
The Real Third World Season 4 Episode 1
The Tyranny of a Benevolent Tyrant
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

The Tyranny of a Benevolent Tyrant
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
SPEAKER_00The Real Third World Season 4, Episode 1, The Tyranny of a Benevolent Tyrant. Hey, Dobarudan, Molibuanji, Zravo, how's it? Alo, I'm Ruthie. I'm from Sarevo to Red Africa. Welcome to our podcast about the people and history of the real Third World. Forget the telethons, the phrase the third world came about as an act of defiance when several smaller and mainly post-colonial nations decided they didn't want to choose between the Western First World or the Eastern Second World, but instead to choose their own third way.
SPEAKER_00Alone, they couldn't rival the superpowers, but together they could be a force to be reckoned with. And even more, the events of the world today directly descend from the third world's past. In our last season, we talked about the sneaky ways nations developed and used to get ahead, or at least to not get taken over. This season, we'll be talking about a word currently being thrown about with all the clumsy enthusiasm of a gaggle of men who just ate entirely too much turkey and found a slightly deflated ball, trying to coax some kind of athletic event into being.
SPEAKER_00Like that pickup ball game, the word we'll be spending all season discussing, tyrant, is often misused, often off the mark, and occasionally a brilliant play no one saw coming. It also involves vomit and bodily fluids far more than one might expect. So, what is a tyrant? Really? Do not put such unlimited power into the hands of husbands.
SPEAKER_00Remember, all men would be tyrants if they could, wrote Abigail Adams to her husband, while he was hammering out the details of the new American Republic at the Continental Congress. It's a famous letter, one which asks him to remember the ladies as he and his founding father brethren argued laws in the face of a lawless break from England. Now, I'm willing to bet that we all tell ourselves that other people might have tyrannical tendencies, but of course we ourselves mostly do not.
SPEAKER_00We only want what's best for everyone. That's not tyranny. That's just helping people to see a truth they can't see on their own. It's all for their own good. Can't make an omelet without cracking a few eggs, right? And that, right there, is the basis of tyranny. C.S. Lewis talked about it as well. Of all tyrannies, a tyranny sincerely exercised for the good of its victims may be the most oppressive.
SPEAKER_00Those who torment us for our own good will torment us without end, for they do so with the approval of their own conscience. Of course, not all tyrants exist for their perception of the good of others, but it is very important that those who support them think they do. And all this is just to say that if you or I or anyone thinks that they most certainly would never support tyranny and that they would be that one guy in the crowd refusing to Hitler salute.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I have news for you. If you have ever said, thought, or dismissed someone else's anger with the phrase for their own good, or they have no idea what is needed, and sometimes we just need to do these things whether they like it or not, or they're too stupid to understand. You've bordered tyranny, my friend. But you know, don't worry. We've all been there. It's a rough line to walk. The truth is that trying to govern a nation well, especially if that particular nation is a melting pot of cultures, ideas, and musical tastes, means compromise.
SPEAKER_00That compromise means that sometimes good ideas don't get implemented. It also means that sometimes bad ideas get implemented, but it also means that the world isn't wholesale adopting one set of ideas without discussion, argument, and pushback. And no matter how good you think your own ideas are, trust me, you need some discussion, argument, and pushback. And that means that the bad parts are usually going to be far less bad in general.
SPEAKER_00Not not bad, less bad. And of course, we all think we have the answer to fixing all the wrongs in the world. And again, I say we're all absolutely wrong. Things are better now than they have ever been in the history of the world. GLP ones alone are solving problems beyond diabetes and being fat. We can fly across the world in half a day. We can make electricity out of the sunlight in the air, for goodness sake.
SPEAKER_00We can transplant hair on bald men. Things can get better. But things will never be perfect. It's a work in progress. Trying to suppress others' thoughts so our thoughts can be forced on everyone isn't going to create utopia. So now that there's a context for us to work from, let's get a definition. Merriam-Webster defines tyrant thus: an absolute ruler unrestrained by law or constitution, a usurper of sovereignty, a ruler who exercises absolute power oppressively or brutally, or one resembling an oppressive ruler in the harsh use of authority or power.
SPEAKER_00So basically, a person who can do anything they want to anyone they want, oppresses others in their exercise of power, and is mean and nasty about it. You probably have a few current world leaders in mind with this one. But here's the thing: that was not always the definition of a tyrant. There was a whole period of time in ancient Greece that was basically the age of tyrants. From around 650 to 500 BCE, men seized power without being one of the recognized noble bloodlines, quote-unquote, worthy of ruling.
SPEAKER_00And initially, that's all the word tyrant meant. Basically, it was a sneer, an upjumped peasant, even if the tyrant wasn't exactly a peasant, the snootiness was real, took control of the government. Pesistratus, who ruled for around 56 years around 546 BCE, was actually pretty popular. He had a massive program of public works and improvements and was strongly supported by both peasants and landowners for fixing so much stuff.
SPEAKER_00But as rule passed down to the sons of Pesistratus, the nasty reputation for tyrants began to take hold. And to be fair, it was deserved. Greek tyrants alone left a trail of depraved acts behind them, roasting people alive in bronze bulls, selling the philosopher Plato into slavery, and the always popular annihilating a city and selling its population into slavery.
SPEAKER_00And we're still only in ancient Greece. We have had 2,500 years since to come up with interesting new ways to tyrannize others. By the time of Aristotle and Plato, tyrants were viewed as evil, not just upjumped peasants. Plato even had a theory as to how tyranny arose. And so tyranny naturally arises out of democracy and the most aggravated form of tyranny and slavery out of the most extreme form of liberty.
SPEAKER_00Trust me, it actually does make sense in the long form of his writings. Basically, he says too much freedom leads to chaos, which leads to a demagogue who arises because that demagogue can fix things. Spoiler alert, not everyone who says they can fix things can actually fix things. But just as tyrants and tyrannical behavior have existed, so have those ready to call anything they don't like tyranny.
SPEAKER_00In the 1600s, Thomas Hobbes wrote, They that are discontented under monarchy call it tyranny, and they that are displeased with aristocracy call it oligarchy. And so also they which find themselves grieved under a democracy call it anarchy. At this point, it's almost too much to untangle. Tyranny, in the eyes of the beholder, is rather like American Supreme Court Justice Potter Stewart's understanding of pornography. I know it when I see it. It's a fine line.
SPEAKER_00And that fine line is exactly where we've decided to begin. With the tyrant whose status as a tyrant is ambiguous. He was also played by Anthony Hopkins in one particular movie, which is always a good sign. Sir Anthony does love his epic characters. Side note, my favorite, and you can argue with me if you'd like to be wrong, is Colonel William Ludlow and Legends of the Fall. Masterful. Anyway, for this particular instance, we're talking about Ptolemy I, good friend and possible half-brother of Alexander the Great, ruler of Egypt, founder of a multi-century dynasty, father of incestuous children, and not the builder of the lighthouse of Alexandria, despite the best efforts of the set designers on the movie Alexander.
SPEAKER_00There were rumors, and there are still rumors, that Ptolemy and Alexander the Great shared a father in Philip of Macedon. Philip was very vigorous. He was a very vigorous man. But even if Ptolemy wasn't a Philippian side quest, he was still a descendant of Alexander I, not the Great, of Macedon, who ruled from 498 BCE. This also allowed him to claim descent from Hercules because you just aren't anyone unless you have some immortal blood somewhere down the line.
SPEAKER_00Now, Ptolemy was with Alexander the Great from the very beginning, and he was with him through the end. And then he seized Alexander's body to bury in Egypt. So he was actually with him past the end. This might seem rather ridiculous to us in the age of podcasts and Uber Eats delivery, but Macedonian rulers kept a burial of their predecessors as part of proof of their right to rule. Ptolemy kept up the pretense of being junior to the kings of Macedon who followed Alexander for a while while they fought amongst themselves, but eventually he stopped pretending and kept his area of Egypt to himself.
SPEAKER_00And this is where the definition of tyranny comes in. By a what right did Ptolemy have Egypt? He was an Egyptian. And to be fully fair, when Alexander the Great conquered Egypt, he didn't take it from the actual Egyptians, he took it from the Persians. Ptolemy did have royal descent, but he didn't have Egyptian royal descent, and he wasn't Alexander's child, or even his actual heir, which was Alexander's child. He got Egypt in a hasty conference held after Alexander's death.
SPEAKER_00So was Ptolemy a tyrant? There were those ethnic Egyptians who didn't want him there. Very early on, he faced an uprising, which he ruthlessly squashed. But even in that, he wasn't as bloodthirsty as many rulers of his time. There was no burning or salting of the earth, no cities emptied into perpetual servitude. He did participate in various parts of the Wars of the Successors post-Alex the Great, but he wasn't a bloodthirsty, fire-fiddling child murderer.
SPEAKER_00And Ptolemy's reign actually resembled more of an idea that took hold in the mid-20th century from a University of Maryland College Park professor, the idea of a benevolent dictator. Dr. Olson actually had a lot of interesting things to say about political development. But basically, these long-term dictators had a stake in making sure that society functions and has what it needs to function at a level which allows them to continue to benefit from the nation.
SPEAKER_00Dr. Olson compared this to the ranchers who feed water and take care of their cattle. The cattle are going to be exploited for milk and meat eventually, but the milk and meat are much better if the cattle are well cared for. Basically, a benevolent dictator realizes that he should not kill the goose that lays the golden egg. It was Ptolemy I who created the Library of Alexandria, cementing Alexandria as a center of learning. He also introduced agricultural reforms and stabilized the currency, all things that are still important parts of running nations today.
SPEAKER_00But Ptolemy realized one more thing: that he, as a Macedonian, was ruling a nation of Egyptians. He needed to be the ruler of both, not the ruler of one and subjugator of the other. To do this, he actually promoted a hybrid god that fit into both the Greek and Egyptian pantheons. Ptolemy realized something that much of the Western world today has lost sight of. People need to have a common cultural base.
SPEAKER_00When one didn't already exist, he created it. The Sirapsis cult survived nearly 700 years until the final temple was destroyed. Now, Ptolemy I himself was not married to his sister. He did have several wives, though, and quite a few children. It was his children who dove into the traditional Egyptian ruling custom of sibling marriage. This was not viewed as okay in the Greek world, but it did provide a way for the Ptolemaic line to avoid, as much as can be, the problems of outmarriage, namely another family having a claim on empire resources.
SPEAKER_00And even though Ptolemy seemed to understand the need for a common culture between the Egyptians and Greeks, it was not quite a common cultural practice. Greeks had different laws than the Egyptians, and they lived in different places. The Greeks had a monopoly on powerful positions, and the Egyptians had to pay higher taxes. It was not an equal world, by any means, even if it wasn't a horrific one, which leads us back to the uprisings of Egyptians that occurred from time to time in the Macedonian ruled twilight of ancient Egypt.
SPEAKER_00The Ptolemaic dynasty that the benevolent dictator Ptolemy I instituted managed to rule for a few hundred years, punctuated by various sorts of excitements. To be completely honest, quite a large percentage of the excitement of Ptolemaic Egypt stemmed from internal fighting rather than external issues. So maybe we might want to rethink that whole idea of incest protecting the family from challenges. Tears for fears knew what they were on about.
SPEAKER_00Everybody wants to rule the world, indeed. The Ptolemaic dynasty was still in power when the era of ancient Egypt came to an end, though, as it was for so many other empires, it was from the growing power of Rome. Cleopatra, the final Cleopatra, portrayed in so many movies and TV series, made some efforts echoing Ptolemy I's efforts toward reconciling Egyptians and Macedonian Greeks, including learning the language.
SPEAKER_00But the end was inexorably coming. And as so often happens, history loves to rhyme. Ptolemaic rule was seen as tyrannical by the Egyptians, who were taxed at a higher rate than Greeks and excluded from the most powerful positions. The Egyptians were, in general, fine with the idea of Rome taking over. There was hope that things would finally equalize. Of course, with hindsight about the whole Roman Empire thing, we know how that turned out.
SPEAKER_00As always, with our podcasts, we have barely scratched the surface of tyrants, some of the history of the ancient world, and anyone involved in these historic events. It would take far more than a 15 to 20 minute podcast to even begin to untangle the nuances of history. And I hope you'll use this as a jumping off point to continue researching. Please read more, go back further, and for heaven's sake, make sure you can find these places on a map. Zravo, salami bueno okay.
SPEAKER_00Ciao, au revoir, videmo save toys.
Nobody is credited on this episode yet.
Tyranny With Habsurgian Glee
Imperial and Royal Information
The French Spy Who Kickstarted the American Revolution
Off With Their Beards!... and their heads…