, The Elephants in the Alps. Hey Dobradan, Mullibuanji, Zdravo, how's it? Owl, I'm Ruthie, and from Sarevo to Red Africa. Welcome to our podcast about the people and history of the real Third World. Forget the telethons, the phrase the third world came about as an act of defiance, when several smaller and mainly post-colonial nations decided they didn't want to choose between the Western First World or the Eastern Second World, but to choose their own third way instead.

SPEAKER_00Alone, they could not rival the superpowers, but together they could be a force to be reckoned with. And even more, the events of the world today directly descend from the third world's past. In our last season, we laid some foundation of various third world countries, and this season we'll be drawing even more lines to show how we got to the world we're living in today. These stories have been overlooked long enough, and we're going to tell them to you here. Rome, for all its loyal and diehard modern following, did not start out as awesome.

SPEAKER_00They did greatly improve through the years of Roman ascendancy, but as intelligence tended to filter through particular powerful people rather than a specific department, what was going to happen when to whom was not quite so easy to track down. Be that as it may, it was one of Rome's greatest enemies that solidified the need for intelligence and warfare. Hannibal of Carthage and the Second Punic War in 218 BCE.

SPEAKER_00We won't rehash the Second Punic War here. As exciting as elephants in the Alps may be, and quite frankly, there's a whole period of over a hundred years that should have epic cinematic music playing under any such discussion, with crashing discordant chords of melancholy when we reach the whole Carthago de Lenda Est part. But there are a few things that need to be discussed in regards to Carthage if we're at all going to discuss Rome's use of intelligence and sneaky spies.

SPEAKER_00The first is that this time in their history, and in truth, for nearly all of Rome's history, not only did the bureaucratic structure for supporting an intelligence gathering department to keep track of external enemies not exist, but it was antithetical to the entire idea of Rome and its senatorial class of leaders as a whole. Secrets are not secrets if everyone knows them, and there were quite a few in Rome's leading families who were perfectly happy to pass on any such top-secret information as came their way for price.

SPEAKER_00After all, being a member of the senatorial class was absolutely not cheap, and a certain standard of living must be maintained above all else. Their lack of a professional intelligence organization was certainly not because such things were unknown at the time. Not only do we know that well-organized spy bureaus existed in Babylonian times, but the Persian spy apparatus, known as the Eyes and Ears of the King, was looked upon with envy by its enemies, like Rome.

SPEAKER_00Indeed, as Rosemary Sheldon wrote, as soon as a man learned to create documents, he began to classify them. This is another indication that gathering intelligence is as old as civilization itself. Intelligence gathering was second nature to any ruler who wanted to protect the safety and independence of his city, and who valued his own life. The Romans did have external intelligence collection. It was just gathered by individuals and used according to individuals' particular micro and macro needs rather than being done by and used for the actual state.

SPEAKER_00This particularly came back to bite them when Hannibal had had about enough of Romans pushing the boundaries of the treaty that ended the First Punic War. Hannibal was able to learn what the Roman plans were, create a plan, and invade what is now Italy before Rome knew what was happening. I mean, can you imagine getting elephants across enormous icy mountains before your enemies figure it out? It's almost beyond belief. But Hannibal had the benefit of his intelligence apparatus, and Rome was depending on their allies to tell them what was up.

SPEAKER_00When those allies stopped being allies, because let's be honest, being allied to Rome was rarely a relationship of equals, their intelligence stopped flowing, or was purposefully changed to misinformation. Hannibal courted Rome's allies and those tribes who were settled around the boundaries of the Roman Empire and used their resentment against Rome. They either allied themselves with Carthage or looked aside. Elephants! Oh no, no, no, no elephants have been here, sir.

SPEAKER_00We don't even know what elephants are. He also had a system of informants who were embedded within Roman camps. We're used to today's military bases, surrounded by barbed wire and fences, sign-in requirements, and high-tech gadgets that keep unwanted visitors away from all the sensitive bits. It was quite a bit easier to get into military camps when the years were counting backward, and that made it easier for information to cross lines. The Romans did discover some of Hannibal's agents in their midst.

SPEAKER_00Titus Livius recounts one such incident. About the same time, a Carthaginian spy who was for two years escaping detection was caught in Rome, and after his hands were cut off, he was sent away. But the Carthaginian army was able to rampage through Roman territories for years, precisely because of the information that Hannibal was able to gather and the much tighter controls he kept on his own intelligence.

SPEAKER_00I have to say, I think my own personal favorite sneaky intelligence misinformation thing that Hannibal did targeted Fabius, who earned the nickname Cunctator, or the Delayer, because he delayed going into pitched battle with Hannibal. Rumors about Fabius's possible traitorousness to his country began to circulate through Rome, which Hannibal heard about through his spy networks, so he quickly used it to his advantage. Whenever the Carthaginians would rampage through a Roman area, he would deliberately avoid any land held by Fabius himself.

SPEAKER_00The decision to forego a bit of war pillage and plunder yielded far greater dividends as misinformation. He also used forged documents to confuse the situation even more. It took Scipio Africanus and his decision to adapt Carthaginian spying, misinformation, and sabotage practices to his own military use to turn the tide. This is obviously vastly simplifying an absolutely complex historic era.

SPEAKER_00But we only have 15 or 20 minutes here. The thing is, Rome didn't really learn all that much from the need for intelligence. Or rather, they still found the whole idea of organizing intelligence for the state as a terrible policy. So they didn't. We do know from Caesar's commentaries that he recognized how important it was to find out what even your friends and allies were up to behind the scenes. His foray into developing an intelligence service ended with his assassination, however.

SPEAKER_00More than 200 years after the Punic Wars began, the Emperor Domitian came to power. Now, the origins of the Frumentari, the Roman secret police, are kind of hazy, but they're often traced back to this particular emperor who was known for being, as a later historian put it, a ruthless but efficient autocrat. Which, if you think about it, is probably what it takes to organize a structure whose job it is to find out everything about everybody.

SPEAKER_00In any case, Domitian had a suspicious nature, and as his reign progressed from the years 81 to 96, he steadily increased his use of informants. Until he was assassinated, that is. It seems that his heavy-handed prosecutions of bribery and corruption and execution of members of the senatorial class weren't appreciated by those above the common folk, and court officials, also prone to corruption, enthusiastically stabbed him as he tried to work.

SPEAKER_00Domitian's auspices, Seers of the Future, had warned him of such an event, but it seems his informers throughout the court missed that bit of information. It wasn't until Hadrian became emperor in 117, about 20 years after Domitian's assassination, that we know the Frumentari are established and being vigorously used. Such infrastructure does not spring up overnight, however, and as there are no literary references to them before Hadrian, pinpointing their exact date of emergence is nearly impossible.

SPEAKER_00Whomever had the idea to create the Frumentari was brilliant, however. Originally, they were members of the military responsible for grain distribution. This means that they were traveling everywhere all the time. They had contact with everyone, and they saw just about everything. The possibilities in such a group of men obviously resonated with someone. Quickly, their mandate grew to include being couriers, so now they not only traveled around more, they were also responsible for moving correspondence about, which created even more opportunities to collect information.

SPEAKER_00More secret police-ish activities were added as their bureaucratic structure, as well as a headquarters at Castra Peregrina. But the thing is, as much as the Frumentari grew and began to gather information on the Roman population to rival the files kept by Stalin's NKVD, it was always inwardly focused. Even as the bureaucratic infrastructure of the Roman government grew to include spies, they were watching themselves and not keeping an eye out for external threats.

SPEAKER_00For external information, Rome relied mainly on its diplomats, and everyone knew it. This made it much easier for other nations to hide vital information from Rome, and relaying what information was gathered was extremely slow and cumbersome. Roman shortcomings in the area of intelligence were horrifically highlighted in 88 BCE when Mithridates organized the murder of about 80,000 people of Roman descent who were living in what is now Turkey.

SPEAKER_00The mass killings of women and children as well as fighting age men were organized in advance and commenced on the same day. No one was warned, certainly not the government of Rome, which was caught up in internal matters anyway. Mithridates offered freedom to the slaves of Romans in this kingdom who participated, and those who killed the Romans they owed money to had their debt written off. The offers were enthusiastically and bloodily embraced.

SPEAKER_00Rome's refusal to see the possibilities of enemies outside their borders continued with the development of the Frumentari, however. It seems like a very parochial view for such an advanced society of its time, and yet it continued and was a significant factor in Rome's eventual fall. Outsiders kept invading, and the Romans kept being taken by surprise. They weren't paying attention to migration patterns, which didn't even require any secrets to change hands.

SPEAKER_00Collecting information from merchants that there were no Gauls in Illyria, and then there were, and that more kept coming, might have staved off significant problems which continued to pile on for hundreds of years. The same inability to track migration meant that Rome was unable to track future threats. This meant that the Roman army required more men, more money, and was too spread out to deal with the correct threats as they appeared. The inefficiency was eye-watering to anyone concerned with resource allocation, otherwise known as budgets.

SPEAKER_00But it also meant that Rome wasn't able to address threats before they became real threats. They were constantly in a position of reacting to problems, i.e., on the defensive. It was not a good position to be in, and yet it was the decision consistently made by those leading Rome. And so, despite a robust internal secret police ish service that survived through a few name changes, Rome fell to invaders from the outside.

SPEAKER_00Even with several hundred years to internalize the lessons of Hannibal in the Second Punic War, Rome never really bothered to try. And that changed everything in history. For the want of an ale, the kingdom was lost, may be the most famous proverb emphasizing the importance of logistics. But maybe one more proverb needs to be applied to Rome and its successor specifically. Knowledge is power. Doesn't merely apply in the classroom.

SPEAKER_00As always with our podcast, we have barely scratched the surface in the sneaky history or lack thereof of Rome and anyone involved in these historic events. It would take far more than a 15 to 20 minute podcast to even begin to untangle the nuances of history, and I hope you'll use this as a jumping off point to continue researching. Please read more, go back further, and for heaven's sake, make sure you can find these places on a map.

SPEAKER_00Zravo, Salami Buino Oke, Ciao, Auvoi Vidimo Sean.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. The Real Third World Season 4 Episode 3

    Nov 6, 202617 minAudio

    Tyranny With Habsurgian Glee

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. The Real Third World Season 4 Episode 2

    Oct 16, 202621 minAudio

    What Exactly Is a Tyrant?

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. The Real Third World Season 4 Episode 1

    Sep 18, 202619 minAudio

    The Tyranny of a Benevolent Tyrant

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. The Real Third World Season 3 Episode 11

    Jun 5, 202616 minAudio

    Imperial and Royal Information

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. The Real Third World Season 3 Episode 10

    May 15, 202615 minAudio

    The French Spy Who Kickstarted the American Revolution

    Credit the people on this episode