Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

The Real Third World

The Real Third World artwork

The Real Third World Season 3 Episode 8

Apr 3, 202617 minAudio

Nobody Expects the Spanish Inquisition!

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_00The Real Third World, Season 3, Episode 8. Nobody expects the Spanish Inquisition. Hey, Dobradan, Molibuangis, Dravo, how's it? Ao? I'm Ruthie, and from Sarevo to Red Africa. Welcome to our podcast about the people and history of the real Third World. Forget the telethons, the phrase the third world came about as an act of defiance, when several smaller and mainly post-colonial nations decided they didn't want to choose between the Western First World or the Eastern Second World, but instead to choose their own third way.

SPEAKER_00Alone, they couldn't rival the superpowers, but together they could be a force to be reckoned with. And even more, the events of the world today directly descend from the third world's past. In our last season, we laid some foundations of various third world countries and how all of those threads met in World War II. This season, we'll be drawing even more lines to show how we got to the world we're living in today and the sneaky ways we got here. These stories have been overlooked long enough, and we're going to tell them to you here.

SPEAKER_00As Monty Python warned us, nobody expects the Spanish Inquisition, except that wasn't terribly true back then, and although hilariously funny while a comedy skip plays out on television, it's not altogether true today either. The Spanish Inquisition was a societal purification response geared toward consolidating power within a royal family and a Catholic tradition that had been at risk for the last 800 years. As the rest of the Monty Python quote went, our three weapons are fear, surprise, and ruthless efficiency, and a fanatical devotion to the Pope.

SPEAKER_00Take the capital P off Pope, making it more of an adjective than a noun, and the Inquisition has repeated itself in many forms throughout history, including in the immediate modern day. But that's not within our history purview. What we are discussing in this season's podcast is how the sneaky world of spies and sabotage developed until it became what we recognize today embodied in the James Bond films, which themselves are not quite accurate.

SPEAKER_00But I digress. Back to the Spanish Inquisition. To understand where this came from, we need to head all the way back to 587 when the Visigoth ruling the Iberian Peninsula converted to Christianity. They celebrated that conversion with what would basically become a Spanish tradition, kicking out or converting all their Jews in 613. Just about a hundred years after that, an Islamic wave came out of the Maghreb and very, very swiftly conquered most of the Iberian Peninsula.

SPEAKER_00It shouldn't have been that easy, but quite frankly, the Visigoth rulers were not particularly well liked, and their nobles were fighting amongst themselves as well. One of them may or may not have asked for the help of the Muslim army. It's how the story goes, but it isn't definitively proven beyond a doubt. The Muslim army drove the Christian nobles back and back until the Battle of Kovadonga in 722. This rump area in the north of Spain became known as the Kingdom of the Asturias, and it's where the Reconquista or the taking back of the Iberian Peninsula pushed out from.

SPEAKER_00The Reconquista took about 800 years, and again it rather went that slow because the Christian nobles kept fighting amongst themselves. But there was inexorable progress because by this time the Islamic army was fighting amongst itself too. So now we're in the second half of the 1400s. An absolutely formidable queen named Isabella had come to power in the reclaimed Kingdom of Castile. Her husband is the King of Aragon, and with the blessing of the Pope and Western Christendom, they were pushing the Islamic rulers out of Spain.

SPEAKER_00Incidentally, just as the Ottomans were conquering the Balkans. Isabella was everywhere at once. Even though she and Ferdinand did their due diligence in making royal babies to either rule their domains or marry off to create strong international royal connections, or sometimes both, she stayed on the move with her armies. She campaigned while pregnant, she gave birth all over her nation, and she shored up her power base. Of course, if you don't unite people behind an idea of some sort, it's much harder to rule.

SPEAKER_00You can, I mean, brutality has its uses, but it's much easier to get people in line if they believe in an idea of something that gives an excuse for the brutality. Even better if it allows people to act brutally together against outsiders. It's inflicting trauma as a bonding experience. Queen Isabella and King Ferdinand were extremely clear. They were the vanguard of the Catholic and Apostolic Church, which was returning to spread over the Iberian Peninsula.

SPEAKER_00This meant getting rid of anyone who wasn't Catholic, namely Muslims and Jews, in their wake. But Spain had other problems as well. Previous rulers had been a bit dodgy with the national finances, and the Kingdom of Castile was dead broke. Previous rulers had also been a bit weak in the whole law and order department. It was a dog-eat-dog world in medieval Spain, and your average Spaniard was wearing milkbone underwear.

SPEAKER_00Isabella saw a chance to kill the three birds, religious differences, public safety, and the treasury, with one stone, and that stone was the Inquisition. Of course, it wasn't that simple, but in the end it turned out that the Inquisition really was the rug that brought the whole room together. Now, the thing is, the Spanish Inquisition was most certainly not the first Inquisition. There were a series of papal inquisitions prior to the grand 1478 kickoff.

SPEAKER_00There were a few differences, however. For one thing, the Papal Inquisitions didn't have the full power of a state behind them. For another, the Papal Inquisitions concerned themselves more with religious movements like the Cathars. In fact, the most recent papal crusade prior to the Spanish royal family getting into the game had some fairly understandable, if not particularly well realized, goals. To put a legal framework around what had previously been often exercised as mob violence.

SPEAKER_00Rules were strengthened, including when and how much torture could be used. As they fought and expanded their Spanish kingdom, Isabella and Ferdinand worried about an enemy bringing down their gains from within, because they saw Christian religious unity as both a commandment from God and a way to get everyone on the same page, rooting out anyone who might deviate from the ways of the Catholic rulers was a priority. One of her first actions was to authorize what had formerly been an ad hoc sort of community policing into an official role.

SPEAKER_00La Santa Hermanidad, the Holy Brotherhood. And the thing is, their reputation was about as pristine as a pair of shorts at the end of a mud run. They were notoriously unreliable, corrupt, and they really didn't give a hoot about the actual people they were supposed to be protecting in the first place. But they were fiercely loyal to Isabella. So although they were reigned in a bit after about 10 years, they were still kept around. Everyone needs a Luca Brazzi in their arsenal.

SPEAKER_00Isabella came to power in 1474 and was immediately thrown into a war of succession with Portugal. Within four years, she managed to win that war and convince the Pope to authorize her desired inquisition. Like I said, a very formidable woman. By 1480, there had been two inquisitors authorized to Sevilla, and by 1481, an auto defe was held where six people were put to death for heresy. That is, they were burned for converting to Christianity and then practicing Judaism in secret.

SPEAKER_00But not only were they burned, their assets were all forfeit to the state, because Ferdinand and Isabella had declared that legally heresy was treason, and treason was punishable by death. It was a surefire way not only to remove the enemies within, but to build the national treasury back up as well. A winning combination. The number of official inquisitors grew and they began traveling to different Spanish cities. The typical schedule was to arrive, announce a 40-day amnesty for people to turn themselves or their neighbors in, and then gather up all the accused for a spate of imprisonment, torture, and executions.

SPEAKER_00But the thing was, there was no need for the bureaucracy of a spy and intelligence system as would later develop in Elizabethan England. There was no need for that because, as anyone who lived through communism can tell you, a system of secret denunciations can work just as well. Everyone informs on everyone else, and not just for heresy either, although that one was pretty well laid out. The idea that someone might still be practicing Judaism in secret was known as crypto-Judaism, and Isabella was a fervent believer that it was a widespread problem and extremely dangerous.

SPEAKER_00I have been told there are certain graveyards beside the monasteries of Saint Bernard, the Holy Trinity, and St. Augustine, in which the conversos of the city used to bury their dead, and that they were buried with Jewish rites and ceremonies, seeking out virgin land in Jewish clothing, with their arms laid straight and not in a cross, insulting and casting a probrium on our ancient Catholic faith. Well, that was just not going to stand. Several ways to identify possible crypto Jews were gathered and used by the inquisitorial staff.

SPEAKER_00For instance, if there was no smoke from the home's chimney on a Saturday. Perhaps someone known to be a converso bought a whole bunch of vegetables right before Passover. That was also a giveaway. And it was very, very suspicious if a person was buying their meat from a converso busher. Although there were never many actual acting inquisitors, there were about 20,000 so-called familiars. Familiars have been referred to as the secret police of the Inquisition, but I don't think this is accurate at all.

SPEAKER_00For one thing, they were in no way secret. Not only did everyone know who they were, their houses were often used for inquisitorial purposes as well. You can't have secret police without a secret. They did perform a lot of functions for the Inquisition, as bodyguards for the Inquisitors, arresting accused, and so on. But there was nothing secret about it. And there were rules about being a familiar. You had to be a local for one. You can't be responsible for eliminating an enemy within if you might actually be connected to that enemy.

SPEAKER_00And it was a strictly no conversos zone. Interestingly enough, the Inquisitors themselves had some well-known converso ancestry, but to act as a familiar, there could be no such thing. Familiars also had to be pious, so religious and honest and all of that. Given the low bar expected of La Santa Romanidad, I'm not prepared to say whether the familiars fulfilled that requirement or not.

SPEAKER_00The last several requirements were just elite snobbery. And as we have seen in regards to the Cambridge spiring 500 years later, elite snobbery is a good excuse to ignore clinging alarm bells. Familiars must be legitimate children, they must not be a manual laborer, and they must be from a prestigious and wealthy family. The wealthy family part is easy to figure out. Isabella wanted money in her treasury, not going out in salary payments. It was best to have people who supported themselves.

SPEAKER_00The rest, though, as we've seen in regards to the Andrew formerly known as Prince, a prestigious family doesn't preclude crappy, immoral, illegal, or downright sick behavior. So ordinary citizens could take themselves or their suspicions to a familiar, who would in turn hand over names to the Inquisition, who would then send out the familiars to perform arrests. An accused was presumed guilty because it was quite hard to prove that you weren't something that was defined by a set of beliefs you were assumed to be lying about in the first place.

SPEAKER_00And that accused didn't even have to be told what they were accused of for years, nor were they ever given the information about who had informed on them. The accused could escape the death penalty by confessing publicly and receiving a public penance. That public penance could range anywhere from just marching around in an embarrassing set of clothes specifically designed for the auto de fe, to being whipped to being sentenced to work as a galley slave on a ship. And always, of course, it included a fine.

SPEAKER_00You also had to pay for your upkeep while in jail and your torture. Isabella did voice some worries about profiting off the Inquisition to the Pope, who basically responded that she shouldn't worry about taking the money because the people shouldn't have committed heresy in the first place. Of course, any time a secret denunciation system is used to identify the enemy within, it is subject to abuse, especially when there's a chance for profit included. After about 1530, some Spaniards openly voiced a pattern they had observed.

SPEAKER_00Those killed and heavily targeted by the Inquisition tended to be wealthy. It just wasn't worth it to denounce and persecute the poor, unless they were really annoying. Now, we only have about 15 or 20 minutes for podcasts, so when it comes to most of history and especially the history of the Spanish Inquisition, we're going to be missing an awful lot of nuance. And we don't have time to go super in depth on the things that flesh out the whole story.

SPEAKER_00Isabella was certainly not a one-dimensional caricature of a religious fanatic. And her reasons for instituting a religious crackdown so severe that we're still talking about it hundreds of years later were very good ones within the medieval setting in which she lived. Truthfully, she was also a woman who removed Columbus from power because he was too vicious to the Native Americans. She educated her daughters better than many at the time educated their sons. She sponsored the first female professor and had that female professor also teaching her children.

SPEAKER_00She was extremely brave, riding into danger, and she had a strong sense of duty, continuing the military campaigns even while pregnant. The first Castilian grammar was produced under her direction and it was used throughout the Spanish areas of the New World, enabling the spread of the Spanish language. She was a woman of her time, and a formidable, remarkable woman of her time. But all of this is taken together with a lot of nuance.

SPEAKER_00And I sincerely hope you will use this podcast not as a final word, but as a jumping off point from which to study more. Please read more, go back further, and for heaven's sake, make sure you can find these places on a map. Zravo, tsalami bueno okay, ciao, au revoir, videmo se donne.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. The Real Third World Season 4 Episode 3

    Nov 6, 202617 minAudio

    Tyranny With Habsurgian Glee

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. The Real Third World Season 4 Episode 2

    Oct 16, 202621 minAudio

    What Exactly Is a Tyrant?

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. The Real Third World Season 4 Episode 1

    Sep 18, 202619 minAudio

    The Tyranny of a Benevolent Tyrant

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. The Real Third World Season 3 Episode 11

    Jun 5, 202616 minAudio

    Imperial and Royal Information

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. The Real Third World Season 3 Episode 10

    May 15, 202615 minAudio

    The French Spy Who Kickstarted the American Revolution

    Credit the people on this episode