
The Real Third World Season 4 Episode 2
What Exactly Is a Tyrant?
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

What Exactly Is a Tyrant?
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
SPEAKER_00The Real Third World. Season 4, Episode 2. What exactly is a tyrant? Hey the Bardan, Mullibuangis, the Ravo, how's it? Alo, I'm Ruthie. I'm from Sarevo to Red Africa. Welcome to our podcast about the people and history of the real third world. Forget the telethons, the phrase the third world came about as an act of defiance, when several smaller and mainly post-colonial nations decided they didn't want to choose between the Western First World or the Eastern Second World, but instead to choose their own third way.
SPEAKER_00Alone, they couldn't rival the superpowers, but together, they could be a force to be reckoned with. And even more, the events of the world today directly descend from the third world's past. In our last season, we talked about the sneaky ways nations developed and used to get ahead, or just to not get taken over. This season, we'll be talking about a word currently being thrown about with all the clumsy enthusiasm of a gaggle of men who just ate too much turkey and found a slightly deflated ball trying to coax some kind of athletic event into being.
SPEAKER_00Like that pickup ballgame, the word we'll be spending all season discussing, tyrant, is often misused, often off the mark, and occasionally a brilliant play no one saw coming. It also involves vomit and bodily fluids more than one might expect. So what is a tyrant really? The right of a nation to kill a tyrant in case of necessity can no more be doubted than to hang a robber or kill a flea. John Adams.
SPEAKER_00I thought since last time we quoted Abigail Adams, it might be good to flip the table and quote her husband this time. But his quote, while quite inspiring, actually leaves more questions than answers. For starters, if we have the right to kill a tyrant, if it's necessary for us to kill a tyrant, we should probably have a pretty good idea of what a tyrant actually is, right? If you search the web, you'll see almost everything and everyone referred to as a tyrant.
SPEAKER_00Death is a tyrant, old age is a tyrant, someone's father was a tyrant about reading, someone else was the victim of a tyrannical teacher who ruthlessly slashed grades for poorly done homework. At this point, the word tyrant has become somewhat diluted in meaning. Basically, it's anyone or anything that might make you feel put upon or with whom you disagree. Tyrants and tyranny are a very real thing, but at this point, most of the world's population may not be able to actually identify the phenomenon due to the layers of hyperbole over the last several thousand years.
SPEAKER_00And to be quite honest, it's really not very nice to kill someone for being a tyrant if you don't have a real idea of what a tyrant actually is. That plan is rather fraught with the danger of killing someone you just don't agree with, and that would make you a murderer rather than a savior. Perhaps a good place to start in the search for actual tyrants is Byzantium. It's a good place to start for an actual tyrant. Andronicos I, Komnenos, was so horrible in his violent rule, it only took a few years before he was captured, tied to a post, beaten for several days, and then, while still alive, tied upside down and repeatedly stabbed until he was basically torn to pieces.
SPEAKER_00All in public, of course. But it might be better to look at yet another example of a tyrant who was also not a tyrant. A tyrant who actually did devote himself to making Byzantium better. A tyrant who was genuined in the fates of the downtrodden in his society, but also a tyrant who had 30,000 people killed in one fell swoop in his own capital city, Justinian I.
SPEAKER_00Straight off the bat, we need to say that most of the tyrant accusations toward Justinian all came from one guy, a historian named Procopius. Procopius accompanied one of Justinian's generals on campaign during wars and wrote several books about Justinian's reign. And then he wrote one book called The Secret History, which was not published during his lifetime and which attacked Justinian and the Empress Theodora mercilessly for everything he felt he couldn't say publicly about them.
SPEAKER_00He literally sounds like the fringes of the political sphere today in the accusations he makes, including accusing Justinian of being possessed by demons, or perhaps just being a demon, himself. The whole thing is a screed, punctuated by the Byzantine version of shouting, and another thing, in a frustrated fervor that throws out everything, including the kitchen sink, and repeatedly references a nebulous quote-unquote they, as in they say.
SPEAKER_00So we should probably keep in mind as we discuss the more tyrannical activities of the Emperor Justinian I, who was helped not at all by the fact he was actually born a peasant in what is now northern Macedonia and married an actress who probably had participated in a bit of prostitution, willingly or not. A huge bit of what most reasonably educated people know about Justinian I was his reformation of the law code. Certainly someone who reformed the legal system in such a way that it's the basis for most of the law systems in continental Europe and the United States couldn't really have been a tyrant, right?
SPEAKER_00Well, I mean, it always depends on who you talk to. On the one hand, he introduced and reformed laws regarding prostitution, protecting women in particular from being forced into prostitution legally against their will. He also made it the law that women who had committed crimes could only be guarded by other women to protect them from the rampant sexual abuse that was going on in imprisoned populations. Women were also supposed to get their dowries back upon divorce, and men were not allowed to enter into significant debt without the agreement of their wives.
SPEAKER_00Of course, things have a way of being ignored. And although these were the laws, laws were not always enforced or followed. But this was still more intention than others even considered at that time, or even before in the history of the world. On the other hand, Justinian's law reforms also made male homosexuality not only illegal, but a conviction was to result in the public humiliation and then the cutting off of the genitals of those found guilty.
SPEAKER_00And it only took one witness to be declared guilty. It was also retroactive. Even by the standards of the time, that was overkill. He also introduced laws against philosophers, astrologers, heretics, pagans, and Jews, along with a wide swath of others. Justinian I was religious, and he became more religious the older he grew. He perceived that these groups were a threat to the state, and so he unilaterally decided to restrict them and hound them as best he could to reduce what he saw as a threat.
SPEAKER_00And finally, he did something that was actually not too unusual for that time and place. Indeed, for most times and places, including up until very recently, he declared that the law was basically given to them through God. And since he, Justinian, was the embodiment of that law under God's authority, he was actually not subject to the law himself. Unfortunately, certain people are using variations of this today.
SPEAKER_00And I have to say that's pretty tyrannical. Like Procopius cun's off like a Karen denied boarding for getting drunk during an extended layover in Secret History. But Justinian was really not doing himself any favors here. Justinian was also waging wars across his part of the world, which wasn't unlike any other ruler at that time. He just had more to back his wars up, but he still needed money to do so, and so a crushing tax burden came into effect that was seriously resented.
SPEAKER_00And his administration reforms called for him to curtail the power of the nobles. Something up with they would not put. It came to a head early on in the 532 NICA riots. Ostensibly, they were kicked off by his insistence that two imprisoned members of rival clans think of this like uh European football teams, except they carried political power as well. These two rival clan members would be put to death for crimes they claimed they were innocent of.
SPEAKER_00Everyone always does. In reality, there was a lot more going on behind the scenes, having to do with Justinian's level of power, war making, and reforms. The rioting went on for a week and burned most of the city, including the highest Sophia. Justinian and several of his advisors wanted to flee by ship, but were stopped by the Empress Theodora, who gave a speech that echoed Marlon Brando's eternal line in The Godfather. You can act like a man! I mean, her speech was much more flowery and less bitchy.
SPEAKER_00But basically, she told him to man up. A king isn't a king when he runs away and has no more kingdom. So Justinian did. He used subterfuge to peel one faction of the riots off the other, and then sent his most important general in to get rid of the problem. The result was 30,000 or so citizens of Constantinople killed inside the Hippodrome. Most were killed by being crushed trying to escape, but the scale of that horror has rarely been met in history.
SPEAKER_00It was bloody. It was awful, and it should horrify everyone. But was that the act of a tyrant or a king putting down a rebellion? The rebels had raised up a new king, after all. It wasn't a problem that would calm down if you just created a cordon sanitaire around the areas that had gone mad. Another horrifying act was the way Justinian put down the Samaritan revolt of 529. Now, the Samaritans are the folks from the Bible.
SPEAKER_00Jesus had a parable about the Good Samaritan, if you'll recall. They identify themselves as the descendants of three of the tribes of Israel. And there are actually about 900 Samaritans still living today. There were a lot more in the time of Justinian, and they were leading revolt after revolt against the Byzantine Empire. In 529, they kicked off another revolt, this time killing Christians and setting churches on fire.
SPEAKER_00Justinian responded with devastation. He suppressed the revolt violently, executing every ringleader. He then proceeded to destroy the population. Accounts say between 20,000 and 100,000 were slaughtered. Tens of thousands were enslaved. Any left were further and further restricted by the law. In 556, they rebelled again, this time between 100,000 and 120,000 were killed.
SPEAKER_00There were a few more revolts, and by the 1100s, long after Justinian died, there were fewer than 1900 Samaritans left anywhere. So again, the repression of the Samaritan minority was horrific. But it also was done in response to murder and attacks on the Christian community. Definitely literal overkill. But the whole black and white aspect of whether this was an act of tyranny or something a ruler of that time and place would have done as a matter of course is a real question.
SPEAKER_00We know what Procopius thought, and again, Procopius had an axe to grind the size of Al Capone's rap sheet. At the same time, Justinian embarked on a building spree that is still there 1,500 years later in what we now call Istanbul. The Hagia Sophia, first built in the 300s, was destroyed three times. After the third time, in the Nika riots, it was rebuilt by Justinian in a manner that outshone everything in the Christian world at that time.
SPEAKER_00It was so grand and so incredible that the emperor supposedly said when he saw the finished product, Solomon, I have surpassed thee. Something I have to admit is exactly what a narcissistic tyrant on a building spree would say. Even Procopius, for all his hatred of Justinian, praised the beauty and importance of the Hagia Sophia. But that was not all Justinian built. He built roads, churches, castles, entire border cities, aqueducts, bridges, monasteries, and orphanages.
SPEAKER_00There was definitely criticism of the crushing tax burden the building and the wars required, but there was also incredible pride in the sight of what looked like imperial Roman prestige returning after previous hard times. Perhaps a big part of the reason for Procopius' hatred of Justinian was actually tied to the mixed feelings of the building, and for that matter, the war. By the end of Justinian's reign, it had become obvious that the revival of the Roman Empire in size and prestige was not going to happen.
SPEAKER_00A psychologically well-documented fact that those who most fervently convert are also the ones that can most fervently turn against what they have converted to when it is not perceived as fulfilling its part of the bargain. And, if we're being completely honest, there is probably some good old-fashioned and ever-in-style snobbery going on. Procopius was from the traditional aristocracy. An exceedingly powerful emperor from the peasant class and his former prostitute wife were an affront to anyone who was proud of their heritage social class.
SPEAKER_00But let's look at this with a little more perspective. What was going on in other kingdoms at that time and with other rulers? Was there a baseline that could help us see what was tyrannical then and what was just normal ruler stuff? Khazraud I, Justinian's contemporary Sasanian ruler who ruled over a Persian empire that is more than twice the size of the current Iran, is known as the philosopher king. He's praised for reforming tax codes and enlightened rule.
SPEAKER_00He was unofficially known as the just, and even today is mentioned as an example of an enlightened non-Muslim ruler in the Middle East. His empire was known for treating religious minorities well as far as they could, but his treatment of non-Orthodox Zoroastrians was a bit less enlightened. When a sect led by a man named Mazdak stopped being helpful in curbing the power of the nobility and began to cause problems, they were summoned to Khosrau I's presence.
SPEAKER_00Khosrau then had them buried alive, upside down, with only their feet sticking out of the ground. Mazdak was brought to witness the fate of his followers, and then he was hanged feet first on a gallows and used for target practice. Then there was Khosrau's ascension to the throne. When his older brother tried to claim the throne, Khosrau had him killed. But he didn't stop there. He killed all his brothers. And then, for good measure, all of his nieces and nephews of all ages.
SPEAKER_00Any nobles conspiring against him met the same fate. Entire families disappeared into execution pits. Kosrau also sacked cities, raising them to the ground and selling captured people into slavery when they weren't killed outright. He did build up a lot of infrastructure and reform the tax system, though. Theodoric the Great of the Ostrogothic Kingdom of Italy was another contemporary of Justinian. He took control of Italy after losing war when he met the winner for a treaty signing, and then used giving the toast as an excuse to raise his sword and cut the victorious leader in half.
SPEAKER_00Theodoric then slaughtered every noble who had been loyal to the man he just killed. And I'm not sure if that extended to the children. Either way, it was not an honorable thing to do. But he did it. And he continued to come up with excuses to execute aristocrats and philosophers that he found threatening. Something increasingly more common as he grew older and more paranoid. Another ruler, King Clothar I of the Franks, and side note here, the early Frankish kings really have a bunch of names which sound like that weird pantheon of gods on top of the building and Ghostbusters.
SPEAKER_00Clothar personally, with his own hand, murdered his ten and seven-year-old nephews in order to take their inheritance. He did offer them the chance to go into a monastery first, but still, Richard III of England was not the first to come up with nepotticide. My point here is that a tyrant is in the eye of the beholder. There really are tyrants. There really are evil rulers, and honestly, there are stupid rulers as well, hereditary and elected officials included.
SPEAKER_00But identifying a tyrant is a lot more complicated than looking at actions which make us uncomfortable in our current understanding of humanity. Which brings us back again to American Supreme Court Justice Potter Stewart in our definition of tyrant. I know it when I see it. Procopius certainly ended his life thinking of Justinian I as a tyrant. Modern scholars 1,500 years later are still arguing about it. As always, with our podcasts, we have barely scratched the surface of tyrants, some of the history of the Byzantine world, and anyone involved in these historic events.
SPEAKER_00It would take far more than a 15 to 20 minute podcast to even begin to untangle the nuances of history. And I hope you'll use this as a jumping off point to continue researching. Please read more, go back further, and for heaven's sake, make sure you can find these places on a map. Zaravo, Salani Bueno Oke, ciao. Au revoir, videmo say.
Nobody is credited on this episode yet.
Tyranny With Habsurgian Glee
The Tyranny of a Benevolent Tyrant
Imperial and Royal Information
The French Spy Who Kickstarted the American Revolution
Off With Their Beards!... and their heads…